1
EjJ]gR[g4 S[ ` Ri EQR]i C\g]o S8?
8.c. x૮~y
Cg_r Oj4 E] EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4 7`o^r Io?
C I
]Q! "qXi CrVg Vg[ cgSo c4C_g\o^ Io?
&[ ]Q!Rchd4 !
Ur_iU& Y4U C8 VTi W] 7`o^r Io?
ZrEg`r
h`. hcૐ `^Zi h`૩gWiNVi SgWVg C\g `4a T]3\gV S8 dRi?
[p5C `4a
cr[VgSVr hJQr6ૐg] C\g Cg_ T]h[\gV S\r dRr?
cr^4CiCg_
Tg:Ti `r]gAVj4 :ૈ] EjJ]gR[g4 7`o^j4 RiS6 S_ C Io?
To^[g^
7Hg\6 7V4Ta4C] ;j`Vr J<[ C\g4 S\r dRr?
6[Tg`gT
‘J[r Sg_ !`V &:4 `g]i...’ Zg``gdi ]HVg CrQo C]i Io?
Zk[gV4T `g[i
EjJ]gR[g4 Jr`g [_Rg C\g Cg]Vg [lEVj4 YiJj 4 Vg[ Cl@Q [lE Io?
Cg_i\g]
`]gJVi ^OR [gMo ]h`a4C] [dg]gB C\j Wj RC F]o F]o
hd4 T `]gJ
Wdr4HRj4 C\j46 dRj4? ભgVi Ch` 6DgVj4 J<[ S_ C\j4 Io?
BR^Wj]
>C [g<\Rg [gQo gHiV c[\[g4 EjJ]gRVi C8 VTiVj4 Vg[ RoVi
cgY][Ri
7cWgc [jCRWQo h`H]Rg cgY] Co cg4Z]Vg Vg[ W]Si WG\j4 dr`gVj4 [Vg\ Io? ahCR :WgcVgVg E]YgVg ]Hh\Rg CrQ Io?
Zુ `I^Z [o`gOg
‘Ta6C’Vi C8 [dgV o[CSg W]Si EjJ]gRi hXI[ YVi Io?
Ko] Rr WiUg4 Io &Qi &Qi
EjJ]gR ` RiVi Tlh@M> Zg]R[g4 C\g K[o 7`o Io?
Tc
`R45 EjJ]gRVi ]HVg [gMo C\j4 74Tr^V S\j4 dRj4?
[dgEjJ]gR 74Tr^V
EjJ]gRVi [jL\ VTiA JQg`r?
"[di [di, [di V[6Tg 6Vo RgWi ઇ
EjJ]gRVg Cg\[i hV`gci >`g cર]Dr]g WબiA >C coC
x~|Si x~|Si yww `DR
CoM^i `g] Wg4Dr XXOg`i aCo Io? Zg]RVg S[ Vg\Y `Og UgV CrQ dRg?
c]Tg] `I^ZZg8 WMo ^
Ch` V[6TVo ‘7!`V \rૐr’ Cdo Vg] CrQ Io?
h`.VgS Zુ
EjJ]gRVj4 csSi [rMj4 Y4T] C\j4 Io?
C4 O^g
&QiRg VgS\Cg] J\a4C] cj4T]iVj4 [k_ Vg[ JQg`r?
J\a4C] ZrJC
o[gV4TVi C9 ClhR T] ahV`g]o E`gRi dRi?
cjTg[gHh]5
C Ii ^rCC_gVo cgH`Rj4 3\jhK\[ C\g4 7`o^4j Io?
64&]
Ch` T\g]g[Vg J<[ S_ Hg4QrTVj4 [k_Vg[ aj4 dRj?4
H4OiWj]
[]Ci Vg ]rEVi T`g arUVg] D] ]cg\Qag 5i CrQ dRg?
h5Zr`VTgc EJJ]ઍ EJJ]ઍcj]R
C\r Zk R]i\ c[\ 7hC6 \V \jEVr >C ZgE Io ?
Ug]`gO
‘V4TY5ici’ 6Vo ‘hc4dgcV Y5ici’ W૩`gRg6A CrQo ^Di Io?
Ch` ag[_
CgCgcgdo Y Cg^o^C]o ^Do^ ‘!`VVr 7V4T’ 6Vo ‘]DO`gVr
^h^R hVY4U
7V4T’ V4SVr cghdW\ Cg] JQg`r? EjJ]gR[g4 Jr`g [_Rg C\g WબiVi haCg]Vo Cg4Mg[g4 Z]g`i
TkhU\r ^Mr]r
]gD`gVi 7TRVo Cg]Qo Ccg8 WબiVj4 :WVg[ [X\j4 Io? ‘CEPT’Vj4 7Dj4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
co<`g\6[o
c]Tg] c]r`] \rJVg WkQ6 SRg CoM^g [oEg`rM h`૩jR ;WW૮
x{|w [oEg`rM
S`gVi c4Zg`Vg Io? ]\g`cgh\C Ur]Qo [rRiVj4 :WWgTV C]`g [gMo C\g S_o IiW ;Io]
hcરg
Co <^ Cg\6]R Io? W]4W]gER ]iRo EjJ]gR[g4 V`g `b6Vr g]4Z C\g]Si Sg\ Io?
CgR]C cjT >C[
Ch` 6Vo c4EiRCg] >[ Y4Vo બo5o 6ZkRWk`6 hchૐ [o_`Vg]
6h`Vga ]\gc
C^gCg]Vj4 Vg[ JQg`r? EjJ]gRVr ]o^[gE6 Zg]Ri\ ]o^`oVg C\g KrV[g4 EQg\ Io?
Wh`[
cd&V4T `g[iVj4 [k_ Vg[ aj4 dRj4?
FVa\g[
2
‘EjJ]gRVr RW `i’ Cg]\ CrQo ^L\j4 Io?
Ch`
Zg]RVi csSi [rMi crXM`o] C4WVi h` rVg Ho][oV C\g EjJ]gRi
6Ki[ o[!
Io? EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vj4 c`r6 H Wgh]RrhbC ‘]QhJR]g[ cj`Q6H4^C’
dh]`I^Z HjVi^g^ Zg\gQi
gYR C]Vg] S[ cghdW\Cg] CrQ dRg? cd&V4T `g[i C\g4Vg `RVi dRg?
IWp\g \g
8.c. x૯x૯[g4 C\g >CM h`]j ૐ EjJ]gR[g4 dORg_ WOi?
]r^oM >CM
Cl@Qh[5 cjTg[gVj4 >C[g5 [4hT] C\g4 7`o^4j Io?
Wr]Y4T]
Zg]R[g4 csSi `Uj [iNj4 :WWgTV C]Rj4 ]gJ\ C\j4?
EjJ]gR
ZcHVi Wg]4Wgh]C d RC_gVj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
cjJVi
‘J\ J\ E]`i EjJ]gR’ Cg]\ ]HVg CrVi Io?
Ch` V[6T
EjJ]gR[g4 C\r Toa ^i^i VgFo] Vg[o &QiRr Io?
Hr]`gOઍ Hr]`gOઍ`o]g`_
WgajWR U[6Vg SgWC Vg[ JQg`r?
^Cj^oa!
cg[g<\ 6YgYi^ EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4Si ha\g_r Eg_`g 7`o Io?
\j]rW 6Vo :ૈ] >ha\gSi
hYh^\O6c[g4 74R]]g@"i\ L\ghR gYR EjJ]gRi \j`g Do^gOi CrQ
W4CJ 6O`gQi
Io? 8<^rOg WgC6 ં gQi c4Vdg^\ઉ C\g4 7`o^4j Io?
Eg4UiVE]
EjJ]gRVi C9 Oo]iVi WoTga 74R]]g@"i\ R]o `DQg\ Io?
6[k^
C8 \rJVg f`g]g EjJ]gR[g4 [dૈ[ Vg[h`Cgc S\r Io?
ErCj^Vg[ \rJVg
C]cVTgc [k_!Vg `gc `Q6Vr C\g Wj RC[g4 c4VhdR Io?
84g^o
`OrT]g ado ][g4Si C8 VTi `do Io?
h`.gh[5i
EjJ]gR[g4 csSi AIr `]cgT C\g hJI^g[g4 WOo Io?
C I
EjJ]gRVg C\g hJI^g[g4 RgWi VTi D4ZgRVg 6DgRVo [_o Io?
cj]R
7J`g Oo[ CrQo Vg]\r dRr?
[dg]g& c\g!]g` Eg\C`gO
do [H4^gHg\o6 SgWo^j4 ભgV[4hT] EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4 7`o^j4 Io?
WgMQ
6hM]gVj4 7Dj4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
6[Tg`gT Mo CcMg8^ 9crhc>aV
EjJ]gRVg S[ [hd^g [45i CrQ dRg?
8
64Yg!Vi V!C[g4 7`o^4j C\j4 S_ RoVi 7]c W]Vi 6TZkR
Cj4Zgh]\gVg4 To]g
CrR]Qi [gMo &QiRj4 Io? Zg]R[g4 csSi `Uj [EX_i :WWgTV C]Rr hJI^r C\r Io?
JkVgEP
EjJ]gRVj4 cs S[ h`J_iSi Hg^Rj4 [agV C\g ado ][g4 SWg\j4
&[VE]
dRj4? ‘Rg]i 74DVr 6XiQi...’ EiRVg ]Hh\Rg CrQ Io?
`oQiZg8 Wj]rhdR
EjJ]gRVr >C[g5 Th]\ghCVg]r B HkVgVi Mo C]iASi Fo]g\o^r Io
ErWVgS
RoV4j Vg[ aj4?
`R45 Zg]RVg S[ ^aC]i `Og C\g EjJ]gRi dRg?
JV]^ ]gB<^hc4d!
" a4cVi\ Cg[Ei]i C]Vg] c]W4H, R^gMi, Rg^jCg h`Cgc
EjJ]gR Vg[rWSgV >`rO6
6hUCg]i, Rg^jCgઍhJI^g [jD `Eo]oVo C\r >`qO6Vj4 6Wg\ Ioઇ? B]4EKoYVr J<[ EjJ]gR[g4 C\g S_o S\r dRr?
TgdrT
C IVr C\r Toa dh]\g_g Toa R]iCo &QiRr Io?
[j4^g
"‘SrOg 74c,j SrOg X^ k ’ Vg[o 7W[CSg CrQo ^Di Ioઇ?
J\a4C] cj4T]i
JkVgEP[g4 7`o^4j C\j4 S_ gHiV Ysૐ EjXgA [gMo hcૐ Io?
:W]CrM
‘c4Z`gh[ \jEo \jEo’Vg ^oDC CrQ Io?
d]i<^ T`o
"a4C]gHg\o6 SgWo^g Hg] [Nr WpCiVr >C EjJ]gR[g4 Io, Ro C\g4
f`g]Cg
7`o^r Ioઇ? EjJ]gR[g4 Dg]i J[iV[g4 DoRiVg h`CgcVi J`gYTg]i CrVg d RC
EjJ]gR ]gJ\ Dg] J[iV h`Cgc [4O_
Io?
3
`gR4WÁ\ H_`_Vj4 hHk ‘HK’ ]gD`gVj4 Eg4Ui!Vo CrQo ckH]\j4 dRj4?
E4EgYoV [J[jTg]
J\rRi<^ T`oVo {w [o `bo6 C\r H4^C 6Wg\r dRr?
]Q!R]g[ cj`Q6H4^C
EjJ]gR[g4 gHiV c[\[g4 C\j4 Y4T] `oWg]i `lhૈSi UiCRj4 dRj4?
ZlEjC I
C8 cg^[g4 64VoJr f`g]g EjJ]gR[g4 cs S[ xw EjJ]gRi
8.c. x૮y}
ag_gA SgW`g[g4 7`i? x૯}wVi zw >h ^ cjUi EjJ]gR C\g ]gJ\Vr ZgE dRj4?
YldTt [j4Y8 ]gJ\Vr
Moh^h`KVVr EjJ]gR[g4 g]4Z C\g]o S\r?
"x| x| @nE@M, @M x૯~| ઇ
‘EjQ`4Ri EjJ]gR’ 6Vo ‘Zg]RZkh[Vj4 J\EgV’ Toa o[Vg4 Cg]\r CrQo
6]Toa] DY]Tg]
^L\g4 Io? ‘ciRgd]Q’ ClhRVg ]Hh\Rg CrQ Io?
C[6Q [45i
EjJ]gRVi S[ B૩rhEC `cgdR C\g4 SWg9 dRi?
]gJCrM
8]gVSi 7`iVo Wg]ciA> EjJ]gRVg C\g ado ][g4 `c`gM C\r6?
`^cgO
Zg`VE] WgcoVg C\g S_o gHiV c[\[g4 h`૩gWiN dRi?
`^ZiWj]
EjJ]gR Mjh]K[ hOWgM6[o
cgWjRg]g
EjJ]gRVr csSi [rMr [do ^ C\r Io?
^q[ih`^gc Wo^ocઍ`OrT]g
‘J[r Sg_ !`V &:4 `g]i...’ Zg``gdi ]HVg CrQo C]i Io?
Zk[gV4T `g[i
Ch` Zg^Qo BVr EjJ]gRi[g4 cg]gVj`gT C\r6 Io Ro ‘CgT4Y]i’Vg
YgQZુ
]Hh\Rg CrQ dRg? OZr8Vr hCI^r Co M^r ^g4Yr 6Vo Co M^r Wdr_r Io?
>C d&] `g] ^g4Yr 6Vo 7Ncr `g] Wdr_r
hd[g^\Vi W`6R[g_g[g4 7`o^g V4TgTo`i haD]Vo cs S[ `DR
V4T^g^ Wj]rhdR
c] C]Vg] EjJ]gRi CrQ Io? WkJ\ ri [rMgVj4 [k_ Vg[ aj4 dRj4?
HjVi^g^ 7ag]g[ Zg`cg]
cgWjRg]g C8 W`6R[g_g[g4 7`o^4j Io?
csgh^
C\g [gEo6 SRr `oWg] EjJ]gRVg 6S6R45[g4 csSi [dWW`Vi Zkh[Cg
Th]\g8 [gE6
6Tg C]o Io? [di VTiVj4 YiJj 4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
[dicgE]
EjJ]gR[g4 7`o^j4 C\j4 t\rhR6h^4E Yg]o\ t\rhR6h^4Er[g4 csSi [rMj4
cr[VgS
ha`h^4E U]g`o Io? ‘Z^4Z^’ V`^CSgVg [jL\ Wg5Vj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
Z^4Z^
HocVi ][R[g4 hXOo]ohM4E [o_`Vg] h`.Vr csSi VgVi `\Vr
RiC Wg]oD
EjJ]gRVr Do^gOi CrQ dRr? hXI[ 6hZV\ બo5o J4W^g`Vg] [ EjJ]gRi 6hZVo5i CrQ dRg4?
^i^g Tocg9
6[Tg`gT Co <^Si h`h`UZg]RiVr g]4Z C\g]o S\r?
8.c. x૯}|
EjJ]gRi Zgbg^oDV 6Vo EjJ]gRi cW]HVg C\g aRg\j
Co a`]g[ Cgai]g[ ag 5i ંCo . Cg. Cg. ag 5iઉ ag 5iઉ
cghdW\Cg]Vr Ydj [kI\ Xg_r Io? EjJ]gRVr Do^gOi ]g@"i\બo5o hchૐ gYR C]o W\g]o RoVo C\r >`rO6 7W`g[g4 7`o Io ? hd4 Er_EP ClhR haબQ 6Z\g]u\ C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^4j Io?
]gJCrM
Eg4Ui!> Zg`VE]Vi C8 Cr^oJ[g4 6v\gc C\r6 dRr?
ag[_Tgc Cr^oJ
EjJ]gR[g4 []gNgAVi Cg\[i cૈg C\g ado ][g4 ]di dRi?
`OrT]g
c Rj4 cghdW\Vg SgWC CrQ dRg?
hZબj 6D4OgV4T
`b6 yww| [gMo EjJ]gRVg C\g Do^gOiVo ‘]g!` Eg4Ui Do^]WV
W4CJ 6O`gQi
>`rO6 ’ >Vg\R S\r dRr? "‘KYkC `iJ_i KYkC’ Yg_Cg]\c4Vd 6Vo ‘Yo Zg8’, ‘Rg9Cr’
[C]4T T`o
Yg_VghMCg CrQo ^L\g4 Ioઇ? EjJ]gR[g4 hXI[ hV[g6Q [gMoVr cs S[ MjhO\r C\g4 Y4Ug\r dRr?
dg^r^
[w\Cg^iV Ch` VgC] C\g4Vr `RVi dRr?
`OrT]g
4
]Q[I^ I4T[g4 C\g ]cVj4 7^oDV S\j4 Io?
`i] ]c
[dgW[g Eg4Ui!Vo 64Jh^ 7WRj4 ‘dh]Vr d4 c^r’ Cg]\Vg4 cxCVj4
Yg^[jCTj4 T`o
Vg[ 7Wr? EjJ]gRi Ch` YgWjcgdo Y Eg\C`gO [k_ C\g4Vg4 `RVi dRg?
`OrT]g
"Tj^6Z hcરgA, XrMryo3c, dhS\g]r, CghN\g`gOi dgS YVg`MVi
Zg`VE]
HiJr, Wj]gRWW`i\ 6Vo Zk R]i\ arUrVg V[kVgA B`i HiJrVr c4Vd U]g`Rj4 Yo]MrV 3\jhK\[ C\g4 7`o^4j Ioઇ? Co <^i\ Ug]gcZgVg4 S[ Zg]Ri\ 6w\બ S[ EjJ]gRi CrQ
h`ૃ^Zg8 WMo^
dRg?
5iWg5rVi Zkh[CgVo ]4EZkh[ W] !`4R C]Vg] VM CrQ dRg?
J\a4C] cj4T]i
EjJ]gRi Ch`Rg[g4 D4OCg]\rVr g]4Z CrQo C\r6?
Ch` Cg
h`. hcૐ `^Zi h`૩gWiNVi SgWVg C\g `4a T]3\gV S8 dRi?
[p5C `4a
V[6TVi Ch`RgVr >C h`ha@M h`b\ C\r dRr?
`RV o[
EjJ]gRVi Clhb \jhV`hc6MiAVj4 `Oj4 [SC C\j4 Io?
Tg4Ri`gOg
‘c[iDgV’Vr hDRgY EjJ]gR[g4 CrVo 7W`g[g4 7`o^r Io ?
6[i] [j RjXg
‘hc4dgcV Y5ici’ CrVi ClhR Io?
][Q^g^ crVi
[w\Cg^iV \jE[g4 ag[_Vj4 `RV `o4EQ] dg^[g4 6[Tg`gTVr C\r
Er[RiWj]
h` Rg] Io? [j4Y8Vi 7].B.B. Cj^ AX 7M6 Vi hOY^r[gVi W]iબg[g4 ro@N
]h`a4C] ]g`_
h`૩gSi6 R]iCo Vr ‘[o\r’ H4^C CrQo [o_]\r dRr? hc4d [rMgZgEo C\g c[\o ExVg C]Rg dr\ Io?
ck\g6 R WIiVg >C C^gC[g4
`b6 ywww[g4 SWg\o^i ‘CQg6`Ri 6RiRVi Kg4Di’ C\g4 7`o^i Io?
c4 Cg] Co <^ઍ ^ઍ6[Tg`gT
EjJ]gR[g4 W`V :&6Si Hg^Rg h`૩jR[SCr C\g4 7`o^g Io?
"ADg ADg, ADg [g4O`i, `i ^g4Yg ઇ
`g[iVg]g\Q c4 Tg\Vg ZCRrVg {T\[g4 Cg\[i SgV Wg[o^i
cd&V4T `g[i
‘haબgW5iVi’ ]HVg CrQo C]i dRi? EjJ]gR CoM^r ^g4Yr Th]\ghCVg]r U]g`o Io?
x}}w hC[i
`R45 Zg]RVi S[ Wg^g6[o
EQoa `gcjTo` [g`_4C]
T\g]g[ Cg]\Vg C\g Cg] [gMo &QiRg Io?
E]Yi
Zg]Ri\ `g[VCg\ IIk 4T] EjJ]gRVg C\g h` Rg][g4 `co Io?
C IVr ]Q h` Rg]
C<\gCo _`QiVo rWcgdV 7W`g [gMo EjJ]gR[g4 C8 \rJVg Cg\6]R
h`૩g^q[i Yr
Io? cs]g@"Vi VTiA C\g Cg]Vi J_ Qg^i ]Ho Io?
h5J\gCg]
EjJ]gRVg C\g Jr`g^g\C Y4T]Vr Xi "oO KrV R]iCo h`Cgc S\r
C4 O^g
Io?
hcૐ cghdW\Cg] [hQ^g^ VZjZg9 hf``oTiVr J<[ C\g4 S\r dRr?
VhO\gT
Ch` V[6TVg [V[r! `Zg`Vo Cg]Qo Ro[Vo h[5r C\g Vg[o
^g^g!
Yr^g`Rg4? EjJ]gR[g4 :Io]`g[g4 7`Ri &R`gV &X]gYgTi &R C\g WajVi
Zo4c
Io? XCR WrRo YVg`o^g [g_gA[g4 J 7]g[ X][g`i aCRj4 Wબi C\j4
CgVChO\g
Io? C\j4 Wબi EjJ]gR[g4 ‘]q\^ YO6 ’ R]iCo WQ A_Dg\ Io?
X^oh[4Er
7hT`gciAVr h5Vo5o.] [o_r agVg [gMo L\gR Io?
`\4`]
EjJ]gR[g4 csSi `Uj `]cgT C\g4 WOo Io?
Og4E
&[VE] Wgco C\g MgWjVr c[kd Io?
hW]rMV
x૯w~[g4 Y4Ug\o^g `g4CgVo]Vg cj hcૐ [do ^Vj4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
]QhJR h`^gc Wo^oc
‘NrN hVagh_\r’ CrVj4 :WVg[ Io?
YCj^ h5WgNi
5
EjJ]gR[g4 Zkh[J_ c4arUV Cg\6 c`6 S[ C\g hJI^g[g4 ac
[do cgQg
C]`g[g4 7]\j4 dRj4? EjJ]gRVj4 csSi [rMj4 DViJ બo5 C\g4 7`o^4j Io?
64C^o.]
c]Tg] WMo ^ Clhb \jhV`hc6Mi C\g4 7`o^i Io?
YVgcCg4Ng
"‘Cg]\ `gHVVr h`b\ VSi, r`QVr Io’ - 7 h`UgV CrQo C\j46 Ioઇ?
]g[Vg]g\Q WgNC
C\g cW\gVdSi `I^ZZg8 WMo ^ Eg4Ui! cgSo JrOg\g?
DoOg cW\gVd
ToaZ][g4 7hC6MoCMVg 6v\gc [gMo &QiRi ‘CEPT’ Vi SgWVg
6[Tg`gT 8. 8.c.x૯}z
C\g4 6Vo C\g]o S8? c\g!]g` Eg\C`gOo cs S[ C\g S_o [XR 6Vo X]!\gR
6[]o^i
haબQVr \rE C\r6 dRr? Vg]g\Q Tocg8 h^hDR Eg4Ui!Vg YldTt !`VHh]5Vj4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
[g]j 4 !`V > J [g]i `gQi
haબQ બo5o EjJ]gR c]Cg] R]XSi C\r [dW`WkQ6 Wj] Cg]
ri [EVZg8 Tocg8 Wj] Cg]
7W`g[g4 7`o Io? V[6TVg C\g Cg]\[g4 >Vj4 7W[Hh]5 hVcWgRj4 Jr`g [_o Io?
`i]hc4d
Wg]ciAVg 64hR[c4 Cg] S_Vo aj4 Cdo `g\ Io?
TD[j4
EjJ]gRVg4 C\g h` Rg][g4 ^EjVVi ]HVg S8 Io?
C IVg Th]\ghCVg]o
Tg4Rg 6Vo Wg^VWj] ` Ho C9 Mo C]iA 7`o^i Io?
Bcr]
JkVgEP[g4 :W]CrM[g4 C8 `g` Jr`g^g\C Io?
6Oi COiVi `g`
‘Mk4 Ci `gRg6 >M^o RQDr’ 7 h`UgV CrVj4 Io?
Es]ia4C] h5WgNi
C I[g4 7`o^4j C\j4 S_ 7hd] >3|r9O]i [gMo &QiRj4 Io?
UVoRi
adiT S\o^g `gR4WÁ\ cphVCVj4 aY Jr8Vo K`o]H4T [oFgQi> C8
[lW\jVr E]Yr
ClhR ]Hi dRi? Ch` T^WR]g[Vr J<[ C\g4 S\r dRr?
`P`gQ
EjJ]gRVg C\g hJI^gVo csSi ^g4Yr Th]\g hCVg]r [_o^r Io?
&[VE]
`g[i 7V4TVj4 [k_ Vg[ aj4 Io?
hd4 [R^g^ ]g[H4^ T`o
‘c4Z`gh[ \jEo \jEo’Vg ^oDC CrQ Io?
d]i<^ T`o
C\g ]gJ`iVg agcVVo EjJ]gRVr cj`Q6\jE EQ`g[g4 7`o Io?
hcૐ]gJ J\hc4d
C\j4 &QiRj4 RiS6 S_ 6Eg: UVCWj]i R]iCo A_DgRj4 dRj4?
OgCr]
Yg^ga4C] :I^gc]g[ C4 Sgh]\gVj4 Cr8 >C :WVg[ JQg`r.
n?
Yg^
EjJ]gRVg C\g `gR45`i] ‘T]Yg]’ Vg :WVg[Si &QiRg Io?
ErWg_Tgc
EjJ]gRVg C\g hJI^g[g4 RgWi VTi D4ZgRVg 6DgRVo [_o Io?
cj]R
V]hc4d [do RgVo JkVgEPVg C\g ]gJ`iVg c[Cg^iV EQ`g[g4 7`o
]g’ ]g [g4Oh^C
Io? EjJ]gRVj4 S[ Ro^બo5 C\g4 7`o^4j Io?
^jQoJ
EjJ]gRVg C\g ^rCVlW\Vj4 Vg[ c4 ClR a}T ‘EZ6TiW’ W]Si :R]i
E]Yg
7]\j4 Io? [w\Cg^iV EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vg4 :bgCg_o S[ []Qi\ Vg[ CrVj4
do [H4^gHg\6
^o`g\ Io? EjJ]gR c]Cg]Vi ZgbghV\g[CVi CHo]i C\j4 cg[h\C CghaR C]o
]gJZgbg
Io? ]4E[4H^બi C^g બo5o EjJ]gR c]Cg] R]XSi C\r [dW`WkQ6
W4hOR A[Cg]VgS NgCj] Wj] Cg]
Wj] Cg] 7W`g[g4 7`o Io? Zg]RVi h`c]g\o^i ^rC][RrVj4 6TZkR ZgSj4 Wjc4 WgOVg] V4SVj4
^rC][Rr
Vg[ JQg`r? V_c]r`] C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^j4 Io?
6[Tg`gT
‘Rg]i 74DVr 6XiQi...’ EiRVg ]Hh\Rg CrQ Io?
`oQiZg8 Wj]rhdR
Og\[
૮w MCg
6
Ch` Cg
6|gd[ h^4CV
Ch` ‘Cg
[hQa4C] ]WV! Zુ
hd4 T IrOr H_`_Vg S[ EjJ]gRi adiT CrQ dRg?
:[gCg
EjJ]gRVg C\g h` Rg][g4 Cg@NC_gVi h`h`U HiJrVr ]\`cg\
Zgc WgMQ
h`C \r Io? Wj]gQr[g4Si EjJ]gRi Zgbg[g4 W૩cWg4R] C]Vg] Ch` C\g dRg?
Ch` Zg^Q
Vod]ha[Vo C9 Wh5Cg IgW`g YT^ V` [gc B^Vi c& S\o^i?
cW\gVd
C\r hd4 Tj Rdo `g] 64Vo! Rg]iD [jJY :J`g\ Io?
:ૈ]g\Q
V]hc4dVg [rMgZgEVg WTr C\g I4T[g4 ]Hg\g Io?
Kk ^Qg I4T
EjJ]gRVg4 C Ii ZiRhH5rVo 4 C\g Vg[o A_D`g[g4 7`o Io?
C[g4E]i ap^i
EjJ]gR[g4 h`Cco^i C8 &QiRi ^rCVgS\C_gVj4 Vg[ c4 ClR a}T
Z`g8
‘Z`’ W]Si :R]i 7]\j4 Io? ‘Wl~`iH<^Hh]5’Vg cxCVj4 Vg[ 7Wr?
[ghQC\cj4T] ckh]
cs S[ `DR 84hg^a HoV^ C\g EjJ]gRi R]`p\g> Wg] C]i
cjhX\gV aoD
dRi? ‘[gU` C\g4\ VSi [Uj`V[g4’ ClhRVg cxC CrQ Io?
dh]<^ T`o
G.E.E.R.Vj4 Wk]j4 Vg[ JQg`r?
EjJ]gR 9Cr^r!C^ >J\jCoaV >
cd&V4T `g[iVj4 [k_ Vg[ aj4 dRj4?
FVa\g[
EjJ]gR[g4Si J ViC_Ri dr\ 6Vo EjJ]gR[g4 J `do Ri dr\ Ro`i
ZgT]
csSi ^g4Yi VTi C9 Io? EjJ]gRVr Cj^ બo5X_Vg hdcgYo h` Rg] CoM^r Io?
"x x,૯} ૯},w~~ ૯} w~~ Hr. Hr.hC. hC.[i. [i. ઇ
EjJ]gR[g4 [iNgVi csSi `Ug]o hVCgc C\g Y4T]oSi Sg\ Io?
YoOi
Ch` Cg
[Qia4C] ]WV! Zુ
VghcCVi EjXg[g4 `hc@NVg Wj5 Wj^j[g`iVg ha^g^oD[g4 cj]ુ Vg[
cs]g@"
W]Si EjJ]gRVg C\g ToaVr :I^oD S\r dr`gVj4 Qg\ Io? ‘W૨ZkbQ’Vj4 c<[gV gYR C]Vg] EjJ]gRVg [dgV hKCoM] CrQ
h`Vj [g4CO
dRg? x૮y}[g4 Wdo ^ઍ`do ^i SWg\o^i EjJ]gRi ag_gVg4 cs S[ haબC
TjEg6]g[ [do Rg
CrQ dRg? EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vj4 c`r6 H Wgh]RrhbC ‘]QhJR]g[ cj`Q6H4^C’
h]`I^Z HjVi^g^ Zg\gQi
gYR C]Vg] S[ cghdW\Cg] CrQ dRg? EjJ]gRVg hcwU F:4Vi &hRVj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
Tg:TDgVi
EjJ]gRVi `Oi 6Tg^RVg S[ [jL\ <\g\[khR6 CrQ dRg?
cj4T]^g^ h5C[^g^ Tocg8
Eg4Ui!Vo h \ >`j4 ‘CgHYgઍCgHYiVj4 WT’ CrQo ] \j4 dRj4?
Ch` Zr& ZER
6d[Tagdo EjJ]gRVi ]gJUgVi WgMQSi C\g4 DcoO`gVr hVQ6\
7ag`^ ંdg^Vj4 6[Tg`gTઉ 6[Tg`gTઉ
C\r6 dRr? Ch` T\g]g[Vj4 Yg_WQVj4 Vg[ aj4 dRj4?
T\ga4C]
64Yg!Vi V!C[g4 7`o^4j C\j4 S_ RoVi 7]c W]Vi 6TZkR
Cj4Zgh]\gVg4 To]g
CrR]Qi [gMo &QiRj4 Io? Z`g9 [4O_iVg [jL\ ]\hCRં[r`OiઉVo C\g Vg[o A_D`g[g4 7`o
Vg\C
Io? ‘>C^]\ 7H6]i >Co Oo[i’Vi SgWVg CrQo C]i dRi?
hTVoa Zi^
Ch` VgC]Vj4 `RV C\j4 dRj4?
`OrT]g
6[Tg`gT ]g9X^ >crhc>aVVg SgWC CrQ dRg4?
:T\V HiVjZg9 Yo]rVoM
EjJ]gRVg C\g Ch`Vo ‘7L\gV Ch` ha]r[Qi’Vj4 :WVg[ [X\j4?
[dgCh` o[gV4T
C\g EjJ]gRi ^oDCo DEr_ag 5 h`bo EjJ]gRi[g4 Wj RCr ] \g4?
!Ro<^ JMga4C] ]g`^
7
`g[i 7V4TVg :ૈ[ ^DgQrVj4 c4C^V C\g Wj RC[g4 S\o^4j Io?
U]RiVi 7]Ri
[rdo4 ઍJrઍTOr 6Vo dOYWg YgT EjJ]gR[g4 C8 dOYWi\ cg8M csSi
^rS^
`Uj c4L\g[g4 dOYWg cv\RgVi A_D c[gV [j^gA U]g`o Io? EjQ`4R]g\ 7Hg\6Vi Th]\g8 cgdcVi C8 hcૐ V`^CSg Io?
Th]\g^g^
cghdW\ બo5o EjJ]gR c]Cg] R]XSi C\r [dW`WkQ6 Wj] Cg]
7hTCh` V]hc4d [do Rg Wj] Cg]
7W`g[g4 7`o Io? EkJ]gR h`૩gWiNVg S[ Cj^WhR CrQ dRg?
[dgW[g Eg4Ui
‘c] `RiH<^’ [dgV`^CSgVg Vg\C ઍ Vgh\CgVj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
c] `RiH<^ 6Vo Cj[jT
‘C^gWi’Vg :WVg[Si &QiRg EjJ]gRVg Ch`Vj4 Vg[ aj4 dRj4?
ck]hc4d! RDRhc4d Erhd^
Zi^rVg ;WCb6 [gMo x૯yy[g4 ‘Zi^ co`g [4O_’Vi SgWVg CrQo C]i
Nર]YgWg
dRi? EjJ]gR[g4 hJI^gAVi WjV6]HVg C\g [jL\[45iVg agcVCg_
a4C]hc4d `gFo^g
T]h[\gV S8 dRi? EjJ]gRVr >C[g5 do ]iMoJ cM C\g4Si C\g4 cjUi &\ Io?
cgY][Ri 7r[Si Tg4Oi
EjJ]gR[g4 Yr^gRi ZgbgVo EjJ]gRi R]iCo cs S[ CrQo
o[gV4T
A_Dg`i? CVp\g^g^ [jVaiVi [dgV`^CSg ‘Cl@Qg`Rg]’ CoM^g ZgE[g4
7N
h`Zg!R Io? ‘ciRgd]Q’ ClhRVg ]Hh\Rg CrQ Io?
C[6Q [45i
‘hf`]oX’ ;WVg[Si A_DgRg EjJ]gRi cghdW\Cg]Vj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
]g[Vg]g\Q h`. h`. WgNC
EjJ]gRi Ch`Rg cghdW\[g4 ‘[dgCh`’ Co ‘Ch`cgM’ R]iCo CrQ
Ch`
A_Dg\ Io? adiT S\o^g `gR4WÁ\ cphVCVj4 aY Jr8Vo K`o]H4T [oFgQi> C8
[lW\jVr E]Yr
ClhR ]Hi dRi? &[VE] 6Vo C IVg Th]\ghCVg]o aoVg J4E^r 7`o^g4 Io?
Ho]
Ch` W૨VgZ C\g ]gJT]Yg][g4 ]gJCh` dRg?
Kg^r]Vr ]gJT]Yg]
`OrT]g ado ][g4Si C8 VTi `do Io?
h`.gh[5i
EjJ]gRi dg \cghdW\Vg ‘dg \ cgM’ Vj4 hYcT CrVo [X\j4 Io?
J\rRi<^ d. d. T`o
EjJ]gR[g4 6[Tg`gT DgRo Wdo ^i ^r Cr^oJ SgWVg] CrQ dRg?
c] ^I^jZg8 7ag]g[ agd
Ch` W૨VgZo C9 ClhRVi ]HVg C]i Io?
Cg
`gR4WÁ\ H_`_Vj4 hHk ‘HK’ ]gD`gVj4 Eg4Ui!Vo CrQo ckH]\j4 dRj4?
E4EgYoV [J[jTg]
"C\g &QiRg VgS\Cg]o cghdW\ClhR ‘SrOg 74c,j SrOg X^ k ’ ]Hiઇ?
J\a4C] cj4T]i
C I hJI^gVj4 [jL\ [SC C\j4 Io?
ZjJ
H4^EjYR [s\o6 JkVgEP[g4 C\j4 J_ga\ Y4Ug]\j dRj4?
cjTa6V R_g`
Hg4WgVo][g4 7`o^g ‘hd cg]ઍ>ઍDgc’Vi 7cWgc hCI^gVj4 hV[g6Q
[rd3[T YoEOr
CrQo C]g]\j4 dRj4? EjJ]gRVg YUg4 J Y4T]rVo JrO`g 6Vo Th]\g8 ]\gWg]Vo :ૈoJV
^DWRSi :[]Eg[
7W`g C\r Ur]i[gE6 h`Ccg`g\r Io? EjJ]gRi ZgbgVi S[ 7W[CSg C8 Io?
[g]i dCiCR
EjJ]gR[g4 C\g [rc[i W`Vr `]cgT 7Wo Io?
Vp
EjJ]gRVj4 c]o]ga RgW[gV CoM^j4 dr\ Io?
y~. y~.|w hOVi co.
cgY][Ri VTi W] Y4Ug\o^r U]r9Y4U C\g Rg^jCg[g4 7`o^r Io?
cR^gcQg
:ORi hDcCr^i EjJ]gRVg C\g `Vh` Rg]r[g4 ToDi aCg\ Io?
ak]WgQo.] 6Vo ThબQઍ ThબQઍ[w\ EjJ]gRVg4 E^r
D4ZgRVg 6CiC :૩rEVo C\g Oj4E]Vi DgQr[g4SiJc]i WWS] [_o
]gJWiW_gVg Oj4 E]rVi
Io? h`VrTiVi Vi^C4 NVi C8 `gRg6 W]Si xz >`rO6 !RVg]i hXI[ YVi
CgaiVr TiC]r
dRi?
8
EjJ]gRi ZgbgઍcghdW\Vg c4TZ6[g4 9.c.x{ww Si x૮wwVr
[w\Cg^iV EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vr \jE
c[\Eg_r C\g \jE R]iCo A_Dg\ Io? EjJ]gRVj4 ]gJ\બi C\j4 Io?
cj]DgY
EjJ]gRVj4 ]gJ\ gQi C\j4 Io?
hc4d
ZhCRVo `R45]c R]iCo `iCg]`gVi hd[g\R CrQo C]i?
Yg^ga4C] C4 Sgh]\g
6[Tg`gT[g4 h`Toai CgWO RSg a]gYVi TjCgVr Y4U C]g``gVj4 VoRlW`
[lTj^g cg]gZg8
CrQo ^iUj4 dRj4? Zg]R[g4 T]]rJ SRi >C[g5 WT\g5g C8 Io?
6[Tg`gT do h]MoJ `rC
EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 ro@N dg \^oDC R]iCo CrVi EQVg Sg\ Io?
J\rhR<^ d. d. T`o
6VgS Yg_CrVo 7r\ [_i ]do Ro [gMoVi ajZ ac7R CrQo
[diWR]g[ cW]g[
C]i? EjJ]gRVg C\g ado ][g4 agd7^[ cgdo YVr hcૐ :c6 Z]g\ Io?
6[Tg`gT
EjJ]gR[g4 7`o^g hcૐ t\rhR6h^4E cr[VgSVg Vg[Vr 6S6 aj4
H4^Vr ]બC
Sg\ Io? ^qCEoM U]g`Rj4 EjJ]gRVj4 >C[g5 Y4T] C\j4 Io?
Zg`VE]
Yr^i`jO hXI[ To`TgcVj4 hV[g6Q C\g EjJ]gRi> C\j64 Io?
c4J\ ^i^g ZQcg^i
x૮{{[g4 EjJ]gR[g4 SWg\o^i cs S[ 64Vo! ag_gVg do O [g M]
TgTrZg Wg4Oj]4E
CrQ dRg? EjJ]gRVr Co M^r h` Rg] `oM ^n
"y~ y~,www y~ www Hr. Hr. hC[i. hC[i. ઇ
EkJ]gR h`૩gWiNVo Oi3O \jhV`hc6MiVr T]JJr C\g]o [X\r?
8.c.૯}z
Wg^VWj] V!C C\r ]icrM6 7`o^r Io?
Yg^g]g[ ]icrM6
c4R]g[ [dg]gJVj4 L\gR [4hT] C\g4 7`o^4j Io?
VhO\gT
EjJ]gR[g4 csSi JkVj4 3\jhK\[ C\j4 Io?
C I 3\jhK\[
`R45 Zg]RVg S[ ^aC]i `Og C\g EjJ]gRi dRg?
JV]^ ]gB<^hc4d!
Zg]R[g4 Wg]ciA EjJ]gRVg C\g Y4T] W] 7]\g?
c4&Q Y4T]
W4Hg\RrVg c`g64Ei h`Cgc [gMo EjJ]gR c]Cg] f`g]g C8 \rJVg
RiS6Vg[ \rJVg
Cg\6]R Io? V[6Tg VTi C\g C\g ]gJ\r[g4Si Wcg] Sg\ Io?
"[w\ To [w\ Toa, [dg]g@" 6Vo EjJ]gR ઇ
W4H[dg^ hJI^gVj4 C\j4 6Z\g]u\ WબiA [gMo &QiRj4 Io?
]RV[dg^
C\r Zk R]i\ c[\ 7hC6 \V \jEVr >C ZgE Io?
Ug]`gO
MoY^ MohVc[g4 EjJ]gRVr V4Y] x Do^gOi CrQ Io?
WhSC [do Rg
` RjWg_Vo EjJ]gRVg [dg6[gW\Vj4 WT CrQo 7Y\j?4
]g& h`a_To` `gFo^g
Tg4OiCkH T]h[\gV WrRgVi U]WCO Sg\ Rr Tg4OiCkHVj4 VoRlW` C]`g
6}Ygc Rp\Y!
[gMo Eg4Ui!> CrVi Wc4TEi C]i dRi? [rd3[T YoEOgVg agcV T]h[\gV C\g &QiRg hX^ckX 6Vo
do YRjI^g agd
EhQRભ EjJ]gRVi [j^gCgRo 7]\g dRg? 6[Tg`gT[g4 7`o^i 6Vo SgWW\C_gVr :ૈ[ V[kVr >`i Jj3[g
6d[Tagd YgTagd
[h JT CrQo Y4Ug`i dRi? EjJ]gR[g4 Ho]Vg `lબrVj4 J4E^ C\g4 7`o^4j Io?
&[VE] 6Vo C IVg Th]\g hCVg]g Wgco
[dgEjJ]gRVi 6^E ]HVgVi 7Eo`gVi CrQo ^iUi dRi?
9
V_c]r`] C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^j4 Io?
6[Tg`gT
V RiS6 S_ Wgh^RgQg C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^4j Io?
Zg`VE]
hE]Vg] W`6R W] [I^iVgSVj4 cj hcૐ [4hT] CrQo Y4Ug]\j4 dRj4?
` RjWg^ઍ g^ઍRoJWg^
EjJ]gR[g4 ^rC[o_gVj4 7\rJV C\g ado ][g4 Sg\ Io?
6[Tg`gT
EjJ]gR[g4 CoM^g4 6v\g]u\r RSg ]g@"i\ :૩gVr 7`o^g4 Io?
yx 6hZ\g]u\ RSg { ]g@"i\ :૩gVr
Wg`gEP[g4Si ViC_Ri >C [dWW`Vi VTiVj4 Vg[ C\g
h`.gh[5
W]Si WG\j4 Io?
9
][Q^g^ crViVj4 EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vg C\g બo5[g4 TgV Io?
Yg_ cghdW\
EjJ]gRi Ch` [iૃj d4 co a4C]gHg\6Vg C\g Rr5Vr EjJ]gRi
cs
c[a^rCi 6Vj`gT C\r6 Io? Cgh^TgcVg ‘6hZભgV agCj
:[ga4C] Jrai
‘J\hZLDj Wj] Cg]’ EjJ]gR c]Cg] R]XSi aoVg [gMo >Vg\R
[gV`CI\gQVg બo5o :[Tg `lhૈ C]`g YT^
C]`g[g4 7`o Io? YgTagdVr d!]r 6Vo ]gQiVr d!]r Vg[Vi 8[g]R 6[Tg`gT[g4
[gQoCHrC
C\g S_o 7`o^i Io? hd4 T IrOr 74Tr^V T]h[\gV EjJ]gR Cq^oJ[g4 hR]4Er ^do ]g``g
h`VrT hCVg]i`g^g
JRg4 CrQo adiTi `dr]i? c4 ClR[g4Si >Vg > J `cWo EjJ]gRi[g4 7`o^g a}Tr C\g Vg[o
RWc[
A_Dg\ Io? Eg4Ui!Vo cg:S 7hyCg[g4 ]oI`oVi X M6 C^gcVi hMhCM dr`g IRg4
WiM] [gh]WKYE6
hYV Er]g dr`gVo VgRo Hg^j cgX]i> cg[gV cgSo "oV[g4Si Uરr [g]iVo :Rg]i To`g[g4 7]\g. > ]oI`o Mo aV C\j4 dRj4? CMrCMi c[\o co
cgUVg cgYRghdC
[dW`Vi Zkh[Cg ZJ`o^ dRi? ‘U`I^C’ > EjJ]gRVg C\g 7UjhVC ado ]Vj4 gHiV Vg[ Io?
Ur_Cg
EjJ]gRVg C\g Kg4hRCg]i ‘EjJ]gR c`r6 H <\g\g^\’ Vg ; H
6}Ygc Rp\Y!
<\g\gUia dRg4? EjJ]gRVr csSi [rMr WajAVr [o_r C\g4 Z]g\ Io?
`sNg
EjJ]gRVi C9 Oo]iVi WoTga 74R]]g@"i\ R]o `DQg\ Io?
6[k^
5iWg5rVi Zkh[CgVo ]4EZkh[ W] !`4R C]Vg] VM CrQ dRg?
J\a4C] cj4T]i
‘h5Zj`VTiWC Y4U’Vg Ch`Vj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
J\aoD] ckh]
Ch` :[ga4C] JraiVj4 C\j4 cg[h\C cghdW\ 6Vo W5Cg]W` બo5o
c4 ClhR
6JrO Cdo `g\ Io? EjJ]gRVg C\g Toa[g4 csSi `Uj Y4T]r 7`o^g Io?
cs]g@"
Er_[o! Wh]bT[g4 J`g Eg4Ui!Vo :્oaiVo ri [oFgQi> C\j4 Cg]\
IoI^r CMr]r
^L\j4 dRj4? EjJ]gRVi cs S[ gTohaC [kC hXI[ C8 dRi?
ZCR h`Tk]
EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 ^rCh \ YVo^i ‘hc4dgcV Y5ici’Vi `gRg6A
Ch` ag[_
CrQo ^Di Io? EjJ]gRVg4 C\g 6VQi :૩rEWhR> Co h^Cr h[^Vi SgWVg C]i
64Yg^g^ cg]gZg8
dRi? EjJ]gRVj4 C\j4 S_ c4R CYi] cgSo c4C_g\o^j4 Io?
CYi]`O
7 MrhO\g Vg[ C\g Zi^ ]g&Vi \gT 6Wg`o Io?
7ag Zi^
‘J\jhY^i AX hKCo M’ Vg[Vj4 Wj RC CrQo ^L\j4 Io?
Jaj WMo^
C Rk]YgVo B^[g4 CrQo ZQR] Wk]j4 WgG\j4?
WkhQ6[gYoV WC`gcg
Zg]RZ]Vi TkU 6Vo Oo ]i rOCScVi [g4EVo Wk]i C]Ri 6[k^ Oo]i
7Q4T
EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4 7`o^i Io? ‘[kIg_i [g’Vg Vg[o C\g Yg_`gRg6Cg] L\gR S\o^g?
hEJjZg8 YUoCg
:Cg8 Y4U C\g4 7`o^r Io?
cj]R
]4E[4H^બi C^g બo5o EjJ]gR c]Cg] R]XSi C\r [dW`WkQ6
W4hOR hOR A[Cg]VgS NgCj] Wj] Cg]
Wj] Cg] 7W`g[g4 7`o Io? ‘7 VZ Kj C\j4 Ro CgV!...’ EiRVg ]Hh\Rg CrQ Io?
h \Cg
>C c[\o EjJ]gRVr ZgE EQgRg hZ૮[g^[g4 J<[o^g |EjYRo
ak<\
aoVi arU C]i dRi?
10
"‘KYkC `iJ_i KYkC’ Yg_Cg]\c4Vd 6Vo ‘Yo Zg8’, ‘Rg9Cr’
[C]4T T`o
Yg_VghMCg CrQo ^L\g4 Ioઇ? WgIg X]Rg [rc[i W`VrVi
ACMrY] 6Vo V`o3Y]
Io? Ch` V[6TVo ‘7!`V \rૐr’ Cdo Vg] CrQ Io?
h`.VgS Zુ
Wl~`i I4TVo `gdi YVg``gVr \rE C\g Ch`> C\r6 Io?
Y_`4R]g\ C. C. NgCr]
T^WR]g[Vg ‘`oVHh]5’[g4 5i!`VVi C8 c[ \gVi `gR Io?
Yg_h`U`gVi c[ \g
‘hcૐdo [a}TgVjagcV’ C\g cghdW\ Cg][g4 ^D`g[g4 7]\r Io?
Tjdg
EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vi S[ Wh]bT C\g4 6Vo C\g]o \r&8 dRi?
6[Tg`gTઍ 6[Tg`gTઍx૯w|
co<"^ crIM 6Vo []iV Co h[CIc ]icH6 9h< MS\kM C\g4 7`o^i
Zg`VE]
Io? hcૐWj] C9 VTi W] `co^4j Io?
c] `Ri
W4H[dg^Vi ha`]gJWj]Vi DgQ[g4Si C9 DViJ [_o Io?
[o4EohVK
Vg]g\Q Tocg8 h^hDR Eg4Ui!Vg YldTt !`VHh]5Vj4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
[g]j 4 !`V > J [g]i `gQi
[o.rVTi :W] Y4U Yg4URg C\j4 c]r`] Rp\g] S\j4?
a\g[ c]r`]
E]Yg VlW\ap^iVj4 cxV CrQo C\j46 dRj4?
ri Cl@QVi Ws5`Uk ;bg
C IVg ]h_\g[Qg ]Q[g4 C8 WkhQ6[gVi ]g5o :Wc` ;J``g[g4
a]T WkhQ6[g
7`o Io? RgWi VTi :W] C9 hc4Hg9 \rJVg 7`o^i Io?
CgC]gWg]
Ei]gUrU C8 VTi W] 7`o^r Io?
64hYCg
`rhagMV[g4 [o\]o EjJ]gRi ^oDC [gMo Dgc hT`c &do ] C\r6 dRr
cj]oa T^g^
Ro ^oDC CrQ dRg? EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vr S[ h``oHVV4S C\r EQg\ Io?
V`^V4Sg`h^
EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vg4 C\g [dgV cxC [j4Y9 ]gJ\Vg4 Eld UgV 6Vo
CVp\g^g^ [jVai
[jL\ <\g\gUia ]sg dRg? Ch` cj
Cr\g ZERVi CO`i `gQi
V`^]g[ C\j4 cg[gh\C H^g`Rg dRg?
EjJ]gRi ag_gW5
[w\Cg^iV EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vg4 :bgCg_o S[ []Qi\ Vg[ CrVj4
do [H4^gHg\6
^o`g\ Io? Ch`A f`g]g DkY a4cg Wg[o^g Wબi HgRCVo cs]g@"[g4 C\g
[rRiOr
Vg[Si A_D`g[g4 7`o Io? h|Mia]gJ T]h[\gV cs S[ SWg\o^i EjJ]gRi ag_gA[g4 C\g
ZkEr_ 6Vo DEr_ag 5
h`b\rVj4 haબQ 7W`g[g4 7`Rj4? C\g EjJ]gRi 8g^o4OVi :[]g` cZgVg cT \ R]iCo hV[g\g dRg?
^rO6 [oFVgT Tocg8
cr[VgSVr hJQr6ૐg] C\g Cg_ T]h[\gV S\r dRr?
cr^4CiCg_
h`Toa[g4 ]diVo Kg4hRCg]i H_`_ H^g`Vg] EjJ]gRi Kg4hRCg]i CrQ
c]Tg] hc4d ]gQg
dRg? EjJ]gRVj4 ‘^rCEo9M’ U]g`Rj4 >C[g5 Y4T] C\j4 Io?
Zg`VE]
hYh^\Gc6Vi ][R[g4 EjJ]gRVo h`. R]o Vg[Vg 6Wg`Vg]
EiR aoNi
Do^gOiVj4 Vg[ JQg`r? EjJ]gRVi cs S[ Clhb \jhV`hc6MiVi SgWVg C\g4 6Vo C\g]o S8?
Tg4Ri`gOgઍ i`gOgઍ8.c. x૯~z
`g[i T\gV4T c] `RiVr J<[ C\g4 S\r dRr?
M4Cg]g ંhJ. hJ. ]gJCrMઉ ]gJCrMઉ
V` ZgE[g4 h` R]o^r ‘ZE`TEr[4O^’ a}TCra C\g ]gJ`i> Rp\g]
[dg]g& ZE`Rhc4d!
C]g]\r dRr? EjJ]gR ]gJ\Vr h` Rg] CoM^r Io?
"x x,૯} ૯},wy{ Hr.hC. hC.[i. [i. ઇ ૯} wy{ Hr.
‘^h^Rg Tj5DTa6C’ VgMCVg ^oDC CrQ Io?
]QIrOZg8 :T\]g[
Wj]gQr[g4 EjJ]gRVi C9 VTiVo ‘E4Eg’ Vg[ 7W`g[g4 7`o^4j Io?
hd]u\g
11
CC6 `lૈ EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4Si Wcg] Sg\ Io?
:ૈ] ZgE[g4Si
EjJ]gR[g4 CoM^g Wબi 6v\g]u\r 7`o^g4 Io?
Wg4H
Wr]Y4T][g4 7`o^j4 Eg4Ui!Vj4 [CgV C\g Vg[o A_Dg\ Io?
CihR6 [4hT]
EjJ]gR Mjh]K[ hOWgM6[o
8.c. x૯~z
[rdo4 ઍJrઍTOr 6Vo dOYWg YgT EjJ]gR[g4 C8 dOYWi\ cg8M csSi
^rS^
`Uj c4L\g[g4 dOYWg cv\RgVi A_D c[gV [j^gA U]g`o Io? EjJ]gR[g4 csSi `Uj Mo CcMg9^ :૩rEr C\g4 7`o^g Io?
cj]R
c Rj4 cghdW\Vg SgWC CrQ dRg?
hZબj 6D4OgV4T
EjJ]gRi Ch`RgVg 7hTCh`Vj4 hYcT CrVo [X\j4 Io?
V]hc4d [do Rg
Cl@Qh[5 cjTg[gVj4 >C[g5 [4hT] C\g4 7`o^4j Io?
Wr]Y4T]
EjJ]gRVg Zg^ Toa[g4 SRg4 F:4 C\g Vg[o &QiRg Io?
Zgh^\g F:4
[dgCh` o[gV4TVr [jL\ ]\`cg\ aj4 dRr?
[gQZુ
7Cga`gQiVr EjJ]gR[g4 h`hU`R g]4Z C\g]o S\r?
x} [i >h ^ઍ >h ^ઍx૯{૯
C.E.E.Vj4 Wk]j4 Vg[ JQg`r?
co<`g\][oJ\jCoaV ં6[Tg`gTઉ 6[Tg`gTઉ
EjJ]gRVj4 C\j4 ado ] ‘[રgVj4 `oaf`g]’ EQgRj4 dRj4?
cj]R
c4R WjhVR [dg]gB ac C]o^4j C\j4 [ghcC 7B\ ^rCh \ Io?
JVCI\gQ
c4 ClR 6^4Cg] ag 5Vr cj hcૐ V4S ‘Cg]\ઍ[i[g4cg’ C8 h^hW[g4
Wg4Ojh^hW
CghaR S\r Io?
5iAVo `g`^4Yi YVg``g [gMo SWg\o^i J\rhRc4F c4 SgVg
Hgc[Ri \rૐg
QoRg CrQ dRg4? Eg4Ui J\4Ri ંy ACMrY]ઉ TjhV\gZ][g4 Yi& C\g Vg[o WQ
74R]]g@"i\ 6hd4 cg hTV
:J`g\ Io? Zg]RVg Wk`6]g@"WhR 6Vo Mo CVrKoM Oq. >.Wi.B.6}Tj^ C^g[Vo
Oq. Oq. h`K[ cg]gZg9
6`Cga h`ભgV બo5o o]Qg Wk]i WgOVg]g EjJ]gRi `pભghVC CrQ dRg? cIRVRCg_Vg 9hRdgcVi [gQZkR 7WRg Cg
Wi]r&ઍ Wi]r&ઍ`i][To
o[CdgQi 7^oDg9 Io? 9O]Vg ]g& ]Q[I^Vg4 !`V W] 7Ugh]R C9 ClhR ]Hg9 Io?
]Q[I^ I4T
Zg]R[g4 cs S[ dg:hc4E [4O_iVj4 ]hJ "oaV C\g4 ado ][g4 S\j4
6[Tg`gT
dRj4? TkUcgE] Oo ]i EjJ]gRVg C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^i Io?
[do cgQg
EjJ]gRVg C\g ][R`i]Vj4 Vg[ `rM]Wr^rVi ][R[g4 &QiRj4 Io?
C[^oa VgQg`Mi
o[gV4To !`VhV`g6d 6So6 C\r ]\`cg\ `iCg\r6 dRr?
crVi
ZE`gVVr ZgE’Vg cxC CrQ Io?
][oa Wg]oD
RgVg U[g6H]QVo Cg]Qo ‘h`h`U U[g6Vj\g\i’ CrQ Cdo `g\g Io?
Ch` Zg^Q
OrT]g[g4 7`o^r csSi JkVr [do ^ C\r Io?
VJ] YgE Wo^oc
]4E 6`UkR [dg]gJVj4 [g]C C\g4 7`o^4j Io?
Vg]o.]
J]gRVg S[ ZshRC h`ભgVi CrQ dRg?
Oq. Oq. h`K[ cg]gZg8
"‘WgI_ `gciA[g4 FQg h[5r WQ dRg, CrQo C\r6 dg] [Vo C4 8
7hT^ [
DY] VSi’ - EK^Vg ^oDC CrQ Ioઇ? EjJ]gRVi S[ ag]ih]C haબQVi c4 Sg C8 Io?
IrMjZg8 Wj]gQi ]\g\g[ [dgh`૩g^\
EjJ]gRVi C<\gA f`g]g 6bgP [hdVg[g4 C]gRg4 6^kQg4 RVo aj4
[r_gCR
Cdo `g\ Io? hc4d [rMgZgEo C\g c[\o ExVg C]Rg dr\ Io?
ck\g6 R WIiVg >C C^gC[g4
‘Z^4Z^’ V`^CSgVg [jL\ Wg5Vj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
Z^4Z^
YgWg ciRg]g[ 7r[ C\g4 7`o^r Io?
YETgQg
Tg4Ri`gOg Y4U \rJVg C\g hJI^g[g4 Io?
YVgcCg4Ng
12
>C [g<\Rg [gQo gHiV c[\[g4 EjJ]gRVi C8 VTiVj4 Vg[ RoVi
cgY][Ri
7cWgc [jCRWQo h`H]Rg cgY] Co cg4Z]Vg Vg[ W]Si WG\j4 dr`gVj4 [Vg\ Io? Ei]Vg [g^Ug]iAVj4 W]4W]gER ]do Qg4C C\g Vg[o A_Dg\ Io?
Kr4C
[dg]g& XRodhc4d 3\jhK\[ C\g ado ][g4 7`o^4j Io?
`OrT]g
EjJ]gRVg4 C\g ado ]Vo ViVciMi R]iCo A_D`g[g4 7`o Io?
Eg4UiVE]
dh_Wj5 >3|r9O]i [gMo C IVj4 C\j4 S_ hcૐ Io?
drOCg
haCgEr 8
dgcV ઍ 6cV
EjJ]gRi hXI[Vo 8Vg[ [X\j4? Z`g8Vg 7૩hWRg 6cg9R NgC] VgR Ydg] [kCg\g YgT C\g4
;4Kg
7`iVo ` \g dRg? EjJ]gRVg4 >C[g5 74R]]g@"i\ h`[gV [SCVj4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
c]Tg] `I^ZZg8 WMo ^ 9]WrM6
Ei]g UrU C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^r Io?
Og4E
EjJ]gRVg 9hRdgc[g4 C\g V4SVi c<[gV\g5g cj hcૐ Io?
hcૐdo [ a}TgVjagcV
6[k^ Oo ]iVg SgWCVj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
h5Zj`VTgc WMo^
EjJ]gRVj4 csSi [rMj4 S[6^ Wg`] Mo aV C\g4 7`o^j4 Io?
Uj`g]Q
C\g S_ V!C cgY][Ri VTi c[j^[g4 h`^iV Sg\ Io?
CrWg^iVi DgOi
[lQg^coVo YVg`o^i C8 hXI[Vj4 hH5g4CV EjJ]gR[g4 S\j4 dRj4?
Zj`V ar[
YEj^Vj4 csSi `Uj :WWgTV C\g hJI^g[g4 Sg\ Io?
[do cgQg
EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vg 8hRdgc[g4 x૯ywSi x૯{~Vr c[\Eg_r C\g
Eg4Ui \jE
Vg[Si A_Dg\ Io? EjJ]gRVj4 ‘VoaV^ []iV WgC6’ C\g4 7`o^4j Io?
&[VE]
EjJ]gRVg 9hRdgc[g4 C\g Cg_Vo cj`Q6Cg_ Cdo `g[g4 7`o Io?
cr^4Ci Cg_
cd&V4T `g[i C\g4Vg `RVi dRg?
IWp\g
IoC 8.c. x૮૮૯[g4 ‘W]Toai [g^ 7WQg Toa[g4 Rp\g] C]`g ag
Z`gVia4C] Jrai
:Wg\ \rJ`g’ > h`b\ W] 9Vg[ h`BRg hV4YUCrQo ^L\r dRr? V_c]r`] W] 7`o^g csSi [rMg MgWjVj4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
WgV`
‘EjJ]gR :&6 h`Cgc hVE[’ C\g ado ][g4 7`o^j4 Io?
`OrT]g
Ch` Cg
6|gd[ h^4CV
Eg4Ui!Vr J<[ C\g4 6Vo C\g]o S\r dRr?
"y y ACMrY] x૮}૯, x૮}૯ Wr]Y4T] ઇ
cgWjRg]g a}TVr ar 6S6 Sg\ Io?
cgWrVj4 hV`gc SgV
EjJ]gRVg C\g 6Qjh`ભgVi> 74R]]g@"i\ R]o Vg[Vg [o_`i
Oq. Oq. dr[i ZgZg
dRi? :ૈ] EjJ]gR[g4 Jr`g [_Rj4 W^gaVj4 `lબ ^rC Yr^i[g4 C\g Vg[o
Co cjOr
Hh^R Io? dh[]c] R_g` C I hJI^gVg C\g ado ][g4 7`o^j4 Io?
ZjJ
:ૈ] EjJ]gRVg Cr_iA[g4 &QiRj4 VlW\ Io?
6. VlW\
EjJ]gR[g4 EjJ]gRi YgT csSi `Uj Yr^gRi Zgbg C8 Io?
[]gNi
6JjV 6 >`rO6 gYR C]Vg] EjJ]gRi [hd^g YoOh[
6WQg6 WrWM
CrQ Io? DrઍDrVi ][R[g4 :WCl@M ToDg` C]iVo 6JjV 6 >`rO6 [o_`Vg]g
cjUi] Zg C]
S[ Do^gOi CrQ Io? T] `bo6 6[Tg`gTVg C\g [4hT]oSi ]S\g5g ViC_o Io?
JE૮gS [4hT]
EjJ]gR[g4 csSi `Uj [4hT]r U]g`Rj4 ado ] C\j4 Io?
Wg^iRgQg
Eg4Ui!Vg J<[hT`cVo C\g 74R]]g@"i\ hT`c R]iCo ;J``g[g4
74R]]g@"i\ 6hd4 cg hT`c
7`o Io? D4ZgRVg 6CiC :૩rEVo C\g Oj4E]Vi DgQr[g4Si Jc]i WWS] [_o
]gJWiW_gVg Oj4 E]rVi
13
Io? hcરg S[6^ Wg`] Mo aV C\g4 7`o^j4 Io?
&[VE]
>C c[\o EjJ]gRVr ZgE EQgRg hZ૮[g^[g4 J<[o^g |EjYRo
ak<\
aoVi arU C]i dRi? 6[k^ Oo ]iVi ac7R C\g `b6[g4 S8 dRi?
8.c. x૯{}
EjJ]gR[g4 ck\6:&6Si ]gh5 Cga [o_`Rj4 Eg[ C\j4 Io?
[oSgQ
ZcH 6Vo cj]R hJI^gVo X_^jW YVg`Ri VTiAVg Vg[ JQg`r?
V[6Tg 6Vo RgWi
Ch` T^WR]g[Vr J<[ C\g4 S\r dRr?
`P`gQ
J\To` C9 ClhRSi V]hc4d [do Rg Zgh`R S\g dRg?
EiR Erh`4T
B]4EKoYVr J<[ EjJ]gR[g4 C\g S_o S\r dRr?
TgdrT
EjJ]gRVg4 Eg[r[g4 Hr`ic C^gC h`J_i C8 \rJVg do N_
J\rhRVg[ \rJVg
7W`g[g4 7`o Io? C IVi :ૈ] ci[g> [rMg ]QVr h` Rg] Hr[gcgVo 64Ro C\g
cj]DgY VE]
VE]Vi ]HVg C]o Io? C IVg ]h_\g[Qg ]Q[g4 C8 WkhQ6[gVi ]g5o :Wc` ;J``g[g4
a]T WkhQ6[g
7`o Io? [4!]gVlW\ > Zg_Cg4Ng[g4 `cRg C\g ^rCrVj4 h`ha@M ^rCVlW\ Io?
W4Pg]
h`Toa[g4 ]diVo Kg4hRCg]i H_`_ H^g`Vg] EjJ]gRi Kg4hRCg]i CrQ
c]Tg] hc4d ]gQg
dRg? [rPo ]gVj4 ck\6[4hT] C\g ]g&Vg agcVCg_ T]3\gV Yg4U`g[g4 7]\j4
]g& Zi[To` Wdo ^r
dRj4? `b6 yww| [gMo EjJ]gRVg C\g Do^gOiVo ‘]g!` Eg4Ui Do^]WV
W4CJ 6O`gQi
>`rO6 ’ >Vg\R S\r dRr? ‘6`g6HiV \jEVg 6cQ’ R]iCo cjUg]C\jE[g4 C\g cxCVo
Ch` V[6Tga4C] ^g^a4C]
hY]Tg``g[g4 7]\g Io? ]`i<^VgS MgEr]o 7V4Ta4C] ;j`Vo C\j4 hY]j T 7Y\j4 dRj4?
:ૈ[ ]\`dg]ભ
‘`gd ]o [gV`i Rg]j 4 dp \j4! >C Wg ^rdiVg CrE_g Vo Yi! Wg
[_o^g !`
iRVg Fk4MOg!’ 7 :ૈ[ c4`gT W૮g^g^Vi C8 V`^CSgVr :ૈ[ 6
[oTgVi ][Rr
][Rr c[g`Rg V4SVj4 Vg[ JQg`r? EjJ]gRVg C\g ado ][g4 agd7^[ cgdo YVr hcૐ :c6 Z]g\ Io?
6[Tg`gT
EjJ]gR[g4 Jr`g [_Rg C\g WબiVi haCg]Vo Cg4Mg[g4 Z]g`i
TkhU\r ^Mr]r
]gD`gVi 7TRVo Cg]Qo Ccg8 WબiVj4 :WVg[ [X\j4 Io? ‘V4TY5ici’ 6Vo ‘hc4dgcV Y5ici’ W૩`gRg6A CrQo ^Di Io?
Ch` ag[_ ag[_
‘]QhJR]g[ cj`Q6H4^C’ cs S[ C\g cghdW\Cg]Vo gYR S\r
K`o]H4T [oFgQi
dRr? 6[Tg`gT[g4 7`o^j4 ro\c 3\jhK\[ C8 C_gClhRAVg Tj^6Z
^rCC_gClhR
V[kVgAVj4 c4Vd SgV Io? EjJ]gR[g4 cs S[ C8 \jhV`hc6Mi SgWVg S8 dRi?
[dg]g& c\g!]g` \jhV`hc6Mi
EjJ]gR[g4 Z`g9 [4O_iA C\g Vg[Si A_DgRi dRi?
WoOg
Zg]RVj4 Y4Ug]Q FO`g[g4 Oq.Yi.7].74YoOC] cgSo [dW`Vi
CVp\g^g^ [jVai
Zkh[Cg ZJ`Vg] EjJ]gRi [dgVjZg` CrQ dRg? EjJ]gRi Zgbg[g4 7a]o CoM^g a}Tr Io?
7a]o WrQg 5Q ^gD
EjJ]gRi Zgbg[g4 JERVr 9hRdgc ^D`gVr S[ \WV CrQo C\r6
Ch` V[6T
Io? 7KgTi Wdo ^g4Vg C I ]gJ\Vg4 H^Qi hcરg C\g4 Vg[Si Hh^R
Cr]i
14
dRg4? T^WR]g[o I4Tag 5[g4 C\r V4S ] \r Io?
T^WR hW4E_
CgaiVr TiC]r hXI[[g4 S[`g] 6Vo IoI^i`g] CrQo c4EiR 7Y\j4
બo[jZg8 hT`oMi\g
dRj4? ]gB<^ agdVo C\g Cg]\c4Vd [gMo ભgVWiN >`rO6 [_o^r Io?
hV]j ્oao
EjJ]gRi ZgbgVr c`6 S[ ]\gC]QV4S CrQo ] \r dRr?
do [H4^gHg\6
EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vj4 S[ cWg4Rh]R VgMC C\j4 Io?
^q[i
"ri [rMg, ri. 64YjZg8 Wj]gQi, ri IrMjZg8 Wj]gQi 6Vo ri
]\g\g[ h`ભgV Crb
Tૈg5o\ [Jj[Tg] C8 Wj RCroQiVi o]Qg[khR6 R]iCo A_Dg\ Ioઇ? c[j^hCVg]o `cRg [gIi[g]r[g4 C\g W`6V4j h`aob [dW` Io?
rg`Qi WkV[
EjJ]gR ]gJ\Vr SgWVgVr [dg c[g]rd C\g4 \rJ`g[g4 7]\r
cgY][Ri 7r[ઍ 7r[ઍ6[Tg`gT
dRr? EjJ]gRVg4 cs S[ [hd^g VgRC S`gVj4 [gV CrVo [X\j4 Io?
h`૩gEs]i Vi^C4 N
[dgZg]RCg_Si V`]gh5 T]3\gV [gRg!Vi WI^i C\g Eg[[g4
cWg^
Z]g\ Io? C8 74R]]g@"i\ c4 Sg> Hg4WgVo]Vo `IO6 do ]iMo JVr T]JJr
\jVo Cr
7Y\r Io? V]hc4d [do RgSi ac S\o^g \jEVo C\g \jE R]iCo A_D`g[g4
ZhCR\jE
7`o Io? ‘[gV`iVi Z`g9’ 6Vo ‘[_o^g !`’ B`i cj hcૐ V`^CSgAVg
W૮g^g^ WMo^
^oDC CrQ Io? h`L\gR Bc^ઍRr]^Vi c[ghU C I hJI^g[g4 C\g4 Io?
64&]
Og4Ei VlW\ 6<\ C\g Vg[o A_Dg\ Io?
Hg_r
cgY]Cg4NgVg ]do `gci C\g UgV 74; ToaVg E`V6] Y<\g dRg?
Oq. Oq.Co .Co . agd
EjJ]gRVj4 C\j4 S_ OiK^ [rMc6Vg :WWgTV[g4 ToaZ][g4 S[
]gJCrM
SgVo 7`o Io? J]gR[g4 Co M^i &hRVg `<\ c RV gQiA Vr4Ug\g Io?
xw~ &hRVg
EjJ]gRVg C\g hf`WCIWVr 7Cg] CgHYgVi WiN B`r Io?
cs]g@"
cs]g@"Vi VTiA C\g Cg]Vi J_ Qg^i ]Ho Io?
h5J\gCg]
h`.cW h`@QjVi Z]\ hR[g EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4 7`o^i Io?
ag[_g!
6[Tg`gT[g4 cs S[ 7\j`oh6 TC Cr^oJVi SgWVg CrQo C]i dRi?
hZબj 6D4OgV4T
V]hc4d]g` hT`ohM\gVi ‘ []Qc4hdRg’ CcQ ah R CrVo :્oaiVo
`E6 S Wj5 Vh^VCg
]Hg8 Io? EjJ]gR[g4 ^gV c[\o E`gRg4 ^gVEiRr C\g Vg[o A_Dg\ Io?
XMgQg
EjJ]gRVg4 >C hJI^g 6Vo VTiVg Vg[ cgSo c4C_g\o^i Oo]iVj4 Vg[
YVgc Oo]i
aj4 Io? C IVj4 C\j4 ado ] cjOi 6Vo I]iઍHYWg :૩rE [gMo &QiRj4 Io?
64&]
`V]gJ Hg`OgVr [45i CrQ dRr?
Hg4Wr `ghQ\r
Eg4Ui!> ]gJCrMVi C8 ag_g[g4 6v\gc C\r6 dRr?
c] 7IyoO dg9 Ck^
‘hc4dVo a 5 ag ! `i]Vo [lW\j ag !’ - 7 W4hCR C\g Ch`Vi Io?
Ch`
EjJ]gR[g4 Co
c4!`Vi ]S
dqh WM^ rBCMVj4 Vg[ aj4 Io? C I[g4Si [_i 7`o^g C]rOr `b6 JkVg 6a[iAVo cgH`Rj4 h`Nr]
[g4O`i
Xrci^ WgC6 C\g4 7`o^4j Io? J_ hY^gOi cg[g<\ ]iRo EjJ]gRVi C8 VTi[g4 Jr`g [_o Io?
V[6Tg
]hcC^g^ W]iDVj4 ‘ah`6^C’ VgMC C\g c4 ClR VgMCVo 7Ug]o
[l IChMC[t
15
]Hg\j4 Io? WgMQ[g4 OY^ 9રR WૐhRSi YVg``g[g4 7`Ri cgOiA [gMo C\j4
hcIC Xg\Y]
Xg\Y] :W\rE[g4 ^o`g\ Io? J\To`Vi C9 ClhRSi V]hc4d [do Rg Zgh`R S\g dRg?
EiR Erh`4T
EjJ]gRVg 9hRdgc[g4 C\g Cg_Vo cj`Q6Cg_ Cdo `g[g4 7`o Io?
cr^4Ci Cg_
ZkC4WVg Cg]Qo C I[g4 S8Vo `do Ri hc4Uj VTiVr `gd C\g `b6Si
`b6 x૮x૯
YT^g8 E\r? "hd]u\g, Crc4Yi 6Vo Zi[gબi VTiAVg h5`oQi c4E[ W] C\j4
DoO|g
ado ] `co^4j Ioઇ? EjJ]gRVg C\g S_o xyww `b6Si Wh`5 6hgV J`h^R Io?
:T`gOg
EjJ]gRVr csSi ;4Hr Oj4 E] C\r Io?
hE]Vg]
EjJ]gRi cghdW\ Wh]bTVj4 [jDW5 C\j4 Io?
W]Y
EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 ^rCh \ YVo^i ‘hc4dgcV Y5ici’Vi `gRg6A
Ch` ag[_
CrQo ^Di Io? C\g EjJ]gRiVo 74R]]g@"i\ 6Qj Cg;
Oq. Oq. [UjC] [do Rg
YV`gVj4 Es]` gYR S\j4 dRj4? EjJ]gRVj4 csSi [rMj4 Y4T] C\j4 Io?
C4 O^g
h`.Z][g4 `DQgRi Co c] Co]i EjJ]gRVg C\g hJI^g[g4 csSi `Uj
JkVgEP
WgCo Io? cj hcૐ Ch` 6DgVg Ej]j CrQ dRg?
Ej]j |gV4T
"cgM 6arC, [dgબ5W ]j ^Tg[g 6Vo C
W4. ZE`gV^g^ 8<^!
ha^g^oDrVg `gHVVi ajwU R Rp\g] C]`gVj4 [gV CrVo Xg_o Ioઇ? [w\Cg^iV EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 C\g CYi]W4Si c4R WrRgVo ‘dh]Vi
Tgci !`Q
Tgci’ R]iCo A_Dg`o Io? `OrT]g ado ] C8 VTiVg hCVg]o `co^4j Io?
h`.gh[5i
do [H4^gHg\6Vj4 J<[ S_ C\j4 Io?
U4UkCg
CVp\g^g^ [jVaiVi [dgV`^CSg ‘Cl@Qg`Rg]’ CoM^g ZgE[g4
7N
h`Zg!R Io? Eg4Ui!Vj4 6[Tg`gT[g4 7`o^ hV`gc SgVVj4 Vg[ aj4 dRj?
{T\ Cj4 J
ag[_Vj4 Vr4UWg5 TgV C\g cghdW\ Cg][g4 Io?
W૩`gRg6
`OrT]g[g4 7`o^g hCRi6[4hT]Vj4 hV[g6Q C8 cg^[g4 S\j4 dRj4?
`b6 x૯zz
EjJ]gR[g4 csSi IoI^o ck\g6 R C\g hJI^g[g4 Sg\ Io?
C I
Ch` V[6TVo ‘6`g6HiVr[g4 7૩’ >`j4 Cdi CrQo hY]Tg]\g Io?
CVp\g^g^ [jVai
EjJ]gRVg S[ CraCg] CrQ dRg4?
Ch` V[6T
EjJ]gRVj4 C\j4 Wબi [gSj4 ;4Fj ]gDiVo Dg\ Io?
X^oh[4Er
EjJ]gR[g4 csSi [rMj `V WhR :૩gV C\g4 Io?
`F9
Wg`gEP W`6R :W] C\g [gRg!Vj4 SgVC Io?
[dgCg_i
Tg4Ri`gOg Y4U \rJVg C\g hJI^g[g4 Io?
YVgcCg4Ng
‘]g8Vr W`6R’ Vg ^oDC CrQ Io?
][Q^g^ Vi^C4 N
EjJ]gRi EK^Vg Eg^iY R]iCo CrQ &QiRg Io?
[]iK
‘EjJ]gRi ZgbgVg &ElR HrCiTg]’ CrQ EQg\ Io?
V]hc4d]g` hT`oMi\g
[d3[T YoEOg> &[g [h JT C\g4 Y4Ug`i dRi?
Wg`gEP 6Vo Hg4WgVo]
Wr]Y4T][g4 7`o^ [dgW[g Eg4Ui CihR6 [4hT] CrQo Y4Ug]\j4?
VgV! Cgh^Tgc [do Rg
EjJ]gRVr C\r hJI^r h`.Vi csSi [rMi X^oh[4Er `cgdR [gMo
C I
&QiRr Io? Cg4Ch]\g R_g` :W] >C [g5 [4hT] C\g c4Ro YVg`o^4j Io?
c4R TgTj T\g^
C\g hJI^gA [di VTi W]Vg Y4UVg Cg]Qo ^gZgSi6 Y<\g Io?
"W4 W4H[dg^, [dg^ DoOg,g 7Q4T ઇ
16
hcૐ J^g]g[ [4hT] C\g4 7`o^j4 Io?
`i]Wj]
`IO6 hHIV Hoc Hoh3W\VaiW !RVg] cs S[ EjJ]gRi CrQ
h]hૐ agd
Io? EjJ]gRVj4 cs S[ VoH] >J\jCoaV co
hd4 Er_EP
dh[]c] R_g` C I hJI^gVg C\g ado ][g4 7`o^j4 Io?
ZjJ
EjJ]gRVi cs S[ "g[ C4 WVi C\g4 SWg8?
Ur^o]g ં8.c. x૮|wઉ x૮|wઉ
Er4O^[g4 C\r ]gJ`i [do ^ 7`o^r Io?
Vs^Dg [do ^
&QiRg EjJ]gRi 6hZVoRg c4!`Cj[g]Vj4 [k_ Vg[ aj4 dRj4?
dh]^g^ J]i`g^g
Z`g8Vg 7૩hWRg 6cg9R NgC] ;4Kg[g4 7]\g WIi C9 ભghR>
R]Eg_g
A_Dg`g ^gg\g? EjJ]gR[g4 [rMg 64Yg! DgRo [o_r C\g [hdVgVi WkV[o Z]g\ Io?
ZgT]`g
h`. hcૐ WMr_g EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4 YVo Io?
WgMQ
]h`a4C] [dg]gJVj4 [jL\ ck5 C\j4 dRj4?
FciVo FciVo ;J_g S8>
h`Toa[g4 ]diVo Kg4hRCg]i H_`_ H^g`Vg] EjJ]gRi Kg4hRCg]i CrQ
c]Tg] hc4d ]gQg
dRg? V_c]r`] Wબi 6v\g]Q R]iCo C\g `b6[g4 &do ] S\j4?
8.c. x૯}૯
EjJ]gR ]gJ\Vi SgWVg S\g WIi C8 WgMi6> c]Cg] YVg`i?
Cr4Voc
`b6 yww| [gMo EjJ]gRVg C\g Do^gOiVo ‘]g!` Eg4Ui Do^]WV
W4CJ 6O`gQi
>`rO6 ’ >Vg\R S\r dRr? MrIcMr\Vi ‘`q] >
J\4hR T^g^
C\r6 Io? Tg4OiCkH T]h[\gV WrRgVi U]WCO Sg\ Rr Tg4OiCkHVj4 VoRlW` C]`g
6}Ygc Rp\Y!
[gMo Eg4Ui!> CrVi Wc4TEi C]i dRi? !.78.8.Mi. Vj4 Wj]j4 Vg[ JQg`r?
EjJ]gR 9< MiS\jM @X >J\jCoaV MoCVr^r!
cd&V4T `g[i C\g4Vg `RVi dRg?
IWp\g
Zg]R[g4 T]]rJ SRi >C[g5 WT\g5g C8 Io?
6[Tg`gT do h]MoJ `rC
hc4Uj c4 ClhRVg ^rCr C8 UgRjVr csSi `Ug]o :W\rE C]Rg4 dRg?
Cg4cj
Ch` :[ga4C] JraiVg C\g Cg]\c4VdVo Zg]Ri\ ભgVWiN Wj] Cg]
hVaiS
[X\r Io? h|hMa c4cTVg S[ EjJ]gRi cv\ CrQ dRg4?
TgTgZg9 V`]r!
WrRgVg agcVCg_[g X]hJ\gR gSh[C haબQ TgD^ C]Vg]
[dg]g& c\g!]g` Eg\C`gOઍ Eg\C`gOઍ`OrT]g
]gJ`i CrQ dRg? EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 S[`g] `R45 hW4E_Vi ]HVg CrQo C]i Io?
Ch` T^WR]g[
EjJ]gRVr >C[g5 Th]\ghCVg]r B HkVgVi Mo C]iASi Fo]g\o^r Io
ErWVgS
RoV4j Vg[ aj4? EjJ]gR[g4 >~^ohMCcVg ]\gW 6Vo h`Cgc [gMo C\j4 [4O_ Cg\6]R
EjJ]gR ]\g\g[ Hg]C [4O_
Io? EjJ]gRVg C\g ado ][g4 Oj4E_i csSi `Uj WgCo Io?
[dj`g
C\g Wબi h`ao >`i DrMi [g<\Rg Io Co RoA `]cgTVj4 J WgQi Wi
YWp\g 6S`g WWidg
aCo Io? C`g4M [o_r C\g4 Z]g\ Io?
IrMg :ToWj]
‘[T6 RodVj4 Vg[...’ - 7 W4hCR CrQo ^Di Io?
Ch` V[6T
`b6 yww૯[g4 VoaV^ 8~^ohMCc Ho3Wi\VaiW[g4 yw
YgYjZg8 WVrHg
Ci.[i. Hg^`gVi WUg6 CrQo !Ri dRi? 6hM]g agVg [gMo &QiRj4 Io C\g4 7`o^j4 Io?
CgWO c4arUVઍ rUVઍ6[Tg`gT
EjJ]gRVj4 C\j4 ado ] :૩gVVE]i R]iCo &QiRj4 Io?
Eg4UiVE]
EjJ]gRVj4 C\j4 S_ ‘6J]D’ Vg[Vi }^rC h h
C I
17
&QiRj4 Io? Ch` VTo C\g cg[h\C f`g]g c[gJ cjUg]gVi Tg4Oi WiMi dRi?
Og4hO\r
^i^i `V]g! RSg Th]\ghCVg]gVg cr4T\6Si [Pg\o^g :Z]gM
c]j 6Vo RgOVg4 `lબr
ંhJ.V`cg]iઉ[g4 C\g `lબr h`aob [gQ[g4 Io? <\jhC^\] 9^ohC"hcMi WoTg C]`g[g4 EjJ]gRVj4 SgV Zg]R[g4
hf`Ri\
CoM^g[j4 Io? X]hJ\gR 6Vo h`Vg[kI\o haબQ C8 :4[]Vg Yg_CrVo ^gEk WOo Io?
}Si x{ `b6
cr^4Ci `4aVg hcૐ ]gJ`i hcૐ]gJ J\hc4dVg agcVCg_[g4 CrVo
do [H4^gHg\6
‘Ch^ Cg^ c`6ભ’Vj4 hY]j T gYR S\j4 dRj4? K`o]H4T [oFgQiVr C\r Cg]\c4Vd Eg4Ui! h`b\C Cg]\rVr Io?
YgWjVg Wg]Qg4
[dgW[g Eg4Ui!Vo cW\RUg]C YV`g C\g VgMCo o]Qg Wk]i WgOi
cW\`gTi ]g& dh]`4^
dRi? c4R WjhVR [dg]gJVi V4SroQiVj4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
ભgVE4Er5i
cgY][Ri VTiVj4 :TE[ SgV C\j4 Io?
Po Y] c]r`]ઍ c]r`]ઍ ]gJ SgV
Hr]`gOSi `o]g`_ cjUiVi 6hD^ hd
`i] cg`]C]
[lhR[g4 \r&\ Io? EjJ]gRVi cs S[ ^q \jhV`ci6Mi C\g4 7`o^i Io?
Eg4UiVE]
EjJ]gR[g4 CoM^g Cg]Vg Ko]i cgW Jr`g [_o Io?
Wg4H
EjJ]gRVg C\g &QiRg Wબih`TVo ‘W૨ZkbQ’Si c<[ghVR C]g\g
c^i[6^i
Io? "‘\g dr[ C]iVo WOr, XRod Io 7Eo’ - 7 W4hCR C\g Ch`Vi Ioઇ?
Ch` V[6T
]Q! "rXi C\g ]gJ`i hKCoM]Vg Vg[Si ][g\ Io?
&[ ]Q!Rhc4d
c]Tg] WMo ^o Yg]Or^i 7r[Vj4 aj4 Vg[ ]gL\j4?
`]gJ 7r[
cs]g@"Vg Cr_i 6Vo CQYiAVj4 &QiRj4 VlW\ C\j4 Io?
ErX Ej4SV
`gciAVg 7Cb6QVj4 Co <^ >`r EjJ]gRVr C\r YiH `!6V YiH
Ti`
R]iCo A_Dg\ Io? ‘J[rSg_ !`V &:4 `g]i...’ Zg``gdi ]HVg CrQo C]i Io?
Zk[gV4T `g[i
]iIVr 4 h \ Dr]gC aj4 dr\ Io?
:U8
EjJ]gRVj4 csSi [rMj4 DgR]Vj4 Cg]DgVj4 C\j4 Io?
EjJ]gR V[6Tg`o^i XMi6^g8K] C4 WVi
EjJ]gRVg4 >C hJI^g 6Vo VTiVg Vg[ cgSo c4C_g\o^i Oo]iVj4 Vg[
YVgc Oo]i
aj4 Io? 7hT`gciAVg :WSgV [gMo ThબQ EjJ]gR[g4 `oOIi DgRo
JjER]g[ T`o
7r[ag_g CrQo SgWi dRi? C\r hd4 Tj Rdo `g] 64Vo! Rg]iD [jJY :J`g\ Io?
:ૈ]g\Q
Zg]RVj4 Yi& K[Vj4 csSi [rMj4 cg\
6[Tg`gT
EjJ]gRi hdW\Vi S[ Wh]bT C\g4 6Vo C\g]o \r&8 dRi?
6[Tg`gTઍ 6[Tg`gTઍx૯w|
&[VE]Vr 6&\Y hCI^r CrQo 6Vo C\g]o Yg4w\r?
8.c. x~૮{ Si x~૮૯ ઍ hT`gV [o]g[Q D`gc
hY4Tj c]r`] EjJ]gRVi C9 VTi Wgco 7`o^4j Io?
c] `Ri
V[6Tg VTiVj4 WgQi 6<\ C8 VTiVo [_o Io?
cgY][Ri VTi 6Vo c] `Ri
EjJ]gRVg C\g hJI^g[g4 csSi `Uj 9cYEj^ WgCo Io?
[do cgQg
"^rCZg]Ri, cQrc]g f`g]g h`Ccg``g[g4 7`o^i F:4Vi &R
^rC`V
JQg`rઇ? EjJ]gRi ZgbgઍcghdW\Vg c4TZ6[g4 9.c.x{ww Si x૮wwVr
[w\Cg^iV EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vr \jE
c[\Eg_r C\g \jE R]iCo A_Dg\ Io? C8 cg^[g4 64VoJr f`g]g EjJ]gR[g4 cs S[ xw EjJ]gRi
8.c. x૮y}
ag_gA SgW`g[g4 7`i? EjJ]gRi ZgbgVj4 ]\gC]Q ]H`gVr \a CrVg Xg_o &\ Io?
do [H4^gHg\6
18
DiJOi\gVj Wબi 6Z\g]u\ C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^4j Io?
&[VE]
EjJ]gR[g4 csSi `Uj Og4E]Vj4 `g`oR] C\g hJI^g[g4 Sg\ Io?
`^cgO
EjJ]gR[g4 >C d&] Yg]iA`g_r [do ^ C\g4 7`o^r Io?
]gJWiW_g
:[ga4C] Jrai> h`cgWj] B^[g4Si cs Wdo ^j4 C\j4 >Cg4Ci ^L\j4
adiTVj4 `YV
dRj4? TkUcgE] Oo ]i EjJ]gRVg C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^i Io?
[do cgQg
EjJ]gRVr csSi [rMr []iVWgC6 C\g4 7`o^r Io?
Wr]Y4T]
‘ YrU Y5ici’ ClhRVg ]Hh\Rg CrQ Io?
Ch` [g4OQ Y4Ug]r
EjJ]gRi ZgbgVo S[ 7W[CSg ં[g]i dCiCRઉ CrQo 7Wi?
Ch` V[6T
EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 Yg_Cg]\r ^D`gVi ac7R CrQo C]i dRi?
Ch` T^WR]g[
EjJ]gRVj4 cs S[ cs] :&6 Eg[ C\j4 Io?
Dg4hO\g
gHiV RiS6 Z^o.] C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^4j Io?
C I
EjJ]gRVi C9 VTiA W] YoઍYo Y4U Yg4U`g[g4 7]\g Io?
RgWi 6Vo [di
‘ &Y4Uj’ 6Vo ‘[j4Y8 c[gHg]’ Vg h]WrM6 ] B[Qo Tg4OiCkHVj4 6RSi
ChW^ cgT T`o
8hR cjUi h]WrhM64 E C\j46 dRj4 Ro CrQ dRg? 6Dr C9 W]4W]gVg cxC R]iCo &QiRr Io?
ભgV[gEi6 Cg]\Ug]g
WkJ\ ri [rMgVj4 [k_ Vg[ aj4 dRj4?
HjVi^g^ 7ag]g[ Zg`cg]
C IઍZ^o.]Vg C\g &QiRg `oWg]i> Tj@Cg_ T]h[\gV 6VgJઍ
aoN JEOkag
Wpcg 6P_C [TT C]iVo TgV`i]Vj4 hY]j T [o_]\j4 dRj4? 8]gVSi 7`iVo Wg]ciA> EjJ]gRVg C\g ado ][g4 `c`gM C\r6?
`^cgO
EjJ]gRVr Do^gOi ]gJ\ Cબg> hchૐ gYR C]o W\g]o RoVo C\r
\TiWhc4d! >`rO6
>`rO6 7W`g[g4 7`o Io? []Ci Vg ]rEVi T`g arUVg] D] ]cg\Qag 5i CrQ dRg?
h5Zr`VTgc EJJ]ઍ EJJ]ઍcj]R
Zg]RVj4 csSi [rMj4 gQic4Vdg^\ C\j4 Io?
"C[^g C[^g Vdo c Kj A^r!C^ WgC6, Cg4C]i\g, ]i\g 6[Tg`gT ઇ
EjJ]gR `gcV hVE[Vi SgWVg C\g]o S8?
8.c. x૯~|
E4EgcRiVi Wj5`UkV4j Vg[ aj4 dRj4?
WgVYg9
>ha\gVi csSi [rMi dqh WM^ C8 Io?
hch`^ dqh WM^ઍ dqh WM^ઍ6[Tg`gT
EjJ]gR[g4 &[VE] V!C cphVC ag_g C\g4 7`o^i Io?
Yg^gIOi
cr^4Ci \jE T]h[\gV EjJ]gR[g4 C\r U[6 h` R\r6?
V
ZE`gV ha`o c૮ S9 V]hc4d [do RgVo aoVg Ta6V C]g]\g dRg?
]gc^i^g
Cl@Qh[5 cjTg[gVj4 >C[g5 [4hT] C\g4 7`o^4j Io?
Wr]Y4T]
EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vg4 hcૐ V`^CSgCg] Er`U6V]g[ h5WgNiVr J<[
VhO\gT
C\g4 S\r dRr? h|hMa c4cTVg S[ EjJ]gRi cv\ CrQ dRg4?
TgTgZg9 V`]r!
Ch` 6Dr 6[Tg`gT[g4 C\g4 ]do Rg dRg?
"To Tocg8Vi Wr_, Wr_ DghO\g ઇ
V]hc4doWrRgVg4 WTr[g4 [jL\W`o C\r [g5g[o_ I4T \rJ\r Io?
Kk ^Qg4
EjJ]gR[g4 ToaVj4 csSi [rMj4 aiW|oCE \gO6 C\g4 7`o^j4 Io?
6^4E
EjJ]gRVj4 DViJRo^Vj4 csSi `Uj :WWgTV C]Rj4 ado ] C\j4 Io?
64C^o.]
]iIVr 4 h \ Dr]gC aj4 dr\ Io?
:U8
EjJ]gR[g4 VoaV^ 8< MiS\jM AX XoaV Mo CVr^r!Vi c4 Sg C\g4
Eg4UiVE]
7`o^i Io? ^rS^Vj4 DrTCg[ CrVg [gE6Ta6V ViHo S\j4 dRj?
Oq. Oq. >c. >c. 7]. 7]. ]g`
6[Tg`gT[g4 EjJ]gRVi S[ WૐhRc]Vi M4Cag_ C\g4 ac S8
Cg^jWj]
dRi? Zg]RVi cs S[ [rO6V Og\ MX C4WVi CrQo SgWi?
C Rj]Zg8 ^g^Zg8
EjJ]gRi [k_Vr C\r Do^gOi 84g^o
h`K[ cr^4Ci
YoSc[oV R]iCo ][Rr dRr?
19
V`^CSg ‘Wo]ho ^hcc’Vg ^oDC CrQ Io?
H4^Cg
6[Tg`gTઍ`OrT]g >Cc oc dg9`o C9 cg^[g4 ac S\r?
`b6 ywwz
yw[i cTiVi ac7R[g4 EjJ]gR[g4 C8 BbhUhV[g6Q c4 SgVi
>^oh3YC Coh[C^ `C6 c C4 WVi h^h[Mo O
SgWVg S8 dRi? Hg]o\ `oTrVi Tp`R c4hdRgAVg c4WgTC `oT[khR6 cgR`^oC]Vg Vg[
hCI^g Wg]Oi ંhJ. hJ. `^cgOઉ `^cgOઉ
cgSo JrOg\o^i c4 Sg EjJ]gR[g4 C\g S_o Io? OZr8Vr hCI^r Co M^r ^g4Yr 6Vo Co M^r Wdr_r Io?
>C d&] `g] ^g4Yr 6Vo 7Ncr `g] Wdr_r
EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 cs S[ h`Hg] UgV Ch`RgVr L\g^ CrQo
Y.C. NgCr]
7Y\r? [sV [4hT]Vg SgWC CrQ dRg?
WkJ\ ri [rMg
gClR[g4Si Xo]Xg] Wg[i 7`o^i Zgbg C\g Vg[o A_Dg\ Io?
6W4a
EjJ]gR chdR c[V Toa[g4 Jr`g [_Ri |gQi Co a4C] a[_i
WgQi W]Si
WrRgVr Dr]gC C\g4Si [o_`o Io? EjJ]gRVg Th]\g8 h` Rg][g4 Jr`g [_Ri OkEr4E [gI^iVj4 `JV
yzwSi yzwSi ૯ww hC. hC.Vg. Vg.
7a]o Co M^j4 dr\ Io? :T`gOg[g4 7`o^i C8 6hE\g]i Jr`g^g\C Io?
Wh`5 9]gVar Xg\] Mo3W^
>ha\g[g4 cs S[ X]Ri ]o Mr]
cj]R
EjJ]gRi VgS\C_gVg 7૩hWRg CrQ EQg\ Io?
]QIrO]g\ :T\]g[
`. Ch` ]gB<^ agdVo ywwx[g4 Cg]\બo5o TgV YT^ C\r ro@N
Zg]Ri\ ભgVWiN
Wj] Cg] gYR S\r Io? Ch` Cg
6|gd[ h^4CV
hE] ]g@"i\ :૩gVVi SgWVg C\g]o C]`g[g4 7`i dRi?
8.c. x૯~|
c]Tg] c]r`] h`.Vr C\g V4Y]Vr Cr4hKM Voh`Mi Oo[ Io?
Yi&
EjJ]gR ]gJ\Vi SgWVg WIi C\j4 ado ] WgMVE] Y<\j4?
6[Tg`gT
‘ZgbgVo aj4 `_Eo Zk]’ - >`j4 CrQo Csj4 Io?
ભgVi Ch` 6Dr
6Qdi^Wj] WgMQVi SgWVg CrQo C]i?
`V]gJ Hg`Og
EjJ]gR[g4 Jr`g [_Rg C\g Cg]Vg [lEVj4 YiJj 4 Vg[ Cl@Q [lE Io?
Cg_i\g]
Wh`5 Vg]g\Q c]r`] C\g4 7`o^4j Io?
C I
Moh^ Cr3\jhVCoaV બo5o Zg]R[g4 Kg4hR ^g`Vg] EjJ]gRi CrQ Io?
cg[ hW5rOg
Og4E hJI^g[g4 hTWOg 6Vo hH4Cg]gVg c4]બQ [gMo C\j4 6Z\g]u\
`g4cTg 6Z\g]u\
7`o^4j Io? C8 cg^[g4 Z\gVC Wk] 7``gVo Cg]Qo ^rS^Vr h`Vga S\r dr`gVj4
8.c. Wk`o6 x૯ww 7cWgc
[Vg\ Io? Co RV [do RgVi ]g@"i\ 6Vo 74R]]g@"i\ c<[gV [o_`Vg]i
Z`Vi Z`g8
EjJ]gRi hXI[ C8? Zg]RVg csSi JkVg gQic4Vdg^\ cર]YgE ંJkVgEPઉVi SgWVg
8.c. x૮}z
C8 cg^[g4 C]g8 dRi? EjJ]gR[g4 CoM^g Wબi 6v\g]u\r 7`o^g4 Io?
Wg4H
EjJ]gR[g4Si J ViC_Ri dr\ 6Vo EjJ]gR[g4 J `do Ri dr\ Ro`i
ZgT]
csSi ^g4Yi VTi C9 Io? 79< Mg9VVg cgWoબ`gTVg hcૐg4R W] c4arUV Cg\6 C]Vg]
Oq. Oq. Wi. Wi.ci. ci. `p૩
EjJ]gRi EhQRભVj4 Vg[ JQg`r? 6[Tg`gTVg S[ [o\] YVVg] ]\hCR CrQ dRg?
HiVjZg8 Yo]rVoM
C IVj4 VgVj4 ]Q C\g gQiVj4 6Z\g]u\ Io?
FjOD] ંJ4E^i EUoOg4ઉ
EjJ]gR[g4 c`6 S[ 7\j`6oT Cr^oJVi SgWVg C\g4 6Vo C\g]o S9
WgMQઍ WgMQઍ8.c.x૯yz
dRi? ‘JkV4j Rr S\j4 ]o To`_...’ WT CrVj4 Io?
[i]g4Yg9
20
Eg4Ui!> 7V4Ta4C] ;j`Vi C9 ClhRVo ‘`lૐWrSi’ Cdi Io?
hd
8.c x૯zw[g4 6[Tg`gTSi Co M^g hC.[i. Hg^iVo Tg4OiCkH C]`g[g4
z૮| hC. hC.[i. [i.
7`i dRi? "V]hc4d 6Vo [i]g4 [gMo ‘D]g 9I[i, D]g ak]g’ h`aobQr CrQo
Ch` C^gWi
`gW\g64 Ioઇ? EjJ]gRVg &QiRg Zi^ ^rCEgh\Cg CrQ Io?
hT`g_iYdo V Zi^
EjJ]gR[g4 cs S[ C9 Cr^oJ ac S9?
EjJ]gR Cr^oJઍ6[Tg`gTઍ 6[Tg`gTઍ8.c.x૮૮~
"Erhd^`gOVg4 Cr_i 5iઍWj]jbr dgS[g4 ckWOg4, cg`]Qi, ck4O^g4,
Pr^r ]gQr
Og^g4, cg4Yo^g4 ^9 `Rj6_gCg]o X]iVo C\j VlW\ C]o Ioઇ? 6[Tg`gTVg hcૐ EiRg[4hT]Vi SgWVg CrQo C]i dRi?
`g[i h`૩gV4T!
"‘Jc[g AOQ’, ‘Kk 4Og Kk ^Q’ 6Vo ‘]g& ToFQ’ B`g `oar ^DVg]
6cg9R NgC]
CrQ dRgઇ? EjJ]gR[g4 cs S[ MiHc6 "o8hV4E Cr^oJ CrQo 6Vo C\g4 SgWi?
o[H4T ]g\H4Tઍ6[Tg`gT
cd 5h^4E R_g` CrQo Y4Ug]\j?
hcૐ]gJ J\hc4d
EjJ]gR \jhV`hc6MiVi SgWVg C\g]o S8 dRi?
8.c.x૯{૯
Yg] d&]Si `Uj EjJ]gRi EiRrVg ]Hh\RgVj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
6h`Vga ]\gc
cgY]Cg4NgVg ]do `gci C\g UgV 74; ToaVg E`V6] Y<\g dRg?
Oq. Oq.Co .Co . agd
EjJ]gR[g4 ]CRhWhૈ\gAVi cg]`g] [gMo CrQo !`V c[hW6R
7\]gQi 6[]Yg8 6Vo To`iTgc!
C]i TiUj4 dRj4? C\g EjJ]gRi VoRgVo Zg]RVg `Og UgV YV`gVj4 Ydj [gV [X\j4 dRj4?
[r]g]!Zg9 Tocg9
Cgh^TgcVg ‘6hZભgV agCj
:[ga4C] Jrai
[w\Cg^iV EjJ]gRi Ch` ag[_o C\g cghdW\ `cWVo 6WVg]\j4
W૩`gRg6
dRj4? "Wr]Y4T] hJI^gVg C\g Eg[[g4 riCl@Q, Y^]g[ 6Vo ]j hC[Qi!Vj4
[gU`Wj]
gHiV [4hT] 7`o^j4 Ioઇ? Co _`QiCg] VgVgZg8 Zુo SgWo^i ^rCZg]RiઍcQrc]g c4 Sg C\g
Zg`VE]
hJI^g[g4 7`o^i Io?
hcૐ [^g` R_g` EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4 7`o^4j Io?
Ur_Cg
h`.Vi csSi [rMi h]Xg9V]i EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4 7`o^i Io?
&[VE]
`g4CgVo][g4 C\r ]gJ`i [do ^ 7`o^r Io?
]QhJRh`^g
6Og^JVi `g` CrQo 6Vo C\g `b6[g4 YVg`i dRi?
]gQi cOgYg8 ઍ 8.c.x{~~
TkUcgE] Oo ]i C\g4 7`o^i Io?
[do cgQg
Cg_r Oj4 E] EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4 7`o^r Io?
C I
dg^Vr cs]g@"Vr h` Rg] gHiV c[\[g4 C\g Vg[o A_DgRr
cj]g@"
dRr? EjJ]gRi [hd^g [g^g hHVr\Vo C\g બo5[g4 TgV 7W`g YT^
RYiYi બo5o
hRh@NR "o8^ |oK] >`rO6 7W`g[g4 7]\r Io? EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 ‘Z`g9c4Vd’ Vg[Vr V4S CrQo c4WghTR C\r6 Io?
[hdWR]g[ Vi^C4 N
6[Tg`gTVr Z^Vr hCI^r CrQo YVg]\r dRr?
cj^RgV 6d[Tagd
VoaV^ Oo ]i Oo `^W[o
7Q4T
[hQ^g^ hf``oTiVi ‘Ej^gYhc4d’ C9 64Vo! V`^CSgVr Zg`gVj`gT
^qO6 h^MVVi ઍ‘Ko KoVrVi’ rVi
Io? MoY^ MohVc[g4 EjJ]gRVr V4Y] x Do^gOi CrQ Io?
WhSC [do Rg
hMYWQi VlW\ cs]g@"Vg C\g h` Rg]Vj4 &QiRj4 VlW\ Io?
Hr]`gO
Eg4Ui!Vj4 6[Tg`gT[g4 7`o^ hV`gc SgVVj4 Vg[ aj4 dRj?
{T\ Cj4 J
Zg]RVo 7KgTi [X\g YgT cr[VgS [4hT]Vr hJQr6wUg] CrQo C\r6?
c]Tg] `I^ZZg8 WMo ^
Cl@Qh[5 cjTg[gVj4 >C[g5 [4hT] C\g4 7`o^4j Io?
Wr]Y4T]
21
7d`g C\g hJI^gVj4 [jL\ [SC Io?
Og4E
[dgEjJ]gR H_`_ [gMo [dgEjJ]gR JVRg Wh]bTVi SgWVg
"cYMo cYMo 3Y], Y] 9. c.x૯|} ઇ
C\g]o S8? ‘] Ro ZMCRr ag\]’ Wj RCVg ^oDC CrQ Io?
aoDgT[ 7Yj`g^g
EjJ]gRi Zgbg[g4 JERVr 9hRdgc ^D`gVr S[ \WV CrQo C\r6
Ch` V[6T
Io? ‘NrN hVag_i\r’> લg ^oDCVj4 :WVg[ Io?
YCj^ h5WgNi
CVp\g^g^ [gQoC^g^ [jVai> C\g4 6Vo C\g]o ]gJ\Wg^ R]iCo
":ૈ] :ૈ] Toa, x૯|y Si x૯|~ ઇ
co`g 7Wi dRi? CrVi 7Eo`gVi do N_ `OrT]g ado ][g4 C^gZ`VVi SgWVg S8
h5Zj`VTgc EJJ]
dRi? CgCgcgdo Y Cg^o^C]o ^Do^ ‘!`VVr 7V4T’ 6Vo ‘]DO`gVr
^h^R hVY4U
7V4T’ V4SVr cghdW\ Cg] JQg`r? ‘hc4dgcV Y5ici’ CrVi ClhR Io?
][Q^g^ crVi
E][ CgWO :૩rE[g4 cs]g@"Vr C\r hJI^r [rD]o Io?
&[VE]
`R45 EjJ]gR ]gJ\[g4 W4Hg\Ri ]gJ C\g]Si 6[^[g4 7]\j4?
"x x >h ^, >h ^ x૯}z ઇ
C I hJI^g[g4 C\j4 ]Q 7`o^4j Io?
S]Wg]C]Vj4 ]Q
‘[T6 RodVj4 Vg[...’ - 7 W4hCR CrQo ^Di Io?
Ch` V[6T
EjJ]gR[g4 C\g S_oSi `g RjC^gVg hV\[r [gQo ^gCOgVj4
cr[VgS
CrR]Cg[ [_i 7]\j4 Io? EjJ]gRVr Do^gOi 74R]]g@"i\ બo5o hchૐ gYR C]o W\g]o RoVo
>C^]\ `rO6
C\r >`rO6 7W`g[g4 7`o Io? h`h`U ]4E U]g`Rg dr`gVo Cg]Qo hT`g_iFrOg WબiAVo C I[g4 aj4
Dh5\gQi
Vg[ 7W`g[g4 7]\j4 Io? Eg4Ui!> ]gJCrMVi C8 ag_g[g4 6v\gc C\r6 dRr?
c] 7IyoO dg9 Ck^
^i^i Wh]K[gVr [o_r EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4 Z]g\ Io?
hE]Vg] W`6RVi R_oMiં iંZ`VgSઉ Z`VgSઉ[g4
c4 ClR 6^4Cg] ag 5Vr cj hcૐ V4S ‘Cg]\ઍ[i[g4cg’ C8 h^hW[g4
Wg4Ojh^hW
CghaR S\r Io? Yg] d&]Si `Uj EjJ]gRi EiRrVg ]Hh\RgVj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
6h`Vga ]\gc
EjJ]gRVr C\r Toa csSi dh]\g_r Io?
ThબQ EjJ]gR
h`VrTiVi Vi^C4 NVi C8 `gRg6 W]Si xz >`rO6 !RVg]i hXI[ YVi
CgaiVr TiC]r
dRi? ‘]hcC `I^Z’ ClhRVg4 CRg6V4j Vg[ aj4 Io?
Ch` T\g]g[
Oq. YgYgcgdo Y 74YoOC] AWV \jhV`hc6MiVi SgWVg C\g]o S8?
8.c.x૯૯~
" ‘J_ C[_ Ig4Oi &Vo Yg_, `g[i 6[g]r &Eao...’ - 7 C\g
ZCR Ch` V]hc4d [do Rg
Ch`Vi ]HVg Ioઇ? haબQ બo5o WrRgVj4 6[kI\ TgV 7Wi ]do ^i c]Tg] WMo^
`I^Z h`૩gVE]
\jhV`hc6Mi C\g4 7`o^i Io? "EjJ]gR ]gJ\Vr C\r h` Rg] EiH J4E^r, h`h`U &hRVg
Og4E
`<\!`r, 7hT`gci c4 ClhR Ro[J 6TZkR CjT]Ri cgT\6Vo Cg]Qo 6<\ Toar C]Rg4 6^E R]i 7`o Ioઇ? 9O]Vg ]g& ]Q[I^Vg4 !`V W] 7Ugh]R C9 ClhR ]Hg9 Io?
]Q[I^ I4T
‘EjJ]gR 9Cr^r! Ch[aV’ C\g ado ][g4 7`o^j4 Io?
`OrT]g
h`L\gR Bc^ઍRr]^Vi c[ghU C I hJI^g[g4 C\g4 Io?
64&]
CC6 `lૈ EjJ]gRVg Co M^g hJI^g[g4Si Wcg] Sg\ Io?
Hg]
EjJ]gR[g4 Wdo ^i [o Vr hT`c C\g hT`c R]iCo :J`g\ Io?
EjJ]gR SgWVghTV
Zi^rVg ;WCb6 [gMo x૯yy[g4 ‘Zi^ co`g [4O_’Vi SgWVg CrQo C]i
Nર]YgWg
22
dRi? EjJ]gRVr C\r ]gJhC\ઍcg4 ClhRC h` Rg] ‘7hT`gci Wુg’ R]iCo
hVbgT
A_Dg\ Io? [gઍYgWVo Zk^ar Vhd ઍ ZJVVi ]HVg CrQo C]i dRi?
c4R WjhVR [dg]gJ
Yi.>[ 9h< MS\kM @X [o
Oq. Oq. h`K[ cg]gZg8
EjJ]gRVj4 Wdo ^j4 Wj RCg^\ C\j4 Io?
di[gZg8 8< MiS\jM
Ch` Zi[ CrVg ha@\ dRg?
Ch` Zg^Q
]QKhQ\j4 6Vo WJhQ\j4 `EgOiVo VgHRg4 EgRg4 7hT`gci JrOCg
ag[_g!Vg [o_g[g4
Jr`gVr Idg`r C\g [o_g[g4 [_o Io? EjJ]gR[g4 C I hc`g\Vg h` Rg]r[g4 Jr`g [_Rj4 Cr\^Cj_Vj4 Wબi
Widg
YWp\r Yi& C\g Vg[Si A_Dg\ Io? ha\g_g[g4 6[Tg`gT hJI^gVg C\g S_o ywwSi `Ug]o &hRVg
V_ c]r`]
h`Toai WબiA csVj4 7Cb6QVj4 Co <^ YVo Io? EjJ]gRVg C\g 7hT Ch`Vi ]HVgA Cl@QZhCRVg ]4Eo ]4Eg\o^i
V]hc4d [do Rg
Jr`g [_o Io? EjJ]gRVj4 C\j4 S_ xwwwSi `Uj [4hT]rVr c[kd U]g`o Io?
Wgh^RgQg
EjJ]gR[g4 S[ MoબMg9^ [i^Vg SgWC CrQ dRg?
]QIrO^g^ IrMg^g^
`. Ch` ]gB<^ agdVo ywwx[g4 Cg]\બo5o TgV YT^ C\r ro@N
Zg]Ri\ ભgVWiN
Wj] Cg] gYR S\r Io? EjJ]gRVj4 C\j4 S_ ‘hd4 TVj4 Yg]j 4’ R]iCo &QiRj4 dRj4?
D4ZgR
CgHYg ઍ CgHYiVg4 &QiRg ZJVVg ]Hh\Rg CrQ Io?
Ch` Zr& ZER
`oUag_gVi SgWVg C\g4 6Vo C\g]o S8?
6[Tg`gTઍ 6[Tg`gTઍ8.c.x૯{~
ri]4E 6`UkR [dg]gB C8 Zgbg[g4 Wj RCr ^L\g4 Io?
"[]gNi []gNi, []gNi EjJ]gRi 6Vo c4 ClR ઇ
c4R Fr]g ZERVg WTr C\g Vg[Si &QiRg dRg?
CgXi
Zg]Ri\ hKCo M Mi[[g4 csSi VgVi `\o SgV Wg[Vg] h`Co M CiW]ઍ
WghS6` WMo^
YoSc[oVVj4 Vg[ JQg`r? 7KgTi YgT Zg]R[g4 cs S[ h`h^V SVg] ]J`gOgVj4 Vg[ aj4
Zg`VE]
dRj4? ‘`gOiAVg hJI^g’ R]iCo EjJ]gRVr C\r hJI^r L\gR Io?
`^cgO
EjJ]gRi `pભghVC Zg]R[g4 6`Cgai c4arUVVg QoRg EQg\ Io?
Oq. Oq. h`K[ cg]gZg8
"cgM 6arC, [dgબ5W ]j ^Tg[g 6Vo C
W4. ZE`gV^g^ 8<^!
ha^g^oDrVg `gHVVi ajwU R Rp\g] C]`gVj4 [gV CrVo Xg_o Ioઇ? f`g]CgVj4 [4hT] C8 VTiVg Cg4Ng :W] 7`o^4j Io?
Er[Ri VTi
`b6 yww| [gMo EjJ]gRVg C\g Do^gOiVo ‘]g!` Eg4Ui Do^]WV
W4CJ 6O`gQi
>`rO6 ’ >Vg\R S\r dRr? [g DrhO\g]Vg Vg[ W]Si C9 VTi :W] Y4U Yg4U`g[g4 7]\r Io?
ao5j4!
7agWj]g [gRgVr [P C\g4 7`o^r Io?
C I
[dgW[g Eg4UiVi 7W[CSgVj4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
cW\Vg \rEr
EjJ]gR ]gJ\Vi [jL\ Zgbg C8 Io?
EjJ]gRi
B ]HVg[g4 Cr9 [dgV ?hRdghcC ]\hCRVj4 Hh]5 7^oDg\j4 dr\
Y4U
RoVo aj4 Cdo Io? CrVg Vg[o dp ^gYgT[g4 VoaV^ Wrh^c >Co O[i Io?
c]Tg] `I^ZZg8 WMo ^
Z`g9[g4 ZgE ^oVg] C^gCg]r C\g Vg[o A_Dg\ Io?
Z`p\g
V`g ]Hg\o^g V[6Tg hJI^gVj4 `Oj4 [SC C\j4 Io?
]gJWiW_g
D4OCg]\Vj4 cxV cs S[ CrQo C\j46 dr`gVj4 [Vg\ Io?
Ch` Cg
XCR WrRo YVg`o^g [g_gA[g4 J 7]g[ X][g`i aCRj4 Wબi C\j4
CgVChO\g
Io?
23
`g[i 7V4To WrRgVg !`VFOR][g4 Xg_r 7WVg] W]gK[i
Cj_CSgA
ZghM\g 5iWj]jbrVg4 Hh]5r C\g V4S[g4 ] \g4 Io? [dgTo`Zg8 Tocg8Vj4 !`VHh]5 ‘6hgVCj4O[g4 ;Eo^j4 Ej^gY’ Vg
Vg]g\Q Tocg8
^oDC CrQ Io? ‘ZE`gVVr ZgE’Vg cxC CrQ Io?
][oa Wg]oD
7ag`^ CrQo !Ri ^oRg RoVj4 Vg[ CQg6`Ri ]gD`g[g4 7]\j4?
CQ6To` cr^4Ci
`g[i T\gV4T c] `RiVr J<[ C\g4 S\r dRr?
M4Cg]g ંhJ. hJ. ]gJCrMઉ ]gJCrMઉ
EjJ]gR[g4 CoM^i &hRVg `<\ c RV gQiA Vr4Ug\g Io?
xw~ &hRVg
VoXg9MVg :WWgTV[g4 EjJ]gR ]gJ\ Zg]R[g4 C\g K[o Io?
5i&
7 MrhO\g Vg[ C\g Zi^ ]g&Vi \gT 6Wg`o Io?
7ag Zi^
EjJ]gRVj4 >C[g5 di^ Mo aV C\j4 Io?
cgWjRg]g
‘EjJ]gRVr RW `i’ Cg]\ CrQo ^L\j4 Io?
Ch`
&[V][g4 C\r Ydj doRjC Oo[ 7`o^r Io?
]QhJRcgE] Oo [
EjJ]gRi cghdW\ Wh]bTVg SgWC CrQ dRg?
]QhJR]g[ `g`gZg8
EjJ]gR ]gJ\Vg S[ 7hT`gci [jL\[45i CrQ dRg?
6[]hc4d HsU]i
akhM4 E[g4 :WCl@M ToDg` C]iVo 6JjV 6 >`rO6 gYR C]Vg]
:T\V HiVjZg8
EjJ]gRVg S[ Do^gOi CrQ Io? 6[Tg`gT[g4 7`o^g 74R]]g@"i\ CબgVg hKCoM MohO\[Vj4 Vg[ aj4
[rMo]g Mo hO\[
Io? Og4E hJI^g[g4 C\j4 hcૐ hE]i[SC 7`o^4j Io?
cgWjRg]g
Rg]4Eg C\g U[6Vj4 &QiRj4 RiS6 S_ Io?
V
EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vg h`ha@M C^g `cW 7L\gVVo FgM C\g
Ch` o[gV4T
[dgCh`> 7Y\r? >ha\g[g4 cs S[ X]Ri ]o Mr]
cj]R
WgajWR U[6Vg SgWCVj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
^Cj^oa!
C`
IrMg ;ToWj]
6Qdi^Wj] WgMQVi SgWVg CrQo C]i?
`V]gJ Hg`Og
dh_Wj5 >3|r9O]i [gMo C IVj4 C\j4 S_ hcૐ Io?
drOCg
]Q! "rXi C\g ]gJ`i hKCoM]Vg Vg[Si ][g\ Io?
&[ ]Q!Rhc4d
Er4O^[g4 7`o^g 6Vo WrRgVi SgWW\hC\ ]HVgVo Cg]Qo &QiRg
V`^Dg [do ^
[do ^Vj4 Vg[ 7Wr? Z`g8Vg 7૩hWRg 6cg8R NgC] C8 cTi[g4 S8 E\g?
x|[i x|[i cTi
Ch` Cg
6|gd[ h^4CV
D4ZgRVg 6DgR[g4 C\r YoM 7`o^ Io?
6h^\gYoM
C IVj4 C\j4 ado ] cjOi 6Vo I]iઍHYWg :૩rE [gMo &QiRj4 Io?
64&]
Ch` T\g]g[Vg cxV[g4 csSi `Ug]o C8 ClhRA Jr`g [_o Io?
E]Yi
EjJ]gR h`UgVcZgVg S[ 6w\બ CrQ dRg?
CI\gQ `i. `i. [do Rg
‘DrYr Z]iVo 6[o >M^j4 d Hg Co Ck`r Z]iVo 6[o ]r8 WG\g’
JETia Jrai
EiRVg ^oDC CrQ Io? ag[_Vj4 Vr4UWg5 TgV C\g cghdW\ Cg][g4 Io?
W૩`gRg6
EjJ]gRVg S[ :Tk6 EK^Cg] CrQ Io?
`^i EjJ]gRi
B૩rhEC h`CgcVi Tlh@M> EjJ]gR[g4 C\j4 S_ MrH W] Io?
64C^o.]
c]Tg] c]r`] \rJVgVr ha^g<\gc CrVg d Ro S\r dRr?
W4hOR J`gd]^g^ Vdo c
Ch` Zi[ CrVg ha@\ dRg?
Ch` Zg^Q
EjJ]gR Zg]R[g4 C8 hTag> 7`o^j4 Io?
Wh`[
V`^Di Y4T] C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^j4 Io?
&[VE]
cIRVRCg_Vg 9hRdgcVi [gQZkR 7WRg Cg
Wi]r&ઍ Wi]r&ઍ`i][To
24
o[CdgQi 7^oDg9 Io?
`R45 EjJ]gR ]gJ\[g4 W4Hg\Ri ]gJ C\g]Si 6[^[g4 7]\j4?
"x x >h ^, >h ^ x૯}z ઇ
hcTiAVj4 VlW\ C\g Vg[Si A_Dg\ Io?
U[g^ VlW\
Zg]Ri\ Mi^ :૩rEVg QoRg J[aoT! MgMgVr J<[ C\g4 S\r
V`cg]i
dRr? EjJ]gRVg C\g hJI^g[g4 cgE Wj@C_ [gQ[g4 Sg\ Io?
Og4E
Ch` V[6TVg [V[r! `Zg`Vo Cg]Qo Ro[Vo h[5r C\g Vg[o
^g^g!
Yr^g`Rg4? 6[Tg`gT[g4 cs S[ hS\oM]Vi SgWVg CrQo C]i dRi?
OgsgZg8 K`o]i
h|hMa c4cTVg S[ EjJ]gRi cv\ CrQ dRg4?
TgTgZg9 V`]r!
Wg`gEP W`6R :W] C\g [gRg!Vj4 SgVC Io?
[dgCg_i
EjJ]gR[g4 Wo"rh^\[ \jhV`hc6Mi C\g4 7`o^i Io?
Eg4UiVE]
C IVr h^gVg9M W] 7Ugh]R `iJ_i rBCM C\g4 7`o^r Io?
Wg<;r
Eg4Ui!Vg V8 Rg^i[ haબQ h`Hg]Vg RWW`r cs S[ C\g
CrNg]i Ch[aV Ch[aV ંx૯}{ ઍ }}ઉ }}ઉ
Ch[aVVi Z^g[Q[g4 Jr`g [X\g dRg? ‘JkV4j Rr S\j4 ]o To`_...’ WT CrVj4 Io?
[i]g4Yg9
EjJ]gR ]gJ\Vg :TFgMC CrQ dRg?
]h`a4C] [dg]gJ
EjJ]gRi ZgbgVi S[ 7W[CSg CrQo ^Di?
V[6T
EjJ]gRi cghdW\ Wh]bTVg S[ [jD CrQ dRg?
Er`U6V]g[ h5WgNi
EjJ]gRVi gHiV VTi .`Ri 7UjhVC Cg_[g4 C\g Vg[o
cgY][Ri
A_Dg\ Io? 6[Tg`gT[g4 ]g\Wk] Wgco C\g `g8c]r\ W] Yr4Y XC`g[g4 7]\r
^rO6 [i
dRr? C\g c4TZ6V4S[g4Si EjJ]gRVr 8hRdgc [_o Io?
Y4U hHRg[Qi 6Vo h[]gRo hcC4T]i
EjJ]gR[g4Si Wcg] SRr csSi `Uj ]\ R VoaV^ dg9`o C\r Io?
VoaV^ dg9`o ઍ V4. ૮
C I[g4 C\g Oj4E]Vj4 haD] csSi ;4H4j Io?
Cg_r Oj4 E]
C4 O^gSi WNgQCrM JRr ]g@"i\ ]gJ[gE6 C\r Io?
]g@"i\ ]gJ[gE6 V4. x|
ThબQ 7hyCg[g4 Eg4Ui!> C\j4 cg[gh\C ac C\j46 dRj4?
9h
ri 6બ]Wj]brૈ[ c4 SgVj4 `Oj4 [SC C\g4 7`o^ Io?
YrHgcQ
6[Tg`gT ado ]Vr Z^Vr hCI^r C\g]o Y4Ug\r?
8.c.x{xx
EjJ]gRVi cs S[ Cr[c6 Cr^oJVj4 Vg[ 7Wr?
>H. >H.>^. >^. Cr[c6 Cr^oJઍ6[Tg`gT ઍ 8.c.x૯z~
‘EjJ]gRVi 6h [Rg’ a}TVr cs S[ \rE C]Vg] EjJ]gRi
CVp\g^g^ [jVai
^oDCVj4 Vg[ JQg`r? [VjZg9 h5`oTi C\g RDI^jcSi h`L\gR Y<\g?
EghX^
EjJ]gRVg Th]\g8 h` Rg][g4 Jr`g [_Ri OkEr4E [gI^iVj4 `JV
yzwSi yzwSi ૯ww hC. hC.Vg. Vg.
7a]o Co M^j4 dr\ Io? EjJ]gRVg WબiA h`aoVi h` RlR &QCg]i 7WRj4 Wj RC
૩j[V C4 HV]g\ Tocg8
‘WબiJER’ CrQo ^L\j4 Io? Hoc[g4 EjJ]gRVo 74R]]g@"i\ R]o Vg[Vg 6Wg`Vg] Do^gOiVj4
RoJc YgC]o
Vg[ aj4 Io? V]hc4d [do RgSi ac S\o^g \jEVo C\g \jE R]iCo A_D`g[g4
ZhCR\jE
7`o Io? [4!]gVlW\ > Zg_Cg4Ng[g4 `cRg C\g ^rCrVj4 h`ha@M ^rCVlW\ Io?
W4Pg]
C\g SWhR> ZjJVg gE [do ^Vi hOKg9V Rp\g] C]i dRi?
[oC^o
EjJ]gR[g4 C\r Toa ^i^i VgFo] Vg[o &QiRr Io?
Hr]`gOઍ Hr]`gOઍ`o]g`_
ri cr[VgS c4 ClR \jhV`hc6MiVi SgWVg C\g4 6Vo C\g]o S8?
`o]g`_ઍ g`_ઍ8.c.yww૮
EjJ]gRVj4 ;g4E;g Eg[ agVg :WWgTV [gMo &QiRj4 Io?
]oRi\g W~S]
25
EjJ]gR[g4 csSi [rMr YrMohVC^ EgO6 V C\g4 7`o^r Io?
`F8
6[Tg`gT 3\jhVhcWg^iMiVg4 c`6 S[ Zg]Ri\ [jD CrQ dRg4?
]g`YdgTj] ]QIrO^g^ IrMg^g^
ri]4E 6`UkR [dg]gB C\g ZE`gVVi ZhCRVr Hg] C\r6 Io?
Tૈ ZE`gV
hd4 T IrOr H_`_Vg S[ EjJ]gRi adiT CrQ dRg?
:[gCg
[dgW[g Eg4UiVg 7w\ghW[C [gE6Ta6C CrQ dRg?
ri[Tt ]gJH4^
Ch`
o[ZhCR
HocVi ][R[g4 hXOo]ohM4E [o_`Vg] h`.Vr csSi VgVi `\Vr
RiC Wg]oD
EjJ]gRVr Do^gOi CrQ dRr? 7Hg\6 7V4Ta4C] ;j`o C9 \jhV`hc6Mi[g4 :WCj^WhR R]iCo dr્r
`g]gQci hd
c4ZgX\r dRr?
S[ EjJ]gRi <\g\[khR6 CrQ dRg4?
VgVgZg9 dh]Tgc
EjJ]gRVj4 DViJRo^Vj4 csSi `Uj :WWgTV C]Rj4 ado ] C\j4 Io?
64C^o.]
EjJ]gRVj4 ]gJ\ `lબ C\j4 Io?
74Yr
EjJ]gRVg4 C\g4 VE]r ha\g_g[g4 csSi `Uj N4 Oi 6Vo ;Vg_g[g4
N4 Oiઍ OiઍVh^\g 6Vo E][iઍ E][iઍcg
csSi `Uj E][i WOo Io? crhVC [j^RgVi C8 ][R &QiRr Do^gOi Io?
VjC]
6cdCg] 74Tr^V `DRo 8
WkVgVi \]`Og B^
]sg dRg? EjJ]gR[g4 cs S[ ]ohO\r Co <^ CrQo ac C]g]\j4?
[dg]g& c\g!]g` Eg\C`gOઍ Eg\C`gOઍ`OrT]g
DiJOi\gVj Wબi 6Z\g]u\ C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^4j Io?
&[VE]
C\g EjJ]gRi DEr_ag 5iVo 6[o]iCV DEr_ h`ભgV c4 Sg
Oq. Oq. :Wo<^ Tocg8
‘Vgcg’[g4 Cg[ C]`gVj4 csZgg\ gYR S\j4 dRj4? ;g4E;gVr ]oRi DOC C8 ]iRo :W\rE[g4 ^o`g\ Io?
9[g]Ri W~S] R]iCo
cr^4Ci `4aVg hcૐ ]gJ`i hcૐ]gJ J\hc4dVg agcVCg_[g4 CrVo
do [H4^gHg\6
‘Ch^ Cg^ c`6ભ’Vj4 hY]j T gYR S\j4 dRj4? Zg]RVj4 cs S[ Th]\g8 :૩gV C\j4 Io?
&[VE] Th]\g8 ]g@"i\ :૩gV
>^oC Co h[C^ `C6 c C4 WVi h^h[MoOVi SgWVg CrVi cdg\Si S8
h5Zj`VTgc EJJ]
dRi? C8 \rJVg f`g]g EjJ]gR[g4 [dૈ[ Vg[h`Cgc S\r Io?
ErCj^Vg[ \rJVg
"EjJ]gRVg C\g c4 ClR Ch`Vg cxV[g4 Cgh^TgcVi :W[g, Tg4OiVj4
[dgCh` [gF
WT^gh^W\ RSg Zg]h`Vj4 6S6Es]` Jr`g [_o Ioઇ? RgWi VTiVj4 7E[V EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4Si Sg\ Io?
d]QXg_
C\g ]gJ`iVg agcVVo EjJ]gRVr cj`Q6\jE EQ`g[g4 7`o Io?
hcૐ]gJ J\hc4d
6hd4 7Wo^i hd4 Ti Cg]\]HVg[g4Si C8 ClhR 6DgVi VSi?
V]hc4d [gs]r
`gR4WÁ\ coVgVi a\g[! Cl@Q `[g6> ^4OV[g4 SgWo^ h`૩gSi6
9h
Ig5g^\Vj4 Vg[ 7Wr? >^oCKg
EjJ]gR `Vg6C\j^] crcgMi
c4 SgVi SgWVg C]i? [w\Cg^iV EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vg4 :bgCg_o S[ []Qi\ Vg[ CrVj4
do [H4^gHg\6
^o`g\ Io? `Ug6[g4 Eg4Ui!> C\r 7r[ SgY\r dRr?
co`gVg[ 7r[
EjJ]gRVr >C[g5 Th]\ghCVg]r B HkVgVi Mo C]iASi Fo]g\o^r Io
ErWVgS
RoV4j Vg[ aj4? 6WQg6 WrWM C8 ][R cgSo c4C_g\o^g [hd^g Do^gOi Io?
YoOh[
Ch` C^gWiVj4 Wj]j4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
cj]hc4d! RLRhc4d! Erhd^
EjJ]gR[g4 S[ ` Ri EQR]i C\g]o S8?
8.c. x૮~y
:aVct C\g Ch`Vj4 ;WVg[ Io?
VM`]^g^ W4O\g
26
Zg]Ri\ `g[VCg\ IIk 4T] EjJ]gRVg C\g h` Rg][g4 `co Io?
C IVr ]Q h` Rg]
SgWW\Vr :ૈ[ V[kVr >`r 6[Tg`gTVr Z^Vr hCI^r Yg4U`g[g4
~ `b6
CoM^g `b6 ^gg\g dRg? J\g4 cjUi EjJ]gRi ZgbgVo Es]` Vdi 4 [_o W\g4 cjUi WgFOi Vdi 4
[dg Ch` o[gV4T
Wdo ]j 4. ઍ 7`i hRભg CrQo ^iUi dRi? Tg:Ti `r]gAVj4 :ૈ] EjJ]gR[g4 7`o^j4 RiS6 S_ C\j4 Io?
To^[g^
Ch` ‘cj4T][t’Vj4 [k_ Vg[ aj4 Io?
h5Zj`VTgc Wj]jbrૈ[Tgc ^jdg]
EjJ]gR ]gJ\Vg cs S[ [jL\[45i CrQ dRg?
Oq. Oq. !`]gJ [do Rg
CgHYg ઍ CgHYiVg4 &QiRg ZJVVg ]Hh\Rg CrQ Io?
Ch` Zr& ZER
[d3[T YoEOg> &[g [h JT C\g4 Y4Ug`i dRi?
Wg`gEP 6Vo Hg4WgVo]
V RiS6 S_ Wgh^RgQg C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^4j Io?
Zg`VE]
RgWi VTiVj4 7E[V EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4Si Sg\ Io?
d]QXg_
C\g EjJ]gRi DEr_ag 5iVo 6[o]iCV DEr_ h`ભgV c4 Sg
Oq. Oq. :Wo<^ Tocg8
‘Vgcg’[g4 Cg[ C]`gVj4 csZgg\ gYR S\j4 dRj4? `V WhRVg c4`U6V 6Vo c4arUV [gMo EjJ]gR[g4 csSi [rMr
`F9
YrMohVC^ EgO6V C\g4 7`o^r Io? MoY^ MohVc[g4 EjJ]gRVr V4Y] x Do^gOi CrQ Io?
WhSC [do Rg
EjJ]gR[g4 .oR Kg4hRVg QoRg CrVo EQ`g[g4 7`o Io?
Oq. Oq. `Ei6c Cjh]\V
EjJ]gRVg &QiRg Zi^ ^rCEgh\Cg CrQ Io?
hT`g_iYdo V Zi^
`OrT]g ado ][g4Si C8 VTi `do Io?
h`.gh[5i
C\g ha`[4hT][g4 V]hc4d [do RgVo ‘]gcTa6V’ S\g dRg?
gEPઉ ErWVgS [dgTo` ંJkVgEPઉ
"‘UrYiVr CkR]r, Vdi 4 F]Vr Co Vdi 4 FgMVr’ Cdo `RVg ]Hh\Rg CrQ
ag[_ Zુ
Ioઇ? ZE`gV ha`Vg Co M^g4 6Vo C\g J\rhRh^64E EjJ]gR[g4 7`o^g Io?
Yo ઍ cr[VgS 6Vo Tg]j Cg`V
EjJ]gRi dg \cghdW\Vg ‘dg \ cgM’ Vj4 hYcT CrVo [X\j4 Io?
J\rRi<^ d. d. T`o
EjJ]gRVi S[ ag]ih]C haબQVi c4 Sg C8 Io?
IrMjZg8 Wj]gQi ]\g\g[ [dgh`૩g^\
CYi]W4Si c4Rr C\g Vg[Si A_Dg\ Io?
cgdo Y
`R45 EjJ]gR ]gJ\ [o_``g [gMo S\o^i [dgEjJ]gRVi H_`_Vr
x૯|} Si x૯}w
c[\ JQg`r? TrઍdT a}T C\g ado ]Vg Vg[ cgSo c4C_g\o^r Io?
TgdrT
"R]Qg ASo Oj4E] ]o, Oj4E] Cr9 ToDo Vdi’ 4 - B`i cj4T] ]HVgVg
Ch` Ui]r
]Hh\RgVj4 Vg[ JQg`rઇ? V`]gh5 T]3\gV Vr[Vg hT`co WI^iVr ;Wc` C\g4 ;J``g[g4 7`o
cWg^
Io? [sV [4hT]Vg SgWC CrQ dRg?
WkJ\ ri [rMg
EjJ]gRVg4 Eg[r[g4 Hr`ic C^gC h`J_i C8 \rJVg do N_
J\rhRVg[ \rJVg
7W`g[g4 7`o Io? EjJ]gR[g4 cs S[ cjR]: CgWOVi [i^Vi SgWVg CrQo C]i?
]QIrO^g^ IrMg^g^
‘CIWck5’Vj4 c4WgTV CrQo C\j64?
UVo.]ckh]
6Tg`gT[g4 cs S[ hS\oM]Vi SgWVg CrQo C]i dRi?
OgsgZg8 K`o]i
a4C]gHg\o6f`g]Cg[g4 SgWo^r [N C\g Vg[o A_Dg\ Io?
ag]TgWiN
"‘R[o Z^o TkY_g4 dr, WQ Cg_Jj 4 `gF 6Vo hc4dVj4 ]gDr’ >`j4
c]Tg] `I^ZZg8 WMo ^
Cdo Vg] VoRg CrQ dRg4ઇ? [jF^ cggJ\ T]3\gV EjJ]gRVg [jL\ Y4T] R]iCo ]do ^g ado ]Vj4
cj]R
Vg[ JQg`r? dg \ cghdW\Vi h` RlR h``oHVg cs S[ CrQo C]i?
][QZg8 Vi^C4 N
ha\g_g[g4 6[Tg`gT hJI^gVg C\g S_o ywwSi `Ug]o &hRVg
V_ c]r`]
27
h`Toai WબiA csVj4 7Cb6QVj4 Co <^ YVo Io? EjJ]gRVg C\g hJI^g[g4 cgE Wj@C_ [gQ[g4 Sg\ Io?
Og4E
ToaZ][g4 7hC6MoCMVg 6v\gc [gMo &QiRi ‘CEPT’ Vi SgWVg
6[Tg`gT 8. 8.c.x૯}z
C\g4 6Vo C\g]o S8? EjJ]gRVj4 csSi [rMj4 c]r`] V_ c]r`] Co M^g h` Rg][g4 Xo^g\o^j4
x૮} Hr. Hr. hC. hC.[i. [i.
Io? 6JjV 6 >`rO6 gYR C]Vg] EjJ]gRi [hd^g YoOh[
6WQg6 WrWM WrWM
CrQ Io?
S[ EjJ]gRi cgYRghdC ‘ri [j4[Y8Vg c[gHg]’ CrQo CghaR
XTj6V! [K6YgV
C\j6? Eg4Ui!> Tg4OiCkH C\g 6<\g\i Cg\TgVg Z4E C]`gVg 7a\Si
[iNg
C]i dRi? ZkJVg ZkhJ\g hCI^g[g4 C\j4 gHiV [4hT] 7`o^j4 Io?
ZjJE 4 [4hT]
Wj]gQr[g4 EjJ]gRVi C9 VTiVo ‘E4Eg’ Vg[ 7W`g[g4 7`o^4j Io?
hd]u\g
dૄWi\ c4 ClhR> TjhV\gVo 7Wo^i Yo h`aob ZoM JQg`r?
VE] 7\rJV 6Vo EM] ]\` Sg
EjJ]gRVi Wk`i6\ c]dT W] Xo ^g\o^i 6]`I^i W`6R[g_g 6Vo
Wg`gEP
h`4w\ W`6R[g_gVj4 h[^V C\g S_o Sg\ Io? ZkTgV H_`_Vg QoRg h`VrYgZg`o CrVg 7w\ghW[C `g]cTg]
Eg4Ui!
EQg\ Io? h`ભgVબo5o EjJ]gR c]Cg] R]XSi C\r [dW`WkQ6 Wj] Cg]
Oq. Oq. h`K[ cg]gZg8 Wj] Cg]
7W`g[g4 7`o Io? 6[Tg`gTVg >h^ch|JVg SWhR CrQ dRg?
]g` YdgTj] hd4 [R^g^ Ui]J]g[
7KgTiVi H_`_ T]h[\gV EjJ]gR[g4 S\o^r S[ cW\gVd
DoOg cW\gVd
C\r? YVgcCg4NgVj4 ^rCVlW\ C\g Vg[o A_Dg\ Io?
[r]g\r
EjJ]gR[g4 cgબ]Rg T] CoM^r Io?
~૯. ~૯.૮ MCg
7\6c[gJVi SgWVg C]Vg] EjJ]gRi c[gJcjUg]C c4R CrQ
`g[i T\gV4T c] `Ri
dRg? 7hT`gciAVr h5Vo5o.] [o_r agVg [gMo L\gR Io?
`\4`]
EjJ]gR[g4 S[ ]o^`o C\g Yo MoaVr ` Ho ac S9 dRi?
:R]gQઍ :R]gQઍ64C^o.]
][Q^g^ crViVj4 EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vg C\g બo5[g4 TgV Io?
Yg_ cghdW\
‘EjJ]gRVi 6h [Rg’ a}TVr cs S[ \rE C]Vg] EjJ]gRi
CVp\g^g^ [jVai
^oDCVj4 Vg[ JQg`r? [w\Cg^iV EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 7L\gVVr IrO CrVg dgSo
V]hc4d [do Rg
]rWg\o^r Io? ][Q^g^ Vi^C4 NVj4 RLRg^g\Ci U]g`Rj4 C\j4 VgMC Io?
]g8Vr W`6R
‘W\gE V MCo ]o `p]gg\ h`Vg...’ ]HVg CrVi Io?
hV@Cj_gV4T `g[i
Yg] d&]Si `Uj EjJ]gRi EiRrVg ]Hh\RgVj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
6h`Vga ]\gc
hYh^\Gc6Vi ][R[g4 EjJ]gRVo h`. R]o Vg[Vg 6Wg`Vg]
EiR aoNi
Do^gOiVj4 Vg[ JQg`r? ભgVWiN Wgh]RrhbC h`BRg W૮g^g^ WMo^Vr J<[ C\g4 S\r dRr?
[g4O^i
EjJ]gR[g4 W`V :&6Si Hg^Rg h`૩jR[SCr C\g4 7`o^g Io?
"ADg ADg, `i ^g4Yg ઇ ADg [g4O`i,
c`g\g EjJ]gRi R]iCo A_Dg\o^g cghdW\Cg] CgCgcgdo Y
]g&w\બ
Cg^o^C]Vi [k_ 6MC aj4 dRi? EjJ]gR[g4Si J ViC_Ri dr\ 6Vo EjJ]gR[g4 J `do Ri dr\ Ro`i
ZgT]
csSi ^g4Yi VTi C9 Io? "C8 h`To &> hT`, T[Q, TgT]g 6Vo VE] d`o^i[g4 Y4T]Vj4
WrMj6 hEK
28
hV[g6Q C]g]\j4 dRj4ઇ? &[ ]Q!Rhc4d!> hKCo MVr XMCr ^Eg]\r Ro C\g Vg[Si
^oE g^g
A_Dg\ Io? J]gRVg C\g hJI^g[g4 RgWi VTi D4ZgRVg 6DgRVo [_o Io?
cj]R
]gc cd 5WTi ClhRVg ]Hh\Rg CrQ Io?
V]hc4d [do Rg
‘6hgVCj4O[g4 :Eo^j4 Ej^gY’ CrVj4 !`VHh]5 Io?
[dgTo`Zg8 Tocg8
E4EgcRiVi Wj5`UkV4j Vg[ aj4 dRj4?
WgVYg9
Z`g8Vg 7૩hWRg 6cg9R NgC] VgR Ydg] [kCg\g YgT C\g4
;4Kg
7`iVo ` \g dRg? [w\Cg^iV EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 W૩`gRg6Vg4 c`r6 H haD]o CrQ
Ch` ag[_
hY]gB Io? 6[Tg`gT Co <^Si h`h`UZg]RiVr g]4Z C\g]o S\r?
8.c. x૯}|
"c] `Ri, hd]u\g 6Vo ChW^g VTiVr h5`oQi c4E[ C\g S_o Sg\
cr[VgS
Ioઇ? 6[Tg`gT MoબMg9^ ^oY] >crha\oaVVi SgWVg CrQo C]i dRi?
[dgW[g Eg4Fi
"‘C4 9C ^gDr hV]gag[g4, 6[] 7ag Ij Wg8 Io’ Vg Ch` CrQ Ioઇ?
[hQ^g^ V. V. hf``oTi
][Q^g^ Vi^C4 NVg4 hWRg!Vj4 Vg[ aj4 dRj4?
[diWR]g[ Vi^C4 N
o[gV4T [k_ C\g4Vg `RVi dRg?
`OrT]g
EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 ‘Z`g9c4Vd’ Vg[Vr V4S CrQo c4WghTR C\r6 Io?
[hdWR]g[ Vi^C4 N
CC6 `lૈ EjJ]gRVg Co M^g hJI^g[g4Si Wcg] Sg\ Io?
Hg]
6[Tg`gTVr Z^Vr hCI^r CrQo YVg]\r dRr?
cj^RgV 6d[Tagd
T\g]g[ Cg]\Vg C\g Cg] [gMo &QiRg Io?
E]Yi
hcૐWjVr c^[g_ CrQo Y4Ug]\r dRr?
[k_]gJ cr^4Ci
h`.[g4 c`6 S[ J SWg8 dr\ Ro`i C9 \jhV`hc6MiVi SgWVg
Xr]oh
EjJ]gR[g4 S9 Io? EjJ]gRVg d Rh^hDR V4SZ4Og][g4 C8 >C[g5 h^hW cH`g\o^i
Wg4Ojh^Wi
Io? "‘Cg]\ `gHVVr h`b\ VSi, r`QVr Io’ - 7 h`UgV CrQo C\j46 Ioઇ?
]g[Vg]g\Q WgNC
f`g]CgVj4 [4hT] C8 VTiVg Cg4Ng :W] 7`o^4j Io?
Er[Ri VTi
EjJ]gRVi ag_gA[g4 [w\gk ZrJV \rJVg C\g [jL\[45i>
[gU`hc4d cr^4Ci
TgD^ C]i dRi? EjJ]gRVg C\g &QiRg Wબih`TVo ‘W૨ZkbQ’Si c<[ghVR C]g\g
c^i[6^i
Io? 6VjcjhHR JV&hRVg \j`gVr[g4 Ri]Cg[NgVj4 CsaI\ Co _`Ri c4 Sg
>C^]\ 7H6]i >Co Oo[i
C8 Io? `^cgO WgcoVr L\gR Th]\ghCVg]r C\r Io?
RiS^
:[ga4C] Jrai> 6DgVo Co`r Ch` Csr Io?
dcRr hX^ckX
IIM-A Vi SgWVgVj4 ro\ CrVo Xg_o &\ Io?
Oq. Oq. h`K[ cg]gZg8
[VjZg9 h5`oTi C\g RDI^jcSi h`L\gR Y<\g?
EghX^
Ch` `i]hc4d ]hHR >C[g5 ClhRVj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
:bgd]Q
Ch` V[6To CrVj4 WT `g4HiVo Cg]\ ^D`gVi o]Qg [o_`o^i?
Ch` Ui]r
6[TgTVi C9 [h JT[g4 5iAVo V[gJ WP`gVi 6^g\Ti ]\` Sg
Jj[g [h JT
Io? EjJ]gRi Ch` Zg^Q C\g4Vg `RVi dRg?
hcૐWj]
Zg`VE] hJI^g[g4 Dg]g WgQi[g4Si [iNj4 WgQi YVg``gVr Y^g
7`ghQ\g
C\g4 7`o^r Io? ‘Mk4 Ci `gRg6 >M^o RQDr’ 7 h`UgV CrVj4 Io?
Es]ia4C] h5WgNi
29
S[ EjJ]gRi ag_g C\g4 6Vo C\g]o ac S9?
cj]R ઍ 9.c. x૮z}
લg ]gJ`iVg agcVVo EjJ]gRVr cj`Q6\jE EQ`g[g4 7`o Io?
hcૐ]gJ J\hc4d
W]4W]gER ]iRo EjJ]gR[g4 V`g `b6Vr g]4Z C\g]Si Sg\ Io?
CgR]C cjT >C[
;g4E;gVr ]oRi DOC C8 ]iRo :W\rE[g4 ^o`g\ Io?
9[g]Ri W~S] R]iCo
Og4EVi TgTi R]iCo CrQ &QiRj4 Io?
WkhQ6[gYo [gYoV WC`gcg
EjJ]gRVg &QiRg hH5Cg] ]h`a4C] ]g`_Vo ]g@"i\ CબgVr C\r
W૨ri
>`rO6 gYR S\r dRr? W4H[dg^Vi ha`]gJWj]Vi DgQ[g4Si C9 DViJ [_o Io?
[o4EohVK
`gh[Vg]g\Q c4 Tg\Vg SgWC CrQ dRg?
cd&V4T `g[i
[VjZg9 W4Hr_i ‘Ta6C’Vi C9 V`^CSg[g4 B^!`VVg4 64ER
Y4TiF]
6VjZ`r 7^oDg\g Io? C\g ado ]Vo X^ k rVj4 ado ] Cdo `g[g4 7`o Io?
Wg^VWj]
‘Co <^ 6Vo Wh]F’ CrVi L\gRVg[ ClhR Io?
\a`4R ajC^
C\r hd4 Tj Rdo `g] 64Vo! Rg]iD [jJY :J`g\ Io?
:ૈ]g\Q
"‘J\g4 J\g4 VJ] [g]i N]o, \gTi Z]i W\g4 7WVi’ - EK^ CrQo
Ch` C^gWi
^Di Ioઇ? EjJ]gRVg Th]\gCg4No 6]Yi c[j^[g4 6h RW` U]g`Ri h`ag_Cg\
{|Si {|Si ~w MV
W[6 ]do ^Vj4 `JV 7a]o Co M^j4 dr\ Io? 6hM]gVg S[ c4Hg^C CrQ dRg?
Oq. Oq. h`K[ cg]gZg9
‘Tg4OiCkH’ C\g cW\gVdVr ZgE dRr?
U]gcQg cW\gVd
6I^gdY4UVi ]HVg C\g]o S9?
x૮x૯Vg x૮x૯Vg ZkC4W WIi
ha\g_g[g4 V_ c]r`]Vi [j^gCgRo 7`Rg \g\g`] WબiA[g4 csSi
ck]DgY ંX^oh[4Erઉ rઉ
h`aob 7Cb6Q C\g WબiAVj4 dr\ Io? C\g EjJ]gRi [hd^g h`. `gci R]iCo &QiRg Io?
iRi coVEjYRg
Ei] 6v\g]Q[g4 Jr hc4d V drR Rr WQ Ro `Vh` Rg] 6<\ C8
Wબiclh@M
`<\clh@MVi `ph`w\Rg [gMo L\gR drR? EjJ]gRVg Th]\g8 h` Rg][g4 Th]\g8 CgHYgVi CoM^i &hRA Jr`g
5Q
[_o Io? ][Q^g^ `. Tocg9Vr J<[ C\g4 S\r dRr?
haVr]
[4hT]rVg VE] R]iCo C\g ado ]Vi EQVg Sg\ Io?
Wgh^RgQg
c]Tg] WMo ^ Clhb \jhV`hc6Mi C\g4 7`o^i Io?
YVgcCg4Ng
EjJ]gRVj4 C\j4 ado ] c[V Zg]R[g4 :WWghTR SRg4 Cj^
cj]R
7hM6hXha\^ hcICVj4 }w MCg :WWgTV C]o Io? V[6To 8hRdgc બo5o 7Wo^g Wj RCVj4 Vg[ 7Wr?
]gJ\]4E
EjJ]gRi Ch` [iૃj d4 co a4C]gHg\6Vg C\g Rr5Vr EjJ]gRi
cs
c[a^rCi 6Vj`gT C\r6 Io? CC6 `lૈ EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4Si Wcg] Sg\ Io?
:ૈ] ZgE[g4Si
6Dr CrVg agcV[g4 M4 Cag_[g4 X]J Y&`Rr dRr?
YgTagd Jdg4Ei]
6[Tg`gTVi C9 [h JT[g4 5iAVo V[gJ WP`gVi 6^g\Ti
Jj[g [h JT
]\` Sg Io? ZCR Ch` V]hc4d [do RgVi Ch`Rg W] C9 h`Hg]Ug]gVr Zg` Io?
o[^બQg ZhCR
EjJ]gR[g4 CghR6CiઍWkV[Vr csSi [rMr [o_r C\g4 Z]g\ Io?
cr[VgS
[rPo ]g VlW\ [drWc`Vj4 7\rJV T] `bo6 C\g [gc[g4 Sg\ Io?
&<\j7]i
Wh`5 \g5gUg[ OgCr]Vg [4hT] Wgco C\j4 R_g` 7`o^j4 Io?
Er[Ri R_g`
C I[g4 7`o^4j C\j4 S_ [rPo .]i 6Vo 7agWj]g [gRgVg [4hT]r
Ro]g Eg[
[gMo &QiRj4 Io? ‘EjJ]gR’ a}T C\g agcVCg_[g4 Hh^R S\r?
cr^4CiCg_
30
EjJ]gRi ZgbgVi S[ c_4E dg \]c UgV V`^CSg C8 Io RoVg
Z^4Z^ ઍ ][Q^g^ [diWR]g[ Vi^C4 N
^oDC CrQ Io? K`o]H4T [oFgQiVg ^rCEiRrVo `]Yૐ C]Vg] Eg\CVj4 Vg[
do [j EP`i
JQg`r? C8 cg^[g4 64VoJr f`g]g EjJ]gR[g4 cs S[ xw EjJ]gRi
8.c. x૮y}
ag_gA SgW`g[g4 7`i? EjJ]gRi ^rCcghdW\Vg h` Rg] [gMo C9 Cr[Vr hc4dXg_r Io?
ZgMHg]Q
c[V EjJ]gR[g4 Jr`g [_Ri To`HC^iVo C I h` Rg][g4 C\g
Cg_i YjHC
Vg[Si A_D`g[g4 7`o Io? 6[Tg`gTVg hcૐ EiRg[4hT]Vi SgWVg CrQo C]i dRi?
`g[i h`૩gV4T!
C`
IrMg ;ToWj]
WgEP W`6R :W] C\g [gRg!Vj4 SgVC Io?
[dgCg_i
EjJ]gRVg Es]`c[g J[aoT! RgRg 6Vo TgTgZg8 V`]r!Vj4
V`cg]i
J<[ S_ C\j4 Io? EjJ]gRYdg] WkJ\ri [rMg> C\g4 7r[ SgY\r dRr?
Cg`o]iVo Cg4No Cj4 ZCrQ3[g4
cj hcૐ `gh[Vg]g\Q c4 Tg\Vj4 [jL\RiS6 C\g4 7`o^j4 Io?
EPOg
EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 cs S[ h`Hg] UgV Ch`RgVr L\g^ CrQo
Y.C. NgCr]
7Y\r? EjJ]gR[g4 Wg]ciAVo 7r\ 7WVg] ]g&Vj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
&Ti ]gQg
EjJ]gR[g4 ^gV c[\o E`gRg4 ^gVEiRr C\g Vg[o A_Dg\ Io?
XMgQg
‘^h^Rg Tj5DTa6C’ VgMCVg ^oDC CrQ Io?
]QIrOZg8 :T\]g[
6cg9RVg `4aJr `R6[gV[g4 C\g Vg[o A_Dg\ Io?
R]Eg_g
ThબQ EjJ]gR[g4 C\j4 d`g Dg`gVj4 S_ 7`o^j4 Io?
cgWjRg]g
EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vo ToaghZ[gV 6Vo `RV o[Vg cs S[ Cg]\r CrQo
Ch` V[6T
7Y\g? EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vi cs S[ V`h^CgVj4 Vg[ aj4 dRj?4
Er`g^Qi
&[VE] hJI^g[g4 WબiAVj4 C\j4 6Z\g]u\ 7`o^4j Io?
[dg E4Eg 6Z\g]u\
`gh[Vg]g\Q c4 Tg\Vg C\g `g[i> T]]rJ Cg]\ ]H`gVr hV\[
|gV4T `g[i
]gL\r dRr? ‘[gU` C\g4\ VSi [Uj`V[g4’ ClhRVg cxC CrQ Io?
dh]<^ T`o
‘Ta6C’Vi C8 [dgV o[CSg W]Si EjJ]gRi hXI[ YVi Io?
Ko] Rr WiUg4 Io &Qi &Qi
EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 ‘Z`g9c4Vd’ Vg[Vr V4S CrQo c4WghTR C\r6 Io?
[hdWR]g[ Vi^C4 N
Ch`A f`g]g DkY a4cg Wg[o^g Wબi HgRCVo cs]g@"[g4 C\g
[rRiOr
Vg[Si A_D`g[g4 7`o Io? hd4 TVi &Vo `gR4WÁ\ H_`_[g4 chK\ C]`g [gMo Eg4Ui!>
\4E 9h
Zg]R[g4 cs S[ C\j4 64Vo! 6DYg] ac C\j64? ;4Kg V!C 7`o^g4 >`g S_Vj4 Vg[ 7Wr J\g4 hd
[i]gTgRg]
Y4Vo Cr[Vg Ta6VgSi6A 7`o Io? Kk ^Rg h[Vg]g C\g4 7`o^g Io RoVj4 [k_ Vg[ aj4 Io?
"6[Tg`gT 6[Tg`gT, 6[Tg`gT hcTi Yai]Vi [h JT ઇ
`^cgO WgcoVr L\gR Th]\ghCVg]r C\r Io?
RiS^
hc4d 6Vo FjOD] >ha\g D4O[g4 XCR C\g4 Jr`g [_o Io?
EjJ]gR
6[Tg`gT[g4 7`o^i 6Vo SgWW\C_gVr :ૈ[ V[kVr >`i Jj3[g
6d[Tagd YgTagd
[h JT CrQo Y4Ug`i dRi? 6[Tg`gT 6Vo C4 O^g C\g V4Y]Vg ]g@"i\ Ur]i[gE6Si JrOg\o^g4
]g@"i\ Ur]i[gE6 V4. ૮ઍ>
Io? CgHYg ઍ CgHYiVg4 &QiRg ZJVVg ]Hh\Rg CrQ Io?
Ch` Zr& ZER
C IVg ]Q[g4 C\g [g4cZબi `<\ gQiA Jr`g [_o Io?
Ea ંdo QrR]rઉ QrR]rઉ 6Vo ]QVj4 ha\g_
31
EjJ]gRi dg \cghdW\Vg ‘dg \ cgM’ Vj4 hYcT CrVo [X\j4 Io?
J\rRi<^ d. d. T`o
ThબQ 7hyCg[g4 Eg4Ui!> C\j4 cg[gh\C ac C\j46 dRj4?
9h
cd&V4T `g[i C\g4Vg `RVi dRg?
IWp\g
EjJ]gRVr csSi ^g4Yrઍ>C`ic hT`cVr [o_r C\r Io?
ag[_g!Vr [o_r
Tg:Ti `r]gAVj4 :ૈ] EjJ]gR[g4 7`o^j4 RiS6 S_ C\j4 Io?
To^[g^
EjJ]gR[g4 cs S[ cjR]: CgWOVi [i^Vi SgWVg CrQo C]i?
]QIrO^g^ IrMg^g^
‘Csj4 CSo Ro agVr Ch` aiDi `gRVo agVo V`i’ - 7 Cg]\W4hCR C\g
Ch` ag[_
Ch`Vi Io? ‘ YrU Y5ici’ ClhRVg ]Hh\Rg CrQ Io?
Ch` [g4OQ Y4Ug]r
[diWR]g[ Vi^C4 No C\j4 `gc Wj RC ] \j4 dRj4?
94g^g
V[6TVi Cg]\Zg`Vg W] C\g Wh`[i cghdW\Cg]Vr Zg` Jr`g [_o
Ch` `OK6`S6
Io? EjJ]gRVj4 C\j4 ado ] c[V Zg]R[g4 6CiCCg[ [gMo &QiRj4 Io?
D4ZgR
[gDi[g] Cj_Vj4 C\j4 Wબi ha\g_r Eg_`g hd[g^\Si EjJ]gR 7`o
hX]r! [gDi[g]
Io? EjJ]gR[g4 C<\gA [gMoVi cs S[ Wrh^Mo ChVCVi ac7R C\g4
6[Tg`gT ઍ x૯}{
S8 dRi? h`.cW h`@QjVi Z]\ hR[g EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4 7`o^i Io?
ag[_g!
EjJ]gRVj4 C\j4 ado ] V C_gVg Rp^hH5rVj4 [jL\ Co <^ EQ`g[g4
WgMQ
7`o Io? `OVE]Vj4 CihR6Rr]Q Yi& C\g Vg[o A_Dg\ Io?
V]hc4d [do RgVr Hr]r
cj hcૐ Wj]gRWW`ag 5i Oq. dc[jD cg4Ch_\g> C\g Eg[Vg
^g4FQJ
hM4YgVj4 :WDVV C]iVo EjJ]gR[g4 Wg4E]o^i gE?hRdgciC c4 ClhRVg Wj]g`g [o_]\g dRg? 6[Tg`gT[g4 [4TYjhૐVg Yg_CrVo Rg^i[ 7WRi ]g@"i\ CબgVi
Yi. Yi.>[. >[.9< MiS\jM @X [o
c4 Sg C8 Io? EjJ]gRVj4 Wdo ^j4 Wj RCg^\ C\j4 Io?
di[gZg8 8< MiS\jM
dOYWi\ cv\RgVi cg9M Ur_g`i]g C8 cg^[g4 arUg8 dRi?
8.c. x૯}~
S[ EjJ]gRi <\g\[khR6 CrQ dRg4?
VgVgZg9 dh]Tgc
W5 \g5gUg[ YoM f`g]CgVj4 6<\ Vg[ JQg`r?
YoM a4DrT]
h`J\ dKg]o C8 ][RVg 74R]]g@"i\ Do^gOi R]iCo &QiRg
hKCo M
dRg? [dgW[g Eg4UiVg 7w\ghW[C [gE6Ta6C CrQ dRg?
ri[Tt ]gJH4^
EjJ]gRVg Hg^jC\ ]gJ`iA h`ao [ghdRi 7WRg4 c4 ClR Cg]\
do [H<^gHg\6
‘Cj[g]Wg^ Hh]5[t’Vg4 ]Hh\Rg CrQ Io? dૄWi\ c4 ClhRVg [dWW`Vg S_ ^rS^Vi arU C\g
Oq. Oq. >c. >c.7]. 7].]g`
Wj]gRWW`ag 5i> C]i dRi? EjJ]gRVj4 cs S[ h`J_iSi Hg^Rj4 [agV C\g ado ][g4 SWg\j4
&[VE]
dRj4? 6[Tg`gT[g4 7`o^j4 ro\c 3\jhK\[ C8 C_gClhRAVg Tj^6Z
^rCC_gClhR
V[kVgAVj4 c4Vd SgV Io? ToaZ][g4 7hC6MoCMVg 6v\gc [gMo &QiRi ‘CEPT’ Vi SgWVg
6[Tg`gT 8. 8.c.x૯}z
C\g4 6Vo C\g]o S8? ‘CgE`gQi’Vg ]Hh\Rg CrQ dRg?
Tj^g Zg\g CgE
EjJ]gRVi S[ c]Cg]Vo Y4Ug]QVg aWS CrQo ^o`Og]\g dRg?
]h`a4C] [dg]gJ
cs]g@"Vj4 csSi [rMj4 Y4T] C\j4 Io?
ADg
]g[To`Wi]Vj4 gHiV [4hT] C\g4 7`o^j4 Io?
]Qj&
32
do [H4^gHg\o6 SgWo^j4 ભgV[4hT] EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4 7`o^j4 Io?
WgMQ
6[Tg`gTVg >h^ch|JVg SWhR CrQ dRg?
]g` YdgTj] hd4 [R^g^ Ui]J]g[
EjJ]gR[g4 csSi `Uj ^Fj :૩rE >C[r C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^g Io?
6[Tg`gT
FoO W4SC C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^r Io?
JjVgEP
"a4C]gHg\o6 SgWo^g Hg] [Nr WpCiVr >C EjJ]gR[g4 Io, Ro C\g4
f`g]Cg
7`o^r Ioઇ? ThબQ EjJ]gR[g4 7hT`gciAVo cg[ghJC 6Vo haબQ બo5o 7E_
JjER]g[ T`o
^g``g[g4 C\g Eg4Ui`gTi Cg\6C]Vr Ydj [kI\ Xg_r Io?
hcૐ cghdW\Cg] ][Q^g^ Vi^C4 NVj4 RDI^jc aj4 Io?
[C]4T
EjJ]gRi ZgbgVg gHiV d Rh^hDR Wj RCrVg c4Vd [gMo C8
XgY6c EjJ]gRi cZg
c4 Sg Cg\6]R dRi? h`. hcૐ WMr_g EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4 YVo Io?
WgMQ
T^WR]g[Vg ‘`oVHh]5’[g4 5i!`VVi C8 c[ \gVi `gR Io?
Yg_h`U`gVi c[ \g
][Q^g^ Vi^C4 NVg h``oHVc4VdVj4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
Ch`Rg 6Vo cghdW\
EjJ]gRVj4 C\j4 S_ xwwwSi `Uj [4hT]rVr c[kd U]g`o Io?
Wgh^RgQg
EjJ]gRi ZgbgઍcghdW\Vg c4TZ6[g4 9.c.x{ww Si x૮wwVr
[w\Cg^iV EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vr \jE
c[\Eg_r C\g \jE R]iCo A_Dg\ Io? ][Q^g^ `c4R^g^ Tocg8Vi C8 V`^CSg> 6VoC ZQo^gઍEQo^g
Vg[^q[i
\j`gVrVo Vg[cjUg] બo5o `gX\g dRg? EjJ]gRi Zgbg cghdW\Vg 6w\\Vઍc4arUV [gMo C8 c4 SgVi
crha\^ >crha\oaV
SgWVg S8 dRi? EjJ]gR chdR c[V Toa[g4 Jr`g [_Ri |gQi Co a4C] a[_i
WgQi W]Si
WrRgVr Dr]gC C\g4Si [o_`o Io? EjJ]gRVg C\g [dgVjZg` cs S[ `DR ]gJ\Wg^ Y<\g dRg C\g
H4Tj^g^ h5`oTiઍ iઍAh] cg
]gJ\[g4? hd4 Ti hXI[rVg &QiRg EjJ]gRi 6hZVoRg c4!`Cj[g]Vj4 [k_ Vg[ aj4
dh]^g^ J]i`g^g
dRj4? X]iT [d[T Ej^g[VYi [
7hT^
EjJ]gR[g4 C I hc`g\Vg h` Rg]r[g4 Jr`g [_Rj4 Cr\^Cj_Vj4 Wબi
WWidg
YWp\r Yi& C\g Vg[Si A_Dg\ Io? Ch` Zg^Qo ‘V_gL\gV’ Vi ]HVg C\g c4 ClR V4SrVo 7Ug]o C]i
VpbUi\ Hh]R 6Vo V^H4Wk
dRi?
ClhR haબQ [gMo &QiRj4 hd4 Er_EP 6hZ\g]u\ C\g4 7`o^j4 Io?
JcTQ
`R45 EjJ]gRVi ]HVg [gMo C\j4 74Tr^V S\j4 dRj4?
[dgEjJ]gR 74Tr^V
]gJCrM V!C 7`o^r xx~z XM k ;4Hr C\r W`6R J`g_g[jDi
HrMi^g
XgM`gVo Cg]Qo Y<\r Io? EjJ]gRVj4 C\j4 ado ] Wk`6Vg ToarVj4 [g
6[Tg`gT
V[6To C8 cghdhW\C c4 SgVi SgWVg C]i dRi?
Yjhૐ`U6CcZg
[hQ^g^ hf``oTiVi ‘Ej^gYhc4d’ C9 64Vo! V`^CSgVr Zg`gVj`gT
^qO6 h^MVVi ઍ‘Ko KoVrVi’ rVi
Io? IPRVj4 Wk]j4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
9< MiS\j 9< MiS\jM @X Y^g[g ]icH6
[o.r Y4U \rJVgVj4 S_ C\j4 Io?
ag[_g!
C IVj4 VgVj4 ]Q 7E_ `URj4 6MCo Ro [gMo C\g Y4UVi ]HVg
cj]JYg]i
C]`g[g4 7`i Io? V`^]g[Vj4 C\j4 VgMC yo
ZMVj4 ZrWg_j
cWg4R] Io? Ch` T\g]g[Vo Ej]j 9 Ig]g[ Zુo C\r [45 7Y\r dRr?
ri Cl@Q5 a]Q4 [[
33
h|Mia ]gJ T]h[\gV [j4Y8Vg C\g E`V6]o C I 3\jhK\[Vi
"c] c] B3c Xg\j6cV, V 8.c. x૮~~ ઇ
SgWVg C]i dRi? ‘^gDr X^ k gQi’ hXI[Vg c4EiRCg] CrQ Io?
Es]g4E ]\gc
CrVg agcVCg_ T]3\gV EjJ]gRVj4 WgMVE] 6[Tg`gTSi Hg4WgVo]
[d4 [T YoEOr
DcoOg\j4? ‘]Q[I^ I4T’Vg cxC CrQ Io?
riU] ]\gc
EjJ]gRVr [dWW`Vr EQgRr 8]iEoaV rBCM C\g4 SgW`g[g4
T[Qઍ T[QઍE4Eg
7]\r Io? Z`g8Vg 7૩hWRg 6cg8R NgC] C8 cTi[g4 S8 E\g?
x|[i x|[i cTi
Ch` T\g]g[Vj4 Yg_WQVj4 Vg[ aj4 dRj4?
T\ga4C]
EjJ]gR :&6 h`Cgc c4 Sg C\g ado ][g4 7`o^i Io?
`OrT]g
V`^Di Y4T] C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^j4 Io?
&[VE]
EjJ]gRVj4 cs S[ Yg_c4Vdg^\ C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^4j Io?
6[]o^i
Og4EVi TgTi R]iCo CrQ &QiRj4 Io?
WkhQ6[gYoV WC`gcg
"EjJ]gRVg C\g c4 ClR Ch`Vg cxV[g4 Cgh^TgcVi :W[g, Tg4OiVj4
[dgCh` [gF
WT^gh^W\ RSg Zg]h`Vj4 6S6Es]` Jr`g [_o Ioઇ? C8 EjJ]gRi [hd^g CQg6MCVg ]gJ\Wg^ Y<\g dRg?
Cj[jTYoV Jrbi
6[Tg`gT[g4 Y4Ug\o^g C\g ^rD4OVg Wj^Vo d! cjUi CgM ^gg\r
>h^c|iJ
VSi?
gHiV EjJ]gRVi ?hRdghcC ]gJUgVi C8 dRi?
7V4TWj] ંdg^Vj4 `OVE]ઉ `OVE]ઉ
WoErh^Vg ]g@"i\ :૩gV EjJ]gRVg C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^j4 Io?
:Vg
EjJ]gR[g4 C\j4 ^rCVlW\ C]Ri `DRo ^gCOiVo U]Ri W] WIgO`g[g4
MiYWQi
7`o Io? EjJ]gRVg S[ [hd^g [45i CrQ dRg?
8
Zg]RVg ZkRWk`6 ]g@"WhR >.Wi.B. 6}Tj^C^g[ :W] C\g
Oq. Oq. h`K[ cg]gZg8
EjJ]gRi `pભghVCVr h`aob Zg` dRr? B ]HVg[g4 Cr9 [dgV ?hRdghcC ]\hCRVj4 Hh]5 7^oDg\j4 dr\
Y4U
RoVo aj4 Cdo Io? J]gRVg `V`EOg[g4 ^રODrTVo Jr`g [gMo C\r c[\ ro@N
`do ^i c`g]Vr
EQ`g[g4 7`o Io? EjJ]gRi Zgbg C9 Zgbg W]Si :R]i 7`i Io?
c4 ClR
ThબQ EjJ]gR[g4 ao]OiVj4 `g`oR] ac C]g`Vg] EjJ]gRi CrQ
T\g]g[ Cj4`]! WMo ^
dRg? EjJ]gRVr csSi [rMr WajAVr [o_r C\g4 Z]g\ Io?
`sNg
C I[g4 EjJ]gRVj4 C\j4 DgVEi 7UjhVC Y4T] 7`o^4j Io?
[j<^g
6[Tg`gTVr Z^Vr hCI^r C\g `b6[g4 Y4Ug\r dRr?
8.c. x{xx
hV]4JV ZERVg YUg Cg]\r C\g Cg]\c4Vd[g4 c4VhdR S\g Io?
I4Tr^\
EjJ]gRVi ZsErh^C ci[gAVr h` Rg] C\g Cj_Vg4 agcV[g4 csSi
cr^4Ci `4a
`Ug]o S\r? cgY] Oo ]i EjJ]gRVg C\g ado ][g4 7`o^i Io?
hd4 [RVE]
Ch`.] T^WR]g[o cs S[ C\r hVY4U ^L\r dRr?
ZkRhVY4U
V_c]r`] Wબi 6v\g]Q R]iCo C\g `b6[g4 &do ] S\j4?
8.c. x૯}૯
C\j4 6`Cg c4arUV Co <^ 6[Tg`gTVo Es]` Yબo Io?
9hhY^CoaV co
EjJ]gRVg C\g hcૐ EK^Cg] 6Vo 7IYM6 79< Mg9V [X\g
aoDgT[ 7Yj`g^g 6Vo 7IYM6 79< Mg9V
dRg? EjJ]gR ]gJ\Vi ]HVgCg_o ંx૯}wઉ C\g &QiRg Ch`> ‘EjJ]gR
:[ga4C] Jrai
R`Vr’ Vg[Vi Cg]\]HVg EjJ]gRVo ch[6WR C]i dRi?
34
Tk]`Ri6 haબQ [gMoVi EjJ]gRVi hcૐ \jhV`hc6Mi C8 Io?
Oq. Oq. YgYgcgdo Y 74YoOC] AWV \jhV`hc6Mi
7Yj[g4 7hTVgSVj4 7]c[4hT] CrQo Y4Ug]\j dRj4?
h`[^ [45i
EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4Vg F:4 `DQg\ Io?
Zg^ Toa
Cg4C]gWg] Y4U C8 VTi W] 7`o^r Io?
RgWi
6`Cga c4arUV બo5o Cg\6]R Woc >hY^CoaV co
6[Tg`gT
EjJ]gRVg C\g ado ][g4 7`o^4j Io? EjJ]gR[g4 `oT[4hT]rVg SgWC CrQ dRg?
`g[i E4Eo.]gV4T!
EjJ]gR[g4 J<[o^g C\g EhQRભ> ak<\Vr 7h`@Cg] C\r6 dr`gVj4
|EjYR
[Vg\ Io? ‘VTiVi ]oR[g4 ][Rj4 VE] [_o Vg [_o’ Vg ^oDC CrQ Io?
7hT^ [
EjJ]gR ]gJ\Vg S[ 7hT`gci [jL\[45i CrQ dRg?
6[]hc4d HsU]i
"‘!`Vo .gcRQi cEg9, F][g4 FOi V ]gDo Zg9’ - 7 WTVg
Ch` Zr& ZER
]HVgCg] CrQ Ioઇ? c4\jCR ]g@"c4FVg 64O] coKoM]i R]iCo C\g EjJ]gRi WrRgVi
hH<[\ hH<[\ Fg]oDgV
6[kI\ co`g 7Wi HkC\g Io? Ch` :[ga4C] JraiVg C\g Cg]\c4VdVo Zg]Ri\ ભgVWiN Wj] Cg]
hVaiS
[X\r Io?
o[^બQg ZhCRVj4 ;4H4j haD] C\g Ch`> c] C\j46 Io?
V]hc4d [do Rg
cr^4Ci ]g& CQ6To`Vg c[\[g4 Cga[i]Si C\g Ch` EjJ]gR[g4
Ch` hYIdQ
7]\g dRg? C I[g4 7`o^4j C\j4 S_ 7hd] >3|r9O]i [gMo &QiRj4 Io?
UVoRi
C IVj4 VgVj4 ]Q 6Vo D4ZgRVr 6DgR C\g c]r`]Si JrOg\o^g Io?
V_ c]r`]
DoRi`gOiVg4 A&]r [gMo EjJ]gRVj4 csSi &QiRj4 S_ C\j4 Io?
]gJCrM
Rg]4Eg C\g U[6Vj4 &QiRj4 RiS6 S_ Io?
V
‘Wl~`i]gJ ]gcr’ V4SVi ]HVg CrQo C]i dRi?
Ch` EQWhR
‘Mk4 Ci `gRg6 >M^o RQDr’ 7 h`UgV CrVj4 Io?
Es]ia4C] h5WgNi
EjJ]gR[g4 csSi JkVj4 3\jhK\[ C\j4 Io?
C I 3\jhK\[
CgCgcgdo Y Cg^o^C]o ^Do^ ‘!`VVr 7V4T’ 6Vo ‘]DO`gVr
^h^R hVY4U
7V4T’ V4SVr cghdW\ Cg] JQg`r? V_c]r`] C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^j4 Io?
6[Tg`gT
Wh`5 \g5gUg[ YoM f`g]CgVj4 6<\ Vg[ JQg`r?
YoM a4DrT]
EjJ]gR[g4 cs S[ >[.>.Vi WT`i CrQo [o_`i dRi?
Yg^g^ cg4C]^g^ Tocg8
c] Mr[c ]rVo Zg]R[g4 `oWg] C]`gVi W]`gVEi EjJ]gRVg C\g
6[Tg`gT
ado ][g4Si 7W`g[g4 7`i dRi? ‘ciRgd]Q’ ClhRVg ]Hh\Rg CrQ Io?
C[6Q [45i
V]hc4d]g` hT`ohM\gVi ‘ []Qc4hdRg’ CcQ ah R CrVo :્oaiVo
`E6 S Wj5 Vh^VCg
]Hg8 Io? &R`gV CghN\g`gOi FrOgAVj4 c4arUV Co <^ C\g4 Io?
JkVgEP
Zg]R[g4 Or^r[g9M DViJVj4 csSi `Uj :WWgTV C\g4 Sg\ Io?
IrMg :ToWj]
>ha\gD4OVi csSi [rMi cdCg]i Oo ]i C\g4 7`o^i Io?
7Q4T
EjJ]gRVj4 csSi [rMj4 CjT]Ri c]r`] C\j4 Io?
V_ c]r`]
EjJ]gR[g4 W4Hg\Ri ]gJVg QoRg CrQ dRg?
Y_`4R]g\ [do Rg
C Ii [o`g R]iCo &QiRj4 X_ C\j Io?
Dg]oC
[dgV ToaZCR a\g[!Cl@Q `[g6Vr J<[ C\g4 S\r dRr?
[g4O`i
EjJ]gRi Zgbg[g4 ‘Mk4Ci `gRg6’ `cW 7WVg] cs S[ cghdW\Cg]
Uk[Co Rj
CrQ dRg? :ERg ck\6Vr Toa R]iCo EjJ]gRVr C\r hJI^r &QiRr Io?
TgdrT
35
‘6[o YUg’ dg \CSg C\g Yo ^oDCr> cgSo [_iVo ^Do^i Io?
J\rhR<^ T`o 6Vo UVcjD^g^ [do Rg
‘Co <^ 6Vo Wh]F’ CrVi L\gRVg[ ClhR Io?
\a`4R ajC^
`gciAVg 7Cb6QVj4 Co <^ >`r EjJ]gRVr C\r YiH `!6V YiH
Ti`
R]iCo A_Dg\ Io? EjJ]gR[g4 csSi ;4Hj haD] C\j4 Io?
Er]DVgSVj Er]DVgSVj4 haD]ઍ haD]ઍhE]Vg]
EjJ]gRVg C\g hJI^g[g4 TkUg_g4 Pr]Vi c4L\g csSi `Uj Io?
7Q4T
[o.r Y4U \rJVgVj4 S_ C\j4 Io?
ag[_g!
W૮g^g^ WMo ^Vi ભgVWiN Wgh]RrhbC [o_`Vg] V`^CSg W]
[gV`iVi Z`g8
7Ugh]R hXI[Vj4 Vg[ JQg`r? W4H[dg^ Zi^ co`g[4O_Vi SgWVg CrQo C]i?
Nર]YgWg
EjJ]gR[g4 cs S[ ]ohO\r Co <^ CrQo ac C]g]\j4?
[dg]g& c\g!]g` Eg\C`gOઍ Eg\C`gOઍ`OrT]g
c4 ClR 6Vo 64Vo! c4 Cg]`g_i E૩ap^i EjJ]gRVg C\g Ch`Vi
cj
]HVgA[g4 h`Cco^i Jr`g [_o Io? EjJ]gRVg Hg^jC\ ]gJ`iA h`ao [ghdRi 7WRg4 c4 ClR Cg]\
do [H<^gHg\6
‘Cj[g]Wg^ Hh]5[t’Vg4 ]Hh\Rg CrQ Io? EjJ]gRVg C\g hcૐ EK^Cg] 6Vo 7IYM6 79< Mg9V [X\g
aoDgT[ 7Yj`g^g 6Vo 7IYM6 79< Mg9V
dRg? YVgc VTiVj4 gHiV Vg[ aj4 dRj4?
WQg6ag
C\j4 SgWW\ ‘6[Tg`gTVj4 ]WV’ R]iCo A_Dg\ Io?
]gQi hc iVi [h JT
6[Tg`gTVg S[ [o\] YVVg] ]\hCR CrQ dRg?
HiVjZg8 Yo]rVoM
CVp\g^g^ [jVaiVg [R [JjY V]hc4d [do Rg C\g cpCg[g4 S9 E\g?
x}[g x}[g cpCg
C.E.E.Vj4 ]j 4 Vg[ JQg`r?
co<`g\][oJ\jCoaV ં6[Tg`gTઉ 6[Tg`gTઉ
‘JkV4j Rr S\j4 ]o To`_ JkVj4 Rr S\j4’ ZJV CrVg f`g]g E`gRj4 dRj?4
[i]g4
f`g]Cg 6Vo ADg ` Ho 7`o^r W4SC C\g Vg[o A_Dg\ Io?
ADg [4O_
Eg4Ui! CrVo H]rR]Vj4 [rRi Cdo Rg?
[rRiZg8 6[iV
haCgEr 8
dgcV ઍ 6cV
EjJ]gRi hXI[Vo 8Vg[ [X\j4? hMYWQi VlW\ cs]g@"Vg C\g h` Rg]Vj4 &QiRj4 VlW\ Io?
Hr]`gO
Ch`A f`g]g DkY a4cg Wg[o^g Wબi HgRCVo cs]g@"[g4 C\g
[rRiOr
Vg[Si A_D`g[g4 7`o Io? akhM4 E[g4 :WCl@M ToDg` C]iVo 6JjV 6 >`rO6 gYR C]Vg]
:T\V HiVjZg8
EjJ]gRVg S[ Do^gOi CrQ Io? `o_g`T] ]g@"i\ :૩gV C\g gQiVo c]4બQ Wk]j4 WgOo Io?
Cgh_\g]
y4o H ^rCr> EjJ]gR[g4 C8 cg^[g4 ]\gWg]i SgQj4 SgY\j4 dRj4?
8.c. x}}૮
Moh^ Cr3\jhVCoaV બo5o Zg]R[g4 Kg4hR ^g`Vg] EjJ]gRi CrQ Io?
cg[ hW5rOg
EjJ]gR[g4 &[X_ 6Vo TgO[Vg :WWgTV [gMo C\r hJI^r csSi `Uj
Zg`VE]
&QiRr Io? `pભghVC c4arUV બo5o :WCl@M TgV C]Vg] c4arUCrVo C\g >o`qO6Si
Oq. Oq. h`K[ cg]gZg8 >o`qO6
V`gJ`g[g4 7`o Io? C I hJI^gVo C8 \rJVg 64RE6R WgQi Wk]j4 WgO`g[g4 7`o Io?
c]Tg] c]r`] V[6Tg \rJVg
EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 [hQ^g^ hf``oTi [gMo C\r a}T \rE `W]g\
6ZoT [gE6Vg4 `gci
Io? ‘BVo ]g[ ]gDo RoVo CrQ HgDo’ Vg[Vj4 WT CrQo ] \j4 Io?
Ch` Ui]r
"a4C]gHg\o6 SgWo^g Hg] [Nr WpCiVr >C EjJ]gR[g4 Io, Ro C\g4
f`g]Cg
7`o^r Ioઇ? MWCg4`g_i J4E^i HiY]i EjJ]gRVg C\g `Vh` Rg]r[g4 Jr`g [_o
Og4E hJI^gVg `g4cTg
Io?
36
cj]RVi csSi &QiRi Oo ]i C8 Io?
ck[j^ Oo]i
EjJ]gRVj4 ]gJ\ gQi C\j4 Io?
hc4d
EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vg4 C\g [dgV cxC [j4Y9 ]gJ\Vg4 Eld UgV 6Vo
CVp\g^g^ Vai
[jL\ <\g\gUia ]sg dRg? cgWjRg]g a}TVr ar 6S6 Sg\ Io?
cgWrVj4 hV`gc SgV
‘Zg]o^r 6hgV’ 6Vo ‘hT]\ Hબj’ B`i C^gW[C V`^CSgVg ^oDC CrQ
][Q^g^ `. `. Tocg9
Io? Co _Vi >C Dgc &R >`i 8^g\Hi Co _Vj4 `g`oR] EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4
Hr]`gO
Sg\ Io? EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vg4 hcૐ V`^CSgCg] Er`U6V]g[ h5WgNiVr J<[
VhO\gT
C\g4 S\r dRr? ao] DgV YgYi> JkVgEP[g4 YgYi`4aVi SgWVg C\g]o C]i?
8.c. x~{~
h`. hcૐ `^Zi h`૩gWiNVi SgWVg C\g `4a T]3\gV S8 dRi?
[p5C `4a
Eg4Ui!Vo ]gJCg]Q[g4 7`Rg Wdo ^g4 >C `b6 cjUi ]gJCg]QVr
>Vi Yoc
6v\gc C]`g >C h`Toai [hd^g> ckH]\j4. > hd^g CrQ dRg?
Co hM4E[g4 :WCl@M ToDg` C]iVo 6JjV 6 >`rO6 gYR C]Vg]
V[V Wg]oD
EjJ]gRVg S[ Do^gOi CrQ Io? Zg]RZ]Vi >C[g5 7\j`6oT \jhV`hc6Mi C\g ado ][g4 7`o^i Io?
&[VE]
]Q! "qXi CrVg Vg[ cgSo c4C_g\o^ Io?
&[ ]Q!Rchd4 !
^4OVVg 7IYM6 dr^[g4 6h`Vga ]\gcVj4 C\j4 EiR cg4Z_iVo
Rg]i `g4Ci ]o WgF^OiVj4...’ ... ...
EjJ]gRi cgSo 64VoJr WQ VgHi :\g dRg? EjJ]gRVr C\r hJI^r [w\ Toa RSg ]gJ SgV ]gJ\r cgSo
TgdrT
chd\g]i J[iV c]dT U]g`o Io? Cg4C]gWg] Y4U C8 VTi W] 7`o^r Io?
RgWi
DiJOi\gVj Wબi 6Z\g]u\ C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^4j Io?
&[VE]
EjJ]gR[g4 cs S[ MWg^co`g C\g4 6Vo C\g]o ac S8?
6[Tg`gT ઍ 8.c. x૮z૮
EjJ]gRi ZgbgVg gHiV d Rh^hDR Wj RCrVg c4Vd [gMo C8
XgY6c EjJ]gRi cZg
c4 Sg Cg\6]R dRi? EjJ]gRVi C8 VTi T] `bo6 ]oRiVg PE[g4 Xo ]`g\ Io?
Cr^C
Cg\TgVj4 haબQ 7WRi EjJ]gRVi JkVi 6Vo &QiRi c4 Sg C8 Io?
ri >^. >^.>. agd ^q Cq^oJઍ6[Tg`gT
ZCR Ch`\5i [i]g4 C9 cg^[g4 EjJ]gRVi f`gh]Cg VE]i[g4
9.c.x|z~
7`iVo ` \g4 dRg4? EjJ]gR[g4 6]Yi c[j^ V!C [iNg WgQiVj4 C\j4 c]r`] 7`o^4j
Vg]g\Q c]r`]
Io? [w\Cg^iV EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 7L\gVVr IrO CrVg dgSo
V]hc4d [do Rg
]rWg\o^r Io? EjJ]gRVg C\g hJI^g[g4 csSi `Uj 9cYEj^ WgCo Io?
[do cgQg
V`g ]Hg\o^g V[6Tg hJI^gVj4 `Oj4 [SC C\j4 Io?
]gJWiW_g
‘h5Zj`VTiWC Y4U’Vg Ch`Vj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
J\aoD] ckh]
"‘hVagV HkC [gX, Vdi 4 [gX ViHj4 hVagV’ - 7 h`UgV CrVj4 Ioઇ?
Y_`4R]g\ C. C. NgCr]
EjJ]gR[g4 ‘`gOiAVr hJI^r’ R]iCo C\r hJI^r L\gR Io?
`^cgO
EjJ]gRVi ag_gA[g4 [w\gk ZrJV \rJVg C\g [jL\[45i>
[gU`hc4d cr^4Ci
TgD^ C]i dRi? :aVct C\g Ch`Vj4 ;WVg[ Io?
VM`]^g^ W4O\g
Moh^h`KVVr EjJ]gR[g4 g]4Z C\g]o S\r?
"x| x| @nE@M, @M x૯~| ઇ
‘J[r Sg_ !`V &:4 `g]i...’ Zg``gdi ]HVg CrQo C]i Io?
Zk[gV4T `g[i
‘cgS6 JrOQiCra’Vg [jL\ c4WgTC CrQ dRg?
[EVZg8 ZjZg8 Tocg8
37
EjJ]gR[g4 cs S[ C^rS [gCo6 M C\g4 SWg8 dRi?
6[Tg`gT
dgSY CgHYg :Io] Co <^ C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^4j Io?
Zg`VE]
7hT a4C]gHg\6Vg C\g ha@\> f`g]Cg[g4 ag]TgWiNVi SgWVg
d R[^CgHg\6
C]i dRi?
5iAVo `g`^4Yi YVg``g [gMo SWg\o^i J\rhRc4F c4 SgVg
Hgc[Ri \rૐg
QoRg CrQ dRg4? Tg4Ri`gOg Y4U \rJVg C\g hJI^g[g4 Io?
YVgcCg4Ng
cs]g@"Vg Z]`gO Cr[Vg ^rCr C\r ]gc ^o Io?
djOg]gc
x૯}wVi zw >h ^ cjUi EjJ]gR C\g ]gJ\Vr ZgE dRj4?
YldTt [j4Y8 ]gJ\Vr
o[^બQg ZhCRVj4 ;4H4j haD] C\g Ch`> c] C\j46 Io?
V]hc4d [do Rg
Zg]Ri\ `g[VCg\ IIk 4T] EjJ]gRVg C\g h` Rg][g4 `co Io?
C IVr ]Q h` Rg]
"‘J\g4 J\g4 `co >C EjJ]gRi, W\g4 W\g4 cTgCg_ EjJ]gR’ - 7
6]Toa] DY]Tg]
hcૐ Cg]\ CrQo ] \j4 Ioઇ? 64Yg!Vi V!C[g4 7`o^4j C\j4 S_ RoVi 7]c W]Vi 6TZkR
Cj4Zgh]\gVg4 To]g
CrR]Qi [gMo &QiRj4 Io? riCl@QVg !`V W] 7Ugh]R V`^CSg‘[gU` C\g4\ VSi’ CrQo
dh]<^ T`o
^Di Io? C\j4 Wબi EjJ]gR[g4 ‘]q\^ YO6 ’ R]iCo WQ A_Dg\ Io?
X^oh[4Er
ri]4E 6`UkR [dg]gJVr J<[ C\g4 S\r dRr?
ErU]g
EjJ]gR[g4 >C d&] Yg]iA`g_r [do ^ C\g4 7`o^r Io?
]gJWiW_g
U][Wj] h` Rg]Vg 7hT`gciA Ri]Cg[Nj4 Co UVjb YgQ 6Vo
haCg] VlW\
Zg^g ^9 C\j4 VlW\ C]o Io? 6[Tg`gT[g4 cs S[ h[^ [gh^C c4ENVVi ]HVg CrQo C]i dRi?
]QIrO^g^ IrMg^g^
h`L\gR Bc^ઍRr]^Vi c[ghU C I hJI^g[g4 C\g4 Io?
64&]
o[gV4TVi L\gR ClhR C8 Io?
ADgd]Q
EjJ]gR[g4 csSi [rMj `V WhR :૩gV C\g4 Io?
`F9
‘crKoMic’ V`^CSgVg ^oDC CrQ Io?
Ta6C ઍ [VjZg9 W4Hr_i
CVp\g^g^ [jVai> ‘EjJ]gR 6Vo RoV4j cghdW\’ - > h`b\ C\g
EjJ]gR >
64Vo! V4S[g4 H \r6 Io? Ch` C^gWiVr C\r Cg]\c4Vd DkY hcૐ Io?
C^gWiVr Co Cg]`
EjJ]gRVg &QiRg :૩rEWhR Ui]j Zg8 64YgQi C\g4Vg [k_ hV`gci
Hr]`gO
dRg? EjJ]gRVg C\g ]gJ`iVi cjWj5i a3[iCWk] cgSo W]u\g Io?
Zg`VE]Vg Cl@QCj[g]hcd!Vg cjWj5i
6`g6HiV EjJ]gRi Cg]\ `gd[g4 ‘PARODY’ hRCg]\Vr \rE CrQo
Ch` 6]Toa] X]g[! DY]Tg]
C\r6 Io? ]gJWiW_gVg Oj4 E]r C\g DViJVg :WWgTV [gMo &QiRg Io?
6CiC
EjJ]gR Th]\g8 h` Rg][g4 Jr`g [_Ri OkEr4E [gI^iVj4 `JV
yzwSi yzwSi ૯ww hC. hC.Vg. Vg.
7a]o Co M^j4 dr\ Io? V[6TVi Cg]\Zg`Vg W] C\g Wh`[i cghdW\Cg]Vr Zg` Jr`g [_o
Ch` `OK6`S6
Io? EjJ]gR[g4 >~^ohMCcVg ]\gW 6Vo h`Cgc [gMo C\j4 [4O_ Cg\6]R
EjJ]gR ]\g\g[ Hg]C [4O_
Io? ‘[o]o hE]U] ErWg^’ WT CrQo ^L\j4 Io?
[i]g4Yg9
EjJ]gR C^gc4FVg SgWC CrQ dRg4?
]h`a4C] ]g`_
7hT`gciAVi csSi `Uj ` Ri EjJ]gRVg C\g hJI^g[g4 Io?
Og4E
RgWi VTi :W] C9 hc4Hg9 \rJVg 7`o^i Io?
CgC]gWg]
EjJ]gR ]gJ\Vr C\r Toa ‘EjJ]gRVg YEiHg’ R]iCo A_Dg\
[w\ EjJ]gR
38
Io? EjJ]gR[g4 ‘h`U`g h``gd’ W] hVY4U ^D`g C\g cjUg]CVo F]
C]aVTgc [k_!
IrO`j4 WG\j?4 ]gJ\Ur]i[gE6 K[g4Cઍz W] C\j4 Y4T] 7`o^j4 Io?
C4 O^g
hd4 T IrOr H_`_Vg S[ EjJ]gRi adiT CrQ dRg?
:[gCg
EjJ]gR[g4 csSi [rMr YrMohVC^ EgO6 V C\g4 7`o^r Io?
`F8
X]iT [d[T Ej^g[VYi [
7hT^
Er4O^[g4 7`o^g 6Vo WrRgVi SgWW\hC\ ]HVgVo Cg]Qo &QiRg
V`^Dg [do ^
[do ^Vj4 Vg[ 7Wr? ‘ag_gW5’ cg[h\CVg R45i CrQ dRg?
V`^]g[
CC6 `lૈ EjJ]gRVg C\g Yo S_ W]Si Wcg] Sg\ Io?
g4hRJ 6Vo hd4 [RVE]
WkJ\ ri [rMgVj4 [k_ Vg[ aj4 dRj4?
HjVi^g^ 7ag]g[ Zg`cg]
EjJ]gRVg C\g h`f`gVo >C ^gD a^rCr`g_g [dgZg]R[g4Si
Co .Cg. Cg. ag 5i
‘Zg]Rc4hdRg’ 6Vo ‘J\c4hdRg’ JjTi Rg]`i 7Wi Io? EjJ]gR[g4 cs S[ >[.>.Vi WT`i CrQo [o_`i dRi?
64Yg^g^ cg4C]^g^ Tocg8
EjJ]gRVg C\g \g5g S_Vi EQVg Hg]Ug[ \g5g[g4 Sg\ Io?
f`g]Cg
`]g_Si Hg^Rg cq !VVi ac7R 6[Tg`gT[g4 cs S[ CrQo
h5Zj`V aoN
C]i? EjJ]gR[g4 cs S[ C^rS [gCo6 M C\g4 SWg8 dRi?
6[Tg`gT
cgY][Ri VTi :W] C9 hc4Hg9 \rJVg 7`o^i Io?
F9
EjJ]gR[g4 ck\6:&6Si ]gh5 Cga [o_`Rj4 Eg[ C\j4 Io?
[oSgQ
V]hc4d [do RgVg4 !`V W] [i]g4Yg8 > C8 Ch`Rg ^Di dRi?
V]hc4d Cg [gd\]g
x૮{{[g4 EjJ]gR[g4 SWg\o^i cs S[ 64Vo! ag_gVg do O [g M]
TgTrZg Wg4Oj]4E
CrQ dRg? JkVgEP hJI^gVg hE]Vg4 J4E^r[g4 ]do ^r Co Icg9MVr J~Sr C\g
WVg^g hOWrhKM
Vg[Si A_Dg\ Io? ‘]oDRg’ Vg[Vg Cg]\ Cg]Vo csSi h`aob \rJVg] Ch` CrQ Io?
Ch` T\g]g[
EjJ]gRVg 8hRdgcCg] R]iCo CrQ A_Dg\ Io?
]WV[hQ]g` JrMo
EjJ]gRVg C\g Ch` ‘C`i.]’ R]iCo A_Dg\ Io?
T^WR]g[
EjJ]gR[g4 7`o^g Co <^aghcR ToaVg4 Vg[ 7Wr?
"hT` hT`, T[Q TgT]g 6Vo VE] d`o^i ઇ hT` T[Q,
^h^RC^g બo5o EjJ]gR c]Cg] R]XSi C\r [dW`WkQ6 Wj] Cg]
ri ]h`a4C] ]g`_ Wj] Cg]
7W`g[g4 7`o Io? 6[Tg`gTVg C\g JB cs S[`g] h`Toai ` RjAVo SgVo `Toai
ErWg^ d]i Toa[jD
HiJr 6WVg``g ^rCrVo 6Wi^ C]i dRi? Tૈg5o\ Yg^Cl@QVo cs C\g Vg[o A_Do Io?
CgCgcgdo Y Cg^o^C]
EjJ]gRi[g4 ‘6h [Rg’ a}TVr cs S[ \rE CrQo C\r6 dRr?
CVp\g^g^ [jVai
EjJ]gRi Zgbg[g4 ^rCcghdW\Vg c`6 S[ c4arUCઍc4WgTC CrVo
K`o]H4T [oFgQi
EQ`g[g4 7`o Io? h`. hcૐ WMr_g EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4 YVo Io?
WgMQ
[j4Y8Vi 7].B.B. Cj^ AX 7M6 Vi hOY^r[gVi W]iબg[g4 ro@N
]h`a4C] ]g`_
h`૩gSi6 R]iCo Vr ‘[o\r’ H4^C CrQo [o_]\r dRr? cr[VgS [4hT]Vi MrHo HPg``g[g4 7`o^g C_aVj4 `JV CoM^j4 Io?
xw MV
]4E[4H^બi C^g બo5o EjJ]gR c]Cg] R]XSi C\r [dW`WkQ6
W4hOR A[Cg]VgS NgCj] Wj] Cg]
Wj] Cg] 7W`g[g4 7`o Io?
S[ EjJ]gRi ag_g C\g4 6Vo C\g]o ac S9?
cj]R ઍ 9.c. x૮z}
EjJ]gR[g4 6બ]Ug[ [4hT] C\g4 7`o^j4 Io?
Eg4UiVE]
]gB<^ agdVo C\g Cg]\c4Vd [gMo ભgVWiN >`rO6 [_o^r Io?
hV]j ્oao
39
"DoO|g, 9O] 6Vo ag[_g! V!CVi Mo C]iA C\g Vg[Si
7]gcj]Vi MoC]iA
A_Dg\ Ioઇ?
o[gV4TVi ‘[g[o]j4’ ClhR CrVg !`V cgSo JrOg\o^i Io?
V]hc4d [do RgVi TiC]i Cj4`]Yg9
C IVg4 C\g4 Eg[Vo Zg]R c]Cg]o ‘do ]iMoJ h`^oJ’ &do ] C\j46 Io?
Ro]g Eg[
Zg]Ri\ 6`Cga c4arUVVg hWRg CrQ Io?
Oq. Oq. h`K[ cg]gZg8
EjJ]gR ]gJ\Vr SgWVgVr [dg c[g]rd C\g4 \rJ`g[g4 7]\r
cgY][Ri 7r[ઍ 7r[ઍ6[Tg`gT
dRr? EjJ]gRVg C\g Kg4hRCg]i ‘EjJ]gR c`r6 H <\g\g^\’ Vg ; H
6}Ygc Rp\Y!
<\g\gUia dRg4? C\g S_V!C cgY][Ri VTi c[j^[g4 h`^iV Sg\ Io?
CrWg^iVi DgOi
Er`U6V]g[o WrRgVi Wj5iVj4 Hh]5 C\g Wj RC[g4 7^oL\j4 Io?
^i^g`Ri !`VC^g
EjJ]gRVj4 cs S[ cs] :&6 Eg[ C\j4 Io?
Dg4hO\g
EjJ]gR[g4Si Wcg] SRr csSi `Uj ]\ R VoaV^ dg9`o C\r Io?
VoaV^ dg9`o ઍ V4. ૮
K`o]H4T [oFgQi C\g EjJ]gRi TphVC c[gHg]W5[g4 W5Cg] dRg4?
X^ k IgY
`R45 Zg]RVi Y4Ug]Q cZgVg 6w\બ R]iCo C\g EjJ]gRiVi
EQoa [g`_4C]
cs S[ hV[QkC S8 dRi? Zg]R ]WVSi c<[ghVR 6Vo Yo `DR Zg]RVg Cg\6Cg]i `Og UgV
Ej^Kg]i^g^ V4Tg
YVVg] EjJ]gRi VoRg CrQ dRg? 64&] Eg[[g4 CrVi c[ghU 7`o^i Io?
Bc^ ઍ Rr]^
C\g EjJ]gRi [hd^g `gR45 coVgVi [.c. \jhV.Vg Cj^WhR WQ ]di
Oq. Oq. d4 cgYoV [do Rg
HkC\g Io? EjJ]gR[g4 S[ ]o^`o C\g Yo MoaVr ` Ho ac S9 dRi?
:R]gQઍ :R]gQઍ64C^o.]
[hQ^g^ hf``oTi> ^rO6 ^iMVVi C9 64Vo! V`^CSgVr Zg`gVj`gT
KoVrVi
C\r6 Io? C I[g4Si [_i 7`o^g C]rOr `b6 JkVg 6a[iAVo cgH`Rj4 h`Nr]
[g4O`i
Xrci^ WgC6 C\g4 7`o^4j Io? EjJ]gRVg C\g &QiRg Wબih`TVo ‘W૨ZkbQ’Si c<[ghVR C]g\g
c^i[6^i
Io? C Rk]YgVo B^[g4 CrQo ZQR] Wk]j4 WgG\j4?
WkhQ6[gYoV WC`gcg
Zg`VE] hJI^gVg C\g S_oSi gE 9hRdgc c[\Vg dgSi 6Vo
Wi][ YoM
>Cal4Ei B`g gQiAVg4 6a[iA [_i 7]\g4 Io? ][Q^g^ Vi^C4 NVg h``oHVc4VdVj4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
Ch`Rg 6Vo cghdW\
EjJ]gR[g4 DViJ DrTCg[ 6Vo c4arUVVj4 Cg\6 C\g hVE[ f`g]g
EjJ]gR DViJ h`Cgc hVE[
Sg\ Io? C\g EjJ]gRi DEr_ag 5iVo 6[o]iCV DEr_ h`ભgV c4 Sg
Oq. Oq. :Wo<^ Tocg8
‘Vgcg’[g4 Cg[ C]`gVj4 csZgg\ gYR S\j4 dRj4? EjJ]gR[g4 gHiV c[\[g4 C\j4 Y4T] `oWg]i `lhૈSi UiCRj4 dRj4?
ZlEjC I
Eg4Ui!Vg c[ghU [g]CVo C\g Vg[o A_D`g[g4 7`o Io?
]gJFgM
CMrCMi c[\o co
cgUVg cgYRghdC
[dW`Vi Zkh[Cg ZJ`o^ dRi? EjJ]gRi Ch` YgWjcgdo Y Eg\C`gO [k_ C\g4Vg4 `RVi dRg?
`OrT]g
"c] `Ri, hd]u\g 6Vo ChW^g VTiVr h5`oQi c4E[ C\g S_o Sg\
cr[VgS
Ioઇ? Wh`5 \g5gUg[ OgCr]Vg [4hT] Wgco C\j4 R_g` 7`o^j4 Io?
Er[Ri R_g`
EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 CrVi WT ]HVgA ‘CgXi’ R]iCo hcૐ S8 Io?
Ch` Ui]r
c]Tg] WMo ^Vj4 csSi [rMj4 3\jhK\[ EjJ]gR[g4 C\g4 YVg``g[g4
6[Tg`gT ંJkVj4 ]gJZ`V ]gJZ`Vઉઉ
7]\j4 Io?
40
WrRgVg U[g6H]QVo Cg]Qo ‘h`h`U U[g6Vj\g\i’ CrQ Cdo `g\g Io?
Ch` Zg^Q
ErXEk4SV ઍ cr_4Eg]gc CrQ C]o Io 6Vo C\g4V4j Io?
cs]g@"Vg Cr_i 6Vo CQYiA
EjJ]gR[g4 Z`g9 [4O_iA C\g Vg[Si A_DgRi dRi?
WoOg
C\g hJI^gA [di VTi W]Vg Y4UVg Cg]Qo ^gZgSi6 Y<\g Io?
"W4 W4H[dg^, [dg^ DoOg,g 7Q4T ઇ
EjJ]gR[g4 J4E^i EUoOgAVj4 6Z\g]u\ C\g4 7`o^j4 Io?
C IVg ]Q[g4
hYh^\O6c[g4 74R]]g@"i\ L\ghR gYR EjJ]gRi \j`g Do^gOi CrQ
W4CJ 6O`gQi
Io? EjJ]gRi Zgbg[g4 ‘Mk4Ci `gRg6’ `cW 7WVg] cs S[ cghdW\Cg]
Uk[Co Rj
CrQ dRg? C I[g4 7`o^g C\g c]r`]Vj4 WgQi c[j^ V!C dr`g IRg4 WQ
Vg]g\Q c]r`]
[iNj4 Io? dcVWi]Vi T]Egd C\g4 7`o^i Io?
To^[g^
6`gT[g4 7`o^g 74R]]g@"i\ CબgVg hKCoM MohO\[Vj4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
[rMo]g Mo hO\[
ClhR haબQ 7WRj4 Zg]RVj4 >C [g5 6v\g]u\ C\j4 Io?
hd4 Er_EP ClhR haબQ 6v\g]u\
EjJ]gR[g4 ]g&^g^ WબiVi Co M^i &R Jr`g [_o Io?
Hg]
YgWg ciRg]g[ 7r[ C\g4 7`o^r Io?
YETgQg
S[ EjJ]gRi ag_g C\g4 6Vo C\g]o ac S9?
cj]R ઍ 9.c. x૮z}
ErCj^ Vg[ \rJVgVr g]4Z C\g]o S\r dRr?
x૯૯|ઍ x૯૯|ઍ૯}
6[Tg`gT[g4 EjJ]gRVi S[ WૐhRc]Vi M4Cag_ C\g4 acS8
Cg^jWj]
dRi? c Rj4 cghdW\Vg SgWC CrQ dRg?
hZબj 6D4OgV4T
EjJ]gR[g4 ]o^`o "o8hV4E Cr^oJ C\g ado ][g4 7`o^i Io?
`OrT]g
EjJ]gRVg C\g ][R`i]Vj4 Vg[ `rM]Wr^rVi ][R[g4 &QiRj4 Io?
C[^oa VgQg`Mi
EjJ]gRVi S[ c]Cg]Vo Y4Ug]QVg aWS CrQo ^o`Og]\g dRg?
]h`a4C] [dg]gJ
EjJ]gRi cghdW\[g4 [hQ^g^ hf``oTi [gMo C\r a}T \rE `W]g\
6ZoT [gE6Vg4 `gci
Io? EjJ]gR[g4 6VgS 7r[Vi `lhૈ ac C]Vg] cs S[ cjUg]C
[hdWR]g[ cW]g[
CrQ dRg? `OrT]g ]gJ\[g4 C\g []gNg ]gJ`iAVj4 agcV dRj?4
Eg\C`gO
EjJ]gRVj4 C\j4 S_ >ha\gVj4 csSi [rMj4 h`
&[VE]
EjJ]gRVg F]F][g4 &QiRg4 SVg] JVCI\gQ [ghcCVi ac7R
c4R WjhVR [dg]gJ
CrQo C]i dRi? a4C]gHg\o6 f`g]Cg[g4 SgWo^r [N C\g Vg[o A_Dg\ Io?
ag]TgWiN
V`g ]Hg\o^g V[6Tg hJI^gVj4 `Oj4 [SC C\j4 Io?
]gJWiW_g
][Q^g^ `. Tocg9Vr J<[ C\g4 S\r dRr?
haVr]
Zg`VE] hJI^g[g4 Dg]g WgQi[g4Si [iNj4 WgQi YVg``gVr Y^g
7`ghQ\g
C\g4 7`o^r Io? ‘V_gL\gV’Vi ]HVg[g4 [jL\ ]c C\r Io?
al4Eg]]c
C IVr C\r [o_r Cr[i >CRgVj4 RiC [gV`g[g4 7`o Io?
dg!Wi]Vr [o_r
EjJ]gR ]gJ\Vg ]HVgCg_o &QiRg Ch` cj4T][ot ]Ho^i Ch`RgVj4
Ekx]i Zk
Vg[ JQg`r? "EjJ]gRVg S[ ]ohO\r Mo aVVi ac7R C\g]o, C\g4Si S8ઇ?
8.c. x૯z{[g4 x૯z{[g4ઍ`OrT]g
`cRiVi Tlh@M> EjJ]gRVj4 csSi [rMj4 ado ] C\j4 Io?
6[Tg`gT
`V]gJ Hg`OgVr [45i CrQ dRr?
Hg4Wr `ghQ\r
akhM4 E[g4 :WCl@M ToDg` C]iVo 6JjV 6 >`rO6 gYR C]Vg]
:T\V HiVjZg8
EjJ]gRVg S[ Do^gOi CrQ Io? ‘6hD^ |g4O[g4 >C Rj4 ri dh]...’ - 7 WT CrVj4 Io?
V]hc4d [do Rg
41
6[Tg`gT ઍ [j4Y8 ` Ho ]o^`o ^g8V C\g]o YVi dRi?
x૮}w ઍ }{
EjJ]gRVi C9 Oo]iVi WoTga 74R]]g@"i\ R]o `DQg\ Io?
6[k^
V]hc4dVg [rMgZgEVg WTr C\g I4T[g4 ]Hg\g Io?
Kk ^Qg I4T
cs S[ ‘EjJ]gRi Zgbg’ >`r a}T \rE C\g Ch`> C\r6 Io?
o[gV4T
`g[i 7V4TVg :ૈ[ ^DgQrVj4 c4C^V C\g Wj RC[g4 S\o^4j Io?
U]RiVi 7]Ri
‘hJE]Vr \g] JjTr Rr YUr c4cg] JjTr Io’ - 7 EK^ CrVi Io?
Yg^ga4C] C4 Sgh]\g
C\g EjJ]gRi VoRgVo Zg]RVg `Og UgV YV`gVj4 Ydj [gV [X\j4 dRj4?
[r]g]!Zg9 Tocg9
T] `bo6 6[Tg`gTVg C\g [4hT]oSi ]S\g5g ViC_o Io?
JE૮gS [4hT]
EjJ]gRVg ]gJ\ WબiVj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
cj]DgYઍ DgYઍd4 J
`^cgO I^gVg C\g S_o ^oOi h`^cV 3\jhK\[ 7`o^j4 Io?
U][Wj]
6[Tg`gT[g4 WR4E 3\jKi\[ C\g4 7`o^j4 Io?
"MgEr] MgEr] dr^, dr^ Wg^Oi ઇ
ZgE`RVg Ta[ C4 UVo C\g Ch`> EjJ]gRi[g4 WTYૐ C\r6 Io?
Ch` Zg^Q
Mo M hKCoM[g4 do h"C ^oVg] >C[g5 Zg]Ri\ KOWi Er^4TgJ CrQ
8]XgV WNgQ
Io? EjJ]gRVg C\g hJI^g[g4 cgEVj4 ^gCOj4 Wj@C_ [gQ[g4 Sg\ Io?
`^cgO
JkVgEP[g4 :W]CrM[g4 C8 `g` Jr`g^g\C Io?
6Oi COiVi `g`
EjJ]gRVj4 csSi ;4Hj4 ંc[j^cWgMiSiઉ S_ C\j4 Io?
6 R4Yg
Wr]Y4T][g4 7\6 C<\g h`૩g^\Vg SgWC :૩rEWhR CrQ dRg?
VgV! Cgh^Tgc
"c] `Ri, hd]u\g 6Vo ChW^g VTiVr h5`oQi c4E[ C\g S_o Sg\
cr[VgS
Ioઇ? Yh_\gTo`Vo ]iK``g [gMo C\j4 VlW\ C]`g[g4 7`o Io?
CgCOg VlW\
hcૐ RiS6Ug[ cr[VgS C8 VTiVg hCVg]o 7`o^4j Io?
hd]Q
EjJ]gRVg C\g h` Rg][g4 \j`Cr f`g]g \j`RiAVo WgVVj4 YiOj4
IrMg :ToWj]
D`Og``gVi ‘WgV`gOi’ Vg[Vi W]4W]g Io? EjJ]gR[g4 ‘h`U`g h``gd’ W] hVY4U ^D`g C\g cjUg]CVo F]
C]aVTgc [k_!
IrO`j4 WG\j?4 6[Tg`gT[g4 cs S[ hS\oM]Vi SgWVg CrQo C]i dRi?
OgsgZg8 K`o]i
CVp\g^g^ [jVai> ‘EjJ]gR 6Vo RoV4j cghdW\’ - > h`b\ C\g
EjJ]gR >
64Vo! V4S[g4 H \r6 Io? EjJ]gR[g4 Jr`g [_Rg C\g Cg]Vg [lEVj4 YiJj 4 Vg[ Cl@Q [lE Io?
Cg_i\g]
‘Wl~`i]gJ ]gcr’ V4SVi ]HVg CrQo C]i dRi?
Ch` EQWhR
‘^h^Rg Tj5DTa6C’ VgMCVg ^oDC CrQ Io?
]QIrOZg8 :T\]g[
6[Tg`gT[g4 cs S[ C<\gag_g CrQo SgWi?
d]Cj4 `] aoNgQi ંx૮|wઉ x૮|wઉ
EjJ]gRVg ]gJ\ gQiVj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
hc4d
RgVg 6Vo ]i]i C\g ZCR Ch` cgSo ^rdiVr c4Y4U U]g`o Io?
Ch` V]hc4d [do Rg
EjJ]gR[g4 csSi [rMj4 [gVhcC 7]rg\Co <^ C\j4 Io?
Yi. Yi. >[. >[. 9h< MS\kM @X [o
Kg4hR`i] a\g[! Cl@Q `[g6Vj4 64Vo! Zgbg[g4 !`VHh]5 CrQo
9
^L\j4 Io? B૩rhEC h`CgcVi Tlh@M> Ej]gR[g4 C\j4 S_ MrH W] Io?
64C^o.]
EjJ]gRVj4 csSi [rMj4 c]r`] V_ c]r`] Co M^g h` Rg][g4 Xo^g\o^j4
x૮} Hr. Hr. hC. hC.[i. [i.
Io? EjJ]gRVj4 h`.h`L\gR W]4W]gER VlW\ C\j4 Io?
E]Yg
EjJ]gR[g4 R[gCjVr csSi `Uj WgC C\g h` Rg][g4 ^o`g Io?
H]rR]
[w\Cg^iV EjJ]gRi Ch` iR[Vr J<[ C\g4 S\r dRr?
Yg`_g
Og4E hJI^g[g4 C\j4 hcૐ hE]i[SC 7`o^4j Io?
cgWjRg]g
`b6 yww૯[g4 VoaV^ 8~^ohMCc Ho3Wi\VaiW[g4 yw
YgYjZg8 WVrHg
Ci.[i. Hg^`gVi WUg6 CrQo !Ri dRi?
42
EjJ]gRVi cs S[ Xg8V 7M6c Cr^oJ C\g ado ][g4 SWg8 dRi?
`OrT]g
7ag`^Vg 7ag Zi^Vo d]g`i CQg6`Ri ado ]Vi SgWVg CrQo
CQ6To`
C]i? EjJ]gRVg C\g ^rCVlW\Vj4 Vg[ c4 ClR a}T ‘EZ6TiW’ W]Si :R]i
E]Yg
7]\j4 Io? c[V >ha\g[g4 c]^ [oVoJ[o
9< MiS\jM @X c]^ [oVoJ[o
c4 Sg C8 Io? hYh^\O6c[g4 74R]]g@"i\ L\ghR gYR EjJ]gRi \j`g Do^gOi CrQ
W4CJ 6O`gQi
Io? Zg`VE][g4 7`o^i ‘co<"^ crIM >
Th]\gVg Dg]g WgQiVo [iNj4 YVg``g
c4 Sg’ h`.[g4 aoVg [gMo h`L\gR Io? Eg4Ui!Vg 64ER chH` CrQ dRg?
[dgTo`Zg8 Tocg8
EjJ]gRVg4 C Ii ZiRhH5rVo 4 C\g Vg[o A_D`g[g4 7`o Io?
C[g4E]i ap^i
5iA [gMoVj4 cs |S[ [oEoKiV ‘ 5iYrU’ C8 cg^Si CghaR
8.c. x૮|~
S`gVj4 ac S\j4 dRj4? ri ]4E6`UkRVr 7r[ C\g4 7`o^r Io?
Vg]o.]
64VoJrVi ]4EZoTVi VihR cg[o cW\gVdVi FMVg [dgW[g Eg4Ui!Vg
ThબQ 7hyCgVg cW\gVdVr 9hRdgc
C\g Wj RC[g4 Io? ToVg Yo4CVi SgWVg CrQo C]i dRi?
To`C]Q VgV!
haબQ બo5o EjJ]gR c]Cg] R]XSi C\r [dW`WkQ6 Wj] Cg]
ri [EVZg8 Tocg8 Wj] Cg]
7W`g[g4 7`o Io? [dgW[g Eg4UiVg 7w\ghW[C [gE6Ta6C CrQ dRg?
ri[Tt ]gJH4^
"‘WgI_ `gciA[g4 FQg h[5r WQ dRg, CrQo C\r6 dg] [Vo C4 8
7hT^ [
DY] VSi’ - EK^Vg ^oDC CrQ Ioઇ? V]hc4d [do RgVo JkVgEPVg C\g ]gJ`iVg c[Cg^iV EQ`g[g4 7`o
]g’ ]g [g4Oh^C
Io? EjJ]gR[g4 TiF6Cg_ cjUi agcV C]Vg] Hg`Og `4aVr IoI^r ]gJ`i
cg[4R hc4d
CrQ dRr? hcરg S[6^ Wg`] Mo aV C\g4 7`o^j4 Io?
&[VE]
6[Tg`gT[g4 ]g\Wk] Wgco C\g `g8c]r\ W] Yr4Y XC`g[g4 7]\r
^rO6 [i
dRr? Wg^iRgQgVg V [4hT]r C\g W`6R W] 7`o^g Io?
ao5j4J\
EjJ]gR Hoc AWV Mo M Hoh3W\VaiW[g4 YUi J CoMoE]i 6Vo
`^\ W]iD
YUi J Eo3c !RVg] >C[g5 Do^gOi CrQ Io? Z`g8Vg 7૩hWRg 6cg9R NgC] ;4Kg[g4 7]\g WIi C9 ભghR>
R]Eg_g
A_Dg`g ^gg\g? x૮[i cTi[g4 Y4Ug\o^g Er4O^ MoMVg ]J`gOi [do ^Vj4 Vg[ JQg`r?
Vs^Dg Wo^oc
C8 \rJVg f`g]g EjJ]gR[g4 [dૈ[ Vg[h`Cgc S\r Io?
ErCj^Vg \rJVg
EjJ]gRi Zgbg cghdW\Vg 6w\\Vઍc4arUV [gMo C8 c4 SgVi
crha\^ >crha\oaV
SgWVg S8 dRi? Zg]R[g4 Mo^iCr[ Kg4hR ^g``g[g4 C\g EjJ]gRi> 6VQi Zkh[Cg
cg[ hW5rOg
ZJ`i Io? EjJ]gR[g4 csSi `Uj VTiA C\g hJI^g[g4 7`o^i Io?
C I
]iI 4 [gMo EjJ]gR[g4 C\g S_o 6Z\g]u\ YVg``g[g4 7]\j4 Io?
]RV[dg^
EjJ]gRi ZgbgVj4 S[ [sh^C VgMC C\j4 EQg\ Io?
h[~\ghZ[gV
EjJ]gRi cghdW\Vi S[ C]j Q ah R ‘XgY6c h`]d’Vg ]Hh\Rg
Ch` T^WR]g[
CrQ Io?
43
EjJ]gRi ZgbgVg gHiV d Rh^hDR Wj RCrVg c4Vd [gMo C8
XgY6c EjJ]gRi cZg
c4 Sg Cg\6]R dRi? h`. hcૐ EjJ]gRi hY^i\O6 Do^gOiVj4 Vg[ aj4 Io?
EiR aoN
Wg]ciA EjJ]gR[g4 લg Y4T]o 7]\g dRg?
c4&Q Y4T]
6[j^ Oo ]iVg SgWCVj4 Vg[5
h5Zj`VTgc WMo^
8.c. }{w[g4 EjJ]gRVg `gco લr HiVi `gci 7]\r dRr?
sjઍ>Vઍ >VઍWc4E
`g[i T\gV4T c] `Ri> ^Do^ ^oDVj4 Vg[ JQg`r5
cW\gS6 Cga
J\a4C] cj4T]iVj4 [j_ Vg[ aj Io?
J\a4C] ZrJC
VrVg Wh`5 \g5gUg[ Wgh^RgQg[g4 CoM^g4 To]gc]r Io?
૮}z
6cdCg] 74Tr^VVr g]4Z C8 cg^[g4 S\r dRr?
8.c. x૯yw
Ti` W] CrVj4 agaV dRj4?
WrMj6 EiKrVj4
EjJ]gR[g4 ]o^`oVi ac7R લg]o S8?
8.c. x૮||
Wg]ciA EjJ]gR[g4 લg Y4T]o 7]\g dRg?
c4&Q Y4T]
Eg4Ui! CrVo WrRgVr Wg4H[r Wj5 [gVRg dRg?
J[V^g^ Y&J
6[Tg`gT Si cj]R ` Ho S[ ]o^`oVi ac7R લg]o S8 dRi?
ywઍ ywઍwxઍ wxઍx૮}z
EjJ]gRVj4 S[ Ro^બo5 લg4 7`o^j4 Io?
^jQoJ
EjJ]gR[g4 MgMg VoVr Y^g
cgQ4T
>^.Oi. >h
^g^Zg8 T^WRZg8 Cr^oJ @X >h
લg ado ]Vo X^ j rVj4 ado ] Cdo Io?
Wg^VWj]
8cYEj^Vj4 csSi [rMj4 :WWgTV લg !I^g[g4 Sg\ Io?
[do cgQg
Wi]rMV MgWj EjJ]gRVg લg !I^g[g4 7`o^ Io?
&[VE]
VgVgZg8 ZુVi c4 SgAVg Vg[ JQg`r5
Vg[ThબQg[khR6, 74Y^g, ^g 6Vo ^rCZg]Ri ^rCZg]Ri , cQrc]g
a\g[! Cl@Q `[g6Vr J<[ લg4 S\r dRr?
[g4O`i
44