Uncertainty Relation Revisited from Quantum Estimation Theory Yu Watanabe Collaborators: Takahiro Sagawa, Masahito Ueda The University of Tokyo

arXiv:1010.3571 (2010).

2/17/2011

Nagoya Winter Workshop 2011 (NWW2011)

Outline 

Two types of uncertainty relation  Our setup of estimation process  Our results  Relation to information geometry

2

Two types of uncertainty relation 

Indeterminacy --- property of quantum states --Trade-off relation on state preparation Non-commutable observables cannot have definite value simultaneously. 

Kennard-Robertson’s inequality (1927, 1929) : quantum fluctuation



Schrodinger’s inequality (1930)

: symmetrized quantum corelation function 3

Two types of uncertainty relation 

Complementarity --- property of measurements (operations) --Trade-off relation between measurement errors We cannot perform measurement without back-action. We cannot perform precise measurement of non-commutable observables simultaneously.

We cannot know

and

precisely, if

.

There must exist trade-off relations obtained information about non-commutable observables. However, the optimal trade-off relation is not found so far. optimal: the equality is achievable for all states and observables. What is the optimal bound of complementarity? 4

Estimation Theory -- Essential Part of Complementarity

: estimator (estimated value) of

5

Example

6

Example

7

Example

8

Example

9

Example

10

Cramer-Rao inequality 

For all consistent estimators such that

for all

and

: Fisher information matrix

: parameter of  11

Quantum Cramer-Rao inequality 

For all POVM

for all : Quantum Fisher information matrix Ex.) SLD, RLD, etc… 

Combining with classical Cramer-Rao inequality,

Projection measurement of

12

Measurement Error 

Measurement error of observable

in POVM

Projection measurement of 

and

cannot vanish simultaneously, if

There must exist trade-off relations between and ..

13

Theorem 1 

For all • POVM measurements • observables • quantum states



Proof From quantum Cramer-Rao inequality, for all

: RLD Fisher information matrix

then the discriminant of quadratic polynomial is always negative. 14

Arthurs and Goodman’s inequality Unbiased measurement Target

Probe : projection measurement of for all : unbiasedness condition For all unbiased measurements,

15

Estimation Scheme on Unbiased Measurement 

One of the simplest (may not be optimal)way to estimate and is : eigenvalue of : number of times we obtain outcome In this case,

then

16

Theorem 1 

For all • POVM measurements • observables • quantum states

However, the bound is not optimal. Example. For for all

17

Conjecture •

The optimal bound of the trade-off relation is

: “intrinsic” quantum fluctuation

: “intrinsic” quantum correlation function

• •

2-dimensional Hilbert space : proved Higher dimension : not proved but numerical evidences exist.

18

What is intrinsic quantum fluctuation and correlation ? : simultaneous irreducible invariant subspace of

and

: projection on

19

Example 

and

cannot be simultaneous block diagonalizable



and

are commutable



In general

20

Theorem 2 --- achievability of the optimal bound --For all observables and quantum states, there exist a measurement

such that

The measurement that attain the inequality is performing projection measurements of with probability

.

Condition for attaining the bound is the off-diagonal element of

equals to zero. 21

Not Optimal Scheme

In this case,

22

Optimal Scheme

23

Example 

Simultaneous measurement of two spin observables.

24

Theorem 3 For the case of

,

is satisfied.

Lemma

: SLD Fisher information matrix

From Gill and Massar bound,

25

Proof of Theorem 3 If

,

26

Numerical Evidence of the Conjecture POVMs are plotted.

Nagaoka’s inequality

27

Relation to Information Geometry •

Cramer-Rao inequality • Fisher metric: monotone metric on probability distribution manifold • Quantum Fisher metric: monotone metric on quantum state space • Quantum Cramer-Rao inequality • Complementarity on quantum information geometry 28

Fisher metric and Cencov’s theorem 

Monotonicity of statistical model Markov mapping



Monotone metric on statistical model is uniquely determined to Fisher metric .

29

Quantum Fisher metric and Petz’s theorem 

Monotonicity of quantum statistical manifold Quantum process



Monotone metric on quantum statistical manifold has minimum and maximum. •

SLD is the minimum and RLD is the maximum. 30

Quantum Cramer-Rao inequality 

What is quantum measurement? Quantum measurement



Quantum Cramer-Rao inequality for all

31

Complementarity from geometrical point of view 

Equality of

cannot be achievable.

Equality of with real vector attained by the projection measurement of

can be .



Complementarity on quantum information geometry Trade-off relation between and  Our conjecture

is important to understand the effect on quantum state manifold by the measurement

. 32

Summary and future studies 

Summary • We conjecture that the optimal bound of measurement errors is





This is important for understanding quantum information geometry.

Future studies • Prove the conjecture. It may come soon!

33

Thank you!

34

Quantum Estimation Theory

optimal: the equality is achievable for all states and observables. [ What is the optimal bound of ... w MX ;§fвз,*£t¢*вв+,¢,Vp¢;'ffi'з *4-*+ 'air q,*-w,44". ~* 1*.

2MB Sizes 1 Downloads 264 Views

Recommend Documents

Quantum Estimation Theory
L~. Example. X€St. Z3. >. $62. 77,. O 100 299. 7 ..... (AQXM)2 := ;p@{Tr[z>11>?,%1 ~ T"ii5aXui2}.

Quantum criticality as a resource for quantum estimation
1Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, California 90089-0484, USA ..... lar shift of the location of the quantum critical point may be ..... 1 H. Cramer, Mathematical Methods of Statistics Princeton.

Quantum Field Theory - Semantic Scholar
that goes something like this: “The pion has spin zero, and so the lepton and the antineutrino must emerge with opposite spin, and therefore the same helicity. An antineutrino is always right-handed, and so the lepton must be as well. But only the

Quantum Theory Notes.pdf
There was a problem previewing this document. Retrying... Download. Connect more apps... Try one of the apps below to open or edit this item. Quantum Theory ...

Agrawal, Quantum Field Theory ( QFT), Quantum Optics ( QED).pdf ...
Retrying... Agrawal, Quantum Field Theory ( QFT), Quantum Optics ( QED).pdf. Agrawal, Quantum Field Theory ( QFT), Quantum Optics ( QED).pdf. Open. Extract.

Optimal quantum estimation in spin systems at criticality
Oct 9, 2008 - example of a many-body system exhibiting criticality, and derive the optimal quantum estimator of the cou- ..... is universal, i.e., independent on the anisotropy and given ..... 19 P. Zanardi et al., e-print arXiv:0708.1089, Phys.

Fradkin, Tseytlin, Quantum String Theory Effective Action.pdf ...
Fradkin, Tseytlin, Quantum String Theory Effective Action.pdf. Fradkin, Tseytlin, Quantum String Theory Effective Action.pdf. Open. Extract. Open with. Sign In.

Schwinger, Relativistic Quantum Field Theory, Nobel Lecture.pdf ...
Schwinger, Relativistic Quantum Field Theory, Nobel Lecture.pdf. Schwinger, Relativistic Quantum Field Theory, Nobel Lecture.pdf. Open. Extract. Open with.

true motion estimation — theory, application, and ... - Semantic Scholar
From an application perspective, the TMT successfully captured true motion vectors .... 6 Effective System Design and Implementation of True Motion Tracker.

true motion estimation — theory, application, and ... - Semantic Scholar
5 Application in Motion Analysis and Understanding: Object-Motion Estima- ...... data, we extend the basic TMT to an integration of the matching-based technique ...