i8aiuuiaraEiBaupiuauGin{uiii»i
(is >
s
we
un V
9. r tslttis 9tf tsfimJi laoocJ ntiaiiaratfiu v
n
H
u
i taltti
g om
PI
j
<=*
to
ajflfTilUMttinR Charles Spinks, The Khmer Temple rah Vihar, The Australian National University, (1959); John Black, "The Lofty Sanctuary of Khao Phra r". The Journal of Siam Society, XLIV, Pt 1, (April 1956), 1-33. Etienne Aymonier, Khmer Heritage in land. White Lotus, (orig. 1901) (translated and printed in 1999)241-257. Raoul Jennar, "The Truth of Trust and Confidence shall be verified" 22 October 2008: taipj7insnpvk.com/documentations.htm.
fit?:
tiis Cambodia Daily too fJH: bOO^t HTOStCUIR M 1|. SHIS |Clsltmf P/znom Pen/i Posf be) flH: bOO^ 1 Nopporn Wong-Anan, "Thai, Cambodian PMs meet er tension eases", Reuters, 27 February 2009.
tjmBjfmti RytgiRQiutJifimfijyap9eL)ttjtsl£!.m.Hm i taiga
s n.ra.Htii9Mtn3cfiHM
glirmsmhsltnmfi RI
R.GJ.H
b. talttg 0m
ujtgMtnna (n^tjitnojtmttalttfnHmtUTHiptnnjtnna)
utisi ^dsio i ttoStjaineiiiaitsiwnBgifliniK Hatarafi) i fincufriH Id H13t3lfiatflIRnm
gtt!tnw<|ut9MnHtii9raia]m9ftjt6) fnSojicj Reports (Merits) icj Reports (1962) 6 ("ICJ Report (Merits) hereafter"); 56(4) American Journal of International Law (Oct 1962). 1033-1053. met ttiR "The Preah Vihear Temple Case" fSlRailTOJUfJfflti^nJUTlUTi mai«R Cambodia] and the United Nations: Comparative Foreign Policies Under Four Regimes,
StRUUSUflJlK
lortca c S/2008/476, 1-9. 1 6
^8ift^-tqJ«[gftnB^[nmiJtraM|M^cii(9)HacBnTnanti-iMjB Qs^gsm nn: ben §m mi aa nGMutnna-tMjH(§)Cj^nl-9^mrt)gingtist3[nft3siti-t8J
Victor Prescott, A Srwrfy o/ ?/ze Delineation of the Thai-Cambodian Boundary. Canberra: Office of Nation
(watershed;
ligne
de partage
des eaux)
piui:nHmjt3Htnnt3-tMf H c nnmnHmnhi) a HstMstutm H stjtnrm i nrnHmntuisirofj ier i tjmmnfmftMfftittnm 5
|
J
3
|
ti
U
HSt58MSMCTn§)^Onl
, (1985), 123-127 1
iJr "ffffifffffffaTffffffffff?fif3ffffififffffffJtf^3a/nffffr^f fslsititfiifm wfoZuti. mfmu. utitrati, sisncrl, mm, fimsaff emmet), tmeu, , sftrntifSffK rthtt) amutfititiffnins tmsnti, rma sttsamajiauJ) v c* i U =* y U
• fjf3>. mti? nj
LJ
eti
U
ni
at
t-i
i
i
U
wwfn tslms :-_•:"
wyms smuugHunmrm/unrifirafjtcinn Rifia ssin Sarin Chhak, L« u a rtjs imtiere khmero-thailandaise, These de Droit public, dactylographiee, Paris, 1966; and Sarin Chhak, Le -: De La Frontiere Cambodgienne Avec le Laos et le Sud-Vietnam, StRUUgunJimtiR^gjlfm
), twjfwrljufimirm iSa OIJSH , mfirn fiHtj1(l£]000),tHCUH£1ugttinf1 tnnn Larry Palmer, "Thailand's Kampuchea Incidents ~ -— '-.:•.'. Disputes and Armed Confrontation along the Thai-Kampuchean Frontier", 1(4) News From uchea (1977), 1-31; SffJUfUM Natalie Gurney, A History of the Territorial Dispute Between Siam and French Indochina and Post-War Political Developments in the Disputed Territories, Master Thesis, John iopkins University (May 1950); Thadeus Flood, "The 1904 Franco-Thai Border Dispute and Phibuun •gkhraam's Commitment to Japan" 10(2) Journal of Southeast Asians History, (1969), 304-244; K. Landon, Ifcaland's Quarrel with France in Perspective", The far Eastern Quarterly (Nov. 1941) 25-42; Lawrence : ".:::> "The Treaty of March 23, 1907 Between France and Siam and the Return of Battambang and Angkor iCimbodia" The Far East Quarterly (1945-6). 439-455. 1 klctor Prescott, A Study of the Delimitation of the Thai-Cambodian Boundary. Canberra: Office of National 15,20.
talsn
•J
WHS 9
90
Tub man,
10
National Jurisprodence in International Tribunals , 28 N.Y.U.J. INTL. & Pol., 134(1995-1996) 1 WS1S
ti& trifla ntitfrn
vdotl sa s^orilt ntpsyswcufnsntjihannJitjffrii
wmi
tiis
m}tui«8{Rftnscui?i^iSiat3i5 chamvit Kasetsin "pwi9Ltisltmi-fiio?iMnfi|n}8fintM tntanfi ^gratti 9-rt (too ytisi boocJ) http://www.charnvitkasetsiri.com/PDF/PreahhFor20June.pdf
(tHBnaitfri ytiSl bOOd) 1
ns Ijcmntui Iggd ytim 9^&9"ta1gatJJtJnLti1tm9tP^tira- samiMma migicmumtlnj ("itnramioniasicmmiraRtiHHaieiR wma") i M ti
Thongchai Winichakul, SIAM MAPPED. A HISTORY OF THE CEO-BODY OF A NATION (1994): PAITOON MIKUSOL, SOCIAL AND CULTURAL HISTORY OF NORTHEASTERS RHAtLAM) FROM 1868-1910: A CASE STUDY OF\ THE HUAMUANG KHAMEN PADONG (1984) (Sunn. Sangkha and Khukhan) ); NEIL ENGLEHART, CULTURAL.
< 3tnutigunJ]finrmfftlJ?gjlrijm
CHOICE .AM) CHAYGE W THAILAND
1868-1910(1996) ( swuugUDSfinwinHilgjiifitDfnfiTniaim)
IN THE REIGN OF
KINGl
; ALFRED BATTYE, THE!
MILITARY, GOVERNMENT AND SOCIETY IN SL^\{ : 1868-1910 : POLITICS AND MnJTARY REFORM DURING THE REING OF\
tu c*>
G)G)
(Watershed) 9j1innt$atnmHfjtt$fl .
ttfitmgjn Hi
i
n
rasstnsggtmtasgtsns i tslRtamnjunJaRU (Cross-Claim) M
«
n
KING CHULALONGKORN (1974) c 3tnuugutinmt3tiJHStnatTji8C)HtjjiKi fmRfulejicutumttuicu) tJi
fmwsismai nnramifi/HranjMHgtti-tnritt ttmn Rithikray i Dessemond tsnM:nHmjGJ8wrifnntnsm^njpaats1{«Rnnjtjsnrami^tmt3GjifJt3i tsjptia jtjifinmitiriMfimntiismSitupt3sts1|t5nRCU 913 lom 9^ocJ, itntiirrutifi tuistires :
nnrafniiuifinTifninntD|t»HJfaitiin(HatMBm9tiimo'i MtttSratittimHtraaitiM victor Prescott, Map of
Mainland Asia by Treaty, Melbourne University Press (1975), 437
1
Er="M8t5 Manich Jumsai LmgMttstnatnmtJaatJiguMHataMaMmisiori tuitutiras m t^atTi fnslmjwmsltJHSMmslfmgfifttifg msmritnsHsjnatri^isluntjiraMtijtRHai wmStu Brig. Gen. Manich Jumsai, History of Thailand & Cambodia (from the Days of Angkor to the Present), Bangkok, (1970),
213-216 i mna tanatnB{ucifit3t9t9jfi {utgMttJnm3ima!tiB9!flnKntingi litBHjraefflnffthf Larry S*ernstein, "A Catalogue of Maps of Thailand", 1 The Siam Society. Fiftieth Anniversary Commemorative ffblication, (1954), 72 . ItntUfmSW ttinR^3t3tflt8JpaSJrimHHim8U81t3tSt3|tilfing RHStHStnH13nfi81t3 Charuwan Phungtian, Thai-Cambodian Culture Relationship Through Arts(2000) (StRUU9 SltrnS) Bodh-Gaya, 248 1
5
nitre ( miaM)ftm«W8nifinra^a9atnsMam&wjtiftft:tismisijnmiJ»aiS8 1 throng u
u
in U
i
*
l «t
1
M81S
until taltuira i tt.m.mmwtsi
ra
sa mS!fi«nwt!Mirtt3WutjiaiHBtiintiarafni«are9ttm8 ti CU
U
O LJ
Vl
-\A
cm)
B.OH.H
Krishna Rao, r/ie Prea/j Vi/zear Case and f/ie Sino-Indian Boundary Questions, New Delhi-1 (1963), 4; R.Y. Jennings, TTie Acquisition of Territory in International Law, Manchester University Press, (1963), 49. 1 14
JtnrnmJOn?iCulfnsraBtiHHS5tflB( HtitMGn)901 be), SfiemnUM A. Rustemeyer, "Temple of Preah Vihear i i n n en n
Case" in Encyclopedia of Public International Law (1981), 273-4; vJfitmiJUM C. Thornberry, "The Temple of Preah Vihear (Cambodia v Thailand), 26 Modem Law Review, (1963), 448-451.
itJH8BmMatii|fi
wst5 trnw
SIS History of Thailand & Cambodia (from the days of Angkor to Present), (1970), 215; MmStCj Phillip Jessup, The Price of International Justice, Columbia University Press (1971), 15. Thomas| Donovan, "The Marouni River tract and its Colonial Legacy in South America," Chicago-Kent Journal International Law and Comparative Law 4 (2004), 11-12; Ashraf Ibrahim, 'The Doctrine of Laches i» International lav/," 83 Virginia Law review, (1997), 654; Thoma Grant, 'Territorial Status, Recognition, and Statehood: Some Aspects of the Genocide Case (Bosnia and Herzegovina v. Yugoslavia)," 33 Stanfor Journal of International Law, (1997), 321; Joaquin Roy, " Lawyers Meet the Law: Critical US Voices Helms-Burton" 6 University of Miami Yearbook of International Law, (1997-1998), 64; Anthony Aust, '" Theory and Practice of Informal International Instruments," 35(4) The International and Comparative Lav Quarterly (Oct. 1986), 810.
6
=*
3JGJ
«(D
1
umsHnasatiiTriiUasagiatsiatiMiitinfiTtiHraJ U U n j U TI LiLnj tnaggraHamnmTmtitjitmn i UGffita9WR«inHGtnftoiiwnt!:HisatiJ!fi u
i n.m.H tstitutsi
u
m
y-
u
fncn:t9M:tnnfli
S RRw ~
,
„
„
o
,
9^
.^.
! S9tumfi miMtiGitiw R.GS.H i tsltti
fi.tll.H 9£e>10 ( HiKMiSfi) S. mo 1 Durward Sandifer, Evidence Before International Tribunals, n n J
orsity Press of Virginia (rev. ed. 1975) 338-9; James Gathii, "Geographic Hegelianism in Territorial uies Involving Non-European Land Relations: An Analysis of the Case Concerning Kasikili/Sedudu wrana/Namibia)", 15 Leiden Journal of International Law (2002) 616; Phillip Jessup, The Price of lonal Justice, Columbia University Press (1971), 15; Masahiro Miyoshi, Consideration in the
jf
StntUrTUfin fi.tll.H 9£Sto (HtJtWtifp S. mcni Giovanni Distefano, "The Conceptualization
•oruction) of Territorial Title in the Light of the International Court of Justice Case Law", 19 Leiden 1 of International Law (2006), 1059-1061. fate to U.N. Acting Secretary General", (July 6 1962), Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Bangkok, 1(6) Foreign r Bulletin (June-July 1962), 130; The Bangkok Post, 22 June 1962; Bangkok World, 4 July 1962; Kgence Memorandum - Cambodia 's Boundary Problems, Directorate of Intelligence, Central Intelligence ^--- .;. CIA/BGT GM 88-2), (27 February 1968), 5. "Vaierstanding the Temple of Preah Vihear Issue", Statement 25 March 2008 of the Ministry of Foreign rri^-. Bangkok, Thailand; Supalak Ganjanakhundee, "Thailand, Cambodia to cooperate on Preah Vihear: ". The Nation 26 December 2008. Bangkok World, 16 July 1962; L. P. Singh, "The
ie f.V
Cambodian Temple Dispute" 2(8) Asian Survey(Oct., 1962). mffimUllSnItSMmffimgHJjhMSl fUHS 7
tffjffffgflftff CThe Temple of Preah Vihearj SCALE 1:15,000
\i The Kingdom of Thailand
s
if ~KL
"v the The Kingdom of C&mbodia^J
« -.*•
m
fijflfi tB^MmrHSnTimSngme1...99CUmSJriUTin^fi&Sl"ntiOTSmfini. Where Foreign Policy counts", 5(9) Asian Survey, (1965), 445. 21
toood
^88/2008/474 9.g, S, e) 1
Bernard
Gordon, "Cambodia
nsi
(fen
mt9MttiMifH3iSftnRjtiisitJ6ai.is.a Q LJ
E
w
cy
v
U
U
t
J
C
i
*
i
R.GJ.H (operative findings)
]JJI9MltitmnJintifil
ttjFismsiciRt5TS!JtififiSfiHtii8fntnattmtn usRJtntu er
tf,
torn
Tirinatsm I*
tl
c*
Oy
n
7J
CU
"V*
taltejtms" fwm^ mtuns rafflta!satinTm!ifTii3iHmi!8nJTnJtfiisnmtmffi«9 i
(in
w-
Liu
u
tg o
o .o
(territorial
fi.HI.H
sovereignty)!
tptfia (Boundary) (Terms of Reference)f1Htjlt|Umfyt3tH18fflHgilHGmRtiJ]fiinn U
24
£os?ra$ttjs 109 rmsi toooc! 1
«^
n
~ tCUS S/2008/474 S.Ci 1
WUlfUtfltflB TO8 S/2008/65 9.fa 1 26
Brian Summer, " tii;FlS9TlBtSl{)tinfnira|aHHSItjlB " 53 and Duke Law Journal, (April 2004), 1811
tK^g&tffiimmnmsattt&tfftftfimri9i39ii]H8mt\ 10
ISCl
nn
R.GJ.H uaimtal
RmtnrnmjwififitfatoffifmwtnunisteeM
-o
ct i
tn
fe^eaes)
c*
o -^
ct
o
. O
CM
<=>•
i A zondereygen". mtimnj unntifiJ§jfninmRnHtimnrajfnci (by reference) i R.tu.H fihitstii =»)£=*
O
o
oO ,
-=»>O . o)
tisssti t8jRacaifitflatnntia9tm8tnaMnnimn
CTIO
s itiftngffSumwjmntsiiJtirfffftijiffSmgtajjfrmtjig mistmsi nttmanss tfifnsfest! /mmfiffifffsmmsstirmtfsSfmmgtfstfif&ntimmmsftfwtiiutfffns u mannnfiw ttfwgwfagn3[fi?t[jgn[Wfiimtistihffijifj i nutstfttniHSmtfaijtfiff}aj9Btijaffiaffai[fcifi}gritistn of
S
m
U
mtnO/lfi gtntflrianmattfStilUtitffli"
tf
U
v
c*
tu
-**
1 Elia Zureik and Mark Salter, Global Surveillance and Policing,
Security and identity (2005), 175. tranafnHtn|fm{fatsnmfniraBtt§HSJtJiBHnrimns8!s|ti! fBmtiHCU tmstfimjlsSmtSStCUWcfifmWmmamnjUtiJia Terms of reference mfllBJ 1 ISt^ttljS Case ceming the Continental Shelf (Libyan Arabic Jamahiriya M Malta), ICJ Reports 13 (1985),
SyswRcmfris ttJita|R699]RRj!8jtn!flat9 ma ntinfnrantwirang|nHt|C|jagttBra [fituStSS 1 RTsISM 9& 1 RiHf)a Case Concerning the Continental Shelf (Tuninia v i Arabic Jamahiriya) ICJ Report 18 (1982),
fT1HW^nJ»Wmij|ffSH|H3lfi
ntiiswig Pippa Tubman, "National Jurisprudence in International Tribunals", 28 New York University Journal of vtional Law and Politics (1995-1996], 134; Gary Scott and Craig Car, "The ICJ and Compulsory ction: the Case for Closing the Clause", 81 American Journal of International Law (1987), 64 Brian Summer, "Territorial Disputes at the International Court of Justice" 53 Duke Law Journal, (April - p.1812. Case Concerning Sovereignty Over Certain Frontier Land (Belgium v. Netherlands) 195*9, I.C.J. Reports 1 )9 WL 5; J. Castellino and S. Alien, Title to Territory in International Law, a Temporal Analysis, 12-3. 'U. ai 122-3. 11
c TtitgMURiuntmMuaratBMmt U
B.m.H
e*
un
U
si
i StScnnjuimatJiRtiatglsinnfni
*1
•**
HRmysiJfiJHit3t3iHisTnli3satutiirit3nfi3tt;ira -B|
L
i
u
c
J
tsia 9iH9iiTn!fiatfiitJjftnit3iTi;ittiatm8Rnnmuin3"mS flttssfittnsTcitflaattfittnjHotnBmTtii U
U
0 ei
fli
u
ni
u
" tti _
tittns
B.GJ.H
msmn
island of Paimas
31
Concerning the Frontier Dispute (Burkina Faso V Mai) ICJ Reports (1986). Id, para. 17. 33 S. Akween, International law and Protection of Namibia's Territorial Integrity (1997 ), 5; Enno Milmanj Chritine Chinkin, Unlawful Territorial Situation in International Law (2006), Ian Brownlie, The Rule Oj in International Law (1998 ), 151; 34 A. Allott, "Boundary and Law in Africa", in African Boundary Problems, 9, C.G Widstand, ed (1969), 13. 35 Surya Sharma, Territorial Acquisition, Disputes and International Law, (1997 ), 23. 36 Brian Summer, "Territorial Disputes at the International Court of Justice" 53 Duke Law Journal, (April 2004), 1812. 37 Case Concerning the Frontier Dispute (Burkina/Faso/Mali), ICJ Reports 1986, 563; Surya Sharma, "Ca^ Concerning the Frontier Dispute (Burkina-Faso/Republic of Mali) - A Critique", 11 & 12 Kurukshetra La Journal (1985-86), 150. 38 The Island of Paimas Case (United States and Netherlands), 2 U.N. Reports of International Arbitration Awards (1928), 829. 12 32
1
ttnmniuiHtii tjttnsmtinninfiSfitn (u
LJ
<=t
i miungMnun.m.HMntiHiji n laltButBMiniTnHiuMsa n.m.H TUfnMfiHfmstjiinJtanjTHfMnG: "tsstii U
ni
Li
*^
«v
LHJ
ju
Id. 838, 840. Case Concerning Sovereignty Over Certain Frontier Land (Belgium v. Netherlands) 1959, CJ. Rep, 209 (20 June 1959). TRltUfT1I[inta8{RftnaHfinfnmminfjamtlIitpra98m^Jn R. Case Concerning f Frontier Dispute (Burkina Faso/Republic of Mali), I.C.J. Rep. 1986, and Case Concerning Territorial (Libyan Arab Jamahiriya/Chad),
1994 I.C.J Rep. l."raHSlg?tnSHSE1TI( Acquiescence) ffmtflSMg
el) fnntit3ranjfli3titH1SH5utEitnjSi3|fltus5HStIJntilfnng", Nuno Sergio Margo Antunes, Estoppel, Vc_:escence and Recognition in Territorial and Boundary Dispute Settlement", 2(8) IBRU Boundary and lory Briefing (2000), 6.
iBffBJtijmgunmh) 9m nu: s t itiunfammuitttimm §8atmrffftff}ffffftftir[meffPtfffff JsjjtH stifljmiotiiffygiftfBTfitijmgttmffffmiJttf
smtfirn
ttftftRtmtfnhlffftttffiffflnajWffjJhmt 9
JasariiiTumtijtfi ft
LJ
mgrntimrnitrnfeBtigmMffnartismtimHilGmMSB er
U
If.
U
lasmatifumMtfttamfffffmmgfUfmffMffmhJcnBfimfftn faajfntfififttf wswnmsnitfjififigffiumtiriffi M
LJ
L/u
&
U
*J
Li
n
13
-v* v v
01
I
fSfintaff
f t si
OJ
fafamgrmenansi c*
mnnnJms
mtfsnG
v ** *J
R.GJ.H stinraustfi " i !nttfHBftroBififi§9 sa to n
1
R.GJ.H "
nannHtiinHffljinn HtiimiMwstniBiH|cnaa O
T
eB
Ci
.,
•
<•»
»
CO
ts
j^niummamRjunJiasmtjTitiJt^^3^1^3 tse"
o
o
Hn.aj.H9froranfftt3ttiipffin
(operative provisions) igtpgRtUlrnjrafU1jlfltJimmSQ1tnt5 -x_j
ttsnifitimet8«an:nHmi5itt3tifnnojm9|timMf!Htjit9 i -o ct
«b
j
u
vJ
n
itnramjon R.ra.H 8. 42 n fi.ra.H g^&la c maracm 8. 9ri i in
n
3
Surya Sharma, Territorial Acquisition, Disputes and International Law, (1997) 27; Brian Summe "Territorial Disputes at the International Court of Justice" 53 Duke Law Journal, (April 2004), 1812.
itnraminj SI.GJ.H
s. 901
md mms
HHtiTI Victor Prescott, Map of Mainland Asia by Treaty, (1975), 437; "Prasat Phra Viharn & Phra Viharn Mountain", in Charuwan Phungtianm, Thai-Cambodian Culture: Relationship Through Arts, PhD Dissertation, Magadh University (2000), 247. 45
14
o
^B
Ci
caJ^gfl]
*^
.
tscuitsfituncutsman i srmnmsl I
n
U
Cl
dt^fra
R
tanmHtnl
Guenter
fi.BJ.H 9d£)l£) (JftKMtsTt) 9. file) 1 St3D. Johnson, "Judgment of May 26, and June 15, 1962, Case PI fi ° J
ling the Temple of Preah Vihear", \\International and Comparative Law Quarterly, (1962), 1202. '•Hcjoinder of the Royal Government of Thailand", itnOJfTllElfl fi.UJ.H 9de)l3 RJIOJSto (fijmtt) 8. ent of Mr. James Nevins Hyde", 273, in Vol. 2 ICJ Reports (Pleadings); Sakeus Akweenda, "The Significance of Maps in Boundary Questions: a Reappraisal with Particulars Emphasis on Nambia" 60 Year Book of International Law (1989) 222; Dennis Rushworth, "Mapping in Support of Frontier tion: Maps as Evidence", IBRU Boundary and Security Bulletin (Winter 1997-1998), 53; William p. International Law. Cases and Materials, (3rd ed. 1962) 446-447; Alexandra Denes, Recovering rr Ethnic Identity From the Thai Nationalist Past: An Ethnography of the Localism Movement in Surin ce. PhD Dissertation, Cornell University, (2006), 138. N. Hyde, "Jessup: Memorials and Reminiscences", 80 American Journal of International Law (1986),
ttms Li
m
WeissbergtintlJHmti 1
J Guenter Weissberg |Ri3 ttUStCJUJ 6rf 1
Phillip Jessup tnsmcu
mtiB9HiatpjtntB|nMij -..-ncrjR mW^ 1
Jessup, The Price of International Justice, Columbia University Press (1971), 15. er Weissberg "Maps as Evidence in International Boundary Disputes: a Reappraisal" 57 American f of International Law (1963), 798. 15
ff u fratSmatifstfsngmslmmsinfff f? u tfffffffftnftfd tsfmrnsf f8tttsninftrm9lffltimG?...timsfinnmmswstimnjm ^^wi^anHJiniMas tnrm weissberg! XJ
I
"
M
/ c*
I
U
n
U
*
Perc
y tmnsmiMtitsf^stmlda -*
-VI
y
c*
/
"
Ou
^
MSMfm
tt^8^ HJttK9jfi6GfiflTIUlIttl043^t!la(»d {UttintiSUfTISHRJnS tnnR Weissberg
tira
"9
50
raae. U
nnffl!1Ha»ffi^(Bllt9l6ltnfinll|tiia!fl11 WmSttf See R.P. Anand, "The Role of Individual and DissentiJ Opinions in International Adjudication" 14(3) The International and Comparative Law Quarterly (Jul. 19651 pp 797-798. See generally, 68 International Court of Justice Yearbook (1947-8). 51
ItJiramJCin fi.GI.H 9de)l3 (HaiHtSR) 9. mc^l D.H.N. Johnson, "Judgment of May 26, 1961, and June 19 ci n 1962 Case Concerning the Temple of Preah Vihear", 11 American Journal of International Law (1962), 16
(fintsistuvfecmcirm
weissberg
atrte
gi laooca juwss
!8J?tjrt0nfHtii9l
u -
O
nms ^tcmn Keith Highet Li
tTm8Hmimitnaiitinfigi3fnciHHtDBiin9ltt«Dta1naif|tima« m LJ
i
a
i ou
of
U
n
_j,^
"
m
•5
a» a consequence" to use the words of J.H. W. Verzijl, "International Court of Justice. Case Concerning Temple of Preah Vihear (Cambodia v. Thailand)", 9 Nederlands Tijdschrift voor Internationaal Recht 248. • Prescott, Map of Mainland Asia by Treaty, Melbourne University Press (1975), 437. Highet, "Evidence, the Court, and the Nicaragua Case," 81 American Journal of International Law .25; also Durward Sandifer, Evidence Before International Tribunals, (rev. ed 1975), 338-339.
nhiiiip jessup tJit«tsi!!t3nj9]iunjiatimicmiuf8MtilgttfJtinw» 17
ffflUffllftflB
OTwmHMtraifctiftiBSSfljraftatJiatJ^^ mffinnfi{$flBtukiJtsi8§9flJipi^ Li
u
na
trra R.GJ.jf "tftnjgtlHKtafntssfljftnoj) o»
u
FI
w
tJ
tifi
°*
i
ttma
ttiBgtB8ffl3tinjfftffflfmBMBMmnuimtnBmmt U
e»
rn
cu
weissberg GtacuutJitn msmci C
'
H
U
I
^
S
I
g^oril tgramrnGgmmoniffttatiimtsi
i mnasHSHim tsltnatg
fltonimiftratmsatinHia >5
Krishna Rao, The Preah Vihear Case and the Sino-lndian Boundary Question, New Delhi-1 (1963),
Jtntuminn R.tu.H 9de)to (HtiiMBm 9. cntoi 1
Guenter Weissberg noted and quoted it in "Maps as Evidence in International Boundary Disputes: Reappraisal" 57 The American Journal of International Law (1963), 797. 57
stntiirnifin fi.cu.H <36!e)la c HtstMGfp s. cncs i
'8 Guenter Weissberge, "Maps as Evidence in International Boundary Disputes: A Reappraisal," America Journal of International Law (1963), 802; Victor Prescott and Gillian Triggs, International Frontiers at Boundaries, Law, Politics and Geography, (2008), 210. 59
ItntUminJi n.ia.H 9de)l3 RJICUS b (wma) 8. Ia5)c) ICJ Reports 1962 Vol 2 (Pleadings), 216
50
Victor Prescott, A Study of the Delimitation of the Thai-Cambodian Boundary. Canberra: Office of Nationa^ Assessments (1985) 15, 20.
18
gurnu ttnmmntJiistTMBfttna i Ttnttetumsis iffffflmnmiKiimwi u
t*.
w*
u
L*
vb
«N.
gRysnmsjtgatif?
g(^ffaiiJjtf«lfjraff)
(Ratio Decidendi) Sfl
(Dispositif)
()
*« l ]
taHftj
0
.*
e
t
•=»
tssrattncuGtistinmTti minonnQtatrtMtsficratio L J
<
=
*
w
O
HSHismRnfnntg i
8. CTICjl Sr3 Kaiyan Kaikobad, Interpretation and Revision of ional Boundary Decisions, Cambridge University Press (2007), 315; Kaiyan Kaikobad, "Some • jtions on the Doctrine of Continuity and Finality of Boundaries", The British Year Book of tional Law (1984), 118-141 139
R.tU.H
tannJTiaHGtT3mtS^9Mltit8lfT1S{UGia^rlH|pr|flMaM8S/2008/474, 6. ( frtHMtsfl) S. mSl n n
19
(binding force) wstfis'S 1tnmattticwitftemjHmttJW8Bfifi pious Fund case (1902) njatas c*
CT
-sj
n
w
«u
"-1
cn
(.Polish Postal Service in Danzing-1925)
snsjcii Batntimgl atfdtsfiftfatfia ~ <=t CT
raimmiil V.>i
i tjcuimjHm{sra?i''99ci5fmci3
tflisfnrnimtfttwaihHfl^ H HitsmtiRtna West
M
Africa
Mohamed Shahabuddeen, Precedent in the World Court, Cambridge University Press, (1996), 161-163 "Decision of Permanent Court of Arbitration in the Matter of the Pious Fund, October 14, 190", 2 7> American Journal of International Law (1908), 900; also Michael Reisman, "The Breakdown of the ConoB Mechanism in ISCID Arbitration", Duke Law Journal (Sept. 1989), 800. 66 Permanent Court of International Justice, Series B, No. 11 (1925), ("PCD") 29-30. 67 PCIJ, Series E, No. 9,174. 20 65
i
1 H1?fhss ^ftnSR.GJ.HHSHfltUmslRi3i:3i3RHt3WfiJSi3tnrii3 {United Kingdom v.
is ttfgmo tsfmtfi §>£rilnl ntTmsfiaftrituTfiHHiaiTifiiaMftitiinBiffTtiatMBfi i i
f
n
L
J
C
*
L
J
i
m§) aatMsfiHatfiB RI ci c* pi
«*
c*
ct
o. uy
J
(res judicata) 1 J
M
res judicata H1slmslRi3tfJQRfj|^lStSt1 res judicata
ri
(ttitutnaniuimmnifniimHafi RGTIU n w
mnJTMUfnttu!fmtUfnflISf£iTfiff1[lJlR!sSffi LJ
tj
p!8MHl«flMtltflj01M8lJ
tftaj^ftTflTfnMtinOTBHSinmrotMGnfi " l -v> JJ u n l in
jtamraim3lRamMt5ntht^tnBti}M81B9tBlftIGnMtJti (award)
lawtJimmrnncmmirnn" t RtinfruggcumngcufutuiHiamw
res judicata
est Africa, 1C J Reports (1966), 56. n of 14 March 1978 on Delimitation of the Continental Shelf (Interpretation of the Decision of 30 . Court of Arbitration (UK vs France), 54(6), International Law Reports, (1978) para. 28.
Sri ntfi.tolai niti. tocji islntittttinjwtDntitmfijaSacQ R c
t
u
u
u
^
u
i
tthtmtatfi :
(Bosnia and Herzegovina v. Serbia and Montenegro) WlCUffmttig l9e) RH: £21
21
••^••••H
.rib
Continental Shelf
(Tunisia v.
Libya)
:^matiHrB iKtSinanBtittitinituntmtni
rtm
Continental Shelf Case Hfi fpMBt"GOJJtSWtIt3tyiM9" " (express findings f^
w*
raia^om"GW)snan«^jiM9"ialRtifmn3UiH intnanl
ttJtfiHsntniwnthtfifi.m.HtiisEQyisticmfM
72
Stephan Wittich, "Permissible Derogation from Mandatory Rules? The Problem of Party Status in the Genocide Case", 18 European Journal of International Law, (2007), 603 73
Case concerning the Continental Shelf
mnjM§nwnSt3Ufi^infflfmCUJJ1H'itj9 tots fJH:
, ritil. i 90 tj (Tunisia/Lybia), Decision of 14 March 1978, 54 International Law Report (1978), 171. 75 Justin Hughes, " American Moral Rights 9. tnb 1 JtiltllfTlJtin fi.m.H
Fixing the Dastar "Gap"" 69 Utah Law Review (2007), 706.
22
R.m.HRiuint3i"t3mtatt8tJC!TiHimf!mtta! M in u.
tItijcirnra*flrti3njfaTm9Mtfi U
epi
nf .
i
iTmtOHmalffteooo LJ
n.
:tnramitu fi.ra.
e.
"Judgment of May 26, 1961 and June 15, 1962, Case Concerning the Temple of Preah Vihear", 1 1 emational and Comparative Law Quarterly, (Oct., 1962), 1 199. Hyung Lee, "Mapping the Law of Legalizing Maps: The Implications of the Emerging Rule on Map idence in International Law," 14 Pacific Rim Law and Policy Journal, (2005), 170-176; Peter Radan, "Poston International Border: A Critical Analysis of the Opinions of the Badinter Arbitration Commission," Melbourne University Law review, (2000), 59; Peter Trooboff, Haihua and Eric Keong, "Treaties - Treaty Peace Between Egypt and Israel - Demarcation of Internationally Recognized Boundaries - Arbitration of tspute - Taba" 83 American Journal of International Law, (1989), 595; Lung-chu Chen, W.M. Reismant, ho Owns Taiwan: a Search for International Title," 81 Yale Law Journal, (1972), 673; Thomas Donovan, hallenges to the Territorial Integrity of Guyana: a Legal Analysis," 32 Georgia Journal of International and mparative Law, (2004), 714; Christopher Brown, "A Comparative and Critical Assessment of Estoppel in ternational Law," 50 University of Miami Law review, (1996), 397,402
samntnsfjilSaSttnn c $6 Stfsi toooo) 23
ira
• f\
n i
:tR!5igT^ U
talww
1
t|mtDBntjti^nmj|afnftJtimrait9Mit i
i
tuntDsm8ltciranHijitija99nj!tJa9|6ii8|ttpBi
80
1(6) June-July (1962) Foreign Affair Bulletin , Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Bangkok, Thailand, 130.
81
cu8ticulsfni|fini|tiiJsmtJiti5Hfisns ^miSjrantjrafiH^tBH^moiinftratiannpSieiH Dag
Library 9lQ WlfTl iQOOCal
maB.ra.a t a i a
cnSralnsititratrastma 24
t
-r
\
•)
f Aftp A>> o«(rf«ji ofiht Survey Department Map repfeseoting the area where the Temple of Phn Viharo is situated, over whirt Thailand his relinquished her sovereignty.
cjold
• Aide Memoire Sur Les Relations Khmero-ThaidaiseslAide Memoire on Khmero-Thai Relations (October 1962), 75. ** Supalak Ganjanakhundee, "Preah Vihear Controversy a Hot Topic in No-confidence", The Nation, 25 June | 2008; tCinfi Abhisit Vejjajiva, ?tfmfiSjftS«jimmmgHl|ltfg1U?lJtJtJ1 "\
''
Bertil Lintner, "Temple Furor Exposes
Delicate Ties", Far Eastern Economic Review, July/August (2008), 39, UQ9SCU | p^gfj^guidajjc^gaBtnJLmSstilHtllfiHtjlinnJtsn
GltHCU Supalak Ganjanakhundee, "Common
Should decide the issue of Preah Vihear Temple, unless it becomes politicized", The Nation, 2 July 2008. 25
Sense
rmsis 8HrmimfinnmHimtaatftiMtJtiJtB«
tpst
fraiaam "ntiBjnQftnn i wsmmjHBtnattitinttTirouwiaihffnnmmnjR
CiCj
d.
snlaootf
HIS um
i5
Alastair Lamb, Asian Frontiers. Studies in a Continuing Problem (1968) p. 5; Nejib Jibril, "The BindiJ Dilemma: From Bakasi to Badme - Making State Comply with Territorial Decisions of the Internatioti Judicial Bodies, 19 American University International Law Review, (2004) p.680; Gary Scott and Craig Cad "The ICJ and Compulsory Jurisdiction: The Case for Closing the Clause", 81 American Journal I International Law, (1987) 63-64; Cambodia: general Survey, National Intelligence Survey, NIS 43A GS (rel April 1972), 46. U.S. Department of State, International Boundary Study No. 40 (Revised), Cambodia-Thailand Boundam (23 November 1966), 2. '7 Durward Sandifer, Evidence before International tribunals (1975), 455, also Advisory Opinion P.C.tB Series. B, No. 9 (1927) , at 22. 18 Generally, D. W. Bowett, "Res Judicata and the Limits of Rectification of Decisions by Internatic Tribunal" 8 Pt.3 African Journal of International Law and Comparative Law (1996), 577-591; K Kaikobad, Interpretation and Revision of International Boundary Decision, Cambridge University (2007); Shabtai Rosenne, Interpretation, Revision and Other Recourses from International Judgments > Awards, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers (2007) 89
mood
s/2008/470 9. ten s/2008/9i79.§)-toi
toti mitt toooti Rein bood
fJtt3l^9l|]JtnS|f1H|5f1JlM|fd8ttr]8 S/2008/653
26
" ^
O
to) tSGHsmtssttSvits]
*t
o>
"*
<*>
tu/ntfomtfarta
i ttJiraraffii ij
rawMttitnattijMaatMtsnrafiwtJMSBmHtjgummBJ tuim^cutsmnmfijtss LJ
n n-vj
w*
m ei
nj
^*
i) Wrongful Act) nH^ifi9iHffii|TtjM^Rraim8t3isnatifTii8G8in!tinMmi: *-J
n
* .
J J u i
,
^
.<&
13 (Restitution) St3fi30ni3gS1fi (compensation)
x
n
y
c
t
^
i
1
vikovo Nagymaros Project 1 ICJ Report (1997) para, 141-74; Kal Raustiala and Anne-Marie Slaughter, \arional Law, International Relations and Compliance, in Handbook of International Relations (Walter lae eds (2002), 538-9; Colter Paulson, "Compliance with Final Judgment of the International Court of e~ 98 American Journal of International Law (July 2004), 436. : Charter of United Nations, reprinted in D.J Harris, Case and Materials on International Law, Sweet & «11 (5th ed. 1998), 1064.
•ratiji
iingh, The Role and record of the International Court of Justice, (1989), 41; M. Bulterman, M. Kuijer, termers, Compliance with Judgments of International Courts, (1996), 26-27. Trawford, The International Law Commission's Articles on State Responsibility: Introduction, Text and tentary (2002), 136. See generally M. Polti and G. Nesi (eds), The International Criminal Court and the of Aggression (2004). of Aggression (2004). 211; see also Enrico Milano, "Territorial Disputes, Unlawful Territorial Situations and State ibility," in The Law and Practice of International Courts and Tribunals (2004).
27
i (demarcation)*" i tnTOtrtgi|n!88|ttftnsn[uifistitnsttn§uttiifujti ttnrarcnstmjtinwfininsmjsfii =»
•a
LJ
«=»
fn
£c!
n
331 ct
of reference)900! ttuitisny|tjfin^ffnnt3
fnmann|n!i3a...inaarattiditTiii Utflltisg - IB|tlll3Btapl9MHtD, J. Trotter, "The Science of Frontier Delimitation", Royal Artillery Joun (1897), cited in D. Ruschworth, "Mapping in Support of Frontier Arbitration: Delimitation and Demarcation IBRU Boundary and Security Bulletin (1997), 61 97
"
James Nevin Hyde mtnliuifitntmtf rtjwmwnn fi.m.H. (wrnti) 3. bnlla "... Ruschworth •'
C3
98
Victor Prescott, Political Frontiers and Boundaries, London: Allen & Unwin (1987), 236; H.J. Collier, • Prescott, V. Prescott, Frontiers of Asia and Southeast Asia, Melbourne University press, (1977), 59 99 Khien Theeravit, "Thai-Kampuchean Relations: Problems and prospects", 22(6) Asian Survey, (1982) 567. 1 100
Michael Leifer, "pgWfimjIStifmewtjfiSIti'',
Pacific Affairs,
Vol. 34(4) (1961-1962) 365-36J
(S/4126);
(s/4i2i);i 101
, s. tMjftfrl fami>itfiijflngtffitiatififftfi, ranjtfliratnMamrangfa, tnarin. a^MummmrartnfJjtinHrntomiTOlljtJiwms gwsn 9dSo mci
U3EU fmSfulSSSauStfttrannaWHHfrnfimfmijm^
1 Michael
nflf»att|mWa8Beai*, Pacific Affairs, Vol 34(4) (1961-1962), 366.
28
en
talttiri idsn taooo HaMn«m:tafnntmflaiWfn i uaiuHmalniatMtsmtiaEminfiHiaiHHtJi v
i
<=t
1 O
usBtmfiiJ^
ta1tts9 96 ytisi toooo H3MmnmTfiJtflBts8tnmnjmrfnjTm9Hgiacij9
i
i
O
]
Liu
U
CN.
HBMIIHUI: i
K1S
ID. •3 •66;
ht.
totf .a. h atJHHUBraMtmlmfin Hiimsnfi
mnmtsAinm ti nntJi sdd^i , mcirn, nytji, rt atasi looooi tooooi
tlflJ
=t
per,
ri itisi Inooo wfl " ci
29
-o
n
i
O
MOJH"
tflCmSISttjtnsggfUffifimflj (Terms of References) ti3tUIHH1SfnJS9CU
( imnaqtiMHa®) tBRnfltfiHmifStttnnts-tHftJ i u
n es»
«t>
U
ss"yssgitffmtuguei5HS9ts1tTmyHswm[in: jsitoooo m
v
A
n&
U
i
O
<=t
90. ttfim?finjRn^
Htii atiTcnflBfitjatBistnBtitmg i traMtastglfi ratgwiti n u -* nj w u
ntitJiununwiiaiattJagStiafB i
106
HSftijimthmnfflmtimfslMififfwfijffisntfinjriGinfffftji 8timntiisimtist!tmn(96§tfmlBooo) 9. lo^
sw&ifiwcu[nsntfin/nG[mtf
37
Generally, McNeil, "Memorandum of Understanding 88 (1994) American Journal of International D.J. Harris, Case and Materials on International Law, (1998) 771; Year Book of International Lam Commission II (1966) 188; Jerry Z. Li, "The Legal Status of Three Sino-US Joint Communiques" 5 ChineM Journal of International Law (2006) 617. "RQfUthsmmfianytflsmij 1 tUTI tllflinti:
, mtMmfnswsfnci, to ym toood" i 108
s/2008/657. M3H3TO8 S/2008/653.
30
: : mnUisTfinraucmTriftiantttJi-tti, ntiJtJifitncuRHtJi om scin U
31
in
U
tl
ran
i
