/DVVRQULVDVPiVGXOFHV /DVVRQULVDVPiVGXOFHVHVFRQGHQORVVHFUHWRVPiVRVFXURV HVFRQGHQORVVHFUHWRVPiVRVFXURV 



  6DUD6KHSDUG 6DUD6KHSDUG 

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

$JUDGHFLPLHQWRV $JUDGHFLPLHQWRV $JUDGHFHPRV D WRGDV DTXHOODV SHUVRQDV FRQ ODV FXDOHV FRQ VX LQWHUpV FRODERUDFLyQ \ DSR\R LQFRQGLFLRQDO VH SXGR VDFDU DGHODQWH HVWH SUR\HFWR $O LJXDO TXH D QXHVWURV OHFWRUHVSRUVXOHDODSR\RHVWRHVSRUXVWHGHV

 0RGHUDGRUD 0RGHUDGRUD 3DROD6

 6WDIIGH7UDGXFFLyQ 6WDIIGH7UDGXFFLyQ $QHOLVVH &OR &\HO\'LYLQQD 'DQL 'KDP/RYH '\DQQD (PLLB*UHJRUL *LR(OL9LF5RVH NLNL PDVL 0HU\6Q] 0RP\ 3DROD6 5XKLHH


6WDIIGH&RUUHFFLyQ WDIIGH&RUUHFFLyQ &DDPLOOH (PLLB*UHJRUL /RR  0DULQD 2EVHVVLRQ 9DQ  ʾ

5HFRSLODFLyQ 5HFRSLODFLyQ\5HYLVLyQ \5HYLVLyQ



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

 'LVHxR 'LVHxR $QGUHD1

ʹ

&DDPLOOH

‹‘’•‹• ”׎‘‰‘ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ͳ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ʹ ƒ’À–—Ž‘͵ ƒ’À–—Ž‘Ͷ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ͷ ƒ’À–—Ž‘͸ ƒ’À–—Ž‘͹ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ͺ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ͻ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ͳͲ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ͳͳ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ͳʹ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ͳ͵ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ͳͶ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ͳͷ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ͳ͸ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ͳ͹ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ͳͺ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ͳͻ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ʹͲ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ʹͳ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ʹʹ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ʹ͵ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ʹͶ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ʹͷ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ʹ͸ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ʹ͹ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ʹͺ ƒ’À–—Ž‘ʹͻ ƒ’À–—Ž‘͵Ͳ ƒ’À–—Ž‘͵ͳ ’‹Ž‘‰‘ ‡ƒ”–Ž‡•• …‡”…ƒ†‡Žƒƒ—–‘”ƒǥƒ”ƒŠ‡’ƒ”†



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

.LOOHU ͷ ͸ ͳͷ ʹʹ ͵Ͳ ͵͹ Ͷͷ ͷʹ ͸ʹ ͹Ͳ ͹͸ ͺͶ ͻͶ ͳͲʹ ͳͲͺ ͳͳͺ ͳʹ͸ ͳ͵͸ ͳͶ͵ ͳͷͲ ͳͷ͹ ͳ͸͵ ͳ͹ʹ ͳͺͲ ͳͺͻ ͳͻ͸ ʹͲʹ ʹͲͻ ʹͳͷ ʹʹͳ ʹ͵ͳ ʹ͵ͺ ʹͶͳ ʹͶͶ ʹͶͷ ʹͶ͸



͵

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

ž‰‹ƒ

6DUD6KHSDUG

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

             ž‰‹ƒ

Ͷ

 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

6LQRSVLV 6LQRSVLV 

(

Q OD IRWR SHUIHFWD GH 5RVHZRRG 3HQQV\OYDQLD UXELDV LOXPLQDFLRQHV VH GHVWDFDQFRQHOEULOORGHOVROGHLQYLHUQR\FRQORVODJRVFRQJHODGRVEULOODQWHV FRPR FULVWDOHV GH 6ZDURYVNL 3HUR ODV IRWRV PLHQWHQ D PHQXGR \ WDPELpQ OR KDFHQODVFXDWURFKLFDVPiVJXDSDVGH5RVHZRRG +DQQD$ULD6SHQFHU\(PLO\KDQHVWDGRPLQWLHQGRGHVGHTXHVHKLFLHURQDPLJDVGH ODEHOOD$OLVRQ'L/DXUHQWLV$OLODVKL]RKDFHUFRVDVWHUULEOHVFRVDVTXHWXYLHURQTXH PDQWHQHU HQ VHFUHWR GXUDQWH DxRV < D SHVDU GH TXH $OL IXH DVHVLQDGD DO ILQDO GHO VpSWLPRJUDGRVXVKiELWRVGHFKLFDVPDODVQRPXULHURQFRQHOOD +DQQD HVWi HQ XQD PLVLyQ SDUD FRUURPSHU D ORV MyYHQHV GH 5RVHZRRG FRPHQ]DQGR FRQXQHVWXGLDQWHGHVHJXQGRDxRPX\DWUDFWLYR$ULDHVStDHQHOSDVDGRGHVXQRYLR 6SHQFHUUREDDVXIDPLOLD<ODSHTXHxD\SXUD(PLO\VHDEVWLHQHGHODDEVWLQHQFLD /DV FKLFDV GHEHQ WHQHU FXLGDGR VLQ HPEDUJR (OODV SHQVDEDQ TXH HVWDEDQ VHJXUDV FXDQGRHODVHVLQRGH$OLIXHGHWHQLGR\ODYHUGDGHUDLGHQWLGDGGH´$µIXHUHYHODGDDO ILQ 3HUR DKRUD KD\ XQD 1XHYD ´$µ HQ OD FLXGDG VXELHQGR HO FDORU < HVWD YH] 5RVHZRRGYDDDUGHU  

ž‰‹ƒ

ͷ

6H[WROLEURGHODVDJD3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

3UyORJR 3UyORJR 6LPDOQRUHFXHUGR 6LPDOQRUHFXHUGR 7UDGXFLGRSRU3DROD6 &RUUHJLGRSRU&DDPLOOH 

¢4

XpSDVDUtDVLGHUHSHQWHSXGLHUDVUHFRUGDUFDGDVHJXQGRGHWXYLGDHQWHUD" < QR VyOR WRGRV ORV DFRQWHFLPLHQWRV LPSRUWDQWHV VLQR UHFRUGDU FRVDV SHTXHxDV WDPELpQ &RPR FXDQGR W~ \ WX PHMRU DPLJD SRU SULPHUD YH] VH GREODURQRGLDQGRHORORUDFHPHQWRGHJRPDHQODFODVHGHDUWHGHWHUFHUJUDGR2OD SULPHUDYH]TXHYLVWHDOFKLFRGHRFWDYRJUDGRTXHWHJXVWDEDHVWDEDFDPLQDQGRSRUHO SDWLRGHODHVFXHODUHERWDQGRXQDSHORWDGHI~WEROHQXQDPDQR\FRQXQL3RG7RXFK HQODRWUD 3HUR FRQ WRGD EHQGLFLyQ YLHQH XQD PDOGLFLyQ &RQ WX PHPRULD LPSHFDEOHPHQWH IODPDQWHW~WDPELpQUHFRUGDUtDVWRGDVODVSHOHDVFRQWXPHMRUDPLJD5HYLYLUtDVFDGD YH]TXHWXHQDPRUDGRGHOI~WEROVHVHQWyMXQWRDRWUDSHUVRQDHQHODOPXHU]R&RQOD PHPRULD  HO SDVDGR GH UHSHQWH SRGUtD YROYHUVH XQ PRQWyQ WRWDOPHQWH GHVDJUDGDEOH¢$OJXLHQWHSDUHFHUtDFRPRXQDOLDGRDKRUD"0LUDGHQXHYRSRGUtDVHU TXHQRHUDWDQDJUDGDEOHFRPRSHQVDEDV¢8QDPLJRTXHUHFRUGDEDVFRPRDOJXLHQTXH VLHPSUHFXLGDEDWXHVSDOGD"£8\(QXQDLQVSHFFLyQPiVFHUFDQDQRWDQWR 6L D FXDWUR ERQLWDV FKLFDV HQ 5RVHZRRG VH OHV GLR GH UHSHQWH PHPRULDV SHUIHFWDV GHEHUtDQ KDEHU UHYLVDGR PHMRU HQ TXLpQ FRQILDU \ GH TXLpQ PDQWHQHUVH DOHMDGDV 3RU RWUDSDUWHWDOYH]VXSDVDGRWHQGUtDPXFKRPHQRVVHQWLGRTXHDQWHV /DPHPRULDHVXQDFRVDFDSULFKRVD<DYHFHVHVWDPRVFRQGHQDGRVDUHSHWLUODVFRVDV TXHKHPRVROYLGDGR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

$OOt HVWDED /D JUDQ FDVD YLFWRULDQD HQ OD HVTXLQD GHO FDOOHMyQ VLQ VDOLGD OD GH OD HQUHGDGHUDGHURVDVDORODUJRGHOHQUHMDGR\ODFXELHUWDGHWHFDFRQJUDGDVHQODSDUWH SRVWHULRU6yORXQRVSRFRVKDEtDQHVWDGRDOJXQDYH]HQHOLQWHULRUSHURWRGRHOPXQGR VDEtDTXLpQYLYtDDOOt(UDODFKLFDPiVSRSXODUGHODHVFXHOD8QDFKLFDTXHHVWDEOHFtD WHQGHQFLDV LQVSLUDED DSDVLRQDGRV DPRUHV \ GDxDED R FUHDED UHSXWDFLRQHV /D FKLFD FRQTXHFDGDFKLFRTXHUtDVDOLU\TXHFDGDFKLFDTXHUtDVHU

͸



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

$OLVRQ'L/DXUHQWLVSRUVXSXHVWR (UD XQD SDFtILFD PDxDQD GH SULQFLSLRV GH 6HSWLHPEUH HQ 5RVHZRRG 3HQQV\OYDQLD XQDLGtOLFD/tQHD3ULQFLSDOGHODFLXGDGDXQRVWUHLQWDNLOyPHWURVGH)LODGHOILD(O6U &DYDQDXJKTXHYLYtDDORWURODGRGHODFDOOHGHODIDPLOLDGH$OLVRQ SDVHDEDSRUVX SDWLRHQEXVFDGHOSHULyGLFR(OSHUUR*ROGHQ5HWULHYHUFRORUOHRQDGRTXHSHUWHQHFtDD ORV9DQGHUZDOVFRUUtDSRUWRGRHOFHUFDGRHQHOSDWLRWUDVHURODGUDQGRDODVDUGLOODV 1LXQDIORUXKRMDHVWDEDIXHUDGHOXJDUDH[FHSFLyQGHFXDWURFKLFDVGHVH[WRJUDGR D ODV FXDOHV VH OHV RFXUULy DUUDVWUDUVH VLJLORVDPHQWH HQ HO SDWLR GH ORV 'L/DXUHQWLV DO PLVPRWLHPSR (PLO\)LHOGVVHHVFRQGtDHQWUHODVJUDQGHVSODQWDVGHWRPDWHWLUDQGRQHUYLRVDPHQWHGH ORVFRUGHOHVGHVXVXGDGHUDGH1DWDFLyQGH5RVHZRRG'D\1XQFDKDEtDWUDVSDVDGROD SURSLHGDGGHQDGLH\PXFKRPHQRVHOSDWLRWUDVHURGHODPiVERQLWDODPiVSRSXODU FKLFD GH OD HVFXHOD $ULD 0RQWJRPHU\ VH DJDFKy GHWUiV GH XQ iUERO GH UREOH UHFRJLHQGRORVERUGDGRVGHODW~QLFDTXHVXSDGUHOHKDEtDWUDtGRGHRWUDFRQIHUHQFLD HQ $OHPDQLD VREUH KLVWRULD GHO DUWH GH ~OWLPD KRUD +DQQD 0DULQ DEDQGRQDED VX ELFLFOHWDHQXQDURFDFHUFDGHODFXELHUWDGHODIDPLOLDHODERUDQGRVXSODQGHDWDTXH 6SHQFHU +DVWLQJV FUX]y D VX SDWLR YHFLQR \ VH DJDFKy GHWUiV GH XQ DUEXVWR GH IUDPEXHVDVFXLGDGRVDPHQWHSRGDGDVLQKDODQGROLJHUDPHQWHHOGXOFH\SLFDQWHRORUGH ODVED\DV (QVLOHQFLRFDGDFKLFDPLUyODYHQWDQDWUDVHUDGHODEDKtDGHORV'L/DXUHQWLV6RPEUDV SDVDEDQDWUDYpVGHODFRFLQD+XERXQJULWRHQHOEDxRGHDUULED8QDUDPDVHTXHEUy $OJXLHQWRVLy

ž‰‹ƒ

³¢4XpKDFHQDTXt"³SUHJXQWy6SHQFHU+DEtDFRQRFLGRD(PLO\+DQQD\$ULDHQOD %LEOLRWHFD 3~EOLFD GH 5RVHZRRG HQ SULPHU JUDGR HQ XQ FRQFXUVR GH OHFWXUD TXH 6SHQFHUKDEtDJDQDGRSHURHQHOTXHWRGDVSDUWLFLSDURQ1RHUDQDPLJDV(PLO\HUDHO WLSR GH FKLFD TXH VH VRQURMDED FXDQGR XQ PDHVWUR OD OODPDED HQ FODVH +DQQD TXH HVWDEDWLUDQGRGHODFLQWXUDGHVXVSDQWDORQHVQHJURVGHPH]FOLOODXQSRFRGHPDVLDGR SHTXHxRV QXQFD SDUHFtD FyPRGD FRQ Vt PLVPD < $ULD EXHQR SDUHFtD TXH KR\ OOHYDEDSDQWDORQHVGHFXHUR6SHQFHUHVWDEDEDVWDQWHVHJXUDGHTXHORVDPLJRVGH$ULD HUDQVyORLPDJLQDULRV ³8KQDGD³UHSOLFy+DQQD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

͹

/DVFKLFDVVHGLHURQFXHQWDTXHQRHVWDEDQVRODVHQH[DFWDPHQWHHOPLVPRPRPHQWR 6SHQFHUREVHUYyDODWRUSH(PLO\SRUHOERVTXH(PLO\HVStRD+DQQDHQFXFOLOODVMXQWR DODURFD+DQQDYLVOXPEUyD$ULDGHWUiVGHOiUERO7RGDVPDUFKDURQKDFLDHOFHQWUR GHOSDWLRWUDVHURGH$OL\VHUHXQLHURQHQXQFtUFXORFHUUDGR



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³6tQDGD³GLMR$ULDPLUiQGRODVFRQUHFHOR(PLO\VHHQFRJLyGHKRPEURV ³¢4XpHVWiVKDFLHQGRW~"³OHSUHJXQWy+DQQDD6SHQFHU 6SHQFHUVXVSLUy(UDREYLRTXHHVWDEDQDTXtSRUODPLVPDUD]yQ+DFHGRVWDUGHVHQ 5RVHZRRG 'D\ OD HVFXHOD SUHSDUDWRULD GH pOLWH D OD TXH DVLVWtDQ KDEtD DQXQFLDGR OD DGHODQWDGD VDOLGD GH VX WDQ HVSHUDGR MXHJR GH OD &iSVXOD GHO 7LHPSR &DGD DxR HO 'LUHFWRU$SSOHWRQFRUWDEDXQDEDQGHUDGH5RVHZRRG'D\D]XO\EULOODQWHHQPXFKDV SLH]DVORVHVWXGLDQWHVGH~OWLPRDxRODVHVFRQGtDQHQODFLXGDG\ORVSURIHVRUHVGDEDQ SLVWDV SDUD OD FD]D VREUH HO SDUDGHUR GH FDGD SLH]D HQ ORV GH OD SDUWH VXSHULRU \ ORV JUXSRVPiVEDMRVGHODHVFXHOD4XLHQHQFRQWUDUDXQDSLH]DWHQtDTXHGHFRUDUODFRPR pO R HOOD TXLVLHUD \ XQD YH] TXH FDGD SLH]D IXHUD HQFRQWUDGD HO SHUVRQDO FRVtD OD EDQGHUDGH QXHYR\VHFHOHEUDEDXQDJUDQDVDPEOHDHQKRQRUDORV JDQDGRUHV\ODV HQWHUUDEDQHQXQD&iSVXODGHO7LHPSRGHWUiVGHORVFDPSRVGHI~WERO/RVHVWXGLDQWHV TXHHQFRQWUDEDQSLH]DVGHOD&iSVXODGH7LHPSRHUDQOH\HQGDV\VXOHJDGRYLYtDSDUD VLHPSUH (V GLItFLO VREUHVDOLU HQ XQD HVFXHOD FRPR 5RVHZRRG 'D\ \ HUD D~Q PiV GLItFLO HQFRQWUDUXQDSLH]DGHODEDQGHUDGHOD&iSVXODGHO7LHPSR6yORXQYDFtROHGDEDD WRGRVXQDOX]GHHVSHUDQ]DODFOiXVXODGHURERTXHGHFODUDEDTXHHUDOHJDOUREDUXQ SHGD]RGHDOJXLHQMXVWRKDVWDHOPRPHQWRHQTXHODSLH]DVHVHSXOWDUD+DFtDGRVGtDV DOJXLHQKHUPRVDVHKDEtDMDFWDGRGHTXHXQDGHODVSLH]DVHUDWDQEXHQDFRPRVX\D $KRUD FXDWUR GRQ QDGLH HVSHUDEDQ WRPDU YHQWDMD GH OD FOiXVXOD GH URER FXDQGR PHQRVVHORHVSHUDUD /D LGHD GH UREDU OD SLH]D GH $OLVRQ HUD HPEULDJDGRUD 3RU XQ ODGR HUD XQD RSRUWXQLGDGGHDFHUFDUVHDHOOD3RURWURODGRHUDXQDRSRUWXQLGDGSDUDPRVWUDUOHDOD FKLFD PiV JXDSD GH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ TXH WDO YH] QR VLHPSUH FRQVHJXtD WRGR OR TXH TXHUtD$OLVRQ'L/DXUHQWLVGHILQLWLYDPHQWHPHUHFtDXQDUHYLVLyQGHODUHDOLGDG 6SHQFHUPLUyDODVWUHVFKLFDV ³
+DQQD VH FXDGUy GH KRPEURV \ PLUy ODV WUHQ]DV GHVRUGHQDGDV GH $ULD \ ORV JUXHVRV FROODUHVHQFDSDV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

ͺ

³7~DFDEDVGHOOHJDUDTXt
6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢<TXLpQWHYDDFUHHU" ³&KLFDV³(PLO\DSXQWyFRQVXEDUELOODSXQWLDJXGDKDFLDODFDVD'L/DXUHQWLV\OOHYy XQGHGRDVXVODELRV+DEtDYRFHVTXHYHQtDQGHODFRFLQD ³1RORKDJDV³VRQyFRPR$OL/DVFKLFDVVHWHQVDURQ ³1RORKDJDV³LPLWyXQDVHJXQGDYR]GHWRQRDOWR ³£%DVWD³$OLFKLOOy ³£%DVWD³6HKL]RHFRODVHJXQGDYR] (PLO\KL]RXQDPXHFD6XKHUPDQDPD\RU&DURO\QVROtDLPLWDUODYR]GH(PLO\DVt\ (PLO\ORRGLDED6HSUHJXQWyVLODVHJXQGDYR]SHUWHQHFtDDOKHUPDQRPD\RUGH$OL -DVRQXQMXQLRUHQ5RVHZRRG'D\ ³£%DVWD ³GLMR XQD YR] SURIXQGD +XER XQ JROSH HQ OD SDUHG VDFXGLHQGR \ URPSLHQGR YLGULRV 6HJXQGRV PiV WDUGH VH DEULy OD SXHUWD GHO SDWLR \ -DVRQ VDOLy IXULRVR VX VXGDGHUD DOHWHDED DELHUWD VXV ]DSDWRV HVWDEDQ GHVDWDGRV \ VXV PHMLOODV HQURMHFLGDV ³0LHUGD³VXVXUUy6SHQFHU/DVFKLFDVFRUULHURQGHWUiVGHORVDUEXVWRV-DVRQHQWUy HQ GLDJRQDO DO SDWLR KDFLD HO ERVTXH OXHJR VH GHWXYR GiQGRVH FXHQWD GH DOJR D VX L]TXLHUGD8QDH[SUHVLyQHQIXUHFLGDVHGHVOL]yOHQWDPHQWHSRUVXFDUD /DVFKLFDVVLJXLHURQVXPLUDGD-DVRQHVWDEDPLUDQGRDOSDWLRWUDVHURGH6SHQFHU/D KHUPDQDGH6SHQFHU0HOLVVD\VXQXHYRQRYLR,DQ7KRPDVHVWDEDQVHQWDGRVHQHO ERUGHGHODWLQDFDOLHQWHGHODIDPLOLD&XDQGRYLHURQD-DVRQPLUDQGR,DQ\0HOLVVD EDMDURQODVPDQRV8QVHJXQGRHORFXHQWH\VHGHVOL]DURQGHQWUR'RVGtDVDQWHVMXVWR GHVSXpV GH TXH $OL VH MDFWDUD GH OD EDQGHUD TXH HVWDED D SXQWR GH HQFRQWUDU ,DQ \ -DVRQKDEtDQWHQLGRXQDSHOHDSRU$OLDOIUHQWHGHWRGDODFODVHGHVH[WRJUDGR7DOYH] ODOXFKDQRKDEtDWHUPLQDGR -DVRQJLUyUtJLGDPHQWH \VHGLULJLyKDFLDHOERVTXH/DSXHUWDGHOSDWLRVHHVWUHOOyGH QXHYR\ODVFKLFDVVHDJDFKDURQ$OLHVWDEDHQODFXELHUWDPLUDQGRDVXDOUHGHGRU6X ODUJRFDEHOORUXELRRQGXODGRKDVWDORVKRPEURV\VXSURIXQGDFDPLVHWDURVDKDFLDTXH VXSLHOVHYLHUDH[WUDUDGLDQWH\IUHVFD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

(PLO\ DEULy PXFKR ORV RMRV PDUURQHV $ULD VH DJDFKy D~Q PiV 6SHQFHU \ +DQQD VXMHWDURQVXVERFDVFHUUDGDV

ͻ

³
6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³(Q VHULR ³$OL FDPLQy SRU ODV HVFDOHUDV GH FXELHUWD HQ HTXLOLEULR SHUIHFWR HQ VXV WDFRQHV GH FXxD (UD OD ~QLFD GH VH[WR JUDGR FRQ ODV DJDOODV VXILFLHQWHV SDUD OOHYDU WDFRQHV HQ FODVH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ WpFQLFDPHQWH QR ORV SHUPLWtD KDVWD OD HVFXHOD VHFXQGDULD³ 6p TXH DOJXLHQ HVWi DOOt 3HUR VL KDV YHQLGR SRU PL EDQGHUD VH KD LGR $OJXLHQ\DORUREy 6SHQFHUVHHPSXMyDWUDYpVGHORVDUEXVWRVLQFDSD]GHFRQWHQHUVXFXULRVLGDG ³¢4Xp"¢4XLpQ" $ULDIXHODVLJXLHQWHHQVXUJLU(PLO\\+DQQDODVLJXLHURQ¢$OJXLHQPiVKDEtDOOHJDGR D$OLDQWHVTXHHOODV" $OL VXVSLUy VH VHQWy HQ HO EDQFR GH SLHGUD MXQWR DO HVWDQTXH NRL GH OD IDPLOLD /DV FKLFDV YDFLODURQ SHUR $OL OHV KL]R XQ JHVWR PiV 'H FHUFD ROtD D MDEyQ GH YDLQLOOD \ WHQtDODVPiVODUJDVSHVWDxDVTXHQLQJXQDKDEtDYLVWRMDPiV$OLVHVDOLyGHVXVFXxDV\ KXQGLyVXVSHTXHxRVSLHVHQODVXDYHKLHUEDYHUGH6XVXxDVHVWDEDQSLQWDGDVGHURMR EULOODQWH ³
ͳͲ

³1RVYDPRVDKRUD¢GHDFXHUGR"

ž‰‹ƒ

³(VWiELHQ³GLMR$OLVRQULHQGR\DJLWDQGRVXDYHPHQWHVXPDQR³£$GLyV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

/D6UD'L/DXUHQWLVKL]RXQDSDXVDFRPRVLTXLVLHUDGHFLUDOJRPiV$OLGLRODYXHOWD KDFLHQGRFDVRRPLVRGHHOOD6HxDOyD6SHQFHU ³(UHV6SHQFHU¢YHUGDG" 6SHQFHUDVLQWLyWtPLGDPHQWH$OLPLUyLQTXLVLWLYDPHQWHDODVGHPiV ³$ULD ³UHFRUGy $ULD D $OL +DQQD \ (PLO\ VH SUHVHQWDURQ WDPELpQ \ $OL DVLQWLy PHFiQLFDPHQWH(UDXQPRYLPLHQWRWRWDOGH$OLTXHREYLDPHQWHVDEtDVXVQRPEUHV SHURGHFtDVXWLOPHQWHTXHHQODMHUDUTXtDGHOJUDQ5RVHZRRG'D\\ODVFODVHVGHVH[WR JUDGR VXV QRPEUHV QR OHV LPSRUWDEDQ 1R VDEtDQ VL HVWDU KXPLOODGDV R KDODJDGDV GHVSXpVGHWRGR$OLHVWDEDSLGLHQGRVXVQRPEUHVDKRUD ³(QWRQFHV ¢GyQGH HVWDEDV FXDQGR WX EDQGHUD IXH UREDGD" ³6SHQFHU SUHJXQWy OXFKDQGRSRUPDQWHQHUODDWHQFLyQGH$OL $OLSDUSDGHyDWXUGLGD ³8K HQ HO FHQWUR FRPHUFLDO ³/OHYy VX GHGR PHxLTXH D OD ERFD \ OR HPSH]y D PDVWLFDU ³¢4Xp WLHQGD" ³SUHVLRQDED +DQQD³ ¢7LIIDQ\" ¢6HSKRUD" ³7DO YH] $OL VH LPSUHVLRQDUtD GH TXH +DQQD VXSLHUD ORV QRPEUHV GH ODV WLHQGDV GH OXMR GHO FHQWUR FRPHUFLDO ³7DO YH] ³PXUPXUy $OL 6X PLUDGD VH GHVSOD]y KDFLD HO ERVTXH 3DUHFtD FRPR VL HVWXYLHUDEXVFDQGRDOJRRDOJXLHQ'HWUiVGHHOODVVHFHUUyODSXHUWDGHOSDWLR/D6UD 'L/DXUHQWLVKDEtDLGRKDFLDHOLQWHULRUGHODFDVD ³7~ VDEHV OD FOiXVXOD GH URER QL VLTXLHUD VH GHEHUtD SHUPLWLU ³GLMR $ULD SRQLHQGR ORVRMRV³(VVyORPDOR $OLVHDSDUWyHOSHORGHWUiVGHODVRUHMDVHQFRJLpQGRVHGHKRPEURV8QDOX]GHDUULED HQODFDVD'L/DXUHQWLVVHDSDJy ³(QWRQFHV¢GyQGHKDEtDHVFRQGLGRODSLH]D-DVRQGHWRGRVPRGRV"³(PLO\LQWHQWy $OLVDOLyGHVXHVWDGR\VHSXVRUtJLGD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

(PLO\ VH HVWUHPHFLy VH KDEtD SUHRFXSDGR SRU GHFLU DFFLGHQWDOPHQWH DOJR TXH OD PROHVWDUD

ͳͳ

³¢+XK"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³7~GLMLVWHKDFHXQRVGtDVTXH-DVRQWHKDEtDGLFKRGyQGHKDEtDHVFRQGLGRVXSLH]D eVDHVODTXHHQFRQWUDVWH¢QR"³(QUHDOLGDG(PLO\HVWDEDPiVLQWHUHVDGDHQHOUXLGR TXHKDEtDRtGRHQHOLQWHULRUGHODFDVD¢$OLKDEtDHVWDGRSHOHDQGRFRQ-DVRQ"¢-DVRQ LPLWDEDODYR]GH$OLEDVWDQWH"3HURQRVHDWUHYLyDSUHJXQWDU ³2K³$OLJLUyHODQLOORGHSODWDTXHVLHPSUHOOHYDEDHQVXGHGRtQGLFHGHUHFKRFDGD YH]PiVUiSLGR³$VtHV6teVDHVODSLH]DTXHHQFRQWUp³(OODJLUySDUDKDFHUIUHQWH DODFDOOH(OPHUFHGHVFRORUFKDPSiQTXHODVFKLFDVDPHQXGRYHtDQUHFRJLHQGRD$OL GHVSXpV GH OD HVFXHOD VXUJLy OHQWDPHQWH SRU OD FDO]DGD \ URGy KDVWD OD HVTXLQD 6H GHWXYRHQHOSDUHSXVRVXOX]LQWHUPLWHQWH\JLUyDODGHUHFKD $ FRQWLQXDFLyQ $OL GHMy HVFDSDU XQ VXVSLUR \ PLUy D ODV FKLFDV FDVL FRPR VL QR ODV FRQRFLHUDFRPRVLVHVRUSUHQGLHUDGHTXHHVWDEDQDOOt ³$VtTXHDGLyV³GLMR6HGLRODYXHOWD\VHGLULJLyDODFDVD0RPHQWRVGHVSXpVOD OX]GHDUULEDODPLVPDTXHDFDEDEDGHDSDJDUVHVHHQFHQGLyGHQXHYR

ž‰‹ƒ

&DGDQLxDVLQWLyOD PLVPDVHQVDFLyQSHVDGD VLQHVSHUDQ]DGHKXPLOODFLyQ¢4XLpQHV FUHtDQTXHHUDQWUDWDQGRGHUREDUXQSHGD]RGHOD&iSVXODGHO7LHPSRDODFKLFDPiV SRSXODU HQ 5RVHZRRG 'D\" ¢3RU TXp VH KDEtDQ LQFOXVR DWUHYLGR D FUHHU TXH SRGUtDQ KDFHUOR"$OLVHKDEtDLGRSUREDEOHPHQWHHQHOLQWHULRUOODPDQGRDVXPHMRUHVDPLJDV 1DRPL=HLJOHU\5LOH\:ROIH\VHUHLUtDQGHODVSHUGHGRUDVTXHDFDEDEDQGHDSDUHFHU HQVXSDWLRWUDVHUR3RUXQLQVWDQWHIXJD]OHVKDEtDSDUHFLGRFRPRTXH$OLLEDDGDUD +DQQD $ULD (PLO\ \ 6SHQFHU OD RSRUWXQLGDG GH XQD DPLVWDG SHUR DKRUD OD SRVLELOLGDGVHKDEtDLGRGHILQLWLYDPHQWH 2«¢QR"



ͳʹ

/DVFDPSDQDVGHYLHQWRHQHOSRUFKHGHDWUiVGHORV'L/DXUHQWLVVRQDURQMXQWDV8QD DUGLOOD VH GHVOL]y D WUDYpV GHO FpVSHG $O SULQFLSLR ODV FKLFDV HVWDEDQ PX\ GHVFRQFHUWDGDV SDUD PRYHUVH &XDQGR TXHGy FODUR TXH $OL QR LED D YROYHU WRGR HO PXQGR GLMR XQD WRUSH GHVSHGLGD \ VH IXHURQ SRU FDPLQRV VHSDUDGRV (PLO\ FRUWy D WUDYpV GHO SDWLR GH 6SHQFHU \ VLJXLy HO UDVWUR D OD FDUUHWHUD WUDWDQGR GH YHU HO ODGR EXHQRHVWDEDDJUDGHFLGDGHTXH$OLLQFOXVROHVKXELHUDKDEODGRDHOODVHQDEVROXWR $ULDFRPHQ]ySRUHOERVTXHPROHVWDGHKDEHUYHQLGR6SHQFHUFDPLQyGHUHJUHVRDVX FDVDDYHUJRQ]DGDGHTXH$OLODKDEtDGHVDLUDGRWDQWRFRPRDODVGHPiV,DQ\0HOLVVD KDEtDQHQWUDGRSUREDEOHPHQWHDFRQHFWDUVREUHHOVRIiGHODVDODGHVXIDPLOLDHZZ <+DQQDUHFXSHUyVXELFLFOHWDGHVGHGHWUiVGHODURFDHQHOMDUGtQGH$OLQRWDQGRXQ FRFKHQHJURDVHQWDGRGLUHFWRHQODDFHUDIUHQWHDODFDVDGH$OL(QWUHFHUUyORVRMRV SHUSOHMD¢/RKDEtDYLVWRDQWHV"(QFRJLpQGRVHGHKRPEURVVHGLRODYXHOWDDQGXYRHQ ELFLFOHWDSRUHOFDOOHMyQVLQVDOLGD\DEDMRHQHOFDPLQR

)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

 (OOXQHVVLJXLHQWHORVUXPRUHVVHDUUHPROLQDEDQHQTXHHOSHGD]RGHODEDQGHUDGH$OL KDEtD VLGR UREDGR +DEtD XQ UXPRU HQ VHJXQGR OXJDU WDPELpQ $OL KDEtD HVWDGR HQ XQDSHOHDIHUR]FRQ1DRPL\5LOH\1DGLHVDEtDDFHUFDGHTXpVHWUDWDEDHODUJXPHQWR 1DGLHVDEtDFyPRKDEtDFRPHQ]DGR7RGDVODVSHUVRQDVVDEtDQTXHDODPiVFRGLFLDGD FDPDULOODHQHOVH[WRJUDGRDKRUDOHIDOWDEDQXQRVSRFRVPLHPEURV &XDQGR$OLKL]RXQDFRQYHUVDFLyQFRQ6SHQFHU+DQQD(PLO\\$ULDHQOD&DULGDG GH&RQGXFFLyQGH5RVHZRRG'D\HOViEDGRVLJXLHQWHODVFXDWURFKLFDVSHQVDEDQTXH HUDVyORXQDEURPDGHVDJUDGDEOH3HUR$OLUHFRUGyVXVQRPEUHV)HOLFLWyODPDQHUDHQ TXH6SHQFHUKDEtDGHOHWUHDGRSHUIHFWDPHQWHDGRUQRV\FDQGHODEURV0LUyODVFLYDPHQWH ODVERWDVIODPDQWHVTXH+DQQDWHQtDGH$QWKURSRORJLH\ORVDUHWHVGHSOXPDVGHSDYR UHDOGH$ULDTXHVXSDGUHOHKDEtDWUDtGRGH0DUUXHFRV6HPDUDYLOOyGHFRPR(PLO\ IiFLOPHQWH SRGtD OHYDQWDU XQD FDMD HQWHUD GH DEULJRV GH OD ~OWLPD WHPSRUDGD GH LQYLHUQR $QWHV GH TXH ODV FKLFDV VXSLHUDQ $OL ODV KDEtD LQYLWDGR D VX FDVD SDUD XQD ILHVWD GH SLMDPDV /R TXH OOHYy D RWUD ILHVWD GH SLMDPDV \ OXHJR RWUD $ ILQDOHV GH 6HSWLHPEUHFXDQGRHOMXHJRGHOD&iSVXODGHO7LHPSRWHUPLQy\WRGRVGHYROYLHURQVXV SLH]DV GHFRUDGDV GH OD EDQGHUD XQ QXHYR UXPRU JLUDED DOUHGHGRU GH OD HVFXHOD $OL WHQtDFXDWURQXHYDVPHMRUHVDPLJDV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

3HUR OD FKLFD DO ILQDO GH OD ILOD XQD GH ODV QXHYDV PHMRUHV DPLJDV GH $OL HVWDED WHPEODQGR WDQWR TXH WHQtD TXH PDQWHQHU VXV URGLOODV WUDQTXLODV SRQLHQGR VXV SDOPDV VREUHHOODV$ULDVDEtDGyQGHHVWDEDODSLH]DGHODEDQGHUDGH$OL$YHFHVGHVSXpVGH ODOODPDGDWHOHIyQLFDGHFLQFRYtDVFRQVXVPHMRUHVDPLJDV\DQWHVGHLUVHDODFDPD PLUDEDODFDMDFHUUDGDGH]DSDWRVHQHOHVWDQWHPiVDOWRGHVXDUPDULRXQGRORUDJULR UiSLGDPHQWHVHIRUPDEDHQODERFDGHVXHVWyPDJR(UDPHMRUTXHQROHKXELHUDGLFKR DQDGLHTXHWHQtDODSLH]DGHODEDQGHUDGH$OLVLQHPEDUJR<IXHPHMRUQRKDEHUOD HQWUHJDGR 3RU XQD YH] VX YLGD LED PX\ ELHQ 7HQtD DPLJDV 7HQtD JHQWH FRQ TXLHQ VHQWDUVH HQ HO DOPXHU]R JHQWH SDUD SDVDU HO UDWR ORV ILQHV GH VHPDQD /R PHMRU HUD ROYLGDUVHGHORTXHKDEtDVXFHGLGRHVHGtDSDUDVLHPSUH

ͳ͵

6H VHQWDURQ MXQWDV HQ OD FHUHPRQLD GHO HQWLHUUR GH OD &iSVXOD GHO 7LHPSR HQ HO DXGLWRULR GH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ YLHQGR FRPR HO 'LUHFWRU $SSOHWRQ OODPDED D FDGD SHUVRQDTXHKDEtDHQFRQWUDGRXQWUR]RGHODEDQGHUDDOHVFHQDULR&XDQGR$SSOHWRQ DQXQFLy TXH XQD GH ODV SLH]DV DQWHULRUPHQWH HQFRQWUDGDV SRU $OLVRQ 'L/DXUHQWLV QXQFDKDEtDVLGRHQWUHJDGD\DKRUDVHFRQVLGHUDEDQRYiOLGDODVFKLFDVDSUHWDURQODV PDQRV GH $OL IXHUWH 1R HV MXVWR OH GLMHURQ HQ YR] EDMD (VD SLH]D HUD OD VX\D 7~ WUDEDMDVWHWDQGXURHQHOOD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

3HUR WDO YH] $ULD QR GHEHUtD KDEHU ROYLGDGR WDQ UiSLGDPHQWH 7DO YH] GHEHUtD KDEHU WLUDGR OD FDMD DEDMR UHWLUDGR OD WDSD \ KDEHUOH GDGR XQD PLUDGD D IRQGR D OD SLH]D SHUGLGDGHODEDQGHUDGH$OL(VWRHUD5RVHZRRG\WRGRVLJQLILFDEDDOJR/RTXH$ULD SRGUtDKDEHUHQFRQWUDGRHQHVDEDQGHUDSRGUtDKDEHUOHGDGRXQDSLVWDVREUHDOJRTXH LEDDYHQLUHQXQIXWXURQRPX\OHMDQRGH$OL 

ž‰‹ƒ

ͳͶ

6XDVHVLQDWR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR /DFKLFDTXHJULWy´FKLFRPXHUWRµ /DFKLFDTXHJULWy´FKLFRPXHUWRµ 7UDGXFLGRSRU 
6

SHQFHU +DVWLQJV VH HVWUHPHFLy HQ HO IUtR GHO DLUH GH OD FDtGD GH OD WDUGH DJDFKiQGRVHSDUDHYLWDUXQDUDPDGHEUH]RHVSLQRVR

³3RUDTXt³GLMRVREUHVXKRPEURDGHQWUiQGRVHHQWUHORVERVTXHVGHWUiVGHVX JUDQFRQYHUWLGDKDFLHQGD³3RUDFiIXHGRQGHORYLPRV 6XVYLHMDVPHMRUHVDPLJDV$ULD0RQWJRPHU\(PLO\)LHOGV\+DQQD0DULQODVHJXtDQ UiSLGDPHQWH SRU GHWUiV 7RGDV ODV FKLFDV VH WDPEDOHDEDQ DO D]DU HQ VXV ]DSDWRV GH WDFyQDOWRVRVWHQLHQGRORVGREODGLOORVGHVXVYHVWLGRVGHILHVWDHUDViEDGRHQODQRFKH \ DQWHV GH HVWR HVWDEDQ HQ OD %HQHILFHQFLD 5RVHZRRG 'D\ HQ OD FDVD GH 6SHQFHU (PLO\ HVWDED VROOR]DQGR SRU VX FDUD VXUFDEDQ ODV OiJULPDV /RV GLHQWHV GH $ULD HVWDEDQ FDVWDxHDQGR FRPR VLHPSUH OR KDFtDQ FXDQGR WHQtD PLHGR +DQQD QR HVWDED KDFLHQGR QLQJ~Q VRQLGR SHUR VXV RMRV HUDQ HQRUPHV \ HVWDED VXMHWDQGR XQ JUDQ FDQGHODEUR GH SODWD HO FXDO DJDUUy GHO FRPHGRU GH ORV +DVWLQJV (O RILFLDO 'DUUHQ :LOGHQHOSROLFtDPiVMRYHQHQHOSXHEORVHDUUDVWUDEDWUDVHOODVDOXPEUDQGRFRQXQD OLQWHUQDDODYHUMDGHKLHUURIRUMDGRTXHVHSDUDEDHOSDWLRGH6SHQFHUGHODTXHDOJXQD YH]OHKDEtDSHUWHQHFLGRD$OLVRQ'L/DXUHQWLV

%XHQRHOVXSXHVWRDVHVLQRGH$OL 6SHQFHUKDEtDHVWDGRWDQDOLYLDGDFXDQGRORVSROLFtDVDUUHVWDURQD,DQSRUHODVHVLQDWR GH $OL 7RGR WHQtD VHQWLGR HO ~OWLPR GtD GH VpSWLPR JUDGR $OL OH KDEtD GDGR XQ



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

ͳͷ

³eOHVWiHQHVWHFODURGHUHFKRSRUHVWHFDPLQR³GLMR6SHQFHU+DEtDFRPHQ]DQGRD QHYDUSULPHURUiIDJDVWHQXHVSHURHUDQPiVIXHUWHVDKRUDJUXHVRVFRSRVK~PHGRV$ OD L]TXLHUGD GH 6SHQFHU HVWDED HO JUDQHUR GH OD IDPLOLD HO ~OWLPR OXJDU HQ HO TXH 6SHQFHU \ VXV DPLJDV KDEtDQ YLVWR D $OL YLYD WUHV DxRV \ PHGLR DWUiV $ VX GHUHFKD HVWDED HO KXHFR D PHGLR FDYDU GRQGH HO FXHUSR GH $OL KDEtD VLGR HQFRQWUDGR HQ 6HSWLHPEUH -XVWR DGHODQWH HVWDED HO FODUR GRQGH KDEtD GHVFXELHUWR UHFLHQWHPHQWH HO FXHUSRGH,DQ7KRPDVHODQWLJXRQRYLRGHVXKHUPDQD(ODPDQWHVHFUHWRGH$OL\VX DVHVLQR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

XOWLPiWXP SDUD TXp R URPSLHUD FRQ 0HOLVVD OD KHUPDQD GH 6SHQFHU R $OL LED D GHFLUWHDOPXQGRTXHHVWDEDQMXQWRV+DUWRGHVXVMXHJRV,DQVHKDEtDHQFRQWUDGRFRQ $OL HVD QRFKH 6X IXULD \ IUXVWUDFLyQ KDEtDQ TXLWDGR OR PHMRU GH pO« \ OD PDWy 6SHQFHU KDEtD YLVWR D $OL \ D ,DQ HQ HO ERVTXH HVD QRFKH TXH PXULy XQ UHFXHUGR WUDXPiWLFRTXHKDEtDVXSULPLGRSRUWUHVDxRV\PHGLR 3HURHOGtDDQWHVTXHHOMXLFLRGH,DQIXHUDHVWDEOHFLGRSDUDTXHLQLFLDUD,DQKDEtDURWR VXDUUHVWRGRPLFLOLDULR\VHKDEtDHVFDEXOOLGRHQHOSDWLRGH6SHQFHUVXSOLFiQGROHTXH QRWHVWLILFDUDHQFRQWUDGHpO$OJXLHQ PiVKDEtDPDWDGRD$OLLQVLVWtDTXHHVWDEDD SXQWRGHGHVFXEULUXQLQTXLHWDQWHDOXFLQDQWHVHFUHWRTXHSUREDUtDVXLQRFHQFLD (OSUREOHPDHUDTXH,DQQXQFDOOHJyDGHFLUOHD6SHQFHUFXDOHUDHVHJUDQVHFUHWRpOVH GHVDSDUHFLy DQWHV GH ODV GHFODUDFLRQHV GH DSHUWXUD GH VX MXLFLR HO SDVDGR YLHUQHV 0LHQWUDVWRGRHO'HSDUWDPHQWRGH3ROLFtDGH5RVHZRRGHQWUDEDHQDFFLyQEDUULHQGR HOFRQGDGRSDUDHQFRQWUDUGyQGHSRGtDKDEHULGRWRGRORTXH6SHQFHUKDEtDSHQVDGR TXHHUDYHUGDGDKRUDORFXHVWLRQDED¢/RKDEtDKHFKR,DQ«RQR"¢6SHQFHUORKDEtD YLVWRDOOiDIXHUDFRQ$OL«RKDEtDYLVWRDDOJXLHQPiV"/XHJRVyORPLQXWRVDWUiVHQOD ILHVWD DOJXLHQ FRQ HO QRPEUH GH ,DQB7 OH KDEtD PDQGDGR D 6SHQFHU XQ PHQVDMH GH WH[WR(QFXpQWUDPHHQHOERVTXHGRQGHHOODPXULyGHFtD7HQJRDOJRTXHPRVWUDUWH 6SHQFHUKDEtDFRUULGRDWUDYpVGHOERVTXHDQVLDQGRGHVFXEULUORWRGR&XDQGROOHJyDO FODUR PLUy KDFLD DEDMR \ JULWy ,DQ HVWDED WLUDGR DOOt KLQFKDGR \ D]XO VXV RMRV YLGULRVRV\VLQYLGD$ULD+DQQD\(PLO\VHDSDUHFLHURQOXHJR\PRPHQWRVGHVSXpV WRGDVUHFLELHURQH[DFWDPHQWHHOPLVPRPHQVDMHGHOD1XHYD´$µ7HQtDTXHLUVH &RUULHURQ GH YXHOWD D OD FDVD GH 6SHQFHU SDUD EXVFDU D :LOGHQ SHUR QR HVWDED HQ QLQJ~QOXJDU&XDQGR6SHQFHUVDOLyDODFDO]DGDFLUFXODUSDUDFKHTXHDUXQDYH]PiV :LOGHQ HVWDED GH SURQWR DOOt SDUDGR FHUFD GH ODV FiPDUDV GH ORV FRFKHV DSDUFDGRV &XDQGRODYLROHGLRXQDPLUDGDVREUHVDOWDGDFRPRVLORKXELHVHHQFRQWUDGRKDFLHQGR DOJR LOtFLWR $QWHV GH TXH 6SHQFHU SXGLHVH SUHJXQWDU GyQGH KDEtD HVWDGR :LOGHQ ODV RWUDV FRUUtDQ KLVWpULFDV VLQ DOLHQWR XUJLpQGROR D TXH ODV VLJXLHUD KDVWD HO ERVTXH < DKRUDDOOtHVWDEDQ

ž‰‹ƒ

³(VDTXt³JULWySRUHQFLPDGHOKRPEUR0LUyKDFLDHOVXHORSUHSDUiQGRVHSDUDOR TXHHVWDEDDSXQWRGHYHU ³2K'LRVPtR³VXVXUUy6SHQFHU



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͳ͸

6SHQFHU SDUy UHFRQRFLHQGR XQ IDPLOLDU iUERO UHWRUFLGR $OOt HVWDED HO YLHMR PXxyQ $OOtHVWDEDODKLHUEDDSLVRQDGDKDFLDDEDMR(ODLUHWHQtDXQDH[WUDxDFXDOLGDGHVWiWLFD VLQR[tJHQR



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(OFXHUSRGH,DQ«QRHVWDED 'LR XQ SDVR DWUiV OOHYiQGRVH ODV PDQRV D OD FDEH]D 3DUSDGHy FRQ QHUYLRVLVPR \ YROYLyDPLUDU(OFXHUSRGH,DQKDEtDHVWDGRDOOtKDFHPHGLDKRUDSHURDKRUDHOOXJDU HVWDEDYDFtRH[FHSWRSRUXQDILQDFDSDGHQLHYH3HUR«¢FyPRHUDHVRSRVLEOH" (PLO\VHOOHYyODVPDQRVDODERFDHKL]RXQVRQLGRGHJRUJRWHR ³6SHQFHU³VXVXUUyFRQXUJHQFLD $ULDGHMyHVFDSDUXQFUXFHHQWUHXQJHPLGR\XQJULWR ³¢'yQGH HVWi pO" ³VROOR]y PLUDQGR D VX DOUHGHGRU HQ HO ERVTXH IUHQpWLFDPHQWH³ (VWDEDMXVWRDTXt /DFDUDGH+DQQDHVWDEDSiOLGD1RGHFtDQLXQDSDODEUD 'HWUiV GH HOORV KDEtD XQ VRQLGR H[WUDxR XQ JUD]QLGR DJXGR 7RGR HO PXQGR GLR XQ EULQFR\+DQQDDJDUUyFRQIXHU]DHOFDQGHODEUR(UDVyORHOZDONLHWDONLHGH:LOGHQ HOFXDOHVWDEDDWDGRDVXFRUUHD9LRODH[SUHVLyQGHODVFKLFDV\OXHJRHOOXJDUYDFtRHQ HOVXHOR ³7DOYH]WLHQHVHOOXJDUHTXLYRFDGR³GLMR:LOGHQ 6SHQFHUQHJyFRQODFDEH]DVLQWLHQGRODSUHVLyQVXELHQGRHQVXSHFKR ³1R (VWDED DTXt ³6H WDPEDOHy GREODGD SRU OD SHQGLHQWH SRFR SURIXQGD \ VH DUURGLOOyVREUHODKLHUEDPHGLRFRQJHODGD&LHUWDSDUWHVHYHtDDSODQDGDFRPRVLDOJR SHVDGRKDEtDHVWDGRUHFLHQWHPHQWHSXHVWRDOOt([WHQGLyORVGHGRVSDUDWRFDUHOVXHOR SHUR OXHJR ORV FRQWUDMR DVXVWDGD 1R VH DWUHYtD D WRFDU XQ OXJDU GRQGH XQ FDGiYHU KDEtDHVWDGR ³7DO YH] ,DQ HVWi KHULGR QR PXHUWR ³:LOGHQ MXJXHWHy FRQ XQR GH ORV EURFKHV GH PHWDOHQVXFKDTXHWD³7DOYH]FRUULyGHVSXpVGHTXHVHIXHURQ 6SHQFHUDEULyPXFKRVORVRMRVDYHQWXUiQGRVHDFRQVLGHUDUODSRVLELOLGDG (PLO\QHJyFRQODFDEH]DUiSLGDPHQWH

³7DO YH] DOJXLHQ PRYLy HO FXHUSR ³DVXPLy $ULD³ +HPRV HVWDGR SRU ORV ERVTXHV SRUPHGLDKRUD(VROHGDUtDWLHPSRDFXDOTXLHUD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³(VWDEDGHILQLWLYDPHQWHPXHUWR³(VWXYRGHDFXHUGR+DQQD³eOHVWDED«D]XO

ͳ͹

³1RKD\PDQHUDGHTXHVRODPHQWHHVWXYLHUDKHULGR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³+DEtDDOJXLHQPiVDOOt³VXVXUUy+DQQD³(VWDEDGHSLHVREUHPtFXDQGRPHFDt 6SHQFHUJLUy\ODREVHUYy ³¢4Xp" ³6HJXUR OD ~OWLPD PHGLD KRUD KDEtD VLGR XQD ORFXUD SHUR +DQQD GHELy KDEHUGLFKRDOJR (PLO\PLUyD+DQQDWDPELpQ ³¢9LVWHTXLpQHUD" +DQQDWUDJyIXHUWHPHQWH ³4XLpQ TXLHUD TXH IXHVH WHQtD XQD FDSXFKD SXHVWD &UHR TXH HUD XQ KRPEUH SHUR FUHRTXHQRORVp7DOYH]VHOOHYyHOFXHUSRGH,DQDDOJ~QRWUROXJDU ³7DO YH] HUD ´$µ ³GLMR 6SHQFHU VX FRUD]yQ SDOSLWDED IXHUWHPHQWH HQ VX SHFKR %XVFy GHQWUR GHO EROVLOOR GH VX FKDTXHWD VDFy VX 6LGHNLFN \ HQVHxy HO PHQVDMH DPHQD]DGRUGH´$µD :LOGHQ7HQtDTXHLUVH:LOGHQREVHUYyHOWHOpIRQRGH6SHQFHU OXHJRVHORUHJUHVy6XERFDHVWDEDWHQVD ³1R Vp FXiQWDV YHFHV WHQJR TXH GHFLU HVWR 0RQD HVWi PXHUWD (VWD ´$µ HV XQD LPLWDGRUD/DKXLGDGH,DQHUDXQVHFUHWRDYRFHVODFLXGDGFRPSOHWDORVDEtD

³7DO YH] ´$µ HV OD DVHVLQD GH $OL WDPELpQ ³DxDGLy +DQQD WRGDYtD VRVWHQLHQGR HO FDQGHODEURIXHUWHPHQWH



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³´$µHVUHDO³SURWHVWy(PLO\VDFXGLHQGRVXFDEH]DGHVHVSHUDGDPHQWH³¢4XpSDVD VL´$µHVODDVHVLQDGH,DQ"¢<VL´$µVHOOHYyD,DQ"

ͳͺ

6SHQFHU LQWHUFDPELy XQD PLUDGD LQTXLHWD FRQ ODV GHPiV (VWH SDVDGR RWRxR 0RQD 9DQGHUZDDOXQDFRPSDxHUDGHFODVHV\ODPHMRUDPLJDGH+DQQDKDEtDPDQGDGRD ODV FKLFDV UHWRUFLGRV \ WRUWXRVRV PHQVDMHV ILUPDGRV FRQ ´$µ 0RQD KDEtD DUUXLQDGR VXVYLGDVHQPDQHUDVLQFRQWDEOHVHLQFOXVRKDEtDFRQVSLUDGRSDUDPDWDUODVJROSHDQGR D +DQQD FRQ VX 689 \ FDVL HPSXMy D 6SHQFHU SRU HO DFDQWLODGR )ORDWLQJ 0DQ 'HVSXpV GH TXH 0RQD VH UHVEDOy SRU HO DFDQWLODGR SHQVDURQ TXH HVWDEDQ D VDOYR« SHUR OD VHPDQD SDVDGD FRPHQ]DURQ D UHFLELU PHQVDMHV VLQLHVWURV GH XQD 1XHYD ´$µ 2ULJLQDOPHQWH SHQVDURQ TXH ODV QRWDV GH ´$µ HUDQ GH ,DQ \D TXH FRPHQ]DURQ D UHFLELUORV MXVWR GHVSXpV GH TXH pO KDEtD VLGR OLEHUDGR GH OD SULVLyQ HQ OLEHUWDG EDMR ILDQ]DWHPSRUDO3HUR:LOGHQHUDHVFpSWLFR6HJXtDGLFLpQGROHVTXHHVRHUDLPSRVLEOH ,DQ QR WHQtD DFFHVR D QLQJ~Q FHOXODU QL SRGUtD KDEHU HVWDGR PHURGHDQGR OLEUHPHQWH SRU DOOt PLHQWUDV HVWDED EDMR DUUHVWR GRPLFLOLDULR YLHQGR FDGD PRYLPLHQWR GH ODV FKLFDV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

:LOGHQ VH KXPHGHFLy ORV ODELRV PLUDQGR LQTXLHWR *UDQGHV FRSRV GH QLHYH HVWDEDQ DWHUUL]DQGRHQODSDUWHVXSHULRUGHVXFDEH]DSHURpOQRVHORVVDFXGLy ³&KLFDVHVWiQYROYLpQGRVHKLVWpULFDV,DQHVHODVHVLQRGH$OL7RGDVGHEHUtDQVDEHU HVR1RVRWURVORDUUHVWDPRVFRQODHYLGHQFLDTXHQRVGLHURQ ³¢4Xp SDVD VL OR GH ,DQ IXH XQ PRQWDMH" ³SUHVLRQy 6SHQFHU³ ¢4Xp SDVD VL ´$µ PDWyD$OLH,DQORGHVFXEULy"³¢<VLHVRHVDOJRTXHORVSROLFtDVHVWiQHQFXEULHQGR" &DVLDxDGLy(UDXQDWHRUtDTXH,DQKDEtDVXJHULGR :LOGHQ SDVy ORV GHGRV DOUHGHGRU GH OD LQVLJQLD GHO 'HSDUWDPHQWR GH 3ROLFtD GH 5RVHZRRGERUGDGRHQVXFKDTXHWD ³¢,DQWHGLMRWRGDHVDPLHUGDGXUDQWHVXYLVLWDDWXSRUFKHHOMXHYHV6SHQFHU" (OHVWyPDJRGH6SHQFHUVDOWy ³¢&yPRORVDEHV" :LOGHQODIXOPLQyFRQODPLUDGD ³6LPSOHPHQWHUHFLEtXQDOODPDGDGHODHVWDFLyQ1RVGLHURQXQDYLVR$OJXLHQORVYLR KDEODQGRDORVGRV ³¢4XLpQ" ³(UDDQyQLPD 6SHQFHU VH VLQWLy PDUHDGD 0LUy D VXV DPLJDV OHV KDEtD GLFKR D HOODV \ VRODPHQWH D HOODV TXH VH KDEtD UHXQLGR HQ VHFUHWR FRQ ,DQ SHUR SDUHFtDQ GHVRULHQWDGDV \ VRUSUHQGLGDV 6yOR KDEtD XQD VROD SHUVRQD PiV TXH VDEtD TXH HOOD \ ,DQ VH KDEtDQ HQFRQWUDGR $

:LOGHQVHEDODQFHyKDFLDDWUiV\DGHODQWHVREUHVXVWDORQHV0LUyILMDPHQWHDOVXHOR GRQGH,DQKDEtDHVWDGRKDFHXQDKRUD\VXVSLUy



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³´$µPHDPHQD]y³SURWHVWy6SHQFHU%XVFyDWUDYpVGHVXVPHQVDMHVUHFLELGRV\OH HQVHxyHVDQRWDGH´$µWDPELpQ6LODSREUH6HxRULWDQRWDQSHUIHFWDGHUHSHQWHGHVDSDUHFH ¢OHLPSRUWDUtDDDOJXLHQ"

ͳͻ

³¢3RU TXp QR YLQLVWH D QRVRWURV LQPHGLDWDPHQWH GHVSXpV" ³:LOGHQ VH LQFOLQy PiV FHUFDKDFLD6SHQFHU6XDOLHQWRROtDDFDIp³+XELpVHPRVOOHYDGRD,DQGHYXHOWDDOD FiUFHOeOQXQFDKXELHVHHVFDSDGR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³0LUHQ YR\ D YROYHU D OD FDVD \ UHXQLU XQ JUXSR 3HUR QR SXHGHQ FXOSDU GH WRGR D ´$µ 6SHQFHUOHGLRXQYLVWD]RDOZDONLHHQVXVFDGHUDV ³¢3RU TXp QR WH FRPXQLFDV SRU UiSLGR FRQ HOORV GHVGH DTXt" ³SUHVLRQy³ 3XHGHV KDFHUTXHVHUH~QHQFRQWLJRHQHOERVTXH\HPSH]DUDEXVFDUHQHVWHPRPHQWR 8QDPLUDGDLQFyPRGDVHDVRPyHQODFDUDGH:LOGHQFRPRVLQRKXELHVHDQWLFLSDGR HVDSUHJXQWD ³'pMHQPHKDFHUPLWUDEDMRFKLFDV7HQHPRVTXHVHJXLU«ORVSURFHGLPLHQWRV ³¢3URFHGLPLHQWRV"³UHSLWLy(PLO\ ³2K'LRVPtR³VXVSLUy$ULD³eOQRQRVFUHH ³/HVFUHROHVFUHR³:LOGHQVHDJDFKyFHUFDGHDOJXQDVUDPDVTXHFROJDEDQEDMDV³ 3HUR OD PHMRU FRVD TXH SXHGHQ KDFHU FKLFDV HV LUVH D FDVD \ GHVFDQVDU XQ SRFR 0H KDUpFDUJRGHVGHDTXt (OYLHQWRVRSODEDDJLWDQGRORVH[WUHPRVGHODEXIDQGDGHODQDJULVTXH6SHQFHUKDEtD FRORFDGR DOUHGHGRU GH VX FXHOOR DQWHV GH FRUUHU KDFLD DFi 8Q SHGDFLWR GH OD OXQD VH DVRPDED HQWUH OD QLHEOD (Q VHJXQGRV QLQJXQD GH HOODV SRGtD YHU OD OLQWHUQD GH :LOGHQ(UDVyORODLPDJLQDFLyQGH6SHQFHU¢RKDEtDSDUHFtDDQVLRVRSRUDOHMDUVHGH HOODV" ¢(UD VyOR SUHRFXSDFLyQ SRU HO FXHUSR GH ,DQ TXH HVWXYLHUD HQ DOJ~Q OXJDU GHO ERVTXH«RHUDSRUDOJRPiV" 6H YROYLy \ PLUy ILMDPHQWH DO YDFtR GHO EDUUDQFR DQKHODQGR TXH HO FXHUSR GH ,DQ UHJUHVDUD GH GyQGH VHD TXH VH KDEtD LGR 1XQFD ROYLGDUtD FRPR XQ RMR SHUPDQHFtD SHUWXUEDGRUDPHQWH DELHUWR \ HO RWUR SDUHFtD VHOODGR 7HQtD HO FXHOOR WRUFLGR HQ XQ iQJXOR DQWLQDWXUDO < WRGDYtD OOHYDED VX DQLOOR GH SODWLQR GH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ HQ VX PDQRGHUHFKDFRQVXSLHGUDD]XOEULOODQGRHQODOX]GHODOXQD

7RGDVDVLQWLHURQWRGDVKDEtDQSHQVDGRORPLVPR+DVWDTXHODSROLFtDGH5RVHZRRG FRPHQ]DUDDEXVFDUQRHVWDEDQDVDOYRDOOtVRODV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³4XLHURLUDFDVD³VROOR]y(PLO\

ʹͲ

/DVRWUDVFKLFDVPLUDEDQDOHVSDFLRYDFtRWDPELpQ/XHJRKDEtDXQDJULHWDOHMRVHQHO ERVTXH +DQQD DJDUUy HO EUD]R GH 6SHQFHU (PLO\ GHMy HVFDSDU XQ FKLOOLGR DJXGR 7RGDVHVWDEDQFRQJHODGDVHVSHUDQGR6SHQFHUSRGtDHVFXFKDUVXFRUD]yQODWLUHQVXV RtGRV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

9ROYLHURQ VREUH VXV SDVRV D OD FDVD GH 6SHQFHU /XHJR GH TXH HVWXYLHURQ IXHUD GH OD TXHEUDGD 6SHQFHU YLR HO KD] GRUDGR GH OD OLQWHUQD GH :LOGHQ PX\ SRU GHODQWH UHERWDQGRHQORVWURQFRVGHORViUEROHV6HGHWXYRVXFRUD]yQVDOWyDVXJDUJDQWDRWUD YH] ³&KLFDV³VXVXUUyVHxDODQGR



ž‰‹ƒ

ʹͳ

/D OLQWHUQD GH :LOGHQ VH DSDJy UiSLGR FRPR VL pO VLQWLHUD TXH OR KDEtDQ YLVWR 6XV SDVRV VH KLFLHURQ PiV \ PiV VRUGRV \ OHMDQRV KDVWD TXH HO VRQLGR VH GHVYDQHFLy FRPSOHWDPHQWH1RHVWDEDUHJUHVDQGRDODFDVDGH6SHQFHUSDUDEXVFDUXQDFXDGULOOD FRPR GLMR TXH LED D KDFHU 1R HVWDED DGHQWUiQGRVH SURIXQGDPHQWH GH PDQHUD DSUHVXUDGDDORVERVTXHV«H[DFWDPHQWHHQODGLUHFFLyQRSXHVWD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR /RTXHVH /RTXHVHYDVLHPSUHYXHOYH VHYDVLHPSUHYXHOYH YDVLHPSUHYXHOYH 7UDGXFLGRSRU*LR(OL9LF5RVH &RUUHJLGRSRU&DDPLOOH 

$

OD PDxDQD VLJXLHQWH $ULD VH VHQWy HQ OD PHVD GH IyUPLFD DPDULOOD HQ OD SHTXHxD FRFLQD GH VX SDGUH HQ 2OG +ROOLV OD FLXGDG XQLYHUVLWDULD MXQWR D 5RVHZRRGFRPLHQGRXQSODWRGH.DVKL*R/HDQURFLDGRFRQOHFKHGHVR\DH LQWHQWy OHHU HO 3KLODGHOSKLD 6HQWLQHO 6X SDGUH %\URQ \D KDEtD FRPSOHWDGR HO FUXFLJUDPD\KDEtDPDQFKDVGHWLQWDHQODVSiJLQDV 0HUHGLWK H[DOXPQD GH %\URQ \ DFWXDO QRYLD HVWDED HQ OD VDOD GH HVWDU TXH HVWDED MXQWRDODFRFLQD+DEtDHQFHQGLGRXQRVSDOLWRVGHLQFLHQVRGHSDFKXOtKDFLHQGRTXH WRGRHODSDUWDPHQWRROLHUDFRPRXQD+HDG6KRS/DVFHSDVUHODMDQWHVGHODVRODV\ODV JDYLRWDVJUD]QDQGRWLQWLQHDEDQGHVGHODVDODGH79 ³7RPH XQD UHVSLUDFLyQ GH OLPSLH]D D WUDYpV GH OD QDUL] DO FRPLHQ]R GH FDGD FRQWUDFFLyQ ³LQVWUX\y XQD YR] GH PXMHU³ &XDQGR H[KDOH FDQWH ORV VRQLGRV KHH KHHKHH9DPRVDLQWHQWDUORMXQWDV ³+HHKHHKHH³JULWDED0HUHGLWK



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

'HVSXpV GH XQD QRFKH VLQ GRUPLU HQ VX PD\RUtD $ULD KDEtD OODPDGR D VX SDGUH HVD PDxDQD\OHSUHJXQWyVLSRGtDTXHGDUVHFRQHOORVGXUDQWHXQWLHPSR(QWRQFHVDQWHV GHTXHVXPDGUH(OODVHGHVSHUWDUD$ULDHPSDFyDOJXQDVFRVDVHQVXORQDGHIORUHV WDSL]DGDV GH 1RUXHJD \ VH IXH $ULD TXHUtD HYLWDU XQD FRQIURQWDFLyQ 6DEtD TXH VX PDGUH HVWDUtD SHUSOHMD GH TXH $ULD WXYLHUD OD HOHFFLyQ GH YLYLU FRQ VX SDGUH \ VX GHVWUX\HKRJDUHV FRPR QRYLD VREUH WRGR DKRUD TXH ILQDOPHQWH (OOD \ $ULD KDEtDQ UHSDUDGR VX UHODFLyQ GHVSXpV GH TXH 0RQD 9DQGHUZDDO FRPR ´$µ  OD KDEtD FDVL GHVWUXLGRSDUDVLHPSUH$GHPiV$ULDRGLDEDPHQWLU\SRUHVRQRSRGtDGHFLUOHD(OOD ODYHUGDGVREUHSRUTXpHVWDEDDTXt7XQXHYRQRYLRWLHQHXQLQWHUpVHQPt\HVWiFRQYHQFLGR

ʹʹ

$ULD DKRJy XQ JHPLGR 0HUHGLWK HVWDED HPEDUD]DGD GH FLQFR PHVHV \ KDEtD HVWDGR YLHQGRYLGHRV/DPD]HSRUOD~OWLPDKRUDORTXHVLJQLILFDEDTXH$ULDKDEtDDSUHQGLGR VREUHWpFQLFDVGHUHVSLUDFLyQERODVGHSDUWR\ORVPDOHVGHODHSLGXUDOSRURVPRVLV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

GHTXH\RORWHQJRKDFLDpOWDPELpQVHLPDJLQDEDGLFLpQGROR(OODSUREDEOHPHQWHQXQFDOH KDEODUtDGHQXHYR 0HUHGLWK VXELy HO YROXPHQ GHO WHOHYLVRU DO SDUHFHU QR SRGtD RtU SRU HQFLPD GH VX SURSLDUHVSLUDFLyQKHH0iVRODVVHHVWUHOODURQ8QDFDPSDQDVRQy ³8VWHG \ VX SDUHMD DSUHQGHUiQ PDQHUDV GH GLVPLQXLU HO GRORU GHO SDUWR QDWXUDO \ DFHOHUDU HO SURFHVR GH WUDEDMR ³GLMR OD LQVWUXFWRUD³ $OJXQDV WpFQLFDV LQFOX\HQ OD LQPHUVLyQ HQ DJXD HMHUFLFLRV GH YLVXDOL]DFLyQ \ GHMDU TXH VX SDUHMD OH OOHYH KDVWD HO RUJDVPR ³2K'LRVPtR³$ULDDSODVWyVXVPDQRVVREUHVXVRUHMDV(UDXQPLODJURTXHQRVH KXELHUDTXHGDGRHVSRQWiQHDPHQWHVRUGD %DMy OD PLUDGD KDFLD HO SDSHO GH QXHYR 8Q WLWXODU VDOSLFDED D WUDYpV GH OD SiJLQD SULQFLSDO¢'yQGHHVWi,DQ7KRPDV"SUHJXQWDED %XHQDSUHJXQWD$ULDSHQVy /RVDFRQWHFLPLHQWRVGHODQRFKHDQWHULRUODWtDQHQVXPHQWH¢&yPRSRGUtDHOFDGiYHU GH ,DQ HVWDU HQ HO ERVTXH XQ PLQXWR \ KDEHUVH LGR DO VLJXLHQWH" ¢$OJXLHQ OR KDEtD PDWDGR \ KDEtD DUUDVWUDGR VX FXHUSR IXHUD FXDQGR KDEtDQ LGR D EXVFDU GHQWUR D :LOGHQ" ¢(O DVHVLQR GH ,DQ OH KDEtD KHFKR FDOODU SRUTXH KDEtD GHVFXELHUWR HO JUDQ VHFUHWRTXHOHKDEtDGLFKRD6SHQFHU" 2WDOYH]WHQtDUD]yQ:LOGHQ,DQHVWDEDKHULGRQRPXHUWR\VHKDEtDDUUDVWUDGROHMRV FXDQGR FRUULHURQ KDFLD OD FDVD 3HUR VL HVR IXH OR TXH SDVy HQWRQFHV ,DQ HVWDED WRGDYtD SRU DKt (OOD VH HVWUHPHFLy ,DQ GHVSUHFLDED D $ULD \ D VXV DPLJDV SRU FRQVHJXLUTXHORDUUHVWDUDQeOSRGUtDTXHUHUYHQJDUVH



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³+D\ LQIRUPHV VLQ IXQGDPHQWR GH TXH HO FDGiYHU GHO 6U 7KRPDV IXH YLVWR HQ HVWRV ERVTXHV D\HU SRU OD QRFKH ³(UD HO MHIH GLFLHQGR³ 7HQHPRV XQ JUDQ HTXLSR

ʹ͵

$ULDUHDFFLRQyDQWHHOSHTXHxRWHOHYLVRUHQODFRFLQDDQVLRVDSRUXQDGLVWUDFFLyQ(O &DQDOPRVWUDEDODUHFRQVWUXFFLyQGHDGRTXLQHVDVtFRPRGHODVHVLQDWRGH$OL$ULD \DORKDEtDYLVWRGRVYHFHV$SUHWyHOPDQGRDGLVWDQFLD(QHOFDQDOVLJXLHQWHHOMHIH GH SROLFtD GH 5RVHZRRG HVWDED KDEODQGR FRQ DOJXQRV SHULRGLVWDV /OHYDED XQD FKDTXHWD D]XO PDULQR SHVDGD IRUUDGDV GH SLHO D]XO \ QR KDEtD SLQRV GHWUiV GH pO 3DUHFtDFRPRVLHVWXYLHUDGDQGRXQDHQWUHYLVWDGHVGHHOERUGHGHOERVTXHGH6SHQFHU +DEtD XQ WtWXOR JUDQGH HQ OD SDUWH LQIHULRU GH OD SDQWDOOD TXH GHFtD ¢,DQ 7KRPDV 0XHUWR"$ULDVHLQFOLQyKDFLDDGHODQWHFRQVXFRUD]yQDFHOHUDGR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

PRQWDGR \ FRPHQ]DURQ D EXVFDU HQ ORV ERVTXHV D ODV  $0 GH HVWD PDxDQD 6LQ HPEDUJRFRQWRGDHVWDQLHYH (O.DVKLEXUEXMHDEDHQHOHVWyPDJRGH$ULD&RJLyVXWHOpIRQRFHOXODUIUHQWHDODPHVD GHODFRFLQDSHTXHxD\PDUFyHOQ~PHURGH(PLO\(OODUHVSRQGLyGHLQPHGLDWR ³¢(VWiVYLHQGRODVQRWLFLDV"³ODGUy$ULDHQOXJDUGHXQKROD ³$FDERGHSRQHUOR³UHVSRQGLy(PLO\FRQYR]SUHRFXSDGD ³¢3RUTXpFUHHVTXHHVSHUDURQKDVWDHVWDPDxDQDSDUDHPSH]DUDEXVFDU":LOGHQGLMR TXHLEDDFRQVHJXLUXQHTXLSRDQRFKH ³:LOGHQWDPELpQGLMRDOJRVREUHHOSURFHGLPLHQWR³(PLO\VXJLULyHQYR]EDMD³$ ORPHMRUWLHQHDOJRTXHYHUFRQHVR $ULDUHVRSOy ³:LOGHQQXQFDSDUHFLyLQWHUHVDGRHQHOSURFHGLPLHQWRDQWHV ³(VSHUD¢TXpHVWiVGLFLHQGR"³(PLO\SDUHFtDLQFUpGXOD $ULD PRYLy XQD HVWHUD GHO OXJDU GRQGH ORV DPLJRV GH 0HUHGLWK KDEtDQ WHMLGR GH FixDPR &DVL GRFH KRUDV KDEtDQ SDVDGR GHVGH TXH KDEtD YLVWR HO FXHUSR GH ,DQ \ PXFKR SXHGH VXFHGHU HQ ORV ERVTXHV HQWUH HQWRQFHV \ DKRUD $OJXLHQ SRGUtD KDEHU OLPSLDGRODHYLGHQFLDRSODQWDGRSLVWDVIDOVDV3HURODSROLFtD³:LOGHQ³KDEtDVLGR GHVFXLGDGDFRQHVWHFDVR:LOGHQQLVLTXLHUDWHQtDXQVRVSHFKRVRSRUHODVHVLQDWRGH $OLKDVWDTXH$ULD6SHQFHU\ODVGHPiVOHVHQWUHJDURQODFDEH]DGH,DQHQXQSODWReO WDPELpQKDEtDSDVDGRSRUDOWRFXDQGR,DQYLVLWyD6SHQFHU\FXDQGRVHHVFDSyHOGtD GHVXMXLFLR'HDFXHUGRFRQ+DQQD:LOGHQTXHUtDTXH,DQVHIULHUDSRUWRGRORTXH KL]RSHURQRKDEtDKHFKRXQPX\EXHQWUDEDMRGHPDQWHQHUOREDMROODYH ³1R Vp ³$ULD ILQDOPHQWH UHVSRQGLy³ 3HUR HV UDUR TXH VyOR HVWpQ URGHiQGROR DKRUD ³¢7HKDPDQGDGR´$µDOJXQDQRWDPiV"³SUHJXQWy(PLO\ $ULDVHSXVRUtJLGD

³1RSHURVLJRSHQVDQGRTXHYR\DFRQVHJXLUXQDHQFXDOTXLHUPRPHQWR ³¢4XLpQFUHHVTXHHVOD1XHYD´$µ"³SUHJXQWy$ULD1RWHQtDHQDEVROXWRDOJXQDV WHRUtDV ¢(UD DOJXLHQ TXH TXHUtD PXHUWR D ,DQ HO PLVPR ,DQ R DOJXLHQ PiV" :LOGHQ



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

ʹͶ

³1R¢$WL"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

FUHH TXH ORV WH[WRV HUDQ EURPDV GH DOJXQD SHUVRQD DO D]DU HQ XQ HVWDGR WRWDOPHQWH GLVWLQWR 3HUR KDEtD XQDV LQFULPLQDWRULDV IRWRV GH $ULD \ ;DYLHU MXQWRV OD VHPDQD SDVDGDHVGHFLU´$µHVWiDTXtHQ5RVHZRRGeOWDPELpQVDEtDVREUHHOFXHUSRGH,DQ HQHOERVTXHWRGRVHOORVKDEtDQUHFLELGRXQDQRWDLQVWDQGRLUDEXVFDUOR¢3RUTXp´$µ HVWDEDWDQGHVHVSHUDGDHQPRVWUDUHOFXHUSRGH,DQ"¢3DUDDVXVWDUODV"¢3DUDDGYHUWLUODV" < FXDQGR FD\y +DQQD KDEtD YLVWR D DOJXLHQ DYHFLQDUVH VREUH HOOD ¢&XiO HUD OD SUREDELOLGDGGHTXHDOJXLHQPiVHVWDEDHQORVERVTXHVDODKRUDH[DFWDTXHHOFXHUSR GH,DQ"7HQtDTXHKDEHUXQDFRQH[LyQ ³1RVp³FRQFOX\y(PLO\³3HURQRTXLHURVDEHU ³7DOYH]´$µVHKDLGR³GLMR$ULDHQODYR]PiVSURPHWHGRUDTXHSRGtDPDQHMDU (PLO\VXVSLUy\GLMRTXHWHQtDTXHLUVH$ULD VHOHYDQWyVHVLUYLyXQ YDVRGHMXJRGH PRUDVD]XOHVTXH0HUHGLWKKDEtDFRPSUDGRHQODWLHQGDGHDOLPHQWRVVDOXGDEOHV\VH IURWy ODV VLHQHV ¢3RGUtD :LOGHQ KDEHU UHWUDVDGR OD E~VTXHGD DSURSyVLWR" 6L HUD DVt ¢SRU TXp" +DEtD SDUHFLGR WDQ LQTXLHWR H LQFyPRGR DQRFKH \ HQWRQFHV VH KDEtD DOHMDGRHQODGLUHFFLyQRSXHVWDGHODFDVDGH6SHQFHU7DOYH]HVWDEDRFXOWDQGRDOJR2 WDOYH](PLO\HVWDEDHQORFLHUWRHOUHWUDVRVHGHELyDOSURFHGLPLHQWR1RHUDPiVTXH XQSROLFtDVLJXLHQGRGHELGDPHQWHODVUHJODVGHOMXHJR 7RGDYtD OH GHVFRQFHUWDED D $ULD TXH :LOGHQ VH KXELHUD FRQYHUWLGR HQ XQ SROLFtD \ PXFKRPHQRV XQRREHGLHQWH:LOGHQ KDEtDHVWDGRHQHODxR GH-DVRQ'L/DXUHQWLVH ,DQHQ5RVHZRRG'D\\HQHVHHQWRQFHVKDEtDVLGRXQEUDEXFyQ(ODxRHQTXH$ULD HVWDED HQ VH[WR \ HOORV VH HQFRQWUDEDQ HQ XQGpFLPR D PHQXGR $ULD VH FRODED HQ OD (VFXHOD 6XSHULRU GXUDQWH VXV SHUtRGRV OLEUHV SDUD HVSLDU D -DVRQ KDEtD WHQLGR XQ IOHFKD]RGRORURVRSRUpO\OHEXVFDEDFDGDYH]TXHSRGtD3RUXQPRPHQWRORPLUDED SRU OD YHQWDQD GH OD FDEDxD GH PDGHUD PLHQWUDV pO OLMDED VX HVWDQWH FDVHUR R VXV PXVFXORVDV SLHUQDV PLHQWUDV FRUUtD DUULED \ DEDMR GH ORV FDPSRV HQ OD SUiFWLFD GH I~WERO$ULDLEDVLHPSUHFRQFXLGDGRGHQRGHMDUTXHQDGLHODYLHUD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

)XH DOUHGHGRU GH XQD VHPDQD GHO FRPLHQ]R GHO DxR HVFRODU $ULD KDEtD HVWDGR REVHUYDQGRD-DVRQVDFDUOLEURVHQODELEOLRWHFDGHVGHHOSDVLOORFXDQGRR\yXQFOLFDVX HVSDOGD $OOt HVWDED 'DUUHQ :LOGHQ FRQ OD RUHMD SHJDGD D OD SXHUWD GH ORV FDVLOOHURV OHQWDPHQWH JLUDQGR HO GLDO /D FDVLOOD VH DEULy \ $ULD YLR XQ HVSHMR HQ IRUPD GH FRUD]yQHQHOLQWHULRUGHODSXHUWD\XQDFDMDGHWRDOODVVDQLWDULDV$OZD\VHQHOHVWDQWH VXSHULRU /D PDQR GH :LOGHQ VH FHUUDED DOUHGHGRU GH XQ ELOOHWH GH YHLQWH GyODUHV HQFDMDGRHQWUHGRVOLEURVGHWH[WR$ULDIUXQFLyHOFHxRSRFRDSRFRSURFHVDQGRORTXH :LOGHQHVWDEDKDFLHQGR

ʹͷ

3HURXQDYH]DOJXLHQORKL]R

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

:LOGHQ VH OHYDQWy \ VH GLR FXHQWD GH HOOD eO OH GHYROYLy OD PLUDGD VLQ DUUHSHQWLPLHQWRV ³1RVHVXSRQHTXHHVWpVDTXt³VHEXUOypO³3HURQRYR\DGHFLUORHVWDYH] &XDQGR$ULDPLUyHOWHOHYLVRUQXHYRKDEtDXQFRPHUFLDOSDUDXQDWLHQGDGHPXHEOHV OODPDGR(O9ROFDGR0LUyVXWHOpIRQRVREUHODPHVDGiQGRVHFXHQWDGHTXHKDEtDRWUD OODPDGD WHOHIyQLFD TXH WHQtD TXH KDFHU (UDQ FDVL ODV RQFH (OOD VLQ GXGD HVWDED GHVSLHUWD 0DUFyHOQ~PHURGHVXFDVD(OWHOpIRQRVRQyXQDYH]OXHJRGRVYHFHV6HR\yXQFOLF \DOJXLHQGLMR ³¢+ROD" /DVSDODEUDVGH$ULDVHTXHGDURQDWDVFDGDVHQVXJDUJDQWD(UD;DYLHUHOQXHYRQRYLR GH VX PDGUH ;DYLHU VRQDED IUDFFLRQDGR \ FyPRGR D JXVWR FRQ HO FRQWHVWDGRU GHO WHOpIRQRGHORV0RQWJRPHU\¢+DEtDSDVDGRODQRFKHDOOtGHVSXpVGHODEHQHILFHQFLD" (Z ³¢+ROD"³GLMR;DYLHUGHQXHYR $ULD VH VHQWtD FRKLELGD \ GLVJXVWDGD &XDQGR ;DYLHU VH KDEtD DFHUFDGR D $ULD HQ OD EHQHILFHQFLDGH5RVHZRRG'D\ODQRFKHDQWHULRU\OHSUHJXQWyVLSRGtDQKDEODU$ULD KDEtD DVXPLGR TXH LED D SHGLU GLVFXOSDV SRU EHVDUOD XQRV GtDV DQWHV 6yOR TXH DO SDUHFHUHQHOOHQJXDMHGH;DYLHU´KDEODUµVLJQLILFD´PDQRVHDUµ 'HVSXpVGHXQRVVHJXQGRVGHVLOHQFLR;DYLHUH[KDOy ³¢(UHVW~$ULD"³GLMRFRQVXYR]YLVFRVD$ULDKL]RXQSHTXHxRFKLOOLGR³1RKD\ QHFHVLGDGGHRFXOWDUVH³EURPHy³3HQVpTXHKDEtDXQHQWHQGLPLHQWR $ULD FROJy UiSLGDPHQWH (O ~QLFR DFXHUGR TXH WHQtDQ HOOD \ ;DYLHU HUD TXH VL OH DGYHUWtD D (OOD TXH FODVH GH SHUVRQD HUD ;DYLHU ;DYLHU OH GLUtD D (OOD TXH D $ULD OH KDEtDJXVWDGR;DYLHUHQXQQDQRVHJXQGR<HVRVHUtDODUXLQDSDUDODUHODFLyQGH$ULD\ (OODSDUDVLHPSUH



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

$ULDVDOWy\PLUyKDFLDDUULED6XSDGUH%\URQHVWDEDGHSLHHQFLPDGHHOODOOHYDED XQD UDtGD FDPLVHWD GHSRUWLYD GH +ROOLV \ VX WtSLFD ODPLQDGD²IXHUD²GH²FDPD FRPR SHLQDGR

ʹ͸

³¢$ULD"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

6HVHQWyHQODPHVDDVXODGR0HUHGLWKTXHOOHYDEDXQYHVWLGRGHPDWHUQLGDGGHHVWLOR VDUL\%LUNHQVWRFNFRQWRQHiQGRVHVHDSR\yHQHOPRVWUDGRU ³4XHUtDPRVKDEODUFRQWLJR³GLMR%\URQ $ULDFUX]yODVPDQRVVREUHVXUHJD]R$PERVVHYHtDQVHULRV ³(Q SULPHU OXJDU YDPRV D WHQHU XQ EDE\ VKRZHU SDUD 0HUHGLWK HO PLpUFROHV SRU OD QRFKH³GLMR%\URQ³9DDVHUXQDFRVDSRFDFRQDOJXQRVGHQXHVWURVDPLJRV $ULDSDUSDGHy¢7HQtDQDPLJRVHQFRP~Q"(VRSDUHFtDLPSRVLEOH0HUHGLWKHVWDEDHQ VXVYHLQWHDxRVDSHQDVVDOLGDGHODXQLYHUVLGDG<%\URQHUDYLHMR ³3XHGHV OOHYDU XQD DPLJD VL TXLHUHV ³DxDGLy 0HUHGLWK³ < QR WH SUHRFXSHV SRU FRQVHJXLUPHXQUHJDOR1RORHVSHURHQDEVROXWR $ULDVHSUHJXQWyVL0HUHGLWKVHUHJLVWUyHQ6XQVKLQHODWLHQGDGHEHEpVHQ5RVHZRRG TXHYHQGHERWLQHVRUJiQLFRVSDUDEHEpVKHFKDVGHERWHOODVGHUHIUHVFRVUHFLFODGDVSRU FLHQGyODUHV ³< HQ FXDQWR D GyQGH HVWH EDE\ VKRZHU VHUi ³%\URQ WLUy GH ODV PDQJDV GH VX VXpWHUEODQFR³1RVRWURVYDPRVDWHQHUQXHVWUDQXHYDFDVD /DV SDODEUDV WRPDURQ XQ PRPHQWR HQ KXQGLUVH $ULD DEULy OD ERFD OXHJR OD FHUUy UiSLGDPHQWH ³1RTXHUtDPRVGHFLUWHQDGDKDVWDTXHHVWXYLpUDPRVVHJXURV³VHDSUHVXUy%\URQ³ 3HUR QXHVWUR SUpVWDPR QR VH GLR KDVWD KR\ \ FHUUDUHPRV HO FRQWUDWR PDxDQD 4XHUHPRVPXGDUQRVGHLQPHGLDWR\QRVHQFDQWDUtDTXHYLQLHUDVFRQQRVRWURVDOOt ³8QD FDVD ³UHSLWLy $ULD 1R HVWDED VHJXUD GH VL UHtU R OORUDU $TXt HQ HO HVWXGLDQWH DPLVWRVR ODPHQWDEOH \ SHJDMRVR SHTXHxR DSDUWDPHQWR GH  PHWURV FXDGUDGRV HQ 2OG +ROOLV OD UHODFLyQ GH %\URQ \ 0HUHGLWK SDUHFtD XQD HVSHFLH GH UHODFLyQILQJLGD8QDFDVDSRUHOFRQWUDULRHUDPiVGHDGXOWRV5HDO ³¢'yQGHHVWi"³$ULDSUHJXQWyILQDOPHQWH



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³(Q&RYHQWU\/DQH(VUHDOPHQWHKHUPRVR$ULD&UHRTXHWHYDDHQFDQWDU+D\XQD HVFDOHUDGHFDUDFROTXHFRQGXFHDXQGHVYiQJUDQGHHQHOiWLFR(VRSXHGHVHUWX\RVL ORGHVHDV/DOX]DKtDUULEDHVPX\EXHQDSDUDODSLQWXUD

ʹ͹

0HUHGLWKVHSDVyORVGHGRVSRUHOWDWXDMHGHWHODGHDUDxDGHFRORUURVDHQHOLQWHULRUGH VXPXxHFD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

$ULD VH TXHGy PLUDQGR XQD SHTXHxD PDQFKD HQ HO MHUVH\ GH %\URQ &RYHQWU\ /DQH KDEtDDOJRIDPLOLDUHQHOODSHURQRHVWDEDVHJXUDGHSRUTXp ³3XHGHVHPSH]DUDPRYHUWXVFRVDVHQFXDOTXLHUPRPHQWRGHVSXpVGHPDxDQD³GLMR %\URQ PLUDQGR D $ULD FRQ FDXWHOD FRPR VL QR HVWXYLHUD VHJXUR GH FyPR LED D UHDFFLRQDU 6HYROYLyGLVWUDtGDDOD79(OQRWLFLHURPRVWUDEDODILFKDSROLFLDOGH,DQ(QWRQFHVOD PDGUHGH,DQHQWUyHQODSDQWDOODSiOLGD\VLQGRUPLU ³1RKHPRVRtGRKDEODUGH,DQGHVGHODQRFKHGHOMXHYHV³H[FODPyOD6UD7KRPDV³ 6LDOJXLHQVDEHORTXHOHKDVXFHGLGRSRUIDYRUTXHVHSUHVHQWH ³(VSHUD ³GLMR $ULD OHQWDPHQWH XQ SHQVDPLHQWR FRQJHODGR HQ VX PHQWH³ ¢1R HV &RYHQWU\/DQHHOEDUULRGHWUiVGHODFDVDGH6SHQFHU" ³£(VRHV³%\URQVHLOXPLQy³9DVDHVWDUPiVFHUFDGHHOOD $ULDQHJyFRQODFDEH]D6XSDGUHQRORHQWHQGtD ³(VDHVODDQWLJXDFDOOHGH,DQ7KRPDV %\URQ\0HUHGLWKVHPLUDURQVXVURVWURVSDOLGHFLHQGR ³¢$VtHV"³%\URQSUHJXQWy (OFRUD]yQGH$ULDJROSHyeVWDHUDXQDGHODVUD]RQHVSRUODVTXHDPDEDDVXSDGUH TXH HUD WDQ LUUHPHGLDEOHPHQWH DMHQR D ORV FKLVPHV $O PLVPR WLHPSR ¢FyPR HUD SRVLEOHTXHHQODWLHUUDQRSXGLHUDVDEHUHVWR" ([FHOHQWH1RVyORLEDDHVWDUDOODGRGHXQERVTXHGRQGHKDEtDHQFRQWUDGRHOFXHUSR GH ,DQ DGHPiV GRQGH $OL KDEtD PXHUWR WDPELpQ ¢< VL ,DQ D~Q HVWDED YLYR DFHFKDQGRHQORVERVTXHV" 6HHQIUHQWyDVXSDGUH ³¢1RFUHHVTXHHVDFDOOHYDDWHQHUXQNDUPDPX\PDOR"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³/R VLHQWR $ULD 3HUR WHQtDPRV XQD LQFUHtEOH RIHUWD GH XQD FDVD XQD TXH QR SRGtDPRVGHMDUSDVDU7LHQHWRQHODGDVGHHVSDFLR\HVWR\VHJXURGHTXHODHQFRQWUDUiV PiV FyPRGD TXH YLYLU DOOt ³+L]R XQ JHVWR FRQ VXV EUD]RV DSXQWDQGR HVSHFtILFDPHQWH D XQ SHTXHxR FXDUWR GH EDxR GHO DSDUWDPHQWR TXH WHQtD TXH FRPSDUWLU

ʹͺ

%\URQFUX]yORVEUD]RVVREUHHOSHFKR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

$ULD PLUy HO WyWHP GH FDUD GH DYHV HQ OD HVTXLQD GH OD FRFLQD TXH 0HUHGLWK KDEtD DUUDVWUDGR D FDVD GH XQ PHUFDGR GH SXOJDV KDFH XQ PHV DSUR[LPDGDPHQWH 1R HUD FRPR VL SXGLHUD YROYHU D FDVD GH VX PDPi /D YR] EXUORQD GH ;DYLHU VH VDFXGLy D WUDYpVGHVXFDEH]D1RKD\QHFHVLGDGGHRFXOWDUWH3HQVpTXHKDEtDXQHQWHQGLPLHQWR ³(VWi ELHQ 0H YR\ D PXGDU HO PDUWHV ³PXUPXUy $ULD 5HFRJLy VXV OLEURV \ VX WHOpIRQRFHOXODU\VHUHWLUyDVXSHTXHxDKDELWDFLyQHQODSDUWHSRVWHULRUGHOHVWXGLRGH 0HUHGLWKVLQWLpQGRVHPX\FDQVDGD\GHUURWDGD 0LHQWUDVVHGHMDEDFDHUFRQVXVFRVDVHQODFDPDDOJRIXHUDGHODYHQWDQDOHOODPyOD DWHQFLyQ(OHVWXGLRHVWDEDHQODSDUWHSRVWHULRUGHODYLYLHQGDIUHQWHDXQFDOOHMyQ\ XQ JDUDMH GH PDGHUD GHWHULRUDGR 8QD VRPEUD YDSRURVD VH PRYLy GHWUiV GH ODV YHQWDQDV RVFXUDV GHO JDUDMH $ FRQWLQXDFLyQ XQ SDU GH RMRV VLQ SHVWDxHDU PLUDURQ D WUDYpVGHOFULVWDOGLUHFWDPHQWHD$ULD $ULDFKLOOy\VHDSUHWyFRQWUDODSDUHGGHOIRQGRFRQHOFRUD]yQGLVSDUDGR3HURHQXQ LQVWDQWHORVRMRVVHGHVYDQHFLHURQFRPRVLQXQFDKXELHUDQHVWDGRDOOt

ž‰‹ƒ

ʹͻ





)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR 9XHODFRQPLJRKDFLDODOXQD 9XHODFRQPLJRKDFLDODOXQD 7UDGXFLGRSRU(PLLB*UHJRUL &RUUHJLGRSRU0DULQD 

(

O GRPLQJR SRU OD WDUGH (PLO\ )LHOGV FUX]y VXV SLHUQDV SRU GHEDMR GH HOOD HQ XQDGHODVFDELQDVDFRJHGRUDGH3HQpORSHXQFRPHGRUKRJDUHxRQRPX\OHMRV GHVXFDVD6XQXHYRQRYLR,VDDFVHVHQWyHQODFDELQDFRQODVGRVUHEDQDGDV GHPDQWHTXLOODGHPDQt\FDUJDQGRHOSDQTXHKDEtDRUGHQDGRHQIUHQWHGHpO(VWDED GHPRVWUDQGRFyPRKDFHUVXViQGZLFKGHPDQWHTXLOODGHPDQtPXQGLDOPHQWHIDPRVR TXHOHFDPELDUDODYLGD ³(OWUXFR³GLMR,VDDF³HVXVDUODPLHOHQYH]GHODMDOHD³7RPyXQDERWHOODFRQ IRUPDGHRVRGHVGHODPLWDGGHODWDEOD(ORVRKL]RXQUXLGRGHSHGRVPLHQWUDV,VDDF DSUHWDEDODPLHOHQXQDGHODVUHEDQDGDV³3URPHWRTXHHVWRVHOOHYDUiOHMRVWRGRWX HVWUpV³eOOHHQWUHJyHOViQGZLFK(PLO\OHGLRXQJUDQPRUGLVFRPDVWLFy\VRQULy ³*RRK³GLMRHOODFRQODERFDOOHQD,VDDFDSUHWyVXPDQR\(PLO\VHGHUULWLy,VDDF WHQtDVXDYHVH[SUHVLYRVRMRVD]XOHV\KDEtDDOJRHQVXERFDTXHOHKDFtDSDUHFHUFRPR VLHVWXYLHUDVRQULHQGRLQFOXVRFXDQGRQRORHVWDED6L(PLO\QRORFRQRFLHUDDVXPLUtD TXHHUDGHPDVLDGRDSXHVWRSDUDVDOLUFRQDOJXLHQFRPRHOOD ,VDDFVHxDOyDODWHOHYLVLyQHQHOPRVWUDGRUGHOFRPHGRU ³+H\¢pVDQRHVODFDVDGHWXDPLJD"

ž‰‹ƒ

³1RKHVLGRFDSD]GHGRUPLUGHVGHHOViEDGR³(VWDEDGLFLHQGR³/DLGHDGHTXH KD\DXQFDGiYHU\DFLHQWHHQHOERVTXHGHWUiVGHPLFDVDHVPXFKRSDUDVRSRUWDU6yOR HVSHURTXHORHQFXHQWUHQUiSLGR

͵Ͳ

(PLO\ VH YROYLy D WLHPSR SDUD YHU D OD 6UD 0F&OHOODQ OD YHFLQD GH 6SHQFHU SRU OD FDOOHGHWHQLpQGRVHGHODQWHGHOD5HVLGHQFLD+DVWLQJVVXSRRGOHEODQFRFRQXQDFRUUHD UHWUiFWLO



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(PLO\VHGHVOL]yKDFLDDEDMRHQVXDVLHQWRHOiFLGRHVWDEDVXELHQGRKDFLDVXJDUJDQWD (VWDEDIHOL]GHTXHODSROLFtDHVWXYLHUDEXVFDQGRD,DQSHURQRTXHUtDHVFXFKDUVREUH HVRDKRUDPLVPR 8QSROLGHOSHUVRQDOGHODSROLFtDGH5RVHZRRGDSDUHFLy ³(O'HSDUWDPHQWRGH3ROLFtDGH5RVHZRRGKDKHFKRWRGDVODVyUGHQHVQHFHVDULDV\ KDQ LQLFLDGR VX E~VTXHGD HQ ORV ERVTXHV KR\ ³$SDUHFLHURQ IODVKHV HQ OD FDUD GHO SROLFtD³ (VWDPRV WRPDQGR HVWH DVXQWR VHULDPHQWH \ PRYLpQGRQRV WDQ UiSLGR FRPR SRGHPRV /RVUHSRUWHURVFRPHQ]DURQDERPEDUGHDUDOSROLFtDFRQVXVSUHJXQWDV³¢3RUTXpHO RILFLDOHQODHVFHQDGHPRUyODE~VTXHGD"¢+D\DOJRTXHORVSROLFtDVHVWpQRFXOWDQGR" ¢(VFLHUWRTXH,DQURPSLyXQDUUHVWRGRPLFLOLDULRDSULQFLSLRVGHVHPDQD\VHUHXQLy FRQXQDGHODVFKLFDVTXHHQFRQWUyVXFXHUSR" (PLO\VHPRUGLyVXXxDPHxLTXHVRUSUHQGLGDGHTXHODSUHQVDVHKXELHUDHQWHUDGRGH TXH,DQKDEtDDFRUUDODGRD6SHQFHUHQVXSDWLRWUDVHUR¢4XLpQOHVGLMRHVR"¢:LOGHQ" ¢8QRGHORVRWURVSROLFtDV"¢$" (OSROLFtDOHYDQWyVXPDQRVLOHQFLiQGRORV ³&RPR DFDER GH H[SOLFDU HO 2ILFLDO :LOGHQ QR UHWUDVy OD E~VTXHGD 7XYLPRV TXH REWHQHU ORV SHUPLVRV FRUUHVSRQGLHQWHV SDUD FRQVHJXLU HO DFFHVR D DTXHOORV ERVTXHV« VRQ SURSLHGDG SULYDGD (Q FXDQWR DO 6U 7KRPDV URPSLHQGR XQ DUUHVWR GRPLFLOLDULR HVRQRHVDOJRTXHHVWpGLVSXHVWRDFRPHQWDUHQHVWHPRPHQWR /D FDPDUHUD KL]R XQ VRQLGR WVN \ FDPELy ORV FDQDOHV D RWUR QRWLFLHUR 5RVHZRRG 5HDFFLRQD GHFtD HO WtWXOR JUDQGH HQ DPDULOOR +DEtD XQD FKLFD HQ OD SDQWDOOD (PLO\ UHFRQRFLyGHLQPHGLDWRVXFDEHOORQHJURD]DEDFKH\HQYROYHQWHVJDIDVGHVROGH*XFFL -HQQD&DYDQDXJK (OHVWyPDJRGH(PLO\VHYROWHy-HQQD&DYDQDXJK/DFKLFDTXH(PLO\\VXVDPLJDV KDEtDQ FHJDGR SRU DFFLGHQWH HQ HO VH[WR JUDGR /D FKLFD TXH OH KDEtD GLFKR D $ULD KDFHSRFRPiVGHGRVPHVHVTXH$OLWHQtDSUREOHPDVSHUWXUEDGRUHVFRQVXKHUPDQR -DVRQSUREOHPDVTXH(PLO\D~QQRTXHUtDQLSHQVDU 6HOHYDQWyGHODPHVD

͵ͳ

³9DPRV³H[FODPyGHVYLDQGRODPLUDGDGHOWHOHYLVRU

ž‰‹ƒ

,VDDFHVWDEDGHSLHWDPELpQOXFLHQGRDIHFWDGR ³9R\DWHQHUTXHDSDJDUHOWHOHYLVRU



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(PLO\VDFXGLyODFDEH]D ³4XLHURLUPH ³(VWiELHQHVWiELHQ³GLMR,VDDFVXDYHPHQWHVDFDQGRXQDVSRFDVFXHQWDVGpELOHV\ FRORFiQGRODV HQ VX WD]D GH FDIp (PLO\ VH WDPEDOHy KDFLD OD SXHUWD IURQWDO &XDQGR DOFDQ]y OD SHTXHxD iUHD SRU HO VRSRUWH GH DQILWULRQD VLQWLy OD PDQR GH ,VDDF FHUFD VREUHODVX\D ³/R VLHQWR ³GLMR HOOD FRQ DLUH GH FXOSDELOLGDG VXV RMRV OOHQRV GH OiJULPDV³ 1L VLTXLHUDOOHJDVWHDFRPHUWXViQGZLFK ,VDDFOHWRFyHOEUD]R ³1RWHSUHRFXSHVSRUHVR1RSXHGRLPDJLQDUPHSRUORTXHHVWiVSDVDQGR (PLO\DSR\yVXFDEH]DVREUHVXKRPEUR&DGDYH]TXHFHUUDEDORVRMRVLPDJLQDEDHO FXHUSRH[SXHVWRHKLQFKDGRGH,DQ1XQFDKDEtDYLVWRDXQDSHUVRQDPXHUWDDQWHVQR HQXQIXQHUDOQRHQXQDFDPDGHKRVSLWDO\FLHUWDPHQWHQRHQHOERVTXHDVHVLQDGR 'HVHDEDSRGHUERUUDUORGHVXPHPRULDFRQVyORSXOVDUXQERWyQWDQIiFLOPHQWHFRPR GHVWUR]DUXQFRUUHRQRGHVHDGRGHVXEX]yQGHFRUUHRHOHFWUyQLFR(VWDUFRQ,VDDFHUD OD~QLFDFRVDTXHWRPDED\DOHMDEDXQSRFRGHVXGRORU\GHVXPLHGR ³$SXHVWR D TXH QR SHQVDVWH HVWR FXDQGR PH SHGLVWH TXH IXHUD WX QRYLD ¢HK" ³HOOD PXUPXUy ³3RU IDYRU ³GLMR ,VDDF VXDYHPHQWH EHViQGROD HQ OD IUHQWH³ 7H D\XGDUtD HQ FXDOTXLHUFRVD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6HKDFtDRVFXURDIXHUD\HODLUHROtDDODFHQDGHKXHYRVUHYXHOWRV\FDIp&DPLQDURQ GH OD PDQR D OD FDPLRQHWD 9ROYR GH OD PDPi GH (PLO\ TXH HVWDED HVWDFLRQDGD HQ SDUDOHORDODDFHUD/RVIOXMRVJUDQGHVGHQLHYHHVWDEDQDPRQWRQDGRVHQODDFHUD\XQ

͵ʹ

/D FDIHWHUD HQ HO FRQWDGRU ERUERWHy )XHUD GH OD YHQWDQD XQD EDUUHGRUD GH QLHYH UHIXQIXxDED FDOOH DEDMR 3RU HQpVLPD YH] (PLO\ SHQVy HQ OR DIRUWXQDGD TXH HUD SRU KDEHU HQFRQWUDGR D DOJXLHQ WDQ PDUDYLOORVR FRPR ,VDDF /D KDEtD DFHSWDGR LQFOXVR GHVSXpVGHTXHOHGLMHUDTXHVHKDEtDHQDPRUDGRGH$OLHQHOVpSWLPRJUDGR\OXHJRGH 0D\D 6W *HUPDLQ HVWH RWRxR eO KDEtD HVFXFKDGR SDFLHQWHPHQWH FXDQGR OH H[SOLFy FyPR VX IDPLOLD OXFKy FRQ VX VH[XDOLGDG HQYLiQGROD D 7UHH 7RSV XQ SURJUDPD JD\ OHMDQR eO KDEtD VRVWHQLGR VX PDQR FXDQGR OH GLMR TXH VHJXtD SHQVDQGR FRQVWDQWHPHQWHDFHUFDGH$OLDSHVDUGHTXH$OLKDEtDJXDUGDGRPXFKRVVHFUHWRVGH HOODV<DKRUDpOODHVWDEDD\XGDQGRDWUDYpVGHHVWR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

SDUGHQLxRVHVWDEDQHQXQWULQHRSRUXQDSHTXHxDFROLQDGHWUiVGHOWHUUHQREDOGtRHQ ODFDOOH $OOOHJDUDOFRFKHXQDSHUVRQDTXHXVDEDXQDJUDQFDSXFKDSHOXGDDSUHWDGDVREUHVX FDEH]DVHYROYLyKDFLDHOORV6XVRMRVEULOODEDQ ³¢(VHVWHWXFRFKH"³6HxDOyHO9ROYR (PLO\VHGHWXYRVRUSUHQGLGD ³6Vt« ³£0LUDORTXHKLFLVWH³3LVRWHyHOKRPEUHDWUDYpVGHODQLHYH\DSXQWyDXQ%0: DSDUFDGRHQIUHQWHGHO9ROYR+DEtDXQDDEROODGXUDGLUHFWDPHQWHEDMRHOQ~PHURGHOD PDWUtFXOD³ 7H HVWDFLRQDVWH DTXt GHVSXpV GH Pt ³JUXxy HO KRPEUH³ ¢,QFOXVR HFKDVWHXQYLVWD]RDQWHVGHWLUDUWHDOOt" ³<\R OR VLHQWR ³(PLO\ EDOEXFHy 1R SRGtD UHFRUGDU JROSHDU DOJR FXDQGR VH KDEtD HVWDFLRQDGRSHURKDEtDHVWDGRDWXUGLGDWRGRHOGtD ,VDDFDIURQWyDOKRPEUH ³3RGUtDKDEHUHVWDGRDOOtDQWHV7DOYH]XVWHGQRORKDEtDQRWDGR ³1R HVWDED ³VH EXUOy HO KRPEUH 0LHQWUDV VH WDPEDOHDED PiV FHUFD GH HOORV OD FDSXFKDVHFD\y7HQtDDOERURWDGRHOFDEHOORUXELRRMRVD]XOHV\XQDFDUDIDPLOLDUHQ IRUPD GH FRUD]yQ (PLO\ DVSLUy VX HVWyPDJR (UD HO KHUPDQR GH $OL -DVRQ 'L/DXUHQWLV (OOD HVSHUy -DVRQ VHJXUR OD UHFRQRFHUtD WDPELpQ (PLO\ KDEtD HVWDGR HQ FDVD GH $OL SUiFWLFDPHQWH WRGRV ORV GtDV HQ HO VH[WR \ VpSWLPR JUDGR \ -DVRQ WDPELpQ OD KDEtD YLVWR HQ HO MXLFLR GH ,DQ HO YLHUQHV 3HUR HO URVWUR GH -DVRQ HVWDED URMR \ VXV RMRV QR HVWDEDQPLUDQGR GLUHFWDPHQWHDQDGDSDUHFtDTXHHVWDEDWUDEDMDQGR HOPLVPRHQXQ WUDQFHHQIXUHFLGR(PLO\ROIDWHyHODLUHIUHQWHDpOSUHJXQWiQGRVHVLHVWDEDERUUDFKR 3HURQRSRGtDROHUHODOFRKROHQVXDOLHQWR ³¢7LHQHQ OD HGDG QHFHVDULD SDUD FRQGXFLU" ³UXJLy -DVRQ 'LR XQ SDVR DPHQD]DGRU KDFLD(PLO\

͵͵

,VDDFVHLQWHUSXVRHQWUHHOORVSURWHJLHQGRD(PLO\GHpO

ž‰‹ƒ

³:KRD1RHVQHFHVDULRTXHJULWHV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

/DV IRVDV QDVDOHV GH -DVRQ OODPHDURQ $SUHWy ORV SXxRV \ SRU XQ PRPHQWR (PLO\ SHQVyTXHLEDDODQ]DUXQJROSH(QWRQFHVXQDSDUHMDVDOLyGHODFDIHWHUtDHQODFDOOH\ -DVRQYROYLyODFDEH]D'HMyHVFDSDUXQJHPLGRIUXVWUDGRJROSHyHOWURQFRGHVXFRFKH GXURVHGLRODYXHOWD\VXELyHQHODVLHQWRGHOFRQGXFWRU(O%0:JUXxyDODYLGD\ -DVRQGHVSHJyKDFLDHOWUiILFRFRUWDQGRDXQDXWRTXHYHQtD7RFDURQODERFLQD/RV QHXPiWLFRV FKLUULDURQ (PLO\ YLR ODV OXFHV WUDVHUDV GHVDSDUHFHU HQ XQD HVTXLQD VXV PDQRVDSUHWDGDVDORVODGRVGHVXURVWUR ,VDDFVHHQIUHQWyD(PLO\ ³¢(VWiVELHQ" (PLO\DVLQWLyHQVLOHQFLRGHPDVLDGRDWXUGLGDSDUDKDEODU ³¢&XiOHUDVXSUREOHPD"(UDDSHQDVXQDDEROODGXUD1RWHUHFXHUGRJROSHiQGROR (PLO\WUDJyVDOLYD ³eVHHUDHOKHUPDQRGH$OLVRQ'L/DXUHQWLV³6LPSOHPHQWHGHFLUODVSDODEUDVHQYR] DOWDODKL]RHVWDOODUHQOiJULPDVGHPLHGRSUHRFXSDGD,VDDFGXGySRUXQPRPHQWR\ OXHJRHQYROYLyVXVEUD]RVDOUHGHGRUGH(PLO\VRVWHQLpQGRODFHUFD ³6KKK³VXVXUUy³9DPRVDHQWUDUHQHOFRFKH9R\DFRQGXFLU (PLO\OHHQWUHJyODVOODYHV\VHPHWLyHQHODVLHQWRGHOSDVDMHUR,VDDFVHUHWLUyGHOOXJDU \HPSH]yDEDMDUSRUHOFDPLQR/DVOiJULPDVURGDEDQSRUODVPHMLOODVGH(PLO\PiV UiSLGR \ PiV UiSLGR 1L VLTXLHUD HVWDED VHJXUD GH SRU TXp HVWDED OORUDQGR« SRU HO HVWDOOLGRLQMXVWRGH-DVRQVtSHURWDPELpQDFDEDEDGHYHUD-DVRQGHODQWHGHHOOD6H YHtDWDQVRUSUHQGHQWHFRPR$OL ,VDDFPLUyRWUDYH]VXURVWURDUUXJDGR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6H VHQWDURQ DOOt SRU XQ WLHPSR VLQ GHFLU QDGD (O ~QLFR VRQLGR HUD HO WUDTXHWHR GHO FDOHQWDGRUGHO9ROYR'HVSXpVGHXQPRPHQWR(PLO\VHVHFyORVRMRVVHLQFOLQyKDFLD GHODQWH\OREHVy IHOL] GHTXHHVWXYLHUDDTXt eOOHGHYROYLyHOEHVR \VHGHWXYLHURQ PLUiQGRVH FRQ QRVWDOJLD HO XQR DO RWUR (PLO\ VH ]DPEXOOy GH QXHYR EHVDQGR PiV iYLGDPHQWH'HUHSHQWHWRGRVVXVSUREOHPDVVHIXHURQDOLJXDOTXHODVFHQL]DVHQXQD EULVD

͵Ͷ

³2\H ³GLMR HQ YR] EDMD 6H GLR OD YXHOWD HQ XQ FDPLQR TXH FRQGXFtD D XQD ILOD GH HGLILFLRVGHRILFLQDVHVWDFLRQDQGRHQXQHVWDFLRQDPLHQWRRVFXURYDFtR\FDPELyHQHO SDUTXH³(VWiELHQ³eODFDULFLyHOEUD]RGH(PLO\

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

/DVYHQWDQDVGHOFRFKHVHHPSDxDURQ0XGDPHQWH,VDDFUHFRJLyHOERUGHLQIHULRUGH VXFDPLVHWDPDQJDODUJD\VHODSXVRVREUHVXFDEH]D6XSHFKRHUDVXDYH\PXVFXORVR \ WHQtD XQD SHTXHxD FLFDWUL] EULOODQWH HQ HO LQWHULRU GH VX EUD]R GHUHFKR (PLO\ H[WHQGLyODPDQR\ORWRFy ³¢4XpHVHVR" ³&DHUVHGHXQDUDPSD%0;HQHOVHJXQGRJUDGR³UHVSRQGLy eOLQFOLQyODFDEH]D\OHGLRXQFRGD]RKDFLDODFDPLVHWDPDQJDODUJDGH(PLO\(OOD OHYDQWyVXVEUD]RV,VDDFOROOHYyDFDER$XQTXHHOFDORUHVWDEDDWRGRYROXPHQORV EUD]RV GH (PLO\ HVWDEDQ WRGDYtD FXELHUWRV GH SLHO GH JDOOLQD (OOD EDMy OD PLUDGD DYHUJRQ]DGDSRUHOVXMHWDGRUGHSRUWLYRD]XOPDULQRTXHKDEtDH[FDYDGRHQHOFDMyQHQ OD PDxDQD (VWDED LPSUHVR FRQ OXQDV HVWUHOODV \ SODQHWDV 6L VyOR VH KXELHUD SXHVWR DOJR XQ SRFR PiV IHPHQLQR \ VH[\« SHUR HQWRQFHV QR HUD FRPR VL VH KXELHUD SODQHDGRTXLWDUVHODURSD ,VDDFVHxDOyHQVXRPEOLJR ³7LHQHVXQRDIXHUD (PLO\ORFXEULy ³7RGRHOPXQGRVHEXUODGHpO³6REUHWRGRTXLVRGHFLU$OLTXHKDEtDWRPDGRXQD RMHDGD HQ HO RPEOLJR GH (PLO\ XQD YH] FXDQGR VH HVWDEDQ FDPELDQGR HQ HO &OXE GH &DPSR GH 5RVHZRRG ³3HQVp TXH VyOR KDEtD QLxRV UHJRUGHWHV FRQ RPEOLJRV FRPR HVWRV ³HOOD EURPHy (PLO\ VH KDEtD SXHVWR WUDMHV GH EDxR GH XQD VROD SLH]D GHVGH HQWRQFHV ,VDDFFXULRVHyFRQVXVPDQRVOHMRV ³&UHRTXHHVJHQLDO³6XVGHGRVUR]DURQHOERUGHLQIHULRUGHOVXMHWDGRUGHVOL]DQGR VX PDQR HQ HO LQWHULRU (O FRUD]yQ GH (PLO\ JROSHy ,VDDF VH LQFOLQy KDFLD HOOD EHViQGROH HO FXHOOR 6X SLHO GHVQXGD WRFy OD VX\D eO WLUy GH VX VXMHWDGRU GHSRUWLYR LQVWiQGROD D TXH VDOLHUD (PLO\ VH WLUy HQFLPD GH VX FDEH]D \ XQD VRQULVD WRQWD DSDUHFLyHQHOURVWURGH,VDDF(PLO\VHULyGLYHUWLGDHQFXDQVHULRVHUDQ6LQHPEDUJR QRVHVHQWtDFRKLELGD(VWRVHVHQWtD«ELHQ

³¢(VWiVVHJXUDGHTXHHVWiVELHQ"³PXUPXUy,VDDF ³


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

͵ͷ

6HDEUD]DURQFRQIXHU]DSUHVLRQDQGRVXVFXHUSRVFDOLHQWHVMXQWRV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³1RWHGLVFXOSHV³,VDDFDFDULFLDEDVXFDEHOORFRQODVPDQRV³&RPRKHGLFKRPH JXVWDUtDD\XGDUWHFRQFXDOTXLHUFRVD
ž‰‹ƒ

͵͸

3HURXQDVHJXQGDYR]HPSXMDEDHQHOODWDPELpQ(VDQRHVWRGDODKLVWRULDODYR]GLMR\ ORVDEHV 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR (VHFKLFRHVPtR (VHFKLFRHVPtR 7UDGXFLGRSRUPDVL &RUUHJLGRSRU0DULQD 

0

iVWDUGHHVDQRFKH+DQQD0DULQVHVHQWyHQXQDPHVDEODQFDEULOODQWHHQ 3LQNEHUU\HQHOFHQWURFRPHUFLDO.LQJ-DPHV

6XV IXWXUDV KHUPDQDVWUDV .DWH 5DQGDOO 1DRPL =HLJOHU \ 5LOH\ :ROIH OD URGHDEDQSHTXHxDVWD]DVGH\RJXUFRQJHODGRHVWDEDQFRORFDGDVDOIUHQWHGHFDGDXQD GH HOODV 8QD FDQFLyQ MDSRQHVD GH SRS VRQDED GHVGH ORV DOWDYRFHV \ XQD OtQHD GH FKLFDV GH 6DQ $XJXVWXV GH OD HVFXHOD SUHSDUDWRULD VH VLWXDEDQ HQ HO PRVWUDGRU PHGLWDQGRVREUHODVRSFLRQHV ³¢1RFUHHQTXH3LQNEHUU\HVXQOXJDUGHUHXQLyQPXFKRPHMRUTXH5LYH*DXFKH"³ GLMR +DQQD HQ UHIHUHQFLD DO UHVWDXUDQWH GH HVWLOR IUDQFpV GHO RWUR H[WUHPR GHO FHQWUR FRPHUFLDO +L]R XQ JHVWR KDFLD OD SXHUWD KDFLD HO DWULR GHO FHQWUR FRPHUFLDO³ (VWDPRV MXVWR HQIUHQWH GH $UPDQL ([FKDQJH \ &DUWLHU 3RGHPRV FRPHUQRV FRQ ORV RMRVDORVFKLFRVVH[\V\YHUGLDPDQWHVPDJQtILFRVVLQWHQHUTXHOHYDQWDUQRV

0HWLyODFXFKDUDHQODFRSDGH3LQNEHUU\\VHPHWLyXQDFXFKDUDGDHQRUPHHQODERFD GHMDQGRHVFDSDUXQSHTXHxR´PPPµSDUDKDFHUKLQFDSLpGHTXHWDQEXHQDHUDODLGHD TXH KDEtD WHQLGR 'HVSXpV DOLPHQWy FRQ XQD SHTXHxD UDFLyQ D 'RW VX GREHUPDQ PLQLDWXUDDTXLHQKDEtDWUDtGRHQVXEROVRSRUWDHTXLSDMHVSDUDODDSHUWXUDGHODQXHYD WLHQGDGH-XLF\&RXWXUHSDUDSHUURV/RVWUDEDMDGRUHVGH3LQNEHUU\VHJXtDQGLVSDUDQGR GDJDVHQGLUHFFLyQD+DQQD$OJXQDUHJODQRGLFKDLPSOLFDEDTXHORVSHUURVQRHUDQ SHUPLWLGRV DTXt SHUR VHJXUDPHQWH VH UHIHUtDQ D ORV SHUURV VXFLRV FRPR ODEUDGRUHV \ 6DQ %HUQDUGRV \ ORV KRUULEOHV \ SHTXHxRV 6KLK 7]X 'RW HUD HO SHUUR PiV OLPSLR GH WRGRV ORV SHUURV GH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ +DQQD OH GDED VHPDQDOPHQWH EDxRV GH EXUEXMD FRQFKDPS~SDUDSHUURVFRQRORUDODYDQGDLPSRUWDGRGHVGH3DUtV

͵͹

5LOH\KL]RJLUDUXQDSLH]DGHFDEHOORFREUL]RDOUHGHGRUGHVXVGHGRV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ž‰‹ƒ

³3HURQRVHSXHGHUREDUDKXUWDGLOODVYLQRDTXtFRPRVHSXHGHHQ5LYH*DXFKH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³6tSHURQRSXHGHVOOHYDUSHUURVD5LYH*DXFKH³GLMR+DQQDDJDUUDQGRODSHTXHxD FDULWDGH'RWHQVXVPDQRV/HGLRRWUDSHTXHxDSRUFLyQGH3LQNEHUU\ 1DRPLSUREyXQSHTXHxRERFDGRGH\RJXUHLQPHGLDWDPHQWHVHYROYLyDDSOLFDUXQD FDSDGHOiSL]GHODELRVGH*XHUODLQ.LVV.LVV ³< OD LOXPLQDFLyQ GH DTXt HV WDQ SRFR IDYRUHFHGRUD ³(OOD PLUDED D ORV HVSHMRV UHGRQGRV TXH VH DOLQHDEDQ HQ ODV SDUHGHV GH 3LQNEHUU\³ 6LHQWR TXH PLV SRURV VH DJUDQGDQ +DQQDGHMyFDHUODWD]DGH3LQNEHUU\VREUHODPHVDKDFLHQGRTXHODSHTXHxDFXFKDUD GHSOiVWLFRVDOWDUD ³%XHQRQRTXHUtDUHFXUULUDHVWRSHURDQWHVGHTXHURPSLpUDPRV/XFDVPHGLMRTXH 5LYH *DXFKH WLHQH UDWDV HQ OD FRFLQD ¢(VWiV VHJXUD GH TXH TXLHUHV SDVDU HO UDWR HQ DOJXQDSDUWHFRQXQSUREOHPDGHURHGRUHV"3RGUtDKDEHUPLHUGDGHUDWDHQWXVSDWDWDV IULWDV ³¢2QRTXLHUHVHVWDUDOOtDFDXVDGHOSUREOHPDGH/XFDV"³1DRPLVHULyVDFXGLHQGR VXFDEHOORUXELRFODURSRUHQFLPDGHVXKXHVXGRKRPEUR.DWHVHULy\OHYDQWyODWD]D GH Wp GH PHQWD TXH KDEtD FRPSUDGR DQWHV HQ 6WDUEXFNV SDUD KDFHU XQ EULQGLV ¢4XLpQHV EHEtDQ Wp GH PHQWD DGHPiV GH ODV VHxRUDV GH HGDG GH WRGRV PRGRV" )HQyPHQR +DQQDIXOPLQyFRQODPLUDGDDVXVPHGLRKHUPDQDVWUDV\JLUyODFDEH]DLQFDSD]GH PLUDUODV $ SULQFLSLRV GH OD VHPDQD .DWH \ +DQQD FDVL KDEtDQ FRQJHQLDGR FRPSDUWLHQGR DOJXQRV VHFUHWRV GXUDQWH HO GHVD\XQR .DWH DOXGLy TXH WHQtD XQ SUREOHPD JLQHFROyJLFR SHUR QR H[SOLFy OR TXH HUD \ +DQQD FRQIHVy VX SUREOHPD GH EXOLPLD3HURFXDQGR´$µFRPHQ]yDLQVLQXDUD+DQQDTXH.DWHHUDPHQRVTXHXQD QXHYDPHMRUDPLJD\PiVXQDPDOYDGDKHUPDQDVWUD+DQQDVHGLRFXHQWDTXHFRQILDU HQ .DWH KDEtD VLGR XQ JUDQ HUURU $Vt TXH HQ OD IXQFLyQ EHQpILFD GH5RVHZRRG 'D\ +DQQDOHFRQWyDWRGDODHVFXHODTXH.DWHWHQtDKHUSHV6L+DQQDQRORKXELHUDKHFKR HVWDEDVHJXUDGHTXH.DWHKXELHUDFRQWDGRHOVHFUHWRGH+DQQDHQVXOXJDU

ž‰‹ƒ

.DWHSDUHFtDKDEHUORGHMDGRSDVDUWDPELpQJLUiQGRVHD+DQQDHQHOFRFKHGHFDPLQR DOFHQWURFRPHUFLDO\GLFLHQGRFRQXQDYR]IUHVFD\GHVSUHRFXSDGD ³6LPSOHPHQWHYDPRVDROYLGDUORGHODSDVDGDQRFKH¢GHDFXHUGR"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

͵ͺ

1DRPL \ 5LOH\ KDEtDQ UHFRQRFLGR HO LQFLGHQWH GHO KHUSHV FRPR XQ JUDQ MXHJR GH SRGHU LQPHGLDWDPHQWH OODPDQGR WDQWR D +DQQD FRPR D .DWH HVD PDxDQD GH GRPLQJRSDUDYHUVLTXHUtDQLUDO.LQJ-DPHVFRPRVLHVRQXQFDKXELHUDVXFHGLGR



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

3RU GHVJUDFLD QR WRGR HO PXQGR YLR HO WUXFR GHO KHUSHV FRPR XQ PRYLPLHQWR GH OD DEHMD UHLQD HO FXDO UHDOPHQWH HUD ,QPHGLDWDPHQWH GHVSXpV GH TXH +DQQD OR GLMHUD /XFDVHOQRYLRGH+DQQDHQHVHPRPHQWRGLMRTXHORVX\RVHKDEtDDFDEDGRTXHQR TXHUtDHVWDUFRQDOJXLHQTXHHVWDEDWDQREVHVLRQDGRFRQODSRSXODULGDG<FXDQGRHO SDGUHGH+DQQDVHKDEtDHQWHUDGROHRUGHQyTXH+DQQDSDVDUDWRGRVXWLHPSROLEUH FRQ .DWH SDUD TXH SXGLHUDQ FRQJHQLDU +DVWD HO PRPHQWR pO VH HVWDED WRPDQGR HO FDVWLJRHQVHULR (VWD PDxDQD FXDQGR .DWH TXHUtD LU D :DZD SRU XQD &RFD&ROD /LJKW +DQQD OD DFRPSDxy 'HVSXpV FXDQGR +DQQD TXLVR WRPDU XQD FODVH GH \RJD %LNUDP .DWH FRUULy HVFDOHUDV DUULED \ VH YLVWLy FRQ VX FDSULV GH \RJD /XOXOHPRQ < HVWD WDUGH OD SUHQVDVHKDEtDPRVWUDGRHQODSXHUWDGH+DQQDSDUDKDFHUOHSUHJXQWDVVREUHHODUUHVWR GH ,DQ SRU DOODQDPLHQWR GH PRUDGD \ OR TXH VXFHGLy OD VHPDQD SDVDGD FXDQGR VH UHXQLy FRQ 6SHQFHU ³¢'H TXp HVWDEDQ KDEODQGR" ³SUHJXQWDURQ ORV SHULRGLVWDV³ ¢3RUTXpQROHGLMHURQDODSROLFtDTXH,DQKDEtDDSDUHFLGR"¢1RVHVWiQRFXOWDQGRDOJR DQRVRWURV"³$PHGLGDTXH+DQQDH[SOLFDEDTXHHOODQRVDEtDTXH,DQDSDUHFLyHQHO SRUFKH GH 6SHQFHU KDVWD PXFKR GHVSXpV GH TXH ,DQ KXELHUD HVFDSDGR .DWH HVWDED MXVWRDVXODGRDSOLFiQGRVHXQDQXHYDFDSDGHEULOORGHODELRV6PDVKER[SDUDHOFDVR GHTXHORVSHULRGLVWDVQHFHVLWDUDQXQDRSLQLyQH[WUDGHXQDFKLFDGH5RVHZRRG'D\ 1RLPSRUWDEDTXHHOODKXELHUDVLGRXQDQLxDGH5RVHZRRG'D\GHVGHKDFtDVyORXQD VHPDQD \ PHGLD (OOD VH KDEtD PXGDGR D OD FDVD GH OD PDGUH GH +DQQD GHVSXpV GH TXHODPDGUHGH+DQQDDFHSWDUDXQWUDEDMRELHQUHPXQHUDGRHQ6LQJDSXUH/DPDGUH GH .DWH ,VDEHO \ HO SDGUH GH +DQQD VH KDEtD PXGDGR D OD FDVD WDPELpQ \ ORV GRV SODQHDEDQFDVDUVH
³(V SUREDEOHPHQWH OR PHMRU ³GLMR +DQQD DOHJUHPHQWH³ (VFXFKp TXH (ULF HV XQ JUDQMXJDGRU<VyOROHJXVWDQODVFKLFDVFRQWHWDVJUDQGHV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

.DWHEDMyVXVRMRV(ULF.DKQHOVH[\KHUPDQRPD\RUGH1RHOHVWDEDLQWHUHVDGRHQ .DWHEXHQRORKDEtDHVWDGRKDVWDHOFRPHQWDULRGHOKHUSHVGHWRGRVPRGRV

͵ͻ

³3HUR W~ SDUHFHV EDVWDQWH GLVJXVWDGD .DWH ³UHSOLFy +DQQD LJXDODQGR OD FDULxRVD YR]GH.DWH³1RKDVRtGRKDEODUGH(ULF¢HK"3REUHFLWD¢7LHQHVHOFRUD]yQURWR"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³/RVSHFKRVGH.DWHHVWiQELHQ³VDOWy5LOH\UiSLGDPHQWH 1DRPLDUUXJyVXQDUL] ³1XQFDKHRtGRTXH(ULFIXHUDXQMXJDGRU +DQQDKL]RXQDERODGHVXVHUYLOOHWDPROHVWDGHTXH1DRPL\5LOH\IXHURQWDQUiSLGDV SDUDVDOWDUHQGHIHQVDGH.DWH ³8VWHGHVFKLFDVQRWLHQHQHOPLVPRWLSRGHLQIRUPDFLyQTXH\RWHQJR 7RGDVVHYROYLHURQDFHQWUDUHQVXV3LQNEHUULHVVLQGHFLUQDGD'HUHSHQWHXQGHVWHOOR GHFDEHOORUXELRHQHODWULROODPyODDWHQFLyQGH+DQQD\VHGLRODYXHOWD8QJUXSRGH FKLFDVGHYHLQWHDxRVSDVDURQFDPLQDQGREDODQFHDQGRODVEROVDVGHFRPSUDVGH6DNV 7RGRVHUDQPRUHQDV +DQQD KDEtD HVWDGR YLHQGR XQ PRQWyQ GH IODVKHV IDQWDVPDV GH SHOR UXELR ~OWLPDPHQWH \ HUD SHUVHJXLGD FRQVWDQWHPHQWH SRU OD LQTXLHWDQWH VHQVDFLyQ GH TXH SRGUtD WUDWDUVH GH 0RQD 9DQGHUZDDO VX DQWLJXD PHMRU DPLJD 0RQD KDEtD PXHUWR FDVL GRV PHVHV DQWHV SHUR +DQQD WRGDYtD SHQVDED HQ HOOD PXFKDV YHFHV DO GtD« HQ WRGDVODVILHVWDVGHSLMDPDVTXHKDEtDQWHQLGRHQWRGDVODVH[FXUVLRQHVGHFRPSUDVD ODVTXHKDEtDQLGRHQWRGDVODVQRFKHVGHERUUDFKHUDHQODFDVDGH0RQDGHUHtUVHGH ORVFKLFRVFRQORVTXHKDEtDQIOLUWHDGR$KRUDTXH0RQDVHKDEtDLGRKDEtDXQDJXMHUR HQRUPHHQODYLGDGH+DQQD$OPLVPRWLHPSRVHVHQWtDFRPRXQDLGLRWD0RQDQR KDEtD VLGR UHDOPHQWH VX DPLJD« 0RQD KDEtD VLGR ´$µ (OOD KDEtD DUUXLQDGR ODV UHODFLRQHVGH+DQQDDLUHDGRVXVWUDSRVVXFLRV\ODKDEtDWRUWXUDGRGXUDQWHPHVHV< GHILQLWLYDPHQWHODVPHMRUHVDPLJDVSDUDVLHPSUHQRDWURSHOODEDQDVXVPHMRUHVDPLJDV FRQHO689GHVXSDGUH 'HVSXpVGHTXHODVFRPSUDGRUDVSDVDURQ+DQQDVHGLRFXHQWDGHXQDILJXUDIDPLOLDU GH FDEHOOR RVFXUR MXVWR IXHUD GH 3LQNEHUU\ KDEODQGR SRU XQ WHOpIRQR FHOXODU (QWUHFHUUyORVRMRV(UDHO2ILFLDO:LOGHQ



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

+DQQDIUXQFLyHOFHxR¢+DEtDGHVFXELHUWRDOJRVREUHHOFXHUSRGH,DQ"(OODWDPELpQ TXHUtD SUHJXQWDUOH VREUH OD ILJXUD HVSHOX]QDQWH \ HQFDSXFKDGD TXH KDEtD YLVWR HQ HO ERVTXH OD QRFKH GH OD ILHVWD $TXHOOD TXH VH KDEtD FHUQLGR VREUH +DQQD DPHQD]DGRUDPHQWH \ GHVSXpV GH XQ PRPHQWR OD SHUVRQD KDEtD OHYDQWDGR XQ GHGR KDVWDVXVODELRV\KDEtDVXVXUUDGR´VKKKµ

ͶͲ

³&iOPDWH ³PXUPXUDED :LOGHQ HQ HO WHOpIRQR FRQ VX YR] XUJHQWH \ DQJXVWLDGD )UXQFLy HO FHxR DO HVFXFKDU D OD SHUVRQD HQ HO RWUR H[WUHPR³ (VWi ELHQ HVWi ELHQ 4XpGDWHVHQWDGR(VWDUpDOOtSURQWR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

¢3RUTXpDOJXLHQKDUtDFDOODUD+DQQDDPHQRVTXHpVWHKXELHUDKHFKRDOJRWHUULEOH\ QRTXLVLHUDVHUYLVWR"+DQQDVHSUHJXQWyVLODSHUVRQDWHQtDDOJRTXHYHUFRQODPXHUWH GH,DQ7DOYH]HUD´$µWDPELpQ +DQQD FRPHQ]y D SRQHUVH GH SLH SHUR DQWHV GH TXH SXGLHUD HPSXMDU VX VLOOD KDFLD IXHUDGHODPHVD:LOGHQVHIXHFRUULHQGR(OODVHKXQGLyHQVXDVLHQWRSHQVDQGRTXH HVWDED RFXSDGR \ QHUYLRVR $ GLIHUHQFLD GH 6SHQFHU +DQQD QR FUHtD TXH :LOGHQ HVFRQGLHUD QDGD :LOGHQ KDEtD VDOLGR FRQ OD PDGUH GH +DQQD DQWHV GH TXH HOOD VH PXGDUD D 6LQJDSXU SDUD WRPDU XQ QXHYR SXHVWR GH WUDEDMR \ +DQQD VHQWtD TXH FRQRFtDD:LOGHQXQSRFRPiVtQWLPDPHQWHTXHODVRWUDV%XHQRHQFRQWUDUOHPRMDGR HQYXHOWRHQVXWRDOODIDYRULWDGH3RWWHU\%DUQHUDPiVLQFyPRGRTXHtQWLPRSHURHUD HVHQFLDOPHQWHXQEXHQKRPEUHTXHHVWDEDSURWHJLpQGRODV¢YHUGDG"6LpOSHQVDEDTXH ´$µHUDXQLPLWDGRUWDOYH]´$µUHDOPHQWHORHUD ¢3RUTXpODVHQJDxDUtD" 6LQ HPEDUJR +DQQD QR HVWDED WRPDQGR QLQJ~Q ULHVJR &RQ HVWR HQ PHQWH VDFy VX QXHYRHVWXFKHSDUDL3KRQHTXHHUDGHSLHOGHYDFDGH'LRU\VHYROYLyKDFLDODVFKLFDV ³$Vt TXH +H FDPELDGR HO Q~PHUR GH PyYLO SHUR QR OR HVWR\ GDQGR D FXDOTXLHUD 8VWHGHV WLHQHQ TXH SURPHWHU TXH QR VH OR SDVDUDQ D QDGLH 6L HV DVt OR VDEUp ³/DV PLUyFRQVHULHGDG ³1RVRWUDV OR SURPHWHPRV ³GLMR 5LOH\ FRQ HQWXVLDVPR VDFDQGR VX %ODFN%HUU\ +DQQDOHVHQYLyDFDGDXQDXQWH[WRFRQVXQXHYRQ~PHUR(QUHDOLGDGGHEHUtDKDEHU SHQVDGR HQ FRQVHJXLU XQ QXHYR Q~PHUR GH WHOpIRQR PXFKR DQWHV HUD XQD PDQHUD SHUIHFWD SDUD TXH ´$µ HVWXYLHUD IXHUD GH VX YLGD $GHPiV GHVKDFHUVH GH VX DQWLJXR Q~PHURHUDXQDPDQHUDGHOLEHUDUVHDVtPLVPDGHWRGRORTXHKDEtDSDVDGRHO~OWLPR VHPHVWUH£9RLOj7RGRVHVRVUHFXHUGRVGHPLHUGDVHKDEtDQLGRSDUDVLHPSUH

ž‰‹ƒ

6DFXGLy VX EDUELOOD HQ GLUHFFLyQ DO DWULR 8Q JUXSR GH MXJDGRUHV GH ODFURVVH GH 5RVHZRRG'D\LQFOX\HQGRD1RHO.DKQ%\HUV0DVRQ\HOKHUPDQRPHQRUGH$ULD 0LNH HVWDEDQ UHPRORQHDQGR SRU OD IXHQWH 0LNH HVWDED JHVWLFXODQGR FRQ VXV PDQRV PLHQWUDVFRQWDEDXQDKLVWRULD(VWDEDGHPDVLDGROHMRVFRPRSDUDTXHHOODVHVFXFKDUDQ ORTXHGHFtDSHURORVPXFKDFKRVGHODFURVVHHVFXFKDEDQFDGDXQDGHVXVSDODEUDV

Ͷͳ

³'D LJXDO GH WRGRV PRGRV ³GLMR .DWH HQ YR] DOWD GHVSXpV GH TXH ODV FKLFDV WHUPLQDUDQVXVPHQVDMHVGHWH[WRWUD\HQGRODDWHQFLyQGHQXHYRDVtPLVPD³2OYLGp D (ULF (VWR\ SRU HQFLPD GH pO +D\ XQ PRQWyQ GH RWURV FKLFRV OLQGRV MXVWR EDMR QXHVWUDVQDULFHV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢&KLFRVGH/D["³+DQQDKL]RXQDPXHFD³'LPHTXHHVWiVEURPHDQGR³(OOD\ 0RQDXQDYH]KDEtDQKHFKRXQSDFWRGHTXHQXQFDVDOGUtDQFRQQDGLHGHOHTXLSRGH ODFURVVH (OORV KDFtDQ WRGR MXQWRV GHVGH HVWXGLDU D HMHUFLWDUVH HQ HO &OXE 'HSRUWLYR 3KLOO\ HO JLPQDVLR PXJULHQWR GH OD SDUWH SRVWHULRU GHO .LQJ -DPHV FRPLHQGR HQ HO GHVDJUDGDEOHGH&KLFNILO$+DQQD\0RQDVROtDQEURPHDUGHTXHWDPELpQWHQtDQXQ JUXSRVHFUHWRGHILHVWDGHSLMDPDV\VHHVWLOL]DEDQHQWUHHOORVHOFDEHOORORVXQRVDORV RWURV .DWHWRPyRWURVRUERGHVXWpGHPHQWD ³$OJXQRVGHHOORVVRQPX\VH[\V ³¢&yPRTXLpQ"³UHWy+DQQD .DWHPLUyDORVFKLFRVPLHQWUDVSDVDEDQDO0$&'DYLG


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

'H SURQWR XQ VHQWLPLHQWR SRVHVLYR FRPHQ]y D DWUDYHVDU ODV YHQDV GH +DQQD (O DVXQWR HUD TXH 0LNH KDEtD HVWDGR VLJXLHQGR +DQQD FRPR XQ SHUULWR SHUGLGR GHVGH KDFtDDxRV8QILQGHVHPDQDHQVH[WRJUDGRFXDQGR+DQQD$OL\ODVGHPiVHVWDEDQ GXUPLHQGRHQODFDVDGH$ULD+DQQDVHKDEtDOHYDQWDGRHQPHGLRGHODQRFKHSDUDLU DOEDxR

Ͷʹ

/RVRMRVGH+DQQDVHDEULHURQSRUFRPSOHWR¢0LNHPDJQtILFR"(UDIXHUWHPROHVWR\ JURVHUR0X\ELHQWDOYH]QRHUDXQWRWDOFDQDOOD«WHQtDHOPLVPRSHORQHJURD]XODGR FXHUSRODUJXLUXFKR\RMRVD]XOKLHORTXH$ULDWHQtD3HURWRGDYtD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(Q HO SDVLOOR RVFXUR XQ SDU GH PDQRV VH H[WHQGLHURQ \ EXVFDURQ D WLHQWDV VXV WHWDV +DQQDJULWy\0LNHHQWRQFHVXQFKLFRGHTXLQWRJUDGRGLRXQSDVRDWUiV ³/R VLHQWR 3HQVp TXH HUDV $OL ³GLMR 'HVSXpV GH XQD SDXVD VH LQFOLQy \ EHVy D +DQQD GH WRGRV PRGRV +DQQD VH OR SHUPLWLy VHFUHWDPHQWH KDODJDGD« \D TXH HUD JRUGLWDIHD\HVWDEDFRMDHQHVHHQWRQFHV\QRHUDFRPRVLKXELHUDWRQHODGDVGHFKLFRV OXFKDQGRSRUHOOD0LNHHUDWpFQLFDPHQWHVXSULPHUEHVR +DQQDVHHQIUHQWyD.DWH6HVHQWtDFRPRXQDROODDSXQWRGHHVWDOODU ³2GLRWHQHUTXHGHFtUWHORFDULxRSHUR0LNHPHJXVWD¢1RKDVQRWDGRODIRUPDHQ TXHPHFRPHFRQORVRMRVHQ6WHDPFDGDPDxDQD" .DWHVHSDVyORVGHGRVSRUHOSHORFDVWDxR ³(VWR\ HQ 6WHDP WRGDV ODV PDxDQDV WDPELpQ +DQ (V GLItFLO VDEHU D TXLpQ HVWi PLUDQGR ³(VFLHUWRLQWHUYLQR1DRPLFHSLOODGRDOJXQRVPHFKRQHVGHVXSHORFRUWRGHFRORU UXELRLQWHQVR³0LNHQRVPLUDDWRGDVQRVRWUDV ³6t³GLMR5LOH\ +DQQD VH FODYy ODV XxDV KHFKDV FRQ OD PDQLFXUD IUDQFHVD HQ HO PXVOR ¢4Xp GHPRQLRV HVWDED SDVDQGR DTXt" ¢3RU TXp HVRV GRV HVWDEDQ WDQ VyOLGDPHQWH HQ HO (TXLSRGH.DWH"+DQQDHUDODDEHMDUHLQD ³7HQGUHPRV TXH YHU HVR ³GLMR +DQQD KLQFKDQGR VX SHFKR .DWH ODGHy OD FDEH]D FRPRVLGLMHUD´¢$KVt"µ (QWRQFHV.DWHVHOHYDQWy ³6DEHQFKLFDVGHUHSHQWHWHQJRXQJUDQDQKHORGHXQSRFRGHYLQRURMR ¢4XLHUHQ TXHQRVGHPRVXQDYXHOWDSRU5LYH*DXFKH" /RVRMRVGH1DRPL\5LOH\VHLOXPLQDURQ

³£2K +DQ ¢(VWiV UHDOPHQWH PROHVWD SRU /XFDV" 3HQVp VHULDPHQWH TXH QR WH LPSRUWDED



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

+DQQDGHMyHVFDSDUXQFKLOOLGRLQGLJQDGR\WRGDVVHGHWXYLHURQ.DWHDO]yHOODELRHQ XQDPXHFDIDOVDGHSUHRFXSDFLyQ

Ͷ͵

³7RWDOPHQWH³GLMHURQDPERVDOXQtVRQR\VHOHYDQWDURQWDPELpQ

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

1R UHSOLFy +DQQD VX YR] LUUHYHUHQWHPHQWH GpELO³ eO QR PH LPSRUWD
ž‰‹ƒ

ͶͶ

.DWHSRGUtDKDEHUJDQDGRODEDWDOODGHODDEHMDUHLQDKR\SHURODJXHUUDHVWDEDOHMRVGH WHUPLQDU(UDODIDEXORVD+DQQD0DULQGHVSXpVGHWRGR(VDSHTXHxDSHUUDWRQWDQR WHQtDLGHDGHFRQTXLpQHVWDEDWUDWDQGR 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR 'DPHXQDRSRUWXQLGDG 'DPHXQDRSRUWXQLGDG 7UDGXFLGRSRUNLNL &RUUHJLGRSRUʾ 

7

HPSUDQRHQODQRFKHGHOOXQHV6SHQFHU\$QGUHZ&DPSEHOOHVWDEDQVHQWDGRV HQ OD VRODQD GH VX IDPLOLD VXV QRWDV GH HFRQRPtD DYDQ]DGD HVSDUFLGDV DQWH HOORV 8Q PHFKyQ GHO ODUJR FDEHOOR UXELR GH $QGUHZ FDtD VREUH VXV RMRV PLHQWUDVVHLQFOLQDEDVREUHHOOLEURGHWH[WR\DSXQWDEDODLOXVWUDFLyQGHXQKRPEUH eVWHHV$OIUHG0DUVKDOO&XEULyHOSiUUDIREDMRVXUHWUDWR5iSLGR¢&XiOHUDVX ILORVRItD" 6SHQFHU SUHVLRQy VXV GHGRV HQ VXV VLHQHV 3RGtD DxDGLU FROXPQDV GH Q~PHURV HQ VX FDEH]D \ VXPLQLVWUDU VLHWH VLQyQLPRV D OD SDODEUD FRQVXHWXGLQDULR SHUR FXDQGR VH WUDWDEDGHHFRQRPtDDYDQ]DGDVXFHUHEURVHYROYtD«SDVWRVR3HURWHQtDTXHDSUHQGHU HVWR 6X SURIHVRU HO 6U 0F$GDP OH GLMR D 6SHQFHU TXH HVWDUtD IXHUD GH VX FODVH D PHQRVTXHVHOXFLHUDHVWHVHPHVWUHD~QHVWDEDPROHVWRGHTXHOHKXELHVHUREDGRDVX KHUPDQDPD\RUHOHQVD\RGHHFRQRPtD\TXHQRVHORKXELHUDFRQIHVDGRKDVWDGHVSXpV GH KDEHU JDQDGR HO SUHVWLJLRVR SUHPLR GH ORV HQVD\RV /D 2UTXtGHD 'RUDGD $Vt TXH DKRUD$QGUHZTXLHQQDWXUDOPHQWHHQWHQGtDHFRQRPtDHUDVXWXWRU 5HSHQWLQDPHQWH6SHQFHUVHLOXPLQy /DWHRUtDGHODRIHUWD\ODGHPDQGDUHFLWyHOOD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6SHQFHU QXQFD KDEtD HVWDGR WDQ FRQIXQGLGD /D FDVD HVWDED YDFtD MXVWR DKRUDORV SDGUHVGH6SHQFHU\VXKHUPDQD0HOLVVDKDEtDQVDOLGRDFHQDUVLQLQYLWDUD6SHQFHU FRPRGHFRVWXPEUHORTXHVLJQLILFDEDTXH$QGUHZSRGtDKDFHUXQPRYLPLHQWRVLDVt ORTXLVLHUD&LHUWDPHQWHKDEtDSDUHFLGRLQWHUHVDGRHQEHVDUODODQRFKHGHOViEDGRHQOD EHQHILFHQFLDGH5RVHZRRG'D\SHURGHVGHHQWRQFHV«QDGD(VFLHUWR6SHQFHUKDEtD HVWDGR SUHRFXSDGD FRQ OD 'HVDSDULFLyQ GHO &XHUSR GH ,DQ OD QRFKH GHO ViEDGR \ HO

Ͷͷ

0X\ELHQ$QGUHZVRQULy3DVyXQDSiJLQDGHOOLEURVXVGHGRVDFFLGHQWDOPHQWH UR]DURQFRQWUDORVGHHOOD(OFRUD]yQGH6SHQFHUVHDFHOHUySHURHQWRQFHV$QGUHZVH DSDUWyUiSLGDPHQWH

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

GRPLQJRKDEtDKHFKRXQUiSLGRYLDMHD)ORULGDSDUDDVLVWLUDOIXQHUDOGHVXDEXHOD(OOD \ $QGUHZ KDEtDQ VLGR DPLJDEOHV HQ FODVHV HO GtD GH KR\ SHUR $QGUHZ QR KDEtD PHQFLRQDGR OR TXH KDEtD SDVDGR HQ OD ILHVWD \ FLHUWDPHQWH 6SHQFHU QR LED D PHQFLRQDUOR SULPHUR 6SHQFHU KDEtD HVWDGR WDQ DQVLRVD DQWHV GH TXH $QGUHZ OOHJDUD TXHKDEtDTXLWDGRHOSROYRGHFDGDXQRGHVXVWURIHRVGHORVFRQFXUVRVGHGHOHWUHRHO FOXEGHGUDPD\ORV093VGHKRFNH\VyORSDUDKDFHUDOJR7DOYH]HOEHVRGHOViEDGR KDEtDVLGRVLPSOHPHQWHXQEHVRQDGDPiV<GHFXDOTXLHUPDQHUD$QGUHZKDEtDVLGR VXQpPHVLVSRUDxRVKDEtDQHVWDGRFRPSLWLHQGRSRUHOSULPHUOXJDUHQODFODVHGHVGH TXH VX PDHVWUR GHO MDUGtQ GH QLxRV VRVWXYR XQD FRPSHWHQFLD SDUD YHU TXLpQ SRGtD KDFHUHOPHMRUWUDEDMRGHWtWHUHVGHEROVD$HOODQROHSRGtDJXVWDUHQUHDOLGDG 3HURQRHVWDEDHQJDxDQGRDQDGLH 8QDGHVOXPEUDGRUDOX]EULOOyDWUDYpVGHORVYHQWDQDOHVGHODVRODQD\6SHQFHUVDOWy &XDQGR 6SHQFHU UHJUHVy GHVGH )ORULGD OD QRFKH DQWHULRU KDEtD FXDWUR IXUJRQHWDV GH PHGLRV GH FRPXQLFDFLyQ HQ VX FpVSHG GHODQWHUR \ XQ HTXLSR GH FiPDUDV FHUFD GHO JUDQHURFRQYHUWLGRHQGHSDUWDPHQWRGHODIDPLOLDHQODSDUWHWUDVHUDGHODSURSLHGDG $KRUD XQ RILFLDO GH SROLFtD \ XQ SDVWRU DOHPiQ GH OD XQLGDG . HVWDEDQ URQGDQGR DOUHGHGRU GH ORV SLQRV HQ OD HVTXLQD GHO WHUUHQR FRQ XQD OLQWHUQD HQRUPH GiQGROH YXHOWDV D DOJR 6SHQFHU WHQtD OD VHQVDFLyQ GH TXH KDEtDQ HQFRQWUDGR OD EROVD FRQ ORV UHFXHUGRV GH $OL TXH OD WHUDSHXWD GH ODV FKLFDV 0DULRQ OHV KDEtD H[LJLGR HQWHUUDU OD VHPDQDSDVDGD8QUHSRUWHURSUREDEOHPHQWHWRFDUtDVXWLPEUHGHXQPRPHQWRDRWUR SUHJXQWiQGROHORTXHVLJQLILFDEDQORVREMHWRV 8Q HVSDQWRVR VHQWLPLHQWR QHUYLRVR ODWLy SURIXQGDPHQWH HQ VXV KXHVRV $QRFKH QR KDEtD SRGLGR SHJDU RMR DWHUURUL]DGD GH TXH QR XQD VLQR TXH DKRUD GRV SHUVRQDV KDEtDQPXHUWRHQHOERVTXHGHWUiVGHVXFDVDDVyORSDVRVGHVXGRUPLWRULR

$QGUHZDFODUyVXJDUJDQWDVHxDODQGRODVXxDVGH6SHQFHUTXHVHHVWDEDQFODYDQGRHQ ODVXSHUILFLHGHOHVFULWRULR

ž‰‹ƒ

¢(VWiVELHQ"  

093V-XJDGRUPiVYDOLRVR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

Ͷ͸

&DGD YH] TXH HVFXFKDED HO FKDVTXLGR GH XQD UDPLWD R HO VLOELGR GHO YLHQWR VH LQFRUSRUDEDKRUURUL]DGDFLHUWDPHQWHHODVHVLQRGH,DQWRGDYtDHVWDEDYDJDQGRSRUHO ERVTXH 1R SRGtD HYLWDU SHQVDU TXH HO DVHVLQR OR KDEtD PDWDGR SRUTXH pO VH KDEtD DFHUFDGRGHPDVLDGRDODYHUGDG¢4XpVL6SHQFHUHVWDEDGHPDVLDGRFHUFDGHODYHUGDG WDPELpQ VRODPHQWH FRQ ODV YDJDV LQGLUHFWDV TXH ,DQ OH KDEtD GDGR FXDQGR KDEODURQ VREUHHOSRUFKHTXHORVSROLFtDVHVWDEDQFXEULHQGRDOJR\TXHLQFOXVRKDEtDXQVHFUHWR PiVJUDQGHVREUHHODVHVLQDWRGH$OLTXHDWRGR5RVHZRRGOHIDOWDEDGHVFXEULU"



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

8KKXKFKDVTXHy6SHQFHU(VWR\ELHQ $QGUHZDSXQWyKDFLDORVSROLFtDVDIXHUDGHODYHQWDQD 3LHQVD HQ HOOR GH HVWD PDQHUD 3RU OR PHQRV WLHQHV SURWHFFLyQ SROLFLDO ODV YHLQWLFXDWURKRUDV 6SHQFHU WUDJy FRQ IXHU]D (VR GHEtD VHU DOJR EXHQR 6SHQFHU QHFHVLWDED GH WRGD OD SURWHFFLyQTXHSXGLHUDFRQVHJXLU2MHyVXVQRWDVGHHFRQRPtDHPSXMDQGRVXVPLHGRV SURIXQGDPHQWH ¢9ROYHPRVDHVWXGLDU" 3RUVXSXHVWRGLMR$QGUHZUHSHQWLQDPHQWHVHULR6HYROYLyKDFLDVXVQRWDV 6SHQFHUVLQWLyXQDPH]FODGHDSUHQVLyQ\GHFHSFLyQ 2 QR WHQHPRV TXH HVWXGLDU EDUEXOOy HOOD HVSHUDQGR TXH $QGUHZ FDSWDUD VX LQGLUHFWD $QGUHZKL]RXQDSDXVD 1RTXLHURHVWXGLDU6XYR]HUDURQFD 6SHQFHU WRFy VX PDQR /HQWDPHQWH pO DYDQ]y KDFLD HOOD (OOD VH PRYLy PiV FHUFD WDPELpQ /XHJR GH XQ SDU GH ODUJRV PRPHQWRV VXV ODELRV VH WRFDURQ (UD XQ DOLYLR HPRFLRQDQWH(QYROYLyVXVEUD]RVDOUHGHGRUGH$QGUHZ2OtDFRPRDODPH]FODGHXQD HVWXID GH OHxD \ DO DURPDWL]DGRU FtWULFR HQ IRUPD GH SLxD TXH FROJDED GHO HVSHMR UHWURYLVRU GH VX 0LQL &RRSHU 6H DOHMDURQ OXHJR VH EHVDURQ RWUD YH] HVWD YH] PiV ODUJR(OFRUD]yQGH6SHQFHUGLRXQUiSLGRYXHOFR (QWRQFHV HO WHOpIRQR GH 6SHQFHU GHMy HVFDSDU XQ IXHUWH SLWLGR 0LHQWUDV WUDWDED GH DOFDQ]DUORHOODWLGRGHVXFRUD]yQVHDFHOHUyFRQODSUHRFXSDFLyQGHTXHIXHUDDOJRGH ´$µ3HURHOHPDLOHVWDEDWLWXODGR´£1RWLFLDV6REUH(O(PSDUHMDPLHQWR&RQ7X0DPiµ 2K'LRVPtRVXVXUUy6SHQFHU $QGUHZVHLQFOLQySDUDPLUDU



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

/DVHPDQDSDVDGD1DQD+DVWLQJVKDEtDKHUHGDGRDVXV´QLHWRVQDFLGRVGHIRUPDQDWXUDOµ 0HOLVVD\ORVSULPRVGH6SHQFHUGRVPLOORQHVGHGyODUHVDFDGDXQR6SHQFHUSRURWUD SDUWHQRREWXYRQDGD0HOLVVDKDEtDSODQWHDGRXQDWHRUtDDFHUFDGHOSRUTXpWDOYH] 6SHQFHUKDEtDVLGRDGRSWDGD

Ͷ͹

(VWDEDDSXQWRGHSUHJXQWDUWHVLKDEtDSDVDGRDOJRFRQHVR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

3RUPXFKRTXH6SHQFHUTXHUtDFUHHUTXHHUDVyORRWUDGHODVWiFWLFDVGH0HOLVVDSDUD KXPLOODUODFRQVWDQWHPHQWH WUDWDEDQ GH VXSHUDVH OD XQD D OD RWUD FRQ 0HOLVVD XVXDOPHQWH JDQDQGROD LGHD OD DFRVDED ¢(UD pVH HO SRU TXp VXV SDGUHV WUDWDEDQ D 6SHQFHU FRPR OD PLHUGD \ D 0HOLVVD FRPR RUR DSHQDV UHFRQRFLHQGR ORV WDOHQWRV GH 6SHQFHULQFXPSOLHQGRVXSURPHVDGHSHUPLWLUD6SHQFHUYLYLUHQHOJUDQHURGHOMDUGtQ WUDVHURVXVDxRVMXQLRU\VpQLRUHLQFOXVRFDQFHODQGRVXVWDUMHWDVGHFUpGLWR"¢(UDpVHHO SRUTXp0HOLVVDVHYHtDFRPRXQFORQGHVXPDGUH\6SHQFHUQR" (OOD OH KDEtD FRQIHVDGR OD WHRUtD D $QGUHZ \ $QGUHZ OH FRQWy D 6SHQFHU VREUH XQ VHUYLFLR TXH HPSDUHMDED PDGUHV ELROyJLFDV TXH XQD DPLJD KDEtD XVDGR &XULRVD 6SHQFHU UHJLVWUy VX LQIRUPDFLyQ SHUVRQDO FRVDV FRPR VX IHFKD GH QDFLPLHQWR HO KRVSLWDOGRQGHQDFLy\HOFRORUGHVXVRMRV\RWURVUDVJRVJHQpWLFRV&XDQGRUHFLELyXQ HPDLO HQ OD EHQHILFHQFLD GH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ HO ViEDGR TXH GHFtD TXH HO VLWLR KDEtD HPSDUHMDGR VXV GDWRV FRQ HO GH XQD PDGUH SRWHQFLDO QR KDEtD VDELGR TXp SHQVDU 7HQtD TXH VHU XQ HUURU &LHUWDPHQWH FRQWDFWDUtDQ D OD PXMHU \ OHV GLUtD TXH QR KDEtD SRVLELOLGDGGHTXH6SHQFHUSXGLHUDVHUVXKLMD &RQPDQRVWHPEORURVDV6SHQFHUDEULyHOHPDLO ´+ROD6SHQFHU0LQRPEUHHV2OLYLD&DOGZHOO(VWR\WDQHPRFLRQDGDSRUTXHFUHRTXHVRPRVXQ HPSDUHMDPLHQWRFRUUHFWR6LHVWiVGHDFXHUGRPHHQFDQWDUtDFRQRFHUWH&RQFDULxRVLQFHUR2µ 6SHQFHUORTXHGyPLUDQGRSRUPXFKRWLHPSRVXPDQRJROSHyVXERFD2OLYLD&DOGZHOO ¢3RGtDVHUHVHHOQRPEUHGHVXYHUGDGHUDPDGUH"$QGUHZODSLQFKyHQVXFRVWDGR ¢9DVDUHVSRQGHU" 1R OR Vp GLMR 6SHQFHU DQVLRVDPHQWH UHVSLQJDQGR FXDQGR XQ FDUUR GH SROLFtD GH DIXHUD HQFHQGLy VX SHQHWUDQWH VLUHQD FKLOORQD &RQWHPSOy OD SDQWDOOD GH VX 6LGHNLFN WDQ IXHUWH TXH ODV OHWUDV FRPHQ]DURQ D GHVHQIRFDUVH 4XLHUR GHFLU«  LQFOXVR HV GLItFLOFUHHUTXHHVWRHVUHDO¢&yPRSXGLHURQPLVSDGUHVRFXOWDUPHHVWR"6LJQLILFDTXH WRGDPLYLGDKDVLGR«XQDPHQWLUDÓOWLPDPHQWHKDEtDGHVFXELHUWRTXHJUDQSDUWH GHVXYLGDHVSHFLDOPHQWHODVFRVDVFRQ$OLHVWDEDQFRQVWUXLGDVVREUHPHQWLUDV1R HVWDEDVHJXUDVLSRGUtDVRSRUWDUDOJRPiV

Ͷͺ

¢3RU TXp QR YHPRV VL OR SRGHPRV SUREDU" $QGUHZ VH SXVR GH SLH \ RIUHFLy VX PDQR7DOYH]VLKD\DDOJRHQHVWDFDVDTXHORH[SOLTXHPiVDOOiGHXQDVRPEUDGH GXGD

ž‰‹ƒ

6SHQFHUORFRQVLGHUySRUXQPRPHQWR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(VWi ELHQ DFFHGLy OHQWDPHQWH 3UREDEOHPHQWH HUD XQ EXHQ PRPHQWR SDUD ILVJRQHDUSRUORVDOUHGHGRUHVVXVSDGUHV\VXKHUPDQDQRHVWDUtDQHQFDVDSRUKRUDV $JDUUyODPDQRGH$QGUHZ\ORGLULJLyDODRILFLQDGHVXSDGUH(OFXDUWRROtDDFRxDF \DFLJDUURVVXSDSiDYHFHVHQWUHWHQtDDVXVFOLHQWHVGHODOH\HQODFDVD\FXDQGR DFFLRQyHOLQWHUUXSWRUHQODSDUHGXQPRQWyQGHVXDYHVOXFHVSDUSDGHDURQSRUHQFLPD GHOSRGHURVRHVWDPSDGRGHXQDEDQDQD:DUKROGHVXSDGUH (OODVHKXQGLyHQODVLOOD$HURQGHOHVFULWRULRGHDUFHGHWLJUHGHVXSDSi\FRQWHPSOy OD SDQWDOOD GH OD FRPSXWDGRUD +DEtD XQD SUHVHQWDFLyQ GH GLDSRVLWLYDV GH IRWRV IDPLOLDUHVFRPRSURWHFFLyQGHSDQWDOOD/DSULPHUDHUDXQDIRWRGH0HOLVVDHJUHVDQGR GHOD8QLYHUVLGDGGH3HQVLOYDQLDFRQODERUODGHOERQHWHHQVXVRMRV/XHJRKDEtDXQD IRWR GH 0HOLVVD GH SLH HQ HO SyUWLFR FRPSOHWDPHQWH QXHYR GH SLHGUD DUHQLVFD GH )LODGHOILD TXH VXV SDGUHV KDEtDQ FRPSUDGR SDUD HOOD FXDQGR FRQVLJXLy HQWUDU HQ :KDUWRQ 6FKRRO (QWRQFHV XQD IRWR GH 6SHQFHU DSDUHFLy HQ OD SDQWDOOD (UD XQD LQVWDQWiQHDGH$OL6SHQFHU\ODVGHPiVDSLxDGDVHQXQDJLJDQWHFiPDUDHQPLWDGGH XQODJR(OKHUPDQRGH$OL-DVRQHVWDEDQDGDQGRMXQWRDHOORVFRQVXSHORDOJRODUJR HPSDSDGR eVWD KDEtD VLGR WRPDGD HQ OD FDVD GHO ODJR GH OD IDPLOLD GH $OL HQ ORV 3RFRQRV 3RU HO DVSHFWR GH FXiQ MyYHQHV HVWDEDQ WRGRV GHELy KDEHU VLGR XQD GH ODV SULPHUDVYHFHVTXH$OLODVKDEtDLQYLWDGRDOOtXQDVSRFDVVHPDQDVGHVSXpVGHTXHVH KXELHUDQKHFKRDPLJDV 6SHQFHU VH UHFRVWy VREUHVDOWDGD DO YHUVH HQ HO PRQWDMH IDPLOLDU 'HVSXpV GH TXH 6SHQFHUDGPLWLyTXHKDEtDKHFKRWUDPSDSDUDJDQDU/D2UTXtGHD'RUDGDVXVSDGUHVOD KDEtDQUHSXGLDGREDVWDQWH<HUDH[WUDxRYHUXQDIRWRWDQDQWLJXDGH$OL1DGDPDOR KDEtDRFXUULGRHQWUH$OL6SHQFHU\ODVGHPiVD~QQLVLTXLHUD´/D&RVDGH-HQQDµQLOD UHODFLyQFODQGHVWLQDGH$OLFRQ,DQQLORVHFUHWRVTXH6SHQFHU\ODVGHPiVLQWHQWDEDQ RFXOWDU GH $OL QL ORV VHFUHWRV TXH $OL RFXOWDED GH HOODV 6L VyOR KXELHVH VLGR GH HVD PDQHUDSDUDVLHPSUH 6SHQFHUVHHVWUHPHFLyWUDWDQGRGHVDFXGLUVXFRQIXVLyQGHVHQWLPLHQWRVFRQIXVRV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6XSDSiWHQtDDELHUWDVDOJXQDVYHQWDQDVGHO,QWHUQHW([SORUHUGHVGHOD~OWLPDYH]TXH KDEtD HVWDGR HQ OD FRPSXWDGRUD 8QD HUD OD SRUWDGD GH OD SiJLQD GHO 3KLODGHOSKLD 6HQWLQHO (O WtWXOR VXSHULRU HUD %~VTXHGD GHO &XHUSR GH 7KRPDV &RQWLQ~D -XVWR GHEDMR HVWDEDXQDPXHVWUDGHRSLQLyQTXHGHFtD´(O'HSDUWDPHQWRGH3ROLFtDGH5RVHZRRG'HEHUtD

Ͷͻ

0L SDSi VROtD JXDUGDU WRGR HQ ILFKHURV H[SOLFy PRYLHQGR HO PRXVH SDUD KDFHU TXH HO SURWHFWRU GH SDQWDOOD GHVDSDUHFLHUD 3HUR PL PDPi HV FRPR XQD PDQLiWLFD GHORUGHQ\RGLDODVSLODVGHSDSHODVtTXHOHKL]RHVFDQHDUWRGR6LKD\DOJRVREUHPt VLHQGRDGRSWDGDVHHQFXHQWUDHQHVWDFRPSXWDGRUD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

6HU&ROJDGR3RU1HJOLJHQFLDµ'HEDMRGHpVDLQFOXVRHVWDEDRWUDKLVWRULDPX\OHtGD/RV $GROHVFHQWHVGH.DQVDV5HFLEHQ0HQVDMHVGH7H[WRGH$ 6SHQFHUPLUyFRQFHxR\PLQLPL]yODSDQWDOOD &RQWHPSOyORVLFRQRVGHODFDUSHWDGHOODGRFRUUHFWRGHOHVFULWRULR ,PSXHVWRV OH\y HOOD HQ YR] DOWD 9LHMR 7UDEDMR &RVDV (OOD JLPLy 0L PDPiORPDWDUtDVLVXSLHUDTXHpORUJDQL]yORVDUFKLYRVGHpVWDIRUPD ¢4XpKD\GHDTXpO"$QGUHZVHxDOyODSDQWDOOD6SHQFHU8QLYHUVLGDG 6SHQFHUIUXQFLyHOFHxR\GLRXQFOLFVREUHHVR+DEtDVyORXQDUFKLYR3')GHQWURGH ODFDUSHWD(OSHTXHxRLFRQRGHOUHORMGHDUHQDJLUDEDPLHQWUDVHO3')OHQWDPHQWHVH FDUJDED HQ OD SDQWDOOD (OOD \ $QGUHZ VH LQFOLQDURQ KDFLD DGHODQWH (UD XQD GHFODUDFLyQUHFLHQWHGHXQDFXHQWDGHDKRUURV :KRD $QGUHZ DSXQWy KDFLD HO WRWDO +DEtD XQ GRV \ PiV TXH XQRV FXDQWRV FHURV6SHQFHUQRWyHOQRPEUHHQODFXHQWD6SHQFHU+DVWLQJV6XVRMRVVHDPSOLDURQ 7DOYH]VXVSDGUHVQRODKDEtDQDEDQGRQDGRFRPSOHWDPHQWH (OOD FHUUy HO 3') \ VLJXLy PLUDQGR $EULHURQ XQRV SRFRV GRFXPHQWRV PiV SHUR OD PD\RUtD GH ORV DUFKLYRV HUDQ KRMDV GH FiOFXOR TXH 6SHQFHU QR HQWHQGtD +DEtD WRQHODGDV GH FDUSHWDV TXH QR WHQtDQ FODVLILFDFLRQHV HQ DEVROXWR 6SHQFHU PXOOy HO SOXPRVR ILQDO GH OD SXQWD GH OD SOXPD TXH VX SDGUH KDEtD FRPSUDGR HQ XQD VXEDVWD FRQWHPDVGHHQ&KULVWLH·V ([DPLQDUHVWRWRPDUiXQDHWHUQLGDG 6LPSOHPHQWHFRSLDHOGLVFRGXURHQXQGLVFR\H[DPtQDORWRGRPiVWDUGHSURSXVR $QGUHZ$EULyXQDJUDQFDMDGH&'·VHQEODQFRTXHVHHQFRQWUDEDVREUHODOLEUHUtDGH VXSDSiHLQWURGXMRXQRHQODXQLGDGGHGLVFR6SHQFHUORPLUyQHUYLRVDPHQWH(OODQR TXHUtDDxDGLUHOLUUXPSLUHQODFRPSXWDGRUDGHVXSDSiDODODUJDOLVWDGHTXHMDVTXH VXVSDGUHVWHQtDQHQVXFRQWUD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6SHQFHU FRQWHPSOy HO URWDWLYR UHORM GH DUHQD HQ HO PRQLWRU XQ HVFDORIUtR QHUYLRVR FRUULyDWUDYpVGHHOOD(UDPX\SRVLEOHTXHODYHUGDGVREUHVXSDVDGRHVWXYLHVHHQHVWD FRPSXWDGRUD 3UREDEOHPHQWH KDEtD HVWDGR MXVWR EDMR VX QDUL] SRU DxRV \ QR KDEtD WHQLGRQLODPiVOHYHLGHD

ͷͲ

7X SDSi QXQFD OR VDEUi GLMR $QGUHZ QRWDQGR VX PLUDGD /R SURPHWR eO KL]RFOLFVREUHDOJXQDVGLUHFWLYDVHQODSDQWDOOD(VWRWRPDUiDOJXQRVPLQXWRVSDUD FRUUHUGLMRpO

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

6DFyVXWHOpIRQR\DEULyHOHPDLOGH2OLYLD&DOGZHOOGHQXHYR´0HHQFDQWDUtDFRQRFHUWH &RQ FDULxR VLQFHURµ 5HSHQWLQDPHQWH HO FHUHEUR GH 6SHQFHU GLR XQ YXHOFR \ VH VLQWLy OXFLGD\VHJXUD¢&XiOHVHUDQODVSUREDELOLGDGHVTXHXQDPXMHUKXELHUDUHJDODGRDXQ EHEpH[DFWDPHQWHHOPLVPRGtDHQTXH6SHQFHUKDEtDQDFLGR\HQHOPLVPRKRVSLWDO" ¢8QD PXMHU FRQ RMRV YHUGH HVPHUDOGD \ VXFLR FDEHOOR UXELR" ¢4Xp VL pVWD QR HUD XQD WHRUtD«VLQRODYHUGDG" 6SHQFHUPLUyD$QGUHZ 1RPHPDWDUtDHQFRQWUDUPHFRQHOODVXSRQJR



ž‰‹ƒ

ͷͳ

8QDVRQULVDVRUSUHQGLGD\H[FLWDGDDSDUHFLyHQODFDUDGH$QGUHZ6SHQFHUVHYROYLy GHUHJUHVRDVX6LGHNLFN\WHFOHyVXUHVSXHVWDXQVHQWLPLHQWRGHPDUHRVHSURSDJyHQ VXHVWyPDJR$SUHWDQGRODPDQRGH$QGUHZWRPyXQDSURIXQGDUHVSLUDFLyQUHGDFWy VXPHQVDMH\SUHVLRQyHQYLDU<DVtFRPRDVtHOHPDLOVHKDEtDLGR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR ([WUDxRVTXHQRHVWiQVREUHXQ7UHQ ([WUDxRVTXHQRHVWiQVREUHXQ7UHQ 7UDGXFLGRSRU'\DQQD &RUUHJLGRSRUʾ 

$

OD PDxDQD VLJXLHQWH HO KHUPDQR GH $ULD 0LNH HQFHQGLy HO HVWpUHR GH P~VLFDGHO6XEDUX2XWEDFNGHODIDPLOLD$ULDKL]RXQDPXHFDPLHQWUDV3HUUR 1HJURGH/HG=HSSHOLQVRQDEDHQORVDOWDYRFHV

³¢3XHGHVEDMDUOHHOYROXPHQ"³VHTXHMyHOOD 0LNHQHJyFRQODFDEH]D ³(V PHMRU HVFXFKDU D =HSSHOLQ DO Pi[LPR YROXPHQ (VR HV OR TXH 1RHO \ \R KDFHPRV ¢6DEtDVTXHORVFKLFRVHQODEDQGDHUDQYHUGDGHURVEDGDVVHV"-LPP\3DJH PRQWyVXPRWRFLFOHWDSRUORVSDVLOORVGHOKRWHO5REHUW3ODQWODQ]yWHOHYLVRUHVSRUODV YHQWDQDVHQHO6XQVHW6WULS ³1RS QR SXHGR GHFLU TXH OR VXSLHUD ³GLMR $ULD VHFDPHQWH +R\ $ULD WHQtD OD GHVDIRUWXQDGDWDUHDGHOOHYDUD0LNHDODHVFXHOD0LNHJHQHUDOPHQWHLEDFRQVXWtSLFR PHQWRU HQ 5RVHZRRG 1RHO .DKQ SHUR HO 5DQJH 5RYHU GH 1RHO VHHQFRQWUDED HQ OD WLHQGD SDUD FRQVHJXLU XQ HTXLSR GH P~VLFD D~Q PiV JUDQGH H LQVWDODUOR < 'LRV SURKtEHD0LNHWRPDUHODXWRE~V 0LNHMXJXHWHDEDGLVWUDtGDPHQWHFRQODSXOVHUDGHJRPDDPDULOODGHODFURVVHGHOGtDGH 5RVHZRRGTXHMDPiVVHVDFDEDGHODPXxHFDGHUHFKD

 

%DGDVVHV1RPEUHFRPHUFLDOGH/HR4XDQXQIDEULFDQWHGHSXHQWHVSDUDJXLWDUUDV\EDMRV 6XQVHW6WULSRODIUDQMD6XQVHWHVHOQRPEUHGDGRDOHVWUHFKRGH6XQVHW%RXOHYDUGTXHSDVDSRU:HVW +ROO\ZRRG&DOLIRUQLD 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³3HQVpTXHGHEHUtDSDVDUHOPLVPRWLHPSRFRQ(OOD\%\URQ³PXUPXUy$ULD+L]R XQ JLUR KDFLD OD L]TXLHUGD VREUH HO FDPLQR ODUJR TXH OD OOHYDED D OD HVFXHOD SDVDQGR PX\ GH FHUFD GH XQD DUGLOOD JUDQGH TXH VH ODQ]y KDFLD HO FDPLQR³ < GHEHPRV FRQRFHUPHMRUD0HUHGLWK¢QRWHSDUHFH"

ͷʹ

³¢(QWRQFHVSRUTXpHVWiVYLYLHQGRFRQSDSiGHQXHYR"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³3HURHVXQDPiTXLQDGHYRPLWDU³0LNHKL]RXQDPXHFD ³1RHVWDQPDOD<VHHVWiQPXGDQGRDHVDFDVDPiVJUDQGHKR\³$ULDKDEtDRtGR D %\URQ GDUOH OD QRWLFLD D (OOD SRU WHOpIRQR OD QRFKH DQWHULRU \ DVXPLy TXH (OOD OH KDEtDGLFKRD0LNH\;DYLHU³9R\DWHQHUXQSLVRHQWHURSDUDPt 0LNHOHGLULJLyXQDPLUDGDVRVSHFKRVDSHUR$ULDVHSHJyDVXKLVWRULD (O WHOpIRQR FHOXODU GH $ULD TXH VH HQFRQWUDED HQ VX EROVR GH SLHO GH \DN VRQy /R PLUyQHUYLRVDPHQWH1RKDEtDUHFLELGRXQPHQVDMHGHWH[WRGHTXLHQTXLHUDTXHIXHUD HVWD1XHYD´$µSXHVWRTXH\DKDEtDGHVFXELHUWRHOFXHUSRGH,DQODQRFKHGHO6iEDGR SHUR FRPR (PLO\ KDEtD GLFKR HO RWUR GtD $ULD WHQtD OD FODUD VHQVDFLyQ GH TXH LED D UHFLELUXQQXHYRWH[WRGH´$µHQFXDOTXLHUVHJXQGR 7RPDQGR XQD UHVSLUDFLyQ SURIXQGD PHWLy OD PDQR HQ VX EROVR (O PHQVDMH GH WH[WR HUDGH(PLO\´(QWUDSRUODSDUWHWUDVHUD/DHVFXHODHVWiDWDVFDGDFRQIXUJRQHWDVGHUHSRUWHURV RWUDYH]µ $ULDJLPLy/DVFDPLRQHWDVGHORVQRWLFLDULRVKDEtDQREVWUXLGRODHQWUDGDGHODHVFXHOD HOGtDDQWHULRUWDPELpQ7RGRVORVPHGLRVGHFRPXQLFDFLyQHQHOiUHDGHOWULSOHHVWDGR KDEtDQKXQGLGRVXVGLHQWHVHQODKLVWRULDGHOFDGiYHUGH,DQ(QODVQRWLFLDVGHODVGH OD PDxDQD ORV UHSRUWHURV KDEtDQ HVWDGR HQ 5RVHZRRG 6WDUEXFNV SUHJXQWiQGROHV HQ IRUPD DOHDWRULD D ODV PDGUHV TXH HVSHUDEDQ FRQ VXV KLMRV HQ SDUDGDV GH DXWREXVHV HVFRODUHV \ DOJXQDV SHUVRQDV HQ OD ORFDOLGDG GH OD OtQHD GHO '09 SUHJXQWDQGR VL SHQVDEDQTXHODSROLFtDKDEtDHVWURSHDGRHOFDVR/DPD\RUtDGHODJHQWHGLMRTXHVt 0XFKRVVHHVFDQGDOL]DURQGHTXHODSROLFtDSXGLHUDHVWDUHVFRQGLHQGRDOJRPiVVREUH HO DVHVLQDWR GH $OL $OJXQRV GH ORV SHULRGLVWDV GH ORV WDEORLGHV KDEtDQ LQYHQWDGR HODERUDGDV WHRUtDV GH FRQVSLUDFLyQ GHVGH TXH ,DQ KDEtD XWLOL]DGR XQ GREOH GH VX FXHUSRHQHOERVTXHRTXH$OLWHQtDXQSULPRSHUGLGRTXHHUDUHVSRQVDEOHQRVyORGH VXDVHVLQDWRVLQRWDPELpQXQDVHULHGHDVHVLQDWRVHQ&RQQHFWLFXW $ULD HVWLUy HO FXHOOR HQ OD OtQHD GH $XGL \ %0: TXH VH KD DWDVFDGR HO FDPLQR GH HQWUDGDDODHVFXHOD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³£&DUDPED ³H[FODPy 0LNH FRQ ORV RMRV VREUH ODV FDPLRQHWDV WDPELpQ³ 'pMDPH DTXt(VD&\QWKLD+HZOH\HVFDOLHQWH¢3LHQVDVTXHPHORKDUtD"³&\QWKLD+HZOH\HUD ODSHULRGLVWDUXELDFXUYLOtQHDGHVSDPSDQDQWHTXHFXEULyHOMXLFLRGH,DQ&DGDWLSRGH 5RVHZRRG'D\HVSHUDEDTXHHOODVHORKLFLHUD

ͷ͵

(IHFWLYDPHQWH KDEtD FLQFR IXUJRQHWDV GH QRWLFLDV HVWDFLRQDGR HQ HO FDUULO EXV EORTXHDQGRHOWUiILFR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

$ULDQRGHWXYRHOFRFKH ³¢4XpSLHQVDVTXHGLUtD6DYDQQDKDOUHVSHFWR"³(PSXMyHOEUD]RGH0LNH³¢2HV TXHKDVROYLGDGRTXHWLHQHVXQDQRYLD" 0LNHPRYLyXQKLORHQVXVXpWHUD]XOPDULQR ³%XHQRFUHRTXH\DQRHVDVt ³¢4Xp"³$ULDKDEtDFRQRFLGRD6DYDQQDKHOGtDGHEHQHILFHQFLDGH5RVHZRRG'D\ KDEtDVLGRXQDFKLFDQRUPDO\DJUDGDEOH$ULDVLHPSUHVHKDEtDSUHRFXSDGRGHTXHOD SULPHUD \ YHUGDGHUD QRYLD GH 0LNH IXHUD XQD %DUELH WRQWD VLQ FHUHEUR SURYHQLHQWH GHVGH7XUEXOHQFLDHOFOXEGHVWULSWHDVH 0LNHVHHQFRJLyGHKRPEURV ³6LTXLHUHVVDEHUORHOODURPSLyFRQPLJR ³¢4Xp KLFLVWH" ³H[LJLy $ULD /XHJR OHYDQWy OD PDQR SDUD KDFHUOR FDOODU³ (Q UHDOLGDG QR PH OR GLJDV ³0LNH SUREDEOHPHQWH KDEtD VXJHULGR TXH 6DYDQQDK FRPHQ]DUDDQRXVDUEUDJDVROHKDEtD URJDGRTXHVHLQYROXFUDUDFRQRWUDFKLFD\OH GHMDUDYHU $ULDFRQGXMRSRUODSDUWHSRVWHULRUGHODHVFXHODPiVDOOiGHORVFDPSRVGHI~WERO\GH OD VDOD GH DUWH 0LHQWUDV VH HVWDFLRQDED HQ XQR GH ORV ~OWLPRV HVSDFLRV HQ HO ORWH GH DWUiV VH GLR FXHQWD GH XQD VHxDO TXH VH DJLWDED VREUH OD SDUWH DOWD PHWiOLFD GH ORV SUR\HFWRUHV/D&iSVXOD'HO7LHPSR£/$(',&,Ð1'(,19,(512&20,(1=$+2< £e67$ (6 78 2325781,'$' '( 6(5 ,10257$/,=$'2 &RQ ODV SDODEUDV HQ PD\~VFXODV

³(VWXSHQGR7HQJRODLGHDSHUIHFWDGHFyPRGHFRUDUOR³6HIURWyODVSDOPDVGHODV PDQRVFRQLPSDFLHQFLD$ULDURGRVXVRMRV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

0LNHVHVHQWyPiVGHUHFKRpOLQVSHFFLRQyHOFDUWHO

ͷͶ

³¢0H HVWiQ WRPDQGR HO SHOR" ³VXVXUUy $ULD /D HVFXHOD RUJDQL]DED HO FRQFXUVR GH /D &iSVXOD 'HO 7LHPSR FDGD DxR DXQTXH $ULD VH OD KDEtD SHUGLGR ORV ~OWLPRV WUHV DxRV SRUTXH VX IDPLOLD KDEtD HVWDGR YLYLHQGR HQ 5H\NMDYtN ,VODQGLD (O MXHJR SRU OR JHQHUDOVHOOHYDEDDFDERHQRWRxRSHUR5RVHZRRG'D\KDEtDVLGREDVWDQWH GLVFUHWR SDUDVXVSHQGHUORHODxRGHVSXpVGHTXHORVWUDEDMDGRUHVGHODFRQVWUXFFLyQHQFRQWUDUDQ HOFDGiYHUGH$OLVRQ'L/DXUHQWLVDOFDYDUXQDJXMHURHQVXSDWLRWUDVHUR6LQHPEDUJR 5RVHZRRG'D\QRVHDWUHYtDDIDOWDUDWUDGLFLyQPiVLPSRUWDQWHSRUFRPSOHWR¢4Xp GHPRQLRVHVWDEDQSHQVDQGR"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢9DVDGLEXMDUXQLFRUQLRVHQpO"¢2HVFULELUXQSRHPDVREUHW~URPDQFHFRQ1RHO" 0LNHOHYDQWyODQDUL]HQHODLUH ³(VPXFKR PHMRUTXHHVR3HUR VLWHORGLJRWHQGUtDTXHPDWDUWH ³6DOXGyD 1RHO .DKQTXHIXHVDOLyGHO+XPPHUGH-DPHV)UHHG\VDOLyFRUULHQGRGHOFRFKHVLQGHFLU DGLyV $ULDVXVSLUyPLUDQGRGHQXHYRODVHxDOGH/D&iSVXOD'HO7LHPSR(QVH[WRJUDGRHO SULPHUDxRTXH$ULDKDEtDSRGLGRMXJDU/D&iSVXOD'HO7LHPSRKDEtDVLGRXQUHSDUWR HQRUPH3HURFXDQGR$ULD6SHQFHU\ODVGHPiVVHKDEtDQHVFRQGLGRHQHOSDWLRGH$OL FRQODHVSHUDQ]DGHUREDUVXSLH]DWRGRKDEtDVDOLGRWDQPDO$ULDKDEtDJXDUGDGROD SLH]D HQ OD FDMD GH ]DSDWRV HQ OD SDUWH SRVWHULRU GH VX DUPDULR 1R KDEtD VLGR OR VXILFLHQWHPHQWHYDOLHQWHFRPRSDUDPLUDUGHQWURGHpOGXUDQWHDxRV7DOYH]ODSLH]D GH$OLODEDQGHUDVHKDEtDGHVFRPSXHVWRDOLJXDOTXHVXFXHUSR ³¢6HxRULWD0RQWJRPHU\" $ULD VDOWy 8QD PXMHU GH FDEHOOR RVFXUR FRQ XQ PLFUyIRQR HVWDED GH SLH IXHUD GH VX FRFKH'HWUiVGHHOODKDEtDXQDWLSRFRQXQDFiPDUDGHWHOHYLVLyQ /RVRMRVGHODPXMHUVHLOXPLQDURQFXDQGRYLRODFDUDGH$ULD ³6HxRULWD 0RQWJRPHU\ ³JULWy HOOD JROSHDQGR YHQWDQD GH $ULD³ ¢3XHGR KDFHUOH XQDVSUHJXQWDV" $ULDDSUHWyORVGLHQWHVVLQWLpQGRVHFRPRXQ PRQRHQXQ]RROyJLFR$JLWyODFDEH]D KDFLD OD PXMHU HQFHQGLy HO FRFKH RWUD YH] \ VDOLy GHO HVWDFLRQDPLHQWR (O UHSRUWHUR FRUULy D VX ODGR /D FiPDUD PDQWXYR VX OHQWH HQ $ULD PLHQWUDV OD VHJXtD KDFLD OD FDUUHWHUDSULQFLSDO 7HQtDTXHVDOLUGHDTXt$KRUD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

1RKDEtDQLXQWUHQDODYLVWD3RURWUDSDUWH$ULDKDEtDHVWDGRWDQIUHQpWLFDSRUGHMDU 5RVHZRRGTXHQRVHOHKDEtDRFXUULGRFRPSUREDUHOKRUDULRGH6(37$6XVSLUDQGR LQJUHVy D OD SHTXHxD FDVHWD GH OD HVWDFLyQ TXH FRQVLVWtD HQ XQD FDMD GH EROHWRV XQ

ͷͷ

(Q HO PRPHQWR HQ TXH $ULD OOHJy D OD HVWDFLyQ 6(37$ GH 5RVHZRRG HO HVWDFLRQDPLHQWRHVWDEDFDVLOOHQRFRQ6DDEV9ROYR\%0:)LQDOPHQWHHQFRQWUyXQ HVSDFLR HPSXMy XQ PRQWR GH FDPELRV HQ HO PHGLGRU \ VH DSDUFy HQ HO ERUGH GH OD SODWDIRUPD /DV YtDV GHO WUHQ HVWDEDQ EDMR XQ SXHQWH GH FDEDOOHWHV R[LGDGRV $O RWUR ODGRGHOFDPLQRKDEtDXQDWLHQGDGHPDVFRWDVHQODTXHYHQGtDQFRPLGDFDVHUDSDUD SHUURV\URSDSDUDJDWRV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

FDMHUR DXWRPiWLFR \ XQ FDIp SHTXHxR HQ TXH WDPELpQ YHQGtDQ OLEURV VREUH YLDMHV HQ WUHQDORODUJRGHODKLVWyULFD/tQHD3ULQFLSDO8QDVSRFDVSHUVRQDVVHVHQWDURQHQORV EDQFRV GH PDGHUD TXH VH DOLQHDEDQ HQ OD KDELWDFLyQ PLUDQGR OiQJXLGDPHQWH OD WHOHYLVLyQGHSDQWDOODSODQDHQODHVTXLQDHQODTXHVLQWRQL]DURQ5HJLV .HOO\$ULDVH DFHUFy D ORV KRUDULRV GH WUHQHV SXEOLFDGRV HQ OD SDUHG GHO IRQGR \ GHVFXEULy TXH HO SUy[LPR WUHQ QR VDOGUtD GH DTXt KDVWD PHGLD KRUD 5HVLJQDGD VH GHMy FDHU HQ XQ EDQFR$OJXQDVSHUVRQDVODPLUDURQERTXLDELHUWRV6HSUHJXQWyVLODUHFRQRFtDQGHOD WHOHYLVLyQ 'HVSXpV GH WRGR ORV UHSRUWHURV KDEtDQ HVWDGR PHURGHiQGROD GHVGH HO GRPLQJR ³2\H³GLMRXQDYR]³
³7~ HUDV OD ~QLFD TXH WHQtD HVWLOR ³DJUHJy -DVRQ GiQGROH XQD HVSHFLH GH VRQULVD VHGXFWRUD(OLQWHULRUGH$ULDVHYROFy(VWLORHUDEXHQR¢QR"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³6t ³$ULD VH VHQWtD UXERUL]DU (OODV DFRVWXPEUDEDQ SUR\HFWDU SHOtFXODV SVHXGR DUWtVWLFDVGH$ULDHQODKDELWDFLyQGH$OL\DYHFHV-DVRQVHGHWHQtDHQODSXHUWDSDUD PLUDU $ULD VROtD VHQWLUVH PX\ FRQVFLHQWH GH VX SUHVHQFLD SHUR DO PLVPR WLHPSR DQKHODED KDEODU FRQ pO \ KDFHU FRPHQWDULRV VREUH VXV SHOtFXODV 3DUD GHFLU TXH HUDQ EULOODQWHVWDOYH]RHQHOSHQVDUHQODSURYRFDFLyQ

ͷ͸

³7~HUHVODTXHKL]RODVSHOtFXODV³/RVRMRVD]XOHVGH-DVRQVHPDQWXYLHURQILMRVHQ HOOD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢9DVD)LODGHOILD"³VROWy$ULDEXVFDQGRDWLHQWDVDOJRTXHGHFLU$OLQVWDQWHTXLVR JROSHDUVXIUHQWH'XK3RUVXSXHVWRTXHLEDD)LODGHOILD(VWDOtQHDGHOWUHQQRLEDD RWUROXJDU -DVRQDVLQWLyFRQODFDEH]D ³$3HQQ0HDFDEDQGHWUDQVIHULU6ROtDLUD
$IXHUDXQWUHQGH$PWUDNUXJLyHQODHVWDFLyQ/DVRWUDVSHUVRQDVTXHKDEtDQHVWDGR HVSHUDQGR VH SXVLHURQ GH SLH \ FDPLQDURQ D WUDYpV GH OD SXHUWD GH OD SODWDIRUPD &XDQGRHOWUHQUXJLyDODGLVWDQFLD-DVRQFDPLQyDWUDYpVGHORWURODGRGHOSDVLOOR\VH VHQWyDOODGRGH$ULD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ž‰‹ƒ

³$VtTXH¢QRWLHQHVHVFXHOD"³SUHJXQWy

ͷ͹

³3RU OR JHQHUDO VXHOR VXELU HQ


6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

$ULDDEULyODERFDEXVFDQGRDWLHQWDVXQDUHVSXHVWD-DVRQHVWDEDUHSHQWLQDPHQWHWDQ FHUFD GH HOOD TXH SRGtD IiFLOPHQWH VHQWLU VX MDEyQ SLFDQWH FRQ RORU D QXH] (UD HPEULDJDGRU ³8K£1R(VHOGtDGHFRQIHUHQFLDHQWUHSDGUHV\PDHVWURV ³¢6LHPSUHOOHYDVWXXQLIRUPHHQORVGtDVOLEUHV"³-DVRQVHxDOyHOERUGHLQIHULRUGHOD WHOD HVFRFHVD GH OD IDOGD GH $ULD GH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ 6H DVRPDED SRU GHEDMR GH VX DEULJRODUJRGHODQD $ULDVLQWLyTXHVXVPHMLOODVVHVRQURMDEDQ ³1RVXHORHVFDSDUPHORMXUR ³1R YR\ D GHFLUOR ³EURPHy -DVRQ 6H LQFOLQy KDFLD GHODQWH KDFLHQGR FUXMLU HO EDQFR³¢&RQRFHVHOJRNDUWHOOXJDUGH:HPEOH\SRUFDUUHWHUD"8QDYH]IXLDOOtWRGR HOGtD&RQGXMHHOSHTXHxRFRFKHGXUDQWHKRUDV $ULDVHULyHQWUHGLHQWHV ³¢(VWDEDHOWLSRODUJXLUXFKRDOOt"¢(OTXHOOHYDSUHQGDVGH1$6&$5GHVGHODFDEH]DD ORV SLHV" ³0LNH VROtD HVWDU REVHVLRQDGR FRQ ODV SLVWD GH JRNDUW DQWHV GH TXH VH REVHVLRQDUDFRQODVVWULSSHUV\ODFURVVH ³¢-LPP\"³/RVRMRVGH-DVRQEULOODEDQ³7RWDOPHQWH ³¢<QRWHSUHJXQWySRUTXpQRLEDVDODHVFXHOD"³SUHJXQWy$ULDSRQLHQGRVXPDQR VREUHHODSR\DEUD]RVGHOEDQFR³3RUORJHQHUDOHVPX\HQWURPHWLGR ³1R³-DVRQVHHQFRJLyGHKRPEURV³3HURWXYHHOVXILFLHQWHVHQWLGRFRP~QSDUD FDPELDUPHHOXQLIRUPHSRUORTXHQRIXHWDQHYLGHQWH3RURWUDSDUWHODVQLxDVVHYHQ PiVOLQGDVHQXQLIRUPHVTXHORVFKLFRV 5HSHQWLQDPHQWH$ULDVHVLQWLyPX\WtPLGDJLUyVXFDEH]D\PLUyILMDPHQWHDODILODGH SDSDVIULWDV\SUHW]HOVHQODPiTXLQDH[SUpV¢-DVRQHVWDEDFRTXHWHDQGR"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³&UHR TXH HV SDUD QRVRWURV ³GLMR $ULD FHUUDQGR OD FUHPDOOHUD GH VX FKDTXHWD³ ¢4XLHUHVTXHQRVVHQWHPRVMXQWRV"

ͷͺ

/RV RMRV GH -DVRQ EULOODURQ 5HVSLUy WDO YH] HVWDED D SXQWR GH GHFLU DOJR PiV $ULD WHQtDODHVSHUDQ]DGHTXHOHSLGLHUDXQDFLWDRLQFOXVRVXQ~PHURWHOpIRQR(QWRQFHV GHODYR]GHOFRQGXFWRUVRQyHQORVDOWDYRFHVDQXQFLDQGRTXHHOWUHQHQGLUHFFLyQD )LODGHOILDOOHJDUtDHQWUHVPLQXWRV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

3HUR-DVRQQRUHVSRQGLy&XDQGR$ULDORPLUyHVWDEDPLUDQGRODWHOHYLVLyQ6XSLHOVH KDEtDSXHVWRSiOLGD\VXERFDHUDXQDOtQHDWHQVDDQJXVWLRVD ³
³+HPRV HVWDGR EXVFDQGR HQ ORV ERVTXHV GXUDQWH GRV GtDV VHJXLGRV \ QR KHPRV SRGLGR HQFRQWUDU XQ VROR UDVWUR GHO FXHUSR GHO 6U 7KRPDV ³GLMR³ 7DO YH] QHFHVLWDPRVGDUXQSDVRDWUiV\FRQVLGHUDURWUDVSRVLELOLGDGHV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ž‰‹ƒ

$ULDIUXQFLyHOFHxR¢4XpRWUDVSRVLELOLGDGHV"

ͷͻ

(Q OD WHOHYLVLyQ HO MHIH GH OD SROLFtD GH 5RVHZRRG HVWDED KDEODQGR D XQ JUXSR GH PLFUyIRQRV



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(OHQIRTXHFDPELyDODPDGUHGH,DQ8QJUXSRGHPLFUyIRQRVHVWDEDQHQFDMDGRVEDMR VXEDUELOOD ³,DQ QRV HQYLy XQ FRUUHR HOHFWUyQLFR D\HU ³GLMR³ 1R QRV GLMR GyQGH HVWDED VyOR TXH HVWDED D VDOYR \ TXH pO QR OR KL]R ³+L]R XQD SDXVD SDUD VHFDUVH ORV RMRV³ $~Q HVWDPRV YHULILFDQGR VL UHDOPHQWH HUD pO R QR UXHJR TXH QR XVHQ VX FXHQWD GH HPDLOSDUDMXJDUQRVXQDEURPD /XHJRHO2ILFLDO:LOGHQDSDUHFLyHQODSDQWDOOD ³


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

5HJUHVyDOHVWDFLRQDPLHQWREXVFDQGRODILJXUDDOWDGH-DVRQ\VXSHORUXELR1RKDEtD QLXQDVRODSHUVRQDDODYLVWD(OFDPLQRIUHQWHDODHVWDFLyQHVWDEDYDFtRWDPELpQODV OXFHVGHOVHPiIRURVHFROXPSLDEDQHQVLOHQFLR3RUXQPRPHQWR$ULDVHVLQWLyFRPR VL IXHUD HO ~QLFR VHU KXPDQR TXH TXHGDED HQ HO PXQGR 7UDJy VDOLYD XQD VHQVDFLyQ SHFXOLDUDUUDVWUyGHVGHVXFXHOORKDVWDVXHVWyPDJR¢-DVRQKDEtDHVWDGRDTXtKDFHXQ PRPHQWR QR" ¢< HOORV KDEtDQ YLVWR HO FXHUSR GH ,DQ HQ HO ERVTXH QR" 3RU XQ

͸Ͳ

$IXHUDHOWUHQGH6(37$UXJLyHQODHVWDFLyQ\VHSDUyHQVHFR'HUHSHQWH$ULD\D QR WHQtD JDQDV GH LU D )LODGHOILD ¢&XiO HUD HO SXQWR" 1R LPSRUWD GyQGH VH IXHUD OD FDUJDGH5RVHZRRGVLHPSUHODVHJXLUtD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

PRPHQWRVLQWLyTXHUHDOPHQWHHVWDEDYROYLpQGRVHORFDWDOFRPRORKDEtDLQVLQXDGRHO SVLTXLDWUD

ž‰‹ƒ

͸ͳ

3HUR UiSLGDPHQWH GHVHFKy HVD LGHD $ PHGLGD TXH HO WUHQ VDOLy GH OD HVWDFLyQ $ULD UHJUHVy D VX FRFKH 6LQ WHQHU QLQJ~Q RWUR PHMRU OXJDU SDUD LU ILQDOPHQWH FRQGXMR GH UHJUHVRDODHVFXHOD 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR .DWH+DQQD .DWH+DQQD 7UDGXFLGRSRU 
+

DQQDSXVRVXFDIpFRQOHFKHGHVFUHPDGDGHYHLQWHRQ]DVHQHOPRVWUDGRUGH D]~FDU \ OHFKH GH 6WHDP HO FDIpEDU DG\DFHQWH D OD FDIHWHUtD GH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ (UD OD KRUD GHO DOPXHU]R HVH PDUWHV \ .DWH 1DRPL \ 5LOH\ HVWDEDQ WRGDYtDHQODFROD8QDSRUXQD+DQQDHVFXFKyRUGHQDUDFDGDXQDWpGHPHQWDH[WUD JUDQGH+DQQDHVWDEDIXHUDGHRQGDSHURDSDUHQWHPHQWHHOWpGHPHQWDHUDODEHELGD GHPRGD

1R VH KD HQFRQWUDGR FXHUSR GH 7KRPDV HQ ORV ERVTXHV GHFtD HO WLWXODU 6X HVWRPDJR VH UHYROYLy $ULD OH KDEtD FRQWDGR DFHUFD GH HVWD KLVWRULD WHPSUDQR HQ OD PDxDQD HQ OD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³+PSK³+DQQDHVQLIyHQYR]EDMD7LUyHOSDTXHWHGH6SOHQGDYDFtRHQHOERWHGHOD EDVXUD FRPSURPHWLpQGRVH D FRPSUDU D 1DRPL \ 5LOH\ DOJR PHMRU TXH XQD HVW~SLGD PiVFDUD/XHJR QRWyHQHOSDQWDOODSODQDSRU HQFLPDGHODMDUUDJUDQGHGHDJXDFRQ OLPyQ3RUORJHQHUDOODWHOHYLVLyQHVWDEDVLQWRQL]DGDHQHOFDQDOGHFLUFXLWRFHUUDGRGH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ TXH PRVWUDEDQ UHV~PHQHV GH ORV DFRQWHFLPLHQWRV GHSRUWLYRV GH OD HVFXHOD FRQFLHUWRV GH FRUDO HQWUHYLVWDV VREUH HO WHUUHQR SHUR KR\ DOJXLHQ OR KDEtD FDPELDGRDODVQRWLFLDV

͸ʹ

(OODDEULyHOVHJXQGRSDTXHWHGH6SOHQGDFRQVXVGLHQWHV6LVyORWXYLHVHXQ3HUFRFHW SDUDDFRPSDxDUFRQVXODWWHRPHMRUXQDUPD+DVWDDKRUDHODOPXHU]RKDEtDVLGR XQGHVDVWUH3ULPHUR1DRPL\5LOH\KDEtDQDGXODGRODVERWDV)U\HGH.DWHVLQGHFLU QDGD DFHUFD GH VXV ]DSDWLOODV VOLQJEDFN &KLH 0LKDUD /XHJR EDOEXFHDURQ DFHUFD GH FXDQWD GLYHUVLyQ WXYLHURQ HQ HO 5LYH *DXFKH D\HU XQR GH ORV PHVRQHURV HQ HGDG XQLYHUVLWDULD OHV KDEtD ILOWUDGR WRQHODGDV GH YLQR SLQRW QRLU 'HVSXpV GH TXH KDEtDQ EHELGRKDVWD VDFLDUVH VHDSDUHFLHURQHQ6HSKRUD\.DWHOHFRPSUyD 1DRPL\5LOH\ PiVFDUDV GH JHO GH RMRV SDUD DOLYLDU OD UHVDFD /DV FKLFDV WUDMHURQ ODV PiVFDUDV D OD HVFXHODKR\\VHODVSXVLHURQHQHOWLHPSRGHGHVFDQVRH[WUDODUJRHQHOEDxRGXUDQWHHO VHJXQGRSHUtRGRGHODVDODGHHVWXGLR/R~QLFRTXHOHYDQWyORViQLPRVGH+DQQDHUD YHUTXHODPiVFDUDIUtDKDEtDYXHOWRDJULHWDGD\GHXQOODPDWLYRURMROD]RQDDOUHGHGRU GHORVRMRVPDUURQHVGH5LOH\

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

FODVHGH,QJOpV$YDQ]DGR¢&yPRSRGtDQORV7KRPDVKDEHUUHFLELGRXQDQRWDGH,DQ" ¢&yPR QR SXHGH KDEHU XQD SLVWD GH ,DQ HQ HVRV ERVTXHV QL VDQJUH QL XQ FDEHOOR QDGD" ¢6LJQLILFDED TXH HOORV QR OR KDEtDQ YLVWR" ¢(VR VLJQLILFD TXH WRGDYtD HVWDED« YLYR" ¢<SRUTXpHVWDEDQGLFLHQGRORVSROLFtDVD+DQQD\DODVRWUDVTXHORKDEtDQDUUHJODGR" :LOGHQQRSDUHFtDSHQVDUTXHORKDEtDQDUUHJODGRODQRFKHGHODILHVWD(QUHDOLGDGVL :LOGHQQRKXELHVHVLGRWDQGLItFLOGHHQFRQWUDUHVDQRFKHHOODVSRGUtDQKDEHUOOHJDGR GHQXHYRDORVERVTXHVPiVUiSLGR7DOYH]KXELHVHQSRGLGRFDSWXUDUD,DQDQWHVGH TXH VH HVFDSDUD R TXH OR DUUDVWUDUDQ 3HUR QR HO 'HSDUWDPHQWR GH 3ROLFtD GH 5RVHZRRG QR SRGtD SDUHFHU FRPR VL OR KXELHVHQ DUUXLQDGR« DVt TXH KLFLHURQ YHU FRPR VL +DQQD \ ODV RWUDV HVWDEDQ ORFDV HQ VX OXJDU < WRGR HVWH WLHPSR SHQVy TXH :LOGHQ OD HVWDED DSR\DQGR +DQQD UiSLGDPHQWH VH DOHMy GHO 79 GHVHDQGR VDFDU OD KLVWRULD GH VX FDEH]D DOJR GHWUiV GHO WDPL] GH FDQHOD OH OODPy OD DWHQFLyQ 3DUHFtD FRPR«WHOD<HUDH[DFWDPHQWHGHOPLVPRFRORUTXHODEDQGHUDGH5RVHZRRG'D\ +DQQDWUDJyIXHUWHWLUyGHODWHODODH[WHQGLy\MDGHy(UDXQDSLH]DGHURSDFRUWDGD HQ XQ FXDGUR LUUHJXODU (O ERUGH GH OD FUHVWD GH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ HVWDED HQ OD HVTXLQD VXSHULRU GHUHFKD %LHQ VXMHWR D OD SDUWH GH DWUiV HVWDED XQ SHGD]R GH SDSHO FRQ HO Q~PHUR  HQ pO 5RVHZRRG 'D\ VLHPSUH QXPHUDED FDGD SLH]D SDUD DVt VDEHU FyPR FRVHUODEDQGHUDQXHYDPHQWH ³¢4XpHVHVR"³GLMRXQDYR]+DQQDVDOWyVRUSUHQGLGD.DWHVHHVFDEXOOyGHWUiVGH HOOD $ +DQQD OH WRPy XQ PRPHQWR UHDFFLRQDU VX PHQWH WRGDYtD HVWDED UHSURGXFLHQGRODVQRWLFLDVGH,DQ ³(VSDUDXQHVW~SLGRMXHJR³PXUPXUy .DWHIUXQFLyORVODELRV ³¢(OMXHJRTXHFRPHQ]yKR\"¢(O7~QHOGHOWLHPSR" +DQQDSXVRHQEODQFRORVRMRV ³/D&iSVXODGHOWLHPSR

ž‰‹ƒ

³8QD YH] TXH ODV YHLQWH SLH]DV GH OD EDQGHUD VH KD\DQ HQFRQWUDGR HOORV OD FRVHUiQ MXQWDV \ OD HQWHUUDUiQ HQ XQD FiSVXOD GHO WLHPSR GHWUiV GH ORV FDPSRV GH I~WERO ³ UHFLWyGHORVFDUWHOHVTXHKDEtDQDSDUHFLGRSRUWRGDVSDUWHVODHVFXHOD

͸͵

.DWHWRPyXQVRUERGHVXWp



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

/DVDQWXUURQD.DWHWHQtDTXHPHPRUL]DUVHODVUHJODVGHOD&iSVXODGHO7LHPSRFRPR VLIXHVHDVHUSXHVWDDSUXHEDSRUHVROXHJR ³< OXHJR SRQGUiQ WX QRPEUH LQPRUWDOL]DGR HQ XQD SODFD GH EURQFH (VR HV DOJR JUDQGH¢QR" ³/R TXH VHD ³PXUPXUy +DQQD +DEODQGR GH OR LUyQLFR FXDQGR D HOOD \D QR OH LPSRUWDED QDGD DFHUFD GH OD &iSVXOD GHO 7LHPSR HQFXHQWUD XQ WUR]R VLQ WHQHU TXH PLUDUWRGDVODVSLVWDVSXHVWDVHQHOOREE\GHODHVFXHOD(QVH[WRJUDGRHOSULPHUDxR TXHVHOHSHUPLWLyMXJDU+DQQDKDEtDIDQWDVHDGRGHFRPRGHFRUDUtDXQWUR]RVLWHQtD ODVXHUWHGHHQFRQWUDUXQR $OJXQRVQLxRVGLEXMDEDQFRVDVVLQVHQWLGRHQVXVWUR]RVFRPRXQDIORURXQDFDUDIHOL] R³ORPiVWRQWRGHWRGR³HOHVFXGRGH5RVHZRRG'D\SHUR+DQQDHQWHQGLyTXHXQD ELHQ GHFRUDGD EDQGHUD GH OD &iSVXOD GHO 7LHPSR HUD WDQ LPSRUWDQWH FRPR OOHYDU HO EROVRGHPDQRGHUHFKDRKDFHUVHUHIOHMRVHQHOVDOyQGH+HQUL)ODXEHUWHQ.LQJ-DPHV &XDQGR +DQQD 6SHQFHU \ ODV RWUDV FRQIURQWDURQ D $OL HQ VX SDWLR HO GtD GHVSXpV GH TXH HO MXHJR FRPHQ]DUD $OL KDEtD GHVFULWR FRQ GHWDOOH OR TXH KDEtD GLEXMDGR HQ VX WUR]R8QORJRGH&KDQHO(OGLVHxRGH/RXLV9XLWWRQ8QDPDQJDGHUDQD8QDQLxD MXJDQGR KRFNH\ VREUH FpVSHG 7DQ SURQWR FRPR +DQQD OOHJy D FDVD HVH GtD HVFULELy WRGR OR TXH $OL GLMR TXH KDEtD GLEXMDGR SDUD TXH QR VH OH ROYLGDUD 6RQDED WDQ JODPRURVR \ H[DFWDPHQWH FRUUHFWR /XHJR HQ RFWDYR JUDGR +DQQD \ 0RQD HQFRQWUDURQXQWUR]RGHOD&iSVXODGHO7LHPSRMXQWDV+DQQDTXHUtDLQFRUSRUDUWRGRV ORVHOHPHQWRVGH$OLHQHOGLVHxRSHURWHPtDTXH0RQDOHSUHJXQWDUDTXHVLJQLILFDEDQ RGLDEDUHFRUGDUOHD0RQDGH$OLGHVGHTXH0RQDHUDXQDGHODVFKLFDVGHODVTXH$OL DPDEDEXUODUVH +DQQDSHQVyTXHHUDXQDEXHQDDPLJDSRFRGHVSXpV VDEUtDTXH0RQDIXHLGHDQGR SRFRDSRFRXQDIRUPDGHDUUXLQDUODYLGDGH+DQQD 1DRPL \ 5LOH\ VDOWDURQ DPEDV LQPHGLDWDPHQWH QRWDQGR OD EDQGHUD GH +DQQD /RV RMRVPDUURQHVGH5LOH\VHVREUHVDOWDURQ



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6HUtD LJXDO TXH XQD GH HVWDV SHUUDV UREDUD OD EDQGHUD GH +DQQD FXDQGR QR HVWDED PLUDQGR 'H UHSHQWH HQWHQGLy OR TXH TXLVR GHFLU $OL FXDQGR OH GLMR D ,DQ TXH LED D JXDUGDUVXSHGD]RFRQVXYLGD<HQWHQGLyWDPELpQSRUTXp$OLKDEtDHVWDGRIXULRVDHO GtDHQTXHDOJXLHQVHODKDEtDUREDGR

͸Ͷ

([WHQGLy XQ SiOLGR SHFRVR EUD]R SDUD WRFDU HO WUR]R SHUR +DQQD OR UHFXSHUy VLQWLpQGRVHSURWHFWRUD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

3RURWUDSDUWH$OLKDEtDHVWDGRIXULRVDSHURQRH[DFWDPHQWHGHYDVWDGD(QUHDOLGDG $OL KDEtD HVWDGR GLVWUDtGD HVH GtD PiV TXH DOJ~Q RWUR +DQQD UHFRUGDED FODUDPHQWH FRPR$OLVHPDQWXYRPLUDQGRKDFLDHOERVTXH\VXFDVDPLHQWUDVSHQVDEDTXHDOJXLHQ HVWDEDHVFXFKDQGR(QWRQFHVGHVSXpVGHTXHMDUVHSRUVXSLH]DSHUGLGDSRUXQWLHPSR $OLYROYLyUHSHQWLQDPHQWHDVXSHUUD\KHODGD\RDOHMiQGRVHGH+DQQD\ODVRWUDVVLQ PiVSDODEUDFRPRVLKXELHVHDOJRPiVLPSRUWDQWHHQVXPHQWHTXHKDEODUFRQFXDWUR SHUGHGRUDV &XDQGRHUDFODURTXH$OLQRLEDDYROYHU+DQQDIXHDOSDWLRGHODQWHUR\VHPRQWyDVX ELFLFOHWD /D FDOOH GH $OL KDEtD SDUHFLGR WDQ DJUDGDEOH /RV &DYDQDXJKV WHQtDQ XQD FDVDGHiUEROURMRLQWHQVRHQHOODGRGHVXSDWLR/DIDPLOLDGH6SHQFHUWHQtDXQPROLQR GHYLHQWRJLUDQGRHQODSDUWHSRVWHULRUGHODSURSLHGDG+DEtDXQDFDVDEDMDQGRODFDOOH TXHWHQtDXQLQPHQVRJDUDMHSDUDVHLVFDUURV\XQDIXHQWHGHDJXDHQHOSDWLRGHODQWHUR /XHJR+DQQDVDEUtDTXHDOOtHUDGRQGH0RQDYLYtD < HQWRQFHV R\y XQ SHWDUGHR GHO PRWRU 8Q FRFKH HOHJDQWH GH pSRFD QHJUR FRQ YLGULRVSRODUL]DGRVUHPRQWDGRHQODDFHUDGH$OLFRPRHVSHUDQGRRYLHQGR$OJRDO UHVSHFWR KL]R TXH HO FDEHOOR HQ OD SDUWH SRVWHULRU GHO FXHOOR GH +DQQD VH SXVLHUD GH SXQWDV 7DO YH] HVH IXH TXLHQ UREy OD EDQGHUD GH $Ot HUD OR TXH KDEtD SHQVDGR 1R HV TXH KXELHVHVDELGRDFLHQFLDFLHUWD +DQQD PLUy D 1DRPL TXLHQ HVWDED DxDGLpQGROH 6SOHQGD D VX Wp GH PHQWD 1DRPL \ 5LOH\VROtDQVHUODVPHMRUHVDPLJDVGH$OLHQVH[WRJUDGRSHUROXHJRGHTXHOD&iSVXOD GHO7LHPSRFRPHQ]y$OLODVGHVHFKyDODVGRV(OODQXQFDH[SOLFySRUTXp 7DOYH]1DRPL\5LOH\KDEtDQVLGRODVTXHUREDURQODEDQGHUDGH$OLWDOYH]KDEtDQ HVWDGRGHQWURGHHVHFDUURQHJURTXH+DQQDKDEtDYLVWRHQODDFHUD<WDOYH]SRUHVR $OLODVGHMyWDOYH]$OLOHVSLGLyODEDQGHUD\FXDQGRQHJDURQTXHODWHQtDQOHVGHMy GHKDEODU3HURVLHVRKXELHVHSDVDGR¢SRUTXp1DRPLR5LOH\QRYROYLHURQODEDQGHUD FRPRVX\D"¢3RUTXpODEDQGHUDVHJXtDSHUGLGD"

5LOH\WRPyHOEUD]RGH.DWHKDFLHQGRTXHHOEUD]DOHWHGHRURHQODPXxHFDGH.DWH WLQWLQHDUD



ž‰‹ƒ

$OOtHVWipO

͸ͷ

+DEtD XQD FRQPRFLyQ HQ IUHQWH GH 6WHDP \ OD PXOWLWXG VH VHSDUy 2FKR FKLFRV GH ODFURVVHVHSDYRQHDEDQHQXQUHEDxRDUURJDQWH\FRQILDGR0LNH0RQWJRPHU\HVWDED HQWUH1RHO.DKQ\-DPHV)UHHG

)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

'HEHUtDVKDEODUFRQpOPXUPXUy1DRPLFRQVXVRMRVD]XOHVELHQDELHUWRV(QHVH PRPHQWR ORV WUHV VH OHYDQWDURQ \ VH DFHUFDURQ 1DRPL PLUDED ODVFLYDPHQWH D 1RHO 5LOH\ODQ]yVXODUJDFDEHOOHUDURMDD0DVRQ $KRUDTXHORVFKLFRVODFURVVHHUDQSHUPLWLGRVHVWRHUDXQDOXFKDJHQHUDO ³5RVHZRRG'D\HVPX\H[LJHQWHFRQODJHQWHTXHGLEXMDPDWHULDOLQDSURSLDGRHQOD EDQGHUDGHOD&iSVXODGHO7LHPSR³(VWDEDGLFLHQGR0LNHDVXVDPLJRV³3HURVLHO HTXLSRGHODFURVVHHQFXHQWUDFDGDWUR]R\KDFHXQJUDQGLEXMRLQDSURSLDGR³FRPRXQ SHQH³$SSOHWRQQRSRGUtDKDFHUQDGDeOQLVLTXLHUDVDEUtDTXHHVXQSHQHKDVWDTXH UHYHOHQODEDQGHUDHQODDVDPEOHD 1RHO.DKQOHGLRXQDSDOPDGDHQODHVSDOGD ³*HQLDO1RSXHGRHVSHUDUDYHUODFDUDGH$SSOHWRQ 0LNHVHLPDJLQyDO'LUHFWRU$SSOHWRQTXHKDHVWDGRDOOtHQDxRVFRQYR]WHPEORURVD GHVSOHJDQGRODUHFRQVWUXLGDEDQGHUDSDUDTXHODHVFXHODODYLHUD ³%LHQ¢TXpHVHVWR"³GLMRFRQYR]HVFDUSDGDGHYLHMRDJXDQWDQGRXQDLQYLVLEOHOXSD HQHORMR³¢(VHVWRORTXHPXFKDFKLWRVOODPDQXQJXHED]R" .DWH VH HFKy D UHtU +DQQD OD PLUy DVRPEUDGD 1R KDEtD PDQHUD HQ TXH .DWH KRQHVWDPHQWH SRGUtD SHQVDU TXH HVRV FUHWLQRV HUDQ JUDFLRVRV 0LNH QRWy VX ULVD \ VRQULy ³(VDLPLWDFLyQGH$SSOHWRQHVSHUIHFWD³JDODQWHy.DWH+DQQDDSUHWyODPDQGtEXOD &RPR VL .DWH KXELHVH FRQRFLGR DO 'LUHFWRU $SSOHWRQ \D +DEtD VLGR HVWXGLDQWH GH 5RVHZRRG'D\VyORSRUXQDVHPDQD ³*UDFLDV ³GLMR 0LNH UHFRUULHQGR GHVGH DEDMR FRQ OD PLUDGD HO FXHUSR GH .DWH GHVGH VXV ERWDV SDVDQGR SRU VXV HVWLOL]DGDV SLHUQDV KDVWD VX FKDTXHWD VSRUW GH 5RVHZRRG'D\ODFXDOHQFDMDQHOPDUFRHVEHOWRGH.DWHSHUIHFWDPHQWH+DQQDQRWy FRQPROHVWLDTXH0LNHQRODPLUyQLXQDYH]³+DJRXQDLPSUHVLyQEDVWDQWHEXHQD GH/DQFHHOSURIHVRUGHWDOOHUWDPELpQ



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

+DQQD DSUHWy ORV GLHQWHV %DVWD 1R KDEtD IRUPD GH TXH VX FDVLIXWXUDKHUPDQDVWUD HVWXYLHVHFRQTXLVWiQGRVHDOWLSRTXH VHVXSRQHTXHLEDDLGRODWUDUODDHOOD6H GLULJLy KDFLDORVFKLFRV.DWHOHGLRXQFRGD]RDXQODGR\SDVyORVGHGRVVREUHODEDQGHUDGH OD&iSVXODGHO7LHPSRTXHVHDFDEDEDGHHQFRQWUDU

͸͸

³0HHQFDQWDUtDHVFXFKDUORDOJXQDYH]³PDQLIHVWy.DWH

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³1R SRGtD GHMDU GH HVFXFKDU WX EULOODQWH LGHD ³GLMR +DQQD IXHUWHPHQWH³ SHUR VLHQWR GHFLU TXH WX JXHED]R YD D HVWDU LQFRPSOHWR ³(OOD RQGHy VX EDQGHUD VREUH OD QDUL]GH0LNH /RV RMRV GH 0LNH VH DEULHURQ 6H HVWLUy SDUD DOFDQ]DUOD SHUR +DQQD OR DOHMy 0LNH H[SOD\yVXODELRLQIHULRU ³9DPRV¢4XpWHQJRTXHKDFHUSRUWLSDUDTXHPHGHVHVHWUR]R" +DQQDWHQtDTXHHQWUHJiUVHORDpO/DPD\RUtDGHORVFKLFRVGHVHJXQGRDxRHVWDEDQ WDQ QHUYLRVRV HQ SUHVHQFLD GH +DQQD TXH FRPHQ]DEDQ D WHPEODU \ WDUWDPXGHDU $SUHWyODEDQGHUDFRQWUDVXSHFKR ³1RYR\DGHMDUDHVWHEHEpIXHUDGHPLYLVWD ³'HEH KDEHU DOJR TXH SXHGD KDFHU SRU WL ³GHFODUy 0LNH³ ¢7X WDUHD GH KLVWRULD" ¢/DYDUDPDQRWXVRVWpQ"¢$FDULFLDUWXVSH]RQHV" .DWH GHMy HVFDSDU RWUD VRQULVD GH QLxD WUDWDQGR GH GHYROYHU OD DWHQFLyQ D HOOD SHUR +DQQDDJDUUyUiSLGDPHQWHHOEUD]RGH0LNH\ORSXVRVREUHODWDEODGHFRQGLPHQWRV OHMRVGHODPXOWLWXG ³3XHGRGDUWHDOJRPHMRUTXHHVWDEDQGHUD³PXUPXUyHOOD ³¢4Xp"³SUHJXQWy0LNH ³
³2KSHUR\RDPRORVEDE\VKRZHU³H[FODPy+DQQDDSHVDUGHTXHHQUHDOLGDGORV RGLDEDXQSRFR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³0PPPLSDSiHVWDUiKDFLpQGROHDVXDPDQWHXQEDE\VKRZHU³0LNHPHWLyODV PDQRV HQ ORV EROVLOORV GH VX FKDTXHWD +DQQD VH HVWUHPHFLy $ULD OH KDEtD FRQWDGR VREUHVXSDSiHVFDSiQGRVHFRQVXHVWXGLDQWHSHUR+DQQDQRKDEtDVLGRFRQVFLHQWHGH TXHHVWDEDQKDEODQGRGHHVRWDQFiQGLGDPHQWH³1RLUtDSHURPLSDSiPHPDWDUtD

͸͹

³¢4XpWHSDUHFHPDxDQD"³OHSUHJXQWyD0LNH

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³
͸ͺ

³0PP³FRQWHVWy+DQQD³3DUHFHTXH\ROHJXVWR

ž‰‹ƒ

/RVRMRVFODURVGH.DWHVHHQVRPEUHFLHURQ8QDPLUDGDVHUHQDDSDUHFLyHQVXFDUD ³%LHQVXSRQJRTXHWHQGUHPRVTXHYHUHVR³GLMRHOOD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³&UHRTXHDVtHV³+DQQDFKLUULyFRQYR]IUtD 6HYLHURQODXQDDODRWUD/DFDQFLyQTXHVRQDEDHQORVDOWDYRFHVGH6WHDPFDPELyGH XQDEDODGDHPRSXQNDXQSDOSLWDQWHULWPRGHGDQ]DDIULFDQD$+DQQDOHHYRFyDXQD FDQFLyQTXHXQDWULEXSRGUtDWRFDUDQWHVGHLUDODEDWDOOD ´(O MXHJR FRPHQ]y SHUUDµ +DQQD DUWLFXOy FRQ OD ERFD /XHJR SXVR GHOLFDGDPHQWH VX EROVRHQHOSHFKR\FDPLQyFDPSDQWHPHQWHDOUHGHGRUGHVXIXWXUDKHUPDQDVWUDHQHO SDVLOOR GH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ PHQHDQGR VXV GHGRV D 0LNH 1RHO \ ORV RWURV 3HUR D PHGLGDTXHSDVDEDODFDIHWHUtDR\yXQDFDUFDMDGDVDUFiVWLFDUHVRQDQGRHQODVSDUHGHV 6H SDUy HO FDEHOOR GHWUiV GH VX FXHOOR VH SDUy GH SXQWDV /D ULVD QR YHQtD GH 6WHDP VLQRGHODFDIHWHUtD 7RGDVODVPHVDVHQHOFRPHGRUHVWDEDQOOHQDV/XHJRFRQHOUDELOORGHORMR+DQQDYLR XQD ILJXUD GHWUiV GHO KRUQR URWDWLYR GH SUHW]HO GHVOL]iQGRVH SRU OD SXHUWD WUDVHUD /D SHUVRQDHUDDOWD\GHOJDGD\WHQtDHOSHORUXELR\UL]DGR (OFRUD]yQGH+DQQDVHGHWXYR¢,DQ"

ž‰‹ƒ

͸ͻ

3HURQR,DQHVWDEDPXHUWR/DSHUVRQDTXHOHVKDEtDHQYLDGRDVXVSDGUHVXQPHQVDMH GHWH[WRPiVWHPSUDQRHUDXQLPSRVWRU6DFXGLHQGRHOSHQVDPLHQWR+DQQDVHSXVRVX FKDTXHWDDOUHGHGRUGHVXVKRPEURVWRPyOR~OWLPRGHVXODWWH\FRQWLQXyFDPLQDQGR SRUHOFRUUHGRUWUDWDQGRWRGRORSRVLEOHGHSDYRQHDUVHFRPRODFKLFDVLQPLHGREHOOD HLPSHUWXUEDEOHTXHHUD 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR 6LODVPXxHFDVSXGLHUDQKDEODU 7UDGXFLGRSRU5XWKLHH &RUUHJLGRSRU2EVHVVLRQ 

7

DQSURQWRFRPR(PLO\ WHUPLQy VXSUiFWLFDGH QDWDFLyQHOMXHYHVSRUODWDUGH PDQHMyKDVWDODFDVDGH,VDDF\VHHVWDFLRQyHQODDFHUD

,VDDFDEULyODSXHUWDGHHQIUHQWHGHVXFDVDDJDUUyDSUHWDGDPHQWHD(PLO\H LQKDOySURIXQGDPHQWH ³0PP0HHQFDQWDFXDQGRKXHOHVDFORUR (PLO\ KL]R XQD ULVLOOD WRQWD $ SHVDU GHO KHFKR GH TXH VLHPSUH VH ODYDED HO SHOR GRV YHFHVHQORVYHVWXDULRVGHODVGXFKDVGHVSXpVGHFDGDSUiFWLFDHORORULQFRQIXQGLEOHGH ODSLVFLQDVHDIHUUDEDWHUFDPHQWHDVXSHOR ,VDDFVHKL]RDXQODGR\(PLO\FDPLQyGHQWURGHODFDVD/DVDODGHHVWDUROtDFRPR XQD PH]FOD GH HVHQFLD GH PDQ]DQDV \ PHORFRWyQ +DEtD XQD IRWR HQ OD UHSLVD GH OD FKLPHQHDGH,VDDFVXPDGUH\/D5DWRQD0LQQLHHQ'LVQH\:RUOG(OVRIiIORUHDGR HVWDEDFXELHUWRFRQDOPRKDGDVGHHQFDMHTXHOD6UD&ROEHUWKDEtDERUGDGRSRUWDQGR PHQVDMHVFRPR$EUD]DUHV6DOXGDEOH\5H]DU&DPELD7RGR ,VDDFWLUyXQDGHODVPDQJDVGHODFKDTXHWDGH(PLO\OXHJRODRWUD &XDQGRpOVHYROWHySDUDDEULUODSXHUWDGHODUPDULRHOODHVFXFKyXQFUXMLGRGHVGHHO YHVWtEXORGHODHQWUDGD(PLO\VHFRQJHOy ,VDDFVHYROWHyKDFLDHOOD\WRFyVXPDQR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

(PLO\VHUHODPLyVXVODELRV/DSUHQVDKDEtDHVWDGRDFRViQGRODDHOOD\DVXVDPLJRV FRQVWDQWHPHQWH\WHPSUDQRHVHGtDKDEtDHVFXFKDGROD~OWLPDQRWLFLDTXHODIDPLOLDGH 7KRPDVKDEtDUHFLELGRXQFRUUHRHOHFWUyQLFRGH,DQ\TXH(PLO\\ODVRWUDVKDEtDQLQYHQWDGRHO YHUHOFXHUSRGH,DQHQORVERVTXHV(VRREYLDPHQWHQRHUDYHUGDGSHUR¢TXpHUDHVR"¢$

͹Ͳ

³¢3RUTXpHVWDVWDQDVXVWDGL]D"/DSUHQVDQRHVWiDTXtORSURPHWR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

GyQGH VH KDEtD LGR ,DQ" ¢(VWDED UHDOPHQWH FRQ YLGD R DFDVR DOJXLHQ TXHUtD TXH FUH\HUDQTXHORHVWDED" 0iV TXH HVR (PLO\ QR SRGtD GHMDU GH SHQVDU DFHUFD GHO LQFLGHQWH GH -DVRQ 'L/DXUHQWLVODQRFKHGHOGRPLQJR1RWHQLDLGHDGHORTXHSRGUtDKDEHUKHFKRVL,VDDF QR KXELHUD HVWDGR FRQ HOOD &DGD YH] TXH FRQVLGHUDED OD SRVLELOLGDG GH HQFRQWUDUVH FDUDDFDUDFRQ-DVRQDVRODVVHHVWUHPHFtDGHPLHGR ³/RVLHQWR³OHGLMRD,VDDFWUDWDQGRGHFRQWURODUVXHVWDGRGHiQLPR³(VWR\ELHQ ³%LHQ ³,VDDF GLMR  eO WRPy VX PDQR³
(OODOHVRQULyD,VDDF



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³£7LHQHV XQD FDEH]D GH OD IUHQRORJtD ³(OOD VH DFHUFy DO PROGH PiV JUDQGH GH XQ FUiQHR\WUD]yVXVGHGRVVREUHODVSDODEUDVTXHHVWDEDQHVFULWDVDWUDYpVGHODFDEH]D $VWXFLD 3UHPHGLWDFLyQ $YDULFLD 0pGLFRV YLFWRULDQRV SHQVDURQ TXH SRGUtDQ GHWHUPLQDU OD SHUVRQDOLGDG GH XQD SHUVRQD VLPSOHPHQWH SRU HO PRGR HQ HO TXH VX FUiQHRHVWDEDIRUPDGR6LpOWXYLHUDXQEXOWRHQSDUWLFXODUHQFRQWUDGRHQVXFDEH]DpO VHUtD XQ EXHQ SRHWD 6L HO EXOWR HVWXYLHUD HQ RWURVOXJDUHV pO HUD VHUtD PX\ UHOLJLRVR (PLO\VHSUHJXQWyTXpHVORTXHORVEXOWRVHQVXFDEH]DGHFtDQVREUHHOOD

͹ͳ

/XHJRQRWyXQREMHWREODQFR\ODUJRHQORDOWRGHVXDSDUDGRU

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢'yQGHREWXYLVWHHVWR" ,VDDFVHDFHUFyDHOOD ³¢5HFXHUGDVDHVDWtD GHODTXHWHGLMHFXDQGROOHJDPRVODVHPDQDSDVDGD"¢/DTXH HVWiPHWLGDHQORVKRUyVFRSRV\HVDVFRVDV"(OODFRQVLJXLyHVWRSDUDPtHQXQPHUFDGR GHSXOJDV³eOWRFyXQEXOWRHQHOFUiQHRGH(PLO\³+PPWHVLHQWHVPX\GHVLJXDO ³eO PLUy OD FDEH]D IUHQROyJLFD³ 'H DFXHUGR FRQ HVWR HUHV PX\ EXHQD GDQGR FDULxRRKDFHVTXHRWURVTXLHUDQGDUWHDIHFWR1XQFDSXHGRUHFRUGDUFXiOHVFXiO ³0X\FLHQWtILFR³(PLO\VHEXUOy7RFyODSDUWHVXSHULRUGHVXFDEH]DEXVFDQGRSRU XQ EXOWR³ 7~ HUHV ³(OOD VH LQFOLQy KDFLD DWUiV EXVFDQGR OD FDEH]D GH FHUiPLFD SDUD XQD DSURSLDGD FXDOLGDG (O ODGUyQ (O LPLWDGRU (O DVHVLQR (O GHSDUWDPHQWR GH SROLFtDGH5RVHZRRGQHFHVLWDXQDGHHVWDVFDEH]DVHOORVSRGUtDQPDVDMHDUFDGDFUiQHR HQODFLXGDG\HQFRQWUDUDODVHVLQRGH$OLGHLQPHGLDWR³(UHVVDELR³FRQFOX\y ³(UHV KHUPRVD ³,VDDF GLMR /HQWDPHQWH pO OD FRQGXMR KDVWD OD FDPD \ WLUy GH HOOD KDFLDDEDMR6HVLQWLyUXERUL]DGD\FRQSRFRDOLHQWR1RKDEtDDQWLFLSDGRDFRVWDUVHHQ OD FDPD GH ,VDDF SHUR QR VH TXHUtD OHYDQWDU (OORV VH EHVDURQ SRU XQ SRFR PiV GH WLHPSR DOLJHUiQGRVH KDFLD DEDMR KDVWD TXH HVWXYLHURQ WXPEDGRV HQ ODV DOPRKDGDV (PLO\ PHWLy VX PDQR GHEDMR GH VX SOD\HUD SDUD VHQWLU VX FiOLGR SHFKR GHVQXGR /XHJRHOODULyVRUSUHQGLGDSRUVXFRPSRUWDPLHQWR ³¢4Xp"³,VDDFSUHJXQWyDOHMiQGRVH³¢4XLHUHVSDUDU" (PLO\UHGXMRVXVRMRV/DYHUGDGHUDTXHVLHPSUHTXHHVWDEDDOUHGHGRUGH,VDDFXQD WUDQTXLOLGDGVHDFHUFDED7RGDVVXVDQVLHGDGHV\SUHRFXSDFLRQHVYRODEDQIXHUDSRUOD YHQWDQD(VWDQGRFRQpOVHVHQWtDDVDOYR\VHJXUD\HQDPRUDGD ³1RTXLHURSDUDU³VXVXUUyVXFRUD]yQSDOSLWDQGR³¢<W~"

ž‰‹ƒ

,VDDF WRFy HO ERUGH GHO VXMHWDGRU URVD HVFDORSDGR 'HVGH TXH pO OH KDEtD VDFDGR VX FDPLVDKDFHGRVGtDVKDEtDYHVWLGRVXMHWDGRUHVPiVOLQGRVHQODHVFXHOD7DPELpQURSD LQWHULRU PiV OLQGD QR ORV FyPRGRV FDO]RQFLOORV TXH VROtD OOHYDU 4XL]iV QR KDEtD DQWLFLSDGRHVWRH[DFWDPHQWHSHURWDOYH]VRODPHQWHWDOYH]HUDH[DFWDPHQWHORTXH KDEtDHVWDGRHVSHUDQGR 



͹ʹ

,VDDF VDFXGLy VX FDEH]D 'HVSXpV VH VDFy VX SOD\HUD 6X SLHO HUD SiOLGD \ VXDYH eO GHVDERWRQy OD EOXVD GH (PLO\ XQ ERWyQ D OD YH] KDVWD TXH VX FDPLVD HVWXYR PX\ DELHUWD(O~QLFRVRQLGRHUDQVXVUHVSLUDFLRQHV

)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&XDQGR HO UHORM GLJLWDO FDPELy GH ODV  D ODV  HQ OD PHVD GH QRFKH GH ,VDDF (PLO\VHVHQWy\VDFyODVVDEDQDVGHIUDQHODDOUHGHGRUGHHOOD/DVIDURODVGHDUULED\ DEDMRHQODFXDGUDGH,VDDFHVWDEDQDKRUDDOXPEUDQGR\XQDPXMHUDORWURODGRGHOD FDOOHHVWDEDOODPDQGRDVXVQLxRVHQIUHQWHGHOSDWLRSDUDFHQDU ³0H GHEHUtD GH LU SURQWR ³(PLO\ GLMR GiQGROH RWUR EHVR D ,VDDF $PERV ULHURQ ,VDDF WLUy GH HOOD GH YXHOWD KDFLD DEDMR \ VH HPSH]DURQ D EHVDU RWUD YH] (YHQWXDOPHQWH DPERV VH SDUDURQ \ VH YLVWLHURQ DVRPDQGR PLUDGDV IXUWLYDV QR WDQ HQFXELHUWDVHOXQRDORWUR0XFKRKDEtDSDVDGRSHUR(PLO\VHVHQWtDELHQFRQHOOR ,VDDFKDEtDLGRGRORURVDPHQWHOHQWREHVDQGRFDGDSXOJDGDGHVXFXHUSRDGPLWLHQGR TXHHUDODSULPHUDYH]GHpOWDPELpQ1RSXGRKDEHUVLGRPiVSHUIHFWR (OORV FRPHQ]DURQ D EDMDU ODV HVFDOHUDV DOLVDQGR VXV URSDV $ PHGLR FDPLQR KDFLD DEDMR(PLO\HVFXFKyDDOJXLHQGHMDUHVFDSDUXQDWRVOOHQDGHIOHPD $PERV VH FRQJHODURQ (PLO\ HVWUHFKy VXV RMRV KDFLD ,VDDF 1R VH VXSRQtD TXH VXV SDGUHVHVWXYLHUDQGHYXHOWDKDVWDDQWHVGHODVVLHWH 8Q SDVR FKLUULDQWH VRQy GHVGH OD FRFLQD 8Q FRQMXQWR GH OODYHV GH FRFKH VRQDURQ OXHJR IXHURQ GHMDGDV HQ XQ WD]yQ GH FHUiPLFD (O HVWyPDJR GH (PLO\ VH SUHFLSLWy 0LUy KDFLD ODV PXxHFDV PXGDV FRQ RMRV YLGULRVRV HQ ORV HVFDORQHV 3DUHFtDQ HVWDU VRQULHQGRKDFLDHOOD (PLO\ H ,VDDF JDWHDURQ KDFLD DEDMR \ VH DUURMDURQ HQ HO VRIi 7DQ SURQWR FRPR VXV WUDVHURV JROSHDURQ ORV FRMLQHV OD 6UD &ROEHUW HQWUy HQ OD KDELWDFLyQ (VWDED YHVWLGD FRQXQDIDOGDODUJDGHODQDURMD\XQVXpWHUEODQFRWHMLGR'HELGRDODIRUPDHQODTXH OD OX] VH UHIOHMDED HQ VXV JDIDV (PLO\ QR SRGtD GHFLU KDFLD GRQGH HVWDED PLUDQGR +DEtD XQD VHYHUD PLUDGD GHVDSUREDWRULD HQ VX URVWUR 3RU XQ VHJXQGR DJRQL]DQWH (PLO\VHTXHGyHQSiQLFRGHTXHOD6UD&ROEHUWKXELHUDHVFXFKDGRWRGRORTXHDSHQDV KDEtDVXFHGLGR 'HVSXpVHOODVHYROWHy\DSODQyXQDPDQRHQVXSHFKR ³£&KLFRV£1RORVYLDKt

(PLO\VHOHYDQWyWDPELpQHVSHUDQGRTXHVXFDEHOORQRIXHUDXQFRPSOHWRGHVDVWUH\ TXHQRWXYLHUDXQFKXSHWyQUiSLGDPHQWHFUHFLHQGRHQVXFXHOOR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³0DPiWHDFXHUGDVGH(PLO\¢YHUGDG"

͹͵

,VDDFVHOHYDQWyGHXQVDOWRJROSHDQGRWRUSHPHQWHODSLODGHiOEXPHVGHIRWRVVREUHOD PHVDGHFDIpDOVXHOR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³+KROD³HOODWDUWDPXGHy³(QFDQWDGDGHYHUOHGHQXHYR ³+ROD(PLO\³+DEtDXQDVRQULVDEDVWDQWHDJUDGDEOHHQHOURVWURGHOD6UD&ROEHUW SHURHOFRUD]yQGH(PLO\FRQWLQXyFRUULHQGRGHODPLVPDPDQHUD ¢(VWDEDUHDOPHQWHVRUSUHQGLGDGHYHUORVR VyORHVWDEDHVSHUDQGRKDVWDTXH(PLO\VH DOHMDUDSDUDJULWDUOHD,VDDFHQSULYDGR" &RQWHPSOyD,VDDFTXLHQVHYHtDLQFRPRGReOSXVRVXPDQRHQORDOWRGHVXFDEH]D HQUHGDQGRKDFLDDEDMRVXFDEHOORGHVSHLQDGR ³8K (PLO\ ¢TXLHUHV TXHGDUWH D FHQDU" ³,VDDF GLMR GH UHSHQWH³ (VWR HVWi ELHQ ¢YHUGDGPDPi" /D 6UD &ROEHUW YDFLOy DSUHWDQGR VXV ODELRV MXQWRV KDVWD TXH SUiFWLFDPHQWH GHVDSDUHFLHURQ ³<\RQRGHEHUi³(PLO\EDOEXFHyDQWHVGHTXHOD6UD&ROEHUWSXGLHUDUHVSRQGHU³ 0LPDPiPHHVWiHVSHUDQGRHQFDVD /D6UD&ROEHUWH[KDOy(PLO\MXUyTXHVHYHtDDOLYLDGD ³%XHQR4XL]iVHQRWURPRPHQWR³HOODGLMR ³¢4XpWDOPDxDQD"³,VDDFSUHVLRQy (PLO\GLVSDUyXQDLQTXLHWDPLUDGDKDFLD,VDDFSUHJXQWiQGRVHVLpOGHEHUtDVRODPHQWH DEDQGRQDUHOWHPDGHODFHQD3HUROD6UD&ROEHUWIURWyVXVPDQRVMXQWDV\GLMR ³0DxDQDHVWDUtDELHQ/RVPLpUFROHVVRQQRFKHVGHFDUQHDVDGD ³8KHVWiELHQ³(PLO\UHVSRQGLy³&UHRTXHSXHGRKDFHUHVR*UDFLDV ³%LHQ³/D6UD&ROEHUWOHGLRXQDWLHVDVRQULVD³£7UDHWXDSHWLWR 6HGHVOL]yGHQXHYRKDFLDODFRFLQD(PLO\VHKXQGLyGHQXHYRHQHOVRIi\FXEULyVX URVWURFRQVXVPDQRV ³6RODPHQWHPiWDPHDKRUD³HOODVXVXUUy

³(VWDPRVDVDOYR1RVDEHTXHHVWXYLPRVDUULED 3HUR PLHQWUDV (PLO\ PLUy D WUDYpV GH OD DUTXHDGD SXHUWD KDFLD OD FRFLQD YLR D OD PDGUHGH,VDDFSDUiQGRVHHQHOIUHJDGHURHQMXDJDQGRORVSODWRVGHOGHVD\XQR$SHVDU



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

͹Ͷ

,VDDFWRFyVXEUD]R

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

GHTXHVXVPDQRVFRQWLQXDURQPDQLiWLFDPHQWHIUHJDQGRORVSODWRVORVRVFXURVRMRVGH OD 6UD &ROEHUW VH ILMDEDQ FRQVWDQWHPHQWH HQ HOORV 6XV ODELRV IUXQFLGRV VXV PHMLOODV HQURMHFLGDV\ODVFXHUGDVGHVXFXHOORKLQFKiQGRVHFRQIXULD

ž‰‹ƒ

͹ͷ

(PLO\VHVREUHVDOWyKRUURUL]DGD/D6UD&ROEHUWQRWyTXH(PLO\HVWDEDPLUDQGRSHUR VX H[SUHVLyQ QR WLWXEHy 6H TXHGy PLUDQGR VLQ SHVWDxHDU D (PLO\ FRPR VL HVWXYLHUD FRQVFLHQWHGHORTXHH[DFWDPHQWHHOODH,VDDFKDEtDQKHFKR<WDOYH]LQFOXVRFXOSDQGR D(PLO\³\VRODPHQWHD(PLO\³SRUWRGRHOOR 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR £6RUSUHVD£eOWRGDYtDHVWiDTXt £6RUSUHVD£eOWRGDYtDHVWiDTXt 7UDGXFLGRSRU&OR &RUUHJLGRSRU/RR  

0

LHQWUDVHOVROVHKXQGtDEDMRHOKRUL]RQWHFRQYLUWLHQGRWRGR5RVHZRRGHQ XQ QHJUR DEVROXWR 6SHQFHU PLUDED SRU OD YHQWDQD GHO GRUPLWRULR GH VX PDGUH PLHQWUDV HO UHVWR GH ORV FRFKHV GHO HVFXDGUyQ GH SROLFtD GH 5RVHZRRG\ODVIXUJRQHWDVGHQRWLFLDVVDOtDQGHVXFDOOH/RVSROLFtDVKDEtDQFDQFHODGR GH UHSHQWH OD E~VTXHGD GHO FXHUSR GH ,DQ OXHJR GH KDEHU HQFRQWUDGR QDGD HQ HO ERVTXH<XQPRQWyQGHJHQWHKDEtDWUDtGRDFRODFLyQODQXHYDWHRUtDGHTXHODVFKLFDV KDEtDQLQYHQWDGRHOKDEHUYLVWRHOFXHUSRGH,DQSHUPLWLpQGROHHVFDSDUGHIiFLOPHQWH GH5RVHZRRGSDUDVLHPSUH 4XpWRQWHUtDV<QRSDUHFtDSRVLEOHTXHORVSROLFtDVQRKXELHUDQHQFRQWUDGRQLXQDVROD HYLGHQFLD 7HQtDTXHKDEHUDOJRDKtDIXHUD8QDKXHOOD8QSHGD]RGHFRUWH]DUHPRYLGRFRQODV XxDVGHDOJXLHQ 6XRUGHQDGRUHQODRWUDHVTXLQDGHOFXDUWRKL]RXQ]XPELGRIXULRVR6SHQFHUOHYDQWy OD YLVWD PLUDQGR HO &' TXH HOOD \ $QGUHZ KDEtDQ KHFKR D\HU GHO GLVFR GXUR GH VX SDGUH (UD GRQGH OR KDEtD GHMDGR GHVSXpV GH TXH VH WHUPLQDUD GH FDUJDU OD QRFKH DQWHULRU DSR\DGR HQ XQD IXQGD GH SDSHO HQ OD SDUWH VXSHULRU GH VX DQWLJXR OLEUR GH DSXQWHV7LIIDQ\ 7RGDYtDQRKDEtDUHYLVDGRORVDUFKLYRVSHURQRKDEtDPRPHQWRPHMRUTXHHOSUHVHQWH 6HDFHUFyDVXHVFULWRULR\GHVOL]yHO&'HQODFRPSXWDGRUD

͹͸

$OLQVWDQWHHOHTXLSRKL]RXQUXLGRGHSHGRUUHR\WRGRVORVLFRQRVHQHOHVFULWRULRGH 6SHQFHUVHFRQYLUWLHURQHQVLJQRVGHLQWHUURJDFLyQ,QWHQWyKDFHUFOLFHQXQRSHURQR VHDEULy/XHJRODSDQWDOODVHYROYLyQHJUD ž‰‹ƒ

7UDWyGHUHLQLFLDUHOVLVWHPDSHURHOHTXLSRQRVHHQFHQGLy



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³0LHUGD³VXVXUUyH[SXOVDQGRHO&'7HQtDFRSLDVGHVHJXULGDGGHWRGRHQVXGLVFR GXURFRPRSRUHMHPSORGHVXVSDSHOHVYLHMRVWRQHODGDVGHIRWRV\YLGHRV\VXGLDULR HO FXDO KDEtD PDQWHQLGR GHVGH DQWHV GH TXH $OL GHVDSDUHFLHUD SHUR VLQ XQ HTXLSR IXQFLRQDOQRSRGUtDUHYLVDUORVDUFKLYRVGHVXSDGUHSDUDHYLGHQFLDV 8QDSXHUWDVHFHUUyGHJROSHHQODSODQWDEDMD6XSDGUHKDEOyFRQYR]DSDJDGDOXHJR VX PDGUH 6SHQFHU OHYDQWy OD PLUDGD FRQ HO HVWyPDJR EXUEXMHDQGR 1R OHV KDEtD KDEODGR UHDOPHQWH GHVGH TXH WRGRV KDEtDQ UHJUHVDGR GHO IXQHUDO GH 1DQD 0LUy GH QXHYRVXFRPSXWDGRUDOXHJRVHSXVRGHSLH\VHGLULJLyHVFDOHUDVDEDMR (O DLUH ROtD FRPR DO TXHVR EULH DO KRUQR TXH VXV SDGUHV VLHPSUH FRPSUDEDQ HQ HO PRVWUDGRU GH OD ILDPEUHUtD )UHVK )LHOGV \ ORV GRV ODEUDSRRGOHV 5XIXV \ %HDWULFH HVWDEDQ KROJD]DQHDQGR HQ OD DOIRPEUD JUDQGH \ UHGRQGD MXQWR DO GHVD\XQDGRU /D KHUPDQDGH6SHQFHU0HOLVVDWDPELpQHVWDEDHQODFRFLQDFDPLQDQGRUiSLGRSRUDKt PLHQWUDVDSLODEDUHYLVWDV\OLEURVGHGLVHxRTXHKDEtDHVSDUFLGRSRUHOFXDUWRHQXQD EROVDGHSDSHO/DPDGUHGH6SHQFHUHVWDEDUHEXVFDQGRHQHOFDMyQTXHFRQWHQtDWRGDV ODV OLEUHWDV GH WHOpIRQR \ ORV Q~PHURV GH ODV GLIHUHQWHV SHUVRQDV TXH D\XGDEDQ HQ OD FDVDSDLVDMLVWDVVHOODGRUHVGHFDO]DGDHOHFWULFLVWDV(O6U+DVWLQJVVHSDVHDEDGHVGHOD FRFLQDKDVWDHOFRPHGRUFRQVXWHOpIRQRFHOXODUHQHORtGR ³8KPLFRPSXWDGRUDWLHQHXQYLUXV³GLMR6SHQFHU 6XSDGUHGHMyGHSDVHDUVH0HOLVVDOHYDQWyODPLUDGD6XPDGUHVDOWy\GLRODYXHOWD &RQODVFRPLVXUDVGHVXERFDKDFLDDEDMR6HYROYLyKDFLDHOFDMyQ ³¢0DPi"³6SHQFHULQWHQWyGHQXHYR³0LFRPSXWDGRUD(VWiPXHUWD /D6UD+DVWLQJVQRVHYROYLy ³¢<" 6SHQFHU SDVy ORV GHGRV D OR ODUJR GHO DUUHJOR IORUDO OLJHUDPHQWH PDUFKLWR HQ OD LVOD KDVWDTXHVHGLRFXHQWDGRQGHKDEtDYLVWRSRU~OWLPDYH]ODVIORUHVVREUHHODWD~GGH 1DQD5HWLUyODPDQRUiSLGDPHQWH

³¢4Xp"³SUHJXQWy6SHQFHUFRQIXQGLGD%HDWULFHOHYDQWyODFDEH]D\OXHJRODYROYLy DEDMDU



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6X PDGUH VH YROYLy \ H[DPLQy D 6SHQFHU SRU DOJXQRV VHJXQGRV &XDQGR 6SHQFHU OH GHYROYLyXQDPLUDGDGHLPSRWHQFLDOD6UD+DVWLQJVVHHFKyDUHtU

͹͹

³%XHQRODQHFHVLWRSDUDKDFHUPLWDUHD¢3XHGROODPDUDOHVFXDGUyQIDQiWLFRVGHOD FRPSXWDFLyQ"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢3RUTXpGHEHUtDSDJDUOHDDOJXLHQSDUDTXHYHQJDDDUUHJODUWXFRPSXWDGRUDFXDQGR GHEHUtDKDFHUWHSDJDUSRUORTXHOHVXFHGLyDOJDUDMH"³6HMDFWyOD6UD+DVWLQJV 6SHQFHUSDUSDGHyUiSLGDPHQWH ³¢(O«JDUDMH" 6XPDGUHVROWyXQEXILGR ³1RPHGLJDVTXHQRORYLVWH 6SHQFHUPLUyGHXQSDGUHDORWURVLQWHQHULGHD/XHJRFRUULyKDFLDODSXHUWDSULQFLSDO \VDOLyDOSDWLRHQFDOFHWLQHVDSHVDUGHTXHHOVXHORHVWDEDKHODGR\HPSDSDGR8QD OX]KDEtDVLGRHQFHQGLGDHQHOJDUDMH&XDQGR6SHQFHUYLRORTXHHVWDEDDOOtVHWDSyOD ERFDFRQODVPDQRV $WUDYHVDQGR DPEDV SXHUWDV GHO JDUDMH HQ SLQWXUD URMR VDQJUH HVWDED OD SDODEUD $6(6,1$ 1R KDEtD HVWDGR DTXt FXDQGR KDEtD UHJUHVDGR D FDVD GHVGH OD HVFXHOD KR\ 6SHQFHU PLUyDVXDOUHGHGRUFRQODFODUDVHQVDFLyQGHTXHDOJXLHQHVWDEDREVHUYDQGRGHVGHHO ERVTXH¢6HDFDEDEDGHPRYHUXQDUDPD" ¢6HDFDEDEDGHDJDFKDUDOJXLHQGHWUiVGHXQDUEXVWR"¢(UDXQ«" 6HHQIUHQWyDVXPDGUHTXLHQKDEtDPDUFKDGRKDVWDVXODGR ³¢/ODPDVWHDODSROLFtD" /D6UD+DVWLQJVODGUyRWUDFDUFDMDGD ³¢&UHHVTXHODSROLFtDQRVTXLHUHKDEODUUHDOPHQWHHQHVWRVPRPHQWRV"¢&UHHVTXHOHV LPSRUWDTXHDOJXLHQOHKD\DKHFKRHVWRDQXHVWUDFDVD" 6SHQFHUDEULyJUDQGHVORVRMRV ³(VSHUD¢W~FUHHVORTXHORVSROLFtDVHVWiQGLFLHQGR" 6XPDGUHVHKXQGLyHQXQDFDGHUD

͹ͺ

³$PEDVVDEHPRVTXHQXQFDKXERQDGDHQHVRVERVTXHV

ž‰‹ƒ

(OPXQGRFRPHQ]yDJLUDU/DERFDGH6SHQFHUVHVHQWtDVHFD ³0DPiYLD,DQ5HDOPHQWHORKLFH



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

6XPDGUHDFHUFyHOURVWURDSXOJDGDVGHOGH6SHQFHU ³¢6DEHV FXiQWR YD D FRVWDU UHSLQWDU HVDV SXHUWDV" 6RQ ~QLFDV HQ VX HVSHFLH ODV FRQVHJXLPRVGHXQYLHMRJUDQHURHQ0DLQH /RVRMRVGH6SHQFHUVHOOHQDURQGHOiJULPDV ³/DPHQWRVHUXQDUHVSRQVDELOLGDGWDQJUDQGH³6HGLRODYXHOWDFDPLQyDSLVRWRQHV SRU HO SRUFKH \ VH PDUFKy HVFDOHUDV DUULED VLQ PROHVWDUVH HQ OLPSLDU HO EDUUR GH VXV FDOFHWLQHVHQHOIHOSXGR /RVRMRVOHSLFDEDQFRQOiJULPDVFDOLHQWHVPLHQWUDVVXEtDODVHVFDOHUDV\DEUtDODSXHUWD GHVXGRUPLWRULR ¢3RU TXp OH VRUSUHQGtD TXH VX PDGUH HVWXYLHUD GHO ODGR GH ORV SROLFtDV" ¢3RU TXp GHEHUtDKDEHUHVSHUDGRDOJRGLIHUHQWH" ³¢6SHQFH" 0HOLVVD DVRPy OD FDEH]D HQ OD KDELWDFLyQ 9HVWtD XQ FRQMXQWR GH FDFKHPLUD DPDULOOR SiOLGR\XQRVVXHOWRVMHDQVRVFXURV6XFDEHOORHVWDEDHFKDGRKDFLDDWUiVFRQXQDFLQWD GH WHUFLRSHOR \ VXV RMRV VH YHtDQ FDQVDGRV H KLQFKDGRV FRPR VL KXELHUD HVWDGR OORUDQGR ³9HWH³PDVFXOOy6SHQFHU 0HOLVVDVXVSLUy ³6yORTXHUtDTXHVXSLHUDVTXHSXHGHVXVDUPLYLHMDSRUWiWLOVLORQHFHVLWDV(VWiHQHO JUDQHUR 7HQJR XQD FRPSXWDGRUD QXHYD HQ OD FDVD GH OD FLXGDG 0H HVWR\ PXGDQGR DOOtHVWDQRFKH 6SHQFHUVHYROYLyOLJHUDPHQWHFRQHOFHxRIUXQFLGR ³¢(VWiQKHFKDVODVUHQRYDFLRQHV"³/DVUHIRUPDVHQODFDVDGHODFLXGDGGH)LODGHOILD GH0HOLVVDSDUHFtDQQRWHQHUILQVHJXtDPHMRUDQGRORVGLVHxRV 0HOLVVDVHTXHGyPLUDQGRODDOIRPEUDGH%HUEHUFRORUFUHPDTXHVHH[WHQGtDHQHOSLVR GHOFXDUWRGH6SHQFHU

͹ͻ

³7HQJRTXHVDOLUGHDTXt³6HOHTXHEUyODYR]

ž‰‹ƒ

³¢(VWiWRGRELHQ"³SUHJXQWy6SHQFHU 0HOLVVDWLUyODVPDQJDVVREUHVXVPDQRV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³6t%LHQ 6SHQFHUVHPRYLyHQVXDVLHQWR+DEtDWUDWDGRGHKDEODUFRQ0HOLVVDVREUHHOFXHUSR GH,DQHQHOIXQHUDOGH1DQDHOGRPLQJRSHUR0HOLVVDVHPDQWXYRDSDUWiQGRODFRQOD PDQR6XKHUPDQDWHQtDTXHWHQHUDOJXQDVLGHDVDFHUFDGHHOORFXDQGR,DQIXHSXHVWR HQ OLEHUWDG EDMR DUUHVWR GRPLFLOLDULR 0HOLVVD KDEtD SDUHFLGR FRPSDVLYD SRU VX GLItFLO VLWXDFLyQ,QFOXVRKDEtDLQWHQWDGRFRQYHQFHUD6SHQFHUTXH,DQHUDLQRFHQWH7DOYH] DOLJXDOTXHODSROLFtDFUHtDTXHHOFXHUSRGH,DQQXQFDKDEtDHVWDGRDOOt6HUtDWtSLFR GH 0HOLVVD FRQILDU HQ XQ JUXSR GH SROLFtDV SRVLEOHPHQWH FRUUXSWRV DQWHV TXH HQ VX KHUPDQDWRGRSRUTXHQRTXHUtDDFHSWDUTXHVXDPDGRSRGUtDHVWDUPXHUWR ³5HDOPHQWH HVWR\ ELHQ ³LQVWy 0HOLVVD FRPR VL SXGLHUD OHHU ORV SHQVDPLHQWRV GH 6SHQFHU³ 6yOR TXH QR TXLHUR HVWDU DTXt VL YD D KDEHU JUXSRV GH E~VTXHGD \ IXUJRQHWDVGHQRWLFLDV ³3HUR ORV SROLFtDV QR HVWiQ EXVFDQGR PiV DTXt ³OH GLMR 6SHQFHU³ (OORV VyOR OR FDQFHODURQ 8QDH[SUHVLyQGHVRUSUHVDFUX]yHOURVWURGH0HOLVVD/XHJRVHHQFRJLyGHKRPEURV\ VHGLRODYXHOWDVLQUHVSRQGHU 6SHQFHUODHVFXFKyFDPLQDUSRUODVHVFDOHUDV /D SXHUWD SULQFLSDO VH FHUUy GH JROSH \ 6SHQFHU SXGR RtU D OD 6UD +DVWLQJV PXUPXUiQGROH FDOPDGD \ DPDEOHPHQWH D 0HOLVVD HQ HO YHVWtEXOR 6X YHUGDGHUD KLMD 6SHQFHU KL]R XQD PXHFD UHFRJLy VXV OLEURV VH PHWLy GHQWUR GH VX DEULJR \ ERWDV \ VDOLySRUODSXHUWDGHDWUiVDOJUDQHURGH0HOLVVD$OFUX]DUHOIUtRHLQPHQVRSDWLRVH GLRFXHQWDGHDOJRDODL]TXLHUGD\VHGHWXYR$OJXLHQKDEtDURFLDGR0(17,526$HQ HOPROLQRGHYLHQWRFRQODPLVPDSLQWXUDURMDTXHHOJUDIILWLHQHOJDUDMH8QSHJRWHGH FRORUURMRJRWHDEDGHVGHHOERUGHLQIHULRUGHOD/KDVWDODKLHUEDPXHUWD3DUHFtDFRPR VLHVWXYLHUDVDQJUDQGR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

0HOLVVDKDEtDGHMDGRHOJUDQHURFRQSULVD+DEtDXQDERWHOODGHYLQRDPHGLRWRPDUHQ HOPRVWUDGRU\XQYDVRGHDJXDPHGLROOHQRTXHVXKHUPDQDGHUHJLVWURSRUORJHQHUDO QR ODYDED 8QD JUDQ SDUWH GH VX URSD HVWDED WRGDYtD HQ HO DUPDULR \ KDEtD XQ JUDQ OLEUROODPDGR/RV3ULQFLSLRVGH)XVLRQHV\$GTXLVLFLRQHVDUURMDGRVREUHODFDPDFRQ XQPDUFDGRUGHOD8QLYHUVLGDGGH3HQVLOYDQLDVLWXDGRHQWUHODVSiJLQDV

ͺͲ

6SHQFHUYROYLyDPLUDUODFDVDFRQVLGHUDQGROXHJRSUHVLRQyVXVOLEURVFRQWUDHOSHFKR \ VLJXLy DGHODQWH 6XV SDGUHV OR YHUtDQ PX\ SURQWR 1R TXHUtD VHU OD TXH GLHUD ODV QRWLFLDV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

6SHQFHUVRSHVyVXEROVR0XOEHUU\GHFRORUFUHPDHQHOVRIiGHFXHURPDUUyQVDFyHO &' GHO FRPSDUWLPHQWR GHODQWHUR GH OD FRPSXWDGRUD GH VX SDGUH VH VHQWy HQ HO HVFULWRULRGH0HOLVVD\GHVOL]yHO&'HQODHQWUDGDGHOSRUWiWLOGHVXKHUPDQD (OGLVFRWDUGyXQSRFRHQFDUJDU\ 6SHQFHUKL]RFOLFHQHOFRUUHRHOHFWUyQLFRGHHOOD PLHQWUDVHVSHUDED(QODSDUWHVXSHULRUGHVXEDQGHMDGHHQWUDGDKDEtDXQPHQVDMHGH 2OLYLD&DOGZHOO6XPDGUHSRWHQFLDO 6SHQFHU VH OOHYy OD PDQR D OD ERFD \ DEULy HO PHQVDMH (UD XQ HQODFH D XQ EROHWR SUHSDJR HQ OD OtQHD $PWUDN $FHOD HO WUHQ EDOD D OD FLXGDG GH 1XHYD


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6SHQFHU PLUy HO GHVFRQRFLGR QRPEUH GH XVXDULR GH PHQVDMHUtD LQVWDQWiQHD 86&0HGLRFDPSR5R[[ ,DQ KDEtD LGR D OD 86& \ MXJDED HQ HO PHGLR FDPSR HQ HO I~WERO3HURHVRQRVLJQLILFDQDGD¢1R"

ͺͳ

2WUREOXS¢(VWiVDKt"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

/RVEOXSVVHJXtDQOOHJDQGR/DPHQWRKDEHUPHLGRVLQGHFLUWH«SHURHOORVPHRGLDEDQ6DEHV TXHVt 6H GLHURQ FXHQWD GH TXH \R VDEtD (V SRU HVR TXH WXYH TXH KXLU /DV PDQRV GH 6SHQFHU FRPHQ]DURQDWHPEODU$OJXLHQHVWDEDMXJDQGRFRQHOODFRPRORKDEtDQKHFKRFRQORV SDGUHVGHpO,DQQRKX\yeOHVWDEDPXHUWR 3HUR ¢SRU TXp QR KDEtD UDVWURV GH VXV UHVWRV HQ HO ERVTXH" ¢3RU TXp ORV SROLFtDV QR KDEtDQHQFRQWUDGRQLXQDVRODFRVD" 6SHQFHUDJLWyVXVGHGRVVREUHODVWHFODV'HPXHVWUDTXHHUHVUHDOPHQWHW~HVFULELyHOODVLQ PROHVWDUVHHQH[SOLFDUTXHQRHUD0HOLVVD&HUUyORVRMRVWUDWDQGRGHSHQVDUHQDOJR SHUVRQDOVREUH,DQ $OJRTXH0HOLVVD\6SHQFHUVDEUtDQ$OJRTXHWDPSRFRHVWXYLHUDHQHOGLDULRGH$OL /D SUHQVD KDEtD KHFKR XQD H[SRVLFLyQ GH WRGR OR TXH $OL KDEtD HVFULWR HQ VX GLDULR DFHUFDGH,DQFRPRODIRUPDHQTXH VHKDEtDQHQFRQWUDGRGHVSXpV GHXQSDUWLGRGH I~WERO HQ HO RWRxR GH VpSWLPR JUDGR FyPR ,DQ VH KDEtD DEDUURWDGR SDUD HO 6$7 XWLOL]DQGRXQDSDVWLOODGH5LWDOLQTXHOHKDEtDGDGRXQDPLJR\FyPRQRKDEtDHVWDGR VHJXUR GH UHDOPHQWH PHUHFHU VHU OODPDGR HO PHMRU MXJDGRU GHO HTXLSR GH I~WERO GH 5RVHZRRG'D\HOKHUPDQRGH$OL-DVRQHUDSRUOHMRVPiVWDOHQWRVR 4XLHQVHDTXHHVWXYLHUDSUHWHQGLHQGRVHU,DQVDEUtDWRGRHVR6LVyORSXGLHUDSHQVDUHQ DOJRV~SHUSULYDGR (QWRQFHVVHOHRFXUULy DOJRSHUIHFWR$OJRTXHHVWDEDEDVWDQWHVHJXUDGHTXHLQFOXVR $OLQRVDEtD ¢&XiOHVWXYHUGDGHURVHJXQGRQRPEUH"HVFULELyHOOD +XER XQD SDXVD 6SHQFHU VH HFKy KDFLD DWUiV HVSHUDQGR &XDQGR 0HOLVVD HUD XQD 6HQLRU HQ OD HVFXHOD VHFXQGDULD VH KDEtD HPERUUDFKDGR FRQ SRQFKH GH KXHYR HQ 1DYLGDG\FRQIHVyTXHORVSDGUHVGH,DQTXHUtDQTXHIXHUDXQDQLxD&XDQGROD6UD 7KRPDVGLRDOX]DXQPXFKDFKRGHFLGLHURQTXHVXVHJXQGRQRPEUHVHUtDHOQRPEUH GHODQLxDTXHKDEtDQHOHJLGRSDUDpO,DQQXQFDQLXQDYH]ORXWLOL]DEDHQORVYLHMRV DQXDULRV GH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ TXH 6SHQFHU KDEtD KRMHDGR FXDQGR HUD HGLWRUD GHO DQXDULRpOQLVLTXLHUDKDEtDOLVWDGRXQDLQLFLDOGHOVHJXQGRQRPEUH

ͺʹ

+XERXQEOXS(OL]DEHWKGHFtDHOPHQVDMH

ž‰‹ƒ

6SHQFHUSDUSDGHyFRQIXHU]D(VWRQRHUDSRVLEOH



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

/D OX] GH OD FRFLQD GH OD FDVD SULQFLSDO VH DSDJy HQYROYLHQGR HO SDWLR WUDVHUR HQ OD RVFXULGDG 8Q FRFKH DUUHPHWLy UXLGRVDPHQWH VREUH HO SDYLPHQWR PRMDGR (QWRQFHV 6SHQFHU HPSH]y D RtU UXLGRV 8Q VXVSLUR 8Q UHVRSOLGR 8QD ULVLWD 6DOWy \ DSUHWy OD IUHQWHFRQWUDHOJUXHVRYLGULRIUtR (O SRUFKH HVWDED YDFLy 1R KDEtD VRPEUDV QL HQ OD SLVFLQD QL HQ HO MDFX]]L QL HQ OD SODWDIRUPD 1R KDEtD QDGLH DUUDVWUiQGRVH FHUFD GHO PROLQR GH YLHQWR DXQTXH OD SDODEUD0(17,526$UHFLpQSLQWDGDSDUHFtDEULOODU 6X FDPDUDGD ]XPEy 6SHQFHU VDOWy FRQ HO FRUD]yQ JROSHWHDQGR 0LUy GH QXHYR OD FRPSXWDGRUD ,DQVHKDEtDGHVFRQHFWDGRGHOD0HQVDMHUtD,QVWDQWiQHD 8QQXHYRPHQVDMHGHWH[WR&RQPDQRVWHPEORURVDV6SHQFHUSUHVLRQy/HHU

ž‰‹ƒ

ͺ͵

4XHULGD6SHQFH&XDQGRWHGLMHTXHpOVHWHQtDTXHLUQRPHUHIHUtDDPRULU$XQDVtKD\DOJR PX\ LPSUHFLVR HQ HVWH FDVR \ WH FRUUHVSRQGH D WL DYHULJXDU OR TXH HV $Vt TXH PHMRU SRQWH D DYHULJXDURODVLJXLHQWH´GHVDSDUHFLGDµVHUiVW~£$XUHYRLU³$ 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR $OJRHVWiLQFRPSOHWRYHUGDG $OJRHVWiLQFRPSOHWRYHUGDG 7UDGXFLGRSRU$QHOLVVH &RUUHJLGRSRU/RR  

$

OD PDxDQD VLJXLHQWH (PLO\ FLxy OD FDSXFKD GH VX DSUHWDGR DQRUDN D]XO SiOLGR \ FRUULy SRU HO DVIDOWR KHODGR EDODQFHiQGRPH KDFLD OD HVFXHOD HOHPHQWDOGH5RVHZRRG'D\HOOXJDUGHUHXQLyQSUHIHULGRGHVXVDPLJDV3RU SULPHUDYH]HQWRGDODVHPDQDHOODUJRFDPLQRGHHQWUDGDHVWDEDOLEUHGHIXUJRQHWDV GHQRWLFLDV'HVGHDKRUDWRGRHOPXQGRSHQVDEDTXH(PLO\\ODVGHPiVVHORKDEtDQ PRQWDGRSDUDYHUHOFXHUSRGH,DQHQHOERVTXHODSUHQVDQRWHQtDSRUTXpHQWUHYLVWDU DORVHVWXGLDQWHV $O RWUR ODGR GHO SDWLR ODV DPLJDV GH (PLO\ HVWDEDQ UHXQLGDV DOUHGHGRU GH 6SHQFHU PLUDQGR D XQD KRMD GH SDSHO GHO RUGHQDGRU \ VX WHOpIRQR PyYLO $QRFKH 6SHQFHU KDEtD OODPDGR (PLO\ SDUD GHFLUOH TXH ,DQ OH KDEtD HQYLDGR XQ ,0  \ TXH ´$µ KDEtD HQYLDGRXQWH[WR'HVSXpV(PLO\QRKDEtDSRGLGRSHJDURMR$VtTXH´$µHVWDEDGH YXHOWD<,DQWDOYH]QRHVWXYLHUDPXHUWR $OJROHJROSHyGXURHOKRPEUR\(PLO\VHGLRODYXHOWDFRQHOFRUD]yQVDOWDQGRDOD JDUJDQWD(UD VyORXQ QLxRGHSULPDULDHPSXMDQGR PiVDOOiGHHOOD FRUULHQGRSRUHO FDPSRGHSHORWD3XVRXQDPDQRHQODRWUDSDUDWUDWDUGHTXHGHMDUDGHWHPEODU6XV PDQRVKDEtDQHVWDGRWHPEODQGRFRPRORFDVWRGDODPDxDQD

³(QFDMD ³URQFy 6SHQFHU³ ,DQ ILQJLy HVWDU PXHUWR \ pO QRV OODPy D ORV ERVTXHV SRUTXHVDEtDTXHLUtDPRVDODSROLFtD\OHGLUtDPRVTXHORYLPRV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

+DQQDHQYXHOWDHQXQDEULJRGHODQDEODQFR\XQDEXIDQGDGHSLHOVLQWpWLFDDO]yORV KRPEURV (O ~QLFR FRORU HQ VX URVWUR HUDQ ORV RMRV HQURMHFLGRV SDUHFtD TXH QR KDEtD GRUPLGRPXFKRODQRFKHDQWHULRUWDPSRFR$ULDFRQXQDILQDFKDTXHWDGHFXHURJULV TXHVHYHtDWUHQG\\JXDQWHVYHUGHVVLQGHGRVQHJyFRQODFDEH]DVLQGHFLUQDGD(OOD QROOHYDEDHOEULOODQWHPDTXLOODMHKDELWXDO,QFOXVROLPSLDFRPRXQDSDWHQD6SHQFHUVH YHtDGHVDOLxDGD«VXSHORHVWDEDJUDVRVRFRQXQDDEXOWDGDFRODGHFDEDOOR

ͺͶ

³¢&yPRSXGR,DQKDEHUILQJLGRVXPXHUWH"³VROWy(PLO\FXDQGROOHJyHOFtUFXOR³ 7RGDVORYLPRVeOSDUHFtDD]XO

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

$ULDVHVHQWyHQXQRGHORVFROXPSLRV ³3HUR¢SRUTXp,DQVLPSOHPHQWHQRFRUULy"¢3RUTXpLEDDPRQWDUXQHVSHFWiFXORSRU QRVRWUDV" ³&XDQGR OD SROLFtD GHVFXEULy TXH KDEtD GHVDSDUHFLGR FRPHQ]DURQ OD E~VTXHGD GH LQPHGLDWR³H[SOLFy6SHQFHU³3HURFXDQGRYLPRVVXFXHUSRHQVXOXJDUYROYLHURQVX DWHQFLyQDORVERVTXHV/RVGLVWUDMRSRUDOJXQRVGtDVHOWLHPSRVXILFLHQWHSDUDTXH,DQ UHDOPHQWH SXGLHUD HVFDSDU 3UREDEOHPHQWH KLFLPRV H[DFWDPHQWH OR TXH pO TXHUtD TXH KLFLpUDPRV³0LUyKDFLDODVQXEHVFRQXQDH[SUHVLyQLPSRWHQWHHQVXURVWUR +DQQDVHKXQGLyHQVXFDGHUDL]TXLHUGD ³¢4XpFUHHVTXHWLHQHDYHU´$µFRQHVWR"´$µQRVVXPHUJHHQHOERVTXHSRUORTXH tEDPRVDYHUD,DQ´$µHVWiREYLDPHQWHWUDEDMDQGRFRQpO ³(VWH WH[WR KDFH TXH VHD EDVWDQWH REYLR TXH ,DQ \ ´$µ HVWDEDQ GH DFXHUGR ³GLMR 6SHQFHU HPSXMDQGR VX WHOpIRQR KDFLD HOODV³ (PLO\ OHH GH QXHYR ODV GRV SULPHUDV OtQHDV&XDQGR\RGLMHTXHpOWHQtDTXHLU\RQRTXHUtDGHFLUTXHWXYLHUDTXHPRULU6LQHPEDUJR KD\DOJRPX\HVTXHPiWLFRHQHVWHFDVR\WHWRFDDWLDYHULJXDUORTXHHV³(OODVHPRUGLy GXUDPHQWHHOODELRDFRQWLQXDFLyQPLUyDODGLDSRVLWLYDHQIRUPDGHGUDJyQGHWUiVGH HOORV+DFtDDxRVFXDQGRDOJRRDOJXLHQHQODHVFXHODODDVXVWDEDVHHVFRQGtDGHQWUR GHODFDEH]DGHOGUDJyQHQODSDUWHVXSHULRUKDVWDTXHVHVHQWtDPHMRU(OODVLQWLyXQD DEUXPDGRUDQHFHVLGDGGHKDFHUHVRDKRUD ³3DUHFH TXH ´$µ D\XGy D ,DQ D TXHEUDUVH ³FRQWLQXy 6SHQFHU³ (OORV WUDEDMDURQ MXQWRVFXDQGR,DQVHUHXQLyFRQPLJRHQPLSRUFKHWUDVHURODVHPDQDSDVDGR´$µPH DPHQD]y GH TXH VL VH OR GHFtD D ORV SROLFtDV PH ODVWLPDUtD 6L \R OHV KXELHUD GLFKR KXELHUDGHWHQLGRD,DQGHQXHYR\QRSRGUtDKDEHUHVFDSDGR ³´$µ HVWDED SUHRFXSDGR DFHUFD GH FXDOTXLHUD GH QRVRWURV GLMHUD QDGD ³(PLO\ KLOR KDFLDDUULED³7RGDVPLVQRWDVGLMRTXHVL\RQRGHFtDHOVHFUHWRGH´$µ´$µQRGLUtD HOPtR +DQQDPLUyD(PLO\FRQXQDFXULRVDVRQULVDHQORVODELRV

(PLO\ VH HQFRJLy GH KRPEURV 'XUDQWH XQ WLHPSR ´$µ VH EXUOy GH (PLO\ DFHUFD GH FyPRHOODKDEtDPDQWHQLGRVXVH[XDOLGDGGH,VDDF

ž‰‹ƒ

³


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͺͷ

³¢(VWH´$µVDEHDOJXQRVVHFUHWRVDFHUFDGHWL"



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(PLO\VDFXGLyODFDEH]D ³/RVWH[WRVQRHUDQGH,DQ/DSROLFtDUHYLVyVXWHOpIRQR ³(OKHFKRGHTXHODV QRWDVGH´$µQROOHJDUDQGHVGHHOWHOpIRQRGH,DQQRVLJQLILFD TXHQRSURYLQLHUDQGH,DQ³OHUHFRUGy+DQQD³eOSRGUtDKDEHUWHQLGRRWUDSHUVRQD SDUDHQYLDUORV2SRGUtDKDEHUFRQVHJXLGRXQPyYLOGHVHFKDEOHRXQWHOpIRQRFRQRWUR QRPEUH (PLO\VHOOHYyXQGHGRDORVODELRV1RKDEtDSHQVDGRHQHVR ³<WRGRVORVWUXFRVTXHpOWLUyGHODQRFKHHQTXHVXSXHVWDPHQWHYLPRVVXFXHUSRVRQ EDVWDQWHIiFLOHVVLVDEHVFyPRXVDUXQHTXLSR³FRQWLQXy+DQQD³,DQSUREDEOHPHQWH GHVFXEULy OD PDQHUD GH UHWUDVDU HO HQYtR GH XQ WH[WR SDUD TXH IXHUD SDUD QRVRWURV HO PRPHQWR HQ TXH YLPRV OR TXH SDUHFtD VX FXHUSR PXHUWR ¢5HFXHUGDV FyPR 0RQD HQYLyXQHPDLOGH´$µHFKiQGRQRV"3UREDEOHPHQWHQRHVWDQGLItFLO 6SHQFHUVHxDOyHOSHGD]RGHSDSHOGHORUGHQDGRU(UDXQDLPSUHVLyQGHOLQWHUFDPELR GHPHQVDMHUtDLQVWDQWiQHDHQWUHHOODH,DQ ³0LUDHVWR³GLMRVHxDODQGRDODVOtQHDVTXHGHFtDQ0HRGLDURQ6HGLHURQFXHQWDTXH\R VDEtD(VRIXHSRUORTXHWXYHTXHKXLU³,DQVHPDUFKyDQWHVGHTXHSXGLHUDSHGLUTXLpQHV IXHURQ´HOORVµ3HUR¢\VLHVWRHVPXFKRPiVJUDQGHTXHODSODQLILFDFLyQGHXQDYtDGH HVFDSHGH,DQ"¢4XpSDVDVL,DQUHDOPHQWHVDEtDDOJRJUDQGHVREUHHODVHVLQDWRGH$OL" ¢<VLVHSHQVDEDTXHVLLEDDMXLFLRDOH[SOLFDUORTXHVDEtDTXHVHUtDDVHVLQDGR")LQJLU VX SURSLD PXHUWH QR DFDEDED GH FRQVHJXLU D ORV SROLFtDV GHWUiV GH VX HVSDOGD VH VXSRQtDTXHpOTXLVLHUDKDFHUOHGDxRDVXHVSDOGDWDPELpQ $ULDGHMyGHSLYRWHDU ³¢&UHHV TXH pO TXH IXH GHWUiV GH ,DQ SRGUtD YHQLU GHVSXpV SRU QRVRWUDV VL TXHUHPRV VDEHUGHPDVLDGR" ³(VR HV OR TXH SDUHFH ³GLMR 6SHQFHU³ 3HUR KD\ DOJR PiV ³6HxDOy XQDV SRFDV OtQHDVGHWH[WRHQODSDUWHLQIHULRUGHODKRMDLPSUHVDSRURUGHQDGRU(UDODGLUHFFLyQ ,3 GH GRQGH SURFHGtDQ GH PHQVDMHV LQVWDQWiQHRV³ (VWR QRV GLFH TXH ,DQ QRV HQYLy PHQVDMHVLQVWDQWiQHRVGHVGHDOJ~QOXJDUGH5RVHZRRG

ͺ͸

³¢5RVHZRRG"³JULWy$ULD³¢4XLHUHVGHFLUTXHWRGDYtDHVWiDTXt"

ž‰‹ƒ

/DFDUDGH+DQQDSDOLGHFLy ³¢3RUTXp,DQVHTXHGDUtDDTXt"¢3RUTXpQRLEDDVDOLUGHODFLXGDG"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³7DOYH]pOQRKDFHODE~VTXHGDGHODYHUGDG³VXJLULy6SHQFHU ³2WDOYH]QRORKDFHFRQQRVRWUDVSDUDJLUDUORHQpO³GLMR$ULD (PLO\ HVFXFKy XQ JULWR \ VDOWy GHWUiV GH HOOD 8Q FXHUYR IXH OHQWDPHQWH URGHDQGR HO SDWLRGHUHFUHR&XDQGRVHGLRODYXHOWDGHQXHYRDVXVDPLJDVVXVRMRVHVWDEDQPX\ DELHUWRV\VXVPDQGtEXODVHVWDEDQWHQVDV ³$ULD HVWi HQ OR FLHUWR ³GLMR +DQQD UHFRJHU XQD FRSLD GH VHJXULGDG GH OD FRQYHUVDFLyQ³ 6L ,DQ HVWi YLYR QR VDEHPRV OR TXH SDVD eO WRGDYtD SRGUtD HVWDU GHWUiVGHQRVRWUDV<WRGDYtDSRGUtDVHUFXOSDEOH ³1RVp³SURWHVWy6SHQFHU (PLO\VHHQIUHQWyD6SHQFHUFRQIXQGLGD ³£3HUROHGLMHDODSROLFtDTXHHUDpO¢4XpSDVDFRQHVDPHPRULDTXHWHQLDVGHTXH$OL VHKDEtDYLVWRFRQ,DQHQODQRFKHHQTXHPXULy" 6SHQFHUPHWLyODVPDQRVHQORVEROVLOORVGHVXDEULJR ³1RHVWR\VHJXURGHVL\RPHDFXHUGRRVLHUDMXVWRORTXH\RTXHUtDFUHHU (O HVWyPDJR GH (PLO\ TXHPy ¢4Xp HUD YHUGDG \ TXH QR OR HUD" 0LUy D WUDYpV GHO SDWLR GH UHFUHR 8Q JUXSR GH HVWXGLDQWHV PDUFKDEDQ SRU OD DFHUD HQ HO DOD GH VH[WR JUDGR0iVHVWXGLDQWHVSDVDURQIUHQWHDODODUJDILODGHYHQWDQDVGHODXODDSLHKDFLDHO DUPDULR GH ORV DEULJRV (PLO\ VH KDEtD ROYLGDGR GH TXH DOXPQRV GH VH[WR JUDGR QR WHQtDQ ORV DUPDULRV DGHFXDGRV \ WXYLHURQ TXH SRQHU VXV FRVDV HQ FXEtFXORV HQ HVH SHTXHxR JXDUGDUURSD (O JXDUGDUURSD XWLOL]D SDUD FRQVHJXLU TXH DSHVWDUDV D PHGLD PDxDQDROLHQGRDDOPXHU]RVHQEROVDVGHWRGRHOPXQGR

ͺ͹

³&XDQGR,DQPHKDEOyHQPLSRUFKHGHDWUiVPHGLMRTXHHVWDEDHTXLYRFDGD«TXH QRPDWyD$OL³FRQWLQXy6SHQFHU³1RKXELHUDKHFKRGDxRDXQSHORHQODFDEH]D GH$OLeO\$OLVLHPSUHFRTXHWHDURQSHURHOODIXHODTXHORDXPHQWyDOVLJXLHQWHQLYHO ,DQSHQVySRUXQPRPHQWRTXHORHVWDEDKDFLHQGRSDUDKDFHUTXHDOJXLHQVHHQRMDUD $OSULQFLSLR\RSHQVpTXHTXHUtDGHFLUDPt«SRUTXHHUDXQDFODVHGHTXHPHJXVWDED 3HUR,DQQRVHSDUHFtDDFRPSUDUHVDWHRUtD<ODQRFKHHQODTXHHOODPXULypOYLRD GRVUXELDVHQHOERVTXH«XQDHUD$OLODVHJXQGDHUDRWUDSHUVRQD(QHVHPRPHQWR \RSHQVDEDTXHVLJQLILFDEDTXHHUD\R3HURGLMRTXHWDOYH]HUDDOJXLHQPiV

ž‰‹ƒ

(PLO\VXVSLUyIUXVWUDGD ³9DPRVSRUODSDODEUDGH,DQGHQXHYR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³6t6SHQFH³+DQQDDUUXJyODQDUL]³,DQPDWyD$OL/XHJRQRVHQJDxy'HEHPRV LUD:LOGHQFRQORVPHQVDMHVLQVWDQWiQHRV'HMDUTXHOLGLDUDQFRQHVR 6SHQFHUUHVRSOy ³¢:LOGHQ"+DKHFKRXQEXHQWUDEDMRHQFRQYHQFHUDWRGRVGH5RVHZRRGTXHHVWDPRV ORFDV,QFOXVRVLSRUXQPLODJURTXHQRQRVFUHDQDGLHPiVHQODIXHU]DGHSROLFtD ³¢4Xp SDVD FRQ ORV SDGUHV GH ,DQ" ³VXJLULy (PLO\³ (OORV WLHQHQ XQD QRWD GH pO WDPELpQ(OORVQRVFUHHUtDQ 6SHQFHUVHxDOyTXHRWUDOtQHDHQHOLQWHUFDPELRGHPHQVDMHVLQVWDQWiQHRV ³6t ¢SHUR OR KDUtDQ" 6XV SDGUHV WLHQHQ XQD SUXHED PiV GH TXH ,DQ HVWi YLYR SHUR SXHGHQGHFLUOHVDORVSROLFtDVTXHVXVPHQVDMHVLQVWDQWiQHRVYLQLHURQGHXQHTXLSRGH 5RVHZRRG'D\<DFRQWLQXDFLyQORVSROLFtDVOHUDVWUHDUtDQ\ORGHWHQGUtDQGHQXHYR ³/RFXiOVHUtDXQDFRVDEXHQD³OHUHFRUGy(PLO\ 6SHQFHUOHGLULJLyXQDPLUDGDLPSRWHQWH ³¢<VLHVWRHVXQDSUXHED"6XSyQTXHOHGHFLPRVDODSROLFtDRDVXVSDGUHV\DOJR QRV SDVD D XQD GH QRVRWUDV ¢< VL DOJR OH VXFHGH D 0HOLVVD" ,DQ SHQVy TXH HVWDED HQYLiQGROHPHQVDMHVLQVWDQWiQHRVDHOODGHVSXpVGHWRGR³6SHQFHUVHIURWyODVPDQRV MXQWDVFRQORVJXDQWHV³0HOLVVD\\RQRQRVOOHYDPRVELHQSHURQRTXLHURSRQHUODHQ SHOLJUR $ULDVHEDMyGHOFROXPSLR\DJDUUyWHOpIRQRGH6SHQFHU\PLUyDOWH[WRGH´$µ ³(Q HVWD QRWD VH GLFH TXH DKRUD QRV WRFD D QRVRWUDV HQWHQGHUOR R YDPRV D VHU ODV SUy[LPDV ³¢4XpVLJQLILFD"³(PLO\VDFyODERWDHQXQSDUFKHGHQLHYH ³7HQHPRV TXH GHPRVWUDU TXLpQ HV HO YHUGDGHUR DVHVLQR GH $OL ³FRQWHVWy $ULD DO SUREOHPDFRQWRGDQDWXUDOLGDG³2ORTXHVHD

+DQQDVROWyXQEXILGR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³¢4XLpQRGLDEDD,DQ"³(PLO\VHUDVFyODFDEH]D³7RGRHOPXQGRHQ5RVHZRRGOR DGRUDED

ͺͺ

³¢&UHHVTXHHODVHVLQRHVODSHUVRQD«RSHUVRQDV«HQORVPHQVDMHVLQVWDQWiQHRVGH ,DQ" ³SUHJXQWy 6SHQFHU³ ¢/D JHQWH TXH OR RGLDED" ¢/RV TXH VH HQWHUDURQ GH TXH VDEtD"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³&KLFDVHVWRHVUHWDUGDGR
ž‰‹ƒ

(PLO\ PLUy HQ OHWUDV GH LPSUHQWD HO VLJQR £(/ 7,(032 '( /$ &É368/$ (67É $48Ì¢+$6&20(1=$'278%Ó648('$"

ͺͻ

³6tFODUR³GLMRVXDPLJDXQDQLxDSHTXHxDGH$VLDFRQXQDFRODGHFDEDOORDOWD³ 1XQFDODILJXUDUiVHQHVDVSLVWDV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢5HFXHUGDVFyPRHVWDEDWRGRHOPXQGRHPRFLRQDGRSRU/D&iSVXODGHO7LHPSRHO SULPHU DxR TXH IXLPRV FDSDFHV GH MXJDU" ³PXUPXUy +DQQD PLUDQGR WDPELpQ D ODV FKLFDV $ULDVHxDOyORVEDVWLGRUHVGHODVELFLFOHWDVFHUFDGHODHQWUDGDGHVH[WRJUDGR ³$KtIXHGRQGH$OLDQXQFLyTXHVDEtDGyQGHHVWDEDXQDGHODVSLH]DV ³(VR IXH WDQ PROHVWR ³JLPLy 6SHQFHU KDFLHQGR XQD PXHFD³ (QJDxy« -DVRQ OH GLMRGyQGHHVWDED1LVLTXLHUDWXYRTXHUHVROYHUODVSLVWDV(VSRUHVRTXHTXHUtDUREDU ODSLH]DGH$OL«\RQRFUHRTXHVHODPHUHFLHUD ³([FHSWRTXHW~QROOHJDVWHDUREiUVHOD³FDQWXUUHy+DQQD³3RUTXHDOJXLHQODUREy SULPHUR<QXQFDYDPRVDHQFRQWUDUTXLpQIXH $ULD WRVLy UXLGRVDPHQWH 7LUy HO DJXD HPERWHOODGD GH VX ERFD 7RGDV VH YROYLHURQ D PLUDUOD ³(VWR\ELHQ³OHVDVHJXUyVLOEDQGR /DFDPSDQDGHODHVFXHODVHFXQGDULDVRQy\ODVFKLFDVVHVHSDUDURQ6SHQFHUVHDOHMy UiSLGDPHQWHVLQDSHQDVGHVSHGLUVH +DQQD VH TXHGy WRFDQGR VX L3KRQH (PLO\ FD\y HQ HO SDVR FRQ $ULD 'XUDQWH XQ WLHPSRHO~QLFRVRQLGRHUDHOFUXMLGRGHVXV]DSDWRVDWUDYpVGHODFRUWH]DKHODGDGHOD QLHYHVREUHORVELHQHVFRPXQHV(PLO\VHSUHJXQWyVL$ULDHVWDEDSHQVDQGRORPLVPR TXH HOOD« ¢3RGUtD ,DQ HVWDU GLFLHQGR OD YHUGDG" ¢+DEtD DOJXLHQ PiV GHWUiV GHO DVHVLQDWRGH$OL" ³1XQFDFUHHUiVDTXLpQPHHQFRQWUpD\HU³GLMR$ULD³$-DVRQ'L/DXUHQWLV (PLO\VHGHWXYRHQVHFR6XFRUD]yQHPSH]yDODWLUFRQIXHU]D ³¢'yQGH" $ULDDQXGyVXSDxXHORFRQPiVIXHU]DDSDUHQWHPHQWHGHVSUHRFXSDGD ³&RUWpODHVFXHOD-DVRQHVWDEDHVSHUDQGRHOWUHQGH)LODGHOILD

ž‰‹ƒ

³9L D -DVRQ WDPELpQ HO RWUR GtD ³HOOD DFRSLy FRQ VX YR] URQFD³


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͻͲ

8QDUiIDJDGHYLHQWRDUUHFLyIXUWLYDPHQWHSRUHOFXHOORGHODFDPLVDGH(PLO\



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢4XpTXLHUHVGHFLU" (PLO\MXJXHWHyFRQORVELOOHWHVGHUHPRQWHGHHVTXtTXHVHFRORFDEDQHQODFUHPDOOHUD GH VX FKDTXHWD (OOD VRVSHFKD TXH $ULD OR XVDED SDUD JXVWDU D -DVRQ \ RGLDED D OD JHQWHKDEODUDPDO3RURWUDSDUWH$ULDQHFHVLWDEDVDEHU ³%XHQR FRPR JULWDUPH SRU XQ WLHPSR < OXHJR VH DEDODQ]y VREUH Pt FRPR VL PH IXHUDDSHUIRUDU ³¢$EROODVWHVXFRFKH" ³,QFOXVRVLORKLFLHUDHUDSHTXHxR'HILQLWLYDPHQWHQRYDOtDODSHQDIOLSDUDFHUFDGH HOOR $ULDPHWLyODVPDQRVHQORVEROVLOORV ³-DVRQDKRUDPLVPRHVWiSUREDEOHPHQWHPX\VHQVLEOH1RPHSXHGRLPDJLQDUORTXH HVWRGHEHVHUSDUDpO ³(VR HV OR TXH \R SHQVDED WDPELpQ SHUR ³(PLO\ VH DSDJy PLUDQGR SUHRFXSDGDPHQWH D $ULD³ 7HQ FXLGDGR ¢GH DFXHUGR" 5HFXHUGD OR TXH GLMR -HQQD $OL GLMR TXH KDEtD ´SUREOHPDVµ FRQ -DVRQ 3RGUtD KDEHU HVWDGR DEXVDQGR GH $OL DO LJXDOFRPR7RE\HVWDEDDEXVDQGRGH-HQQD ³1RVDEHPRVVLHVRHVFLHUWR³ODGUy$ULDFRQORVRMRVRVFXUHFLpQGRVHOH³$OLTXHUtD VDEHUVHFUHWRVDFHUFDGH-HQQD\7RE\(OODVHORGLMRSDUDTXH-HQQDQRKDEODUD-DVRQ QRHUDPiVTXHGXOFHFRQ$OL



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

'HKHFKRDKRUDTXHORSHQVDEDODSULPHUDYH]TXH(PLO\KDEtDYLVWRHQVXYLGDD$OL -DVRQHVWDEDEURPHiQGROH)XHXQRVGtDVDQWHVGHHPSH]DUHOWHUFHUJUDGR\(PLO\\ VX PDGUH HVWDEDQ HQ OD WLHQGD GH FRPHVWLEOHV VDFDQGR FDMDV GH MXJR \ EROVDV GH 'RULWRV PLQL SDUD ORV DOPXHU]RV HVFRODUHV 8QD JXDSD FKLFD UXELD VREUH OD HGDG GH (PLO\OLPLWDEDGLUHFWDPHQWHPiVDOOiGHHOODVVDOWDQGRSRUHOSDVLOORGHORVFHUHDOHV +DEtDDOJRLQWR[LFDQWHGHHOODSUREDEOHPHQWHSRUTXHHUDHYLGHQWHWRGRORLQWURYHUWLGD TXH(PLO\QRHUD

ͻͳ

(PLO\ PLUy KDFLD RWUR ODGR PLUDQGR ILMDPHQWH DO DVWD GH OD EDQGHUD DO ILQDO GH ORV ELHQHV FRPXQHV GH OD HVFXHOD 1R HVWDED WDQ VHJXUD VREUH HVR 5HFRUGDED ORV JULWRV SURFHGHQWHV GHO LQWHULRU GH OD FDVD GH $OL HO GtD HQ TXH VH KDEtD FRODGR HQ HO SDWLR WUDVHURGHODFDVDGH$OLSDUDUREDUVXEDQGHUDGH/D&iSVXODGHO7LHPSR$OJXLHQVH PDQWHQtD LPLWDQGR OD YR] GH $OL < OXHJR KXER HO VRQLGR GH XQD UXSWXUD \ XQ UXLGR VRUGR FRPR VL DOJXLHQ KXELHUD VLGR HPSXMDGR -DVRQ VDOLy GH OD FDVD PRPHQWRV GHVSXpVFRQVXFDUDURMRIXHJR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

9LHURQ D OD QLxD GH QXHYR HQ OD VHFFLyQ GH DOLPHQWRV FRQJHODGRV PLUDQGR HQ FDGD FDVRWUDWDQGRGHGHFLGLUORTXHTXHUtD 6X PDGUH DUUDVWUDED XQ FDUUR \ XQ QLxR SUREDEOHPHQWH DOUHGHGRU GH FDWRUFH DxRV VHJXLGDPLUDQGRXQD*DPH%R\ ³0DPi ¢SRGHPRV WHQHU (JJRV" ³OORULTXHy OD QLxD DEULHQGR XQD SXHUWD GHO FRQJHODGRUFRQVXJUDQVRQULVD\PRVWUDQGRORVGLHQWHV(ODGROHVFHQWHSXVRRMRV³ 0DPi¢SRGHPRVWHQHU(JJRV"³,PLWyVXYR]DJXGD\PHGLD <DOLJXDOTXHODFKLFDVHDEODQGy6XODELRLQIHULRUWHPEOy\FHUUyODSXHUWDFRQXQ JROSHGHVFRUD]RQDGR /DPDGUHDJDUUyHOEUD]RGHOPXFKDFKR ³7~ VDEHV VHU PHMRU ³(O PXFKDFKR VH HQFRJLy GH KRPEURV \ VH GHMy FDHU SHUR (PLO\SHQVDEDTXHPHUHFtDVHUJULWDGR$UUXLQyODGLYHUVLyQGHODQLxDVLPSOHPHQWH SRUTXH SRGtD 8QRV GtDV PiV WDUGH FXDQGR FRPHQ]y HO WHUFHU JUDGR (PLO\ VH GLR FXHQWDGHTXHODFKLFDGHODWLHQGDKDEtDVLGR$OL(UDQXHYDHQ5RVHZRRG'D\SHUR HUDWDQERQLWD\EXUEXMHDQWHTXHWRGRHOPXQGRDOLQVWDQWHTXHUtDVHQWDUVHDVXODGRHQ ODDOIRPEUDGXUDQWHHOPRVWUDU\FRQWDU(UDGLItFLOFUHHUTXHQDGDODSRQGUtDWULVWH (PLO\ SDWHy XQD EROD GH QLHYH KHODGD SRU OD DFHUD HQ VLOHQFLR GHEDWLHQGR VL GHEtD GHFLUOH HVWR D $ULD 6LQ HPEDUJR DQWHV GH TXH SXGLHUD $ULD PXUPXUy XQ ODFyQLFR DGLyV\VHGLULJLyUiSLGDPHQWHKDFLDHODODGHFLHQFLDVFRQODVERUODVHQORVH[WUHPRV GHVXVRPEUHURRUHMHUDUHERWDQGR 6XVSLUDQGR (PLO\ VXELy OHQWDPHQWH ODV HVFDOHUDV KDFLD VX FDVLOOHUR HVTXLYDQGR D XQ ODGRGHXQPRQWyQGHFKLFRVPiVMyYHQHVGHOHTXLSRGHOXFKDOLEUHTXHVHGLULJtDQSRU ODV HVFDOHUDV HQ OD RWUD GLUHFFLyQ 6t KDEtD DSUHQGLGR TXH $OL WHQtD XQD PDQHUD GH PDQLSXODUDODJHQWHSDUDREWHQHUVXVVHFUHWRV<VtSRGtDDGPLWLUTXH$OLKDEtDWHQLGR XQDOtQHDGHVDJUDGDEOH«(PLO\KDEtDVLGRYtFWLPDGHHOODWDPELpQVREUHWRGRFXDQGR $OLEURPHyD(PLO\IUHQWHDODVGHPiVDFHUFDGHODYH]TXHODEHVyHQODFDVDGHOiUERO 3HUR -HQQD QR HUD SRSXODU QR HUD DPLJD GH $OL \ QR WHQtD QDGD TXH $OL QHFHVLWDUD &ODURTXH$OLHUDPDODSHURSRUORJHQHUDOKDEtDXQJUDQRGHYHUGDGHQORTXHGLMR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6HGLRODYXHOWDPLUDQGRDODLQXQGDFLyQGHHVWXGLDQWHVTXHFDPLQDEDQSRUHOSDVLOOR GHO DXOD 8QD FKLFD IDPLOLDU QDGy D OD YLVWD (UD QDGD PHQRV TXH -HQQD &DYDQDXJK (VWDEDGHSLHHQHOXPEUDOGHODXODGH4XtPLFD,,FRQVXSHUURSHUGLJXHURGHRURJXtD

ͻʹ

(PLO\ VH GHWXYR IUHQWH D VX FDVLOOHUR 0LHQWUDV FROJDED VX DEULJR R\y XQD SHTXHxD ULVLWDGHWUiVGHHOOD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

DVXODGR/DSLHOGH(PLO\VHDUUDVWUy(UDFRPRVLFRQVyORSHQVDUDFHUFDGH-HQQD (PLO\ODKXELHUDFRQMXUDGR 8QD VRPEUD VH PRYLy GHWUiV GH -HQQD \ OD H[QRYLD GH (PLO\ 0D\D 6W *HUPDLQ DSDUHFLyWDPELpQHQODSXHUWD (PLO\ DSHQDV KDEtD KDEODGR FRQ 0D\D \D TXH KDEtD URWR FXDQGR KDEtD DWUDSDGR D 0D\DEHVDQGRD7ULVWDXQDFKLFDTXHKDEtDFRQRFLGRFXDQGRVXVSDGUHVODHQYLDURQD YLYLU FRQ VX WtD \ WtR HQ 1HZ


ž‰‹ƒ

ͻ͵

*ROSHDQGR OD SXHUWD GH VX WDTXLOOD GXUDPHQWH (PLO\ FRUUHWHy SRU HO SDVLOOR VLQ QL VLTXLHUD UHFXSHUDUORVOLEURVTXHQHFHVLWDSDUD VXVFODVHVGHOD PDxDQD&XDQGRPLUy SRU HQFLPD GHO KRPEUR 0D\D HVWi PHQHDQGR VXV GHGRV $GLyV 0D\D PXUPXUD GUDPiWLFDPHQWH FRQ ORV RMRV FKLVSHDQWHV GH PDOLFLD \ GLYHUVLyQ FRPR VL VXSLHUD H[DFWDPHQWHORPXFKRTXHHVWDEDKDFLHQGRTXH(PLO\VHUHWXHU]D



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR (OEHEpPiVHQJDODQDGRGH5RVHZRRG (OEHEpPiVHQJDODQDGRGH5RVHZRRG 7UDGXFLGRSRUNLNL &RUUHJLGRSRU(PLLB*UHJRUL 

(

O PLpUFROHV SRU OD WDUGH $ULD HVWDED GH SLH HQ HO YHVWtEXOR GH OD QXHYD FDVD UHFLpQ FRPSUDGD SRU %\URQ \ 0HUHGLWK 7HQtD TXH DGPLWLU TXH HO OXJDU HUD UHDOPHQWHHQFDQWDGRU(UDXQDYLHMDFDVDGHXQDVRODSODQWDGHHVWLOR$UWHVDQR HQ XQD HVTXLQD DSDUWDGD GH OD FDOOH FRQ SLVRV GH PDGHUD GH FRORU QRJDO \ H[WUDxRV FDQGHODEURV GH EURQFH \ IRUWtQ &RPR 0HUHGLWK KDEtD SURPHWLGR KDEtD XQ SHTXHxR GRUPLWRULRHQHOiWLFRFRQXQDJUDQOX]SDUDSLQWDU



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

%\URQKDEtDHQYLDGRXQRVHPSOHDGRV GHWUDVODGRDODFDVDGH(OODHVWDPDxDQDSDUD UHFRJHUDOJXQDVFRVDVGHOGRUPLWRULRGH$ULD$QRFKH$ULDILQDOPHQWHKDEtDOODPDGR D(OOD\OHKDEtDGDGRODQRWLFLDGHTXHLEDDPXGDUVHFRQ%\URQSRUXQWLHPSRSDUD OOHJDUDFRQRFHUPHMRUD0HUHGLWK(OODKL]RXQDSDXVDSUREDEOHPHQWHUHFRUGDQGROD YH] TXH $ULD KDEtD SLQWDGR XQD RGLRVD \ DG~OWHUD $ HQ OD EOXVD GH 0HUHGLWK \ HQWRQFHVKDEtDSUHJXQWDGRVL$ULDHVWDEDGLVJXVWDGDSRUDOJR£&ODURTXHQR$ULD FKLOOy UiSLGDPHQWH (OOD OH FRQWHVWy TXH UHDOPHQWH OH JXVWDUtD TXH $ULD VH TXHGDUD ¢+DEtD DOJR TXH SRGtD KDFHU SDUD TXH $ULD IXHUD PiV IHOL]" 6t SRGUtDV GHVKDFHUWH GH ;DYLHU$ULDGHVHDEDSRGHUVXJHULU

ͻͶ

/D~QLFDLQWHUIHUHQFLDHUDTXHSRGtDYHUODYHOHWDHQORDOWRGHODFDVDGH,DQGHVGHOD YHQWDQD GH VX GRUPLWRULR 7DPELpQ WHQtD XQD YLVWD GHO iULGR ERVTXH GRQGH KDEtDQ HQFRQWUDGRHOFDGiYHUDSDUHQWHPHQWHIDOVRGH,DQ/RVYHKtFXORVGHSROLFtD\HOHTXLSR GH E~VTXHGD VH KDEtDQ LGR SHUR HO WHUUHQR HVWDED GHVSHGD]DGR HQ DOJXQRV SXQWRV \ KDEtD PXFKDV KXHOODV GH ERWDV HQ HO EDUUR $KRUD TXH VDEtD TXH ,DQ HVWDED SUREDEOHPHQWH WRGDYtD YLYR³\ WRGDYtD SHUPDQHFLHQGR HQ 5RVHZRRG³QL VLTXLHUD SRGtDPLUDUKDFLDHOERVTXHVLQVHQWLUVHLQWUDQTXLOD<FXDQGRHOODPiVWHPSUDQRVH KDEtD SDUDGR HQ HO SRUFKH HVSHUDQGR D TXH 0HUHGLWK DEULHUD OD SXHUWD $ULD KDEtD MXUDGR TXHKDEtDFDSWDGRHOGHVWHOOR GHDOJXLHQGHVDSDUHFLHQGRGHWUiVGH XQDFDVDDO ILQDOGHOFDOOHMyQVLQVDOLGD3HURFXDQGRGLRXQSDVRDWUiVSDUDYHUPHMRUQDGLHHVWDED DOOt

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

$OILQDO$ULDGLRPDUFKDDWUiVFRQYHQFLHQGRD(OODGHTXHGHMDUtDDOJXQRVPXHEOHV\ URSDVHQVXYLHMRGRUPLWRULRHQYH]GHWUDVODGDUODVDODFDVDGH(OOD\DODGH%\URQ 1R TXHUtD TXH (OOD SHQVDUD TXH $ULD OD DEDQGRQDED HVSHFtILFDPHQWH 'H FXDOTXLHU PDQHUD¢TXpWDQGLItFLOSRGtDVHUHYLWDUD;DYLHU"$ULDVHTXHGDUtDHQODFDVDGH(OOD ORVGtDVHQTXHHVWDEDVHJXUDGHTXHpOQRHVWDUtDDOOtFRPRFXDQGRpOHVWXYRIXHUDGH ODFLXGDGSDUDXQDH[KLELFLyQGHDUWH /RV GHO WUDVODGR KDEtDQ GHMDGR ODV FDMDV PiV OLJHUDV HQ HO YHVWtEXOR GHODQWHUR \ $ULD HVWDED HQ HO SURFHVR GH OOHYDUODV HVFDOHUDV DUULED 0LHQWUDV VH LQFOLQDED SDUD DJDUUDU XQD FDMD PDUFDGD FRPR )5É*,/ 0HUHGLWK GHVOL]y XQ VREUH EODQFR HQ HO EROVLOOR WUDVHURGHORVIODFRVYDTXHURVGH$ULD&RUUHRSDUDWLHOODFDQWy\OXHJRUHYRORWHy SRUHOYHVWtEXOROLPSLDQGRFRQHOWUDSHDGRUHQVXPDQR $ULD VDFy HO VREUH 6X QRPEUH HVWDED LPSUHVR HQ XQD HWLTXHWD YHUGH GH GLUHFFLyQ DQyQLPD6HHVWUHPHFLySHQVDQGRHQORTXHOHKDEtDGLFKR(PLO\D+DQQDKR\´$µ VHKDSXHVWRHQFRQWDFWRFRQQRVRWUDVSRURWURVPHGLRV1RHVWDEDOLVWDSDUDXQQXHYR ERPEDUGHRGHQRWDV 'HQWURHQFRQWUyXQDLQYLWDFLyQ\GRVEROHWRVDQDUDQMDGRVSDUDXQDILHVWDHQXQKRWHO QXHYROODPDGR7KH5DGOH\8QDQRWDHVWDEDDGMXQWD £$ULD\DWHH[WUDxR¢&XiQGRHVWDUiVGHUHJUHVRFRQQRVRWURV"'HFXDOTXLHUPDQHUD£XQDGHPLV SLQWXUDV IXH VHOHFFLRQDGD SDUD FROJDU HQ HO YHVWtEXOR $TXt KD\ GRV LQYLWDFLRQHV SDUD OD LQDXJXUDFLyQ£3RUIDYRUUH~QHWHFRQ;DYLHU\FRQPLJRDOOt &RQDPRU(OOD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6XELyODVHVFDOHUDV\ VHPHWLyHQ VXSHTXHxR GRUPLWRULRDFRJHGRU(UDHOGRUPLWRULR TXH VLHPSUH KDEtD TXHULGR FRQ WUDJDOXFHV VREUH VX FDPD XQ FyPRGR DVLHQWR HQ OD YHQWDQD \ SLVRV GH PDGHUD OLJHUDPHQWH LQFOLQDGRV GHO WLSR GyQGH SRGtD FRORFDU XQ OiSL] HQ XQ H[WUHPR GHO FXDUWR \ pVWH FRPHQ]DUtD D URGDU OHQWDPHQWH KDVWD HO RWUR H[WUHPR SRU VX FXHQWD /DV FDMDV GH VX DQWLJXR GRUPLWRULR HVWDEDQ DSLODGDV KDVWD HO WHFKR \ ORV WtWHUHV GH DQLPDOHV UHOOHQRV GH $ULD HVWDEDQ HVSDUFLGRV VREUH OD FDPD GH SODWDIRUPD TXH VXV SDGUHV OH KDEtDQ FRPSUDGR HQ XQ DOPDFpQ HQ 'LQDPDUFD (OOD KDEtD FROJDGR OD PD\RU SDUWH GH VXV URSDV HQ XQ YLHMR DUPDULR TXH %\URQ OH KDEtD FRPSUDGRIXHUDGH&UDLJVOLVWSRQLHQGRVXVFDPLVHWDVVRVWHQHVEUDJDV\FDOFHWLQHVHQ ODV JDYHWDV PiV EDMDV 7RGDYtD WHQtD TXH HQFRQWUDU XQ OXJDU SDUD ODV FDMDV GH KLOR PDQWDV DGLFLRQDOHV ]DSDWRV GHPDVLDGRV SHTXHxRV \ MXHJRV GH PHVD GH VX DQWLJXR DUPDULR

ͻͷ

$ULD PHWLy ORV SDSHOHV GH YXHOWD DO VREUH FRQ VX FRUD]yQ KXQGLGR 7DO YH] HYLWDU D ;DYLHULEDDVHUPiVGXURGHORTXHSHQVDED

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

3HUR QR WHQtD JDQDV GH KDFHU DOJR GH HVWR MXVWR DKRUD 7RGR OR TXH TXHUtD KDFHU HUD HFKDUVH HQ VX FDPD \ GDUOH YXHOWDV DO HQFXHQWUR GH D\HU FRQ -DVRQ 'L/DXUHQWLV ¢eO KDEtD HVWDGR FRTXHWHDQGR FRQ HOOD" ¢3RU TXp KDEtD FDPELDGR VX KXPRU WDQ UiSLGDPHQWH"¢(UDSRUTXHHOUHSRUWDMHGH,DQ(O&KLFR0XHUWRHVWDEDHQ79" 6HSUHJXQWDEDVL-DVRQVHJXtDWHQLHQGRDPLJRVHQHOiUHD(QODVHFXQGDULDVROtDSDVDU XQ PRQWyQ GH WLHPSR HQ Vt PLVPR HVFXFKDQGR P~VLFD OH\HQGR R FDYLODQGR $OL KDEtDGHVDSDUHFLGRHO~OWLPRGtDGHODxRVHQLRUGH-DVRQ\$ULDDSHQDVORKDEtDYLVWR GHVGHHQWRQFHV'HVSXpVGHOYHUDQRpOVHKDEtDLGRD
8Q PLQXWR HVWDED HQ PL EROVRHOVLJXLHQWH PLQXWRVHKDEtDLGR$OLOHVKDEtD GLFKR ¢3RU TXp -DVRQ VH OD KDEtD TXLWDGR D $OL" $ULD TXHUtD SHQVDU TXH KDEtD VLGR SRU XQD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

(QWRQFHV ODV UDPLWDV FUDTXHDURQ /RV DUEXVWRV PXUPXUDURQ $ULD YLR OD FDPLVHWD QHJUD\HOUXELRFDEHOORGH-DVRQ\FRQWXYRVXUHVSLUDFLyQ+DEtDIDQWDVHDGRDOYHUD -DVRQHVHGtD«\pOHVWDEDDOOt1RVXSRTXpKL]RTXHVXVRMRVVHIXHUDQDODSLH]DGHOD EDQGHUDTXHFROJDEDGHVXEROVLOOR&XDQGR-DVRQYLRORTXHHVWDEDPLUDQGRHPSXMy ODSLH]DKDFLDHOODVLQGHFLUQDGD

ͻ͸

$ULDKDEtDHQWHUUDGRHOUHFXHUGRGHTXpRFXUULyHVHGtDSRUWDQWRWLHPSRSHURDKRUD TXHVHSHUPLWtD SHQVDU HQHVRFDGDGHWDOOHVHQVRULDOOD LQXQGyFODUR FRPRHOFULVWDO 5HFRUGyD$OLGDUVHPHGLDYXHOWD\FDPLQDUGHUHJUHVRDVXFDVDHORORUGHVXMDEyQGH PDQRGHYDLQLOODIORWDQGRGHWUiVGHHOOD6HUHFRUGySLVDQGRIXHUWHDWUDYpVGHOERVTXH SDUD OOHJDU FDVD OD WLHUUD WRGDYtD PRMDGD SRU OD OOXYLD GH XQRV GtDV DWUiV 5HFRUGy FyPRHVWDEDQODVKRMDVHQORViUEROHVWRGDYtDPX\YHUGHV\JUXHVDVSURSRUFLRQDQGR DPSOLDVRPEUDGHOVROGHILQDOHVGHYHUDQR(OERVTXHROtDFRPRDSLQR\DOJRPiV« TXL]iVXQFLJDUULOOR/HMRVHQODGLVWDQFLDXQFRUWDFpVSHGJUXxtD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

UD]yQSUiFWLFD\pWLFDQRVyORSRUVHUFUXHO1RKDEtDPDQHUDGHTXH-DVRQDEXVDUDGH $OLFRPR-HQQDLQVLQXy\FRPR(PLO\TXHUtDFUHHU'HKHFKR-DVRQVLHPSUHKDEtD SDUHFLGRIHUR]PHQWHSURWHFWRUGH$OLeOKDEtDVDOWDGRGHDOJXQDSDUWHSDUDLQWHUYHQLU FXDQGR$OLH,DQHVWDEDQKDEODQGRHQHOSDWLRHOGtDHQTXH/D&iSVXODGHO7LHPSRIXH DQXQFLDGD,QFOXVRHOGtDHQTXHKDEtDQWUDWDGRGHUREDUODEDQGHUDGH$OL\(PLO\ ODVKDEtDKHFKRFDOODUSDUDHVFXFKDUXQDSHOHDWHQLHQGROXJDUGHQWURGHODFDVDGH$OL -DVRQKDEtDVDOLGRYLROHQWDPHQWHPRPHQWRVPiVWDUGHDOWHUDGRSRUDOJR&XDQGR$OL VDOLy D KDEODU FRQ HOODV WRGDYtD SDUHFtD SUHRFXSDGD QHUYLRVD PLUDQGR IXUWLYDPHQWH SRU VX KRPEUR KDFLD OD FDVD ¢6L KDEtD WHQLGR DVXQWRV FRQ -DVRQ QR KDEUtD HVWDGR DOLYLDGDGHTXHpOVHKXELHVHLGR" (VD PDxDQD 6SHQFHU OH KDEtD GLFKR TXH TXHUtD UREDU OD EDQGHUD GH $OL SRUTXH SHQVDED TXH GH HVWD PDQHUD $OL KDEUtD KHFKR WUDPSD SDUD JDQDU 7DO YH] -DVRQ VH VHQWtDFXOSDEOHSRUKDFHUWUDPSDWDPELpQ7DOYH]OHKDEtDGLFKRD$OLTXHQRGLMHUD TXH pO OH KDEtD GLFKR GyQGH KDEtD HVFRQGLGR VX SLH]D \ VH KDEtD PROHVWDGR FXDQGR R\yD$OLDODUGHDQGRDQWHWRGRVHQHOSDWLR $ULD VH DJDFKy DO ODGR GH OD FDMD GH ]DSDWRV FRQ VX FXHUSR KRUPLJXHDQGR +DEtD SDVDGRPXFKtVLPRWLHPSRGHVGHTXHKDEtDPLUDGRODSLH]DGHODEDQGHUDGH$OLGH/D &iSVXODGHO7LHPSRFDVLKDEtDROYLGDGRORTXH$OLKDEtDGLEXMDGRHQHVWD/DWDSDVH GREOyPLHQWUDVODVDFDED8QDQXEHGHSROYRVHGLVSHUVyHQHODLUH ¢$ULD"/DYR]GH%\URQIORWyGHVGHHOSULPHUSLVR£%DMDDOVKRZHUGH0HUHGLWK $ULDKL]RXQDSDXVD(OPLVPRERUGHGHODEULOODQWHEDQGHUDD]XOVHDVRPySRUGHEDMR GHXQPRQWyQGHSDSHOHVYLHMRV

8KP ¢KROD"$ULD GLMRFDXWHORVDPHQWH.DWHVRQULyFRQ VXILFLHQFLD0LNHVRQULy LQFOXVRFRQPiVVXILFLHQFLD3XVRVXPDQRHQHOPXVORGH.DWH\.DWHORGHMy$ULD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

0HUHGLWK %\URQ XQ PRQWyQ GH KRPEUHV GHVDOLxDGRV TXH $ULD UHFRQRFLy FRPR ORV FROHJDVGH%\URQHQ+ROOLV\XQDVSRFDVFKLFDVGHXQRVYHLQWHDxRVHQSDQWDORQHVGH \RJDRYDTXHURVVDOSLFDGRVHQSLQWXUDVHDUUHPROLQDEDQDOUHGHGRUGHODVDODGHHVWDU 8QDFDIHWHUDIUDQFHVDGHSUHVLyQERWHOODVGHYLQR\DJXDPLQHUDO\XQJUDQSODWRGH HPSDUHGDGRV GH SHSLQR FRQ SXUp GH JDUEDQ]RV HVWDEDQ FRORFDGRV VREUH OD PHVD \ KDEtD XQD JUDQ SLOD GHUHJDORV DO ODGR GHO VRIi /XHJR DOJXLHQ D OD L]TXLHUGD GH $ULD WRVLy 0LNH HVWDED VHQWDGR HQ OD HVTXLQD GH OD VHFFLyQ FRQ XQD ERQLWD PRUHQD D VX ODGR $ULD SHVWDxHy WHPSRUDOPHQWH HVWXSHIDFWD (UD OD SURQWRDVHU KHUPDQDVWUD GH +DQQD.DWH

ͻ͹


6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

IUXQFLy HO FHxR SUHJXQWiQGRVH VL VX FHUHEUR KDEtD VLGR GDxDGR SRU HO SROYR GH VX QXHYRGRUPLWRULRGHOiWLFR /RV WDFRQHV FKDVTXHDURQ SRU HO YHVWtEXOR \ $ULD VH YROYLy MXVWR D WLHPSR SDUD YHU HQWUDUD+DQQD/OHYDEDXQYHVWLGRGHVHGDYHUGHGHHVSDOGDHVFRWDGDFRQVXGHFRUDGD EDQGHUD GH /D &iSVXOD GHO 7LHPSR HQUROODGD DOUHGHGRU GH VX FLQWXUD FRPR XQ FLQWXUyQ /OHYDED XQD FDMD HQYXHOWD HQ SDSHO HVWDPSDGR GH FLJHxDV $ULD HVWDED D SXQWR GH GHFLU KROD SHUR +DQQD QR PLUDED HQ VX GLUHFFLyQ (VWDED PLUDQGR KDFLD .DWH6XERFDDSUHWDGD 2K £+ROD+DQQD.DWHVDOXGy£0HDOHJURGHTXHORKLFLHUDV 7~QRHVWDEDVLQYLWDGD+DQQDHVSHWy 6tORHVWDED/DVRQULVDGH.DWHQRYDFLOy 8Q P~VFXOR EDMR HO RMR GHUHFKR GH +DQQD VH PRYLy 8Q IORUHFLPLHQWR GH URMR YLDMy GHVGHVXFXHOORKDVWDVXVPHMLOODV$ULDGLRYXHOWDVGHDTXtSDUDDOOi HQWUHODVFKLFDV VLQWLpQGRVHFRQIXQGLGD\IDVFLQDGDDOPLVPRWLHPSR 0HUHGLWKSDUHFtDGLYHUWLGD 0LNH¢WUDMLVWHGRVFLWDV" +H\ HV XQD ILHVWD 0LNH GLMR HQFRJLpQGRVH GH KRPEURV &XDQWDV PiV PHMRU ¢FLHUWR" £(VR HV OR TXH \R GLJR .DWH DODUGHy &XDQGR OD V~SHUGHOJDGD .DWH VRQUHtD GH XQD FLHUWD PDQHUD OH UHFRUGDED D $ULD DO JLEyQ FKLUULDQWH HQ VX SyVWHU GH /RV $QLPDOHV GHO 0XQGR GH 1DWLRQDO *HRJUDSKLF TXH D~Q FROJDED HQ OD SXHUWD GH VX DQWLJXRGRUPLWRULR+DQQDHUDGHILQLWLYDPHQWHODPiVERQLWDGHODVGRV

+DQQD0DULQ6R\XQDYLHMDDPLJDGHODIDPLOLD/HRIUHFLyVXUHJDORD0HUHGLWK \0HUHGLWKORPHWLyHQODSLODFRQODVRWUDVFRVDV +DQQD PLUyIXULRVDPHQWHD.DWH OXHJRVHFRORFyDORWURODGRGH0LNHDSUHWiQGRVHWDQWRTXHVXVWUDVHURVFRPSDUWtDQXQ FRMtQGHOVRIi

ž‰‹ƒ

.DWHPLUyVLQGLVLPXORHOFLQWXUyQGHODEDQGHUDGH/D&iSVXODGH7LHPSRGH+DQQD ¢4XpHVHVDFRVD"6HxDOyXQDPDQFKDQHJUDTXH+DQQDKDEtDGLEXMDGR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͻͺ

+DQQDSXVRORVKRPEURVKDFLDDWUiVVHSDYRQHyKDFLD0HUHGLWK\VDFyVXPDQR



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

+DQQDOHGLVSDUyVXDUURJDQWHPLUDGD (VXQDUDQDPDQJD'XK $ULD VH VHQWy HQ OD PHFHGRUD DEUXPDGRUDPHQWH H[WUDxDGD &DSWXUy OD PLUDGD GH +DQQD DSXQWy KDFLD VX WHOpIRQR FHOXODU \ HPSH]y D HVFULELUOH D +DQQD XQ PHQVDMH +DQQDDUHJDxDGLHQWHVOHKDEtDGDGRD$ULD\DODVGHPiVHOQ~PHURGHVXL3KRQHHVD PDxDQD ¢4XpHVWiVKDFLHQGRDTXt" (O,3KRQHGH+DQQDGLRXQSLWLGR(OODOH\yHOWH[WRPLUyD$ULD\WHFOHy6HJXQGRV PiVWDUGHHOWHOpIRQRGH$ULD]XPEy ¢3RUTXpQRQRVGLMLVWHTWPXGDEDVSXHUWDVGHVSXpVGH,DQ" $ULD DEULy XQ PHQVDMH GH UHVSXHVWD +DQQD QR SRGtD HVTXLYDU OD SUHJXQWD WDQ IiFLOPHQWH(OODFRQWHVWy $FDERGGHVFXEULUOR¢7JXVWD0LNH" +DQQDHVFULELy 7DOYH](VHO~QLFRFKLFRTQRSXHGHVUREDUPH $ULD DSUHWy VXV GLHQWHV +DQQD VH HVWDED UHILULHQGR DO PRPHQWR GHO ~OWLPR RWRxR FXDQGR$ULDKDEtDVDOLGRFRQVXH[6HDQ$FNDUG+DVWDHOGtDGHKR\+DQQDSDUHFtD VHJXUDGHTXH$ULDOHKDEtDUREDGRD6HDQ 0HUHGLWK HPSH]y D GHVHQYROYHU VX JUDQ SLOD GH UHJDORV PRVWUDQGR WRGR HQ OD PHVD SDUDFDIp+DVWDDKRUDKDEtDUHFLELGRXQPRQWyQGHMXJXHWHVGHEHEpXQDFRELMD\XQ H[WUDFWRUGHOHFKHGH0LNH&XiQGROOHJyDXQUHJDORHQYXHOWRHQSDSHOUD\DGR.DWH VHHQGHUH]y £2KHVHHVPtR)URWyVXVPDQRVMXQWDV DOHJUHPHQWH(OFHxRGH+DQQDVHKL]R PiVKRQGR

2K 'LRV 0tR UHVSLUy OHYDQWDQGR XQ PDPHOXFR FRORU FUHPD GH XQD FDSD GH SDSHOGHVHGDURVDGR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ž‰‹ƒ

(VFDFKHPLUDRUJiQLFDGH0RQJROLD.DWHUHFLWy&RPSOHWDPHQWHHOWUDWRMXVWR

ͻͻ

0HUHGLWKVHVHQWyHQHOVRIi\GHVHQYROYLyODFDMD



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

0XFKtVLPDV JUDFLDV 0HUHGLWK SUHVLRQy HO PDPHOXFR HQ VX FDUD %\URQ OR WRFy HQWUHVXVGHGRVDVLQWLHQGRVDELDPHQWHFRPRVLIXHUDXQH[SHUWRGHODFDFKHPLUD/DV FDPLVHWDV GH DOJRGyQ GHVKLODFKDGDV DOJRGyQ \ ORV SDQWDORQHV GH SLMDPD GH IUDQHOD XVXDOPHQWHHUDQORVX\R +DQQDDEUXSWDPHQWHVHSXVRGHSLHGHMDQGRHVFDSDUXQSHTXHxRFKLOOLGR ¢(VSLDVWHHQPLKDELWDFLyQ" ¢'LVF~OSDPH".DWHSUHJXQWyHQVDQFKDQGRVXVRMRV /RVDEtDV+DQQDFKLOOy%XVTXpGXUDQWHKRUDVSRUODFRVDSHUIHFWD 1RVpGHHVWiVKDEODQGR.DWHVHHQFRJLyGHKRPEURV (QHVHPRPHQWR0HUHGLWKHVWDEDGHVHQYROYLHQGRHOUHJDORHQYXHOWRSRUFLJHxDVTXH +DQQDKDEtDWUDtGR$GHQWURKDEtDRWUDFDMDGH6XQVKLQH 2K0HUHGLWKGLMR DJUDGDEOHPHQWH VDFDQGRXQ PDPHOXFRGHFDFKHPLUDLGpQWLFR GHXQSDSHOGHVHGDURVDGRLJXDO(VKHUPRVR'HQXHYR 8QR QXQFD SXHGH WHQHU PXFKRV GH HVRV 7DWH XQR GH ORV FROHJDV GH %\URQ HQ +ROOLVVHULyDFDUFDMDGDVXQSHJRWHGHSXUpGHJDUEDQ]RFDtDHQVXVXFLDEDUED .DWHVHULyGHEXHQJUDGRWDPELpQ /DV JUDQGHV PHQWHV SLHQVDQ LJXDO VXSRQJR GLMR OR FXDO KL]R TXH OD FDUD GH +DQQD VH UHWRUFLHUD FRQ IHURFLGDG /D FDEH]D GH 0LNH JLUy GH XQD FKLFD D OD RWUD REYLDPHQWHDFHSWDEDFRQHQWXVLDVPRHOGUDPDGHODVSHOHDVGHPXMHUHV

0LUyDOUHGHGRUGHOFXDUWRSHURQDGLHPiVSDUHFtDQRWDUOR$FODUiQGRVHVXJDUJDQWDVH OHYDQWyGHOVRIi\DYDQ]ySRUHOYHVWtEXOR6XFRUD]yQODWtDFRQIXHU]DPLHQWUDVJLUDED ODSHULOOD\GDEDSDVRDIXHUD(OEDUULRHVWDEDPRUWDOPHQWHTXLHWR\HODLUHROtDDOHxD (O FLHOR VH HVWDED REVFXUHFLHQGR \ OD OiPSDUD DO ILQDO GH OD QXHYD FDO]DGD GH $ULD SUR\HFWDEDXQFtUFXORSiOLGRGHRURHQODKLHUED&XDQGRYROYLyDYHUODILJXUDSRUHO EX]yQUHVSLQJyKDFLDDWUiV$JUDGHFLGDPHQWHQRHUD,DQ(UD«

ž‰‹ƒ

¢-HQQD"$ULDFKLOOyVXDYHPHQWH

ͳͲͲ

5HSHQWLQDPHQWH $ULD QRWy XQD IRUPD RVFXUD PRYLpQGRVH DIXHUD GH OD YHQWDQD GHODQWHUD /D FDUQH GH VXV EUD]RV VH YROYLy GH JDOOLQD $OJXLHQ HVWDED SDUDGR HQ HO SDWLRREVHUYDQGRODILHVWD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

-HQQD &DYDQDXJK YHVWtD XQ DFROFKDGR DEULJR QHJUR SHVDGR PLWRQHV  QHJURV \ XQ VRPEUHURJULVFRQRUHMHUDV/DOHQJXDGHVXJROGHQUHWULHYHUFROJDEDGHVXERFD(OOD LUJXLyVXFDEH]DKDFLDHOVRQLGRGHODYR]GH$ULD 6XVODELRVVHGLYLGLHURQ (V$ULD$ULDH[SOLFy0HPXGpDTXtFRQPLSDSiD\HU -HQQDDVLQWLyGpELOPHQWH /RVp(OODQRVHPRYLy+XERXQDPLUDGDFXOSDEOHHQVXFDUD ¢(VWiVELHQ"$ULDSUHJXQWyGHVSXpVGHXQPRPHQWRFRQVXFRUD]yQODWLHQGRFRQ IXHU]D¢1HFHVLWDVDOJR" -HQQDHPSXMyVXVJUDQGHVJDIDVRVFXUDV*XFFLSRUHOSXHQWHGHVXQDUL](UDH[WUDxR HOYHUDDOJXLHQOOHYDQGRJDIDVRVFXUDVDODWDUGHFHU3DUHFtDFRPRVLHVWXYLHUDDSXQWR GHGHFLUDOJRSHURHQWRQFHVVHJLUyGHVSLGLpQGRVH 1R

ž‰‹ƒ

ͳͲͳ

£(VSHUD $ULD OODPy SHUR -HQQD VLJXLy FDPLQDQGR /DV HWLTXHWDV GH VX SHUUR WLQWLQHDURQ6XV]DSDWRVQRSURGXMHURQVRQLGR'HVSXpVGHXQPRPHQWRWRGDORTXH $ULDSRGtDYHUHUDVXEULOODQWHEDVWyQEODQFROHQWDPHQWHPRYLpQGRVHGHODGRDODGRDO ILQDOGHODFDOOH 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR £4XpOHFRUWHQODFDEH]D £4XpOHFRUWHQODFDEH]D 7UDGXFLGRSRU3DROD6 &RUUHJLGRSRU(PLLB*UHJRUL 

(

OPLpUFROHVSRUODQRFKH(PLO\FRORFyFXDWURSODWRVGHFRORUFUHPDDOUHGHGRU GHODPHVDFXDGUDGDGHJUDQMDHQHOFRPHGRUGHORV&ROEHUWV&XDQGROOHJyDOD SODWD VH GHWXYR SHUSOHMD ¢/RV FXFKLOORV LEDQ DO ODGR GH ORV WHQHGRUHV R ODV FXFKDUDV"/DVFHQDVFRQ´VXSURSLDIDPLOLDµHUDQPiVFDVXDOHV(PLO\\VXKHUPDQD &DURO\QDPHQXGRFRPtDQPiVWDUGHTXHVXVSDGUHVDFDXVDGHODSUiFWLFDGHQDWDFLyQ ,VDDFSDVHyGHODFRFLQDFRQVXVRMRVGHXQD]XOH[WUDHQVXVXpWHUHQFRJLGRFRQFXHOOR HQ9\SDQWDORQHVGHPH]FOLOODRVFXUR7RPyODPDQRGH(PLO\\SXVRDOJRVXDYH\ UHGRQGRHQHOOD0LUyDVXSDOPD(UDXQDQLOORGHFHUiPLFDD]XO ³¢4XpHVHVWR" /RVRMRVGH,VDDFHVWDEDQEULOODQWHV ³1RKD\UD]yQ3RUTXH7H$PR

ž‰‹ƒ

³7HDPRWDPELpQ³GLMR\GHVOL]yHODQLOORHQVXGHGRtQGLFHHQHOTXHHQFDMDPHMRU (OOD QR SRGtD GHMDU GH SHQVDU HQ OR TXH KDEtD VXFHGLGR HQWUH HOORV D\HU 6H VHQWtD LUUHDO SHUR PDUDYLOORVR WDPELpQ XQD JUDQ GLVWUDFFLyQ GH SHQVDU HQ HO UHJUHVR GH ´$µ'XUDQWHWRGRHOGtDHQODHVFXHODVHJXtD\HQGRDHVFRQGLGDVDOFXDUWRGHEDxRGH ODV QLxDV LQVSHFFLRQiQGRVH D HOOD PLVPD HQ HO HVSHMR HQ EXVFD GH FDPELRV (UD VLHPSUH OD PLVPD (PLO\ PLUDQGR KDFLD HOOD FRQ OD PLVPD DVSHUVLyQ GH SHFDV ORV PLVPRVRMRVPDUURQHVODPLVPDQDUL]OLJHUDPHQWHKDFLDDUULED6LJXLyHVSHUDQGRYHU XQEULOORHVSHFLDORXQDVRQULVDGHFRPSOLFLGDGDOJRTXHLQGLFDUDXQDWUDQVIRUPDFLyQ 'HVHySRGHUDJDUUDUORVKRPEURVGH,VDDFEHVDUORFRQIXHU]D\VXVXUUDUOHTXHTXHUtD YROYHUDKDFHUOR3URQWR

ͳͲʹ

(PLO\DSUHWyORVODELRVFRQIXHU]DVXSHUiQGROR1DGLHFRQTXLHQKDEtDVDOLGROHKDEtD GDGRXQUHJDORDQWHV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

8QIXHUWHJROSHHQODFRFLQDGHVWUR]yORVSHQVDPLHQWRVGH(PLO\HQPLOSHGD]RV1R HVTXHVHDWUHYLHUDDGHFLUOHD,VDDFDKRUDSRUVXSXHVWR1RFRQVXVSDGUHVDOUHGHGRU ,VDDFWRPyODSODWDGH(PLO\\HPSH]yDFRORFDUODGRDODGRODVFXFKDUDVMXQWRDORV FXFKLOORVDODGHUHFKDWHQHGRUHVVyORHQODL]TXLHUGD ³7HYHVQHUYLRVD³GLMR ³1RWHSUHRFXSHV/HVGLMHDPLVSDGUHVQRVDFDUORGHOMXLFLRGH$OL ³*UDFLDV ³(PLO\ WUDWy GH VRQUHtU /DV LQGLVFUHWDV SUHJXQWDV VREUH HO MXLFLR GH $OL HUDQHOPHQRUGHVXVSUREOHPDVHVWDQRFKHHVWDEDPiVSUHRFXSDGDDFHUFDGHORTXHOD 6UD&ROEHUWKDEtDRtGRD\HU&XDQGRKDEtDOOHJDGRDODSXHUWDOD6UD&ROEHUWODKDEtD VDOXGDGRFRQIULDOGDGFRPRVLQRHVWDEDFRQWHQWDGHYHUOD <GHVSXpVGHTXH(PLO\VDOLHUDGHODVDODHQHVHPRPHQWRMXUyTXHOD6UD&ROEHUWOH HVWDED PLUDQGR MX]JDGRUDPHQWH FRPR VL SHQVDUD TXH (PLO\ VH KDEtD ROYLGDGR GH ODYDUVHODVPDQRV (PLO\ VH DSUHVXUy D OD FRFLQD SDUD D\XGDU D OD PDPi GH ,VDDF D OHYDU OD FDUQH HQ OD FDFHUROD \ ODV FDFHURODV GH EUyFROL SXUp GH SDSDV FRQ DMR \ UROORV D OD PHVD (O 6U &ROEHUWEUDPyHQHOFRPHGRUDIORMDQGRVXFRUEDWD'HVSXpVGHTXHODIDPLOLDGLRODV JUDFLDOD6UD&ROEHUWSDVRODFDUQHHQODFDFHURODHQODGLUHFFLyQD(PLO\PLUiQGROD GHIUHQWHSRUSULPHUDYH]HQWRGDODQRFKH ³$TXtWLHQHVTXHULGD³/DVHVTXLQDVGHODERFDGHOD6UD&ROEHUWVHFXUYDURQ³6L WHJXVWDODFDUQH¢QR" (PLO\SDUSDGHy¢(UDHOODRHVDGHFODUDFLyQSDUHFtDFDUJDGD"5HYLVyD,VDDFSRUVX UHDFFLyQSHURpOHVWDEDLQRFHQWHVHOHFFLRQDQGRXQUROORGHXQDFHVWDGHPLPEUH ³8KJUDFLDV³GLMR(PLO\WLUDQGRHOSODWRKDFLDHOOD$HOODOHJXVWDEDODFDUQH'HO WLSRTXHXPVHFRPH

/D6UD&ROEHUWEXIyHQYR]EDMD(OWHQHGRUGH(PLO\FD\yDOSODWR(O~QLFRVRQLGR HQODVDODIXHODUHMLOODGHYHQWLODFLyQGHOYHQWLODGRUVREUHODHVWXID



ž‰‹ƒ

³¢/DWHQJR"

ͳͲ͵

³3RU OR WDQWR (PLO\ ³(O 6U &ROEHUW FDYy XQD FXFKDUD JUDQGH HQ HO SODWR GH SDWDWDV³/HVSUHJXQWpDDOJXQRVHPSOHDGRVGHODVFRPLGDVDFHUFDGHWL$OSDUHFHU WLHQHVXQDUHSXWDFLyQ

)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³7RGR HO PXQGR GLFH TXH HUHV XQD JUDQ QDGDGRUD ³WHUPLQy HO 6U &ROEHUW³ ¢$ QLYHOQDFLRQDOFODVLILFDGDHQPDULSRVD"(VRHVLQFUHtEOHHVXQJROSHGXUR¢YHUGDG" ³2K ³(PLO\ WRPy XQ ODUJR WUDJR WHPEORURVR GH VX YDVR GH DJXD³ 6t ³¢4Xp KDEtDHVSHUDGR"¢4XpHO6U&ROEHUWLEDDSUHJXQWDUOHFRPRHUDEHVDUVHFRQFKLFDV"³ (VGXURSHURSRUDOJXQDUD]yQVR\QDWXUDOPHQWHUiSLGDHQHOOR <OXHJROD6UD&ROEHUWPXUPXUyDOJRHQYR]EDMD(PLO\SRGUtDKDEHUMXUDGRTXHGLMR ³7XHUHVQDWXUDOPHQWHUiSLGDFRUUHFWR (PLO\EDMyVXYDVR/D6UD&ROEHUWPDVWLFDEDWUDQTXLODPHQWHPLUDQGRD(PLO\ 6HVHQWtDFRPRVLVXVRMRVHVWXYLHUDQSHQHWUDQGRHQHOFUiQHRGH(PLO\ ³¢4XpIXHHVRPDPi"³SUHJXQWy,VDDFHQWUHFHUUDQGRORVRMRV /DH[SUHVLyQGHOD6UD&ROEHUWVHWUDQVIRUPyHQXQDGXOFHVRQULVD ³'LMH TXH (PLO\ HV QDWXUDOPHQWH PRGHVWD (VWR\ VHJXUD GH TXH KD WUDEDMDGR PX\ GXURSDUDOOHJDUDVHUXQDEXHQDQDGDGRUD ³7RWDOPHQWH³VRQULy,VDDF(PLO\PLUyDVXPRQWyQGHSXUpGHSDSDVVLQWLpQGRVH XQ SRFR FRPR VL VH HVWXYLHUD YROYLHQGR ORFD ¢(UD HVR OR TXH OD 6UD &ROEHUW KDEtD GLFKR" 3DUD HO SRVWUH OD 6UD &ROEHUW VDFy XQ SDVWHO GH PDQ]DQD \ XQD WD]D GH FDIp (O 6U &ROEHUWPLUyDVXHVSRVD ³3RUFLHUWRHVWDPRVOLVWRVSDUDODDSHUWXUDHVWHViEDGR3HQVpTXHQRtEDPRVDWHQHU HO Q~PHUR VXILFLHQWH GH SHUVRQDV SDUD HO WUDEDMR \D TXH OD ILHVWD HV WDQ JUDQGH SHUR WHQHPRVVXILFLHQWH ³(VRHVJUDQGLRVR³GLMROD6UD&ROEHUW ³(VWDILHVWDYDDVHUGXOFH³PXUPXUy,VDDF (PLO\WRPyXQSODWRGHSDVWHO



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³0LSDSiHVWiHQODUHVWDXUDFLyQGHODDSHUWXUDGHXQQXHYRKRWHOIXHUDGHODFLXGDG ³H[SOLFy,VDDF/HWRPyODPDQRGHEDMRGHODPHVD³6ROtDVHUXQDHVFXHODRDOJR ¢YHUGDG"

ͳͲͶ

³¢)LHVWD"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³8QD LQVWLWXFLyQ SDUD HQIHUPRV PHQWDOHV ³,QWHUYLQR OD 6UD &ROEHUW DUUXJDQGR OD QDUL] ³1R H[DFWDPHQWH ³HO 6U &ROEHUW OD FRUULJLy³ )XH XQ FHQWUR SDUD QLxRV FRQ SUREOHPDVOODPDGR7KH5DGOH\(OKRWHOYDDOODPDUVHWDPELpQDVt/RVSURSLHWDULRVVH HVWiQERWDQGRHQODSURJUDPDFLyQGHODDSHUWXUDFRQODILHVWDGHHVWHILQGHVHPDQDQR WRGDVODVUHIRUPDFLRQHVHVWiQKHFKDV3HURODVKDELWDFLRQHVTXHQRKDQKHFKRWRGDYtD HVWiQHQORVQLYHOHVVXSHULRUHVORVLQYLWDGRVQLVLTXLHUDSRGUiQYHUODV3HURW~FRQRFHV DODJHQWHGHOKRWHOWRGRWLHQHTXHVHUSHUIHFWR ³(OKRWHOHVUHDOPHQWHPDJQtILFR³GLMR,VDDFD(PLO\³(VFRPRXQYLHMRFDVWLOOR ,QFOXVRKD\XQODEHULQWRGHURVDVHQHOMDUGtQ0HHQFDQWDUtDTXHYLQLHUDVFRQPLJR ³&ODUR³GLMR(PLO\UDGLDQWH6HPHWLyXQERFDGRGHSDVWHOHQODERFD ³$VtTXHHVXQDFHQD³H[SOLFy,VDDF³3HURWDPELpQKDEUiEHELGDV\EDLOH ³3HURVyORWHVLUYHQEHELGDVYtUJHQHV(PLO\³DFODUyOD6UD&ROEHUW /D SLHO GH (PLO\ VH HUL]y ¢9LUJHQ" 0LUy D ,VDDF LQFDSD] GH FRQWURODU ORV P~VFXORV DOUHGHGRUGHVXERFD/RVDEHSHQVy(OODGHILQLWLYDPHQWHVDEH ,VDDFVRQULyDSDFLJXDGR ³1RWHSUHRFXSHV1RYDPRVDEHEHU ³%LHQ³GLMROD6UD&ROEHUW³0HSUHRFXSDTXHXVWHGHVYD\DQDHVWDVIXQFLRQHVSDUD DGXOWRV0XFKRVGHORVFDPDUHURVQLVLTXLHUDSLGHQGRFXPHQWRVGHLGHQWLGDG³(OOD VXVSLUy GUDPiWLFDPHQWH³ 3HQVp TXH HVWDUtDV PiV HQWXVLDVPDGR SRU HO YLDMH GH OD LJOHVLDD%RVWRQODSUy[LPDVHPDQDTXHSRU ODDSHUWXUD7KH5DGOH\ ,VDDF1XQFDWH LQWHUHVDVWHSRULUDILHVWDVSDUDDGXOWRVGHOXMRKDVWDKDFHXQSDUGHVHPDQDV³0LUy GHOLEHUDGDPHQWHD(PLO\FRPRVLTXLVLHUDGHFLUTXHODVIRUPDVGHODVILHVWDVGH(PLO\ ORKDEtDQGDxDGR ³6LHPSUHPHKDQJXVWDGRODVILHVWDV³GHIHQGLy,VDDFUiSLGDPHQWH



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

(O WHOpIRQR VRQy \ OD 6UD &ROEHUW VH OHYDQWy GH XQ VDOWR SDUD FRQVHJXLUOR ,VDDF VH H[FXVy SDUD LU DO EDxR \ HO 6U &ROEHUW GHVDSDUHFLGR D VX RILFLQD (PLO\ FRUWy ODV URGDMDV GH VX SDVWHO HQ WUR]RV PiV SHTXHxRV \ PiV SHTXHxRV VXV PDQRV \ PHMLOODV HVWDEDQFDOLHQWHV¢4XpSDVDEDFRQHOOD"¢(VWDEDVLHQGRH[FHVLYDPHQWHVHQVLEOH"

ͳͲͷ

³2KGpMDORVSDVDUXQEXHQUDWR0DUJDUHW³GLMRHO6U&ROEHUWVXDYHPHQWH³9DD VHUEXHQR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(VWRWHQtDTXHHVWDUWRGRHQVXFDEH]D/D6UD&ROEHUWQRODWHQtDHQFRQWUDGH(PLO\\ QRHVWDEDWUDWDQGRGHPHWHUVHFRQVXPHQWH(OODQRHUD´$µ 5HXQLyORVSODWRV\ORVOOHYyDOIUHJDGHURFRQODHVSHUDQ]DGHSDUHFHU~WLO'HVSXpVGH XQRV SRFRV PLQXWRV GH ODYDGR VLQWLy HQ HO EROVLOOR VX WHOpIRQR FHOXODU eVWH VHUtD XQ PRPHQWR RSRUWXQR SDUD TXH ´$µ HVFULELHUD XQ PHQVDMH VDUFiVWLFR VREUH HO FRPSRUWDPLHQWRGH/D0DPL4XHULGD 'H KHFKR WDO YH] OD 6UD &ROEHUW QR VDELD DFHUFD GH (PLO\ H ,VDDF D\HU SHUR ´$µ VHJXUROHKDEtDHVFULWRMXVWRDWLHPSRSDUDODFHQDGHHVWDQRFKH $OLJXDOTXHODDQWLJXD´$µ/D1XHYD´$µVLHPSUHSDUHFtDVDEHUORWRGRGHVSXpVGH WRGR 3HURODSHTXHxDSDQWDOODHQHO1RNLDGH(PLO\HVWDEDHQEODQFR'HUHSHQWH(PLO\VH GLR FXHQWD TXH HQ UHDOLGDG TXHUtD XQ WH[WR GH ´$µ 6L ´$µ HVWDED GHWUiV GH HVWR HQWRQFHVSRUORPHQRVODPDPiGH,VDDFVHUtDYtFWLPDGHXQDPDQLSXODFLyQHQOXJDU GHVLPSOHPHQWHVHUXQDRJUDSDVLYDDJUHVLYD &XDQGROD6UD&ROEHUWGHMyHVFDSDUXQDFDUFDMDGDHQODRWUDKDELWDFLyQ(PLO\PLUy DOUHGHGRUGHODFRFLQD /DPDGUHGH,VDDFFROHFFLRQDEDFRVDVGHYDFDVGHODPLVPDPDQHUDTXHODPDPiGH (PLO\FROHFFLRQDEDJDOOLQDV(OODVWHQtDQORVPLVPRVLPDQHVH[DFWRVGHUHIULJHUDGRUGH XQDFDVDFRQWHFKRGHSDMDIUDQFHVDXQDLJOHVLDDOWDFRQFDPSDQDULR\XQDSDQDGHUtD /D 6UD &ROEHUW HUD XQD PDGUH QRUPDO FRQ XQD FRFLQD QRUPDO DO LJXDO TXH OD 6UD )LHOGV7DOYH](PLO\HVWDEDH[DJHUDQGR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6HGHVOL]yKDFLDGHODQWH,VDDFHVWDEDGHSLHHQHOYHVWtEXORIUHQWHDODIDPLOLDOOHYDQGR HO WUDMH OLJHUDPHQWH JUDQGH TXH SHUWHQHFLy D VX SDGUH eO WHQtD VX EUD]R DOUHGHGRU GH (PLO\OOHYDEDXQYHVWLGRGHVDWpQURVDTXHKDEtDVDFDGRGHODUPDULRGH&DURO\QeVWD KDEtDVLGRWRPDGDODVHPDQDDQWHULRUFXDQGRHVWDEDQHQVXFDPLQRDODEHQHILFHQFLD GH5RVHZRRG'D\/D6UD&ROEHUWKDEtDIORWDGRDOUHGHGRUGHHOORVVXVPHMLOODVURVDV VXV RMRV EULOODQWHV ³£8VWHGHV GRV VH YHQ WDQ OLQGRV ³FDQWy +DEtD DMXVWDGR HO

ͳͲ͸

(PLO\ UHXQLy ORV WHQHGRUHV FXFKDUDV \ FXFKLOORV \ ODV VHFy FRQ XQ SDxR GH FRFLQD SUHJXQWiQGRVHGRQGHHVWDEDHOFDMyQGHORVFXELHUWRV7UDWyHQODJDYHWDPiVFHUFDQD 8QDEDWHUtDGREOH$URGRDODSDUWHGHODQWHUD+DEtDXQDVWLMHUDVSLQ]DVGLVSHUVRVGH SDSHOXQJXDQWHGHFRFLQDGHYDFD\XQPRQWyQGHPHQ~VGHFRPLGDSDUDOOHYDUVH PDQWHQtDQXQLGRVSRUXQDJRPDGHFRORUS~USXUD(PLO\FRPHQ]yDFHUUDUODSHURXQD LPDJHQTXHVHHPSXMyDODSDUWHSRVWHULRUGHOFDMyQOHOODPyODDWHQFLyQ

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

UDPLOOHWH GH (PLO\ UHDSUHWDGR OD FRUEDWD GH ,VDDF \ OXHJR OHV RIUHFLy JDOOHWDV GH FKRFRODWHUHFLpQKRUQHDGDV (Q OD IRWR VH FRQWDED XQD KLVWRULD IHOL] H[FHSWR SRU XQD FRVD (PLO\ \D QR WHQtD FDEH]D 6H OD KDEtDQ FRUWDGR HQ OD LPDJHQ SRU FRPSOHWR ODV WLMHUDV OLPSLDPHQWH HOLPLQDURQWRGRVORV~OWLPRVUDVWURVGHVXFDEHOOR (PLO\FHUUyUiSLGRHOFDMyQ3DVyVXVGHGRVVREUHVXFXHOOROXHJRKDVWDODPDQGtEXOD \ OXHJR D VX DOUHGHGRU ODV RUHMDV ODV PHMLOODV \ OD IUHQWH 7HQtD OD FDEH]D SHJDGD $ PHGLGD TXH PLUDED SRU OD YHQWDQD GH OD FRFLQD WUDWDQGR GH VDEHU TXp KDFHU VX WHOpIRQRFHOXODUVRQy (OFHQWURGH(PLO\VHKXQGLy$VtTXH´$µHVWDEDLQYROXFUDGD7RPyHOWHOpIRQRVXV GHGRVWHPEORURVRV8QPHQVDMHFRQLPDJHQQXHYD 8QDLPDJHQDSDUHFLyHQODSDQWDOOD(UDXQDYLHMDIRWRGHOSDWLRWUDVHURGHDOJXLHQ(O SDWLRWUDVHURGH$OL(PLO\UHFRQRFLyODFDVDGHOiUEROSRUHOJUDQUREOHDXQODGR< HVWDED $OL VX URVWUR MRYHQ \ VRQULHQWH \ EULOODQWH /OHYDED SXHVWR XQ XQLIRUPH GH KRFNH\VREUHFpVSHGGH/LJDGH-9GH5RVHZRRGORTXHVLJQLILFDEDTXHODIRWRHUDGH TXLQWRRVH[WRJUDGRGHVSXpVGHTXH$OLKDEtDMXJDGRSDUDOD-9GH5RVHZRRG'D\ +DEtDRWUDVGRVFKLFDVHQODIRWRWDPELpQ8QDWHQtDHOSHORUXELR\VHRFXOWDEDHQVX PD\RUtDSRUXQiUEROWHQtDTXHVHU1DRPL=HLJOHUXQDGHODVPHMRUHVDPLJDVGH$OL HQ HO PRPHQWR /D RWUD FKLFD HVWDED GH SHUILO 7HQtD HO SHOR RVFXUR SLHO SiOLGD \ ODELRVURMRQDWXUDO-HQQD&DYDQDXJK (PLO\ VRVWXYR HO WHOpIRQR H[WHQGLGR SHUSOHMD ¢'yQGH HVWDED HO FKDQWDMH HQ HVR" ¢'yQGHHVWDEDHOPHQVDMHDOHJUHGH£7HWHQJR£0DPiSLHQVDTXHHUHVXQDJUDQSXWD VXFLD¢3RUTXpQRVHFRPSRUWDEDFRPR´$µ" (QWRQFHV VH GLR FXHQWD GHO WH[WR HQ OD SDUWH LQIHULRU GH OD IRWR (PLO\ OH\y FXDWUR YHFHVWUDWDQGRGHHQWHQGHU 8QDGHpVWDVQRSHUWHQHFH'HVF~EUHORUiSLGDPHQWHRVREUDUiV 

ž‰‹ƒ

ͳͲ͹

³$



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR (VHYtQFXORPDGUH (VHYtQFXORPDGUHKLMD KLMD 7UDGXFLGRSRU&\H/\'LYL11D &RUUHJLGRSRU9DQ  

(

VHPLVPRPLpUFROHVSRUODQRFKH6SHQFHUVXELyDOWUHQEDODGH$PWUDN$FHOD HQ OD HVWDFLyQ GH OD FDOOH  VH LQVWDOy HQ XQ DVLHQWR GH SHOXFKH MXQWR D OD YHQWDQD DMXVWR HO FLQWXUyQ GH VX DEULJR GH ODQD VREUH VX YHVWLGR JULV \ VH VDFXGLyXQSHGD]RGHKLHUEDVHFDGHODSXQWDGHVXGHGRGHOSLHGHVXVERWDV/RHIIOHU 5DQGDOO+DEtDSDVDGRPiVGHXQDKRUDHQODHOHFFLyQGHVXYHVWXDULR\FRQItDHQTXH VXYHVWLGRGLMHUDTXHHVWDEDDODPRGDHUDXQDMRYHQVHULD£\VR\XQDLPSUHVLRQDQWH KLMDELROyJLFDGHYHUGDG(VXQHTXLOLEULRGLItFLOGHJROSHDU (OFRQGXFWRUXQFDQRVRKRPEUHDPDEOHHQXQDOHJUHXQLIRUPHFRORUD]XOGH$PWUDN H[DPLQyHOELOOHWH ³¢9DVD1XHYD
³¢6SHQFHU" ³GLMR OD SUHRFXSDFLyQ HQ VX YR] (UD FRPR VL KXELHUD ROYLGDGR WHPSRUDOPHQWHTXHVHVXSRQtDTXHODRGLDED



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

+DEtDWUDWDGRGHKDFHUIUHQWHDVXIDPLOLDDFHUFDGHVXDGRSFLyQSRU~OWLPDYH]DQWHV GHLUVH6XSDSiHVWDEDWUDEDMDQGRGHVGHVXFDVD\6SHQFHUKDEtDHVWDGRHQODSXHUWD GHVXRILFLQDPLUiQGROROHHUHO1HZ
ͳͲͺ

³(VWR\YLVLWDQGRDPLPDPi³HVSHWyHOOD(OFRQGXFWRUVRQULy8QDPXMHUPD\RUD WUDYpV GHO SDVLOOR FKDVTXHy DSUREDFLyQ 6SHQFHU HVSHUDED TXH QLQJXQR GH ORV DPLJRV GHVXPDGUHRORVVRFLRVGHQHJRFLRVGHVXSDGUHIXHUDQFDVXDOPHQWHHQHVWHWUHQ1R HUDFyPRTXHUtDTXHVXVSDGUHVVXSLHUDQORTXHHVWDEDKDFLHQGR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

7RQHODGDVGHSDODEUDVKDEtDQEURWDGRHQODFDEH]DGH6SHQFHU4XHUtDSUHJXQWDUOHDVX SDSiVLDOJRGHHVWRSRGUtDVHUUHDO4XHUtDSUHJXQWDUOHSRUTXppOQXQFDOHKDEtDGLFKR 4XHUtDSUHJXQWDUOHVLHVWRHUDHOSRUTXpODWUDWDEDFRPRXQDPLHUGDEXHQDSDUWHGHO WLHPSRSRUTXHQRHUDUHDOPHQWHVX\D3HUROXHJRSHUGLyVXVQHUYLRV $KRUDVXWHOpIRQRFHOXODUVRQy6SHQFHUORVDFyGHOEROVLOORGHODQWHURGHVXEROVD(UD GH$QGUHZ¢4XLHUHVVDOLU" 8QWUHQGH$PWUDNTXHLEDHQODRWUDGLUHFFLyQWURQySDVDGR6SHQFHUDEULyXQWH[WR GHUHVSXHVWD(VWR\FHQDQGRFRQPLIDPLOLDORVLHQWRHOODHVFULELyGHQXHYR1RHUDXQD PHQWLUDFRPSOHWD4XHUtDGHFLUOHD$QGUHZVREUH2OLYLDSHURWHQtDPLHGR\VLHOODOH GHFtD HVWDUtD HVSHUDQGR HQ HVWD QRFKH FRQ DQWLFLSDFLyQ PXULHQGR SRU VDEHU FyPR KDEtD LGR D VX HQFXHQWUR 3HUR ¢\ VL LED PDO" ¢4Xp SDVDED VL 6SHQFHU \ 2OLYLD VH RGLDEDQ"


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

/DSXHUWDTXHFRQHFWDEDGRVYDJRQHVWUDTXHWHDQGRVHDEULy\ XQDPXMHUHQXQWUDMH D]XOPDULQRVHWDPEDOHDEDSRUHOSDVLOOROOHYDQGRXQDFDMDGHFDUWyQGHFDIpFRQRORU DTXHPDGR\DJXDVHPERWHOODGDV6SHQFHUDSR\yODFDEH]DFRQWUDODYHQWDQDPLUDQGR ORViUEROHV GHVQXGRVUHVLVWLpQGRVHDDEULUVXWHOpIRQR ¢<TXpTXLVRGHFLU,DQFXDQGR HVFULELy TXH HOORV PH RGLDEDQ" ¢7HQtD DOJR TXH YHU FRQ HO PHQVDMH GH LPDJHQ TXH

ͳͲͻ

$ PHQRV TXH DOJXLHQ HVWXYLHUD DVXVWDQGR D 0HOLVVD SDUD JXDUGDU VLOHQFLR 6SHQFHU KDEtD OODPDGR D VX KHUPDQD HQ UHSHWLGDV RFDVLRQHV GXUDQWH ODV ~OWLPDV FXDUHQWD \ RFKR KRUDV GHVHRVD GH VDEHU VL 0HOLVVD VDEtD DOJR PiV GH OR TXH HOOD VDEtD 3HUR 0HOLVVDQRKDEtDUHJUHVDGRQLQJXQDGHVXVOODPDGDV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(PLO\ KDEtD UHPLWLGR D 6SHQFHU KDFH DSUR[LPDGDPHQWH PHGLD KRUD OD YLHMD IRWR GH $OLSDUFLDOPHQWHRFXOWDGH1DRPL=HLJOHU\-HQQD&DYDQDXJKHQHOSDWLRGH$OL"8Q WH[WRTXHDFRPSDxDEDODIRWRGDEDDHQWHQGHUTXHODIRWRHUDXQDSLVWD¢SHURGHTXp" %XHQR HUD H[WUDxR TXH $OL HVWXYLHUD FRQ OD WRQWD GH -HQQD &DYDQDXJK SHUR -HQQD KDEtDGLFKRTXHHOOD$ULD\$OLHUDQDPLJDVHQFXELHUWDV¢<TXpWHQtDHVRTXHYHUFRQ ,DQ" 6yORXQLQFLGHQWHGHDOJXLHQTXHRGLDUDD,DQHVWDEDSHJDGRHQODPHQWHGH6SHQFHU &XDQGR 6SHQFHU \ ORV RWURV VH HVFRQGLHURQ HQ HO SDWLR WUDVHUR GH $OL SDUD UREDUOH OD SLH]DGH/D&iSVXODGHO7LHPSR-DVRQ'L/DXUHQWLVKDEtDVDOLGRGHODFDVD\VHKDEtD FRQJHODGRHQHOFHQWURGHOSDWLRPLUDQGRD0HOLVVDH,DQTXHHVWDEDQVHQWDGRVHQHO ERUGH GH OD EDxHUD GH KLGURPDVDMH +DEtDQ FRPHQ]DGR D VDOLU 6SHQFHU UHFRUGy TXH 0HOLVVDKDEtDDJRQL]DGRVREUHODHOHFFLyQGHORVSHUIHFWRV]DSDWRV\EROVDGHOSULPHU GtDGHHVFXHODXQRVGtDVDQWHVGHVHRVDGHLPSUHVLRQDUDVXQXHYRQRYLR'HVSXpVGH TXH$OLVHIXHUD\6SHQFHUUHJUHVyDVXFDVDR\yHOPXUPXOORGHODQXHYDSDUHMDHQOD VDODGHHVWDU ³eOYDDVXSHUDUOR³GHFtD0HOLVVD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

¢(VWDEDQ KDEODQGR GH -DVRQ R DOJXLHQ PiV" 3RU OR TXH 6SHQFHU HQWHQGtD -DVRQ \ 0HOLVVD QR HUDQ UHDOPHQWH DPLJRV 7HQtDQ DOJXQDV FODVHV MXQWRV D YHFHV FXDQGR 0HOLVVDHVWDEDHQIHUPD6SHQFHUWXYRTXHLUDOODGR\UHFRJHUVXVWUDEDMRVGHFODVHGH -DVRQ SHUR -DVRQ QXQFD IXH SDUWH GH OD FDPDULOOD GH JUDQGHV TXH DOTXLODQ OLPXVLQDV +XPPHU SDUD ORV IRUPDOHV GH OD HVFXHOD R SDVDED ODV YDFDFLRQHV GH SULPDYHUD HQ &DQQHV&DER6DQ/XFDVR9LxHGRV0DUWKD-DVRQFRUUtDSRUDKtFRQDOJXQRVGHORV PXFKDFKRV GHO I~WERO RWURV TXH HUDQ IDPRVRV SRU KDFHU HO ´(VR QRµ MXHJR TXH $OL 6SHQFHU \ ORV GHPiV MXJDEDQ SHUR HO KHUPDQR GH $OL WDPELpQ SDUHFtD QHFHVLWDU XQ PRQWyQGHHVSDFLRSHUVRQDO/DPLWDGGHOWLHPSR-DVRQQLVLTXLHUDSDVDEDHOUDWRFRQ VXIDPLOLD/DVIDPLOLDV+DVWLQJV\'L/DXUHQWLVHUDQPLHPEURVGHO&OXEGH&DPSRGH 5RVHZRRG\DPERVDVLVWtDQFRQILGHOLGDGDORVDOPXHU]RVVHPDQDOHVGHOGRPLQJRGH MD]] D H[FHSFLyQ GH -DVRQ TXH ILHOPHQWH QR OR KDFtD 6SHQFHU UHFRUGy D $OL PHQFLRQDUDVXVSDGUHVTXH-DVRQLUtDDVXFDVDGHOODJRHQODVPRQWDxDVGH3RFRQR VyORHQORVILQHVGHVHPDQD¢HUDDGRQGHpOLEDWRGRVORVGRPLQJRV"6HDFXDOVHDOD UHVSXHVWDDORV'L/DXUHQWLVQLVLTXLHUDSDUHFHLPSRUWDUOHVTXHVHKDEtDLGR\HVWDEDQ IHOLFHVVDERUHDQGRVXVKXHYRV%HQHGLFW\GDQGRPLPRV\FDULxRVD$OL(UDFDVLFRPR VLVyORWXYLHUDQXQKLMRQRGRV

ͳͳͲ

³1R HV TXH PH SUHRFXSH ³UHVSRQGLy ,DQ /XHJR PXUPXUy DOJR TXH 6SHQFHU QR FDSWXUR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

6SHQFHUFHUUyORVRMRVHVFXFKDQGRFXDQGRHOWUHQVRSOyVXVLOEDWR(VWDEDWDQFDQVDGD GH SHQVDU HQ HVWR 7DO YH] PLHQWUDV PiV OHMRV HVWXYLHUD GH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ PHQRV LPSRUWDUtD 'HVSXpVGHXQUDWRHOWUHQLEDPiVOHQWR ³(VWDFLyQ 3HQQ ³OODPy HO FRQGXFWRU 6SHQFHU WRPy VX EROVR \ VH TXHGy FRQ ODV URGLOODV WHPEODQGR (VWR HVWDED VXFHGLHQGR (OOD VLJXLy OD OtQHD GH SDVDMHURV SRU HO SDVLOORHVWUHFKRDODSODWDIRUPD\KDVWDODHVFDOHUDDODVDODSULQFLSDO/DHVWDFLyQROtD D SUHW]HOV FHUYH]D \ SHUIXPH 8Q DQyQLPR ORFXWRU VRQDED SRU ORV DOWRSDUODQWHV GLFLHQGRTXHHOWUHQD%RVWRQKDEtDOOHJDGRDODSXHUWDGHOHVWH8QDDJORPHUDFLyQ GHJHQWHFRUULySDUDOD(VWHDOPLVPRWLHPSRFDVLDYHQWDQGRD6SHQFHU0LUyDVX DOUHGHGRU LPSDFLHQWHPHQWH ¢&yPR LED D HQFRQWUDU D 2OLYLD HQ HVWH JUXSR" ¢&yPR VDEUtD2OLYLDTXHHUDHOOD"¢4XpGHPRQLRVLEDQDGHFLUODXQDDODRWUD" (QDOJ~QOXJDUGHODPXOWLWXGGHSHUVRQDV6SHQFHUHVFXFKyXQDULVDIDPLOLDUGHWRQR DOWR < HQWRQFHV FRQVLGHUy OD SHRU GH ODV SRVLELOLGDGHV ¢4Xp SDVDED VL 2OLYLD QR H[LVWtD"¢4XpSDVDEDVLVHWUDWDEDGHXQDEURPDFUXHORUTXHVWDGDSRUDOJXLHQ" ³¢6SHQFHU"³JULWyXQDYR] 6SHQFHU VH GLR OD YXHOWD 8QD MRYHQ UXELD FRQ XQ VXpWHU GH FDFKHPLUD JULV - &UHZ \ ERWDVGHPRQWDUFRORUPDUUyQHVWDEDFDPLQDQGRKDFLDHOOD/OHYDEDXQDSHTXHxDEROVD GHSLHOGHVHUSLHQWH\XQDJUDQFDUSHWDGHDFRUGHyQUHOOHQDGHSDSHOHV &XDQGR6SHQFHUOHYDQWyOD PDQROD PXMHU VRQULy(OFRUD]yQGH 6SHQFHUVHGHWXYR /DPXMHUWHQtDODPLVPDDPSOLDVRQULVDTXH6SHQFHUYHtDFDGDYH]TXHVHPLUDEDHQXQ HVSHMR ³6R\ 2OLYLD ³DQXQFLy OD PXMHU WRPDQGR ODV PDQRV GH 6SHQFHU ,QFOXVR VXV GHGRV HUDQVLPLODUHVDORVGH6SHQFHUSHTXHxRV\GHOJDGRV<2OLYLDWHQtDORVPLVPRVRMRV YHUGHV\XQDIDPLOLDUYR]FODUDGHJDPDPHGLD³6DEtDTXHHUDVW~WDQSURQWRFRPR EDMDVWHGHOWUHQ
ž‰‹ƒ

³9DPRV ³2OLYLD WLUy GH 6SHQFHU KDFLD XQD GH ODV VDOLGDV ERUGHDQGR XQ JUXSR GH RILFLDOHVGHSROLFtDGH1XHYD


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͳͳͳ

/RV RMRV GH 6SHQFHU VH OOHQDURQ GH YHUWLJLQRVDV OiJULPDV $O LJXDO TXH VXV WHPRUHV FRPHQ]DURQDGHVYDQHFHUVH$OJRGHHVWRSDUHFtDWDQEXHQR



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

)XH XQD QRFKH GH HQHUR LQXVXDOPHQWH FiOLGD \ ODV FDOOHV HVWDEDQ UHSOHWDV GH JHQWH 7RPDURQXQWD[LKDVWDHO:HVW9LOODJHGRQGH2OLYLDVHDFDEDEDGHPXGDU\VHGHWXYR HQ'LDQH9RQ)XUVWHQEHUJXQDGHODVWLHQGDVIDYRULWDVGH2OLYLD\6SHQFHU$PHGLGD TXH VH HQWUDEDQ D WUDYpV GH ORV EDVWLGRUHV 6SHQFHU VH HQWHUy GH TXH 2OLYLD IXH XQD GLUHFWRUD GH DUWH HQ XQD QXHYD UHYLVWD GHGLFDGD D OD YLGD QRFWXUQD GH OD FLXGDG GH 1XHYD
³¢4XLHUHV TXH WRPH HVR SRU WL" ³SUHJXQWy 6SHQFHU /D FDUSHWD HQFDMDED IiFLOPHQWH HQODORQDGHJUDQWDPDxRGH6SHQFHU



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

(O DUFKLYR GH DFRUGHyQ EDMR HO EUD]R GH 2OLYLD FRPHQ]y D GHVOL]DUVH \ HOOD VDFy OD FDGHUDSDUDHYLWDUVHGHUUDPDUDKDVWDODDFHUD

ͳͳʹ

6SHQFHU DVLQWLy FRQ OD FDEH]D 1R HVWDED VHJXUD VL KXELHUD VLGR FDSD] GH VRSRUWDU HO VXVSHQVRGXUDQWHGRVVHPDQDVPiVWDPSRFR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢/RKDUtDV"³2OLYLD HPSXMyKDFLDHOODFRQJUDWLWXG³*UDFLDV0HHVWiYROYLHQGR ORFD 0RUJDQ TXHUtD TXH \R OOHYDUD OD LQIRUPDFLyQ DFHUFD GH QXHVWUR QXHYR DSDUWDPHQWRSDUDTXHSXGLHUDPLUDUSRUHQFLPD 5HFKD]y XQD FDOOH ODWHUDO SDVDQGR GH XQD KLOHUD GH FDVDV GH KHUPRVD SLHGUD /RV QLYHOHV GH OD VDOD VH LOXPLQDURQ FRQ OX] GRUDGD \ 6SHQFHU PLUy D ORV RMRV D XQ JUDQ JDWR FDOLFy GHVFDQVDQGR HQ XQD GH ODV YHQWDQDV IUHQWH D OD EDKtD (OOD \ 2OLYLD VH TXHGDURQHQVLOHQFLRHO~QLFRVRQLGRHUDHOGHVXVWDFRQHVHQODDFHUD/DVODJXQDVHQ OD FRQYHUVDFLyQ VLHPSUH LQTXLHWDEDQ D 6SHQFHU VLHPSUH SUHRFXSDGD GH TXH OD LQFRPRGLGDG IXHUD DOJXQD IDOWD GH HOOD DVt TXH HPSH]y D EDOEXFHDU DFHUFD GH VXV ORJURV +DEtD DQRWDGR XQ WRWDO GH GRFH JROHV HVWD WHPSRUDGD GH KRFNH\ +DEtD FRQVHJXLGRHOSDSHOSULQFLSDOHQFDGDREUDGHODHVFXHODGHVGHHOVpSWLPRJUDGR ³< WHQJR XQD $ HQ FDVL WRGDV ODV FODVHV ³VH MDFWy HOOD \ OXHJR VH GLR FXHQWD GH VX HUURU+L]RXQDPXHFD\VHSUHSDUyDVtPLVPDODFHUWH]DGHORTXHVHDYHFLQDED 2OLYLDVRQULy ³£(VRHVIDQWiVWLFR6SHQFHU(VWR\PX\LPSUHVLRQDGD 6SHQFHUDEULyXQRMRFRQFDXWHOD+DEtDHVSHUDGRTXH2OLYLDUHDFFLRQDUDGHODPLVPD PDQHUDTXHVXPDGUHORKDUtD ³¢&DVLWRGDVODVFODVHV"³(OODFDVLSRGtDRtUHOGHVSUHFLRGHOD6UD+DVWLQJV³¢(Q TXpFODVHQRWLHQHVXQD$"¢<SRUTXpVyORHOORVWLHQHQ$"¢3RUTXpQRWLHQHQXQD$ PiV"³<HQWRQFHV6SHQFHUVHVHQWLUtDFRPRXQDPLHUGDSDUDHOUHVWRGHOGtD 3HUR 2OLYLD QR HVWDED KDFLHQGR HVR 4XLpQ VDEtD TXH VL 2OLYLD KXELHUD PDQWHQLGR D 6SHQFHU WDO YH] KXELHUD VLGR GLIHUHQWH 7DO YH] QR VHUtD WDQ REVHVLYD DFHUFD GH VXV FDOLILFDFLRQHV R VH VHQWLUtD WDQ LQIHULRU FRQ RWUDV SHUVRQDV VLHPSUH GHVHVSHUDGD SRU GHPRVWUDUTXHHUDEDVWDQWHEXHQDEDVWDQWHGLJQDVXILFLHQWHPHQWHDPDEOH(OODQXQFD KDEUtD FRQRFLGR D $OL (O DVHVLQDWR GH $OL VHUtD VLPSOHPHQWH RWUD KLVWRULD HQ HO SHULyGLFR ³¢3RUTXpPHGHMDVWH"³VROWy6SHQFHU



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³%XHQR \R WHQtD GLHFLRFKR DxRV FXDQGR WH WXYH 'H OHMRV GHPDVLDGR MRYHQ SDUD WHQHU XQ EHEp DFDEDED GH HPSH]DU OD XQLYHUVLGDG
ͳͳ͵

2OLYLDVHGHWXYRHQHOFUXFHGHSHDWRQHVPLUDQGRSHQVDWLYDPHQWHDORVDOWRVHGLILFLRV GHHQIUHQWH

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

)LODGHOILDLEDDDGRSWDUWHVHQWtFRPRTXHHUDODRSFLyQFRUUHFWD3HURVLHPSUHPHKH SUHJXQWDGRDFHUFDGHWL /DOX]FDPELy6SHQFHUERUGHRHQWRUQRDXQDPXMHUTXHFDPLQDEDFRQXQYHVWLGRFRQ XQVXpWHUEODQFRGHOFDEOHXQLGRDOFUX]DU ³¢0LVSDGUHVVDEHQTXLpQHUHV" 2OLYLDVDFXGLyODFDEH]D ³


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6SHQFHU UHVWy LPSRUWDQFLD D VX GHFHSFLyQ QR TXHULHQGR SHQVDU TXH 2OLYLD IXHUD PDOFULDGD 2OLYLD \ 6SHQFHU VH DSUHVXUDURQ D XQ SHTXHxR \ DFRJHGRU UHVWDXUDQWH D SRFDVFXDGUDVGHGLVWDQFLD/DKDELWDFLyQROtDDD]DIUiQDMR\ORVPHMLOORQHV\HVWDED OOHQD GH JHQWH 6SHQFHU \ 2OLYLD VH VHQWDURQ HQ XQD PHVD OD OX] GH ODV YHODV SDUSDGHDQWHV HQ VXV URVWURV 2OLYLD GH LQPHGLDWR RUGHQy XQD ERWHOOD GH YLQR LQVWUX\HQGRDOFDPDUHURDTXHYHUWLHUDXQSRFRHQODFRSDGH6SHQFHUWDPELpQ

ͳͳͶ

³1R HVWR\ VHJXUD GH TXH WHQHPRV WLHPSR VXILFLHQWH DQWHV GH QXHVWUDV UHVHUYDV /D SUy[LPDYLVLWDVLQHPEDUJR7HORSURPHWR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³8Q EULQGLV ³GLMR HOOD OHYDQWDQGR VX FRSD FRQ OD GH 6SHQFHU³ 3RU PiV YLVLWDV FRPRpVWD 6SHQFHU VRQULy \ PLUy DOUHGHGRU 8Q MRYHQ TXH VH SDUHFtD PXFKR D 1RHO .DKQ H[FHSWR SUREDEOHPHQWH PHQRV SXHULO HVWDED VHQWDGR HQ HO EDU 8QD FKLFD FRQ ERWDV PDUURQHV\ORVSDQWDORQHVYDTXHURVPHWLGRVHQHOODVVHVHQWyMXQWRDpOULHQGR-XQWR D HOORV KDEtD XQD KHUPRVD SDUHMD PD\RUHV GH HVD HGDG OD PXMHU WHQtD XQ SRQFKR GH FRORU SODWHDGR HO KRPEUH FRQ XQ WUDMH HVWUHFKR D UD\DV 8QD FDQFLyQ SRS IUDQFpV HVWDEDVRQDQGRSRUORVDOWDYRFHV7RGRHQ1XHYD
³9R\DKDEODUOHGHWLHQ3DUtV³DJUHJy2OLYLD³<XQDYH]TXHWHFRQR]FDVpTXHWH DGRUDUD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6SHQFHU DVLQWLy FRQ OD FDEH]D &LHUWDPHQWH 2OLYLD FRPSUHQGLy SRU TXp QR OH KDEtD GLFKR D 0RUJDQ TXH VH UHXQLUtD FRQ HOOD FRPR HOOD QR OH KDEtD GLFKR D OD JHQWH WDPSRFR

ͳͳͷ

³'DUtD FXDOTXLHU FRVD SRUTXH YLYLHUDV DTXt ³GLMR³ 3HUR WHQJR XQD FRQIHVLyQ TXH KDFHU 0RUJDQ WLHQH GLILFXOWDGHV SDUD FRQILDU HQ OD JHQWH DOJXQRV DPLJRV OR KDQ XWLOL]DGR SRU VX GLQHUR HQ HO SDVDGR \ DKRUD HV PX\ FXLGDGRVR FRQ OD JHQWH TXH QR FRQRFH1ROHKHKDEODGRGHWLVLQHPEDUJRpOVDEtDTXHGLDXQEHEpFXDQGR\RHUD MRYHQSHURpOQRVDEtDTXH\RHVWDEDEXVFiQGRWH4XHUtDDVHJXUDUPHGHTXHHVWRHUD UHDOHQSULPHUOXJDU

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

6SHQFHUPRUGLyXQSHGD]RGHSDQFRQVLGHUDQGRVXVRSFLRQHV ³6LPHPXGRDTXtQLVLTXLHUD WHQGUtD TXHYLYLUFRQXVWHGHV³HOOD VRQyDSDJDGD³ 3XHGRFRQVHJXLUPLSURSLROXJDU 2OLYLDWHQtDXQDPLUDGDHVSHUDQ]DGRUDHQVXURVWUR ³¢3RGUtDVPDQHMDUYLYLUSRUWXFXHQWD" 6SHQFHUVHHQFRJLyGHKRPEURV ³&ODUR TXH Vt ³6XV SDGUHV HVWDEDQ DSHQDV DOUHGHGRU GH HVWRV GtDV HVWDED SUiFWLFDPHQWHYLYLHQGRSRUVXFXHQWD ³0HHQFDQWDUtDWHQHUWHDTXt³DGPLWLy2OLYLDFRQORVRMRVEULOODQWHV³%DVWDSHQVDU TXHSRGUtDVFRQVHJXLU XQGRUPLWRULRHQHOSXHEORFHUFDGHQRVRWURV(VWR\ VHJXUDGH TXHQXHVWURDJHQWHGHELHQHVUDtFHV0LFKDHOSRGUtDHQFRQWUDUDOJRUHDOPHQWHHVSHFLDO ³
ͳͳ͸

'HVSXpVGHSXOLUODERWHOODGHYLQR\GRVyUGHQHVGHSDVWDSXWWDQHVFDVHSDVHDEDQDOD SLVWD GH DWHUUL]DMH HQ HO UtR +XGVRQ D DFWXDU PiV FRPR ODV PHMRUHV DPLJRV TXH OD PDGUH\VXKLMD&XDQGR6SHQFHUYLRD2OLYLDHVSHUDQGRHOKHOLFySWHURVHDJDUUyGHVX EUD]R ³9R\DHFKDUWHGHPHQRV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ž‰‹ƒ

(OODELRLQIHULRUGH2OLYLDVHHVWUHPHFLy



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³(VWDUpGHYXHOWDSURQWR<YDPRVDKDFHUSODQHVSDUDKDFHUHVWRGHQXHYR¢7DOYH] XQDYLDMHGHFRPSUDVHQ0DGLVRQ$YHQXHODSUy[LPDYH]"7HYDVDPRULUHQODWLHQGD GH/RXERXWLQ ³(VXQWUDWR³6SHQFHUHQYROYLyVXVEUD]RVDOUHGHGRUGH2OLYLD2OtDFRPR1DUFLVR 5RGUtJXH] QR GH ORV SHUIXPHV IDYRULWRV GH 6SHQFHU 2OLYLD ODQ]y XQ EHVR \ VXELy DO KHOLFySWHUR/DKpOLFHFRPHQ]yDJLUDU\6SHQFHUJLUR\YROYLyDPLUDUDODFLXGDG/RV WD[LVLEDQKDVWDHO:HVW6LGH+LJKZD\/DJHQWHFRUUtDSRUHOFDPLQRGHO:HVW6LGHD SHVDU GH TXH KDEtDQ SDVDGR ODV  /DV OXFHV EULOODEDQ HQ HO YHQWDQDV GHO DSDUWDPHQWR8QEDUFRGHILHVWDHQHO+XGVRQVHGHVOL]DEDVLQLQYLWDGRVYHVWLGRVFRQ HOHJDQWHVWUDMHV\YHVWLGRVGHPDQHUDYLVLEOHHQODFXELHUWD 6HPRUtDGHJDQDVGHYLYLUDTXt$KRUDWHQtDXQDUD]yQSDUDKDFHUOR (OKHOLFySWHURGHVSHJyGHOVXHOR2OLYLDGHVOL]yDXULFXODUHVJUDQGHVVREUHODVRUHMDVVH DVRPySRUODYHQWDQD\VDOXGyFRQHQWXVLDVPRD6SHQFHU ³£%RQYR\DJH³6SHQFHUOORUDED&XDQGRVRSHVyODEROVDPiVDOWDHQHOKRPEUROD PHWLyHOEUD]R/DFDUSHWDGHDFRUGHyQGH2OLYLD /DVDFy\ODDJLWyVREUHVXFDEH]D

ž‰‹ƒ

ͳͳ͹

³£6H WH ROYLGy HVWR ³3HUR 2OLYLD HVWDED GLFLHQGR DOJR DO SLORWR FRQ ORV RMRV HQ HO KRUL]RQWH 6SHQFHU DJLWy KDVWD TXH HO KHOLFySWHUR HUD XQ SXQWLWR HQ HO KRUL]RQWH SRU ~OWLPR EDMR ORV EUD]RV \ VH GLR OD YXHOWD 3RU OR PHQRV WHQtD XQD H[FXVD SDUD YHU D 2OLYLDGHQXHYR 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR <HQXQWUHQUXPERKDFLD <HQXQWUHQUXPERKDFLD HORHVWHDOGtDVLJXLHQWH HORHVWHDOGtDVLJXLHQWH 7UDGXFLGRSRU'\DQQD &RUUHJLGRSRU9DQ  

/

DVLJXLHQWHWDUGH$ULDHVWDEDHQODSODWDIRUPDRHVWHGH6(37$HQ


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

$ULD HQWHQGtD SRU TXp ORV 'L/DXUHQWLV QR KDQ TXHULGR YROYHU D 5RVHZRRG PLHQWUDV GXUDEDHOMXLFLRSHUR¢SRUTXpKDEtDQHOHJLGR
ͳͳͺ

7DPSRFRKXERXQVRILVWLFDGR:DZDR6WDUEXFNVFHUFDQRVyORXQDWLHQGDVyUGLGDTXH RIUHFtDOHFWXUDVGHPDQRV\´RWURVVHUYLFLRVSVtTXLFRVµLQGHSHQGLHQWHPHQWHGHORTXH HVWRVLJQLILFDED\XQEDUOODPDGRHO
6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

3HQVyYHUD-HQQD&DYDQDXJKHQVXSDWLRGHODQWHURD\HU/HKDEtDSDUHFLGRFRPRVL -HQQD OH HVWXYLHUD D SXQWR GH GHFLUOH DOJR D $ULD SHUR OXHJR GHFLGLy QR KDFHUOR $GHPiV GH HVR (PLO\ OH KDEtD PRVWUDGR D $ULD XQ WH[WR GH ´$µ XQD IRWR GH $OL \ -HQQDMXQWDVORTXH$ULDQXQFDKDEtDYLVWR ¢9HV"GLMR(PLO\HQHOWH[WR3DUHFHTXH$OL\-HQQDIXHURQDPLJDV3HURQRHUDSRVLEOHTXH $OLHVWXYLHUDKDFLpQGRVHSDVDUSRUDPLJDGH-HQQDFRQHOILQGHREWHQHUODFRQILDQ]D GH -HQQD (UD FRPR TXH $OL OOHYDUD D DOJXLHQ D VX FDVD VyOR SDUD UREDU WRGRV VXV VHFUHWRV (OWUHQUXJLyHQODHVWDFLyQ\SDUyHQVHFR(OFRQGXFWRUGHXQJROSHDEULyODSXHUWD\ ODJHQWHSRFRDSRFREDMyODVHVFDOHUDVGHPHWiOLFDV&XDQGR$ULDYLRHOSHORUXELRGH -DVRQ\VXFKDTXHWDJULVVXERFDVHVHFy&RUULyKDFLDpO\OHWRFyHOFRGR ³¢-DVRQ"³-DVRQVHJLURGHXQWLUyQDOSDUHFHUHQJXDUGLD&XDQGRYLRTXHHUD$ULD pOVHUHODMy ³2K ³GLMR³ +H\ ³6XV RMRV SDUSDGHDURQ XQ ODGR D RWUR³ ¢4Xp HVWiV KDFLHQGR DTXt" $ULDVHDFODUyODJDUJDQWDUHVLVWLHQGRODWHQWDFLyQGHGDUODYXHOWDYXHOYHDVXFRFKHH LUVH ³7DOYH]HVWR\KDFLHQGRHOULGtFXORGHPtPLVPDSHURPHJXVWyKDEODUFRQWLJRHORWUR GtD < \R TXHUtD VDEHU VL SRGUtDPRV SDVDU HO UDWR DOJ~Q PRPHQWR 3HUR VL QR HVWi ELHQWDPELpQ -DVRQVRQULyPLUDQGRLPSUHVLRQDGR6DOLyGHODIRUPDGHXQDPXOWLWXGGHKRPEUHVGH QHJRFLRV ³1RHVWiVKDFLHQGRHOULGtFXOR³GLMRPLUDQGRDORVRMRVGH$ULD ³¢1RORHVWR\"³(OFRUD]yQGH$ULDYROWHDEDPiV -DVRQPLUyVXUHORMGHJUDQWDPDxR ³¢4XLHUHVWRPDUXQWUDJRHQHVWHPRPHQWR"7HQJRDOJ~QWLHPSR

ž‰‹ƒ

³
ͳͳͻ

³6VHJXUR³$ULDEDOEXFHyFRQODYR]TXHEUDGD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

$ULDDVLQWLyFRQODFDEH]DDJUDGHFLGDGHTXHQRKXELHUDVXJHULGRHO6DOyQ


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

/RVGHVWHOORVUXELRVTXHKDEtDYLVWRKDEtDQVLGRSUREDEOHPHQWHGH0RQDTXHODKDEtD DFRVDGRDFDGDXQDGHHOODVFRQVXVPiVVXFLRVVHFUHWRV3HURDKRUDTXH0RQDKDEtD PXHUWR$ULDWRGDYtDDYHFHVMXUDEDTXHKDEtDYLVWRDDOJXLHQFRQSHORUXELRFRPRHO

ͳʹͲ

6H DFHUFy KDFLD OD EDUUD \ VH VHQWy HQ XQ WDEXUHWH $ULD DSDUWR OD PLUDGD 9ROYLy D DQWHVGHTXHHOFXHUSRGH$OLKXELHUDVLGRHQFRQWUDGRKDEtDSHQVDGRTXH$OLR´$µWDO YH]VXIDQWDVPD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

GH $OL GHWUiV GH ORV iUEROHV \ DSDUHFHU HQ ODV YHQWDQDV PLUiQGROD PiV DOOi GH VX WXPED 8QFDPDUHURGHSHORFRUWR\YHVWLGRGHQHJURWRPRVXVyUGHQHV$ULDSLGLySLQRWQRLU HOODSHQVDEDTXHODKDFtDSDUHFHUPiVVRILVWLFDGD\-DVRQRUGHQyXQDJLPOHW&XDQGR VHGLRFXHQWDGHH[SUHVLyQFRQIXVDGH$ULDGLMR ³(VYRGND\MXJRGHOLPyQ8QDDPLJDPHGLRHVWRHQ


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³%XHQR ³$ULD VH TXHGy PLUDQGR ORV UHWUDWRV GH DOUHGHGRU GH OD KDELWDFLyQ GH OD YLHMD DULVWRFUDFLD 3RU GHEDMR GH FDGD XQR GH ORV UHWUDWRV HVWDEDQ VXV IHFKDV GH QDFLPLHQWR\ODGHVXPXHUWH³/RVFKLFRVSRUHMHPSOR(Q,VODQGLDQROHVLPSRUWDED VL\RHUDPX\SRSXODU6HSUHRFXSDEDSRUODP~VLFDTXHHVFXFKDRORVOLEURVTXHPH JXVWDEDOHHU(Q5RVHZRRGDORVFKLFRVVyOROHVJXVWDEDXQWLSRGHFKLFD

ͳʹͳ

³¢&yPRHVHVR"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

-DVRQDSR\yORVFRGRVHQODEDUUD ³8QDFKLFDFRPRPLKHUPDQDTXLHUHVGHFLU³$ULDVHHQFRJLyGHKRPEURVPLUDQGR DRWURODGR(VRHUDORTXHTXHUtDGHFLUSHURQRKDEtDTXHULGRGHFLUHOQRPEUHGH$OL HQYR]DOWD 8QDH[SUHVLyQTXH$ULDQRSXGRDQDOL]DUIORWDEDVREUHHOURVWURGH-DVRQ6HSUHJXQWy VL-DVRQVDEtDHOHIHFWRTXH$OLKDEtDWHQLGRHQORVFKLFRVLQFOXVRORVPiVYLHMRV-DVRQ KDEtDVDELGRGHODUHODFLyQVHFUHWDGH$OLFRQ,DQDODYH]RWXYRTXHVHUXQDVRUSUHVD GHVSXpV GH KDEHU VLGR DUUHVWDGR ¢&yPR VH VLQWLy -DVRQ DO UHVSHFWR" -DVRQ WRPy XQ VRUERGHVXJLPOHWVXPLUDGDVHULDVHKDEtDLGR ³¢$VtTXHWHHQDPRUDURQPXFKRHQ,VODQGLD" $ULDQHJyFRQODFDEH]D ³+H WHQLGR DOJXQRV QRYLRV SHUR VyOR KH HVWDGR HQDPRUDGR XQD YH] ³7RPy WRUSHPHQWH RWUR WUDJR GH YLQR $SHQDV KDEtD FRPLGR DOJR KR\ \ WRPDED HO YLQR VXPDPHQWHUiSLGR³)XHFRQPL$3SURIHVRUGH,QJOpV7DOYH]W~KDVRtGRKDEODUGH pO 8QSOLHJXHIRUPDGRHQWUHORVRMRVGH-DVRQ7DOYH]QR ³6HWHUPLQRDKRUD³GLMR³+RQHVWDPHQWH IXHXQGHVDVWUH/HSLGLHURQTXHGHMDUD VXSXHVWRGHHQVHxDQ]DSRUPteOGHMyODFLXGDGKDFHXQSDUGHPHVHV\GLMRTXHVH PDQWHQGUtDHQFRQWDFWRSHURQRKHWHQLGRQRWLFLDVGHpO -DVRQ DVLQWLy FRQ VLPSDWtD $ULD VH VRUSUHQGLy GH OR FyPRGD TXH VH VHQWtD D GHFLUOH HVWR$OJRVREUHpOODKDFtDVHQWLUVHVHJXUDFRPRVLQRODIXHUDDMX]JDU ³¢$OJXQDYH]KDVHVWDGRHQDPRUDGR"³SUHJXQWyHOOD ³6yORXQDYH]³-DVRQLQFOLQyVXFDEH]DKDFLDDWUiV\VHWUDJyHOUHVWRGHVXEHELGD (OKLHORVHVDFXGLyFRQWUDHOYDVRYDFtR³(OODPHURPSLyHOFRUD]yQ ³¢4XLpQHUD"

ž‰‹ƒ

³1RHVLPSRUWDQWH$KRUDQRSRUORPHQRV³(OFDPDUHURWUDMR-DVRQRWUDJLPOHW (QWRQFHV-DVRQHPSXMRHOEUD]RGH$ULD³7~VDEHV\RSHQVpTXHLEDVDGHFLUTXHOD SHUVRQDGHODTXHHVWDEDVHQDPRUDGRHUDGHPt /DERFD$ULDGHVHDEULy¢-DVRQORVDEtD"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͳʹʹ

-DVRQVHHQFRJLyGHKRPEURV



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³
³3HQVp TXH HUD XQD FKLFD EHOOD \ PDGXUD FRQ OD TXH HQ UHDOLGDG TXHUtDV KDEODU QR FRQXQDORFDGHVH[WRJUDGR³DJUHJy$ULDVVRQURMiQGRVH



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

< DKRUD $ULD TXH SHQVDED HQ HOOR OD VHFUHWDULD KDEtD GLFKR HOOD GLMR TXH HUD VX KHUPDQD¢3HUR$ULDQRKDEtDYLVWRD$OLHVHPLVPRGtDGLULJLpQGRVHDORVYHVWLGRUHV GHO JLPQDVLR" 4XL]iV HUD OD QRYLD VHFUHWD GH -DVRQ TXH OR OODPDED VDELHQGR TXH OD ~QLFDPDQHUDGHTXHHOSHUVRQDOGH5RVHZRRG'D\VHORSDVDUDVHUtDVLGLMHUDTXHHUD XQPLHPEURGHIDPLOLD

ͳʹ͵

$ULD DVLQWLy FRQ OD FDEH]D /D VHFUHWDULD KDEtD WRPDGR GHO EUD]R GH -DVRQ \ OR JXLy KDFLDODRILFLQD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

-DVRQDVLQWLyFRQODFDEH]DOHQWDPHQWHFRQUHFRQRFLPLHQWReOPXUPXUyDOJREDMRVX DOLHQWRDOJRTXHVRQDEDPX\SDUHFLGRQRH[DFWDPHQWH ³¢3HUGyQ"³SUHJXQWy$ULD ³1DGD³-DVRQWRPyHOUHVWRGHVXJLPOHWHQXQVHJXQGR(QWRQFHVpOODPLUyFRQ WLPLGH]³%LHQ0HDOHJURGHHVWpVKDFLHQGRWXHQDPRUDPLHQWRXQSRFRPiVHYLGHQWH DKRUD 8QDRQGDHOpFWULFDSDVRSRUODHVSDOGDGH$ULD ³7DOYH]VHDPiVTXHXQIOHFKD]R³VXVXUUy ³(VRHVSHUR³GLMR-DVRQ6HVRQULHURQWtPLGDPHQWHXQRVDRWURV$ULDGLRXQYXHOFR HOFRUD]yQHQVXVRtGRV /DSXHUWDSULQFLSDOVHDEULy\XQJUXSRGHHVWXGLDQWHVGH+ROOLVHQWUDURQGHVILODQGR $OJXLHQHQODHVTXLQDHQFHQGLyXQFLJDUULOORVRSODQGRHOKXPRHQHODLUHWUDQVSDUHQWH -DVRQPLUyVXUHORM\VHPHWLyODPDQREROVLOOR ³(VWR\ PX\ WDUGH ³6DFy VX FDUWHUD \ VDFy XQ ELOOHWH GH YHLQWH OR VXILFLHQWH SDUD FXEULUWRGDVODVEHELGDV/XHJRPLUyD$ULD³$VtTXH³FRPHQ]y ³$Vt TXH ³$ULD UHSLWLy < HQWRQFHV VH LQFOLQy KDFLD GHODQWH DJDUUy OD PDQR \ OR EHVy GH OD IRUPD HQ OD TXH KDEtD TXHUtD EHVDUOR KDFH DxRV D IXHUD GHO VDOyQ GH SHULRGLVPR6XVODELRVVDEtDQDMXJRGHOLPyQ\YRGND -DVRQODDWUDMRKDFLDpODPDVDQGRVXFDEHOORFRQVXVPDQRV'HVSXpVGHXQPRPHQWR URPSLHURQHOEHVRFRQXQDVRQULVD $ULDSHQVyTXHVHLEDDGHVPDOODU ³$VtTXHQRVYHPRVPiVWDUGH³GLMR-DVRQ

ž‰‹ƒ

³2K'LRVPtR³VXVXUUy$ULDYROYLHQGRGHQXHYRDODEDUUD8QDJUDQSDUWHGHHOOD TXHUtDVXELUHQHOWDEXUHWHGHODEDUUD\JULWDUDWRGDODVDODORTXHDFDEDGHVXFHGHU 7HQtD TXH FRQWiUVHOR D DOJXLHQ 3HUR (OOD HVWDED RFXSDGD FRQ ;DYLHU $ 0LNH QR OH LPSRUWDUtD 3HQVy HQ (PLO\ SHUR (PLO\ SRGUtD PDWDUPH GLFLHQGR TXH $OL HUD UHDOPHQWHEXHQDGHFRUD]yQ\-DVRQQRORHUD

ͳʹͶ

³'HILQLWLYDPHQWH³UHVSLUy$ULD-DVRQFDPLQDEDSRUODKDELWDFLyQDEULyODSXHUWD\ VHIXH



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

6XWHOpIRQRFRPHQ]yDVRQDU$ULDVDOWR\ORPLUy8QQXHYRPHQVDMHGHWH[WRGHFtD ODSHTXHxDYHQWDQD(OUHPLWHQWHHUDGHVFRQRFLGR (O HQWXVLDVPR GH $ULD VH HVIXPR DO LQVWDQWH 0LUy DOUHGHGRU GH OD EDUUD GHO EDU /DV SHUVRQDV VH VHQWDEDQ HQ ORV VRIiV FRQFHQWUDGDV SURIXQGDPHQWH HQ VX FRQYHUVDFLyQ 8QKRPEUHGHHGDGXQLYHUVLWDULRFRQUDVWDVOHVXVXUUyDOFDPDUHURGHYH]HQFXDQGR PLUDQGRHQGLUHFFLyQGH$ULD8QDFRUULHQWHGHDLUHTXHVDOtDGHODSDUWHGHDWUiVGHOD VDOD KDFLHQGR EDLODU D ODV OODPDV GH ODV YHODV (UD FRPR VL XQD SXHUWD LQYLVLEOH VH DFDEDEDGHDEULU\FHUUDU 8QQXHYRPHQVDMHGHWH[WR$ULDSDVyODVPDQRVSRUVXFDEHOOR3RFRDSRFRDSUHWyHO ERWyQOHHU ¢'LVIUXWDVWHGHVXJLPOHW"%XHQRORVLHQWRFDULxRSHURODIDQWDVtDWHUPLQy(OJUDQKHUPDQRHVWi HVFRQGLHQGRDOJRGHWL<FRQItDHQPtQRTXLHUHVVDEHUORTXHHV 

ž‰‹ƒ

ͳʹͷ

³$



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR (QJXDUGLD.DWH (QJXDUGLD.DWH 7UDGXFLGRSRU'KDP/RYH &RUUHJLGRSRU&DDPLOOH 

8

QDKRUDGHVSXpVHVDPLVPDQRFKH +DQQDKROJD]DQHDEDIXHUDGHODH[WUDxD FDVD PRGHUQLVWD GH ORV 0RQWJRPHU\ HVSHUDQGR TXH 0LNH VDOLHUD 0iV WHPSUDQR HVD PLVPD WDUGH KDEtD OODPDGR D VX SDSi DO WUDEDMR \ OH KDEtD SUHJXQWDGRVLSRUIDYRUSRGtDLUDODOLEUHUtDHVWDQRFKHDHVWXGLDUSDUDXQDSUXHEDGH IUDQFpV«VLQ.DWH1HFHVLWDEDHVWDUVRODSDUDPHPRUL]DUORVXILFLHQWHODODUJDOLVWDGH YHUERVLUUHJXODUHVH[SOLFy



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

0LUy IXHUD GH OD YHQWDQD KDFLD ODV SHTXHxDV OXFHV GHO SyUWLFR IURQWDO GH ORV 0RQWJRPHU\ +DEtDQ SDVDGR DxRV GHVGH TXH KDEtD HVWDGR HQ OD FDVD GH $ULD \ \D KDEtD ROYLGDGR OR H[WUDxD TXH HUD (O IUHQWH GH OD FDVD WHQtD VyOR XQD YHQWDGD SRVLFLRQDGDSRUHQFLPDGHODHVFDOHUD(OUHVSDOGRGHODFDVDSRUHOFRQWUDULRQRHUD QDGD VLQR VyOR YHQWDQDV TXH VH H[WHQGtDQ GHVGH HO SULPHU SLVR KDVWD HO WHUFHUR 8QD YH]FXDQGR+DQQD\ORVRWURVHVWDEDQHQHOHVWXGLRGH$ULDPLUDQGRXQDIDPLOLDGH YHQDGRV FDPLQDQGR SHQRVDPHQWH SRU VX SDWLR $OL PLUy D ODV JUDQGHV YHQWDQDV \ FKDVTXHyVXOHQJXD³¢1RVHSUHRFXSDQFKLFDVSRUTXHODVSHUVRQDVORVHVStHQ"³(OOD OHGLRD$ULDXQVXDYHFRGD]R³(QWRQFHVLPDJLQRTXHVXVSDSiVQRWHQGUiQQLQJ~Q VHFUHWRTXHQRTXLHUHQTXHQDGLHVHSD¢FLHUWR"³$ULDVHKDEtDVRQURMDGR\GHMDGROD KDELWDFLyQ +DQQD QR KDEtD VDELGR SRUTXH $ULD VH KDEtD HQRMDGR WDQWR SHUR DKRUD VDEtD$OLKDEtDGHVFXELHUWRTXHHOSDSiGH$ULDHVWDEDWHQLHQGRXQDDYHQWXUD\HVWDED

ͳʹ͸

³'HDFXHUGR³6XSDSiHVWXYRGHDFXHUGRGHPDQHUDEUXVFD$IRUWXQDGDPHQWHVX SDSi \D HVWDED DIORMDQGR FRQ VX UHJOD GH YHDFXDOTXLHUVLWLRGRQGHYD\D.DWH D\HU KDEtD GHMDGR D +DQQD FRPSUDU HO UHJDOR SDUD HO EDE\ VKRZHU GH 0HUHGLWK VROD WDPELpQ 3DUHFtD TXH pO WDPELpQ OH SHUPLWLy D .DWH KDFHU DOJXQDV FRPSUDV SULYDGDV SDUD HO EHEp« HQ OD PLVPD WLHQGD ,QPHGLDWDPHQWH GHVSXpV GH TXH +DQQD KXER UHFLELGRVXSDVHIXHUDGHODFiUFHOGH.DWHGHVXSDSiOHKDEtDHQYLDGRXQPHQVDMHD 0LNH\OHKDEtDGLFKRTXHTXHUtDTXHODOOHYDUDDXQDFLWD«GHXQRDXQR/RTXHVX SDSiQRVXSLHUDQRORODVWLPDUtD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

WRUWXUDQGRD$ULDFRQHVDLQIRUPDFLyQGHODPLVPDPDQHUDTXHVROtDWRUWXUDUD+DQQD VREUHDWUDFRQHV\SXUJDV 7RGDXQDSHUUD 0LNH DSDUHFLy HQ HO SyUWLFR GHO IUHQWH 7HQtD SXHVWRV XQRV MHDQV RVFXURV XQ ODUJR DEULJRGHODQDFRQHOFXHOORGREODGR\FDUJDEDXQHQRUPHUDPRGHURVDV+DQQDVLQWLy FRVTXLOODV HQ VX HVWyPDJR 1R HV TXH HVWXYLHUD HPRFLRQDGD SRU HVWD FLWD R DOJR (UD VLPSOHPHQWHDJUDGDEOHFRQVHJXLUIORUHVHQXQGtDWDQJULVGHLQYLHUQR ³6RQKHUPRVDV³GLMRPLHQWUDV0LNHDEUtDODSXHUWD³1RGHELVWH ³'H DFXHUGR ³0LNH KDOy ODV IORUHV GH QXHYR D VX SHFKR \ HO SDSHO FHORIiQ DUUXJiQGRVH³6HODVGDUpDPLRWUDQRYLD +DQQDWRPyVXEUD]R ³1RWHDWUHYDV³(VRGHILQLWLYDPHQWHQRHUDJUDFLRVRQRGHVSXpVGHOWUXFRTXHKDEtD VDFDGRFRQ+DQQD\.DWHHQHO%DE\VKRZHUD\HU(OODJROSHWHyFRQVXVGHGRVHQHO YRODQWHGHVX3ULXV³(QWRQFHV¢$GyQGHYDPRV" ³$O.LQJ-DPHV³0LNHEURPHy +DQQDORPLUyFRQFDXWHOD ³1RD5LYH*DXFKH³&RQVXVXHUWH/XFDVVHUtDHOPHVHUR'HPDVLDGRLQFyPRGR ³


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

7RPDURQORVFDPLQRVWUDVHURVKDFLDHOFHQWURFRPHUFLDO+DQQDGLVPLQXtDODYHORFLGDG FDGDYH]TXHYHtDXQDVHxDOGH&58&('(9(1$'26HVWDEDQGHVSLDGDGDVHQHVWD pSRFDGHODxR0LNHSXVRXQ&'HQHOHVWpUHRGHO3ULXV8QDEDMDYLEUDFLyQGHOEDMR OOHQy HO FDUUR OXHJR OD YR] FKLOORQHV GHO FDQWDQWH 0LNH LQPHGLDWDPHQWH HPSH]y D FDQWDU+DQQDUHFRQRFLyHVDFDQFLyQ\FDQWyWUDQTXLODPHQWHWDPELpQ0LNHODPLUy

ͳʹ͹

³(VPHMRUTXHYD\DPRVHQWRQFHVDQWHVGHTXHFDPELHVGHSDUHFHU

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢6DEHVTXLpQHVVRQ" ³(V /HG =HSSHOtQ ³GLMR +DQQD GH PDQHUD FDVXDO 6HDQ $FNDUG HO H[H[QRYLR GH +DQQDKDEtDWUDWDGRGHHVFXFKDUDODEDQGDHOYHUDQRSDVDGRSDUHFLyVHUXQGtDGH I~WERO HQ 5RVHZRRG \ FRVDV GH FKLFRV SHUR KDEtD GHFLGLGR TXH HUDQ GHPDVLDGR RVFXURV \ GH PDO KXPRU SDUD VXV SXURV \ YLUJLQDOHV RtGRV (O FHxR GH 0LNH HVWDED IUXQFLGR FRQ LQFUHGXOLGDG³ ¢4Xp FUHtDV TXH HVFXFKDED 0LOH\ &\UXV" ³HOOD GLMR³ ¢/RV -RQDV %URWKHUV" ³'H KHFKR .DWH HVFXFKDED D ORV -RQDV %URWKHUV (VR \ PHORGtDVGHHVSHFWiFXORVGH%URDGZD\ 3DUD HO PRPHQWR HQ TXH HVWDEDQ OOHJDQGR DO FHQWUR FRPHUFLDO .LQJ -DPHV DPERV HVWDEDQ FDQWDQGR D WRGR SXOPyQ ODV OHWUDV GH ´'D]HG DQG &RQIXVHGµ 0LNH VH VDEtD FDGDYHUVRGHFRUD]yQHLQFOXVRKL]RXQGUDPiWLFRVyORGHJXLWDUUDHQHODLUHORTXH KL]RTXH+DQQDVHGREODUDGHULVD (O HVWDFLRQDPLHQWR GHO FHQWUR FRPHUFLDO HVWDED OOHQR 8Q +RPH 'HSRW HVWDED D VX L]TXLHUGD ODV SXHUWDV GHO %ORRPLQJGDOH HQ OD PLWDG \ OD VHFFLyQ DOWD FRQ WLHQGDV FRPR /RXLV 9XLWWRQ \ -LPP\ &KRR HVWDEDQ D OD GHUHFKD 0LHQWUDV VDOLHURQ DO DLUH FUXMLHQWH GH OD QRFKH +DQQD HVFXFKy D DOJXLHQ JUXxLU XQ KRPEUH HVWDED SDUDGR DO ODGRGHOFDUUREODQFRHQHODSDUFDPLHQWRGHO+RPH'HSRWOXFKDQGRSDUDOHYDQWDUXQ WRQHOSHVDGRGHORTXHSDUHFtDFRPRSURSDQRHQHOED~OGHVXDXWR&XDQGRVHPRYLy IXHUDGHOFDPLQRVHGLRFXHQWDGHODHVFULWXUDHQODSXHUWDGHOFDUUR'HSDUWDPHQWRGH 3ROLFtDGH5RVHZRRG(OVXMHWRWHQtDXQDEDUELOODDQJXODU\XQDQDUL]SXQWLDJXGD8Q PHFKyQGHFDEHOORRVFXURVHHVFDSRGHODFLPDGHVXVRPEUHURQHJURGHODQD ¢:LOGHQ"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³9DPRV ³OH GLMR D 0LNH GiQGROH D :LOGHQ XQD ~OWLPD PLUDGD +DEtD FHUUDGR HO ED~O\DKRUDHVWDEDVRVWHQLHQGRVXWHOpIRQRHQHORtGRVXSRVWXUDUtJLGDVXVKRPEURV FXDGUDGRV/HUHFRUGyD+DQQDGHXQDYH]KDFHXQRVFXDQWRVPHVHVGHYXHOWDFXDQGR :LOGHQ\VXPDGUHKDEtDQHVWDGRVDOLHQGReOKDEtDSDVDGRODQRFKH\HQODPDxDQD +DQQDKDEtDHVFXFKDGRORVVXVXUURVHQHOSDVLOOR&XDQGRPLUyYLRD:LOGHQSDUDGR DOIUHQWHGHODYHQWDQDGHOFRUUHGRUPLUDQGRKDFLDHOSDWLRFRQVXFXHUSRUtJLGR\VX YR]URQFD\iVSHUD¢$TXLpQGHPRQLRVOHHVWDEDKDEODQGR"¢(UDVRQiPEXOR"+DQQDVH KDEtDGHVOL]DGRDVXKDELWDFLyQDQWHVGHTXH:LOGHQODYLHUD

ͳʹͺ

+DQQDPLUyPLHQWUDVOHYDQWDEDHOVHJXQGRWXERGHSURSDQROXFKDQGRSDUDPHWHUORHQ HO ED~O DO ODGR GHO RWUR ¢$FDVR VX FDVD QR WHQtD XQ FDOHQWDGRU QRUPDO" &RQVLGHUR VDOXGDUSHUROXHJRVHJLUy:LOGHQKDEtDGLFKRDODSUHQVDTXHKDEtDQYLVWRHOFXHUSR GH,DQHQHOERVTXH+DEtDSXHVWRDWRGR5RVHZRRGHQFRQWUDGHHOORV,PEpFLO

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(QVHULR¢TXpYLRODPDPiGH+DQQDHQHVHVXMHWRGHWRGDVIRUPDV":LOGHQHUDOLQGR SHURQRWDQOLQGR&XDQGR+DQQDORKDEtDDWUDSDGRVDOLHQGRGHODGXFKDKDFHWRGRV HVRVPHVHVQLVLTXLHUDOXFtDDVtGHIDEXORVRPHGLRGHVQXGR1RHVTXHDHOODOHJXVWDUD RDOJRSHUR+DQQDWHQtDHOSUHVHQWLPLHQWRREVHVLRQDGRGHODFURVVHGHTXH0LNHOXFLUtD PXFKRPiVVHQVXDO 2WWHUODERXWLTXHIDYRULWDGH+DQQDHVWDEDPHWLGDDOODGRGH&DUWLHU\/RXLV9XLWWRQ (OODHQWUyLQKDODQGRODHVHQFLDFRQRORUDYHODV'LSW\TXH)HUJLHHVWDEDHQHOHVWpUHR \EDVWLGRUHVGH&DWKHULQH0DODQGULQR1DQHWWH/HSRUH\0RVFKLQRVHH[WHQGtDQDQWH HOOD6XVSLUyIHOL]/DVFKDTXHWDVGHFXHURHUDQEULOODQWHV\H[XEHUDQWHV/RVYHVWLGRV GLiIDQRVGHVHGDODVEXIDQGDVGHJUDQWDPDxRSDUHFtDQJLUDUGHORUR6DVKDXQDGHODV FKLFDV GH YHQWDV YLR D +DQQD \ OD VDOXGR +DQQD HUD XQD GH ODV PHMRUHV FOLHQWHV GH 2WWHU +DQQDLQPHGLDWDPHQWHVHOHFFLRQyXQRVFXDQWRVYHVWLGRVGLVIUXWDQGRHOVRQLGRTXHORV SHUFKHURVGHPDGHUDKDFtDQFXDQGRHUDQFROJDGRVMXQWRV ³¢7HJXVWDUtDTXHSXVLHUDHVRVHQVXYHVWXDULR"³GLMRXQDIDOVDYR]DJXGD+DQQDVH JLUy0LNHHVWDEDSDUDGRGHWUiVGHHOOD³
³1R SDUD WL ³+DQQD VH EXUOy³ 7HQGUiV TXH XVDU WX LPDJLQDFLyQ ³&HUUDQGR OD FRUWLQDQRSXGRHYLWDUVRQUHtU0LNHPHUHFtDXQRVFXDQWRVSXQWRVSRUVHUWDQFUHDWLYR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³¢1LVLTXLHUDWHSUREDUDVORVELNLQLV"

ͳʹͻ

/DH[SUHVLyQGH0LNHVHPDUFKLWy

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

6HOOHYyODEROVDGHJDPX]DFRORUFLUXHODDOWDEXUHWHGHFXHURVXDYH\DFDULFLyVXREUD GH OD EDQGHUD GH /D &iSVXOD GHO 7LHPSR TXH KDEtD HQYXHOWR DOUHGHGRU GH OD FRUUHD 'HVSXpV GH FLHUWD FRQVLGHUDFLyQ +DQQD KDEtD GHFLGLGR GHFRUDU HO SHGD]R GH KRPHQDMHSDUD$OLLQFRUSRUDQGRORVGLVHxRVRULJLQDOHVGH$OLGHVH[WRJUDGR(OORJR &KDQHO HVWDED DO ODGR GHO VDSR PDQJD 8QD FKLFD MXJDGRUD GH KRFNH\ JROSHDED FRQ IXHU]DXQDERODDODVLQLFLDOHVGH/RXLV9XLWWRQ+DQQDHVWDEDEDVWDQWHFRPSODFLGDFRQ HOUHVXOWDGRILQDO *LUiQGRVHVHTXLWyVXVZHDWHUVHGHVDSXQWRVXEUDVLHU\OHTXLWyODFUHPDOOHUDDVXV SDQWDORQHV \ ORV SDWHy -XVWR FXDQGR HVWDED DOFDQ]DQGR SRU HO SULPHU YHVWLGR OD FRUWLQDGHOYHVWLGRUVHDEULy0LNHPHWLyVXFDEH]D +DQQDGHMyVDOLUXQJULWR\VHFXEULyORVVHQRV ³¢4XpGHPRQLRV"³HOODJULWy ³£2RSV ³GLMR 0LNH³ 0LHUGD OR VLHQWR +DQQD 3HQVp TXH pVWH HUD HO EDxR £eVWH OXJDU HV FRPR XQ ODEHULQWR ³6XV RMRV DWHUUL]DURQ HQ HO HVFRWH GH +DQQD /XHJR VH PRYLHURQDVXURSDLQWHULRUHVFDVDGHHQFDMH ³£6DOGHDTXt³+DQQDJUXxyGiQGROHD0LNHXQDSDWDGDFRQVXSLHGHVQXGR8QRV FXDQWRVPLQXWRVGHVSXpVVDOLyGHOYHVWLGRUXQRGHORVYHVWLGRVSXHVWRVREUHVXEUD]R 0LNHHVWDEDVHQWDGRDOODGRGHVLOODDOODGRGHOHVSHMRGHWUHVFDUDV3DUHFtDFRPRXQ FDFKRUULWRPDOYDGRTXHUHFLpQDFDEDGHPDVWLFDUODVSDQWXIODVGHVXGXHxR ³¢(VWiVHQRMDGD"³pOSUHJXQWy ³6t³GLMR+DQQDIUtDPHQWH$XQTXHVLQFHUDPHQWHQRHVWDEDWDQPROHVWDHUDFDVL KDODJDGRU TXH 0LNH WXYLHUD HVDV JDQDV SRU YHU HO FXHUSR GH +DQQD 3HUR TXHUtD YHQJDUVH 3DJySRUVXYHVWLGR\0LNHOHSUHJXQWyVLTXHUtDDOJRGHFRPHU ³1RDO5LYH*DXFKH³+DQQDOHUHFRUGy

ž‰‹ƒ

/DOOHYyDO´


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͳ͵Ͳ

³/RVpORVp³GLMR0LNH³3HURKD\XQOXJDUTXHHVLQFOXVRPHMRU



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³1RWHSUHRFXSHV³OHDVHJXUy³7HWHQJRFXELHUWD 8QDGHOJDGDPXMHUDVLiWLFDFRQSDOLWRVFKLQRVHQVXPRxRORVOOHYRDXQtQWLPRSXHVWR \OHVOOHQRODVFRSDVGHWpYHUGHFDOLHQWH+DEtDXQJRQJRHQODHVTXLQD\XQJUDQ%XGD GH -DGH PLUDQGR GH UHRMR KDFLD HOORV GHVGH XQ HVWDQWH DOWR 8QD PHVHUD PiV YLHMD DSDUHFLy \ OHV HQWUHJy ORV PHQ~V 3DUD OD VRUSUHVD GH +DQQD 0LNH EDOEXFHy XQDV FXDQWDVSDODEUDVHQPDQGDUtQ6HxDOyD+DQQD\ODPHVHUDDVLQWLy\VHJLUy0LNHVH VHQWyFRQDLUHGHVXILFLHQFLD\DJLWDQGRHOJRQJRFRQVXSXOJDU\VXGHGRtQGLFH +DQQDTXHGyERTXLDELHUWD ³¢4XpGHPRQLRVGLMLVWH" ³/HGLMHTXHHUHVXQDPRGHORGHURSDLQWHULRU\QHFHVLWDVPDQWHQHUWXVHQVXDOFXHUSR HQEXHQDIRUPD\TXHQRVJXVWDUtDYHUHOPHQ~HVSHFLDOVDOXGDEOH\EDMRHQJUDVD³ 0LNHH[SOLFyFRQLQGLIHUHQFLD³2GLDQGDUOHHVHPHQ~DODJHQWH7LHQHVTXHSHGLUOR ³¢6DEHVFyPRGHFLUURSDLQWHULRUHQFKLQR"³+DQQDHVSHWy 0LNHGHMyFDHUVXVEUD]RVVREUHODSDUWHWUDVHUDGHOSXHVWRGHFXHUR ³$SUHQGt XQD R GRV FRVDV GXUDQWH HVH DEXUULGRU WLHPSR TXH SDVp HQ (XURSD (O WHUPLQRPRGHORGHURSDLQWHULRUHVODSULPHUDFRVDTXHDSUHQGRHQFDGDLGLRPD +DQQDVDFXGLyVXFDEH]DIDVFLQDGD ³*XDX ³¢$Vt TXH QR WH PROHVWD TXH ORV PHVHURV SLHQVHQ TXH HUHV XQD PRGHOR GH URSD LQWHULRU"³0LNHSUHJXQWy +DQQDVHHQFRJLyGHKRPEURV ³1R HQ UHDOLGDG ³/DV PRGHORV GH URSD LQWHULRU HUDQ ERQLWDV GHVSXpV GH WRGR < EDVWDQWHGHOJDGDV 0LNHVHLOXPLQy

ž‰‹ƒ

+DQQD WRPy XQ OHQWR VRUER GH Wp LQFRQVFLHQWH GH TXH 0LNH KDEtD WHQLGR QRYLDV DQWHULRUHV ³¢)XH«XQDQRYLDUHFLHQWH"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͳ͵ͳ

³*HQLDO7UDMHDPL~OWLPDQRYLDDTXtSHURQROHSDUHFLyTXHWRGRHOWUXFRGHOPHQ~ GHGLHWDIXHJUDFLRVR3HQVyTXHODHVWDEDREMHWLYDQGRRDOJXQDPLHUGD



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(O PHVHUR OHV HQWUHJy VXV PHQ~V HO PHQ~ UHJXODU SDUD pO \ GH GLHWD SDUD +DQQD 'HVSXpVTXHVHIXH0LNHDVLQWLy ³$FDEDPRV GH WHUPLQDU (OOD VHJXtD TXHMiQGRVH DFHUFD GH FyPR HVWDED GHPDVLDGR SUHRFXSDGRSRUVHUSRSXODU ³/XFDV GHFtD HVR WDPELpQ ³+DQQD FKLOOy DQWHV GH TXH SXGLHUD GHWHQHUVH D Vt PLVPD³ 1R OH JXVWDED TXH \R OH GLMHUD D WRGRV TXH .DWH WHQtD KHUSHV ³6H HVWUHPHFLy HQRMDGD GH KDEHU GLFKR HO QRPEUH GH .DWH GHPDVLDGR IXHUWH 0LNH SUREDEOHPHQWHVDOWDUtD\ODGHIHQGHUtD3HURVyORVHHQFRJLyGHKRPEURV ³7HQtDTXHKDFHUOR³+DQQDFRQWLQXy³
+DEtDXQDOtQHDGHRULQDOHVSHUR0LNHQRHVWDEDHQQLQJXQRGHHOORV7DPSRFRYHtD VXVPRFDVLQHV7RGSRUGHEDMRGHODVSXHUWDV(VFXFKyXQSHTXHxRUXLGRYLQLHQGRGHOD ]RQD GH ODYDPDQRV \ FDPLQy KDFLD DOOt 0LNH HVWDED SDUDGR HQ HO ODYDPDQRV XQ FHSLOORXQDODWDGHGHVRGRUDQWH\XQWXERGHFUHPDGHQWDOHQODHVTXLQDDOODGRGHpO



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³2RSV³GLMR6XYR]KL]RHFRHQODEULOODQWH\YDFtDKDELWDFLyQ

ͳ͵ʹ

7HUPLQDURQGHFRPHUVXVFHQDV\VHFKXSDURQORVJDMRVGHQDUDQMDTXHYHQtDQFRQOD FXHQWD 0LNH OH KL]R XQ FXPSOLGR D +DQQD VXJHVWLYDPHQWH HQ VXV KDELOLGDGHV GH VXFFLyQ\OHDFRQVHMyTXHJXDUGDUDXQSRFRGHOSRGHUFKXSDGRUSDUDPiVWDUGH/XHJR VHGLVFXOSySDUDLUDOEDxR+DQQDORPLUyVHUSHQWHDUSRUODVPHVDVGiQGRVHFXHQWDGH ODRSRUWXQLGDGGHYHQJDUVH/HQWDPHQWHVHOHYDQWyGHMyODVHUYLOOHWDHQVXSODWR\VH GHVOL]y SRU HO FRUUHGRU (VSHUR KDVWD TXH OD SXHUWD GHO EDxR HVWXYLHUD FHUUDGD FRQWy KDVWDGLH]\HQWUy

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

6RVWHQtDXQFHSLOORHQVXPDQR&XDQGRYLRD+DQQDHQHOHVSHMRHOFRORUVHHVFDSyGH VXURVWUR +DQQDVROWyXQDULVD ³¢7HHVWiVDUUHJODQGR" ³¢4XpHVWiVKDFLHQGRDTXt"³H[FODPy ³/R VLHQWR SHQVp TXH pVWH HUD XQ YHVWLGRU ³+DQQD UHFLWy (Q UHDOLGDG QR WXYR HO HIHFWRTXHEXVFDED 0LNHSHVWDxHy\UiSLGDPHQWHPHWLyVXVDUWtFXORVGHKLJLHQHSHUVRQDO GHQXHYRHQVX PDOHWDGH-DFN6SDGH+DQQDVHVLQWLyXQSRFRPDOpOQRWHQtDTXHSDUDU5HWURFHGLy GHOiUHDGHORODYDPDQRV ³(VWDUp DIXHUD ³PXUPXUy 6H DEULy FDPLQR KDFLD DIXHUD \ UHJUHVy D VX VLOOD VRQULpQGRVHDVtPLVPD0LNHVHKDEtDHVWDGRFHSLOODQGRVXVGLHQWHV¢(VRVLJQLILFDED TXHTXHUtDEHVDUOD" (QHOFDPLQRGHYXHOWDDODFDVDGH0LNHHVFXFKDURQ´:KROH/RWWD/RYHµGHQXHYR FDQWDQGRDWRGRSXOPyQODOHWUD6HSDUTXHyHQODDFHUDGH0LNH\DSDJyHOPRWRU ³¢4XLHUHVDFRPSDxDUPHDPLSXHUWD" ³6HJXUR³UHVSRQGLy+DQQDGiQGRVHFXHQWDTXHVXFRUD]yQHVWDEDVDOWDQGR6LJXLy D0LNHSRUORVSDVRVGHSLHGUDKDFLDHOSyUWLFR0RQWJRPHU\+DEtDXQMDUGtQGHURFDV =HQDOODGRL]TXLHUGRGHODSXHUWDSHURVHKDEtDFRQJHODGR\DXQDGHOJDGDFRUWH]DGH KLHORHQODDUHQD 0LNHVHSDUyGHIUHQWHDHOOD$+DQQDOHJXVWDEDTXHpOHUDXQSRFRPiVDOWR/XFDV WHQtDPiVRPHQRVVXHVWDWXUD\6HDQVXH[H[KDEtDVLGRXQSRFRPiVEDMR ³%XHQRHVWRIXHFDVLWDQGLYHUWLGRFRPRFXDQGRVDOJRFRQPLVSXWDV³GLMR0LNH +DQQDJLUyVXVRMRV

ͳ͵͵

³7DOYH]SRGUtDVGDUOHDWXVSXWDVODQRFKHOLEUHHOViEDGRWDPELpQ9HQFRQPLJRDOD LQDXJXUDFLyQGH5DGOH\ 0LNHSXVRVXSXOJDUHQVXEDUELOODSUHWHQGLHQGRSHQVDUORXQSRFR

ž‰‹ƒ

³&UHRTXHHVRSXHGHVHUDUUHJODGR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

+DQQDVROWyXQDULVLWD0LNHWRFyVXDYHPHQWHHOLQWHULRUGHVXEUD]R6XDOLHQWRROtDD PHQWD&DVLLQFRQVFLHQWHPHQWHVHDFHUFyXQSRTXLWRPiV /DSXHUWDVHDEULyGHUHSHQWH8QDEULOODQWHOX]VDOLyGHOYHVWtEXORGHORV0RQWJRPHU\ \+DQQDUHWURFHGLy8QDDOWDSHOLFDVWDxDHVWDEDSDUDGDDGHQWUR1RHUDODPDPiGH 0LNH\VHJXURQRHUD$ULD(OFRUD]yQGH+DQQDVHGHVSORPy ³¢.DWH"³JULWy ³£+ROD0LNH³.DWHJULWyDODYH] +DQQDODVHxDOy ³¢4XpHVWiVKDFLHQGRDTXt" .DWHSHVWDxHyLQRFHQWHPHQWH ³/OHJXpDTXtWHPSUDQRDVtTXHODPDPiGH0LNHPHGHMyHQWUDU³0LUyD0LNH³ (VV~SHUDJUDGDEOH<VXWUDEDMRDUWtVWLFRHVHVSHFWDFXODU0HGLMRTXHWHQtDXQDSLH]D TXH LED D VHU H[SXHVWD HQ HO OREE\ GHO 5DGOH\ \ KD\ XQD JUDQ LQDXJXUDFLyQ HVWH ViEDGR'HEHUtDPRVLUMXQWRV¢1RFUHHV" ³¢4XpTXLHUHVGHFLUFRQTXHOOHJDVWHWHPSUDQR"³LQWHUUXPSLy+DQQD .DWHSXVRODPDQRHQVXSHFKR ³¢0LNHQRWHGLMR"7HQHPRVXQDFLWD +DQQDPLUyD0LNH ³1R0LNHQRPHGLMR 0LNHVHODPLyORVODELRVOXFLHQGRFXOSDEOH ³%XHQR£HVWRHVH[WUDxR³.DWHGLMR³/DFXDGUDPRVD\HU 0LNHPLUyD.DWH

(PSXMyD+DQQD\WRPyHOEUD]RGH0LNH



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³$GHPiV ³.DWH LQWHUUXPSLy XVDQGR VX LQRFHQWH \ GXOFH YR] GH QXHYR³ ¢1R VH VXSRQtD TXH GHEHUtDV HVWDU HQ OD ELEOLRWHFD +DQ" &XDQGR QR WH YL HQ HO DXGLWRULR GXUDQWH OD SUiFWLFD GH +DPOHW OODPp D 7RP < pO GLMR TXH QHFHVLWDEDV HVWXGLDU SDUD XQDJUDQSUXHEDGHIUDQFpV

ͳ͵Ͷ

³3HURPHGLMLVWHTXHQRGLMHUDQ«

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢(VWiVOLVWR"7HYR\DOOHYDUDXQDVRPEURVROXJDUSDUDHOSRVWUH 0LNHDVLQWLyOXHJRPLUyGHQXHYRD+DQQDFX\DPDQGtEXODHVWDEDSUiFWLFDPHQWHHQ HO SRUFKH eO OHYDQWy VXV KRPEURV HQ VHxDO GH GLVFXOSD FRPR GLFLHQGR QR VRPRV H[FOXVLYRV¢RVt" (VWXSHIDFWD +DQQD ORV PLUy FDPLQDU SRU OD DFHUD GRQGH HO $XGL TXH SHUWHQHFtD D ,VDEHO OD PDPi GH .DWH HVWDED SDUTXHDGR +DQQD KDEtD HVWDGR WDQ GLVWUDtGD SRU FRPR WHUPLQDU VX FLWD FRQ 0LNH TXH QL VLTXLHUD OR KDEtD QRWDGR ¢(UD SRU HVWR TXH 0LNHKDEtDHVWDGRDUUHJODQGRHQHOUHVWDXUDQWH"¢3DUDUHIUHVFDUVHSDUDVXVHJXQGDFLWD" 'HVSXpV GH VX IDEXORVD FLWD ¢3RU TXp 0LNH VHJXtD WHQLHQGR VXV RSFLRQHV DELHUWDV" ¢&yPRHUDTXHQRTXHUtDVHUH[FOXVLYR" (O$XGLJUXxyKDFLDODYLGD\VHDOHMySRUODDYHQLGD\GHVDSDUHFLy(QHOVLOHQFLRTXH VLJXLy+DQQDHVFXFKyXQDLQKDODFLyQGHWUiVGHHOOD6HYROWHy\VXFXHUSRVHWHQVy 2WUDLQKDODFLyQ6RQDEDFRPRVLDOJXLHQHVWXYLHUDDKRJDQGRXQDULVD

ž‰‹ƒ

ͳ͵ͷ

³¢+ROD"³GLMR+DQQDWUDQTXLODPHQWHHQHORVFXURSDWLRGHORV0RQWJRPHU\1DGLH UHVSRQGLy SHUR +DQQD WRGDYtD WHQtD OD VHQVDFLyQ GH TXH DOJXLHQ HVWDED DOOt 8Q IULR H[WUDxRVHDSRGHURGHHOODSHQHWUDQGRKDVWDVXVKXHVRV\VDOLyFRUULHQGRGHOSyUWLFR WDQUiSLGRFRPRSXGR 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR 6SHQFHU+DVWLQJVIXWXUD 6SHQFHU+DVWLQJVIXWXUD SHUVRQDGHOPRVWUDGRUHQ:DZD SHUVRQDGHOPRVWUDGRUHQ:DZD 7UDGXFLGRSRU'KDP/RYH &RUUHJLGRSRU&DDPLOOH 

(

VD PLVPD QRFKH 6SHQFHU HVWDED HQFDUDPDGR HQ HO EUD]R GHO VRIi HQ OD KDELWDFLyQYLHQGRODVQRWLFLDV8QUHSRUWHURHVWDEDKDEODQGRWRGDYtDGHFyPR OD SROLFtD KDEtD GHMDGR YDFDQWH HO ERVTXH GHWUiV GH VX FDVD \ QR HVWDEDQ EXVFDQGR HQ ORV (VWDGRV 8QLGRV SRU ,DQ +R\ DOJXLHQ GH OD IXHU]D GH SROLFtD KDEtD UHFLELGR XQD EXHQD SLVWD GH GyQGH SRGUtD HVWDU SHUR QR LEDQ D GDU PiV GHWDOOHV WRGDYtD 6SHQFHUJUXxy/XHJRODVQRWLFLDVVHLQWHUUXPSLHURQSRURWURFRPHUFLDOQXHYRGHO(ON 5LGJH 6NL 5HVRUW KDEtDQ DELHUWR VHLV HVWDFLRQHV PiV \ HVWDEDQ SUHVHQWDQGR HO 6NL GH FKLFDVSDUDORV-XHYHV*UDWLV (O WLPEUH GH OD SXHUWD VRQy \ 6SHQFHU VDOWy DQVLRVR GH FRQFHQWUDU VX DWHQFLyQ HQ FRVDVPiVSRVLWLYDV$QGUHZHVWDEDSDUDGRHQHOSRUFKHFRQHVFDORIUtRV ³7HQJRWDQWRTXHGHFLUWH³FKLOOy6SHQFHU ³¢(QVHULR"³$QGUHZHQWUyFDUJDQGRVXOLEURGHHFRQRPtD$3GHEDMRGHVXEUD]R 6SHQFHULQKDOyDSiWLFDPHQWH(FRQRPtDDGXUDVSHQDVLPSRUWDEDDKRUD 6SHQFHUORJXLyGHODPDQRDODKDELWDFLyQFHUUyODSXHUWD\DSDJRHOWHOHYLVRU ³¢7HDFXHUGDVTXHOHHQYLpXQFRUUHRDPLPDPiELROyJLFDHOOXQHV"0HUHVSRQGLy< D\HUIXLDYHUODD1XHYD
ͳ͵͸

$QGUHZSHVWDxHyUiSLGDPHQWH

ž‰‹ƒ

³¢1XHYD


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³0HHQYLyXQWLTXHWGH$PWUDN\PHGLMRTXHQRVHQFRQWUiUDPRVHQODHVWDFLyQ3HQQ <IXHPDUDYLOORVR³$SUHWyODVPDQRVGH$QGUHZ³2OLYLDHVMRYHQHVLQWHOLJHQWH\ HV« QRUPDO 7XYLPRV XQD FRQH[LyQ LQPHGLDWD ¢1R HV PDUDYLOORVR" ³(OOD VDFy VX FHOXODU \ OH PRVWUy XQ PHQVDMH TXH 2OLYLD OH KDEtD HVFULWR OD QRFKH SDVDGD SUHVXQWDPHQWH FXDQGR OOHJR DO DHURSXHUWR 4XHULGD 6SHQFHU £
ͳ͵͹

³1RORHVWR\³$QGUHZVDOWyJROSHiQGRVHIXHUWHODURGLOODFRQWUDODPHVD³8PVH PH ROYLGDED« GHMp OD FDOFXODGRUD HQ OD HVFXHOD 'HEHUtD PHMRU LU SRU HOOD 7HQHPRV WRGRVHVRVSUREOHPDVGHWDUHD³$JDUUyVXVOLEURV\VHGLULJLyKDFLDODSXHUWD 6SHQFHUDJDUUyVXEUD]ReOVHGHWXYRSHURQRODPLUR

ž‰‹ƒ

³¢4XpSDVD"³OHSUHJXQWyVXFRUD]yQODWtDPX\UiSLGR $QGUHZDIHUUyORVOLEURVIXHUWHPHQWHFRQWUDVXSHFKR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³%XHQR«TXLHURGHFLU«WDOYH]YD\DVXQSRFRUiSLGRFRQWRGRHVWRGH1XHYD


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6SHQFHU OR PLUy /DV PHMLOODV GH $QGUHZ HVWDEDQ VRQURMDGDV FRPR VL HVWXYLHUD WUDWDQGR PX\ IXHUWH GH QR OORUDU 'H UHSHQWH« OR HQWHQGLy 6H LPDJLQy T $QGUHZ UHFLELHQGRODLQYLWDFLyQGHO5DGOH\\DSUHVXUiQGRVHKDFLDDTXtDQVLRVRGHSHGLUOHTXH IXHUDVXFLWD(VWDDUUHJODUtDORGH)R[\KDEUtDSODQHDGRTXHGHFLUUHILULpQGRVHDORV GHVDVWURVRVEHQHILFLRVTXHKDEtDQSDVDGRMXQWRVHVWHRWRxR7DOYH]WRGDHVWDFRVDVLQ

ͳ͵ͺ

³6yORHVWDFRVDTXHKHUHFLELGRHQHOFRUUHR'HEtKDEHUODFRJLGRSRUHUURU

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

VHQWLGR VREUH TXH 6SHQFHU VH WRPDUD ODV FRVDV GHVSDFLR \ QR TXHUHU TXH VH ODVWLPDUD HUDHQUHDOLGDGSRUTXH$QGUHZQRTXHUtDTXHHOODVHIXHUD (OODWRFyVXEUD]RJHQWLOPHQWH ³9ROYHUp\WHYLVLWDUp<SXHGHVYLVLWDUPHWDPELpQ 8QDPLUDGDGHYHUJHQ]DSURIXQGDVHDVRPyHQODFDUDGH$QGUHZeOVHGHVSUHQGLy ³0HPHWHQJRTXHLU³6DOLySRUODSXHUWDKDFLDHOFRUUHGRU³7HYHUpHQODHVFXHOD PDxDQD ³£$QGUHZ ³SURWHVWy 6SHQFHU SHUR \D VH KDEtD SXHVWR OD FKDTXHWD \ HVWDED HQ OD SXHUWD(OYLHQWRODFHUUyWDQIXHUWHTXHODSHTXHxDHVWDWXDGHPDGHUDTXHHVWDEDHQOD PHVDVHYROFy 6SHQFHUFDPLQyDODYHQWDQDVLJXLHQWHDODSXHUWDIURQWDO\PLUyD$QGUHZFRUUHUKDFLD VX0LQL&RRSHU7RPyODSHULOODGHODSXHUWDSDUDLUWUDVpOSHURXQDSDUWHGHHOODQR TXHUtD$QGUHZDFHOHURUiSLGRFRQODVOODQWDVFKLOODQGR<OXHJRVHKDEtDLGR  8QJUDQ QXGR VHIRUPyHQVXJDUJDQWD¢4XpDFDEDEDGHSDVDU" ¢+DEtDQWHUPLQDGR" $KRUDTXH6SHQFHUSRGUtDLUVH¢$QGUHZQRWHQtDQDGDPiVTXHKDFHUFRQHOOD"¢3RU TXpQRHVWDEDIHOL]SRUHOOD"¢3RUTXpVyORHVWDEDSHQVDQGRHQpO\HQORTXHTXHUtD" 0RPHQWRVGHVSXpVOD SXHUWDGHDWUiVVHFHUUyIXHUWH\6SHQFHU VDOWy+DEtDQSDVRV OXHJRODYR]GHO6U+DVWLQJV6SHQFHUQRKDEtDKDEODGRFRQVXVSDGUHVGHVGHDQWHVGH VXYLDMHD1XHYD
ž‰‹ƒ

(O SXQWR GRQGH QRUPDOPHQWH SDUTXHDED HO SHTXHxR 0HUFHGHV HVWDED YDFtR 3HUR 6SHQFHU OR KDEtD SDUTXHDGR XQDV FXDQWDV KRUDV DQWHV GHVSXpV GH OD HVFXHOD ¢+DEtD ROYLGDGRHQFHQGHUODDODUPD"¢$OJXLHQVHORKDEtDUREDGR"

ͳ͵ͻ

6XFDUURQRHVWDED



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

6H GHYROYLy GH QXHYR D OD FRFLQD OD 6UWD +DVWLQJV HVWDED SDUDGD HQ OD HVWXID SRQLHQGRXQRVYHJHWDOHVHQXQDJUDQWD]DGHVRSD(O6U+DVWLQJVVHHVWDEDVLUYLHQGR XQSRFRGH0DOEHF ³0LFDUURQRHVWi³GLMR6SHQFHU³&UHRTXHDOJXLHQVHORUREy (O 6U +DVWLQJV VLJXLy VLUYLHQGR FDOPDGDPHQWH /D 6UD +DVWLQJV VDFR XQ WDEOD SDUD FRUWDUSOiVWLFDVLQVLTXLHUDSDUSDGHDU ³1DGLHVHORUREy³HOODGLMR 6SHQFHUVHGHWXYR$JDUUyHOERUGHGHOFHQWURGHODFRFLQD ³¢&yPRVDEHVTXHQDGLHVHORUREy" /D ERFD GH VX PDGUH HVWDED IUXQFLGD FRPR VL HVWXYLHUD SUREDQGR DOJR iFLGR 6X FDPLVHWDQHJUDVHDSUHWDEDFRQWUDVXVKRPEURV\SHFKR7HQtDXQFXFKLOORIXHUWHPHQWH VXMHWDGRHQVXSXxRVRVWHQLpQGRORFRPRXQDUPD ³3RUTXH7XSDSiVHORGHYROYLyDOYHQGHGRUHVWDWDUGH /DVURGLOODVGH6SHQFHUVHVLQWLHURQGpELOHV6HJLUyKDFLDVXSDSi ³¢4Xp"¢3RUTXp" ³(UD XQ FRPLOyQ GH JDVROLQD ³/D 6UD +DVWLQJV KDEOy SRU pO³ 7HQHPRV TXH HPSH]DUDSHQVDUHQODHFRQRPtD\HQHODPELHQWH³/HODQ]yD6SHQFHUXQDVRQULVD GHDXWRVXILFLHQFLD\VHJLUyKDFLDVXWDEODGHFRUWDU ³3HUR«³(OFXHUSRGH6SHQFHUFD\yHOHFWULILFDGR³£8VWHGHVKHUHGDURQPLOORQHVGH GyODUHV<«HVHFDUURQRHVXQFRPLOyQGHJDVROLQD£(VPXFKRPiVHILFLHQWHTXHHOGH 0HOLVVD³6HJLUyDVXSDSi7RGDYtDODHVWDEDLJQRUDQGRVDERUHDQGRVXYLQR¢1ROH LPSRUWDEDSDUDQDGD" /OHQDGHUDELD6SHQFHUDJDUUyVXPXxHFD

ž‰‹ƒ

³6SHQFHU³(O6U+DVWLQJVGLMRHQXQDYR]WUDQTXLODDSDUWDQGRVXPDQR(OSLFDQWH RORU GHO YLQR URMR OOHQR OD QDUL] GH 6SHQFHU³ (VWiV VLHQGR PX\ GUDPiWLFD +HPRV HVWDGR KDEODQGR GH HQWUHJDU HO FDUUR SRU XQ ODUJR UDWR ¢UHFXHUGDV" 1R QHFHVLWDV XQ FDUURSDUDWLVROD ³¢3HURFyPRVHVXSRQHTXHYD\DGHXQODGRDRWUR"³6SHQFHUGLMR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͳͶͲ

³¢7LHQHVDOJRTXHGHFLU"



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

/D6UD+DVWLQJVVLJXLyUHEDQDQGRODV]DQDKRULDVHQSHGD]RVPiV\PiVSHTXHxRV(O FXFKLOORKDFLDXQUXLGRFRPRGHURHUVREUHODWDEODGHFRUWDU ³6LWHTXLHUHVFRPSUDUXQFDUURKDVODFDQWLGDGGHFRVDVTXHKDFHQORVRWURVFKLFRV GHWXHGDG³3XVRODV]DQDKRULDVHQODROOD³&RQVLJXHXQWUDEDMR ³¢8Q WUDEDMR" ³JULWy 6SHQFHU 6XV SDGUHV QXQFD OD KDEtDQ KHFKR WUDEDMDU DQWHV 3HQVyHQODVSHUVRQDVTXHWHQtDQXQWUDEDMRHQHO5RVHZRRG'D\7UDEDMDEDQHQ*DS RHQ.LQJ-DPHV2HQORVSUHW]HOGHOD7tD$QQH(Q:DZDKDFLHQGRViQGZLFKHV ³2WRPDSUHVWDGR QXHVWURFDUUR³GLMR OD6UD+DVWLQJV³ 2KHHVFXFKDGRTXHKD\ XQD PDUDYLOORVD LQYHQFLyQ QXHYD TXH WH OOHYD D OXJDUHV GRQGH HO FDUUR WDPELpQ ³ 'HVOL]yHOFXFKLOORHQODWDEODGHFRUWDU³/ROODPDQEXV 6SHQFHU ORV PLUy D ORV GRV FRQ VXV RtGRV WLPEUDQGR (QWRQFHV SDUD VX VRUSUHVD XQ VHQWLPLHQWRGHSD]VHDSRGHUyGHHOOD7HQtDVXUHVSXHVWD6XVSDSiVHQUHDOLGDGQROD DPDEDQ6LORKLFLHUDQQRHVWDUtDQWUDWDQGRGHTXLWDUOHWRGR ³'HDFXHUGR³GLMRODFyQLFDPHQWHJLUDQGRDOUHGHGRU³,JXDOQRHVTXHYD\DDHVWDU DTXt PXFKR PiV ³0LHQWUDV VDOtD GH OD FRFLQD HVFXFKy HO YDVR GH VX SDSi FRQWUD OD PHVDGDGHJUDQLWR ³6SHQFHU³GLMRHO6U+DVWLQJV3HURHUDPX\PX\WDUGH 6SHQFHU FRUULy SRU ODV HVFDOHUDV KDFLD VX FXDUWR 8VXDOPHQWH GHVSXpV GH TXH VXV SDGUHVOHIDOWDUDQHOUHVSHWRODVOiJULPDVURGDEDQSRUVXURVWUR\VHWLUDEDHQODFDPD SUHJXQWiQGRVHTXHKDEtDKHFKRPDO3HURQRHVWDYH]6HIXHKDFHVXHVFULWRULR\WRPy ODFDUSHWDH[SDQGLEOHTXH2OLYLDKDEtDHVWDGRVRVWHQLHQGRD\HU7RPDQGRXQSURIXQGR UHVSLUR PLUy GHQWUR -XVWR FRPR 2OLYLD GLMR HVWDED OOHQD GH SDSHOHV VREUH HO GHSDUWDPHQWRTXH2OLYLD\VXHVSRVRKDEtDQFRPSUDGRFRPRODVGLPHQVLRQHVGHODV KDELWDFLRQHV HO PDWHULDO GHO SLVR \ GH ORV DUPDULRV \ ORV VHUYLFLRV GHO HGLILFLR HO SDUTXH GH PDVFRWDV OD SLVFLQD ROtPSLFD LQWHULRU \ XQ VDOyQ GH (OL]DEHWK $UGHQ 3HJDGRDOSDSHOIURQWDOKDEtDXQDWDUMHWDGHQHJRFLRV0LFKDHO+XWFKLQV,QPRELOLDULD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6SHQFHUPLUyDOUHGHGRUGHODKDELWDFLyQHYDOXDQGRVXFRQWHQLGR7RGRVORVPXHEOHV GHVGHVXFDPDKDVWDVXHVFULWRULRDQWLJXRKDVWDVXDUPDULR\VXPHVDGH&KLSSHQGDOH WRGR HVR HUD VX\R (OOD OR KDEtD KHUHGDGR GH VX WtD DEXHOD 0LOOLFHQW DSDUHQWHPHQWH HOOD QR VHQWtD OD PLVPD DQLPRVLGDG GH DGRSWDU QLxRV 3RU VXSXHVWR TXH KDEtD WHQLGR TXH TXHGDUVH FRQ VX URSD ]DSDWRV PDOHWDV \ XQD FROHFFLyQ GH OLEURV WDPELpQ

ͳͶͳ

0LFKDHO QXHVWUR FRUUHGRU GH ELHQHV UDtFHV WH SRGUtD HQFRQWUDU XQ OXJDU UHDOPHQWH HVSHFLDOKDEtDGLFKR2OLYLDHQODFHQD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

3UREDEOHPHQWHWRGRHVRFDEUtDHQXQFDPLyQ,QFOXVRPDQHMDUtDODFRVDHOODPLVPDVL WHQtDTXHKDFHUOR 6X WHOpIRQR YLEUy \ 6SHQFHU VH HVWUHPHFLy /R DOFDQ]y DQVLRVD HVSHUDQGR TXH IXHUD $QGUHZTXLHQOODPDUDDDUUHJODUVHSHURFXDQGRYLRTXHHUDXQPHQVDMHGHXQQ~PHUR GHVFRQRFLGRVXFRUD]yQFD\yDOVXHOR 4XHULGD6HxRULWD6SHQFHU&RPRTXLHUDTXHVHDWXQRPEUH ¢1RGHEHUtDVVDEHU\DORTXHSDVDVLQRPHHVFXFKDV"8VDUpSHTXHxDVSDODEUDVHVWDYH]SDUDTXH KDVWDW~HQWLHQGDV2OHGDUiVDWXPDPiSHUGLGDXQGHVFDQVR\GHMDUDVGHEXVFDUSRUORTXHHQ YHUGDGSDVy«RWHQGUiVTXHSDJDUPLSUHFLR¢4XpWDOVXHQDGHVDSDUHFHUSRUVLHPSUH" 

ž‰‹ƒ

ͳͶʹ

³$



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR &RPRHQORVYLHMRVWLHPSRV« 7UDGXFLGRSRU 
/

XHJR HVD QRFKH GHVSXpV GH TXH OD SUiFWLFD GH QDWDFLyQ WHUPLQy (PLO\ VH GHVOL]yHQVXSXHVWRIDYRULWRHQ$SSOHEHH VHOTXHWLHQHXQDDQWLJXD ELFLFOHWD WiQGHP VXVSHQGLGD GHVGH HO WHFKR \ ODV FRORULGDV SODFDV HQ OD SDUHG 6X KHUPDQD&DURO\Q*HPPD&XUUDQ\/DQLH,OHU³RWUDVQDGDGRUDVGH5RVHZRRG'D\³ VH DPRQWRQDURQ D VX ODGR (O FRPHGRU ROtD FRPR D SDSDV IULWDV \ KDPEXUJXHVDV \ WRGDVODVFDQFLRQHVGHORV%HDWOHVVRQDEDQHQHOHVWpUHR&XDQGR(PLO\DEULyHOPHQ~ HVWDEDFRPSODFLGDGHTXHORVSDOLWRVGHPR]]DUHOOD\ODVDOLWDVGHSROORWRGDYtDIXHUDQ DSHULWLYRV /D HQVDODGD GH SROOR DO VXURHVWH WRGDYtD YHQtD FRQ DGHUH]R UDQFK SLFDQWH 6L (PLO\ FHUUDED VXV RMRV KDVWD SRGtD SUHWHQGHU TXH HUD HO DxR SDVDGR HQ HVD IHFKD FXDQGR VROtD YHQLU D $SSOHEHH·V FDGD MXHYHV SRU OD QRFKH« HQ HO SDVDGR FXDQGR QDGD PDOR KDEtDSDVDGR ³(O HQWUHQDGRU /DXUHQ WHQtD TXH HVWDU IXPDQGR FUDFN FXDQGR KL]R HVH FRQMXQWR GH TXLQLHQWRV³VHTXHMy*HPPDKRMHDQGRHOPHQ~ODPLQDGR ³(QVHULR³VLJXLy&DURO\QHQFRJLpQGRVHGHKRPEURVHQVXFKDTXHWDGHO(TXLSRGH 1DGDGRUHVGH5RVHZRRG'D\³£&DVLQRSXHGROHYDQWDUPLVEUD]RV (PLO\VHULyFRQODVRWUDVOXHJRYLRXQDUiIDJDGHSHORUXELRSRUHOUDELOORGHORMR«VH SXVRUtJLGD\PLUyKDFLDODEDUUDTXHHVWDEDOOHQDGHJHQWHYLHQGRXQSDUWLGRGH/DV ÉJXLODVHQORVWHOHYLVRUHVGHSDQWDOODSODQD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

(PLO\QRSRGtDVDFDUD-DVRQGHVXPHQWH3GLDEDTXH$ULDKXELHVHGHVHFKDGRWRGDV VXVDGYHUWHQFLDVDFHUFDGHpOHQHOSDWLRHOPDUWHVLQYHQWDQGRH[FXVDVSRUVXLUD<HOOD QRVDEtDTXHKDFHUFRQODIRWRTXH´$µOHKDEtDHQYLDGRD\HUHQODTXHHVWDEDQ$OL 1DRPL\-HQQDMXQWDVSUHVXPLEOHPHQWHDPLJDV

ͳͶ͵

+DEtD XQ KRPEUH UXELR DO ILQDO GH OD EDUUD KDEODQGR DQLPDGDPHQWH FRQ VX FLWD (O FRUD]yQGH(PLO\VHGHWXYR3RUXQVHJXQGRSHQVyTXHHUD-DVRQ'LODXUHQWLV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

6L -HQQD HUD DPLJD GH $OL $OL SRGtD KDEHU VLGR KRQHVWD FRQ HOOD ¢QR" 3XGR KDEHUOH GLFKRD-HQQDXQSURIXQGR\RVFXURVHFUHWRDFHUFDGHVXKHUPDQRVLQWHQHULGHDTXH -HQQDLEDDUHYHODUDOJRVLPLODU 8QRV PHVHV DWUiV DQWHV GH TXH ORV SROLFtDV DUUHVWDUDQ D ,DQ SRU HO DVHVLQDWR GH $OL (PLO\KDEtDYLVWRXQDHQWUHYLVWDFRQ-DVRQ'L/DXUHQWLVHQWHOHYLVLyQ%XHQRHUDXQD FODVH GH HQWUHYLVWD XQ UHSRUWHUR OR KDEtD UDVWUHDGR KDVWD
ž‰‹ƒ

8QD FDPDUHUD UXELD HQ XQD FDPLVD YHUGH GH $SSOHEHH·V \ XQD JRUUD GH /DV ÉJXLODV WRPy VXV yUGHQHV /XHJR ODV QDGDGRUDV FRPHQ]DURQ D KDEODU DFHUFD GH OD ILHVWD GH 5DGOH\

ͳͶͶ

(PLO\KDEtDHQYLDGRXQDIRWRDFDGDXQRGHVXVYLHMDVDPLJDV7DQWR6SHQFHU\+DQQD KDEtDUHVSRQGLGRGLFLHQGRTXHQRWHQtDLGHDGHORTXHSRGUtDVLJQLILFDUSHUR$ULDQR OD KDEtD UHFRQRFLGR HQ DEVROXWR ¢4XH VL GHEHUtDQ SUHRFXSDUVH SRU -DVRQ" +DEtD PXFKRGHpOQRORVDEtDQ



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³7RSKHU ORJUy REWHQHU XQD LQYLWDFLyQ \ pO TXHUtD TXH IXHUD ³(VWDED GLFLHQGR &DURO\Q³¢3HURTXpXVDVSDUDDOJRFRPRHVR" (PLO\WRPyXQVRUERGHVX&RFD&ROD9DLQLOOD7RSKHUHUDHOQRYLRGH&DURO\QSHUR XVXDOPHQWHORVGRVSUHIHUtDQPDUDWRQHVGH+pURHVTXHILHVWDVJODPRURVDV ³¢4XpWDOHOYHVWLGRURVDGRTXHXVpHQOD%HQHILFHQFLDGH5RVHZRRG'D\"³VXJLULy HOOD/XHJRWDPERULOHyORVGHGRVVREUHODPHVD³1RWLHQHVTXHSUHRFXSDUWHGHTXH\R SLGDSUHVWDGRDOJRGHWXFORVHWRWUDYH]
³/R FRQR]FR ³GLMR *HPPD GHUULWLpQGRVH³ 7UDEDMDPRV MXQWRV HQ HO PLVPR SUR\HFWRGH+iELWDWSDUDOD+XPDQLGDGeOHVJXDStVLPR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ž‰‹ƒ

³¢(VVHULR"³ORVRMRVGH&DURO\QVHDEUtDQFDGDYH]PiV

ͳͶͷ

(PLO\DVLQWLyODVDWLVIDFFLyQODVRQURMy



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(PLO\DVLQWLyRWUDYH]YLHQGRDVXKHUPDQD 3ODQHDED GHFLUOH D PDPi \ D SDSi 1R OHV GLJDV QDGD SULPHUR 6yOR QHFHVLWDED DVHJXUDUPHGHTXHIXHUD«GHYHUGDG &DURO\QWRPyXQSHGD]RGHSDQGHDMRTXHUHFLpQKDEtDQSXHVWR ³%LHQKHFKR³*HPPD\(PLO\FKRFDURQODVPDQRV\/DQLHOHGLRXQDVSDOPDGLWDV HQODHVSDOGD (PLO\ H[KDOy DOLYLDGD 6H KDEtD SUHRFXSDGR SRU FyPR LED D LU HVR < OH LQTXLHWDED HVSHFLDOPHQWH TXH &DURO\Q KLFLHUD XQD FDUD \ OH SUHJXQWDUD SRU TXp KDEtD SXHVWR OD IDPLOLDDWUDYpVGHODFXHVWLyQGHVHUOHVELDQDVLILQDOPHQWHLEDDVDOLUFRQFKLFRV 3HUR DKRUD TXH VXV SHQVDPLHQWRV VH KDEtDQ YXHOWR KDFLD ,VDDF QR SRGtD GHMDU GH SHQVDU HQ OR TXH KDEtD VXFHGLGR HQ OD FHQD GH DQRFKH 7RGDV HVDV LQGLUHFWDV KRUURURVDV 7RGDV HVDV PLUDGDV DPDUJDV < HVD IRWR HQ HO FDMyQ OD GH (PLO\ GHFDSLWDGD ¢3RGUtDQ (PLO\ H ,VDDF LU D OD ILHVWD 5DGOH\ MXQWRV VL OD 6UD &ROEHUW VXSLHUDORTXHKDEtDQKHFKR" 'HMyODFDVDGH,VDDFWHPSUDQRGHVSXpVGHYHUODIRWRVLQGHFLUOHD,VDDFXQDSDODEUD DFHUFDGHHOOR3HURWHQtDTXHGHFLUDOJR(OORVHUDQXQDSDUHMD(VWDEDQHQDPRUDGRV 6HJXUDPHQWHpOHQWHQGHUtD3RGUtDGHFLUOH¢HVWiVVHJXURTXHOHFDLJRELHQDWXPDPi" ¢$ WX PDPi OH JXVWD JDVWDU QRYDWDGDV D WXV QXHYDV QRYLDV" ¢6DEtDV TXH WX PDPi HV XQDSVLFySDWD\PHGHVFDEH]yHQXQDIRWR" 6XVFHQDVKDEtDQOOHJDGR\VHODGHYRUDURQ&XDQGRODFDPDUHUDUHWLUyVXVSODWRVHO WHOpIRQR GH (PLO\ VRQy 6SHQFHU +DVWLQJV GHFtD OD YHQWDQD GHO LGHQWLILFDGRU GH OODPDGDV 8Q PDQRMR GH QHUYLRV JROSHy HO HVWyPDJR GH (PLO\ (FKy XQD PLUDGD GH GLVFXOSD D VXV DPLJDV VH GHVOL]y IXHUD GH VX SXHVWR \ FDPLQy SRU HO SDVLOOR KDFLD HO EDxR +DEtD GHPDVLDGR UXLGR HQ OD ]RQD GHO EDU SDUD PDQWHQHU XQD FRQYHUVDFLyQ WHOHIyQLFD ³¢4XpSDVy"³GLMR(PLO\FXDQGRHPSXMyODSXHUWDGHOEDxR

(PLO\SXVRXQDPDQR WHPEORURVDHQHOODYDERGHPiUPRO\PLUyHOHVSHMR6XVRMRV HVWDEDQFRPRSODWRV\VXFDUDVHKDEtDYXHOWRSiOLGD

ž‰‹ƒ

³¢4Xp«TXpGLFH" %iVLFDPHQWHTXHWHQHPRVTXHVHJXLUEXVFDQGRRSDJDUHOSUHFLRGH´$µ



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͳͶ͸

³5HFLEtRWUDQRWD³GLMR6SHQFHU



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢%XVFDQGR«DHODVHVLQR"³VXVXUUy(PLO\ ³6XSRQJR1RVpTXHPiVSXHGHVLJQLILFDU ³¢1RWHQGUiTXHYHUFRQHVDIRWRTXHREWXYH"¢&RQ$OL\-HQQD" ³1RORVp³6SHQFHUVRQyGHVHVSHUDQ]DGD³1RWLHQHPXFKRVHQWLGRWDPSRFR 8QLQRGRURVRQy\XQSDUGHPRFDVLQHV VHDUUDVWUDURQ GHWUiVGHODSXHUWD(PLO\ VH SXVRWHQVD1RVHKDEtDGDGRFXHQWDTXHKDEtDDOJXLHQPiVHQHOEDxR ³0HWHQJRTXHLU³OHVXVXUUyDOWHOpIRQR ³%LHQ³GLMR6SHQFHU³7HQFXLGDGR (PLO\FHUUyVXWHOpIRQRGHXQWLUyQ\ORPHWLyHQVXEROVLOOR&XDQGRODSXHUWDVHDEULy \ODPXMHUVDOLy/DVDQJUHGH(PLO\VHFRQJHOy 2K /D 6UD &ROEHUW VH GHWXYR HQ VHFR (VWDED YHVWLGD FRQ XQD EOXVD \ SDQWDOyQ QHJURFRPRVLYLQLHUDGHOWUDEDMR/RVERUGHVGHVXERFDVHWHQVDURQDEUXSWDPHQWH ³+ROD³JRUMHy(PLO\VXYR]HUDXQRFWDYRPiVDOWRGHORQRUPDO(VWUHFKDURQVXV PDQRV³¢&yPRHVWiXVWHG" /D6UD&ROEHUWVHSXVRMXQWRDHOODHQHOODYDER\DEULyHOJULIRGHDJXDFDOLHQWH3XVR VXVPDQRVGHEDMRGHOFKRUURGHDJXDIURWiQGRVHFRQWDQWRYLJRUTXHHUDXQDPDUDYLOOD TXHVXSLHOQRVHGHVSUHQGLHUDHQWUR]RV(VWDEDEORTXHDQGRHOGLVSHQVDGRUGHWRDOOLWDV SHURQRVHDWUHYLyDSHGLUOHTXHVHPRYLHUD ³¢8VWHG \ HO 6U &ROEHUW HVWiQ FHQDQGR DTXt" ³SUHJXQWy (PLO\ MXQWDQGR XQD VRQULVD³$PRVXVKDPEXUJXHVDV /D6UD&ROEHUWVHJLUy\ODYLR ³&RUWDODVHQWLPHQWDODFWXDFLyQ(VLQVXOWDQWH (PLO\VLQWLyXQWLUyQHQVXHVWyPDJR2WURYLWRUHRYLQRGHOEDU

ž‰‹ƒ

/D6UD&ROEHUWFHUUyHOJULIR\VDFyXQSHGD]RGHWRDOOLWDYLROHQWDPHQWHIURWDQGRVXV PDQRV

ͳͶ͹

¢'LVFXOSH"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³1RTXHUtDGHFLUORHQIUHQWHGHPLKLMRSRUTXHIXHODUD]yQSRUODTXHWHWROHUpHQOD FHQD GH OD RWUD QRFKH 3HUR PH KDV LUUHVSHWDGR D Pt \ D PL FDVD (Q OR TXH D Pt UHVSHFWDHUHVEDVXUD1RWHDWUHYDVDSRQHUXQSLHHQPLFDVDRWUDYH] (PLO\ SDOLGHFLy 7RGRV ORV RWURV VRQLGRV VH HVIXPDURQ 0DUHDGD VDOLy GHO EDxR GH HVSDOGD\FRUULyGHQXHYRDVXPHVD &RJLyHODEULJRGHVXVLOOD\FRUULyKDFLDODSXHUWD ³¢(PLO\"³JULWy&DURO\QPLWDGGHSLH3HUR(PLO\QRUHVSRQGLy7HQtDTXHVDOLUGH DOOt7HQtDTXHDOHMDUVHGHODPDPiGH,VDDFDQWHVGHTXHSXGLHVHGHFLUQDGDPiV (O YLHQWR DPDUJR UHFRUULy VXV PHMLOODV PLHQWUDV FDPLQDED KDFLD HO HVWDFLRQDPLHQWR &DURO\QHVWDEDMXVWRGHWUiVGHHOODWLUDQGRGHODPDQJD ³¢4XpYDPDO"³OHSUHJXQWyVXKHUPDQD³¢4XpSDVy" (PLO\QRUHVSRQGLy1RHVWDEDVHJXUDVLSRGtDUHVSRQGHU0HKDVLUUHVSHWDGRDPt\DPL FDVD/D6UD&ROEHUWORKDEtDGLFKRWRGR 2EVHUYy HO DYLVR EULOODQWH GH $SSOHEHH·V PDOGLFLHQGR VX WHUULEOH VXHUWH ¢3RU TXp OD 6UD &ROEHUW WHQtD TXH FRPHU DOOt HVD QRFKH GH WRGDV ODV QRFKHV" < HUDQ ODV  GH OD QRFKH QR H[DFWDPHQWH XQD KRUD QRUPDO SDUD FHQDU < HVWDED KDFLHQGR XQ SRFR IUtR DIXHUDXQDEXHQDQRFKHSDUDTXHGDUVHHQFDVD (QWRQFHVGHQWURGHVXEROVRHOWHOpIRQRGH(PLO\LQWHUYLQR'HUHSHQWHODYHUGDGOD JROSHy 7DO YH] QR HUD OD VXHUWH R OD FRLQFLGHQFLD TXH OD 6UD &REHUW HVWXYLHUD HQ $SSOHEHH·VHVWDQRFKH7DOYH]DOJXLHQOHKDEtDGLFKRTXHIXHUD

ž‰‹ƒ

8QDIRWRDSDUHFLyHQODSDQWDOODGHVX1RNLD3HURQRWHQtDQDGDTXHYHUFRQ(PLO\ ,VDDFRVXPDPi(QYH]GHHVRHUDXQJUDQFXDUWRFRQYLGULHUDVEULOODQWHEDQFRVGH PDGHUD\XQDDOIRPEUDJUXHVDURMD(PLO\IUXQFLyHOFHxR(UD+RO\7ULQLW\ODLJOHVLD GHVXIDPLOLD(VWDEDHOFRQIHVLRQDULRGHO3DGUH7\VRQODSHTXHxDDOFREDGHPDGHUD FHUFDGHODUHFHSFLyQ$OJXLHQHVWDEDVDOLHQGRGHOFRQIHVLRQDULRVXFDEH]DLQFOLQDGD (PLO\DFHUFyHOWHOpIRQRDVXFDUD(OKRPEUHGHODIRWRHUDDOWRFRQHOFDEHOORFRUWR\ RVFXUR8QDSODFDGHO'HSDUWDPHQWRGH3ROLFtDGH5RVHZRRGEULOODEDHQVXFKDTXHWD \XQSDUGHHVSRVDFROJDEDQGHVXFLQWXUyQ¢:LOGHQ"

ͳͶͺ

6yORGDPHXQVHJXQGROHGLMRDVXKHUPDQD(OODFDPLQyKDFLDODDFHUDFHUFDGH ODSXHUWDGHVDOLGD\VHDJDFKy/DYHQWDQDYHUGHGHVXFHOXODUEULOORHQODRVFXULGDG 8QQXHYRPHQVDMHPXOWLPHGLDGHFtDODSDQWDOOD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

/XHJRQRWyHOWH[WRGHEDMRGHODIRWR$XQTXHQRHVWDEDVHJXUDGHORTXHVLJQLILFDUD XQHVFDORIUtRLQFyPRGROHFUX]yGHVGHODSDUWHVXSHULRUGHVXFDEH]DKDVWDODVSODQWDV GHVXVSLHV 6XSRQJRTXHWRGRVWHQHPRVFRVDVSRUODVFXDOHVVHQWLUQRVFXOSDEOHV¢QR" 

ž‰‹ƒ

ͳͶͻ

³$



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR $OJRKXHOHDSRGULGRHQ5RVHZRRG« 7UDGXFLGRSRUNLNL &RUUHJLGRSRU0DULQD 

/

D PDxDQD GHO YLHUQHV PLHQWUDV HO FLHOR VH WUDQVIRUPDED GH D]XO RVFXUR D S~USXUD SiOLGR +DQQD FHUUy OD FUHPDOOHUD GH VX FKDTXHWD YHUGH GH FRUUHU PDUFD3XPDHKL]RXQSDUGHIOH[LRQHVGHSDQWRUULOODFRQWUDGHOJUDQDUFHHQ VX SDWLR GHODQWHUR /XHJR VH HFKy D FRUUHU SRU VX FDO]DGD HVFXFKDQGR P~VLFD HQ VX L3KRQH +DEtD VLGR XQD LGLRWD DO QR WHQHU XQ L3KRQH PXFKR DQWHV HTXLSDGR FRQ XQ Q~PHURGHWHOpIRQRQRUHJLVWUDGRQRKDEtDUHFLELGRXQVyORWH[WRGHOD1XHYD´$µ /D 1XHYD ´$µ FLHUWDPHQWH OH HVWDED HQYLDQGR XQ PRQWyQ GH WH[WRV D (PLO\ VLQ HPEDUJR+DQQDKDEtDUHFLELGRXQDYDQFHGH(PLO\WHPSUDQRHVWDPDxDQDXQDIRWR GH 'DUUHQ :LOGHQ PHURGHDQGR DOUHGHGRU GH XQD LJOHVLD ¢4Xp FUHHV TXH VLJQLILTXH HVWR" (PLO\ HVFULELy FRPR VL +DQQD UHDOPHQWH OR VXSLHUD 8Q PRQWyQ GH JHQWH LED D OD LJOHVLD1RFUHtDTXH´$µOHHQYLDEDD(PLO\WH[WRVFRPRSLVWDVGHPXFKDLPSRUWDQFLD /R PiV SUREDEOH HUD TXH ´$µ VLPSOHPHQWH HVWDED MXJDQGR FRQ OD SREUH \ \D GHVFRQFHUWDGDPHQWHGH(PLO\ 3HUR +DQQD KDEtD UHFLELGR EDVWDQWHV WH[WRV GH 0LNH 0RQWJRPHU\ &RPR HO TXH OOHJDEDDKRUDPLVPR 6WDVGVSLHUWD" 6t+DQQDWLSHyUiSLGDPHQWH(QXQDFDUUHUD 6H[\0LNHUHVSRQGLy¢4OOHYVSXHVWR"




)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

0LNH£3DVD[PLFDVD

ͳͷͲ

+DQQDVRQULyWUDYLHVDPHQWH6SDQGH[6XSUDMXVWDGR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

HQWRQFHV VH SUHRFXSy GH TXH SXGLHUD VRQDU OORURQD H LQVHJXUD ¢0LNH SHQVDED TXH .DWHHUDPiVERQLWD"¢0iVGHOJDGD"¢7RPDEDVXVFRPSUDV\WUDWDEDHLUUXPStDHQVX UHFiPDUDWDPELpQ"¢4XpKDFtD.DWH"¢5HtUVH«RHPRFLRQDUVH" ¢$TKRUDTXLHUVTWUHFRMDSDUDODILHVWDG5DGOH\PxDQD"+DQQDHVFULELy (OODHVWDEDDOILQDOGHVXFDOOHDQWHVGHTXH0LNHUHVSRQGLHUD ¢7LPSRUWDUtDVLDxDGLPRVXQWUFHUR"+DQQDOOHJyDGHWHQHUVHDEUXSWDPHQWHHQODHVTXLQD (UDREYLRTXHODWHUFHUDSHUVRQDTXH0LNHTXHUtDDxDGLUHUD.DWH (OODSDWHyHOSRVWHGHPHWDOGHODVHxDOGHDOWRFRQIXHU]DeVWHKL]RXQIXHUWHVRQLGR PHWiOLFRVREUHVDOWDQGRDXQDVFXDQWDVDYHVGHXQiUEROFHUFDQR6XSDSiSRGtDKDEHU UHODMDGRHOFDVWLJRGHFRQ.DWHWRGRHOWLHPSRSHURWRGDYtDHVWDEDWUDWDQGRGHREOLJDU D+DQQD\D.DWHDVHU%))&RPRD\HUFXDQGR.DWHKDEtDUHJUHVDGRGHVXFLWDFRQ 0LNH VH KDEtD XQLGR D +DQQD \ DO 6U 0DULQ HQ OD FRFLQD GRQGH +DQQD OH HVWDED PRVWUDQGRRUJXOORVDPHQWHDVXSDGUHVXGHFRUDGDEDQGHUDGH/D&iSVXODGHO7LHPSR (O 6U 0DULQ OD HVWXGLy OXHJR D .DWH \ OXHJR DPDEOHPHQWH OH SUHJXQWy D +DQQD VL .DWHSRGtDWHQHUXQDSDUWHGHOFUpGLWRSRUHQFRQWUDUODEDQGHUDWDPELpQ¢+DQQDWDO YH]SRGUtDVGLEXMDUOHXQDSHTXHxDGHFRUDFLyQHQXQDGHODVHVTXLQDV" /DERFDGH+DQQDFD\yDELHUWD

/DSULPHUDYH]TXH+DQQDHVWXYRHQODHQFUXFLMDGDIXHHOGtDHQTXHKDEtDWUDWDGRGH UREDUODSLH]DGHODEDQGHUDGH$OLGH/D&iSVXOD'HO7LHPSR+DQQDUHFRUGyPLUDU ILMDPHQWHDORVVXDYHVRMRVJUDQGHVGHOSRQ\GHVHDQGRSRGHUSHGLUOHVXRSLQLyQVREUH



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

+XERXQFKDVTXLGRGHWUiVGHHOOD\+DQQDVHGLRODYXHOWDUHSHQWLQDPHQWHJROSHDGD FRQ OD DSDUHQWH VHQVDFLyQ GH TXH DOJXLHQ OD HVWDED VLJXLHQGR 6yOR TXH OD FDUUHWHUD DQJRVWD HVWDED YDFtD (OOD GHMy HVFDSDU XQ VXVSLUR ODUJR \ GHFLGLy QR FRQWHVWDUOH D 0LNH HQ DEVROXWR GHVOL]DQGR VX L3KRQH HQ VX EROVLOOR \ VXELHQGR HO YROXPHQ GH OD P~VLFD %DMy FRUULHQGR OD FROLQD GH VX EDUULR DWUDYHVy XQ HVWUHFKR SXHQWH SHDWRQDO HQWUH GRV SDWLRV \ VH HQFRQWUy HQ XQD LQWHUVHFFLyQ IDPLOLDU +DEtD XQD YLHMD FDVD GH JUDQMDJULVHQ ODHVTXLQDDOHMDGDGHODFDOOH 'RVFDEDOORV GHFRORUFDQHOD\XQSRQ\ 6KHWODQGPRWHDGRHVWDEDQSDUDGRVVHUHQDPHQWHDOODGRGHODFHUFDGHPDGHUDeVWDHUD ODYXHOWDGH$OL

ͳͷͳ

(VPLEDQGHUDHOODJULWyDVRPEUDGDGHTXHLQFOXVRVXSDSiOHVXJLULHUDWDOFRVD
6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

OR TXH HVWDED D SXQWR GH KDFHU ¢4XLpQ VH FUHtD TXH HUD HOOD DVXPLHQGR SRGHU LU \ DUUHEDWDUOHODEDQGHUDGH$OL"¢4XpVL1DRPL\5LOH\HVWDEDQDOOt\WRGDVVHUHLUtDQHQ ODFDUDGH+DQQD"7DOYH]GHEHUtDFRQIURQWDUHOKHFKRGHTXHQXQFDVHUpSRSXODUHOOD FDVL OR KDEtD VROWDGR KDFLD HO SRQ\ 3HUR HQWRQFHV XQ FRFKH KDEtD SDVDGR \ KDEtD FXDGUDGRVXVKRPEURV\HQWUyHQVXELFLFOHWD $KRUDWURWDEDHQHOEDUULRGH$OLUHVSLUDQGRFRQIXHU]D/DFDVDGH0RQDHUDXQDGH ODVSULPHUDVFDVDVHQODFDOOHVXJUDQGLRVDFDO]DGDFLUFXODU\VXJDUDMHGHVHLVFRFKHV GH JDEOHWHV GRORURVDPHQWH IDPLOLDU +DQQD DSDUWy OD PLUDGD /XHJR YLQR OD FDVD GH -HQQDODURMDFRORQLDOFRQHOJUDQiUERODXQODGRHOTXHDOJXQDYH]KDEtDVXMHWDGROD FDVDGHiUEROGH7RE\/XHJRODSURSLHGDGGH6SHQFHUODFXDOHVWDEDFRORFDGDDXQD JUDQ GLVWDQFLD GHWUiV GH XQ JUDQ SRUWyQ GH KLHUUR IRUMDGR /RV UDVWURV GHO JUDIILWL $6(6,1$ HUDQ YLVLEOHV D WUDYpV GH ODV SXHUWDV UHSLQWDGDV GHO JDUDMH GHO JUDQHUR /D DQWLJXD FDVD GH $OL SRU ~OWLPR VXUJtD DPHQD]DGRUDPHQWH DO ILQDO GHO FDOOHMyQ VLQ VDOLGD +DQQDFRUULyKDFLDHOVDQWXDULRGH$OLHOFXDOWRGDYtDHVWDEDHQVDPEODGRHQODFXQHWD $OJXQDVGHODVYHODVKDEtDQVLGRUHHPSOD]DGDV\XQDHVWDEDHQFHQGLGDGDQ]DQGRHQ HO YLHQWR +DEtD DOJXQRV FDUWHOHV URWXODGRV HQ FDUWXOLQDV TXH GHFtDQ FRVDV FRPR /2 (1&2175$5(026$/,H£,$13$*$5É325(672

ž‰‹ƒ

+DQQDIUXQFLyHOFHxRPLUDQGRPiVGHFHUFDODIRWR'HWUiVGH$OLODSXHUWDSULQFLSDO GH ORV +DVWLQJV HVWDED OLJHUDPHQWH DELHUWD RIUHFLHQGR XQD YLVWD SDUFLDO GHO SDWLR GHODQWHUR GH 6SHQFHU 'H SLH HQ OD FDO]DGD GH 6SHQFHU DO ODGR GH ,DQ \ OD OLPRVLQD +XPPHU GH 0HOLVVD HVWDED XQD ILJXUD VROLWDULD HQ XQD FKDTXHWD \ YDTXHURV EDMRV +DQQD UHDOPHQWH QR SRGtD GLYLVDU TXLpQ HUD VX FDUD HUD XQ ERUUyQ 6LQ HPEDUJR KDEtDDOJRLQWUXVLYR\YR\HXULVWDHQODSRVWXUDGHODSHUVRQDFRPRVLTXLHQTXLHUDTXH IXHUDTXLVLHUDHVSLDUD,DQ\0HOLVVDWDPELpQ

ͳͷʹ

6HSXVRHQFXFOLOODV\PLUyODIRWRJUDItDTXHKDEtDVLGRSDUWHGHOVDQWXDULRGHVGHTXH SRU SULPHUD YH] IXH HQVDPEODGR GHVSXpV GH TXH HO FXHUSR GH $OL KDEtD VLGR UHFXSHUDGR/DIRWRHVWDEDGHIRUPDGD\GHVYDQHFLGDSRUORVPHVHVGHOOXYLD\QLHYH (UD XQD LPDJHQ GHO VH[WR JUDGR GH $OL YLVWLHQGR XQD FDPLVHWD D]XO 9RQ 'XWFK \ YDTXHURV 6HYHQ SDUDGD HQ HO JUDQGLRVR YHVWtEXOR GH 6SHQFHU /D IRWR KDEtD VLGR WRPDGD OD QRFKH HQ TXH 0HOLVVD H ,DQ HVWDEDQ YROYLHQGR DO -XHJR GH ,QYLHUQR GH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ $OL KDEtD VLGR YHKHPHQWH VREUH HVSLDUORV ULHQGR KLVWpULFDPHQWH FXDQGR0HOLVVDWURSH]yHQODVHVFDOHUDVGXUDQWHVXJUDQGLRVDHQWUDGD4XLpQVDEHWDO YH]$OLWHQtDDOJRFRQ,DQLQFOXVRGHVGHDTXHOHQWRQFHV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

8QD SXHUWD VH FHUUy +DQQD VDOWy OHYDQWDQGR OD PLUDGD 3RU XQ PRPHQWR HOOD QR SRGtDORFDOL]DUGHGyQGHKDEtDYHQLGRHOUXLGR/XHJRYLRD'DUUHQ:LOGHQGHSLHHQ ODFDO]DGDGHORV&DYDQDXJK&XDQGRpOYLRD+DQQDUHDFFLRQyFRQVRUSUHVD +DQQDGLMR:LOGHQ¢4XpHVWiV«KDFLHQGR" (O FRUD]yQ GH +DQQD HPSH]y D SDOSLWDU PiV UiSLGR FRPR VL DFDEDUD GH KDEHU VLGR DWUDSDGDUREDQGRHQXQDWLHQGD &RUULHQGR¢4XpHVWiVKDFLHQGRW~" :LOGHQSDUHFtDFRQPRFLRQDGReOVHYROYLyDPHGLDVJHVWLFXODQGRDORWURODGRGHOD FDOOHKDFLDHOERVTXHGHWUiVGHODFDVDGH6SHQFHU (VWDEDXKPVLPSOHPHQWHW~VDEHV&KHTXHDQGRODVFRVDVGHSRUDOOt +DQQD FUX]y VXV EUD]RV /RV SROLFtDV KDEtDQ DEDQGRQDGR OD E~VTXHGD HQ HO ERVTXH KDFH XQRV FXDQWRV GtDV < :LOGHQ KDEtD YHQLGR GH OD FDVD GH -HQQD OD FXDO HVWDED FUX]DQGRODFDOOHGHVGHHOERVTXHQRHQODGLUHFFLyQFRUUHFWDHQDEVROXWR ¢(QFRQWUDVWHDOJR" :LOGHQUHVWUHJyMXQWDVVXVPDQRVHQJXDQWDGDV 1RGHEHUtDVHVWDUDTXtpOHVSHWy +DQQDFODYyORVRMRVHQpO +DFHIUtRGLMR:LOGHQWRUSHPHQWH +DQQDH[WHQGLyVXSLHUQDL]TXLHUGD 3DUDHVRVRQODVPDOODV<ORVPLWRQHV\ODVJRUUDV

+DQQD VH UHWRUFLy ¢(VWDED :LOGHQ YHUGDGHUDPHQWH SUHRFXSDGR SRU HOOD« R VLPSOHPHQWH TXHUtD TXH VH IXHUD" eO PLUy SRU HQFLPD VX KRPEUR RWUD YH] KDFLD HO ERVTXHGH6SHQFHU+DQQDHVWLUyVXFXHOORWDPELpQ¢+DEtDDOJRDOOt"¢$OJRTXHpOQR TXHUtDTXHHOODYLHUD"¢3HURQROHKDEtDGLFKRpODODSUHQVDTXHQXQFDKDEtDFUHtGRTXH DOJRKXELHVHDOOt"¢1RSHQVDEDpOTXH+DQQD\ODVGHPiVORLQYHQWDURQ"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ž‰‹ƒ

(OWH[WRGH´$µVREUHODFRQIHVLyQGH:LOGHQUHODPSDJXHyDWUDYpVGHVXPHQWH

ͳͷ͵

$~Q DVt :LOGHQ JROSHy VX SXxR GHUHFKR HQ VX SDOPD L]TXLHUGD 3UHILHUR TXH HVWpVFRUULHQGRHQDOJ~QOXJDUPiVVHJXUR&RPRODSLVWD0DUZ\Q



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

7RGRVWHQHPRVFRVDVGHODVTXHVHQWLUQRVFXOSDEOHV¢QR" ¢1HFHVLWDV TXH WH OOHYH D DOJXQD SDUWH" SUHJXQWy :LOGHQ HQ YR] DOWD KDFLHQGR VDOWDUD+DQQD+HWHUPLQDGRDTXt 6LQFHUDPHQWHORVGHGRVGHORVSLHVGH+DQQDVHHVWDEDQHQWXPHFLHQGR 'HDFXHUGRWDUWDPXGHyWUDWDQGRGHSHUPDQHFHUFDOPDGD/HGLRDOVDQWXDULRGH $OLXQD~OWLPDPLUDGDOXHJRVLJXLyD:LOGHQDXQFRFKHFXELHUWRHQXQDFDSDVXFLDGH QLHYHHQGXUHFLGD\KLHOR¢eVHHVWXFRFKH"SUHJXQWy+DQQD+DEtDDOJRIDPLOLDU HQpVWH :LOGHQDVLQWLy 0L FRFKH GH SDWUXOOD HVWi HQ HO WDOOHU DVt TXH WXYH TXH UHFXUULU D HVWH YLHMR WUDVWR eO DEULy OD SXHUWD GHO SDVDMHUR (O LQWHULRU GHO FRFKH ROtD D YLHMDV HQYROWXUDV GH KDPEXUJXHVDV 0F'RQDOG eO UiSLGDPHQWH ODQ]y XQ PRQWyQ GH FDUSHWDV FDMDV GH ]DSDWRV &'V SDTXHWHV YDFtRV GH FLJDUULOORV FRUUHR VLQ DEULU \ XQ SDU GH JXDQWHV DGLFLRQDOHVKDFLDHODVLHQWRWUDVHUR3HUGyQSRUHOGHVRUGHQ 8QDFDOFRPDQtDGHIRUPDRYDODOSLHGHODVLHQWRGHODQWHURFDSWyODDWHQFLyQGH+DQQD +DEtD XQ GLEXMR GH XQ SH] VREUH HVWD FRQ XQDV FXDQWDV LQLFLDOHV \ ODV SDODEUDV 'D\ 3DVV /D FDOFRPDQtD QR KDEtD VLGR UHWLUDGD GHO UHVSDOGR EULOODQWH \ OD WLQWD SDUHFtD UDGLDQWH\QXHYD ¢5HFLHQWHPHQWH IXLVWH D SHVFDU HQ KLHOR" EURPHy +DQQD VHxDOiQGROD $QWHV FXDQGR VX SDSi HUD HO DPLJR GH +DQQD HQ YH] GH VHU HO ]iQJDQR VLQ DOPD TXH VyOR TXHUtD KDFHU IHOL] D OD 3ULQFHVD .DWH VROtDQ LU GH SHVFD DO /DJR .HXND DO QRUWH GH 1XHYD
ž‰‹ƒ

(O PRWRU DUUDQFy \ :LOGHQ FDPELy D UHYHUVD FRQ WDQWD IXHU]D TXH +DQQD IXH JROSHDGD'REOyHOFDOOHMyQVLQVDOLGDFDVLFRUULHQGRVREUHHOVDQWXDULRGH$OLOXHJR DFHOHUy SDVDQGR OD FDVD GH 6SHQFHU OD GH -HQQD \ OD GH 0RQD +DQQD HPSXxy OD SHTXHxDDJDUUDGHUDSRUHQFLPDGHODYHQWDQD

ͳͷͶ

1RKHOLPSLDGRHVWHFRFKHHQDxRV6XVSDODEUDVVDOtDQDSUHVXUDGDPHQWH(VD FRVDHVYLHMD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(VWR QR HV XQD FDUUHUD EURPHy HOOD FRQ YR] WHPEORURVD SRQLpQGRVH PiV \ PiV HVWXSHIDFWD :LOGHQODPLUySRUHOUDELOORGHORMRVLQGHFLUQDGD+DQQDQRWyTXHpOQROOHYDEDVX FKDTXHWD GHO 'HSDUWDPHQWR GH 3ROLFtD GH 5RVHZRRG SHUR HQ YH] GH HVR YHVWtD XQD VXGDGHUD FRQ FDSXFKD VLPSOH H[WUD JUDQGH \ JULV \ YDTXHURV QHJURV 8QD VXGDGHUD FRQFDSXFKDH[WUDJUDQGHGHKHFKRpVDVHSDUHFtDPXFKRDODTXHYHVWtDHVDSHUVRQD GHO*ULP5HDSHULVKTXHKDEtDHVWDGRYLJLOiQGRODGHVGHHOERVTXHODQRFKHGHOViEDGR 3HURHVRHUDVLPSOHPHQWHXQDFRLQFLGHQFLD«¢FLHUWR" +DQQDSDVyVXPDQRVREUHODSDUWHWUDVHUDGHVXFXHOOR\VHDFODUyODYR] (QWRQFHVXKP¢FyPRHVWiODLQYHVWLJDFLyQGH,DQ" :LOGHQODPLUyFRQVXSLHWRGDYtDSUHVLRQDGRILUPHPHQWHHQHODFHOHUDGRU7RPDURQ ODYXHOWDHQORDOWRGHODFROLQDPX\UiSLGR\ODVOODQWDVGHOFRFKHKLFLHURQXQUXLGR FKLUULDQWH 7HQHPRVXQDSLVWDEDVWDQWHEXHQDGHTXH,DQHVWiHQ&DOLIRUQLD +DQQDDEULyVXERFDOXHJRODFHUUyUiSLGDPHQWH/DGLUHFFLyQ,3GHORV,0VGH,DQ KDEtDGLFKRTXHpOWRGDYtDHVWDEDHQ5RVHZRRG ¢8KFyPRWHHQWHUDVWHGHHVR"SUHJXQWyHOOD 8QDYLVRJUXxy:LOGHQ ¢'HTXLpQ" eOOHODQ]yXQDIXULRVDPLUDGDKHODGD 6DEHVTXHQRSXHGRGHFLUWHHVR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

¢4Xp HVWiV KDFLHQGR" JULWy +DQQD SRQLpQGRVH QHUYLRVD :LOGHQ QR UHJUHVDED DO FDUULOFRUUHFWR£$OWRJULWy+DQQD$OPLVPRWLHPSRIXHFDWDSXOWDGDGHUHJUHVRD ODQRFKHHQTXHKDEtDHVWDGRGHSLHHQHOHVWDFLRQDPLHQWRGHO5RVHZRRG'D\FRQHO 689GH0RQDGLULJLpQGRVHGLUHFWDPHQWHKDFLDHOOD&XDQGRVHKDEtDSHUFDWDGRGHTXH HO 689 QR LED D GHVYLDUVH QR SRGtD PRYHUVH HVWDED SHWULILFDGD H LQGHIHQVD +DEtD VHQWLGRFRPRVLQRKXELHVHQDGDTXHSXGLHUDKDEHUKHFKRSDUDGHWHQHUORTXHVXFHGLy

ͳͷͷ

8Q1LVVDQ3DWKILQGHUJULVHVWDEDGHODQWHGHHOORVOHQWDPHQWHVXELHQGRSRUODFROLQD :LOGHQ DFHOHUy DO Pi[LPR HO PRWRU \ VH JLUy KDFLD HO FDUULO GH WUiILFR HQ FRQWUDULR DFHOHUDQGR SDUD GHVSOD]DUVH (O 3DWKILQGHU GLR XQ ERFLQD]R 'RV OXFHV QHEXORVDV DSDUHFLHURQHQODGLVWDQFLDGLULJLpQGRVHDODGLUHFFLyQFRQWUDULD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

+DQQD FHUUy VXV RMRV OD DQVLHGDG OD VREUHSDVy +XER XQ ERFLQD]R UXLGRVR \ HVWULGHQWH \ HO FRFKH GH :LOGHQ VH GHVYLy &XDQGR +DQQD YROYLy D DEULU VXV RMRV HVWDEDQGHUHJUHVRHQVXSURSLRFDUULO ¢4XpHVWiPDOFRQWLJR"GHPDQGy+DQQDFRQVXFXHUSRHQWHURWHPEODQGR :LOGHQOHGLRXQYLVWD]RSRUHOUDELOORGHVXRMReOVHYHtD«GLYHUWLGR &iOPDWH ¢&iOPDWH"+DQQDSDVyVXPDQRDORODUJRGHVXFDUDDSXQWRGHYRPLWDU(OLQFLGHQWH UHODPSDJXHy D WUDYpV GH VX PHQWH XQD \ RWUD YH] FDGD YH] PiV UiSLGR 'HVGH VX DFFLGHQWH KDEtD LQWHQWDGR PX\ PX\ LQWHQVDPHQWH QR SHQVDU DFHUFD GH HVD QRFKH\ DTXtHVWDED:LOGHQULpQGRVHGHHOODSRUDVXVWDUVH7DOYH]QRGHEHUtDKDEHUVLGRWDQ UiSLGDHQGHVFRQWDUORVWH[WRVGH´$µVREUH:LOGHQGHVSXpVGHWRGR +DQQDHVWDEDDSXQWRGHGHFLUOHTXHVHGHWXYLHUD\ODGHMDUDVDOLUFXDQGRVHSHUFDWyGH TXH :LOGHQ HVWDED VXELHQGR SRU VX VLQXRVD FDO]DGD &XDQGR OOHJDURQ DO ILQDO UiSLGDPHQWH VH GHVDEURFKy VX FLQWXUyQ GH VHJXULGDG \ VDOLy GHO FRFKH QXQFD WDQ DJUDGHFLGDSRUYHUVXFDVD &HUUy UXLGRVDPHQWH OD SXHUWD GH WRGRV PRGRV SHUR :LOGHQ SDUHFLy QR QRWDUOR eO VLPSOHPHQWH DFHOHUy HQ UHYHUVD \ EDMR OD FDO]DGD QL VLTXLHUD VH PROHVWy HQ KDFHU OD YXHOWDGHWUHVSXQWRV8QDSDUWHGHODQLHYHVHKDEtDFDtGRGHOPRUURGHOFRFKH+DQQD SRGtDYHUTXHWHQtDXQH[WUHPRDILODGR\IDURVTXHPHGLRVHYHtDQ 8QD VHQVDFLyQ GH GpMj YX UHSHQWLQDPHQWH OD PROHVWy $OJR GH OR TXH DFDEDED GH RFXUULU KDEtD SDVDGR DQWHV \ QR VyOR OD QRFKH GH VX DFFLGHQWH (OOD WHQtD HO PLVPR VHQWLPLHQWR FXDQGR QR SRGtD UHFRUGDU XQD SDODEUD GH YRFDEXODULR HQ OD FODVH GH IUDQFpVFRQHOWpUPLQRHQODSXQWDGHVXOHQJXD8VXDOPHQWHODSDODEUDYHQtDGHVSXpV HQODKRUDPiVH[WUDxDFRPRFXDQGRHVWDEDQDYHJDQGRHQL7XQHVRJXLDQGRD'RW 0X\SURQWRHVWHYROYHUtDDHOODWDPELpQ 

ž‰‹ƒ

ͳͷ͸

3HURH[DFWDPHQWHQRWHQtDJDQDVGHHQFRQWUDUOR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR &RFKHV\WUDWRVGH6SHQFHU &RFKHV\WUDWRVGH6SHQFHU 7UDGXFLGRSRU0HU\6Q] &RUUHJLGRSRUʾ 

(

OYLHUQHVGHVSXpVGHODHVFXHODODDPLJDGHFDPSRGHKRFNH\PiVFHUFDQDGH 6SHQFHU .LUVWHQ &XOOHQ VH GHWXYR HQ OD FDVD GH 6SHQFHU \ WLUy GHO IUHQR GH PDQR

³0XFKDV JUDFLDV SRU HO YLDMH ³GLMR 6SHQFHU 6yOR SRUTXH VXV SDGUHV OH KXELHUDQ TXLWDGR VX DXWR QR VLJQLILFDED TXH HVWXYLHUD D SXQWR GH VXELU D ERUGR GHO PDOROLHQWH DXWRE~VHVFRODUGH5RVHZRRG'D\ ³1RWHSUHRFXSHV³GLMR.LUVWHQ³¢1HFHVLWDVXQDYHQWyQHOOXQHVWDPELpQ" ³6LQRHVPXFKDPROHVWLD³PDVFXOOy6SHQFHU

/D FDVD HVWDED YDFtD ROLHQGR FRPR HO MDEyQ GH DFHLWH GH 0XUSK\ \ :LQGH[ OR TXH VLJQLILFDED TXH OD VHxRUD GH OD OLPSLH]D GH ORV +DVWLQJV &DQGDFH DFDEDED GH LUVH 6SHQFHU FRUULy HVFDOHUDV DUULED DJDUUy OD FDUSHWD GHO H[SHGLHQWH GH 2OLYLD GHVGH HO



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

.LUVWHQKL]RXQDVHxDOD6SHQFHU\UHJUHVyVXDXWRDODDFHUDPDQHMDQGRFRQXQDVROD PDQR *LUiQGRVH 6SHQFHU FDPLQy KDFLD OD HQWUDGD (O YHFLQGDULR HVWDED WUDQTXLOR \ VLOHQFLRVR \ HO FLHOR HUD GH XQ PRQyWRQR JULV SXUS~UHR (O JUDIILWL $6(6,1$ HQ ODV SXHUWDVGHOJDUDMHKDEtDVLGRSLQWDGRSRUHQFLPDSHURHOQXHYRFRORUQRFRLQFLGtDGHO WRGR FRQ HO DQWHULRU \ OD SDODEUD VH VHJXtD PRVWUDQGR D WUDYpV GH pO GpELOPHQWH 6SHQFHU DSDUWy ORV RMRV QR TXHUtD YHUOR ¢4XLpQ OR KDEtD SXHVWR DOOt" ¢´$µ" 3HUR ¢&RQTXpPRWLYR"¢$VXVWDUODRDGYHUWLUOH"

ͳͷ͹

+DEtD LQWHQWDGR OODPDU D $ULD SDUD XQ DYHQWyQ \D TXH DKRUD $ULD YLYtD HQ HO YHFLQGDULR SHUR $ULD KDEtD GLFKR TXH WHQtD ´DOJR TXH KDFHUµ HVD WDUGH PLVWHULRVDPHQWH QR GLMR OR TXH HUD < QR HUD FRPR VL VH OR SXGLHUD SHGLU D $QGUHZ 'XUDQWHWRGRHOGtDKDEtDSHQVDGRTXHpOLUtDDSHGLUOHGLVFXOSDVVLORKXELHUDKHFKR HOODVHKDEUtDGLVFXOSDGRWDPELpQ\SURPHWLGRTXHHOORVSRGUtDQSHUPDQHFHUMXQWRVVL HOODVHJXtDDGHODQWH$QGUHZGHOLEHUDGDPHQWHQROHGLMRQLXQDSDODEUDHQQLQJXQDGH ODVFODVHVTXHFRPSDUWtDQ4XHHUDFRPRLPDJLQDED6SHQFHUORTXHRFXUULUtD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

HVFULWRULRGHVXKDELWDFLyQ\VDOLyGHODFDVDSRUODSXHUWDWUDVHUD$SHVDUGHTXHVXV SDGUHV QR HVWDEDQ DKt QR TXHUtD HVWDU HQ VX FDVD FXDQGR HVWDED KDFLHQGR HVWR 1HFHVLWDEDFRPSOHWDSULYDFLGDG $EULyODSXHUWDGHOJUDQHUR\HQFHQGLyODVOXFHVGHODFRFLQD\ODVDODGHHVWDU7RGR HVWDEDFRPRORKDEtDGHMDGRGHVGHOD~OWLPDYH]TXHKDEtDHVWDGRDOOtKDVWDHOYDVRGH DJXDPHGLROOHQRFHUFDGHODFRPSXWDGRUD6HGHMyFDHUHQHOVRIi\VDFyVX6LGHNLFN (OPHQVDMHGH´$µHUDHO~OWLPRWH[WRTXHKDEtDUHFLELGR¢&yPRVXHQDGHVDSDUHFHUSDUD VLHPSUH" $OSULQFLSLRODQRWDODKDEtDDVXVWDGRSHURGHVSXpV GHXQWLHPSRORKDEtDYLVWRGH RWUD PDQHUD 'HVDSDUHFHU SDUD VLHPSUH VRQDED ELHQ GHVDSDUHFHU GH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ HVWDEDHQHVR<6SHQFHUVDEtDODPDQHUDMXVWDGHSRGHUKDFHUOR 'HMy FDHU OD FDUSHWD GH 2OLYLD FRQ ORV DUFKLYRV VREUH OD PHVD GH FDIp VX FRQWHQLGR SUiFWLFDPHQWH VH GHUUDPy VREUH OD DOIRPEUD /D WDUMHWD GHO DJHQWH GH ELHQHV UDtFHV VREUHVDOtD HQ OD SDUWH VXSHULRU GHUHFKD &RQ PDQRV WHPEORURVDV 6SHQFHU PDUFy VX Q~PHUR(OWHOpIRQRVRQyXQDYH]OXHJRGRVYHFHV ³0LFKDHO+XWFKLQV³FKLOOyODYR]GHKRPEUH 6SHQFHUVHLQFRUSRUy\VHDFODUyODJDUJDQWD ³+ROD 0L QRPEUH HV 6SHQFHU +DVWLQJV ³GLMR HOOD WUDWDQGR GH SDUHFHU PD\RU \ SURIHVLRQDO³0LPDPiHVVXFOLHQWH¢2OLYLD&DOGZHOO" ³3RU VXSXHVWR SRU VXSXHVWR ³0LFKDHO VRQDED PX\ FRQWHQWR³ 1R PH GL FXHQWD TXH WHQtD XQD KLMD ¢
³%XHQR PH JXVWDUtD XQ DSDUWDPHQWR (Q 1XHYD
ž‰‹ƒ

2\yD0LFKDHOWLUDUXQRVSDSHOHV ³&UHRTXHVt(VSHUD9R\DEXVFDUHQODEDVHGHGDWRVORTXHHVWiGLVSRQLEOH



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͳͷͺ

&UX]y\GHVFUX]yODVSLHUQDV6XFRUD]yQUHWXPEDEDDWUDYpVGHVXVRtGRV



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

6SHQFHU PRUGLy FRQ IXHU]D OD XxD GH VX SXOJDU (VWR VH VHQWtD VXUUHDO 0LUy SRU OD YHQWDQDDODSLVFLQDGHURFDVDOLQHDGDV\EDxHUDGHKLGURPDVDMHODHVFDORQDGDFXELHUWD WUDVHUDORVGRVSHUURVUHWR]DQGRFHUFDGHODEDUGD/XHJRVHYROYLy\PLUyHOPROLQR GHYLHQWR0(17,526$7RGDYtDHVWDEDDOOtD~QQRKDEtDVLGRSLQWDGR7DOYH]VXV SDGUHVVHORKDEtDQGHMDGRD6SHQFHUFRPRXQUHFRUGDWRULRHOHTXLYDOHQWHDODJUDQ\ URMD $ HQ /D /HWUD (VFDUODWD /D DQWLJXD FDVD GH $OL MXQWR D OD VX\D \D QR WHQtD OD FLQWD GH ´1R FUX]DUµ VREUH ORV KR\RV PHGLR FDYDGRV ORV QXHYRV GXHxRV ILQDOPHQWH KDEtDQ WHQLGR HO VHQWLGR SDUD VDFDUOD SHUR HO DJXMHUR QR KDEtD VLGR UHOOHQDGR D~Q 'HWUiVGHODJUDQMDVHHQFRQWUDEDQORVERVTXHVHVSHVRVRVFXURV\OOHQRVGHVHFUHWRV 2OLYLDOHKDEtDGLFKRTXHVHWRPDUDODVFRVDVOHQWDVSHURVDOLUGH5RVHZRRG'D\HUDOD PiVLQWHOLJHQWH³\VHJXUD³FRVDTXHSRGtDKDFHU ³¢(VWiV DKt" ³OODPy OD YR] GH 0LFKDHO 6SHQFHU VDOWy³ +D\ DOJR HQ OD GRVFLHQWRV YHLQWLWUpV GH 3HUU\ 6WUHHW 1L VLTXLHUD KD VDOLGR DO PHUFDGR D~Q HO SURSLHWDULR HVWi OLPSLDQGR\SLQWDQGR SHURSUREDEOHPHQWHOR VXELUHPRVDQXHVWURVLWLRZHEHOOXQHV (V GH XQ GRUPLWRULR HQ HO QLYHO GH VDOD HO QLYHO HVWi KHFKR GH SLHGUD URML]D (VWR\ PLUDQGR ODV IRWRV HQ HVWH PRPHQWR \ HO OXJDU VH YH SUHFLRVR 7HFKRV DOWRV SLVRV GH PDGHUD PROGXUDV GH FRURQD XQD FRFLQDFRPHGRU XQD WHUUD]D WUDVHUD XQD EDxHUD DQWLJXD (VWDUiV FHUFD GHO PHWUR \ D XQD FXDGUD GH 0DUF -DFREV 6XHQDV FyPR XQD SRVLEOHFKLFDGH0DUF-DFREV ³7LHQHVUD]yQHQHVR³6RQULy6SHQFHU ³¢(VWiV FHUFD GH XQD FRPSXWDGRUD" ³GLMR 0LFKDHO³ 3XHGR HQYLDUWH SRU FRUUHR HOHFWUyQLFRXQDVIRWRVGHOOXJDUDKRUDPLVPR ³&ODUR ³GLMR 6SHQFHU GiQGROH VX GLUHFFLyQ GH FRUUHR HOHFWUyQLFR 6H OHYDQWy \ VH GLULJLyD ODSRUWiWLOGH 0HOLVVDTXHHVWDEDXELFDGDFHUFDQRDHOODHQ HOHVFULWRULR(Q FXHVWLyQ GH VHJXQGRV XQ QXHYR HPDLO DSDUHFLy HQ VX EDQGHMD GH HQWUDGD /DV IRWRV DGMXQWDV HUDQ GH XQ FRORU FDIp URML]R FRQ SLQWRUHVFDV HVFDOHUDV GH SL]DUUD (O DSDUWDPHQWRWHQtDSLVRVGHUREOHJUXHVRGRVYHQWDQDOHVODGULOORVDODYLVWDHQFLPHUDV GHPiUPROHLQFOXVRXQDODYDGRUD\VHFDGRUD

³(VR HVWi ELHQ VHJXUR³GLMR pO OD YDFLODFLyQ HQ VX YR] FDVL SDOSDEOH³ 3HUR WHQJR TXH DGYHUWLUOH $SDUWDPHQWRV FRPR HVWH QR VH YHQ PX\ D PHQXGR \ 1XHYD


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

(OODHVFXFKyXQERFLQD]RIXHUDGHODYHQWDQDGH0LFKDHO

ͳͷͻ

³3DUHFH LQFUHtEOH ³UHVSLUy 6SHQFHU FDVL GHVPD\DGD³ (VWR\ HQ )LODGHOILD SRU HO PRPHQWR SHUR ¢SRGUtD OOHJDU D OD FLXGDG HQ OD WDUGH GHO OXQHV \ FRPSUREDU TXH IXQFLRQD"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

XQDFLXGDGGHOXMRGHYHUGDGXQDORFXUDeVDHVXQDGHODVPHMRUHVFDOOHVHQODFLXGDG \ODJHQWHYDDVDOWDUVREUHHOOD(VSUREDEOHTXHHOOXQHVSRUODPDxDQDDOJXLHQYHQJDD SUHVHQWDUVHHQQXHVWUDRILFLQDFRQXQFKHTXHWDQSURQWRFRPRHOOXJDUHVWpHQODZHE VLQ KDEHUOR YLVWR (Q HO PRPHQWR GH TXH OOHJXHV DTXt HO OXJDU SRGUtD KDEHU VLGR YHQGLGR 3HUR QR TXLHUR SUHVLRQDUWH +D\ RWURV OXJDUHV TXH SRGtD PRVWUDUWH HQ HVH YHFLQGDULRWDPELpQ 6SHQFHU WHQVy VXV KRPEURV OD DGUHQDOLQD IOXtD SRU VXV YHQDV 'H UHSHQWH VH VHQWtD FRPR VL HVWXYLHUD FRUULHQGR SRU HO EDOyQ HQ HO FDPSR GH KRFNH\ OXFKDQGR SRU OD DSUREDFLyQGHXQSURIHVRUHQFODVHeVWHHUDHODSDUWDPHQWRTXHOHFRUUHVSRQGtDDHOOD QR D DOJXLHQ PiV ,PDJLQy VXV PXHEOHV HQ HO GRUPLWRULR 6H LPDJLQy D Vt PLVPD YHVWLGD FRQ VX SRQFKR GH &KDQHO ORV ViEDGRV SRU OD PDxDQD PLHQWUDV FDPLQDED D 6WDUEXFNV 3RGUtD WHQHU XQ SHUUR \ FRQWUDWDU D XQR GH HVRV SDVHDGRUHV GH SHUURV TXH DQGDEDQFRQTXLQFHSHUURVDODYH]+R\WHPSUDQRKDEtDPLUDGRODVHVFXHODVSULYDGDV HQ1XHYD


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

/HQWDPHQWH DEULy OD FDUSHWD \ OXHJR HO 3') 7RGD OD LQIRUPDFLyQ TXH QHFHVLWDED HVWDEDDOOt/DFXHQWDHVWDEDDVXQRPEUH2OLYLDKDEtDGLFKRTXHXQDYH]TXH0RUJDQ ODFRQRFLyVHKDEtDHQDPRUDGRGHHOOD3UREDEOHPHQWHUHHPEROVDUtDHVWDFXHQWDGLH] YHFHV

ͳ͸Ͳ

6SHQFHU PRYLy ORV GHGRV VREUH HO WHFODGR GHO RUGHQDGRU SRUWiWLO 2OLYLD KDEtD GHMDGR FODURTXHVXPDULGR0RUJDQVRVSHFKDEDGHODVSHUVRQDVTXHQRFRQRFtD6LOHSHGtD GLQHUR D 2OLYLD \ 0RUJDQ VH DUULHVJDED D SHUGHU VX FRQILDQ]D (FKy XQ YLVWD]R D OD SDQWDOOD $OOt HVWDED OD FDUSHWD HQ OD HVTXLQD GHUHFKD GHO HVFULWRULR 6SHQFHU 8QLYHUVLGDG

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³1R QHFHVLWDPRV LQYROXFUDU D PL PDGUH ³GLMR 6SHQFHU³ 7HQJR XQD FXHQWD D PL QRPEUHTXHGHVHRXWLOL]DU ³(VWi ELHQ ³GLMR 0LFKDHO VLQ SHUGHU HO ULWPR 3UREDEOHPHQWH WUDWDED FRQ FKLFRV ULFRVGHODFLXGDGFRQVXVSURSLDVFXHQWDVEDQFDULDVWRGRHOWLHPSR6SHQFHUOHOH\yD 0LFKDHO ORV Q~PHURV HQ OD SDQWDOOD FRQ OD YR] WHPEORURVD 0LFKDHO OR UHSLWLy GH UHJUHVR\OXHJROHGLMRTXHWRGRORTXHWHQtDTXHKDFHUHUDOODPDUDOSURSLHWDULR\WRGR HVWDUtD OLVWR $FRUGDURQ UHXQLUVH HQ IUHQWH DO HGLILFLR D ODV  30 HO OXQHV SDUD TXH 6SHQFHUSXGLHUDILUPDUHOFRQWUDWR\UHFRJHUODVOODYHV'HVSXpVGHHVRHODSDUWDPHQWR VHUtDVX\R ³*UDQGLRVR³GLMR6SHQFHU(QWRQFHVFROJyHOWHOpIRQR\VHTXHGyPLUDQGRILMDPHQWH DODSDUHG /RKDEtDKHFKR5HDOPHQWHORKDEtDKHFKR(QSRFRVGtDV\DQRYLYLUtDDTXt(VWDUtD HQ 1XHYD


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6XHVWyPDJRVHHPSHTXHxHFLy1RSRGtDVHUXQSROLFtDHOORVKDEtDQDEDQGRQDGRORV ERVTXHV KDFH XQRV GtDV 6H DVRPy SRU OD YHQWDQD FXULRVD SRU VDEHU TXLpQ HUD OD SHUVRQDTXHHVWDEDKDFLHQGRUXLGR3DUDVXKRUURUODYHQWDQDKL]RXQVRQLGRIXHUWHGH UDVSDGRFRQWUDODMDPED6SHQFHUKL]RXQDPXHFDHQFRJLpQGRVHIXHUDGHYLVWD

ͳ͸ͳ

6SHQFHUVHSXVRHQSLH/DVOXFHVYHQtDQGHXQDOLQWHUQDFUX]DQGRVREUHORVWURQFRVGH ORViUEROHV8QDILJXUDVHDJDFKy\FRPHQ]yDKXUJDUHQODVXFLHGDG4XLpQTXLHUDTXH IXHUDORLQWHQWyHQXQSXQWRVHGHWXYR\OXHJRFDPLQyXQRVSDVRVDODL]TXLHUGD\OR LQWHQWyHQRWUR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

/D ILJXUD VH GHWXYR YROYLpQGRVH KDFLD HO JUDQHUR /D OX] GH OD OLQWHUQD VH PRYtD GH IRUPD HUUiWLFD SULPHUR D OD GHUHFKD OXHJR D OD L]TXLHUGD \ D FRQWLQXDFLyQ SRU XQ PRPHQWRVREUHHO URVWURGH ODILJXUD 6SHQFHUYLRODSDOLGH]GHGRV RMRVD]XOHV/RV ERUGHV GH XQD VXGDGHUD QHJUD FRQ FDSXFKD 8Q IDPLOLDU PHFKyQ GH FDEHOOR UXELR SiOLGR 6SHQFHUDUUXJyODQDUL]FRQLQFUHGXOLGDG¢(VDHUD«0HOLVVD" /DILJXUDVHHVWUHPHFLyHQODRVFXULGDGFRPRVL6SHQFHUKXELHUDKDEODGRHQYR]DOWD $QWHVGHTXH6SHQFHUSXGLHUDGHWHUPLQDUVLUHDOPHQWHHUDVXKHUPDQDODOLQWHUQDHQHO ERVTXHVHDSDJy3RFDVUDPDVFUXMtDQ3DUHFtDTXHWRGRHOTXHTXLpQIXHUDTXHKXELHUD HVWDGR DOOt VH HVWDED DOHMDQGR /RV SDVRV VH YROYLHURQ PiV \ PiV GpELOHV KDVWD TXH 6SHQFHU\DQRSXGRGLVWLQJXLUORVHQWUHORViUEROHV &XDQGR 6SHQFHU HVWXYR VHJXUD GH TXH OD SHUVRQD VH IXH FRUULy IXHUD \ FRPHQ]y D UHYLVDUODWLHUUD(IHFWLYDPHQWHODWLHUUDHVWDEDEODQGD\VXHOWD3DOSyWRGRVXDOUHGHGRU SRU XQ PRPHQWR WRFDQGR VyOR SLHGUDV \ UDPDV SHUR OD WLHUUD WRGDYtD VH VHQWtD FDOLHQWHFRPRVLODVPDQRVGHRWUDSHUVRQDDFDEDUDQGHHVWDUDOOt$OOHYDQWDUODYLVWD R\yXQOLJHURVRQLGRPX\OHMRVGHORViUEROHV/DSLHOGHJDOOLQDVHHUL]yHQVXVEUD]RV &DVLVRQDEDFRPRXQDULVLWD

ž‰‹ƒ

ͳ͸ʹ

3HUR FXDQGR 6SHQFHU ODGHy OD FDEH]D HO UXLGR VH GHVYDQHFLy \ QR SXGR GHMDU GH SUHJXQWDUVHVLHVRVyORKDEtDVLGRHOYLHQWR 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR /DFDtGDOLEUHGH$ULD /DFDtGDOLEUHGH$ULD 7UDGXFLGRSRU'DQL\3DROD6 &RUUHJLGRSRUʾ 

(

VD PLVPD WDUGH $ULD VH HQFRQWUy FRQ -DVRQ IXHUD GH 5RFNV DQG 5RSHV XQ JLPQDVLRSDUDHVFDODUHQSDUHGHVDXQDVPLOODVDODVDIXHUDVGH5RVHZRRG ³'HVSXpVGHWL³GLMR-DVRQVRVWHQLHQGRODSXHUWDSULQFLSDO

³*UDFLDV³GLMR$ULDFRQYR]DKRJDGD6HDUUHPDQJyODVPDOODVGH\RJDHODVWLFDGDV OLJHUDPHQWHGHPDVLDGRJUDQGHVTXHKDEtDUREDGRGHODUPDULRGH0HUHGLWKHVSHUDQGR TXH -DVRQ QR QRWDUD OR VXHOWRV TXH OH TXHGDEDQ HQ HO WUDVHUR -DVRQ SRU RWUR ODGR OXFtDFyPRGR\VH[\HQXQDFDPLVHWDJULVGHPDQJDODUJD\XQRVSDQWDORQHVGHSRUWLYRV 1LNHFRPRVLHVFDODUDSDUHGHVURFRVDVWRGRHOWLHPSR7DOYH]ORKDFtD 8QD YH] GHQWUR OD OX] HUD IOXRUHVFHQWH \ GHVDJUDGDEOH $JUHVLYD P~VLFD GH JXLWDUUD UHVRQDEDDWUDYpVGHORVSDUODQWHV\ODKDELWDFLyQGHWHFKRDOWR\RORUDFDXFKRWHQtD PLOHV GH FRORULGRV DIORUDPLHQWRV GH DSDULHQFLD SOiVWLFD VREUH ODV SDUHGHV -DVRQ OH KDEtD PDQGDGR XQ PHQVDMH D $ULD LQYLWiQGROD D 5RFNV \ 5RSHV HVWD PDxDQD DGPLWLHQGR TXH QR HUD HO WLSR GH FKLFR TXH OOHYDED D ODV FKLFDV GH FHQD \ D YHU XQD SHOtFXOD(QUHDOLGDG$ULDVHKXELHUDSDUDGRHQODILODGH'09FRQ-DVRQVLHUDHVROR TXHpOFRQVLGHUDEDFRPRXQDFLWD 'HVSXpVGHUHJLVWUDUVHFDPLQDURQKDFLDODJUDQSDUHG\PLUDURQDOUHGHGRU$ULDODQ]y XQDVPLUDGDVODVFLYDVDODVFKLFDVTXHHVWDEDQHVFDODQGRODSDUHGDWDGDVFRQDUQHVHV ¢&yPRSRGtDQHVWDUWDQDOWR"'HVyORPLUDUKDFLDDUULEDOHGLRYpUWLJR6HHVWUHPHFLy ³¢(VWDVDVXVWDGD"³OHSUHJXQWy-DVRQ

ͳ͸͵

$ULDQDULRQHUYLRVDPHQWH ³1RVR\WDQDWOpWLFD

ž‰‹ƒ

-DVRQVRQULy\ODWRPyGHODPDQR ³(VGLYHUWLGRORSURPHWR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

$ULDVHVRQURMyFRQSODFHUHQWXVLDVPDGDSRUTXH-DVRQODHVWXYLHUDWRFDQGR7RGDYtD WHQtD TXH SHOOL]FDUVH D Vt PLVPD SDUD DVHJXUDUVH GH TXH HVWR UHDOPHQWH HVWDED RFXUULHQGR 8QRGHORVLQVWUXFWRUHVXQKRPEUHFRQFDEHOORRVFXUR\XQDEDUEDSHOXGDVHDFHUFyD HOORVFRQVXHTXLSDPLHQWRORTXHLQFOXtDXQRVDUQHVHVFLQWXURQHV\JXDQWHVHVSHFLDOHV SDUDHVFDODU3UHJXQWyTXHFXDOGHORVGRVTXHUtDVXELUSULPHUR-DVRQVHxDOyD$ULD ³6HxRULWD ³0X\FDEDOOHURVR³/RPROHVWyHOOD ³0LPDPiPHHGXFyPX\ELHQ³UHVSRQGLy-DVRQ (OLQVWUXFWRUFRPHQ]yDFRORFDUOHHODUQpVD$ULD/XHJRVHDOHMySDUDHQFRQWUDUXQDV DEUD]DGHUDVGLIHUHQWHV$ULDVHYROYLyKDFLD-DVRQ ³(QWRQFHV ¢FyPR HVWi WX IDPLOLD" ³SUHJXQWy WDQ FDVXDOPHQWH FRPR SXGR³ ¢(VWiQWRGRVELHQ" -DVRQVHTXHGyPLUDQGRILMDPHQWHDXQDVSHUVRQDVHVFDODQGR ³(VWiQ WRGRV GHVWUR]DGRV ³GLMR GHVSXpV GH XQ WLHPSR (O OHYDQWy VXV RMRV D]XOHV KDFLDHOOD\OHVRQULy³7RGRVORHVWDPRV¢3HURTXpSRGHPRVKDFHU"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

$ULDDVXPLyTXH´$µHVWDEDVXJLULHQGRTXHHOVHFUHWRGH-DVRQWHQtDDOJRTXHYHUFRQ VXVSUREOHPDV´GHKHUPDQRVµFRQ$OLFRPR-HQQDOROODPDEDSHURHOODQRVHORFUHtD 1RKDEtDPDQHUDGHTXH-DVRQ\$OLKD\DQWHQLGRDOJ~QWLSRGHUHODFLyQPiVTXHOD DPRURVD GH KHUPDQRV $ULD KDEtD LQWHQWDGR UHFRUGDU WRGRV ORV PRPHQWRV HQ TXH -DVRQKDEtDVLGRRGLRVRFRQ$OLSHURQRVHOHRFXUUtDQLQJ~QLQFLGHQWH(QVXOXJDU -DVRQ SDUHFtD XQ KHUPDQR VREUHSURWHFWRU 8QD YH] QR PXFKR GHVSXpV GH TXH VH KDEtDQKHFKRDPLJDV$ULD\ODVRWUDVFKLFDVKDEtDQLGRDVXFDVDSDUDXQDSLMDPDGD (VWDEDQSODQHDQGRPDTXLOODUVHODVXQDVDODVRWUDV\WRGDVKDEtDQOOHYDGRVXVEROVDV GH PDTXLOODMH SDUD FRPSDUWLU H[FHSWR SRU (PLO\ SRUTXH D HOOD QR OH SHUPLWtDQ XVDU PDTXLOODMHWRGDYtD0LHQWUDVHVWDEDQGHOHLWDGDVFRQODVRPEUDGHRMRV'LRUGH+DQQD OD6UD'L/DXUHQWLVHQWUyHQVXKDELWDFLyQ+DEtDXQDPLUDGDIUD]]OHGHQVXURVWUR

ͳ͸Ͷ

$ULDDVLQWLyVLQWHQHULGHDGHTXHGHFLU/DQRWDGHOGtDDQWHULRUGH´$µUHVXUJLyHQVX FDEH]D(OKHUPDQRPD\RUHVFRQGHDOJRGHWL<FRQItDHQPLQRTXLHUHVVDEHUORTXHHV$ULD QR OH KDEtD SDVDGR OD QRWD D QLQJXQD GH VXV DPLJDV SRU PLHGR GH TXH VDFDUDQ FRQFOXVLRQHV VREUH -DVRQ ´$µ WHQtD TXH HVWDU PHWLHQGR FRQ HOODV VL HUD HO DQWLJXR \ QXHYR0RGXV2SHUDQGLGH´$µGHVSXpVGHWRGR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³$OL ¢DOLPHQWDVWH D OD JDWD FRQ WRGD XQD ODWD GH FRPLGD PRMDGD" ³SUHJXQWy VX PDPi $OL HVWDED HQ EODQFR /D 6UD 'L/DXUHQWLV EDMR VXV EUD]RV³ &DULxR GHEHV PH]FODUODFRQFRPLGDVHFD¢UHFXHUGDV"¢<FRORFDVWHXQDVJRWDVGHPHGLFLQDSDUDODV ERODVGHFDEHOOR"³$OLVHPRUGLyORVODELRV/D6UD'L/DXUHQWLVJUXxy\VHYROWHy³ ¢2OYLGDVWHHVRWDPELpQ"£(OODYDDERWDUERODVGHSHORVSRUWRGDODQXHYDDOIRPEUDGHO VyWDQR $OLFRORFyHOSLQFHOGHUXERUGH+DQQDHQODPHVD ³¢7HSRGUtDVUHODMDU"£$KRUDHVWR\HQVH[WRJUDGR\WHQHPRVPXFKDWDUHD'LVFXOSD VLHVWR\XQSRFRGLVWUDtGDFRPRSDUDUHFRUGDUTXHGHERDOLPHQWDUDODJDWD /D6UD'L/DXUHQWLVQHJyFRQODFDEH]D ³$OLKDVDOLPHQWDGRODJDWDGHODPLVPDPDQHUDGHVGHTXHHVWiVHQWHUFHUJUDGR³ /XHJRVHSUHFLSLWyDIXHUD 8QPRPHQWRGHVSXpV-DVRQDSDUHFLyGHVGHODFRFLQDFRQXQDEROVDGHSUHW]HOVHQVX PDQR ³0DPiHVWDGHPDOKXPRU¢FLHUWR"³GLMRJHQWLOPHQWH³3XHGRDOLPHQWDUDODJDWD SRUWLGXUDQWHXQWLHPSRVLHVRD\XGD 7RFRHOKRPEURGH$OLSHURHOODORDOHMy ³'HWHQWH(VWR\ELHQ



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

2¢TXpSDVDVL-HQQDHVWDEDPLQWLHQGR"7DOYH]-HQQDKDEtDLQYHQWDGRTXH$OL\-DVRQ WHQtDQSUREOHPDVGHKHUPDQRV4XL]iVpVHHUDHOSRUTXp-HQQDHVWDEDSDUDGDDOERUGH GHO SDWLR GH $ULD KDFH GRV GtDV FRQ XQD PLUDGD FXOSDEOH VREUH VX URVWUR 7DO YH] TXHUtDGHFLUOHD$ULDTXHORTXHOHKDEtDGLFKRHQODVDODGHDUWHXQRVPHVHVDWUiVQR KDEtDVLGRWRGDODYHUGDG

ͳ͸ͷ

-DVRQ UHWURFHGLy FRQ XQD PLUDGD WULVWH HQ VX URVWUR $ULD KDEtD TXHULGR ODQ]DUVH \ DEUD]DUOR $OL VH KDEtD SRUWDGR GH OD PLVPD PDQHUD HO GtD HQ TXH /D &iSVXOD GHO 7LHPSR IXH DQXQFLDGD -DVRQ VH KDEtD DFHUFDGR D $OL \ D ,DQ IUHQWH DO SDUTXH GH ELFLFOHWDV GLFLpQGROH D ,DQ TXH GHMDUD D $OL WUDQTXLOD \ HOOD KDEtD GHVSUHFLDGR HVH JHVWREXUOiQGRVHGHpOSRUSUHRFXSDUVHGHPDVLDGR4XL]iV-DVRQKDEtDSHUFLELGRTXH ORVVHQWLPLHQWRVGH,DQKDFLD$OLQRHUDQSUHFLVDPHQWHLQRFHQWHV\ODTXHUtDSURWHJHUOD GH HVR 4XL]iV $OL VDEtD TXH -DVRQ KDEtD SHUFLELGR HVR \ OR KDEtD DOHMDGR 6L $OL \ -DVRQWXYLHUDQSUREOHPDVGHKHUPDQRVTXL]iV$OLIXHUDODTXHORVHVWXYLHUDFUHDQGR\ QRDOUHYpV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

3HUR ¢SRU TXp PHQWLUtD -HQQD" ¢3RGUtD WHQHU DOJR FRQWUD -DVRQ DOJXQD UD]yQ SDUD SRQHUDODVFKLFDVHQVXFRQWUD"¢3RGUtD-HQQDVHU´$µ" ³(VWiVOLVWD³OHGLMRHOLQVWUXFWRUD$ULDGHYROYLpQGRODGHJROSHDOSUHVHQWHeOHVWDED DWUiVVHxDODQGRODODUJDFXHUGDTXHHVWDEDDWDGDDOWHFKR\DOPHGLRGHVXFLQWXUD³ ¢1HFHVLWDVXQDOHFFLyQ" ³/H HQVHxDUp  ³GLMR -DVRQ (O LQVWUXFWRU DVLQWLy \ IXH D FRQVHJXLU ODV DEUD]DGHUDV SDUD ODV FRUUHDV GH -DVRQ (QWRQFHV -DVRQ VH GHVOL]y PiV FHUFD GH $ULD \ OD HPSXMy VXDYHPHQWH D VX ODGR³ 1R PLUHV DKRUD  ³GLMR HQ YR] EDMD³ SHUR FUHR TXH OD DQWLJXDHQIHUPHUDGHODHVFXHODHVWiDTXt6ROtDWHQHUSHVDGLOODVVREUHHOOD $ULD HFKy XQ YLVWD]R SRU VREUH VX KRPEUR 6XILFLHQWHPHQWH VHJXUR XQD UHFKRQFKD PXMHUFRQFDUDGHEXOOGRJHVWDEDGHSLHHQHOVDOyQDOODGRGHODPiTXLQDGH0RXQWDLQ 'HZLOXPLQDGDSRUOXFHVGHQHyQ ³£(VDHVOD6UD%RRW³VXVXUUy$ULD /RVRMRVGH-DVRQVHDPSOLDURQ ³¢7RGDYtDWUDEDMDDOOt" $ULDDVLQWLy ³6LHPSUHTXHODYHRHQORVSDVLOORVPLFXHURFDEHOOXGRSLFD1XQFDROYLGDUpFXDQGR KDFtDPRVILODVHQVXRILFLQDHQODHVFXHODSULPDULDSDUDODVSUXHEDVGHSLRMRV ³2GLDED HVR ³-DVRQ VH HVWUHPHFLy /XHJR VH GLHURQ OD YXHOWD KDFLD OD 6UD %RRW (VWDED IUXQFLHQGR HO FHxR GXUDPHQWH KDFLD OD SDUHG FRPR VL IXHUD XQ HVWXGLDQWH GH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ ILQJLHQGR WHQHU ILHEUH /XHJR XQ QLxR SHTXHxR FRUULy IXHUD GH OD KDELWDFLyQ GH ORV FDVLOOHURV GLUHFWDPHQWH D ORV EUD]RV GH OD 6UD %RRW /D KRVFD DQFLDQDVRQUHtDOLJHUDPHQWH\ORVGRVVDOLHURQGH5RFNVDQG5RSHVMXQWRV

³7DPELpQHVFXFKpHVHUXPRU³(QWRQFHVIUXQFLyHOFHxR³¢3RUTXpHVWDEDVPXFKR HQ OD RILFLQD GH OD HQIHUPHUD" ³1R UHFRUGDED D -DVRQ VLHQGR SDUWLFXODUPHQWH HQIHUPL]RHUDXQMXJDGRUHVWUHOODGHI~WEROHQHORWRxR\MXJDEDEHLVEROHQSULPDYHUD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

$ULDULyWRQWDPHQWH

ͳ͸͸

³7XYHTXHSDVDUPXFKRWLHPSRHQOD RILFLQDGHODHQIHUPHUD³PXUPXUy-DVRQ³ 6LHPSUHTXHLEDDKtOD6UD%RRW PHPLUDEDFRQHOFHxRIUXQFLGRFRQVXRMREXHQR 8QDYH]HVFXFKpXQUXPRUGHTXHVXPLUDGDHUDFRPRXQUD\ROiVHUTXHSRGtDIXQGLU WXFHUHEUR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³1R HVWDED HQIHUPR ³FRUULJLy -DVRQ 0RYLy EUXVFDPHQWH HO SHTXHxR FLHUUH GHO EROVLOORGHVXVSDQWDORQHVGHSRUWLYRV³
ž‰‹ƒ

³(QWRQFHVPHGLMLVWHHORWURGtDTXHDFDEDV GHPXGDUWHFRQWXSDGUH\VXQRYLD³ GLMR-DVRQPDQWHQLHQGRHOULWPRFRQHOOD³¢'HTXpVHWUDWDHVR" $ULDHVWLUyHOEUD]RSDUDDJDUUDURWUDURFD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͳ͸͹

³(VRHVORTXHOHVGLFHVDWRGDVODVFKLFDV³JLPLy$ULD3HURVLJXLyVXELHQGRDOJXQDV URFDVPiV1RPLUHVKDFLDDEDMRVHUHSHWtDDVtPLVPD6ROtDPDUHDUVHVyORSRUSDUDUVH DOERUGHGHOWUDPSROtQEDMRHQODSLVFLQDORFDO



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³0LV SDGUHV VH VHSDUDURQ FXDQGR UHJUHVp GH ,VODQGLD ³FRPHQ]y SUHJXQWiQGRVH FyPR GHFLU HVWR³ 0L SDGUH WXYR XQD DYHQWXUD FRQ VX DQWLJXD HVWXGLDQWH $KRUD VH YDQDFDVDU<HOODHVWiHPEDUD]DGD -DVRQOHHFKyXQYLVWD]R ³:KRD ³(VH[WUDxR1RHVPXFKRPD\RUTXHW~ -DVRQKL]RXQDPXHFD ³¢&XiQGRHPSH]DURQDYHUVH" ³&XDQGR \R HVWDED HQ VpSWLPR JUDGR ³DGPLWLy $ULD (VFDQHy ODV URFDV VREUH HOOD EXVFDQGR OD PHMRU SDUD DJDUUDUVH (UD OLQGR TXH HVWXYLHUDQ KDEODQGR OD KDFtD ROYLGDUVHGHFXiQGLItFLOHUDHVFDODU³/RVSLOOpEHViQGRVHHQHOFRFKHGHPLSDSi³< OXHJR WDO YH] SRUTXH KDEtD UHFRUGDGR OD YH] TXH $OL KDEtD UHFKD]DGR D -DVRQ WDQ GHVSLDGDGDPHQWH VREUH HO JDWR DxDGLy³ W~ XP KHUPDQD« HVWDED FRQPLJR < QR PHGHMyHVFXFKDUHOILQDOGHHVR (FKyXQYLVWD]RKDFLD-DVRQSUHJXQWiQGRVHVLKDEtDVREUHSDVDGRVXVOtPLWHVeOWHQtD XQDH[SUHVLyQQHXWUDOVREUHVXURVWURXQDTXHQRSRGtDHYDOXDU ³/RVLHQWR³GLMR³1RGHEHUtDKDEHUGLFKRHVR ³1R« OR FRPSUHQGR 0L KHUPDQD HUD DVt &RQRFtD HO ERWyQ SUHFLVR SDUD SUHVLRQDU GHWRGRV $ULDFROJDEDVREUHODSDUHGUHSHQWLQDPHQWHGHPDVLDGRFDQVDGDSDUDPRYHUVH ³¢7DPELpQWHQtDVXQERWyQ" ³8KKXK(UDQODVFKLFDV ³¢&KLFDV"

³6DEtD WRGDV QXHVWUDV GHELOLGDGHV HVWi ELHQ ³GLMR $ULD /HYDQWy OD YLVWD RWUD YH] UDGLDQWHGHFXOSD³7RGDYtDPHVLHQWRPDOKDEODQGRVREUHHOODFRQWLJR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³$ YHFHV VROtD PROHVWDUPH VREUH ODV FKLFDV 3RGtD VHU« WRUSH VXSRQJR 6ROtD PROHVWDUPHVREUHHVR

ͳ͸ͺ

-DVRQDVLQWLy

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

5HSHQWLQDPHQWH-DVRQVHDSDUWyGHODSDUHGEDODQFHiQGRVHOLEUHPHQWHGHODFXHUGD ³%DMDDOSLVRSRUXQVHJXQGR³GLMR³'HVOt]DWHKDFLDDEDMRFRQWXDUQpV $ULD VH GHVOL]y KDFLD DEDMR FRPR OH LQVWUX\y DWHUUL]DQGR WRUSHPHQWH VREUH OD FROFKRQHWD-DVRQODHVWXGLyPX\VHULDPHQWH\$ULDVHSUHJXQWyVLKDEtDFRPHWLGRXQ HUURUWUD\HQGRDFRODFLyQD$OL3HURHQWRQFHVpOGLMR ³7DOYH]HVEXHQRTXHHVWHPRVKDEODQGRVREUHHOOD4XLHURGHFLUHQHVWHPRPHQWR $OLVRQHVXQJUDQHOHIDQWHHQODKDELWDFLyQTXHQDGLHGLVFXWLUiFRQPLJR&XDQGRHVWR\ HQFDVDPLVSDGUHVQR ODVDFDQDFRODFLyQ&XDQGRHVWR\DIXHUDFRQPLVDPLJRVQR GLFHQXQDSDODEUD6pTXHODJHQWHHVWiKDEODQGRVREUHHOODSHURVLHPSUHTXHHVWiQD PtDOUHGHGRUVHFDOODQ6pTXHPLKHUPDQDWHQtDGHIHFWRV6pTXHDDOJXQDVSHUVRQDV QR OHV DJUDGDED $ DOJXQDV SHUVRQDV PiV TXH« ³PXUPXUy DOJR PiV \ VH IXH DSDJDQGRMXQWDQGRFRQIXHU]DVXVODELRV ³¢4XpIXHHVR"³SUHJXQWy$ULDLQFOLQiQGRVHKDFLDDGHODQWH -DVRQPRYLyUiSLGDPHQWHVXPDQRDOHMDQGRORTXHDFDEDEDGHGHFLU ³0HJXVWDUtDTXHKDEODUDVVREUH$OLFRQPLJR $ULDVRQULyDOLYLDGD+DEODUVREUH$OLFRQ-DVRQOHGDUtDWRGDXQDQXHYDSHUVSHFWLYD VREUH TXLpQ HUD $OL UHDOPHQWH 6H SUHJXQWDED VL GHEHUtD FRQWDUOH D -DVRQ FyPR $OL KDEtDHVSDUFLGRUXPRUHVVREUHpOFRQ-HQQD&DYDQDXJKRFyPR-HQQDKDEtDHVSDUFLGR UXPRUHV VREUH -DVRQ D $ULD 2 VREUH FyPR ,DQ KDEtD VH KDEtD SXHVWR HQ FRQWDFWR D WUDYpVGHXQ0,GLFLHQGRTXHDOJXLHQORKDEtDREOLJDGRDKXLU2FyPROD1XHYD´$µ KDEtDD\XGDGRD,DQDHVFDSDU

³¢9DVDHVFDODUDTXt"³,QWHUUXPSLyXQQLxRGHVHFXQGDULDORTXHKL]RVDOWDUD$ULD +L]RXQJHVWRKDFLDODSDUHGHQTXHHVWDEDDSR\DGD$ULD$ULDQHJyFRQODFDEH]D\VH WUDVODGyIXHUDGHOFDPLQR/XHJRWUHVQLxDVSDVHDURQFHUFDPLUDQGRVRVSHFKRVDPHQWH



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

$ULDFXUYRORVGHGRVGHOSLHIXULRVDGHTXHDOJXLHQHVWXYLHUDLQWHQWDQGRPDQLSXODUOD XQDYH]PiV,DQSUREDEOHPHQWHORKDEtDKHFKR\DKRUDHUDXQMXHJRHODERUDGR(OOD PLUyD-DVRQOLVWDSDUDGHFLUOHWRGR

ͳ͸ͻ

$OJR PiV OD UHWXYR eVWD HUD OD UD]yQ GH TXH ´$µ HVWXYLHUD WUDWDQGR GH VHPEUDUOH OD LGHD GH TXH -DVRQ HVWDED RFXOWDQGR DOJR ´$µ TXHUtD YROYHU D $ULD SDUDQRLFD \ DVXVWDUODOHMRV6L$ULDFRPHQ]DEDDVDOLUFRQ-DVRQHUDEDVWDQWHSUREDEOHTXHHOODOH GLMHUDQRVyORORGHOHQYtRGHQRWDVGH´$µVLQRTXHWDPELpQHOTXH´$µHVWDEDHQHO SODQPDOYDGRGH,DQ/DSROLFtDQRFUHtDTXH´$µHUDUHDOSHUR-DVRQSUREDEOHPHQWH ORKDUtD(UDHODVHVLQDWRGHVXKHUPDQDGHOTXHHVWDEDQKDEODQGR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

D -DVRQ \ D $ULD FRPR VL ORV UHFRQRFLHUDQ GH ODV QRWLFLDV ,QFOXVR OD P~VLFD SDUHFtD PiVWUDQTXLODFRPRVLWRGRHOPXQGRVLQWLHUDTXHXQDFRQYHUVDFLyQLPSRUWDQWHHVWDED VXFHGLHQGR $ULDFHUUyODERFDeVWHQRSDUHFtDHOOXJDUDGHFXDGRSDUDKDEODUGH$OL\ODVFRVDVGH ,DQ7DOYH]OHSRGUtDGHFLUD-DVRQHQHOFRFKHFXDQGRHVWXYLHUDQHQPDUFKDFXDQGR HVWXYLHUDQVRORV (QWRQFHVUHFRUGyODLQYLWDFLyQTXHHVWDEDDFXxDGDHQHOEROVLOORGHODQWHURGHVXEROVR GHSLHOGH\DNHOTXHKDEtDGHMDGRMXQWRDODEULJRGHHOOD\HOGH-DVRQDXQODGRGHOD SDUHG$~QDWDGDVHWDPEDOHyKDFLDVXEROVR\ORVDFy ³¢7LHQHVSODQHVPDxDQD"³SUHJXQWyD-DVRQ ³1RORFUHR¢3RUTXp" ³0L PDPi WLHQH XQR GH VXV FXDGURV HQ HO YHVWtEXOR GH HVWH KRWHO QXHYR ³(OOD OH HQWUHJyODLQYLWDFLyQ³+D\XQDILHVWDGHOXMRPDxDQDSDUDODDSHUWXUD0LPDPiYDD HVWDU DOOt FRQ VX QXHYR QRYLR \ UHDOPHQWH QR PH DJUDGD 7~ VHUtDV XQD GLVWUDFFLyQ HQFDQWDGRUD³,QFOLQyODFDEH]DFRQFRTXHWHUtD -DVRQOHGHYROYLyODVRQULVD ³1RKHHVWDGRHQXQDILHVWDGHOXMRHQXQEXHQWLHPSR³eOVDFyODLQYLWDFLyQPiV FHUFD \ OD OH\y (QWRQFHV VX URVWUR VH HQVRPEUHFLy 6X QXH] GH $GiQ VH EDODQFHDED DUULED\DEDMR ³¢+D\DOJRPDO"³SUHJXQWy$ULD ³¢(VHVWRDOJXQDFODVHGHEURPD"³/DYR]GH-DVRQHVWDEDURQFD $ULDSDUSDGHy ³¢4XTXpTXLHUHVGHFLU" ³3RUTXH QR HV GLYHUWLGR ³GLMR -DVRQ FRQ ORV RMRV PX\ DELHUWRV 1R SDUHFtD H[DFWDPHQWHHQIDGDGRPiVELHQDVXVWDGR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

-DVRQ OD PLUy XQD YH] PiV 6X H[SUHVLyQ FDPELy OOHJDQGR D VHU FDXWHORVD \ WDO YH] LQFOXVR XQ SRFR GLVJXVWDGD FRPR VL $ULD HVWXYLHUD FXELHUWD GH SLHV D FDEH]D FRQ VDQJXLMXHODV$FRQWLQXDFLyQSDUDVXKRUURUGHVHQJDQFKyODVFXHUGDVGHVXDUQpVWLUy GHpOIXHUDVHDFHUFyDVXVFRVDV\VHSXVRHODEULJR

ͳ͹Ͳ

³¢4XpWHSDVD"³H[FODPy$ULD³1RHQWLHQGR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³0HWHQJRTXHLU ³¢4Xp" ³$ULD WUDWy GH DJDUUDU VX EUD]R SHUR VHJXtD WRUSHPHQWH DWDGD \ QR SRGtD HQFRQWUDUODPDQHUDGHVDFDUHODUQpV-DVRQQLVLTXLHUDODPLUDED(PSXMyODVPDQRV HQ ORV EROVLOORV \ VH GLULJLy UiSLGDPHQWH SRU OD UHFHSFLyQ FHUFD GH FKRFDU FRQWUD XQ JUXSRGHDGROHVFHQWHVTXHDFDEDEDQGHHQWUDU 8QRV PRPHQWRV PiV WDUGH $ULD ILQDOPHQWH ORJUy ]DIDUVH GH VX DUQpV /XFKy SDUD SRQHUVHVXDEULJR\VDOLyFRUULHQGR+DEtDXQJUXSRGHFKLFRVVDOLHQGRGHXQD5DQJH 5RYHU 8QD PDGUH HVWDED VRVWHQLHQGR OD PDQR GH XQD SHTXHxD QLxD D\XGiQGROD D HQWUDU$ULDPLUyDODGHUHFKDOXHJRDODL]TXLHUGD ³-DVRQ³JULWyHOOD+DFtDIUtRVXILFLHQWHFRPRSDUDYHUVXDOLHQWR8QDFDPLRQHWDGLR XQJLURDODL]TXLHUGDFRQFKLOOLGRFUX]DQGRDXQODGRGHODFDOOHHQ:DZD-DVRQVH KDEtDLGR $ULDHVWDEDGHEDMRGHODOiPSDUDHQHOIUHQWHGHODVLQVWDODFLRQHV\PLUyILMDPHQWHDOD LQYLWDFLyQGHO5DGOH\'DEDODGLUHFFLyQ\ODKRUD8QKRPEUHOODPDGR*HRUJH)ULW] KDEtD VLGR HO DUTXLWHFWR HQ HO UHGLVHxR GHO KRWHO +DEtD XQD OLVWD GH ORV DUWLVWDV GHVWDFDGRVHOQRPEUHGH(OODHQWUHHOORV¢4XpHQHVWDLQYLWDFLyQKDEtDGHMDGRD-DVRQ WDQ DVXVWDGR" 4Xp TXLVR GHFLU FRQ ¢(V HVWR DOJXQD FODVH GH EURPD" ¢1R TXHUtD FRQRFHUDVXPDPi"¢(VWDEDDYHUJRQ]DGRGHVHUYLVWRFRQHOOD"

ž‰‹ƒ

ͳ͹ͳ

³£-DVRQ ³JULWy GH QXHYR PiV GpELO HQ HVWD RFDVLyQ (Q HVH PRPHQWR R\y XQD FDUFDMDGD $ULD PLUy D VX DOUHGHGRU VRUSUHQGLGD \ DVXVWDGD 1R YLR D QDGLH SHUR OD ULVDFRQWLQXDEDFRPRVLDOJXLHQHVWXYLHUDULpQGRVHGHHOODSHURHVWDEDVROD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR 1DGDH[FHSWR 1DGDH[FHSWRODYHUGDG ODYHUGDG 7UDGXFLGRSRU*LR(OL9LF5RVH &RUUHJLGRSRU2EVHVVLRQ 

(

VHPLVPRYLHUQHVSRUODQRFKH(PLO\GLYDJDEDHQODDFHUDGHODFDVDGH,VDDF PLUDQGRFRQQHUYLRVLVPRPLHQWUDVVHGHVOL]DEDSRUODSXHUWDSULQFLSDO\FRUULy DVXFRFKH

³£+H\ ³H[FODPy \ OXHJR PLUy KDFLD HO FLHOR³ 3DUHFH TXH SRGUtD QHYDU ¢(VWiV VHJXUDGHTXHTXLHUHVLUDGDUXQDYXHOWD" (PLO\DVLQWLyFRQODFDEH]DUiSLGDPHQWH,VDDFOHHQYLyXQPHQVDMHGHWH[WRGHVSXpV GH OD HVFXHOD SUHJXQWDQGR VL YHQGUtD HVWD QRFKH $O SULQFLSLR (PLO\ KDEtD SHQVDGR TXHHUDXQDEURPD3HURFXDQGRpOOHHQYLyXQPHQVDMHQXHYRSUHJXQWiQGROHSRUTXp QROHKDEtDUHVSRQGLGRVHFXHVWLRQyVLOD6UD&ROEHUWQROHKDEtDGLFKRTXHVHKDEtD HQIUHQWDGRD(PLO\DQRFKHHQ$SSOHEHH VRTXHVDEtDTXHKDEtDQGRUPLGRMXQWRV7DO YH],VDDFHVWDEDWRGDYtDEDMRODLPSUHVLyQGHTXHWRGRHVWDEDELHQ 3HURQRKDEtDPDQHUDGH(PLO\SXVLHUDXQSLHHQODFDVDGHORV&ROEHUWLQFOXVRVLVXV SDGUHVLEDQDHVWDUHQODILHVWDGHLQDXJXUDFLyQ5DGOH\WRGDODQRFKH(PLO\QRHUDHO WLSRGHFKLFDTXHGHVREHGHFtDODVyUGHQHVGHORVDGXOWRVD~QFXDQGRSDUHFtDQGXUDV PDODV\SRFRUD]RQDEOHV6yORTXH¢TXpVHVXSRQtDTXHWHQtDTXHKDFHUQXQFDYLVLWDU D ,VDDF HQ VX FDVD RWUD YH]" ¢6DOLU FRQ H[FXVDV ORFDV FDGD YH] TXH pO TXHUtD TXH HOOD SDVDUDSRUDOOt"

³¢3RUTXpLEDDGHFLUTXHOHIDOWDVWHHOUHVSHWRHQVXFDVD"³OHSUHJXQWy³¢6HUiSRU ORGH0D\D"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ž‰‹ƒ

(PLO\VDFXGLyODFDEH]D

ͳ͹ʹ

$\HU SRU OD QRFKH FXDQGR (PLO\ \ &DURO\Q HVWDEDQ DFRPRGiQGRVH HQ OD FDPD &DURO\Q OH SUHJXQWy RWUD YH] SRU TXp KDEtD VDOLGR OORUDQGR GH $SSOHEHH V (PLO\ VH URPSLy \ OH GLMR OR TXH OD 6UD &ROEHUW KDEtD GLFKR &DURO\Q VH VHQWy HQ OD FDPD DELHUWDHQHOKRUURU



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³/R GXGR ³(OOD VH VLQWLy DYHUJRQ]DGD 6L VXV SDGUHV DWUDSDEDQ D (PLO\ H ,VDDF KDFLpQGRORHQVXGRUPLWRULRSUREDEOHPHQWHOHGDUtDQXQDRUGHQGHUHVWULFFLyQ³7DO YH]PHORPHUHFtD³PXUPXUy $PEDVVHTXHGDURQHQVLOHQFLRHVFXFKDQGRORVWDOORVGHPDt]HQHOFDPSRIXHUDGHVX FDVD ³1R Vp OR TXH KDUtD VL OD PDPi GH 7RSKHU PH RGLDUD ³GLMR &DURO\Q HQ OD RVFXULGDG³1RHVWR\VHJXUDGHVLSRGUtDPRVHVWDUMXQWRV ³
ž‰‹ƒ

(PLO\ KL]R SXFKHUR DVRPEUDGD ¢eO WRGDYtD DVXPtDQ TXH LEDQ MXVWRV D OD ILHVWD GH 5DGOH\" ³&ODUR³GLMRHOOD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͳ͹͵

³¢(VWDV HPRFLRQDGD SRU OD ILHVWD HQ 5DGOH\ PDxDQD" ³SUHJXQWy ,VDDF³ +H DOTXLODGRXQHVPRTXLQHVWDYH]0HMRUTXHHOYLHMRWUDMHGHPLSDGUH¢YHUGDG"³eOVH ULyHQWUHGLHQWHV



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³0LSDSiHVWRWDOPHQWHHVWUHVDGRSRUHOVHUYLFLRGHFRPLGD\VLJXHEXUOiQGRVHGHPt DFHUFDGHFyPR\RQR HVWR\D\XGDQGRXQDYH]PiVSRUTXHWHQJRXQDFLWD³6RQULy ,VDDF\OHGDXQFRGD]R (PLO\DSUHWyHOYRODQWHVXVRMRVEURWDGRV1RSRGtDVRSRUWDUORPiV ³¢$VtTXHWXVSDGUHVQRKDQGLFKRQDGDDFHUFDGHQRLUMXQWRV"³OHHVSHWy ,VDDFPLUyFRQFXULRVLGDG ³%XHQRDSHQDVORVKHYLVWRORV~OWLPRVGtDVKDQHVWDGRWDQRFXSDGRV3HUR¢SRUTXp HOORVWHQGUtDQDOJ~QSUREOHPDFRQQRVRWURVSRULUMXQWRV"(OORVHVWDEDQDOOtFXDQGRWH SUHJXQWp 8QFRFKHSDVySRUODRWUDGLUHFFLyQORVIDURVGHQHyQFHJiQGROD1RGLMRQDGD ³¢(VWiVVHJXUDGHTXHHVWiVELHQ"³,VDDFSUHJXQWyGHQXHYR (PLO\WUDJyVDOLYD6LQWLHQGRPDQWHTXLOODGHPDQtHQODERFDODVHQVDFLyQTXHVLHPSUH WHQtDFXDQGRHVWDEDDSXQWRGHWHQHUXQDUHDFFLyQGHOXFKDRKXLGD7HQtDD:DZDD ODGHUHFKD\DQWHVGHTXHVXSLHUDORTXHHVWDEDKDFLHQGRHVWDEDWLUDQGREUXVFDPHQWH HQHOHVWDFLRQDPLHQWR\FRQGXFLHQGRHQUHYHUVDHQXQSXHVWRFHUFDGHXQFRQWHQHGRU GH EDVXUD GH FRORU YHUGH 'HVSXpV GH TXH VH PHWLy HO FRFKH DSR\y OD FDEH]D HQ HO YRODQWH\GHMyHVFDSDUXQVROOR]RUHSULPLGR ³¢(PLO\"³GLMR,VDDF³¢4XpSDVD" /DVOiJULPDVERUUDURQVXYLVLyQ3RUPXFKRTXHQRTXHUtDGHFLUHVWRVDEtDTXHWHQtD TXH KDFHUOR /H GLR OD YXHOWD DO DQLOOR D]XO OH KDEtD GDGR HO RWUR GtD DOUHGHGRU GH VX GHGR ³(VWXPDPi ,VDDFWUD]yXQRFKRHQVXHVSDOGD

³(OODVDEHTXHW~VDEHV'RUPLPRVMXQWRV³(PLO\JLPLy³<HOODGLMRWRGDVHVWDV FRVDV H[WUDxDV GH Pt HQ OD FHQD &RPR VHJXtD LQVLQXDQGR TXH \R HUD UiSLGD 2 SHUGLGD<OXHJRFXDQGRHVWDEDODYDQGRORVSODWRVPiVWDUGHHVDQRFKHPHHQFRQWUp



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

(PLO\ SDVy ODV SDOPDV GH ODV PDQRV D OR ODUJR GH ODV SLHUQDV GH VXV SDQWDORQHV YDTXHURVXQVXVSLUR´6yORVpKRQHVWDµ&DURO\QKDEtDGLFKR3RGtDVHUKRQHVWRFRQ ,VDDF¢YHUGDG"

ͳ͹Ͷ

³¢4XpSDVDFRQPLPDPi"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

FRQXQDIRWRGHWL\GHPtDQWHVGHLUDODEHQHILFHQFLDGH5RVHHZRRG'D\7XPDGUH KDEtD FRUWDGR PL FDEH]D HQ OD IRWR 6yOR PL FDEH]D ³(OOD WUDJy VDOLYD QR OR VXILFLHQWHPHQWHYDOLHQWHVSDUDPLUDUKDFLDDUULED³$~QDVtSHQVpTXHWDOYH]HVWDED H[DJHUDQGR
ž‰‹ƒ

,VDDFHVWDEDHQVLOHQFLRGXUDQWHPXFKRWLHPSRPLUDQGRDVXVPDQRV/DVSXQWDVGH VXVGHGRVFDOORVRVGHDxRVGHWRFDUODJXLWDUUD

ͳ͹ͷ

³7DOYH]HOODQRTXHUtDGHFtUWHORSRUTXHPHTXHUtD(OODTXHUtDTXH\RIXHUDODPDOD 4XpHVH[DFWDPHQWHORTXHHVWiSDVDQGR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³0L QRYLD HO DxR SDVDGR GLMR H[DFWDPHQWH OR PLVPR ³GLMR OHQWDPHQWH³ (OOD GLMR TXHPLIDPLOLDOHGHFtDTXHVHPDQWXYLHUDDOHMDGDGHPt ³£7DOYH]WXPDGUHHVWDEDKDFLHQGRORPLVPRFRQHOOD³H[FODPy(PLO\ ,VDDFQHJyFRQODFDEH]D ³0HGLMRPiVWDUGHTXHORLQYHQWyWRGR/RKL]RSDUDOODPDUODDWHQFLyQ³eOPLUyD VXSDUHMDFRPRVLHVSHUDUDTXHHVWXYLHUDHQHOERUGH /DSLHOGH(PLO\SDVyGHYDSRUFDOLHQWHDIUtRKHODGR ³¢4Xp FRPR YHU HO FDGiYHU GH ,DQ HQ HO ERVTXH HUD XQD PDQHUD GH OODPDU OD DWHQFLyQ"³FKLOOy ,VDDFOHYDQWyODVPDQRVLPSRWHQWH ³1RHVWR\GLFLHQGRHVR(VVyORTXH\RTXHUtDVDOLUFRQDOJXLHQTXHQRHVWXYLHUDHQ HOGUDPD3HQVpTXHWDPELpQORKLFLVWH'H WRGDV PDQHUDVFRQFXDOTXLHUDFRQTXLpQ VDOLHUDWLHQHTXHJXVWDUOHPLIDPLOLDQREDWDOODUFRQWUDHOORV ³£(VRQRHVORTXHHVWR\KDFLHQGR³(PLO\GHFODUy ,VDDFHPSXMyDDEULUODSXHUWDGHOSDVDMHUR\VDOLy(ODLUHKHODGRVHDUUHPROLQyGHQWUR GXURFRQWUDVXSLHOGHVQXGD ³¢4XpHVWiVKDFLHQGR"³(PLO\H[LJLy 6HLQFOLQyVREUHODSXHUWDDELHUWDFRQODERFDSHTXHxD\VROHPQH ³'HERLUDFDVD ³£1R ³([FODPy (PLO\ (OOD VDFXGLy VX SURSLD SXHUWD \ OR VLJXLy SRU HO HVWDFLRQDPLHQWR³£9DPRV ,VDDFHVWDEDFDPLQDQGRKDFLDHOVHQGHURERVFRVRTXHFRQGXFtDGHVGH:DZDDODFDOOH 0LUySRUHQFLPDGHOKRPEUR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³£+H SHQVDGR HQ HOOR ³(PLO\ JULWy 3HUR ,VDDF VLJXLy VX FDPLQR VLQ FRQWHVWDU 6H GHWXYRIUHQWHDODWLHQGDLEDFRMHDQGR3RUHQFLPDGHHOODHOVLJQRGHQHyQGH:DZD ]XPEDEDIHUR]PHQWH+DEtDXQDILODGHQLxRVFRPSUDQGRFDIpVVRGDV\GXOFHV(VSHUy DTXH,VDDFDUHJUHVDUDSHURQRORKL]R3RU~OWLPRVHGLULJLyGHQXHYRDVXFRFKH\

ͳ͹͸

³(VPLPDPiGHODTXHHVWiVKDEODQGR3LHQVDHQORTXHHVWiVGLFLHQGR(VUHDOPHQWH GXUR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

HQWUy (O LQWHULRU GHO 9ROYR ROtD DO GHWHUJHQWH GH ORV &ROEHUW (O DVLHQWR GHO DFRPSDxDQWHHVWDEDWRGDYtDFDOLHQWHGHOFXORGH,VDDF3RUORPHQRVGLH]PLQXWRVVH TXHGy DWXUGLGR HQ HO FRQWHQHGRU GH EDVXUD VLQ VDEHU TXp KDFHU FRQ OR TXH KDEtD VXFHGLGR 8QSHTXHxRWLPEUHVDOtDGHVGHVXPRFKLOD(PLO\VHJLUySDUDOOHJDUDVXWHOpIRQR7DO YH]HUD,VDDFHVFULELHQGRSDUDSHGLUGLVFXOSDV<WDOYH]GHEHUtDSHGLUSHUGyQWDPELpQ eO\VXPDPiHUDQXQLGRV\HOODQRTXHUtDRGLDUDVXIDPLOLD7DOYH]GHEHUtDKDEHU HQFRQWUDGRRWUDIRUPDGHGDUOHODQRWLFLDHQOXJDUGHVRUSUHQGHUORFRQHOOD (PLO\DEULyHOQXHYRWH[WRWUDJyXQSRFRGHDLUHIUtR1RHUDGH,VDDF ¢'HPDVLDGRGLVWUDtGDSDUDGHVFLIUDUPLVFODYHV"$QGDDODYLHMDFDVDGHWXSULPHUDPRU\WDOYH] WHQGUiVHQWLGR ³$ (PLO\IXOPLQyFRQODPLUDGDODSDQWDOOD/RKDEtDWHQLGRGLItFLOFRQHVWDVSLVWDVYDJDV ¢4XpTXHUtD´$µ" 3RFR D SRFR VH UHWLUy GHO HVWDFLRQDPLHQWR :DZD IUHQy SDUD TXH XQ -HHS OOHQR GH FKLFRV VHFXQGDULD VDOLHUD GHODQWH GH HOOD ´,U D OD YLHMD FDVD GH WX SULPHU DPRUµ ´$µ REYLDPHQWHVHUHIHUtDD$OL(OODWRPyODFDUQDGDDQWLJXREDUULRGH$OLHVWDEDDSRFDV FXDGUDVGHGLVWDQFLD¢4XpPiVWHQtDTXHKDFHUDKRUD"1RHUDFRPRTXHSRGtDJROSHDU HQODSXHUWDGH,VDDFSLGLpQGROHTXHYROYLHUD

ž‰‹ƒ

/D DQWLJXD FDVD GH $OL VH DO]DED DO ILQDO GH OD FDOOH HO VDQWXDULR GH $OL XQ EXOWR RVFXUROOHQRGHVRPEUDVHQODDFHUD/DIDPLOLD0D\DYLYtDHQODFDVDDKRUD$OJXQDV GH ODV OXFHV HVWDEDQ HQFHQGLGDV LQFOX\HQGR OD YLHMD KDELWDFLyQ GH $OL HO QXHYR GRUPLWRULRGH0D\D&RPR(PLO\PLUyHQpO0D\DDSDUHFLyFDVLFRPRVLHOODKXELHUD VDELGRTXH(PLO\LEDDHVWDUDOOt(PLO\DEULyODERFDVHDSDUWyGHODYHQWDQDDJDUUyHO YRODQWH\FRUWDQGRHO&XOGHVDF8QDYH]TXHHVWDEDIUHQWHDODHQWUDGDGH6SHQFHU VHGHWXYRWDPELpQSDUDVXSHUDU\VHJXLUDGHODQWH  ϰ

&XOGHVDF&DOOHMyQVLQVDOLGDHQIUDQFpV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͳ͹͹

6H GLR OD YXHOWD HQ XQD FDOOH WUDQTXLOD FRQ DFUHV GH FDPSRV DJUtFRODV ODV OiJULPDV WRGDYtD SLFDEDQ VXV RMRV /D VHxDO GH SDUH HQ OD FDOOH GH $OL VH DFHUFy UiSLGDPHQWH +DEtD XQ FDUWHO TXH GHFtD 2%6(59$725,2 '( /$ ,1)$1&,$ HQ OD HQWUDGD DO EDUULR +DFH DxRV HQ XQD QRFKH FiOLGD \ SHJDMRVD GH YHUDQR $OL \ (PLO\ KDEtDQ GHFRUDGR HO FDUWHO FRQ SHJDWLQDV GH FDUDV VRQULHQWHV TXH KDEtDQ FRPSUDGR HQ XQD WLHQGDGHSURGXFWRVSDUDILHVWDV6HKDEtDQLGRWRGDVDKRUD



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(QWRQFHVYLRXQGHVWHOORGHDOJRDVXGHUHFKD$OJXLHQHQXQDFDPLVHWDEODQFDHVWDED SDUDGRHQODYHQWDQDGHOIUHQWHGHODFDVDGHORV&DYDQDXJK (PLO\ DSDJy ODV OXFHV eO TXH HVWDED HQ OD YHQWDQD HUD DOWR \ DPSOLR XQ SRFR SUREDEOHPHQWH XQ KRPEUH 6X URVWUR HVWDED RFXOWR SRU XQD JUDQ OiPSDUD GH IRUPD FXDGUDGD 'H UHSHQWH -HQQD DSDUHFLy MXQWR D pO (PLO\ FRQWXYR HO DOLHQWR (O SHOR RVFXURGH-HQQDHQFDVFDGDSRUVXVKRPEURV/OHYDEDXQDFDPLVHWDQHJUD\SDQWDORQHV GHOSLMDPDDFXDGURV6XSHUURVHVHQWyMXQWRDHOODUDVFiQGRVHHOFXHOORFRQVXSDWD WUDVHUD -HQQDYROYLy\KDEOyFRQHOKRPEUH+DEOyGXUDQWHPXFKRWLHPSR\OXHJRpOGLMRDOJR D FDPELR -HQQD DVLQWLy FRQ OD FDEH]D HVFXFKDQGR (O KRPEUH DJLWDED ORV EUD]RV FRPR VL -HQQD SXGLHVH YHU VXV JHVWRV 6X URVWUR HVWDED RFXOWR WRGDYtD /D SRVWXUD GH -HQQDVHSXVRDODGHIHQVLYD(OKRPEUHYROYLyDKDEODU\-HQQDEDMyODFDEH]DFRPR DYHUJRQ]DGD6HDSDUWyXQPHFKyQGHFDEHOOROHMRVGHVXVJUDQGHVJDIDVGHVRO*XFFL 'LMR DOJR PiV FRQ OD FDUD FRQWRUVLRQDGD FRQ XQD H[SUHVLyQ TXH (PLO\ QR SRGtD GHWHUPLQDUFRQUD]yQ¢'RORU"¢3UHRFXSDFLyQ"¢0LHGR"/XHJR-HQQDVHDOHMyVXSHUUR VLJXLpQGROD

³2K'LRVPtR³VXVXUUy(OSHORUXELRDOHVWLORVKDJJ\ORVODELRVHQIRUPDGHDUFR HVRVFUXGRVRMRVD]XOHVWRGDYtDFHUUDGRVFRQORVVX\RV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

/DSXHUWDSULQFLSDOGHORV&DYDQDXJKVVHDEULy\(PLO\VHDJDFKyGHQXHYR(OFKLFR GHODVDODGHHVWDUSLVRWHDEDORVHVFDORQHVGHHQWUDGDDODUXWDRVFXUDGHDFFHVRIURQWDO &XDQGR OD OX] GHO VHQVRU GH PRYLPLHQWR SRU HQFLPD GH ODV SXHUWDV GHO JDUDMH VH HQFHQGLy VH TXHGy SDUDOL]DGD VRUSUHQGLGD (PLO\ OR YLR GH IUHQWH FRQ PXFKD OX] /OHYDED ]DSDWLOODV GH FRUUHU \ XQD SHVDGD FKDTXHWD $PEDV PDQRV VH FHUUDEDQ HQ SXxRV HQRMDGR &XDQGR ORV RMRV GH (PLO\ VH SRVDURQ HQ VX FDUD VX HVWyPDJR VH UHGXMR D OD SDUWH LQIHULRU GH VXV ERWDV eO HVWDED PLUDQGR D OD GHUHFKD HQ HOOD (OOD LQPHGLDWDPHQWHVHGLRFXHQWDGHTXLpQHUD

ͳ͹ͺ

(O FKLFR VH IURWy ODV PDQRV SRU HO SHOR REYLDPHQWH QHUYLRVR $ FRQWLQXDFLyQ OD OiPSDUD GH VDOyQ VH DSDJy (PLO\ VH LQFOLQy KDFLD DGHODQWH HQWUHFHUUDQGR ORV RMRV SHURQRSRGtDYHUQDGD0LUyDVXDOUHGHGRUHQHOSDWLRGH-HQQD7RGDYtDTXHGDEDQ ORV EORTXHV GH PDGHUD VXMHWDV DO WURQFR GH XQ iUERO ODV HVFDOHUDV LPSURYLVDGDV SDUD HQWUDU HQ OD YLHMD FDVD GHO iUERO GH 7RE\ (O 6U &DYDQDXJK KDEtD EDMDGR OD FDVD GHO iUEROSRFRGHVSXpVGHORVIXHJRVDUWLILFLDOHVFHJDURQD-HQQD(UDLQFUHtEOHTXHGHVSXpV GHWRGRHVWHWLHPSRORV&DYDQDXJKWRGDYtDFXOSDUDQD7RE\SRUHOFHJDPLHQWRGHVX KHUPDQD(QYHUGDGKDEtDVLGR$OLTXLHQORKDEtDKHFKR<KDEtDVLGR-HQQDODTXH KDEtDTXHULGRHVWDEOHFHUODEURPDSDUDGHVKDFHUVHGH7RE\SDUDVLHPSUH

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(UD-DVRQ'L/DXUHQWLV (PLO\ FDPELy OD PDUFKD \ VDOLy GHSULVD GH OD FDOOH 6yOR FXDQGR \D HVWDED HQ OD HVTXLQD SUHQGLy ODV OXFHV GH QXHYR < HQWRQFHV VH R\y XQ SLWLGR GHVGH VX WHOpIRQR FHOXODU 5HYROYLy VX FDUWHUD OR DJDUUy \ PLUy D OD SDQWDOOD 8Q QXHYR PHQVDMH GH WH[WR ¢3RUTXpFUHHVTXHe/(67ÉWDQHQRMDGR" 

ž‰‹ƒ

ͳ͹ͻ

³$



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR 1DGDFRPRXQXOWLPiWXP 1DGDFRPRXQXOWLPiWXP SDUDHPSH]DUODVHPDQD SDUDHPSH]DUODVHPDQD 7UDGXFLGRSRU
$

OOtHVWDED/DJUDQFDVDYLFWRULDQDHQODHVTXLQDGHOFDOOHMyQVLQVDOLGDODGHO HQUHMDGR URVD D OR ODUJR GHO FHUFDGR \ OD FXELHUWD GH WHFD HQYROYHQWH HQ OD SDUWH SRVWHULRU /D FLQWD DPDULOOD GH ´1R &UX]DUµ GH OD SROLFtD GHEtD HVWDU DOUHGHGRU GHO KXHFR D PHGLR FDYDU HQ HO SDWLR WUDVHUR VyOR TXH QR KDEtD QLQJXQD FLQWD (QUHDOLGDGQRKDEtDXQDJXMHURHQQLQJXQDSDUWH(OSDWLRHUDXQDH[WHQVLyQDPSOLD SODQDGHKLHUEDUHFLpQVHJDGDQRWRFDGDSRUQLQJXQDSDODKLGUiXOLFDRH[FDYDGRUDV +DQQD PLUy KDFLD DEDMR (VWDED HQ VX YLHMD ELFLFOHWD PRQWDxHUD OD FXDO QR KDEtD WRFDGR GHVGH TXH REWXYR VX OLFHQFLD GH PDQHMR < VXV PDQRV OXFtDQ KLQFKDGDV 6XV MHDQVOHDSUHWDEDQHOWUDVHUR6XVPXVORVHUDQDEXOWDGRV8QPHFKyQGHSHORGHFRORU PDUUyQSXS~FDtDVREUHVXVRMRV(OODSDVyVXOHQJXDSRUORVGLHQWHV\VLQWLyORVWRVFRV IUHQLOORV&XDQGROHGLRXQDPLUDGDDOSDWLRWUDVHURGH$OLYLRD6SHQFHUDJDFKiQGRVH GHWUiVGHORVDUEXVWRVGHIUDPEXHVDTXHERUGHDEDQODFDVDGH$OL\ODGHHOOD(OFDEHOOR GH 6SHQFHU HUD PiV FRUWR \ XQ SRFR PiV FODUR GH OD PDQHUD HQ TXH OXFtD HQ VH[WR JUDGR

ž‰‹ƒ

+DQQD VH HVWUHPHFLy 6DEtD SRU TXp HOODV HVWDEDQ DTXt TXHUtDQ UREDU OD EDQGHUD GH $OL(UDHOViEDGRGHVSXpVGHTXH/D&iSVXODGHO7LHPSRKDEtDFRPHQ]DQGR

ͳͺͲ

(VWDED XQD (PLO\ IODFD FRQ FDUD GH QLxD GHWUiV GH ODV SODQWDV GH WRPDWH VXV RMRV PRYLpQGRVH QHUYLRVDPHQWH KDFLD DWUiV \ KDFLD DGHODQWH $ULD FRQ JUDQGHV PHFKDV URVDV HQ VX FDEHOOR \ XVDQGR XQD ORFD W~QLFD DOHPDQD VH DJDFKy DO ODGR GH XQ JUDQ UREOH



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

/DV FXDWUR QLxDV PDUFKDEDQ XQD GHWUiV GH OD RWUD PROHVWDV (QWRQFHV R\HURQ XQ UXLGRVRUGR\VHDEULyODSXHUWDGHDWUiV+DQQD\ORVGHPiVVHDJDFKDURQGHWUiVGHORV iUEROHVPLHQWUDVTXH-DVRQLUUXPSLyHQHOSDWLR /D SXHUWD GHO SDWLR VH FHUUy GH QXHYR $OL VH SDUy HQ HO SRUFKH VXV PDQRV HQ VXV FDGHUDVVXFDEHOORUXELRGHUUDPiQGRVHSRUORVKRPEURVVXVODELRVURVDV\EULOODQWHV ³3XHGHVVDOLU³JULWyHOOD 6XVSLUDQGR$OLPDUFKyDWUDYpVGHOSDWLRVXVWDFRQHVGHSODWDIRUPDVHKXQGtDQHQOD KLHUEDPRMDGD&XDQGRVHDFHUFyD+DQQD\DODVGHPiVPHWLyODPDQRHQHOEROVLOOR \VDFyXQSHGD]RGHWHODD]XOEULOODQWH6HYHtDH[DFWDPHQWHLJXDOTXHHOSHGD]RGHOD EDQGHUDGH/D&iSVXODGHO7LHPSRTXH+DQQDKDEtDHQFRQWUDGRHQ6WHDPKDFHXQRV GtDV ¢3HUR$OLQRKDEtDSHUGLGRVXEDQGHUD"+DQQDPLUyDODVRWUDVFRQIXQGLGDVSHURVXV YLHMDVDPLJDVQRSDUHFtDQQRWDUTXHDOJRDQGDEDPDO %LHQDVtHVFRPRODKHGHFRUDGRH[SOLFy$OLVHxDODQGRORVGLIHUHQWHVGLEXMRVHQOD EDQGHUD$TXtHVWiHOORJRGH&KDQQHO<pVWHHVODPDQJDGHODUDQD\DTXtHVWiOD QLxDGHKRFNH\VREUHKLHUED¢<QRDGRUDQHVWHSDWUyQGH/RXLV9XLWWRQ" /DEDQGHUDOXFHFRPRXQEROVRH[FODPy6SHQFHU +DQQDORVFRQVLGHUDEDFRQLQTXLHWXG$OJRVHVHQWtDFRQIXVR(VWRQRHVWDEDSDVDQGR FRPRVHVXSRQtD<HQWRQFHV$OLFKDVTXHyORVGHGRVODVYLHMDVDPLJDVGH+DQQDVH FRQJHODURQ /D PDQR GH $ULD TXHGy LQPyYLO FDVL WRFDQGR OD EDQGHUD GH $OL 8Q PHFKyQ GH FDEHOOR GH (PLO\ VH VXVSHQGLy  HQ HO DLUH FRJLGR SRU XQD EULVD 6SHQFHU WHQtDXQDH[WUDxDH[SUHVLyQHQVXURVWURDOJRHQWUHXQDVRQULVDIDOVD\XQDPXHFD +DQQD PRYLy ORV GHGRV (UD OD ~QLFD TXH QR VH KDEtD FRQJHODGR 0LUy D $OL VX FRUD]yQODWtDFRQIXHU]D $OLVRQULyGXOFHPHQWH

+DQQD PLUy KDFLD DEDMR D VXV MHDQV GHPDVLDGR DMXVWDGRV \ VH SDVy ODV PDQRV SRU HO SHOR IORMR 5HFXSHUDGD QR HUD OD SDODEUD TXH KXELHVH HOHJLGR 6X UHFXSHUDFLyQ GH SHUGHGRUDDGLYDQRSDVDUtDHQXQRVFXDQWRVDxRV

ž‰‹ƒ

$OLQHJyFRQODFDEH]DQRWDQGRODFRQIXVLyQGH+DQQD ³'HODFFLGHQWHWRQWD¢1RWHDFXHUGDVGHPtHQHOKRVSLWDO"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͳͺͳ

³/XFHVPXFKRPHMRU+DQQD&RPSOHWDPHQWHUHFXSHUDGD¢QR"



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢+RKRVSLWDO" $OLDFHUFyVXFDUDDODGH+DQQD ³(OORV GLFHQ TXH ODV SHUVRQDV GHEHQ KDEODUOH D ODV SDFLHQWHV HQ FRPD (OORV SXHGHQ HVFXFKDU¢7~PHHVFXFKDVWH" +DQQDVHVLQWLyPDUHDGD'HUHSHQWHHVWDEDGHYXHOWDHQVXKDELWDFLyQGHOKRVSLWDOHQ 5RVHZRRG 0HPRULDO GRQGH ORV SDUDPpGLFRV OD KDEtDQ OOHYDGR GHVSXpV GH VX DFFLGHQWHGHFRFKH +DEtDXQDUHGRQGDOX]IOXRUHVFHQWHEULOODQWHVREUHVXFDEH]D(OODSRGtDRtUHOVLOELGR GHODVGLIHUHQWHVPiTXLQDVTXHFRQWURODEDQVXVVLJQRVYLWDOHV\OHGDEDQGHFRPHUSRU YtDLQWUDYHQRVD (Q HO HVSDFLR QHEXORVR HQWUH HO FRPD \ OD FRQFLHQFLD +DQQD FUH\y YHU D DOJXLHQ FHUQLUVHVREUHVXFDPD$OJXLHQTXHVHSDUHFtDVRUSUHQGHQWHPHQWHFRPR$OL ³(VWiELHQ³ODQLxDFDQWXUUHyVXYR]H[DFWDPHQWHFRPRODGH$OL³
ͳͺʹ

+DQQDHQWUHFHUUyVXVRMRV

ž‰‹ƒ

³¢7RGRDFHUFDGHTXp" $OLSXVRXQGHGRHQVXVODELRV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

'HHOORVGRV³(OODVHULyPLVWHULRVDPHQWH ³¢'RVGHHOORVTXp" (OORVORVDEHQWRGR +DQQDSDUSDGHy ³¢$K"¢4XLpQ" $OLSXVRORVRMRVHQEODQFR +DQQD HUHV PX\ OHQWD /D PLUy GLUHFWDPHQWH³ $OJXQDV YHFHV QR PH GR\ FXHQWDGHTXHHVWR\FDQWDQGR¢7HDFXHUGDV" ³¢$TXpWHUHILHUHV"³SUHJXQWy+DQQDGHVHVSHUDGD³¢&DQWDUTXp" ³9DPRV+DQQD³$OLOXFtDDEXUULGD(OODOHYDQWyVXFDEH]DKDFLDHOFLHORSHQVDQGR SRUXQPRPHQWR³¢4XpWDOVLYDPRVDSHVFDU" ³¢,UDSHVFDU"UHSLWLy+DQQD¢(OMXHJRGHFDUWDV" $OLJUXxyIUXVWUDGD ³1R,UDSHVFDU³(OODDJLWyORVEUD]RVWUDWDQGRGHTXH+DQQDORHQWHQGLHUD³£,UD SHVFDU ³¢'HTXpHVWiVKDEODQGR"³VROOR]y+DQQDGHVHVSHUDGD ³£,5 $ 3(6&$5 ³JULWy $OL³ £,U D SHVFDU £,U D SHVFDU ³UHSHWtD XQD \ RWUD YH] FRPRVLIXHVHOD~QLFDFRVDTXHSXGLHUDGHFLU&XDQGRUR]yODPHMLOODGH+DQQDFRQ ORV GHGRV OD SLHO GH +DQQD VH VHQWtD SHJDMRVD \ PRMDGD +DQQD WRFy VX FDUD DODUPDGD&XDQGRDOHMyVXVPDQRVHVWDEDQFXELHUWDVGHVDQJUH

+DQQDVHTXHMyVHIURWyORVRMRV\WRPyVXEDQGHUDGH/D&iSVXODGHO7LHPSRTXH HVWDEDHQVXPHVLWDGHQRFKH)XHXQVXHxRHVW~SLGRILQGHODKLVWRULD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

´1HFHVLWDVHQFRQWUDUOR+DQQD<VLORHQFXHQWUDVWHGLUpWRGRORTXHVHDFHUFDGHHOORµ

ͳͺ͵

+DQQD VH OHYDQWy UiSLGDPHQWH FRQ ORV RMRV DELHUWRV FRPR SODWRV (VWDED HQ VX GRUPLWRULR/DSiOLGDOX]GHODPDxDQDVHILOWUDEDSRUODVYHQWDQDV(UDViEDGRSRUOD PDxDQD SHUR XQD PDxDQD GH ViEDGR HQ HO XQGpFLPR JUDGR QR VH[WR 'RW HVWDED DO ODGRGHVXDOPRKDGDODPLHQGRODFDUDGH+DQQD6HWRFyODPHMLOOD1RKDEtDVDQJUH DOOtVyORODEDEDGHOSHUULWR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(VFXFKyYRFHVHQHOSDVLOORSULPHURVXSDGUHHQWRQRGHEURPDOXHJRODULVDDJXGDGH .DWH +DQQD DJDUUy XQ SXxDGR GH FRELMDV \ ODV DSUHWy (VR HUD WRGR .DWH QR VyOR KDEtDUREDGRDOSDGUHGH+DQQDVLQRWDPELpQD0LNH 'H UHSHQWH ODV DSUHPLDQWHV LPiJHQHV GH VX VXHxR VH GHVYDQHFLHURQ +DQQD VDOLy GLVSDUDGDGHODFDPD\VHSXVRVXVXpWHUGHFDFKHPLUDFHxLGR(QODFODVHGHLQJOpVGH D\HUKDEtDRtGRGHFLUD.DKQ1RHO0DVRQ%\HUVTXHHOHTXLSRGHODFURVVHVHUHXQtD SDUDXQDVHVLyQGHILQGHVHPDQDHQHO)LODGHOILD6SRUWV&OXE7HQtDXQDVHQVDFLyQGH TXHGRQGHTXLHUDTXH1RHOIXHUD0LNHLUtDWDPELpQ1RKDEtDFRQYHQFLGRGHUHWUDFWDU D 0LNH DFHUFD GH WUDHU D .DWH D OD ILHVWD GH 5DGOH\ SRUTXH HOOD QR VDEtD TXp GHFLU $KRUDVtVDEtD +DEtDVyORXQDFKLFDFRQODTXH0LNHSRGtDVHUH[FOXVLYR+DQQD(UDHOPRPHQWR GHVDFDUD.DWHGHOFDPLQRGHEXHQDPDQHUD 3KLOO\ 6SRUWV HVWDED HQ OD VHFFLyQ GHO FHQWUR FRPHUFLDO .LQJ -DPHV TXH FRQWHQtD ORV HVWDEOHFLPLHQWRVQRPX\GHOXMROXJDUHVJXHWWRFRPR2OG1DY\&KDUORWWH5XVVH\³ GH PLHGR³-&3HQQH\ +DQQD QR KDEtD SXHVWR ORV SLHV DTXt GXUDQWH DxRV WHODV GH PH]FODDFUtOLFDIUDQHODVGHGLVHxRVHQVHULH\FROHFFLRQHVGHGLVHxRSRUTXLHQHVKDQ VLGRFHOHEXWDQWHVOHGLHURQXUWLFDULD (OOD DSDUFy HO 3ULXV \ JROSHy FRQ IXHU]D HO ERWyQ SDUD HQWUDU WUHV YHFHV YLHQGR XQ +RQGD R[LGDGR D VX ODGR 0LHQWUDV FDPLQDED SRU HO HVWDFLRQDPLHQWR VX L3KRQH SDUSDGHy OR TXH LQGLFDED TXH WHQtD XQ WH[WR (OOD DOFDQ]y VX WHOpIRQR FRQ VX HVWyPDJRUHYXHOWR6HJXUDPHQWH´$µQRSRGUtDKDEHUODHQFRQWUDGR¢YHUGDG" (OWH[WRHUDGH(PLO\´(VWDVDOUHGHGRU"5HFLEtRWUDQRWD7HQHPRVTXHKDEODUµ

ž‰‹ƒ

¢4Xp HVWDED WUDWDQGR GH GHFLUOH VX FHUHEUR" ¢$OL TXHUtD VDEHU GyQGH KDEtD LGR VX EDQGHUD" ¢3RGUtD VHU FLHUWR TXH KDEtD DOJR HQ OD EDQGHUD GH $OL TXH GDED D HQWHQGHU TXpKDEtDSDVDGRFRQHOOD"<OXHJR$OLOHGLMRYDULDVYHFHV´1RPHGR\FXHQWDTXH HVWR\ FDQWDQGRµ HVSHUDQGR TXH +DQQD VXSLHUD D TXp VH UHIHUtD ¢(UD DOJR TXH $OL GHFtD R HUD DOJR TXH DOJXLHQ OH GHFtD D $OL" +DQQD QR SRGtD UHFRUGDU HQ DPERV VHQWLGRV

ͳͺͶ

+DQQDVHGHVOL]yHOWHOpIRQRHQHOEROVLOORPRUGLpQGRVHHOODELRGXUDPHQWH6DEtDTXH GHEtDOODPDUD(PLO\GHYXHOWD<GHFLUOHDFHUFDGHFXDQH[WUDxDPHQWH:LOGHQVHKDEtD FRPSRUWDGRFXDQGRUHJUHVDURQFRUULHQGRDFDVDGH+DQQDD\HUSHURHVWDEDRFXSDGD HQ HVWH PRPHQWR 6LQ HPEDUJR HO VXHxR TXH KDEtD WHQLGR HVWD PDxDQD OOHJDED GH QXHYRDHOOD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(OODKDEtDLQFXUVLRQDGRLQFOXVRDWUDYpVGHORVSHUVRQDMHVGHPHQRULPSRUWDQFLDHQOD YLGD GH $OL FRPR HO HVWXGLDQWH GH LQWHUFDPELR GH +RODQGD TXH KDEtD GDGR D $OL XQ SDUGH]DSDWRVGHPDGHUDFRPRPXHVWUDGHVXDIHFWRHOFKLFRFRQHOSHORJUDVRVRTXH RSHUDEDORV-HWVN\HQORV3RFRQRVTXHVLHPSUHOHGHFtDD$OtTXHKDEtD´FDOHQWDGRHO DVLHQWRVyORSDUDHOODµRHO6U6DOWHOÓQLFRELEOLRWHFDULRPDVFXOLQRHQODHVFXHODTXH VLHPSUH OH GHFtD D $OL TXH WUDHUtD VX SULPHUD HGLFLyQ GH +DUU\ 3RWWHU HVSHFLDOPHQWH SDUDHOOD VLDOJXQDYH] TXHUtDOHHUORV ,XJ+DQQDQRSRGtD UHFRUGDUDQDGLHGLFLHQGR QDGDHVSHOX]QDQWHDFHUFDFDQWDU/DIUDVHHUDDOJRIDPLOLDUSHURHVSUREDEOHTXHVyOR IXHUD XQD HVW~SLGD OtQHD GH XQD GH ODV PHORGtDV GH HVSHFWiFXORV GH .DWH R DOJ~Q HVORJDQWRQWRDOTXHVHDSHJDEDQODVPDHVWUDVGHOFRURHQ5RVHZRRG /DP~VLFDWHFQRHQHOLQWHULRUGHOJLPQDVLRDVDOWRODVRUHMDV+DQQDDQWHVGHTXHHOOD DEULHUDODSXHUWDSULQFLSDO8QDFKLFDDOHJUHHQXQVXMHWDGRUURVD\SDQWDORQHVGH\RJD QHJURVVDOWyGHGHWUiVGHODUHFHSFLyQGHOJLPQDVLR ³£%LHQYHQLGD D 'HSRUWHV )LODGHOILD ³UHVRQy HOOD³ ¢3XHGH DFFHGHU SRU IDYRU" ³ (OOD OHYDQWy XQ DUWHIDFWR TXH SDUHFtD XQ HVFiQHU SDUD FRPSUREDU OD FDOLGDG GH PLHPEURVGH+DQQD ³


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

%DMRHOKLORPXVLFDOORVRtGRVGH+DQQDODWtDQ$WUDYpVGHODVDODXQDFKLFDGHOJDGD FRQEUD]RVYHQRVRVJLUDEDIUHQpWLFDPHQWHORVEUD]RVHQXQDPiTXLQDHOtSWLFD8QWLSR FRQHOSHORPRMDGR\UL]DGRVHVHFDEDHOVXGRUHQXQDFLQWDGHFRUUHU+DQQDHVFXFKy HO VRQLGR PHWiOLFR GH ODV EDUUDV HQ OD GLVWDQFLD (IHFWLYDPHQWH WRGR HO HTXLSR GH ODFURVVHGH5RVHZRRG'D\VHHQFRQWUDEDHQODHVTXLQDGHODVSHVDVOLEUHV1RHOHVWDED KDFLHQGR IOH[LRQHV GH EUD]RV GHODQWH GH XQ HVSHMR DGPLUiQGRVH D Vt PLVPR -DPHV )UHHGHVWDEDKDFLHQGRPXHFDVPLHQWUDVVHEDODQFHDQHQXQDERODGH%268<0LNH

ͳͺͷ

³£1R JUDFLDV ³&DQWy +DQQD SDVDQGR GLUHFWR PiV DOOi GH HOOD &RPR VL IXHUD D SDJDU DOJXQD YH] SRU XVDU HVH EDVXUHUR /D FKLFD HQ UHFHSFLyQ VROWy XQ FKLOOLGR SHTXHxR LQGLJQDGD SHUR +DQQD QR VH YROYLy 6XV ]DSDWRV GH WDFyQ DOWR KDFtDQ FOLF PLHQWUDVSDVDEDSRUOD WLHQGDTXHYHQGtDSDQWDORQHVFRUWRVGHVSDQGH[ORVIRUURVGH QHRSUHQR SDUD L3RGV \ VXMHWDGRUHV GH GHSRUWHV \ SDVy HO JUDQ HVWDQWH GRQGH VH JXDUGDEDQODVWRDOODV+DQQDROIDWHyFRQDOWLYH]¢(VWDPLHUGDQLVLTXLHUDWHQtDXQEDU &KLF"3UREDEOHPHQWHODJHQWHRULQDEDHQODVGXFKDVGHORVYHVWXDULRVWDPELpQ

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

0RQWJRPHU\ HVWDED DFRVWDGR HQ OD EDQFD HQYROYLHQGR VXV PDQRV DOUHGHGRU GH OD EDUUDSUHSDUiQGRVHSDUDOHYDQWDUOD (OSUHPLRPD\RU +DQQD HVSHUy KDVWD TXH 0LNH VH KXELHUD OOHYDGR OD EDUUD DO SHFKR \ OXHJR FDPLQy GHUHFKRKDVWDDUULED\HVSDQWyD0DVRQ%\HUVTXHD\XGDEDD0LNH ³
³3URPpWHPHOR HQ SULPHU OXJDU ³LQVWy +DQQD 6H LQFOLQy XQ SRFR PiV DOOi RIUHFLpQGROHPiVTXHXQYLVWD]RGHVXYHVWLGR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ž‰‹ƒ

/RVRMRVGH0LNHVHGHVOL]DURQGLUHFWRDKt/RVWHQGRQHVGHVXFXHOORVDOLHURQ

ͳͺ͸

³3RUIDYRU³URJy0LNH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³.DWHPHSLGLyTXHIXHUDDODILHVWDGH5DGOH\DQWHVGHTXH\RVXSLHUDTXHTXHUtDVVHU H[FOXVLYD\ORTXHVHD1RSXHGRDQXODUODLQYLWDFLyQ ³6tSXHGHV³JUXxy+DQQD³(VIiFLO ³7HQJRXQDLGHD³H[FODPy0LNH³'pMDPHSRQHUHVWR\\RYR\DGHFLUWH +DQQD VH KL]R D XQ ODGR \ pO GHYROYLy OD EDUUD eO GHMy HVFDSDU XQ JUDQ VXVSLUR VH VHQWy\VHHVWLUy+DQQDVHVRUSUHQGLyDOYHUFXiQGHILQLGRVHVWDEDQVXVEUD]RV+DEtD HVWDGR HQ OR FLHUWR HO RWUR GtD FXDQGR KDEtD DGLYLQDGR TXH 0LNH VH YHUtD PHMRU GHVSXpVGHODGXFKDTXHHO2ILFLDO:LOGHQ 'HMyFDHUXQDWRDOODHQXQEDQFRYDFtRMXQWRDpO\VHVHQWy ³(VWiELHQ6XpOWDOR³0LNHWRPyXQDWRDOODTXHHVWDEDDVHQWDGDHQHOVXHORMXQWRDO EDQFR \ VH VHFy OD FDUD³
ͳͺ͹

+DQQD SDVy ODV PDQRV SRU OD SDUWH SRVWHULRU GH VX FXHOOR WUDWDQGR GH QR SUHVWDUOH DWHQFLyQDORVRWURVMXJDGRUHVTXHHVWDEDSLURSHiQGRODIHDPHQWHGHVGHORVFLUFXLWRVGH SHVR 6L 0LNH TXHUtD TXH +DQQD OR OOHYDUD D VX EDLOH GH JUDGXDFLyQ VLJQLILFDED TXH +DQQDOHJXVWDEDPiV¢YHUGDG"<HVRVLJQLILFDEDTXHKDEtDJDQDGR6HOHIRUPyXQD VRQULVDHQORVODELRV ´7RPDSHUUDµ(OODQRSRGtDHVSHUDUDYHUODFDUDGH.DWHFXDQGRHOODOHGLMHUD

ž‰‹ƒ

³(VWiELHQ³GLMR³7HOOHYDUpDPLILHVWDGHJUDGXDFLyQ



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³%LHQ ³GLMR 0LNH 0LUy D VX FDPLVHWD PRMDGD³
ž‰‹ƒ

ͳͺͺ

³


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR 0HPRULDVGHODQXDULR 0HPRULDVGHODQXDULR SDUDGXUDUWRGDXQDYLGD SDUDGXUDUWRGDXQDYLGD 7UDGXFLGRSRU(PLLB*UHJRUL &RUUHJLGRSRU/RR  

(

VDWDUGHXQFDPLyQGHOD836VHGHWXYRHQODDFHUDGHODQXHYDFDVDGHOSDGUH GH$ULD(OUHSDUWLGRUXVDEDODUJDURSDLQWHULRUD]XOEDMRVXFDPLVDPDUUyQGH PDQJDFRUWD836\VKRUWVOHHQWUHJyXQDFDMDD$ULD$ULDOHGLRODVJUDFLDV\ PLUyDODHWLTXHWDGHFRUUHR%RWLQHV2UJiQLFRVGH%HEp/DGLUHFFLyQGHOUHPLWHQWHHUD GH6DQWD)H1XHYR0p[LFR¢4XLpQVDEtDTXHWDOHVSHTXHxRVERWLQHVGHEHEpSRGUtDQ GHMDUWDOKXHOODGHFDUERQRGHWDPDxRDGXOWR"

6X WHOpIRQR VRQy \ PHWLy OD PDQR HQ HO EROVLOOR GH VX DEULJR YROXPLQRVR WHMLGR GH VXpWHUSDUDDJDUUDUOR+DEtDUHFLELGRXQWH[WRGH(OOD´¢9LHQHVDODILHVWDGH5DGOH\HVWD QRFKH"µ 2WUR PHQVDMH OH VLJXLy UiSLGDPHQWH ´(VSHUR TXH SXHGDV £7H KH HFKDGR GH PHQRVµ<OXHJRRWUR´£(VWRVLJQLILFDUtDPXFKRµ

(O FRUD]yQ GH $ULD VDOWy $EULy OD QRWD UiSLGDPHQWH ´(VFXFKD +H HVWDGR SHQVDQGR -DVRQHVFULELy5HDFFLRQpH[DJHUDGDPHQWHHQ5RFNV 5RSHVD\HU4XLHURH[SOLFDUWH¢4XLHUHV YHUPHHQPLFDVDHQXQDKRUD"µ



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6X WHOpIRQR VRQy GH QXHYR $ULD KL]R FOLF HQ HO QXHYR PHQVDMH HVSHUDQGR TXH IXHUD RWUD PLVLYD GH (OOD (Q FDPELR HUD XQ HPDLO (O QRPEUH GHO UHPLWHQWH HUD -DVRQ 'L/DXUHQWLV

ͳͺͻ

$ULDVXVSLUy(OODKDEtDHVWDGRHVFULELpQGROHD$ULDDVtWRGDODPDxDQDSLGLpQGROHSRU XQDUHVSXHVWD6L$ULDGHFtDTXHQRTXHUtDLUDODILHVWDGH5DGOH\(OODLQHYLWDEOHPHQWH SUHJXQWDUtDSRUTXp¢\HQWRQFHVTXpKDUtD$ULD"¢'HFLUOHTXHQRTXHUtDHVWDUDPHQRV GHVHLVSLHVGHVXQRYLRHVFDORIULDQWH"¢,QYHQWDUXQDPHQWLUDODFXDOTXL]iKDJDTXHVX PDGUH SHQVDUD TXH QR TXHUtD DSR\DU VX FDUUHUD DUWtVWLFD"
6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

'HEDMRGHHOORHVWDEDVXGLUHFFLyQHQ


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

/DQXHYDFDVD'L/DXUHQWLVHVHVWDEDHQXQDWUDQTXLOD\KHUPRVDFDOOHPX\OHMRVGHOD HVWDFLyQ GH WUHQHV URxRVD GH
ͳͻͲ



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

VREUHODDOIRPEUDGHELHQYHQLGDHVSHUDQGRDTXHEDMDUDHOODVLHPSUHKDFtDVRQDUODV FDPSDQDVHQFRQMXQWRWUDWDQGRGHFRPSRQHUXQDFDQFLyQ (O FDPLQR GH HQWUDGD HVWDED YDFtR \ OD FDVD SULQFLSDO SDUHFtD RVFXUD ODV FRUWLQDV MDODGDV\FHUUDGDV\ODVOXFHVDSDJDGDV/DHVWUXFWXUDTXHDOEHUJDEDHOJDUDMHSDUDWUHV FRFKHV \ XQ DSDUWDPHQWR GH -DVRQ HQ HO VHJXQGR SLVR HVWDED VHSDUDGR SRU XQ EDMR PXUR GH SLHGUD \ GHO RWUR ODGR GH HVR KDEtD XQD YDOOD DOWD GH KLHUUR IRUMDGR 6RUSUHQGHQWHPHQWH QR KDEtD QLQJ~Q VDQWXDULR GH $OL HQ HO SDWLR R HQ OD FDOOH SHUR HQWRQFHV WDO YH] ORV 'L/DXUHQWLVHV KDEtDQ SHGLGR D ORV PHGLRV GH FRPXQLFDFLyQ JXDUGDUVLOHQFLRDFHUFDGHTXHHOORVYLYtDQDTXt<WDOYH]LQFUHtEOHPHQWHORVPHGLRV GHFRPXQLFDFLyQKDEtDQUHVSHWDGRVXVGHVHRV $ULDFRPHQ]ySRUHOFDPLQRKDFLDHOJDUDMH XQDHPRFLyQTXHPDED HQVXHVWyPDJR (QWRQFHVR\yXQWLQWLQHR\XQODGULGRUXLGRVR8Q5RWWZHLOHUVDOLyFRUULHQGRGHVGHHO HVWUHFKR HVSDFLR HQWUH HO JDUDMH \ OD YDOOD GH KLHUUR IRUMDGR DUUDVWUDQGR XQD FDGHQD ODUJDGHPHWDOGHDPDUUHDOUHGHGRUGHVXFXHOOR $ULD GLR XQ VDOWR KDFLD DWUiV (O SHUUR URFLDED HVSXPD GH VX ERFD 6X FXHUSR HUD JUXHVR\UREXVWRWRGRP~VFXOR ³6KK³HOODWUDWyGHGHFLUSHURVDOLyDSHQDVDOJRPiVTXHXQVXVXUUR(OSHUURJUXxy EUXWDOPHQWH VLQ GXGD ROLHQGR VX PLHGR SDUDOL]DQWH 0LUy GHVHVSHUDGDPHQWH HQ HO DSDUWDPHQWRHQHOVHJXQGRSLVRGHOJDUDMH-DVRQEDMDUtD\OHD\XGDUtD¢YHUGDG"3HUR QRKDEtDQLQJXQDOX]DOOtWDPSRFR

³£-DVRQ³JULWy1RKXERUHVSXHVWD)UHQpWLFD$ULDPRYLyHOSRPRGHODSXHUWDGH -DVRQ(VWDEDFHUUDGDFRQOODYH



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

$ULD WUDJy VDOLYD \ VH ODQ]y KDFLD DUULED VX FRUD]yQ ODWLHQGR FRPR ORFR (O SHUUR VH DSUHVXUyGHWUiVGHHOODVXVSDWDVVHUHVEDODURQHQODHVFDOHUDGHPDGHUDK~PHGD(OOD JROSHyODSXHUWD

ͳͻͳ

$ULD H[WHQGLy VXV PDQRV DO IUHQWH GH HOOD WUDWDQGR GH SDUHFHU WUDQTXLOD SHUR VyOR SDUHFLyLUULWDUPiVDOSHUURKDFLpQGRORUHVRSODU\SODQWDUVXVSLHV\GHVFXEULHQGRVXV GLHQWHVODUJRV\DILODGRV$ULDGHMyHVFDSDURWURJHPLGRLQGHIHQVR\GLRXQSDVRKDFLD DWUiVGHQXHYR6XFDGHUDJROSHyDOJRGXUR\FKLOOyVRUSUHQGLGD+DEtDJROSHDGRHQ ODEDUDQGLOODGHODHVFDOHUDGHODSDUWDPHQWR&RQKRUURUVHGLRFXHQWDGHTXHHOSHUUR ODKDEtDDFRUUDODGRODSDUHGGHSLHGUDGHWUiVGHHOODTXHVHSDUDEDHOJDUDMHGHODFDVD SULQFLSDOHUDGHPDVLDGRDOWDSDUDHVFDODUODUiSLGDPHQWH\HOSHUURHVWDEDEORTXHDQGR HO HVWUHFKR VHQGHUR TXH FRQGXFtD DO SDWLR WUDVHUR DVt FRPR HO UHVWR GHO FDPLQR GH HQWUDGD/D~QLFDYtDSRVLEOHSDUDOD VHJXULGDGHUDVXELUORVHVFDORQHVGHPDGHUDGHO JDUDMHKDVWDHODSDUWDPHQWRGH-DVRQ

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢4Xp GHPRQLRV" ³H[FODPy DSODVWiQGRVH D Vt PLVPD FRQWUD OD SXHUWD (O SHUUR HVWDED VyOR D XQD HVFDOHUD GH GLVWDQFLD $ULD HVSLy XQD YHQWDQD DELHUWD DO ODGR GH OD SXHUWD 'HVSDFLR PRYLy ORV GHGRV KDFLD HO DOIpL]DU GH OD YHQWDQD HPSXMiQGROD D~Q PiV DELHUWD 7RPDQGR XQD UHVSLUDFLyQ SURIXQGD VH GLR OD YXHOWD \ SDVy GHQWUR 6X JROSH WUDVHUR VRQy DOJR VXDYH 8Q FROFKyQ &HUUy OD YHQWDQD GH XQ JROSH (O SHUUR ODGUy\DUDxyODSXHUWDGH-DVRQ(OSHFKRGH$ULDVHODQ]yKDFLDGHQWUR\KDFLDIXHUD PLHQWUDVHVFXFKDEDODWLUVXFRUD]yQ/XHJRPLUyDVXDOUHGHGRU/DKDELWDFLyQHVWDED RVFXUD \ YDFtD +DEtD XQ SHUFKHUR FHUFD GH OD SXHUWD SHUR ORV JDQFKRV HVWDEDQ GHVQXGRV $ULDPHWLyVXPDQRHQHOEROVLOORSDUDWHOpIRQR\PDUFyHOQ~PHURGH-DVRQ6HGLULJLy LQPHGLDWDPHQWHDOFRUUHRGHYR]$ULDFROJySXVRHOWHOpIRQRHQODFDPD\VHOHYDQWy (OSHUURVHJXtDODGUDQGRQRVHDWUHYtDDWUDWDUGHVDOLU (O DSDUWDPHQWR HUD EiVLFDPHQWH XQ JUDQ HVWXGLR GLYLGLGR HQ XQ GRUPLWRULR XQ FRPHGRU \ XQ ULQFyQ SHTXHxR GH WHOHYLVLyQ +DEtD XQEDxR HQ HO RWUR H[WUHPR GH OD KDELWDFLyQ \ XQ PRQWyQ GH HVWDQWHUtDV D OD GHUHFKD &DPLQy SRU OD KDELWDFLyQ LQVSHFFLRQDQGRORVOLEURVGH+HPLQJZD\%XUURXJKV\%XNRZVNLHQODSODWDIRUPDGH -DVRQ7HQtDXQDSHTXHxDLPSUHVLyQGHXQGLEXMRGH(JRQ6FKLHOHXQRGHORVDUWLVWDV IDYRULWRV GH $ULD 6H DJDFKy \ SDVy HO GHGR D OR ODUJR GH ODV HVSLQDV GH VXV '9'V QRWDQGRODVPXFKDVSHOtFXODVH[WUDQMHUDV+DEtDIRWRVHQVXSHTXHxDLVODGHODFRFLQD PXFKDV GH ORV FXDOHV SDUHFtDQ WRPDGDV HQ


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

/RDEULyOHQWDPHQWH(ODQXDULRROtDDSROYR\DWLQWDYLHMD2MHyDWUDYpVGHODVIRWRV VXSHULRUHV FD]DQGR OD IRWR GH -DVRQ /OHYDED XQ WUDMH QHJUR \ PLUDED D XQ SXQWR OHMDQRGHWUiVGHOIRWyJUDIR6XERFDHUDPX\GLUHFWD\SHQVDWLYD\VXFDEHOORUXELROH UR]DED ORV KRPEURV 3DVy VXV GHGRV D OR ODUJR GH OD QDUL] \ GH ORV RMRV GH -DVRQ 6H

ͳͻʹ

(Q FXDQWR UHJUHVy D OD HVWDQWHUtD VH GLR FXHQWD GH XQ PRQWyQ GH DQXDULRV GH 5RVHZRRG 'D\ DOLQHDGRV SRU DxR 8QR VREUHVDOtD OLJHUDPHQWH XQ SRFR PiV TXH ORV GHPiV FRPR VL VyOR KXELHUD VLGR KRMHDGR $ULD OR VDFy \ PLUy D OD FXELHUWD (UD GH KDFH FXDWUR DxRV HO DxR HQ TXH -DVRQ VH KDEtD JUDGXDGR (O DxR TXH $OL KDEtD GHVDSDUHFLGR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

YHtD WDQ MRYHQ H LQRFHQWH (UD GLItFLO FUHHU OR PXFKR TXH KDEtD SDVDGR SRU HQWUH HQWRQFHV\DKRUD 8QDV SRFDV SiJLQDV PiV DGHODQWH VH HQFRQWUy FRQ 0HOLVVD +DVWLQJV OD KHUPDQD GH 6SHQFHUTXHOXFtDFDVLLJXDOFRPROXFtDKR\$OJXLHQKDEtDHVFULWRDOJRSRUHQFLPDGH VX IRWR HQ WLQWD URMD SHUR TXH OXHJR OR WDFKy WDQ IXHUWH TXH $ULD QR SRGtD GLVWLQJXLU QLQJXQDGHODVSDODEUDV/DIRWRGH,DQ7KRPDVHUDFDVLOD~OWLPD6XFDEHOORRQGXODGR HUD PiV ODUJR \D WDPELpQ \ VX URVWUR HUD XQ SRFR PiV GHOJDGR eO VRQUHtD FRQ VX ILUPD DUUXJDGD GH ,DQ 7KRPDV TXH pO XWLOL]DED SDUD DVHJXUDUOHV D WRGRV ORV GH 5RVHZRRG TXH pO HUD HO PiV LQWHOLJHQWH HO PiV EXHQR HO TXH VLHPSUH WHQGUtD EXHQD VXHUWH &XDQGR OD IRWR IXH WRPDGD ,DQ KDEtD HVWDGR MXJDQGR XQ UDWR FRQ $OL $ULD FHUUyORVRMRVHVWUHPHFLpQGRVH/DLGHDGHHOORVMXQWRVHUDWDQPDOD (QODSDUWHLQIHULRUGHODSiJLQDKDEtDRWUDIRWRGH,DQXQVLQFHURGHpOVHQWDGRHQXQ VDOyQ GH FODVH FRQ OD ERFD OLJHUDPHQWH DELHUWD \ VX PDQR OHYDQWDGD $OJXLHQ KDEtD GLEXMDGRXQSHQHDOODGRGHVXERFD\ORVFXHUQRVGHOGLDEORHQODSDUWHVXSHULRUGHVX FDEH]DUL]DGD+DEtDXQPHQVDMHHVFULWRGHEDMRGHODIRWRHQWLQWDFRORUQHJUR/DOHWUD HUDSHTXHxD\GHVLJXDO ´2\H DPLJR $SODXVRV D OD FHUYH]D ERQJV HQ HO .DKQ HO PRPHQWR HQ TXH FDVL GHVWUR]DPRV HO FRFKHGH7UHYRUDFXDWURUXHGDVHOILQGHVHPDQDGHWUiVGHODSURSLHGDG\TXpPRPHQWRHQHO VyWDQRGH
(ODQXDULRVHUHVEDOyGHORVGHGRVGH$ULDKDFLHQGRXQUXLGRVRUGRDOJROSHDUHOVXHOR -DVRQ HVWDED GH SLH HQ OD SXHUWD /OHYDED XQD EXIDQGD GH FRORU URMR YLYR \ XQD FKDTXHWDGHFXHURQHJUD(OSHUURQRHVWDEDDODYLVWD$ULDKDEtDHVWDGRWDQFDXWLYDGD SRUHODQXDULRTXHQRORKDEtDRtGRDFHUFDUVHSRUODVHVFDOHUDV

ž‰‹ƒ

³2K³VXVSLUyHOOD -DVRQVHDFHUFyD$ULDEUXVFDPHQWHVXVIRVDVQDVDOHVOODPHDQGR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͳͻ͵

³¢4XpGHPRQLRV"



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢&yPRKDVHQWUDGR" ³7W~QRHVWDEDVDTXt³FKLOOy$ULDHPSH]DQGRDWHPEODU³7XSHUURVHHVFDSy\ PHDFRUUDOy1LVLTXLHUDSRGtDYROYHUDPLFRFKH/D~QLFDPDQHUDGHHVFDSDUGHpOIXH DFRUUHUSRUODVHVFDOHUDV\SDVDUSRUODYHQWDQD /RVODELRVGH-DVRQVHVHSDUDURQ ³¢4XpSHUUR" $ULDVHxDOySRUODYHQWDQD ³(OHO5RWWZHLOHU ³1RWHQHPRVXQ5RWWZHLOHU $ULDVHOHTXHGyPLUDQGR(OSHUURKDEtDHVWDGRDUUDVWUDQGRXQDSHVDGDFDGHQD(OOD KDEtD DVXPLGR TXH pO VH KDEtD OLEHUDGR GH VX DPDUUH IXHUD GHO SRVWH SHUR WDO YH] DOJXLHQKDEtDFRUWDGRODFDGHQDGHVXOXJDU$KRUDTXHORSHQVDEDHOSHUURQRKDEtD ODGUDGR XQD YH] TXH HOOD KDEtD HQWUDGR 8Q SHQVDPLHQWR KRUULEOH FRPHQ]y D WRPDU IRUPDHQVXPHQWH ³¢7~ QR PH HQYLDVWH HVH FRUUHR HOHFWUyQLFR HVWD PDxDQD" ³GLMR FRQ YR] WHPEORURVD³¢1RPHSHGLVWHTXHWHHQFRQWUDUDDTXt" /RVRMRVGH-DVRQVHHVWUHFKDURQ ³1XQFDWHKHGLFKRGHHQFRQWUDUQRVDTXt /DVWDEODVGHOVXHORFUXMtDQPLHQWUDV$ULDGDEDXQSDVRDWUiV¢&yPRSRGtDKDEHUVLGR WDQ HVW~SLGD" 3RU VXSXHVWR TXH HO FRUUHR HOHFWUyQLFR TXH KDEtD UHFLELGR HVWD PDxDQD QRKDEtDVLGRGH-DVRQ+DEtDHVWDGRWDQDOLYLDGRGHVDEHUGHpOHOODQRUHFRUGDEDTXH pO QR WHQtD VX GLUHFFLyQ GH FRUUHR HOHFWUyQLFR KDVWD HVWH PLVPR PRPHQWR /D QRWD KDEtDVLGRGHRWUDSHUVRQD$OJXLHQTXHKDEtDFRQRFLGRFXDQGR-DVRQQRHVWDEDHQ FDVD $OJXLHQ TXH WDO YH] LQFOXVR RUTXHVWDQGR HQYLDUOH XQ SHUUR H[WUDxR D VX SHUVHFXFLyQHQVXDSDUWDPHQWR(OODPLUyD-DVRQVXFRUD]yQFRPHQ]DQGRDSDOSLWDU ³¢+DVYHQLGRVRODDTXtRIXLVWHDODFDVDSULQFLSDOWDPELpQ"³H[LJLy-DVRQ

ͳͻͶ

³6VyORDTXt

ž‰‹ƒ

-DVRQVHFHUQtDVREUHHOODFRQVXPDQGtEXODDSUHWDGD ³¢0HHVWiVGLFLHQGRODYHUGDG"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

$ULDVHPRUGLyHOODELR¢3RUTXpHVLPSRUWDQWH" ³3RUVXSXHVWR ³6DO³ODGUy-DVRQeOVHKL]RDXQODGR\VHxDOyODSXHUWD $ULDQRVHPRYLy ³-DVRQ ³GHFODUy³ 6LHQWR KDEHU YHQLGR DTXt )XH XQ PDOHQWHQGLGR ¢3RGHPRV FRQYHUVDUSRUIDYRU" ³6DO $IXHUD ³-DVRQ D]RWy VX EUD]R D XQ ODGR WLUDQGR XQ PRQWyQ GH OLEURV GH OD HVWDQWHUtD 8QD SODFD GH YLGULR FD\y WDPELpQ URPSLpQGRVH HQ IUDJPHQWRV DILODGRV HQRMDGRV³£6DO\D³-DVRQYROYLyDUXJLU$ULDVHDJDFKy\GHMyHVFDSDUXQDWUDSDGR \DWHPRUL]DQWHJHPLGR/DFDUDGH-DVRQVHKDEtDWUDQVIRUPDGR6XVRMRVHVWDEDQPX\ DELHUWRVODVFRPLVXUDVGHVXVODELRVUHWLUDGDVHLQFOXVRVXYR]VRQDEDGLIHUHQWH%DMD 0iVPDOR$ULDQRORUHFRQRFLyHQDEVROXWR &RUULyKDFLDODSXHUWD \HFKyHOFHUURMRSRUODVHVFDOHUDVUHVEDODQGR XQSDUGHYHFHV VREUH DOJXQDV SLVDGDV PRMDGDV 6XV PHMLOODV HVWDEDQ VXUFDGDV GH OiJULPDV 6XV SXOPRQHV TXHPDGRV SRU ORV VROOR]RV %XVFy ODV OODYHV GHO FRFKH \ VH DUURMy HQ HO DVLHQWRGHODQWHURFRPRVLDOJRODHVWXYLHUDSHUVLJXLHQGR

ž‰‹ƒ

ͳͻͷ

&XDQGRPLUySRUHOHVSHMRUHWURYLVRUVXUHVSLUDFLyQVHFRUWyHQODJDUJDQWD/HMRVHQOD GLVWDQFLD YLR D GRV IRUPDV GH VRPEUDV GH XQD SHUVRQD \ XQ SHUUR ¢XQ 5RWWZHLOHU" GHVOL]DUVHFRQVHJXULGDGHQHOERVTXH 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR 6SHQFHU1HR\RUTXLQD 6SHQFHU1HR\RUTXLQD 7UDGXFLGRSRU(PLLB*UHJRUL &RUUHJLGRSRU/RR  

6

ž‰‹ƒ

7DOYH]HVRHUDORTXH,DQVLQWLyXQDYH]TXHKDEtDHVFDSDGRGH5RVHZRRGOLEUHGHVXV SUREOHPDVDQVLRVRSRUFRPHQ]DUGHQXHYR¢'yQGHHVWDED,DQDKRUD"¢5RVHZRRG"¢2 VH KDEtD SXHVWR DO WDQWR \ KDEtD VDOWDGR OD FLXGDG" (OOD YROYLy D SHQVDU DFHUFD GH OD SHUVRQD TXH KDEtD YLVWR HQ HO ERVTXH IXHUD GHO HVWDEOR OD QRFKH DQWHULRU 'HILQLWLYDPHQWH VH KDEtD SDUHFLGR D 0HOLVVD ¢SHUR QR HVWDED HQ )LODGHOILD" 4XL]iV ,DQKDEtDGHMDGRDOJRGHWUiVGHVSXpVGHVXWUXFRGHPXHUWHDOJRTXHpOOHKDEtDSHGLGR 0HOLVVD D UHFXSHUDU 3HUR HQWRQFHV ¢VLJQLILFD HVWR TXH 0HOLVVD VDEtD DOJR DFHUFD GH GyQGH HVWDED \ TXp HVWDED KDFLHQGR" 7DO YH] VDEtD TXLpQ HUD ´$µ WDPELpQ 6L VyOR 0HOLVVDOODPDUDD6SHQFHUGHQXHYROHTXHUtDSUHJXQWDUDVXKHUPDQDVLVDEtDDOJRGH ODV IRWRV TXH (PLO\ KDEtD UHFLELGR ¢4Xp KDFtD TXH XQD IRWR GH $OL 1DRPL \ -HQQD WXYLHUD TXH YHU FRQ XQD IRWR GH :LOGHQ HQ OD LJOHVLD" ¢< SRU TXp QR KDEtD $ULD R +DQQD UHFLELGR PLVLYDV GH ´$µ VyOR 6SHQFHU \ (PLO\" ¢(VWDED ´$µ FHQWUiQGRVH HQ HOODV SULPHUR" ¢(VWDEDQ HQ PiV SHOLJUR TXH ODV GHPiV" < VL 6SHQFHU VH WUDVODGDED D 1XHYD


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ͳͻ͸

SHQFHUVHUHFRVWyHQVXDVLHQWRDERUGRGHOOXMRVRWUHQGH$PWUDN$FHODD1XHYD


6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³(VWDFLyQ 3HQQ OD VLJXLHQWH ³OD YR] GH XQ FRQGXFWRU UHVRQy HQ ORV DOWDYRFHV 6SHQFHUWRPyVXEROVRGHORQD\VHSXVRHQOtQHDFRQORVGHPiV &XDQGRVDOLyDODJUDQVDODPLUyDVXDOUHGHGRU$ODVVHxDOHVGHOPHWURDORVWD[LV\ D ODV VDOLGDV TXH HUDQ XQ UHYROWLMR 7LUDQGR VX FDUWHUD FHUFD GH VX ODGR VLJXLy D OD PXOWLWXGKDVWDXQODUJRHOHYDGRUDODFDOOH /RV WD[LV DWDVFDURQ OD DPSOLD DYHQLGD /DV OXFHV EULOODEDQ HQ VX URVWUR /RV HGLILFLRV JULVHVVHHOHYDURQHQHOFLHOR 6SHQFHUOHKL]RVHxDVDXQWD[L ³'RVYHLQWLWUpV&DOOH3HUU\³OHGLMRDOFRQGXFWRUFXDQGRHQWUy(OFRQGXFWRUDVLQWLy FRQ OD FDEH]D \ OXHJR YLUy KDFLD HO WUiILFR FDPELDQGR OD HVWDFLyQ GH GHSRUWHV HQ OD UDGLR 6SHQFHU VH PRYLy DUULED \ DEDMR YHUWLJLQRVDPHQWH FRQ JDQDV GH GHFLUOH TXH YLYtDDTXtTXHLEDDHVWUHQDUVXDSDUWDPHQWR\TXHHVWDEDDODYXHOWDGHODHVTXLQDGH ODGHVXPDPi (OWD[LVWDGHDPEXOySRUOD6pSWLPD$YHQLGD\VHFRQYLUWLHURQHQODVFDOOHVODEHUtQWLFDV GHOD9LOOD2FFLGHQWDO&XDQGRpOWRPyDODGHUHFKDHQ3HUU\6SHQFHUVHHQGHUH]y(UD XQD KHUPRVD FDOOH 9LHMD ELHQ PDQWHQLGDV ODV SLHGUDV DUHQLVFDV GH FRORU SDUGR DOLQHDGDV FDGD ODGR 8QD QLxD GH OD HGDG GH 6SHQFHU HQ XQ DEULJR GH ODQD EODQFR LQYHUQDO\XQDKHUPRVDSLHOTXHHOVRPEUHURVREUHSDVDEDSDVHDEDXQODEUDGRRGOHFRQ XQDFRUUHD(OWD[LVHGHVOL]ySRUXQDWLHQGDGHTXHVRVJRXUPHWXQDWLHQGDTXHYHQGtD LQVWUXPHQWRVPXVLFDOHV\XQDHVFXHODSLQWRUHVFDVXSDWLRSHTXHxRGHWUiVGHXQDYHUMD GH KLHUUR SXOLGR 6SHQFHU HVWXGLy ODV LPSUHVLRQHV TXH KDEtD KHFKR GH ODV IRWRV GH 0LFKDHO+XWFKLQVTXHKDEtDHQYLDGRHORWURGtD6XIXWXURKRJDUSRGUtDVyORHVWDUHQHO EORTXHVLJXLHQWH([SORUyODFDOOHHQODDQWLFLSDFLyQ ³¢6HxRULWD" ³(O WD[LVWD JLUy PLUiQGROD 6SHQFHU VDOWy³ ¢+D GLFKR GRV YHLQWLWUpV 3HUU\" ³'RVYHLQWLWUpV3HUU\HVFLHUWR³6SHQFHUWHQtDODGLUHFFLyQGHPHPRULD (O FRQGXFWRU VH DVRPy SRU OD YHQWDQD /OHYDED JDIDV GH JUXHVDV \ WHQtD XQD SOXPD HVFRQGLGDGHWUiVGHODRUHMD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

(IHFWLYDPHQWHHVWDEDQHQHOH[WUHPRRHVWHGH0DQKDWWDQ$ORWURODGRGHO3DVHR:HVW 6LGH GH OD DXWRSLVWD OOHQD GH FDPLQDQWHV \ FLFOLVWDV 0iV DOOi TXH IXH HO UtR +XGVRQ 0iVDOOiGHHVRHUDGH1XHYD-HUVH\

ͳͻ͹

³1RKD\GRVYHLQWLWUpVHQ3HUU\6HUtDHQHO+XGVRQ

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³2K³6SHQFHUIUXQFLyHOFHxR(OODUHYROYLyVXVQRWDV0LFKDHOQRKDEtDLQFOXLGROD GLUHFFLyQGHVXFRUUHRHOHFWUyQLFRQLSRGtDHQFRQWUDUHOGLEXMRGHORWURGtD³%XHQR WDOYH]FRQVHJXtODGLUHFFLyQHTXLYRFDGD8VWHGPHSXHGHGHMDUDTXtIXHUD (PSXMyXQSDUGHFXHQWDVDOFRQGXFWRU\VHEDMy(OWD[LWRPyDODGHUHFKDHQODOX]\ 6SHQFHU GLR YXHOWDV DOUHGHGRU GHVFRQFHUWDGD (PSH]y D FDPLQDU KDFLD HO (VWH FUX]DQGR :DVKLQJWRQ OXHJR *UHHQZLFK 0LFKDHO OH KDEtD GLFKR TXH HO DSDUWDPHQWR HVWDEDDODYXHOWDGHODHVTXLQDGH0DUF-DFREVTXHVHHQFRQWUDEDHQ3HUU\\%OHHFNHU /RVQ~PHURVGHORVHGLILFLRVDVXDOUHGHGRUHUDQ3HUU\2FKHQWD\FXDWUR3HUU\¢/D GLUHFFLyQGHODSDUWDPHQWRKDEtDVLGRXQRGHDTXHOODV" (OOD VLJXLy FDPLQDQGR KDVWD 3HUU\ SDUD DVHJXUDUVH SHUR ORV Q~PHURV GH ORV HGLILFLRV GH DSDUWDPHQWRV VHJXtDQ EDMDQGR QR VXELHQGR (OOD VH DVHJXUy GH EXVFDU HQ FDGD HGLILFLR FRQ FXLGDGR WUDWDQGR GH FRLQFLGLU FRQ OD FRQVWUXFFLyQ GH ODV IRWRV SHUR QLQJXQRSDUHFtDOXFLUH[DFWDPHQWHLJXDO)LQDOPHQWHJROSHyODLQWHUVHFFLyQGHOD&DOOH 3HUU\ \ GH OD $YHQLGD *UHHQZLFK /D FDOOH WHUPLQDED HQ XQD 7 $O ODGR GH OD FDOOH 3HUU\QRHVWDEDDODYLVWDKDEtDXQUHVWDXUDQWHOODPDGR)LGGOHVWLFNV3XE *ULOOHQVX OXJDU (OFRUD]yQGH6SHQFHUHPSH]yDFRUUHU6HVHQWtDFRPRVLKXELHUDHVWDGRFD\HQGRHQ XQ VXHxR UHFXUUHQWH TXH KDEtD WHQLGR GHVGH HO VHJXQGR JUDGR GRQGH XQ SURIHVRU DQXQFLDED XQD SUXHED GH VRUSUHVD \ PLHQWUDV TXH HO UHVWR GH ORV HVWXGLDQWHV FRQ HQWXVLDVPR FRPHQ]DEDQ D REWHQHU ODV UHVSXHVWDV 6SHQFHU QL VLTXLHUD SRGtD GHVFLIUDU ODVSUHJXQWDV 6DFy VX WHOpIRQR FHOXODU WUDWDQGR GH PDQWHQHU OD FDOPD \ PDUFy HO Q~PHUR GH 0LFKDHO+DEtDREYLDPHQWHXQDH[SOLFDFLyQSDUDHVWR 8QDJUDEDFLyQGHODYR]GHXQRSHUDGRUUHVRQDEDDWUDYpVGHOUHFHSWRUHOQ~PHURTXH KDEtD PDUFDGR KDEtD VLGR GHVFRQHFWDGR 6SHQFHU H[FDYy DOUHGHGRU GH VX EROVR \ HQFRQWUyODWDUMHWDGH 0LFKDHO(OODLQWURGXMRVXQ~PHURGHQXHYRUHSLWLpQGRVHORGH QXHYRDVtPLVPDSDUDDVHJXUDUVHGHTXHQRKDEtDWUDQVSXHVWRQLQJ~QGtJLWR+DEtDHO PLVPRPHQVDMHJUDEDGR6SHQFHUVRVWXYRHOWHOpIRQRH[WHQGLGRHOGRORUVHLUUDGLDHQ VXVVLHQHV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

(QWRQFHVPDUFyHOQ~PHURGH2OLYLD3HURHOWHOpIRQRGH2OLYLDDSHQDVVRQy\VRQy 6SHQFHU VRVWXYR VX GHGR HQ HO H[WUHPR ERWyQ GXUDQWH PXFKR WLHPSR (VWR QR QHFHVDULDPHQWHVLJQLILFDQDGD\DVHDGHVyORGHTXH2OLYLDQRGHEHWHQHUXQSODQGH OODPDGDVLQWHUQDFLRQDOHV

ͳͻͺ

7DOYH]FDPELyHOQ~PHURGHWHOpIRQRVHGLMR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

8QD PXMHU HPSXMDQGR XQ FRFKHFLWR GH EHEp VH GHVYLy GH VX FDPLQR OXFKDQGR SDUD FRQWHQHUXQPRQWyQGHEROVDVGHVXSHUPHUFDGRHQSRVLFLyQYHUWLFDO&XDQGR6SHQFHU PLUy DEDMR SRU OD FDOOH VH GLR FXHQWD GHO QXHYR HGLILFLR GH DSDUWDPHQWRV GH 2OLYLD EULOODQGRHQODGLVWDQFLD &RPHQ]yDFDPLQDUSRUHOORYLJRUL]DGDGHQXHYR7DOYH]2OLYLDWHQtDRWURQ~PHUR GH 0LFKDHO HQ DOJXQD SDUWH 7DO YH] HO SRUWHUR GHMDUtD D 6SHQFHU HVFDOHUDV DUULED SRU XQDSHTXHxDPLUDGDHQODWHUUD]DGH2OLYLD 8QDPXMHUFRQXQDEULJRGHODQDGHFRORUD]XOEULOODQWHVDOLyGHODVSXHUWDVJLUDWRULDV GHO HGLILFLR GH DSDUWDPHQWRV 2WUDV GRV SHUVRQDV HQWUDURQ OOHYDQGR EROVRV GH JLPQDVLR 6SHQFHU VH HPSXMy SRU OD SXHUWD GHVSXpV GH HOORV DQGDQGR HQ XQ DWULR GH PiUPRO (Q HO H[WUHPR OHMDQR GH OD KDELWDFLyQ KDEtD XQ EDQFR GH WUHV HOHYDGRUHV +DEtD XQ PDUFDGR GH OD YLHMD HVFXHOD VREUH FDGD XQR GH HOORV GLFLHQGR HQ TXp SLVR HVWDEDQORVFRFKHV/DKDELWDFLyQROtDDIORUHVIUHVFDV\DOOtHVWDEDODUHSURGXFFLyQGH P~VLFDFOiVLFDHQVLOHQFLRGXUDQWHXQDOWDYR]RFXOWR (OFRQVHUMHHQOD UHFHSFLyQOOHYDEDXQ WUDMHJULV\JDIDVSUtVWLQDV VLQ PRQWXUD/HGLR XQDVRQULVDFDQVDGDD6SHQFHUPLHQWUDVVHDFHUFDED ³8P KROD ³GLMR 6SHQFHU HVSHUDQGR TXH VX YR] QR VRQDUD GHPDVLDGR MRYHQ H LQJHQXD³(VWR\HQEXVFDGHXQDPXMHUTXHUHFLHQWHPHQWHVHPXGyDTXt6XQRPEUH HV 2OLYLD (OOD HVWi HQ 3DUtV DKRUD SHUR PH SUHJXQWR VL SXGLHUD HQWUDU HQ VX DSDUWDPHQWRSRUXQPRPHQWR ³/RVLHQWR³GLMRHOSRUWHURVHFDPHQWHYROYLHQGRDVXVSDSHOHV³1RSXHGRGHMDUWH DPHQRVTXHWHQJDSHUPLVRGHOLQTXLOLQR 6SHQFHUIUXQFLyHOFHxR ³3HURHOODHVPLPDPi6XQRPEUHHV2OLYLD&DOGZHOO (OSRUWHURQHJyFRQODFDEH]D ³1RKD\QLQJXQDOODPDGD2OLYLD&DOGZHOOYLYLHQGRDTXt

³7DO YH] HOOD QR YD SRU VX QRPEUH GH VROWHUD (OOD SXHGH LU SRU 2OLYLD )ULFN (O QRPEUHGHVXPDULGRHV0RUJDQ)ULFN



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ž‰‹ƒ

(OFRQVHUMHOHGLULJLyXQDPLUDGDIXOPLQDQWH

ͳͻͻ

6SHQFHUWUDWyGHLJQRUDUHOUHSHQWLQR\SXQ]DQWHGRORUHQVXHVWyPDJR



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³1DGLH YLYH FRQ HO QRPEUH 2OLYLD DTXt &RQR]FR D WRGRV ORV UHVLGHQWHV HQ HVWH HGLILFLR 6SHQFHU GLR XQ SDVR DWUiV PLUDQGR D XQD OtQHD GH EX]RQHV GRUDGD HQ OD SDUHG GHO IRQGR7HQtDTXHKDEHUGRVFLHQWDVXQLGDGHVHQHVWHOXJDU¢&yPRSRGtDHVWHKRPEUH KRQHVWRFRQRFHUDFDGDSHUVRQD" ³(OODVHDFDEDGHPXGDU³SUHVLRQyHOOD³¢3XHGHVFKHTXHDU" (OFRQVHUMHVXVSLUy\OXHJRWRPyXQOLEURQHJURHQHVSLUDO ³eVWDHVXQDOLVWDGHORVLQTXLOLQRVHQHOHGLILFLR³H[SOLFy³¢&XiOGLMLVWHTXHHUDVX DSHOOLGR" ³&DOGZHOO2)ULFN (OFRQVHUMHSDVyKDFLDOD&OXHJRKDFLDOD) ³1R1RKD\QDGLHFRQFXDOTXLHUDGHHVRVQRPEUHV0LUDSRUWLPLVPD (PSXMyHOOLEURHQFLPDGHODPHVD6SHQFHUVHLQFOLQyPLUiQGROR+XERXQ&DOGHFRWW \XQD&DOHESHURQR&DOGZHOO+DEtDXQ)UDQN\XQD)ULHOSHURQRXQD)ULFN7RGR VXFXHUSRHVWDEDFDOLHQWHOXHJRIUtR ³(VWRQRSXHGHVHUYHUGDG (OFRQVHUMHROLy\GHYROYLyHOOLEURDVXHVWDQWH8QWHOpIRQRQHJURHQODUHFHSFLyQGHMy HVFDSDUXQJHPLGR ³3HUGyQHPH³7RPyHODXULFXODU\KDEOyHQYR]EDMDDPDEOHPHQWH

1R (O OLEUR GH LQTXLOLQRV QR KDEtD VLGR DFWXDOL]DGR UHFLHQWHPHQWH 2OLYLD \ 0RUJDQ DFDEDED GH PXGDUVH DTXt < HO WHOpIRQR GH 2OLYLD QR VRQDED SRUTXH HVWDED IXHUD GHO SDtV < HO Q~PHUR GH 0LFKDHO +XWFKLQV HVWDED IXHUD GH RUGHQ SRUTXH KDEtD TXH pO



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

/DYR]GH$QGUHZVHDUUHPROLQDEDHQVXFDEH]D¢1RFUHHVTXHHVWiVPRYLpQGRWHXQSRFR UiSLGR"1RTXLHURTXHWHODVWLPHV

ʹͲͲ

6SHQFHU VH GLR OD YXHOWD SUHVLRQDQGR VX PDQR HQ VX IUHQWH 'RV PXMHUHV SRUWDQGR EROVDVGHODFRPSUDGH%DUQH\VH[SORWDURQDWUDYpVGHODVSXHUWDVJLUDWRULDVULHQGRD FDUFDMDGDV 8Q KRPEUH TXH SDVHDED XQ SHUUR ODQXGR GH PRQWDxD EHUQpV HQWUy \ VH XQLy D HOODV HQ ORV HOHYDGRUHV 6SHQFHU HVWDED PXULpQGRVH SRU GHVOL]DUVH FRQ HOORV WRPDU HO HOHYDGRU KDVWD HO ~OWLPR SLVR \ ¢\ TXp" ¢$VDOWDU OD WHUUD]D GH 2OLYLD SDUD GHPRVWUDUTXHUHDOPHQWHYLYtDDTXt"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

LQHVSHUDGDPHQWHORFDPELDED(ODSDUWDPHQWRGH6SHQFHUH[LVWtD6HLEDDPXGDUDXQ DSDUWDPHQWR HQ 3HUU\ 6WUHHW HO PHMRU EORTXH GHO SXHEOR OD VLJXLHQWH VHPDQD SDUD YLYLUVLHPSUHIHOL]DXQDVSRFDVFXDGUDVGHVXKRQHVWDSDUD'LRVPDGUHELROyJLFD(VWR QRHUDGHPDVLDGREXHQRSDUDVHUYHUGDG ¢/RHUD" /D SLHO GH 6SHQFHU VH VHQWtD HVWRIDGD 2 ELHQ OH GDV D OR ODUJR OR GH WX PDGUH SHUGLGD GHVFDQVDV\VLJXHVEXVFDQGRORTXHUHDOPHQWHVXFHGLyRSDJDVPLSUHFLR´$µKDEUtDGLFKR 0iV DOOi LQGLIHUHQWHPHQWH GH FRQWDUOH D ORV GHPiV TXH ´$µ OH KDEtD HQYLDGR XQD VHJXQGD QRWD 6SHQFHU QR KDEtD EXVFDGR XQ YHUGDGHUR DVHVLQR GH $OL HQ DEVROXWR ¢4Xp SDVD VL HVWR HUD HO SUHFLR GH ´$µ" ´$µ VDEtD TXH HVWDED EXVFDQGR D VX PDGUH ELROyJLFD7DOYH]´$µFRQWDEDFRQXQHTXLSRGHSHUVRQDVEDMRVXFRQWURO8QDPXMHU OODPDGD 2OLYLD 8Q KRPEUH TXH VH KL]R SDVDU SRU XQ DJHQWH GH ELHQHV UDtFHV LQYHQWDQGR XQ DSDUWDPHQWR HQ HO  GH OD &DOOH 3HUU\ VLQ PLUDU D XQ PDSD GH SUHFLVLyQ ´$µ VDEtD TXH 6SHQFHU TXHUtD XQD IDPLOLD TXH DPDUD OR VXILFLHQWH FRPR SDUD DUULHVJDUORWRGRLQFOXVRODHGXFDFLyQGHODXQLYHUVLGDG (OOD GLR YXHOWD OHMRV GHO HVFULWRULR GHODQWHUR HQ HO YHVWtEXOR EXVFDQGR D WLHQWDV VX 6LGHNLFN(QXQRVSRFRVFOLFVHVWDEDUHJLVWUDQGRHQODFXHQWDGHTXHKDEtDHQFRQWUDGR HQODFRPSXWDGRUDGHVXSDGUH6HVHQWtDFRPRVLQRSXGLHUDREWHQHUXQDUHVSLUDFLyQ SURIXQGD3RUIDYRUPXUPXUyHQYR]EDMD(VWRQRSXHGHHVWDUSDVDQGR 8Q FRPXQLFDGR DSDUHFLGR HQ OD SDQWDOOD (UD HO QRPEUH GH 6SHQFHU GLUHFFLyQ \ Q~PHURGHFXHQWD(OVDOGRHVWDEDHQIXHQWHHQFRORUURMRHQODSDUWHLQIHULRU&XDQGR HOODORYLRHOHVWyPDJRGH6SHQFHUVHODQ]y6XYLVLyQVHUHGXMRKDVWDTXHWRGRVORTXH YLRHUDXQDILJXUDTXHWHQtDGHODQWH1RHUDQVLQRPXFKRVFHURVVyORXQR 

ž‰‹ƒ

ʹͲͳ

/DFXHQWDKDEtDVLGROLPSLDGDKDVWDHO~OWLPRFHQWDYR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR <ODJDQDGRUDHV« <ODJDQDGRUDHV« 7UDGXFLGRSRU&\H/\'LYL11D &RUUHJLGRSRU(PLLB*UHJRUL 

/

DQRFKHGHOViEDGR+DQQDVHVHQWyHQVXWRFDGRUEDUULHQGRORV~OWLPRVWRTXHV GH EURQFHDGRU HQ VXV PHMLOODV (O YHVWLGR GH YDLQD 5DFKHO 5R\ IRUUDGR FRQ HQFDMH QHJUR TXH KDEtD FRPSUDGR SDUD OD ILHVWD GH 5DGOH\ VH DGDSWDED D OD SHUIHFFLyQDMXVWDGRSHURQRGHPDVLDGRDSUHWDGRDOUHGHGRUGHODFLQWXUD\ODVFDGHUDV +DEtDHVWDGRGHPDVLDGRRFXSDGDFRPSLWLHQGRSRU0LNHHVWDVHPDQDSDUDVXFXPELUD VXVKDELWXDOHVDWUDFRQHVGH&KHH],WV6LVyORODGLHWDGH0LNH0RQWJRPHU\YLQLHUDHQ XQDERWHOOD /ODPDURQDVXSXHUWD \+DQQDVDOWy6XSDGUHHVWDEDHQODSXHUWDGHVXGRUPLWRULR YHVWLGRFRQXQVXpWHUQHJURFRQFXHOORHQ9\SDQWDORQHVYDTXHURV ³¢9DVDDOJXQDSDUWH"³SUHJXQWy +DQQD WUDJy VDOLYD PLUDQGR VX UHIOHMR FRQIHFFLRQDGR HQ HO HVSHMR 'XGDED TXH VX SDGUHIXHUDDFRPSUDUTXHHVWDEDSDVDQGRXQDQRFKHWUDQTXLODGHQWUR ³+D\XQDDSHUWXUDSDUDHVWHJUDQKRWHODIXHUD ³¢(VSRUHVRTXHODSXHUWDGH.DWHHVWiFHUUDGDWDPELpQ"¢9DQODVGRVMXQWDV" +DQQDGHMyODEURFKDGHPDTXLOODMHUHVLVWLHQGRHOLPSXOVRGHVRQUHtU1RLEDQMXQWDV SRUTXH+DQQDKDEtDJDQDGRD0LNHSDUDHOODVROD-D ³1RH[DFWDPHQWH³GLMRSRUHOFRQWUDULRIUHQDQGRVXVVHQWLPLHQWRV

ʹͲʹ

(O 6U 0DUtQ VH VHQWy HQ HO ERUGH GH VX FDPD 'RW WUDWy GH VDOWDU VREUH VXV URGLOODV SHURORDJLWyDGLVWDQFLD ³+DQQD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ž‰‹ƒ

+DQQDORPLUyVXSOLFDQWH¢,EDDFXPSOLUODSHQDDKRUD"



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³7HQJR XQD FLWD 6HUtD H[WUDxR VL YLHQH FRQ QRVRWURV +H DSUHQGLGR PL OHFFLyQ OR MXUR (O6U0DUtQKL]RFUXMLUORVQXGLOORVXQKiELWRTXH+DQQDVLHPSUHKDEtDRGLDGR ³¢4XLpQHVHOFKLFR" ³6LPSOHPHQWH³HOODVXVSLUy³(QUHDOLGDGpOHVHOKHUPDQRPHQRUGH$ULD ³¢$ULD 0RQWJRPHU\" ³HO 6U 0DUtQ HQWRUQy ORV RMRV SHQVDQGR /D ~QLFD YH] TXH +DQQDUHFRUGDEDDVXSDGUHUHXQLGRFRQ0LNHIXHFXDQGRVHKDEtDOOHYDGRD+DQQD $ULD \ ORV RWURV D XQ IHVWLYDO GH P~VLFD HQ 3HQQ V /DQGLQJ $ULD KDEtD WHQLGR TXH DUUDVWUDUDORODUJRD0LNHSRUTXHHO6HxRU\OD6HxRUD0RQWJRPHU\HVWDEDQIXHUDGH OD FLXGDG 0LHQWUDV HVWDEDQ YLHQGR XQR GH ORV DFWRV 0LNH GHVDSDUHFLy 6H OH EXVFy IUHQpWLFDPHQWHSRUWRGRHOUHFLQWRILQDOPHQWHOHHQFRQWUDURQHQHOEDUGHDSHULWLYRVeO HVWDEDSHJDGRDXQDGHODVFKLFDVKRODQGHVDVGH3HQQV\OYDQLDTXHKLFLHURQHOSDVWHO ³¢7LHQH.DWHXQDFLWD"³SUHJXQWyHO6U0DUtQ +DQQDVHHQFRJLyGHKRPEURV(OGtDGHKR\OHKDEtDGLFKRD0LNHSDUDTXHIXHUDVX FLWDGLFLpQGROHD.DWHTXHKDEtDSURPHWLGRLUFRQORVFKLFRVHQXQ+XPPHUDOTXLODGR 6L pO OH KDEtD GLFKR TXH LED D LU FRQ +DQQD .DWH OH KDEUtD GLFKR LQPHGLDWDPHQWH D SDSi\DUUXLQDGRWRGR 6XSDGUHVXVSLUy\VHOHYDQWy ³(VWiELHQ3XHGHVLUSRUWXFXHQWD ³*UDFLDV³VRSOy+DQQD /HGLRXQDVSDOPDGLWDVHQODHVSDOGD

+DQQDVLQWLyVXVPHMLOODVHQURMHFHU'HYXHOWDHQTXLQWR\VH[WRJUDGRFXDQGR+DQQD \ VX SDGUH VROtDQ HVWDU FHUFD VROtD TXHMDUVH FRQ pO GHVSXpV GH OD HVFXHOD 0H VLHQWR FRPRXQDJUDQQDGDFRQIHVy6XSDGUHVLHPSUHOHDVHJXUyTXHODVFRVDVVHGDUtDQOD YXHOWD+DQQDQROHFUH\ySHURKDEtDWHUPLQDGRVLHQGRFLHUWR/OHJDUDVHUDPLJDGH $OLKDEtDFDPELDGRWRGRSDUDELHQ

ž‰‹ƒ

+DQQDPLUyDVXSDGUHFRQUHFHOR ³.DWHSDUHFHPX\IHOL]HQ5RVHZRRG'D\(VODPHMRUDPLJDGH1DRPL\5LOH\



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ʹͲ͵

³6yORTXLHURTXH.DWHVHVLHQWDELHQYHQLGDDTXt(OODHVWiWHQLHQGRXQPRPHQWRPX\ GLItFLOHQ5RVHZRRG'D\6HJ~QUHFXHUGRQRVLHPSUHIXHIiFLOSDUDWLWDPSRFR



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(O6U0DUtQVHSXVRGHSLH ³6LKDEODVFRQHOODVDEUiVODYHUGDG/RTXHPiVGHVHDHVVHUWXDPLJD+DQQD3HUR SDUHFHVHVWDUKDFLHQGRTXHVHDORPiVGLItFLOSRVLEOH /XHJRVDOLyGHODKDELWDFLyQFDPLQDQGRVXDYHPHQWHSRUHOSDVLOOR+DQQDVHPDQWXYR HQODFDPDVLQWLpQGRVHWDQWRGHVFRQFHUWDGDFRPRPROHVWD£&RPRVL .DWHUHDOPHQWH TXLVLHUDVHUVXDPLJD(OODOHKDEtDGLFKRREYLDPHQWHDOSDGUHGH+DQQDSDUDWHQHUOR PiVGHVXODGR +DQQD HQWHUUy VX SXxR HQ HO FROFKyQ 1R HUDFRPR VL PXFKD JHQWH KXELHUD URWR VXV SXHUWDVGHVHVSHUDGDPHQWHTXHULHQGRVHUVXPHMRUDPLJD'HKHFKRVyORGRVSHUVRQDV YLQLHURQDODPHQWH$OLTXHKDEtDHOHJLGRD+DQQDHQWUHPXFKDVRWUDVQLxDVHOHJLEOHV GHVH[WRJUDGR\0RQDTXHVHKDEtDVHQWDGRMXQWRD+DQQDHQYHUVLRQHVGHSUXHEDGH SRUULVWDVGHRFWDYRJUDGRHQWDEOyXQDFRQYHUVDFLyQ\ODLQYLWyOXHJRDXQDILHVWDGH SLMDPDVHQVXFDVD(QHVHPRPHQWR+DQQDKDEtDSHQVDGRWDQWRHQSRUTXHODVFKLFDV ODHOLJLHURQSRUGHWHUPLQDGDVUD]RQHVSRUTXHSDUD0RQD+DQQDKDEtDVLGRDPLJDGH $OL \ SRU OR WDQWR DOJXLHQ FRQ XQD SHTXHxD VLWXDFLyQ \ SDUD $OL SRUTXH YLR XQ SRWHQFLDO HQ +DQQD GHO TXH QDGLH PiV VH KDEtD GDGR FXHQWD WRGDYtD $KRUD +DQQD VDEtD TXH HUDQ GLIHUHQWHV 'HVGH HO SULQFLSLR 0RQD SUREDEOHPHQWH KDEtD WUD]DGR OD FDtGD GH +DQQD 7DO YH] $OL KDEtD WHQLGR PRWLYRV PiV VLQLHVWURV SDUD OD HOHFFLyQ GH +DQQD WDPELpQ WDO YH] YLR OD LQVHJXULGDG +DQQD 7DO YH] VH GLR FXHQWD GH OR IiFLOPHQWHTXH+DQQDSRGUtDVHUPDQLSXODGD (QHOIRQGRXQDSDUWHGH+DQQDTXHUtDFUHHUTXHORTXHVXSDGUHGLMRHUDFLHUWRTXHD SHVDUGHWRGR.DWHKRQHVWDPHQWHTXHUtDFRPRDPLJDD+DQQD3HURGHVSXpVGHWRGR +DQQDKDEtDVXIULGRHUDGLItFLOFRQILDUHQTXHORVREMHWLYRVGH.DWHSRGUtDQVHUSXURV &XDQGRVDOLyGHVXKDELWDFLyQR\yHODJXDFRUULHQGRHQODVDODGHEDxR.DWHHVWDED FDQWDQGRHQYR]DOWDXQDUHFLHQWHFDQFLyQGH$PHULFDQ,GROFRQWRGDHODJXDFDOLHQWH +DQQDVHGHWXYRMXQWRDODSXHUWDVLQWLpQGRVHWRWDOPHQWHLQHVWDEOH(QWRQFHVFXDQGR XQFDPLyQUHWXPEDEDIXHUDDVXSDVRGLRPHGLDYXHOWD\PDUFKyHVFDOHUDVDEDMR

&XDQGR HOOD \ 0LNH HQWUDURQ HQ HO VDOyQ GH EDLOH SULQFLSDO OD PDQGtEXOD GH +DQQD FD\yD~QPiV(OWHPDGHODILHVWDHUDHO3DODFLRGH9HUVDOOHV\HOOREE\5DGOH\HVWDED



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

(QFXDQWRVDOLy+DQQDWRPyORVSDVLOORVGHODGULOORFRQHQFDQWRHOODJRGHKLHORGH FRUWH]D HQ HO SUDGR GH YXHOWD \ OD JUDQ HVFDOLQDWD GH SLHGUD TXH FRQGXFH D OD PDMHVWXRVDSXHUWDGHPDGHUD

ʹͲͶ

(O+RWHO7KH5DGOH\HVWDEDOOHQRGHLQYLWDGRVIRWyJUDIRV\SHUVRQDO+DQQD\0LNHVH TXHGDURQHQODFDO]DGDDSDUFDGRV\OHHQWUHJDURQHOFRFKHDOYDOHW

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

FXELHUWRFRQWDSLFHVGHVHGD\OOHQRGHDUDxDVGHFULVWDORUR\SLQWXUDVHQODVSDUHGHV DGRUQRV \ FDPDVWURV +DEtD XQ JUDQ IUHVFR GH XQD HVFHQD PLWROyJLFD HQ OD SDUHG GHO IRQGR\+DQQDSRGUtDYHUXQDJDOHUtDGHORVHVSHMRVHQODSDUWHSRVWHULRUDOLJXDOTXH HQHOUHDOGH9HUVDOOHVDODVDIXHUDVGH3DUtV$VXGHUHFKDKDEtDXQDVDODGHOWURQRFRQ XQDVLOODDOWDUHDOFRQXQFRMtQGHWHUFLRSHORFRORUEXUGHRV8QJUXSRGHSHUVRQDVVH UHXQLHURQ FHUFD GH OD EDUUD \ GH SLH HQ JUXSRV FHUFD GH ODV PHVDV 8QD RUTXHVWD FRPSOHWDVHHVWDEOHFLyHQODSDUWHGHDWUiV\KDFLDODL]TXLHUGDHVWDEDHOPRVWUDGRUGH UHFHSFLyQORVDVFHQVRUHV\XQDVHxDOGLVFUHWDGHOVSD\ORVEDxRV ³:RZ³VXVSLUy+DQQDeVWHHUDVXWLSRGHKRWHO ³6tHVWiELHQ³GLMR0LNHDKRJDQGRXQERVWH]R 0LNHHVWDEDYHVWLGRFRQXQHVPRTXLQQHJUROLVR7HQtDHOSHORRVFXURSHLQDGRKDFLDVX FDUD PRVWUDQGR VXV SURPLQHQWHV SyPXORV 6LHPSUH TXH +DQQD OR PLUDED VHQWtD ORV EUD]RV \ SLHUQDV GHUUHWLUVH $~Q PiV H[WUDxR VLJXLy UHFLELHQGR SXQ]DGDV GH YDJD WULVWH]D1RHUDODIRUPDHQTXHVHVXSRQtDTXHXQJDQDGRUGHEtDVHQWLUVH 8QHPSOHDGRGHFDWHULQJFRQXQWUDMHEODQFRSDVyGHODUJR ³0H YR\ D WRPDU XQ WUDJR ³GLMR +DQQD DOHJUHPHQWH GHVWHUUDQGR ORV VHQWLPLHQWRV PHODQFyOLFRVGHVXFDEH]D6HDFHUFyDODEDUUD\VHSXVRHQODILODGHWUiVGHO6U\OD 6UD.DKQTXHFXFKLFKHDEDQFRQHQWXVLDVPRVREUHHODUWHHQODH[KLELFLyQTXHTXHUtDQ FRPSUDU $ FRQWLQXDFLyQ XQ PHFKyQ GH SHOR UXELR HQ OD VDOD OODPy OD DWHQFLyQ GH +DQQD (UD OD 6UD 'L/DXUHQWLV HQIUDVFDGD HQ XQD FRQYHUVDFLyQ FRQ XQ KRPEUH GH FDEHOOR SODWHDGR FRQ XQ HVPRTXLQ (O KRPEUH DUUDVy FRQ VXV EUD]RV VHxDODQGR HO EDOFyQODVFROXPQDVHVWULDGDVODVDUDxDVHOSDVLOORKDVWDHOVSD\ODVKDELWDFLRQHV/D 6UD'L/DXUHQWLVDVLQWLy\VRQULySHURVXH[SUHVLyQSDUHFtDSHJDGD +DQQDVHHVWUHPHFLyLQTXLHWDDOYHUDODPDPiGH$OLHQXQDILHVWD

.DWH 6XKHUPDQDVWUDHVWDEDYHVWLGDFRQXQWUDMHD]XOPDULQRODUJRKDVWDHOSLVR\WDFRQHVGH GLH] FHQWtPHWURV 1DRPL \ 5LOH\ OD IODQTXHDEDQ D DPERV ODGRV XVDQGR XOWUD FRUWRV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

(OFDPDUHURVHDFODUyODJDUJDQWD\+DQQDVHYROYLy\RUGHQyXQPX\VXFLRPDUWLQL .HWHO2QH&XDQGRpOORPH]FORVHYROYLy\VHSXVRGHSXQWLOODVHQEXVFDGH0LNH &XDQGR ILQDOPHQWH OR HQFRQWUy HVWDED HQ OD HVTXLQD FHUFD GH XQD SLQWXUD DEVWUDFWD JLJDQWHMXQWRD1RHO0DVRQ\DOJXQDVFKLFDV+DQQDHQWUHFHUUyORVRMRVHQHOVXVXUUR GHXQDPXFKDFKDERQLWDHQVXRtGR

ʹͲͷ

(UDFRPRYHUDXQIDQWDVPD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

YHVWLGRV QHJURV +DQQD DJDUUy VX PDUWLQL \ VH GLVSDUy D WUDYpV GHO FXDUWR HO YRGND FKDSRWHDQGR VREUH HO ERUGH GHO YDVR (OOD OOHJy D 0LNH \ OR JROSHy FRQ IXHU]D HQ HO KRPEUR ³+ROD ³GLMR 0LNH XQD PLUDGD GH \RQRHVWR\KDFLHQGRQDGDPDOR HQ VX URVWUR .DWH1DRPL\5LOH\PLUDURQDVXDOUHGHGRUULpQGRVH /DSLHOGH+DQQDVLQWLyXQDTXHPDGXUD7RPyODPDQRGH0LNH+DQQDVHHQIUHQWyD ODVGHPiV ³¢(VFXFKDQFKLFDV"0LNH\\RYDPRVDOEDLOHMXQWRV 1DRPL\5LOH\SDUHFtDQFRQIXQGLGDV/DVRQULVDGH.DWHIXHDWHQXDGD ³¢3DUHMD" ³8KKXK ³FKLUULy +DQQD SDViQGRVH ODV PDQRV SRU HQFLPD GH VX SHGD]R GH /D &iSVXODGHO7LHPSRTXHVHKDEtDDWDGRDODFDGHQDGHRURGHVXEROVRGH&KDQHO 1RHO.DKQDSODXGLyD0LNHHQODSDUWHSRVWHULRU ³'XOFH 0LNHVHHQFRJLyGHKRPEURVFRPRVLpOKXELHUDVDELGRGHVGHHOSULQFLSLRTXHHUDOR TXH+DQQDOHSUHJXQWDED ³1HFHVLWRRWURWUDJRGH-lJHU³GLMR\VHHQFDPLQyFRQ1RHO\0DVRQGHODVDODD ODEDUUDGiQGRVHHPSXMRQHVORVXQRVDORVRWURVFDGDSRFRVSDVRV /D RUTXHVWD VH ODQ]y D XQ YDOV \ DOJXQRV GH ORV DVLVWHQWHV D OD ILHVWD YLHMRV \ SROYRULHQWRV TXH UHDOPHQWH VDEtDQ OR TXH TXHUtD GHFLU HPSH]DURQ D EDLODU +DQQD EORTXHyODVPDQRVHQODFDGHUD\OHGLVSDUyD.DWHXQDVRQULVDGHVXILFLHQFLD ³£$MD¢4XLpQHVHOJDQDGRUDKRUD" .DWHEDMyXQKRPEUR ³'LRV+DQQD³HOODVHHFKyDUHtU³¢(QVHULROHSUHJXQWDVWHSDUDHOEDLOH"

ʹͲ͸

+DQQDURGyORVRMRV ³3REUHEHEp1RHVWiVDFRVWXPEUDGDDSHUGHU3HURHQIUpQWDORORKLFLVWH

ž‰‹ƒ

.DWHQHJyFRQODFDEH]DYLJRURVDPHQWH ³1RHQWLHQGHV1LVLTXLHUDOHJXVWDED



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

+DQQDGHMyHVFDSDUXQDSUHWyQGHODELRV ³/HJXVWDEDVWDQWRFRPR\R .DWHEDMyODEDUELOOD ³¢/R KDFtD" ³HOOD FUX]y ORV EUD]RV VREUH HO SHFKR³ 4XHUtD YHU VL LUtDV GHVSXpV VL SHQVDEDVTXHLEDGHWUiVGHpOWDPELpQ/DEURPDHVVREUHWL+DQQD7RGRVVDEtDPRV GHpO 1DRPL KL]R XQ UXLGR YDFLODQWH 5LOH\ IUXQFLy ORV ODELRV WUDWDQGR GH QR HVWDOODU HQ ULVDV +DQQD SDUSDGHy FRQ IXHU]D SHUGLHQGR HO HTXLOLEULR ¢.DWH KDEODED HQ VHULR" ¢+DQQDIXHODSHRUSDUWHGHHVWDEURPD" /DFDUDGH.DWHVHVXDYL]y ³2KIUtR£3LHQVDHQHVWRFRPRYHQJDQ]DSRUODFRVDGHOKHUSHV\DKRUDLQFOXVRHVWi ¢3RUTXpQRKDFHUXQDILHVWDFRQQRVRWURV"+D\DOJXQRVFKLFRVJXDSRVGH%UHQWPRQW SUHSDUiQGRVHHQHO6DOyQGHORV(VSHMRV (OODFRORFyVXEUD]RDWUDYpVGH+DQQDSHURHOODQHJyFRQODGLVWDQFLD¢&yPRSRGtD VHUWDQDUURJDQWH.DWH"¢&yPRIXHHVWRXQDYHQJDQ]DSRUORGHOKHUSHV"+DQQDKDEtD WHQLGRTXHGHFLUOHVDWRGRVTXH.DWHWHQtDKHUSHV6LQRORKXELHUDKHFKR.DWHKDEUtD GLFKRDWRGRHOPXQGRHOVHFUHWRGH+DQQDVREUHHODWUDFyQSXUJD 3HURGHUHSHQWH+DQQDUHFRUGyTXHORVRUSUHQGLGDTXHSDUHFLy.DWHFXDQGR+DQQDOH GLRODQRWLFLDGHOKHUSHV(OODKDEtDPLUDGRD+DQQDLPSRWHQWHFRPRVLKXELHUDVLGR VRUSUHQGLGDSRUODWUDLFLyQ¢(UDSRVLEOHTXH.DWHQXQFDWXYLHUDODILQDOLGDGGHDYLVDU HOVHFUHWRGH+DQQDHVDQRFKH"¢3RGUtDORTXHVXSDGUHGLMRTXH.DWHVyORTXHUtDVHUVX DPLJDGHYHUGDG" 3HURQR 1R +DQQDVHHQIUHQWRD.DWH

ž‰‹ƒ

6DOLyPiVIXHUWHGHORTXHSUHWHQGtD8QDVSRFDVSHUVRQDVVHGHWXYLHURQ\PLUDURQ8Q QHJURGHDVSHFWRIRUQLGRHQXQHVPRTXLQSUHVXPLEOHPHQWHXQJRULODPLUyD+DQQD FRQRMRVGHDGYHUWHQFLD .DWHOHYDQWyODFDGHUD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ʹͲ͹

³7~TXHUtDVD0LNHSHUR\RORWHQJR



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢6LW~UHDOPHQWHFUHHVTXHHVDVt" +DQQDQHJyFRQODFDEH]D ³£+HJDQDGR³H[FODPy³£+DVSHUGLGR .DWHPLUySRUHQFLPDGHOKRPEURGH+DQQDVXH[SUHVLyQFDPELRGHSXHVWR+DQQD VLJXLyVXPLUDGD0LNHHVWDEDFRQGRVPDUWLQLVH[WHQGLGRVXQRSDUDpO\HOUHOOHQDGR SDUD HOOD 6XV RMRV VH PLUDEDQ H[WUDD]XOHV 3RU OD IRUPD HQ TXH PLUDED D +DQQD SDUHFtDFRPRVLpOHQWHQGLHUDSHUIHFWDPHQWHORTXHDFDEDEDGHVXFHGHU$QWHVGHTXH +DQQD SXGLHUD GHFLU XQD SDODEUD VXDYHPHQWH GHMR OD EHELGD GH +DQQD D VX ODGR D PHGLRWHUPLQDU\VHGLRODYXHOWDVLQGHFLUQDGD6XHVSDOGDHVWDEDWLHVDFRPRXQSDOR FXDQGRVHFRQIXQGLyFRQODPXOWLWXG ³0LNH ³+DQQD OODPy GHVSXpV GH pO UHFRJLHQGR OD IDOGD \ FRPHQ]DQGR D FRUUHU 0LNH SHQVy TXH +DQQD VyOR ILQJtD TXH OH JXVWDED SHUR WDO YH] QR HUD OD YHUGDG HQ DEVROXWR 0LNH HUD GLYHUWLGR \ JHQXLQR 7DO YH] HUD D~Q PiV SHUIHFWR SDUD HOOD TXH FXDOTXLHUFKLFRTXHKDEtDFRQRFLGRQXQFD ([SOLFDEDSRUTXpVHQWtDPDULSRVDVHQHOHVWyPDJRFDGDYH]TXHHVWDEDFHUFDSRUTXp VRQUHtDYHUWLJLQRVDPHQWHFXDQGRHQYLDEDVXVPHQVDMHVGHWH[WR\SRUTXpVXFRUD]yQ ODWtD FRQ IXHU]D FXDQGR FDVL OH GLR XQ EHVR HQ VX SRUFKH ([SOLFDED SRU TXp +DQQD KDEtDHVWDGRVLQWLHQGR PDOKXPRUHVWDQRFKHWDPELpQQRTXHUtDTXHHVWHMXHJRFRQ 0LNHWHUPLQDUD

ž‰‹ƒ

ʹͲͺ

6 GHWXYR HQ HO RWUR H[WUHPR GHO VDOyQ GH EDLOH EXVFDQGR IUHQpWLFDPHQWH DOUHGHGRU 0LNHKDEtDGHVDSDUHFLGR 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR $OJXLHQWLHQHXQVHFUHWR $OJXLHQWLHQHXQVHFUHWR 7UDGXFLGRSRU&\H/\'LYL11D &RUUHJLGRSRU(PLLB*UHJRUL 

(

PLO\HVWDEDHQHOSRUFKHGHJUDQGHVSLHGUDVDODHQWUDGDGHO5DGOH\YLHQGRODV OLPXVLQDV \ ORV FRFKHV FLUFXODQGR HQ OD FLXGDG (O DLUH ROtD D XQD PH]FOD GH SHUIXPHVFDURV\XQIRWyJUDIRLEDUHYRORWHDQGRDOUHGHGRUGHORVDVLVWHQWHVDOD ILHVWDWRPDQGRIRWRV&DGDYH]TXHXQIODVKVHGLVSDUDED(PLO\SHQVDEDHQODVIRWRV HVSHOX]QDQWHV GH $ $OL -HQQD \ 1DRPL VH UHXQLHURQ HQ HO SDWLR WUDVHUR GH $OL 'DUUHQ :LOGHQ TXH VDOtD GH OD FRQIHVLyQ < OXHJR HVWDED -DVRQ 'L/DXUHQWLV GLVFXWLHQGRFRQ-HQQD&DYDQDXJKHQODVDODGH-HQQD¢3RUTXpFUHHVTXHHVWiWDQHQRMDGD" ¢4XpVLJQLILFDED"¢4XpHVWDEDWUDWDQGRGHGHFLUOH´$µ" 6DFy VX WHOpIRQR FHOXODU GH VX EROVR \ PLUy OD KRUD XQD YH] PiV (UDQ ODV RFKR \ FXDUWR \ $ULD VH VXSRQtD TXH VH HQFRQWUDUtD HQ OD HQWUDGD KDFH XQ FXDUWR GH KRUD $OUHGHGRU GH XQD KRUD GHVSXpV GH VX FRQYHUVDFLyQ WHOHIyQLFD LQFyPRGD GH HVWD PDxDQD $ULD OODPy D (PLO\ GH YXHOWD \ OH SUHJXQWy VL TXHUtD LU D OD ILHVWD MXQWR D 5DGOH\(PLO\LPDJLQyTXHHUDODPDQHUDGH$ULDGHSHGLUGLVFXOSDVSRUJULWDUOHDHOOD \DXQTXHQRVHKDEtDVHQWLGRUHDOPHQWHELHQFRQHOODSDUDVDOLUFRQ,VDDFDVtTXHKDEtD DFHSWDGR GH PDOD JDQD +DEtD OODPDGR D 6SHQFHU \ OH SUHJXQWy VL TXHUtD LU WDPELpQ SHUR6SHQFHUGLMRTXHHVWDEDSDVDQGRODQRFKHHQHOJUDQHURKDFLHQGRORVGHEHUHVGH VXKHUPDQD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

(OLQWHULRUGHOKRWHOHVWDEDFDOLHQWH\ROtDDPHQWD(PLO\VHGHVOL]yIXHUDGHVXDEULJR \VHORHQWUHJyDODPXFKDFKDHQODYHQWDQDGHDEULJRWLFNHWDOLVDQGRVXYHVWLGRVLQ WLUDQWHVGHFRORUURMRRVFXUR'HVSXpVGHTXH,VDDFODLQYLWyKDEtDVDOLyFRUULHQGRDO FHQWUR FRPHUFLDO VH SUREy HO YHVWLGR \ VH LPDJLQy D ,VDDF GHVPD\iQGRVH FXDQGR OR YLHUDHQHOOD3RUXQDYH]HQVXYLGDORKDEtDFRPSUDGRVLQVLTXLHUDPLUDUODHWLTXHWD GHSUHFLR

ʹͲͻ

0iVSHUVRQDVIOX\HURQDWUDYpVGHODVSXHUWDVGH5DGOH\PRVWUDQGRVXVLQYLWDFLRQHVD XQD FKLFD TXH XVDED XQ DXULFXODU \ OHYDQWDED XQ SRUWDSDSHOHV (PLO\ KDEtD OODPDGR SRUWHOpIRQRD$ULDSHURQRUHVSRQGLy(OODVXVSLUy7DOYH]$ULDKDEtDLGRVLQHOOD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

¢<SDUDTXp"$ODVDPD\HUSRUODQRFKH(PLO\KDEtDURGDGRHQODFDPD\PLUDGR DODSHTXHxDYHQWDQDGHVXWHOpIRQRFRQODHVSHUDQ]DGHTXH,VDDFOHKXELHUDHQYLDGR XQWH[WRGHGLVFXOSD3HURQRKDEtDQDGD (VWLUyHOFXHOORHQEXVFDGHpODKRUD(VWDEDGHILQLWLYDPHQWHDTXtHQDOJXQDSDUWH\DVt HVWDEDQHO6U\OD6UD&ROEHUW 6XSLHOFRPHQ]yDSLFDUOH7DOYH]QRGHEHUtD HVWDUDTXt8QDFRVDHUDDFRPSDxDUD $ULDSRUORPHQRVWHQGUtDXQWDPSyQSHUR(PLO\QRFUHtDTXHSXGLHUDKDFHUIUHQWHD HVWH OXJDU VROD 6H YROYLy KDFLD OD HQWUDGD SHUR PXFKtVLPD JHQWH KDEtD OOHJDGR D OD YH]EORTXHDQGRODVSXHUWDV (VSHUyDTXHODPXOWLWXGVHIXHUDURJDQGRSRUTXpQRODYLHUDQLQJXQRGHORV&ROEHUW (OODQRSRGtDVRSRUWDUODLGHDGHYHUHORGLRHQVXVRMRV (QODSDUHGMXQWRDHOODKDEtDXQDJUDQSODFDGHEURQFHTXHGHVFULEHODKLVWRULDGHOD 5DGOH\ *& 5DGOH\ 5HWLUR GH %LHQHVWDU GH OD ,QIDQFLD VH LQLFLy HQ  FRPR XQ RUIDQDWR SHUR FRQ HO WLHPSR VH FRQYLUWLy HQ XQ UHIXJLR VHJXUR SDUD ORV QLxRV FRQ SUREOHPDV(VWDSODFDFRQPHPRUDDORVQLxRVTXHVHKDQEHQHILFLDGRGHODLQVWDODFLyQ ~QLFD GH 5DGOH\ \ HO PHGLR DPELHQWH \ ORV PpGLFRV \ HO SHUVRQDO TXH KDQ GHGLFDGR DxRVGHVXYLGDDODFDXVD 3RU GHEDMR HVWDEDQ ORV QRPEUHV GH YDULRV GLUHFWRUHV \ GHFDQRV GH ODV LQVWDODFLRQHV (PLO\ORVHVFDQHySHURQRVLJQLILFDEDQDGDSDUDHOOD ³+HRtGRTXHDOJXQRVGHORVQLxRVTXHVHTXHGDURQDTXtHVWDEDQORFRVUHDOPHQWH

³¢9HV HVH EDOFyQ" ³0D\D VHxDOy HO HQWUHVXHOR GHO KRWHO /D JHQWH HVWDED LQFOLQDGD VREUHODEDUDQGDHODERUDGDGHKLHUURIRUMDGRPLUDQGRKDFLDDEDMRDODPXOWLWXG³+H



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³+KROD³(PLO\EDOEXFHy3HQVyHQ0D\DGHSLHHQODYHQWDQDGHVXKDELWDFLyQOD QRFKH DQWHULRU DO LJXDO TXH (PLO\ HQWUy HQ HO FDOOHMyQ VLQ VDOLGD FRPR VL KXELHUD HVSHUDGRODOOHJDGDGH(PLO\¢)XHVyORXQDFRLQFLGHQFLD"<HORWURGtDHQODHVFXHOD TXH KDEtD YLVWR D 0D\D \ -HQQD KDEODQGR 9LYtDQ DO ODGR OD XQD GH OD RWUD ¢KDEtDQ HQWDEODGRXQDDPLVWDG"

ʹͳͲ

(PLO\PLUy\TXHGyVLQDOLHQWR0D\DHVWDEDGHSLHMXQWRDHOODYHVWLGDFRQXQDEDWD GHFRORUDYHOODQD7HQtDHOSHORKDFLDDWUiVGHVXURVWUR\OOHYDEDODVRPEUDGHRMRVGH XQGRUDGREULOODQWH+DEtDXQDVRQULVDEXUORQDHQVXSHTXHxRURVWURQRPX\GLIHUHQWH GH OD PLUDGD TXH $OL XWLOL]DED SDUD (PLO\ FXDQGR TXHUtD KDFHU VHQWLU LQFyPRGD D (PLO\

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

RtGRTXHDOJXQRVQLxRVVHVXLFLGDURQVDOWDQGRGHHVR(OORVVDOSLFDURQMXVWRGRQGHHVWi ODEDUUD<RtTXHXQDSDFLHQWHDVHVLQyDXQDHQIHUPHUD 0D\DWRFyODPDQRGH(PLO\6XVGHGRVHVWDEDQUtJLGRV\IUtRVGHPXHUWH<FXDQGR GLRVXURVWURFRQHOGH(PLO\VXDOLHQWRROtDREVHVLYDPHQWHFRPRODJRPDGHEDQDQD ³(QWRQFHV¢GyQGHHVWiWXQRYLR"³0D\DFDQWXUUHR³¢2HVTXHXVWHGHVGRVWLHQHQ XQDSHOHD" (PLO\ UHWLUy OD PDQR VX FRUD]yQ JROSHDQGR FRQWUD VXV FRVWLOODV ¢0D\D OR VDEtD GH DOJXQDPDQHUDRTXHVLPSOHPHQWHORKDEtDDGLYLQDGR" ³
(VWDED GHPDVLDGR HVSHOX]QDQWH DTXt (PLO\ VH YROYLy SDUD LUVH FXLGDGRVDPHQWH PDQLREUDQGR DOUHGHGRU GH ODV SLODV GH OLEURV \ UHYLVWDV GH GLIXVLyQ SRU WRGR HO SLVR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

8QHQWDULPDGRFUXMLy(PLO\VHYROYLyKDFLDODSXHUWD\VHTXHGyPLUDQGR1DGD8QD VRPEUDSDVySRUODSDUHG(PLO\PLUyKDFLDHOWHFKRDJULHWDGR8QDDUDxDVHVHQWyHQ HO FHQWUR GH XQD UHG JUDQGH VLQXRVD +DEtD XQ FXHUSR QHJUR GH DOJR DWUDSDGR HQ OD VHGDWDOYH]XQDPRVFD

ʹͳͳ

'RFXPHQWRV VXHOWRV HVWDEDQ HVSDUFLGRV SRU HO VXHOR MXQWR FRQ XQD WD]D FRQ OiSLFHV SDWDV DUULED &DVL SDUHFtD TXH OD KDELWDFLyQ KDEtD VLGR GHOLEHUDGDPHQWH OD SDSHOHUD (PLO\UHFRUGyDO6HxRU&ROEHUWPHQFLRQDUTXHDOJXQDVSDUWHVGHOKRWHOQRKDEtDQVLGR UHQRYDGDVDWLHPSRSDUDODILHVWD7DOYH]VHWUDWDEDGHXQDRILFLQDGHVGHFXDQGRHVWH OXJDUHUDXQDHVFXHODRFRPR0D\DGLMRXQDFDVDGHORFRV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(QWRQFHVDOJROHOODPyODDWHQFLyQ(UDXQOLEURDELHUWRH[WHQGLGRDVXVSLHVXQDOLVWD GHQRPEUHVHVFULWRVFRQWLQWDGHFRORUD]XORVFXUR3DUHFtDFRPRXQWURQFR/DSiJLQD VHGLYLGtDHQFROXPQDVWLWXODGDV1RPEUH)HFKD(QWUDGD6DOLGD8QRGHORVQRPEUHV HUD (PLO\ VH DUURGLOOy SHQVDQGR FRQ OD HVSHUDQ]D GH TXH HOOD OR KXELHUD LPDJLQDGR 6X YLVLyQERUURVD ³2K'LRVPtR³VXVXUUy 8QRGHORVQRPEUHVHQHOOLEURHUD-DVRQ'L/DXUHQWLV 6XQRPEUHDSDUHFLyHQODSiJLQDWUHVYHFHVHQSULPHUOXJDUHOGHPDU]ROXHJRHO GHPDU]ROXHJRHOGHPDU]R6LHWHGtDVGHGLIHUHQFLD(PLO\SDVyXQDSiJLQD$Kt HVWDED HO QRPEUH GH -DVRQ GH QXHYR HO  GH PDU]R OXHJR  GH DEULO OXHJR  GH DEULO+DEtDHQWUDGRHQHOOLEURGHODPDxDQD\ODVHVLyQGHODWDUGH'LRODYXHOWDDODV SiJLQDV PiV UiSLGR \ PiV UiSLGR (O QRPEUH GH -DVRQ VHJXtD DSDUHFLHQGR 6H KDEtD UHJLVWUDGRHOGHDEULOHOFXPSOHDxRVGH(PLO\/DIHFKDHUDGHKDFHRFKRDxRV (PLO\GLRFXHQWDDWUiVKDEtDWHQLGRQXHYH+DEtDVLGRXQViEDGR(VHDxRVXVSDGUHV KDEtDQOOHYDGRD(PLO\\VXVDPLJRVGHOHTXLSRGHQDWDFLyQDXQDFHQDGHFXPSOHDxRV HQ£$OO7KDW-D]]VXDQWLJXRUHVWDXUDQWHIDYRULWRHQHOFHQWURFRPHUFLDO.LQJ-DPHV +DEtDHVWDGRHQHOWHUFHUJUDGR$OLKDEtDFRPHQ]DGRHQ5RVHZRRG'D\DSULQFLSLRV GHHVHDxRVXIDPLOLDVHPRYLyGHVGH&RQQHFWLFXW $JDUUyHOSUy[LPROLEURHQYLUWXGGHOPLVPR(OQRPEUHGH-DVRQDSDUHFLyGXUDQWHHO YHUDQRHQWUHHOWHUFHUR\FXDUWRJUDGRGH(PLO\HOLQYLHUQRGHVXFXDUWRDOILQDOGHVX TXLQWRSDUDHOYHUDQRHQWUHVXTXLQWR\VH[WR

ž‰‹ƒ

3DVy FRQ LQWHUpV HO SUy[LPR ILQ GH VHPDQD VREUH HO WLHPSR $OL VH KDEtD DFHUFDGR D WRGRV HOORV HQ 5RVHZRRG 'D\ SDUD OD SUHSDUDFLyQ GHO ODYDGR GH FRFKHV GH FDULGDG DXPHQWDQGR VXV QXHYRV DPLJRV 7RGDYtD QR DSDUHFtD -DVRQ 3DVy SRU GHODQWH 6X QRPEUHQRDSDUHFLyGHQXHYR(OILQGHVHPDQDGHVSXpVGHOSULPHUGtDGHFODVHVIXHOD ~OWLPDYH]TXHVXQRPEUHDSDUHFLyHQHOOLEURGHUHJLVWUR

ʹͳʹ

+DEtDHVWDGRDTXtHOILQGHVHPDQDGHVSXpVGHOSULPHUGtDGHFODVHVFXDQGR(PLO\$OL \ORVRWURVFRPHQ]DURQHOVH[WRJUDGR3RFRVGtDVGHVSXpVODHVFXHODKDEtDDQXQFLDGR ODSDWDGDGHVDOLGDGHOMXHJR/D&iSVXODGHO7LHPSR3DVyDODSiJLQDTXHUHJLVWUDEDHO SUy[LPR ILQ GH VHPDQD FXDQGR HOOD \ VXV YLHMDV DPLJDV HQWUDEDQ D HVFRQGLGDV HQ HO SDWLRWUDVHURGH$OLSDUDUREDUVXEDQGHUD(OQRPEUHGH-DVRQQRHVWDEDDOOt



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(PLO\EDMyHOOLEURDVXUHJD]RVLQWLpQGRVHPDUHDGD¢4XpGHPRQLRVKDFtDHOQRPEUH GH-DVRQ'L/DXUHQWLVHQXQOLEURHQHVWDRILFLQDRVFXUD\SRFRK~PHGD"3HQVyHQOD EURPD TXH $OL KDEtD KHFKR DxRV DWUiV TXH GHEtD SRQHUOR HQ OD VDOD GH HQIHUPRV PHQWDOHV D GRQGH SHUWHQHFH ¢6L KXELHUD VLGR JUDYH GHVSXpV GH WRGR" ¢-DVRQ IXH XQ DPEXODWRULRHQHVWDOLVWD" 7DO YH] HVWR IXH OR TXH $OL KDEtD TXHULGR GHFLU FXDQGR OH GLMR D -HQQD VREUH ORV SUREOHPDV HQWUH KHUPDQRV WDO YH] $OL OH GLMR TXH -DVRQ WHQtD SUREOHPDV SUREOHPDV WDQJUDQGHVTXHWHQtDTXHLUDXQFHQWURSDUDHOWUDWDPLHQWR<WDOYH]HVRHUDORTXH -HQQD\-DVRQHVWDEDQGLVFXWLHQGRODRWUDQRFKHTXHUtDDVHJXUDUVHGHTXH-HQQDQROH GLMRDXQDOPD 3HQVyHQFyPRODFDUDGH-DVRQVHKDEtDWRUFLGR\HQURMHFLGRFXDQGRSHQVyTXHKDEtD JROSHDGR VX FRFKH eO KDEtD VDOLGR WDQ FHUFD GH HOOD VX IXULD SDOSDEOH ¢'H TXp HUD UHDOPHQWHFDSD]-DVRQ"¢4XpHVFRQGtD-DVRQ" 6HR\HURQSDVRVHQHOSDVLOOR(PLO\VHFRQJHOy2\yODUHVSLUDFLyQGHDOJXLHQ/XHJR XQDVRPEUDDSDUHFLyHQODSXHUWD(PLO\FRPHQ]yDWHPEODU ³¢+KROD"³JUXxyHOOD ,VDDFVDOLyDODOX] /OHYDEDXQWUDMHGHFRFLQHUREODQFRFRQ]DSDWRVQHJURV(PLO\VXSXVRTXHVXSDGUHOH KDFtDWUDEDMDUHVWDQRFKHDKRUDTXHpOQRWHQtDXQDFLWD(OODVHHFKyKDFLDDWUiVVX FRUD]yQODWLHQGRIXHUWHPHQWH ³3HQVpTXHWHYLYHQLUDTXt³GLMR (PLO\PLUyHOOLEURGHQXHYRHVGLItFLOFDPELDUGHPDUFKDGH-DVRQD,VDDF (OODEDMyODFDEH]DLQFDSD]GHFXPSOLUFRQVXPLUDGD7RGRORTXHVHKDEtDQGLFKRHO XQRDORWURODQRFKHDQWHULRUVHPRYtDDWUDYpVGHVXFDEH]DGHPDVLDGRSUHVHQWH ³1RFUHRTXHVHVXSRQJDTXHGHEHVHVWDUDTXt³GLMR,VDDF³0LSDSiGLMRTXHHVWD VDODHVVyORSDUDHPSOHDGRV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³(VSHUD ³,VDDF VH VHQWy HQ HO EUD]R GHO VRIi GH FXHUR FRQ PXFKR SROYR 3DVDURQ DOJXQRVVHJXQGRVHQFDOPD6XVSLUy³¢/DLPDJHQGHODTXHPHKDEODVWHWHQtDODFDUD FRUWDGD"/DHQFRQWUpDQRFKH(QHOFDMyQGHEDVXUDHQODFRFLQD<\PHHQIUHQWpD PLPDPi(OODODSHUGLy

ʹͳ͵

³
6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

/D ERFD GH (PLO\ VH TXHGy ERTXLDELHUWD DSHQDV SRGtD FUHHU OR TXH RtD ,VDDF VDOWy GHVGHHOEUD]RGHOVRIi\VHDUURGLOOyDOODGRGH(PLO\ ³/R VLHQWR PXFKR ³VXVXUUy³ 6R\ XQ LGLRWD \ OD KH SHUGLGR SUREDEOHPHQWH ¢3XHGHVSHUGRQDUPH" (PLO\ PRUGLy HO LQWHULRU GH VX PHMLOOD 6DEtD TXH HOOD GHEtD VHQWLUVH ELHQ DKRUD R DO PHQRV MXVWLILFDGD SHUR HQ FDPELR VH VHQWtD D~Q SHRU 6HUtD WDQ IiFLO GHFLUOH D ,VDDF TXHHVWDEDELHQ(OORVHVWDEDQELHQ3HURORTXHKDEtDKHFKRD\HUHVWDEDPDO1RKDEtD FRQVLGHUDGR FUHHU HQ HOOD +DEtD VDOWDGR GH LQPHGLDWR D ODV FRQFOXVLRQHV VHJXUR GH TXHHVWDEDPLQWLHQGR 6H DSDUWy GH pO VH DJDFKy \ UHFRJLy HO OLEUR JUDQGH /D FXELHUWD GHO OLEUR HVWDED FXELHUWDGHHVSHVRSROYR\KROOtQ ³
ž‰‹ƒ

ʹͳͶ

%DMy FRUULHQGR ODV HVFDOHUDV WDQ UiSLGR FRPR SXGR (Q HO UHOODQR R\y XQD ULVLWD IDPLOLDU GHVGH HO RWUR ODGR GH OD KDELWDFLyQ (OOD FRQWXYR HO HVWyPDJR PLUDQGR QHUYLRVDPHQWHDOUHGHGRU(OS~EOLFRFDPELy\VHGLVLSyODULVD/D~QLFDSHUVRQDTXH (PLO\ KDEtD UHFRQRFLGR HQ WRGR HO VDOyQ GH EDLOH HUD 0D\D (VWDED GH SLH FRQWUD OD SDUHGFRQXQPDUWLQL\PLUDQGRILMDPHQWHD(PLO\XQVXVXUURGHXQDVRQULVDHQORV ODELRVDQFKRV\EULOODQWHV 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR 'pMjYX«UHYHODGR 'pMjYX«UHYHODGR 7UDGXFLGRSRU'DQL &RUUHJLGRSRU9DQ  

+

DQQDSDWLQyWUDYpVGHOUHVEDODGL]RSLVRGHPiUPROOOHJDQGRDXQILQDO(VWH KRWHOHUDXQODEHULQWR\GHDOJ~QPRGRVHODVKDEtDDUUHJODGRSDUDUHFRUGDU VXV SDVRV \ HVWDED GH SLH HQ IUHQWH GHO WDSL] GH 1DSROHyQ TXH LED GHVGH HO VXHORKDVWDHOWHFKRRWUDYH]0LUyGHODGHUHFKDKDFLDODL]TXLHUGDEXVFDQGRD0LNH /DPXOWLWXGGHODILHVWDHUDWDQHVSHVDTXHQRORYHtDHQQLQJXQDSDUWH 3DVy OD KDELWDFLyQ GHO WURQR \ HVFXFKy XQD YR] IDPLOLDU 'HQWUR HVWDED 1RHO .DKQ KDFLHQGRGHFRUWLQDVREUHHOODUJRWURQRGHWHUFLRSHORVXVKRPEUHVVDFXGLpQGRVHSRUOD ULVD &RQ XQ FXER GH FKDPSDxD GDGR YXHOWD VREUH VX FDEH]D LPSURYLVDQGR XQD FRURQD +DQQD JLPLy (UD LQFUHtEOH TXH 1RHO SXGLHUD HVFDEXOOLUVH HQ WRGDV ODV ILHVWDV GH 5RVHZRRGVyORSRUTXHVXVSDGUHVILQDQFLDURQODFLXGDG 6XELyKDVWD GRQGHHVWDED\OHHPSXMyHOEUD]RHQHOGHGR1RHOVHGLRODYXHOWD\VH LOXPLQy ³£+DQQD³2OtDFRPRVLKXELHUDEHELGRXQDEDxHUDHQWHUDGHWHTXLOD ³¢'yQGHHVWi0LNH"

1RHOOHWLUyVXVSLHUQDVVREUHODVLOOD6XVSDQWDORQHVVHVXELHURQOLJHUDPHQWHUHYHODQGR XQRVFDOFHWLQHVFRQGLVHxRGHURPERVD]XOHV\URMRV ³1RORVp3HURGHEHUtDEHVDUWH

ʹͳͷ

8JK ³¢3RUTXp"

ž‰‹ƒ

³3RUTXH³GLMRDUUDVWUDQGRODYR]³0HKLFLVWHJDQDUTXLQLHQWRVGyODUHV 5HWURFHGLyXQRVSDVRV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³¢'LVFXOSD" 1RHO OOHYy VX EHELGD GH FyFWHO URML]D TXH VH SDUHFtD XQ PRQWyQ D XQD 5HG %XOO FRQ YRGNDKDFLDVXVODELRV/tTXLGRJRWHySRUVXFDPLVD\VHMXQWyHQODSDUWHGHDEDMRGH OD VLOOD 8QDV FKLFDV GH OD HVFXHOD 4XDNHU VHQWDGDV VREUH ODV EDQTXHWDV SDUD ORV SLHV WDSL]DGDV FRQ FDFKHPLUD VH GLHURQ FRGD]RV ODV XQDV D ODV RWUDV ULHQGR WRQWDPHQWH ¢&yPRSRGtDQSHQVDUTXH1RHOHUDFDOLHQWH"6LHVWHIXHUDUHDOPHQWH9HUVDOOHV1RHOQR VHUtD/XLV;,96HUtDODYHUVLyQIUDQFHVDGHXQLGLRWDGHOSXHEOR ³7RGRHOHTXLSRGHODFURVVHWHQtDXQDDSXHVWDVREUHDTXLpQ0LNHSRGUtDFRQVHJXLU TXH OR OOHYDUD D OD JUDGXDFLyQ ³H[SOLFy 1RHO³ 7~ R WX KHUPDQDVWUD FDOLHQWH +LFLPRVODDSXHVWDGHVSXpVTXHFRPHQ]DURQDWLUDUVHDVtPLVPDVHQFLPDGHpO9R\D GDUOHODPLWDGGHPLVJDQDQFLDVD0LNHSRUVHUXQEXHQGHSRUWLVWD +DQQDSDVyVXVPDQRVSRUVXSLH]DGHODEDQGHUDGH/D&iSVXODGHO7LHPSRODTXH KDEtDDPDUUDGRDODFDGHQDGHVXEROVR&KDQHO6LQWLyHOFRORUGUHQDUVHGHVXURVWUR 1RHOPRYLyVXFDEH]DKDFLDODSXHUWD ³6LQRPHFUHHVSUHJ~QWDOHD0LNHWXPLVPD +DQQD VH GLR OD YXHOWD 0LNH HVWDED DSR\DGR FRQWUD XQD GH ODV FROXPQDV GH HVWLOR JULHJRVRQULHQGRKDFLDXQDFKLFDGHODSUHSDUDWRULD7DWH +DQQD VROWy XQ EDMR JUXxLGR \ FDPLQR HQ OtQHD UHFWD KDFLD pO &XDQGR 0LNH OD YLR VRQULyWtPLGDPHQWH ³¢7XV FRPSDxHURV DSRVWDURQ VREUH QRVRWURV" ³FKLOOy +DQQD /D FKLFD GH 7DWH UiSLGDPHQWHVHDOHMyGHXQVDOWR0LNHEHELyVXYLQRHQFRJLpQGRVHGHKRPEURV ³1RHVGLIHUHQWHGHORTXHXVWHGHVHVWDEDQKDFLHQGR$H[FHSFLyQTXHORVFKLFRVGHO HTXLSR GH ODFURVVH HVWDEDQ MXJDQGR SRU GLQHUR ¢3RU TXp HVWDEDQ MXJDQGR XVWHGHV" ¢7DPSRQHV"

ʹͳ͸

+DQQDSDVyVXPDQRSRUVREUHVXIUHQWH(VWRQRHVWDEDSDVDQGRFRPRVHVXSRQtDTXH ORKLFLHUD0LNHVHVXSRQtDTXHWHQtDTXHVHUYXOQHUDEOH\GpELOXQDYtFWLPD<WRGRHO WLHPSR pO KDEtD VDELGR TXH HOODV KDEtDQ HVWDGR FRPSLWLHQGR 7RGR HO WLHPSR KDEtD HVWDGRMXJDQGRFRQHOOD 6XVSLUyFDQVDGD

ž‰‹ƒ

³(QWRQFHV¢VXSRQJRTXHQXHVWUDFLWDSDUDODILHVWDGHJUDGXDFLyQGHFDQFHOD" 0LNHSDUHFtDVRUSUHQGLGR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³1RTXHUtDHVR +DQQDEXVFyVXURVWUR ³¢'HYHUGDG"³0LNHVDFXGLyVXFDEH]D³(QWRQFHV«¢QRWHLPSRUWDTXHVyORIXHUD DOJXQD«DSXHVWD" 0LNHOHHFKyXQYLVWD]RWtPLGDPHQWHOXHJRDSDUWyODPLUDGD ³1RVLDWLQRWHLPSRUWD +DQQDKL]RVXPi[LPRHVIXHU]RSDUDHVFRQGHUVXVRQULVD\VXDOLYLR/HGLRXQFRGD]R FRQIXHU]DHQODVFRVWLOODV ³%XHQRHVPHMRUTXHPHGHVODPLWDGGHWXVJDQDQFLDV ³<HVPHMRUTXHPHGHVODPLWDGGHWXV«³0LNHVHGHWXYRKDFLHQGRXQDPXHFD³ 1RLPSRUWD1RQHFHVLWRODPLWDGGHWXVWDPSRQHV8VDUHPRVODVJDQDQFLDVSDUDXQD ERWHOOD GH &ULVWDO SDUD OD JUDGXDFLyQ ¢WH SDUHFH ELHQ" ³< HQWRQFHV VH LOXPLQy D~Q PiV³<SDUDXQDKDELWDFLyQGHXQPRWHO ³¢8QPRWHO"³+DQQDORPLUy³¢4XpFODVHGHFKLFDSLHQVDVTXHVR\" ³&DULxR FRQPLJR QR WH LPSRUWDUi GyQGH HVWHPRV ³GLMR 0LNH FRQ OD YR] PiV EDERVD TXH +DQQD QXQFD KDEtD HVFXFKDGR 6XSULPLy XQ JHPLGR LQFOLQiQGRVH KDFLD pOeOVHLQFOLQyKDFLDHOODWDPELpQKDVWDTXHVXVIUHQWHVVHWRFDURQ ³¢+RQHVWDPHQWH" ³VXVXUUy 0LNH VX YR] VXDYL]iQGRVH \ YROYLpQGRVH FDVL WLHUQD³ 6LHPSUHPHKDVJXVWDGRPiVW~



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³£
ʹͳ͹

(OLQWHULRUGH+DQQDGLRYXHOWD9HUWLJLQRVRVWHPEORUHVFRUUHWHDURQSRUVXHVSDOGD6XV FDUDVHVWDEDQPX\FHUFDFRQVyORXQDSHTXHxDFROXPQDGHDLUHFROJDQGRHQWUHHOORV (QWRQFHV0LNHVHPRYLyKDFLDGHODQWH\DSDUWyHOFDEHOORGHORVRMRVGH+DQQD+DQQD VROWyXQDULVLWDQHUYLRVD6XVODELRVVHHQFRQWUDURQ/DERFDGH0LNHHUDFiOLGD\VDEtD FRPRDYLQRWLQWR+RUPLJXHRVVHGLVSDUDURQSRUODFDEH]DGH+DQQDKDVWDWRGRVORV GHGRVGHVXVSLHV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

+XER XQ DOWR FUXMLGR GH HVWiWLFD \ XQD UiSLGD \ DOHJUH FDQFLyQ UHVRQy SRU ORV DOWDYRFHV+DQQDVHDVRPyDOEDOFyQ/DVHFFLyQGHODRUTXHVWDKDEtDGHVDSDUHFLGR\ KDEtDXQDFDELQDGH'MHQVXOXJDU(O'MHVWDEDYHVWLGRFRQXQDODUJDSHOXFDULVDGDDO HVWLORGH/XLV;,9SDQWDORQHVDJOREDGRV\XQDODUJDW~QLFD ³¢0HSHUPLWHV"³SUHJXQWy0LNHRIUHFLpQGROHVXPDQR +DQQDVHGHWXYR\ORVLJXLy$WUDYpVGHOVDOyQGHEDLOH1DRPL5LOH\\.DWHHVWDEDQ VHQWDGDV HQ XQ VLOOyQ REVHUYDQGR 1DRPL OXFtD PROHVWD SHUR .DWH \ 5LOH\ WHQtDQ SHTXHxDV VRQULVDV VREUH VXV URVWURV FDVL FRPR VL HVWXYLHUDQ IHOLFHV SRU +DQQD 'HVSXpV GH XQ PRPHQWR +DQQD OH GLVSDUy GH UHJUHVR XQD SHTXHxD VRQULVD D .DWH 4XLpQVDEtDWDOYH].DWHUHDOPHQWHTXHUtDTXHIXHUDQDPLJDV7DOYH]+DQQDWDPELpQ SRGtDGHMDUORSDVDGRHQHOSDVDGR 0LNH HPSH]y D UHWRUFHUVH D VX DOUHGHGRU SUiFWLFDPHQWH IROOiQGROH OD SLHUQD \ OR HPSXMy OHMRV ULpQGRVH &XDQGR OD FDQFLyQ WHUPLQy HO 'M VH LQFOLQy KDFLD HO PLFUyIRQR ³$FHSWRSHWLFLRQHV³GLMRFRQXQDYR]VXDYH ³$TXtKD\XQD 7RGRVVHFRQJHODURQHQDQWLFLSDFLyQ8QRVDFRUGHVOOHQDURQHODLUH(OULWPRHUDPiV OHQWRPiVDSDJDGR0LNHKL]RJHVWRVFRQVXPDQR ³¢4XpSHUGHGRUDSHWLFLyQHVHVD"³6HEXUOyFDPLQDQGRKDFLDODFDELQDGHO'MSDUD DYHULJXDUOR $OJXQDV QRWDV OOHQDURQ OD KDELWDFLyQ +DQQD VH GHWXYR OHYDQWDQGR VX FDEH]D 5HFRQRFtDDOFDQWDQWHSHURQRVDEtDSRUTXH 0LNHHVWDEDGHUHJUHVR ³(VDOJXLHQOODPDGR(OYLV&RVWHOOR³DQXQFLy³4XLpQTXLHUDTXHVHD

/DERFDGH+DQQDFD\yDELHUWD6DEtDSRUTXHHVWDFDQFLyQOHHUDIDPLOLDUXQRVPHVHV DWUiVDOJXLHQKDEtDHVWDGRFDQWiQGRODHQVXGXFKD

ž‰‹ƒ

$OOLVRQPLREMHWLYRHVYHUGDGHUR«

ʹͳͺ

(OYLV &RVWHOOR $O PLVPR WLHPSR FRPHQ]y HO FRUR $OOOLVRQ Vp TXH HVWH PXQGR WH HVWiPDWDQGR«



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&XDQGR+DQQDHPHUJLyHQHOSDVLOORHVHGtDYLRD:LOGHQHQYXHOWRHQVXWRDOODEODQFD 3RWWHU\%DUQIDYRULWD :LOGHQKDEtDOXFLGRVRUSUHQGLGR&XDQGR+DQQDOHSUHJXQWySRUTXHHVWDEDFDQWDQGR HVDFDQFLyQVyORXQDSHUVRQDGHPHQWHFDQWDUtDHVRGHQWURGHFLHQPLOODVFXDGUDGDVGH 5RVHZRRGHQHVRVGtDV:LOGHQVHKDEtDSXHVWRURMR ³$YHFHVQRPHGR\FXHQWDORTXHHVWR\FDQWDQGR 8QD FKLVSD SLOOy HO IXHJR HQ HO FHUHEUR GH +DQQD £$ YHFHV QR PH GR\ FXHQWD GH OR TXH HVWR\ FDQWDQGR $OL OH KDEtD GLFKR HVR HQ HO VXHxR HVWD PDxDQD 7DPELpQ KDEtD GLFKRVLORHQFXHQWUDVWHGLUpVREUHHVR/RVGRVGHHOORV¢$OLHVWDEDWUDWDQGRGHGHFLU TXH:LOGHQHVWDEDGHDOJ~QPRGRYLQFXODGRFRQHODVHVLQDWRGH$OL" <HQWRQFHVODVHQVDFLyQGHGpMjYXTXHKDEtDWHQLGRFXDQGR:LOGHQVHKDEtDUHWLUDGR GHOFDPLQRGHHQWUDGDYROYLyGHXQJROSHDHOOD(UDSRUHOFRFKHGH:LOGHQODYLHMD FRVDQHJUDTXHHVWDEDFRQGXFLHQGRDOUHGHGRUPLHQWUDVVXSDWUXOODHVWDEDHQODWLHQGD +DEtDYLVWRHVHFRFKHDQWHVKDFHPXFKRVDxRV(UDHOFRFKHHVWDFLRQDGRHQODFDVDGH ORV'L/DXUHQWLVHOGtDTXH+DQQD\ODVRWUDVKDEtDQWUDWDGRGHUREDUODEDQGHUDGH$OL ³¢+DQQD"³GLMR0LNHPLUiQGRODFRQFXULRVLGDG³¢(VWiVELHQ" +DQQD VDFXGLy VX FDEH]D OLJHUDPHQWH (O VXHxR GH $OL VHUSHQWHy HQ VX PHQWH 9H D SHVFDUKDEtDGLFKR$OLXQD\RWUDYH]FXDQGR+DQQDOHKDEtDSUHJXQWDGRVREUHTXLpQ HVWDEDKDEODQGR/DVSDODEUDVHUDQSRU:LOGHQ«\+DQQDWDPELpQHQWHQGLyHVR(VD SHJDWLQDHQODJXDQWHUDHOTXHWHQtDHOORJRGHSHVFDVREUHpO+DQQDVDEtDGRQGHOR KDEtD YLVWR SRU XOWLPR ORV 'L/DXUHQWLV WHQtD XQR H[DFWDPHQWH FRPR HVH (O SDVH OHV JDUDQWL]DED DFFHVR D VX FRPXQLGDG FHUUDGD HQ ORV 3RFRQRV ¢3HUR HQWRQFHV TXp" 8Q PRQWyQGHSHUVRQDVYDFDFLRQDEDQDKtWDOYH]ODIDPLOLDGH:LOGHQWDPELpQORKDFtD ¢3RU TXp :LOGHQ KDEtD WUDWDGR GH HVFRQGHU OD SHJDWLQD" ¢3RU TXp KDEtD VLGR WDQ PLVWHULRVRVREUHHVR"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³¢4XpHV"³VHJXtDSUHJXQWDGR0LNH 1HJy FRQODFDEH]DLQFDSD] GHFRQWHVWD7DO YH] :LOGHQ WHQtD XQ VHFUHWR +DEtD HVWDGR DFWXDQGR WDQ H[WUDxR ~OWLPDPHQWH 0HURGHDQGRDOUHGHGRU7HQLHQGRVLOHQFLRVDVFRQYHUVDFLRQHVHQVXWHOpIRQRPyYLO1R HVWDQGR GRQGH GHFtD TXH HVWDUtD 7DQ UiSLGR SDUD FXOSDU D ODV FKLFDV SRU OD GHVDSDULFLyQ GH ,DQ (VWDQGR D KXUWDGLOODV DOUHGHGRU GHO DQWLJXR SDWLR GH $OL &RQGXFLHQGR FRPR XQ PDQLiWLFR SDUD OOHYDU D +DQQD D FDVD SUiFWLFDPHQWH

ʹͳͻ

$ PHQRV TXH :LOGHQ QHFHVLWDUD TXH IXHUD XQ VHFUHWR +DQQD VH WDPEDOHy HQFRYDGDPHQWHDODVLOODPiVFHUFDQD\VHKXQGLyHQHOOD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

PDWiQGROD8VDQGRHVDFDSXFKDFRPRODILJXUDTXHVHKDEtDFHUQLGRVREUH+DQQDHQ HO ERVTXH OD QRFKH TXH KDEtDQ GHVFXELHUWR HO FXHUSR GH ,DQ 7DO YH] pO HUD OD ILJXUD ¢4XpVLWHGLJRTXHKD\DOJRTXHQRVDEHV"/HKDEtDGLFKR,DQD6SHQFHUHQVXSRUFKH $OJRJUDQGH &UHR TXH ORV SROLFtDV VDEHQ VREUH HVR WDPELpQ SHUR OR HVWiQ LJQRUDQGR (VWiQ WUDWDQGR GH FXOSDUPH < HQWRQFHV VXV PHQVDMHV 'HVFXEULHURQ TXH OR Vp 7XYH TXH HVFDSDU (OVDOyQGHEDLOHJLUDEDFRQSHUVRQDV+DEtDQJXDUGLDVGHVHJXULGDGHQFDGDHQWUDGD\ PiVTXHXQRVSRFRSROLFtDVGH5RVHZRRGSHUR:LOGHQQRHVWDEDHQWUHHOORV/XHJRHQ HOUHIOHMRGHXQRGHORVHVSHMRVGHOSLVRKDVWDHOWHFKRDWUDSyODPLUDGDGH+DQQD9LR XQDFDUDIDPLOLDUFRQRMRVD]XOHV\SHORUXELR+DQQDVHSXVRUtJLGD(UDOD$OLGHVX VXHxR 3HUR FXDQGR PLUy RWUD YH] OD FDUD KDEtD FDPELDGR .LUVWHQ &XOOHQ HVWDED HQ FDPELR 0LNHWRGDYtDHVWDEDPLUDQGRILMDPHQWHD+DQQDVXVRMRVDPSOLRV\DVXVWDGRV ³7HQJRTXHLUDHQFRQWUDUDWXKHUPDQD³GLMRWRFDQGRVXPDQR³3HURYROYHUp/R SURPHWR < HQWRQFHV VH GLVSDUy D WUDYpV GHO VDOyQ GH EDLOH 'H DFXHUGR DOJXLHQ HVWDED HVFRQGLHQGRDOJR<HVWDYH]QRSRGtDDFXGLUDORVSROLFtDVSRUD\XGD

ž‰‹ƒ

ʹʹͲ





)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR 0iVHVSHOX]QDQWH\PiVHVSHOX]QDQWH 0iVHVSHOX]QDQWH\PiVHVSHOX]QDQWH 7UDGXFLGRSRU5XWKLHH &RUUHJLGRSRU9DQ  

3

DUDHOPRPHQWRHQTXH$ULDILQDOPHQWHOXFKyDWUDYpVGHODPDUDxDGHWUiILFR HQ OtQHD SDUD DSDUFDU HQ OD HQWUDGD GHO 5DGOH\ WHQtD PiV GH XQD KRUD GH UHWUDVR 7LUy ODV OODYHV DO PR]R GHO KRWHO \ EXVFy HQ HO JUXSR GH JRULODV SHUVRQDV TXH LEDQ D OD ILHVWD IRUPDOPHQWH YHVWLGDV \ IRWyJUDIRV SHUR (PLO\ HOOD QR HVWDEDHQQLQJ~QODGR 'HVSXpV GH TXH -DVRQ KXELHUD HQFRQWUDGR D $ULD HQ VX GHSDUWDPHQWR PiV WHPSUDQR KR\ \ OH H[LJLHUD TXH VH IXHUD $ULD QR KDEtD VDELGR TXH KDFHU )LQDOPHQWH KDEtD FRQGXFLGRDOFHPHQWHULRGH6W%DVLO\FDPLQySRUODVFROLQDVKDFLDODWXPEDGH$OL /DXOWLPDYH]TXH$ULDKDEtDHVWDGRDTXtHODWD~GGH$OLQRHVWDEDD~QHQHOVXHORHO 6U \ OD 6UD 'L/DXUHQWLV KDEtDQ UHWHQLGR HO HQWHUUDUOD QHJDQGR TXH VX KLMD HVWXYLHUD YHUGDGHUDPHQWHPXHUWD<DSHVDUGHTXHODHYLGHQFLDGHO$'1QRKDEtDLGHQWLILFDGR TXH HQ YHUGDG HUD HO FXHUSR GH $OL HQ HO KR\R PHGLR H[FDYDGR HQ HO SDWLR GH ORV 'L/DXUHQWLV OD IDPLOLD GHELy GH KDEHU DIURQWDGR OD UHDOLGDG SRUTXH $ULD KDEtD HVFXFKDGRTXHHOORVILQDOPHQWHKDEtDQHQWHUUDGRD$OLWUDQTXLODPHQWHHOPHVSDVDGR VLQXQDFHUHPRQLD

³¢7LHQHV XQD LQYLWDFLyQ" ³SUHJXQWy FRQ VX YR] QDVDO \ FRQGHVFHQGLHQWH $ULD SUHVHQWR OD LQYLWDFLyQ TXH (OOD OH KDEtD HQYLDGR \ OD FKLFD DVLQWLy 7LUDQGR GH VX



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

8QDFKLFDHQXQYHVWLGRDSUHWDGRGHWXERGHWXYRD$ULDHQODVJUDQGHVGREOHVSXHUWDV GHODHQWUDGD

ʹʹͳ

$OLVRQ /DXUHQ 'L/DXUHQWLV GHFtD OD ODSLGD PRUWXRULD +DEtD XQD QXHYD FDSD GH FpVSHGIUHVFDPHQWHSODQWDGRDOUHGHGRUGHOVLWLRGHODWXPED\DUtJLGR\KHODGRSRUHO IUtR$ULDVHTXHGyYLHQGRGXUDPHQWHDODORVDGHPiUPROGHVHDQGRTXH$OLSXGLHUD KDEODU (OOD TXHUtD GHFLUOH D $OL DFHUFD GHO DQXDULR TXH KDEtD HQFRQWUDGR HQ HO GHSDUWDPHQWR GH -DVRQ 4XHUtD SUHJXQWDU DFHUFD GH OD LQVFULSFLyQ TXH :LOGHQ KDEtD HVFULWR VREUH OD LPDJHQ GH ,DQ ¢4Xp KDEtD KHFKR ,DQ TXH HUD WDQ WHUULEOH" ¢< TXH WH KDEtDSDVDGR"¢4XpQRVDEtDPRV"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

DEULJR DOUHGHGRU GH VX FLQWXUD $ULD EDMR D JUDQGHV SDVRV HQ OD HQWUDGD GH SLHGUD \ HQWUyHQHOKRWHO8QPRQWyQGHFKLFRVGHO5RVHZRRG'D\LQFOX\HQGRD1RHO.DKQ 0DVRQ %\HUV 6HDQ $FNDUG \ 1DRPL =HLJOHU HVWDEDQ HQ OD SLVWD GH EDLOH GDQGR YXHOWDV DOUHGHGRU GH OD PH]FOD GH FDQFLyQ GH 6HDO 'HVSXpV GH DJDUUDU XQD IODXWD GH FKDPSDxD \ EDMiQGROD HQ XQRV SRFRV UiSLGRV WUDJRV FRPHQ]y D ODQ]DUVH VREUH ORV JUXSRVGHJHQWHEXVFDQGRD(PLO\7HQtDTXHGHFLUOHDFHUFDGHODQXDULR &XDQGRVLQWLyXQWRTXHFLWRHQVXKRPEURHOODVHYROWHR ³£/RORJUDVWH³(OODFKLOOyGiQGROHD$ULDXQJUDQDEUD]R ³++ROD³$ULDWUDWyGHVRQUHtU(OODXVDEDXQDEULJRGHHQFDMHGHFRORUYHUGHPDU HQYXHOWRDOUHGHGRUGHVXVKRPEURV\XQDHOHJDQWHIXQGDGHVHGDQHJUR;DYLHUHVWDED MXVWRDOODGRGHHOOD(OYHVWtDXQWUDMHGHUD\DGLSORPiWLFDVREUHXQDFDPLVDD]XOGH FRQODVSXQWDVGHOFXHOORDERWRQDGDV\VRVWHQtDXQDFRSDGHFKDPSDxD ³(QFDQWDGRGHYHUWHGHQXHYR$ULD³/RVRMRVGH;DYLHUVHPRYLHURQGHORVRMRVGH $ULDDVXVWHWDVGHVSXpVDVXVFDGHUDV/RVLQWHULRUHVGH$ULDFRDJXODURQ ³¢&yPRHVWiODYLGDHQODFDVDGHWXSDGUH" ³%LHQJUDFLDV³$ULDGLMRUtJLGDPHQWH7UDWyGHGLVSDUDUOHD(OODXQDSULYDGDPLUDGD VXSOLFDQWHSHURORVRMRVGHVXPDGUHHVWDEDQYLGULRVRV$ULDVHSUHJXQWyVLHOODKDEtD WRPDGR XQ SDU GH WUDJRV DQWHV GH TXH OOHJDUD (OOD D PHQXGR KDFLD HVR DQWHV GH XQ HVSHFWiFXOR (OSDGUHGH1RHO.DKQGLRXQJROSHFLWRHQHOKRPEURGH(OOD\ODPDGUHGH$ULDVH YROYLy SDUD KDEODU FRQ pO ;DYLHU VH PRYLy PiV FHUFD GH $ULD \ SXVR VX PDQR HQ VX FDGHUD ³7HKHH[WUDxDGR³GLMR6XDOLHQWRHVWDEDFDOLHQWH\ROtDDZKLVNH\ ³¢0HKDVH[WUDxDGR"

(OODYLQRDGHWHQHUVHHQIUHQWHGHXQDYLGULHUDTXHSUHVHQWDEDXQUHWUDWRGHXQMXJODU FDUD GH WDUWD \ VX OD~G &XDQGR VLQWLy XQ VHJXQGR WLUyQ HQ VX EUD]R VH HQFRJLy SUHRFXSDGD GH TXH ;DYLHU OD KXELHUD VHJXLGR 3HUR VyOR HUD (PLO\ 8QRV SRFRV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³¢$ULD"³+DEtDGRORU\GHFHSFLyQHQVXYR]3HUR$ULDVLJXLyDGHODQWH

ʹʹʹ

³7HQJRTXHLUPHDKRUD³$ULDGLMRHQYR]DOWDVLQWLHQGRHOFRORUOHYDQWiQGRVHHQVXV PHMLOODV (OOD VDOLy GLVSDUDGD OHMRV GH ;DYLHU UiSLGR HVTXLYDQGR DOUHGHGRU GH XQD PXMHUHQXQDHVSRQMRVDHVWRODGHYLVyQ(VFXFKyD(OODOODPDUOD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

PHFKRQHV GH VX FDEHOOR GRUDGR URML]R VH KDEtDQ FDtGR GH VX WUHQ]D IUDQFHVD \ VXV PHMLOODVHVWDEDQVRQURMDGDV ³7HKHHVWDGREXVFDQGRSRUWRGDVSDUWHV³(PLO\H[FODPy ³$FDERGHOOHJDU³$ULDGLMR³(OWUiILFRHVWDEDKRUULEOH (PLO\VDFyXQODUJROLEURYHUGHSROYRULHQWRSRUGHEDMRGHVXEUD]R6XVSiJLQDVHUDQ GHSULPHUDFODVH\OHUHFRUGyD$ULDDXQYROXPHQGHXQDHQFLFORSHGLD ³0LUD HVWR ³(PLO\ OR DEULy \ DSXQWR D XQ QRPEUH HQ FXUVLYD -DVRQ 'L/DXUHQWLV +DEtDXQDIHFKD\KRUDMXQWRDVXQRPEUHGHVGHKDFHVLHWHDxRV ³/RHQFRQWUpDUULEDHQHOSLVRVXSHULRU³(PLO\H[SOLFy³(VWRGHEHVHUXQOLEURGH UHJLVWURVGHFXDQGRHVWHOXJDUHUDXQKRVSLWDOPHQWDO $ULDSDUSDGHyHQLQFUHGXOLGDG(OODOHYDQWyVXFDEH]DPLUDQGRDOUHGHGRU8QDSXHVWR KRPEUHFDQRVRSUREDEOHPHQWHHOGXHxRGHOKRWHOVHGHVOL]yDWUDYpVGHODPXOWLWXG YLpQGRVHVDWLVIHFKRFRQVXREUD+DEtDSDQWDOODVHQWRGRHOVDOyQGHEDLOHGHVFULELHQGR HOJLPQDVLRPXOWLPLOORQDULRTXHKDEtDVLGRFRQVWUXLGRHQHOVHJXQGRSLVR\HOHVWDGR GHODVLQVWDODFLRQHVDODYDQJXDUGLDGHOVSD+DEtDHVFXFKDGRDOJRGHHVWHOXJDUVLHQGR XQKRVSLWDOQLxRVPHQWDOPHQWHHQIHUPRVSHRUHUDGLItFLOFUHHUHVRDKRUD ³0LUD ³(PLO\ KRMHy SiJLQD SRU SiJLQD³ (O QRPEUH GH -DVRQ HVWD DTXt \ OXHJR DTXt \ GHVSXpV DTXt 6LJXH DVt SRU DxRV 6H GHWLHQH MXVWR DQWHV GH TXH QRV DYHQWXUiUDPRVSRUODEDQGHUDGH$OL³(PLO\EDMyHOOLEURDVXFDGHUDGiQGROHD$ULD XQDPLUDGDODVWLPHUD ³6HTXHVLHQWHV DOJRSRU-DVRQ3HRUHVWRHVUDUR ¢1RFUHHV TXHWDO YH]pOHUD«XQ SDFLHQWH"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³2K 'LRV PtR ³$ULD JUD]Qy³ ´$µ PH PDQGy XQ PHQVDMH KDFH XQ SDU GH GtDV 'HFtD TXH -DVRQ HVWDED HVFRQGLHQGR DOJR GH Pt \ TXH QR TXHUtD VDEHU TXH HUD (Q FLHUWR PRGR« OR LJQRUp ³%DMy VXV RMRV³ 3HQVp TXH ´$µ VH HVWDED PHWLHQGR FRQPLJR3HUR«\R«\RVDOtFRQ-DVRQXQSDUGHYHFHV(QXQDGHQXHVWUDVFLWDVVH SXVRUHDOPHQWHLQFRPRGRFXDQGROHGLMHTXHLEDDYHQLUDXQDILHVWDDTXt7DPELpQPH GLMRTXHHOYLRDXQSVLTXLDWUDHQ5RVHZRRG'D\7DOYH]HVRHUDDGHPiVGHOGRFWRU

ʹʹ͵

$ULDUHFRUULyVXVPDQRVDWUDYpVGHODLUH¢(UDHVWDXQDHVSHFLDGHEURPD"-DVRQKDEtD SUHJXQWDGR FXDQGR $ULD OH KDEtD PRVWUDGR OD LQYLWDFLyQ 5DGOH\ 6X FRUD]yQ VH KXQGLy7DOYH]pOXQDYH]KDEtDVLGRXQDSDFLHQWHDTXt7DOYH]HOSHQVyTXH$ULDVH HVWDED EXUODQGR FRQ OD LQYLWDFLyQ SDUDQRLFR GH TXH $ULD VXSLHUD PiV VREUH pO GH OR TXHHOODKDEtDVROWDGR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

TXHYLR«DTXt³6HTXHGyYLHQGRDOOLEURRWUDYH](OQRPEUHGH-DVRQHVWDEDHVFULWR HQGRORURVDPHQWHFRQOHWUDFODUDFXUVLYDFDGDOHWUDIRUPDQGRXQOD]RFRQVWDQWH (PLO\DVLQWLy ³< KH HVWDGR WUDWDQGR GH GHFLUWH WRGR HO GtD TXH ´$µ PH PDQGR XQD QRWD DQRFKH GLFLpQGRPH TXH YD\D DO DQWLJXR YHFLQGDULR GH $OL 9L D -DVRQ HQ OD FDVD GH -HQQD *ULWiQGROH $ULDVHKXQGLyHQXQDVLOODGHWHUFLRSHORMXQWRDODYLGULHUDOOHQDFRQD~QPiVWHUURU ³¢4XpHVWDEDQGLFLHQGR" (PLO\VDFXGLyVXFDEH]D ³1R OR Vp 3HUR HOORV SDUHFtDQ DOWHUDGRV 7DO YH] pO HQ YHUGDG OH KDEtD KHFKR DOJR WHUULEOHD$OL\HVRHVHOSRUTXHIXHPDQGDGRDTXt $ULDVHTXHGyYLHQGRDEDMRDOVXHxRGHPiUPROSXOLGR3RGtDYHUXQUHIOHMRDXUHRODGR GH VX YHVWLGR D]XO HOpFWULFR HQ ORV FXDGURV 7RGD OD VHPDQD FRPSOHWD $ULD KDEtD HVWDGRWDQHQRMDGDFRQ(PLO\FRQYHQFLGDGHTXHQRHVWDEDPLUDQGRDODVLWXDFLyQGH $OL\-DVRQREMHWLYDPHQWH3HURWDOYH]$ULDWDPSRFRORHVWDED (PLO\VXVSLUy ³3UREDEOHPHQWHGHEHUtDPRVKDEODUGHHVWRFRQ:LOGHQ ³1RSRGHPRVLUFRQ:LOGHQ³XQDYR]LQWHUUXPSLy $PEDVVHYROWHDURQ+DQQDVHSDURGHWUiVGHHOODVXQDFDQVDGDPLUDGDHQVXURVWUR ³:LOGHQHVOD~OWLPDSHUVRQDFRQODTXHGHEHUtDPRVLUFRQFXDOTXLHUFRVD (PLO\VHLQFOLQyFRQWUDODYHQWDQD ³¢3RUTXp"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³¢6H DFXHUGDQ FXDQGR QRV HQFRQWUDPRV HQ HO SDWLR WUDVHUR GH $OL SDUD UREDUOH VX EDQGHUD" 'HVSXpV GH TXH VH IXH DGHQWUR YL D HVWH FRFKH HVWDFLRQDGR HQ VX DFHUD 3DUHFtDFRPRTXLpQTXLHUDTXHHVWXYLHUDDGHQWURHVWDEDFXEULHQGRHVWHOXJDU<HORWUR GtDIXLDFRUUHU\YLD:LOGHQSDUiQGRVHHQIUHQWHGHODFDVDGH$OLGHQXHYRDSHVDU GH TXH ORV RILFLDOHV FDQFHODURQ OD E~VTXHGD 0H GLR XQ DYHQWyQ« SHUR pO QR HVWDED

ʹʹͶ

+DQQDVHHVWDEOHFLyHQODWXPERQD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

PDQHMDQGRVXFRFKHGHHTXLSR(VWDEDPDQHMDQGRHOPLVPRFRFKHTXHYLKDFHDxRVHQ IUHQWHGHODFDVDGH$OL¢4XpWDOVLODHVWDEDDFHFKDQGR" (PLO\ODPLUyFRQFXULRVLGDG ³¢(VWDVVHJXUDGHTXHHVHOPLVPRFRFKH" +DQQDDVLQWLy ³(VHVWHYLHMRFOiVLFRGHORVVHVHQWDV1RSXHGRFUHHUTXHQRKLFHODFRQH[LyQDQWHVGH HVWDQRFKH<OXHJRFXDQGRHVWDEDHQHOFRFKHGH:LOGHQYLHVWDYLHMDHVWDPSDFRQXQ SH]HQpO'HFtD3DVHGH'tD¢6DEHQFXiQGRIXHOD~OWLPDYH]TXHYLHVWDHVWDPSD"(Q OD689GHOSDSDGH$OLFXDQGRVROtDPRVLUDORV3RFRQRV¢5HFXHUGDQ" $ULDIURWyVXEDUELOODWUDWDQGRGHVHJXLUOHODSLVWD$OLVROtDWUDHUDODIDPLOLDGH$ULD\ GHODVGHPiVDVXFDVDGH3RFRQRVPXFKR8QDYH]$ULDKDEtDD\XGDGRDODIDPLOLDD HPSDFDU VXV SHUWHQHQFLDV HQ HO FRFKH 'HVSXpV GH TXH HO 6U 'L/DXUHQWLV FDUJDUD ORV HTXLSDMHV VH KDEtD DFXUUXFDGR HQ HO SDUDFKRTXHV WUDVHUR \ GHVSXpV GH XQD QXHYD WHPSRUDGDGH3RFRQRVSDVyMXVWRHQFLPDGHODSDVDGDGHODxRDQWHULRU $ULDDVLQWLyOHQWDPHQWH ³¢3HURHVRTXHVLJQLILFD" /DFDEH]DGH+DQQDVHPRYLyIHUYLHQWHPHQWH(O'-FDPELRDODOX]HVWURERVFySLFD\ HO URVWUR GH +DQQD IXH GH OD OX] D OD VRPEUD \ GH YXHOWD 3DUHFtD FRPR VL HVWXYLHUD GHVDSDUHFLHQGR\UHDSDUHFLHQGR ³¢4Xp SDVD VL :LOGHQ VH DSRGHUy GH XQ SDVR KDFH PXFKR WLHPSR" ¢4Xp WDO VL VROtD PDQHMDU D ORV 3RFRQRV SDUD HVSLDU D $OL" ¢4Xp VL« TXH WDO VL WHQtD DOJ~Q UDUR HQDPRUDPLHQWR SRU HOOD XQ HQDPRUDPLHQWR GH PDQHUD PDV H[WUDxD TXH HO GH ,DQ" ¢1R FUHHQ TXH VH HVWD FRPSRUWDQGR GH PDQHUD H[WUDxD ~OWLPDPHQWH" )XH WDQ UiSLGR HQDUUHVWDUD,DQFXDQGR6SHQFHUYLQRGLUHFWDPHQWHFRQVHDPRVKRQHVWDVXQWLSRGH HYLGHQFLDGpELO¢4XpWDOVLHVWiHVFRQGLHQGRDOJR"¢4XpWDOVLHVTXLpQORKL]R"

/DVFRPLVXUDVGHODERFDGH+DQQDVHEDMDURQHQGLVJXVWR(PLO\SUHVLRQyVXPDQRHQ VXFXHOORGHVQXGR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³3HUR :LOGHQ SXGR KDEHU REWHQLGR HO SDVH GH -DVRQ ¢6DEtDQ TXH -DVRQ \ :LOGHQ HUDQDPLJRV"

ʹʹͷ

$ULDDJLWyVXVPDQRVGHWHQLHQGRD+DQQD

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³6p TXH VXHQD ORFR ³$ULD DGPLWLy³ +R\ UHFLEt XQ FRUUHR HOHFWUyQLFR GH -DVRQ GLFLpQGRPHTXHORHQFRQWUDUDHQODFDVDGHVXVSDGUHVHQ


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

(O'-TXLWyODOX]HVWURERVFySLFDHLQLFLRHQRWUDFDQFLyQSDUDEDLODU/DVSHUVRQDVGH ODILHVWDVHWDPEDOHDURQHQODSLVWDGHEDLOH/RVSDGUHVWLQWLQHDEDQODVFRSDVGHYLQR EULQGDQGRSRURWURQXHYRKRWHODOFXDOHVFDSDUVHHQORVILQHVGHVHPDQD$ULDLQFOXVR QRWyDORV6U\6UD'L/DXUHQWLVDWUDYpVGHODSLVWDGHEDLOHKDEODQGRMRYLDOPHQWHFRQ ORV6U\6UD%\HUVFRPRVLQDGDHVWXYLHUDPDO

ʹʹ͸

³6L1RVRWUDVD\XGDPRVD´$µ«R´$µDUUXLQDQXHVWUDVYLGDV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(OOD PLUy HO OLEUR HQ ODV PDQRV GH (PLO\ /RV SDGUHV 'L/DXUHQWLV SXGLHURQ KDEHU HVWDGR HQYLDQGR D -DVRQ D WHUDSLDV SRU DxRV PDQWHQLpQGROR XQ EXHQ VHFUHWR JXDUGDGR7DOYH]HOORVKDEtDQHVWDGRRFXOWDQGRRWUDVFRVDVDFHUFDGH-DVRQWDPELpQ -DVRQKDEtDHVWDGRWDQHQRMDGRKR\¢3RGUtDVHUXQDGHHVDVSHUVRQDVTXHHVFRQGtDQVX HQRMRKiELOPHQWHSDUHFLHQGRWDQGXOFH\JHQWLOKDVWDTXHGHUHSHQWH«HVWDOOD"7DOYH] :LOGHQHUDXQDGHHVDVSHUVRQDVWDPELpQ ³¢4XpWDOVL-DVRQGHVFXEULyTXH$OLH,DQHVWDEDQVDOLHQGR"³$ULDVXJLULy³(VHGLD TXH VH DFHUFR D ,DQ \$OL HQ HO SDWLR HVWDED UHDOPHQWH SURWHFWRU FRQ HOOD FRPR VL HO VXSLHUDTXHDOJRHVWDEDSDVDQGR7DOYH]DHVRVHUHIHUtD:LOGHQFRQ1RSXHGRFUHHUOR TXH HVH LGLRWD KL]R 3RGUtD VXSRQHU TXH HO KHUPDQR PD\RU TXHUUtD PDWDU DO FKLFR TXH HVWXYLHUDDSURYHFKiQGRVHGHVXKHUPDQD +DQQDFUX]yVXVSLHUQDVVXFDUDDUUXJDGDHQSHQVDU ³,DQGLMRHQVXV,0VTXHTXHUtDQODVWLPDUOR¢4XpWDOVLVRQ:LOGHQ\-DVRQ" ³3HUR,DQLPSOLFyTXHTXLHQHVOROOHYDURQIXHUDGHODFLXGDGIXHURQTXLHQHVUHDOPHQWH HVWDEDQGHWUiVGHHOOR³(PLO\GLMR³$VtTXHHVRVLJQLILFDUtD« ³-DVRQ\:LOGHQWXYLHURQDOJRTXHYHUHQODPXHUWHGH$OL³+DQQDVXVXUUy ³7DOYH]IXHXQDFFLGHQWH7DOYH]DOJRKRUULEOHSDVyTXHHOORVQRKDEtDQSODQHDGR $ULDVHVLQWLyHQIHUPD¢(UDHVRSRVLEOH"(OODYLRDODVGHPiV ³/D~QLFDSHUVRQDTXHVDEHODYHUGDGHV,DQ¢&UHHQTXHSRGUHPRVKDEODUFRQHOHQ ,0"¢&UHHQTXHQRVORGLJD" (OODVLQWHUFDPELDURQPLUDGDVLQTXLHWDVVLQHVWDUVHJXUDVGHTXHKDFHU(OEDMRVRQDED HQ HO IRQGR /RV RORUHV GH FDPDUyQ D OD SDUULOOD \ ILOHWH GH PLxyQ OOHQDURQ HO DLUH KDFLHQGRTXHHOHVWRPDJRYHJHWDULDQRGH$ULDVHUHYROYLHUD

+DQQDSDUSDGHyGXURFRPRVLVHFRQIXQGLHUDSRUHOFDPELRGHWHPDGH$ULD/XHJR H[WHQGLy OD EDQGHUD DIXHUD \ OHV HQVHxy HO SHGD]R FRPSOHWR 7DPELpQ DKt HVWDED HO ORJRGH&KDQHOXQFDPSRGHODFKLFDKRFNH\\PRGHORGH/RXLV9XLWWRQ



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³¢3RUTXpGLEXMDVWHXQDPDQJDGHUDQDHQWXEDQGHUD"

ʹʹ͹

5HVSLUyGLItFLOPHQWHVXVQHUYLRVPDQWHQLpQGRVHHQHOH[WUHPR6XVRMRVDWHUUL]DURQHQ HO SHGD]R GH OD EDQGHUD GH /D &jSVXOD GHO 7LHPSR GH +DQQD TXH OD KDEtD DWDGR DOUHGHGRUGHODFDGHQDGHVXEROVR+DEtDDSXQWDGRDODPDQFKDQHJUDHQODHVTXLQD UHFRUGDQGRFRPR+DQQDVHODKDEtDGHVFULWRD.DWHHQHOEDE\VKRZHUGH0HUHGLWK

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³/RGHFRUpHQKRQRUD$OLFRQODVFRVDVTXHKDEtDGLEXMDGRHQHOVX\RDQWHVGHTXH IXHUDUREDGR $ULDPRUGLyVXXxDGHOSXOJDU ³+DQQD$OLQRGLEXMyXQDPDQJDGHXQDUDQDHQVXEDQGHUD +DQQDPLUyDODUPDGD ³6LORKL]R)XLDFDVDHVDWDUGH\HVFULEtWRGRORTXHHOODGLMR 8QVHQWLPLHQWRGHKRUPLJXHRWUHSRODHVSDOGDGH$ULD ³(OODQRGLEXMyXQDPDQJDGHXQDUDQD³HOODSURWHVWy³1RGLEXMRQLQJ~QDQLPDO SDUDQDGD /RV RMRV GH +DQQD SDUSDGHDURQ GH LGD \ YXHOWD VX FDUD GUHQiQGRVH GH FRORU (PLO\ HPSXMRXQPHFKyQGHFDEHOORGHWUiVGHVXVRUHMDVYLpQGRVHSUHRFXSDGD ³¢&yPRVDEHVHVR" (OHVWRPDJRGH$ULDVHUHYROYLy+DEtDWHQLGRHOPLVPRSUHFLSLWDGRVHQWLPLHQWRFRPR ODYH]HQTXHHOODWHQtDVHLVDxRV\TXHUtDLUDODJUDQPRQWDxDUXVDHQ*UDQ$YHQWXUD 6XSDSiODDWyHQHODVLHQWR\MDOyODJUDQEDUUDGHPHWDODEDMRVREUHVXSHFKRSHURHO SDVHRHVWDEDSRUHPSH]DUHOODHVWDEDHQYXHOWDHQXQSiQLFRDEUDVDGRU+DEtDJULWDGR \ JULWDGR KDFLHQGR TXH HO WpFQLFR GHO SDUTXH GH GLYHUVLRQHV GHWXYLHUD HO SDVHR SDUD TXHDVtSXGLHUDEDMDUVH

³(VHGtDWUDWDPRVGHWRPDUODEDQGHUDGH$OLFRUWpDWUDYpVGHORVERVTXHVSDUDLUD FDVD $OJXLHQ HVWDED YLQLHQGR SRU HO RWUR ODGR (UD« -DVRQ <« EXHQR« WHQtD OD EDQGHUD GH $OL $QWHV GH TXH VXSLHUD OR TXH HVWDED SDVDQGR HO PH OD HVWDED HPSXMDQGR1RH[SOLFySRUTXH6DEtDTXHGHEtDGHGHYROYpUVHODD$OLSHURSHQVpTXH WDO YH] -DVRQ QR TXHUtD TXH OR KLFLHUD 3HQVp TXH WDO YH] KDEtD XQD UD]yQ SDUD TXH -DVRQ VH OD TXLWDUD &RPR VL SHQVDUD TXH QR HVWDED ELHQ TXH HOOD OD HQFRQWUDUD WDQ IiFLOPHQWH2TXHHVWDEDSUHRFXSDGRDFHUFDGHORTXH,DQGLMRXQRVSRFRVGtDVDQWHV HQHOSDWLRTXHODKXELHUDPDWDGRSDUDREWHQHUVXSHGD]R2TXHWDOYH]DOHJXVWDED \R«

ž‰‹ƒ

(PLO\EXIy6RVWXYRHOOLEURGHODRILFLQDGHDUULED ³2WDOYH]ODWRPySRUTXHWHQtDSUREOHPDV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ʹʹͺ

6XVDPLJDVSDUSDGHDURQKDFLDHOODHVSHUDQGR7DQWRFRPRHOODQRTXHUtDGLVFXWLUHVWR WHQtDTXHGHFLUOHVODYHUGDG7RPyXQDSURIXQGDUHVSLUDFLyQ



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³1RVXSHTXHSHQVDUHQHVHPRPHQWR³$ULDSURWHVWy ³¢$VtTXHHQYH]OHPHQWLVWHD$OL"³(PLO\GLVSDUyGHYXHOWD $ULDJUXxy+DEtDVDELGRTXH(PLO\LEDDUHDFFLRQDUGHHVWDPDQHUD ³£$OLQRVPLQWLyWDPELpQ³HOODFKLOOy³7RGDVKHPRVJXDUGDGRVHFUHWRVODVXQDVD ODVRWUDV¢&yPRHVHVWRGHGLIHUHQWH" (PLO\VHHQFRJLyGHKRPEURV\VHYROWHy ³4XHUtDGHYROYpUVHODD$OLUHDOPHQWHTXHUtD³$ULDGLMRFRQFDQVDQFLR³3HUROXHJR QRVYROYLPRVDPLJDVGHHOOD&XDQWRPiVWLHPSRQRGLMHUDDOJRPiVUDURKXELHUDVLGR 1R VDEtD TXH KDFHU ³$SXQWy GH QXHYR D OD EDQGHUD GH +DQQD³ 1R KH PLUDGR OD EDQGHUDGH$OLGHVGHHVHGtDTXHODREWXYHSHURMXURTXHQRKD\QLQJXQDUDQDHQHOOD +DQQDOHYDQWyVXFDEH]D ³(VSHUD$ULD¢7LHQHVWRGDYtDODEDQGHUD" $ULDDVLQWLy ³+DHVWDGRHQXQDYLHMDFDMDGH]DSDWRVSRUDxRV&XDQGRPRYtPLVFRVDVDODFDVD GHPLSDSiYLODFDMDRWUDYH]3HURQRODDEUt /DFDUDSiOLGDGH+DQQD ³7XYHXQVXHxRHVWDPDxDQDDFHUFDGHOGtDHQTXHWUDWDPRVGHUREDUOHVXEDQGHUDD $OL1HFHVLWRYHUOD $ULD FRPHQ]y D SURWHVWDU FXDQGR VLQWLy XQ ]XPELGR HQ VX FDGHUD 6X FHOXODU HVWDED VRQDQGR ³(VSHUHQ³PXUPXUyPLUDQGRDODSDQWDOOD³7HQJRXQQXHYRPHQVDMH /DSHTXHxDFDUWHUDGH(PLO\FRPHQ]yDWDUDUHDU



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

¢1RRGLDQFKLFDVFXDQGRWX0DQRORFRPLHQ]DDSHOOL]FDU"$PtPHJXVWDUHPRMDUORVGHGRVGH PLVSLHVHQPLMDFX]]LGHPLSDWLRWUDVHUR2VHQWDUPHHQPLJUDQHURDFRJHGRUDFXUUXFDGDEDMR XQDPDQWD(VWiWDQFDOODGRDKtDKRUDTXHORVJUDQGHVSROLFtDVSURWHFWRUHVQRHVWiQ

ʹʹͻ

³7DPELpQ\R³HOODVXVXUUy6HPLUDURQODXQDDODRWUD(OL3KRQHGH+DQQDHVWDED HQVLOHQFLRSHURVHLQFOLQyVREUHHO1RNLDGH(PLO\$ULDPLUyKDFLDDEDMRDVXSURSLR FHOXODU\SUHVLRQyOHHU

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³$ $ULDPLUyDOUHGHGRUDODVRWUDVFRQIXQGLGD ³6XHQD FRPR VL ´$µ HVWXYLHUD KDODQGR DFHUFD GHO JUDQHUR GH 6SHQFHU ³(PLO\ VXVXUUy6XERFDPHGLRDELHUWD³+DEOpFRQ6SHQFHUKR\WHPSUDQR(OODHVWiDIXHUD HQ HO JUDQHUR« FRPSOHWDPHQWH VROD ³$SXQWy KDFLD ODV SDODEUDV DKRUD TXH ORV JUDQGHV SROLFtDV SURWHFWRUHV QR HVWiQ³ ¢4Xp WDO VL HVWi HQ SHOLJUR" ¢4Xp WDO VL ´$µ QRVHVWDDGYLUWLHQGRGHTXHDOJRKRUULEOHHVWiSRUSDVDU" +DQQDSXVRVXL3KRQHHQDOWDYR]\PDUFyHOQXPHURGH6SHQFHU3HURODOtQHDVRQy\ VRQyILQDOPHQWH\pQGRVHDEX]yQGHYR](OFRUD]yQGH$ULDSDOSLWDQGRIXHUWH ³'HEHUtDPRVLUSDUDDVHJXUDUQRVTXHHVWiELHQ³VXVXUUy /XHJR $ULD VLQWLy ORV RMRV GH DOJXLHQ HQ HOOD DO RWUR ODGR GH OD KDELWDFLyQ 0LUy DOUHGHGRU \ QRWy D XQ KRPEUH FRQ FDEHOOR RVFXUR HQ HO XQLIRUPH GH OD 3ROLFtD GH 5RVHZRRG'D\HQODSXHUWD:LOGHQ(VWDEDPLUDQGRKDFLDHOODVVXVSHQHWUDQWHVRMRV YHUGHVHQUHQGLMDVHVWUHFKDVVXERFDKDFLDDEDMR6HYHtDFRPRVLHOKXELHUDHVFXFKDGR WRGRORTXHHOODGLMHURQ«\WRGRIXHUDYHUGDG $ULDDJDUUyODPDQRGH+DQQD\HPSH]yDMDODUODKDFLDHOODGRGHODHQWUDGD

ž‰‹ƒ

ʹ͵Ͳ

³&KLFDVWHQHPRVTXHVDOLUGHDTXt³HOODFKLOOy³$KRUD



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR 7RGRVHOORVHVWiQWDQHTXLYRFDGRV 7RGRVHOORVHVWiQWDQHTXLYRFDGRV 7UDGXFLGRSRU'\DQQD &RUUHJLGRSRU0DULQD 

(

UDQODVGHODQRFKH\6SHQFHUKDEtDHVWDGRUHOH\HQGRHOPLVPRSiUUDIRHQOD FDVDGHODDOHJUtDGHVGHKDFHXQDKRUD\PHGLD/LO\%DUWODOXFKDGRUDDQVLRVD GH 1XHYD


)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

¢&yPRSRGtDKDEHUVLGRWDQHVW~SLGD"$QGUHZOHKDEtDDGYHUWLGR7RGRVORVVLJQRVGH TXH2OLYLDHUDXQDHVWDIDGRUDHVWDEDQDOOt&XDQGRHOODODKDEtDYLVLWDGR2OLYLDQROD KDEtDGHMDGRGHWHQHUVH HQHODSDUWDPHQWRQL VLTXLHUDSRUXQPLQXWR<2OLYLDKDEtD WHQLGR SUREOHPDV FRQ OD FDUSHWD GH DUFKLYRV JUDQGHV ROYLGiQGROR FRQYHQLHQWHPHQWH FXDQGRHOODVXELyHQHOKHOLFySWHUR(OODSUREDEOHPHQWHVHKDEtDUHtGRXQDYH]TXHHOOD HVWXYR HQ HO DLUH VDELHQGR H[DFWDPHQWH OR TXH 6SHQFHU LED D KDFHU £< SHQVDU TXH 6SHQFHUKDEtDPLUDGRDORVRMRVGH2OLYLD\SHQVyTXHVHSDUHFtDQ(OODKDEtDDEUD]DGR D 2OLYLD HVWUHFKiQGROD DQWHV GH TXH VH IXHUD ILQDOPHQWH HOOD VHQWtD TXH HVWDED FRQHFWDQGR FRQ XQ PLHPEUR GH VX IDPLOLD 2OLYLD SUREDEOHPHQWH QL VLTXLHUD HUD VX QRPEUH YHUGDGHUR < 0RUJDQ )ULFN HO HVSRVR GH OD OODPDGD GH 2OLYLD HUD GHILQLWLYDPHQWH IDOVR ¢&yPR SRGtD KDEHU RPLWLGR HVR" 0RUJDQ )ULFN IXH VyOR HO QRPEUHGHGRVPXVHRVGH1HZ
ʹ͵ͳ

(OODGHMyHOOLEUR\PLUyWULVWHPHQWHDOUHGHGRUGHVXKDELWDFLyQHQHOJUDQHURHQHOTXH HOODVHKDEtDUHIXJLDGRWDQSURQWRFRPRKDEtDUHJUHVDGRGH1XHYD
6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(O JUDQHUR FUXMtD \ VH VDFXGtD 6SHQFHU HQFHQGLy HO WHOHYLVRU +DEtD WRQHODGDV GH PXHVWUDGHVKRZHQ7L9RGHVXKHUPDQDWRGDYtDVLQYHU$SULQFLSLRVGHHVWDWDUGH 6SHQFHU KDEtD RtGR D XQD PXMHU HQ HO VSD )HUPDWD GHMDU XQ PHQVDMH HQ OD PiTXLQD FRQWHVWDGRUD GH 0HOLVVD GLFLHQGR TXH 0HOLVVD KDEtD SHUGLGR VX FLWD SDUD HO R[tJHQR IDFLDOKR\\TXHVLGHVHDEDSURJUDPDUODGHQXHYR ¢3RUTXpVXKHUPDQDVHIXHFRQWDQWDSULVD"+DEtDHVWDGR0HOLVVDHQHOERVTXHD\HUHQ EXVFDGHDOJR"6SHQFHUVHYROYLyKDFLDHOWHOHYLVRUGHQXHYRQRLPSRUWDED6XPLUDGD YDJDED HQ OD HVWDQWHUtD GH 0HOLVVD eVWD HVWDED UHSOHWD GH YLHMRV OLEURV GH WH[WR GH OD HVFXHODVHFXQGDULDHQWUHHOORVHOOLEURTXHKDEtDXWLOL]DGRSDUDODHFRQRPtDGH$3 -XQWR D OR TXH IXH XQD KRMD YHUGH DUUXJDGD GH .DWH 6SDGH PDUFDGD FRQ QRWDV GH OD HVFXHODVHFXQGDULD6SHQFHUUHXQLyXQSHTXHxRUHVRSOLGRVDUFiVWLFR1RWDV¢FyPRGHO WLSRTXHVHSDVDQGHLGD\YXHOWDHQFODVH"/D3ULVV\0HOLVVDQRSDUHFtDGHHVHWLSR (OODVDFyODFDMDGHERWDV\DEULyODWDSD8QFXDGHUQRD]XOGHHVSLUDOTXHGHFtDFiOFXOR HVWDEDHQFLPD0HOLVVDGHEHGHKDEHUTXHULGRGHFLUFXDGHUQR+XERFDUDVVRQULHQWHV HQODSRUWDGD\HOQRPEUHGH0HOLVVD\HOQRPEUHGH,DQJUDEDGRVXQD\RWUDYH]HQ FXUVLYD IORUHDGR 6SHQFHU DEULy HO FXDGHUQR HQ OD SULPHUD SiJLQD (VWDED OOHQR GH SUREOHPDVGHPDWHPiWLFDVGLDJUDPDV\SUXHEDV$EXUULGR6SHQFHUSHQVy (QODVLJXLHQWHSiJLQDXQFKRTXHGHWLQWDYHUGHOHOODPyODDWHQFLyQ+DEtDQQRWDVHQ HOPDUJHQHVFULWRVSRUGRVFRORUHVGLIHUHQWHVGHWLQWDV3DUHFtDXQDFRQYHUVDFLyQHQWUH GRVSHUVRQDVSDVDGRGHLGD\YXHOWDGHXQHVFULWRULRDRWUR6SHQFHUUHFRQRFLyODOHWUD GH0HOLVVDHQQHJUR\RWUDSHUVRQDHQYHUGH

6SHQFHUSDVyODSiJLQDDFHQWtPHWURVGHVXURVWURFRPRVLHVWXGLDUORGHFHUFDORGHMDUD PiVFODUR¢-'"6XFHUHEURVHUHYROYLyEXVFDQGRXQDUHVSXHVWDPiVOyJLFD¢3XHGHTXH TXLHUDGHFLU-DVRQ'L/DXUHQWLV"(OGtDTXHHOORVWUDWDURQGHUREDUODEDQGHUDGH$OL\ -DVRQ KDEtD VDOLGR GH VX FDVD KDEtD IXOPLQDGR FRQ OD PLUDGD D 0HOLVVD \ D ,DQ HQ SDWLRWUDVHURGHODFDVDGH6SHQFHUeOODREWHQGUi0HOLVVDOHKDEtDPXUPXUDGRD,DQ PiV WDUGH ¢-DVRQ SRGUtD KDEHU HVWDGR FHORVR GH TXH 0HOLVVD HVWXYLHUD VDOLHQGR FRQ ,DQ"¢3RGUtDKDEHUHVWDGRVHFUHWDPHQWHHQDPRUDGRGHHOOD"

ž‰‹ƒ

(OODDSUHWyORVGHGRVHQODVVLHQHV1RSDUHFtDSRVLEOH

ʹ͵ʹ

¢6XSRQJRTXHKDFtDVHQODILHVWDGHO~OWLPDGHOILQGHVHPDQD"'HFtDHOSULPHUPHQVDMH GH0HOLVVDTXHLQGLFDEDQORVJDUDEDWRV'HEDMRGHHVRKDEtDXQDSUHJXQWDPDUFDGDHQ YHUGHHVSXPRVR-'IXHODUHVSXHVWDGH0HOLVVD/XHJRYLQRXQVLJQRGHH[FODPDFLyQ HQYHUGH<OXHJR£WUDYLHVDMXJXHWRQD(VHFKLFRHVWiWDQHQDPRUDGRGHWL



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

+XERXQJROSHFRQWXQGHQWHHQODSXHUWD\HOFXDGHUQRVHGHVOL]yGHOUHJD]RGH6SHQFHU DODDOIRPEUD /XHJRRWURJROSH ³£6SHQFHU³R\yOODPDUDDOJXLHQ (PLO\ \ +DQQD HVWDED HQ HO SRUFKH (PLO\ HQ XQ ODUJR YHVWLGR URMR \ +DQQD HQ XQR QHJUR\FRUWRGHHQFDMH ³¢(VWiV ELHQ" ³+DQQD VH SUHFLSLWy HQ HO JUDQHUR \ DJDUUy HO DQWHEUD]R GH 6SHQFHU (PLO\DSDUHFLyGHWUiVGHHOODOOHYDQGRXQJUDQOLEURFRQXQDFXELHUWDGHFXHURRVFXUR ³6t³GLMR6SHQFHUOHQWDPHQWH³¢4XpHVWiSDVDQGR" (PLO\SXVRHOOLEURHQODPHVDGHODFRFLQD ³$FDEDPRV GH UHFLELU XQ PHQVDMH GH $ 1RVRWUDV QRV SUHRFXSDPRV GH TXH DOJR WH KXELHUDVXFHGLGR¢+DVRtGRDOJ~QUXLGRH[WUDxRIXHUD" 6SHQFHUSDUSDGHyDVRPEUDGD ³1R /DV FKLFDV VH PLUDURQ HQWUH Vt UHVSLUDURQ VXVSLURV GH DOLYLR /RV RMRV GH 6SHQFHU VH ILMDURQHQHOOLEURGHFXHURTXH(PLO\OOHYDED ³¢4XpHVHVR"³SUHJXQWy (PLO\VHPRUGLyHOODELR(FKyXQYLVWD]RD+DQQD\DPEDVOHODQ]DURQODH[SOLFDFLyQ GH OR TXH KDEtDQ GHVFXELHUWR HVH PLVPR GtD 7DPELpQ OH GLMHURQ TXH $ULD KDEtD TXHGDGRDWUiVHQVXFDVDSDUDUHFXSHUDUDOJR³ODEDQGHUDTXH$OLKDEtDSHUGLGR³TXH SRGUtD FRQWHQHU XQD SLVWD YLWDO \ VH UHXQLUtDQ DTXt &XDQGR SRU ILQ HVWXYLHURQ FDOPDGDV6SHQFHUODVPLUyDHOODVDWXUGLGD ³-DVRQ\:LOGHQVDEHQDOJR³VXVXUUy+DQQD³$OJRHVWiQRFXOWDQGR1RVRWUDV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

6SHQFHU DIHUUy VX DOPRKDGyQ HQWUH ODV PDQRV VH VHQWtD LQFRPRGD ³¢< VL HV SHOLJURVR" ,DQ VH IXH GH OD FLXGDG SRUTXH VDEtD GHPDVLDGR (VR QRV SXHGH SDVDU D QRVRWUDVWDPELpQ

ʹ͵͵

QHFHVLWDPRVOOHJDUD,DQRWUDYH]7RGDVHVDVFRVDVTXHpOHQYLDEDHQ,0DFHUFDGH³ TXHpOWHQtDTXHFRUUHUTXHHOORVORRGLDEDQTXHHOORVVHHQWHUDURQGHTXHpOVDEtD³ QHFHVLWDPRVVDEHUTXHHVORTXH,DQVDEH

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

+DQQD QHJy FRQ OD FDEH]D ³$ QRV HVWi URJDQGR TXH KDJDPRV HVWR $ SRGUtD DUUXLQDUQRVVLQRORKDFHPRV 6SHQFHU FHUUy ORV RMRV SHQVDQGR HQ HO FHUR URMR JUDQGH HQ OD OtQHD GHO EDQFR GH VX FXHQWDGHDKRUURVXQLYHUVLWDULRV$\DODKDEtDDUUXLQDGR (OODVHHQFRJLyGHKRPEURV\VHDFHUFyDORUGHQDGRUSRUWiWLOGH0HOLVVDVLQVDEHUTXp PiVKDFHU3RFRDSRFRHOODVHPRYLyDOUHGHGRUGHOPRXVHVDFXGLHQGRODSDQWDOODGH YXHOWD D OD YLGD /D FRPSXWDGRUD WRGDYtD HVWDED HQ OD FXHQWD ,0 GH 0HOLVVD \ DOOt HVWDEDQORVDPLJRVHQOtQHDHQODYHQWDQDGH´DPLJRVµ&XDQGR6SHQFHUYLRHOIDPLOLDU QRPEUHHQODSDQWDOODVXFRUD]yQFRPHQ]yDODWLUFRQIXHU]D ³1R OR SXHGR FUHHU (V pO ³GLMR VHxDODQGR D 86&0LGILHOGHU5R[[ (VWD IXH OD SULPHUDYH]TXHHOODORKDEtDYLVWRHQOtQHDHQXQDVHPDQD +DQQDPLUyORVRMRVGH6SHQFHU ³+DEODFRQpO³GLMR 6SHQFHUKL]RFOLFHQHOLFRQRGH,DQ\FRPHQ]yDHVFULELU,DQHV6SHQFHU1RFLHUUHVOD VHVLyQ (VWR\ DTXt FRQ +DQQD \ (PLO\ &UHHPRV HQ WL 6DEHPRV TXH HUHV LQRFHQWH 4XHUHPRV D\XGDU D UHVROYHU HVWR 3HUR W~ WLHQHV TXH GHFLUQRV DFHUFD GH ODV SUXHEDV FRQWUDGLFWRULDV TXH LQVLQXDVWH FXDQGR HVWDEDV HQ HO SRUFKH OD VHPDQD SDVDGD ¢4Xp SDVyODQRFKHHQTXH$OLIXHDVHVLQDGD" /DSDQWDOODSDUSDGHD/DVPDQRVGH6SHQFHUHPSH]DURQDWHPEODU <DFRQWLQXDFLyQODSDQWDOODGH,0EULOOy6HLQFOLQyKDFLDGHODQWH¢6SHQFHU"GHFtDHO PHQVDMH /DV PDQRV GH ODV FKLFDV HQWUHOD]DGDV 2WUR PHQVDMH DSDUHFLy GHVSXpV 1R GHEHPRVKDEODUGHHVWR6LW~VDEHVSRGUtDVHVWDUHQSHOLJUR 6SHQFHUSDOLGHFLy\PLUyD(PLO\\+DQQD ³¢9HV"7DOYH]WLHQHUD]yQ



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

/DYHQWDQDGH,0EULOOyGHQXHYR$OL\\RHVWiEDPRVKDFLHQGRSODQHVSDUDUHXQLUQRV HVD QRFKH ,DQ HVFULELy (VWDED QHUYLRVR SRU QXHVWUR HQFXHQWUR DVt TXH PH HPERUUDFKp0HIXLDHVSHUDUDTXHHOODOOHJDUDSHURHOODQRDSDUHFLy&XDQGRPLUpD WUDYpVGHOSDWLRWHMXURTXHYLDGRVSHUVRQDV FRQHOSHORODUJR\UXELRHQHOERVTXH 3DUHFtDTXHXQRGHHOORVHUD$OL

ʹ͵Ͷ

+DQQDHPSXMyD6SHQFHUXQODGR\HVFULELy7HQHPRVTXHVDEHUOR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

6SHQFHUTXHGyVLQDOLHQWR,DQOHKDEtDGLFKRHVWRFXDQGRODYLRHQHOSRUFKHODVHPDQD SDVDGD (OOD \ $OL GLVFXWLHURQ HVD QRFKH SHUR ,DQ GLMR TXH SRGUtD KDEHU VLGR RWUD SHUVRQD &HUUy ORV RMRV WUDWDQGR GH LPDJLQDU RWUD SHUVRQD TXH HVWXYLHUD SRU DKt HVD QRFKHDOJXLHQGHTXLHQQRKDEtDVRVSHFKDGRQXQFD6XHVWyPDJRHPSH]yDGROHU /RV PHQVDMHV GH ,DQ VHJXtDQ OOHJDQGR 3DUHFtD TXH ODV GRV SHUVRQDV HVWDEDQ GLVFXWLHQGRSHURHVWDEDQGHPDVLDGROHMRVSDUDVDEHUORTXHGHFtDQ3HQVpTXH$OLQR LEDDYHQLUTXHWDOYH]HUDEXHQRSRUTXH\RHVWDEDEDVWDQWHSHUGLGR'HVSXpVGHTXH $OLVHSHUGLyQRPHGLFXHQWDGHTXHODSHUVRQDTXHFRQODTXHHVWDEDGLVFXWLHQGRHVD QRFKHSRGUtDKDEHUODODVWLPDGRSRUHVRQRGLMHQDGDDOSULQFLSLR(OODKDEtDKDEODGR PXFKRDFHUFDGHHVFDSDUKDFLDRWUROXJDUFXDQGRHVWiEDPRVMXQWRV\HVRIXHORTXH\R FUHtDTXHHOODKDEtDKHFKR 6SHQFHUPLUyDODVGHPiVSHUSOHMD ³$OLQXQFDKDEOyGHKXLU¢YHUGDG" ³
ž‰‹ƒ

¢1RSDUHFHH[WUDxRTXHHQWUyHQDSOLFDFLyQGHODOH\"GLMRHOVLJXLHQWHPHQVDMHGH,DQ LJQRUDQGRODSUHJXQWDGH6SHQFHUeOHUDHOKRPEUHPHQRVSURSHQVRDKDFHUDOJRDVt 3HUR OD FXOSD HV XQD ORFXUD 3UREDEOHPHQWH TXHUtD DEVROYHUVH D Vt PLVPR GH OR TXH VXFHGLy GH OD PDQHUD TXH SXGR < DPERV WHQtDQ XQD FRDUWDGD VyOLGD HVD QRFKH 6H VXSRQtDTXHGHEtDQHVWDUHQODFDVDGHODPRQWDxD1DGLHVDEtDTXHHVWDEDQUHDOPHQWH HQ5RVHZRRG(VSRUHVRTXHQXQFDIXHURQFXHVWLRQDGRV(OORVQRHVWDEDQDOOt +DQQDSUHVLRQyVXVPDQRVDVXVPHMLOODV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH

ʹ͵ͷ

¢4XLpQHV VRQ" 6SHQFHU HVFULELy ¢4XLpQ OR KL]R" 7HQtD OD VHQVDFLyQ GH TXH VDEtD UHVSXHVWDGH,DQSHURHOODORTXHUtDFRQILUPDU



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

³/DFDVDGHODPRQWDxD/DHWLTXHWDDGKHVLYDGH:LOGHQ ³<SHUPLWLHURQD-DVRQVXELUDOOtVROR³VXVXUUy6SHQFHU(OODYROYLyDOWHFODGR'LPH TXLpQHV'LPHVXVQRPEUHV 3RGUtDQVDOLUKHULGDV,DQHVFULELy/HVKHGLFKRGHPDVLDGR\D(OORVYDQDVDEHUTXHW~ VDEHV(OORVSUREDEOHPHQWH\DORVDEHQ(OORVQRVHGHWLHQHQDQWHQDGDSDUDPDQWHQHU HVWHVHFUHWR 'Ì0(/2HOODHVFULELy /DSDQWDOODSDUSDGHDED)LQDOPHQWHHOVLJXLHQWHPHQVDMHOOHJyFRQEORRSUXLGRVR -DVRQ'L/DXUHQWLV,DQHVFULELy<'DUUHQ:LOGHQ 6SHQFHU SUHVLRQy VX PDQR HQ VXV PHMLOODV K~PHGDV XQD DSHUWXUD GH GHIHFWR HQ VX FDEH]D(OODUHFRUGyODIRWRTXHKDEtDHVWDGRVREUHHOSURWHFWRUGHSDQWDOODGHVXSDGUH XQDGHWDQWDVGHHOORVHQODFDVDGHODPRQWDxDGHORV'L/DXUHQWLV(OSHORPRMDGRGH -DVRQVHKDEtDHVWLUDGRKDFLDDEDMRSRUGHODQWHGHVXVKRPEURVFRPRORVGHXQDFKLFD (OODHQVDQFKyVXVRMRVHQ(PLO\\+DQQD³(OSHORGH-DVRQVROtDVHUODUJRHQWRQFHV ¢UHFXHUGDV"$VtTXHVL,DQYLRDGRVSHUVRQDVFRQHOSHORODUJRUXELR« ³3RGUtDKDEHUVLGRpO³VXVXUUy(PLO\³<$OL 6SHQFHUFHUUyVXVRMRV(VWRHQFDMDEDHQODPHPRULDTXHHOODWHQtDGHDTXHOODQRFKH WDPELpQ'HVSXpVGHTXHHOODKDEtDOXFKDGRFRQ$OL\FDtGR$OLKDEtDTXHGDGRSRUHO FDPLQR6SHQFHUKDEtDH[DPLQDGRHQHOSDWLR\KDEtDYLVWRD$OLKDEODQGRFRQDOJXLHQ 3RUVXSXHVWRHOODKDEtDDVXPLGRTXHHUD,DQ«WDQWRVVLJQRVVHxDOiQGRORDpO3HURHOOD H[SULPLyVXVRMRVFHUUDGRV\SHQVyVHULDPHQWHHOFXDGURFRPHQ]yDFDPELDU



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

¢&yPR SXGR KDEHU VXFHGLGR" ¢)XH XQ DFFLGHQWH WRUFLGR" ¢-DVRQ IXH VXSHUDGR SRU OD UDELD LQTXLHWDQWH GH OR TXH VX KHUPDQD HVWDED KDFLHQGR FRQ ,DQ" ¢+DEtDQ OXFKDGR \ KDEtDFDtGRHQIRUPDDFFLGHQWDOHQHODJXMHUR$OL"¢-DVRQ\:LOGHQKDEtDQHVFDSDGRD ORV ERVTXHV SHWULILFDGR SRU OR TXH KDEtD VXFHGLGR" ,DQ QR KDEUtD GLFKR D OD SROLFtD DFHUFD GH YHU D QDGLH HQ HO ERVTXH FRQ $OL SRUTXH KDEUtD TXH SRQHUOR D pO HQ OD HVFHQD«\pOWDPELpQKDEUtDWHQLGRTXHH[SOLFDUVXUHODFLyQVHFUHWDFRQ$OL

ʹ͵͸

/DSHUVRQD\DQRWHQtDQODPDQGtEXODGHFLQFHODGD\FDEHOORFRUWR\RQGXODGRGH,DQ 6X FDEHOOR HUD UHFWR \ UXELR VXV UDVJRV PiV GHOLFDGRV eO VH DSR\DED HQ $OL tQWLPDPHQWH SHUR WDPELpQ GH PDQHUD SURWHFWRUD /D IRUPD HQ TXH OR KDUtD XQ KHUPDQRQRXQQRYLR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

3HUR FXDQGR VH DGHODQWy FRQ OR TXH pO VDEtD UHDOPHQWH GHVSXpV GH VX GHWHQFLyQ OD SHUVRQD TXH KDEtD OOHYDGR D VX PiV SUREDEOH GHFODUDFLyQ IXH :LOGHQ \ :LOGHQ REYLDPHQWHQRSUHVHQWDUtDODKLVWRULDGH,DQDXQDDXWRULGDGVXSHULRU 8QDYH]TXH,DQFRQVLJXLyXQDERJDGR\FRPHQ]yDGHVSRWULFDUDFHUFDGHTXHpOQR HUDHODVHVLQR\ODYHUGDGVHTXHGDIXHUDDOOtWDOYH]:LOGHQORDPHQD]y¢&XiOIXHOD UD]yQSRU,DQWXYRTXHKXLU" 7RGRHOPXQGRVHTXHGyHQVLOHQFLRGXUDQWHPXFKRWLHPSR+XERXQUHOLQFKRGHXQ FDEDOOR D OR OHMRV HQ ORV HVWDEORV GH 6SHQFHU 8Q VLOELGR GHO YLHQWR VDFXGLHQGR ODV UDPDV GH ORV iUEROHV (QWRQFHV (PLO\ OHYDQWy OD EDUELOOD ROIDWHDQGR HO DLUH 8QD PLUDGDSHUWXUEDUWHFUX]RVXURVWUR ³¢4Xp"³+DQQDOHSUHJXQWySUHRFXSDGD ³
ž‰‹ƒ

ʹ͵͹

³2KPL'LRV(VJDVROLQD³<OXHJRHOODVR\HURQHOVRQLGRUHYHODGRUGHXQIyVIRUR VLHQGRJROSHDGR 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR (O,QILHUQRHQOD7LHUUD (O,QILHUQRHQOD7LHUUD 7UDGXFLGRSRU0RP\ &RUUHJLGRSRUʾ  ULD EDMy SRU OD HVFDOHUD GH FDUDFRO GHVGH VX GRUPLWRULR HQ VX QXHYD FDVD WURSH]DQGR GRV YHFHV \ DSR\iQGRVH FRQWUD OD EDUDQGLOOD GH KLHUUR IRUMDGR 6DOLyFRUULHQGRSRUODSXHUWDSULQFLSDOFRUULyKDFLDHO6XEDUX\ORHQFHQGLy 1RSDVyQDGD$SUHWy ORVGLHQWHV\ORLQWHQWy GHQXHYR(OPRWRUQRIXQFLRQDED³ 3RUIDYRUQRKDJDVHVWR³SLGLy$ULDDOYHKtFXORJROSHDQGRVXFDEH]DHQHOYRODQWH /DERFLQDUHVRQyGpELOPHQWH

$

'HUURWDGD VDOLy GHO FRFKH \ PLUy D GHUHFKD H L]TXLHUGD +DEtD GHMDGR VX ELFLFOHWD D (OODORTXHVLJQLILFDEDTXHWHQGUtDTXHFDPLQDUKDVWDHOJUDQHURGH6SHQFHU/DIRUPD PiV UiSLGD HUD DWUDYHVDU HO HVSHVR ERVTXH QHJUR FRPR XQ DWD~G 3HUR $ULD QR KDEtD LGRDOOtHQODQRFKHSRUVLVRODEXHQRQXQFD

$ULD H[WHQGLy OD SLH]D FRPSOHWDPHQWH KDVWD VXV HVTXLQDV $ OD L]TXLHUGD $OL KDEtD GLEXMDGR XQ H[WUDxR VtPEROR TXH QR KDEtD QRWDGR DQWHV 6H YHtD FRPR XQD VHxDO GH 12(67$&,21$5GHOWLSRTXHWHQtDXQDOHWUD(FRQXQDJUDQOtQHDURMDDWUDYpV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

/D WHOD D~Q HVWDED EULOODQWH \ HVSHVD FDVL SHUIHFWDPHQWH FRQVHUYDGD ,QFOXVR ROtD XQ SRFRFRPRHOMDEyQGHPDQRVGHYDLQLOODGH$OL$ULDHQFHQGLyODOLQWHUQDTXHKDEtD DJDUUDGRGHODFRFLQD H[DPLQDQGRORVGLVHxRVTXH$OLKDEtDGLEXMDGR$OOtHVWDEDHO ORJR GH &KDQHO \ HO GLVHxR GH /RXLV 9XLWWRQ ORV PLVPRV GLEXMRV TXH KDEtD HQ OD EDQGHUDGH+DQQD7DPELpQKDEtDXQPRQWyQGHHVWUHOODV\FRPHWDV\XQGLEXMRGHXQ SR]RGHORVGHVHRV3HURQRKDEtDXQDUDQDHQQLQJ~QOXJDU7DPSRFRKDEtDXQDQLxD MXJDQGRKRFNH\VREUHFpVSHG(QWRQFHV+DQQDKDEtDUHFRUGDGRLQFRUUHFWDPHQWH¢R KDEtDVLGR$OL"

ʹ͵ͺ

8QDPHGLDOXQDFROJDEDHQHOFLHOR/DQRFKHHVWDEDPX\TXLHWD\VLOHQFLRVDVLQXQD SL]FD GH YLHQWR $ULD SRGtD YHU OD OX] GRUDGD GHO SRUFKH GHO JUDQHUR GH 6SHQFHU D WUDYpVGHORViUEROHV$QWHVGHHPSH]DUDDWUDYHVDUHOERVTXHVDFyODEDQGHUDGH$OL GHO EROVLOOR GH VX FKDTXHWD /D EDQGHUD HVWDED GRQGH HOOD VDEtD TXH HVWDUtD VLWXDGR SURIXQGDPHQWHHQODFDMDGH]DSDWRV(OODODFRJLyVLQPLUDUODGHVHVSHUDGDSRUYROYHU FRQ6SHQFHU\ODVRWUDV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

GHOFHQWUR6yORTXHHQOXJDUGH($OLKDEtDHVFULWRRWUDLQLFLDOHQVXOXJDU$ULDDFHUFy ODEDQGHUDFHUFDGHVXFDUD$SULPHUDYLVWDODOHWUDSDUHFtDXQD,SHURDOPLUDUPiV GHFHUFDVHGLRFXHQWDGHTXHQRORHUD(UDXQD- 'H¢-DVRQ" &RQHOFRUD]yQODWLHQGRIXHUWHPHQWH$ULDHPSXMyODEDQGHUDGHUHJUHVRHQVXEROVLOOR \ FRUULy KDFLD HO ERVTXH /D QLHYH VH KDEtD GHUUHWLGR \ HO VXHOR HVWDED UHVEDODGL]R $ULDFRUULyVREUHODVKRMDVK~PHGDV\FKDUFRVHPSDSDGRVVDOSLFDQGREDUURSRUWRGDV SDUWHV &XDQGR OOHJy DO IRQGR GH XQ EDUUDQFR VXV ERWDV VH UHVEDODURQ SRU GHEDMR GH HOOD*ROSHyHOVXHORFRQXQWKZDFNFD\HQGRFRQIXHU]DVREUHVXFDGHUD(OGRORUHUD EODQFR\FDOLHQWH\$ULDGHMyHVFDSDUXQJULWRDKRJDGR 3DVDURQ DOJXQRV VHJXQGRV GH FDOPD (O ~QLFR VRQLGR TXH HVFXFKDED HUD VX SURSLD UHVSLUDFLyQ3RFRDSRFRHOODVHOHYDQWyVHOLPSLyHOEDUURGHVXURVWUR\PLUyDVX DOUHGHGRU &UX]DQGR HO FODUR KDEtD XQ IDPLOLDU iUERO WRUFLGR $ULD IUXQFLy HO FHxR GiQGRVH FXHQWD(VWHHUDHOOXJDUGRQGHKDEtDQHQFRQWUDGRHOFXHUSRGH,DQODVHPDQDSDVDGD HVWDEDVHJXUDGHHOOR$OJREULOODEDGHVGHGHEDMRGHXQFKDUFRGHWURQFRV\KRMDVVHFDV $ULDVHDFHUFyDHOORFXLGDGRVDPHQWH\VHDJDFKy (UDXQDQLOORFODVHSODWLQRPHGLRFXELHUWRGHEDUUR7LURGHODPDQJDGHVXFDPLVDHQ OD PDQR \ OR OLPSLy 8QD SLHGUD D]XO EULOODED \ DOUHGHGRU GH OD EDVH GH OD SLHGUD HVWDEDQODVSDODEUDV5RVHZRRG'D\&HUUyORVRMRVUHFRUGDQGRHOFXHUSRGH,DQWLUDGR HQWUHODVKRMDVKDFHDSHQDVXQDVHPDQD6XPLUDGDVHKDEtDLGRGLUHFWDPHQWHDODQLOOR GHODFODVHDOUHGHGRUGHVXGHGRKLQFKDGR(VHDQLOORWHQtDXQDSLHGUDD]XOWDPELpQ (OOD DOXPEUy FRQ OD OLQWHUQD HQ HO QRPEUH LQVFULWR HQ HO LQWHULRU GH OD EDQGD ,DQ 7KRPDV¢6HOHKDEUtDFDtGRPLHQWUDVHVFDSDED"¢$OJXLHQVHORKDEtDDUUDQFDGR"



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

8QD UDPD VH TXHEUy $ULD JLUy VX FDEH]D (O UXLGR SDUHFtD FHUFDQR 0iV UDPLWDV VH URPSLHURQ/DVKRMDVFUXMtDQ(QWRQFHVXQDILJXUDVHGHVOL]yHQWUHORViUEROHV\$ULDVH SXVR HQ FXFOLOODV /D ILJXUD GLR XQRV SRFRV SDVRV \ VH GHWXYR (VWDED GHPDVLDGR RVFXUR SDUD YHU TXLpQ HVWDED DOOt $OJR KL]R HO UXLGR FRPR GH XQ FKDSRWHR OtTXLGR JROSHDQGR ORV ODGRV GH XQ FRQWHQHGRU /RV RMRV GH $ULD VH KXPHGHFLHURQ XQ RORU H[WUDxROOHQyVXQDUL](UDHORORUGHXQDJDVROLQHUDXQRGHVXVRORUHVPiVRGLDGRVHQ HOPXQGR

ʹ͵ͻ

9ROYLyDPLUDUHOPRQWyQGHKRMDVPRMDGDV(ODQLOORKDEtDHVWDGRVREUHHOODVDSHQDV RFXOWR¢&yPRHVTXHODSROLFtDQRORKDEtDHQFRQWUDGR"

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&XDQGR YLR D OD ILJXUD DJDFKDUVH \ HVFXFKy HO JRUJRWHR GHO OtTXLGR VDOLHQGR GHO FRQWHQHGRU \ VDOSLFDQGR HQ HO VXHOR IDQJRVR $ULD VH GLR FXHQWD GH OR TXH HVWDED VXFHGLHQGR 6H SXVR GH SLH UiSLGDPHQWH XQ JULWR VH FRQJHOy HQ VX JDUJDQWD /HQWDPHQWHODSHUVRQDPHWLyODPDQRHQHOEROVLOOR\VDFyXQREMHWR $ULDR\yXQFKDVTXLGR ³1R³VXVXUUy (O WLHPSR SDVy PiV OHQWR (O DLUH VH VHQWtD GHQVR \ HQ FDOPD /XHJR HO ERVTXH VH YROYLyQDUDQMD7RGRVHLOXPLQy $ULDJULWy\FRUULyGHYXHOWDKDVWDHOEDUUDQFR6DOLyGHHQWUHORViUEROHV\GLRXQSDVR HQXQSHTXHxRIRVRWRUFLpQGRVHHOWRELOOR(QORVSULPHURVVHJXQGRVOR~QLFRTXHRtD HUDHOKRUULEOHFUHSLWDUGHOIXHJRHOHYiQGRVHPiV\PiVFRQVXPLHQGRWRGRDVXSDVR 3HUR DO GREODU XQD HVTXLQD R\y RWUR VRQLGR (UD SHTXHxR PLVHUDEOH \ GHVHVSHUDGR 8QSHTXHxRJHPLGR $ULD VH GHWXYR /DV OODPDV HVWDEDQ HQ HO EDUUDQFR GRQGH KDEtD HVWDGR KDFH XQRV PRPHQWRV $ OD GHUHFKD KDEtD XQD ILJXUD DFXUUXFDGD (VWD SHUVRQD SDUHFtD PiV SHTXHxD \ PiV GpELO GH OR TXH SDUHFtD OD ILJXUD TXH KDEtD YDJDGR D WUDYpV GH ORV ERVTXHVPRPHQWRVDQWHVLOXPLQDQGRWRGRFRQIXHJR/DSLHUQDGHODSHUVRQDHVWDED DWUDSDGD GHEDMR GH OD SHVDGD UDPD GH XQ iUERO TXH KDEtD FDtGR \ SHTXHxDV OODPDV FRPRGHGRVVXEtDQVREUHODUDPDFDGDYH]PiV\PiVFHUFDGHOSLHGHODSHUVRQD ³£$\XGD³JULWyTXLHQTXLHUDTXHIXHUD³£3RUIDYRU $ULDFRUULyKDFLDDOOt(OURVWURGHODSHUVRQDHVWDEDFXELHUWRSRUXQDFDSXFKDHQRUPH (OODHYDOXyHOWURQFR(UDJUDQGH\SHVDGR\HVSHUDEDSRGHUPRYHUOR ³9DVDHVWDUELHQ³JULWyHOODVXURVWURFRPHQ]DEDDFDOHQWDUVHGHELGRDODVOODPDV 5HXQLHQGRVXIXHU]D$ULDHPSXMyHOWURQFRKDFtDDEDMRGHODFROLQD5RGyKDFLDXQD SLVFLQDGHJDV\H[SORWy/DSHUVRQDFKLOOy\VHGHUUXPEyFRQWUDHOiUERO+XERRWUR HVWDOOLGRHQVRUGHFHGRUGHWUiVGHHOORV\$ULDVHYROYLy\JULWy

³9DPRV ³JLPLy $ULD HPSH]DQGR D FRUUHU³ £7HQHPRV TXH VDOLU GH DTXt DQWHV GH TXHHVWHPRVPXHUWDV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

/D SHUVRQD HVWDED DSUHWDGD D~Q FRQWUD HO WURQFR GHO iUERO PLUDQGR D $ULD FRQ XQD QHXUyWLFDPLUDGDHQVXURVWURFXELHUWRGHKROOtQ

ʹͶͲ

/RVERVTXHVHUDQXQDSDUHGGHFRORUQDUDQMD(OIXHJRHVWDEDVXELHQGRSRUORViUEROHV DKRUDGHUULEDQGRPiVUDPDV(QFXHVWLyQGHVHJXQGRVHVWDUtDQURGHDGRV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

&DStWXOR &DStWXOR 5HQDFLHQGRGHODVFHQL]DV 5HQDFLHQGRGHODVFHQL]DV 7UDGXFLGRSRU$QHOLVVH &RUUHJLGRSRU&DDPLOOH 

(

PLO\ 6SHQFHU \ +DQQD VDOLHURQ FRUULHQGR GHO JUDQHUR FRUULHQGR WDQ UiSLGR FyPRSXGLHURQ\OHMRVGHODVOODPDVTXHKDEtDQHVWDOODGRDVXDOUHGHGRU(ODLUH ROtDDKXPRHVSHVR\DiUEROHVHQOODPDV/RVSXOPRQHVGH(PLO\TXHPDEDQ PLHQWUDVFRUUtD 6H PHWLHURQ D WUDYpV GH XQ PRQWyQ GH JUXHVRV DUEXVWRV KDFLHQGR FDVR RPLVR GH ODV UHEDEDV TXH VH FRORFDEDQ HQ VXV VXpWHUHV SLHO \ FDEHOOR $ FRQWLQXDFLyQ +DQQD VH GHWXYRDEUXSWDPHQWH\VHOOHYyODVPDQRVDODSDUWHVXSHULRUGHODFDEH]D ³2KPL'LRV³VHODPHQWy³:LOGHQ/RYLHORWURGtDHQHO+RPH'HSRWFDUJDQGR XQJUXSRGHWDPERUHVGHDOJRHQVXFRFKH(UDSURSDQR (PLO\VLQWLyQiXVHDV\PDUHRV3HQVyHQFyPR-DVRQODKDEtDPLUDGRGLUHFWDPHQWHD ORVRMRVGHODRWUDQRFKHGHVSXpVGHTXHpOVDOLHUDGHODFDVDGH-HQQD&yPR:LOGHQ ODVKDEtDPLUDGRHQODILHVWD(OORVVDEtDQ ³9DPRV³LQVWyD6SHQFHUVHxDODQGRDWUDYpVGHORViUEROHV3RGtDQYHUODVLOXHWDGHO PROLQRGHYLHQWRGH6SHQFHUSRUGHODQWH/DVHJXULGDGHVWDEDFHUFD

,UUXPSLHURQHQHOSDWLRWUDVHURGH6SHQFHUWRVLHQGRHOKXPRQRFLYRGHVXVSXOPRQHV (OPROLQRGHYLHQWRGHORV+DVWLQJVHVWDEDHQOODPDVWDPELpQ&DGDXQDGHODVYLHMDV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

$TXt HVWDEDQ FRUULHQGR SRU HO PLVPR ERVTXH GRQGH HOOD KDEtD PXHUWR PX\ SRVLEOHPHQWHFRQODPLVPDJHQWHTXHODKDEtDQPDWDGRWUDWDEDGHPDWDUODVWDPELpQ

ʹͶͳ

(O YLHQWR DUUHFLy VRSODQGR ODV FHQL]DV HQ WRGDV SDUWHV $OJR FXDGUDGR \ SODQR UHYRORWHy SDVDQGR D (PLO\ OOHJDQGR D XQD SDUDGD HQ HO SLH GH XQ SHTXHxR iUERO QXGRVR (UD OD LPDJHQ GHO VDQWXDULR GH $Ot HQ OD TXH $OL OOHYDED XQD FDPLVHWD 9RQ +RODQGHVD \ ODV FXDWUR DOUHGHGRU GH HOOD ULHQGR /DV HVTXLQDV GH OD IRWR HVWDEDQ FDUERQL]DGDVSRUODVOODPDV\ODPLWDGGHODFDEH]DGH6SHQFHUKDEtDVLGRTXHPDGD (PLO\PLUyDORVRMRVD]XOHVDOHJUHV\EULOODQWHVGH$OL

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

OiPLQDVGHPDGHUDVH URPSLy\FD\HQGRDO VXHOR(QODSDUWHLQIHULRUKDEtDQHVFULWR 0(17,526$ D WUDYpV GH HOODV FRQ SLQWXUD GH DHURVRO URMR VDQJUH HVWDED DFRVWDGD VREUHODKLHUEDSDUHFtDTXHTXHPDUDPiVEULOODQWHPHQWH 8Q JULWR VXUJLy GH OD ILQD PDGHUD $O SULQFLSLR (PLO\ SHQVy TXH HUD XQD VLUHQD GH ERPEHURV« VHJXUDPHQWH HOORV LEDQ GH FDPLQR (QWRQFHV R\y RWUR JULWR DJXGR \ DWHUURUL]DGR$JDUUyODPDQRGH6SHQFHU ³¢4XpSDVDVLHVRHV$ULD"6XQXHYDFDVDHUDHQXQEDUULRPiV3RGUtDKDEHUFRUWDGR SRUHOERVTXHSDUDOOHJDUKDVWDDTXt $QWHVGH6SHQFHUSXGLHUDFRQWHVWDUGRVILJXUDVFD\HURQGHVGHORViUEROHVJUXHVRVTXH TXHPDEDQ$ULD$OJXLHQPiVHVWDEDGHWUiVGHHOODDOJXLHQYHVWLGRFRQXQDVXGDGHUD FRQFDSXFKD\YROXPLQRVRVSDQWDORQHVYDTXHURV /DVFKLFDVURGHDURQD$ULD ³(VWR\ ELHQ ³GLMR HOOD UiSLGDPHQWH +L]R XQ JHVWR D OD SHUVRQD D VX ODGR 4XLHQTXLHUDTXHIXHUDVHKDEtDDFXUUXFDGRHQSRVLFLyQIHWDOVREUHODKLHUEDPXHUWD ³(VWDEDDWUDSDGRGHEDMRGHXQDUDPDJUDQGH³H[SOLFy$ULD³7XYHTXHHPSXMDUOR ³¢(VWiVKHULGR"³OHSUHJXQWy(PLO\DODSHUVRQD6DFXGLyODFDEH]DJLPLHQGRRWUD YH]$OROHMRVHQODGLVWDQFLDVHR\yHOLQFHQGLRGHXQPRWRU(VSHUHPRVTXHHQYtHQ XQDDPEXODQFLDWDPELpQ ³¢4XpKDFtDVHQHOERVTXHGHWRGRVPRGRV"³OHSUHJXQWy6SHQFHU /DSHUVRQDTXHGHMyHVFDSDUXQDWRVYLROHQWD\VHFD ³5HFLEtXQDQRWD (PLO\VHGHWXYR/DYR]GHODSHUVRQDHUDSRFRPiVTXHXQVXVXUURSHURVRQDEDFRPR ODGHXQDFKLFDQRXQPXFKDFKR ³¢8QDQRWD«"³UHSLWLy(PLO\

³¢(OORV"³SUHJXQWy6SHQFHU0LUyDODVGHPiV/DVOODPDVGHORVERVTXHVEDLODURQHQ VXURVWUR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³0HGLMHURQTXHHQWUDUDHQHVWRVERVTXHV(UDUHDOPHQWHLPSRUWDQWH3HURFUHRTXH HVWDEDQWUDWDQGRGHPDWDUPH

ʹͶʹ

/DPXFKDFKDVHWDSyODFDUDFRQODVPDQRVHVWUHPHFLpQGRVHSRUORVVROOR]RV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

/DQLxDYROYLyDWRVHU ³(VWDEDVHJXUDGHTXHLEDDPRULU 8QDVHQVDFLyQUHVEDODGL]DVHDUUDVWUyVREUHODSLHOGH(PLO\/DYR]GHODQLxDWRGDYtD HUDDPRUWLJXDGD\iVSHUDSHURWHQtDXQWRQRFiOLGRTXH(PLO\QRKDEtDRtGRGXUDQWH PXFKR WLHPSR PXFKR WLHPSR +H LQKDODGR GHPDVLDGR KXPR VH GLMR (VWR\ HVFXFKDQGR OR TXH TXLHUR HVFXFKDU 3HUR FXDQGR PLUy D ODV RWUDV OH VRUSUHQGLHURQ WDPELpQODVH[SUHVLRQHVHQVXVFDUDV ³(VWiELHQ(VWiVDVDOYRDKRUD³PXUPXUy6SHQFHU /DFKLFDWUDWyGHDVHQWLUFRQODFDEH]D&XDQGROHFRJLyODVPDQRVGHVXFDUDHVWDEDQ FXELHUWDV GH QHJUR KROOtQ $ FRQWLQXDFLyQ OHYDQWy OD FDEH]D (O KROOtQ \ HO KXPR OH KDEtDQUD\DGRVXVPHMLOODVUHYHODQGRXQDSLHOFODUDGHFRORUURVD&XDQGRPLUyDODV FKLFDV SRU SULPHUD YH] \ VRQULy FRQ JUDWLWXG HO FRUD]yQ GH (PLO\ VH GHWXYR /D PXFKDFKDWHQtDXQRVRMRVD]XOEULOODQWH8QDQDUL]SHUIHFWDXQSRFRKDFLDDUULED/RV ODELRV HQ IRUPD GH DUFR 0LHQWUDV VH OLPSLDED VDFiQGRVH HO KROOtQ HVWDED VX FDUD DQJXODU\HQIRUPDGHFRUD]yQ /DV PLUy ILMDPHQWH SDUHFLHQGR TXH QR ODV UHFRQRFtD 3HUR OD UHFRQRFLHURQ +DQQD GHMy HVFDSDU XQ SHTXHxR FKLOOLGR GROLGD 6SHQFHU VH TXHGy PX\ TXLHWD (PLO\ VH VHQWtDWDQPDUHDGDTXHVHKXQGLyHQHOSDVWRDIHUUiQGRVHODFDEH]D $OOt HVWDED OD FKLFD GH ODV IRWRV HQ ODV QRWLFLDV /D FKLFD HQ HO VDOYDSDQWDOODV GH ORV WHOpIRQRV GH (PLO\ /D FKLFD GH OD IRWR TXH KDEtD YRODGR D WUDYpV GHO ERVTXH XQRV PRPHQWRV DQWHV /D TXH KDEtD HVWDGR XVDQGR XQD FDPLVHWD 9RQ +RODQGHVD HQ HVD IRWRULHQGRFRPRVLQDGDPDOROHLEDDSDVDU (VWRQRSRGtDHVWDUSDVDQGRSHQVy(PLO\1RKDEtDPDQHUDGHTXHHVWRSXGLHUDHVWDU RFXUULHQGR 

ž‰‹ƒ

ʹͶ͵

(UD«$OL



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(SLORJR (SLORJR ¢4XpSDVDGHVSXpV" ¢4XpSDVDGHVSXpV" 7UDGXFLGRSRU3DROD6 &RUUHJLGRSRU&DDPLOOH  D$SXHVWRTXHQRYLVWHpVDYHQLU3HURW~ VDEHVFyPRHVHQ5RVHZRRGHQXQ PLQXWR YHV DOJR \ DO VLJXLHQWH £SXI 6H KD LGR /R TXp KDFH TXH VHD DOJR LPSRVLEOH DYHULJXDU OR TXH UHDOPHQWH HVWi SDVDQGR 7DDDDDDQ IUXVWUDQWH ¢YHUGDG"

£-

/DVSUHJXQWDVSUREDEOHPHQWHWHHVWiQPDWDQGR¢(VWi,DQUHDOPHQWHPXHUWRRHVWi EHELHQGR PRMLWRV HQ 0p[LFR SODQHDQGR VX YHQJDQ]D" /D LPLWDFLyQ GH OD PDPi GH 6SHQFHU UHDOPHQWH UREy VX GLQHUR HQ HIHFWLYR ¢2 VLPSOHPHQWH HVWi SDJDQGR PL SUHFLR" (V HO HQDPRUDGR GH $ULD XQ DVHVLQR SVLFyWLFR ¢2 PLV QRWDV VyOR OD KDFHQ SHQVDUTXHORHV"(PLO\GHVFXEULyXQRVFXURVHFUHWRGHODIDPLOLD'L/DXUHQWLV¢2VX VHUYLGRUD GHMyHOOLEURILUPDGRSDUDTXHORHQFRQWUDUD"(O3ROLFtDIDYRULWRGH+DQQD DFDEy GH WUDWDU GH TXHPDUOD KDVWD TXHGDU FUXMLHQWH ¢2 DOJXLHQ PiV TXLHUH D HVWDV SHUUDVPXHUWDV"¢<TXpKD\GHPt"¢(VWR\GHOODGRGHHVWDVFKLFDVRHVWR\WLUDQGRGH WRGRV ORV KLORV" 3HUR DTXt HVWi OD SUHJXQWD GHO PLOOyQ ¢$ TXLpQR TXpDFDEDQ GH YHU UHVXUJLUGHODVFHQL]DV" ¢3RGUtD$OLHVWDUYLYD"¢2HVVyORKXPR\HVSHMRV" (VVXILFLHQWHSDUDYROYHUORFRDFXDOTXLHUD(O5DGOH\SXHGHHVWDUFHUUDGRDOS~EOLFR SHUR KD\ RWURV PDQLFRPLRV FHUFD 3DUD HO PRPHQWR HQ TXH KD\D WHUPLQDGR FRQ +DQQD$ULD 6SHQFHU \(PLO\FXDWUR QXHYDVERQLWDVSDFLHQWHVSRGUtDQHVWDU VLHQGR UHJLVWUDGDV 'XHUPDQELHQFKLFDV0LHQWUDVWRGDYtDSXHGDQ

)LQ )LQ



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

³$

ʹͶͶ

%HVRV

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU

(QHOSUy[LPRWRPRGHHVWDIDVFLQDQWHVDJD« (QHOSUy[LPRWRPRGHHVWDIDVFLQDQWHVDJD«

+HDUWOHVV +HDUWOHVV          (Q HO SLQWRUHVFR 5RVHZRRG 5RVHZRRG  3HQQV\OYDQLD ORV YHFLQRV FKLVPHDQ VREUH FHUFDV GH G PDGHUDV\ODV689VEULOODQWHVVHHVWDFLRQDQHQFDG PDGHUDV\ODV689VEULOODQWHVVHHVWDFLRQDQHQFDGDHQWUDGDGHJUDQLWRWULWXUDGR6LQ DHQWUDGDGHJUDQLWRWULWXUDGR6LQ HPEDUJRUHFLHQWHPHQWHODVVRQULVDVDPLVWRVDVKDQ HPEDUJRUHFLHQWHPHQWHODVVRQULVDVDPLVWRVDVKDQVLGRUHHPSOD]DGDVSRUVRVSHFKRVDV VLGRUHHPSOD]DGDVSRUVRVSHFKRVDV PLUDGDV \ VXVXUURV DFXVDWRULRV DFXVDWRULRV³\ \ HV WRGR SRUTXH +DQQD $ULD (PLO\ \ 6SHQFHU QR SXHGHQPDQWHQHUODERFDFHUUDGD SXHGHQPDQWHQHUODERFDFHUUDGD« 3ULPHUR DILUPDURQ HQFRQWUDU XQ FDGiYHU HQ HO ERVTXH ERVTXH GHWUiV GH OD FDVD GH 6SHQFHU VyOR SDUD TXH GHVDSDUHFLHUD VLQ GHMDU UDVWUR /XHJR /XHJR  FXDQGR HO PLVPR ERVTXH VH LQFHQGLyMXUDURQTXHYLHURQDDOJXLHQ UDURQTXHYLHURQDDOJXLHQ³TXHVHVXSRQHHVWDPXHUWD³OHYDQWDUVHGHODV OHYDQWDUVHGHODV FHQL]DV ( LQFOXVR GHVSXpV GH WRGR HVR ODV SHTXHxD SHTXHxDV V OLQGDV PHQWLURVDV WRGDYtD HVWiQ MXJDQGRFRQIXHJR



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ

/DVDPLJDVLQVLVWHQHQTXHHVWiQGLFLHQGRODYHUGDG /DVDPLJDVLQVLVWHQHQTXHHVWiQGLFLHQGRODYHUGDGVREUHORTXHYLHURQSHURWRGRVHQ VREUHORTXHYLHURQSHURWRGRVHQ 5RVHZRRGFUHHQTXHHVWiQVLPSOHPHQWH 5RVHZRRGFUHHQTXHHVWiQVLPSOHPHQWHWUDWDQGRGHOODPDUODDWHQFLyQ³ ³\DQDGLHOH JXVWD XQD FKLFD OORURQD $Vt TXH FXDQGR HO DVHVLQR IHUR] YHQJD WUDV GH ODV FKLFDV DOJXLHQOHVFUHHUi«¢2VHUiQODVSUy[LPDVHQGHVDSDUHFHU" VHUiQODVSUy[LPDVHQGHVDSDUHFHU"

ʹͶͷ

+DQQDHVWDEXVFDQGRHQ'LRUXQDFDPLVDGHIXHU]D$ +DQQDHVWDEXVFDQGRHQ'LRUXQDFDPLVDGHIXHU]D$ULDHVWiWUDWDQGRGHFRQWDFWDU ULDHVWiWUDWDQGRGHFRQWDFWDUD ORV PXHUWRV (PLO\ ERWR D VX QRY QRYLR \ VH HVFDSR GH OD FLXGDG« RWUD YH] < 6SHQFHU SLHQVDTXHDOJXLHQHQVXIDPLOLDKDDVHVLQDGR SLHQVDTXHDOJXLHQHQVXIDPLOLDKDDVHVLQDGR

6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU



$FHUFDGHODDXWRUD«

6DUD6KHSDUG 

—ƒ†‘ ƒ”ƒ Š‡’ƒ”† ‡”ƒ Œ‘˜‡ǡ Žƒ• …‘•ƒ• “—‡ “—‡”‹ƒ •‡” …—ƒ†‘ …”‡…‹‡”ƒ ‡”ƒǣ •–”‡ŽŽƒ†‡–‡Ž‡‘˜‡Žƒ•ǡ†‹•‡Óƒ†‘”ƒ†‡ ǡ †‹”‡…–‘”ƒ †‡ …‹‡ǡ ƒ”–‹•–ƒ †‡ ’Žƒ•–‹Ž‹ƒǡ ‰‡‡–‹•‹•–ƒǡ ‡†‹–‘”ƒ †‡ ”‡˜‹•–ƒ• †‡ ‘†ƒ ›ǡ ƒ•“—‡ƒ†ƒǡ‡•…”‹–‘”ƒǤ  — ’”‹‡”ƒ Š‹•–‘”‹ƒǡ Žƒ …—ƒŽ ‡ŽŽƒ ‡•…”‹„‹‘ ‡ ‹Ž—•–”‘ǡ ‡”ƒ ƒ…‡”…ƒ †‡ ƒ‹‰ƒ„Ž‡• …”‹ƒ–—”ƒ• ƒƒ”‹ŽŽƒ• “—‡ ˜‹˜‹ƒ ‡ ‡Ž Œƒ”†‹ †‡Ž ’ƒ–‹‘ –”ƒ•‡”‘†‡—ƒ‹ÓƒǤ—•‡‰—†ƒ•‡‰—‹ƒƒ— ‰”—’‘†‡ƒ‹ƒŽ‡•ǡ‹…Ž—›‡†‘ƒ—…ƒ‡ŽŽ‘ †‡…‹…‘’‹‡”ƒ•ŽŽƒƒ†‘Ž‘›†ǡ“—‡‹„ƒ‡ —ƒ ‡š’‡†‹…‹‘ ƒ –”ƒ˜‡• †‡Ž •‹•–‡ƒ …‹”…—Žƒ–‘”‹‘†‡Ž…—‡”’‘Š—ƒ‘Ǥ ƒ”ƒ › •— Š‡”ƒƒ Ž‹•‘Ȅ“—‹‡ ‘ •‡ ’ƒ”‡…‡ ‡ ƒ†ƒ ƒ Žƒ Ž‹•‘ †‡ ”‡––› ‹––Ž‡ ‹ƒ”•ȄŠƒ ‡•–ƒ†‘ …”‡ƒ†‘ ‡ …‘Œ—–‘ ƒ”–‹•–‹…‘ › ‡•…”‹–‘ ’”‘›‡…–‘• †‡•†‡ “—‡ ‡”ƒ ‹Óƒ•’‡“—‡Óƒ•ǡ‡š…‡’–‘“—‡‡ŽŽƒ•‡•–ƒ„ƒ•–ƒ–‡•‡‰—”ƒ•“—‡‡ŽŽƒ••‘Žƒ•…ƒ•“—‡ Ž‘‡…—‡–”ƒ‰”ƒ…‹‘•‘Ǥ  ƒ”ƒ”‡…‹‡–‡‡‡•‡—†‘†‡—‡˜‘ƒŽƒ‹‹‡†‡ ‹Žƒ†‡Žˆ‹ƒ†‡•†‡”‹œ‘ƒǡ†‘†‡ •——‡˜ƒ•‡”‹‡†‡Ž‹„”‘•ǡ   ǡ‡•–ƒŽ‹•–ƒǤ  ”ƒ†—…‹†‘’‘”†”‡ƒ ƒ”ƒ ‡ —ƒ ‡•…‡ƒ †‡ ”‡––›  ‹––Ž‡ ‹ƒ”•ǡ ‡Ž ’”‘‰”ƒƒ†‡„ƒ•ƒ†‘‡•—•‡”‹‡†‡Ž‹„”‘•Ǥ

 



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH



ž‰‹ƒ



ʹͶ͸



6DUD6KHSDUG

3UHWW\/LWWOH/LDUV

.LOOHU 

   7UDGXFLGR&RUUHJLGR\'LVHxDGR 7UDGXFLGR&RUUHJLGR\'LVHxDGR 

(QHO)RUR (QHO)RUR





´3XUSOH5RVHµ ZZZSXUSOHURVHFRP

ž‰‹ƒ

ʹͶ͹

£7HHVSHUDPRV £7HHVSHUDPRV



)RUR3XUSOH5RVH )RUR3XUSOH5RVH