WWW.TAXSCAN.IN - Simplifying Tax Laws


Court No. ­ 3 Case :­ CENTRAL EXCISE APPEAL No. ­ 21 of 2012 Appellant :­ Commissioner Central Excise 7­A Ashok Marg Lucknow Respondent :­ M/S Bajaj Hindustan Ltd. Khambarkhera, Lakhimpur  Kheri Counsel for Appellant :­ Rajesh Singh Chauhan Counsel for Respondent :­ Rajesh Tewari

Hon'ble Sudhir Agarwal,J. Hon'ble Ravindra Nath Mishra­II,J. 1. 

This is an appeal under Section 35­G of Central Excise Tax Act,

1944 (hereinafter referred to as "Act, 1944") at the instance of Revenue, i.e.,   Commissioner,   Central   Excise,   Lucknow.   This   appeal   has   arisen from   the   judgment   and   order   dated   17.05.2012   passed   by   Custom, Excise   and   Service   Tax   Appellate   Tribunal,   New   Delhi  (hereinafter referred   to   as   "Tribunal")  allowing   appeal   of   Assessee   holding   that 'Welding Electrode' is eligible for CENVAT Credit. 2. 

The   Assessee,   i.e.,   M/s   Bajaj   Hindustan   Ltd.,   had   claimed   that

'Welding Electrode' is specified under Head 8311.00 of Central Excise Tariff   and   used   in   repair   and   maintenance   of   'Machines',   therefore, would   fall   within   the   category   of   'Capital   Goods'.   The   claim   was accepted by Tribunal allowing Assessee's appeal. 3. 

Before   this   Court,   appellant   has   contended   that   'Welding

Electrodes' would not fall in the category of 'Capital Goods' under the provisions   of   Rule   57­Q   of   Central   Excise   Rules,   1944  (hereinafter referred to as "Rules, 1944"). The question of law on which this appeal was admitted vide order dated 01.11.2012, required to be decided by this Court, is:

WWW.TAXSCAN.IN - Simplifying Tax Laws


"Whether   tribunal   suffers   from   substance,   learned   counsel keeping in view the fact. It is extremely non speaking?” 4.

Learned   counsel   for   the   parties,   however,   submitted   that   real

question up for consideration is, “whether “Welding Electrodes” would come  in  the   category  of   “Capital  goods”  as  claimed  by  Assessee and upheld by Tribunal or the Assessee has wrongly claimed CENVAT Credit on   use   of   Welding   Electrodes   during   the   period   in   dispute   in   this appeal”. 5.

So   far   as   first   question   is   concerned,   Tribunal   has   followed

another judgment dealing with similar question decided by Karnataka High Court in Commissioner of Central Excise and Service Tax, LTU. vs. ABB Ltd., 2011 (23) STR 97 and it is not shown to this Court that said judgment of Karnataka High Court does not cover dispute in this appeal, therefore, order of Tribunal cannot be said to be bad for want of reasons since reasons contained in the judgment followed by Tribunal would   form   part   of   order   of   Tribunal   also.   Question­1,   therefore,   is answered against Revenue. 6. 

Now we come to second question. The period of dispute for which

CENVAT  Credit  has   been  accepted   is  from   April,  2007   to  December, 2008. This Court finds that in the period of July' 2002 to 09.09.2004, matter of CENVAT Credit was governed by CENVAT Credit Rules, 2002 (hereinafter   referred   to   as   "Rules,   2002")  and   thereafter   by   CENVAT Credit Rules, 2004  (hereinafter referred to as "Rules, 2004"). The term 'Capital Goods' was defined in Rule 2 (b) of Rules, 2002 and Rule 2(a) of Rules, 2004 as under: Rules, 2002: "(b) "capital goods" means:­  (i)   all   goods   falling   under   Chapter   82,   Chapter  84,  Chapter   85, Chapter 90, heading No. 68.05 and sub­heading No. 6801.10 of the First Schedule to the Tariff Act; (ii) pollution control equipment;

WWW.TAXSCAN.IN - Simplifying Tax Laws


(iii) components, spares and accessories of the goods specified at (i) and (ii) above; (iv) moulds and dies; (v) refractories and refractory materials; (vi) tubes and pipes and fittings thereof; and (vii) storage tank, used in the factory of the manufacturer of the final products, but does not include any equipment or appliance used in an office;"  Rules, 2004:  "(a) "capital goods" means:­  (A) All following goods, namely:­  (i)   all   goods   falling   under   Chapter   82,   Chapter  84,  Chapter   85, Chapter 90, heading No. 6805, grinding wheels and the like, and parts thereof falling under heading 6804 of the First Schedule of the Excise Tariff Act; (ii) pollution control equipment; (iii) components, spares and accessories of the goods specified at (i) and (ii) above; (iv) moulds and dies; jigs and fixtures; (v) refractories and refractory materials; (vi) tubes and pipes and fittings thereof; and (vii) storage tank, used­


(1) in the factory of the manufacturer of the final products, but does not include any equipment or appliance used in an office; or  (2) for providing output service;" (B) motor vehicle registered in the name of provider of output service for providing taxable service as specified in sub­clauses (f),   (n),   (o),   (zr),   (zzp),   (zzt)   and   (zzw)   of   clause   (105)   of section 65 of the Finance Act;”

WWW.TAXSCAN.IN - Simplifying Tax Laws



It is admitted by the parties that the Heading of Chapter 8311 is

not   included   specifically   in   the   definition   of   'capital   goods'.   The Assessee, however, relied on Rule 2(b)(iii) of Rules, 2002 and Rule 2(a) (A)(iii) of Rules, 2004, and contended that 'Welding Electrodes' would come within the term 'components' so as to fall within the category of 'capital goods'. 8. 

The definition of 'capital goods' under Rule 2(b) of Rules, 2002

and Rule 2(a) of Rules, 2004 is exhaustive in the sense that it clearly specifies what 'capital goods' would mean. The items which fall under certain chapters of Central Excise Tariff Act are specifiably mentioned in Rule 2(b)(i) of Rules, 2002 and Rule 2(a)(A)(i) of Rules, 2004. Then comes pollution control equipment', moulds and dies, jigs and fixtures, refractories and refractory material, tubes and pipes and fittings thereof and storage tank. All these things, if used in the factory of manufacturer of final products, or, for providing output service, would mean 'capital goods'. However, it would not include any equipment or appliance used in office. There is one more aspect, i.e., Rule 2(b)(iii) of Rules, 2002 and Rule 2(a)(A)(iii) of Rules, 2004, which say that in respect to items mentioned in Rule 2(b)(i) and (ii) of Rules, 2002 and Rule 2(a)(A)(i) and   (ii)   of   Rules,   2004,   components,   spares   and   accessories   of   the goods   specified   thereunder   would   also   fall   within   the   category   of 'capital   goods'.   Having   failed   to   point   out   application   of   any   other provision under Rule 2 (b) of Rules, 2002 and Rule 2(a) of Rules, 2004, the stress on the part of Assessee was on the term 'components' under Rule 2 (b)(iii) of Rules, 2002 and 2(a)(A)(iii) of Rules,2004 and it is contended that 'Welding Electrodes', being used for maintenance and repair   of   machineries   and   factories,   would   fall   in   the   category   of "components", hence would be entitled for CENVAT Credit being 'capital goods'. We find that 'capital goods' as defined under Rule 2(b) of Rules, 2002 and 2(a) of Rules 2004, in substance, are pari­materia with the

WWW.TAXSCAN.IN - Simplifying Tax Laws


'capital goods' specified in Rule 57­Q of Rules, 1944 and there is no substantial difference therein. 9. 

Considering a similar argument in  the context of Rule 57­Q of

Rules, 1944, as it stood in 1999, similar question and submissions have already   been   considered   by   this   Court   recently   in  Central   Excise Appeal No. 135 of 2005 (M/s Upper Ganges Sugar & Industries Ltd. Vs. Commissioner Customs & Central Excise) decided on 25.2.2015. 10. 

For the reasons given in the judgment dated 25.2.2015 in  M/S

Upper Ganges Sugar & Industries Ltd. Vs. Commissioner Customs & Central Excise (supra), Question­2 is answered in favour of Revenue and against Assessee. 11. 

Appeal   is,   accordingly,   allowed.   The   order   of   Tribunal   dated

17.05.2012 is hereby quashed. 12. 

There shall be no order as to costs.

Order Date :­ 10.01.2017 AK

Welding Electrode - Taxscan.pdf

Respondent : M/S Bajaj Hindustan Ltd. Khambarkhera, Lakhimpur. Kheri. Counsel for Appellant : Rajesh Singh Chauhan. Counsel for Respondent : Rajesh ...

162KB Sizes 9 Downloads 289 Views

Recommend Documents

Clay-Modified Electrode
(1) Gill, R.; Qua, S. C.; Moffat, A. C. J. Chromatogr. 1983, 255, 483. ... (4) Yuen, S. H.; Bagness, J. E.; Myles, D. Analyst 1967, 92, 375. ..... Calibration data.

ADEL-FC Advanced Electrode and Fuel Cell
Our BUSINESS. MODEL. guarantees ... Application ... Novel technology using activated carbon &. catalyst ... Displaying Для сайта_1308_v3.pdf. Page 1 of 12.

Welding Essentials
standard numbering systems used by manufacturers. New and improved drawings throughout. Discussions ... New information on the wire feeding process and.

Materials & Welding -
Dear Mr. Karthik / Raghuram bathula. My Question is whether the filler metal. (SMAW with E9018-G; SFA 5.5; A=10; F no. 4 & SAW with F9P6 EG F3; SFA 5.23; ...

stabilized gold nanoparticles modified electrode
It is thus expected that the substantial decrease in the oxidation peak current of As(III) in ..... The authors gratefully acknowledge financial support ... (2006) 247.

Electrochemical Determination of Dobutamine Using Gold Electrode ...
with Self-Assembled Monolayer of Functionalized Multi-Walled Carbon. Nanotubes Decorated with Ruthenium Oxide Nanoparticles. A. Mahdavi Shakiba, S.

Embedded, Multi-electrode Bioimpedance ... - Research at Google
a compact and embedded form factor. 2. A set of form factors (hand pad, chair, and smartphone), where unique electrode configurations generate characteris- ...... iPad". (2 November 2015). Retrieved September 18, 2016 from https://support.apple.com/e

There was a problem previewing this document. Retrying... Download. Connect more apps... Try one of the apps below to open or edit this item.

Welding - 123.is
Further information on single plate thickness can be found in TechSupport #61 at ... The WeldCalc computer program can be used for preheat and interpass ...

Welding - 123.is
This brochure is aimed at simplifying, improving and boosting the efficiency of the welding process. ..... as well as commercial and technical support. For more ...

Standard Electrode Potentials Notes Blank.pdf
The substance with the greater Eo. value (higher on the table) will always undergo. reduction while the other is forced to undergo oxidation. Page 1 of 4 ...

Read Welding Fundamentals - PDF books
Read Welding Fundamentals - PDF books

welding electrodes pdf
There was a problem loading more pages. welding electrodes pdf. welding electrodes pdf. Open. Extract. Open with. Sign In. Main menu. Displaying welding ...

Welding with Children
"Melvin says 'shit dog.'" 'Would you do everything your mama's boyfriend does?" "Melvin can drive," Tammynette said. "I'd like to drive." I got out my penknife and worked the splinter from under Moon- bean's nail while she jabbered to Tammynette abou

SHORTSTOPP® Welding Fittings -
Pipeline. T.D. Williamson, Inc. P.O. Box 3409. Tulsa, Oklahoma 74101-3409. 918-447-5100. Fax: 918-446-6327 www.tdwilliamson.com. Data subject to change ...

What is welding - Arcraft Plasma
HCP. 17 . Metal with highest resistivity and lowest conductivity a. copper b. iron c. nickel d. Titanium. 18 . Susceptibility to stress corrosion cracking is generally less in a. High purity metal b. Martensitic microstructure c. High CE alloys d. HS

welding journals pdf
Download. Connect more apps... Try one of the apps below to open or edit this item. welding journals pdf. welding journals pdf. Open. Extract. Open with. Sign In.

Reaction Kinetics , Electrode Kinetics And Photo Chemistry - 04 16 ...
a) Stern b) Helmholtz ... b) H2 c) H2O2 d) All the above. II. Match the following. 11. Plot of 1. log Vs k. T. is a)J=Lx. 12. ... Explain stern-volmer analysis. 33. ... Displaying Reaction Kinetics , Electrode Kinetics And Photo Chemistry - 04 16.pdf

Screen Printed Carbon Electrode Modified with Poly(L ...
electron microscopy and transmission electron microscopy revealed the size and distribution of gold nanoparticles. The PLA – AuNP/SPE was applied effectively ...

Barrel Plating Rhodium Electrode: Application to Flow ...
Abstract. We introduce here the application of barrel plating technology for mass production of disposable-type electrodes. Easy for mass production, barrel ...

Studies of Solid Oxide Fuel Cell Electrode Evolution ...
imaging contributes to development of mechanistic evolu- tion models needed to ... scanning electron microscopy (FIB-SEM) and transmission X- ray microscopy ...

Influence of TaN Gate Electrode Microstructure on Its ...
negligible and should be taken into account during development of the metal gate ... cross-sectional scanning electron microscope (X-SEM). The thick- ness can ...

An Enzymatic Clay-Modified Electrode for Aerobic Glucose Monitoring ...
AC960830O. X Abstract published in Advance ACS Abstracts, March 1, 1997. Figure 8. (A) Ten repetitive measurement cycles at the SWa-1/DA-GS in (a) 5 mM glucose and 0.8 mM DA and (b) 0.8 mM DA. (B) Sensor stability over a 60 day period. Scan rate, 50