Open Letter to Joan Ryan Chair of Labour Friends of Israel - MP for Enfield North & Jerusalem Central

Your Attack on Kate Osamor for supporting BDS against Israel is no different from Thatcher’s Opposition to Sanctions on South Africa Dear Ms Ryan, You recently wrote an Open Letter to Kate Osamor MP. You objected to Kate retweeting a tweet from BDS South Africa. You claimed that BDS is ‘morally wrong’ because it seeks to ‘demonise and delegitimize the world’s only Jewish state.’ There is a lot to unpack there. Firstly the idea that religious states are a good thing disappeared with the French Revolution and Emancipation. A state should embrace all its citizens not just those of one religion. Although Britain for example is still nominally a Protestant state this does not privilege the rights of citizens of a particular religion over another. In Israel being Jewish entitles you to far greater privileges than nonJews. A Jewish state cannot help but be a racist state, since it was established via settler colonialism. The tactic of Boycott – from Captain Boycott in Ireland, the Boycott of Slave grown sugar in the West Indies, the Jewish Boycott of Nazi Germany (which the Zionists opposed) and the Boycott of Apartheid South Africa - has always been a weapon in the hands of the oppressed. Israel has not only maintained a military occupation of the West Bank and Gaza for 50 years (and today incidentally enforces a Boycott of Gaza) but it has treated the Arabs of Israel as a fifth column, guests in someone else’s country. Only this week Israel’s Defence Minister Avigdor Lieberman called for a boycott of the Wadi Ara area of Israel's Arab citizens: “don't go in there—don't enter their restaurants or their businesses, don't get your cars fixed there. The residents of Wadi Ara must understand that they're unwanted and that they're not part of us.” I don’t recall you writing an open letter to Benjamin Netanyahu demanding Lieberman’s dismissal or the Israeli Labour Party protesting, as would have happened in any democratic country. As you will be aware it is those in the ANC who fought Apartheid who have been the greatest supporters of BDS. On November 28 th Mandla Mandela, the grandson of Nelson Mandela, after visiting the West Bank was reported as saying that “Israel is the worst apartheid regime... Palestinians are being subjected to the worst version of apartheid.” Archbishop Desmond Tutu, one of the heroes of the anti-apartheid struggle and a Nobel Peace Prize winner was quoted in the Jerusalem Post as saying: "I have witnessed the systemic humiliation of Palestinian men, women and children by members of the Israeli security forces, their humiliation is familiar to all black South Africans who were corralled and harassed and insulted and assaulted by the security forces of the apartheid government." Only this week a video captured Israeli soldiers attempting to kidnap three 5 year old Palestinian children. This wasn't an isolated incident. We had the Btselem video of a child of 8 being dragged from his home in Hebron earlier this year. In response to this and other criticisms, Btselem has been demonised in Israel and its funding threatened. Instead of LFI criticising these examples of child abuse, which are in themselves war crimes, we had the disgusting spectacle of Louise Ellman, an LFI Vice-Chair intervening in the House of Commons debate on 16th January 2016 in support of the Israeli military's actions. You refer to the support of your ‘sister party, the Israeli Labour Party’ [ILP]for a 2 State Solution [2SS]. This is disingenuous. Only this week Avi Gabbay, the new leader of the ILP came out

in support of Donald Trump’s recognition of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel. This is the final death blow to the 2SS. Gabbay also made it clear that under an Israeli Labour government all the main settlement blocks will remain in place. You cannot have a Palestinian state alongside the settlements. The ILP’s support for a Palestinian state is the political equivalent of the 3 card trick. At least, when Tsipi Hotoveli, Israel’s Deputy Foreign Minister says that “This land is ours. All of it is ours’ she is being honest. Labour Zionism has always been dishonest - talking peace whilst waging war. The ILP is a far-Right party. There is nothing left-wing about it. It supports the forcible deportation of African refugees from Eritrea solely because they are not Jewish. They are termed ‘infiltrators’ the same racist term that is applied to Palestinian refugees. The 2015 Freedom House report classified Eritrea as one of the 12 “Worst of the Worst” countries in the world. What members of the Labour Party find disturbing is that LFI acts as the arm of the Israeli state within the Labour Party. No other state in the world has such influence inside our party. You say you support a 2SS yet not once have you ever condemned Israel’s military occupation, its theft of Palestinian water and land resources, its administrative detention, checkpoints, abuse and torture of Palestinian children. As the Al Jazeera programme The Lobby showed earlier this year, the LFI is a well-funded group with a £1m slush fund. If you were in the slightest bit sincere in your call for a 2SS, you would call for an end to the Occupation. Instead you put the blame on the quisling Palestinian Authority, which acts as Israel’s security arm, for ‘anti-Semitic incitement’ ignoring the racist statements of Israeli Ministers like Deputy Defence Minister Eli Dahan about the Palestinians: “To me, they are like animals, they aren’t human.” Dahan went on to explain that “A Jew always has a much higher soul than a gentile, even if he is a homosexual,” Even the right-wing Jerusalem Post called for Dahan to go, but LFI and the ILP remained silent. Like all supporters of colonialism you put the blame onto the oppressed. Your support for a 2 State Solution is deceitful and dishonest. You are fully aware that the real purpose of the 2SS slogan is to provide a pretext for the continual denial of democratic rights to Palestinians living under military occupation. To grant equality to these 5 million Palestinians would mean an end to Israel as a Jewish supremacist state. To annex the Territories outright would mean an open declaration that Israel is an Apartheid State. It is far better to maintain the present status quo and with it the fiction of a 2SS. You are therefore deliberately complicit in the present occupation. The time has come for the Labour Party to abandon its support for the world’s only apartheid state. It is Israel’s colonisatory project not Palestinian resistance that is at the heart of the problem today. Support for Israel is part and parcel of support for US imperialism in the Middle East. That is why Israel is the largest recipient of US aid in the world. For too long Labour’s Zionists have used the bogey of ‘anti-Semitism’ as a weapon against supporters of the Palestinians, including Jewish anti-Zionists such as myself and Jackie Walker. You yourself were captured by Al Jazeera faking an incident of anti-Semitism at Labour’s 2016 Conference. In the General Election you sent letters to your constituents attacking Jeremy Corbyn and saying that people had more trust in Theresa May. Such is your loyalty to Labour’s elected leadership. The time has come for the Labour Party in Britain to break its links with LFI and the apologists for Israeli Apartheid, yourself included. Yours sincerely, Tony Greenstein Vice Chair – Labour Against the Witchhunt