Tonto National Forest

Wild and Scenic Rivers Frequently Asked Questions June 2016

There were many questions generated from the Wild & Scenic River Educational Forums. Those questions have been consolidated and categorized into this Frequently Asked Questions document. The meeting location is noted after the question: Payson, Globe, and Scottsdale.

Wild & Scenic Rivers Process Question: Who officially designates a river segment into the Wild and Scenic River System? (Scottsdale) Answer: Congress. The Tonto National Forest will make a recommendation for suitable river segments, but Congress makes the final decision to designate them. Question: When does Congress designate Wild and Scenic Rivers? (Payson) Answer: Congress can add a river segment to the WSR system at any time. They do not follow a specified timeline for making decisions after a segment has been suggested for designation. Question: When the Wild and Scenic Rivers Act was signed, only 7 rivers were designated as Wild and Scenic Rivers, and only 27 river segments congressionally authorized Study Rivers; how did we go from those original designations and study segments to having 122 segments designated as Wild and Scenic Rivers today? (Globe) Answer: The intent of the Wild and Scenic Rivers Act was not to designate a few select rivers and then be done; it was intended to encourage the continued study of additional river segments, so that the appropriate areas would eventually be designated as Wild, Scenic, or Recreational Rivers. Question: Did the original Wild and Scenic Rivers Act specify that rivers had to flow year-round? (Scottsdale) Answer: The original Act did not define rivers in as much detail as they are defined today. Since the Act was signed, Congress has established a process for defining rivers and carrying out the Wild & Scenic Rivers process. See FSH 1909.12 Chapter 80 for more information on Wild & Scenic Rivers. Question: Are river segments on the Tonto National Forest designated in the same way as they were after the 1993 Potential Wild and Scenic Recreational River Designation Report? (Scottsdale) Answer: Yes. The rivers have the same status now as they did in 1993, with the exception of rivers that have been designated since then. Fossil Creek and Verde River are the two designated Wild & Scenic Rivers on the Tonto National Forest. Question: Who officially recommends a river segment for designation into the Wild and Scenic River System? (Globe) Answer: The agency who manages the river segment makes the recommendation to Congress for designation. For river segments on the Tonto National Forest, the Forest Supervisor will make the recommendation.

Outstandingly Remarkable Values (ORVs) Question: What are the criteria for Outstandingly Remarkable Values? (Globe) Answer: To be identified as outstandingly remarkable, a river-related value must be a unique, rare, or exemplary feature that is significant when compared with similar values from other rivers at a regional or national scale. Unique, rare, or exemplary features are those that are conspicuous examples of these values, among the best representatives of these features, within a region or the nation. In addition, each ORV must be; 1) located on a river or its corridor, 2) contribute substantially to the functioning of the river ecosystem, or 3) be river dependent and owe their existence to the presence of the river. Question: How do you determine whether a river-related value is “regionally significant”? Answer: To determine whether the river-related value is “regionally significant,” the Tonto National Forest Interdisciplinary Team will: 1) identify the particular value; 2) select an appropriate region of comparison for that value or that river; and 3) compare the value in the river being evaluated to the other rivers in the region of comparison. If the river-related value in the river being evaluated is unique, rare, or exemplary when considered against the region of comparison, then the river is regionally significant for that value, and meets the definition of “Outstandingly Remarkable Value.” Question: Who determines the Outstandingly Remarkable Values? (Globe) Answer: The determination that a river area does or does not contain one or more ORVs is a professional judgement on the part of the Responsible Official as informed by the Interdisciplinary Team, best available scientific information, and public participation.

Definition of Rivers and their Corridors for Eligibility Question: What is a “river corridor” as defined by the Wild and Scenic Rivers Act? (Globe) Answer: Under FSH 1909.12 Chapter 80, the river corridor is the “geographic area generally encompassed within one-quarter mile on either side of a river studied for eligibility or suitability that contains the river and its outstandingly remarkable values”. Question: What is the definition of a river? If the Wild and Scenic Rivers Act does not require that a “river” flows all year round, how can we tell what a river is? (Globe) Answer: There are no specific requirements for minimum flows or for temporal or spatial continuity of flows for an eligible segment. Flows are considered sufficient for eligibility if they sustain or complement the outstandingly remarkable values for which the river would be designated. Under FSH 1909.12 Chapter 80, a river is “a flowing body of water or estuary, or a section, portion, or tributary thereof, including rivers, streams, creeks, runs, kills, rills, and small lakes”. Question: Does a river segment need to be on federal land in order to be considered eligible for a WSR designation? (Globe) Answer: In order for the Tonto National Forest to determine a river segment eligible, part of the segment must occur on TNF land. However, other agencies (such as the Bureau of Land Management or

the Arizona State Land Department) can also determine that river segments are eligible on lands they manage.

Designated River Segments Question: Does it make extra work for the Forest Service when a river segment is added to the WSR system? (Scottsdale) Answer: River segments added to the WSR system are managed to maintain their condition upon designation. Therefore, Forest Service staff usually do not have to change the management of the river segments following designation. Question: Does a WSR designation restrict human activities on the rivers? (Payson) Answer: There is a spectrum of activities and development allowed on designated river segments. Wild, Scenic, and Recreational designations each have their own requirements. Keep in mind that designations are made based on the current conditions of rivers; WSR designations are not intended to change the management of rivers, but to maintain their existing Outstandingly Remarkable Values. Depending on the activities that are already happening on the river, future activities may or may not become restricted following designation. Question: Some rivers may contain Outstandingly Remarkable Values, but they are not entirely freeflowing. Can stretches of a river be designated in the Wild and Scenic River System if there are existing impoundments on other parts of the river? (Globe) Answer: Yes. “Free flowing” means that the river exists or flows in a natural condition without impoundment, diversion, straightening, riprapping, or other modification of the waterway. 16 U.S.C. § 1286(b). The fact that a river may flow between large impoundments will not necessarily preclude its designation. There are no specific requirements for minimum flows or temporal or spatial continuity of flows for a segment. Flows are considered sufficient for eligibility if they sustain or complement the outstandingly remarkable values for which the river would be designated.

Making Comments on Outstandingly Remarkable Values (ORVs) Question: What is the role of the public in contributing to the Tonto National Forest effort to determine eligibility for Wild and Scenic Rivers (WSRs)? (Scottsdale) Answer: The Tonto National Forest is looking for public information and perspectives on which river segments on the Forest may have Outstandingly Remarkable Values (ORVs). This information will be used in addition to the USFS information as the TNF studies whether river segments are eligible for WSR designation. The more information that can be contributed to the study process, the better. Question: How much time do we have to comment on ORVs? (Payson) Answer: Comments on ORVs are welcome at any time, since there is no official “public comment period” for the WSR evaluation. However, the Tonto National Forest hopes to begin its internal study of river segments on August 1st, 2016. Comments on ORVs will be most constructive if they are submitted prior to August 1st.

Question: Can you make a comment on areas that you do not feel contain ORVS? (Globe) Answer: Yes. Comments about the lack of ORVs will not guarantee that a segment will not be determined eligible. Regardless of the comments made, the TNF will study the segment to determine whether it is eligible. Question: When making comments about wildlife or fish, do we have to know whether the species is native or non-native before suggesting that a segment has possible ORVs? (Scottsdale) Answer: No, there is no need to identify species in detail when commenting on potential ORVs. The TNF staff will determine whether species are native or non-native during the ORV review process for eligibility. What is important for commenting is connecting the ORV to the river or river corridor and making the case for outstandingly remarkable.

WSR FAQs June 2016.pdf

addition, each ORV must be; 1) located on a river or its corridor, 2) contribute substantially to the. functioning of the river ecosystem, or 3) be river dependent and ...

122KB Sizes 0 Downloads 354 Views

Recommend Documents

WSR Attendees List.pdf
Michael Pastor Gila County Supervisor. John Fowler Permittee. Frank Dalmonin Permittee. David Cook Rancher. Tom Hale Rancher. Jennifer Martin Sierra Club.

FAQs - CMS.gov
Q: What are the requirements for Ambulatory Surgical Centers (ASCs) regarding the participation in a community full- scale exercise? A: Per 416.54(d)(2)(i) of the final rule an ASC is required to participate in a full-scale exercise that is community

WSR Attendees List.pdf
Scott Wood Friends of the Tonto. Elizabeth Butler Friends of the Tonto. John Jordan Land Owner. Stephen Flora Salt River Project. Rose Leather Sierra Club.

WSR SAR GAME 3 INFO.pdf
Page 1 of 56. Memorial Cup. (CHL Championship). J Ross Robertson Cup. (OHL Championship). Wayne Gretzky Trophy. (Western Conference Champions) Hamilton Spectator Trophy Emms Trophy. Champions Finalist Champions Finalist Champions Finalist (OHL Best R

FAQs -
Can I apply for hardware that isn't yet available to the public for purchase (e.g. Google Glass)?. ○. We evaluate proposals based on whether the work can be done at the time of funding. Google will not assist for purchase of any hardware or softwar

faqs-ffm.pdf
MBA- IInd Sem. Prepared By: Garima Shrivastava, Asst. Prof. MBA, and VIT Indore. Unit No- I st Introduction. 1. What is Financial Management? Meaning of ...

CMALT Portfolio Review: FAQs
sign in to your account using your e-mail address. If you have forgotten ... Once you have renewed your membership online once, a "renew" button will appear ...

CMALT Portfolio Review: FAQs
You will have received an e-mail with your account details previously from ... Once you have renewed your membership online once, a "renew" button will ...

FAQs - Texting - Parents.pdf
What if I have children in more than one school? How will I know where the message is from? The. school will identify their message. A sample message might be: TCHS report cards out today where TCHS. stands for Timber Creek High School. Each principa

Google Patent Starter Program FAQs
Answer: We are big fans of the ​LOT Network​ program, which we think of as a great longterm ... Question: How do you define startups or developers? What if ...

FAQs - DOR approved.pdf
CAN THE TAX CREDIT CREATE A COLORADO INCOME TAX REFUND? No, the Colorado income tax credit may not exceed the tax liability for the year.

FAQs - HealthOP action.pdf
You will also need to select coverage from. another carrier to be effective January 1, 2016 to avoid a gap in your employees' coverage. What happens to my ...

GTL FAQs Final.pdf
Loading… Whoops! There was a problem loading more pages. Whoops! There was a problem previewing this document. Retrying... Download. Connect more apps... Try one of the apps below to open or edit this item. GTL FAQs Final.pdf. GTL FAQs Final.pdf. O

DEFINE FAQS copy.pdf
curriculum for the meaningful and intentional teaching of emotional intelligence. Yet. Harvard ... o Multiple activities under one roof ... DEFINE FAQS copy.pdf.

FAQs for WEBSITE.pdf
if one of those limited special ducks win the race. Additional al significant prizes may be. awarded to the people who sponsor top-finishing ducks. Page 1 of 3 ...

2016 FAQs InHouse.pdf
Page 1 of 2. Mercer Area Youth Soccer Association. FALL IN-HOUSE. RECREATIONAL SOCCER. Register Online Today at. www.MercerSoccer.org.

CNPS – FAQs
Many Phytophthora species can attack a wide range of hosts, although some are more. “host specific”. Some of the species that are now being recognized as inhabiting native plant nurseries are many of the same species commonly found throughout. Ca

FAQs - Potential Donors.pdf
provider, you get an income tax credit for 50% of your contribution, plus the possibility of additional standard state and. federal deductions. You'll want to talk to ...

Google Patent Starter Program FAQs
originated with operating companies. ... Agreement, every company that participates grants a license to the other participants ... No other penalties would apply.

DEFINE FAQS copy.pdf
There was a problem previewing this document. Retrying... Download. Connect more apps... Try one of the apps below to open or edit this item. DEFINE FAQS ...

Allen Transition FAQs 082516.pdf
Center is located at 2775 Boardwalk. Bus transportation from the Allen. area to the Westerman Center will be provided each day if families have. need of this ...

FAQs about the DP.pdf
Page 2 of 2. FAQs about the DP.pdf. FAQs about the DP.pdf. Open. Extract. Open with. Sign In. Main menu. Displaying FAQs about the DP.pdf.

Allen Transition FAQs 082516.pdf
There was a problem loading this page. Whoops! There was a problem loading this page. Allen Transition FAQs 082516.pdf. Allen Transition FAQs 082516.pdf.

FAQs on NICR Programme -
At least 15 hours of e-learning by logging on to the Learning Management System. • At least 30 hours of self-study using the study manuals. • It is estimated that a typical learner will be able to cover the entire course and go for the certificat