A Corpus-‐based Approach to the English Middle Construc7on Fuminori NAKAMURA (Keio University) fumi3648[at]gmail.com
Introduc7on and Aims
1. To introduce new kinds of middle sentences 2. To consider the mechanism of linguis7c change 3. To explain future survey
The middle construc7on
Note: • This is for a full descrip7on of the middle construc7on by using linguis7c theory. • Thus, it does not mainly aim to explore some linguis7c ability by examining the construc7on.
Seman7c frames: NP V (Adv). Seman7cs: An en7ty (NP) has a certain property (Adv) concerning an ac7on (V). a. The book sells well. b. The car drives easily. c. This water drinks like water. d. The knife cuts easily (pseudo-‐middle)
Backgrounds: language change and acceptability
• The seman7cs and acceptability of the middle construc7on may change li`le by li`le. • Thus, analyses should be updated with newly collected data. • Originally acceptability of middle instances varies among speakers. (from Honda 2005)a. This movie watches easily (Goldberg 1995: 187) b. *That film watches well. (Dixon 1991: 330)
previous studies
• The contemporary linguis7cs have made a`empt to explain the phenomenon mainly in terms of (i) affectedness or (ii) ac7vity. • (i) implies that effec7ve nouns cannot be the subject of the construc7on (verbs of crea7on). (ii) implies that non-‐ac7ve verbs cannot appear in the middle construc7on. From <>
Collected examples
• Though the number is quite small, the middle construc7on with verbs of crea7on can be found.
A. A dense-‐crumb carrot cake bakes easily in a springform pan. B. Odes to herself write easily when she's narcissis7c mood. (Rosta 1995: 127)
• Not ac7vity verbs also appears in some instances as well.
• This approach is not a different approach from previous ones, rather a synthe7c approaches in that hypotheses such as ac7vity and affectedness are factors in this approach. The network itself form the middle construc7on Most abstract framework Tag/Regular Expression
different from other intransi7ve construc7on (similar to entrenchment, Seman7c path, inheritance)
____ ____easily
[NP V (Adv)] Corpus research Adv High coverage Ddv Low Precision
____ reads ____
The book ____ ____ n n n
Most instan7ated cases Instances
Two aspects of this approach. 1. Rela7on between words (for Acceptability) •
_____ reads easily
The book ____ easily
The book reads easily
• The book reads ____
Able to search each block independently. Unable to search this network at once Each Block does not characterize the middle construc7on
Corpus research Adv High Precision Ddv Low coverage
Example • “The cake bakes easily with the pan” case According to 1, the rela7onship between “cake” and “bake” is a key factor to determine its acceptability.
•
When schema7za7on (increasing slots) in general, colloca7onal informa7on between nouns and verbs, verbs and adverbials, and nouns and adverbials in this case accumulate. This is a linguis7c representa7on of affordances to a large extent. (the rela7onship between “book” and “read”). This is used for the acceptability judgment.
2. Rela7on between slots and words. (for crea7vity) • • •
The middle construc7on forms a network. When a new instances appears, exis7ng acceptable instances will be accessed to judge accessibility. The slot in [ ] reads easily chooses nouns similar to book ontologically. The slot in the book [ ] reads easily chooses verbs similar to read. The slot in the the book reads [ ] adverbials similar to easily.
• • •
119
8.35
9 10
scone
4
7.71
gratin
2
7.55
loaf
7
7.47
cookie
2
6.93
pastry
4
6.78
snap
2
6.59
batch
5
6.48
bun
3
6.44
17
6.39
tart
2
6.18
chart
5
5.09
tin (4)
7
4.96
tray
3
4.88
clay
2
4.52
shore
2
4.31
brick
2
3.91
earth
2
2.61
potato (10) bean 7
11 12 13
dish 3 14 15 16 17 18
The object list of verb bake, adapted from Word Sketch
Selected References
Goldberg, Adele. 1995. Construc6ons: a construc6onal • grammar approach to argument structure. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. • Honda, Akira. 2005. Afodansu-‐no ninchi-‐imiron [An affordance-‐theore6c approach to Cogni6ve seman6cs]. Tokyo: University of Tokyo Press. Rosta, Andrew. 1995. ‘How does this sentence The English middle construc7on has been changing li`le by li`le and they have marginal members of interpret?’ The seman7cs of English mediopassives. In Aarts, Bas and Charles F. Meyer the category that show different acceptability among speakers. (eds.), T he v erb i n c ontemporary E nglish: t heory To explain mul7-‐factor framework is necessary to capture subtle differences. and descrip6on. Cambridge: Cambridge The future research aims to a par7ally-‐ordered set (list) from most prototypical verbal clusters to University Press. 123-‐144. most unlikely clusters like below, according to acceptability. One goal of this research as a linguis7c enterprise is to
Summary •
cake (62)
LogDICE (Relevance)
biscuit 2 bread 49 pie 6 2
A. French acquires more rapidly than Esperanto when children are under six. (Rosta 1995: 127) B. Tomorrow never knows. (such as in Beatles 1966)
Raw. Freq.
explore the rela7onship between individual acceptability and changes of a language.
A Corpus-âbased Approach to the English Middle ...
movie watches easily (Goldberg 1995: 187) b. *That film ... The network itself form the middle construcUon different from ... Unable to search this network at once.
The network itself form the middle construcUon different from ... Unable to search this network at once. â« Each Block ... In Aarts, Bas and Charles F. Meyer. (eds.) ...
Blessed bay the teem that apple takuh was. Therefore way moon singen Deo Gratias. Page 4 of 15. Ceremony of Carols Middle English pronunciation glosses.
Page 1 of 5. VELLAMA THE MIDDLE OF ENGLISH. JOURNY. File name : vellama the middle of english journy.pdf. Click button below to free register and download PDF Ebook : VELLAMA THE MIDDLE OF ENGLISH JOURNY PDF. Page 1 of 5 ...
of saddle type. In the last section another approach to the problem, which relies on degree-theoretical arguments, will be discussed and compared to ours. We want to describe here a ... vortex points, namely zeroes of the Higgs field with vanishing o
paying for them to access your content. Publisher choice and control. As a publisher, you control when and where survey prompts appear on your site and set any frequency capping. Visitors always have a choice between answering the research question o
the real time r which the job has spent in the computer system, its processing requirement t, an externally as- signed importance factor i, some measure of its ...
There was a problem loading more pages. Whoops! There was a problem previewing this document. Retrying... Download. Connect more apps... Try one of the apps below to open or edit this item. Natural-Fingering-A-Topographical-Approach-To-Pianism.pdf. N