MESSAGE It is my pleasure, on behalf of the key officials and staff of the Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB) MIMAROPA Region, to present our Annual Accomplishment Report for CY 2016. As we commenced the year with an affirmative outlook of taking every opportunity in carrying out the Bureau’s mandates and advocacy to the higher level, we also concluded the 2016 with remarkable level of fulfillment and milestone of achievements through accomplishments of broad sets of targets and collaborations of all the Divisions. We pride that based on the latest Philippine Statistics Authority report, the mining contribution to the GDP of the mining sector of the Philippines is a measly 0.6%, however, the contribution of the mining and quarrying sector has consistently been the highest contributor, at more than 20%, to the share of the GRDP for almost a decade in the MIMAROPA Region. The MGB MIMAROPA Region has significantly managed to carry out the activities outlined in the work plan within the expected timeframe amidst the intensified programs and demands brought about by the new directives and changes in strategies of the new administration. The Mine Safety, Environment and Social Development Division (MSESDD), as steward in the implementation of the safety, environment and social provisions of the Philippine Mining Act of 1995, consistently monitored the approved Safety & Health, Environment and Social Development (SHES) Programs of all permit holders in the Region. This endeavor of the Division, under the direction of this Office, resulted to the conferment of the prestigious Presidential Mineral Industry and Environmental Award (PMIEA) during the 63rd Annual National Mine Safety and Environmental Conference to Coral Bay Nickel Corporation (CBNC) for its exemplary SHES performance. Likewise, in the same conference, Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation (RTNMC) took the PMIEA Platinum Award and Intex Resources Philippines, Inc. (IRPI) garnered the Best Mining Forest Award for the Exploration Category. This recognition of RTNMC and CBNC was further fortified by the Secretary of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR), by setting the performances of the two (2) companies as benchmark or standard in environmental protection and social development on mineral resource utilization in the country during her visit late in the year. The Mine Management Division (MMD) continued to dynamically conduct compliance monitoring on the stipulations under the mining contracts/permits granted within its jurisdiction, including the implementation of plans and programs as required by and in

accordance with existing mining and other applicable laws, rules and regulations. To curb illegal mining and/or prevent theft of minerals, the Office has issued Deputation Orders to qualified individuals that were recommended by the Provincial/City Mining Regulatory Board (P/CMRB) and the Local Government Units concerned and has passed the criteria given by this Office. A continuing capacity building on small-scale mining was also conducted in close coordination with the P/CMRBs. The accomplishments of three planned activities, nonetheless, were affected by the issuance of DENR Administrative Order No. 2016-01, which calls for the moratorium on new mining projects. Further, the efforts of the Geosciences Division in accomplishing broad sets of targets under the geohazard survey and assessment program have provided critical inputs to the establishment of flood and landslide exposure database and to the formulation of effective information campaign plans for disaster preparedness. Accomplishments on geological and coastal hazard mapping are commendable despite target activities were implemented outside MIMAROPA region. Certainly, these activities will not be possible without the technical support of the Finance and Administrative Division. More so, the MGB MIMAROPA Region, in partnership with the City Government of Puerto Princesa City, was also in the midst of its mission to rehabilitate and convert to an eco-tourism destination the abandoned mine site of Palawan Quicksilver Mines, Inc. through continuous dialogue with the concerned stakeholders, monitoring of the pit lake and initial implementation of the blue print of the rehabilitation program. We share these accomplishments and acknowledge the support extended to us by the DENR, MGB Central Office, our fellow government agencies, the LGUs, the NGOs, the mining companies and other stakeholders. The year 2016 has been a hopeful year for the Philippines as new initiatives and regulations were developed. With the combined efforts of the stakeholders, this Office is confident that we can sustain our drive if we will work harder hand in hand towards the growth and success of the mining industry. Our sincere appreciation for your endless support.

ROLAND A. DE JESUS Regional Director

TABLE OF CONTENTS

TITLE Executive Summary Highlights of Accomplishments A.01 General Administration and Support Services OPERATIONS A.03.a Mineral Resource Services 1. Communication Plan for Minerals Development 1.a Conduct of Awareness and Advocacy on Mineral Resources and Geosciences 1.b Capacity Building on MRGS 1.c Generate /Publish/Disseminate Information & IEC Materials A.03.b Geosciences Development Services 1. Geohazard Survey and Assessment 1. Vulnerability and Risk Assessment 2. Updating of 1:10,000 scale Geohazard Maps 3. Sub-surface Assessment 4. Geohazard IEC Materials Dissemination 5. Capacity Building 6. Conduct of IEC to LGUs 1.b Coastal Geohazard and Impact of Climate Change 2. Geologic Mapping 2.a Quadrangle Geological Mapping 2.b Mineral Resources Inventory 2.c Provision of Laboratory Services 3. Groundwater Resource Assessment 4. Miscellaneous Geological Services A.03.c Mining Regulation Services 1. Mineral Investment Promotion Program 1.a Issuance of Mining Permits/Contracts and other related permits 1. Issuance of Permits/Contracts 2. Use It or Lose It Policy 3. Approval of SHES Programs 4. Assistance to P/CMRBs, LGUs and other stakeholders 2. Mining Industry Development Program 2.a Monitoring/Audit of approved mining contracts/permits 1. Work program 2. SHES Programs

PAGE NO. 1 8

13 13 23 35 37

39 44 47 47 48 48 52 66 80 81 82 98

102 111 112 118 122 122 123

TABLE OF CONTENTS

TITLE 3. Mine Rehabilitation Program  Task Force Marcopper 4. Resolution of Complaints/Cases/Conflicts 5. Anti-Illegal Illegal Mining  Illegal Mining Sites with CDO issued GAD Accomplishment Report Other Special Events Conducted Other Significant Accomplishments ANNEXES PHOTO DOCUMENTATION

PAGE NO. 125 136 151 154 161 171

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY The Mines and Geosciences Bureau IV-B (MIMAROPA) continuously pursues its mandate through the implementation of different programs/projects and activities anchored on the agency's thrust towards the realization of its vision for an industry that subscribes to the requirements of Sustainable Development. Coherently, MGB IV-B makes certain that its regulatory function is carried out effectively ensuring that the mining firms within its jurisdiction not only significantly contribute to regional economic growth but also perform responsibly and are pro-people and pro-environment in sustaining wealth creation and improved quality of life.

General Administration and Support Services This program provides for the overall management, supervision and administrative support to the entire regional operations. The Finance and Administrative Division continuously directs and supervises its personnel on matters involving recruitment and selection, training, performance evaluation, promotion, provision of fringe benefits to employees. The Division also ensures judicious allocation and utilization of funds. For CY 2016, attendance of personnel to various trainings were supported and coordinated by the said division for continuous updating and skills development and improvement. Other essential general services such as office properties, supplies and records management were also undertaken while the effective discharge of functions of the Accounting, Budget and Cashier Sections have provided substantial and financial logistic support to all divisions. The division also undertakes financial analysis in support to planning, controlling and decision-making; provides financial information to the management for purposes of review and assessment of financial performance; and ensures the proper implementation of rules and regulations on the proper allocation and use of appropriations and allotments, and accounting and auditing. For this year, the Region had generated revenue amounting to ONE HUNDRED TWENTY TWO MILLION EIGHTY TWO THOUSAND FOUR HUNDRED TWENTY THREE and 6/100 (PhP 122,082,423.06).

Communication Plan for Mineral Development MGB-MIMAROPA employed various modes of information and advocacy campaigns to enhance the understanding and awareness level of stakeholders. These include Information and Education Campaigns on MRGS Laws, Rules and Regulations; conduct of Trainings/Seminars for MGB personnel; dialogues with local government officials and other concerned stakeholders; and establishment of linkages with other government agencies, academe, church representatives and other concerned groups. For CY 2016, dialogues were focused on the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of the five provinces. The Region also

1

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

continues to conduct deputation trainings for environment and natural resources officers in the different provinces. The maiden issue of the official newsletter of MGB MIMARAPA called the Mine Scoop was released in the first quarter of CY 2016 and was distributed to various stakeholders. The Region also utilized the services of radio stations both the amplified and frequency modulation, uploaded feature stories (e-news) to the Region’s official website, and generated and disseminated various IEC materials. Selected personnel also managed to link with other government agencies (OGAs), local government units (LGUs), and other nongovernment organizations (NGOs) through dialogues and participation in meetings for regular updating and collaboration.

Geosciences Development Services In 2016, the Geosciences Division of MGB MIMAROPA continued to improve the region-wide implementation of geohazard mapping projects through streamlined acquisition and processing of geologic hazard database. The results of geohazard mapping surveys conducted in the past were reviewed and updated to provide critical inputs to the creation of new database for risk exposure analysis, interpretation of elements at risk, and development of landslide and flooding exposure maps. For the first half of 2016, the planned activities under the Geohazard Survey and Assessment Program were implemented in Oriental and Occidental Mindoro as there have been broad scale changes to rivers and their watersheds in these provinces that have resulted in an increased flood risk after “Typhoon Nona” devastated Mindoro Island on December 15, 2015. The remaining target activities, most specifically, geohazard IEC as well as conduct of other VRA surveys were carried out during the last half of 2016 covering the provinces of Palawan, Romblon and Marinduque. Major geohazard activities accomplished included updating of flood/landslide susceptibility maps, conduct of VRA activities, development of hazard exposure maps, and holding of geohazard seminars/meetings along with distribution of IEC materials to LGUs. Risk analysis applied in VRA involves the use of available information to estimate the risk (from hazards) to individuals or populations, property, and environment. The analysis generally contains the following steps: hazard identification, hazard assessment, elements at risk/exposure analysis, vulnerability assessment and risk estimation. MGB’s streamlined VRA methodology was used to conduct risk analysis and to develop initial geohazard exposure maps. This methodology relied mainly on updated flood and landslide susceptibility maps, remotely sensed data provided by various government agencies, spatial and nonspatial datasets from local government units, and information acquired from detailed recording and mapping of field evidences. Flood/landslide analysis focused primarily on the estimation of potential adverse impacts using all available elements at risk. Re-scoping of critical geohazard areas was initially undertaken to generate a broad range of flood/landslide risk indicators that can provide significant flood and landslide scenarios to the affected communities. For this year, VRA activities involving field and desktop surveys were

2

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

completed in the eleven (11) municipalities in the provinces of Oriental Mindoro, Occidental Mindoro, Marinduque and Palawan, and two (2) municipalities in the province of Capiz in Region VI as additional target outside MIMAROPA region. Total number of municipalities covered by VRA is thirteen (13), which is equivalent to 108% accomplishment relative to the annual target of twelve (12) municipalities. Development of flood/landslide exposure maps using various elements at risk is still on-going for the total thirteen VRA areas. In addition to flood/landslide risk assessment, activity related to updating of flood and landslide hazard database was performed in critical flood/landslide prone areas of Baco municipality in Oriental Mindoro. This updating exercise was performed as a result of changes in landscape and overall morphology of the river systems caused by “Typhoon Nona”. Results of this activity were used to update the flood/landslide susceptibility zonation and development of flood/landslide exposure maps of the municipality. The region-wide implementation of the coastal geohazard mapping program continued this year with the participation of all MGB Regional Offices in the completion of geohazard assessment of the coastal cities/municipalities of Regions VII and VIII as priority target areas for 2016. As for the accomplishment of coastal mapping targets assigned to the region, MGB-MIMAROPA completed the assessment of nine (9) target coastal municipalities in Western and Eastern Samar. The inclusion of this detailed 1:10,000 scale coastal mapping project in the regular planned activities of MGB commenced in 2015 to determine the impact of climate change on coastal environment. The 2016 accomplishment under coastal geohazard mapping included mainly identification of shoreline shifts and coastal hazards, and conduct of beach profiling activities. A total of nine (9) coastal municipalities were assessed covering the coastal lowlands and shorelines of Marabut, Basey, Sta. Rita, Talalora and Villareal, all in the province of Western Samar, and the municipalities of Lawaan, Balangiga, Giporlos and Guiuan in Eastern Samar province. This mapping coverage is equivalent to accomplishment rating of 100% based on the annual target of nine (9) municipalities assessed for coastal hazards and shoreline changes. On geohazard IEC campaign activities, all programmed plans were implemented on time following the target work planset for the entire year of 2016. The accomplished activities on Geohazard IEC included dissemination of updated advisories and lists of identified flood and landslide hotspots, provision of updated geohazard maps to local government units, conduct of geohazard meeting/seminar per municipality, and participation in Disaster Risk Reduction and Management (DRRM) activities initiated by various DRRM member agencies. From January to December 2016,a total of 64 geohazard meetings and seminars intended for barangay officials and MDRRMC officers were conducted in the 11 municipalities of Oriental Mindoro; 11 municipalities of Occidental Mindoro; 2 municipalities of Marinduque; 16 municipalities of Romblon; and24 municipalities of Palawan province. A total of 1,078 barangays were informed about the meetings organized by MGB-MIMAROPA. This number gives an equivalent accomplishment rating of 100% based on annual target of 1,078 barangays provided with geohazard seminar and updated IEC materials. Aside from the conduct of regular geohazard surveys in the region, MGBMIMAROPA also served forty two (42) clients requesting for geohazard assessment assistance and other geological evaluation surveys. The Office issued a total of twenty (29) geohazard certifications for various projects involving construction of housing units, school

3

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

buildings and evacuation sites, and provided assistance to secure other geohazard-related documents, mostly verbal requests from LGUs and DRRM-member agencies. Also, twenty one (21) investigation reports were prepared for various developers, proponents and LGUs. These are mainly geohazard identification reports (GIR) related to ECC application, and geoenvironmental assessment reports pertaining to identification of waste disposal sites. Other significant geohazard accomplishment in 2016 involved inspection of critical structures and facilities of Marcopper with highlights of investigation on the occurrence of subsidence and its potential mechanism in the reservoir floor of Maguila-guila Siltation Dam, a zoned earthen dam, of Marcopper Mining Corporation (MMC) located in Sta. Cruz, Marinduque. During the first quarter of 2016, special investigations on the causes and effects of Typhoon Nona in Northeast Oriental Mindoro were carried out in response to the multi-sectoral task force “Iwas Baha” formed by the Chief Executive of the province.MGB MIMAROPA, being the lead member of the task force who has mandate to conduct geologic hazard assessment, commissioned a team of geologists to undertake flood hazard investigation covering the major flooding hotspots in the municipalities of Naujan, Baco, and San Teodoro, including the City of Calapan. Impacts of the operation of Sta. Clara hydropower plant in Bgy. Arangin, Naujan municipality, were also included in the task force’s hazard investigation.

Mineral Investment Promotion Program The Mineral Investment Promotion Program aims for the institution of mining reforms towards responsible and sustainable mining and the identification of mining investment opportunities. For the Permits/Contracts Issued/Indorsed, this Office was able to indorse to the MGB-Central Office two (2) applications, namely, Application for Mineral Agreement denominated as AMA-IV-144A of Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation and Exploration Permit Application denominated as EPA-IVB-324 of Itawes Mining Exploration Limited Company. Unfortunately, this translates only to a 75% accomplishment inasmuch as this activity was affected by the DENR Memorandum Order (DMO) No. 2016-01 dated 08 July 2016 which provides, among others, for a moratorium on new mining projects. Under Section 1 of the said DAO, the moratorium shall cover the acceptance, processing and /or approval of mining applications and/or new mining projects for all metallic and nonmetallic minerals. Other activities included in the Mineral Investment Promotion Program are the processing of applications for Mineral Ore Export Permit (MOEP), Ore Transport Permit (OTP) and Certification to transport small quantities of mineral/ore samples which have reached 81%, 103% and 75%, respectively, of the annual targets. Jointly, the OTC/Certification target account for 87% of the target for the year. The generally below-target accomplishments, specifically in the issuance of Mineral Ore Export Permit and Ore Transport Certification can be primarily attributed to the suspension of the mining operations of Berong Nickel Corporation (BNC) and Citinickel Mines and Development Corporation (CMDC), two of the three large-scale nickel mining

4

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

companies in the Region. CMDC’s suspension was ordered even prior to the conduct of the mining audit under DMO No. 2016-01, which refers to the audit of all operating mines and the moratorium on the approval of new mining projects. Moreover the price of nickel has been very persistently low during the 1st three (3) quarters of the year, thus also affecting the selling frequencies. Another activity under this program include is the assistance to P/CMRBs and other stakeholders. For this part, the Region's representatives actively participated in the meetings conducted by the Provincial Mining Regulatory Boards of Occidental Mindoro, Oriental Mindoro, Romblon and Palawan. A regional small-scale summit was also conducted to update the different P/CMRBs on new laws and regulations regarding small-scale mining. Another significant accomplishment for this year is the identification a Minahang Bayan site in So. Underground, Bgy. Poblacion, Quezon, Palawan. The area was located inside the mineral claim of Central Palawan Mining designated as MPSA No. 171-2001-IVB. The commodity of the proposed Minahang Bayan site is limestone which is processed into hydrated lime as product using four (4) units of furnace.

Mining Industry Development Program The Mining Industry Development Program is geared towards the attainment of an economically revitalized and environmentally and socially responsible mining industry. It essentially consists of the administration and supervision of all stages of mining operation from exploration to development and utilization of minerals. To support the program and in order to achieve its goal, MGB IV-B (MIMAROPA) dynamically conducts compliance monitoring on the conditionalities stipulated under their mining contracts/permits, including the implementation of plans and programs as required by and in accordance to existing mining and other applicable laws. A total of twelve (12) mining permits – nine (9) Mineral Production Sharing Agreements (MPSAs), two (2) Mineral Processing Permits (MPPs), and a Financial and Technical Assistance Agreement (FTAA) were monitored as to compliance with the terms and conditions of the permits and progress report on the implementation of activities indicated in the submitted work plans. Meanwhile, monitoring of Integrated Safety, Health and Environmental (ISHES) Programs on four (4) Mineral Production Sharing Agreement (MPSA) holders, (all in the exploration stage) located in Sablayan, Occ. Mindoro and Victoria, Or. Mindoro and one (1) FTAA holder located in the Mindoro Provinces was conducted. The activity is anchored on the companies’ approved Environmental Work Program (EnWP), Annual Safety and Health Program (ASHP), and the Community Development Program (CDP). Moreover, Multipartite Monitoring Teams (MMTs) are being operationalized annually in all active mining operations to establish an appropriate check and balance mechanism in the monitoring of project implementation. Three (3) nickel mining companies, namely Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation (RTNMC), Berong Nickel Corporation (BNC), and Citinickel Mines and Development Corporation (CMDC), and two (2) nickel processing plants, Coral

5

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Bay Nickel Corporation (CBNC) and Unichamp Mineral Philippines, Inc., are being monitored quarterly by their respective Multipartite Monitoring Teams (MMTs) relative to their accomplishments on Safety, Health, Environment and Social Programs (SHES).

Mine Rehabilitation Program This program is intended to assess and determine the existing and imminent/adverse environmental impact posed by mine-out/mine affected areas. It is also aimed at the formulation and implementation of sound mitigating measures that will enhance positive impacts and minimize negative impacts on the environment by abandoned sites. First in the list is the regular monitoring of Marcopper Mining Corporation, spearheaded by the Mine Safety, Environment and Social Development Division that was aimed to: (1) to visually assess the structural integrity of the mine structures and facilities; (2) to determine presence of hazards that may pose hazard to the environment and to the residents of the nearby communities; and (3) to closely monitor and/or to have an update on the precarious status of Maguila-Guila Dam. This Office also conducted an investigation on the subsidence/sediment collapse within the silt impoundment facilities of Marcopper Mining Corporation located in Maguilaguila Creek, Sitio Taluntunan, Brgy. Bocboc, Mogpog, Marinduque. Second is the Palawan Quicksilver Mines, Inc. (PQMI) Rehabilitation Project. It may be recalled that The Philippine Development Plan (PDP) 2011-2016 envisions an environment that is healthy, ecologically balanced, sustainably productive, climate change resilient and responsive to the needs of the present and future generations as described in Chapter 9 of the plan, “Sustainable and Climate-Resilient Environment and Natural Resources.” The Palawan Quicksilver Mines, Inc. (PQMI) abandoned its open pit mining operation located in Brgy. Sta Lourdes, Puerto Princesa City in 1976. The pit lake environs, as assessed by the Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB), poses potential geologic hazard, such as; rain induced landslide, slope undercutting and surface erosion. Moreover, presence of pollutants in the pit water itself due to leachate from the sanitary landfill managed by the City Government of Puerto Princesa and human activity, including possible remnants/contamination of mercury that may still be present in the water of the pond and its downstream. The area was assessed as potential for ecotourism and adheres to the socioeconomic and environment development programs of the City Government of Puerto Princesa (CGPP). MGB Region IVB (MIMAROPA) entered into a Memorandum of Agreement (MOA) with the CGPP on 29 December 2015 for a joint collaboration in the project implementation. The MGB and the CGPP are now steadfast to implement the three (3) – year duration on the rehabilitation and development of the pit lake and pit benches with an allotment of fifteen million (15million) on a five million (5million) wedged release each year beginning on 2014. Accordingly, this endeavor is projected as a major showcase

6

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

converting a once futile abandoned mine site into one of Puerto Princesa’s tourist destinations.

Resolution of Complaints/Cases/Conflicts There were 11 investigations conducted by the technical personnel related to mining, safety, health and environment that were filed by concerned individuals/stakeholders to this Office and were promptly and judiciously investigated and resolved.

Anti-Illegal Mining This activity is geared towards curbing down, if not totally eradicating, illegal mining in the Region. For CY 2016, five Cease and Desist Orders (CDO) were issued by this Office based on the results of the various investigation conducted by the technical personnel of this Office in coordination with the Deputized Environment and Natural Resources Officers (DENROs) for Mines and different Local Government Units (LGUs).

7

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

HIGHLIGHTS OF ACCOMPLISHMENTS A.01 General Administration and Support Services (GASS) The Finance and Administrative Division (FAD) provides general administrative services pertaining to human and financial resources, property and records management. It has the following sections, namely: 1) Finance Section which provides budgeting and accounting services, and 2) Administrative Section which provides services on human resources, property and records management including cashiering and other general services. A.01.a.1 Administrative Services The Administrative Section continues its role in the implementation of plans and programs on human resource management and development and civil service rules and regulations. Monthly reports on Manpower Strength were regularly submitted to the MGB Central Office. Attendance of personnel to various trainings were supported and coordinated by the Administrative Section for continuous updating and skills development and improvement. The table below shows the list of Special Orders issued for CY 2016 with regard to trainings and seminars conducted and participated by the MGB MIMAROPA personnel. Summary of Regional Special Order Issued in CY 2016 Title

8

Duration

Venue

Seminar-workshop on the Implementation of the Government Accounting Manual and the 2015 Year-end Closing of the Books cum Conference on Administrative Matters and Mechanism

January 10-15, 2016

Cagayan de Oro

1st 2016 Middle Management Conference

February 3-5, 2016

Brentwood, Quezon City

1st Philippine Environment Summit

February 9-11, 2016

SMX Convention Center, Pasay City

Technical Conference on ILO Convention on Safety and Health in Mines Training on RA 9184 and its Revised IRR including the Preparation of Bidding Documents 2016 National Mine Safety, Environment and Social Development Division Participation in the Sama-samang Pagsulong sa mga Agenda ni Juana as part of the National Women's Month Celebration

February 9-11, 2016

Century Park Hotel, Manila

February 23-24, 2016 March 14-18, 2016

Ortigas

March 16, 2016

Quirino Grandstand, Manila

Basic Records and Archives Management

March 29-31, 2016

Hotel Jen, Manila

Capacity Building and Continuing Legal Education for DENR Lawyers Guild Budgeting Workshop for the Preparation of FY 2017 Budget Proposal 6th Freedom Run

March 28 to April 1, 2016 April 5-9, 2016

B Hotel, Scout Rallos, Laging Handa, Quezon City Sequoia Hotel, Quezon City

10-Apr-16

CCP Complex, Manila

Learning Course on Administrative Reforms and Anti-corruption 4th MAB and Panel of Arbitrators Seminar Workshop on Mining Conflict/ Dispute Resolution

April 18-22, 2016

ENR Academy, Carranglan, Nueva Ecija Puerto Princesa City, Palawan

April 18-22, 2016

Bayview Park Hotel, Manila

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Summary of Regional Special Order Issued in CY 2016 Title

Duration

Venue

In-house Basic ARC GIS Training for Technical Personnel

April 19-22, 2016

MGB MIMAROPA Conference Room

3rd Pro-earth Run

April 30, 2016

Mall of Asia Grounds, Pasay City

42nd Directorate Meeting and Convention of Geodetic Engineers

May 19-21, 2016

Vigan City, Ilocos Sur

4th Mining Engineers Convention

June 8-12, 2016

Legaspi City, Albay

Training of Trainers on DENR Strategic Performance Management System Gender Sensitivity Orientation

June 14-17, 2016

Azurro Hotel, Angeles City

May 27, 2016

GIS Mapshop

June 27 to July 1, 2016 July 12, 2016

Luca Cucina Italiana, Talipanan, Puerto Galera, Oriental Mindoro Calapan City, Oriental Mindoro

Conduct of Re-orientation Seminar on the Implementation of the DENR Strategic Performance Management System and discussion on Basic Finance and Administrative Policies Participation in the Competency-Based System Validation and Updating Seminar-workshop of the MGB Participation in the R.A.C.E. to Serve Fun Run VI

July 26-28, 2016

September 3, 2016

Creation of MGB MIMAROPA Screening Committee for Purposes of RA 8439 otherwise known as the Magna Carta for Scientists, Engineers, Researchers and other Science and Technology Personnel in Government

August 2, 2016

Participation in the 2016 Geosciences Workshop

August 24-29, 2016

Participation in the Joint Mobile Blood Donation activity of the DENR MIMAROPA and the Philippine Children's Medical Center Participation in the Strategic Planning for the 2018 MGB Gender and Development Work plan and Budget and Orientation on Basic Concepts on Gender and Development Participation in the Consumer Awareness and Trade Fair Exhibits Participation in the Consumer Empowerment Orientation Conduct of Orientation on Pertinent Guidelines and Documentary Requirements for Common Government Transactions

MGB MIMAROPA Conference Room

Roxas Blvd. Manila

DENR MIMAROPA Conference Room September 26-30, 2016

Camelot Hotel, Mother Ignacia Avanue, Quezon City

September 30, 2016

Assembly Hall, Cafeteria Bldg. of Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas DENR, Quezon City

October 7, 2016 October 7, 2016

Creation of MGB MIMAROPA ISO Team

October 12, 2016

Conduct of 6th Regional Small Scale Mining Summit Participation in the Technical Report and Correspondence Writing Skills Seminar-workshop Participation in the Programming Workshop for the Preparation of the 2017 Work and Financial Plan

October 18-20, 2016 October 18-20, 2016 October 24-29, 2016

MGB MIMAROPA Conference Room

Bayview Park Hotel, Manila Icon Hotel, Timog Avenue, Quezon City

9

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Summary of Regional Special Order Issued in CY 2016 Title Seminar on Implementing the Use of Government Accounting Manual for National Government Agencies Participation in the 4th National Community Relations Officers' Conference Participation to the 63rd Annual Mine Safety and Environment Conference Participation in the Training and Capability Building for Statistical Data and Analysis, website maintenance and Information Dissemination Participation in the Annual Geological Convention Participation in the 3rd PAGBA Quarterly Seminar and Meeting Participation in the NEDA MIMAROPA multi stakeholder Summit Participation in the Public Consultation on the Proposed Amendments to the Social Development and Management Program Participation in the Orientation on the 2016 Omnibus Rules on Appointments and other Human Resource Actions Participation in the System Development Training for the MGB in-house Legal Information System

Duration

Venue

November 7-11, 2016

COA Region IV-B, Quezon City

November 16, 2016

Baguio City

November 15-18, 2016 November 22-26, 2016

Baguio City

December 13-14, 2016 November 16-19, 2016 November 17-18, 2016 December 8, 2016

Makati City

December 8-9, 2016

Antipolo City

December 19-21, 2016

Pasay City

Metro Manila

Davao City Tagaytay City DENR, Quezon City

In compliance with Section 93 of the Republic Act No 10155, the Region has fully updated the requirements and conditions of good governance by posting in the MGB MIMAROPA Region official website, with Uniform Resource Locator (URL), http://region4b.mgb.gov.ph/ the following: 

 

Transparency Seal Provision of the General Appropriations Act of 2016 which include the thrust of the Office, name of its officials with their position and designation and contact information, annual financial reports, approved budget, programs, projects and activities, beneficiaries and status of implementation, annual procurement plan, system of ranking delivery units and individuals and Quality Management System (QMS) certified by International Certifying body or Agency Operation Manual. Office service standards known as Citizen's Charter were also posted in a conspicuous area in the office, and All regular official and employees submitted their respective Statement of Assets, Liabilities and Networth (SALN) for CY 2015 in compliance with Section 8 of Republic Act No. 6713 otherwise known as "Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials and Employees."

The Administrative Section satisfactorily supervise the maintenance of equipment, furniture and fixture and provides safety, security, and transport services. The Region was also able to conduct regular housekeeping together with the implementation of waste segregation program. The Division also conducted regular de-cluttering activities and monitoring of the performance of janitorial services. Reports

10

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

on fuel, electrical and water consumption including telephone usage and other mandatory expenses were regularly monitored. In terms of property management, the Administrative Section was able to procures, distributed and stored supplies, materials and equipment needed in the operation and properly act as overall custodian of office's property. In terms of records management, the Region accurately received and released and maintained records/ documents. For the Cashiering activities, the Region appropriately collects payments and received funds and temporarily acts as custodian of payments and funds. A.01.a.2 Financial Management Services For CY 2016, the Finance Section continues its role in implementing the accounting, budgeting and auditing rules and regulations including provision of assistance in administering the internal operations of other divisions. It has provided financial logistic support to various divisions' operations. Work and Financial Plan targets we all accomplished. Financial reports and documents which include Financial Monitoring Reports, Quarterly Statement of Appropriations, Allotments, Obligations, Disbursements and Balances (per activity and by object of expenditure), List of Allotments and Sub-allotments (FAR 1-B), Ageing of Due and Demandable Obligations (FAR No. 3), Monthly Report of Disbursement (FAR No. 4), Quarterly Report of Revenue and Other Receipts (FAR No. 5), and Statement of Comparison of Budget and Actual Amounts were prepared and submitted to concerned government agencies. As of December 30, 2016, the Region was able to obligate Forty Nine Million One Hundred Seventy Six Thousand Three Hundred Seventy One and Forty Two Centavos (PhP 49,176,371.42). This represents 98.67% of the total allotment (PS, MOOE and CO) of the Region. Annex A shows the Financial Monitoring Report of the Region for the entire year in review. The Region was also able to submit its budget proposal for Fiscal Year 2017 in the amount of Thirty Eight Million Four Hundred Ninety Eight Thousand Pesos (PhP 38,498,000.00). Total PS budget amounted to Nineteen Million Two Hundred Twenty Three Thousand Pesos (PhP 19,223,000.00). Total MOOE budget is Nineteen Million Two Hundred Thirty Nine Thousand Pesos (PhP 19,239,000.00), breakdown as follows: PhP 5,020,000.00 for the General Administration and Support Services, PhP 334,000.00 for Support to Operations, PhP 1,084,000.00 for the Mineral Resource Services, PhP 3,552,000.00 for Mineral Land Administration and PhP 9,249,000.00 for the Geosciences Development Services. For CY 2016, the Region was able to generate a total collection amounting to One Hundred Twenty Two Million Eighty Two Thousand Four Hundred Twenty Three and Six Centavos (PhP 122,082,423.06). Summary of revenue generated if shown in Annex B.

11

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

A.01.a.3 Planning Management Services The Planning Unit has continued to provide technical assistance during the preparation of CY 2017 budget proposal and in the preparation of short, medium and long range plans for the Region in the context of national development goals. The Region was also able to submit to MGB Central Office its proposed budget for CY 2017. In terms of monitoring of plans and programs, regular staff meetings were conducted to ensure accomplishment of the targeted activities and programs for the year. Monthly Physical Accomplishment Report including the monthly Physical and Financial Accomplishment Monitoring Report and Performance Information Report were regularly submitted to the MGB Central Office.

12

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

OPERATIONS A.03.a MINERAL RESOURCE SERVICE A.03.a.1 Communication Plan for Minerals Development This program involves the conduct of awareness and advocacy on mineral resources and geosciences, capacity building on Mineral Resources and Geociences laws, rules and regulations, as well as the generation, publication/dissemination of Information, Education and Communication (IEC) materials. Listed below are the accomplishments for CY 2016 under this program. A.03.a.1.a Conduct of Awareness and Advocacy on Mineral Resources and Geosciences (MRGS) The MGB MIMAROPA Region employed various modes of information and advocacy campaigns to enhance the understanding and awareness level of all stakeholders of minerals industry. These include: a. Dialogue with the Sangguniang Panlalawigan Technical personnel from this Office conducted dialogues with the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of the five provinces in MIMAROPA, as listed below. This translates to 100% accomplishment of the annual target under this activity. 1. Dialogue with the Members of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of Palawan on 02 August 2016 Initially, the dialogue was calendared in the regular session of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan. However, going into the initial deliberation/discussion of the Agenda for the day’s session, the members were informed of an on-going rally of residents and IPs from Brgy. Berong, Quezon, Palawan seeking the lifting of the Suspension Order against Berong Nickel Corporation (BNC). Vice-Governor Socrates suggested meeting with the Team in the Vice-Governor’s Lounge in an Executive Session. The Team generally updated the body on the latest events in the DENR/MGB and the mining industry in the region, particularly in Palawan. Hereunder are the highlights of discussion during the 5th Regular Session of the 42nd Sangguniang Panlalawigan of the Province of Palawan held in the Vice-Governor’s Lounge on 02 August 2016: 

 

Organization of the DENR Audit Team who will validate compliances of mining companies to mining and environmental laws, rules and regulations; Acquisition of ISO 14001 Certification of mining companies; Suspension Order issued to Berong Nickel Corporation;  Partial submergence of LCT Marl Jayson

13

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report





 Discoloration of Llabongan River and Berong Bay Suspension Order against Citinickel Mines and Development Corporation; and  2012 suspension because of the spillage incident in Pinagduguan River that was lifted already  2014 suspension due to spillage incident in Pulot River, likewise already lifted  Suspension issued by the Assistant Director of MGB due to documentary requirement Commendation on the performance of Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation and Coral Bay Nickel Corporation.

2. Dialogue with the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of Marinduque on19 August 2016 On August 19, 2016, two technical personnel conducted a dialogue with the vice governor of Marinduque and members of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan in the Provincial Capitol. Prior to the dialogue, the group conducted ocular inspection of the river quarries in response to the request of the Sannguiang Panlalawigan. Hereunder are the highlights of the discussion: 

 



The Sanggunian requested for an update of the composition of the Provincial Mining Regulatory Board (PMRB). The body was informed that the Board was reconstituted through a Special Order signed by then Sec. Ramon Paje on October 2015. The SP then requested the names of the members of the PMRB which the technical personnel provided. The SP expressed their desire to be represented in the PMRB. They were then briefed by the technical personnel on the duties and authority of the PMRB. Result of the ocular inspection conducted earlier was reported to the SP.

3. Dialogue with the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of Romblon last Sep. 2, 2016 A special meeting of the SangguniangPanlalawigan (SP) of Romblon regarding Alad Mining and Development Corporation (AMDC) was held in Quezon City on 31 August 2016. The meeting was called to order by the Vice Governor and Chairman of the SP, Hon. Jose R. Riano. Issues raised: One of the SP member, Hon. Sam Romero stated that the earnings of the local government from mining is not proportionate to the damages it caused. He also emphasized the need to have an environmental fund as per mining and environmental laws, rules and regulations. Hon. Romero stressed out that it's alright to explore Romblon's resources but it should be done in a responsible manner and suggested to AMDC the planting of Cadena-de-amor or Coral vine

14

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

as part of the company’s rehabilitation activities/regreening project. He further suggested that a view deck on the mountain top similar to that of Cebu be constructed as part of AMDC's assistance to community development. Other issues raised: Engr. Alvin S. Requimin informed about the lack of supervision of some quarry operators and recommended that the “camote mining” type of operation be stopped. Vice Governor Jose R. Riano added that among the problems usually encountered is that "it's easy to register as part of the cooperative, but no monitoring is being done on its members.” He suggested that stricter policies be implemented with regard to this matter. He further said that the other problem concerning the local processing of marble is that "rubbles bring less revenues for the province than marble blocks/blockettes. AMDC presented their five-year work program during the meeting. among the issues raised were as follows:  On tax contribution, Hon. Romero commented that AMDC’s tax contribution is quite minimal to which Hon. SP Member Andres Fondevilla replied that it is because the province is using “waste material” (referring to rubbles) as the basis for generating tax revenues;  On economic contribution of AMDC, SP Romero said that the local employees of the company are earning relatively good income;  Hon. Fondevilla suggested that AMDC provide updates in the form of Self-Monitoring Reports with regard to AMDC's activities and environmental compliance;  Hon. Fondevilla encouraged AMDC to continue with its production of aesthetic novelty items and that he requested the company to process the novelties in Romblon to generate additional tax revenues for the province. He likewise suggested that AMDC establish an office in Romblon, Romblon to again generate tax income for the province. AMDC, however, informed that the company already has an office in Bgy. Cajimos and that the company is paying annual fee for the acquisition of mayor's permit aside from other taxes being paid in the municipality;  Engr. Pamintuan suggested to promote the use of Computer Numerical Control (CNC) in carving marble products to maintain consistency in design dimensions;  For and in behalf of the SP Members, Hon. Romero apologized to AMDC for having mistaken the company of clearing overburden from the mountain top in Bgy. Caray-Caray. This was done upon clarification by AMDC that the quarry areas considered as eyesores by Hon. Romero were not operated by the company but were undertaken by illegal quarry operators who were recently issued a Cease and Desist Order by the Provincial Environment and Natural Resources Officer of Romblon;  Engr. Requimin recommended establishing boundary markers on the quarry area/s of AMDC;

15

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report



It was learned that the application for the Small Scale Mining Contract of Agtongo-Bagasyong Multi-Purpose Cooperative (ABMC) is at the Office of the Provincial Governor pending renewal of the Contract.

4. Dialogue with the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of Occidental Mindoro last Nov. 14, 2016 Technical personnel form this Office were able to conduct a dialogue with the Honorable Peter J. Alfaro, Vice-Governor and SP Chairman of Occidental Mindoro. The activity was undertaken at the Provincial Capitol Bldg. Compound of Occidental Mindoro on November 13-15, 2016, inclusive. Vice-Governor Alfaro was briefed, among others, on DENR Memorandum Order (DMO) No. 2016-01 dated 08 July2016 and MGB Memorandum Circular No. 2016-03 dated 28 January 2016. The former refers to the audit of all operating mines and the moratorium on the approval of new mining projects. The latter, on the other hand, refers to the basic procedure to effectively implement the government’s campaign against illegal mining activities. As regards the former, the Honorable Vice-Governor and concurrent SP Chairman was informed that ten (10) metallic mines were already suspended prior to the audit, twenty (20) mines were recommended for suspension due to various offenses after the audit, and only eleven (11) mines passed the audit.

5. Dialogue with the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of Oriental Mindoro last Dec. 5, 2016 MGB MIMAROPA technical personnel conducted a dialogue with Hon. Jean Paulo R. Umali, SP Member and Chair of the Committee on Environment on Dec. 5, 2016 in the Provincial Capitol of Oriental Mindoro. He was briefed on DENR Memorandum Order (DMO) No. 2016-01 dated July 8, 2016 and MGB Memorandum Circular No. 2016-03 dated January 28, 2016. The former refers to the audit of all operating mines and moratorium on the approval of new mining projects. The latter, on the other hand, refers to the basic procedure to effectively implement the government’s campaign against illegal mining activities.

16

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

b. Dialogue with other groups (Religious groups, academe, etc.) A total of six (6) dialogues with different groups were conducted by the personnel of this Office resulting to an annual accomplishment of 100%. 1. Dialogue with Tagbanua tribe thru BATA, Inc. in Quezon, Palawan On January 27, 2016, MGB MIMAROPA technical personnel conducted a dialogue with the Tagbanuas Indigenous Cultural Committees from the three sitios of Barangays Berong and Aramaywan in Quezon, Palawan. During the course of the dialogue, it was explained to the IP communities why royalty payments (minimum of 1% of the gross revenues of mining contractors) should be spent wisely under the Community Royalty Development Program that was developed in cooperation with the National Commission of Indigenous Peoples (NCIP). It was emphasized that the CRDP is important in the attainment of sustainable development in their communities, even after the life of the mine, and preservation of their cultural customs and traditions.Another highlight of the activity is the inauguration of three IP Tagbanua tribal halls. 2. Groundbreak Series: Palawan Edition Intensifying their advocacy towards responsible mining, the UP Mining Engineering Society (UP MINERS), in partnership with the Chamber of Mines of the Philippines and Nickel Asia Corporation, conducted thethird installment of Groundbreak Series in the province of Palawan held on February 19, 2016 at the Legend Hotel in Puerto Princesa City. The one-day symposium aimed to educate the participants, who are grades 4 to 6, high school and college students from various schools in Palawan and the University of the Philippines, and promote the conduct of responsiblemining. This year’s theme, The Quest for Genuine Responsible Mining Advocacy and Awareness, summarizes the organization’s goals and principles towards their advocacy with emphasis on the current situation of the Mining industry in Palawan. MGB IV-B Regional Director Roland De Jesus was one of the invited resource speakers for the event.His discussion focused on the current mining laws and policies in the country. He presented the concept and importance of sustainable development in the conduct of the mining business, and the interdependency of its three pillars – economic, environmental, and social development.

17

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Also invited as resource speakers were Dr. Carlo Arcilla of the National Institute of Geological Sciences; Dr. Bibiano Ranes, Mining Rehabilitation Unit Head of the Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation; and Mr. Jose Bayani Baylon of the Nickel Asia Corporation who provided the synthesis of all discussions. Other highlights of the event are the Open Forum where participants actively posed queries on various presentations, and the poster-making and essay-writing contests. Groundbreak is a project of the UP MINERS with objectives of promoting and raising the level of awareness and interest of students on different issues on mining as well as thewidespreadpromotion of the practice of responsible mining in the country.

Recognition of resource speakers (from left to right): Dr. Bibiano Ranes,Regional Director Roland De Jesus, and Dr. Carlo Arcilla (NIGS) with UP MINERS members and Mr. JB Baylon.

3. Dialogue/Meeting with the Contractors Association of Puerto Princesa City

and

Sand

and

Gravel

The dialogue aimed to reach out to sand and gravel operators in the areas to address their issues and concerns. The association’s recent activities in its area such as tree planting, distribution of concrete monuments for marking of boundaries of their permit areas and applications for Mineral Processing Permit were discussed. Issues such as the problem on the location of tree planting activities as required in the renewal of application for Commercial Sand and Gravel Permit was raised by the Association’s president. It was suggested that the area to be planted should be coordinated with the CENRO-PPC and seedlings to be used should be sourced from the same. Technical personnel from this Office reminded that a commitment

18

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

certificate on the Tree Planting Program should be submitted for the renewal of application to continue. It was also tackled that Multi-Partite Monitoring Team (MMT) should be established to monitor compliance on environmental provisions in the sand and gravel extraction activities in the City. 4. Dialogue with Indigenous People's group in Oriental Mindoro In the course of the fieldwork regarding the conduct of the Integrated Safety and Health, Environment and Social Development (ISHES) monitoring of exploration permits in Oriental and Occidental Mindoro, the MSESDD personnel took the chance to confer with Mayor Unyok, Tribal Chieftain of the Mangyans in the Mindoro Provinces. Initially, Mayor Unyok was asked on the assistance given to them by Intex Resources Philippines, Inc. (IRPI). He gladly replied that there were numerous programs provided to them by the company that certainly help uplift their living conditions. Some of the assistance given to them were, but not limited, to the following:  Formation of cooperatives;  IPs participation in the National Greening Program of the DENR, nursery operations and Mining Forest Program;  Assistance in the processing of their Certificate of Ancestral Domain Claim (CADC) for subsequent titling (CADT);  Provision of P5Million livelihood funds and organizational operating funds, and of poultry, livestock (cattle, goats) and work animals (carabaos);  Provision of a variety of materials, tools and equipment;  Agro-forestry projects;  Support for education/scholarships; and  Organizational training and skills development. Mayor Unyok raised the issue on the potability of water supply coming from the impounding tank provided to them by the company. It was informed that their water supply has a high coliform content. Result of the potability test on the water taken from faucets sourced from the tank which contains high content of coliform. Mayor Unyok, in collaboration with IRPI, was advised to coordinate with the local health authorities to improve the quality of their drinking water for proper treatment process. For the time being, he was advised to discourage his constituents in Brgy. San Agustin to drink or use water for cooking purposes sourced from the tank.

19

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

In an inspection of the periphery of the water tank, it was found that there are human wastes scattered near and its surrounding areas most likely affected the quality of their drinking water. An IEC, in cooperation with the local health authorities was recommended regarding the importance of hygiene and sanitation. 5. Dialogue with the students of St. Anthony College, Calapan, Inc. MGB MIMAROPA conducted an Information, Education and Communication (IEC) campaign on responsible mining in St. Anthony College, Calapan City Inc., Camilmil Campus on July 7, 2016. The activity was attended by more than a hundred students of different degree programs, together with their professors and instructors. The activity aimed to educate students on responsible mining and sustainable development. Presentations covers topics on overview of mining, minerals found in MIMAROPA Region, government mining policies and the three pillars of sustainable development – environmental protection, social development and economic growth. The students were given a chance to raise their issues and concerns during the open forum. 6. PH-EITI Forum: Making Transparency Work for You The Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB)-MIMAROPA Regional Office participated in the 3rd leg of the Philippine-EITI roadshows staged in Puerto Princesa City on September 15, 2016 as a show of its continuing support to the promotion of transparency and accountability in the mining, oil and gas industries. The series of forum was conceptualized to serve as a regular venue for updating and continuous dialogue between the government sector and its stakeholders on policy gaps and issues pertaining to regulation and governance of the sector and for collective discussion of plans to address the identified gaps. The forum was attended by participants from the national and local governments, civil society organizations, and representatives from mineral, oil and gas companies in the Province of Palawan. The event aims to strengthen EITI implementation process, specifically the full disclosure of payments, contracts and other relevant information, to improve governance and ensure that the country is rightfully benefiting from the extractive industries. The forum specifically catered for the presentation of key findings of the 2nd PH-EITI country report and for gathering of feedbacks from stakeholders; initiated dialogue on policy gaps and issues pertaining to

20

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

regulation and governance of the sector; encouraged collective discussions on plans to address the identified gaps and issues and improve EITI implementation in the country; and urged to maximize the EITI process as a tool to strengthen governance of the extractive industries at the local level. MGB-MIMAROPA Regional Director Roland De Jesus imparted relevant information on Environmental Governance and Monitoring Processes of the Multipartite Monitoring Teams and LGUs. SDMP and Local Development Planning Process was provided by Ms. RocelynF. Rebullante of MGB-MIMAROPA.Other presenters were from MGB Central Office, other government agencies and civil society organizations. One of the highlights of the event is the Transparency Pledge of Commitment to the implementation of the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative by the participants as their commitment to promote transparency and accountability in the extractive industries sector. PH-EITI is an international standard that seeks to improve the transparency around the countries’ oil, gas and mineral resources based on the premise that a country’s natural resources belong to the State and its citizens have the right to know what their government is receiving from the extractive industries and how the government is spending. EITI is overseen by an international board, with members from government, companies and civil society, the Mining Industry Coordinating Council (MICC) chaired by the Department of Finance (DOF) and the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR). c. Radio/TV Guestings For CY 2016, fifteen (15) radio/TV interviews were completed thereby giving 125% accomplishment of the annual target. Details of radio/TV interviews from January to December 2016 are tabulated on the below.

Interviewer 1

3

Jocelyn Asignacion Jocelyn Asignacion Redempto Anda

4

Jay Zabanal

2

List of TV/Radio Guestings Radio/TV Interviewee Date Station RD Roland De Jesus The Palawan Jan. 22, 2016 News RD Roland De Jesus The Palawan Feb. 19, 2016 News RD Roland De Jesus Philippine Daily Mar. 18, 2016 Inquirer RD Roland De Jesus

ABS-CBN Palawan

Mar. 18, 2016

Topic PQMI rehabilitation project PQMI rehabilitation project Siltation at BNC pier area due to submergence of barge loaded with 1,120 WMT of nickel ore Siltation at BNC pier area due to submergence of

21

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

List of TV/Radio Guestings Radio/TV Interviewee Date Station

Interviewer

5

Jocelyn Asignacion

RD Roland De Jesus

The Palawan News

Mar. 19, 2016

6

Janina Lim

RD Roland De Jesus

Business World

Mar. 20, 2016

7

Jay Zabanal

RD Roland De Jesus

Apr. 29, 2016

8

Maricar Cinco

RD Roland De Jesus

9

Dennis Datu

RD Roland De Jesus

ABS-CBN Palawan Philippine Daily Inquirer DZMM

10

CJ Andres

RD Roland De Jesus

Brigada News

Aug. 13, 2016

11

Catherine Santos

RD Roland De Jesus

Palawan News

Aug. 12, 2016

12

Claudio Dacquer

RD Roland De Jesus

DZEZ Palawan

Aug. 17, 2016

13

Maricar Cinco

RD Roland De Jesus

Sep. 1, 2016

14

Roger Lagasca

RD Roland De Jesus

Philippine Daily Inquirer DZIP

15

Lynette Dela Cruz

RD Roland De Jesus

ABS-CBN News

Dec. 21, 2016

June 3, 2016 June 27, 2016

Sep. 26, 2016

Topic barge loaded with 1,120 WMT of nickel ore Possible issuance of Cease and Desist Order to Berong Nickel Corp. due to the submergence of barge loaded with nickel ore Suspension of Berong Nickel Corp. transport operations after barge accident Alleged agrounding of barge in Berong Mining application of Asian Palladium in Romblon Mining application in Romblon Audit of mining companies in Palawan Audit of mining companies in Palawan; and suspension of BNC and CMDC Audit of mining companies in Palawan; and suspension of CMDC Acid mine drain in Marcopper Delay on the issuance of sand and gravel permits in Palawan PQMI rehabilitation project

d. Press Releases/Feature Stories A total of thirteen (13) press releases were reported resulting to a 108% accomplishment based on the annual target. These include: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.

22

MGB implements new government accounting manual MGB-MIMAROPA receives Gawad Kalasag Award MGB IV-B participates in the Groundbreak Series 2016 Year-end Review: Palawan Nickel Producers Affected by Falling Metal Prices in 2015 MGB-MIMAROPA Geosciences Division conducts a 2-day seminar on ArcGIS MGB IV-B Intensifies campaign against unlawful mining activities in the MIMAROPA region MAB/PA convenes at Seminar-Workshop on Mining Conflict and Dispute Resolutions Geoscientists from MGB-MIMAROPA lead Task Force "IWAS BAHA" in Oriental Mindoro

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

9. Stakeholders convene for finalization of MIMAROPA MMT’s Manual of Operations 10. MGB-MIMAROPA Supports DENR Chief in the People's/Civil Society Organizations Forum on Environmental Concerns 11. Mining Sector of MIMAROPA Tops GRDP in 2015 12. MGB-MIMAROPA Holds 6th Regional Small-scale Mining Summit 13. Subsidence in the Maguila-guila Siltation Dam of Marcopper: a new threat to Mogpog riverine environment according to MGB-MIMAROPA A.03.a.1.b Capacity Building on MRGS laws, rules and regulations a. Workshops/training participated by MGB personnel To orient MGB personnel on Mineral Resources and Geosciences (MRGS) laws, rules and regulations, the following activities were undertaken. 1. Mine Safety, Environment and Social Development Division (MSESDD) Forum held on March 14-16, 2016 at the Bayview Park Hotel, Manila The first ever forum of the Mine Safety, Environment and Social Development Division (MSESDD) of the Mines and Geosciences Bureau and its Regional offices was participated by the concerned division and section chiefs of the MSESDD. In that event, following are the issues and concerns that were discussed: 

Mine Environmental Audit o Submission of MWT semi-annual report and payment of MWT fees as provided for in Section 191 and 192 andthe reckoning period for the computation of the penalty for the non-submission of report after the end of each semester o MWT monitoring reports (consolidated or per project, who will issue the order of payment for the payment of MWTF and who will receive the payment ) o Authority to Construct Tailings Storage Facility is no longer issued by EMB-RO. Instead, it issues Water Discharge Permit to ensure that effluents are within established standards. o No detailed guidelines on the implementation of Section 27, DAO 99-32. o Clarification on the definition of a well-engineered Tailings Storage Facilities and lack of close supervision by qualified MGB personnel during the TSF construction o Standard reporting on the ISHES monitoring o Standard format on CEMCERR, including rating system to be adopted o Score card and/or checklist for EnWP implementation and monitoring o Penalty for not reporting with the MGB environmental disasters, within 24 hours

23

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

o Possible sanction/penalty for minimal program implementation of mining companies in the approved programs to ensure implementation and consistency of required/in-placed environmental works. o DAO 2015-02, in re: “Harmonization of the implementation of the PEISS and Philippine Mining Act of 1995 in relation to mining projects”       

MMT membership Supervision of MMT Monitoring of funds Action on complaints Development of Manual of Operation SDMP and SHP Monitoring Honorarium of MMT and MRFC

 Mine Environment o o o o o o o

o o o o o o o o o o

Scope of work of Multi-Partite Monitoring Team (MMT); Composition of MMT based on DAO 2015-02; Duration of representation of LGUs, NGO and IPs; Guidelines or Manual of Procedure in the conduct of monitoring; Standardized minimum honoraria and per diem Format of MMT report. Sanctions for partial implementation of programmed activities in the AEPEP with prescribed minimum percentage of accomplishment Approving body of FMR/DP of MPP; Scorecard for EPEP and FMR/DP implementation and monitoring; Standardized checklist to assess implementation of AEPEP; Specific provision in CDAO that requires contractors to submit a Care and Maintenance Program; Duration of representation of LGUs, NGO and IPs; Preliminary evaluation of EPEP and FMR/DP; National Greening Program Mining Forest Program EITI (Environmental Expenditures) Database Format

 Mine Safety and Health o Standardization of procedures, forms and permits o Accreditation of Service Contractors o DAO 2000-98, Mine Safety and Health Standards should be reviewed and revised/updated to adapt to the current mining/milling technologies with utmost emphasis on Mine Safety and Health Management

24

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

o Review and revision of Chapter XV of DAO 2010-21 in compliance with ILO Convention No. 176, Health and Safety in Mines o Capacity building for Mine Safety and Health personnel o Safety and Health Inspection and Monitoring procedures (Quarterly Safety and Health Inspection, Mechanical/Electrical Inspection, Explosives Magazine Inspection) o Mine Safety and Health Forms (MGAR/ETR/EACR/Minutes of CSHC meeting) o Permits (Safety Engineer/Inspector Permit/ ASHP Approval) to include terms and conditions, minimum criteria and template of certificate/permit o Inclusion of environment protection, technical and financial capabilities as criteria for the issuance of accreditation o Definition of industrial accident o Increase in penalties for violations of the Mine Safety and Health Standards o Basic Occupational Safety and Health in Mines Training Course for MGB Personnel is programmed for this year o Additional courses will depend on the Training Needs Assessment to be conducted  Social Development o SDMP and CDP Guidelines o Submission of the following:  Annual SDMP  Sworn Statement of Operating Cost  Semi-annual and Annual Reports (SDMP and CDP) o Standard Certificate of Approval Format (SDMP, IEC, DMTG and CDP) o Monitoring and evaluation manual for SDMP o Program requirement for contractors/permit holders during feasibility and construction stage o SDMP Monitoring during MMT o Monitoring of LGU issued mining permits – new and for renewal o Monitoring of PPAs on non-operating and with CDO mining permit/contractors o Frequency of field monitoring o Lack of personnel o Honoraria to members of monitoring team o Honoraria to MGB RO Personnel o CTWG o Penalty for partial or non-implementation of PPAs o Penalty for non-submission of reports o Unspent SDMP fund o Policy on re-alignment of unspent or unutilized budget for SDMP, IEC, DMTG

25

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

o Determination of host and neighboring communities including the sharing scheme (if municipalities and provinces are included) o Priority PPAs for ASDMP o Standard MOA for counterpart activities/projects for LGUs o Performance Review/SIA o Technical personnel from company to implement SDMP project o Suspended or expired permit holders required to implement unexpended budget o Standard scorecard for CDP/SDMP implementation o Capability enhancement program for MGB personnel on social development o Recognition/Awards for SDMP o Policy on Offshore Mining o Operating cost definition o CeMAP petition re: 1.5% Oeprating Cost o EITI concerns o SDMP, IEC, DMTG and IP database o 5-Year SDMP and ASDMP deliberation to be separated from MRFC o Socio-economic activity under EPEP if credited under SDMP including budget allocation In the said forum, the participants were grouped according to their sections and workshop was conducted. Most of the issues presented were thoroughly discussed, with some properly resolved and the others were still for finalization, in collaboration with MSESDD MGB-CO. Foremost in the agenda was DAO 2015-02, Harmonization of PD 1586 and RA 7942 wherein a draft clarificatory guideline was crafted for consideration in the forthcoming dialogue between the EMB and MGB. Director Leo L. Jasareno was present during the last day of the forum who provided guidelines and advisories on the resolution of issues presented. 2. Technical Conference on International Labor Organization (ILO) Convention on Safety and Health in Mines at the Century Park Hotel, Manila MSESDD personnel attended the one (1) day Technical Conference on International Labor Organization (ILO) Convention on Safety and Health in Mines (Convention 176) held on February 19, 2016 and was attended by representatives from the DILG, DOE, BWC, OSHAS, DOH, DOLE, MGB-CO, MGB-IVB, ILO. The conference was aimed to brief officials of concerned implementing agencies of the government on the provisions and requirements of the Convention, to learn the good practices of the countries that ratified the Convention and to guide the government in providing response on the long standing observations of the Committee of Experts on the Application of Conventions and Recommendations (CEACR).

26

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

The issues and concerns regarding Safety and Health in Mines were properly addressed by the Engr. Rodolfo Velasco of MSESDD MGBCO and informed Mr. Jajoon Coue, ILO representative that the government through the MGB has already responded to the issues, to wit: a. Section 144 of DAO 2010-21 requires all mining contractors/permittee/lessee/permit holder to submit an Annual Safety and Health Program (ASHP) covering its area of operations within 15 working days before the start of every calendar year; b. Information on appropriate plans of workings (3yr Environmental Work Program), Section 150 of DAO 2010-21, Section 5 Rule 21 and Section 68 Rule 989 of DAO 2000-98 to be provided to International Labor Affairs Bureau (ILAB) in Intramuros, Manila for their reference; c. Information on the “Chapa” recording system, accidents/ Hazards reporting/accident statistics; d. A draft Memorandum of Agreement was presented that prescribe the efficient coordination and harmonization of enforcement functions of the DOLE, DENR, DOE, DILG, DOH in ensuring health and safety in all mining operations from exploration, development and construction, utilization, and rehabilitation and decommissioning; e. Agencies particularly the DOE informed the group that they lack personnel who can participate in the conduct of an investigation/validation in case of mine accidents on coal mining. 3. Seminar-Workshop on Mining Conflict and Dispute Resolutions In line with the continuing program for the members and staff of the Mines Adjudication Board/Panel of Arbitrators (MAB/PA), the Mines and Geosciences Bureau - Central Office (MGB-CO) spearheaded the 4thMAB/PA Seminar-Workshop on Mining Conflict/Dispute Resolutionsheld on April 18-22, 2016 at Citystate Asturias Hotel, Puerto Princesa City, Palawan. The activity, with the theme “Moving Forward: Opportunities and Challenges in Dispute Resolution on Mining Conflict,” was participated in by the members and staff of the MAB/PA from the Central and Regional Offices of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) and the MGB. The seminar-workshop aimed to: (1) set a universe in target setting vis-à-vis budget requirements; (2) finalize the Proposed Revised Rules of Pleading, Practice and Procedure before the Mines Adjudication Board and the Panel of Arbitrators; (3) draft a Memorandum Circular for the Panel defining its jurisdiction based on actual cases decided; (4) update knowledge on the new laws, rules, and regulations on mining and jurisprudence; and (5) finalize the proposed Establishment of an Electronic Content Management System and orientation on the MGB Central Database System.

27

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

A mine site tour was also organized for the attendees since this was the first time in the last four years to hold the event outside of Metro Manila. They visitedone of the operating mine companies in Palawan, the Citinickel Mines and Development Corporation (CMDC) located in Narra, Palawan. The company staff and personnel, led by CDMC’s Resident Mine Manager Engr. Jainal M. Uy, warmly welcomed the participants. Overview of the mine and its activities and orientation on safety were provided to the participants before the actual mine tour. Aside from the mineand piersite tours, projects under the Social Development and Management Program (SDMP) and the nursery were also visited.

Members and staff of the Mines Adjudication Board/Panel of Arbitrators (MAB/PA)during the 4th MAB/PA Seminar-Workshop on Mining Conflict/Dispute Resolutions

4. 4th Mining Engineer's Convention (MinECon 2016) held in Legazpi City, Albay on June 8-10, 2016 Members of the Philippine Society of Mining Engineers (PSEM) all over the country gathered for the 4th Mining Engineer’s Convention (MinECon 2016) in Legazpi City, Albay held on June 8 to 10. Nine mining engineers from the Mines and Geosciences Bureau Regional Office No. IVB (MIMAROPA), headed by Regional Director Roland A. De Jesus, joined the convention which was highlighted by mine exhibits, sportsfest, technical symposium and Mining Engineer’s convention/general assembly. For this year, seven mining engineers garnered The Outstanding Mining Engineers (TOEM) of 2016 award. The award is given to mining engineers who largely contributed in various fields of mining. Representatives from different companies/agencies imparted some innovations and technical know-how for the advancement of the mining profession and technologies through their technical paper presentations in the technical symposium.

28

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

An important part of the convention is the election of the new set of PSEM national officers for C.Y. 2016-2018 held during the Mining Engineer’s Convention and General Assembly. Status reports were as well presented by different PSEM chapters. The assembly was concluded by an acceptance speech made by the incoming national PSEM president who outlined his plans and programs for his coming term. The 3-day event served as a venue for mining engineers to discuss the prospects of the mining industry under the upcoming leadership. PSEM members were reminded and encouraged to be resilient and to persevere all the more in the quest for a responsible and sustainable mining industry amidst the issues hurled to the industry. The MinEcon is a biennial convention of mining engineers in the Philippines which started in Davao City on 2010. The PSEM – Bicol Chapter co-hosted this year’s event with the theme: “A Stronger Philippine Mining Industry Amid the Challenges and Adversities.”

MGB – MIMAROPA mining engineers posed with RD Roland A. De Jesus and Mr. Ramon Santos of Marcventures Mining and Development Corp. during the Technical Symposium

5. Finalization of MOO and 1st Regional ComRel Conference The event was attended by the members of the MMT representing all the sectors/agencies in the Province of Palawan and the Community Relations Officers of the three (3) operating mines: Berong Nickel Corporation, Citinickel Mines and Development Corporation, Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation, and two (2) mineral processing plants: Coral Bay Nickel Corporation and the Unichamp Minerals Phils., Incorporated and technical personnel of this Office.

29

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

The workshop and conference aimed to achieve the following: 1. to formulate monitoring schemes/checklists that will clearly define the duties and responsibilities of the concerned member agencies/organizations to the MMT, particularly in monitoring activities; 2. to standardize practices and procedures in the conduct of monitoring, consistent with DAO 2015-02 (Harmonization of RA 7942 and PD 1586); 3. to formulate Work and Financial Plan for each MMT; 4. to harmonize and standardize the implementation of the Social Development and Management Program (SDMP), including monitoring and audit as provided in CDAO 2010-21; and 5. to be able to come-up with a final and consolidated Manual of Operation. In the workshop proper, the members were divided into clusters wherein concerned sector/agency were asked to formulate a monitoring checklist/schemes attendant to the mining permit issued by MGB and such will serve as the basis/guide in the monitoring activities which will form as an integral part of the manual of operations. It was hosted and moderated by PENRO Samuel Danganan, Head, ExecutiveAssistant (HEA) of EMB-IV MIMAROPA and Engr. Percival Ladub, OIC-Mine Safety, Environment and Social Development Division, MGB-IV MIMAROPA.

Workshop Proper

Participants of the Workshop on the Finalization of the MMTs MOO and 1st Regional ComRel Conference

30

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

6. Harmonization and Finalization of SDMP Guidelines Driven by the pursuit to achieve the government’s and the industry’s common objective on responsible mining and community development, last October 6-7, 2016, Community Relation Officers of the three (3) operating mines and two (2) mineral processing plants in the Province of Palawan converged for the 2 nd time for the harmonization and standardization in the implementation of the Plans/Programs/Activities (P/P/As) of the Social Development and Management Program (SDMP). Discussions include the expounding of workshop objectives and rationale, presentation of standardized reporting template for the Extractive Industry Transparency Initiative (EITI) Process; and the consolidation and strengthening of National Community Relation Practitioners (NCRP) of the Philippine Mining/Mineral Industry’s effort in building a sustainable mining communities. A breakout/workshop session was conducted for the drafting of the SDMPs Planning, Implementing and Monitoring (SDMP PIM) Manual. The SDMP PIM Manual will serve as a guide/roadmap for the CROs to achieve its objective in undertaking the maximization of benefits and the development of sustainable host and neighboring communities. The harmonization and standardization of the guidelines of SDMP implementation would answer the allegations that some of the program if not all, were hurriedly designed and implemented, or were often thought to be dole outs, lack/absence of community counterpart and/or not properly coordinated with the local development plans resulting to resources leakage or worst waste of money. The event concurred with the election of officers for the ComRel Palawan Group who will represent the Regional Cluster for MIMAROPA REGION to the NCRP. The group was organized in response to the call of the NCRP to strengthen the social and community development work and to advance the contibution of mining on socio-economic development. The event was organized by the Mine Community Development Section of the Mine Safety, Environment and Social Development Division of the MIMAROPA Region in cooperation with the ComRels of the operating mines and mineral processing plants in the Province of Palawan.

31

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

The CROs during the breakout/workshop session for the drafting of the SDMP’s Planning, Implementing and Monitoring (SDMP PIM) Manual.

7. 4th National Community Relations Officers Conference On November 16, 2016 three (3) technical staff of the MSESDD attended the 4th ComRel Conference in CAP John Hay Convention Center, Baguio City. This year’s theme “Advancing Community Development Strategies in Attaining Sustainable Socioeconomic Growth” was focused on knowledge sharing on mining and sustainable development goals, social entrepreneurship and marketing as well as CSR/social development strategies. One of the highlights of the event is the recognition of SDMP/CDP of mining companies that achieve excellence in terms of services to stakeholders and innovative sustainable solutions to pressing social challenges. The PMSEA and the National Community Relations Pratitioners (NCRP) in the Philippine Mining/Minerals Industry gave Special Recognition to Leading Community Development Projects. The conference was organized by the Philippine Mine Safety and Environment Association (PMSEA), in partnership with the Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB), in line with the 63 rd Annual Mines Safety and Environment Conference in Baguio City on November 15-18, 2016 with the theme “63 Years of Responsible Mining … Moving Forward By Doing It Right”.

b. Workshops/Training conducted for LGUs and other stakeholders Pursuant to DAO 2008-22, the Revised Guidelines on the Deputation of Environment And Natural Resources Officers (ENRO), and to directly involve the citizenry in the protection and conservation of the country's environment and natural resources, deputation trainings were conducted by the technical and legal personnel of this office in the provinces/city within the region, as listed below:

32

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

List of Workshops/Trainings conducted for LGUs and other stakeholders Accomplishment

Date

1

Deputation Training in the Province of Palawan

March 17, 2016

2 3

Deputation Training in the Province of Oriental Mindoro Orientation on laws and rules governing sand and gravel operations in Victoria, Or. Mindoro

September 20, 2016 September 21, 2016

4

Deputation Training in the City of Puerto Princesa

November 09, 2016

5

Deputation Training in the Province of Palawan

November 09, 2016

Deputation trainings are conducted to impart basic knowledge on environmental and natural resources laws, rules and regulations as basis of the prospective DENROs in the apprehension of illegal mining activities; to orient participants in the proper preparation of investigation report and in the preparation of and filing of cases in court and surveillance techniques; and to intensify the campaign against illegal mining activities. Said trainings usually involves discussions on the different substantive laws such as 1) R.A. No. 7942 otherwise known as the “Philippine Mining Act of 1995 and its consolidated Implementing Rules and Regulations”; 2) E.O. No. 79 or “Institutionalizing and Implementing Reforms in the Philippine Mining Sector, Providing Policies and Guidelines to Ensure Environmental Protection and Responsible Mining in the Utilization of Mineral Resources”; 3) R.A. No. 7076 or the “People Small-Scale Mining Act of 1991”; and 4) the recent Memorandum Order No. 2016-01, “Audit of all Operating Mines and Moratorium on New Mining Projects. Participants are also briefed on the general rules on apprehension, search, seizure and detention (ASSD) and Investigation, Documentation and Evidence Gathering (IGED).

Photos taken during the Deputation Training in Oriental Mindoro

33

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

c. d. e. Photos taken during the Deputation Training in Palawan

c. Workshops/Training conducted for small-scale miners Capacity building re: existing mining laws, rules and regulations for the smallscale miners in the Province of Romblon MGB IV-B in coordination with the Provincial Mining Regulatory Board (PMRB) of Romblon conducted a capacity building for small-scale miners to update their basic knowledge on mining laws; to study the issues and constraints confronting the sector; and to put forward policy recommendations that will enhance decent work outcomes.

Photos taken during the training for small-scale miners

34

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

The training was held in Romblon, Romblon on August 24, 2016. in Brgy. Cajimos, Romblon, Romblon. The activity was participated by permit holders, laborers, barangay officials and PMRB representatives. The following topics were presented: (a) R.A. No. 7076, People's Small- scale Mining Act of 1991 and its new Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR) - DENR Administrative Order (DAO) 2015-03; (b) R.A. No. 7942 or the Philppine Mining Act of 1995 and its IRR with emphasis on Mineral Processing Permit; and (c) DAO No. 9730, Small-scale Mine Safety Rules and Regulations. Lecture on the Philippine Reference System of 1992 (PRS ’92) was undertaken by Engr. Alvin S. Requimin.

A.03.a.1.c Generate/Publish/Disseminate Information and IEC Materials 1. Website Maintained MGB IV-B (MIMAROPA) maintains an official websitewith Uniform Resource Locator (URL), http://region4b.mgb.gov.ph/. The official website was successfully migrated from a private host server to the government server handled by the Department of Science and Technology (DOST). 

Articles Posted To update the stakeholders of the activities of the Office, a total of twenty-seven (27) articles were posted in the official website, to wit: 1. 2. 3.

MGB Implements New Government Accounting Manual MGB-MIMAROPA Receives Gawad Kalasag Awards MGB-MIMAROPA Geologist Investigate the Impacts of Massive Flooding Caused by Typhoon NONA in Baco, Oriental Mindoro 4. MGB-MIMAROPA Validates the Occurrence of Sinkhole in Odiongan, Romblon 5. MGB IV-B Participates in the Groundbreak Series 2016 6. MGB IV-B Regional Director Roland De Jesus Meets with Executives of Puerto Princesa City on PQMI Rehabilitation Program 7. MGB-MIMAROPA Joins 2016 National Women's Month Celebration 8. Year-end Review: Palawan Nickel Producers Affected by Falling Metal Prices in 2015 9. MGB IV-B (MIMAROPA) Personnel Unites with other Freedom Runnersfor a corrupt-free Philippines 10. MGB-MIMAROPA Geosciences Division conducts a 2-day seminar on ArcGIS 11. MGB IV-B Intensifies Campaign Against Unlawful Mining Activities In The MIMAROPA Region

35

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

12. MAB/PA convenes at Seminar-Workshop on Mining Conflict and Dispute Resolutions 13. Geoscientists from MGB-MIMAROPA lead Task Force “IWAS BAHA” in Oriental Mindoro 14. MGB-MIMAROPA Pursues Gender Responsive Governance 15. MGB-MIMAROPA Conducts 2016 Team Building Activity 16. Stakeholders Dialogue with DENR and MGB on Recent Mining Application in Romblon 17. MGB-MIMAROPA Mining Engineers Partake in MinEcon 2016 18. MGB-MIMAROPA Supports DENR Chief in the People's/Civil Society Organizations Forum on Environmental Concerns 19. Stakeholders convene for finalization of MIMAROPA MMT’s Manual of Operations 20. MGB-MIMAROPA joins the 6th R.A.C.E. to serve fun run 21. MGB-MIMAROPA joins 2016 PH-EITI Roadshow 22. Mining Sector of MIMAROPA Tops GRDP in 2015 23. MGB MIMAROPA Takes on its ISO 9001:2015 certification 24. MGB-MIMAROPA Initiates Harmonization and Standardization of SDMP Audit 25. Greening of the PQMI Rehabilitation Site, A Success 26. MGB-MIMAROPA Holds 6th Regional Small-Scale Mining Summit 27. Subsidence in the Maguila-guila Siltation Dam of Marcopper: a new threat to Mogpog riverine environment according to MGBMIMAROPA 2. IEC materials reproduced/distributed One hundred (100) copies of the maiden issue of the official publication of MGB IV-B (MIMAROPA), MIMAROPA Mine Scoop, were reproduced and distributed to different agencies, LGUs and other stakeholders. As a consequence of the deputation trainings and small-scale mining summit, a total of 250 IEC materials were distributed to the participants. Overall, the Region was able to distribute 350 IEC materials to different stakeholders.

A.03.a.1.d National Linkages The MGB IV-B (MIMAROPA) managed to link with other agencies (NEDA, DENR, and DOLE) and local government units and other non-government organizations (LGUs, church representatives) by conducting a dialogue and participation into meetings to enhance the understanding and awareness level of all stakeholders of minerals industry.

36

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

A.03.b GEOSCIENCES DEVELOPMENT SERVICES In 2016, the Geosciences Division of MGB MIMAROPA continued to improve the region-wide implementation of geohazard mapping projects through streamlined acquisition and processing of geologic hazard database. The results of geohazard mapping surveys conducted in the past were reviewed and updated to provide critical inputs to the creation of new database for risk exposure analysis, interpretation of elements at risk, and development of landslide and flooding exposure maps. For the first half of 2016, the planned activities under the Geohazard Survey and Assessment Program were implemented in Oriental and Occidental Mindoro as there have been broad scale changes to rivers and their watersheds in these provinces that have resulted in an increased flood risk after “Typhoon Nona” devastated Mindoro Island on December 15, 2015.The remaining target activities, most specifically, geohazard IEC as well as conduct of other VRA surveys were carried out during the last half of 2016 covering the provinces of Palawan, Romblon and Marinduque. Major geohazard activities accomplished included updating of flood/landslide susceptibility maps, conduct of VRA activities, development of hazard exposure maps, and holding of geohazard seminars/meetings along with distribution of IEC materials to LGUs. Risk analysis applied in VRA involves the use of available information to estimate the risk (from hazards)to individuals or populations, property, and environment. The analysis generally contains the following steps: hazard identification, hazard assessment, elements at risk/exposure analysis, vulnerability assessment and risk estimation. MGB’s streamlined VRA methodology was used to conduct risk analysis and to develop initial geohazard exposure maps. This methodology relied mainly on updated flood and landslide susceptibility maps, remotely sensed data provided by various government agencies, spatial and nonspatial datasets from local government units, and information acquired from detailed recording and mapping of field evidences. Flood/landslide analysis focused primarily on the estimation of potential adverse impacts using all available elements at risk. Re-scoping of critical geohazard areas was initially undertaken to generate a broad range of flood/landslide risk indicators that can provide significant flood and landslide scenarios to the affected communities. For this year, VRA activities involving field and desktop surveys were completed in the eleven (11) municipalities in the provinces of Oriental Mindoro, Occidental Mindoro, Marinduque and Palawan, and two (2) municipalities in the province of Capiz in Region VI as additional target outside MIMAROPA region. Total number of municipalities covered by VRA is thirteen (13), which is equivalent to 108% accomplishment relative to the annual target of twelve (12) municipalities. Development of flood/landslide exposure maps using various elements at risk is still on-going for the total thirteen VRA areas. In addition to flood/landslide risk assessment, activity related to updating of flood and landslide hazard database was performed in critical flood/landslide prone areas of Baco municipality in Oriental Mindoro. This updating exercise was performed as a result of changes in landscape and overall morphology of the river systems caused by “Typhoon Nona”. Results of this activity were used to update the flood/landslide susceptibility zonation and development of flood/landslide exposure maps of the municipality.

37

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

The region-wide implementation of the coastal geohazard mapping program continued this year with the participation of all MGB Regional Offices in the completion of geohazard assessment of the coastal cities/municipalities of Regions VII and VIII as priority target areas for 2016. As for the accomplishment of coastal mapping targets assigned to the region, MGB-MIMAROPA completed the assessment of nine (9) target coastal municipalities in Western and Eastern Samar. The inclusion of this detailed 1:10,000 scale coastal mapping project in the regular planned activities of MGB commenced in 2015 to determine the impact of climate change on coastal environment. The 2016 accomplishment under coastal geohazard mapping included mainly identification of shoreline shifts and coastal hazards, and conduct of beach profiling activities. A total of nine (9) coastal municipalities were assessed covering the coastal lowlands and shorelines of Marabut, Basey, Sta. Rita, Talalora and Villareal, all in the province of Western Samar, and the municipalities of Lawaan, Balangiga, Giporlos and Guiuan in Eastern Samar province. This mapping coverage is equivalent to accomplishment rating of 100% based on the annual target of nine (9) municipalities assessed for coastal hazards and shoreline changes. On geohazard IEC campaign activities, all programmed plans were implemented on time following the target work planset for the entire year of 2016. The accomplished activities on Geohazard IEC included dissemination of updated advisories and lists of identified flood and landslide hotspots, provision of updated geohazard maps to local government units, conduct of geohazard meeting/seminar per municipality, and participation in Disaster Risk Reduction and Management (DRRM) activities initiated by various DRRM member agencies. From January to December 2016,a total of 64 geohazard meetings and seminars intended for barangay officials and MDRRMC officers were conducted in the 11 municipalities of Oriental Mindoro; 11 municipalities of Occidental Mindoro; 2 municipalities of Marinduque; 16 municipalities of Romblon; and24 municipalities of Palawan province. A total of 1,078 barangays were informed about the meetings organized by MGB-MIMAROPA. This number gives an equivalent accomplishment rating of 100% based onannual target of 1,078 barangaysprovided with geohazard seminar and updated IEC materials. Aside from the conduct of regular geohazard surveysin the region, MGB-MIMAROPA alsoserved fourty two (42) clients requesting for geohazard assessment assistance andother geological evaluation surveys. The Office issueda total of twenty (29) geohazard certifications for various projects involving construction of housing units, school buildings and evacuation sites, and provided assistance to secure other geohazard-related documents, mostly verbal requests from LGUs and DRRM-member agencies.Also, twenty one (21) investigation reports were prepared for various developers, proponents and LGUs. These are mainly geohazard identification reports (GIR) related to ECC application, and geoenvironmental assessment reports pertaining toidentification of waste disposal sites. Other significant geohazard accomplishment in 2016 involved inspection of critical structures and facilities of Marcopper with highlights of investigation on the occurrence of subsidence and its potential mechanism in the reservoir floor of Maguila-guila Siltation Dam, a zoned earthen dam, of Marcopper Mining Corporation (MMC) located in Sta. Cruz, Marinduque. During the first quarter of 2016, special investigations on the causes and effects of Typhoon Nona in Northeast Oriental Mindoro were carried out in response to the multi-sectoral task force “Iwas Baha” formed by the Chief Executive of the province.MGB MIMAROPA, being the lead member of the task force who has mandate to conduct geologic

38

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

hazard assessment, commissioned a team of geologists to undertake flood hazard investigation covering the major flooding hotspots in the municipalities of Naujan, Baco, and San Teodoro, including the City of Calapan. Impacts of the operation of Sta. Clara hydropower plant in Bgy. Arangin, Naujan municipality were also included in the task force’s hazard investigation.

A.03.b.1 Geohazard Survey and Assessment A.03.b.1.a Identification and Mapping of Critical Land Areas A.03.b.1.a.1 Vulnerability and Risk Assessment (VRA) Implementation of VRA activities was undertaken in the eleven(11) municipalities withinthe provinces of Oriental Mindoro, Occidental Mindoro, Marinduque and Palawan including the two (2) municipalities on the northeastern section of Capiz province in Region 6. The objective of the assessment is to identify all geographical areas where potential significant flood/landslide risks exist or might be likely to occur.The thirteen (13) municipalities accomplished this year were selectedbased on the reportedsites affected by massive flooding and landslide during the onslaughtof Typhoon Nona and also based on critical ground that has history of frequent flood inundation and landslide occurrence. VRA Conducted in 2016 MUNICIPALITY

PROVINCE

Socorro

Oriental Mindoro

Pola

Oriental Mindoro

Pinamalayan

Oriental Mindoro

Bongabong

Oriental Mindoro

Mamburao

Occidental Mindoro

Sablayan

Occidental Mindoro

San Jose

Occidental Mindoro

Mogpog

Marinduque

Boac

Marinduue

Panay

Capiz

Pontevedra

Capiz

Taytay

Palawan

Roxas

Palawan

To further optimize the usefulness of the geohazards maps produced by theGeosciences Division of Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA-, vulnerability and risk assessment were undertaken over highly critical and priority areas of the region. Vulnerability Risk Assessment (VRA) focuses on exposures of elements at risk to flooding and landslide.

39

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

40

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Generally, the creation of a flood and landslide exposure database underthe Vulnerability and Risk Assessment (VRA) program aims to accomplish the following: a.

Development of risk exposure maps to provide a rapid assessment tool to the disaster responder and warning agency regarding the potential impact of waterrelated hazards to the concerned community;

b.

Use available spatial dataset and high resolution remote sensing data (e.g. IFSAR and Google Satellite Image data) to create flood and landslide exposure maps;

c.

and to analyze the state of the exposure to flood and landslide risks. This is based on the combination of digitized elements at risks such as, for this report, built-up/residential areas, population and roads and the flood susceptibility map.The purpose of the flood and landslide hazard exposure analysis is to use a consistent, accurate, and reproducible method to quantify the people that might be harmed and the roads that may be affected by flooding and landslide.

41

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

The specific objectives are: (1) To generate maps on vulnerability and risk relative to the impacts of geohazards on the municipality; (2) To disseminate these maps to local government units and to formulate systematic and intensified information and awareness campaigns on geohazards; and (3) to provide these information as critical inputs to the regional, provincial and local disaster preparedness, management and mitigation plans; and land use plans. Activities include (1) development of exposure database involving identification of the elements at risk from landslides and floods; (2) field assessment; (3) data gathering for exposure information development; and (4) generation of exposure maps on different type of elements at risk. The Assessment of Flood and Landslide Exposure Information involves identification and analysis of major Elements at Risk. Initial Elements at Risk Considered under the VRA program of MGB are listed below: 1. Population 2. Road Network 3. Built-up Areas Geo-spatial data used in the assessment comprised the following: a. Administrative boundaries of the municipalities and barangays as well as general information about the municipality/city were provided by the LGUs. b. Updated MGB 1:10,000 scale flood and landslide susceptibility maps Updating of flood susceptibility maps begins with determination of stream and corresponding water flows through processing of IFSAR image using the Hydrology tool in ArcGIS 10.3. The DEM was used as an input. Tiles of IFSAR images with 5m resolution were mosaicked to form a digital terrain map (DTM). By using ArcGIS software, other thematic maps such as contour maps, elevation maps, and slope maps were generated and were used in updating the geohazard susceptibility maps. c. Exposure data (Population, built-up areas and Road Networks) Major building footprints, residential structures and land use data were provided by the Local Government Unit (LGU); these databases were validated using Google Earth-based mapping and through field activities conducted by MGB-MIMAROPA. 2015 population data for each VRA area was obtained from the National Statistics Office (NSO) database. The availability of the spatial database of the flood and landslide-related factors are very important in the creation of flood and landslide exposure component for the flooding/landslide risk assessment and consequent production of risk maps. Coupled with remotely sensed information and ground validation,the exposure maps can provide significant and informative flood/landslide scenarios to the decision makers, disaster managers and the affected communities. ESRI software ArcGIS 10.3 was used in converting these data into vector file by means of digitization. The program was also used in deriving thematic layers such as river systems, slope, elevation and contour from IFSAR image or raster

42

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

digital elevation model (DEM). The MGB’s updated flood zonation in vector form was superimposed in these layers to produce the flood exposure map. The exposure will then need to undergo ground or field verification that can be useful to the end user such as PAGASA, NDRRMC, LGUs and other regional agencies. Spatial data used in the assessment comprise the built environment of the 13 covered municipalities that include infrastructure, civic and service centers, parks and planned open spaces, neighborhoods, landmarks, roads and walkways, and all those public and private places that compose the community and constitute a critical frontier. MGB-MIMAROPA has utilized all available spatial datasets provided by the Municipal Planning Office of each municipality, and the high resolution remote sensing data (e.g. Satellite data) including IFSAR maps from NAMRIA in preparation for thedevelopment of flood risk/flood exposure maps.Processing of all gathered information were undertaken usingArc GIS software version 10.2 to form a grid spatial database used in the preparation of preliminary Flood Exposure Map. The elements at risk from the database will be used as value added product that can provide relevant information for disaster response and rehabilitation. Methodology Used for Exposure Analysis for the Elements at Risks to flooding and landslide are shown in the the following flowchart : For Population Exposure Analysis

Extract residential zones from land use map (or use built-up areas) and Google Earth

Get total area of residential zones per barangay

Get area of residential zones exposed to a certain susceptibility rating (per barangay)

Calculate population density

Number and percentage of people exposed (per barangay) to certain susceptibility rating

For Road Network Exposure Analysis

43

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

For Built-up Exposure Analysis

The exposure database for built-up areas, population at risk and road for high, moderate and low susceptible areas for flooding and landslide were created.Generation of final flood and landslide exposure maps for the thirteen (13) municipalities covered by 2016 VRA in Oriental Mindoro, Occidental Mindoro, Marinduque, Palawan and Capiz are still ongoing . VRA activities presently undertaken by MGB-MIMAROPA are based on MGB’s Guidebook on the Preliminary Methodology in the Rain-Induced Landslide and Flood Exposure Information Development for Vulnerability and Risk Assessment Project. The Guidebook only involves streamlined methodology and does not follow examples of complex risk assessments cited in various academic literatures. Final flood and landslide exposure analysis and development of hazard exposure maps for the thirteen (13) municipalities covered by VRA in the provinces of Oriental Mindoro, Occidental Mindoro,Marinduque and Capiz are still ongoing. A.03.b.1.a.2 Updating of 1:10,000 scale Geohazard Maps Activities related to updating of 1:10,000 scale geohazard maps were conducted in the municipality of Baco as there have been many changes in the morphology and character of major river courses after the passage of Typhoon Nona last December 2015.Changes in river and floodplain morphology, river flow direction, and the surrounding landscape were reviewed using the updated Google Earth satellite images and IFSAR maps. These were validated on the ground through re-scoping and field interviews. Results of this assessment were used to update the flood susceptibility zonation and flood susceptibility maps generated by MGB-MIMAROPA. Some rivers in Baco have been straightened and deepened and effectively separated from their flood plains by the construction of embankments and flood defences to prevent agricultural land and urban development from flooding. In many cases these human alterations to watercourses and their catchments have increased downstream flood risk to communities by increasing run-off rates and stream flow.

44

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Flood/Landslide Hazard Assessment of Baco Municipality The heavy rainfall spawned by tropical cyclone “Nona” on December 15, 2015 caused widespread flooding across central Baco, which is one of the municipalities hardest hit by the typhoon in Oriental Mindoro. The total damage to property and agriculture was so huge, which prompted Mayor Reynaldo Marco of LGU-Baco to seek assistance from the Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB)-MIMAROPA to assess the impacts of “Nona” particularly in the harshly damaged barangays of Bayanan, Baras, Alag, Mayabig, Lantuyang, and Sta. Rosa II. On January 12 to 15, 2016, MGBMIMAROPA geologists visited the municipality of Baco to determine the cause of massive flooding in the mentioned barangays and to study the extent of flash flood and inundation that brought enormous damage to the municipality. A combination of channelized debris flows that transported cobble and bouldersize materials and flash floods carrying extremely high sediment loads (induced mainly by exceptional heavy rains) were the principal agents of destruction in Brgy. Bayanan. This interior community is situated at the foot of a mountainous area near the confluence of two rivers, namely: Kantuhan and Bayanan Rivers that flow toward the main Mayabig River, a tributary of Alag River which is a major river system in the municipality. As observed from the aerial view taken by video camera attached to a drone provided by

45

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

the Mayor’s Office of Baco, the upstream portions of the river beds of Kantuhan and Bayanan Rivers are still covered with thick deposits of debris materials (fluviatile deposits) which may eventually flow out of the river valley during period of heavy downpour. The source of debris flow materials are fluvial deposits comprising of unconsolidated material laid down by stream, hillslope debris flows (landslide) and river valley erosion. These debris materials accumulated in the river channel and were brought downstream by exceptional flashflood creating a channelized debris flow that almost buried a big portion of the barangay proper of Bayanan. The barangays of Baras, Lantuyang and portion of Sta. Rosa II experienced intense flashflood that washed out several houses, affected agricultural farmlands and deposited much sediments along the affected channels and floodplain of Tiboy River (in Bgy. Baras and Sta. Rosa II), and Karayrayan River (in Bgy. Lantuyang). Barangay Baras is situated west-northwest of the municipal proper of Baco. The main drainage system traversing the barangay is Tiboy River, which generally flows southeast towards the main Alag River, one of the major river systems of Baco municipality. Three sitios were severely affected by raging floods, namely: sitio Centro, Ariring, and Malmis. Portions of Sitio Centro and Sitio Ariring were heavily damaged by silty to muddy sediments that covered several residential structures and other barangay facilities near the river. The accumulated sediment deposits transported by flashflood in the area reached up to 1 meter in thickness and consist mainly of gravel- to boulder-sized materials. In Sitio Malmis, half of the residential area was covered by sandy to muddy sediment materials with an estimated thickness of 1.5 meters. Inundation and sediment deposition are attributed to the flash flood along the northern tributary of Tiboy River that contains much load of coarse sediments. Site inspection of portion of Mayabig and Alag Rivers in barangays Mayabig and Alag showed that extensive inundation of the broad floodplains of these rivers is due largely to the amount of runoff, extreme sedimentation of the river bed, and active fluvial erosion, which is common in old meandering streams like Alag River. With this alarming state of the river courses in the municipality of Baco, residents living in flood prone areas may now experience increased frequency of flooding during rainy season. Among the recommendations provided by MGB-MIMAROPA to local government units of Baco include:    

  

46

relocation of the residents from the affected villages to safer places to avoid the eventual flow downstream of thick deposits of debris materials; desiltation /dredging of critical stretch of Mayabig River and other heavily silted river courses in Baco to minimize flooding events; setting ‘no residential zones’ at critical areas to lessen the impact of flooding; clearing out areas from any obstructions (natural and man-made) to avoid spreading of flood water along active floodplain during period of incessant rainfall; construction of flood control structures like levees or protection dikes, promotion of flood hazard awareness and preparedness to the public, and establishment of early warning system for flooding.

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Location map of barangays covered by flood investigation in Baco, Or. Mindoro

A.03.b.1.a.3 Subsurface Assessment There are notargeted sites for subsurface assessment in MIMAROPA region for 2016 but new schedules of trainings for this activity will beorganized by MGB Regional Offices in coordination with MGB-CO sometime in the first half of 2017. MGBMIMAROPA has already finalized the inclusion of Sta. Cruz municipality in Marinduque as one of its target areas for subsurface mapping and assessment in 2017. A.03.b.1.a.4 Geohazard IEC Materials Dissemination The dissemination of geohazard IEC materials to LGUs was accomplished largely during the conduct of geohazard meetings and seminars with the local officials of the 11 municipalities of Oriental Mindoro; 11 municipalities of Occidental Mindoro; 16 municipalities of Romblon; 2 municipalities of Marinduque; and 24 municipalities of Palawan.IEC materials such as posters, pamphlets, video CDs, hazard threat advisories, and updated flood/landslide susceptibility maps were disseminated to the lowest level of governance, the barangays, so that the communities living in high risk areas will be able to manage and cope with the impacts of natural disasters. Likewise, local DRRM officials were provided with various geohazard IEC materials including lists of geohazard hotspots with moderate to high susceptibilities to flood and landslide hazards.Other recipients of IEC materials are the DRRM member-agencies of MIMAROPA region, government schools, state colleges and universities, and NGOs connected to disaster reduction and management operation. Additional IEC activities include one (1) TV guesting in Calapan City after the investigation of massive flood incidents in the municipalities of Baco and Naujan, five (5) radio guestingsand interviews during the conduct of geohazard meetings and seminars in Mamburao and San Jose, Occidental Mindoro, and in the municipalities of Coron and Brooke’s Point including the city of Puerto Princesa in Palawan. Its objective is to inform

47

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

the public about the adverseimpacts of geologic hazards in areas with “high” and “very high” susceptibilities to flooding and landslide. In these occasions, flooding and landslide assessment results were explained using the latest GIS-generated geohazard maps of MGB IVB. For geohazard IEC materials disseminated,a total of 894 geohazard maps (1:50,000 scale municipal geohazard maps and 1:10,000 scale quadrangle maps in digital and hard copies including shape files), 1,495 landslide/flood posters, 83 VCDs and 7,300 pamphlets/flyers were distributed region-wide from January to December 2016.To warn the public on the impending occurrence of landslide along major roads, two (2) landslide warning signages were installed in the region, all locatednear the landslide prone areas along theMarinduque Circumferential Road in Buenavista and Sta. Cruz municipalities. A.03.b.1.a.5 Capacity Building Under capacity building, six (6) trainings/seminars/conferences were attended by MGB-MIMAROPA-Geosciences Division personnel from January to December 2016, to wit: 1. Formulation of Regional Disaster Response Plan organized by OCDMIMAROPA; 2. Attended workshop on the standardization of procedures for lay-outing final geohazard maps organized by MGB-CO, Quezon City; 3. Attended workshop on standardization of procedures for geologic quadrangle mapping organized by MGB-CO; 4. September 2016 MGB Geosciences Workshop in Quezon City; 5. 2016 MGB technical Forum held in Angeles, Pampanga; and 6. 2016 Geological Conference held in Makati City A.03.b.1.a.6 Conduct of Geohazard IEC to LGUs Conduct of major geohazard meetings and seminars were completed in the 11 municipalities of Oriental Mindoro, 11 municipalities of Occidental Mindoro, 16 municipalities of Romblon, 2 municipalities of Marinduque, and 24 municipalities of Palawan. A total of 1,078 barangays participated in these occasions organized by MGBMIMAROPA. The list of the number of barangays per municipality which joined the seminar and IEC activities are shown below. The total number gives an equivalent accomplishment rating of 100% based on the annual target of 1,078 barangays provided with updated geohazard information and IEC materials. 2016 GEOHAZARD SEMINARS/MEETINGS PROVINCE

48

MUNICIPALITY

NO. OF BARANGAYS

Oriental Mindoro

San Teodoro

8

Oriental Mindoro

Victoria

32

Oriental Mindoro

Socorro

26

Oriental Mindoro

Pola

23

Oriental Mindoro

Pinamalayan

37

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

2016 GEOHAZARD SEMINARS/MEETINGS PROVINCE MUNICIPALITY NO. OF BARANGAYS Oriental Mindoro

Gloria

27

Oriental Mindoro

Bansud

13

Oriental Mindoro

Bongabong

36

Oriental Mindoro

Roxas

20

Oriental Mindoro

Mansalay

17

Oriental Mindoro

Bulalacao

15

Occidental Mindoro

Abra de Ilog

10

Occidental Mindoro

Paluan

12

Occidental Mindoro

Mamburao

15

Occidental Mindoro

Santa Cruz

11

Occidental Mindoro

Sablayan

22

Occidental Mindoro

Calintaan

7

Occidental Mindoro

Rizal

11

Occidental Mindoro

San Jose

38

Occidental Mindoro

Magsaysay

12

Occidental Mindoro

Lubang

16

Occidental Mindoro

Looc

9

Marinduque

Gasan

25

Marinduque

Buenavista

15

Romblon

Banton

17

Romblon

Corcuera

15

Romblon

Concepcion

9

Romblon

Calatrava

7

Romblon

San Agustin

15

Romblon

Santa Maria

6

Romblon

Alcantara

12

Romblon

Magdiwang

9

Romblon

Cajidiocan

14

Romblon

San Fernando

12

Romblon

Looc

12

Romblon

Ferrol

6

Romblon

Sta. Fe

11

Romblon

San Andres

13

Romblon

Odiongan

25

Romblon

San Jose

5

Palawan

Coron

23

Palawan

Busuanga

14

Palawan

Culion

14

Palawan

Linapacan

10

Palawan

El Nido

18

Palawan

Taytay

31

Palawan

San Vicente

10

Palawan

Puerto Princesa City

66

49

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

2016 GEOHAZARD SEMINARS/MEETINGS PROVINCE MUNICIPALITY NO. OF BARANGAYS Palawan

Roxas

31

Palawan

Dumaran

16

Palawan

Araceli

13

Palawan

Aborlan

19

Palawan

Narra

23

Palawan

Quezon

14

Palawan

Rizal

11

Palawan

Sofronio Española

9

Palawan

Brooke’s Point

18

Palawan

Bataraza

22

Palawan

Balabac

20

Palawan

Agutaya

10

Palawan

Cuyo

17

Palawan

Magsaysay

11

Palawan

Cagayancillo

12

Palawan

Kalayaan

1

Total no. of Barangays = 1,078

50

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

51

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

The preparation for each geohazard seminar included coordination with the municipal government, usually through the MDRRMO (Municipal Disaster RiskReduction and Management Officer), in order to finalize the logistics of the event. Since the dissemination of IEC materials (A.03.b.1.a.4) had been integrated within the geohazard seminar, the posters, pamphlets, video CDs, and updated barangay-level geohazard maps were all prepared beforehand. Aside from these, the geologists would conduct fieldworks before the seminar takes place in order to gather data and observations related to flooding and landslide hazards within the municipality which would then be presented during the geohazard seminar. The geohazard seminar/meeting is a half-day event consisting mainly of talks which aim to increase the knowledge and awareness of the communities regarding geohazards and the tools that can be used in adaptation to the presence of these geohazards. The talks included in the program are: (i) Introduction to Geohazards and Geohazard Maps, (ii) Flooding Hazards, (iii) Landslide Hazards, (iv) Landslide and Flooding Cases in MIMAROPA, and (v) Understanding Geohazard Maps. The distribution of barangay-level geohazard maps, posters, pamphlets, and video CDs are also included in the program. Aside from these, a time is also set aside for the queries, comments, and remarks of the audience who are mostly LGUs. A.03.b.1.b Coastal Geohazard and Impact of Climate Change As for the accomplishment of coastal mapping targets assigned to the region, MGB-MIMAROPA has completed the assessment of all the nine (9) target coastal municipalities in Western and Eastern Samar. The inclusion of the detailed 1:10,000 scale coastal mapping project in the regular planned activities of MGB commenced in 2015 to determine the impact of climate change on coastal environment. Accomplishment under coastal geohazard mapping included mainly of identification of shoreline shifts and completion of beach profiling activities. A total of nine (9) coastal municipalities were assessed covering the coastal lowlands and shorelines of the following: Marabut, Basey, Sta. Rita, Talalora and Villareal, all in the province of Western Samar; Lawaan, Balangiga, Guiuan, and Giporlos, all in the province of Eastern Samar. This mapping coverage is equivalent to accomplishment rating of 100% based on the annual target of nine municipalities assessed for coastal hazards and shoreline changes.

52

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Map of the Province of Samar showing the Location of the Nine Coastal Municipalities covered by the Coastal Geohazard Mapping Activities conducted by MGB-MIMAROPA in 2016

The primary objective of the mapping program is to study shoreline changes particularly the hazards associated with coastal erosion (land loss) and coastal accretion. The coastal geohazard mapping project undertaken consists of four (4) major activities namely: (1) Shoreline mapping, (2) Beach Profiling, (3) Gathering historical/anecdotal record (4) Identification of areas prone to coastal geohazard, i.e., coastal erosion and accretion. Shoreline Mapping Shoreline mapping aims to determine the long-term shoreline trend by comparing the newly acquired GPS track datawith the shoreline data in the NAMRIA topographic maps, which were gathered approximately in the 1950’s, as well as short-term changes. The conduct of this activity also determines the significant

53

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

shoreline shifts brought about by marine transgression (coastal erosion) and regression (coastal accretion/deposition). Coastal erosion and regression constitute the mapped geohazards along the shorelines of Western Samar. Beach Profiling Beach profiling is a simple survey technique used to measure the contour of a beach. Every beach profile was established from selected areas where baseline data on beach morphology were identified. The method aims to compare the beaches or coastlines in different locations and to examine the rock type, cliff profile, sediment size and other conditions of the beach area.These baseline data will be used as reference materials for future works such as preparation of coastal management plan, investigation of seasonal changes in the beach profile, and analysis of beach dynamics. Gathering of Historical Data Gathering of historical data was conducted to validate and to augment existing and newly acquired field information in the coastal areas. Historical data gathering involved interviews with local government officials and coastal residents concerning coastal flooding, erosion and accretion, and tsunami occurrences in the area. Identification of Areas Prone to Coastal Geohazard (Coastal Erosion and Accretion) The assessed coastal areas were rated as having low, moderate, high or very high to coastal erosion, and as having low, moderate, high and very high susceptibility to coastal accretion/siltation based on the parameters as shown below. Rating and Criteria Used in the Assessment for Coastal Erosion

54

Very High

Alluvial deposits/beach sand. The coast is composed of unconsolidated alluvial deposits especially noncohesive materials, largely sand, granules and pebbles that are easily carried away by waves and currents even at calm sea conditions. Presence of severely damaged hard engineering coastal protection structures, and dwelling units at or very near the shoreline; line of permanent vegetation is approximately 1-2 meters away from the existing shoreline. Unprotected areas with long-term net erosion of >50 m.

High

Alluvial deposits/mud and silt. The coast is composed of cohesive materials, largely mud and silt that are not easily carried away by waves and currents even at moderate sea conditions. Absence of engineering coastal protection structures and dwelling units near the shoreline; line of permanent vegetation is

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

approximately 3-5 meters away from the existing shoreline. Unprotected areas with long-term net erosion of 30-50 meters. Moderate

Low

Alluvial deposits/gravel, cobbles and boulders. Geological materials at the coast are essentially gravel, cobbles and boulders where coastal protection structure are slightly damaged; houses far from the existing line of permanent vegetation is about 5-10 m away from the existing shoreline. Unprotected areas with long-term net erosion of 2030 m. Hard rocks with closely spaced joints and fractures. Also undisturbed mangrove forests, or in areas composed of consolidated or semi-consolidated cohesive materials like clays and silt with minor sand. Presence of fringing corals along the foreshore. Longterm net erosion is <20m.

Rating and Criteria Used in the Assessment for Coastal Accretion/Siltation High

Moderate

Low

River mouths, shoals, longshore ridge, existing sand bars. Mouths of large river systems where propagated deltas have developed. Foreshore beds have low seaward slope (0° to 3°) and blanketed with relatively thick sand; shallow water depth up to about 100 meters seaward of the existing shoreline. Line of permanent vegetation about 50 meters distance from the existing shoreline. Areas with long-term accretion of ≥ 50m. Updrift of groins/solid-based piers. Foreshore bed has gentle to moderate slope of 4° to 10°. It usually occurs towards the downdrift ends of coastal sediment cells with abundant sediment supply. Areas with long-term accretion of 20 to 50m. Sheltered areas; downdrift of groins/solid-based piers. Areas with long-term accretion of <20m. Foreshore bed has steep seaward slope of more than 30°. Sediment supply inadequate.

When appropriate, the barangay officials were presented with a Coastal Geohazard Advisory. This advisory informs them of their areas’ susceptibility to coastal erosion/accretion and contains the corresponding recommendations.

55

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Results of Coastal Geohazard Mapping in the Province of Samar Below summarizes the results of the assessment of the covered areas. MUNICIPALITY OF MARABUT BARANGAY

PUROK/SITIOS

COASTAL EROSION RATING

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

Purok 1

Low

Low

Purok 2

Low

-

Purok 3

Low

-

Purok Hilaba

Low

-

Sitio Cabalagnan

Moderate

-

Sitio Malatapay

Low

-

Sitio Bakhaw

Low

-

AMANBUCALE

AMANTILLO

CANYOYO

REMARKS Wave action gradually consumes the coastal parts of this barangay which are characterized by silty to sandy beach coast. In contrary, coastal accretion/siltation was observed near the river mouth of an unnamed river in Purok 1. Strong wave-attacks promote the coastal erosion along the coastal portion of Sitio Cabalagnan especially during storm events. The coastal portions in these sitios are characterized by sandy to rocky shore. Slightly damaged coastal protection structures (seawall) are partly destroyed due to persistent wave action.

LOGERO

Sitio Pampang

Moderate

-

Exposed roots of coconut trees and diminishing shore were observed in Brgy. Logero. These are evidences of high susceptibility to coastal erosion

ODOC

Coastal parts of the brgy.

Low

Low

The coastal section in this barangay is subjected to persistent wave action that makes it susceptible to coastal erosion.

LEGAZPI

Coastal parts of the brgy.

High

Low

Presence of sea notch about 3 meters high is an indication of intense coastal erosion. This occurrence is due to the gradual undercutting of the base of the shore face by wave action during high tide condition. However, coastal accretion/siltation in boundaries of Brgy. Veloso and Legaspi was observed.

MUNICIPALITY OF BASEY BARANGAY

PUROK/SITIOS Zone 1 Zone 2

BASYAO Purok 3 Purok 4

56

COASTAL EROSION RATING Very Low to Nil Very Low to Nil Very Low to Nil Very Low to Nil

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

REMARKS

Low -

The coastal section in this barangay is subjected to wave action that makes it susceptible to coastal erosion.

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

MUNICIPALITY OF BASEY BARANGAY

PUROK/SITIOS

COASTAL EROSION RATING

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

Purok Tambis

High

-

Purok Pasayan

High

-

Purok Papaya

High

Low

Purok Caimito

Low to Moderate

-

Purok Mangga

Low to Moderate

Low

Purok Atis

Low

-

Zone 1

Moderate

-

Zone 2

Moderate

-

Zone 3

Moderate

-

Zone 4

Moderate

-

Zone 5

Moderate

-

Zone 6

Moderate

-

Coastal area of Poblacion

High

-

BALUD

SAN FERNANDO

SAN ANTONIO

CATADMAN

REMARKS Exposed roots of coconut trees and diminishing shore were observed in Brgy. Balud. These are evidences of high susceptibility to coastal erosion. Based on anecdotal account, for the past 50 years, 20 meters of land have been eroded in Purok Pasayan. These coastal parts of the barangay are characterized by unconsolidated alluvial deposits and are mainly composed of sand and gravel with the associated vegetative cover of mangroves.These can be easily carried away by waves and currents even at calm sea conditions. Coastal erosion was aggravated by Typhoon Yolanda Accretion are confined near the river mouth of an unnamed river in Purok Mangga. . Characterized by sandy and gravelly coast. Wave actions gradually consume the coastal parts of this barangay. The presence of pier structure prohibits the replenishment of beach materials in this area.

Coastal erosional evidences such as fallen trees and exposed roots of coconut trees were observed.

MUNICIPALITY OF STA. RITA BARANGAY

PUROK/SITIOS

COASTAL EROSION RATING

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

REMARKS

BOKINGGAN

Coastal area of Poblacion

Low to Moderate

-

The coastal parts of this barangay are exposed to wave action during storm event that makes it vulnerable to coastal erosion hazards.

SANTAN

Coastal area of the barangay

Moderate to High

The coastal section within the jurisdiction of Brgy. Santan experiences sustained period of erosion or sediment loss. This occurrence is influenced by constant wave action and strong current during extreme weather phenomena. -

According to the locals, approximately five (5) meters of beach land area had eroded (coastal retreat) due to strong waves during the passage of Typhoon Ruby.

57

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

MUNICIPALITY OF STA. RITA BARANGAY

HINAGUTDAN

PUROK/SITIOS

Coastal area near proper

COASTAL EROSION RATING

High

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

Low to Moderate

REMARKS The coastal stretch of the barangay are characterized by unconsolidated alluvial deposits and are mainly composed of, sand and gravel with the associated vegetative cover of mangroves.They can be easily carried away by waves and currents even at calm sea conditions. Furthermore, exposed roots of coconut trees along the coastal community indicates coastal erosion. On the other hand, during “HABAGAT” season, episode of sand deposition occurs and during “AMIHAN” coastal erosion transpires particularly near the barangay proper.

CABUNGAAN

IGANG-IGANG

Purok 1

High

-

Purok 2

High

-

Purok 3

High

-

Coastal area of Proper

High

-

The coastal areas in these communities are characterized by rocky and sandy to gravelly coast. Based on anecdotal accounts, sixteen (16) meters of coastal land area were eroded over the period of 20 years. Based on the historical/anecdotal accounts of a 30- year old resident in the area, fifteen (15) meters of coastal land area were so far eroded (coastal retreat). Meanwhile, coastal protection structure such as seawall was observed in the area to mitigate coastal erosion by wave action during storm event.

MUNICIPALITY OF TALALORA BARANGAY

PUROK/SITIOS

COASTAL EROSION RATING

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

REMARKS

Coastal Portion

High

-

Exposed coconut roots of about a meter in high in this area are indicative of severe erosion. Exposures of bedrock comprising conglomerate with interbeds of sandstone and siltstone were noted.

Near Brgy Boundary with Brgy Igang-igang

-

Low

Sand transport that had caused sand deposition (accretion) in some parts along the beach area were also observed on the adjacent barangay.

MALAGUINING

NAVATAS DAKO

58

Coastal Portion near Brgy Covered Court

Very Low to Nil

Low

The coastal portions are composed of pebbly to gravelly –sized grains. The presence of coral reef along the coast reduces the vulnerability of the area to erosion. Sand deposition (accretion) was noted near the wharf area.

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

MUNICIPALITY OF TALALORA BARANGAY

PUROK/SITIOS

COASTAL EROSION RATING

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

Sitio Bersales

Low

Low

Sitio Cabangangan

Low

Low

Sitio Sabang

Low

Low

POBLACION I

POBLACION II

REMARKS Presences of pier and other structures (sea wall) in the barangay proper helps in the protection from coastal erosion. Coastal erosions on some areas of barangay were occurs only during storm events. Beach deposits were consumed by high-energy waves during extreme weather condition and, then, slowly “re-deposited back” onshore and rebuild the original profile during fair-weather conditions. Evidence of coastal erosion such as exposed tree roots were noted.

MUNICIPALITY OF VILLAREAL BARANGAY

BANQUIL

PUROK/SITIOS

COASTAL EROSION RATING

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

Purok 1

Moderate

-

Purok 2

Moderate

-

Purok 3

Moderate

-

REMARKS Characterized by sandy and gravelly coast. Wave actions gradually consume the coastal parts of this barangay. Coastal erosion was aggravated by alleged sand extraction along the beach. At Sitio Bunga, the coastline has already retreated for about10 meters based on anecdotal accounts of local residents. At Sitio Bunga, the coastline has already retreated for about10 meters based on anecdotal accounts of local residents.

BURABOD

GUINTARCAN

Sitio Bunga

Moderate

-

Sitio Balerigan

Moderate

-

Brgy. Proper

Low

Low

Brgy. Proper

-

Low

Sitio Butawanan

High

-

Sitio Campalma

High

-

Sitio Canudlas

High

-

Sitio Gimbalangawan

High

-

The presence of pier structure prohibits the replenishment of beach materialsin some portion of the barangay. Construction of seawall near the pier help in mitigating coastal erosion in the area. Coastal erosions are experienced during HABAGAT season while sand deposition occurs during the AMIHAN season. Diminishing shoreline can be observed in areas as shown by sea water has already reaching portions of the cemetery. Some tombs are already disturbed by wave action during high tide sea condition. In some areas, tree roots are exposed from about 20cm to more than a meter. These are evidences of high susceptibility of the area to coastal erosion. Coastal areas are subjected to persistent wave

59

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

MUNICIPALITY OF VILLAREAL BARANGAY

LAMINGAO

SAN RAFAEL

STO. NINO

PUROK/SITIOS

COASTAL EROSION RATING

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

Sitio Halaba

High

-

Sitio Liog-liog

High

-

Sitio Tigib

High

-

Sitio Cabagsan

Low

-

The coastal section in this barangay is subjected to persistent wave action that makes it susceptible to coastal erosion. Sediment deposition characterized by gravelly and sandy sediments are observed on the coastal areas along with the presence of mangrove trees.

Brgy Proper

-

Low

Purok 1

Low

Low

Purok 3

Low

Low

Purok 4

Low

Low

REMARKS action that makes it susceptible to coastal erosion.

Presence of mangroves in sandy to muddy sediments in the coastal areas of the barangay provide protection to wave action. However, in some beach portions, erosion is promoted by wave actions especially during high tide condition. Coastal accretion/siltation was observed near the river mouth of the river between San Rafael and Sto Nino.

MUNICIPALITY OF LAWAAN BARANGAY

PUROK/SITIOS

COASTAL EROSION RATING

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

Proper

Very Low to Nil

Very Low to Nil

Sitio Olot

BOLUSAO

Purok Marasal

Purok 3

Purok 1

60

REMARKS

There are no significant indications of shoreline shift or change in the coastal parts of Barangay Bolusao. The coastal areas are mainly characterized by coral platforms with narrow sandy beaches and some mangrove sections. This type of environment is least vulnerable to coastal erosion due to its resistance to erosion. In addition, presence of seawall particularly in barangay proper, also aids in mitigating the occurrence of coastal erosion by wave action especially during storm events. Furthermore, minor beach erosion transpires during “Habagat” season while during “Amihan”, episode of sand deposition replenishes the eroded sediments in the coastal portions of the barangay.

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

MUNICIPALITY OF LAWAAN BARANGAY

POBLACION VI

PUROK/SITIOS

Sitio Kanwakay

COASTAL EROSION RATING

Moderate to High

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

Low

REMARKS Active coastal erosion that resulted to coastal retreat and loss of land was prominent in Sitio Kanwakay. Exposed coconut roots near the coast are evidence of intense erosion in the area. On the other hand, accretion or sand deposition are confined only near the river mouth of Lawaan River northwest from the community.

GUINOB-AN

Coastal portion of the barangays

Low

Low

BETAOG

Coastal portion of the barangays

Low

Low

POBLACION I

Coastal portion of the barangays

Low

Low

POBLACION II

Coastal portion of the barangays

Low

Low

POBLACION III

Coastal portion of the barangays

Low

Low

TAGUITE

Coastal portion of the barangays

Low

Low

MASLOG

Coastal portion of the barangays

Low

Low

Based on the field mapping and assessment carried out in the municipality of Lawaan, the following barangays proximal to the coastal margins are categorized as “low” in terms of coastal erosion and accretion hazards. These areas are characterized with rocky shores and protected with mangroves. However, coastal flooding may transpire during extreme climatic conditions due to storm surges. In addition, ongoing construction of coastal protection structures was observed in the coastal barangays near the municipal proper.

MUNICIPALITY OF BALANGIGA BARANGAY

PUROK/SITIOS

POBLACION VI

Coastal portion of the barangay

POBLACION IV

Coastal portion of the barangay

COASTAL EROSION RATING

Very Low to Nil

-

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

Moderate

-

REMARKS Shoreline stabilization structuressuch as seawall have already been constructed in the following barangays Presence of seawall helpsin the mitigation of coastal hazard in the area. However, sections of the seawall specifically near Poblacion VI are partly damaged due to constant wave attacks. On the other hand, according to the local residents, the coastline in Poblacion VI and IV have advancedto about three (3) meters in length (measured perpendicular to the beach) as new deposits of sediments (beach sands)

61

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

MUNICIPALITY OF BALANGIGA BARANGAY

POBLACION V

CANSUMANGCAY

SAN MIGUEL

PUROK/SITIOS

Coastal portion of the barangay

Coastal portion of the barangay

Coastal portion of the barangay

COASTAL EROSION RATING

-

Very Low to Nil

Low

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

Low to Moderate

REMARKS were added along the coast(accretion).Accretion started after the Typhoon Yolanda event. Furthermore, episode of sand deposition are confined only near the river mouth of Balangiga River west of Poblacion V.

Very Low to Nil

The coastal area in this barangay are comprised primarily of mangroves with some sections of rocky shore. This type of environment are likely least susceptible to coastal hazard since mangroves provide coastal protection to the impact of wave , while rocky shores offer resistance to coastal erosion. However, coastal flooding may occur during extreme weather phenomena due to storm surges.

Low to Moderate

The coastal parts within the area jurisdiction of Barangay San Miguel experiences coastal erosion during “Habagat” season and coastal accretion or sand deposition during “Amihan.”Accretion is notable near the mouth of the river. Seasonal changes of shoreline occur along the coastal stretch of the barangay.

BACJAO

Coastal portion of the barangay

Low to Moderate

Low to Moderate

Accordingly, erosion transpires during “Habagat “season and sand deposition occurs during “Amihan”. The coastal portions in barangay Bacjao are mainly consists of rocky shore (coralline limestone) with mangroves. Moreover, an old port/pier facility was observed in the vicinity that were previously utilized by the former operating mining company (Industrial Enterprises, Inc) in Giporlos. In addition, based on the anecdotal accounts, about four (4) metershigh of wave due storm surge hit the barangay during the passage of Yolanda in the area.

MUNICIPALITY OF GIPORLOS BARANGAY

PUROK/SITIOS

PARINA

Coastal portion of the Barangay

COASTAL EROSION RATING Very Low to Nil

BARANGAY V

Coastal portion of the Barangay

Very Low to Nil

-

COTICOT

Coastal portion of the Barangay

Very Low to Nil

-

62

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING -

REMARKS These coastal communities are comprised primarily of mangroves. This type of environment is likely least susceptible to coastal hazard since mangroves serve as a natural buffer against coastal erosion induced by strong wave attacks, tidal waves, and storms. However, coastal flooding may still occur during extreme weather

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

MUNICIPALITY OF GIPORLOS BARANGAY

PUROK/SITIOS

SAN ISIDRO

Coastal portion of the Barangay

COASTAL EROSION RATING Very Low to Nil

PAYA

Coastal portion of the Barangay

Very Low to Nil

-

BIGA

Coastal portion of the Barangay

Very Low to Nil

-

BARANGAY I

Coastal portion of the Barangay

Low to Moderate

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

REMARKS phenomena.

-

Based on anecdotal accounts, waves having a height of more than one (1) meter, due to storm surge, hit the low lying grounds of Purok/Sitio Navotas during the course of Typhoon Yolanda. In addition, slightly damaged coastal protection structures (seawall) are partly destroyed due to persistent wave action.

-

On the other hand, presence of mangroves were also observed on the southern extremities of the barangay. BARANGAY II

Coastal portion of the Barangay

Very Low to Nil

The presence of a pier structure alters the deposition of sediments on the area, specifically on the structure’s eastern side.

Very low

The coastal portions in Barangay Gigoso are consisted mainly of mangroves with some sections of rocky shore (coralline limestone). GIGOSO

Coastal portion of the Barangay

Low

-

According to the locals, approximately five (5) meters of beach land area were eroded (coastal retreat) due to strong waves over the period of twenty (20) years.

MUNICIPALITY OF GUIUAN BARANGAY

PUROK/SITIOS Purok 1

BITAUGAN

CASUGURAN

PAGBABANGNAN

COASTAL EROSION RATING Moderate to High

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING -

Purok 2

Moderate to High

Low

Purok 3

Moderate to High

-

Purok 1

-

Low to Moderate

Purok 2

-

Low to Moderate

Purok 3

Moderate to High

-

Nasumo

Moderate to High

-

REMARKS Wave action gradually consumes the coastal parts of this barangay that are characterized by silty to sandy beach coast. Based on anecdotal accounts, the shoreline have regressed by three (3) meters during the passage typhoon Yolanda. The coastal section within the jurisdiction of Brgy. Casuguran experiences sustained period of erosion or sediment loss. This occurrence is induced by constant sea wave action and strong current during extreme weather phenomena. Active coastal erosion that resulted to coastal retreat and loss of land was

63

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

MUNICIPALITY OF GUIUAN BARANGAY

BARAS

PUROK/SITIOS

COASTAL EROSION RATING

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

Purok 1

Moderate to High

-

Purok 2

Moderate to High

-

Sitio Cantilado (Purok 3)

Moderate to High

-

Cabadlungan

-

Low

13A

-

Moderate to High

13B

High

-

SULANGAN

POBLACION 12

CULASI

CAMPOYONG

64

Coastal Area

Low

-

Purok 1

-

Low

Purok 2

-

Low

Purok 3

Moderate to High

-

Purok 1

Low

-

Purok 2

Low

-

Purok 3

Low

-

Purok 4

Low

-

Purok 7

Low

-

REMARKS prominent in these localities. Exposed coconut roots near the coast are evidence of intense coastal erosion in the area. Furthermore, several infrastructures were heavily damaged due to the strong waves that hit the barangay during the course of Typhoon Yolanda. Presence of mangroves in sandy to muddy sediments in the coastal areas of the barangay provide protection to wave action. Exposed roots of coconut trees and diminishing shore were observed in Purok 13B. These are evidences of high susceptibility to coastal erosion. In contrary, the northern portion of the said locality are characterized by coral platforms with mangroves in some sections that are considerably less susceptible to coastal hazards due to its resistance to persistent strong wave action. On the other hand, coastal accretion/siltation was also observed on the southwestern most tip of Calicoan Island fronting Sulangan Island specifically in Purok 13A. The coastal area in this barangay is comprised primarily of mangroves. This type of environment is likely least susceptible to coastal hazard since mangroves provide coastal protection to the impact of waves. According to the local residents, the coastline in Purok 1, 2 and 3 have retreated to about three (3) meters in length (measured perpendicular to the beach). This event of high rate erosion occurs during Habagat Season. Accretion were also noted along the northwestern stretch of the beach proximal to the pier structure (stock piles of bouldersized rocks). The coastal area in this barangay is comprised primarily of mangroves. This type of environment is likely least susceptible to coastal hazard since mangroves provide coastal protection to the impact of waves.

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

MUNICIPALITY OF GUIUAN BARANGAY

PUROK/SITIOS

BANAAG

Coastal areas

HAMORAWON

COASTAL EROSION RATING

low

COASTAL ACCRETION RATING

-

REMARKS There are no significant indications of shoreline shift or change in the coastal parts of these coastal communities. The coastal section in these areas are mainly characterized by coral platforms with narrow sandy beaches and some mangrove sections. This type of environment is least vulnerable to coastal erosion due to its resistance to erosion. Furthermore, minor beach erosion transpires during “Habagat” season while during “Amihan”, episode of sand deposition replenishes the eroded sediments in the coastal portions of the barangay.

Other barangays of the municipalities of Marabut, Basey, Sta. Rita, Talalora, and Villareal that are proximal to the coastal margins which have confined beaches, mangrove sections, and rocky shores are classified as “low” in terms of coastal erosion and accretion hazards. However, coastal flooding may transpire during typhoon events due to storm surges. Preliminary findings on the municipalities of Marabut and Villareal show that the coastal erosions on some areas of the barangays, from the said municipalities, were considered short term shoreline changes which occur only during storm events. Beach deposits were consumed by high-energy waves during extreme weather conditions and were slowly “re-deposited back” onshore which then rebuilds the original profile during fair-weather conditions. General Recommendations MGB recommends strict and continuous monitoring by the barangays as well as the following, to wit; 

Observe for and/or monitor for occurrence of distinct or severe coastal erosion. Report such to the MGB office concerned and the municipal/city authorities



Increase Level of Awareness and Preparedness of the Residents of HazardProne Areas on Geohazards and Disasters.



Identify Relocation Sites for Communities Situated in High Risk Areas.



Establish Coastal Setback and No Build/Construction Zones. (Please Refer to RA No.386 (Civil Code of the Philippines), PD 1067 (Water Code), PD 1096 (National Structural Code of the Philippines), PD 705 (Forestry Code), Joint Memorandum Circular 2014-01)



Protect Mangroves, Coral Platforms and Sand Dunes.

65

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report



Constructions of shoreline stabilization structures should be complemented by other measures including promotion of coastal hazard awareness and preparedness to the public.



Reactivate the Barangay Disaster and Risk Reduction Management Council (BDRRMC) and coordinate with the Municipal Disaster and Risk Reduction Management Council of Romblon Municipality (MDRRMC) during extreme weather conditions.



Immediate evacuation of residents during prolong and incessant rainfall.

A 1:10,000 scale coastal erosion and accretion susceptibility map of the covered areas will soon be prepared showing the above cited locations and their corresponding susceptibility ratings. The MGB will furnish the concerned barangays and municipalities with the 1: 10,000 scale coastal erosion and accretion susceptibility maps once they are completed.

A.03.b.2 Geologic Mapping A.03.b.2.a Quadrangle Geological Mapping For the purpose of completing the geologic quadrangle mapping of Region III as the priority target area for 2016, a team from the Geosciences Division of Mines and Geosciences Bureau Region IV-MIMAROPA was tasked to conduct geological mapping of PAPAYA and DIKABASAN Quadrangles located in the provinces of Nueva Ecija and Aurora. The fieldwork was accomplished during the last week of March until the second week of May 2016. Prior to the mapping activities, a workshop on standardization of procedures for geologic quadrangle mapping was held last March 7 to 11, 2016 in Contemporary Hotel, Quezon City. The objectives and field methodologies of the said mapping activities were discussed during the workshop. It was also agreed that two quadrangles will be assigned for every region, one for quadrangle updating and the other one for semi-detailed mapping. The MGB- III Regional Office provided the team with 1:50,000 Geologic Map of the PAPAYA Quadrangle and topographic map of DIKABASAN Quadrangle. Shapefiles were also distributed to the teams which include municipalities and barangays locations, access roads and trails. The shapefiles were then overlain to the available maps and were used by the team during the conduct of fieldwork. The objectives of the geological mapping activity are to: (1) identify and divide every quadrangle into distinct lithologies or mappable units, and to show the areal distribution of these units for PAPAYA and DIKABASAN Quadrangles; (2) to depict the nature of the boundaries between mappable units, whether stratigraphic, tectonic or intrusive; (3) to determine the age of the mappable units; (4) to generate regional scale geologic map for DIKABASAN Quadrangle; (5) to update the existing geologic map of PAPAYA Quadrangle; and finally, (6) to write technical reports regarding the results and findings of the field mapping activities to be submitted to the MGB-Central Office.

66

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

The methodologies applied during the conduct of geological mapping are the following:  Review and collation of the available geological literature and analysis of the relevant topographic, hydrologic and geological maps;  Field traverse, verification and identification of rock types, rock formational contacts/boundaries, and geologic structures during field mapping;  Collecting and GPS tagging of rock samples for petrographic and paleontological analyses on the purpose of renaming formations, inclusion of another formation or extension of geologic age constraint;  Data interpretation and utilization for the generation of maps and technical report.  The team field findings regarding these lithologic formations will then be correlated from the existing data from Geology of the Philippines (Aurelio and Pena, 2010). Areas Covered by Geologic Mapping

The original geologic map of PAPAYA Quadrangle

67

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Topographic map of DIKABASAN Quadrangle used during the conduct of field mapping, this map was generated using IFSAR Imagery

A quadrangle map has geographic coordinates of 10 minutes latitude and 15 minutes longitude and has an area of more or less 48,000 hectares. The team was assigned to conduct regional geological mapping of PAPAYA and DIKABASAN Quadrangles. The PAPAYA Quadrangle encompasses largely of General Tinio municipality (formerly Papaya). Also included in the quadrangle are small portions of the municipalities of Peñaranda and Sta. Rosa, Laur, Gabaldon, and the cities of Cabanatuan and Palayan in Nueva Ejica. The Municipality of General Tinio is a first class municipality of Nueva Ecija and is about 180 aerial kilometers northeast of Metro Manila. DIKABASAN Quadrangle covers almost the entire Dilasag municipality in Aurora Province. Dilasag is a third class municipality of Aurora and is located in the northernmost part of the province. The municipal proper is about 240 aerial kilometers northeast of Metro Manila. Geological Mapping Activity in the Study Areas PAPAYA QUADRANGLE (3266-II) The geological mapping team first targeted the PAPAYA Quadrangle. The activity executed on March 27 to April 7, 2016. The team made courtesy calls at the LGUs of municipality of General Tinio and Palayan City, to seek for assistance and to inform barangay officials regarding on the activities that will be conducted by the team. The LGUs provided field guides that are familiar in the terrain especially on the upland areas. The team also coordinated with the military detachments before entering the upland areas. The topography of PAPAYA exhibits flat to gently sloping on the west and rugged terrain with moderate to steeply sloping mountains on the east. The western section is

68

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

predominantly underlain by Quaternary Alluvium consisting of detrital/alluvial deposits essentially made up of silt, sand, and gravel. The first part of the field mapping focuses on the eastern section of the quadrangle particularly in Barangays Pias and Rio Chico, General Tinio. The team traverses the Chico River from its emerging point at SitioWawangTakla down to the junction of Sumacbao and Chico River at Barangay Concepcion, until the quarry site at Barangay Pias (Northeast of the Minalungao National Park). The team also traversed the mountains and rivers that bound the barangays of Palale and Nazareth up to Mt. Baca. Several formational contacts and well-exposed outcrops of oxidized volcanic and siliceous deposits, as well as intrusive bodies have been observed by the team in the vicinity. The last part of the survey was done at military reservation under the Fort Magsaysay in Palayan City where well-exposed sedimentary sequences can be seen along the Laur-Palayan Road. Results include renaming of previously-mapped geologic formations and regrouping them with identified stratigraphic units based on the Geology of the Philippines and Lexicon of Philippine Stratigraphy. Among the geologic formations identified in the area are members of the Montalban Ophiolitic Complex, Kinabuan Formation, Maybangain Formation, Sta. Ines Diorite, Binangonan Formation (Upper Limestone Member), Angat Formation, Madlum Formation, and Quaternary Alluvium deposits. Inferred geologic structures such as faults were also traced based on morphologic manifestations observed through satellite imagery. Formation

Age

Description

Quaternary Alluvium

Quaternary (Holocene)

Loose, unconsolidated sediments (sand and gravel), soil, and other alluvial deposits

Madlum Formation

Middle Miocene

gentle to moderately-dipping (5-15°) Interbedded tuffaceous, brown to gray siltstones and sandstones

Angat Formation

Early Miocene

White, massive biohermal Limestones

Binangonan Formation

Late Oligocene to Early Miocene

massive, light cream to pink to bluish gray and fossil-rich limestone

Sta. Ines Diorite

Early Oligocene

Hornblende diorites, tonalites

Early Paleocene – Middle Eocene

volcanogenic turbiditic, gray-black sandstones and laminated siltstones, grayish-brown bedded/laminated siltstones and sandstones with green and red siltstone inclusions, graded beds with volcanogenic clasts ranging from boulderssand, and minor lithic tuff and porphyry andesite.

Late Cretaceous – Early Paleocene

beds of indurated, alternating reddish and greenish siltstones with occasional white chert interbeds, green cherts intercalated with greenish-gray siltstones, folded, thinly-bedded gray siliceous siltstones

Late Cretaceous

massive gabbro in overlain by pillow basalts and layers of indurated gray siltstone, composed of Augite (30%), An>50 Plagioclase (25%), and relict Hornblende (10%)

Maybangain Formation

Kinabuan Formation

Montalban Ophiolitic Complex

69

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

The Philippine Fault, a NW-trending sinistral fault that runs through the entire archipelago bisects a segment of the province of Nueva Ecija and Aurora at the LaurDingalan fault zone and is morphologically expressed as the division between the Northern and Southern Sierra Madre Ranges. The fault has probable splays at the Papaya Quadrangle and is manifested by the abundance of NW-trending lineaments andsinistral faults, and morphological expressions such as shutter ridges and truncated stream channels. Using GIS-processed hillshade map of the Papaya Quadrangle, structures and morphological expressions are easily visualized and delineated. The presence of NWtrending structures parallel to the orientation of the Philippine Fault may be a direct consequence of the movement along this segment. Field structural observations included the presence of a graben and thrust faults. We interpret this as a probable consequence of strike-slip faulting. In general, NW and NE-trending joints are present in older formations, but we observe abundance of NE-trending joints in the Kinabuan Formation, while NW-trending joints are more common in the Maybangain Formation. Abundance of NE- trending joints in the Kinabuan Formation may be attributed to Early Tertiary tectonic conditions and may give us an idea on the migration of the Montalban Ophiolitic Complex and Kinabuan Formation to its current position; while NW-trending joints can be attributed to postemplacement stresses such as the NW-migration of the PMB and the Philippine Fault. The absence of prominent joints in the Madlum Formation and the aforementioned minor differences in the directions of gently- dipping beds may support the possibility that it has not experienced great stresses. A total of nine rock samples were collected during the geologic mapping in PAPAYA quadrangle. A total of three samples were sent for petrographic analyses in Geological Lab Services of MGB-Central. SAMPLES TAKEN FROM PAPAYA QUADRANGLE FOR LABORATORY ANALYSIS SAMPLE LABEL GEM-PA-01

LOCATION Brgy. Nauzon, Laur, Nueva Ecija N 15 29 54.3 , E 121 08 20.5

GEM-PA-02

Sitio Wawang Takla, Brgy. Rio Chico, General Tinio, Nueva Ecija N 15 21 59.2, E 121 12 27.9

GEM-PA-02

Sitio Wawang Takla, Brgy. Rio Chico, General Tinio, Nueva Ecija N 15 21 59.2, E 121 12 27.9

70

DESCRIPTION

ROCK ID

REMARKS

Gray silt-sized components, calcitic veins

Siltstone

For Paleontological Dating

Massive, darkcolored, with minor olivine mineralization

Olivine Basalt

Massive, darkcolored, with minor olivine mineralization

Olivine Basalt

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

SAMPLES TAKEN FROM PAPAYA QUADRANGLE FOR LABORATORY ANALYSIS SAMPLE LABEL

GEM-PA-04

LOCATION Sitio Wawang Takla, Brgy. Rio Chico, General Tinio, Nueva Ecija N 15 21 38.8, E 121 13 11

DESCRIPTION

ROCK ID

REMARKS

Green layered chert interbedded with gray, indurated sandstone

Bedded chert, sandstone

For Paleontological Dating

GEM-PA-05

Brgy. Nazareth stockfarm, General Tinio, Nueva Ecija N 15 23 46.6, E 121 09 40.6

Dark rock with patches of green silicic minerals

Silicified/ metamorphosed basalt

GEM-PA-07

Sitio Santol, Brgy. Palale, General Tinio, Nueva Ecija N15 24 35.7, E 121 11 24.4

Interbedded greenred siltstone and white chert

White chert, red siltstone

For Paleontological Dating

Sitio Tambo, Brgy. Palale , General Tinio, Nueva Ecija N15 24 43.9, E 121 11 36.8,

Light-colored rock with <1mm phenocrysts of plag and dark-colored minerals (amphiboles, biotites) and minor quartz

Quartz diorite

GEM-PA-08

GEM-PA-08

RESULTS OF PETROGRAPHIC ANALYSIS Sample No.

Composition Primary Minerals: Augite

30%

Plagioclase (An>50)

25%

Relict Hornblende

10%

Olivine Opaques

Altered 5%

GEM-PA-02 PM16-223 Secondary Minerals: Tremolite

15%

Clay

5%

Titanite

5%

Chlorite

4%

Opaques

1%

Clasts: GEM-PA-05 PM16-224

Lithic Fragments

75%

Description

Rock ID

Granular texture; Fineto medium-grained, subhedral to euhedral crystals of augite and relict forms of olivine are surrounded by interlocking divergent and variolitic laths of calcic and clayey feldspar laths + superimposed tremolite needles + thin brown hornblende laths + opaque specks + titanite granules. Olivine prisms are fully replaced by tremolite and chlorite fibers. Brown hornblende laths show partial alteration to chlorite + titanite.

GABBRO

Clastic texture; Fine- to medium-sized, irregularly shaped lithic fragments are held

LITHIC TUFF

71

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

RESULTS OF PETROGRAPHIC ANALYSIS Sample No.

Composition Matrix: Glass Chlorite

Primary Minerals: Relict Plagioclase (An<50) Quartz Mafic Minerals

20% 5%

43% 30% Altered

Accessory Minerals: GEM-PA-08 PM16-225

Opaques

Trace

Secondary Minerals: Clay

15%

Chlorite

10%

Epidote

1%

Opaques

1%

Description together by a matrix of glass + minor chlorite fibers.

Rock ID

Lithic fragments are mostly volcanic, showing porphyritic, amygdaloidal, vesicular and trachytic textures. They are generally affected by clay, chlorite, and goethite. Fine, anhedral- to subhedral-granular texture; composed essentially of sodic plagioclase + quartz + minor altered mafics. Plagioclases appear turbid due to superimposed clay fibers. Pre-existing mafic minerals are fully replaced by chlorite + epidote + opaques.

TONALITE

After the field mapping in PAPAYA Quandrangle, the team had a 5-day break which was allocated for the consolidation of data and documents in the office. The following maps were also generated from the data gathered from field investigations:

72

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Revised Geologic Map of the Papaya Quadrangle, showing new formational boundaries and inferred/observed structures

Slope map of the Papaya Quadrangle, showing contrasting changes in topographic relief from west to east.

73

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Drainage Divide Map of the Papaya Quadrangle, showing major river basins in the area.

Hillshade Map of the Papaya Quadrangle, showing major lineaments and displacements, most probably splays of the Philippine Fault.

DIKABASAN QUADRANGLE (3469-III) The team’s target for regional to semi-detailed mapping is the DIKABASAN Quadrangle. The first week of the fieldwork was allotted to coordination and courtesy call with LGU of Dilasag, Aurora as well as with the National Commission on Indigenous People (NCIP) offices stationed in the province. Large portion of DIKABASAN

74

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Quadrangle particularly the isolated and densely forested uplands was identified as ancestral domain of Dumagat tribes. The aforementioned activities were able to cover the entire lowlands of the Dikabasan quadrangle; however, due to security reasons on the upland areas, the team was not able to push through further mapping the mountainous areas.In this regard, an inference of the geologic formations through satellite imagery, structural and topographic analyses, and review of published literature will be done to complete the missing portions of the geologic map to be produced. The stratigraphic groups identified in the area were the Isabela Ophiolite, a vast sedimentary sequence belonging to the Caraballo Formation, Dinalungan Diorite Complex intrusive bodies, and Quaternary Alluvium deposits. Localized chromite mineralization was observed within the olivine websterites of the Isabela Ohpiolite, while locals report occurrence of bornite-chalcopyrite bearing deposits at the Dinalungan Diorite bodies. Formation

Age

Quaternary Alluvium

Caraballo Formation

Quaternary (Holocene)

Middle – Late Eocene

Description Loose, unconsolidated sediments (sand and gravel), soil, and other alluvial deposits Proximal Facies: andesitic and basaltic flows with associated volcanic sandstones, conglomerates, and breccias that are occasionally intercalated with pyroclastic rocks, indurated mudstones, and minor chert Distal Facies: by interbedded red and green mudstones, siltstones, sandstones, and pyroclstic rocks with occasional fragmental flows and conglomerates

Dinalungan Complex

Isabela Ophiolite

Diorite

Middle Eocene

gabbroic and dioritic rocks that grade to tonalite. The diorites range from darkgreen, coarse- medium grained to lightcolored, coarse-medium grained

Late Cretaceous

as massive, brownish-black rocks with blister-like texture identified as serpentinized olivine websterite

Major structures found in the area include the the NE-trending Casiguran Fault in the municipality of Casiguran which extends further NE in Dilasag as a thrust fault contact between the Dinalungan Diorite Complex and Caraballo Formation. NW-trending thrust fault observed on the ultramafic outcrops on the eastern section of the quadrangle is almost parallel to the Divilacan Bay Fault and may signify obduction mechanism of the Isabela Ophiolite.

75

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Rose Diagrams of the formations within the Dikabasan Quadrangle were generated to visualize the general trends and density of joints measured, as well as the preferred directions of σ1. Generally, NW-trending joints that are well-distributed in most rocks in the Dikabasan Quadrangle appear to be the most abundant; which, in a regional scale, could imply consequences of the Eocene-Miocene direction of migration of the Philippine Mobile Belt. Younger NE-trending faults that cut through beds and joints on the other hand, can imply a change in direction of movement of the PMB during the Late Miocene. A total of eight rock samples were collected during the geologic mapping in DIKABASAN quadrangle. Four samples were sent for petrographic analyses in the Geological Lab Services of MGB-Central. SAMPLES TAKEN FROM DIKABASAN QUADRANGLE SAMPLE LABEL

GEM-DKB-01

LOCATION

DESCRIPTION

ROCK ID

Casapsapan Bay, Brgy. Dinyog, Dilasag, Aurora

Dense dark rock with prominent chromite and minor pyrite mineralization overlying quaternary terrace coral deposits.

Chromite vein; Peridotite (host rock)

Greenish-gray breccias/ coarse greywacke with probable lithic/volcanic matrix

Breccia/ Greywacke

Predominantly brownish-black pyroxenes, outcrop has slickensides that trend NW-SE

Pyroxenite

Large intrusive body (batholiths) trending NE-SW; mainly diorite stockworks varying crystal sizes and composition (dioritetonalite)

Diorite, Tonalite

Part of the large intrusive body, but mostly composed of smoky quartz, plagioclase, and amphiboles

Tonalite

N 16 21'31.6, E 122 13'21.6

GEM-DKB-04

Sitio Kasaysayan, Brgy. Diagyan, Dilasag, Aurora N 16 29 4.6, E 122 12 38.4

GEM-DKB-06

Barangay Maligaya, Dilasag, Aurora N 16 23 27, E 122 13 35 Barangay Lawang, Dilasag, Aurora

GEM-DKB-08

GEM-DKB-09

76

N 16 21 10, E 122 5 15

Barangay Lawang, Dilasag Aurora N 16 21 30, E 122 5 10

REMARKS

Vein and host rock petrographic analysis

Petrographic analysis of all components of the rock

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

RESULTS OF PETROGRAPHIC ANALYSES OF ROCKS AT THE DIKABASAN QUADRANGLE Sample Number

Composition Primary Minerals: Relict Olivine

22%

Relict Enstatite

20%

Augite

20%

Secondary Minerals: GEM-DKB-01

Serpentine

22%

Goethite

7%

Opaques

3%

Calcite

2%

Tremolite

2%

Description The sample has mesh texture due to serpentinization; however, the original anhedral-granular texture of relict olivine + pyroxenes can still be recognized. Poikilitic texture can also be observed in some enstatite crystals. Large Olivine + pyroxene plates are broken into smaller fragments by an interweaving network of serpentine + goethite + secondary opaques + calcite. Most enstatite crystals show bastite inclusions parallel to its lamellae. Tremolite occurs as radiating sheafs.

Rock Name Serpentinized Olivine Websterite

Clastic texture; irregular lithic clasts are indentified as volcanic rocks with porphyritic and amygdaloidal textures. These are affected by an assemblage of chlorite + calcite + clay + secondary quartz. Crystal fragments are composed of partially altered plagioclase laths, fresher but fractured clinopyroxenes, and clear angular quartz. Other clasts are fully replaced by varying amounts of chlorite + quartz + calcite + epidote. Clast size range from 0.02 to ~11.5 mm in length. Few calcite veinlets cut across this section.

Lapilli Tuff

Granular texture is defined by interlocking large, euhedral to subhedral calcic plagioclase laths + relict mafic minerals (augite, hornblende, and olivine).

Gabbro

Accessory Mineral: Opaque GEM- DKB- 04

GEM- DKB-08

GEM-DKB-09

Clasts: Lithic fragments Crystal fragments Altered fragments Opaques Matrix: Chlorite Clay Calcite Goethite Secondary Opaques Primary Minerals: Plagioclase (An > 50) Relict Hornblende Relict Augite Relict Olivine Opaques- trace Secondary Minerals:

2%

20% 7% 5% 2% 40% 10% 10% 1% trace

Tremolite-Actinolite ChloriteClay Opaques Goethite Primary Minerals: Plagioclase (An > 50) Relict Augite

50% 25%

Relict Olivine

4%

Secondary Minerals: Tremolite Opaques

15% 5%

Plagioclases appear turbid due to clay and chlorite. Mafics are partially altered to tremolite-actinolite + chlorite +/- opaques

20% 10% 5% 2% 2% Granular texture; made up of anhedral augite + olivine and euhedral to subhedral calcic plagioclase laths. Plagioclase crystals remain fresh. Selected augite prisms and olivine crystals partly affected by tremolite + opaques + chlorite

Gabbro

77

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

RESULTS OF PETROGRAPHIC ANALYSES OF ROCKS AT THE DIKABASAN QUADRANGLE Sample Number

Composition Chlorite Goethite

GEM- DKB- 01

Description 1% trace

Ore Minerals: Chromite Pyrrhotite Gangue

Rock Name

45% trace 55%

Abundant chromite and trace pyrrhotite crystals are the metallic components of the rock. Chromite exhibits dark gray color, reddish brown internal reflection, and smooth edges. It occurs as rounded aggregates and often has broken appearance. Yellowish pyrrhotite crystals are occasionally fond in close association with chromite

Chromite vein

The following maps were also generated from the data gathered from field investigations and interpretation of IfSAR-derived satellite imagery:

Geologic Map of the Dikabasan Quadrangle, showing new formational boundaries and inferred/observed structures.

78

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Slope map of the Dikabasan Quadrangle, depicting a generally steep and mountainous terrain in the area.

Watershed Divide Map of the Dikabasan Quadrangle, showing the major river basins within the area.

79

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

After the quadrangle mapping activities, the team submitted two (2) sets of reports (progress report) and 1:50,000 scale maps, both for updating and semi-detailed mapping activities to MGB-Central Office not later than the end of August, 2016. Moreover, two separate reports were done for each of the designated quadrangles, one is for the updating of geologic map of Papaya Quadrangle and the other is for the semi-detailed mapping of Dikabasan Quadrangle both were successfully accomplished on October 2016. The reports included detailed discussions on the work programs under the Geologic Quadrangle Mapping Project of MGB such as the standard mapping procedures, rock sample methodologies, delineation of geological structures and lithologic boundaries and the generation of geologic maps of the assigned areas.

A.03.b.2.b Mineral Resources Inventory Updating of provincial mineral resource map of Palawanwas accomplished this year under the Mineral Resource Inventory program of MGB IV-MIMAROPA. Activities pertaining to the preparation and review of updated mineral resource map of Palawan were completed during the last quarter of 2016.

80

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

A.03.b.2.c Provision of Laboratory Services From January to December 2016, the Geological Laboratory Services Section of MIMAROPA Region conducted a total of Fourteen Thousand Four Hundred Eighty (14,480) chemical/physical determinations from one hundred seventy eight (178) samples submitted by13 private clienteles and 8 official MGB-MIMAROPA sources. This is equivalent to annual accomplishment ratings of 100.21% and148.33% for the number of “determinations” made and the number of samples received, respectively. These percentages are based on annual target of 14,450 chemical/physical determinations for 120 target samples. Tabulated below is the summary of laboratory accomplishment reports from January to December, 2016. Summary of Laboratory Accomplishment Reports Target*

Accomplish ment**

Sample received

Total Detmns.

Physical Detmns.

Chemical Detmns.

Jan.

700

166

15

1,160

260

Feb.

950

152

36

1,440

Mar.

950

29

2

Apr.

1,400

99

16

Month

Private Clients

Official Clients

Revenue (Php)

900

1

1

9,100.00

0

1,440

0

1

21,600.00

280

0

280

0

1

1,100.00

1,380

80

1,300

6

1

750

81

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Summary of Laboratory Accomplishment Reports Target*

Accomplish ment**

Sample received

Total Detmns.

Physical Detmns.

Chemical Detmns.

Private Clients

Official Clients

May

1,600

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

June

1,600

188

15

3,000

0

3,000

0

1

8,250.00

July

1,600

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

August

1,600

186

16

2,980

40

2,940

5

1

3,300.00

Sept.

1,400

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

Oct.

950

316

25

3,000

0

3,000

0

1

8,250.00

Nov.

950

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

Dec.

750

165

53

1,240

1,000

240

1

1

10,000.00

178

14,480

1,380

13,100

13

8

62,350.00

Month

TOTAL

14,450

Revenue (Php)

* No. of Determinations ** % Accomplishment

A.03.b.3 Groundwater Resource Assessment Pursuant to the thrust of the Mines and Geosciences Bureau in addressing the exacerbating water shortages nationwide, the target coverage of groundwater assessment per region was broadened to one whole province for CY 2016. As per this regional office’s commitment to this program, MGB-MIMAROPA selected the province of Marinduque as its target area for the study. The objective of this undertaking isto determine specific hydrogeological information on the availability and characteristics of the groundwater system including the condition of the underlying water bearing formations (aquifer) in the province of Marinduque. Methodology The Groundwater Resource Assessment survey consisted of (1) data research, (2) well and spring inventories, and (3) in situ water quality measurements of these stations. The research involved gathering of relevant geological, hydrological, and meteorological literature from various government agencies (PAGASA, LWUA, DPWH) and local government units (LGUs) to consolidate existing information and studies in the area. The data in the well/spring inventory were acquired from interviews with the well owners and/or barangay officials. These data include the station location, construction data of the well, depth to groundwater, age of the well, areas supplied by the water extracted from the well, and other information such as relative salinity, yield fluctuation, and possible subsurface materials. For the water quality analysis, a multi-meter was used to determine several physical parameters of the water including pH, dissolved oxygen content, conductivity, resistivity, total dissolved solids (TDS), total salinity, and temperature. The hydrogeologic map was produced through conversion of known geologic/lithologic units into hydrogeologic units based on the occurrence and movement

82

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

of groundwater in these geologic/lithologic units. The well locations and static water levels were plotted on topographic and hydrogeologic base maps and interpolated to produce a piezometric contour map. The resulting piezometric contour map is then used to interpret the groundwater condition of the area in terms of occurrence or groundwater availability, flow direction, recharge area for groundwater replenishment, and discharge area for groundwater extraction. Summary of Results and Findings: GEOLOGIC MAP WITH DISTRIBUTION OF WELL/SPRING INVENTORY POINTS OF THE GROUNDWATER RESOURCE ASSESSMENT IN THE PROVINCE OF MARINDUQUE

83

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

84

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Based on the geologic map above and the initial results of the well/spring inventory, the following hydrogeologic map for the province of Marinduque was produced: HYDROGEOLOGIC MAP OF MARINDUQUE PROVINCE

85

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report



Hydrogeology of Gasan Municipality Most of Gasan municipality is categorized as a shallow well zone with an average sand/gravel aquifer thickness of more than 5 meters, which may have fairly good groundwater potential. Deep aquifers of conglomerate belonging to the Boac Formation exist, and can also be developed in areas located at a safe distance from the shoreline. The identified aquifers for potable groundwater supply in Gasan are the highly permeable Quaternary Alluvial deposits and the tuffaceous siltstone layers of the Silt Member of the Boac Formation that are gently dipping westward towards Tablas Strait. The confining layers of this siltstone aquifer or the aquiclude that render this aquifer to be artesian are the intervening intercalated impermeable tuffaceous shale layers of the same Silt Member. Free flowing artesian wells that are penetrated in the siltstone aquifer are found in the northwestern part of the area. The low to moderately elevated terrain in the middle northwestern to southeastern parts of the mapped area served as the recharged area for this artesian siltstone aquifer though there were no free flowing artesian wells found in the southern part of the mapped area. In addition to the fifteen(15) shallow and deep wells previously inventoried in the area, six (6) deep well and two (2) spring stations were added in August 2016. The shallow wells are less than 20 meters deep but most of them yield potable water. They are mostly found near the coast. The open wells, on the other hand, are shallower than the tube wells and yield drinkable water. The shallow and deep tube wells had penetrated and obtained groundwater from the siltstone aquifer, the open wells on the other hand are obtaining groundwater from the Quaternary Alluvium aquifer. Most of the aquifers in the Silt Member rock unit could be artesian in nature, whereas the aquifers in the alluvial deposits are more likely to be unconfined or water table aquifers. An upland spring source hosted by the tuffaceous clastics of the Gasan Formation was also noted in Brgy. Tabionan. The potentiometric surface in the area ranges from more than 20 meters above mean sea level (mamsl) found inland to less than 1 mamsl found near the shore. It follows a normal or decreasing contour level which shows a normal groundwater flow direction thru gravity along the confined aquifers from higher to lower point which is possibly due to undisturbed equilibrium on constant recharge and the aforesaid discharge of groundwater and base flow along effluent perennial streams. The water table in the unconfined aquifers of the said two rock units is less than a meter below ground surface found near the shoreline to more than 20mbgs found inland particularly in the relatively high elevated areas. The water quality analysis conducted in selected wells shows that water extracted from the unconfined aquifer of the Quaternary Alluvium has generally good quality and may be considered potable. However, local variations such as increased alkalinity and relatively high amount of TDS also occur which are attributed to the geologic and environmental conditions of some wells.

86

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

WELL/SPRING INVENTORY IN THE MUNICIPALITY OF GASAN, MARINDUQUE Well ID

Barangay

Latitude

Longitude

Elevation (masl)

Water Source

Intake Method

Well Depth (ft)

Groundwater Level (masl)

Discharge (L/s)

MAR-GAS-1

Bahi

N 13 22 21.2

E 121 50 9.4

26.342899

artesian well

pipe

110

8.054899

0.24

MAR-GAS-2

Bahi

N 13 22 8.5

E 121 49 35.9

4.324194

artesian well

pipe

80

7.867806

0.16

MAR-GAS-3

Tapuyan

N 13 22 4.0

E 121 51 1.7

33.545807

intermediate well

pump

40

27.449807

0.12

MAR-GAS-4

Pangi

N 13 20 15.8

E 121 50 12.5

1.319049

artesian well

open well

220

29.160951

0.014

MAR-GAS-5

Pangi

N 13 20 2.9

E 121 50 23.2

3.82626

artesian well

open well

240

8.36574

0.32

MAR-GAS-6

Tabionan

N 13 19 22.2

E 121 53 51.2

86.021828

spring

free flowing

-

-

0.068

MAR-GAS-7

Tabionan

N 13 18 47.9

E 121 53 31.3

146.088791

spring

tank / open well

0

N/A

-

MAR-GAS-8

Antipolo

N 13 16 43.3

E 121 54 12

intermediate well

pump

40

9.057005

0.37

Salinity (‰)

Well ID

pH

9.057005

Temperature (°C)

Dissolved Oxygen (mg/L)

Temperatur e (°C)

Conductivity (μS/cm)

Resistivity (Ω·cm)

Total Dissolved Solids (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

MAR-GAS-1

7.15

28

6.66

28.3

554

1807

0.27

268

23.1

MAR-GAS-3

7.27

27.7

4.09

28

483

2072

0.23

233

28

MAR-GAS-4

8.08

29.3

3.92

29.6

906

1103

0.44

445

29.6

MAR-GAS-5

7.41

28.6

1.41

28.8

733

1364

0.36

358

28.9

MAR-GAS-6

7.52

29.9

7.01

30.5

652

1528

0.32

318

30.7

MAR-GAS-8

6.91

29.4

2.28

29.5

1576

635

0.79

788

30.3



Hydrogeology of Mogpog Municipality The surveyed area is categorized into three categories: shallow well zone in the west coast fringes, a difficult zone at the middle portion and a deep well zone at the eastern section. The difficult zone has a very low potential for groundwater resource while the areas classified as shallow and deep well zones have high potential for groundwater supply as these areas have similar conditions to that of the Boac area wherein there are thick aquifers in the alluvium and Boac Formation and the accompanying presence of free flowing wells. Nine (9) well and seven (7) spring stations were covered during the August and December 2016 fieldworks, in addition to the nineteen (19) inventoried wells in the groundwater database of Mogpog. Most of the easily pumped unconfined artesian aquifer in Mogpog occurs in the younger Boac Formation-Terrace Gravel deposits which consists of poorly unconsolidated sand and gravel and is probably connected with the overlying Quaternary Alluvium. The shallowest point of the water table was

87

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

encountered in an open well in Janagdong Bato where water is just 3 meters below the ground surface and may probably increase upslope as it mimics the surface topography. Based on the available data acquired from the unpublished report of Jose Ronan et al, the thickness of this alluvium reaches up to 10 meters thick. Based on well inventory, the thickness of the unconfined aquifer is estimated to reach as much as 25 meters in the Terrace Gravel Member of the Boac Formation considering that water is penetrated at various depths ranging from 12 m below the ground surface. Water from these aquifers is mainly consumed for domestic purposes. On the other hand, the confined aquifer in the area was plotted to be within the older Boac Formation -Silt Member underlying the unconfined aquifer. This formation is assumed to have extended towards the study area based from existing geologic condition in the region. This rock unit is generally a sequence of low-dipping marine siltstone and sandstone with basal conglomerate. Its thickness is about 400 meters as stated on the GMRP-Volume 1 by Corby (1951). The siltstone acts as an aquitard that is a leaky confining layer of low permeability that can store groundwater and transmit it sluggishly from one aquifer to another. Under this confined aquifer, hydrostatic pressure is high resulting to hydrostatic head or potentiometric surface. Deep wells penetrating this confined aquifer were noted on several wells with depth of wells ranging from 48.9 to 67.06 meters below the ground surface. Water from these wells is mainly utilized for drinking purposes. Most of the wells penetrated within this aquifer exhibit a flowing artesian well in which the water flows from the well without pumping. Water quality testing of water derived from spring sources in barangays near the Mogpog River showed good quality and potability based on preliminary physical parameters. On the other hand, increased amounts of TDS and higher conductivities were observed in unconfined aquifers of the Limestone Member of the Torrijos Formation, and the volcaniclastic rocks of the San Antonio Formation and Taluntunan-Tumicob Formation – Clastic Member. The high TDS of the limestone aquifer is attributed to the dissolution of calcium carbonate (CaCO 3) which gives rise to an increase of concentration of calcium ion (Ca2+) in solution, among other possible present metals. This occurrence is a primary cause for the phenomenon called “hard water” in carbonate environments. For the water hosted by volcaniclastic aquifers, the high TDS is attributed to the presence of ions and metals which were likely produced through chemical weathering of silicates. Saltwater intrusion in wells near the northwestern tip of Mogpog (Brgy. Silangan) is possible based on high total salinity values in said area. WELL/SPRING INVENTORY IN THE MUNICIPALITY OF MOGPOG, MARINDUQUE Well ID

Barangay

Latitude

Longitude

Elevation (masl)

Water Source

Intake Method

Well Depth (ft)

Groundwater Level (masl)

Discharge (L/s)

MAR-MOG-1

Sumangga

N 13 28 40.7

E 121 51 47.5

5.361383

artesian well

pipe

180

-2.258617

0.28

MAR-MOG-2

Sumangga

N 13 28 43.1

E 121 51 44.7

4.962933

artesian well

pipe

180

-1.133067

1.15

88

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

WELL/SPRING INVENTORY IN THE MUNICIPALITY OF MOGPOG, MARINDUQUE Well ID

Barangay

Latitude

Longitude

Elevation (masl)

Water Source

Intake Method

Well Depth (ft)

Groundwater Level (masl)

Discharge (L/s) 0.37

MAR-MOG-3

Sumangga

N 13 28 31.3

E 121 52 27.9

8.560539

artesian well

pipe

180

-0.583461

MAR-MOG-4

Silangan

N 13 33 55.2

E 121 51 18.3

2.288665

intermediate well

open well

20

1.069465

MAR-MOG-5

Silangan

N 13 33 55.6

E 121 51 19.1

1.962512

intermediate well

pump

30

0.743312

MAR-MOG-6

Silangan

N 13 33 42.2

E 121 51 44.3

57.41119

shallow well

open well

8

56.19199

MAR-MOG-7

Silangan

N 13 33 42.6

E 121 51 44.1

57.847137

deep well

pump

80

56.627937

0.34

MAR-MOG-8

Hinanggayo n

N 13 33 25.5

E 121 51 31.1

4.580041

intermediate well

pump

20

0.312841

0.28

MAR-MOG-9

Argao

N 13 32 51.1

E 121 52 25.6

32.960354

intermediate well

pump

40

26.864354

0.2

MAR-MOG-10

Balanacan

N 13 31 49.2

E 121 52 11.3

2.967256

spring

free flowing

-

2.967256

0.2

MAR-MOG-11

Balanacan

N 13 31 14.3

E 121 51 43.1

75.696617

spring

free flowing

-

75.696617

0.056

MAR-MOG-12

Lamesa

N 13 29 37.6

E 121 56 7.9

179.33395 4

spring

free flowing

-

179.333954

0.15

MAR-MOG-13

Lamesa

N 13 29 35.7

E 121 55 37.7

126.26804 4

spring

springb ox

-

N/A

MAR-MOG-14

Bocboc

N 13 28 24.2

E 121 56 3.8

49.205624

spring

faucet / tank

-

N/A

0.11

MAR-MOG-15

Danao

N 13 27 35.5

E 121 52 25.6

98.79229

spring

springb ox / faucet

-

N/A

0.00934

MAR-MOG-16

Mampaitan

N 13 27 48

E 121 52 43.6

189.18437 2

spring

free flowing

-

189.184372

0.36

0.35

WATER QUALITY ANALYSIS FOR WELL/SPRING INVENTORY OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF MOGPOG, MARINDUQUE Well ID

pH

Temperature (°C)

Dissolved Oxygen (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

Conductivity (μS/cm)

Resistivity (Ω·cm)

Salinity (‰)

Total Dissolved Solids (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

MAR-MOG-1

7.32

28.5

3.76

28.8

662

1510

0.32

323

29

MAR-MOG-3

7.17

28.4

2.92

28.6

588

1700

0.28

286

28.4

MAR-MOG-5

7.03

30.3

3.36

30.6

4880

204.9

2.61

2560

31.9

MAR-MOG-7

7.16

28.7

2.65

29

2810

356

1.45

1436

28.9

MAR-MOG-8

6.96

29.46

3.6

29.7

1943

515

0.99

979

29.8

MAR-MOG-9

7.21

28.9

3.38

29.2

1369

731

0.68

681

29.5

MAR-MOG-14

7.67

28.7

7.33

28.9

469

2130

0.22

227

29

MAR-MOG-15

3.78

26.2

6.92

27.5

225

0.11

158

26.2

89

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

WATER QUALITY ANALYSIS FOR WELL/SPRING INVENTORY OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF MOGPOG, MARINDUQUE



Well ID

pH

MAR-MOG-16

6.85

Temperature (°C)

Dissolved Oxygen (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

Conductivity (μS/cm)

28

3.41

27.4

761

Resistivity (Ω·cm)

Salinity (‰)

Total Dissolved Solids (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

0.38

540

28

Hydrogeology of Boac Municipality

The recharge area for groundwater supply in the municipality of Boac are the mountainous terrain found inland to the east and south, and the discharge areas are the coastal plains particularly the deltaic area, found at the northwestern to western outer girdle of the town proper of Boac where free flowing artesian wells abound. The main confined artesian aquifer is mapped within the Boac Formation-Silt Member. It is comprised of generally medium grained clastics, with thickness of more than 10 meters. These rocks together with the overlying three meter thick layer of shale act as aquicludes. This aquifer shows good and effective permeability as partly determined in the field utilizing an improvised device of measuring permeability using a cylindrical plastic material and a wristwatch. The rate of infiltration was measured at approximately 1.55 cm per minute for Silt Member; 13.9 cm per minute for the terrace gravel Member and 50 cm per minute for the alluvium. The sorting of grains, degree of consolidation, composition, size and massive characteristics influence its high yield and good aquifer potential. The main confined artesian aquifer is not connected with the various aquifers found within the Quaternary Alluvium especially near the deltaic area along the coasts since the depth of the free flowing wells drilled in the alluvium is more than 30 meters. Thus, the deep wells probably had penetrated the main confined artesian aquifer, as the alluvium could not be more than 30 meters thick in this area since it is quite near the exposure/outcrop of the Terrace Gravel Member. Observations made from the eighteen (18) well and three (3) spring stations in addition to the sixteen (16) previously inventoried well stations revealed that potentiometric level in the area varies and follows a normal/decreasing contour level, from 8 meters mamsl which is found inland to the east and south to 0.5 masml found near the coastal plains or to the western portion of the Boac town proper. This potentiometric contour in the area shows a normal groundwater flow direction thru gravity, from higher to lower point and is probably due to undisturbed equilibrium such as constant recharge and discharge of groundwater and base flow. The unconfined or water table aquifer in the area on the other hand is observed to be within the younger massive Boac Formation (Terrace Gravel Member) which is conformably overlying the aforesaid Silt Member of the same rock formation. The thickness of this unconfined aquifer is estimated to reach as much as 40 meters in the Terrace Gravel Member of the Boac Formation. The thickness, however, of the unconfined aquifer within the Quaternary Alluvium at the vicinity of the deltaic area is less than 30 meters as the artesian wells drilled in this low lying areas is more than 30 meters deep as mentioned above. The water table in the alluvium is generally less than a meter below the ground surface along riverbanks and more than 6 meters upslope particularly on hilltops. Based on the water quality results of the inventoried wells, most of the wells tapping both confined (with Boac Formation – Silt Member as aquitard) and

90

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

unconfined (Quaternary Alluvium and Boac Formation – Terrace Gravel Member) aquifers had good quality. Water derived from spring sources near Boac River also showed good quality and may be potable. However, according to accounts of barangay officials and locals, the Department of Health had conducted bacteria tests in specific wells with some water samples testing positive (MAR-BOA-21). WELL/SPRING INVENTORY IN THE MUNICIPALITY OF BOAC, MARINDUQUE Well ID

Barangay

Latitude

Longitude

N 13 22 13.6 N 13 23 3.3 N 13 23 1.5 N 13 25 41.1

E 121 53 10.4 E 121 50 29.3 E 121 49 24.8 E 121 49 12.5

Elevation (masl)

Intake Method

Well Depth (ft)

Groundwater Level (masl)

Discharge (L/s)

spring

free flowing

36.15575

deep well

pump

80

20.91575

0.088

4.220405

artesian well

pipe

240

-1.875595

0.01

1.57046

artesian well

pipe

120

0.04646

E 121 49 25.8

3.500276

intermediate well

54

-2.290924

0.21

N 13 26 52.8

E 121 49 44.2

2.545245

deep well

80

1.021245

0.38

Bahay-Igat (Creek)

N 13 24 31.2

E 121 51 40.9

25.576742

spring

springbox

25.576742

0.32

MAR-BOA-8

Maybo

N 13 25 21.9

E 121 51 13.3

85.266525

intermediate well

Jetmatic pump

25

19.480742

0.15

MAR-BOA-9

Tabi

N 13 27 29.1

E 121 50 2.1

5.419444

intermediate well

Jetmatic pump

20

0.085444

0.1

MAR-BOA-10

Buliasnin

N 13 28 7.5

E 121 49 55

3.263199

deep well

Jetmatic pump

80

1.739199

0.31

MAR-BOA-11

Balogo

N 13 27 50.3

E 121 49 43.7

3.167679

artesian well

pipe

110

-2.166321

0.058

MAR-BOA-12

Poras

N 13 27 45.5

E 121 49 40.1

2.881749

artesian well

pipe

250

-4.738251

0.56

MAR-BOA-13

Pili

N 13 27 46.1

E 121 49 27.8

1.490475

artesian well

pipe

200

-6.129525

0.24

MAR-BOA-14

Tabi

N 13 27 18.0

E 121 50 3.2

3.836664

artesian well

pipe

170

-2.259336

0.13

MAR-BOA-15

Lupac

N 13 27 24.7

E 121 49 22.5

2.900835

artesian well

pipe

200

-3.195165

0.079

MAR-BOA-16

Tabigue

N 13 27 15.1

E 121 49 9.0

2.525553

artesian well

pipe

190

-3.570447

0.31

MAR-BOA-17

Tabigue

N 13 27 19.1

E 121 49 9.1

2.425645

deep well

pump

180

-3.670355

1.67

MAR-BOA-18

Binunga

N 13 24 18.9

E 121 54 50.8

91.803131

spring

free flowing

91.803131

1.13

MAR-BOA-19

Balimbing

N 13 26 1.105

E 121 52 48.2

22.55072

intermediate well

pump

40

10.35872

0.232

MAR-BOA-20

Balimbing

N 13 26 8.37

E 121 52 44.6

22.125868

intermediate well

pump

30

12.981868

0.295

MAR-BOA-21

Sawi

N 13 26 26.8

E 121 51 21.6

13.827923

shallow well

motorized pump (2 hp)

10

12.608723

0.104

MAR-BOA-1

Duyay

MAR-BOA-2

Cawit

MAR-BOA-3

Cawit

MAR-BOA-4

Ihatub

MAR-BOA-5

Bangbangal on

N 13 26 33.8

MAR-BOA-6

Santol

MAR-BOA-7

157.82089 2

Water Source

-

motorized submersi ble pump (3 hp) motorized submersi ble pump (2 hp)

0.078

-

-

91

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

WATER QUALITY ANALYSIS FOR WELL/SPRING INVENTORY OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF BOAC, MARINDUQUE



Total Dissolved Solids (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

Dissolved Oxygen (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

Conductivity (μS/cm)

Resistivity (Ω·cm)

Salinity (‰)

7.41

26.1

6.77

26.6

638

1567

0.34

310

26.4

MAR-BOA-2

7.24

28.2

4.1

28.2

603

1658

0.29

293

28.6

MAR-BOA-5

7.25

29.4

2.19

29.6

1060

943

0.53

523

29.9

MAR-BOA-7

7.76

28.1

7.08

29.4

322

3110

0.15

154.4

29.1

MAR-BOA-9

7.82

28.1

1.86

28.2

565

1771

0.27

274

28.3

MAR-BOA-10

7.87

29

2.75

29.1

513

1999

0.25

248

28.9

MAR-BOA-12

7.31

28.2

2.61

28.1

542

1844

0.26

263

28.5

MAR-BOA-14

7.67

28.8

1.85

28.7

556

1800

0.27

270

29.3

MAR-BOA-17

7.51

26.3

5.97

26.3

333

0.17

237

26.3

MAR-BOA-19

7.45

28.9

5.36

28.4

492

0.25

350

28.9

MAR-BOA-20

7.05

28.9

4.46

28.1

500

0.25

356

28.9

MAR-BOA-21

7.1

28.8

5.69

28.4

548

0.27

390

28.8

Well ID

pH

MAR-BOA-1

Temperature (°C)

Hydrogeology of Buenavista Municipality A total of twelve (12) wells and three (3) spring sources were inventoried during the August 2016 fieldwork. Potential aquifers currently tapped by the residents of Buenavista and surrounding areas include the thick Quaternary Alluvium deposits and rock units of the Boac Formation. The shallow depths of the wells support this contention. Megascopically, the Quaternary Alluvium displays poor consolidation and sorting. The deposits of the Boac Formation are often poorly consolidated as well and are dominated by sand- and silt-sized sediments. These features are typically characterized by pervious aquifers (i.e. those with high coefficients of permeability). In the general absence of thick layers of rock types like claystones and mudstones that can retard groundwater flow between the Quaternary Alluvium and the Boac Formation, unconfined aquifer conditions could be prevailing on the shallow aquifers below Buenavista. The data collected during the survey do not allow rigorous constraints on total thickness of these shallow aquifers. Majority of the recharge areas for aquifer below Buenavista are concentrated on the rolling hills and mountainous terrains located northeast and southeast of the municipality. Recharge to these aquifers is primarily controlled by percolation of rainwater downward through the unsaturated zone. In addition, surface water conduits like rivers and creeks might also be important groundwater recharge routes although available data do not allow their quantification.

92

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Discharge areas, on the other hand are found on the alluvial plains and river basins. It emits through the main river system, springs, creeks and intermittent streams mostly concentrated perpendicular to coastal plains. During the field survey, most of the creeks and streams were however dry. Incorporation of the reports of the recent field survey and static water levels from previous investigations suggest that the groundwater flow below Buenavista and surrounding areas is generally dissected towards the west. The flow direction is roughly consistent with the orientations of the draping slopes of the mountainous terrains. Most of the inventoried shallow and deep wells showed good water quality. All free-flowing spring sources also exhibited good to excellent water quality. WELL/SPRING INVENTORY IN THE MUNICIPALITY OF BUENAVISTA, MARINDUQUE Barangay

Latitude

Longitud e

MAR-BUE-1

2 (Poblacion)

MAR-BUE-2

Daykitin

N 13 15 19.8 N 13 16 26.9 N 13 17 27.7 N 13 16 11.5 N 13 15 55.2 N 13 16 2.4 N 13 16 6.6 N 13 14 44.0 N 13 13 31.0 N 13 13 31.3 N 13 13 31.8 N 13 12 31.5 N 13 12 18.7

E 121 56 27.3 E 121 54 25 E 121 56 13.2 E 121 56 2.9 E 121 56 2.3 E 121 56 59.5 E 121 57 14.7 E 121 57 8.8 E 121 57 59.1 E 121 58 0.8 E 121 58 2.4 E 121 59 8.8 E 121 59 55.0

Well ID

MAR-BUE-3

Bagtingon

MAR-BUE-4

Kaigangan

MAR-BUE-5

Kaigangan

MAR-BUE-6

Malbog

MAR-BUE-7

Malbog

MAR-BUE-8

Libas

MAR-BUE-9

Yook

MAR-BUE-10

Yook

MAR-BUE-11

Yook

MAR-BUE-12 MAR-BUE-13

Tungib Lipata Tungib Lipata

Elevation (masl) 1.788859 3.260004 57.930534 21.642166 13.157215 14.800376 24.614273 3.461448 7.701131 9.760102 13.495997 9.644234 2.651372

Water Source

Intake Method

Well Depth (ft)

Groundwater Level (masl)

Discharge (L/s)

intermediate well intermediate well

Jetmatic pump

20

-1.259141

0.68

pump

30

0.212004

0.12

-

57.930534

0.14

pump

20

18.594166

pump

37

7.366015

0.26

pump

20

11.142776

0.27

pump

40

16.689473

0.23

pump

20

-1.110552

0.3

pump

20

3.129131

0.26

-

9.760102

0.044

pump

20

10.447997

0.16

pump

40

-1.023766

0.11

-

2.651372

0.06

spring intermediate well intermediate well intermediate well intermediate well intermediate well intermediate well spring intermediate well intermediate well spring

free flowing

free flowing

free flowing

WATER QUALITY ANALYSIS FOR WELL/SPRING INVENTORY OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF BUENAVISTA, MARINDUQUE Well ID

pH

Temperature (°C)

Dissolved Oxygen (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

Conductivity (μS/cm)

Resistivity (Ω·cm)

Salinity (‰)

Total Dissolved Solids (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

MAR-BUE-1

6.88

31.5

2.43

32

916

1081

0.45

450

31.9

MAR-BUE-2

7.73

29.1

4.44

29

915

1093

0.45

450

28.8

MAR-BUE-3

8

27.8

8

28.3

348

2870

0.17

167.1

28

MAR-BUE-5

7.06

29.1

2.47

29.2

868

1152

0.42

426

29.4

MAR-BUE-6

6.98

38.4

3.06

30.3

721

1386

0.35

352

30

MAR-BUE-7

6.8

35.5

3.39

35

1070

935

0.53

528

35.2

MAR-BUE-8

6.82

30.7

4.97

31

422

2370

0.2

203

31.4

MAR-BUE-9

6.69

29.9

5.17

30.6

443

2260

0.21

213

30.9

93

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

WATER QUALITY ANALYSIS FOR WELL/SPRING INVENTORY OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF BUENAVISTA, MARINDUQUE Well ID MAR-BUE10 MAR-BUE11 MAR-BUE12 MAR-BUE13

pH

Temperature (°C)

Dissolved Oxygen (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

Conductivity (μS/cm)

Resistivity (Ω·cm)

Salinity (‰)

Total Dissolved Solids (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

6.7

30.6

4.8

30.7

227

4400

0.11

108.3

30.7

6.5

29

4.04

29.1

507

1970

0.24

245

29.5

6.2

30

4.85

30.1

759

1317

0.37

371

30.2

7.45

28.4

8.34

28.7

152.4

6560

0.07

72.2

29

 Hydrogeology of Torrijos Municipality From the August and December 2016 fieldworks, fourteen (14) wells and ten (10) spring sources were inventoried. The Quaternary Alluvium unconfined aquifer is only defined and limited near the coastlines, hence the concentration of pump wells along this discharge area. The rest of Torrijos is characterized by a generally rugged topography with Mt. Malindig peaking at 1,157 mamsl. The coastal boundary is also marked by a submerging shoreline manifested by embayments and drowned valleys. These morphologic factors together with the lithologic and hydrologic properties of the rocks in the area make a major portion of Torrijos to be considered as difficult areas with low potential for groundwater development. Most of the municipality’s water demand is primarily supplied by spring sources produced through secondary porosity along fractures hosted by volcanic rocks of the Torrijos Formation – Volcanic Member and San Antonio Formation. The water quality analysis showed relatively high conductivity values in wells underlain by the Quaternary Alluvium unconfined aquifer. The increase in conductive materials dissolved in solution is probably due to the percolation of water near volcanic rocks in upland recharge areas underlain by several impervious rock units of the Malindig Volcanic Complex, San Antonio Formation, and Torrijos Formation – Volcanic Member. Most of the springwaters tested had indications of good to excellent quality of water.

WELL/SPRING INVENTORY IN THE MUNICIPALITY OF TORRIJOS, MARINDUQUE Well ID

Barangay

MAR-TOR-1

Dampulan

MAR-TOR-2

Tigwi

MAR-TOR-3

Tigwi

MAR-TOR-4

Buangan

MAR-TOR-5

Buangan

MAR-TOR-6

Nangka

MAR-TOR-7

Nangka

MAR-TOR-9

Sibuyao

MAR-TOR10

Poblacion

94

Latitude

Longitude

N 13 13 53.5 N 13 16 17.4 N 13 16 15.9 N 13 18 58.2 N 13 19 1.3 N 13 21 15.8 N 13 21 17.6 N 13 20 31.6

E 122 2 47.7 E 122 2 17.0 E 122 2 26.3 E 122 4 27.2 E 122 4 25.6 E 122 1 48.4 E 122 1 49.6 E 122 0 38.8

N 13 19 12.2

E 122 5 1.5

Elevation (masl) 4.892597 5.385847 2.06812

Water Source intermediate well artesian well

Intake Method

Well Depth (ft)

Groundwater Level (masl)

Discharge (L/s)

pump

30

2.758997

0.14

artesian

60

2.337847

0.073

-

2.06812

0.016

6.986661

0.25

40

5.757947

0.25 0.0073

spring

free flowing

6.986661

shallow well

pump

8.805947

intermediate well

pump

462.777313

spring

free flowing

-

462.777313

440.989624

spring

free flowing

-

440.989624

396.355377

spring

free flowing

-

396.355377

0.31

deep well

motorized pump (1 hp)

80

3.794049

0.48

15.986049

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

WELL/SPRING INVENTORY IN THE MUNICIPALITY OF TORRIJOS, MARINDUQUE Well ID MAR-TOR11 MAR-TOR12 MAR-TOR13 MAR-TOR14 MAR-TOR15 MAR-TOR16 MAR-TOR17 MAR-TOR18 MAR-TOR19 MAR-TOR20 MAR-TOR21 MAR-TOR22 MAR-TOR23 MAR-TOR24

Barangay Poctoy Poctoy Poctoy Cagpo Bonliw Bonliw Malinao Suha Matuyatuya Matuyatuya Bolo Mabuhay Macawayan Macawayan

Latitude

Longitude

N 13 19 54.0 N 13 19 48.0 N 13 20 14.8 N 13 20 29.0 N 13 22 24.7 N 13 22 36.4 N 13 23 5.0 N 13 23 57 N 13 23 43 N 13 23 44.6 N 13 23 1.3 N 13 24 16.7 N 13 15 46.1 N 13 16 1.5

E 122 5 28.4 E 122 5 55.8 E 122 6 12.5 E 122 6 39.3 E 122 6 50.9 E 122 6 45.1 E 122 6 42.5 E 122 6 50.7 E 122 5 56.9 E 122 5 55.3 E 122 5 34.3 E 122 5 44.0 E 122 2 38 E 122 2 27.1

Elevation (masl) 6.667014 11.735754

Water Source intermediate well intermediate well

13.600219

deep well

17.279039

deep well

17.039976 12.928832 11.57675 13.258274

intermediate well intermediate well intermediate well intermediate well

Intake Method pump

Well Depth (ft)

Groundwater Level (masl)

Discharge (L/s)

20

3.619014

55

-3.504246

0.12

120

-13.831781

0.15

pump

68

2.039039

0.12

pump

60

10.943976

0.17

pump

40

9.880832

0.11

pump

40

5.48075

0.19

pump

40

4.114274

0.095

Jetmatic pump Jetmatic pump

25.125637

deep well

pump

80

19.029637

0.7

24.736753

spring

faucet

-

N/A

0.15

44.319939

spring

free flowing

-

44.319939

0.028

17.006973

spring

tank / faucet

-

N/A

0.045

19.007124

spring

faucet

-

N/A

0.045

5.329917

spring

faucet

-

N/A

0.0905

WATER QUALITY ANALYSIS FOR WELL/SPRING INVENTORY OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF TORRIJOS, MARINDUQUE pH

Temperature (°C)

Dissolved Oxygen (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

Conductivity (μS/cm)

Resistivity (Ω·cm)

Salinity (‰)

Total Dissolved Solids (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

MAR-TOR-1

6.05

30.2

3.72

30.2

704

141

0.34

343

29.9

MAR-TOR-2

7.83

28

10.13

28.2

160.2

6240

0.07

76

28.3

MAR-TOR-3

6.78

27.9

2.42

28

215.3

4640

0.1

102.5

28

MAR-TOR-5

6.96

29.5

2.94

29.5

838

1194

0.41

410

29.4

MAR-TOR-7

6.7

26.7

6.75

27.2

245

4080

0.12

116.8

27.4

MAR-TOR-9

7.88

25.3

7.68

25.7

224

4460

0.11

106.9

26

MAR-TOR-10

7.5

28.8

3.16

28.5

857

1167

0.42

420

28.2

MAR-TOR-12

7.24

29.3

3.83

29.5

1130

885

0.56

558

29.5

MAR-TOR-13

7.45

30

3.51

30

892

1122

0.44

438

29.8

MAR-TOR-14

7.09

29.6

2.51

29.7

1661

602

0.84

832

29.3

MAR-TOR-15

7.1

30.1

2.18

30.4

592

1690

0.29

287

30.4

MAR-TOR-16

7.2

30.2

3.07

30.3

865

1157

0.42

424

30.4

MAR-TOR-17

7.26

29.9

3.39

30

896

1116

0.43

440

30.1

MAR-TOR-18

7.26

30

5.71

30.1

1798

556

0.91

903

29.9

MAR-TOR-20

7.65

30.6

7.22

30.5

893

1120

0.44

438

30.4

MAR-TOR-21

7.55

28.9

7.14

29

571

1750

0.28

277

29.2

MAR-TOR-23

7.95

27.6

7.79

27.9

193

8400

0.1

137

30.4

MAR-TOR-24

7.95

31.6

8.23

30.6

128.2

7510

0.06

90.8

31.6

Well ID

95

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report



Hydrogeology of Sta. Cruz Municipality The potable groundwater supply in the town of Sta. Cruz is mainly obtained from the confined artesian aquifers in the mapped Torrijos Formation –Volcanic Member found at the northeastern part of the area. The open fractures along foliations of these rocks and the moderately permeable massive sandstone horizons conformably lying over them serve as aquifers in the area. The intervening horizons in this aquifer unit with less permeability constitute the aquiclude or confining layers of the aquifers which allowed the occurrence of free-flowing artesian wells in the area. Likewise, the confined aquifers have inflow or recharge area for groundwater that is found on the mountainous terrain on the southwest side of the area and the natural discharge area that is found in the low-lying areas along the coast. The man-made artificial discharge areas through deep and shallow wells are found on the flat to rolling terrain near the coast at the northeastern part of the area as also mentioned above. Fourteen (14) wells and twelve (12) spring sources were inventoried during the August and December 2016 fieldworks. Observations of these wells revealed that the free flowing wells are mostly shallow wells with depths of less than 20 mbgs, although there are some deep wells of more than 20 mbgs that are free flowing. The potentiometric surface in the area as observed in the various artesian wells appears to nearly coincide or correspond with the ground surface. Most of the free flowing artesian wells in the area have relatively very low yield. Thus, pumps are being used in all the water wells in the area in order to obtain higher volume of water discharge. The water table in the area as observed in the open wells ranges from about two mbgs, at the low lying flat areas where the unconfined aquifers in the Quaternary Alluvium is found, so more than 8 mbgs at the higher elevated rolling terrain where the unconfined aquifer in the Torijos Formation-Volcanic Member is found. The unconfined aquifers in both the Quaternary Alluvium and Torrijos Formation-Volcanic Member appear insignificant in the area. Although the water obtained thru tube wells from the unconfined aquifers particularly those of the Torrijos Formation –Volcanic Member, are generally potable, the water obtained thru the open wells from the unconfined or water table aquifers, particularly those of the Quaternary Alluvium are mostly not potable but could be used for cleaning purposes of households. The results of the water quality analysis for the wells in Sta. Cruz highlighted the correlation of the measured physical parameters with the aquifer and lithology of the underlying materials. Good quality water was mostly observed in shallow wells tapping the unconfined aquifer of the Quaternary Alluvium. Relatively high conductivities were measured in water from aquifers underlain by the Torrijos Formation – Volcanic Member indicating the possible presence of metals and other ions. Even higher conductivities and high TDS were observed in well MAR-SCR15/16 which is underlain by the Taluntunan-Tumicob – Limestone Member. Occurrences of calcite precipitating from the water have also been reported which indicates high concentration of calcium carbonate dissolved in solution.

96

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

WELL/SPRING INVENTORY IN THE MUNICIPALITY OF STA. CRUZ, MARINDUQUE Well ID

Barangay

MAR-SCR-1

Taytay

MAR-SCR-2

Taytay

MAR-SCR-3

Taytay

MAR-SCR-4

Angas

MAR-SCR-5

Angas

MAR-SCR-6

Tagum

MAR-SCR-7

Morales

Latitude

Longitude

N 13 25 9.8 N 13 25 13.3 N 13 25 21.7 N 13 26 18.1 N 13 26 23.0 N 13 26 53.0 N 13 27 46.4

E 122 5 19.9 E 122 4 57.2 E 122 5 4.5 E 122 5 33.8 E 122 6 22.0 E 122 6 12.6 E 122 5 59.3

Elevation (masl)

Water Source

Intake Method

Well Depth (ft)

Groundwater Level (masl)

10

6.680473

-

5.805292

Discharge (L/s)

8.204473

shallow well

pump

5.805292

spring

open well

7.834013

intermediate well

pump

60

6.310013

0.26

4.267165

shallow well

pump

15

2.743165

0.32

17.991385

deep well

pump

80

8.847385

31.510101

deep well

pump

80

19.318101

dug well

open well

13

2.76446

80

11.015659

0.3

5.81246

0.092

MAR-SCR-8

Alobo

N 13 28 31.5

E 122 5 38.4

11.015659

deep well

motorized pump (1 hp)

MAR-SCR-9

Tawiran

N 13 27 3.2

E 122 4 29.3

11.397898

intermediate well

pump

43

1.644298

0.11

MAR-SCR-10

Tawiran

see #9

see #9

11.397898

spring

faucet

-

11.397898

0.13

N 13 26 47.5 N 13 26 16.6 N 13 30 10.0 N 13 30 8

E 122 2 29.0 E 122 2 20.8 E 122 1 21.1 E 122 2 23

-

69.643105

-

98.704437

0.23 0.1

MAR-SCR-11

Banogbog

MAR-SCR-12

Banogbog

free flowing free flowing

69.643105

spring

98.704437

spring

10.833158

intermediate well

pump

50

6.261158

7.55327

deep well

pump

160

7.55327

100

-5.149913

0.23

MAR-SCR-13

Hupi

MAR-SCR-14

Balogo

MAR-SCR-15

Balogo

N 13 30 2.7

E 122 2 36.9

7.042087

deep well

submersi ble pump / faucet

MAR-SCR-16

Balogo

see #15

see #15

7.042087

intermediate well

pump

64

-2.101913

0.15

N 13 27 37.8 N 13 27 29.8 N 13 28 2.7 N 13 30 51.7 N 13 30 31.4 N 13 31 42.2 N 13 32 6.5 N 13 29 26 N 13 29 38.9 N 13 29 5.7

E 122 1 31.3 E 122 1 1.4 E 122 0 58.1 E 121 59 5.1 E 121 59 17.3 E 121 56 38.5 E 121 56 14.4 E 121 56 46.7 E 122 0 11.1 E 122 0 4.7

267.819824

spring

faucet

-

267.819824

0.06

326.978149

spring

faucet

-

326.978149

0.12

218.567352

spring

faucet

-

218.567352

0.033

intermediate well

pump

20

6.662853

0.22

-

10.342189

0.24

-

69.0382

0.029

26

-3.609431

0.042

-

214.497177

0.23

MAR-SCR-17

Kinyaman

MAR-SCR-18

Kinyaman

MAR-SCR-19

Libjo

MAR-SCR-20

Ipil

MAR-SCR-21

Ipil

MAR-SCR-22

Botilao

MAR-SCR-23

Botilao

MAR-SCR-24

Lamesa

MAR-SCR-25

Landy

MAR-SCR-27

Bangcuang an

11.234853 10.342189

spring

69.0382

spring

free flowing free flowing

intermediate well

pump

spring

free flowing

17.720591

intermediate well

pump

20

13.148591

0.247

83.587677

spring

faucet

-

83.587677

0.316

2.486569 214.497177

WATER QUALITY ANALYSIS FOR WELL/SPRING INVENTORY OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF STA. CRUZ, MARINDUQUE Well ID

pH

Temperature (°C)

Dissolved Oxygen (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

Conductivity (μS/cm)

Resistivity (Ω·cm)

Salinity (‰)

Total Dissolved Solids (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

MAR-SCR-3

7.21

29.5

3.86

29.4

632

1583

0.31

307

29.8

MAR-SCR-4

6.92

30

3.14

30

734

1362

0.36

359

30.3

MAR-SCR-6

7.06

30.3

2.81

30.4

650

1538

0.31

317

30.4

MAR-SCR-8

6.85

30.6

2.1

30.9

1029

972

0.51

507

31.2

MAR-SCR-9

6.85

29.3

3.18

29.5

954

1048

0.47

469

29.4

97

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

WATER QUALITY ANALYSIS FOR WELL/SPRING INVENTORY OF THE MUNICIPALITY OF STA. CRUZ, MARINDUQUE Well ID

pH

Temperature (°C)

Dissolved Oxygen (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

Conductivity (μS/cm)

Resistivity (Ω·cm)

Salinity (‰)

Total Dissolved Solids (mg/L)

Temperature (°C)

MAR-SCR-10

7.61

29.6

8.96

29.7

225

4440

0.11

107.2

29.6

29.9

8.65

30.6

213.2

4690

0.1

101.5

30.8

MAR-SCR-12 MAR-SCR-13

6.81

29.6

3.23

29.8

862

1160

0.42

423

30.5

MAR-SCR-15

6.68

29.2

3.37

29.7

2440

410

1.25

1239

29.9

MAR-SCR-16

6.61

30.5

1.73

30.6

2510

398

1.29

1278

30.3

MAR-SCR-17

6.81

26.3

4.01

26.5

264

3790

4.01

126.1

26.4

MAR-SCR-18

7.36

26

7.18

26.2

145

6910

0.07

68.7

26.2

MAR-SCR-19

6.95

31.1

7.77

30.5

262

3820

0.12

125

30.1

MAR-SCR-20

6.96

29.4

2.41

29

901

1110

0.44

440

29.3

MAR-SCR-21

6.93

29.1

2.17

28.6

685

1459

0.33

334

29.5

MAR-SCR-22

7.11

30.1

6.89

30.2

787

1271

0.38

385

30.2

MAR-SCR-23

6.96

29.5

3

29.6

929

1076

0.46

457

29.8

MAR-SCR-24

7.07

29.9

6.26

30.1

155.5

6430

0.07

73.7

30.3

MAR-SCR-25

7.18

28.1

2.88

28

692

0.35

492

28.1

MAR-SCR-27

5.03

26.7

7.9

25.6

46.1

0.02

33.9

26.7

A.03.b.4 Miscellaneous Geological Services Aside from the conduct of regular geohazard surveys in the region, MGBMIMAROPA also served fourty two (42) clients requesting for various geohazard assessment assistance and other geological evaluation. The Office issued a total of thirty (30) geohazard certifications for various projects involving construction of housing units, school buildings and evacuation sites, and provided assistance to secure other geohazardrelated documents, mostly verbal requests from LGUs and DRRM-member agencies. Also, twenty one (21) investigation reports were prepared for various developers, proponents and LGUs. These are mainly geohazard identification reports (GIR) related to ECC application, and assessment reports pertaining to identification of waste disposal sites. Technical Assistance Provided a. List of Investigation Reports Prepared

98

o

Geohazard Identification Report (GIR) on the proposed site of Two Seasons Bayside Hotel Project in Brgy. Tagumpay, Coron, Palawan

o

Geohazard Identification Report (GIR) on the proposed site of Cesareo Benedito Subdivision in Brgy. Pangobilian, Brooke's Pt. Palawan

o

Geohazard Identification Report (GIR) on the proposed site of Cherry Villas Housing Project in Brgy. Irawan, Pto. Princesa, Palawan

o

Investigation report on the reported occurrence of sinkhole in Brgy. Gabawan, Odiongan, Romblon

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

o

Geohazard Identification Report on the proposed site of Palawan Shores project in Brgy. Bacungan, Pto. Princesa City, Palawan

o

Investigation Report on the cause and effect of massive flooding in Baco, Oriental Mindoro during the wake of Typhoon Nona

o

Geohazard Identification Report for the proposed site of KASAPI Relocation site located in Bgy. Sta. Monica, Puerto Princesa City,

o

Geological Assessment Report on the proposed sanitary landfill site in the municipality of Sablayan, Occidental Mindoro

o

Geohazard Identification Report on the project site of PANJA Resort located in Brgy. Tagburos, Puerto Princesa City, Palawan

o

Geohazard identification report on the proposed site of Villa Pico Expansion project in Pto. Galera, Oriental Mindoro

o

Geohazard identification report on the proposed site of Lazareto Bayville Subd. In Calapan City, Oriental Mindoro

o

Investigation report on the 3rd Quarter 2016 monitoring of Marcopper Mines structures in Marinduque

o

Report on the geological assessment of the proposed site of Brooke's Pt. Ecological Center sanitary landfill in Brgy. Maasin, Brooke's Pt., Palawan

o

GIR on the proposed commercial building site of DURAPAD Development Corporation in Brgy. San Isidro, Puerto Galera, Oriental Mindoro

o

GIR on the proposed project site of Grand Bay Subd. in Brgy. Balatero, Pto. Galera, Or. Mindoro

o

Report on the geological assessment and evaluation of the proposed solid waste management disposal site in Buenavista, Marinduque

o

Report on the geological assessment of the proposed sanitary landfill site in the municipality of Culion, Palawan

o

Geohazard identification report on the exisiting site of Palawan Uno Hotel in Brgy. San Pedro, Pto. Princesa City, Palawan

o

Geological assessment report on the proposed sanitary landfill site in Bgy. IV, Roxas municipality, Palawan

o

Geological assessment report on the proposed sanitary landfill site in Bgy. Villaflor, Pto. Galera, Oriental Mindoro

99

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

o

GIR on the proposed housing project site of the provincial government of Oriental Mindoro located in Bgy. Suqui, Calapan City, Oriental Mindoro.

b. Clients Served o

Provision of Geohazard Certification for the following projects:                      

100

Proposed construction of Rizal Fire Station within the municipal complex of Rizal in Brgy. Punta Baja, Rizal, Palawan Proposed construction of BJMP Facility in Brgy. Pangobilian, Brooke's Point, Palawan Proposed establishment of Sicsican National High School - Sta. Monica Annex in Brgy. Sta. Monica, Pto. Princesa City, Palawan Proposed evacuation center in Poblacion, Calintaan, Occidental Mindoro Newly constructed Mabini National High School, Brgy. Mabini, San Fernando, Romblon Proposed site of relocation site in Brgy. Bagong Silang, Victioria, Oriental Mindoro Proposed site of housing project in San Antonio, Municipality of Victoria, Oriental Mindoro Proposed site of the Socialized Housing Project of LGU-Brooke's Pt. In Brgy. Ipilan, Brooke's Pt., Palawan Proposed construction of Rizal Fire Station within the municipal complex of Rizal in Brgy. Punta Baja, Rizal, Palawan Proposed construction of BJMP Facility in Brgy. Pangobilian, Brooke's Point, Palawan Proposed establishment of Sicsican National High School - Sta. Monica Annex in Brgy. Sta. Monica, Pto. Princesa City, Palawan Provided Geohazard Certification for the proposed evacuation center in Poblacion, Calintaan, Occidental Mindoro Newly constructed Mabini National High School, Brgy. Mabini, San Fernando, Romblon Proposed site of relocation site in Brgy. Bagong Silang, Victioria, Oriental Mindoro Proposed site of housing project in San Antonio, Municipality of Victoria, Oriental Mindoro Water system projects (9 locations) in Roxas, Palawan Water system projects (23 locations) in Taytay, Palawan Water system projects (8 locations) in El Nido, Palawan Water system projects (6 locations) in Araceli, Palawan Establishment of Magkalip Primary School in Brgy. Taburi, Rizal, Palawan Proposed construction of Day Care Center in Brgy. Tanagan, San Andres, Romblon Proposed site of Agripino Armedilla National High School in Brgy. Mat-i, Sta. Fe, Romblon

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

      



Proposed construction of evacuation center located in Brgy. Pag-asa, Bansud, Or. Mindoro Proposed sites for the Child Development Center and Senior Citizen Bldg. In Brgy. Poblacion, Maasin and Nasukob, Bulalacao, Or. Mindoro Proposed construction of BOC Bldg. In Brgy. Sta. Monica, Pto. Princesa City, Palawan Construction of 2-storey TESDA Bldg. in Brgy. Sto Nino, Rizal, Occidental Mindoro Construction of a permanent evacuation center in Brgy. Dapawan, Odiongan, Romblon Establishment of Buenavista High School in Brgy. Buenavista, Pto. Princesa City Proposed construction of Provincial Evacuation and Emergency Operation Center in Brgy. Andres Bonifacio and Brgy. Macario Adriatico, Municipality of Gloria, Or. Mindoro Construction of evacuation center in Brgy. Poblacion, Municipality of Bansud, Or. Mindoro

o

Provided assistance to LGU-Baco,Oriental Mindoro on how to secure geohazard certification for the proposed relocation site for Mangyan tribes located in Brgy. Bangkatan, Baco, Oriental Mindoro

o

Provided assistance to LGU-Brooke's Pt., Palawan concerning geohazard identification survey (GIS) for the proposed housing site of the municipality

o

Provided NEDA-Region IVB with geohazard data and information for the preparation of new Regional Physical Framework Plan

o

Identified potential site for category 1 sanitary landfill for LGU-Buenvista, Marinduque province

o

Conduct of geohazard identification survey for the proposed site of Villa de Pico Expansion Project in Palangan, Pto. Galera, Or. Mindoro

o

Provided assistance to LGU-Culion, Palawan in connection with the identification of suitable categorized landfill site

o

Review of the EGGAR for the 8 MW Catuiran Hydropower Plant in Naujan, Oriental Mindoro

o

Provided assistance to the Provincial Government of Oriental Mindoro for the assessment of massive flooding caused by Typhoon Nona

o

Assessment of proposed sanitary landfill site of LGU-Culion, Brgy. Baldat, Culion, Palawan

o

Assessment of proposed sanitary landfill site of LGU-Brooke's Pt., Palawan

101

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

o

Attended the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of Oriental Mindoro meeting regarding the investigation conducted by Task Force Iwas baha to determine the cause of flooding in Or. Mindoro during Typhoon Nona

o

Provision of provincial/municipal geohazard maps to the governor of Oriental Mindoro

o

Assisted the LGU-Buenavista, Marinduque in the assessment of their proposed landfll

o

Disseminated information on the status of Marcopper facilities and structures to the local officials of Mogpog, Marinduque

MINING REGULATION SERVICES A.03.c.1 Mineral Investment Promotion Program The Mineral Investment Promotion Program aims for the institution of mining reforms toward responsible and sustainable mining and the identification of mining investment opportunities. This action alludes to the issuance of mining contracts/permits incorporating zones inside mineral reservations through evaluation and field verification upon submission of complete mandatory requirements by the applicants as required under CDAO 2010-21 or the Consolidated DENR Administrative Order for the Implementing Rules and Regulations of RA 7942 otherwise known as the Philippine Mining Act of 1995. A.03.c.1.a.1 Issuance of Permits/Contracts This action refers to the issuance of mining contracts/permits through evaluation upon the submission of complete mandatory requirements by the applicants and field verification, if necessary, as required under CDAO 2010-21 or the Consolidated DENR Administrative Order for the Implementing Rules and Regulations of RA 7942 otherwise known as the Philippine Mining Act of 1995. Activities under this program were successfully embraced by the MGB-MIMAROPA Region which incorporates: a. Agreements/Contracts/Permits (FTAA, MPSA, EP, ISAGP, MPP) For the Permits/Contracts Issued/Indorsed, this Office was able to indorse to the MGB-Central Office two (2) applications, namely, Application for Mineral Agreement denominated as AMA-IV-144A of Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation and Exploration Permit Application denominated as EPA-IVB-324 of Itawes Mining Exploration Limited Company. Unfortunately, this translates only to a 75% accomplishment inasmuch as this activity was affected by the DENR Memorandum Order (DMO) No. 2016-01 dated 08 July 2016 which provides, among others, for a moratorium on new mining projects. Under Section 1 of the said DAO, the moratorium shall cover the acceptance, processing and /or

102

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

approval of mining applications and/or new mining projects for all metallic and nonmetallic minerals. List of Issued/Endorsed Agreements/Contracts/Permits APPLICATION DATE INDORSED TO COMPANY LOCATION NO. MGB-CO 1

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation

AMA-IV-144A

Palawan

June 6, 2016

2

Itawes Mining Exploration Limited Company

EPA-IVB-324

Occ. Mindoro

June 30, 2016

b. OTP/Certifications This Office has issued 82 Ore Transport Permits (OTPs) and 71 Ore Transport Certifications (OTCs). Accordingly, these account for an annual accomplishment of 103% and 75%, respectively. However, combined OTP and OTC translate to 87% accomplishment of the annual target. Compared to the previous years’ accomplishments, it can be noticed that there has been a decrease in the terms of issued OTCs. This is generally attributed to the currently persistent low nickel prices. However, in the case of MGB MIMAROPA, this year’s slump in the issuance of OTCs can be traced to the change of third party certifying agency of Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation (RTNMC). Intertek China, a certifying agency operating outside the Philippines, is now doing the required third party certification of RTNMC. The reason for this change in 3 rd party assay agency is the result of new agreements between the buyers and RTNMC start ing early this year in order to arrive at an amicable settlement regarding assay difference between the Loading port (RTNMC) and the discharging port (China). Prior to the said revised contract agreements, reconciliation of assay differences will be made between RTNMC’s in-house assay lab and Intertek Philippines located in Manila. In order to accordingly achieve more objectivity and fairness, it was agreed between the buyers and RTNMC that the reconciliation shall be made between the Loading port (i.e., RTNMC's assay) and at the Discharging port.The result of this is that the task of obtaining the 3rd party assay has been deferred to Intertek China rather than Intertek Philippines and as a result the latter no longer has to obtain samples from RTNMC nor request OTCs to transport any to Manila for analysis.

Enumerated are the OTPs and OTCs issued for the period January to December 2016.

103

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

b.1 Ore Transport Permit

PERMIT No.

104

List of Issued Ore Transport Permit TONNAGE PROPONENT COMMODITY (WMT)

DESTINATION

OTP-RTNMC-01-01-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

Nickel Ore (HFO)

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-02-02-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

Nickel Ore (HFO)

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-03-03-2016-IVB

RTNMC

150,000.00

Crushed Limestone

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-04-04-2016-IVB

RTNMC

600,000.00

Low Grade Limonite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-05-05-2016-IVB

RTNMC

75,000.00

Crushed Limestone

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-06-06-2016-IVB

RTNMC

546,000.00

Nickel Ore (HFO)

OTP-CMDC-07-01-2016-IVB

CMDC

200,000.00

Nickel Laterite Ore

OTP-CMDC-08-02-2016-IVB

CMDC

200,000.00

Nickel Laterite Ore

Bataraza, Palawan S. Espanola, Palawan Narra, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-09-07-2016-IVB

RTNMC

50,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-CBNC-10-01-2016-IVB

CBNC

Mixed Sulfide

Niihama, Japan

OTP-BNC-11-01-2016-IVB

BNC

Lateritic Nickel Ore

Quezon, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-12-08-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-13-09-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-14-10-2016-IVB

RTNMC

50,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-15-11-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

Type IV Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-16-12-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

Type IV Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-17-13-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-18-14-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-CBNC-19-02-2016-IVB

CBNC

3,636.89

Mixed Sulfide

Niihama, Japan

OTP-RTNMC-20-15-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

Limonite Ore

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-21-16-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-BNC-22-02-2016-IVB

BNC

200,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

Quezon, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-23-17-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

Nickel Ore (HFO)

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-24-18-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

Type IV Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-25-19-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

High Iron Limonite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-26-20-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

High Iron Limonite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-CBNC-26-03-2016-IVB

CBNC

Mixed Sulfide

Niihama, Japan

OTP-RTNMC-28-21-2016-IVB

RTNMC

50,000.00

Type II Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-29-22-2016-IVB

RTNMC

50,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-BNC-30-03-2016-IVB OTP-RTNMC-31-23-2016-IVB (Amd.) OTP-RTNMC-32-24-2016-IVB (Amd.) OTP-RTNMC-33-25-2016-IVB (Amd.) OTP-RTNMC-34-26-2016-IVB

BNC

200,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

Bataraza, Palawan

RTNMC

150,000.00

Crushed Limestone

Bataraza, Palawan

RTNMC

600,000.00

Low Grade Limonite

Bataraza, Palawan

RTNMC

75,000.00

Crushed Limestone

Bataraza, Palawan

RTNMC

52,000.00

Type IV Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-CBNC-35-04-2016-IVB

CBNC

Mixed Sulfide

Niihama, Japan

OTP-BNC-36-04-2016-IVB

BNC

Lateritic Nickel Ore

Quezon, Palawan

3,547.03 100,000.00

3,974.00

4,320.97 200,000.00

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

PERMIT No.

List of Issued Ore Transport Permit TONNAGE PROPONENT COMMODITY (WMT)

OTP-RTNMC-37-27-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

OTP-CMDC-38-03-2016-IVB

CMDC

200,000.00

OTP-RTNMC-39-28-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

OTP-BNC-40-05-2016-IVB

BNC

OTP-RTNMC-42-30-2016-IVB

RTNMC

OTP-CBNC-42-05-2016-IVB OTP-BNC-43-06-2016-IVB (Amd.) OTP-CBNC-44-06-2016-IVB

CBNC

OTP-RTNMC-45-31-2016-IVB

RTNMC

OTP-CBNC-46-07-2016-IVB

CBNC

OTP-RTNMC-47-32-2016-IVB

RTNMC

OTP-RTNMC-48-33-2016-IVB

DESTINATION

Type IV Saprolite Nickeliferous Laterite Ore Type IV Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan S. Espanola, Palawan Bataraza, Palawan

Lateritic Nickel Ore

Quezon, Palawan

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

Mixed Sulfide

Niihama, Japan

Lateritic Nickel Ore

Quezon, Palawan

Mixed Sulfide

Niihama, Japan

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

Mixed Sulfide

Niihama, Japan

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

RTNMC

50,000.00

Type II Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-49-34-2016-IVB

RTNMC

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-CBNC-50-08-2016-IVB

CBNC

Mixed Sulfide

Niihama, Japan

OTP-RTNMC-51-35-2016-IVB

RTNMC

600,000.00

Low Grade Limonite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-52-36-2016-IVB

RTNMC

150,000.00

Crushed Limestone

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-53-37-2016-IVB

RTNMC

75,000.00

Crushed Limestone

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-BNC-54-07-2016-IVB

BNC

55,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

Quezon, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-55-38-2016-IVB

RTNMC

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-BNC-56-08-2016-IVB

BNC

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

Quezon, Palawan

OTP-CBNC-57-09-2016-IVB

CBNC

2,718.97

Mixed Sulfide

Niihama, Japan

OTP-RTNMC-58-39-2016-IVB

RTNMC

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-59-40-2016-IVB

RTNMC

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-CBNC-60-10-2016-IVB

CBNC

Mixed Sulfide

Niihama, Japan

OTP-RTNMC-61-41-2016-IVB

RTNMC

50,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-62-42-2016-IVB

RTNMC

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RNTMC-63-43-2016-IVB

RTNMC

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-CBNC-64-11-2016-IVB

CBNC

Mixed Sulfide

Niihama, Japan

OTP-RTNMC-65-44-2016-IVB

RTNMC

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-66-45-2016-IVB

RTNMC

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-67-46-2016-IVB

RTNMC

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-68-47-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-CBNC-69-12-2016-IVB

CBNC

Mixed Sulfide

Niihama, Japan

OTP-RTNMC-70-48-2016-IVB

RTNMC

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-71-49-2016-IVB

RTNMC

50,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-72-50-2016-IVB

RTNMC

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-73-51-2016-IVB

RTNMC

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

BNC CBNC

200,000.00 52,000.00 3,413.11 244,670.00 1,868.13 50,000.00 1,705.41

1,985.24

3,296.30

2,955.68

2,258.88

105

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

List of Issued Ore Transport Permit TONNAGE PROPONENT COMMODITY (WMT)

PERMIT No. OTP-RTNMC-74-52-2016-IVB

RTNMC

OTP-DSV-75-01-2016-IVB

DSV

OTP-RTNMC-76-53-2016-IVB

DESTINATION

50,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

754.80

Lumpy Chromite

Puerto Princesa City

RTNMC

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-77-54-2016-IVB

RTNMC

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-78-55-2016-IVB

RTNMC

50,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-CBNC-79-13-2016-IVB

CBNC

Mixed Sulfide

Niihama, Japan

OTP-RTNMC-80-56-2016-IVB

RTNMC

50,000.00

Type II Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-81-57-2016-IVB

RTNMC

57,000.00

Type III Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

OTP-RTNMC-82-58-2016-IVB

RTNMC

51,500.00

Type II Saprolite

Bataraza, Palawan

2,919.22

b.2 Ore Transport Certification List of Issued Ore Transport Certification PROPONENT Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

2

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

3

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

4

Del Monte Fresh Produce (Philippines) Inc. c/o Mr. Archie Talaban or Mr. Sherwin Lebria

5

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

6

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

7

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

8

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

1 kg. of Processed Ore/Mixed Sulphide Sample 120 kg. of Iron Hydroxide Slurry 1 kg. of Processed Ore/Mixed Sulphide Sample 3 kg. of Scandium Oxalate Sample

9

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

100 kg. of Metal Sulfate Solution

Japan

10

Berong Nickel Corp.

200 kg. of Lateritic Nickel Ore

Muntinlupa City

11

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

Japan

12

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

13

15

Berong Nickel Corp. Philippine Nuclear Research Institute (PNRI) c/o Mr. Reymar R. Diwa Berong Nickel Corp.

4 kg. of Scandium Oxalate Sample 1 kg. of Processed Ore/Mixed Sulphide Sample 200 kg. of Nickel Laterite Sample 20 kg. of Monazite, Allanite, Soil and Rock Samples 200 kg. of Nickel Laterite Sample

16

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

1 kg. of Scandium Oxalate Sample

Japan

17

Coral Bay Nickel Corp. Del Monte Fresh Produce (Philippines) Inc. c/o Mr. Archie Talaban or Mr. Sherwin Lebria

36 kg. of Metal sulfate Solution

Japan

1,200 kg. of Soil Samples

Davao City

18 19

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

20

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

50.60 kg. of Metal sulfate Solution

DESTINATION

1

14

106

COMMODITY

1 kg. of Ore Blended & Mixed Sulfide Sample 13 kg. of Scandium Oxalate Sample 800 kg. of Soil Samples

1 kg. of Processed Ore/Mixed Sulphide Sample 1 kg. of Processed Ore/Mixed Sulphide Sample

Japan Japan Japan Davao City Japan Japan Japan Japan

Japan Muntinlupa City Manila Muntinlupa City

Japan Japan

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

List of Issued Ore Transport Certification 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29

PROPONENT Mr. Mirko Uy &/or Mr. William Tamayo (UP-NIGS) Dr. Masanobu Nishimura (University of Hokkaido) Ms. Roxanne K. Samosa (UP-NIGS) Dr. Christian Schardt (University of Minnesota) Dr. Naoki Fujii (RWMC - Japan) Ms. Misato Shimbasi (University of Hokkaido) Berong Nickel Corp. UP-NIGS c/o Ms. Barbie Ross B. Villaplaza UP-NIGS c/o Ms. Barbie Ross B. Villaplaza

COMMODITY

DESTINATION

100 kg. of Rock Samples

Manila

25 kg. of Rock Samples

Manila and Japan

25 kg. of Rock Samples

Manila

20 kg. of Rock Samples

Minnesota, USA

20 kg. of Rock Samples

Japan

20 kg. of Rock Samples

Hoikkaido, Japan

200 kg. of Nickel Laterite Sample

Muntinlupa City

100 kg. of Rock Samples

Manila

100 kg. of Rock Samples

Manila

30

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

31

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

50 kg. of Scandium Sulphate Solution 1 kg. of Scandium Oxalate Sample

32

UP-NIGS c/o Mr. Juan Miguel Guotana

100 kg. of Rock Samples

Manila

33

Adamson University

50 kg. of Rock Samples

Manila

34

100 kg. of Rock Samples

Manila

20 kg. of Mineral/Ore Samples

Manila

50 kg. of Rock Samples

Manila

37

Mapua Institute of Technology Engr. Alvin S. Requimin &/or Engr. Elmer R. Crisologo UP-NIGS c/o Ms. Barbie Ross B. Villaplaza Mr. Edwin M. Mojares, Ph. D.

10 kg. of Mineral/Ore Samples

Manila

38

Engr. Francis M. Mirto

Manila

39

Mr. Morrys Y. Ang

1 kg. of Nickel Laterite Ore Sample 10 kg. of Coraline Limestone Mineral Sample

40

UP-NIGS c/o Mr. Mengming Yu et.al.

100 kg. of Rock Samples

41

DOE c/o Mr. Ariel D. Fronda

42

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

43

Berong Nickel Corp.

44

Mr. Marcelino D. Javier

18 kg. of Rock Chip Samples 1 kg. of Processed Ore/Mixed Sulphide Sample 200 kg. of Nickel Laterite Sample 60 kg. of Copper Waste Material/Ore

45

Mr. Randy Rosalla

25 kg. of Nickel Laterite Sample

46

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

1 kg. of Zinc Sulfide Sample

47

Berong Nickel Corp.

Muntinlupa City

48

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

49

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

200 kg. of Nickel Laterite Sample 1 kg. of Processed Ore/Mixed Sulphide Sample 1 kg. of Processed Ore/Mixed Sulphide Sample 100 kg. of Soil Samples

Davao City

1 kg. of Resin Sample 1 kg. of Processed Ore/Mixed Sulphide Sample

Japan

35 36

51

Del Monte Fresh Produce (Philippines) Inc. c/o Mr. Archie Talaban Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

52

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

53

UP - Diliman c/o Ms. Fe Corazon B. Loreto et al.

50

500 kg. of Laterite Samples

Japan Japan

Manila and China GIGCAS, Guangzhuo, China Manila

Muntinlupa City Binondo, Manila c/o Mr. Carlos Rodil Manila then Surigao City, Surigao Japan Japan Japan

Japan UP Diliman Lab., Quezon City

107

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

List of Issued Ore Transport Certification PROPONENT

c.

COMMODITY 100 kg. of Rock Powder and Rock Chip Samples 100 kg. of Rock Powder and Rock Chip Samples 100 kg. of Rock Powder and Rock Chip Samples 200 kg. of Lateritic Nickel Ore 10 kg. of Scandium Oxalate Sample 1 kg. of Zinc Sulfide Sample

DESTINATION Metro Manila and Tokyo, Japan Metro Manila and Tokyo, Japan

Japan

54

Macroasia Corp.

55

Macroasia Corp.

56

Macroasia Corp.

57

Berong Nickel Corp.

58

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

59

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

60

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

61

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

62

Citinickel Mines & Dev't Corp.

2 kg. of Scandium Oxalate Sample 1 kg. of Processed Ore/Mixed Sulphide Sample 10 kg. of Limestone samples

63

Unichamp Minerals Philippines, Inc.

10 kg. of Limestone samples

64

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

65

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

66

Cotechna Elite Philippines, Inc.

67

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

68

Cotechna Elite Philippines, Inc.

69

Cotechna Elite Philippines, Inc.

70

Ms. Betchaida D. Paynor, Ph.D.

71

Cotechna Elite Philippines, Inc.

1 kg. of Processed Ore/Mixed Sulphide Sample 1 kg. of Processed Ore/Mixed Sulphide Sample 500 kg. of Lateritic Nickel Ore samples 1 kg. of Processed Ore/Mixed Sulphide Sample 500 kg. of Laterictic Nickel Ore sample 500 kg. of Nickel Ore sample 150 kg. of Rock samples 500 kg. of Lateritic Nickel Ore samples

Metro Manila Muntinlupa City Japan Japan Japan Bataraza, Palawan Petaling Jaya Selangor, Malaysia Japan Japan Metro Manila Japan Metro Manila Metro Manila Manila Metro Manila

Accreditation as Dealer, Trader and Retailer of Minerals/Mineral Products and By-Products As a prerequisite to engage in the trading of minerals/mineral products and byproducts locally or internationally, aspiring contractors/mining rights/holders are required to secure a Certificate of Accreditation as Dealer, Trader and Retailer of Minerals/Mineral Products and By-Products. For CY 2016, the Region was able to issue four (4) Certificates of Accreditation as enumerated below thus attaining a 133% accomplishment. List of Issued Certificate of Accreditation ACCREDITATION NO.

108

PROPONENT

DATE ISSUED

1

CA-2016-001-IVB

Alad Mining Corp.

June 28, 2016

2

CA-2016-002-IVB

Pure and Natural Ventures Quarrying Corp.

June 28, 2016

3

CA-2016-003-IVB

The Coolstone Enterprises

July 26, 2016

4

CA-2016-004-IVB

DSV Mineral Ore Trading

November 23, 2016

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

d. Mineral Ore Export Permit Pursuant to DENR Memorandum Order No. 2010-07 dated 29 June 2010 which delegates the authority to issue Mineral Ore Export Permits to the Director, Regional Director of the Mines and Geosciences Bureau concerned and the Provincial Governors/City Mayors concerned, among others, eighty-one (81) MOEPs were issued and validated for CY 2016, as shown below. This Office was not able to accomplish its target to issue 100 MOEPs for CY 2016. This can be traced to the suspension of the mining operations of Berong Nickel Corporation and Citinickel Mines and Development Corporation even prior to the conduct of the mining audit under DMO No. 2016-01, which refers to the audit of all operating mines and the moratorium on the approval of new mining projects. Moreover the price of nickel has been very persistently low during the 1 st three (3) quarters of the year, thus also affecting the selling frequencies. List of Issued Mineral Ore Export Permit

MOEP-CMDC-01-01-2016-IVB

Citinickel Mines and Dev’t Corp.

TONNAGE (WMT) 50,000.00

MOEP-RTN-02-01-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Nickel Ore (HFO)

MOEP-RTN-03-02-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Nickel Ore (HFO)

MOEP-RTN-04-03-2015-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Nickel Ore (HFO)

MOEP-CMDC-05-02-2016-IVB

Citinickel Mines and Dev’t Corp.

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-06-04-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

50,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-CMDC-07-03-2016-IVB

Citinickel Mines and Dev’t Corp.

50,360.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-08-05-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-09-06-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-10-07-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

50,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-11-08-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type IV Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-12-09-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type IV Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-13-10-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-14-11-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-CMDC-15-04-2016-IVB

Citinickel Mines and Dev’t Corp.

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-16-12-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Limonite Ore

MOEP-RTN-17-13-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-BNC-18-01-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

56,800.00

Lateric Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-19-14-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Nickel Ore (HFO)

MOEP-BNC-20-02-2016-IVB (Amd.)

Berong Nickel Corp.

53,000.00

Lateric Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-21-15-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type IV Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-22-16-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

High Iron Limonite

MOEP-RTN-23-17-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

High Iron Limonite

PERMIT NO.

PROPONENT

COMMODITY Lateritic Nickel Ore

109

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

List of Issued Mineral Ore Export Permit

MOEP-BNC-24-03-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

TONNAGE (WMT) 55,000.00

MOEP-RTN-25-18-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

50,000.00

Type II Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-26-19-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

50,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-BNC-27-04-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-BNC-28-05-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

55,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-29-20-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type IV Saprolite

MOEP-BNC-30-06-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-BNC-31-07-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-BNC-32-08-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-CMDC-33-05-2016-IVB

Citinickel Mines and Dev’t Corp.

49,200.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-BNC-34-09-2016-IVB (Amd.)

Berong Nickel Corp.

55,805.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-35-21-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type IV Saprolite

MOEP-BNC-36-10-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

59,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-BNC-37-11-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

59,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-38-22-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type IV Saprolite

MOEP-BNC-40-12-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

57,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-BNC-41-13-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

52,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-42-24-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type IV Saprolite

MOEP-BNC-42-14-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-BNC-43-15-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-44-24-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type IV Saprolite

MOEP-BNC-45-16-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-46-25-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

50,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-BNC-47-17-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-BNC-48-18-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-BNC-49-19-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-BNC-50-20-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-51-26-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-52-27-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

50,000.00

Type II Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-53-28-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-54-29-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-55-30-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type IV Saprolite

MOEP-BNC-56-21-2016-IVB

Berong Nickel Corp.

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-57-31-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-58-32-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

50,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-59-33-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

PERMIT NO.

110

PROPONENT

COMMODITY Lateritic Nickel Ore

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

List of Issued Mineral Ore Export Permit

MOEP-RTN-60-34-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

TONNAGE (WMT) 55,000.00

MOEP-RTN-61-35-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-62-36-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-63-37-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-64-38-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-65-39-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-66-40-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

50,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-CMDC-67-06-2016-IVB

Citinickel Mines and Dev’t Corp.

55,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-68-41-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-69-42-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-70-43-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

50,000.00

Nickel Ore

MOEP-CMDC-71-07-2016-IVB

Citinickel Mines and Dev’t Corp.

55,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-72-44-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

52,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-73-45-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

55,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-CMDC-74-08-2016-IVB

Citinickel Mines and Dev’t Corp.

55,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-CMDC-75-09-2016-IVB

Citinickel Mines and Dev’t Corp.

55,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-76-46-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

50,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-77-47-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

50,000.00

Type II Saprolite

MOEP-CMDC-78-08-2016-IVB

Citinickel Mines and Dev’t Corp.

50,000.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-CMDC-79-09-2016-IVB

Citinickel Mines and Dev’t Corp.

55,500.00

Lateritic Nickel Ore

MOEP-RTN-80-48-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

57,000.00

Type III Saprolite

MOEP-RTN-81-29-2016-IVB

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

51,500.00

Type III Saprolite

PERMIT NO.

PROPONENT

COMMODITY Type III Saprolite

A.03.c.1.a.2 Use It or Lose It Policy 

Mining Applications with Final Action In conformity with the Mines and Geosciences Bureau's (MGB) "Use It or Lose It" Policy, two (2) mining applications were indorsed to the Central Office for further review and final evaluation, as follows: Applicant 1 2



Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp. Itawes Mining Exploration Limited Company

Application No.

Location

AMA-IV-144A

Palawan

EPA-IVB-324

Occ. Mindoro

Mining Permits/Contracts Reviewed Pursuant to the provisions of Section 6 of DAO No. 2012-07, as amended, the Rules and Regulations of Executive Order (EO) No. 79 (s. 2012) entitled:

111

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Institutionalizing and Implementing Reforms in The Philippine Mining Sector Providing Policies and Guidelines to Ensure Environmental Protection and Responsible Mining in the Utilization of Mineral Resources, a total of fifteen (15) Mining Permits/Contracts were reviewed as shown below: Mining Permits/Contracts Reviewed Permit/Contract No.

Location

1

MPSA-229-2007-IVB

Narra & Espanola, Palawan

2

MPSA-114-98-IV

3

MPSA-213-2005-IVB

4

MPSA-017-2000-IV

Brooke's Point, Palawan

5

MPP-15-2014-IVB

Bataraza, Palawan

6

MPSA-167-2000-IV

7

MPSA-277-2009-IVB

8

MPSA-341-2010-IVB

9

MPSA-342-2010-IVB

10

MPSA-235-2007-IVB

Quezon, Palawan

11

MPP-006-2005-IVB

Bataraza, Palawan

12

FTAA-003-2008-IVB

Or. Mindoro & Occ. Mindoro

13

MPSA-220-2005-IVB

Brooke’s Pt., Palawan

14

MPSA-221-2005-IVB

Brooke’s Pt., Palawan

15

EP_003-2010-IVB

Sta. Cruz, Marinduque

Bataraza, Palawan

Oriental and Occidental Mindoro

A.03.c.1.a.3 Approval of SHES Programs a. EPEP/FMRDP/PEIR endorsed to MRFC The submission of the FMRDP of CMDC, CBNC and RTNMC-Gotok were discussed during the series of MRFC meetings in 2013. The deadline for submission of the revised plan was set before the 3 rd Quarter 2016 MRFC meeting, for deliberation and final evaluation of the MRFC/MGB IV-B. However, CMDC and RTNMC requested for deferment of the submission of their FMRDP. In the case of CBNC, during the 4th Quarter 2016 MRFC meeting, the company informed the body that they will be submitting their revised FMRDP after approval of their request for amendment in its ECC due to the inclusion of TSF 3. b. Annual Environmental Protection and Enhancement Programs (AEPEP) approved Mining companies operating in the region regularly submits their respective Annual Environmental Protection and Enhancement Programs (AEPEP) for evaluation and approval of MGB MIMAROPA Region. These serve as basis for ISHES and MMT monitoring. Six (6) AEPEPs were submitted and were

112

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

subsequently approved by this Office. Hereunder are the companies with approved AEPEP for CY 2016. List of Companies with Approved AEPEP COMPANY

CERTIFICATE NO.

LOCATION

Coral Bay Nickel Corporation

AEPEP 2016 No.IVB - 01

Brgy. Rio Tuba, Bataraza,

Rio Tuba Nickel Corporation (Nickel)

AEPEP 2016 No. IVB - 02

Brgy. Rio Tuba, Bataraza, Palawan

Rio Tuba Nickel Corporation (Limestone)

AEPEP 2016 No. IVB - 03

Brgy. Rio Tuba, Bataraza,Palawan

Citinickel Mines and Dev't. Corporation - Pulot

AEPEP 2016 No. IVB - 04A

Sofronio, Española, Palawan

Citinickel Mines and Dev't. Corporation - Toronto

AEPEP 2016 No. IVB - 04B

Brgy. San Isidro, Narra, Palawan

Unichamp Mineral Philippines Inc.

AEPEP 2016 No. IVB - 05

Brgy. Rio Tuba, Bataraza, Palawan

Berong Nickel Corporation

AEPEP 2016 No. IVB - 06

Brgy. Berong, Quezon, Palawan

c. Social Development and Management Program/Community Development Programs approved Three (3) Community Development Programs, as tabulated below, were evaluated and approved for CY 2016. List of Companies with Approved CDP NAME OF COMPANY

MPSA No.

LOCATION

No.

Date of Registration

Alagag Mining Corp.

MPSA No. 3422010-IVB

Brgy. Pag-asa and San Agustin, Sablayan, Or. Mindoro

CDP No. MGBIVB-2016-01

March 2016

Aglubang Mining Corp.

MPSA No. 1672000-IV

Brgy. Villa Cerveza, Victoria, Or. Mindoro

CDP No. MGBIVB-2016-02

March 2016

Aglubang Mining Corp.

MPSA No. 3412010-IVB

Brgy. Villa Cerveza, Victoria, Or. Mindoro

CDP No. MGBIVB-2016-03

March 2016

The implementation of the approved ASDMPs and CDPs of the above mentioned companies were regularly monitored and validated in the field through the Integrated Safety, Health, Environment and Socials (ISHES) compliance monitoring activity of this Office and during the quarterly Multipartite Monitoring Team (MMT) field validation. Companies are also required to submit quarterly and semi-annual accomplishment report, on the implementation for its physical vis-avis financial status based on the approved ASDMP and CDP.

113

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

d. Annual Social Development and Management Programs (ASDMP) approved The Community Development Section under the Mine Safety, Environment and Social Development Division, MGB Region IV MIMAROPA, evaluated and subsequently approved five (5) Annual Social Development and Management Program for CY 2016. Hereunder are the companies with approved ASDMP: List of Mining Companies with Approved ASDMP NAME OF COMPANY

MPSA No.

LOCATION

No.

Date of Registration

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

MPP 006-2004-IVB

Brgy. Rio Tuba, Bataraza, Palawan

ASDMP No. MGBIVB-2015-01

9-Mar-16

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

MPSA 114-98-IV

Brgy. Rio Tuba, Bataraza, Palawan

ASDMP No. MGBIVB-2016-02

4-Mar-16

Brgy. Rio Tuba, Bataraza, Palawan

ASDMP No. MGBIVB-2016-03

4-Mar-16

Brgy. Berong, Quezon Palawan

ASDMP No. MGBIVB-2016-04

13-Mar-16

Brgy. San Isidro, Narra, Palawan

ASDMP No. MGBIVB-2016-05A

Brgy. Pulot, Sofronio Espanola, Palawan

ASDMP No. MGBIVB-2016-05B

Brgy. Rio Tuba, Bataraza, Palawan

ASDMP No. MGBIVB-2015-06

RTNMC Gotok Quarry Berong Nickel Corp.

Citinickel Mines and Development Corp.

Unichamp Minerals Phils., Inc

MPSA 235-2007-IVB

MPSA No. 2292007-IVB

9-Mar-16

Mar-16

For 2016, RTNMC and CBNC allocated PhP 126,654,383.37 for its 2016 Annual Social Development and Management Program (ASDMP). The budget is allocated in three (3) main categories, namely: RTNMC and CBNC jointly implement its SDMP covering all the twenty two (2) barangays and twenty eight IP communities in the Municipality of Bataraza. Of the total fund allotted for ASDMP 2016, RTNMC shares 17.28% and 82.72% for CBNC. Map showing the host and neighboring communities covered by the SDMP of RTNMC and CBNC.

114

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Berong Nickel Corporation allotted Php 22,890,000.00 for CY 2016 covering two (2) barangays: Brgy. Berong and Brgy. Aramaywan. Development of Host and Neighboring Communities (DHNC)

• Php 17,167,500.00

Information, Education and Communication (IEC)

• Php 3,433,500.00

Development of Mining Technologies and Geosciences (DMTG)

• Php 2,289,000.00

Unichamp Minerals Phils., Inc. allotted Php 4,926,191.71 for its 2016 ASDMP covering four (4) barangays: Rio Tuba, Iwahig, Ocayan and Sandoval, divided into three (3) major components: Development of Host and Neighboring Communities (DHNC)

• Php 3,811,191.71

Information, Education and Communication (IEC)

• Php 445,000.00

Development of Mining Technologies and Geosciences (DMTG)

• Php 670,000.00

Citinickel Mines and Development Corporation (CMDC), on the other hand, allotted a total of Php 15,202,538.74 for its 2016 ASDMP covering Brgy. San Isidro, Narra and Brgys. Pulot Interior, Pulot Shore, Pulot Center, Punang and Labog, Sofronio Espanola. Development of Host and Neighboring Communities (DHNC)

• Php 11,401,904.06

Information, Education and Communication (IEC)

• Php 2,280,380.81

Development of Mining Technologies and Geosciences (DMTG)

• Php 1,520,253.87

115

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

The SDMP is considered as the vehicle that maximizes opportunity/ies for social and economic development and facilitate the equitable distribution of resources/benefits. The approved program/s also includes projects and activities to be implemented or possible interventions and initiatives that will address the communities’ identified problems and concerns. Driven by the pursuit to achieve the government’s and the industry’s common objective on responsible mining and community development, CROs in MIMAROPA Region, being in the front line, ensure that the benefits of the people and the communities from mining are maximize in all possible ways through the implementation of the SDMP. e. Annual ASHP approved Out of the fifteen (15) companies that were required to submit a Safety and Health Program (SHP) with corresponding Emergency Response and Preparedness Program (ERPP), twelve (12) companies have submitted their respective programs for evaluation and approval of this Regional Office. All 12 were approved after being found sufficient in form and substance, and in accordance with Section 144 of DAO 2010-21. List of Companies with Approved ASHP/ERPP COMPANY

116

LOCATION

MPSA/EP/MPP No.

CONTROL NO.

DATE APPROVED Jan. 08, 2016

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp. (RTNMC)

Bataraza, Palawan

MPSA 114-98-IV

ASHP/ERPP_MGBIVB_ 2016-01

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp. (Gotok)

Bataraza, Palawan

MPSA 213-2005-IVB

ASHP/ERPP_MGBIVB_ 2016-02

Jan. 08, 2016

Citinickel Mines and Development Corp. (CMDC)

MPSA 229-2007-IVB

ASHP/ERPP_MGBIVB_ 2016-03

Jan. 12, 2016

Ipilan Nickel Corporation (INC)

Narra &Sofronio Española, Palawan Brooke’s Pt., Palawan

MPSA 017-93-IV

ASHP/ERPP_MGBIVB_ 2016-04

Feb. 02, 2016

Coral Bay Nickel Corporation (CBNC)

Bataraza, Palawan

MPP 006-2004-IVB

ASHP/ERPP_MGBIVB_ 2016-05

Feb. 02, 2016

Aglubang Mining Corporation (AMC)

Oriental Mindoro

MPSA 167-2000-IV

ASHP/ERPP_MGBIVB_ 2016-06

Feb. 04, 2016

Aglubang Mining Corporation (AMC)

Occidental Mindoro

MPSA 277-2009-IVB

ASHP/ERPP_MGBIVB_ 2016-07

Feb. 04, 2016

Aglubang Mining Corporation (AMC)

Occidental Mindoro

MPSA 341-2010-IVB

ASHP/ERPP_MGBIVB_ 2016-08

Feb. 04, 2016

Alag-ag Mining, Inc. (AMI)

Occidental Mindoro

MPSA 342-2010-IVB

ASHP/ERPP_MGBIVB_ 2016-09

Feb. 04, 2016

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

List of Companies with Approved ASHP/ERPP COMPANY

LOCATION

MPSA/EP/MPP No.

CONTROL NO.

DATE APPROVED Feb. 11, 2016

Berong Nickel Corporation (BNC)

Quezon, Palawan

MPSA 235-2007-IVB

ASHP/ERPP_MGBIVB_ 2016-10

Unichamp Mineral Philippines, Inc. (UMPI) Affluere Mineral Corporation (Affluere)

Bataraza, Palawan

MPP 15-2014-IVB

ASHP/ERPP_MGBIVB_ 2016-11

Mar. 22, 2016

Sta. Cruz, Marinduque

EP-003-2010-IVB

ASHP/ERPP_MGBIVB_ 2016-12

Mar. 29, 2016

Two exploration companies failed to submit their ASHP/ERPP, these are the Agusan Petroleum and Minerals Corporation (APMC) with exploration project in Occidental Mindoro under FTAA No. 03-2008-IVB and MacroAsia Corporation (MAC) with two (2) exploration projects in the province of Palawan under MPSA No. 220-2005-IVB and MPSA No. 221-2005-IVB. A follow-up letter was sent to MacroAsia Corporation on June 15, 2016 reiterating our previous letter dated October 2015, requiring the company to submit a SHP/ERPP for CY 2016. MacroAsia Corporation submitted their ASHP on July 11, 2016 and was subsequently approved by MGB-IVB on July 15, 2016. APMC on the other hand had requested on November 21, 2014 to reconsider the order for the company to submit a SHP/ERPP as required under Rule 144 of the Consolidated DAO 2010-21 due to the promulgation of Municipal Ordinance No. 106-2008 of Abra De Ilog and Provincial Ordinance No. 34-09 of Occidental Mindoro which both prohibits any kind of mining activity within their respective territories. The company was unable to fully implement its duties and responsibilities in the approved FTAA, including the submission of SHP/ERPP. The implementation of the approved ASHPs/ERPPs of the above mentioned companies were regularly monitored and validated in the field through the Integrated Safety, Health, Environment and Socials (ISHES) compliance monitoring activity of this Office and during the quarterly Multi-partite Monitoring Team (MMT) field validation. Operating mines and quarry, and mineral processing plants are also required to submit quarterly accomplishment reports on the implementation of their respective SHP/ERPP to this Office. 

National Greening Program All the mining companies in the MIMAROPA Region had met the target set forth in the National Greening Program (NGP) Guidelines of the MGB and they are continuously monitoring and maintaining the existing plantations. The MSESDD validates their accomplishments on a quarterly basis. Geo-tagging technology is being used by the technical personnel in monitoring NGP accomplishments to generate real-time field findings and to provide the specific location (with geographical coordinates) of the areas planted.

117

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

For CY 2016, a total 2,795.37 hectares were planted. Tabulated below are the accomplishments of the different companies from CY 2011 to the first semester of CY 2016. Consolidated NGP Accomplishment COMPANY Berong Nickel Corp. Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

Total Target as per MGB guideline

ACCOMPLISHMENTS (has.) 2011

2012

2013

2014

2015

180

4.5

125.2

90.7

19.14

17.7

0.49

554

38.53

383.1

420.64

6.53

18.41

1.6

Citinickel Mines and Development Corp.(S. Española)

90

100.4

61.07

48.33

6.72

Citinickel Mines and Development Corp. (Narra)

105

94.8

49.7

15.55

9.11

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

895

42.5

328.5

585.18

23.57

2.76

Intex Resources Philippines, Inc.

3.2

27.67

33.94

133.81

68.56

28.26

1827.2

113.2

1,065.94

1,341.10

181.68

82.96

TOTAL

As of Dec 2016

8.4

10.49

A.03.c.1.b Assistance to P/CMRB, LGUs and other stakeholder 1. PSSM/MB/SSM/Quarry Sites inventoried All the five provinces in MIMAROPA region was inventoried for small-scale mining and quarry sites. This translates to 100% accomplishment of the annual target. 2. Minahang Bayan site identified One (1) Minahang Bayan site was identified in So. Underground, Bgy. Poblacion, Quezon, Palawan. The area was located inside the mineral claim of Central Palawan Mining designated as MPSA No. 171-2001-IVB. The commodity of the proposed Minahang Bayan site is limestone which is processed into hydrated lime as product using four (4) units of furnace. The quarrying and processing operation started only this year and is currently being undertaken by a Cooperative Development Authority (CDA)-registered

118

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

cooperative. The operation is still at its initial stage wherein their product is still not being sold but rather utilized to build more furnaces.

Quarry site and processing plant of Barangay Community Lime Producers Cooperative in Sitio Underground, Poblacion, Quezon, Palawan

Photo showing the top of the kiln fully loaded with crushed limestone materials ready for firing

Close-up view of the 3x3 meters limestone kiln

119

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

MGB personnel together with CENRO Fernando Tactay conducting an ocular inspection on the 18-tonner limestone kiln

3. Minahang Bayan Site Endorsed Another previously identified Minahang Bayan site located in Romblon, Romblon was indorsed to the Mines and Geosciences Bureau Central Office. This proposed Minahang Bayan site covers the marble-rich areas of Barangays Cahimos, Capaclan, Agtongo, Lintian, Guinpingan and Agbalato in the Municipality of Romblon, Province of Romblon. The area is approximately 226 hectares These are the same areas which the Provincial Mining Regulatory Board (PMRB) – Romblon and this Office has proposed to declare as PSSMA or Minahang Bayan way back in 1990s covering the active marble quarry sites of Romblon, Romblon and within the cancelled mining claims of Filipinas Marble Corporation (FILMARCO). The said declaration process was not completed/perfected due to the lack of posting and publication as required by law. Despite that, the PMRB proceeded with the issuance of PSSM contracts to various subsistence miners who organized themselves into legitimate mining cooperatives as required under R.A. 7076. However, said contracts have already expired and cannot be renewed as the PSSMA has not been officially declared. Hence, this Office has endorsed for the declaration of the said Minahang Bayan site. 4. P/CMRB meetings participated A total of 26 meetings were undertaken, during the year, with the different P/CMRBs within the region garnering a 108% accomplishment, as follows: List of P/CMRB Meetings Attended/Participated Month

P/CMRB

January

CMRB Puerto Princesa

Jan. 7, 2016

PMRB Palawan

Feb. 12, 2016

PMRB Romblon

Feb. 18, 2016

CMRB Puerto Princesa City

Feb. 18, 2016

PMRB Palawan

March 18, 2016

February March

120

Date

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

List of P/CMRB Meetings Attended/Participated Month

P/CMRB

Date

CMRB Puerto Princesa

March 18, 2016

PMRB Oriental Mindoro

March 30, 2016

PMRB Occidental Mindoro

April 12, 2016

PMRB Oriental Mindoro

April 15, 2016

PMRB Occidental Mindoro

April 26, 2016

CMRB Puerto Princesa City

May 19, 2016

PMRB Palawan

May 24, 2016

June

PMRB Romblon

June 17, 2016

July

PMRB Palawan

July 22, 2016

August

PMRB Romblon

Aug. 25, 2016

PMRB Palawan

Sept. 15, 2016

PMRB Occidental Mindoro

Sept. 30, 2016

PMRB Oriental Mindoro

Oct. 6, 2016

CMRB Puerto Princesa City

Oct. 13, 2016

PMRB Romblon

Nov. 10, 2016

CMRB Puerto Princesa City

Nov. 24, 2016

PMRB Palawan

Nov. 25, 2016

PMRB Palawan

Dec. 5, 2016

PMRB Palawan

Dec. 8, 2016

PMRB Occidental Mindoro

Dec. 9, 2016

PMRB Oriental Mindoro

Dec. 13, 2016

April

May

September October

November

December

5. P/CMRB Regional Consultation On October 19, 2016, MGB MIMAROPA Region, through the Mine Management Division (MMD), conducted its 6 th Annual Regional Summit for Small-scale Mining participated by the members of the different Provincial/City Mining Regulatory Boards (P/CMRB) in the Region. For this year’s summit, discussions were focused on the laws governing small-scale mining, particularly the DENR Administrative Order (DAO) No. 201503 or the Revised Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR) of the People’s Small-Scale Mining Act of 1991. Other activities include: 1) Review of CY 2014-2015 accomplishments, issues and concerns and their corresponding actions taken; 2) Reporting of accomplishments for the first to third quarter of 2016; and 3) open forum on the recent issues and concerns encountered by the P/CMRBs. Issues and concerns were given appropriate recommendation, incorporating suggestions from other P/CMRBs. The summit was concluded by the awarding of the Best P/CMRB. PMRB Palawan garnered the said award in account of their remarkable accomplishments.

121

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Engr. Roland De Jesus, Regional Director of MGB MIMAROPA, awarded the Best P/CMRB to PMRB Palawan in recognition of their remarkable accomplishments.

A.03.c.2 Mining Industry Development Program The Mining Industry Development Program is geared towards the attainment of a technically feasible, environmentally compliant, financially viable and socially acceptable mining industry. It essentially consists of the administration and supervision of all stages of mining operation - from exploration, development and utilization, to decommissioning. To support the program and in order to achieve its goal, MGB MIMAROPA Region continuously provides assistance to mining project proponents in securing mining contracts/permits while dynamically conducting compliance monitoring on the conditionalities stipulated under their mining contracts/permits, including the implementation of plans and programs as required by and in accordance with existing mining and other applicable laws, rules and regulations. A.03.c.2.a Monitoring of Approved Mining Contracts/ Permits including Areas within Mineral Reservations as to Compliance to Approved Work Program and Safety, Health, Environment and Social Programs A.03.c.2.a.1 Work Program Monitoring For this year, two (2) Mineral Processing Plants (MPPs), four (4) Mineral Production Sharing Agreements (MPSAs) in the operation stage, seven (7) MPSAs under exploration stage, one (1) Financial and/or Technical Assistance Agreement or FTAA, and one (1) Exploration Permit (EP) have been monitored as to compliance with the terms and conditions of the permits and progress report on the implementation of activities indicated in the submitted work plans and SHES programs. Mining Permits Monitored re: Work Program PROPONENT

122

PERMIT No.

TRAVEL DATE

LOCATION

1

Citinickel Mines and Development Corporation

MPSA-229-2007-IVB

Feb. 22-26, 2016

Narra & Espanola, Palawan

2

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation

MPSA-114-98-IV

March 28–April 2,

Bataraza, Palawan

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Mining Permits Monitored re: Work Program PROPONENT

PERMIT No.

TRAVEL DATE

LOCATION

3

RTN Gotok Quarry Project

MPSA-213-2005-IVB

2016

4

Ipilan Nickel Corporation

MPSA-017-2000-IV

April 13-16, 2016

Brooke's Pt., Palawan

5

Unichamp Mineral Philippines, Inc.

MPP-15-2014-IVB

April 25-29, 2016

Bataraza, Palawan

6

Aglubang Mining Corporation

MPSA-167-2000-IV

7

Aglubang Mining Corporation

MPSA-277-2009-IVB

8

Aglubang Mining Corporation

MPSA-341-2010-IVB

May 16-21, 2016

Oriental and Occidental Mindoro

9

Alagag Mining, Inc.

MPSA-342-2010-IVB

10

Berong Nickel Corporation

MPSA-235-2007-IVB

May 16-19, 2016

Quezon, Palawan

11

Coral Bay Nickel Corporation

MPP-006-2005-IVB

May 22-25, 2016

Bataraza, Palawan

12

Agusan Petroleum

FTAA-003-2008-IVB

June 26-30, 2016

13

MacroAsia Corporation

MPSA-220-2005-IVB

July 4-7, 2016

Brooke’s Pt., Palawan

14

MacroAsia Corporation

MPSA-221-2005-IVB

July 4-7, 2016

Brooke’s Pt., Palawan

15

Affluere Mineral Corporation

EP-003-2010-IVB

July 14, 2016

Sta. Cruz, Marinduque

Or. Mindoro & Occ. Mindoro

A.03.c.2.a.2 Monitoring of Safety, Health, Environment and Social Programs Monitoring of the Integrated Safety, Health and Environmental (ISHES) accomplishments were conducted on the following permit holders: four (4) Mineral Production Sharing Agreements (MPSAs) in the production stage; two (2) Mineral Processing Permits; seven (7) Mineral Production Sharing Agreements (MPSAs) in the exploration stage; one (1) Exploration Permit; and one (1) Financial Technical Assistance Agreement (FTAA). The monitoring activity is anchored on the companies’ approved 2016 Annual Environmental Protection and Enhancement Program (AEPEP) and 2016 Annual Social Development and Management Program (ASDMP) for those in active operation/production and the Environmental Work Program (EnWP) and theCommunity Development Program (CDP) for those in the explorations stage, including the FTAA. With regards to safety, the companies’ compliances were monitored based on their approved 2016 Annual Safety and Health Program (ASHP) and Emergency Response and preparedness Program (ERPP). Incidentally, Agusan Petroleum is applying for a force majeure and there was no operation observed at the time of monitoring and even no personnel assigned in the field. List of Mining Permits Monitored re: SHES Programs PROPONENT

PERMIT No.

Aglubang Mining Corp.

MPSA-167-2000-IV

Aglubang Mining Corp.

MPSA-277-2009-IVB

Aglubang Mining Corp.

MPSA-341-2010-IVB

LOCATION Oriental and Occidental Mindoro

Date of Monitoring May 16 - 21, 2016

123

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

List of Mining Permits Monitored re: SHES Programs PROPONENT

PERMIT No.

Alag-ag Mining, Inc. Agusan Petroleum and Minerals Corp. (APMC) Macroasia Corporation

MPSA-342-2010-IVB

MacroASia Corporation

MPSA-221-2005-IVB

Ipilan Nickel Corporation

LOCATION

Date of Monitoring

Or. Mindoro & Occ. Mindoro

May 19 - 21, 2016

Palawan

Sept.20-23, 2016

MPSA-017-2000-IV

Palawan

Sept. 20-23, 2016

Affluere Mineral Corp.

EP-003-2010-IVB

Marinduque

Oct. 27-29, 2016

Berong Nickel Corp.

MPSA 235-2007-IV

Palawan

Nov. 21-26, 2016

Citinickel Mines Dev’t. Corp.

MPSA-229-2007-IVB

Palawan

Nov.21-26, 2016

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

MPSA-114-98-IV

Palawan

Dec. 5-10, 2016

RTN Gotok Quarry Project

MPSA-213-2005-IVB

Palawan

Dec. 5-10, 2016

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

MPP-006

Palawan

Dec. 5-10, 2016

Unichamp Mineral Philippines, Inc.

MPP-15-2014-IVB

Palawan

Dec. 5-10, 2016

FTAA-003-2008-IVB MPSA220-2005-IVB

A.03.c.2.bStrengthen Multi-Partite Monitoring System Multipartite Monitoring Teams (MMTs) are being operationalized annually in all active mining operations to establish an appropriate check and balance mechanism in the monitoringof project implementation.Three (3) nickel mining companies, namely Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation (RTNMC), Berong Nickel Corporation (BNC), and Citinickel Mines and Development Corporation (CMDC), and two (2) nickel processing plants, Coral Bay Nickel Corporation (CBNC) and Unichamp Mineral Philippines, Inc., are being monitored quarterly by their respective Multipartite Monitoring Teams (MMTs) relative to their accomplishments on Safety, Health, Environment and Social Programs (SHES). Multi-Partite Monitoring Team (MMT) Validation Conducted Company Name Citinickel Mines & Devt. Corp.

1st Qtr. 2016

2nd Qtr 2016

3rd Qtr. 2016

Oct. 21-16, 2015

Jan. 25-30, 2016

Apr. 25-30, 2016

Jul 25-30, 2016

Berong Nickel Corp.

Oct. 21-16, 2015

Jan. 25-30, 2016

Apr. 25-30, 2016

Jul 18-23, 2016

Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corp.

Oct.26-Nov.1, 2015

Jan. 18-24, 2016

Apr.18-24, 2016

Aug. 1-6, 2016

RTN Gotok Quarry Project

Oct.26-Nov.1, 2015

Jan. 18-24, 2016

Apr.18-24, 2016

Aug. 1-6, 2016

Coral Bay Nickel Corp.

Oct.26-Nov.1, 2015

Jan. 18-24, 2016

Apr.18-24, 2016

Aug. 1-6, 2016

Unichamp Minerals Phils.

Oct.26-Nov.1, 2015

Jan. 18-24, 2016

Apr.18-24, 2016

Aug. 1-6, 2016

124

4th Qtr. 2015

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

A.03.c.3 Mine Rehabilitation Program Task Force Marcopper MGB-IVB conducted its regular quarterly monitoring of the structures and facilities of Marcopper. In addition to the above regular function of MSESDD-MGB MIMAROPA Region, technical personnel from this Office likewise look into any possible effect of the reported 3.2 magnitude – Intensity II earthquake in the province of Marinduque that occurred on August 24, 2016. According to the Philippine Institute of Volcanology and Seismology (PHIVOLCS), the epicenter is located 6 kilometers southwest of the municipality of Sta. Cruz, near the location of Marcopper Mining Corporation (MMC) and has a focus 5 kilometers beneath the surface. Objectives of the monitoring are as follows:  To visually assess the structural integrity of the mine structures and facilities; and  To determine presence of hazards that may pose threat to the environment and to the residents of the nearby communities.  To closely monitor and/or to have an update on the precarious status of MaguilaGuila Dam I.

Updated findings /observations A. Pit Lake The eastern wall of Tapian Pit is benched from top to bottom. Although the slope appears stable, based on the previous monitoring it was observed that the top portion of the slope is slowly eroding. During the 4 th quarter monitoring there was no remarkable accumulation of loose soil/sediments at the northeast and the eastern part of the Tapian Pit. The water level in the pit is almost the same as compared to the previous monitoring, although there was a heavy rainfall that occurs in the area during to the conduct of monitoring. The water from the pit is continuously draining through Tunnel 310 thus preventing the same from overtopping and discharges to Bol River. B. Tunnel 310 Water from Tapian Pit is discharged continuously through Tunnel 310 thence towards Bol River. The tunnel has a length of about 231 meters from inlet to outlet with a general trend of N20ºW. As of 4th quarter monitoring, there are no presence of fissures, damages or debris observed in the vicinity of the outlet of Tunnel 310 even after the reported a 3.2 magnitude – Intensity II earthquake

125

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

C. Bol River Dam Despite the prevalence of increased siltation in several portions of the water reservoir, Bol River dam and its spillway can still accommodate the volume of water discharged from Tunnel 310, including the surface water from upstream. Lower Makulapnit Dam is located below the southern rim of Tapian Pit. Based on the previous monitoring, it shows sign of active erosion. Nevertheless, during the 4th Quarter 2016 monitoring, there was no notable increase of loose soil/sediments observed. Furthermore, there was no breaching or damage along the embankment of the said dam. D. Upper Makulapnit Dam At the Upper Makulapnit Dam, the same observation as in the previous monitoring was noted. Water flows continuously through the spillway and exits at Boac River, hence, the dam has a low risk of overtopping. However, trees and woody vegetation are continuously growing in its vicinity and may cause the following:    E.

Roots may loosen soil embankment; Roots could also penetrate existing cracks in the embankment and could lead to internal erosion and seepage; and Uprooted trees may dislodge sizeable amount of embankment materials.

Hinapulan Creek At present, the water exiting in the lower and upper Makulapnit creeks converge at Hinapulan creek and exits to Boac River. Last 17 August 2016, the Local Government Unit of Boac reported bluish discoloration of the water in Boac River.

F.

San Antonio Pit Condition of the pit is observed stable and no noticeable hazards on the surrounding areas during inspection. Refer to Figures 18 and 19 for San Antonio Pit Lake and Discharge Channel 1 and 2. Further, it is noted that water inside the pit continuously flows through discharge channel 2 going to Mapalos creek. On the other hand, there is no water discharge at discharge channel 1 due to low water level at San Antonio Pit.

G.

North Dam (Old Tailings Storage Area) The North Dam or Old Tailings Storage Area is exposed to weathering and erosional process which resulted to gradual erosion of the unstable section of the northern portion of the dam. This process created channel openings and

126

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

eventually forms narrow valleys that triggered slope erosion such as gullying and block fall. Remnants of tailings from the Tapian pit operations are still present at the North Dam. The tailings deposit appears as small and greyish irregular dump and clay-like materials on the northern slope of the old impoundment facility. A constructed diversion channel, lined with concreted sand bags, connecting a creek (upper tributary of Mogpog River) and northern rim of San Antonio Pit is functional. Runoff coming from the creek is being diverted towards the pit lake to lessen the volume of water run-off passing through the breached area of the North Dam. The top portion of the canal had already eroded into the channel and these eroded materials could block the channel which could prevent runoff water from flowing towards San Antonio Pit Lake. H.

Maguila-guila Mine Waste Dump The materials at Maguila-guila waste dump are waste/overburden generated from the mining operations of MMC. These are composed of lightweight and porous materials. The porous materials are evident of water seepage which in due time would be saturated and may lead to erosion, such as; gullying and slumping. Furthermore, steeply sloped waterways and gullies are observed in the eastern portion of the waste dump.

I.

Maguila-guila Siltation Dam The Maguila-guila Siltation Dam is a decant structure that prevents soil/sediments erosion and large debris from Maguila-guila waste dump to be carried by riverine water/run-off to Mogpog River. The trash cage on the structure serves as strainer for large debris and the let the water pass through its openings then to the decant tunnel going to Mogpog River. Based on the previous monitoring, the structure is no longer functioning due to the piping failure of the decant tunnel and leads to backward erosion on the accumulated soil/sediments on the mouth of the structure that cause a sudden depression. At present, the following observations were listed down, as follows: 





Increased amount of siltation in the entire river channel which is attributed to the continuous erosion up stream and further aggravated by water current and excessive sediment supply originating from the Maguila-guila Mine Waste Dump; Expansion of the collapsed portion of the sediment storage facility near the earth dam and formation of deep narrow incised channels along t h e stream bed as a result of worsening subsurface flow and localized subsidence; The observed erosional features on the surface of the sediment storage facility has considerably drained the water from the

127

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report





temporary pond created by collapsing surface sediments; Slight increase of sediment accumulation at the Maguila-guila Drain Tunnel. The vertical clearance at the exit of the tunnel decreased from 1.30meters during the 3rd quarterly monitoring to 1.27 meters during the 4th quarterly monitoring; and Further deterioration of the Decant Structure, as evident on broken and transported concrete blocks, was observed near the drain tunnel.

II. GENERAL RECOMMENDATIONS A.

Tapian and San Antonio Pits 1. Detailed assessment of the integrity of dam structures must be undertaken; 2. Continuous monitoring of any indication of slope instability, such as; seepage, ground crack and mass movement within and around the dam facilities; 3. Identification of the potential hazard in all water impounding structures of MMC should be undertaken by dam experts. Hazard Potential is the potential losses to downstream interests, if a dam should fail for any reason; and 4. Determination of the volume capacity of the two pits in preparation for possible dewatering.

B.

Hinapulan Creek 1. With reference to the said concern, it is recommended to suggest to the Environmental Management Bureau - MIMAROPA Region (EMB MIMAROPA) to conduct stream sediments and water sampling at Hinapulan Creek to determine the probable cause of acidification of the riverine water, particularly during rainy days, and to determine the degree of the adverse effect of pollutants to the water quality and ecosystem in the area.

C.

Maguila-guila Creek 1. Dredging of waste materials in Maguila-Guila creek should be done in order to prevent further transport of waste materials downstream; and 2. Take sample and analyze the waste material to determine its grade and see if it is still economically viable for further processing.

D.

Maguila-guila Mine Waste Dump 1. Slope stabilization and erosion control measures are needed for immediate implementation to minimize the transport of sediment/soil that adds up to the worsening condition of the Maguila-guila Dam.

E.

Maguila-guila Dam 1. Immediate repair of the decant tunnel and trash cage preferably to its original condition or modification of the spillway to control the flow of water if the decant structure will be sealed;

128

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

2. In-depthanddetailedstructuralengineeringstudiesforlong-termplanning and buildingofsafety and mitigatingmeasures; and 3. Installation of gabion dams, with geotextile, downstream of Mogpog River to prevent soil/sediments deposited downstream. F.

Others: 1. With the technical assistance of competent persons, assessment on the vulnerability of the mining area to seismic-related hazards should be included in the monitoring activities due to the presence of the active Central Marinduque Fault; and 2. Degree of erosional processes must also be monitored and evaluated in all critical slopes associated with major structures, including the river systems around Marcopper mine area.

Prior to the regular quarterly monitoring, MGB-IVB regularly informed the LGU of Marinduque of the activity that will be conducted to enlist their participation in the monitoring. Unfortunately the focal person of the province was not able to join the regular monitoring. Nevertheless, no other than Representative Lord Allan Velasco of the Lone District of Marinduque and his staff joined in the monitoring during the 4th Quarter monitoring. QUARTERLY MONITORING

Mouth of tunnel 310 (left) and its drainage canal (right)

Eastern slope of the Maguila-guila waste dump

129

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Markers/sticks were placed to observe erosional process on north dam near San Antonio pit.

Deteriorated mouth of the Decant Structure

Landscape view of the land subsidence within the sediment storage facility of Maguila-guila Siltation Dam

130

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Investigation on subsidence/sediment collapse In addition to the quarterly monitoring, this Office conducted an investigation on the subsidence/sediment collapse within the siltation impoundment of Marcopper Mining Corporation in Maguila-guila Creek, Sitio Taluntunan, Brgy. Bocboc, Mogpog, Marinduque. Field Findings and Observations: 

The concentration of the field survey was confirmed only within the immediate vicinity of the reported landslide occurrence near the Maguilaguila creek and Maguila-guila Siltation Dam. According to the local residents, a weeklong of torrential rains was experienced in the locality;



The Maguila-guila creek and its tributaries were observed heavily silted. The source of materials accumulated in the river channel was attributed from the major slumping and gullying along the slope surface of Maguilaguila mine waste dump. These materials were brought downstream by exceptional water erosional force that contributed the vigorous siltation along the active waterways;



The reported landslide within the vicinity of Maguila-guila Siltation Dam of Marcopper Mining Corporation (MMC) on March 9, 2016 was an incident of riverbed collapse that happened at the sediment impounding area of Maguila-guila Siltation Dam which can be regarded as a form of land subsidence resulting from internal erosion and piping failure. Internal erosion occurred when extreme runoff percolated through large pore spaces in the sand materials and create seepage discharge surfaces within the sediments. Large seepage forces that usually occur along beds of gravel materials may have triggered piping failure causing the top bedload materials to collapse and form a circular depression on the surface. Though the disturbed sediment has no signs of seepage discharge across the earth dam, the possibility of underground flow that started from the nearby creek on the west towards the direction of the drain tunnel inlet on the east has been considered as the cause of subsidence, which significantly contributed to the increased sedimentation of the drain tunnel. The size of the disturbed area caused by land subsidence is measuring 35 meters in length from north to south and is presently filled up with stream water originating from the main river channel and tributary streams with an estimated maximum water depth of 2 to 3 meters;



Another possibility of the cause of subsidence was the failure of the concrete walls of the under drain of the decant tower due to continuous abrasive actions of silt-laden water flowing inside the drain tunnel. Increased hydraulic pressure has scoured the concrete walls of the structure causing it to breach and trigger sediment collapse. During the inspection, there were evidences of concrete floor scouring at the lower section of the decant tower, which was an indication that the concrete channel of the decant structure is deteriorating;

131

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report



Further evaluation of the structure showed that the highly silted drain tunnel of the decant tower poses the greatest threat as little regard was given to the rate at which will likely to silt up. Brisk siltation of the estimated 100-meter long drain tunnel is now apparentand if left unmaintained, continuous sediment build up may result to complete blocking of the drain inlet and incessant ponding of the sediment impounding area. This condition, if not remediated, could pose severe impact to the integrity of the earth dam specially its upstream section. Observation of sediment build up inside the drain tunnel disclosed a decreasing vertical clearance from 1.60 meters at the drain outlet to an estimated clearance of less than 0.5 meter near the inlet. These figures only show that sediments do not build up evenly along the horizontal base of the tunnel, which may create adverse problems when maintenance and clean-up activities are performed; and



It is also evident that most sections of the river upstream of the siltation dam cannot adjust continuously to massive sedimentation, thereby, disabling the channel to develop a form appropriate for the flows and sediment regime imposed on it. As a result, some of the exposed sediments that are flushed downstream become floodplains.

Remarks and Recommendations: The dam has now very limited floodwater and sediment storage capacity. Its catchment reservoir is now heavily-silted by bed-load materials that create great loads on the dam wall. Huge amount of sediment is attributed to high rate of erosion and increased sediment supply during large flood events. Large amount of sediments may eventually choke up the inlet tunnel of the siltation dam. This may cause diverting the stream flow of Maguila-guila creek towards the emergency spillway. 

 

    

132

Desilt the downstream area of the breached earth dam structure (North Dam) of the old tailings impoundment that used to contain the saturated Tapian Mine Tailings; Stabilize the slope surface of the 24-hectare highly erosive Maguila-guila Mine Waste Dump; All critical parts of the Maguila-guila river systems, from upstream to downstream, should be regularly dredged to avoid spreading of floodwater along active floodplain during period of incessant rainfall; De-clog or dredge the heavily-silted drain tunnel of the decant tower; Undertake remediation measures to address the deteriorating condition of the decant tower and its under drain; Dewater and cover the disturbed sediment storage area caused by land subsidence; Construct a diversion canal to prevent surface water from running onto disturbed area of the sediment storage facility; Repair the decant tower and under drain of Maguila-guila Siltation Dam; and

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region



Implement necessary actions to prevent adverse negative impacts on the lives and properties of the inhabitants residing downstream.

INVESTIGATION ON THE SUBSIDENCE WITHIN MAGUILA-GUILA SILTATION DAM

Location Map of the Landslide Affected Area in the Municipality of Santa Cruz/Mogpog, Marinduque

Topographic Map of the Landslide Affected Area in the Municipality of Santa Cruz/Mogpog, Marinduque

133

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Google Earth Sattelite Image Showing the Location of Major Facilities of Maguila-guila Siltation Dam Located in Sitio Taluntunan, Brgy Bocboc, Mogpog, Marinduque

Decant Structure Trash Cage Area covered by land subsidence Maguila-guila creek

Picture of the heavily sedimented Maguila-guila creek, decant structure and the land subsidence within Maguila-guila Siltation Dam of Marcopper Mining Corporation (MMC)

134

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Evidence of wall scouring was noted at the decant tower which lead to a possibility that the decant tower structure is deteriorating

Picture of the outlet of the drain tunnel

135

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Photo of sediment build-up inside the drain tunnel of Maguila-guila decant structure

A.03.c.4 Resolution of Complaints/Cases Conflicts From January to December 2016, eleven (11) complaints related to mining, safety, health and environment were filed by concerned individuals/stakeholders to this Office. These were promptly and judiciously investigated. 1. Field investigation on the reported ongoing road works in the Mt. Mantalingahan protected landscape (MMPL) in the Province of Palawan The Hon. Douglas S. Hagedorn, 3rd District Representative of Palawan, made a letter-request to the Office of the DENR Secretary Ramon J. Paje pertaining to the alleged road works and the possible illegal expansion of an existing mining operation, or the intrusion of new mining activities in the MMPL area. The said letter was received by this Office on 3 December 2015 thru a Memorandum from the Director of MGB-CO. In this connection, RD Roland de Jesus instructed Engr. Alvin S. Requimin and Engr. Elmer R. Crisologo to conduct an investigation on January 25-29, 2016. The MGB-IVB team was accompanied by the technical personnel and staff under MMPL Monitoring Team of CENRO-Quezon, Palawan. When coordination with CENRO-Quezon was made, it was learned that there are Forest Rangers employed under the created MMPL Monitoring Unit of their office to monitor and guard the protected area. Their Office did not receive any report regarding the road work activities inside the MMPL except for the construction of Farm to Market road connecting different sitios in Brgy. Ransang and its adjoining barangay in Rizal, Palawan.

136

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

During the investigation, it was found out that the road works in the area are improvement of Farm to Market road being undertaken by the Provincial Government Office (PGO) of Palawan. The said Farm to Market road is about 5 to 7 kilometers from the provincial road and asserted to be outside the MMPL. In addition, there is a clearing activity being undertaken by the PGO. The said clearing is a proposed primary school site and is located hillside of the provincial road connecting municipalities of Rizal and Bataraza, Palawan. It has an approximate area of 0.38 hectares and is found to be outside the MMPL. Coordination and consultation with CMDC situated in Sofronio Espanola, with its mining area within and/or adjoining/adjacent to MMPL, disclosed that no road work expansion are undertaken inside MMPL. Moreover, as per this Office’s record, no exploration permit(s) were issued in the municipalities of Quezon and Rizal, Palawan adjacent to MMPL. 2. Investigation on the subsidence / sediment collapse incidence within the siltation impoundment of Marcopper Mining Corporation in Maguila-guila creek, SitioTaluntunan, Brgy. Bocboc, Mogpog, Marinduque Initial Investigation on the subsidence/sediment collapse was undertaken by technical personnel of this Office on March 16-19, 2016. A follow-up investigation was done on April 26 - 30, 2016). Details of the said investigation can be found under Task Force Marcopper. 3. Investigation on the reported submergence of Nickel Corporation’s (BNC)

LCT Mark Jason at Berong

This Office received a Spot Report from BNC dated 17 March 2016 regarding the submergence of LCT Mark Jason at the company’s old pier. On March 18, 2016, Engr. Irwin P. Martinez and Engr. Noel L. Masangkay proceeded to Brgy. Berong, Quezon, Palawan to conduct an investigation on the reported submergence. The MGB-IVB team was joined by personnel from the Palawan Council for Sustainable Development (PCSD) to conduct water sampling and to assess the impact/damage caused by the incident. The said LCT is loaded with 1,120 WMT of Nickel Ore and 4,000 liter of fuel as per company’s Spot Report. In addition, the incident happened on 17 March 2017 at 0400H wherein water intruded the vessel causing it to submerge partially at the old pier area. During the investigation on 18 March 2016, the MGB-IVB team noted a discoloration on the sea/body of water of BNC’s pier area. The discoloration of water caused by ore spillage from LCT Mark Jason was approximately 14 hectares. On March 19, 2016, the discoloration disappeared almost one hundred percent compared to the previous day. However, traces of reddish brown particles in some segments of the coastline were observed when strong waves struck the coastline and the materials were agitated due to wave action. In addition, a fisherman noticed a coin-sized floating brown materials partly covered by bubbles and smelled like diesel fuel. The MGB-IVB team suspected that the materials were fine laterite particles mixed with diesel fuel. It was recommended to the company to immediately retrieve the remaining nickel ore on the partially submerged LCT to prevent further damage to the marine environment, traces of silt materials on the body of water should be suctioned, day to day environmental activities should be undertaken, conduct coastal resource

137

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

assessment in coordination with PCSD and to submit reports on baseline and previous coastal resource assessment for comparison purposes. Moreover, the company, thru its service contractor, was recommended to immediately afloat the vessel to avoid oil leak and oil spill boon should be put in place before commencing the refloating activity to prevent escape of oil. Investigation on March 18, 2016

Coco logs laid at sea to filter silt materials. Murky/to turbid Geo-textile filter cloth to be laid out as well. water was also noted

Water sampling activity conducted by PCSDS. Parameter to be considered: heavy metals,TSS, DO, color, oil and grease.

MARCH 19, 2016

Clear water noted at the pier area two (2) days after the incident

138

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

New coco logs being prepared for replacement

Silted portion of the sea about 100m from the pier area

4. Investigation Report Regarding the Resolution Requesting the Department of Environment and Natural Resources – Mines and Geosciences Bureau (DENRMGB) for the Conduct of Investigation on the Appropriateness of the Mining Areas Claimed by Ipilan Nickel Corporation, Macro Asia and Lebach in the Municipality of Brooke’s Point, Palawan and to Recall any Permits Issued Thereby Deferring any Operations of the said Mining Companies While the Issues have not been Settled. Field Findings and Recommendations: 1. The over deposition of transported river aggregates may not only decrease the capacity of the dam to impound water, it can also pose danger to its structure and eventually breakdown. Thus, Sabsaban and Maasin Irrigation Dams should be dredged in order to effectively impound water for irrigation purposes and to protect the dam from being damaged. Consent/clearance from National Irrigation Authority (NIA) should be secured prior to any dredging activities that will be undertaken. 2. The INC should be obliged to help in the maintenance of the irrigation dams as part of their corporate social responsibility and/or the maintenance may likewise form part of the social development management program of the company. 3. The Local Government Unit concerned should immediately issue a Cease and Desist Order against individuals conducting unauthorized and unsystematic quarrying activities as this will threaten the integrity of the irrigation dam. 4. The identified watersheds are located within highly susceptible to landslide zones as per MGB Geohazard Maps. Thus, landslide will occur naturally with or without human activities within these watershed areas. Landslides can be controlled and/or addressed by engineering remediation, such as slope stabilization, rock support, etc.

139

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

5. It is therefore highly recommended that engineering design and intervention of highest standards to control landslides should be applied by INC, which should be included in the company’s Environmental Protection and Enhancement Program (EPEP). 6. Since portions of blocked/defined mine pits fall within the watershed of Mambalot (12.79%) and Maasin (0.03%) Irrigation Dams, mining operation may potentially increase the silt load of run-offs coming from these watersheds. 7. In this regard, sufficient number of in-pit siltation control ponds must be established by INC, in order to mitigate, if not eliminate, siltation coming from mining operations. Furthermore, these siltation ponds may be used as a reservoir wherein the clean water may be recycled and utilized to augment the supply of water for irrigation of farm lots especially during dry season. 8. Should INC will be allowed to operate, it is hereby recommended that progressive block mining should be implemented to mine out each block in order to minimize surface clearing. Moreover, immediate progressive rehabilitation of mined-out areas should be undertaken to bring back the lost areas of the watersheds. 9. The water system and all irrigation dams should be protected from environmental degradation that mining activities may cause. Hence, should INC will be allowed to operate, in addition to the Contingent Liability and Rehabilitation Fund (CLRF), environmental guarantee trust funds should be established together with the concerned LGU to ensure just and timely compensation for damages and progressive and sustainable rehabilitation for any adverse effect a mining operation or activity may cause. 10. Mining concessions and/or agreements in the municipality of Brooke’s Point, Palawan (with denomination as Mineral Production Sharing Agreement or MPSA) were already granted during 90’s under Republic Act No. 7942 known as the “Philippine Mining Act of 1995” prior to the composition of the CLUP of the municipality. Since these mining tenements/areas are existing and it covered about 5%-6% of the total land area of the municipality of Brooke’s Point, its land use should also be included/ reflected in the general land use of the municipality. 11. The INC should confer with the irrigators-farmers directly affected by the mining project and come up with a written agreement that will address their issues and concerns, copy furnished this Office. The terms and conditions provided in the agreement shall be part of the social responsibility of the mining company to the irrigators-farmers and may likewise form part of the social development management program of the company. 12. The company should honor any legal tenurial instruments that the affected families may possess, and the rights conferred by and may be inferred therefrom.

140

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Locations of the mining tenement areas in Brooke’s Point, Palawan

5. Field investigation on the discoloration of Berong in Brgy. Berong, Quezon, Palawan During monitoring of nickel ore shipment of BNC on June 23, 2016 conducted by Engr. Alvin S. Requimin and Engr. Elmer R. Crisologo, discoloration of seawater was noted. The extent of discoloration was estimated to be beyond 500 meters from the shoreline with a lateral extent of 3 kilometers. The matter was brought to the company and an investigation was subsequently undertaken by the MGB-IVB team. Intermittent heavy rain occurred during the time of investigation wherein surface run-off in the locality were traceable including the swelling of rivers/creeks. The investigation revealed that silt ponds in the active mine pit area were observed intact and capable of containing/trapping surface run-offs. Upon inspection of rivers draining to the sea, it was found that Llabongan River is the source of murky and silted/discolored water. Incidentally, one of the upstream tributary of Llabongan River, the Marangreg River, was found to be the source of highly silted and discolored water. According to the Company’s Environmental Officer, the Kukukon Silt Pond was installed in the upstream of Marangreg River to contain excess run-offs from the active mine pit area and run-offs from SOREX hauling road (active access road utilized by the company from pier yard to mine site area). However, it was observed that only run-offs from the upper SOREX road are contained in the silt pond while the lower SOREX directly drained to the downstream Marangreg River. Thus, the main source of siltation that cause the discoloration of the water body were from the surface run-offs of SOREX road. The company was advised that silt ponds should be installed in the affected tributary creeks of Marangreg River upstream from the river junction to contain run-

141

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

offs from the lower SOREX road as well as larger silt pond in the mine pit area to increase its capacity to contain run-offs during rainy season. In addition, further monitoring of the source of discoloration should be determined and corrective measure should be immediately undertaken. Relative to the above reported discoloration, operation of BNC was suspended by MGB-IVB and has remained suspended to date. Nevertheless, validation of the company’s compliance to the conditions of the Suspension Order by the Rapid Reaction Team (RRT) and the regular Multipartite Monitoring Team (MMT) showed that BNC has substantially complied with the said conditions and recommendation for the lifting of the Suspension Order was forwarded to MGB-CO. 6. Field Investigation on the Complaint of Atty. Alfredo Muniz as endorsed by Senior Police Officer 2 Seriolito V. Dimaranan, Deputy Chief of Police/OIC of Lubang Municipal Police Station regarding the alleged illegal quarrying activity of a certain private contractor In response to the letter from SPO2 Seriolito V. Dimaranan Deputy Chief of Police of Lubang Municipal Station, requesting for an urgent investigation regarding the complaint of Atty. Alfredo T. Muniz on the alleged illegal quarrying activities on the municipality of Lubang, On July 6 to 11, 2016 MGB-MIMAROPA sent Engr. Mario W. Alban and Engr. Markus Peter Q. Mantubig and was joined by For. Orlino B. Gacuan of Provincial Environmental and Natural Resources Office, and Mr. Hernan Alfaro and Mr. Joseph Maranan both, of the Environmental and Natural Resources Office of Provincial Government to conduct an investigation on the said matter. During the conduct of the investigation there were at least eight (8) quarry areas observed located in different barangays in the Municipality. Limestone materials were excavated from the said quarry areas and were used as filling materials in several road construction projects of the Municipality of Lubang.The quarrying operations conducted in the different barangays within the Island Municipality of Lubang are considered illegal due to the absence of any mining or quarry permit. Moreover, some of the excavated areas are located near the municipal roads. If such activities remained unabated, these may cause destruction of the newly constructed municipal roads due to erosion. The concerned company was verbally advised to stop its illegal activities. Based on the foregoing, the investigation team hereby recommended, without prejudice to the filing of appropriate legal action/charges; 1. To issue CDO against all the illegal operators; 2. For the provincial government to impose penalties of reasonable amount for the extracted materials and damage caused to the environment; and 3. For the provincial government to order the rehabilitate of excavated area within one (1) km radius pursuant to Sec. 79.a of DAO 2010-21

142

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

which states that, “No extraction, removal and/or disposition of materials shall be allowed within a distance of one (1) kilometer from the boundaries of xxx, public or private works or structures. 7. Investigation on the alleged illegal gold panning activities in Brgy. Caramay, Roxas, Palawan BACKGROUND: The complaint was raised by Barangay Chairman Gil Saclet of Caramay, Roxas, Palawan against the alleged illegal gold panning activities during the People’s Organizations and Civil Society Forum with the DENR Secretary in Palawan on 22 July 2016. In response to the complaint, two technical personnel from this office were sent to Roxas, Palawan to conduct an investigation together with personnel from the CENRO, Bantay-Palawan, ENRO, PMRB, PCSD and the Barangay LGU. According to Chairman Saclet, gold panning activities in the gold rush area in SitioNanabu, Caramay have contributed to the siltation of the Caramay River that caused damage to the fishing grounds of the residents in the lowland. Moreover, he mentioned that gold panning activities in the upstream of the river caused the discoloration of the river system. FINDINGS: Remnants and fresh riverbed extractions were noted in the Caramay River within the jurisdiction of SitioNanabu. Disturbed riverbeds were noted as proof of previous unsystematic sluicing and panning activities to recover free gold from riverbeds. Diversion canals alongside the river were established as sluicing areas in lieu of sluice boxes. Alluvial materials are dislodged thru hydraulicking wherein the river banks were subjected to a pressurized water to loosen alluvial riverbank walls. Dislodged alluvial deposits were then directed towards a sluice box to collect gold concentrate for panning and final gold recovery. The muddy water from this activity is directly drained to the river system causing heavy siltation. A thick deposit of silt was observed in the downstream of the Caramay River. Based on the interviews, the miners did not utilize mercury in gold recovery. The team observed that there are no manifestation of mercury contamination. According to the respondents, the gold mining activity is one source of livelihood of the residents in the area. They further mentioned that eight (8) groups were actively operating in the area having 4 to 6 persons per group. The residents expressed their concern regarding their alternative livelihood if the gold mining activity is stopped.

143

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS: The gold mining activity in the area is an active gold rush area where at least 50 miners are involved and is confined within the stretch of 4 km of the Caramay River. The said activity is considered illegal since the miners are operating without a permit. The method of extraction, hydraulicking, is outlawed pursuant to Section 13, Item c.3 of DAO 2015-03. Finally, the operation is a violation of the SangguniangPanlalawigan Resolution No. 7728-08 declaring a 25-year moratorium in the issuance of endorsements of new small-scale mining activities in the province of Palawan. It is recommended that the individuals involved in the gold mining activity in the area be issued a Cease and Desist Order (CDO) to avoid further damage to the environment. An alternative livelihood program must also be in place and be provided by the Government. It is further suggested that the barangay officials and PNP personnel in the area be deputized as Deputized Environment and Natural Resources Officers for Mines to monitor the area and to apprehend illegal miners. Lastly, water sampling of river system is also recommended to determine the presence of mercury, heavy metals and other parameters for water quality.

Active river bank extraction employing hydraulicking method

Gold pan (right) is used for final recovery of gold nuggets from the concentrate collected from the sluice box (left).

144

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Thick silt materials and discoloration of water bodies along caramay river are some of the adverse effects of gold extraction activities

8. Alleged fatal mine accident in Sitio Hanggan, San Fernando, Romblon BACKGROUND: In response to the reported fatal accident of two (2) miners on 20 August 2016, this Office sent two technical personnel to conduct an investigation on August 22-27, 2016. The investigating team was composed of MGB personnel, accompanied Mr. Gary Ribot, Philippine Army Reservist and guide; Mr. Allan Joseph Falo, Inspector of PMRB-Romblon; and three (3) personnel from the Sibuyan Sub-Station and Protected Area Office (SSSPAO) of Mt. Guiting-GuitingNatural Park (MGGNP), namely: Messsrs. Bernie A Soguilon, Forest Tech II; Rogelio M. Agcaoili, Forest Ranger; and LudwinRuado, Forest Ranger. Prior to fieldwork, coordination with the following officials were undertaken to gather vital information on the cause of the alleged fatal mine accident, namely: Hon. Guillermo Rocha, Vice Mayor of Magdiwang, Romblon, Hon. Joven R. Rodeo, Chairman of Brgy. Dulangan, Magdiwang, Romblon, Police Inspector Kim MarabeBadillo of PNP – Magdiwang, Romblon, and Forester Malvin R. Rocero, OIC, Sibuyan Sub-Station and Concurrent Protected Area Superintendent (PASu) of MGGNP. FINDINGS: 





The alleged area where the fatal accident occurred was centered by geographic coordinates: N12° 26´14ʺ and E 122° 28´ 32ʺ at an elevation of more than 500 meters above sea level. It is located inside the Protected Area of Mount Guiting-Guiting Natural Park and is within the political jurisdiction of Brgy. Mabini, San Fernando, Romblon. The site was found near the top of a cliff about 35-40 meters high from the river. A North trending 60-meter drop waterfalls is a prominent landmark in the area situated about ten meters East of the alleged site. None of the miners were around when the team arrived in the morning of August 24, 2016. However, evidence of recent activity were observed in the site. The site is located near the top of a cliff which was found to be almost vertical and made from bedrock that is highly fractured. Apparently, series of

145

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report











fracturing/fissures were observed on the exposed bedrock which was relatively trending Northwest and dipping Southwest. The distance of fracturing was almost uniform measuring about ten (10) centimeters apart from each other and appeared as inclined beds leaning towards the site where the victims were allegedly found. Signs of weathering and erosion on the slopes of the cliff were observed as evidenced by grasses and shrubs clinging along the cliff. A small cut was carved out from the cliff to form a pathway of less than a meter which leads to the mine working area. The width of the working area (platform) including the pathway was about 150 centimeters measured from the rock face/wall to the edge of the cliff which while the length was about two hundred centimeters with no barriers or railings installed. Detached slabs of rock were found in the working area which was apparently brought by the collapse of the cliff wall. The biggest debris found on the floor was a slab measuring about 50 cm x 60 cm x 25 cm believed to have pinned down one of the miners to his death. The other miner may have miscalculated his footing during the accident and unfortunately fell from the cliff and caused his death. The corpse of Mr. Rodrigo Ragas Dianco, one of the victims did not undergo post mortem examination according to the medical personnel of the Health Care Center in Magdiwang, Romblon who prepared the Death Certificate due to refusal of the relatives of the victim. Consequently, the resident physician then demanded one of the victim’s kin to sign a waiver and requested the Chairman of Barangay Dulangan, Magdiwang, Romblon to witness, while there was no available information in the case of the other victim. Historically, mine accident victims usually do not undergo post mortem examination according to the PNP because no one bothers to question the death of these victims and foul play is usually ruled out.

CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS: The most probable cause of the accident was the collapse of some part of the cliff wall/rock slab destabilized by undermining. The constant pounding of the sledgehammer on the bedrock may have induced the rock slab to fall as the miners were trying to dig materials from below, pinning one of the miners to his death. The unsafe condition of the mining area which was very close to the cliff edge may have caused the second victim to fall to his death. In view of the foregoing, hereunder are the recommendations in order to prevent the recurrence of such incident in the future: 1. Seal off all entry points to mine working areas/stopes located inside the protected area either by backfilling the mine openings with waste materials or controlled blasting which may be subject for approval of the Protected Area Management Board (PAMB). 2. Strategically install hidden Closed Circuit TV cameras in the area to monitor trespassers and thereby be used as evidence during filing of cases.

146

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

3. Apprehend identified non-accredited BSP gold buyers in the Municipalities of Magdiwang and San Fernando, Romblon by means of entrapment operation with the assistance of the NBI pursuant to BSP regulation on gold buying. 9. Field investigation on the conflict/overlapping of commercial Sand and Gravel Permit Applications situated in Sitio Kinse Diaz, Brgy. Guadalupe, Coron, Palawan BACKGROUND: The undertaking is in response to the undated letter of Mr. Jorge C. Paterno, addressed to this Office, which was sent through e-mail on 29 July 2016, regarding the event that transpired in the meeting dated 28 July 2016 at the Mayor’s Office of Coron, Palawan, and with the result of PMRB meeting dated 16 September 2016 wherein the above subject matter was tackled for investigation. Two technical personnel were instructed to conduct the said investigation on September 20 to 23, 2016. The issue is the conflict/overlapping of Commercial Sand and Gravel (CSAG) Permit Applications of Mr. Sam Fabia and Mr. Jimmy Mandap situated in Labangan River, SitioKinse Diaz, Bgy. Guadalupe, Busuanga Island, municipality of Coron, province of Palawan. The site inspection was conducted by the MGB personnel together withFor. Mark Glenn T. Managdag, Forester I of Community Environment and Natural Resources Office (CENRO) - Coron, Palawan; Barangay Chairman Richard G. Badang of Bgy. Guadalupe, Coron, Palawan; Mr. AbelardoLogronio, representative of Mr. Jimmy Mandap, Jorge Paterno, original lot owner of the conflicted area. FINDINGS: Traces of sand and gravel extraction were noted in Labangan River. Near the extraction area, two (2) stockpile areas of aggregate materials were noted. According to Barangay Chairman Badang, said stockpiles were owned by Mr. Sam Fabia and certain Mr. Tan. The stockpiles which were approximately 100 cu. meter volume each were originated from the adjacent Labangan River. Unsystematic sand extraction can be noted within the stretch of Labangan River since no buffer zone was maintained to protect the adjacent lots. Actual extractions were undertaken along the side of the river banks causing to erode. Irregular depth of extractions was also noted causing the river flow to irregularly meander that affects and cause riverbank scouring. Using handheld Global Positioning System (GPS) equipment, the investigating team had located in the area of the actual extraction area of Mr.Fabia and the actual positions of the river banks of Labangan River in the contested area. Upon plotting of the GPS readings, the CSAG applied areas and the private lot shows the following:

147

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report



Portions of the CSAG Permit application area of Mr.Mandap are not covered by river system which is within inland private properties and traversing the present western side riverbank of Labangan River.



Larger portion of the extraction area of Mr. Fabia is outside his CSAG application area.



Portion of the CSAG application area of Mr. Fabia is covered by the lot owned by Mr. Paterno and Mr. Mandap.

COMMENTS AND RECOMMENDATION: 

 

If a permit is granted/issued to the CSAG application area of Mr. Fabia, the actual extraction of sand and gravel should be made within the in-land private properties including riverbank which is along the western side of the Labangan River. These said extractions will cause the possible widening of river system in the area that can be considered as environmentally destructive. Consent from the lot owner should be required prior to the entry of the CSAG operators. A systematic extraction of sand and gravel along the river bed is necessary as part of dredging work for a flood control activity. A commercial sand and gravel permit application covering the exact river bed area can be allowed for this purpose.

10. Request for Suspension and Survey of All Sand and Gravel Quarries in Palawan Pursuant to the instruction of the Regional Director of this Office, legal and technical personnel conducted investigation and ocular inspection of the disused Magarwak City Quarry in Bgy. Sta. Lourdes, Puerto Princesa City on November 10-11, 2016 and November 21, 2016, respectively. This is in response to the Letter of Mr. Jose Maria Mirasol, Managing Director of Advocate for Excellent Government, A.C.S.O. (Civil Society Organization), requesting for the suspension and survey of all sand and gravel quarries in Palawan. In the aforesaid Letter, Mr. Mirasol raised three (3) issues, to wit: 1. The lifting of the 20-year moratorium at Sitio Magarwak, Bgy. Sta. Lourdes, where the City Quarry is located, by virtue of City Ordinance No. 757  Mr. Mirasol alleged that the City Quarry and private quarries in Magarwak were shut down by the previous administration because of overextraction, and because the area is designated as a watershed. Based on the Watershed Map of Puerto Princesa City, the City Quarry is not situated within the major rivers and catchment areas in the Watersheds of Puerto Princesa City. The identified major rivers from North to South of Puerto Princesa City are as follows: Langogan River Babuyan River, Sabang River, Cabayugan River, Bacungan River, Irawan River, Montible River, and Inagawan River.

148

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

2. The validity of the reason given for the lifting of the moratorium  Mr. Mirasol questioned the validity of the reason given for the lifting of the moratorium. According to him, the City Government of Puerto Princesa justified its action due to the demand for aggregates required for national government projects, in particular the Puerto Princesa Airport Development Project. He claimed that the project is nearing completion and is scheduled to be turned over by January 2017, thus, it cannot be a valid reason for the action. Based on the Situational Analysis conducted by the Provincial Government-Environment and Natural Resources Office (PG-ENRO) of Palawan, the major producers of sand and gravel are Narra and Aborlan with increasing annual volume. The main market of Aborlan and Narra is the City of Puerto Princesa. Despite the distance of Puerto Princesa City from the municipalities of Aborlan and Narra, transporters of sand and gravel materials were enticed to supply the City with sand materials in view of the demand and higher price of the commodity. Accordingly, the demand of aggregate materials is steadily increasing in view of construction boom in Puerto Princesa and other places in Palawan. 3. Possible sources of aggregates to address the demand for government projects  In his Letter, Mr. Mirasol suggested to suspend extractions until after the survey and inspection of all existing quarries to ascertain the true state of aggregate resources is completed. Meanwhile, he suggested that the demand for aggregates required for government projects can be supplied from nearby provinces, like Mindoro and Antique, which some contractors have already been doing. Based on the results of the situational analysis conducted, the Provincial Government-Environment and Natural Resources Office suggested to consider other sources of aggregates other than from the rivers such as from private/public lands in low or higher grounds. In addition, they likewise recommended that the services of Mines and Geosciences Bureau may be requested for the evaluation of the area as to the geology and physical characteristics of rocks suited for construction purposes. Salient results of the quarry inspection conducted at the site with recommendation are as follows: 



The location of the 11-hectare quarry ground is about 4.5 kilometers north of the barangay proper of Sta. Lourdes. It lies on the lower drainage basin of Magarwak and covers only a meager 1.15% of the 950-hectare Magarwak River Watershed. The water falling on steeply-sloped land, where the City Quarry is located, runs off quickly towards the coastal area, thus, decreasing the possibility of heavy metal release to surface and groundwaters. There are no major water bodies traversing the rock quarry site

149

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report







making it less vulnerable to the adverse impacts of fluvial hazards. The nearest natural drainage in the area is the downstream portion of Magarwak River about 30 meters across the national highway on the northeast. The quarry area is drained only by small intermittent stream and a number of gullies and slope channels which serve as waterways for runoffs. Previous quarry operation had no direct impact on the streamflow patterns of the nearby Magarwak River located below the quarry site. This only indicates that the downstream river was not disturbed by previous quarry operation at the lower basin area. Although the rock quarry is located close to the major road infrastructure of the city, it is still not part of the environmentallysensitive, residentially-zoned neighborhood. If extraction of the same quality of aggregate materials will be pursued in the nearby areas, it is recommended that the adjacent ridge-like landform located southwest of the City Quarry site be assessed to determine new positive source of rock aggregates. Preparation and development of a good mining plan for new quarry site must be done in case extension of extraction activities will be approved.

11. Investigation on the alleged illegal quarrying at Brgy. Apurawan, Aborlan, Palawan BACKGROUND: In response to a text message from the Office of the Secretary of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR), The Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB) – MIMAROPA Region, assisted by the PMRBP headed by Mr. Fernando D. Morante, Jr. and the armed personnel from the Philippine National Police and the security of the Office of the Provincial Governor of Palawan, conducted an investigation to validate the report of Provincial Mining Regulatory Board of (PMRB) Palawan (PMRBP) about the illegal quarrying in Barangays Apurawan and Culandanum of the Municipality of Aborlan, Province of Palawan. FINDINGS: It appears that the illegal quarrying activities were conducted by the contractors hired by the DPWH in its various construction projects. Hence, confiscation of the quarried materials pursuant to the pertinent provision of Section 118 of DAO No. 2010-21 is not feasible because it would mean digging the filling materials spread across the project and thereby delaying the said government project. RECOMMENDATION: This Office recommends that the monitoring staff involved should be suspended for the blatant disregard of their duties. They should be thoroughly investigated to verify if there were no connivance between them and the illegal quarry contractors. If found guilty, then an appropriate case should be filed against them. The Punong Barangays, allegedly dropping the name of the Governor, should

150

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

likewise be investigated. They should not be allowed to malign a person in authority. It disappoints the community and disgraces the Office of the Governor. The DPWH should be advised to clear the source of materials used by its contractors in its construction projects. It should be informed that any entity who needs to extract quarry materials should first secure the pertinent appropriate permit from the concerned Government agency pursuant to the mining laws as well as its implementing rules and regulations. The personalities who did not respond or with an unacceptable response to the 02 November 2016 CDO issued by the PMRBP should be held liable for Theft of Minerals pursuant to Section 103 of the Republic Act No. 7942, otherwise known as the Philippine Mining Act of 1995.

A.03.c.5 Anti-Illegal Mining 

Illegal mining sites with Cease and Desist Order (CDO) issued/implemented a. On June 21, 2016, this Office issued a Cease and Desist Order (CDO) against Mr. Joel Rosa, Mr. Manolito Teologo, Mr. Eduardo Fabila and Mr. Rogelio Rosa, all residing at Brgy. Pato-o, Odiongan, Romblon. The CDO was issued based on the result of the investigation conducted by the Deputized Environment and Natural Resources Officers (DENROs) for Mines in coordination with the Provincial Government of Romblon through the Environment and Natural Resources Office. The investigation rooted from a letter of the Barangay Council and Barangay Chairman requesting for an investigation on the alleged illegal mining in Sitio Silangan, Brgy. Pato-o, Odiongan, Romblon. Five sites of scattered shallow digging/ excavation were observed in the vicinity near a creek with two (2) pieces of different sizes of wooden duyang and two (2) pieces of UPVC pipes, which were accordingly confiscated by the DENROs for Mines. The ball mill, an equipment use to process gold, was not confiscated for lack of available vehicle to transport the same, instead its pulley, cover and lock were detached and confiscated so that the ball mill will no longer be used by the illegal miners. A criminal case for Illegal Exploration under Section 102 of CDAO 2010-21 or the IRR of RA 7942 will be filed before the Office of the Provincial Prosecutor of Romblon, against the above-mentioned individuals by the DENROs for Mines who participated in the investigation and confiscation, to be assisted by MGB RIVB. b. On August 1, 2016, this Office issued a Cease and Desist Order (CDO) against Mr. Rowel Q. Catuday, Mr. Edgar Caabas, Sps. Rodulfo and Marlyn Caabas, Ms. Celsa Yara, Mr. Toto Pantolinao, Mr. Victor Timario, Mr. Enting Francisco, Mr. Milven Santiago and Mr. Dodong Jumuad, all residing at So. Nanabu, Brgy.

151

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Caramay, Roxas, Palawan, pursuant to a report of illegal gold panning being conducted in Brgy. Caramay, Roxas, Palawan. The mineral extracted was 18 karat Gold sold at Php1,500 per gram to a certain Mr. Chito Manabat, a gold buyer in Roxas, Palawan. The mining activities conducted constitute violation of Section 102 of R.A. 7942 for Illegal Exploration, violation of Section 103 of R.A. 7942 for Theft of Minerals, Hydraulicking method of extraction prohibited under Section 13c(3) of DAO 2015-03 and violation of Sangguniang Panlalawigan Resolution No. 772808 declaring a 25-year moratorium for small-scale mining activities in the province of Palawan. c. On August 16, 2016, this Office issued a Cease and Desist Order (CDO) against Mr. Santiago “Jun Jun” Tria and Engr. Glenn Alvarez, both residing at Lubang, Occidental Mindoro. Based on the field findings of the investigating team spearheaded by the technical personnel of this Office, the above-named persons were found to be undertaking quarrying operation without a valid clearance/permit in several areas of Lubang, Occidental Mindoro. Such acts constitute a violation of Section 103 of R.A. 7942 for Theft of Minerals and Section 79.a of DAO 2010-21 which states that “No extraction, removal and/or disposition of materials shall be allowed within a distance of one (1) kilometer from the boundaries of xxx, public or private works or structures, unless the prior clearance of the government agency(ies) concerned or owner is obtained. 

Complaints/Charges filed with the Provincial/City Prosecutors office COMPLAINANTS: RAYNALDO ANGEL M. DE JUAN, BERNIE G. TIAGA, PAULINO P. FABON III, NORWOOD N. FALCULAN, DENNIS F. MAGNO AND EDGAR F. FOS RESPONDENTS:

JOEL ROSA, ROGELIO ROSA, MANOLITO TEOLOGO, JOELEM TEOLOGO MAESTRO AND EDUARDO FABILA

WITNESSES: COMPLAINANTS LIKEWISE SERVED AS WITNESSES CASE FILED: ILLEGAL EXPLORATION (SEC. 102, R.A. 7942) DATE FILED: JUNE 30, 2016 Engr. Raynaldo Angel M. De Juan, Engr. Bernie G. Tiaga, Paulino P. Fabon III, Norwood N. Falculan and Dennis F. Magno, as Environment and Natural Resources Officers and Staff, respectively, and as Deputized Environment and Natural Resources Officers of Mines and Geosciences Bureau, confiscated the following articles: diesel engine, pulley, PVC, duyang, ball mill cover and ball mill lock used by the above-named respondents in the conduct of illegal mining in Sitio

152

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Silangan, Brgy. Pato-o, Odiongan, Romblon on February 22, 2016 at around 8:30 in the morning. COMPLAINANT: CITY GOVERNMENT OF PUERTO PRINCESA represented by HON. LUCILO R. BAYRON RESPONDENT:

JOSE MARIA MIRASOL

WITNESSES: LOLITO A. JUAN CARDELAR STEVIE ANGEL M. MADRIÑAN PALERMO L. BANGLOY ELGINO V. DE GUZMAN ELIEZER B. ABRINA FILOMENO O. DUATIN CASES FILED:

THEFT OF MINERALS

DATE FILED: APRIL 28, 2016 On or about the 13th day of March 2016, at more or less 1:15 in the afternoon, at the wharf of Brgy. Mandaragat, Puerto Princesa City, the above-named respondent wilfully, unlawfully and feloniously ship and/or transport approximately 1,167.60 cubic meters of sand and gravel from the Province of Antique to Puerto Princesa City. With intent to cause damage to the government, respondent use and present to the Deputized Environment and Natural Resources Officers of Mines and Geosciences Bureau, the apprehending officers and witnesses herein, a falsified copy of an Ore Transport Permit (OTP) purportedly issued by the Environment and Natural Resources Office of the Province of Antique, which OTP contained false and fabricated entries such as the name and address of the buyer, destination and the amount paid as environmental fee.

153

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

GAD YEAREND ACCOMPLISHMENT REPORT CY- 2016 I.

INTER-AGENCY WOMEN’S MONTH CELEBRATION HELD ON MARCH 16, 2016 AT QUIRINO GRANDSTAND, RIZAL PARK, MANILA With this year’s call for inclusion of women’s concerns in leadership platforms and the government’s agenda in development, personnel from Mines and Geosciences Bureau-MIMAROPA gathered at the Burnham Green, in front of the Quirino Grandstand in Rizal Park, Manila on March 16, 2016. The event, with this year’s theme “Sama-Samang Pagsulong sa mga Agenda ni Juana,” was part of a series of activities organized by the Philippine Commission on Women (PCW) for the National Women’s Month celebration. About 8,000 participants from different national government agencies, local government units, state universities and colleges, private and civil society organizations, and GAD advocates attended and celebrated the empowerment of women to bridge the gender gap in the society. Highlighting the event was the Keynote Speech of UP Economics professor and broadcast journalist-columnist, Ms. Solita “Winnie” Monsod. She emphasized the need for women empowerment in the country, thus she encouraged everyone to vote for public officials that advocate the rights of the women, as well as those who include women on their agenda and platforms. The Philippines ranked 7 th among the 145 countries in terms of global gender gap index according to a report done in 2015. A national poll was conducted that allowed the participants to cast their votes in the Agenda ni Juana Ballot, where each participant selected five priority issues under the list of agenda that include economic empowerment, social development, security, justice and peace, climate change and disaster risk reduction, and gender-responsive governance. The National Women’s Month is celebrated annually pursuant to the Proclamation No. 227 s. 1988, which aims to give due recognition to the contributions of Filipino women in our society.

154

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

MGB IVB MIMAROPA personnel showing their fingerprints at the “I am Counted” photo area during the advocacy campaign of the 2016 National Women’s Month celebration at Quirino Grandstand, Rizal Park, Manila

II. GENDER SENSITIVITY ORIENTATION FOR NEWLY-HIRED EMPLOYEES OF MGB IV MIMAROPA HELD ON MAY 26, 2016 AT LUCA CUCINA ITALIANA, TALIPANAN, PUERTO GALERA, ORIENTAL MINDORO The Mines and Geosciences Bureau Region IV MIMAROPA, through the Regional GAD Focal Point System, hosted a Gender Sensitivity Orientation for its newly-hired employees on May 26, 2016 at Luca Cucina Italiana, Talipanan, Puerto Galera, Oriental Mindoro. Ms. Lorenza A. Umali, a GAD Specialist, was invited as resource speaker to impart her knowledge and expertise on gender and development. The activity was in pursuance to the undertaking of MGB to fully support the programs and activities that geared towards the recognition, protection, fulfilment and promotion of women’s rights especially those in the marginalized sectors in consonance with relevant women human rights laws. The resource speaker gave emphasis on the difference between sex, which is relatively permanent and universal, and gender which refers to socially constructed attributes, roles and responsibilities of women and men in a given culture or society. An input on women’s status in the Philippine society through time was better understood after the resource speaker presented the history of women during the pre-colonial time, Spanish colonial time, American colonial period and during the Japanese occupation where women and girls were forced into sexual slavery as “comfort women”. The participants were made aware of the five (5) spheres of gender discrimination or gender-bias which include marginalization, subordination, multiple roles, gender stereotyping and violence against women. The objective of the discussion was for the participants to fully appreciate their rights in terms of selfdevelopment, opportunities in employment, equality in benefits and representation in the public service, among others. The activity was concluded with a film showing entitled “The Impossible Dream”, a film that served as an eye-opener not only for women, but also for men.

155

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Participants posed with RD Roland De Jesus and Ms. Loren Umali after the orientation.

RD De Jesus presenting a token of appreciation to Ms. Loren Umali

III.

MGB personnel listens attentively during the orientation.

GAD BULLETIN The Mines and Geosciences Bureau-MIMAROPA Region, through the Regional GAD Focal Point System, maintained for the whole year one (1) Gender and Development Bulletin Board where notices, updates and IEC materials are posted for the information and awareness of women and men employees and clients.

156

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

IV.

ASSESSMENT OF WOMEN’S ORGANIZATIONS/ASSOCIATIONS/GROUPS INVOLVEMENT IN ADDITION TO WOMEN OFFICIALS IN THE 2016 GEOHAZARD INFORMATION AND EDUCATION CAMPAIGN IN THE MUNICIPALITIES OF CORON, BUSUANGA, CULION, SAN VICENTE, TAYTAY, EL NIDO AND LINAPACAN A field party composed of GAD Focal Point and members conducted an assessment on the involvement of women’s organizations/associations/groups in addition to women officials in the IEC activity on geohazard awareness and disaster preparedness in the municipalities of Coron, Busuanga, Culion, San Vicente, Taytay, El Nido and Linapacan. The IEC activity for each municipality was done through a seminar which consisted of talks on landslide and flooding hazards and map reading. Participants invited for the IEC are the LGUs and non-governmental organizations. The IEC activities were conducted within the period of September 1 to 15, 2016. Based on the list of attendees for each municipality, it would appear that only 1% to 6% representing women’s organizations/associations/groups participated in the IEC activity for the municipalities of Coron, El Nido, San Vicente, Busuanga and Linapacan. No representative from the women’s group attended during the IEC in the municipalities of Taytay and Culion. Mu

Municipal Mayor of Coron gave his Opening Remarks/ Inspirational Message to the participants of the IEC activity

Dr. Edwin M. Mojares, Chief of the Geosciences Division, MGB-MIMAROPA, during the conduct of IEC on Geohazard in the Municipality of Coron

157

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

V.

SURVEY OF DEMOGRAPHIC PROFILE OF MEN AND WOMEN RESIDENTS IN HIGH RISK AREAS IN THE MUNICIPALITIES OF CORON, BUSUANGA, AND CULION A field party composed of GAD Focal Point and members conducted a survey of the demographic profile of men and women residents in high risk areas. The activity was conducted within the period of September 1 to 15, 2016. The methodologies used in the conduct of survey were through the use of questionnaire and interview of key informants in different barangays of Coron, Busuanga and Culion, Palawan. It would appear that women residing in high risk areas are greater in number compared to men. Most of them positively responded when asked if they are willing to participate in any geohazard awareness and disaster preparedness seminar.

Courtesy Call of GAD Focal Point and Members with the Officials of Brgy. Tagumpay, Coron, Palawan

Ms. Perla M. Domingo of MGB-MIMAROPA GAD with Survey Respondent from Brgy. Tagumpay, Coron, Palawan

158

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

VI.

ANNUAL GAD WORK PLAN AND BUDGET, AND ORIENTATION ON THE BASIC CONCEPTS ON GENDER AND DEVELOPMENT ON 26-30 SEPTEMBER, 2016 AT CAMELOT HOTEL, MOTHER IGNACIA AVENUE, QUEZON CITY On 26-30 September 2016, the Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB)MIMAROPA Region -Gender and Development (GAD) Technical Working Group attended the Annual GAD Work Plan and Budget, and Orientation on the Basic Concepts on Gender and Development at Camelot Hotel, Mother Ignacia Avenue, Quezon City. The said undertaking was spearheaded by the MGB-Central Office which aims to recognize the equal contribution of women and men in all aspects and sectors of development including the process of identifying interventions which transform gender disparities into opportunities that equally benefit women and men. The five (5) day-seminar started with the viewing of an indie film entitled “Boses” which premiered in Cinemalaya 2008. The story was about child protection and its advocacy against child violence, exploitation and abuse. On the next day, orientation on basic GAD concepts and policies were discussed by Ms. Lorenza A. Umali, lead facilitator of the seminar. She pointed out that these policies mandate non-discriminatory and pro-gender equality and equity measures enabling women’s participation in the formulation, implementation, and evaluation of policies, plans, and programs for national, regional, and local development. On the third and fourth day, workshop on the process of attribution to the GAD Budget was conducted and discussion on the guidelines for programs, projects and activities were also given. The group resolves to convert the national policies on gender equality and women's empowerment into concrete programs and projects of MGB on the next programming workshop.

Participants of the Strategic Planning for 2018 Mines and Geosciences Bureau Gender and Development Work Plan and Budget and Orientation on Basic Concepts on Gender and Development

159

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Ms. Lorenza A. Umali, Lead Facilitator for the Annual GAD Workshop (left) and Mr. Mario Luis J. Jacinto, Undersecretary for Mining and Concurrent MGB Director, giving his closing remarks for the Annual GAD Workshop (right)

160

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

OTHER SPECIAL EVENTS CONDUCTED DENR Secretary Lopez visits Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation and Coral Bay Nickel Corporation On December 7, 2016, Ms. Regina Paz L. Lopez, Secretary of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources, paid a visit to Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation (RTNMC) and Coral Bay Nickel Corporation (CBNC) both located in Rio Tuba, Bataraza Palawan. Roland A. De Jesus, Regional Director of the Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB) MIMAROPA Region, accompanied by: Rodolfo L. Velasco Jr., Chief of the MSESDD of MGB-CO; Takanori Fujimura, President, Sumitomo Metal Mining Philippines Corp. and Jose B. Anievas, Senior Vice President and Chief Operating Officer of Nickel Asia Corporation (NAC), arrived first in the Rio Tuba Airport. Fifteen minutes later, the advance party was followed by the main group headed by Ms. Lopez, accompanied by: Leo L. Jasareno, former MGB Director and USEC of the DENR; Gerard H. Brimo, NAC Chief Executive Officer and President; Martin G. Zamora,Senior Vice President for Marketing and Strategic Planning of NAC; and Takeshi Kubota,SMM Director and Managing Executive Officer. Ms. Lopez’ delegation was welcomed by officers of the two (2) companies based in Rio Tuba, members of the Indigenous Peoples Development Organization, officials of the LGU pf Rio Tuba, selected school children, etc. With no time to spare, the group headed straight to the COMREL Information Center where an exhibit of the companies’ milestones, awards, Social Development Management Programs (SDMP) and Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) initiatives of both companies were being displayed. A short meeting ensued where the companies presented an overview of their operations, environmental protection activities and SDMP accomplishments. This was followed by a tree planting activity in front of the center Ms. Lopez and party then visited the RTNFI Hospital and Leonides S. Virata Memorial School (LSVMS), observed the ongoing mining operation of RTNMC and visited the GP-4 Rehabilitation Project Area of RTNMC and Tailings Storage Facility No.1 Rehabilitation Project of CBNC. By afternoon, the group proceeded to visit Sitio Bongkol-Bongkol where Secretary Lopez entered one of the Gawad Kalinga house and spoke with the owner. While in GK Bongkol-Bongkol, the group witnessed the opening and blessing of the Bongkol-Bongkol Cultural Artifacts Center that was part of the 2016 ASDMP of CBNC and RTNMC. Last in the itinerary was the causeway area where Secretary Lopez observed the fish pen project of CBNC, a bio-indicator project. Before leaving the mine site, Secretary Lopez gave her overall impression of the operations of RTNMC and CBNC in an impromptu dialogue in the RTN’s Guest Lodge, quoting: “Your SDMP and your people do seem really happy. I feel that in my experience sa experience ko in doing any kind of development work is if you have a

161

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

model, what you are saying is pwedepala, kaya palanatin and this sets the bar and Leo who has handled the MGB for six (6) years and has been with DENR for 38 years had said Ma’am you know this is really the best,” she said. She further commended the two (2) companies for the rehabilitation works that they have conducted and expressed her interest of working together with them to create a bigger impact in the community, which will happen if the government and companies communicate with each other. “And I want to let you know that I would like to work together with you to make an even bigger difference in the whole area. I asked, Gerry is it ok if we work with you, with your SDMP funds natalagangpagbutihan, develop the ability of the community to make money, which is independent of the mine site. Then you’re developing the economic potential of the area, not just dependent on you. I feel that is where you want to go so that if one day you stop then this thing just goes on. I just want to say that in my experience in doing development work, the best development work is if we communicate with each other” she added. In the end, she concluded that as the long as the company and the government were in the same page then this can go a long way.

Students warmly welcome DENR Secretary Lopez who arrived together with former MGB Dir. Leo L. Jasareno, NAC President and CEO Gerard H. Brimo, NAC SVP for Marketing and Strategic Planning Martin G. Zamora and SMM Director and Managing Executive Officer Takeshi Kubota

Secretary Lopez participating in the tree planting activity

162

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

At the TSF No.1 rehabilitation site of CBNC

Walking along the Flower and Butterfly Garden inside the decommissioned TSF No.1

Secretary Lopez talks candidly with a house owner at GK Bongkol-Bongkol

Dialogue with members of the community at the hangar

163

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

MGB MIMAROPA Regional Director De Jesus visits Citinickel Mines and Development Corporation On 30 November 2016, taking a break in the series of Mine Rehabilitation Fund Committee (MRFC) meetings being held in Puerto Princesa, Regional Director Roland A. Jesus of the Mines and Geosciences Bureau – MIMAROPA Region, visited the miningareas of Citinickel Mines and Development Corporation (CMDC) in the municipalities of Sofronio Española and Narra in the province of Palawan. Pulot Nickel Mining Project First in his itinerary was Pulot Nickel Mining Project (PNMP) in S. Española, wherein there was a complaint from the Palawan NGOs Network, Inc. (PNNI) alleging of an active mining operation in the areabased on a video taken by a PNNI para-enforcer on 23 November 2016 amidst a Suspension Order issued against the company by the Mines and Geosciences Bureau on 22 July 2016. Prior to the visit, RD De Jesus coordinated with Atty. Roberto Chan, Executive Director of the PNNI, informing of his plan to make an ocular inspection of the area to verify the veracity of the allegation. He requested that Mr. Teofilo Tredes, a regular member of the Multipartite Monitoring Team (MMT) for CMDC, and a certain Mr. David Abela, the PNNI para-enforcer who recorded the video, to join him and his party during the ocular inspection, wherein Atty. Chan readily agreed. Before proceeding to Palawan for the series of MRFC meetings, upon receipt of the video footage on November 23, 2016, RD De Jesus instructed MGB – MIMAROPA personnel who were incidentally at that time monitoring the Integrated Safety & Health, Environment and Social Development (ISHES) accomplishments of CMDC in S. Españolato conduct an immediate investigation. An official report of the investigating team has yet to be released by MGB – MIMAROPA. RD De Jesus and his party that includes Mr. Samuel Danganan, Regional Executive Assistant of the Regional Director of the Environmental Management Bureau – MIMAROPA Region, MRFC Secretariat and the two (2) PNNI personnel coordinated first with CMDC personnel. In the entry conference, the video footage was shown, including the video taken by the MGB MIMAROPA investigating Team, for comparison. It was agreed that the team proceed to the mine site for the ocular inspection. The group initially went to Block A where the alleged loading operation (mining activity) that was video recorded by. Mr. Abela took place. Engr. Jainal M. Uy, CMDC Resident Manager, explained that Area A is a mined-out area where recontouring of slopes is being conducted in preparation for rehabilitation. He further explained that the backhoe and dump truck in the video were used to transfer materials that were removed from Ridge 3 to be used as back-fill materials in Ridge 1. The site where the alleged loading operation took place is located within the geographical coordinates: 9°3’53” N and 117°57’39” E; and 9°4’50” N and 117°57’55” E. The area was later identified by Mr. Teofilo Tredes, wherein he had visited during MMT monitoring, as mined-out and where there is an on-going progressive rehabilitation undertaken by the company. Mr. Abela confirmed to the group that the same location is the subject of his video recording taken from across Maribong River on the opposite hillside of the mine site.

164

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

General Location Map of Pulot Nickel Project showing the approximate supposed location of PNNI para-enforcer when taking the video. - Location of PNNI Para-enforcer

Pictures taken at the supposed location where the PNNI para-enforcer took videos

165

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Pictures taken at the supposed location where the PNNI para-enforcer took videos

Still photos captured from the PNNI video (Take note of the background as compared to the photos of the Investigating Team)

Pictures taken in the area where the alleged mining activity was being conducted

166

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Pictures taken in the area where the alleged mining activity was being conducted

Subject area

CMDC General Location Map showing where the alleged mining activity was being undertaken

RD De Jesus and his entourage then proceeded to other rehabilitation area in Block C where they participated in the tree planting. The group likewise inspected the siltation ponds upstream of Pasi and Tagusao Rivers where a free-board of 1.5 meters in both ponds and no discharge to the adjoining river systems were observed.

167

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Pictures taken during the tree planting in TNMP

Pasi Siltation Pond

Portion of Pasi River

Pasi Siltation Pond Tagusao Siltation Pond

168

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

Toronto Nickel Mining Project In the Toronto Nickel Mining Project (TNMP) located in Narra Palawan, the group visited the site of the Phase 1 Rehabilitation Project where the Director and the Regional Directors of the Mines and Geosciences Bureau conducted tree planting during a Management Conference held in Palawan.The trees planted, consisting mostly of Narra, were observed growing vigorously. Various on-going and future rehabilitation sites were also visited wherein defined benches were observed. Just like in PNMP, the group also conducted tree planting in a rehabilitation area in Block A of TNMP. The team then proceeded to Block B, the area subject of a Cease-and-Desist Order issued last year for operating outside the coverage of theStrategic Environmental Plan Clearance issued by the Palawan Council for Sustainable Development (PCSD). A large area in Block B, which was opened by CMDC, was already re-contoured as observed by the group. Some sites were already planted with tree seedlings while other were planted with different grass species for vegetation purposes to control soil erosion. RD De Jesus recommended that the company fast track completion of the rehabilitation of Block B.

Re-contoured areas of Block B of TNMP

Block A of TNMP

169

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

RD De Jesus backfilling the hole with top soil

Tree Planting Activity at Block A of TNMP

170

Mines and Geosciences Bureau MIMAROPA Region

OTHER SIGNIFICANT ACCOMPLISHMENTS IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE PRONOUNCEMENTS/ INSTRUCTIONS/DIRECTIVES OF THE NEW ADMINISTRATION



DENR Administrative Order No. 2015-07 “Mandating Mining Contractors to Secure ISO 14001 Certification dated 30 April 2015 As per DAO No. 2015-07, all holders of valid and existing Mineral Agreement (MA) and Financial or Technical Assistance Agreement (FTAA) are required to secure ISO 14001 within the one (1) year period after the effectivity of the Administrative Order. The Order aimed to institutionalize an environmental management system that shall ensure the adherence of local mining operations to international standards as measure of Responsible Mining in the country. In MIMAROPA Region, company/permit holderare all required to obtain at least the generic management standards, an ISO 9001 (Quality-Management Systems) and ISO 14001 (Environmental-Management Systems) certification and encouraged to be a ISO 26000 certified (Social Responsibility) for a well-rounded activity/organization who may able to conduct business within the international standards. Prior to the issuance of the Administrative Order, Coral Bay Nickel Corporation is an ISO 14001:2004 (EMS Certification) and 9001:2008 (QMS Certification) certified.

In compliance to DAO 2015-07, Rio Tuba Nickel Mining Corporation (RTNMC) and Citinickel Mines and Development Corporation (CMDC) are certified ISO 14001:2004 + Cor. 1:2009 and ISO 14001:2004, respectively, within one (1) year period after the effectivity of the Administrative Order. Berong Nickel Corporation (BNC) and Unichamp Minerals Phils., Inc. (UMPI) are both in the process of securing the certification, however requested for an extension but committed to secure ISO 9001 and ISO 14001.

171

CY 2016 Annual Accomplishment Report

Snapshot of the ISO Certification:

172