Optimal Streaming of Layered Video: Joint Scheduling and Error Concealment Philippe de Cuetos

Keith W. Ross

Institut EURECOM 2229, route des Crêtes 06904 Sophia Antipolis, France

Polytechnic University Six MetroTech Center Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

[email protected]

[email protected]


 
 


 
!"#
$%

& 
 (')%*
+ *  !,-/.*

 0*.1* 
2%34
5
6
&798(:#; 5(%6 <




 =%>5
?

/*
@!A
?,*,- 
B2CDE%&
0+.-F ::#

x
  
:?
9!,*qS
yCc*o0g9
/zE   *{/5(% 
/ @ |5
1Cc<89% w:#0 CD!A0
j*% 
;z%C$,-
 Cc*!% 
?
  Fa /8

S(z&
  &5-&E%.*
1798(:#;z*%  z9 *89@X
V
&* E
5
CcE&
0*.& 2ijm6nk %8   , 9
 8 
8  !ijnX}a~Vg€&‚~ƒ 
&E%
 @)|5
>!:!*Sp E8 * $%
„:'†…9ƒ ‡}aˆz*, !‚,-%#/
 6,-
 CD‰q(

 5(%rm "u%9Šƒ‡}Xˆ‹,  !:<,-#/
 F?%

x;Œ*'&5
j,-
 Cc p 2% 
1C5
*, 2:





39,9#/ e%8 96Cc5
&
* 
&
9<&
E5-p 9 £%<5
B

/*
@z
!
/Cc
?A59 CcE&
0*.=% GH9I"J-K LM/N-OEP9Q9RI"J9TU9J-P!OW/W;H9W6MEH9J-M/OEURY
S-5
&¡ 9p 

F*5
q(%

0† 5B#%q9
 
% <%, ,9#% *1  .9 0VU¤‚W/IH9W/I %

!*% 
 5 8 5 8 5
 
 !%,9p ,9#% *¥@<  8E5j
 0*.!
9 &
9 Fh

 9g9
9
 
1 <%, ,*, 
j#¦9F‚§SFX„„F)„:¨SFX„¦9F‚ŒS„/;@|5

1 
9p 9
 &9<©% 
>ª‚:*
;©ªb') !698 


 798(:# -«$%

9 (:
9
 e}Xª¥ &, *
  
/e
 5-
B5





 j798-# @ ¡;& 9,9:h 
:% <%, ,S#:% hF-5
 



a 9(%# LM/N-OEP9Q9RO:Lh5
6E <  j%C¬&
 9,(%E.
  6Cc8  *1%C *:#%q9
6q(%

0† 5<
)!%3<4
5



 < 
 798(:# *@|5
 



!</5 9 
>*E%  *&
&
 9 ,(%E.
 F5

q9= ! 


S z *&
1
 &{ ?
1CcE%&
 @ ¡ j*

E:cF‚5
 E5
 89# A!Š: &E8
!5
<
E%  p {C6* ,(%E.
 15(%&{ 
s%!5
B

/*
1q(
/Cc
5
/
9 9 A
% 9#
 @1Ÿ>5
&

/
F) &
?%C+5
&?
/p

9­,(%E.
 2%
B#%q9
A*k &
FX5(% FXq-
ECc
!5
/&
/p 9 9!
% 9#
 @®65
,(%E.
 6
*q-
<*:#qS
F‚
/5
 q-
:%8 
5
j0

E 
 =%

­* Fb* &,9Aq-
%8 
5
 

&

& /5
 8S
 z5
¯Cc<E%   h@kŸ<5
 &
<%C+



  j!5
<8 
Fh5
<
9
 9,9:#°%, ,S#
 
*
E:+&
5 9  <%C$OW/W;H9WMEH9J-MEO/URY
9 
j!9
,-%
1   ,-/.*
 6Cc²5
& 8 8 

Sp  {*:#%q9
z,(%E.
 k#Œ*³:;@dB 
 F?° ?,S
e%

r,-,9p 89%!&
5 9 lCc*&
&,(E:>
*&*
::&
9! & S ,9F  
% %CX5
<  B!%!q99/.1CD‹5
8 
9CcE%&
*F 5
&!%1q99/.=5
? E%&
& ,(% 9 =q8 6Cc*¯5
, 
8 6CcE%?
@ n)/.*
 E5
 89# =%

k
* 
&
9!
;0CD8

-p &
9E&,-*
9 o=A
 9g9g9


= 
j 
:% j 9 p 
1@$¥8 
j„##8 E
 &5
/
 ,-
 
Cc8    @<ŸV>5




F)5
! E5
 89
&


 &5

 5(%< 5*8S =q-

9<j5
!

/
@sŸ5
!

E
F+q-
/Cc*


  k5
&
 9SF<5
k
9
j,-
 Cc*& j
*j 
&
9jCc£5
*:#%q9
l*
 @‹|)E% 9 (:#F?,-/.*
j /5
 8S# w%

{
 p B 
&
9
A
 
 {
,-

9 x05 8 j9p 
 °%9j9
,S=q-
;0

s5
! 0+@B¡ k,(% 89%F+5
E5
 89#B,-%#! *!:#B,  4
 j05 8 VE.<9 %8 95
V, 
 
 
>%C‚
+ 
&
9a5
6

/
>#¨9F „Ž9Fb„:´:;@ ¡;&5S +,-,-
F 0
>%*8
>5-a5
 /5
 8S# B%


X9p

ABSTRACT

Categories and Subject Descriptors

@  @#Ž1 /‘b’“(”%•s–—˜c“-‘r™bšh›—œ9•k›/;ž<ˆ&<89  Ÿ>,,9#p  * Ÿ* 5& F‚|5
F(nb
 Cc*!% 


General Terms

Keywords

  
 
:% F-

 Sg€ 
F)
* 
&
9

;¡ jINTRODUCTION 5S ,(%,-
0
 
 
:% 1

 
j
$ *  !,-/.*

 0*.1* 
2%34
5
6
&798(:#; 5(%& B


 r&5
j

/*
@¢
j,*,- 
s%e


Sg€%g
 jCcE%?
0.105SE5,-/.*
 /5
 8S# k
/ * !65


1.

Permission to make digital or hard copies of all or part of this work for personal or classroom use is granted without fee provided that copies are not made or distributed for profit or commercial advantage and that copies bear this notice and the full citation on the first page. To copy otherwise, to republish, to post on servers or to redistribute to lists, requires prior specific permission and/or a fee. MM’03, November 2–8, 2003, Berkeley, California, USA. Copyright 2003 ACM 1-58113-722-2/03/0011 ...$5.00.

„

layer L

Playback buffer

Decoder with Error Concealment

...

Lossy Scheduler Channel

layer 2 layer 1

Sender

†˜ )”œ 


!˜ )œ9“A›—”%œ9– •k˜c‘ k›šh›—œ9•

 







:&
9?,-
9 C‚6 
 
  9 
 5 89 !q-



 *
 &uv%9 j B* 
,-E%
/*@¡ !,(% 89%F‚05

/p *S & /5
 8S# ,-%#*F)*6*Sj 5 89 A0+
&8 9VCD 5
*

 = 88
B%C>5
B&
 9SFX5
1E5-
/>/5(%E
 p    F 5
&
h
 C   A,(%E.
 *k 9  hFXq8  0+
 5 89 { k
39,9#/ {*89&Cc*
* 
:?
9B% 5
6

/
@a|598 F 0
8
VCc*&
>89#f(
 ¥F(


Sg€%g9
 ,, 9/5jCc* 
 9j
! 
%<B 9 
& @ |59 V,(%,(
5- V;0<!:B9 q 8 * @$¥ F-0+
6, 
 
9 j
0 *, <4% * CcE&
0*.ACc*6u%9!,(%E.
? /5
 8S#   <
&,(E:(
*b*
::&
9@ V  ijnX}a~Vg€‚~ƒo
 E
 F‚0
&*&,(%
6u9 E5
 89# k k
*
::&
9  9 "u9 & E5
 89#Š%

j
*
:&
9ž ˜c› “-˜c‘b—)™ )œ c˜ ‘ 6– ‘ V””“-” “-‘ 9œ9– c•kœ9‘b— ˜c› %“-˜c‘‚—k™ >|5
 



1


 %

r
&,9%9 5
>,  !:¬ /5
 8S# 1,(%#Fh059/5! q E:
 j05Sp 8 <%8 9 ACD
**
:&
9!%<5
!

/
@ |5
)

/
)
*
5
E
  ,,9#
 X
) 
:?
9)q-
/p Cc
>



  15

@ “-˜c‘b—+™ )œ c˜c‘ <–‘ ”%”“-” <“-‘ 9œ9– c•kœ9‘‚— “-˜c‘b— ™ ‚|V5
 



 


 <%

A
?,S9 5
*,Sp  !:X E5
 89# j,-%#*Fb059/5s%8 9 6Cc
*6*Sp 
&
9@&|5


/
&,,9#
 &
* 
&
9



  15

@ ¡; &,(E%9!*
15(%&q(5z E5
&
 &
&,Se}Xˆ$F¬  5(%05
j?,- B5





 j
!798-# %C)5
< 0 E5
&
 F(0

V



 j!%. !oC;*&,-  h@A
> 50 5(%Cc5
 E%&

0 5¥FX…%9$ƒ‡}Xˆ :%j 9#f(%9  ?,
B 
k798-# =
?m† "uv%9Bƒ‡}Xˆ6@a;ˆ*9
 
/*Fa :%!q-
 50!5-051…%9†ƒ‡}Xˆ6F95
> 
%<?%, ,S#::p  *k=%E5S

!5
? E%&
!
E#
j798-# = &m "u%9 ƒ ‡}Xˆ q 805j 9#f(%9 j
  6q(%

0† 5h@#' ®68  


!:9 q 8  A > 5 0¢5 %0w5
<5
 C9f(S
/g€5* "4hF!
E
/g€
0 ¢ij.rmV
E  n)%p 
  
 ;ijm6n) E' )I"KN­U OW UT9O MEHLEK¥MEH9JLKcW U9I"J-K"Lh1q-
<,,9#
 !5
Vuv%9 E5
 89#s%

A
6 
:?
9, q9
1@<|) *8+.90
 
F Sf(S
Eg95  4j* E
 ijm6n) 5-*
6  q(

r%, ,9#
 x*
!k
= 
% @ 
j 5 %0 5 %0 *Sp E
 ¢ijm>n± B%eq-
A8 
 zCc*BA0 
*% 
;z%C<798(:#; ?
  F- /8 9 j&
  >0V59E5jE%.
<798(:# j* % j9 *89@+A
$: & 5 0{5-†CD 
 !%, ,S#:% ( 0†5 2:# ,9:*8 a
/9 c 8 /5< ¥#
+ 
% 9'/F€5
)* E
 ijm>nx,, 9/5j *&,8 E% *-#"sE%EqS
F‚, % 9 A*,Sp  2:) E5
 89# j,-%#/
 oCc*5
&…96ƒ ‡}Xˆ E5
&
@ |59 V,(%,(
6 9S4
 =% Cc#0V @
*/8


&5S > 
/p  *105B6 S 8  *ACb
E%
 B0.-@)¡;BƒS
 BŒo0+
†##8 p E
5
,-*
9 :+q-

/f( 6%C…9ƒ ‡}aˆ6@(¡ jƒ9
 *kŽ&0
99 8 
B %*
/X,  4 kCcE&
0*.1Cc<…%9<ƒ ‡}aˆ6@

¡ 2ƒS
 10+
V 5 0z5 0z* E
 ijm>n± +%&q(
%, ,9#
 k5
1*, !!…%9Bƒ ‡}aˆ‹,*qS
1@rA
j,  
 

E: 98 &
 
3 %?,S
 <05SE5 50 5-&…%9<ƒ ‡}aˆr%,p 
& 9#f-:%9&, 
?
9 o,-
 CD!
?%*
m "u%9 ƒ ‡}aˆ6@)¡;=ƒS
 e´10
!* 
B1&9 9#f-
 e
 *=%C>5
, q9
1FB05SE515

6 j%

9 (:X* E96!798(:#p  <*% qS## @¡;!ƒ9
 B¨60
+,
 89% *1
 89 aCc* ijnX}a~Vg€k‚~ƒ°
kE
 FX05SE5=9f( 5
1q-

/f( &%C …%9>ƒ ‡}aˆz*
m† "uv%9ƒ ‡}Xˆ$@ 
6*E8
oŠƒS
 Š¦S@



)| BRelated 8 .9 0†
 Work *
F5
!& /* 
/=
/%
 k0.159 ,(%,-
& !5
j0.kC<ˆ5 8{ i%z ´SF†¨:>05SE5z  Sp
 BE%
/g€ S * ¢*, 4
 ¢ 
 @‹ˆ5 8r ri * 
 E5
 89#,-/.*
 4
 s&
 92*
&,(%E.
>
E% 8 
E5-
/<x* 
j=94
e¢  9 
e
9   %

e:*
E%*
!E%
@j|5
! 
 
 <%C>,-,-
 &2%.
 & 98 q-
C*9 q8   F>q-5=l
*
/,9 ­ 
/>*, #p 4 jCcE%?
0.-F( Š%, ,S j5
6CDE%&
0+.&!< #p
;j%C>,-/.*

 0*.A?9 
/ @B|5
!&* 6&,-*E%9& 9 h
 p
 
6q(
 0

&5
/0.?%

!8  a 5(%ˆ5 8! Bi%?    
6
* 
&
9Vj5
/,  4 ACDE%&
/p 0*.-@
o99 8
&5
u96 E5
 89# j
*6*
:#p &
9+,*qS
B@ŸV  Fhˆ5 8j Ši%&
*
/,5
8   !#p * 5 Ccf-

S & 8q9g9*, 2:+ /5
 8S# A,(%#F¬0V5  
,-
 CD!
j2:=q-
B 9#f-:%9 rq-
/0 5
189=,  !: E5
 89#B,-%#*@®68  E:
 Šijm6n=%, ,€%E51,  
 1E%E%q9
j&
% Cc< 

9=5
89=,  !:<…9 ƒ ‡}aˆx,(%#@B;V0
*
Fh5
oCcE&
0*.1Cˆ5 8s%

ki :#0 Cc
E <   Fa05

 0
& 8 ,,-* 
!B
E% p   * @ '!¥-#F-5
aCcE&
0*.,
 &59 a,(%,(
a:% 5(%

S
B798-# =*% %q9## e&
  F±%

l:%kq-
?
39



 = 5(%

S
&

 j05)}Xˆ$@ ®65
0*.9 !*, !) E5
 89#!C)&
 98  BVCc

 9p q(%E.1E5-
/X/8


1 „:´SF)„:§:;@|5
 
0*.9 6 !*6* 

*& 
&
9@rnb9 % .9e
!c@6„´:> 8

=*, !>
/p E%   *l E
%
 C %q9
!&
 9S@&|5
/<%(:9  < q(% 
 k*=ij%.*AE5- <05= E
! ,-
!5-0 
3p ,-*
9 #A05B5
98 q(
%C)
 @+ƒ9

­„§‚ 8 9
 E5
 89#kC*&,S

1~®n) <
9 
 k89 ,9
j 
  ,Sp  =9
 @j|5
& 



!% (%,  &5
&98&6ijiA@





1.1



 

,+



  




 

!



"

!# 

$

%&')(*

-  




 

.



/

.# +

5

%0!)(*

1

2

Receiver

43

;¡ ABENEFITS 59  
 k0+
&OF ,JOINT


B &,9S+EC 
1
3 &,9
B5S*5S#*59 5
Vq(

Ef- C u%9X /5
 8S# B%

&
*a*
:&
9@ˆ9p 
 
 
*&
9)*&,-* 
 &%C(f-*
†CDE%&
 F*
/5<%Ch059/5  !
 9 
 l95

!
 @eA
B 8, ,-* 
1z59 
3 %&,9
5(%
/5!CcE%?
V a


,-



9 j
 9
 ¥@+|5
>9
,-
Sp


E
 &
& 8
<

 k
 9 9 Fbc@
*@ F‚!%
A
C Œ

2.

frame # :

Distortion without EC :

7

3

1

n-1

Distortion with EC :

0

n

n-1

1

n

n-1

2

n

n-1

3

n

n-1

0

 "$#%#%#"&!<%
< B:*#%q9
15

9
@ 
! 8, ,- 
!5(%<5
? 
*9E:  ' CcE%?
 F) s5- (  
 1
j*&&* 9g9*&,-
 E%
 ‚F6c@
*@ F+5
B 
9 Sp  z%C*
) !CCcE&
{ 9
 B*1
,-


r{5
j 
9 Sp  j%C+,
*8 CcE&
 )*"%#$#%#@|59 <%  8 &, *k # Cc*5

5(% 
&
9V
 C)5959j
 g€
 ##
96
   E5
?
 !5- k !
 9
A5
j
 5-
&
9*
 105 &* =?,-
 E% hF 8 /5e% <5
1‚~ƒ€gS}aª{
/f-
 k=5
ijnX}a~Vg€ E%

- ­„/;@)Ÿ F90
+ 8, ,- 
>5-a5
>%

S *- 798(:# q 8 595
&
l"c@
@F¥*
 !CCcE%?
kq   &*8*5S 5
6 E%?
%?8 9%C¬798-# !oCDE%&+
5(%*
, !bChCcE%&
.-0/yACcE&
)-0/B'/@ri1
j*

E:#F>Cc& = 
 *9E:9j<8S ,9
& 

 >05j S h

9 8-X/5(%E
  p   F)5
&798(:#;kq*8*59&q92*
o #.
Ek1*% 9#C"p 9 ACc> S

9&,(% C5
&
k2 1 @<¡;A59 % 
*F)0
8 ,,-* 
&5(%65
< 
B5- q-

j, 
*8 k 
&
9
 19 5 &*

8  
*&
9 %CX
&CcE%?
 F- 8 /5B5-5
798(:#p  eq*8*591q9=
/5z
 1*8*5S{ E%915 8 5 8  5
& 
?
9@|5

/Cc
*F¥5S < 8

F‚0
< 
&&  %
5 &*

8 < 
&
99ES   '¯CcE%?
 @<¡ j5
&% 
<%C  

 F¬0
0+89 =%, ,S8 ,  4 kCcE&
0*. &
/5B 
,(%E%
< 
*&
9@ |5 8 5 8 659 ,-,-
F(0
 8, ,- 
<5(%5
6E   * E5-
/ ?,(%E.
 g€
E% 8 
1E5(% 
/†0†5j E%9Cc

 q(%E.-@ ¡ B8 6&9
/cF‚5
E5(% 
/X5(% $&,*q-qS##;k%CX 8 
  >%4C 39@ 
1 A < 
!/5(% 
E
**
 *¥F 8 /5e &* p 0 =}±*!ˆ
 {;)}aˆ'& 
E
 
j
E%    @ V0

F+8 2CDE%&
0+.k{?&9 -
)}aˆ‰9 
 B %

9 (:X:*
 c59 60##Xq-
5
 8 qSuv
6CbCc8 8 
0. '/@ Ÿ5
=
9
F!0
k 8 ,,( 
{5(%Fw
k{*
::   <%C†,-/.*
 oCD6CcE&
&98 q-
 bF)*SjSCD! kCc , 
8 CcE&(
5! &8 
 h@eV0
*
F)SCc*!% *zCc CcE&6
+.> 9
  

  E #Cc89#&*
:h  +%C‚,-/.*
 Cc* CDE%&
b@ V*
5(%F9&, E% 
*F9Cc! !Cc 6 
 %C>* 
8 *
A, 
*8 &CcE&
 F =
*
kCc 8 q 
798
9 CcE&
 F)=: q-
!8 
 k1,(
 Cc
* 
:?
9Cc* 5
18 
9&CcE%?
j%!5
1
9
@{|59 5(% !5
1,-*
9 : 1 
% 
j5
B%8EA=,
 S  =9k   k,-/.*
F q 8>%+5
> CX2 
 
oB89g9 ?
&,9
3;1%C¬5



9
#Œ*³:;@)|5
>5
*!,
 
9
 15

6:%1q(
6
39



 1 5(%

S
5
 
&
> , 5S  :%
 1Cc*& X%C‚
X*
::&
9« 
! 

5
Cc
 >5*8*5A5
&

 Fh5*8*5*8<0
Cc98 X&*S&8  5
, 
8 CcE%&
X&
X*
::&
9@ *%
1 E5
 89#B,-%#8 7bFS
: 9%;=@BA%CEDF7Ga
*
5

E
jE   *¢E%
!Cc!5
j 
F>0V59E5l &{89 %C+98 q-
6%C+E% 
 j
 @oª¥
 H=I?J$


 j 
!:Cc

*
:#p &
9@+Ÿ¢ 9,9X,*qS
 Cc<8S %CXE
/g9 9  *k,9p  4
 A 
 2 5
oCD%#0#¨9F-Œ9„/;ž L MNPORQ*SUTy„*: @ VXI"J-PjU9JsH/¤‚K IYUR)LMEN-O/P9Q9RI"J9TV¤(HRI"$M W7 hN-I"MEN Y*@%A%CDF7G^]_,` 05
:
_j V5
62%3<8‹E   *jE%
>0V59E5 >:#0
 q9&5
6
 0+.&*
 *¥F(
(% 
EFb5
E%
>q8

*
 05SE51 >:#9
 k&5
 
 @¡;a 6
39, 
  
 1*
 p %*
&98 q-
C
 < 
9Cc<&CcE%&
*@!®68 6CcE%&
0./p *89 )Cc)* %  %Ch5
>#%q9
q- 0 5!q9</5(% %  5
6*:8
%aC _@)|59 
7989
 5
> 

6f( B
0e,  !: E5
 89#j,-#/
 @ ¡;j!{q-
= 
% 9 ¢z 
/¢8 
z*
E%*
A!%*
= S p  *¥F¬8 8(:#=
39, 
  
 As
& %CV:*
E%*
Bijƒ}t;i1
:%

n

4

3

˜ )”œ 
¥– • cœ1“ ’œ
aœ 9—œ )˜c›—“-”—˜c“-‘– )œ9›o’v“-” – h˜ )œ9“kœ9‘ 9“ )œ  &˜c— c–9š-œ9”› 


.











4





"



A frame # :

1

2

3

B 4

5

1

2

3

4

5

5

5

without EC : Distortion with EC :

1

3

0

3

1

=8

1

1

3

1

1

=7

1

2

0

1

1

=5

1

1

2

1

1

=6

1

2

3

4

5

1

2

3

4

5

0

0

0

7

7

=14

0

7

0

7

0

=14

0

0

0

3

7

=10

0

3

0

3

0

=6

C frame # :

without EC : Distortion with EC :

D

˜ )”œ 
h– • cœk“’?› )œ c˜c‘ a“ c˜ 9˜cœ9›&—”– ‘)›•k˜c— —˜ ‘ )– -œ9—› 







"





4-  




 

$


!CcE%&


 <:#X5
60
:*
 %CX5
< E%&
CcE%?
 q(
V
9
 h@XA
 8 ,,-* 
65(%)
/5<:*
)f- X
3 % 9
,(%E.
F :#h,(%E.
 
V5
 E%&
+ 4
F(%

!:#(CcE%&
 )5-
5
E&
E%
Eg9 9  Cc8  * @ ®6j5

/Cc>%C>¥*8
2ŒSF‚0

&5
& 9  *l*8
 6CD
:%E5CcE&
Fh >oCc8  *j%CX5
98%C‚:*
 6059/5
*:#qS
6CD)5
aCcE%?
@)|5
 
%
 9  *1*:8
 X
39,-

 q95
 

&05 8 & 
 s
&,-*E:>}Xˆ‰5
!
/p 
/
@ ®6z5
j 59B%C?¥8 
sŒSF0
j 5 0 5
j S *  *8
 6CDCcE%?
j05
}XˆzCc‹5
, 
*8 6CcE&
   8 
 h@&|5
 
&
&5
& S * k*8
 <05SE5=
&8-# *qE
 kCc
 
9 S @ ¥*8
=Žk 5 0V !Cc8 1,(  q9
z E5
 89#{,-#/
 =15


&cŸF ©VFhˆ6F %

km>'/F-05
j0

798S
&5(%>
%E5j,-# 
 e
3 % =9
j,(%E.
 @k¡ 9 :#9F> 8, ,-* 
j5-&5

  &,(%E.
X  @ 
/5! E5
 89#B,-%#Fh0
%*
5
*E:

9  *k05k j05 8 <}aˆ6@ V0¢* 
5
*, ! m "u%92ƒ‡}Xˆ¢,-%#°%

A5
!,  !:>…%9?ƒ‡}Xˆ¢,-%#@ |5
,  !:+m "u%9<ƒ ‡}Xˆ ,-#1 6,(%#©VF(05SE5j9#p <4
 65
< S * s%65


E
>0†5 8 E%. B}aˆz9 *89@>ŸVCc
6,,9 j
> 
&
9&,-#s©VF-5

 8S  1 9  *1 6¨9@+V
 
F 5
,  !:±m† "u9ƒ ‡}aˆ ,(%#=5(% ? 9  e%C$¨S@B©X8<5
!*, !…%9?ƒ ‡}aˆ ,(%#{ 1,-#{ŸF+05SE5{5- j­0
1




 { S *  5(%j,(%#©x"c@
@F-´*'/@ ;¡ PROBLEM 59 ,(%,-
F-0
>FORMULATION   
V
& 
:% F-#*
 *
 ¥@ |5
6
!a5
6 



 
 9 
 9­*
 %C‚ E%9 4
@ †
:#(5-b5
a2:&, ,-
 %C 

 Sg€
9 
 !
  5(%
 !‚%CX<%
CcE&
%  q-
6
9
 j8 S
  :#

1

3.

Ž

ƒ9798(%
 e})E'/F‚%*89Cc*5
&798(:#;=%C5
&




 
 @¥ F-5
*
E%*
6!%*
 S * j 9
 *V?
% 8 

&,-E¬% #C; F 8E5B% X& 7989& % 
&c& !% #C; 8  e
 
 E'*&  #Cc 1c& k,*,-9 {%C>, 
 9 
 <:CD
6E   *-'/@2ƒS


¥F¬5S*5A*%   798-#p ;!q-
 0+

1 8 
  
!%*
 6!&

:% 
5
%*
E:#¬,-
 p 
,8(:>798(:#;z%C>5
1
@ |5

/Cc*
FX5
!Cc<8S  C*8&, q9
£ 5*8S z *,-E
k  9 (:<798(:#;z*Sp E9 @ ¡ {59 1,(%,-
F60
j
:%B% Š%{
3 &,S
5
A 
C*%   2s798-# kq-
 0

A* 
8 *
!
 @Š*< 
 E5
 89#j,-#  7¬F 
 ;=9 @%A%C DF7GV
*
5
?:*
E%*
* % j1 9  *Aq(
 0

1;0 
8  
!%*
 @
:%j %0{Cc*89%
5
6Cc%#0 j,*qS
Bž L,MNORQS=T ŒS@ VXI"J-PBU9JkH/¤‚KcI"Y @%A%C DF7G ]_ U9J-P

ƒ
&k? <%, ,9#% 9 !%C#*

 
%< F) 8E5= 
<%C ,-

9 X)
9*SCc

E-Fh5
* 
8Sp  
<
! 
&
9 68 8-#j5-
<
8 
9> #% 8(: E5-E%
    Fb0
>
39,-
65(%5

  !% *ACX5
 9  p  <! 3%C %<8,-  
?
9)% 
 S+EC 0
 8 OPTIMIZATION

Šn±*qS
 „@+A
< 50r5-n)q9p 
 „<Aq(
oCc*89%
 =% $2 E:
 eijm6nbFh05SE5A:% z8 =q-
j %*
 zq9k#
%B,*E&  „³ @=|5
1, q9p 
¢ (%8 E:#&Cc*89%
 B f-9
/g95  4ijm6n0†(5 ' 
, F-05

'  >5
>98%C‚CcE%&
 ao
! 
*&
9@ V0

F(5
*&, 8E (:
>%  9/
 k05jf(S
Eg 5  4*=ijm6n{%jq(
&  j05
  '  6%*
1 Ž:;@6|59 ! q-
B1 
 *8 ?,-
 9&
9&Cc<
#g9 &
B 

 @j|5

/Cc*
F 0
1 
% r8 
1Sf(S
Eg95 4 * E
 wijm6n) @ |5
 5(:*
1*, ! E (%z,(%#/
 Š%

z5(
0
&?,8 E:p  (:?* @ |V5
jSf(S
Eg95  4d%  8 &,  r
 ,-

 {* 
  xSf(9
/g
 5‹
x 
&
9 =F'ACB='/@ |5*8*5*8s5S  8 F<5
k*:8
 9%;=*@%A%C$DF7PG/F H=I?J$
;=9%@%ABC DF7G0##)q-
6*g98 k*
E%*
 @ 4.



1

;=9 @%A%C DF7G^]
P`

05


 5
=!38  
E%
=*%   ¢ S *  059/5k !#0
 h@{c¡  <8
B%=q-
!Cc8 

°CD 8q9u
 

  @#' ªh
  

U"$"%#B#%# " S@±ª¥
 °
 
>5
> /5
 8S#   B5-5
> 

E%.*
 Cc)CcE&
bF9c@
*@ F 5
98
k15
&

E
Cc6CDE%&
b@ V*
5(%+E%  &
 !‚%C±o
!CcE%&
>05*8E < p   k
 !  B%C<5(%CcE&
j!.
 &# 
 
 
*@{¡ 



 ¥F *
 !¥0##¬
*
q-
> 
9 
 #C)5
6 

5(%  + 
9a
 !a@$ª¥
  z
 
&5
& E
&65


/
6CD6, 
/p *8 CcE%?
  F9c@
*@ F 5
98%CX 8 
  *
o
 65(% 
j*:#qS
s%<5
B 
9 
CcCcE&(
  @ |5
B
 C) 8 

 S B% * $%

1 E%
 a   "  !" "#  "#  "E#B#%#@ ªh
% $ 
 
5
 9  *ACbCcE&
:Cc

9 9 @ |5 8 5 8 59 1,(%,(
!0
1 8 ,,( 
5-&5
j 

!% *q 

  05
=/5 9  =5
Š% *&    @s|V59 &,9#
 Š CD

 q-/./5(% 
/Cc* 

/
<1 

<0†5°) b||¢5(%  6
  5-j
CcE%?
 &
*@|5S $%  8 &, *k 6
 (%q9
CDb9
E 

<%, ,S#:% 9 F- 8 /5?% )
9*SCc

E-F 5(%X
7989
6 5 X


Sg€%g9
 BE%   B 
/9 @+¡ b +:  
:% (%q9
Cca#*
 
:% !%

1 *
 1
& 9 
& 0†5 5 X,9:9q(%E.! 
E:9 †%

&5S*5! 6ˆ ag#.*
V9
E  *@|V59 ?9 
/ %! q-

39



 &5- 9
V
X,9:9q(%E.! 
E:9  e 
E:*
 lCD

 q-/.-F059/5e0†##>q-
j5
1 8 q9u
?%C6CD88 
0+.-@ 
A
 
=q9 H(' F>5
s S *  %C2°CcE&
k*9E:9 *S{5
1f( ) !6
 Bq-
/Cc*
A
&,-E?}aˆ6@cl5 8 1  CB

E:#;F!0
=E%.*
H*)+, r H!-. @ ' A
=5(:*
H*)/ H*)  /102020/0H  / H!-*@B3  ] I "54.] †F¬0

 
q9  H(6 7B5
j S * {%C$1CcE%?
j:CD
&
&,(E:>
*&*Sp 
:&
9F)05
  Ia
 <%C5
&, 
8 CcE%&
2% 8

4&
 C5
&8 
96CcE%?
&0

<

/*
 =q9j5
? 
9 
@?z5
9p

( I)]14F5
j
9
1 B 
 &
 B%C<5
8
9CcE&
oCD¯5
&, 
8 CcE&
F‚5

ECc
H 6 7  H 7 @ 

*
q9P9I LKcH9W/KcI"H9J!Y 7 =) @ ¡;*8+ 9 
1F-0+
6 8 ,,-* 
5-5
> 

.9 %0 5
6 9 p * j! 3!%CX5
68 
9 
 
&
9@+z5
1 
:%p  z *
 r 
 F<5
 S *  ! 3{%rq-
&, 8 
  -g#
@¡ <kq-
! 
 °%5
 

FX*
5
05k5

1f 
@!z5
k 
:% 1#
!
FX5
& 



<

 
  !%
B5
&*8
B%C>5
! 9  *l2% 3kq-
ECc
! E%   5

 9 S ! &E <  1Ch5
V8
9X
 
&
9@ |59 6
  2%
<%Bq-
q(% 
 j15
, 
8  
1 
*&
9 5(%<5(:*
j
% =q-

=
 9
 e%

l 
9j5
!

/*
 @


1Analysis * 
!5
1ij.=m
/ rn)9
  D E  "   "  U"B#%#%#FS@eA
j
/f(
j5
j
0 {  9/%
 {05 %  *  F 05
15


/*
6 E
6 -F(% ž 9DG  "#  GH %IJ: $ LK   "#  ;K" „:' %

&5
 X%C‚E59* ?% * 3&aE   *1 * !% ž ;Œ*' M DG  "<  GHN  # * 5
 
 
Ef-9  F?%

x
r5-OIJ:29DG  "#  GP;Q %IJ: $RS;;Fhn)q9
 „$%q-
<
0 
% f-

S jj,  !: ,-#  7"T6059/5j!34
 5
6 %g€8s
E
<
0 ¥ž

4.1

 !U Y3VXW Z   \I [*: ]  9DG ^ "  ^ GP; ^_ ;Ž*'  @ @!U Y3VXW Z   I[*: ] M DG ^ "< ^ PG ;a]_," ^`_ 

05SE51C;# V9!5
*

E:¬5
*1CX E:
 sijm6n) @ 
:%1::89%
&5

0 j j* >% Cc%#0 ž @

9DFI " ;=G5 D&3*G D ]

M DFIK"&;=G;R#

 7 H(6 7%3 G H(6 @ 3 @ " 7_ -

c€' ;´*'

*>E%

*4
  E% *-1,-# 7bF
67 6 @3aH[RDG   K    I?G/@XA
< 
*
q9a 6 @ 7 ba DG dce &4 K    IK"<   ;=GaCc5
60xCX& *j%CX5

|59 ijm6n1 /
 !V8 9/5(:Šijm6nl„³9F-$„ 1 @)¡;)5

/Cc
Cc#%0 5(%)5
,  !:‚,-#Cc*a5
* E
 jijm6nj  E%

4
 k E% *-A,-#@?8 5
&
F‚E%

4  98  1w%1? 1*
 E%
=$„ 1:;@dŸ6{,  !< E% (% ,-#  7"T6!!q-
<q E:
 1Cc*‹5
6Cc#0† 1, 9
 8 
ž





™b—œ  <¥ s%j*, 2:+ %8   T  6 T @ "%DFIK"&;=G 
d ?5
6#
%, *E% ;ªbnX'/ž 

1

q = 0.8 q = 0.9 q=1

0.9

W ] ] 9DFI " ;=G 6 @ 6 @  6 @  M DFIK"&;=G 6 @ ]_  aH6 @ 7 G 6 @  U"54R g h i @ @ h 66  @@   D

6 6 @375  hhj 6 @ U"BI" ^" ;^# ;¦' ªh
 T   * I   6 T @ k Cc*V *&
;  9@ ™b—œ m


!1,  !X,-%# 7 T % Cc#%0 ž  CcIHT " 7"6 T @         CcI T " 7"6T @ 5  6Cc *&
<%q9E%(; , # F1'

0.8

463 578 01 2

0.7

0.6

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.2

0.1

0

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

/

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

˜ )”œ:9 <;r˜ ‘)˜c• )• –-œ9”– -œ )˜ ›—“-”—˜c“-‘l’v“-”0 





5(%5

&
 

E+:* 5 & ! %
?ªbn) @|5




"


? ,-*,89%& <5
& ?,S
3°:* 5B@j¡ 5(% 
39,(
9 : 0+  g9:% 
<&,9
3;Fhq8 6
798S
 $& !:#¬98%C)
 p   a!,E 
@X¡;&8  <8S  F-CcX6
&*9E:9 8 ,A„³&
 F)5
&*, ! E5
 89# k,-%#k0% >
%E5
 w%B& Œk& BreƒS8 ¢ƒ n-Ÿ ˆ²¨³S@d|5

=%
5
 * 5& B5-&
!&
B
/%q-*E%
j5(%k5
1 ?,S
3-F> 059/5e5-*
j,-%9 &&,9
3 *F6 8 /5 % !5
1, %u
 
* 5¯q9 !%.*%< „:Œ:;@ ¥(:#Fh 
>5->ªbnz;¦'±CDX5
69f-9
/g€5* 49A, q9
    6%4C DF-  G
*% qS
 $%

j& ^ - * E9 @ |5
*
 ,-

9!ª‚nŠCD<8S &Cc)5
 E:
 Bijm6n 056f(S
+5* 4 '‰F' /B='¥0*8S <  b96 '"! DF4- $G#
* %q9
 <% '$!+DF.- G -* E9 Fh0V59E51 V#.
Ej  
 
65
&, 8 E% (:¬ &
 9#f-:%9 CDX5S*5*8
 C 'A@

100

q = 0.8 q = 0.9 q=1

90

% increase in distortion

80

70

60

50

40

30

20

10

0

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

/

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

0.9

1

˜ )”œ>= @?¢“-”›—BA 9– ›œe˜ ‘ 9”œ9– ›œk˜c‘ )˜ ›—“-”—˜c“-‘{“’ ˜c› %“(˜ ‘‚—<™ a“ ˜ 9š6C¥’v“-”5* ¡;¢¥*8
=F<0
 5 %0 5
=S<8  *
E%*
l 9  * H=I?J$< @%T A%C %*
lr„„'?% !­CD8  e%C$5
B!%3<8£*
 p %*
!E%   eE%
_FbCc* 
/

 =*:8
 &C>5
&E5(% 
/ 8 
  E
39@
j
&Cc
0zCDE%&
 F7 - T ED !% . 7 T   k;§*''/F =/5(% 
/  
 j =*15(
8 /5{
h
@ V0
*
FCc* 595
*8
 ,C _Fh*, 2:X,-#/
 & 


s?
&98 
7 T FD '/F) B5
&*8
!%C†5
&E5(% 
/ 8 
  >E%
3<5- 6595
V&,(E% 
@ |)q E:<5
a*, ! ,-%#oCc*h5
X% 
X%C m† "uv%9Xƒ ‡}aˆ6F 0
 
?ªbn ;¦*'0†(5 H  -% *@a
6f( j5(%5

6 9fp 9
&98%C+,  !:+E%   *k,-%#E
 F)/8

95
, 
8 ,  !:+,-#1Cc…9<ƒ‡}Xˆ6@-|5
<S<8²
3p ,-

  S * &05 8 ) 
 ?}XˆŠ ‚%
q96H=IZJ$< @%T A%C  = _ 39«950

F*5
†%E5S
*
 ! S * B:CD
)}Xˆk 
,(
 X 5
&/5  
A*, !,(%#@!¡;¥8 
B´SFh0
<%*
5
<0  g  

% 
 9  °:Cc
>8  !m† "u9&ƒ ‡}Xˆx,9p  !X,-%#1 
 k%CX5
…9ƒ ‡}aˆ{,  !X,-%#*@A


>5-a8 2m† "u96ƒ ‡}Xˆl,  !b,(%#/
 >%!q-
>5S*5S


 &
9E!5





 798-# %C+5
< 
F‚
 ,-
/# Cc*&
 98 8
 &%C _r Cc595=E5-
/ 8 
  <E%
 c59 V5(% †: &q-

1*
 #f-
 1CcX*:8
 6C H  -*5
5- =#**'/@ 


>Ÿ %1Layer
3 &,S
*Video F) 
5
<,- 8S& 
&05l„
 F  :'/ž{ E5
 89#r   Ar 
/ S xCc*1
/5{CcE&
05
5
6& 
 B5
< 

> 


j*5S j>:#c@  59 & ,-
/:> 
F)0
&:%e%8(:#s 
 *
j1/* 
 9gCc*
3p , 
  *Cc‚5
+,  !:(,-%#1c5

q9/8 *
9  6#
 , *E%&<€'/@ ŸCc
+%(:9  F‚5
&…96ƒ ‡}Xˆz,  !:¬,-%#j:%1q(
6
3p , 
  
  ž  7 - T  _% D& _ 3*G "67 T  N #C _] &D&,-3*G " ;§' 7 - T  5"67 T  0 -D?_  $G'D?_ 3G *5
0 
@



4.2



%0!







 

5

5

|5
6,  !+:*
E%*
E%   sE%
<%

1 9  *k

jq9-ž 9%;= @%T A%C _ „:³'   _ 3D)(:H* - G H=IZJ$< @%T A%C  D& _ 3*G D&3D&6H - G&G #4C 5 _
] 0& 
D&@  -3*G "  „*„' ¡;1
>2##8 E%
!5
 
<
 8S Fh  
5
Cc%#0

9  *A2% 3Ac0.5 H* - & U# *'/ž : H 6 7 ;,+ = #* .„:Œ'



´



$

1

0.32

q = 0.8 q = 0.9 q=1

0.9

minimum distortion achieved distortion 0.3

0.8 0.28

0.7

463 578 01 2

0.26

0.6

3 578 01 2

0.5

0.4

0.24

0.22

0.3 0.2

0.2 0.18

0.1

0

0

˜ )”œ 


0.5

/

1

<;x˜c‘)˜c• 

1.5

2

2.5

0.16

3

)• –-œ9”– -œ )˜c›—“-”—˜c“-‘=’“-”(  

/


0

500

1000

1500

=

;' S *  2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

4500

5000

1.8

;¡ k5General
!*

E:>Case % 
!C6of<89Multiple  ,S
j
 Layers F+0
&8 
jªbn ;¦' 
!n)q=„@
&* 
5

3 %&,9
!%C+Ž
 
j ¥*8
Œ9FX0†5=5
1 E&
1 9  *z*:8
 @e|V5
! S *  2% 3 >%*
jq9-ž

4.3

: H(6 7<;L


   















  (















1.7

1.65

1.6

1.45

1.4

1.35

cq-'E   *kE%
˜ )”œ $™b˜c• c– —˜c“-‘)›4 &˜c—   6C33& U# &– ‘ _ 0# * C ’“(”h˜ )œ9“›œ -•kœ9‘‚—› 9“-‘‚—–˜c‘)˜c‘ z—“ = j’”–•sœ9› 1.3

5






1000

1500






2000

2500

3000

4

)

3500

4000

4500






5000





¥(:#FX0
< 5 %0 <8S  &%C+8 &…%9<ƒ ‡}Xˆx,  !: ,-#/
 jCc!E%
E <  ¢E
j%C _  # *SF
B E5-
/+0†5j 8 
  6E%
3  =# @A
?
E
 8 6
 89 
&„:³³!/5(% 
E
:#4:%  @Š¥8 )
19;' s¥8 
(1Scq(' ,9<5
!/59
*
 e:*
E%*
! S * e%

=
E
!E%  p !E
F9
 ,-
 
/*Fh% XVCD8  !Cb5
98 q(
%C(CcE%&
 %CX5

. ' c8 ,1 * &CcE&
 E'/@X
,9>9f-
 
9p 
*: <5(%
, 
 
9 * C5
&E5-
/+8 @&Ÿ> 0
:% 

<q-5jf(8 
 F) 5
<98 q-
%CXCcE%&
 V 
% 
 F)5
%E59

 sE%   =E%
?%

 S * =
E%
 A
<:# E5-
/)
::#4  *9
*
0% 5
>E%
VE
_k 5
98  S *  H=I?JE< @%T A%C F*
 ,-
 
/*@*)6´*³aCcE%&

*&
9F5
A9

 
=
 Š%
9xC CD!q-5

9   %

=E%   {E
@V0

F)5
19f-
 
9
*: 
A7989
j%
Cc! 
*&
9 105rA0 98 
z5
1 9  *x8 ,z   5S*5
15(% H=I?J$< @%T A%C @& <1´*³³&CcE%&
< 
*&
9F)5
 
&
* ?
& 0  ‹%

F 
 ,-
 
/*@ ƒ
F9*&&*& 
 F9&* )5*&*

8  
*&
9 X%
*&,- 
 C‚
 +5*8 E %ChCcE%?
 Vc5 ?

*8  
p

5

 





500

,-
 CD!
+q-
 0+

<:# E5
 89# ,-#/
 ) b0
¥CD¥0
 *:8
 %aC 39@XŸ6* S &*&&*989 hFh9h,-%#E
 %0‰E5-
/> 8 
  &E
 ?%
&
  &
@2/
9<5-z595 8 
  >E%
 @



0

 







1.55

1.5



¥*8
$¨6%
 V5
98  
E
6 9  *. H=I?JE< @%T A%C FS% j Cc8  *{%C5
jE%*
!E%   rE%
._FXCc! 9 h

9 *8
 C)E5-
/X 8 
  >E%
39@XA
*q 

<5-65
8*
C H=I?J$< @%T A%C % <&Cc8  *k%C^_z5(% <5
& 5(%,(
&%C>A
39,-
9p  X 
-ž5
9<8¯ 9  *A

:% 
 >
39,-
9 #" 055
<E%*
6E <  =E%
@>¡ >&
 5(%>5S*5l"
   
*% 
:'o 9  * &
798S
&5
&E   *=%C†2*
 2:#<98 q-
1%C<,(%E.
 F0V59#
A0 S *  A
7989
 
 *
&%*
98 q(
6CX,-/.*
 @ 
 8 j5
*&,(%  sq-
 0+

j,  ! 9-&ESp

<4
 =,-%#E
 F>% 
=q98 *, 4:% zCDE%&
0+.-F   ?
& &,9
 E &E%

4
 k,-%#E
 @&
&
*
&q9 LI"Y¤hROa¤(HRI"$M W:D?!K" G/F 5
6,-#15(%+ 
 >:
(% *
/. !¥p
 F905&,*q-qS##; B%  !%:*
 X0†5?,*q-qS##;  R b@ ƒ&,9
&,-#  D?!K"B$G
 ,-

 >&< E%  9g9E%

4
 ,(%#j5(% 


6 !b
 Cc>:#‚CcE%?
 %CX5
 
 @ ¥*8
Š¦S;'?%

z¥*8
¦9cq-',9FaCD& 9 h

9!*:8
 &C 39F‚5
?S<8  *
E%*
& S *   H=I?J$< @%T A%C % <&Cc8  *AC 5
6E
XE%   *AE
_F€0V5
!8 !6 ?,S
*, ! E ,-%#*F->m† "u9ƒ ‡}aˆk,  !h 9(%<V,(%#B%

? …9>ƒ‡}Xˆ *, 2:X 9-,(%#@>¥ F(0
6 

5-FSCD q(5&E5-
/h

S * ?33 U# *>%  3 & U# 9'/F …%9+ƒ ‡}aˆ *, 2: 9-1,(%#/
 !
!5
!q-
 ,-
 Cc!
2CD<:# *8
 >%C¬5
E
E%6
_@)|5
6 
 
oB S * 05
 8  jm† "uv%9?ƒ‡}Xˆ *, 2:+,-%#/
 
…%9<ƒ ‡}Xˆ *,Sp  2:X,-#/
 &j!8 ,A U 

  F-CD: 3Q =# * 3Q =# &
 ,-
 *
/zc59 6*
 ,-

  _  U# 9'/@>ƒ9
* hF 0+
&q 

B5- a &,9
 E% >,-%#E
 @¡ X&
 5(%F 
<8 b 9  *&! R3 : H 6 7 ;;F,  4/  E5
 89#<05Sp *8  
   
9 
?}Xˆx%*
  <#%<,-
 Cc*!% 
B% $ *
! &,9
 E5
 89#* 51@+|5S  5 %0 5(%?,S
3 *, <4% *l, 9
 8 
 6Cc>,-/.*
6 E5
 89# j%C+ 
%  ?
 S<%!q-
- 
798(%
<05
 +  
 !
9
>}aˆ6@ ¥(:#*Fa&,(%  1q-*5­f(8 
 F‚*
5(%>5
? S h


 

578

3

„:Ž'

 #

target rate achieved rate

1.75

 





 

5

 

¨



1

1

Simple policies Disjoint S+EC optimal policy Joint S+EC optimal policy

0.9

0.8

463 578 01 2

0.8

0.7

463 578 01 2

0.6

0.5

0.6

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

;*'^3N/ =# * “-•)– ”˜c›“-‘
Xœ9— œ9œ9‘{“R)—˜ •s– +™

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

˜ )”œ 


0.7

0.4

0

Simple policies Disjoint S+EC optimal policy Joint S+EC optimal policy

0.9

.

/

cq(',33/  U# a “ ˜ 9˜cœ9›6– ‘ {›˜c• cœ!”–‘ )“-•s˜9œ X“ c˜ 9˜ œ9›6’v“-”( 0

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3



%0!

?
9 18 8-#¢*
 ,-

rl
e 

 k21c'/F0+
A
39,(
 5(%B8 j,  4 ¢CcE%?
0.e
Š%z9f-9
/g95  4* 0##†%E5S

!!99 ,-
E (:,(
 Cc2% 
& >% 
 @  )
 
?
9 )?,- 
 ?%C‚Cc
0ACcE&
 )*SF*)!q-
?
!,, ,  %
!!8 

 






E

0 ¥ž   U Y3VXW Z  I  @ @ U U VXVXWW

 [ :] ^_ !Y3Z !Y3Z





 

U

 9DG ^ $"  ^ "# ^ GP;   I [ : ^_  M DG ^ %"  ^ "  ^ GP; ] _,"  I[*: ^_  M  DG ^ " "  ^ "# ^ GP; ]
P"

;¡ n)ADDITIONAL q9
 ŒSF*0
X 
 ?QUALITY †
0k798(:#;CONSTRAINT  E:9)8 b*,Sp  <4% *lCcE&
0*.-@BƒS,-
/#f-::#Fq-
  
 ?S<4/-k5
*
E%*
k S * hFH=IZJ$< @%A%C F>5
,  !&E   *¢,-#p A 5 89 e: j!9E:e%s
E
!*% % *kk S *  q(
 0

! 
8  
!%*
 F ;=9%@%A%CF q-
/0r!%3<8 ‹ 8 p E-qS
s8

¥@{Ÿ> &rn±*qS
 „F+0
j* 
15(%!5

5- o9f(S
1
 5h@*&!%*
= /5
 8S# =,-%# 7¬F ;=9 @%A%C DF7G+ >5
6*g98 k*
E%*

/f(
 jq9-ž  ;=9 @%A%C DF7G   U Y3 VXW Z    I [ : ] 6 K $R6 $R6 " K ; „9' _
Ÿ> VCc*
39,-

 1p
E%
s S *  %C2l
xCDE%&
¢ 
,(
 9{w%/p  *   %

¢*x5
= E%
ACc*j5
s,
*8 CcE%&
  F c@
@F -@r%0+

F+5
j
39,-

 
E
j*%  {z 9 p * kCc*6CcE%&(
= 
,(
 ! A*k5
!*:8
1C5
 E
CD&CcE%?
 (9FVc@
@F D"@¢¡ 



 hF6Cc „9'/F>0
j5(:*
;=9B@%A%CDF7G bI[ : K $  $ "dK ; F€0V5

$   5
> S *  CD)CcE%&6
:.F 059/5!
,-


 *5
98
$" R" 3R"  U"$#%#%#<9F-05



  "   j% &

  j
15
1 E
1 % *z, 9
  
 F 
 ,-
 *
/@
 
/f(
5

0 j%

j* †CD8   <% ž 9DG!"%" D" UG5%IJ: $R K !"%" D" S; „:´' „:¨' M DG  "   "   G&  " M DG !" "   "   GIJ: K $   $ !" KXK   "   "   ;F# „:¦' *{5
 
 
Ef-9  F(n±*qS
 Π:%q-
X
0 
?% ¥f(

Sp  B%B,  !:¬,-%#  7"T>05SE51!34
 5
6 %g€8p

„ 1' 05SE51C;# V9!5
*

E:¬5
*1CXij%.*jmV
/ sn±p 
  
 V05B89 ,S
? E:9 @+|V5
6*, 2:X,-#11q-
Cc*8

zCc ­#
%j, *E%£ #%jk5
j
j%*
zCc* n)q9
 „@sˆ&,(%
 zn)q9
 „FX5
198 q-
&%C$ #p %q9
 CX5
?ªbnk V 
% 
 ACc DF.- $G
) DF.-  GFh 5
98 6- F059/5?
!: E%E%q9
@(V*
&5-5
2%

S *-6 E:9 
39, 
  
 % Cc#0V ž @  M  DFIK" 4*"&;=G5D&3*G D ] - K H 7 H(6 7 K 3 G - K H 7 @ H(6 7 K 3 @ „§*' _ ¥*8
§9;'<%

z¥*8
Š§Scq('o 5 0F±CD   FX5
<S#p <8 9    H=I?JE< @%T A%C % ?Cc8  =%C5
!E%*
E
_F Cc* 
/

 =*:8
 &%C†5
!!38  *%  =l 9  *
¥@!Ÿ> 0
&k 

!q-5f-*8

k!%*
kE%*
E%
_Fh5

?
3p   98 ¯*:8
<%`C
2CD‹05SE5j5
S<8  9  p  ? E:9 X* E9@®65
X 89% * F(05SE5!%
 X 50 5

F- 5 0
 B5-V59 
 ,-

 <5
8
<%C¬5
<*
 p %*
6*%  1! 9  /59
*
 1q9&5
6*, 2:),(%#!%C n)q9
 „*Fc@
@F05 8 65
 E:9* ;=9%@BA%C@

5.



¥  MPEG–4
{~6E98S  FGS dƒS::VIDEOS %q9##  ;b~ƒ ' =l
0 , %f 
z%C ijnX}a~Vg€F*0V59E55(% ‚q-

 ,-
/#f-::#& E (% 94
 CDbE p   *xC< 
=
15
j¡ 9

j „E @r|5
b~ƒg }Xª :% q-
>8 %
 j%9905

6q(
/Cc
>E%   hFh% !5
f(
Eg E
 k,*,-
;@&|5

  j& *A*&,-
 E% *kk5
b~ƒg }Xª±F+ =5-2& B5S*5S{
 ##
9AkE <  r
 p  @+Ÿ6 9B&5


1Œ*³ &'/F+j 9,9:

¦

6.

¥*8
„³ 50 FCc) 9 h

9X

, *& E%
, DG  "   c" G/F 5
6nXƒ=:z%C(CcE%&
6B:Cc
X
*a*
:&
9FCc*,!q-
 0+

 „³*³&1„´*³S6@ 
#5(%  dce
*
 5
98
 98 q-
C

/*
 A
 CcCcE%?
bF)5
2na=ƒ :¢%C+CcE%&
  
 
 j0 5  c98 q(
j%C
 1Cc&CcE&
 :'/@ |5S < 5 %0 <5-
&,-E
* 
&
9 &
h
 *
2  
%  k5
!798-# kC65
!




 k 
@j|5
2 
 
{798(:# e%eq-
j5959{ 9#f-9­CD& *&
1CcE%?
 @r*
3 &,S
*F±CD6CcE&
j„Œ³9F)
,9%/ k5
f( &‚~ƒ€gS}aªzC5
8 
96CcE&
&q9j5
f- <}Xª°CD 5
&, 
*8 CDE%&
&:% &, 
j5
798(:#;zq9s:&*  (1 -©‹c0V5
   
 ³SFX5
nXUƒ 6‰%CCcE&
j„Œ*³­*9
 Cc*  U# (1 -©¢05
   
-  j *< -©{05
O   
- 5'/@ ¥*8
<„„ 5 0 49&
 &,-aCh
9
 &CcE%&6
 $:Cc

**
:&
9&05
 }aª=0% <

/*
 ACc*oCDE%&
1„9³  6Cc*6CcE%&
B„Ž§j"
/CcE'/F‚Š}aª=0% 

/
 ACc6CDE%&
1„9³ q 8B:#oŽŠ*
 1C6CcE&
k„Ž*§­0

j

/*
 xc

9
'/F 05
r:#<Žj:*
 j%CCDE%&
k„9³A0

j

/*
 tc *59E'/@¢Ÿ> 0
<% 

Fh5
&
E:#+798-# kCaCcE&
!„9³& q-

05
 :#)*
 CX5
?,
*8 CcE&
5(

S
,98
:'o5(%05
s!:*
 <:*#%q9
%5
&

/*
6Cc* 5
a, 
8 )CcE%&
"
ECcb,98 
'/@+V0
*
F5
X798(:#  b  ## 0
>5-A05
:#)
 %CXCcE%&
&„9³!5-

j
9
 kc 59>,S8 
'/@ 
&, 8
<5
<:*
E%*
 9  *k
>#)CcE%&
 VCX5

! 
&
9aCc†:#),(  q9


/
> E%
 @XŸCc
X*!:#p 4/ Fh0
*qEj5
Cc#%0 1 9  *A! 3Cc*  9I W*Hž 5

39

−,3 3,0 2,0 1,0 0,0

38

37






36

35

34

33 100

105

110

115

120

125

130

135

140

145

150

frame number n



˜ )”œ ™ t“ ’)’”–•sœ9› !—“ 6= !“’

–9’—œ9” Cb’v“-” )˜+9œ ”œ9‘b—”œ 9œ9˜?-œ9”!›—– —œ9›DGD" D c"BG  


!

  

 



 




- Cc*E%   1ijnX}X~Vg9!‚~ƒ2
9
 B 
?%*
 5
6¡;9

 E <65
©ªj05595j
E#%q9##";k"c@
@F 05{E5-
/<
*!
 ('/F<%

{5
‚~ƒ€gS}aª¢05{ 
19%c@w|5

ECc
F>0
B%{ 9
 r,,9{8 1*, #p <4% *lCcE&
0*.jj5
Bb~ƒg }Xª±@‚
 8 , ,- 
B5-5
©+ªŠ E <
 105 8 a  F(%

!5-5
698 q-
%C¬}Xª¥
39E%

S  *
 &l5
!,
8 2CDE%&
@sm8  k8 &
39,(
 &
9 F0
5(
>* 
 !5-59  E%
*,(
 Cc? 0
/#-CD)%0e& * 
! 
*&
9 q8 
!,-9* 1Cc+ 
&
9 V05B5S*5j&%p  *¥@$ V
1 
*&
9 05s?C : j595=&8 9%CX&* hF 8 E5j% <_)HULK T9Q U9W P*: VhH9W OY5
8
9XCcE%&
*@ƒ 
0
 8, ,-* 
5(%5
©+ª VE <
 05 8 o*  F) 8 /5s E
089 q-
&
 #=%, ,S#:%q9"
B *8< 9 
1@­V0
*
F)59 
7989
 &?9 S#Cc k5
! 
9 

X 
&
9a&,9
&
9E% hFh05SE5 *8)C‚5
 *,-
CX5S > 8 @ 
=,
 
9A
39,(
 &
9 =05¢5
°0y&*  
*&
9 SI WH@)
8 
 15

kBb~ƒg }Xªz0†5 *
E%*
Vq9E%
>%CŠ§³*³V.9q , @X
8X5
6‚~ƒ€gS}aª9F 6p
 &%C<
798(:> 4
kF  9'/@=|5
j
k 
&
9& !
 9
 9j5
Bˆ¡lCc*!%& *( ( j,S39
E E'/F<CcE%?
&E%
&C Ž*³­CcE&
 % 
@{¡ ?9E8 ', d ACcE&
 @{¡;=
! , 
*
99<8E 5 -8 8(% * 6!798(:# Bq-
;0

B 8
  
CDE%&
 FX5
&f- !©+ªlCcE%&
& &
9
 e% 2%k¡cg9,98
 #Cc%#0 lCcE&
 B% Bnbg9,98
 @‹cA
j  
 x5(%!8   $,© ‰©+ª g9
9
&89 l
!&,-E9&*%   2s798-#p ;kq-
;0

=5
! S h

9! 9,-
 ?%CCcE%?
 1 1:;F)05SE5=089 q(

E:9A &9*5
 Aq9&q-

6
 9
@#'j¡ j59 ,(%,-
F 0+
68 
65
nb
.g ƒ(:#g9=g % 
% 1;nXUƒ 6'a&
 8
>
8-
5
798(:#;C‚5
>


 !
CcE%&
 @aŸ5*8*5 5
Bna=ƒ :x <*5959k*
/%
 l05k 8 q9u
 *
1798(:#;F  
 AB&, 8 
!%

kA
B%A

9% *z%C+
E# 798(:#;@

 U # * = #( U # : H(6 7<;"!$#$% &$'3 U #  U U## **( = =##( ( # ;Œ³*' U # &* U# ( =#  
j5(%H   = #* ( k H -  U# s%

H   U# (k H  -  U # &*9@j|
5S &?
% 5(%<

,9%/ =#
 CD 5









 









 

8 
9VCDE%&
8 
9CcE%&
$%

15
 8q 
798
9V*
 %C)5
6, 
#p 8 CcE%?
@X|V59  6 8
?8 V ?,S
&
&,-EX}Xˆz E%
*@ ƒ
B0
! S e*o?,S
?
9B%9k&* =*&,-
 E% *lCc* }Xˆ$Fh5
!
,9%
?
9C
 <%C†5
&8
96CDE%&
&q91p
 &C>5
!, 
8 &CcE%&
B

 *&
1 8(:&,(:?
9 @ |5
 
o&,(:?
9 &
8 8(:# 6Cc*%0g€& *k 
 
*&
9 @%0+

F‚CcCcE%?
 059/5°%
! 9#f-:%9 z 9#C"p Cc

92CDy5
j,
*8 1CDE%&
 F5

 8S  l 
 
­

9  j:%&q-
> #59 B5S*5
5(%!5
V

:% 
V! 9  p  jq 8 59>q9!
*
::&
9@ ¥*8
„ŒS;*' °¥8 
A„Œ9cq-' 5 %0FbCD…%9>%

Bm† "u9ƒ ‡}aˆz*, !‚,-%#/
 F) 0
/#$  &,9
,  !:>,-#/
 @{Ÿ> oe¥8 
¦SFX5
1!3p <8 798-# {/59
*
 zq9=m "u%9Šƒ‡}Xˆt*, 2:>,-%#E
 %

{ &,9
=,-%#/
 ­ j #F<0V59#
=…%9ƒ ‡}aˆ‹,  !: ,-#/
 %E59

5
jq(
 &798(:# zCD!#E%*
!E%
 @e|5
9!q*8*59aq9u%9 ?,  4/ & /5
 8S# ! &
X9p 
&
9 8,. # *& -© CD!/5(% 
/05s595 8
  E%
k?3 U# *'/@wA
j
39,-
B5
 S

 
A{798(:# {q(
/p  0+

A…9 m "u%9<ƒ ‡}aˆ{,  !X,-%#/
 &q(

*
 595
605!
*
:&
96 E5
?
 5(%?,-
 E%
6Cc* &* hFh*E%q91q918  5
<©ª­9Cc*!% *¥@ ¥(:#F!|XqS
e„k, 
 
9 j5
k
 89 j%C! <8S  ACc*  9I W*HV
6„³*³o
#4% * C¬o,(%E.

E 8
>/5(% 
/)05

5

1

5

1

1

γ = 0.1 γ = 0.2 γ = 0.3 γ = 0.4 γ = 0.5

0.9

0.8

0.8

0.7

463 578 01 2

463 578 01 2

0.6

0.5

0.7

0.6

0.5

0.4

0.4

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

;*'^3N =# * cq(',33/  U# †˜ )”œ8 <;x˜c‘)˜c• )• )˜c›—“-”—˜c“-‘e–›&–j’ )‘ 9—˜ “(‘l“ ’6— )œj—–” -œ9—!—”– ‘)›•k˜c››˜c“-‘e”–—œ _ bC ’v“-” 0

0

0.5




˜ )”œ

a
' 


/

γ = 0.1 γ = 0.2 γ = 0.3 γ = 0.4 γ = 0.5

0.9

1





1.5

2

2.5

0

3



 



6’v”–•kœ9 j“’

 ))œ9‘ #cœ’v— ( #5  -%N ="   =# &  C# ”˜
b— ( #     ( Aa
'  U# 0 

(

A

a
'

2.5

3



 C # •k˜  cœ"(

U

5  -% ="    N #

37.5

37

37

36.5

36.5



36

36



35.5

35.5

35

35

34.5

34.5

34

34

33.5

33.5

/ ;*'^3N/ =# * cq(',33 U# <;x–=
h˜c• )• ™   – ›–j’ )‘ 9—˜ “(‘k“’— )œ1—– ” -œ9—1–-œ9”– -œ—”–‘)›•s˜ ››˜c“-‘{”–—œj’“(”

 C 

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

33

3

0

0.5




2

Joint S+EC Disjoint S+EC Simple policies

38

37.5

†˜ )”œ

1.5

38.5

Joint S+EC Disjoint S+EC Simple policies

38

33

1




 N

38.5



0.5







0







1

1.5

2

2.5

3



 



§




"


U

(

A

/.-0/1 2

/.-0/1 > /.-CB:1 2

"# 354( 6 3 6?( 6 358( 9


   !$ % !&' #! )( 7 354( 89 354:( ; < 3 3 6?( 6; 3 6@( 3 6 4 358( 9D; 3 6@( 7 3

   "'#!$ % ! # ! 9( = = 9( =9 9( 4= 9( 49 A( = = A( =9

)| E%   h@‚¡ NK+W HM O)HPQ_RHB^aF(,-
 <„9´g-„1SF ªb8 E
F‚ƒ90†4
 %

¥F¬ƒ9
,
q-
Œ³*³Œ9@  ´:onb@-Ÿ@(ˆ5 8j SMb@ i%@a
/g m  °®6, 4
 ƒS

 g m 
°ƒS
 1
>©a
  g } h+ V
;0.9 @ ¡ S  KW;H%M O)H PUTŒ³³9„@  ¨:onb@-Ÿ@(ˆ5 8jS

Mb@ i%a@ 
/g m  °®6, 4
 ƒS
:% 1C+n)%E.
 4
 i1
 S9@)L=Q [YIK KcOEPKc*H Q/^X^a^ VW;U9JLU9MKcI"H9JL†H9U J HjQ9RK IYOEP9I"UF 
q8(%ŠŒ³³9„@  ¦:onb@-
<ˆ†8
* Fhnb@(~68S##*
/ F @ x@†*  Fh mo@(|V5 
:%8h@h¡ &,9
&
9E %CXŸ> -, *
&ƒ9
%<!%C ƒS*
 ijnX}a~Vg€1‚~ƒ  
 @h¡ S  KW;H%M O)H PQR_ HB^aF(,-
 9³*´:g9€³ 19F‚ªb%8 E% 
F‚ƒS04
 %

¥F‚Ÿ68 8 Œ*³³Œ9@  1:onb@-
<ˆ†8
* FhiA@ 
/  
E¥F¬%

@ x@*  @ }±*8- j5
<ƒS
:% 1CXb~ƒg }) 9 
 A  
 0 5 V
/g m  *k|)E%
 @|)
/5 S:: 
,-* +gS³Žg ³*¦ 1SF‚¡   8$}±8  W*1Fb…8 
<Œ³³*ŽS@  §:onb@-
<ˆ†8
* 6 @ r@  @(Ÿ6 (%,  
%
<ˆ*9% Cc>ƒ9
%<ŠƒS*
 j¥
/pv~6E:
 =ƒ9:qS
? V
@h¡; KW;HM O)H PJX*YX\-Z \ I\[hF‚i%<cF‚¥  (SF¬ij:BŒ*³³Œ9@ „³:oˆ6@hmV
!%h@ VXI"J(I"KcO6\hKcU9K JO HŠU9W 9H I"U9LJ IOEM%ILI"H9J KW;HM/OLELOLE@9Ÿ6 
&n)
   F V
^ 0 ]X.-F‚„§¦*³S@ „„/ o@ VhF @hƒ9859<8S#
F¬iA@hª-.-F‚ Š©V@h~V9 h@ q 8 >¡ 9

6  
|)E <  s©% 
 B ƒS::%q9
Bˆ9 S B%

V
798-X})>n)
 *¥@)\ I#T9J-UR KW;HM/OLELI"J€@ T _`QYUT9O!_)H9YY
8 Sg€ &
m† * =© 
 jƒ9E5
 89#1Cc*>mV
/#*
j%C+ƒ9:qS
i1
 9S@h¡ S  KW;HM O)H PQJ(K OWEJ-U9KcI"H9J-URh_)H9aJ POW OJ-MEOH PJKU9M 9OK [‚I"P9O/HF(nb q8 F‚n-Ÿ, #+Œ*³³*ŒS@ „%oi Cc@h¡ƒ ® %¡v}aˆ¢„*9§*¨2  
 
/Cc

 
?ƒSCc 0†%
@ i Cc g )mŸ$iA„/g Œ9@#Žg ³*³S„Œ9„*ŽS@ „´:oiA@hnb9 % .9F¬iA@  a

 #cF‚%

jƒ-@hi1ˆ
@hª-
 
E%   s%C 
:#g€|&
!ªb*

 ji189 &
 9S@¬¡  KW;HM O)H PUT*
/
 ˆŸˆ†**
  ˆ*9%#
  V
Bn¬9q(%E. 
>5
¡;9

@-¡ S  KW;HM O)H Pª‚:*

 b68-# g€Ÿ6 (%,  "*
¡;9

 V
Bn¬9q(%E.-@h¡ N  K+W HM O H PKN-U O T
n)%  g m
,-



9 nb%#/
 oCc*ij%.*jmV
/ =n)9
  
 V=5ki189 ,9
ˆ E:9 @ Y¥¤(OW U9KcI"H9J hL g+OLOEU9W MENF€Ž¦9;Ž'/ž 9¦%g9€¦¦SF ijg-…8 
!„*§ 1§S@ „§:oƒ @ mo@ ƒS
*
@+_)H9Y¤‚W OL/LI"H9JBU9J-.P gORI"U [RO VW;U9JLY
bj@ M-598h@‚}±*6ˆ*9%X Šˆ 
:?
9 Cc  
Bˆ?8 S:%  žŸ 

0@ K+W HM ObH Pi18S ?
 Sjƒ9
!
V5
¡ 9

 @ VW U9J L O)H9UJ HŠQSRKcI"Y
"! * +,( 9( =4 9( 6A A( 9A



a–
cœ <™b˜c• c– —˜c“-‘)›: ?˜ — 33 U# 8 
  &E%
3 1 U# @j
! 50F)Cc< S

9!*:8
 &%C>5
*
E%*
E
>E%   eE%
_Fb5
?%E5S
*
 =798-# j nXƒ=:¢ j5
E <  kE
Fh
E%
 A
:#XE5(% 
/ 
::#4  @A
?: ! 5 0¢5
<S<8²798-# %

!%3#p <8  E   *=E%
F(0V59E5k
&/59

 kq91*
&E5(% 
/ 
::#4 h@&Ÿ6 >0
<%j 

*Fb5
&*
E%*
!%E5S

 k*8
 <
*
k/* 
jj5
BE%*
&*:8
 @=|5S ? 50 &5(%?%, ,S  *8)9f-9
/g95  491,  4 !CcE%&
0.f-9
/g
*5 
* 
 !*
A*99 z,-
 Cc!
@k¡;k5S !
3 &,9
F5


9 h


sq-
 0+

{5
A9<8 /59
*
 ¢nX=ƒ :¯ {5
E
?798-# k !:0†:9 &0
<5(%e³S@ Ž­ (©V@)|5
! S h


q(
 0

k5
2%3<8 %E5S
*
 =E%   eE%
B%

k5
E
E   *kE%
6 >09 V0
>5-. 1 !@ E

 





5

5

5

2

;¡ CONCLUSION 5S ),(%,-
F0
X5(:*
, ,-* 
 &
0=,  4 &CcE%?
/p 0+.ACc*Vuv%9&,(%E.
? /5
 8S# e%

z
**
:&
9C *

 9g9
1…%9+ƒ ‡}aˆ'/@
V8 
 &
 8S X< E:
 ij.!m
/ Šn±9
  
 X%*
Sf(9
/g95  49hFh6p , 8 
j,  !:<,-#/
 j05z*
k0†g€?,S
3;¢ =Cc2 0
E*
%CX798(:#;j&
  @ 
&-94
 =5
, q9
 %C<S4Ek5
?:*
E%*
& 9 p * &8 


Xa#
 E <  !E%
@±®68¬%(:9  a
  0g9&,9
3  :* 5 1Fq- 
 k*zª-
:%!n)*E%p < @ 
 50
 r5
A,-*
9 :?798(:# r9¢q 8 59jq9 …9ƒ ‡}aˆ=,  4% *A*
m "u%9>ƒ ‡}aˆz*, <4% *¥@ 
 S !98 &
 ‚ 89% * >%*
+6,-/.*
 g9
E 8
E5(% 
/ 05= E9Cc

 q(%E.-Fz* 
!=  
  !5
B,-
 Cc*!% 
C*8>,  4 ACcE&
0*.Cc*f-9
/g
*5l
* @6
5(
 

<5(%)8 X&
5 9 f- ),(% 8S 0+
/#-> 
 
%p ?
9 &,-* 
 zC598  
 C> 
jCcE&
 @j
! 50
 5(%X8 aCcE&
0*.&#0V +&?&9 -
  9 (:¬798-#p ;=&
  !5
&5(%=5

E
1 9  *¥F> 8 /5 % &5
* % jj 9  q-
;0

B 
8  
<!%*
 Fh051  <8 /5x 
 
l¢&, 8E (:B*&,S
3 @£¥(:#*F10
5(
&
8-
 5
<,-
 Cc*!% 
&C*8>,  4 kCcE%?
/p 0+.&j5
9
39>%C) 
:% jijnX}a~Vg€!b~ƒ1
* @ ¡;lCc8 8
j0+.-F>0
j,S{=
39


{8 CcE&
0*.l° 
;0.&?9 
/‚051
/
 Cc

 q(%E.B%


/
 j,-/.*
 *  
 &;~V#q-
?9 
/'/@>ŸV  Fb0+
0†##)9*
  9
u%9 j*,Sp  <4/s /5
 8S# e%

k/5(% 
/>
<
 hFq98   )}Xˆ{9 
 % >  9 (:X
 @

7.





 „E<¡REFERENCES ƒ ® %¡v}aˆx„9§*¨:gSŒ <Ÿ6& GFFh~6

 ?ˆ9 S !%C Ÿ68

Sg9  8-®6q9u
 ža  8-c@h¡ƒ ® %¡v}aˆ …|>ˆ$„ ƒ ˆŒ§ e~„„>Ž³§*´SF mV

q-
„§*§§9@ #Œ 
,-*ijna}X~Vg9&  8-+¥
?~6E%989% ; ƒS::%q9## |)9% > a
 #f- |)
  @ ¡ƒ ® %¡v}aˆ …|>ˆ$„ ƒ ˆŒ§ e~„„ 9¦§9„F ij:ŠŒ³*³ŒS@ #Ž?}†@ Ÿ!%h@_)H9J LKcW U9IJ-O/*P HjU9W SH JI$O/MI LI"H9LJ KW;H%MEOL/LOL/@ ˆ5-,!j >:#cF)„§*§§9@  ?o@(ˆ:cF ~@-ƒ95
¥F‚a@ 8¥F ƒ @ ª cF %

©V)@ M-
 @ }±* ˆ 
:?
9VCc*>¥
?~6E%989% ;ƒS%q9
& V


8.



2

„³