Government of Uttarakhand Uttarakhand Urban Sector Development Investment Program (UUSDIP) [ADB Loan No: 2410 IND]
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I) Contract Package- WWM01D, WWM02D, WWM03D & WWM04DN
March 2011 Investment Program Management Unit, Urban Development Department, Government of Uttarakhand
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
LIST OF CONTENTS Section
Title
Page
List of Abbreviations Executive Summary
A B C D E F G H I J K
Description of the Subproject Objectives of the Short Resettlement Plan Scope of Land Acquisition & Resettlement Socio-economic Profile of the Affected Households Gender Impacts Resettlement Principles & Policy Framework Public consultation, information and Disclosure
Grievance Redress Mechanism Compensation and Income Restoration Institutional Arrangements/Framework, Resettlement Budget/Cost and Implementation Schedule Monitoring & Evaluation and Reporting
2 3 6 9 10 13 14 14 16 17 17 18 21
List of Appendices Appendix 1: Appendix 2: Appendix 3: Appendix 4: Appendix 5:
Consultation and Focus Group Discussion Schedule of Resettlement Plan Safeguards Disclosure Session held on 07-06-2007 Census Survey Questionnaire List of Affected Persons (APs)
23-33 34-34 35-36 37-38 49-43
List of Tables Table No. 1. 2 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. List of Figures Figure No. 1.
Title Sewerage System Sub-Projects & Its Resettlement Impacts Summary of Resettlements Impacts Extent of Impacts Educational Attainment Income Level Occupation Entitlement Matrix Institutional Role & Responsibilities Summary of Resettlement Cost Implementation Schedule Title Location of Sewerage collection System Sub-Project Zones in the Map of Dehradun
Pages 11 12 13 13 13 14 15 18 19 20 Pages 22
1
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
ADB APs BC BPL CAPP DSC FGD GOI GRC ESMC EA IA IP IR IPMU IPMC LA NGO NPRR PAP PIU PWD RoW RF RP R&R RIC SC SRP ST SDS SIA TLC ToR UDD UUSIDIP VC
Asian Development Bank Affected Persons Backward Community Below Poverty Line Community Awareness Public Participation Design and Supervision Consultants Focus Group Discussions Government of India Grievance Redressal Committee Environment and Social Management Cell Executing Agency Implementing Agency Indigenous Peoples Involuntary Resettlement Investment Program Management Unit Investment Program Management Consultants Land Acquisition Non-Government Organizations National Policy on Resettlement & Rehabilitation Project Affected Person Project Implementation Unit Public Works Department Right of Way Resettlement Framework. Resettlement Plan Resettlement & Rehabilitation Resettlement Implementation Committee Schedule Caste short resettlement plan Schedule Tribe Social Development Specialist Social Impact Assessment Town Level Committee Terms of Reference Urban Development Department Uttarakhand Urban Sector Development Investment Programme Valuation Committee
2
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Executive Summary of the Short Resettlement Plan A.
Description of the Project
Uttarakhand Urban Sector Development Investment Program (UUSDIP) is intended to optimize social and economic development and poverty reduction throughout the urban sector in Uttarakhand. This will be achieved through investments in urban infrastructure (water supply; sewerage and sanitation; solid waste management; urban transport and roads). UUSDIP will also provide policy reforms to strengthen urban governance, management, and support for urban infrastructure and services. The sub-project comprises of Sewerage Collection System of Dehradun to the centrally located Kargi zone. The total length of Sewerage Collection System lines in this centrally located Kargi zone is 158.39 Km. This is a short resettlement plan (SRP) which has been prepared for Sewerage Collection System, Dehradun Contract Package under the Sewerage System sub-project in Dehradun under the Investment Program’s Tranche 1. . B.
Objectives of the Short Resettlement Plan
This Short Resettlement Plan is prepared to deal with impacts of land acquisition and resettlement issues resulting from the rehabilitation of the said Sewerage Collection System. The Plan provides an analysis of the impacts, identifies the nature and types of losses, and establishes an entitlement matrix as a guide to payments for compensation and resettlement benefits. The primary objective of this SRP is to restore the income and living standards of the affected persons (APs), if any, due to the subproject within a short period of time without any disruptions in their own economic and social environment. C.
Scope of Land Acquisition & Impacts
The Project has its objectives of avoiding involuntary resettlement wherever possible, by means of adopting an appropriate technical design, which leads to minimization of the resettlement impact. However to avoid any disturbance to daily business activities, it is proposed that work should be executed during early hours of day in order to avoid inconvenience to public as well as traders and vendors. Even after there will be 96 APs affected temporarily during the construction. This is the Dehradun Nagar Nigam and PWD roads and these 96 APs will be affected on a temporary basis during the laying of pipeline and, the same road will be put into use after the laying of the pipe line. If their livelihood will be affected they will be compensated properly as per the entitlement matrix put in the report, The summary of cost is based on the information collected from the Directorate of Labour Commission, Government of Uttarakhand to hire a labour from the market is Rs. 149/labour/day and secondly in consultation with the APs. The restoration supports to five vulnerable women- headed households are calculated on lump-sum basis. D.
Gender impacts
The Consultants analyzed the potential impact of the Project on women by means of undertaking FGDs during the course of the social assessments. Five woman-headed households were found among the APs. The subproject as per the women groups will benefit them indirectly by means of better sewerage, roads and solid waste management infrastructure.
3
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
E.
Resettlement Principles and Policy Framework
The legislation governing the land acquisition is the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (revised in 1984). In accordance with the Act the legal process for the acquisition of the land, if required, shall be initiated by the Executing Agency (EA) through the District Collector (DC) of the respective district. It also takes into account the entitlement benefits as listed in the National Policy on R&R, (Govt of India) 2007 and the relevant Asian Development Bank’s (ADB) policies and operations manuals, in particular the policy on Involuntary Resettlement (1995), and Operations Manual F2 on Involuntary Resettlement (2006). ADB’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement requires (i) projects to avoid or minimize impacts where possible through making appropriate design modifications; (ii) consultation with affected people in project planning and implementation, including disclosure of RP and project related information; (iii) payment of compensation for acquired assets at the market/replacement value; (iv) resettlement assistance to be provided to affected people, including non-titled persons; (v) special attention to be given vulnerable people and/groups; and (vi) income restoration and rehabilitation program to be provided. The cut off date for those without titles the cut-off will be the date of the census survey as undertaken on December 2010. People moving into the subproject area after this date will not be entitled for support. Entitlement Matrix for the subproject is given in the main text. . F.
Stakeholder Participation and Disclosure of SRP
Local level stakeholders were consulted in the subproject area while conducting initial social and poverty assessment. Similarly, due consideration was also given for Stakeholder consultations and public participation at different levels during SRP preparation. The SRP will be translated into Hindi and will be made available to the affected people by the implementing agency (IA) for their comments. Copies of the SRP will be made available at the local level public offices. The final SRP will be disclosed on the ADB and UUSDIP websites. G.
Implementation Arrangements
The Urban Development Department (UDD) is the Executing Agency (EA) of the UUSIDIP. The EA has already set up a state-level Investment Program Management Unit (IPMU). A Central Investment Program Implementation Unit (IPIU) has been set up as Implementing Agency (IA) which has further set up the sub-IPMUs to manage implementation of sub-projects in each town. The IPMU is being assisted by Investment Program Management Consultants (IPMC) which is providing program management support, assure the technical quality of design and construction, and provide advice on policy reforms whereas two DSCs have been established for two regions, one for Garhwal & another for Kumaun. All compensation and other assistances will be paid to all APs prior to commencement of civil works. A detailed implementation schedule for the various activities is provided in the main text. H. Grievance Redressal Grievances of APs will first be brought to the attention of the CAPP NGO or the Environment and Social Management Cell (ESMC). Grievances not redressed by the CAPP NGO will be brought to the Town Level Committees (TLC) set up to monitor project implementation in each town. The
4
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
TLC, acting as a grievance redress committee (GRC) is chaired by the Mayors or Chairpersons with representatives of ward members, the District Magistrate, Commissioner, Uttarakhand Peya Jal Nigam (UPJN), Uttarakhand Jal Sansthan (UJS), Public Works Department (PWD), business, and civil society. As a GRC, the TLC will meet every month (if grievances are brought to the Committee), determine the merit of each grievance, and resolve grievances within a month of receiving the complaint. The IPMU will submit SRP for ADB’s review and approval, and will ensure that affected persons will receive compensation and other assistances prior to commencement of civil works. I.
Budget
The total estimated cost for resettlement operation and management for the Project is Rs. 460092.00 (US $ 100021) (Rupees Four Lacs Sixty thousand ninety two only). J.
Monitoring, Evaluation and Reporting
14. Internal monitoring of Implementation of Short Resettlement Plan by CAPP NGO will be the responsibility of the ESMC and IPIU. Internal monitoring will include: (i) administrative monitoring: daily planning, implementation, feedback and trouble shooting, individual AP file maintenance, and progress reports; (ii) socio-economic monitoring: baseline information for comparing AP’s socio-economic conditions, relocation, salvaging materials, community relationships, dates for consultations, and number of grievances placed; and (iii) impact evaluation monitoring: income restored, and socioeconomic conditions of affected persons. The internal monitoring report will be submitted quarterly to the Asian Development Bank (ADB) by the IPMU. The implementing NGO will report its activity to IPIU on a monthly basis and the IPIU will send it to IPMC for review and then IPMC will forward to IPMU. IPMU will send it to ADB on a quarterly basis. To review the field report of NGO, DSC should help IPIU. The quarterly progress report to ADB from IPMU will be supported and revised by IPMC. An external monitoring agency/Consultant with prior experience in resettlement implementation monitoring and evaluation will be engaged by the EA. The external monitor will monitor and verify SRP implementation to determine whether resettlement goals have been achieved, livelihood and living standards have been restored, and provide recommendations for improvement. The external agency will report its findings simultaneously to the EA and to ADB twice a year.
1
Calculated as per the current value i.e. One US $= 46 Indian Rupee.
5
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Short Resettlement Plan A.
Description of the Subproject
1. Uttarakhand Urban Sector Development Investment Program (UUSDIP) is intended to optimize social and economic development and poverty reduction throughout the urban sector in Uttarakhand. This will be achieved through investments in urban infrastructure (water supply; sewerage and sanitation; solid waste management; urban transport and roads). UUSDIP will also provide policy reforms to strengthen policy reforms, management, and support for urban infrastructure and services. The Investment Program will support the Government of India (GOI) and the Government of Uttarakhand (GOU) in their policy of balanced regional socio-economic development and poverty reduction through improvements in urban governance, management, and infrastructure and service provision in 31 towns in Uttarakhand.2 The Investment Program will support: (i) water supply; (ii) sewerage and sewage treatment; (iii) municipal solid waste management; (iv) urban roads and traffic management; (v) slum upgrading and poverty reduction; and (vi) planning and design, institutional and policy development, capacity building, and awareness raising. The UUSDIP is funded by ADB through Multi-tranche Financing Facility (MFF). This Program will be implemented over a period of 08 years, beginning in 2008. The Executing Agency (EA) is the Urban Development Department (UDD) of Government of Uttarakhand (GOU), which has set up a state-level urban sector Investment Programme Management Unit (IPMU) and Investment Program Implementing Units to execute the UUSDIP. 2. This is an updated version of original Short Resettlement Plan (SRP) approved by ADB for Sewerage System sub-project in Dehradun to be taken in Tranche-1, prepared at the time of BTA. The updated SRP is specifically prepared for the Contract Package – Sewerage Collection System Contract Package WWM02D, WWM03D & WWM04D and Construction of Sewerage Treatment Plant Contract Package WWM01D in Dehradun. . Dehradun city has been divided in to six sewerage zones, The Kargi zone is biggest zone in the city. For the purpose of planning and designing the sewerage system, the Kargi zone has been divided into three sub areas, viz Un-Sewered area (newly developed), Sewered area sub zone E1, E2 & part of A3 and Sewered area sub zone E4(THDC colony). This SRP is for un-sewered area (contract package no. WWM02D), and sewered area (sub zones E1, E2 & part of A3) under the package no. WWM03D, Sewered Area THDC colony (Contract Package no.WWM04DN) and Sewerage Treatment Plant WWM01D. The brief details of these packages are as below
Details of Contract Package WWM01D 1 Location : Bamanwala/Kargi village, Haridwar bypass, Majra, Dehradun 2
Land Area
: 3.12 Hectare
3
High Flood Level
: 603.7 M
4
Road Level
: 606 M
5
Average Ground level
: 602 M
6
Collection System
: Separate Sewer System
2
These towns are: Almora, Bageshwar, Bajpur, Barkot, Champawat, Dehradun, Gangotri, Gopeshwar, Haldwani, Haridwar, Jaspur, Joshimath, Kashipur, Kichcha, Kotdwar, Manglore, Mussoorie, Nainital, New Tehri, Pauri, Pithoragarh, Ramnagar, Roorkee, Rudraprayag, Rudrapur, Srinagar, Kedarnath, Badrinath, Sitarganj, Uttarkashi, and Yamunotri.
6
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Details of Contract Package WWM01D 7 Effluent Discharge Point : Bindal River 8
Discharge Point Level
: 602 M
9
Design Year
: 2027
10
Design Population
: The total 2027 population (projected) of Dehradun town is about 11,42,764 comprising 10,12,190 of resident population and of 1,30,574 floating population which is about 12.9% of the resident population. The design population of Zone I (Kargi) for which this STP is proposed is accordingly considered to be 5,33,245 of resident population plus 12.9% extra for the floating population amounting. Resident population : 5,33,245 Floating population (12.9%) : 68,789 Design population : 6,02,034
11
Water Supply Rate
: 135 litre per capita per day+ 2% private source usage
12
Sewage Generation Rate
: 80% of water supply + 2 % infiltration 112.40 litres per capita per day
13
Sewage Flow
: 67.70 mld say 68 mld (602034 * 112.40)
14
Plant Capacity
: 68 MLD
15
Peak Factor
: 2.25 (as per CPHEEO Manual)
16
Peak Flow
: 153,000 m3/day (2.25 * 68,000)
17
Design Sewage Quality
:
17.1
Per Capita contribution
17.2
Per Capita SS contribution
: 70 g /Cap.day (Arciewala etal., 2006)
17.3
Incoming sewage BOD
: 45 x 103 mg/cap. day * 1/(112.40 L) /day = 400 mg/L
17.4
Incoming sewage BOD assumed in the design
: 400 x 0.625 = 250 mg/L (It is assumed that 35-40% of the BOD is degraded in the sewers)
17.5
Incoming sewage SS
: 70 x 103 mg/cap.day * 1/(112.4 L) day = 623 mg/L
17.6
Incoming sewage SS assumed in the design
: 623 x 0.625 = 389 mg/L or 400 mg/L (It is assumed that 35-40% of the SS is degraded in the sewers)
18
Treated Sewage Quality
:
BOD : 45 g /Cap.day (CPHEEO Manual)
Item
Influent
Effluent
BOD (mg/L)
250
30
SS (mg/L)
400
50
Coliforms
It is desirable to remove coliforms by appropriate disinfection techniques, even though it is not mandatory but desirable by Ministry of Environment & Forests, Govt. of India. Based on extensive data by IIT Roorkee,
7
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Details of Contract Package WWM01D influent fecal coliform concentration in sewage is assumed as 5 x 106 MPN/100 ml, which is to be reduced to 500 MPN/100 ml prior to discharging into Bindal River or for irrigation.
Details of Contract Package No WWM02D 1.
The colonies/layouts and areas covered under this package are; Kalindi Enclave, Arawali Enclave, Priyadarshani Enclave, Kaonli Gaon, Dwarika Puri, Hari Pur, Vyom Prasth, Engineers Enclave, Sailok Phase I and III, Anupam Vihaar, Sangam Vihaar, Ankitpuram, Narmada Enclave, Chandershekhar Azaad Colony, Gandhi Gram, Mayur Vihaar, Vasundhara Kunj, Pushpanjali Enclave, KaliMandir Enclave, Dronpuri, Alkananda Enclave, Janakpuri, Green Park, Braham Puri, Lohia Nagar, Gangotri Enclave, Aman Vihaar, Dashmesh Puri, Ashok Enclave, Kashmiri Colony, Nehru Vihaar, Brahman wala, Niranjanpur, Rishabh Vihaar, Shakti Vihaar Phase I and II, Mehboob Colony, Azaad Colony, Bank Colony, Hameed Colony, Moolchand Enclave, Choudhary Enclave, Sandhu Enclave, Uday Vihaar, Parkash Lok,Vasundhara Enclave, Shimla Enclave (W), Ashwani Enclave etc.
2.
Total coverage of area in the city in this package
: 6 sq km
3.
Population to be benefited (by 2011)
: 72,138
4.
Population to be benefited (by 2041)
: 2,00,567
5.
Total length of sewer network
: 81,167 meters
6.
Minimum diameter of sewers
: 200 mm
7.
Maximum diameter of sewers
: 1000 mm
8.
Number of manholes
: 3,033 nos
9.
Number of road side chambers
: 1950 nos
10. Length of Property Connections (PVC Pipes)
: 27509 m(110mm&160 mm diameter)
11. Pipe material
: RCC pipes of different classes
12. Manholes
: Brick masonry on internal roads and RCC on main roads.
Details of Contract Package WWM03D 1. The colonies/layouts and areas covered under this package are; Mansrovar Colony, Siddharth Enclave, Nehru Enclave, Hari Kunj, Hari Vihar, Satya Vihar, Vijay Park, Vijay Park Extension, Akashdeep Colony, Mahendra Vihaar, Deep Lok Colony, Mitralok Colony, Govindgarh, Teachers Colony, Parkash Nagar. Idgah, Shivaji Marg, Khurbura Mohalla, Shiv Colony, Gandhi Gram(east of Bindal River), Saraswati Soni Marg, Park Road, Keshav Road, New Basti (East of Bindal River), Sanjay Colony, Patel Nagar(West and East), Bhandari Bagh etc. 2. Total coverage of area in the city in this package
: 2.89 sq. km
3. Population to be benefited (by 2011)
: 55612
8
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
4. Population to be benefited (by 2041)
: 114150
5. Total length sewer network
: 44525 meters
6. Minimum diameter of sewers
: 200 mm
7. Maximum diameter of sewers
: 400 mm
8. Total number of manholes
: 1780 Nos
9. Total number of property chambers
: 1382 Nos.
10. Length of property connections (uPVC Pipes)
:14518m(110mm&160mm diameter)
11. Pipe material
: RCC pipes of different classes
12. Manholes
: Brick masonry on internal roads and RCC on main roads .
Details of Contract Package WWM04DN
1. The colonies/layouts and areas covered under this package are; THDC Dehrakhas colony, Nanak Vihaar, part of Vidya Vihaar phase II and phase III, Samridhi Enclave, Kargi, Sai Baba Enclave, Dev Rishi colony, Rest Camp area, Chander Nagar, Madrasi colony, Kusum Vihaar etc.
2. Total coverage of area in the city in this package
: 1.86 sq. km
3. Population to be benefited (by 2011)
: 23126
4. Population to be benefited (by 2041)
: 62497
5. Total length sewer network
: 32700 meters
6. Minimum diameter of sewers
: 200 mm
7. Maximum diameter of sewers
: 1400 mm
8. Total number of manholes
: 1352 Nos
9. Total number of property chambers
: 1295 Nos.
10.
B.
Length of property connections (uPVC Pipes)
: 10899m(110mm&160mm dia)
11. Pipe material
:
12. Manholes
:
RCC pipes of different classes & DI pipe through Nallah/River. Brick masonry on internal roads and RCC on main roads
Objectives of the Short Resettlement Plan 3. This Short Resettlement Plan is prepared to deal with the impact of land acquisition and resettlement impact resulting from the rehabilitation of the subproject. The Plan provides an analysis of the impacts, identifies the nature and types of losses, and establishes an entitlement matrix as a guide to payments of compensation and resettlement benefits. The primary objective of this SRP is to restore the income and living standards of the affected households due to the subproject within a short period of time without any disruptions in their own economic and social environment.
9
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
C.
Scope of Land Acquisition and Resettlement 4. The sub-project comprises of Sewerage Collection System of Dehradun to the centrally located kargi zone. The total length of Sewerage Collection System lines in this centrally located kargi zone is 158.39 Km. Map of Dehradun displaying the kargi zone of Sewerage Collection System is presented in Figure No.1. Sub-project design minimized land acquisition and resettlement impacts. There are no requirements for permanent land acquisition. However, updating of the SRP shows that for Sewerage Collection System of Dehradun to the Kargi zone, procuring, laying, jointing and commissioning of pipe networks will be undertaken within road rights of way (ROWs), and construction work may have minimal impacts. The proposed pipeline length of 158.39 Km comprises of various diameters from 200 to 1400mm. As per the proposed work new pipeline will be laid with minimum 1m from the crown of the proposed pipeline. 5. The networking of sewerage system solely depends on the coverage of water supply and the quantity of water supply which is essentially 135 litre per capita per day for maintaining the flow in the sewer. In addition, the topography and population density of the area play a major role in planning and designing an economical system. To utilize the city’s topographical advantage different sewerage zones are created, so that the sewers can have gravity flow, and the population density is taken into consideration to have maximum number of house connections by most economical length of sewers. With this concept the coverage of sewerage system under UUSDIP is about 50 to 90% in larger towns and 30 to 50% in medium towns. Accordingly for Dehradun, the largest city of the state, the sewerage coverage proposed is about 90%. However the pipeline has to be done on both the side of the road this will not involve any land acquisition. Only one side will be taken at a time to minimise the inconvenience of the society/community. However, any temporary impact occurs at any phases of the implementation period will be compensated properly. The above points have been discussed with the APs both formally and informally during the census survey and also during the public consultations. The Residents are informed about the proposed pipeline and will also be informed before starting of the work with the help of consultations and IEC activities. In addition to this the IPMU will publish the pamphlets and posters in Hindi to inform the local people about the short term incontinences. 6. Total 96 vendors, squatters and encroachers will temporarily be affected during the construction all along the Kargi zone area within the Municipal Limits of Dehradun Nagar Nigam. The potential temporary impacts on shops/ kiosks/ squatters/ vendors with an estimated 96 APs is counted on the basis of census survey. The census survey conducted by DSC in the month of December 2010. All existing structures, facilities, and land use beside the road and fronting the existing road shoulders or ROW of the Sewerage Collection zone are noted. The survey team (Comprises of 01 Supervisor, 05 Surveyors in close guidance of DSC and R&R Expert-DSC-I, Social & Community Dev. Officer-IPMU) documented the following: current uses of the ROW land or road shoulders (whether for residential, commercial; the type and dimension of structures that will most likely to be affected, its uses (whether residential, commercial or other purposes such as religious, cultural, etc.); the category of APs (formal or informal) who are affected; and whether such temporary impact will adversely affect their livelihood activities and how much is the average daily income generated from the respective livelihood activities. A structured questionnaire was used to collect the information from the affected persons along with the consultation with the affected persons. Moreover, the survey team went around the town municipal area to have a cursory assessment of the entire length of the proposed Sewerage Collection Zone to determine the approximate proportion representing the density of affected areas. 7. A census survey was carried out among these APs to know the type of impacts. These APs are mostly movable and can be shifted to other side of the road with prior information.
10
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
The prior information will be given with the help of implementing CAPP NGO. The survey result revealed that during the construction of the project (lying of Sewerage System Network pipe line) their daily livelihood will be affected which will be compensated properly as per the standards (market rate) or consultation with the APs. These movable vendors/ squatters are selling their goods by occupying one side of the road and this is their daily livelihood. These vendors are mostly related to selling of vegetables and fruit vending (35.5%), Tea stall and small eatery (27%) variety items (8.3%),Pan shop(10.4%) Barber (5.3%), pressing iron (7.2%) Other structure like cattle shed, Boundary, Frontage (7.2%). Also, there is no severance of impacts as far as the livelihood issues are concerned since the amount of impact is so minimal and temporary in nature. Since these vendors are movable, therefore, the ID cards would need to be distributed 30 days before the execution of work. Five Women headed families and two Scheduled caste families have been considered as vulnerable and special attention has been given in SRP Implementation. During project implementation, these vulnerable APs will receive preferential treat for work in the project civil work. 1.
Table 1: Sewerage System Sub-project, Dehradun and its Resettlement Impacts Resettlement Impacts Component Unit Location Permanent Temporary Construction 1.0 No. Bamanwala/Kargi None Nil Sewage Treatment village, Haridwar Plant of Capacity bypass, Majra, 68 MLD Dehradun Supplying laying, 44525 mtrs Pipeline will be laid None 63(Including 5 Female APs) testing and along/ within the commissioning of roadway; Pipe will be branch sewer buried min 1m below network in sewered in a trench on the area (Sub zone E1 edge of the road within & E2) of kargi zone the Right of Way at Dehradun (RoW). Supplying laying, testing and commissioning of sewer network in un-sewered area of kargi zone at Dehradun
81167 mtrs
Pipeline will be laid along/ within the roadway; Pipe will be buried min 1m below in a trench on the edge of the road within the Right of Way (RoW).
None
20
Supplying laying, testing and commissioning of sewer network in THDC Colony of kargi zone at Dehradun
32700 mtrs
Pipeline will be laid along/ within the roadway; Pipe will be buried min 1m below in a trench on the edge of the road within the Right of Way (RoW).
None
13((Including 2 SC APs)
Source: Census Survey December 2010
11
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
8. To estimate the temporary impacts of laying the proposed Sewerage System of Dehradun, census survey were conducted along the proposed alignment of Sewer Lines . Based on the census survey and confirmation with detailed designs, there are no expected impacts on permanent structures. Impacts are confined to Squatters placed on ROWs in busy market area or in residential area. Estimated summary resettlement impacts based on census survey conducted in the month of December 2010 by an experienced team of the Sewerage Collection System are in the Table 2. The main livelihood activities in this Sewerage Collection System sub-project ROW are mostly small-scale selling operations and the Income Sources includes fruit, vegetable, and variety items vending will temporarily be affected. APs will be assisted in moving to the other side of the road and returning to their structures/ place after construction is completed. The assistance could be given in case of any damage occurs in their temporary structure or it might be in the form of labour to help them to shift to another side of the road. Where moving is not required, access will be ensured by the contractor. The total execution period of Sewerage System in kargi zone area of Dehradun Nagar Nigam will be finished within a period of 24 months. Hence it is clear from the detail designing of the contract package that there is no issue of land acquisition and very minimal impact of temporary resettlement.
Table 2: Summary of Resettlement Impacts Dehradun Nagar Nigam Kargi zone Permanent Land Acquisition (ha) 0 Temporary Impact on Private Residential Land (Square meter) 0 Titled APs (Temporarily Affected) 0 Non-titled APs (Temporarily Affected Vendors and Squatters) 96 Female APs 5 Sc/ST APs 2 BPL APs (Temporarily Affected) 0 Affected Trees 0 Temporarily Affected Common Structures 0 Average Family Size 5.832 Average Household Income (per year) Rs.36,545.85 Source: Census Survey December 2010 APs=Affected Persons, BPL=Below Poverty Line, ha=hectare, IP=Indigenous People, ST=Scheduled Tribe Impact
9. 96 private assets are getting affected due to the project will have partial impact are kiosks, ambulatory vendors, temporary shops will have to move backward. These temporary shops and kiosks will experience temporary income loss. The consultation process revealed that all of them are willing to shift backward. All affected households are squatters and they will be considered for assistance as per the entitlement matrix. The extent of impact is depicted in Table-3 as given below:
12
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Table 3: Extent of Impact Sl.
Category of APs
1 2
Titleholder Nontitleholder Total
Extent of loss of land & structure to APs (in percentage) Less than 11 26-50% 51- 75% 7610% 25% 100% 96
-
96
-
-
-
Total APs
-
96
-
96
Source: Census Survey, December 2010. D. Socio-economic Profile of the Affected Households 10. The census survey identified the primary source of income of the affected households was mainly coming from running small shops and kiosks. The survey revealed that about 54 percent of PAPs are literates, including the functional literates. The details are given in Table-4. The primary source of income of the APs was mainly coming from running small shops and kiosks. The annual income of affected households has been given in Table -5 and the primary occupation of APs is given in Table-6. 40 percent of households have annual income between Rs. 35000-50000.
Table 4: Educational Attainment of APs No. of APs Sl. No. Educational Attainment 1. Functional Literate 28 2. Primary 21 3. Middle 2 4. Higher Secondary 1 5. Senior Secondary 2 6. Bachelor and above 0 7. Illiterate 42 Total 96 Source: Census Survey, December 2010
% 29 22 2 1 2 0 44 100
Table 5: Income Level of the of APs No. of APs Sl. No. Annual Income (in Rs.) 1. Less than 35000 25 2. 35000-40000 39 3. 40000-50000 32 4. Above 50000 0 Total 96 Source: Census Survey, December 2010
% 26 41 33 0 100
13
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Table 6: Sl. No. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
Occupation of APs
Occupation Category
Vegetables and fruit vending Tea stall and small eatery Pan shop Variety items Barber Pressing iron Other
Total Source: Census Survey, December 2010 E.
No. of APs 34
Percentage 35.5
26 10 8 5 7 6 96
27 10.4 8.3 5.3 7.2 6.3 100
Gender Impacts
11.
The DSC analyzed the potential impact of the Project on women through FGDs, during the course of the social assessments. Five woman-headed household was found among the affected households. The subproject as per the women groups will benefit them indirectly by means of better sewerage and improvement of health and hygiene. F.Resettlement Principles and Policy Framework
12. The policy framework and entitlements for the Investment Program are based on national laws: The Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (LAA, amended in 1984), and the National Rehabilitation and Resettlement Policy, 2007 (NRRP); ADB’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement, 1995 and revised 2009; and the agreed Resettlement Framework (RF). Based on these, the following core involuntary resettlement principles applicable are:
(i) (ii) (iii) (iv) (v) (vi) (vii) (viii)
3
land acquisition, and other involuntary resettlement impacts will be avoided or minimized exploring all viable alternative sub-project designs; where unavoidable, time-bound RPs will be prepared and affected persons (APs) will be assisted in improving or at least regaining their pre-program standard of living; full information and consultations with APs including consultation with APs on compensation, disclosure of resettlement information to APs, and participation of APs in planning and implementing sub-projects will be ensured; vulnerable groups will be provided special assistance3; payment of compensation to APs including non-titled persons (e.g., informal dwellers/squatters, and encroachers) for acquired assets at replacement rates; payment of compensation and resettlement assistance prior to the contractor taking physical acquisition of the land and prior to the commencement of any construction activities; provision of income restoration and rehabilitation; and Establishment of appropriate grievance redress mechanisms.
Including poor households, households headed by women, the elderly, the physically handicapped and scheduled tribes considered vulnerable based on the agreed Indigenous Peoples Development Framework (IPDF).
14
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
13.Policy framework and entitlements are further discussed in the RF. The entitlement matrix for the sub-project based on the above policies and Section F of this RP are in Table 7.
Table 7: Entitlement Matrix
Type of Loss 1
2
Temporary disruption of livelihood
Impacts on vulnerable APs
4
5
Application Vendors and Squatters affected on Road Right of Way
All impacts
Definition of Entitled Person Non-titled affected persons APs
Vulnerable APs
Compensation Policy
Implementat ion Issues
Responsible Agency
• 30 days advance notice regarding construction activities, including duration and type of disruption. • Contractor’s actions to ensure there is no income/access loss consistent with the initial environmental examination.4 • Assistance to vendors/ hawkers to temporarily shift for continued economic activity.5
• Identif ication of alternative temporary sites to continue economic activity.
VC will determine income lost.
Vulnerable households will be identified during the census survey.
Non government organizations (NGO) will verify the extent of impacts.
For construction activities involving unavoidable livelihood disruption, compensation for lost income or a transitional allowance for the period of disruption whichever is greater. Livelihood of Vulnerable households will be given priority in project construction employment and provided with additional special assistance for income
Contractors will perform actions to minimize income/ access loss.
This includes: leaving spaces for access between mounds of soil, providing walkways and metal sheets to maintain access across trenches for people and vehicles where required, increased workforces to finish work in areas with impacts on access, timing of
works to reduce disruption during business hours, phased construction schedule and working one segment at a time and one side of the road at a time. For example assistance to shift to the other side of the road where there is no construction.
15
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Type of Loss 3
Any other loss not identified
Application
Definition of Entitled Person
-
-
Compensation Policy restoration support. • Unanticipated involuntary impacts will be documented and mitigated based on the principles of ADB’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement, 1995 and revised 2009.
Implementat ion Issues
Responsible Agency
-
NGO will ascertain the nature and extent of such loss. The Investment Program Management Unit will finalize the entitlements in line with ADB’s Policy on Involuntary Resettlement, 1995 and revised 2009.
G.PUBLIC CONSULTATION, INFORMATION DISSEMINATION & DISCLOSURE 14. SRP has been prepared in consultation with the stakeholders employing various methods of structured questionnaires (Focus Group Discussion, Census Survey) conducted at Sewerage Collection System in Kargi zones area of alignment under Dehradun Nagar Nigam, where laying of new Sewerage Collection System pipeline network will be carried out in roads in the kargi zone area of Dehradun Nagar Nigam started from the month of February 2010. People were apprised of the measures to be taken during construction including scheduling of activities during early morning or less rush hour (details of consultations are presented in Appendix 1 & 2). Also consultations employing various methods (household sample surveys and two-stage consultation workshops and discussion with the line agencies and other stakeholders) were conducted during program preparation (May-August 2006). Informal consultations at the sample sub-project sites involving the public as well as non government organizations (NGOs) were also conducted in November 2006 and March 2007, to understand needs and preferences for basic infrastructure facilities, and social and environmental issues in order to reflect these in program design. This also included consultations and focus group discussions involving 25 participants in Dehradun. Consultations were again undertaken in June 2007 involving 62 stakeholders including 21 from Dehradun to disclose and discuss safeguards documents.
15. The updated SRP for the Sewerage System, Dehradun will be made available to the relevant local government agencies in Dehradun, and in IPIU and IPMU offices. This SRP will be made available in local language (Hindi). The updated SRP will also be disclosed on UUSDIP and ADB’s website. Finalized SRPs will also be disclosed on ADB’s website, and information dissemination and consultation will continue throughout Investment Program Implementation.
16
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
H.GRIEVANCE REDRESS MECHANISMS 16. Grievances of APs will first be brought to the attention of the implementing CAPP NGO or the Environment and Social Management Cell’ (ESMC). Grievances not redressed by the NGO will be brought to the Town Level Committees (TLC) set up to monitor project implementation in each town. The TLC will be act as grievance redress committee (GRC) will be chaired by the Mayors or Chairpersons with representatives of ward members, the District Magistrate, Commissioner, Special Area Development Authority, Uttarakhand Peya Jal Nigam (UPJN), Uttarakhand Jal Sansthan (UJS), Public Works Department (PWD), business, and civil society. As a GRC, the TLC will meet every month (if grievances are brought to the Committee), determine the merit of each grievance, and resolve grievances within a month of receiving the complaint by the General Body. The General Body consists of the Chief Secretary as its chairman and the secretaries of the relevant GOU departments and representatives of ULBs and NGOs as its member. If grievance will not be addressed further grievances will be referred by APs to the appropriate courts of law. Records will be kept of all grievances received including: contract details of complainant, date of the complaint received, nature of grievance, agreed corrective actions and the date of these were effected, and final outcome. I.COMPENSATION AND INCOME RESTORATION 17. APs will be provided 30 days advance notice to ensure no or minimal disruption in livelihood. If required, they will also be assisted to temporarily shift for continued economic activity. For example they will be assisted to shift to the other side of the road where there is no construction. Ensuring there is no income or access loss during sub-project construction is the responsibility of contractors. Consistent with the initial environmental examination, contractors will ensure: leaving spaces for access between mounds of soil, providing walkways and metal sheets to maintain access across trenches for people and vehicles where required, increased workforces to finish work in areas with impacts on access, timing of works to reduce disruption during business hours, phased construction schedule and working one segment at a time and one side of the road at a time. If construction activities results unavoidable livelihood disruption, compensation for lost income or a transitional allowance for the period of disruption whichever is greater will be provided. 5 Vulnerable APs will be given priority in project construction employment and provided with additional special assistance for income restoration support. Compensation and assistance to APs must be made prior to possession of land/assets and prior to the award of civil works contracts. The encroached area of Dehradun Nagar Nigam kargi zone roads by vendor/squatters to be affected temporarily due to laying of pipeline will have adequate compensation provisions as mentioned in the entitlement matrix which are: (i) Cash Compensation for the lost income or a transitional allowance for the period of disruption whichever is greater during the disruption period (ii) Advance notice regarding construction activities, including duration and type of disruption and (iii) Restoration of affected roads of Dehradun Nagar Nigam kargi zone back to original position. Similarly the non title holders especially the movable vendors and squatters have been provided with compensation in the entitlement matrix which are: (i) 30 days advance notice regarding construction activities, including duration and type of disruption, (ii) Contractor’s actions to ensure there is no income/access loss (iii) Assistance to vendors/ hawkers to temporarily shift for continued economic activity and (iv) For construction activities involving unavoidable livelihood disruption, compensation for lost income or a transitional allowance for the period of disruption whichever is greater.
17
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
J. INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS/ FRAMEWORK, RESETTLEMENT BUDGET/ COSTS, AND IMPLEMENTATION SCHEDULE 18. The Urban Development Department (UDD) is the Executing Agency (EA) of the Investment Program. The EA has already set up a state-level Investment Program Management Unit (IPMU). The Implementing Agencies (IAs) has set up district-level Investment Program Implementation Units (IPIUs) to manage implementation of sub-projects in their districts.6 The IPMU is being assisted by Investment Program Management Consultants (IPMC) who are providing program management support, assuring the technical quality of design and construction, and providing advice on policy reforms. IPIUs is being assisted by Design and Supervision Consultants (DSC), who are designing the infrastructure, managing tendering of Contractors and supervising the construction process. Construction Contractors (CC) has been appointed to build elements of the infrastructure. The CCs are being managed by the IPIUs, and construction is being supervised by the DSC. 19. An ESMC has been set up within the IPMU to address environmental and social issues of the Investment Program staffed by an Environmental Specialist and an SDS. The ESMC is assisted by the IPMC (staffed with a Resettlement Specialist) to provide guidance to the ESMC ensuring timely and effective implementation of SRPs and to provide internal monitoring. The DSC has resettlement specialists who will work closely with the ESMC and will be responsible for updating existing SRPs, preparing new SRPs for future sub-projects, and support monitoring and grievance redress. The EA and IPMU are implementing SRPs through CAPP NGO. The responsible agencies, resettlement costs, and implementation schedules are provided in Tables 8, 9 and 10 respectively. Details on institutional arrangements, flow of funds, and implementation schedules are in the Resettlement Framework (RF). Table 8: Institutional Roles and Responsibilities Activity Sub-project Initiation Stage Finalization of sites for sub-projects Disclosure of proposed land acquisition and sub-project details by issuing Public Notice Meetings at community/ household level with APs Formation of VCs SRP Preparation and Updating Stage Conducting Census of all APs Conducting FGDs/ meetings/ workshops Computation of replacement values of land/ properties proposed for acquisition and for associated assets Categorization of APs for finalizing entitlements Formulating compensation and rehabilitation measures Conducting discussions/ meetings/ workshops with APs and other stakeholders Fixing compensation for land/ property with titleholders Finalizing entitlements and rehabilitation packages Disclosure of final entitlements and rehabilitation packages
6.
Responsible Agency IPMU IPMU IPIU/ CAPP NGO IPMU/ IPIU NGO/ DSC RS NGO/ DSC RS VC/ ESMC/ CAPP NGO/ DSC RS ESMC/ DSC RS ESMC/ DSC RS ESMC/ CAPP NGO/ DSC RS VC/ IPMU ESMC/ DSC RS IPMU/ CAPP NGO
The IA for the Investment Program are the Uttarakhand Peya Jal Nigam (UPJN) for water supply and sewerage sub-projects, and the Public Works Department (PWD) for roads and traffic management sub-projects. A special cell within the IPMU, with assistance from Urban Local Bodies (ULBs), will be the IA for solid waste management and slum improvement sub-projects.
18
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Approval of SRP Sale deed execution and payment Taking possession of land SRP Implementation Stage Implementation of proposed rehabilitation measures Consultations with APs during rehabilitation activities Grievances redressal
EA/ ADB EA/ IPMU EA/ IPMU IPIU/ CAPP NGO IPIU/CAPP NGO CAPP NGO/ ESMC/ GRC ESMC/ IPIU External Agency
Internal monitoring External monitoring
ADB=Asian Development Bank, AP=Affected Person, DSC RS=Design and Supervision Consultant’s Resettlement Specialist, ESMC=Environment and Social Management Cell, FGD=Focus Group Discussion, IPIU=Investment Program Implementation Unit, IPMU=Investment Program Management Unit, NGO=Nongovernmental Organization, SRP=Short Resettlement Plan, VC=Valuation Committee
Budget: 20.The summary of cost is based on the information collected from the Directorate of Labour Commission; Government of Uttarakhand to hire a labour from the market is Rs. 149/labour/day and secondly in consultation with the APs. The restoration support to 05 vulnerable women headed households calculated on lump-sum basis. Table 9: Summary of Land Acquisition and Resettlement Costs Sl. Item Quantity Unit Unit Cost Total Cost No. (Rs) (Rs) A Compensation and Assistance 1 Assistance for the temporary 7 Person 2000 14000.00 disruption of livelihood to Vulnerable households(5 women headed household and 2 SC Affected household)7 2 Assistance for temporary livelihood 96 Person 149 286080.00 restoration to licensed vendors (20 x 96 x 149) Per day per affected household for 20 days 3 Support Cost for SRP Lump 50,000.00 sum Implementation Note: Administrative Budget/ Costs are not included: Input of various Experts for complete Program Duration: (i) IPMU Social Development Specialist in the Environmental and Social Cell (96 person months); (ii) IPMC Resettlement Specialist-National Consultant (10 person months); and (iii) DSC Resettlement SpecialistNational Consultant (6 person months).
4
Cost for external monitoring consultant Total R&R Cost Contingency @15 % of the total R&R Cost Grand Total (Rupees)
Lump sum
50000.00 400080.00 60012.00 460092.00
7
Restoring the livelihood of vulnerable APs with lump sum Rs 2000 special assistance for income restoration support.
19
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Table 10: Implementation Schedule Activity
Months 2008 2009
Jan 2011
Feb 2011
March2011
April 2011
Tasks Already Completed Establishment of IPMU (including ESMC) and ♦ IPIU Appointment of SDS, and RS (PMC and DSC) ♦ Appointment of NGOs ♦ Briefing of the TLC on GRC functions ♦ Consultations and disclosure of Draft SRP ♦ Confirmation of government land to be used and ♦ transfer from other departments Tasks under Updating and Implementing of SRP for Sewerage Collection System, Dehradun Census surveys (for updation of SRP) ♦ Preparation and Updation of SRP ♦ SRP review and approval (IPMU and ADB) ♦ Issue notice to APs Implementation of Compensation and ♦ resettlement assistance Relocation as required ♦ Takeover possession of acquired property ♦ Internal monitoring Handover land to contractors ♦ Start of civil works ♦ Start of Rehabilitation of temporarily occupied ♦ lands
20
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I) )
K. MONITORING AND EVALUATION AND REPORTING
21. Internal monitoring will be the responsibility of the ESMC and the implementing NGO. Internal monitoring will include: (i) administrative monitoring: daily planning, implementation, feedback and trouble shooting, individual AP file maintenance, and progress reports; (ii) socioeconomic monitoring: baseline information for comparing AP’s socio-economic conditions, relocation, salvaging materials, community relationships, dates for consultations, and number of grievances placed; and (iii) impact evaluation monitoring: income restored, and socioeconomic conditions of affected persons. Monitoring and evaluation reports documenting progress on resettlement implementation and RP completion reports will be provided by the implementing NGO to the IPIU and after reviewing the report IPIU will submit the report to IPMU on monthly basis. The internal monitoring report will be submitted quarterly to the Asian Development Bank (ADB) by the IPMU. Monitoring will also ensure recording of AP views on resettlement issues; AP understanding of entitlement policies, options, and alternatives; site conditions; compensation valuation and disbursement; grievance redress procedures; and staff competencies. The implementing NGO will report its activity to IPIU on a monthly basis and the IPIU will send it to IPMC for review and then IPMC will forward to IPMU. IPMU will send it to ADB on a quarterly basis. To review the field report of NGO, DSCs should help to IPIU. The quarterly progress report to ADB from IPMU will be supported and revised by IPMC. 22. An external monitoring agency/Consultant with prior experience in resettlement implementation monitoring and evaluation will be engaged by the EA. The external monitor will monitor and verify RP implementation to determine whether resettlement goals have been achieved, livelihood and living standards have been restored, and provide recommendations for improvement. The external monitoring will undertake monthly monitoring and impact evaluation on a sample basis during mid-term and project completion. Monitoring will also ensure recording AP views on resettlement issues; AP understanding of entitlement policies, options, and alternatives; site conditions; compensation valuation and disbursement; grievance redress procedures; and staff competencies. The external agency will report its findings simultaneously to the EA and to ADB twice a year.
21
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Figure 1: Location of the Collection System Subproject kargi zone
22
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Appendix-I Public Consultation & Focused Group Discussions (Socio-Economic and Environmental) Name of the Component /Site: WWM02D , WWM03D,WMM03D Number of Participants: 132 Name of the Village/ Ward: Bharampuri / Chamanpuri, Gandhi Gram Kanwali New Basti, GMS Road Kanwali Goan, Indira Puram, MDDA Colony GMS Road, Majra, Patel Nagar Name of the Block: Dehradun Name of the District: Dehradun Distance from the District Head Quarter: 0 Km Date: December 2010 Time: 03 pm Issues General perception about the Investment Program (UUSDIP). Awareness about the
Participant’s Opinion, Comments and Suggestions People were not aware about the investment program before the consultation. They had favorable opinion about the Investment program
Investment Program especially the Waste Water Management component. Support of the people for the Investment Program. Support of local people for the proposed
Local peoples are ready to support the programme.They are also
Waste Water Management component of the
willing to get connected with sewer system.
project. Any critical issue or concern by the local
Nil
people regarding this project? Any criteria you would like to see considered during
project
design,
construction
and
Consideration should be made to protect the vendors and the ongoing business activities. There should be continuous consultation with the local people.
operation stage? Number of Households in this area and Population of the village/ area
Concerned APs within Bharampuri / Chamanpuri, Gandhi Gram Kanwali New Basti, GMS Road Kanwali Goan, Indira Puram, MDDA Colony GMS Road, Majra, Patel Nagar location. .
Any Ethnic minorities/ tribal population living in this
area
(Note
the
name
of
Tribe/
indigenous community, if any)
It is being an urban centre, there are no tribal people found here. All the people are living in urban centre and have access to the modern infrastructure facilities. Therefore, no such IP found here in the investment program impact zone.
Any Vulnerable groups (women headed, BPL, ST, PH etc.) are living in this ward/area? Do the village/ ward people face any problems of Sewage and Waste Water Management in
According to the people, the sewer system is very old and does not exist in all areas. They are paying Rs.800-900 /- for sewer cleaning to the
private person.
their houses? If yes, how they are managing at
23
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
present? If there is any problem related to these issues
The residents expressed that up gradation of the system is necessary.
and services do you think that any upgradation/ renovation are necessary? Do you have any ideas on what is to be
Nobody knew in detail, only a few had little idea.
involved in the process of up-gradation? For this up-gradation, the road/ street/ path
Yes it is acceptable to us.
may be affected - What is your opinion on this? Is it acceptable? What
extent
this
total
Waste
Water
Partially.
Management civil works will affect you? Who else is to be affected due to this up-
General public & shopkeepers
gradation process? How intense could be the effect?
Partially.
Do you think the effect will be of a permanent
No
nature? If it is not, how intense will be the temporary effect? The work will be executed in this part of the
The intensity of effect will not be very high; it will depend on the nature of up gradation. The residents were not able to tell it exactly. All wanted shift on their own; they felt otherwise They will be punished..
road/footpath. You may require shifting to other side of the road. Please give your comments and suggestions. During the time of execution of work will you
Other side of the road.
shift to other side of road or any other place in the town? If requested to shift, would you like to return
Yes
here? If you shift other side of the road/ place is there
Our income will be affected.
any problem? Give your comments. In what way Executive Agency of GOU can
Financial help.
assist you so that your daily business is not affected? What extra support you want from the Executing Agency of GOU? What are your perceived benefits from the
Sanitation will be better.
Investment Program? Do you think that local labour force would like
Yes
to participate in construction work? Do you think that the local people would like to get
regular
information
regarding
Yes
this
24
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Investment Program? Number of Shops/ Commercial establishments
75
in the village/ town/ area Numbers of Industrial Units in the village/ town
Nil
and surrounding area General socio-economic standing: What are
N.A
the economic activities? Land use, cropping pattern (Seasonal), types of crops, value of the crops, Average land holding size etc. Is the land Irrigated and what are the sources
N.A
of Irrigation? Current
rates
for
the
agricultural
land
N.A
(Government as well as market rates). Source of drinking water in this area.
Hand pump.
Loss of residential/ commercial structures, if
No
any due to the project. Loss of community life like any Market Places
No
or community activities to be affected Shortage of water for human consumption,
No shortage of water.
irrigation, and other downstream uses? How extensive are they? Any conflicts on water use rights and its social
No
impacts? Resettlement and Land acquisition (if foreseen
No
due to setting up of Waste Water Management especially on private land). Has there been land acquisition before? If yes, what was the process of land acquisition and compensation package? Health status and availability of hospitals in
Only fewer.
this area. Is there any chronic disease prevalent in this area? Are you aware about of the disease of HIV/AIDS and STD? Poverty Level: Is the village/ ward is poor or
Middle class.
very poor or well off? Education Status in this village/ward: Literate,
Yes literate.
illiterate etc. Employment
Status:
Percentage
of
25
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
employment/unemployment/underemployment. Migration Pattern (If any), inward or outward
People from behind mainly labour class.
Type of compensation expected (Cash / Kind)
Cash
Perceived benefits from the project
General people will be benefited health & hygiene of the area will be better.
Perceived losses from the project
No
What other organizations of a social nature
None
(NGOs/CBOs/ Civil Society) active in this village/ward? Name of these organizations. Organization of the village/ ward and its
Ward member elected by us. Who are representing in municipal
structure. Do you have a village/ ward
corporation.
committee? What
is
the
decision-making
system in your village/ward? Who are the decision makers on community related issues in your village/ward? Are they elected or selected? If elected: By consensus or By majority vote. Is there any protected area (national park,
No
protected forest, religiously sensitive sites, historical or archaeological monument) in or near the project area? Mention the distance from project site. Do you think any adverse impacts may happen due to this proposed project? Do you think that the raw water supply from upstream,
wastewater
discharge
No
from
communities, industries, agriculture, are polluting in this area or soil erosion taking place? Do you feel any type of noise and dust may
Yes
come from project construction activities? Do you think there may be increased road
Only local traffic people can manage coring and going irons small
traffic
other areas.
due
to
the
interference
of
construction activities? If yes, what extent? Do you think any continuous soil erosion may
takes
place
during
No
construction
activities? If yes, How can we prevent it? Do you feel any safety risk may arise due to
We will do the self security of we own children small area difference
accidental or natural calamities during
26
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
construction,
operation,
and
decommissioning? If yes, what security measures should be taken? Do you feel any soil erosion may takes
No
place during sewer line construction work in this hilly area? Do you wish to have waste construction
People who are living in low lying area these waste excavated
material and excavated soil which could be
material will be useful for them
used for any of your purpose? If no, Can you suggest any area where it could be dumped? Does
this
area
have
water
logging
No
problem? Can you suggest the type of measures can be taken to reduce this problem during construction work? Response of local people towards the
Small children play in dirty area.
overall environmental condition of the area proposed for the project. Any Other Issues you may feel to share:
Work should be completed before rainy season.
(Demand of any support form authority and whether they welcome the project, will there be cooperation from the local community during the implementation and security measures, etc). Do you think that the local people would like to involve
in
construction
of
Yes
project
implementation of Waste Water Management Project? Is this consultation useful? Comments
Everybody felt that the consultation was useful as it had made them knowledgeable regarding the Investment program.
27
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
LIST OF PARTICIPANTS: Sl. No 1 2 3 4 5 6
Name of the Participant
Occupation
Bharampuri / Chamanpuri Pinku Prajapati
Tailoring
Kaluram
Garments shop
Khalik
Milk
Anish
Mobile vendor
Keshaw Gupta
Cloth
Joyti Prasad Naushad Ahmed
Star Electrical
Jeet Singh
Shopkeeper
Vipin Kumar
Provision store
Mahesh Kumar
Tea stall
Mahendra Singh
Provision store
Dilshad
Rudiment
A.K. Singh
-
14
Indira Puram, MDDA Colony G.M. Road M.L. Karhuria
Retired
15
V.S. Rawat
Retired
16
Taravati
House wife
17
Radha Yadave
House wife
18
Lima Bhatia
House wife
19
Kuljeet Kaur
House wife
Puspa Bhugana
House wife
21
Vimlesh Singh
House wife
22
Neerima Sharma
House wife
23
Lisha Takaurs
House wife
24
Priya
House wife
25
Sapana
House wife
26
Sulachna
House wife
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Signature (If agreed by the participants)
28
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
27
Vijay Bala Gupta
House wife
28
Ansu
House wife
29
Asha Bhatt
House wife
30
Rekha
House wife
31
Gudee
House wife
32
Asha
House wife
33
Kajal
House wife
34
Amreet Kaur
House wife
35
Gurdeep
House wife
36
Seema
House wife
37
Suneeta
House wife
38
Amreet
House wife
39
Lata
House wife
40
Maya Bisht
House wife
41
House wife
42
Pooruinia Kothala G.M.S Road Kawali (Shive Mendir) Chander Singh
43
Madan Lal
44
Upendra Prasad
Mobile vendor
45
Sunjay
Chat vendor
46
Chote Lal Saiui
Mobile vendor
47
R.K. Aggarwal
Pan stall
48
Rajesh Kumar
Labourer
49
Jusvant Kumar
Labourer
50
Rajesh
Labourer
51
Manoj Sharma
Tea stall
52
Arun Sharma
-
53
Ajay Kumar Sharma
Tea shop
54
Ramesh shaini
-
55
Harish Chandra
Marble worker
Bagger
29
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
56
Vijay
Driver
57
Mahipal
Driver
58
Bajnath
Old person
59
G.M.S. Road Kawali Goan Saleem
Shopkeeper
60
Anish
Business
61
Gulbahar
Shopkeeper
62
Imranbag
Business
63
Sachin Sharma
Business
64
Vijendra Gurg
Business
65
Mosashad
Business
66
Pathariya, Sharanpur Road (Patel Nagar) Mayaram
Mobile vendor
67
Amit
Mobile vendor
68
Harikant
Shopkeeper
69
Basant
Shopkeeper
70
Anil
Tea stall
71
Seetaram
Shopkeeper
72
Pankaj
73
Dharmender
74
Ramvichar
75
Niranjan Kumar
Shopkeeper
76
Chudi Lal Verma
Private Job Holder
77
Sumesh
Business
78
Madu
-
79
R Pal
Business
80
Sharan Kumar
81
Majra Masjid wali gali Abdul Masid
Teacher
82
Joshat Ali
Tailors
83
Aajat Hassan
Business
30
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
84
Ashrol Ali
Business
85
Jameel
Shopkeeper
86
Haj Mohd Alihasan
-
87
Ubaidullah Khan
Retired Bank officer
88
Irshad Khan
Advocate
89
Mustkim
Labourer
90
Abdul ajiz
-
91
Izajudeen
-
92
Jaheed Anshari
Electrician
93
Naseem humad
-
94
Hadeem Habub jali
Shopkeeper
95
Mohadi Hassan
-
96
Mustkeen Hassan
Principal
97
Ubed Rajput
Student
98
Gandhi Gram (Kawali New Basti) Sukh Ram
Car Panter
99
Ilam Chand
Business
100
Tej Pal
Barber
101
Setender Singh
Provision store
102
Mahatam Chohan
Labourer
103
Lal Chand Chohan
Labourer
104
Shriram Moria
Palamber
105
Kapil
Student
106
Ram Atri
Shopkeeper
107
Kamal Singh
Chat stall
108
Vijay
Photograph
109
Dharmender
Chat stall
110
Monu
Grocery
111
Syham Kumar
Mobile vendor
112
Ajay
Student
31
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
113
East Patel Nagar Dharmender
Farming
114
Ramsharan
Farming
115
Baseet Kumar
Farming
116
Amarjeet
Farming
117
Mahesh
Farming
118
Ishwardeen
Farming
119
Angat Prasad
Farming
120
Rakesh yadav
Farming
121
Ram Ajor Yadav
Farming
122
Madan Yadav
Farming
123
Bindra Prasad
Farming
124
Ramnaresh
Farming
125
Tilkaw
Farming
126
Kamlesh
Farming
127
Rashiram
Farming
128
Dvareeka Prasad
Farming
129
Prakash
Farming
130
Raju
Farming
131
Pankaj Kumar
Farming
132
Raj
Farming
32
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Photographs: Focus Group Discussions/ Census Survey- Dehradun (Nov-Dec 2010)
33
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Appendix-II
The Schedule for the Resettlement Plan
S.No.
Short Resettlement Plan For
Start dates of public consultation/ dissemination of information
Start dates of SRP disclosure to the entitled APs
Close dates of public consultation/ dissemination of information
1
WWM02D
07-06-2007
December 2010
March 2011
2
WWM03D
07-06-2007
December 2010
March 2011
3
WWM04D
07-06-2007
December 2010
March 2011
Sub Project: Sewerage System in Kargi Zone of Dehradun (Loan No. 2410-IND) Author/s Name: Investment Program management Unit- UUSDIP Consultant Firm Name: Mott MacDonald Consortium Government Ministry; Urban Development Department, Govt. of Uttarakhand, INDIA
34
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Appendix-III SAFEGUARDS DISCLOSURE SESSION 1. Proceedings of Environmental and Social Safeguard Disclosure Meeting at Dehradun on June 7, 2007 1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
This public consultation meeting was organised on June 7, 2007 at Dehradun Nagar Nigam (DNN) meeting hall. The meeting was arranged by the DNN on the request of the Executing Agency (EA) of Uttarakhand Urban Sector Development Investment Program (UUSDIP). The DDN has invited the elected representatives, prominent persons of the city, non-governmental organisations (NGOs), community based organisations (CBOs), general public and also invited were the technical staff of the various government agencies. Twenty-one participants were present in the meeting (Photo 1). The objective of the meeting was to inform the stakeholders on the environmental and social impacts of the proposed program and the safeguards provided in the program to mitigate the impacts, and elicit stakeholders’ opinion to further improve the measures recommended. In the specific context of Dehradun, the environmental and social impacts of the proposed sub-projects under Tranche 1 in Dehradun were discussed. A detailed presentation was made on: (i) objective and benefits of UUSDP, (ii) proposed subprojects and investments thereof in Dehradun, (iii) selected sub-project sites, (iv) mandatory environmental and social assessment requirements of sub-projects, i.e. Government Regulations and as well as ADB policies on Environment, Involuntary Resettlement and Indigenous People salient features of these three key safeguard polices were presented, (v) key social safeguard features in the program to avoid social impacts, (vi) draft resettlement framework (vii) IR impacts of Tranche 1 sub-projects in Dehradun, (vi) environmental sub-project selection criteria to minimise the negative environmental impacts of sub-project implementation and, lastly, (vii) identified environmental impacts and mitigation measures through sample sub-project IEEs (Photo 2 and 3). Draft resettlement framework (RF) and summary initial environmental examination (SIEE) documents of UUSDP, translated in the local language – Hindi, were displayed in the Notice Board of DDN and also distributed during presentation to the participants of the meeting. The copies of documents are also available to all the interested parties through the DDN. The EA has distributed these documents to the project implementation agencies, the DDN, Uttarakhand Pey Jal Nigam (UPJN) and Uttarakhand Jal Sansthan (UJS) etc., prior to the meeting. The comments, suggestions of the stakeholders are presented below: (i)
The meeting was chaired by the deputy Mayor (elected representative) of DNN in the absence of the Mayor.
(ii)
The meeting started with a briefing by the UUSDP Project Co-ordinator followed by safeguard specialist presentation.
(iii)
All the stakeholders were supportive of the project and indicated their willingness to participate in the program to make it successful. They were of the view that program will benefit all sections of people by improving water supply, sewerage, roads and solid waste management infrastructure.
(iv)
Stakeholders enquired whether any carrying capacity study was conducted prior to proposing infrastructure expansion in the city. The team explained that although specific carrying capacity studies are not conducted as part of this assignment, the proposed infrastructure improvements invariably takes consideration of these issues. Specific to Dehradun, the tranch 1 sub-projects proposed involve only optimisation of existing system and therefore no new development is anticipated. However, for future sub-projects in the Program, the sub-project implementation will strictly follow the approved land use plans. The city land use plan/master plan is the basic document that defines the carrying capacity of the city. This is one of the important selection criteria for the sub-projects to be implemented under UUSDP.
(v)
Stakeholders were of the view that a proper state-level study shall be conducted before taking up any slum improvement project. The team explained that at the outset State Slum Policy will be developed and the slum improvement will be as per the policy.
35
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I) (vi)
A participant indicated that population projections made for Dehradun sub-projects are on lower side and needs to be revised. It was explained that these issues will be looked into if required during the detailed design.
(vii)
People were impressed by the ADB Policy that the “absence of formal legal title to land is not a bar to ADB policy entitlements”.
(viii)
The EA appraised that UUSDP is designed to minimise the IR impacts. In unavoidable cases, the LA and R & R will be handled through the Resettlement Framework (RF) of UUSDP. Stakeholders were satisfied that all possible IR issues are included in RF, however, indicated that this shall be implemented in letter and spirit.
(ix)
Few stakeholders requested for the copy of RF and SIEE (in Hindi). EA has provided the copies through DNN.
36
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Appendix-IV INVENTORY OF TEMPORARY LOSS ON RIGHT OF WAY 1. Questionnaire No: ___________ Date: ........................ 2. Name of the Project Component /Site: WWM02D / WWM03D 3. Name of the Mohallah: 4. Name of the Street: 5. Name of the Ward: 6. Name of the Pourashava/ Nagar Nigam: 7. Name of the Tehesil: Dehradun 8. Name of the Zilla/District: 9. Name of the State: Uttarakhand 10 Property No. -----------------------11. Location 1. Left
2. Right
12. Status of the Property 1. Squatters 2. Encroachers 13. Name of the Owner................................................. 14. Sex 1. Male 2. Female 15. Father’s Name .......................................................
16. Use of Structure 1 4 7 10
House Shops Small Eatery/Teas Stall Others (Mention)-----------
2 5 8 ---
Huts Kiosks and Vendors Cattle shed -----
3 6 9
Sheds Mobile Vendors Boundary Walls/Fences
17. Area of the affected structure (in Square Meter) ………………….. 18. Type of Structure 1. Temporary 2. Semi-Permanent 3. Permanent 19. Age of the structure (Years)……………………. 20. Type of Construction Structure Sl Particulars Type of Construction Nº (1). Simple (thatch/sack/bamboo/slats, (2) Earth/clay/sand, (3) Wood, (4) Brick, (5), RCC (Concrete) (6) Corrugated iron sheet, (7) Tile, (8), Asbestos sheet and (9) Other (specify) 1 Roof 2 Floor 3 Wall 21. Market Value of the Structure (in Rupees)............................ 22. Number of family members. Total…………
Male ……
Female……….
23. Is it a woman headed household? 1. Yes 2. No 24. Is it a household owned by physically handicapped? 1. Yes 2. No. 25. Total Monthly income of the family (in Rupees)…………………
37
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
26. Willing to shift 1. Voluntarily
2. Need Resettlement
27. Compensation Option 1. Alternate structure 2. Cash for structure loss 28. Desire Assistance and other help 1. Shifting Allowance 2. Employment Opportunities in Construction work 3. License to resume the current activities 4. Others (specify ..........................................................) 29. Is there alternate site available for relocation? 1. Yes 2. No. 30. If Yes, How far and the name of the place……………………………. 30. Caste…………………………………. 31. Social status 1. General 2.OBC
3.SC
4.ST.
5.BPL
6.WHH
38
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Appendix-V
List of Affected Person WWM02D Sl.No
Name
1.
Ramprakash
Fathers Name/Husband name Ramtirath
Street
Ward
2.
Mayaram
3.
Poorviy a Barti
East Patel Nagam
Santram
Tapir Gali
Late Jagprasad
4.
Guravachan Verma Dharmbeer Gupta
5.
Chote Lal
Surajpal
6.
Shivlal
Puran Singh
7.
Pappu Gupta
Ram Bharose Lal
8.
Pradeep Gupta
Pappu Gupta
9.
Manoj Sharma
Jai Prakash Sharma
10.
Ruksana Praveen
Rashid Ali
11.
Praveen Kumar
Ramkishan Dass
12.
Chatrapal
Bittu Singh
13.
Suresh chand
14.
Pakesh kumar saini Chandra Kala
.15.
Santosh Kumar
Karamchand
16.
Abdul
Imna
17.
Ranjeet Semwal
Rattan Singh
18.
Sameer
Ashrat
19.
Ram kishore
Nihal Singh
20.
Vikas
Shri Rampal
21.
Mata Prasad
Banwari Lal
22.
Manju Devi
W/o Dhavoripal
Vishram Gupta
Late Dharampal
Type of Impact Temporary
Use of structure Vegetable Seller
Vul. / Non vul. NV
East Patel Nagam
Temporary
NV
Poorviy a Basti Poorviy a Basti Balliwal a Chowk Gali Kawali Gaon Kawali Mandir Mandir Gali Shiv Mandir Near Kawali Gali
East Patel Nagam East Patel Nagam Balliwala Chowk
Temporary
Small Eatery/Teas Stall Vegetable Seller Vegetable Seller Shops
Kawali ward
Temporary
Kawali Gaon Kawali Gaon Kawali Gaon (50)
Temporary
Kawali Gaon (50)
Temporary
Dwarika Puri Haripur Kawali Phase-1
Kawali Ward (50)
SemiPermanent
Sangam Vihar Kawali GMS Road GMS Road GMS Road GMS Road Indra Puram Enginee r Enclave Phase-1 Phase-3 Near water tank Sai lok
Engineer Enclave Gandhi Gram Gandhi Gram Shanti Vihar
Temporary Temporary
Temporary SemiPermanent
GMS Road
NV NV
NV
NV NV NV
Vul.
NV
Pressing Iron
NV
Temporary
House
NV
Temporary
Shops
Vul.
Temporary
Vegetable Stall Fruit Stall
NV
Temporary GMS Road
Small Eatery/Tea Stall Vegetable Seller Vegetable Seller Small Eatery/Tea Stall Small Eatery/TeaSt all Small Eatery/Tea Stall
NV
SemiPermanent Temporary
NV NV
Groundnut Seller Pressing Iron stall Pressing Iron
NV
Indra Puram Engineer Enclave
SemiPermanent Temporary
NV
Engineer Enclave
SemiPermanent
Small Eatery/Teas Stall
NV
Sai lok
Semi-
Pressing Iron
Vul.
NV
39
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Sl.No
Name
Fathers Name/Husband name
23.
Mohd Zakir
Nazir
24.
Satpal
Late Kabula
25.
Sonia
W/o Pradeep
26.
Mahefooj
Yashin Ahemad
27.
Meehashi Devi
W/o Sumeschand
28.
Jeet lal
Late Bengaram
29.
Akhtar
Late Asgar
30.
Sadhu Singh
31.
Chandi Singh Negi Kalawati
Munni lal Yadav
32.
Namshad Khan
33.
Street
Ward
Use of structure
Vul. / Non vul.
near chakkito la Chakki Tola Simla Bypss
Type of Impact Permanent
Chakki Tola
Temporary
Barbour Stall
NV
Niranjanpur
Temporary
Small Eatery/Teas Stall Bidi cigrate stall
NV
Small Eatery/Teas Stall Pan shop
NV
Chaman puri (Near Thana) Chaman puri
Chamanpuri
Temporary
Chamanpuri (44)
Temporary
Chaman puri Chaman puri
Chamanpuri (44) Chamanpuri (44)
Temporary
Chaman puri Chaman puri Chaman puri
Chamanpuri (44) Chamanpuri (44) Chamanpuri (44)
Temporary
Late Shamshad Khan
Chaman puri
Chamanpuri
Temporary
Gulshan Kumar
Late Puran Prakash
Mahesh Kumar
Lattan lal
Bharampuri (44) Bharampuri (44)
Temporary
34.
Bharam puri Bharam puri
35.
Jeet Singh
Late Phool Singh
Rahul Gupta
Rambabu Gupta
Bharampuri (44) Bharampuri (44)
Temporary
36.
Bharam puri Bharam puri
37.
Ajay Gupta
V.K. Gupta
Niranjanpur (44)
Temporary
38.
Mohd Sohail
Mohd Iqbal
Nagar Nigam Colony Lohia Nagar
Lohia Nagar
Temporary
39.
Umesh
Bahadur
Bharam puri
Bharampuri (44)
Temporary
40.
Rajesh Kumar
Bhaiya lal
Samim
Gaalib
42.
Chaman
Bhndu
43.
Mohd wali
Mohd ali
Bharampuri (44) Sharanpur Road Ghandhi Marg Niranjanpur
Temporary
41.
44.
Rashid
Abbass
Bharam puri Sharanp ur Road Ghandhi Marg Sharanp ur Niranjan pur
Niranjanpur
Temporary
Temporary Temporary
Temporary
Temporary
Temporary
Small Eatery/Teas Stall Cycle Repair Shop Tea Stall Small Eatery/Teas Stall Small Eatery/Teas Stall Cycle Repair Shop Small Eatery/Teas Stall Shops
Vul.
Vul. NV
NV NV Vul.
NV
NV NV
NV
Small Eatery/Teas Stall Vegetable Seller
NV
Small Eatery/Teas Stall Small Eatery/Teas Stall Shops
NV
NV
NV
NV
Temporary
Groundnut Stall Fruit Seller
NV NV
Temporary
Fruit Stall
NV
Temporary
Vegetable Seller
NV
40
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
Sl.No
Name
45.
Nawab
Fathers Name/Husband name Arub
Street
Ward
46.
Raj
Ratam Chand
47.
Chote lal
Dhjai Ram
48.
Istakar
Jammaluddin
49.
Diyazul
Nazeer Hassan
50.
M. Sakeel
M. Jameel
51.
Dilip Kumar
Sambhu nath Gupta
52.
Murari lal
Bahmekeshwar Lal
53.
Ramesh Kumar
Guptar Singh
54.
Gopal Singh
Jatter Singh
55.
Vinod Kumar
56.
Type of Impact Temporary
Use of structure Fruit Seller
Vul. / Non vul. NV
Noor Basti
Niranjanpur (44)
Niranjan pur Sharanp ur Road Niranjan pur Niranjan pur Niranjan pur
Niranjanpur (44) Marava
Temporary
Fruit Stall
NV
Temporary
Shops
NV
Niranjanpur (44) Niranjanpur (44) Niranjanpur (44)
Temporary
Fruit Seller
NV
Temporary
Fruit Seller
NV
Temporary
Small Eatery/Teas Stall Vegetable Stall Vegetable Seller Pan Stall
NV
Sharanp ur Road Niranjan pur Sharanp ur Road Sharanp ur Road
Sharanpur Road Niranjanpur (44) Sharanpur Road Sharanpur Road
Temporary
Late Kaluram
Sharanp ur Road
Majra
Temporary
Mohd Akmal Khan
S/o Late Mansoor Khan
Masjid wali Gali
Majra
Temporary
57.
Veer Bahadur
Dhan Bahadur
GMS Road
Majra
Temporary
58.
Sadhu Ram
Thakur din
Pawan Gupta
Late Munshi Ram Gupta
Sewla Kalan Marava (16)
Temporary
59.
GMS Road Sharanp ur Road
Temporary
60.
Mukesh
Late Fattu lal
Marava (16)
Temporary
61.
Ashok Kumar
Late Sewa lal
Marava (16)
62.
Alok Kumar
Ashok Kumar
63.
Abhisekh Mittal
Shri S.C. Mittal
Sharanp ur Road Sharanp ur Road Sharanp ur Road Niranjan pur
Temporary Temporary Temporary
NV NV NV
Temporary
Small Eatery/TeaSt all Small Eatery/TeaSt all Small Eatery/Tea Stall Small Eatery/TeaSt all Pressing Iron Stall Small Eatery/Tea Stall Vegetable Seller Fruit Stall
NV
NV
Marava (16)
Temporary
Pan Shop
NV
Niranjanpur
Temporary
Small Eatery/TeaSt all
NV
NV
NV
NV
NV NV
NV
Vul.-Vulnerable AP NV-Non vulnerable AP
41
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
List of Affected Person WWM03D Sl. No
Name
1.
Manoj Kumar
Fathers Name/Husband name Pramod Kumar
2.
Raju Kashayap
Shri Pale Ram
3.
Roshan lal Gupta
Late Shyam lal
4.
Ram Brij
Basant Thakur
5.
Ramesh Thapa
Padam Singh Thapa
6.
Amar Kumar Chetri
Jung Bahadur Chetri
7.
Sonu Kumar
Rajendra Singh
8.
Sunil
Om Prakash
9.
Ajab Lal Thakur
10.
Harey Ram Thakur Ranjeet Yadav
11.
Sario Kumar
Bhagwat Kumar
12.
Mohan Lal
13.
Pawan Kumar
14.
Bindva Prasad
Late Bhagat Prasad Late Nohar Kumar Cheddi Lal
15.
Mangal Singh
Ram Pyare
16.
Jamshed Ali
Ramzan Ali
17.
Aziz Ahmed
18.
Naseem Ahmed Gainda Ram
19.
Roshan Lal
Ram Swaroop Singh Sita Ram
20.
Omkar
Ram Chander
Tilak Ram Yadav
Street
Ward
Type of Impact
Use of structure
Vul / Non vul
Gali no-5
Shri Ram Puram Rajiv Chowk Kawali Road
Temporary
NV
Rajiv Chowk Gali no 3 Gali no72 Near Shiv Mandir Sridev Nagar Vijay Park Gali No-4 Vijay Park Gali No-1 Gali No1 Tapir Gali Poorviya Basti Sharanp ur Road 4, Guru Road 97, Park Road Kawali Road Gandhi Gram Gandhi Gram Kawali Road Kawali Road Kawali Road Kawali Road
Mitralok Colony Sridev Suman Nagar 58 (Sridev Suman Nagar) Vijay Park (58)
Temporary
Mobile Vendors Vegetable Seller Small Eatery/Tea Stall Sheds
Temporary
Cattle Shed
NV
Temporary
NV
Temporary
Small Eatery/Tea Stall Pressing iron
NV
Vijay Park
Temporary
Pressing iron
NV
Vivek Vihar
Temporary
Barber
NV
East Patel Nagam
Temporary
Vegetable Seller
NV
New Basti
Temporary
NV
Guru Road
Temporary
Small Eatery/Tea Stall Shops
Park Road
Temporary
Bidi Ciggrette
NV
Gandhi Gram Gandhi Gram Gandhi Gram Gandhi Gram Gandhi Gram Gandhi Gram Gandhi Gram
Temporary
Fruits Stall
NV
Temporary
Vegetable Seller Vegetable Seller Vegetable Seller Vegetable Seller Vegetable Seller Vegetable Seller
NV
Temporary Temporary
Temporary Temporary Temporary Temporary Temporary
NV NV
NV
NV
NV NV NV NV NV
Vul.-Vulnerable AP NV-Non vulnerable AP
42
Short Resettlement Plan for Sewerage System in Kargi Zone, Dehradun (Tranche-I)
List of Affected Person WWM04DN Sl.No
Name
Fathers Name
Street
1.
Raju
2.
Radhe Shyam
Shiv Ram Singh Sh. Mittan Lal
Opposite PWD Quarter Chander Nagar Near Kusth Ashram
3.
Raju Ram Yadav Sohan M. Lukman
Babu Ram M.Muslim
6.
Swami Dayal Gupta
Gajathar P Gupta
7. 8.
Gabbu Sanjay yadav
Majnuddeen Sh. Ram Tirath Yadav
9.
Rajesh Kathria
Ramdas
10. 11.
Virender Sharma Ajay Arora
12.
M. Dilshad
13.
Daya Ram
Aatma Sharma Late Shri Vijay Arora M. Abdul Kayam Badri Prasad
4. 5.
Rampal Yadav
Chander Nagar Shri ram mandir kusth ashram Chander Nagar Shri ram mandir kusth ashram Pathari Bagh (SGRR Public School Gate) Pathari Bagh (S.L.V. Inter college Ground)
Ward
Type of structure SemiPermanent SemiPermanent
Use of structure Small Eatery/ Teas Stall Small Eatery/ Teas Stall
Vul / Non vul
16
Temporary
Pan,Bidi Stall
NV
16 39
Temporary Permanent
Vegetable stall Iron shop
Vul.(SC) NV
39
Permanent
Cement, Iron shop
NV
42
Temporary Temporary
Barbour stall Small Eatery/ Teas Stall
NV NV
43
Temporary
Pan,Bidi, Shop
Vul.(SC)
Temporary
Furniture Maker Small Eatery/ Teas Stall Sugarcane Juice Fruit Stall
NV
39
Temporary Dehra Khas Chowk
43
Temporary SemiPermanent
NV NV
NV NV NV
Vul.-Vulnerable AP NV-Non vulnerable AP
43
