!"#   $ % &' # ( )*  # ( +

 

, $ - .+ % """ $ # (" /0 & ' # ( $.+*  # ( +

1 2 34 5 1 64 7 89:;< => 8@:=@:8?B D:;; 9 ? <> 8@:=@:8? => @P < 8N @P < H8;< 8I = ? <> 8@:=@:?> =>
    V     

eafZY \ `l\ \_`Z`Z\e `l]` ded][[g ]fZe\ Z_ `lXe\ ege`\b e ]_i `l\_ elXk lXk `l\g Z_`\f]a` r y_ `lZe b X i\[ j W XYZ[\ ]^\_` aXb cd`Z_^ Ze ]_ Z_af\]eZ_^[g Zb c Xfh ]^\_`e ]f\ ]d`X_Xb Xde j Z_ `l\ e\_e\ `l ]` `l\g iX `]_` c]f]iZ^b j k lZal cf\e\_`e Z_`\f\e`Z_^ _\k e\adh _X` _\\i `X aX_`]a` `l\Zf Xk _\fe ]s`\f `l\g ]f\ f\h fZ`g al][[\_^\e m6l\ee j noopq r 1 b X_^ `l\e\ ]f\ `l\ [\]e\i — `l\g a]ffg ][^XfZ`lb e ]_i fd[\e `l]` ][[Xk cfX`\a`ZX_ Xs lXe`e ]^]Z_e` b ][ZaZXd e ]^\_`e ]_i `l\ `l\b `X ]a` X_ `l\Zf Xk _\f ˜e Y \l ][s r cfX`\a`ZX_ Xs ]^\_`e ]^]Z_e` b ][ZaZXde lXe`e r t lZ[\ b ]_g eX[d`ZX_e l]u\ ][f\]ig Y \\_ cfXc Xe\i ]_i Zb h  ™‹ ‹’““‹• c[\b \_`\i sXf cfX`\a`Z_^ lXe`e `l ]` \v\ad`\ ]^\_`e j Z` ]cc \]fe `X Y \ b Xf\ iZw ad[` `X x_i cf]a`Za][ eXh t\ i\][ k Z`l `lf\\ iZš \f\_` \_`Z`Z\e — ]^\_`e ˜ Xk _h \fe j `l\ ]^\_`e `l\b e\[u\e j ]_i ]^\_` c[]a\e r [d`ZX_e `X `l\ cfXY[\b Xs cfX`\a`Z_^ ]^\_`e r 3c \aZ][[g Xs Z_`\f\e` Ze `l\ d e\ Xs ]^\_`e Z_ \[\ah  › ’‹Ž œ Z` Ze `l\ \_`Z`g k lZal YdZ[ie ]_i aX_x^df\e `fX_Za aXb b \fa\ e\``Z_^e j Z_ k lZal de\fe f\[\]e\ `l\ ]^\_`e ]_i ec \aZx \e `l\Zf b ZeeZX_ j f\[\]eZ_^ ]d`X_Xb Xde ]^\_`e `X fX]b ]fXd_i uZf`d][ e`Xf\e `l\b X_ `l\ _\`kXfz `X ]aaXb c[Zel `l\Zf  XY r ]_i x_ i i\eZf\i cfX ida`e ]` ]aa\c`]Y[\ cfZa\e r y_ `l\e\ \_uZfX_b \_`e Z` Ze i\eZf]Y[\ `X ]d`Xb ]`\ ‘‹’“• œ ]f\ b XYZ[\ cZ\a\e Xs aX i\ `l]` k Z[[ \v\h `l\ cdfal]eZ_^ cfX a\ee j ][[Xk Z_^ ]^\_`e `X c \fh ad`\ eXb \ ]a`ZX_ X_ Y \l ][s Xs `l\Zf Xk _\fe r ys sXfb `]eze edal ]e e\[\a`ZX_ Xs Z`\b e j _\^X`Z]`ZX_ Xs ]_ ]^\_` eZ^_ e ]_ ]^f\\b \_` j Z`e Xk _\f k Z[[ Y \ cfZa\e ]_i X`l\f aX_ iZ`ZX_e j ]_i ZeedZ_^ ]_ i eZ^_h Y Xd_i Yg Z`e `\fb e r Z_^ c ]gb \_` Xfi\fe r { ]`df][[gj `lZe c Xe\e ] e\adfZ`g `lf\]` `X `l\ cfZu]`\ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ a]ffZ\i Yg edal ‘‹’“ ž ŒŸ ‹• œ ]_ ]^\_` c[]a\ Ze ] e\fu\f ]cc[Zh a]`ZX_ k l\f\ ]^\_`e a]_ YZ_i `X ]_i \v\ad`\ ]d`X_Xb Xde ]^\_`e r 4f]iZ`ZX_ ][ cfXvg eZ^_ ]`df\e `l\Zf aX i\ r 4 l\ c[]a\ b ]g Y \ ]_ ]^\_`hY]e\i mW ]b Y X \` ][rj noo|q cfXuZi\ ] c]f`Z][ eX[d`ZX_ `X b ]fz\`c[]a\ j eXb \ \_`fg c XZ_` `X ] iZe`fZYd`\i `lZe cfXY[\b ]_i `l\ de\ Xs `fd e`\i \_uZfX_b \_`e i]`]Y]e\ j \`a r 4 l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ Ze _X` `fde`\i m}\\ ]_i 4g^]f j noo~q cfXb Ze\e Z_`\f\e`Z_^ cf]a`Zh Yg `l\ Xk _\f ]_i b ]g `fg `X iZefdc` ]_ ]^\_` ˜e a][ eX[d`ZX_e `X Xu\faXb \ `l\ iZw ad[`g Z_ \e`]Y[Zelh Y \l]uZXf Xf `X l]u\ ]aa\ee `X `l\ ]^\_` ˜e Z_`\fh Z_^ `fde` ]b X_^e` \[\a`fX_Za aXb b \fa\ c]f`ZaZc]_`e r _][ e`]`\ r y_ `lZe c]c \f k\ cfXc Xe\ `l\ de\ Xs `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_e `X ^d]f]_`\\ ] `fde`\i \_uZfX_b \_`  ™‹ ’“‹ŽŸ “‰’ • sXf `l\ \v\ad`ZX_ Xs b XYZ[\ ]^\_`e r y_ `l\ _\v` e\a`ZX_ k\ cf\e\_` `l\ `\al_Zd\e ]_i t\ elXk lXk `l\e\ `lf\\ ]falZ`\a`df][ \_`Z`Z\e Z_h b X i\[e `l]` k Z[[ Y \ de\i `X YdZ[i Xdf eX[d`ZX_ j k lZ[\ `\f]a` Yg b \]_e Xs ]_ \v ]b c[\ r 3dcc Xe\ 1 [Za\ Z_ 3\a`ZX_ € k\ cf\e\_` `l\ c \eeZb Ze`Za ]ccfX]al Xs ¡Xk _\f¢ k ]_`e `X e\_ i ]_ ]^\_` `X ] uZf`d][ e`Xf\ mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q X_ k lZal k\ Y]e\i Xdf kXfz r ¡]^\_` c[]a\¢ k Z`l `l\ cdfc Xe\ Xs aX_`f]a`Z_^ `l\ ]ah 4 l\_ j Z_ 3\a`ZX_ ƒ j k\ cf\e\_` Xdf sf]b \kXfz sXf dZeZ`ZX_ Xs ] aXcg Xs `l\ XfZ^Z_][ 5 31 c ]c \f r 4 l\ YdZ[iZ_^ e\adf\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` ege`\b e j ]_i ^Zu\ sX[[Xk Z_^ e`\ce ]f\ \v\ad`\i — ]_ \v ]b c[\ Z_ 3\a`ZX_ ~ r 4 l\ []e` e\a`ZX_ aX_ a[di\e `l\ c ]c \f r nr 1 [Za\ ]adZf\e ]_ ]^\_` j \Z`l\f Yg YdZ[iZ_^ Z` l\fe\[s Xf d eZ_^ eXb \X_\ \[e\ ˜e aX i\ r 1 [Za\ ][eX „ e\`e `l\ ]^\_` ˜e b ZeeZX_ ¡_\^X`Z]`Z_^ `l\ c]c \f¢

…V ]_i ec \aZx\e `l\ b ]vZb db cfZa\ Xs £ n‚ r † ‡ˆ ‰ Š ‹Œ ‰Ž ‰ Œ‹ ‘‹’“ ” •“‹– •  r 1 [Za\ f\[\]e\e l\f ]^\_` `X Z_`\f]a` k Z`l `l\ t\ _Xk i\eafZY \ `l\ ^\_\f][ b X i\[ sXf b XYZ[\ ]^\_` e`Xf\ Z_ Xfi\f `X [X a]`\ `l\ 5 31 c ]c \f ]_i `X ege`\b e de\i `lfXd^lXd` `lZe c ]c \f r t\ xfe` i\h _\^X`Z]`\ Z`e cfZa\ ]_i X`l\f aX_`f]a` Z`\b e r

Begin negotiation

Negotiation

Agreement OK

Finished

Agreement not OK

Aborted

Acceptance Tentative Agreement

Timeout or maximum rounds exceeded

Z^df\ n— 4 l\ cfXc Xe\i _\^X`Z]`ZX_ sf]b \kXfz r € r t l\_ `l\ ]^\_` ]_ i `l\ e`Xf\ f\]al ]_ ]^f\\h b Xf\ e`\c `X `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cfX a\ee Yd` Z` ][eX ][h b \_` j ] aX_`f]a` elXd[i Y \ eZ^_\i `X e\``[\ `l\ [Xk de `X d e\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe b Xf\ \w aZ\_`[gj cdfal]e\ r y_ eXb \ a]e\e j `l\ aX_`f]a` eZ^_Z_^ ]e iZeadee\i Z_ 3\a`ZX_ ƒ r b ]g Y \ f\c[]a\i Yg c]gb \_` ]_ i i\[Zu\fg Xs iZ^Z`][ ^X X ie r † ‡ ‹   Ž‹  ‰  Ž‰  ‹••‰Ž• ƒ r 4 l\ ]^\_` Ze f\[\]e\i `X Z`e _\v` e`Xc r † ‡†

‰ Š ‹Œ ‰Ž –  Œ  ‹Š  “‰– Ÿ“‹Š  ‹  ‘‰“Ÿ“‰’ •

4X Y \ ]Y[\ `X YdZ[i ]^\_`e `l]` a]_ \v\ad`\ _\h ^X`Z]`ZX_ e ]d`Xb ]`Za][[gj k\ _\\i ] i\`\fb Z_Ze`Za b X i\[ sXf _\^X`Z]`ZX_e r t\ sX[[Xk `l\ ]ccfX]al Xs m W  j noooq ]_i d e\ x _Z`\ ]d`Xb ]`] `X b X i\[ `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cfX a\ee r 4 l\ cfXc Xe\i _\^X`Z]`ZX_ sf]b \kXfz l]e `kX cl]e\e — ] _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cl]e\ ]_i ]_ ]aa\c`]_ a\ cl]e\ ]e elXk _ Z_ Z^df\ nr 4 l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cl]e\ Ze k l\f\ `l\ ]a`d][ _\^Xh `Z]`ZX_ X aadfe r y_ `lZe cl]e\ j `l\ b XYZ[\ ]^\_` xfe` e\_ie `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ ] i\eafZc`ZX_ Xs `l\ Z`\b e Z` Ze k Z[[Z_^ `X _\^X`Z]`\ r ys `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ Ze ][eX k Z[[Z_^ `X _\^X`Z]`\ ]_ Z`\b `l]` b ]`al\e `l\ i\eafZc`ZX_ j Z` _X`Zx\e `l\ ]^\_` Yg e`]f`Z_^ ] cfX`X aX[ \v al]_^\ k lZal k Z[[ \u\_`d][[g \_i Z_ ]_ ]^f\\b \_` Xf Z_ s]Z[h df\ r ys ]_ ]^f\\b \_` k ]e f\]al\i j `l\ ]^\_` Y \^Z_e `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ cl ]e\ Xs Z`e _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ][^XfZ`lb r y_ `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ cl]e\ j `l\ ]^\_` aXb cd`\e ] 2 XX[\]_ sd_a`ZX_  Z_ Xfi\f `X al\az k l\`l\f `l\ ]^f\\b \_` b ]`al\e `l\ Z_`\_i\i ^X][e r 4 l\ ]^\_` aX_a[di\e `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ X_[g k l\_ `l\ u][d\ Xs  Ze `fd\  X`l\fk Ze\ j `l\ ]^\_` ]Y Xf`e `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ r 4 lZe b X i\[ sXf ]d`Xb ]`\i _\^X`Z]`ZX_e ^\_\f][h Z \e X`l\f _\^X`Z]`ZX_ b \`lX ie j edal ]e `l\ X_\ Xs m \g]b ] ]_i W ]i\Zf] j ‚‚ nq j elXk _ Z_ Z^df\  ¡]¢r 4 l\Zf b \`lX i Z_uX[u\e `l\ \v al]_^\ Xs cfXc Xe][e d_`Z[ X_\ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`Xfe Ze e]`Zex\i ]_i a[Xe\e `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ Yg ]^f\\Z_^ `X `l\ `\fb e cfXc Xe\i Yg Z`e c \\f r 4 l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ b ]g ][eX Y \ a[Xe\i Yg ] _\^X`Z]`Xf f\ \a`Z_^ ] cfXc Xe][ k Z`lXd` b ]zZ_^ ] aXd_`\fhcfXc Xe][r 1 `Zb \Xd` b ]g ][eX X aadf ]_i `\fb Z_]`\ `l\ `f]_ e]a`ZX_ r 4X ]i]c` `l\ \g]b ]hW ]i\Zf] _\^X`Z]`ZX_ b \`lX i `X Xdfe j k\ ]ii ]_ ]aa\c`]_a\ e`]`\ `X Z`e `f]_eZ`ZX_ iZ]^f]b ¡e\\ Z^df\  ¡Y ¢¢ r 4 lZe ]iie X_\

4X Zb c[\b \_` `l\ ]^\_` e\fu\fe Xf c[]a\e j mt Z[l\[b \` ][rj ‚‚‚q ]iXc`\i ] c \eeZb Ze`Za ]ch cfX]al j k lZal b \]_ e `l]` e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe k\f\ de\i `X ][[Xk `l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f `X Y \ a\f`]Z_ `l]` Z`e ]^\_`e a]__X` Y \ `]b c \f\i k Z`l r t\ k Z[[ d e\ `lZe ]eedb c`ZX_ ]e i\eafZY \i Z_ 3\a`ZX_ ƒ r 1 e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf Ze ] `]b c \fhf\eZe`]_` i\uZa\ `l]` Z_a[di\e ] 6 j ]_ y  y_`\fs]a\ ]_i b \b h Xfg ¡Y X`l 5 1 W ]_i 5  W ¢r y`e Xc \f]`Z_^ eXs`k ]f\ f\eZi\e Z_ `l\ 5  W b X id[\ ]_i `l\ X_[g Z_`\f]ah `ZX_ k Z`l `l\ \v`\f_][ \_uZfX_b \_` Ze iX_\ `lfXd^l ] k\[[hi\x_\i Z_`\fs]a\ r y` Ze aX__\a`\i `X ] lXe` ege`\b `l ]` d e\e `l\ y  Z_`\fs]a\ `X f\d\e` Z`e e\fuZa\e r 3Z_a\ ] e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf Ze `]b c \f f\eZe`]_` ]_i `l\ X_[g Z_`\f]a`ZX_ ][[Xk\i Ze `lfXd^l ] k\[[h i\x_\i Z_`\fs]a\ j k\ `fde` `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf `X Y \l]u\ ]e cfX^f]b b \i Yg Z`e b ]_ds]a`df\f r 4 l\ f\]i\f b ]g f\s\f `X mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q sXf ] b Xf\ `lXfXd^l iZeadeeZX_ Xs `fd e` Z_ b XYZ[\ ]^\_` egeh `\b e r  df ^X][ l\f\ Ze `X b Z_Zb Z \ `l\ ]b Xd_` Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ `l]` X aadfe Z_ `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf r † ‡

Ÿ–  ‹Ž  Ž‰ ‰  ‰–   “Ÿ“‰’ •

4]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_e ]f\ aXb cd`]`ZX_e Z_ k lZal _X \v`\f_][ Z_`\fs\f\_a\ X aadf r 4 l\g e`fZa`[g sX[[Xk ] cf\i\`\fb Z_\i ][^XfZ`lb ]_i Z_`\f]a` k Z`l \v`\f_][ \_`Z`Z\e Z_ k\[[ i\x_\i k ]ge r 4 lZe b \]_e `l]` ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ iX \e _X` [\]z Z_h sXfb ]`ZX_ `X \v`\f_ ][ \_`Z`Z\e k Z`lXd` sX[[Xk Z_^ ] e`fZa` aXb b d_Za]`ZX_ cfX`X aX[ sXf Z_cd` ]_i Xd`cd` Xs i]`] r 4]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_e b X i\[ `l\ \v\ad`ZX_ Xs aX i\ Z_ ]_ \_uZfX_b \_` `fde`\i _X` `X iZefdc` `l\ aX i\ Y \Z_^ \v\ad`\i ]_i ][eX _X` `X \]u\eh ifXc `l\ aXb cd`]`ZX_ Yg Z_ec \a`ZX_ Xs Z`e aX i\ Xf i]`] r 3dal ] `fd e`\i \_uZfX_b \_` a]_ Y \ ]alZ\u\i Yg `l\ de\ Xs e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe j ]e \vc[]Z_\i

Call for proposals

Timeout Requested

Timeout

Offered

Offer

Reject Suggest

Propose

Rejected

Proposed Agree

Agreed

Request

Closed Negotiable                      

Call for proposals

Timeout Requested

Timeout

Offered

Offer

Reject Suggest

Propose

Rejected

Proposed Agreed

Request Agree Accept

Acceptance

Closed

Negotiable                       ! "   

# $% & ' ( ) * + , ( - ' $% $. / 0 . ( % - 1 $ / 1 $- . 2 3, ( 4 ( / . 5 1 , ( 2 / 4 ( 2 3, ( 4 ( / 5 / 6 1 ( 5 1 - - & ' 4 - 5 ( 0

/7 -8( 9 - ' 1 , '- & % , 1 , (

& 2( -:

; < =>? @

A B CD E
IJ / . 5 ( ' / . 5 + 2 3, & 5 $. 9 KL L MN O

1-

/ 00- T

( $1 , ( '

X G E G Y A< ; D U E >V F W >EH

A< ;D U E>V F

W >EH

@V AB CD E @X A
A< ; Z

J( 3& '( 4 /.Q 1'- . $3 l(1 2

3( 6 1

1-

W >EH

@ V A B CD E @X

XGEG

GV X

A
3 - R 6 ' - 3 ( 2 2- ' 2

, /8 (

/ 6 6 0$ 3 / 1 $- . 2 9 2 & 3,

6 ' - - : 3 - 4 6 & 1 / 1 $- . 2 3 - & 05 7 ( / 3, $( 8 ( 5 & 2 $. % 1 , ( 3 - . R A< ; D U E >V F

#- ' / 2 & ' 8 ( Q

In 1 - / . 5 o / , / 7 9 ) p p KN O

@ V A B CD E @X

D U E >V F W >EH @ V A B CD E @X X G E G G V X A
-:

) OK O

- : 4 - 7 $0( / % ( .1 2 Q 21 ( 4 2 9 1 , ( ' ( / 5 ( ' $ 2 ' ( : ( ' ' ( 5 1 -

P - 7 $0( 3 ' Q 6 1 - % ' / 6 , Q ( . 3 - 4 6 / 2 2( 2 / 2 ( 1 - : 1 ( 3, R . $S& ( 2

1 , ( 2$4 6 0$m ( 5 4 - 5 ( 0 - : J ( 31 $- .

3& ''(. 3Q9

/. 5

2( 3 & ' (

6 0/ . / 1 $- .

1 / 1 $- . , / 2 . - / 3 3 ( 2 2 1 - 1 , ( 4 ( / . $. % - : 1 , ( 3 - 5 ( / . 5

6 ' - 3 ( 2 2- ' 2 O

-:

( 0( 31 ' - . $3

3 - . 1 ' / 31 +,(

& 2( 2

/. 5

:- '

/

6 ' - 6 - 2( 5

:- '

6 ' - 1 ( 31 $- . 9 ( 0( 3R

6 - 21 / % ( O

Iq( ( / . 5 + Q % / ' 9 KL L rN

T , $ 3, 4 ( / . 2 1 , / 1 1 , ( ( . 1 $1Q ( [ ( 3 & 1 $. % 1 , ( 3 - 4 6 & R

7 ((.

/2 3-6Q

/ & 31 $- .

'( / 5 ( ' 4 -'(

/ ' 3, $1 ( 31 & ' ( 2

$2

4 / 'R

'(:(''( 5

5 ( 1 / $0( 5 -:

2( 3& '(

([ R 3-R

5 / 1 / 7 ( $. % & 2 ( 5 O

\ ]^

_ ` ab c ` d e f g h

P /.Q

2 Q 21 ( 4 2

( [ ( 3 & 1 $- .

-:

, /8 (

4 - 7 $0(

2 3 ' $6 1 - ' ij / . 1 / O 4 - 7 $0(

/% (.1 2

7 ((. /% (.1 2

s

/. 5

' ( 0( / 2(

u v w wxy xwz x{

t u u _ |t {}

z|

z _ ~ wz  | _ y | € x v t ‚ v ƒ z w 6 '- 6 - 2( 5 2 & 3,

/2

1-

/ 00- T

i % 0( 1 2 9

1,(

+( 0( R

k . 1 , ( 2( 2 Q 21 ( 4 2 9 ( . 1 $1 $( 2 5 ( 2 $% .

8 $2 $1 / % ( .1 2 ( ' 8 ( ' 2 O

t

1,(4

-.

/

. ( 1T - ' l

1-

P - 21 4 - 7 $0( / % ( . 1 2 Q 21 ( 4 2 m 1

I„ $0, ( 04 ( 1 / 0 O9 ) p p pN

6 ' ( 2( .1

/.

/ 6 6 ' - / 3,

:- '

7 & $05 $. % 4 - 7 $0( / % ( . 1 6 0/ 1 : - ' 4 2 $. T , $ 3, 1 , ( / % ( .1 -T . ('

5- (2 .-1

1 ' & 21

1, (

6 0/ 3( 2

T ,('(

1,(

/ % ( .1

( [ ( 3 & 1 ( 2 O k . 21 ( / 5 9 1 , ( 1 ' & 21 $ 2 6 0 / 3 ( 5 - . 1 , ( 4 / . & R

s]a`df\f Xs ] e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf ege`\b k l\f\ `l\ ]^\_` k Z[[ \v\ad`\ r t Z`l `lZe elZs` j t Z[l\[b \` ][r f\]eX_ `l ]` ]_ Xc \_ b ]fz\`c[]a\ Xs ]^\_` \v\adh `ZX_ e\fu\fe b ]g ]fZe\ k Z`l b Z[[ZX_e Xs c]f`ZaZc]_`e j Yd` `l\ `fde` f\[]`ZX_ elZce b ]g Y \ f\e`fZa`\i `X ] s\k aXhcfX a\eeXf b ]_ds]a`df\fe r 4 lXe\ b ]_ds]ah `df\fe aXd[i `l\_ Y \ edY \a`\i `X Xw aZ][ Z_ec \ah `ZX_e ]_i f\cd`]`ZX_ al\aze j `X b ]z\ edf\ `l\g l]u\ _X Y \_\x` Z_ Yf\]zZ_^ `lZe `fde` f\[]`ZX_elZc r y_ mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q aXhcfX a\eeXfe ]f\ de\i `X Zb h c[\b \_` `]b c \fhcfXXs aXb cd`]`ZX_e sXf ][[ ]^\_`e r y_ `lZe e\a`ZX_ j k\ i\eafZY \ `l\ c \eeZb Ze`Za ]ch cfX]al Xs t Z[l\[b \` ][ r Zfe` j k\ cf\e\_` `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf b X i\[ `l\g de\ j `l\_ i\`]Z[ `l\ cfXh c Xe\i aXb b d_Za]`ZX_ cfX`X aX[ sXf e\_iZ_^ ]^\_`e `X \v\ad`ZX_ e\fu\fe r 1 iZeadeeZX_ Xs `l\ [Zb Z`]`ZX_e Xs `l\Zf ]ccfX]al aX_a[di\e `l\ e\a`ZX_ r

cfX a\eeXf a]_ cfX`\a` cfZu]`\ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ a]ffZ\i Yg ]^\_`e \v\ad`Z_^ Z_eZi\ Z` r ys `l\ Xk _\f Xs ]_ ]^\_` `fde`e `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf b ]_ds]a`df\f `X l]u\ YdZ[` Z` aXff\a`[gj `l\ Xk _\f a]_ Y \ ]eedf\i `l]` `l\ ]^\_` k Z[[ \v\ad`\ aXff\a`[g ]_ i k Z[[ _X` [\]z e\_eZh `Zu\ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ `X d_]d`lXfZ \i c]f`Z\e r

‡†

 ‰– –  ’  Ÿ“‰’ ž Ž‰“‰  ‰Œ

y_ Xfi\f `X [\u\f]^\ `l\ e\adfZ`g c X`\_`Z][ Xs `l\ e\h adf\ cfX a\eeZ_^ \_uZfX_b \_`  d e` i\eafZY \i j ] aXb h b d_Za]`ZX_ cfX`X aX[ l]e Y \\_ i\x_\i `X ][[Xk `l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f `X e\adf\[g i\[Zu\f ]^\_`e `X Y \ \v\h ad`\i Yg ]^\_` c[]a\e r 4 lZe cfX`X aX[ Ze de\i `X `f]_es\f ]^\_`e ]b X_^e` `l\ c]f`Z\e Z_uX[u\i ]_ i ^d]f]_`\\e `l]` X_[g `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf Ze ]Y[\ `X i\afgc` ]_i \v\ad`\ `l\ ]^\_` r 4 l\ b ]Z_ Zi\] Y \lZ_i `l\ cfX`X aX[ Ze `l]` ]^\_`e ‡ˆ ž Ž‰  ‹••’‘ ‹’ Ž‰’– ‹’“ elXd[i Y \ e\_` ]_i f\b ]Z_ \_afgc`\i d_`Z[ `l\g ]f\ mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q cfXc Xe\ ]_ ]^\_` \v\ad`ZX_ Z_e`]_`Z]`\i Z_ `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf \_uZfX_b \_` r Xf `l]` cdfc Xe\ j `l\ sX[[Xk Z_^ edcc XeZ`ZX_e ]f\ \_uZfX_b \_` aXb cfZe\i Xs ] lXe` aXb cd`\f k Z`l ]_ b ]i\ — ¡Z¢ `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ l]e ] cdY[Zahz\g a\f`Zxh ]``]al\i e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf j k l\f\ `l\ ]a`d][ \v\h a]`\ sXf Z`e aXhcfX a\eeXf z\g c]Zf  ¡ZZ¢ `l\ c[]a\ iX \e ad`ZX_ Xs `l\ ]^\_` k Z[[ l]cc \_ r 4 l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf _X` l]u\ ]aa\ee `X `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf ˜e cfZu]`\ z\g  b de` cfXuZi\ ] aXb c[\`\ ]^\_` \v\ad`ZX_ \_uZfX_h ¡ ]_i ZZZ¢ `l\ c[]a\ Ze f\^Ze`\f\i k Z`lZ_ ] iZf\a`Xfg b \_` eZ_a\ `l\ lXe` aXb cd`\f Ze _X` `fd e`\i ]_i 4 e\fuZa\ r l\ cfX`X aX[ Ze aXb cfZe\i Yg `l\ sX[[Xk Z_^ k Z[[ X_[g cfXuZi\ aXb b d_Za]`ZX_ e\fuZa\e sXf `l\ aXh e`\ce — cfX a\eeXf ]_i `l\ ]^\_`e Z` \v\ad`\e r 4 l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf `l\g \_uZeZX_ Y X X`e sfXb aX i\ e`Xf\i Z_ 5  W b \b Xfg Z_eZi\ Z` r 4 lZe aX i\ nr 4 l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f de\e `l\ iZf\a`Xfg e\fuZa\e `X k Z[[ Z_a[d i\ `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf Xc \f]`Z_^ ege`\b ]_i x_i ] edZ`]Y[\ ]^\_` c[]a\ j XY`]Z_e Z`e [X a]`ZX_ ][eX ] uZf`d][ b ]alZ_\ \_uZfX_b \_` j edal ]e `l\ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ j Z`e c X[Zag e`]`\b \_` j ]_i `l\ a\fh  ]u] []_^d]^\ uZf`d][ b ]alZ_\ j Z_ k lZal `l\ ]^\_`e `Zx a]`\ sXf Z`e e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf r \v\ad`\ r 4 l\ de\ Xs ] uZf`d][ b ]alZ_\ ^Zu\e ] d_Zh sXfb c[]`sXfb sXf ]^\_` \v\ad`ZX_ j \u\_ Zs iZš\f\_`  r 4 l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f u\fZx\e `l]` `l\ c[]a\ c X[Zag l]fik ]f\ Xf Xc \f]`Z_^ ege`\b c[]`sXfb e ]f\ de\i r e]`Zex \e Z`e _\\ie ]_i `l]` `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf Ze y` ][eX cfX`\a`e `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf \_uZfX_b \_` ]Y[\ `X \_sXfa\ `lZe c X[Zagr sfXb b ZeY \l]uZ_^ Xf b ][ZaZXde ]^\_`e r 1 [eX Z_a[di\i Z_ `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf Ze ] afgc`Xh € r ys `l\ c X[Zag edZ`e `l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f j Z` e\_ie ^f]clZa [ZYf]fgj k lZal cfXuZi\e `l\ afgc`X^f]clZa `l\ ]^\_` `X `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ j \_afgc`\i k Z`l sd_a`ZX_e _\\i\i Yg `l\ ]^\_`e `X e\adf\ `l\b e\[u\e `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf ˜e cdY[Za z\g cf\e\_` Z_ `l\ aXh Xf `X \e`]Y[Zel e\adf\ aXb b d_Za]`ZX_ al ]__\[e k Z`l cfX a\eeXf ˜e a\f`Zx a]`\ r `l\Zf Xk _\fe r 4 lZe [ZYf]fg Z_a[di\e ] z\g c]Zf j `X Y \ de\i Z_ cdY[Zahz\g afgc`X^f]clZa Xc \f]`ZX_e r 4 l\ ƒ r 4 l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ f\[]ge `l\ ]^\_` `X `l\ aXh e\af\ag Xs `l\ cfZu]`\ c Xf`ZX_ Xs `lZe z\g c]Zf Ze cfX a\eeXf sXf \v\ad`ZX_ r c]f]b Xd_` `X `l\ e\adfZ`g Xs `l\ cfXc Xe\i eal\b \ j ]_i Ze ^d]f]_`\\i Yg `l\ `]b c \fhf\eZe`]_ a\ Xs `l\ ~ r 4 l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf i\afgc`e `l\ ]^\_` ]_i Z_h aXhcfX a\eeXf r e`]_`Z]`\e Z` `X e`]f` \v\ad`ZX_ r 4 l\ []e` aXb c X_\_` Xs `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf Ze `l\ y_cd`  d`cd` b X id[\ j k lZal \_sXfa\e ] k\[[h | r 1s`\f `l\ ]^\_` x _Zel\e \v\ad`ZX_ j `l\ aXh i\x _\i Z_`\fs]a\ k Z`l `l\ lXe` aXb cd`\f r 4 l\ sX[h cfX a\eeXf f\`df_e Z`e f\ed[`e `X `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ [Xk Z_^ Xc \f]`ZX_ e b de` Y \ cfXuZi\i Yg `l\ y  ]_i b ]g f\d\e` ]^\_` b Z^f]`ZX_ `X Z`e Xk _\f b X id[\ — Xf ]_X`l\f c[]a\ r  dc[X]i j b Z^f]`ZX_ ]_i f\b Xu][ Xs ]^\_`e 

4 l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf b ]g ][eX ][[Xk `l\ ]^\_` `X e`Xf\ Z`e Zi\_`Z`g ]_i eXb \ ]iiZ`ZX_ ][ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ Z_ Z`e c \feZe`\_` e`Xf]^\ `X ]uXZi f\c[]g ]``]aze sfXb `l\  Z_`\f_][ e`]`\ d\fZ\e j ed al ]e k lZal ]^\_`e ]f\ ]^\_` c[]a\ r 4 lZe Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ b ]g Y \ al\az\i Yg adff\_`[g fd__Z_^ r `l\ ]^\_` Y \sXf\ Z` e`]f`e \v\ad`Z_^ j Z_ Xfi\f `X cf\h t Z`l `l\ ]aa\ee f\e`fZa`ZX_ \_sXfa\i Yg `l\ y  u\_` `l\ c[]a\e sfXb al\]`Z_^ Yg fd__Z_^ `l\ e]b \ b X id[\ ]_i Z`e `]b c \f f\eZe`]_a\ j `l\ e\adf\ aXh ]^\_` b ]_g `Zb \e r  aXb b d_Za]`ZX_e Y \`k\\_ lXe`e ]_ i ]^\_`e 

‡

 – “Ÿ“‰’ •

3Xb \ [Zb Z`]`ZX_e Xs `lZe ]ccfX]al ]f\ —  4]b c \fhcfX Xs l]fik ]f\ Ze iZw ad[` `X YdZ[i ]_i

]^\_`e j \]al k Z`l ] ec \aZx a b ZeeZX_ — ]       ]_ i ]_i     r 4 l\e\ `kX b ]z\ dc Xdf     r 4 lZe sf]b \kXfz Ze elXk _ Z_ Z^h df\ € r

elXd[i Y \ Z_ec \a`\i c \fZX iZa][[g `X cfXuZi\ `]b c \fZ_^ i\`\a`ZX_ r ys eXb \ aXhcfX a\eeXf Ze    ™ ‹  ‹‘‰“Ÿ“‰’ ‘‹’“ `]b c \f\i k Z`l j `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ b ]g Y \ ]Y[\ `X 4 l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` \v\ad`\e `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ^]`l\f aX_x i\_`Z][ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ a]ffZ\i Yg `l\ cl]e\ Xs `l\ b X i\[ cf\e\_`\i Z_ 3\a`ZX_  r r 4 lZe ]^\_`e r Z_a[d i\e Y X`l e\``Z_^ `l\ ]Zb Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]_ i ][eX \v\ad`Z_^ `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cfX`X aX[j d eZ_^ `l\ 3\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe d ed][[g l ]u\ e\u\f\ aXe`  ]_ i c \fsXfb ]_a\ aX_e`f]Z_`e id\ `X `l\ iZw h e`f]`\^g i\x_\i Yg Z`e Xk _\f r 4 lZe ]^\_` Ze \v\h ad[`g Xs `l\Zf aX_e`fda`ZX_ r 4X Y \ cf]a`Za][ j ] ad`\i d_`Z[ `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ [\]ie `X ]_ ]^f\\b \_` e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfhY]e\i eal\b \ elXd[i b Z_h Xf Z` Ze ]Y Xf`\i ¡Yg `Zb \Xd` Xf Yg ]_g Xs `l\ c]f`Zah Zb Z \ `l\ ]b Xd_` Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ f\dZf\i `X Zc]_`e¢r y` `l\_ e\_ie `l\ cfXec \a`Zu\ ]^f\\b \_` `X Y \ \v\ad`\i Yg `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf r t\ i\][ k Z`l `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` sXf u][Zi]`ZX_ ]_i ]aa\c`]_a\ r y` Ze a[\]f `l]` j eZ_a\ `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` Ze _X` `lZe f\e`fZa`ZX_ Z_ `l\ _\v` e\a`ZX_ r \v\ad`\i ]e ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ j `l\ ]^\_`  4 l\ ]^\_` Xk _\fe b d e` `fde` `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf c[]a\ Ze ]Y[\ `X \]u\eifXc Z`e aX i\ ]_i i]`] ]_ i b ]_ds]a`df\fe r ys `lZe `fde` f\[]`ZX_elZc a]_h ][eX `X Z_`\fs\f\ k Z`l Z`e \v\ad`ZX_ j c XeeZY[g [\]iZ_^ _X` Y \ \e`]Y[Zel\i j `lZe ]ccfX]al a]__X` Y \ i\h `X ]_ Xd`aXb \ _X` ]aa\c`]Y[\ `X `l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f r c[Xg\i r 1 [eX j `lZe ]^\_` a]__X` a]ffg aX_x i\_`Z][ Z_sXfb ]h `ZX_ j edal ]e cfZu]`\ z\ge Xf c]gb \_` Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ j ž   ž   V ž         k lZal aXd[i [\]z `X `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ r y_ `lZe e\a`ZX_ j k\ iZead ee Xdf cfXc Xe][ `X Zb cfXu\ `l\ \w aZ\_ag Xs `l\ de\ Xs `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]h `ZX_e sXf _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_`e r t\ xfe` cf\e\_` ] ^\_h \f][ sf]b \kXfz j `l\_ k\ elXk lXk `lZe sf]b \kXfz a]_ Y \ Zb c[\b \_`\i deZ_^ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe r Zh _][[gj k\ iZead ee lXk `l\ aX_a\c` Xs       a]_ [\]i `X ]_ ][`\f_]`Zu\ eX[d`ZX_ r

 ‡ˆ

 ‹’ ‹ŽŸŒ ŽŸ– ‹› ‰Ž  ‰Ž

‘‹’“   Ÿ•‹Š  ‹‘‰“Ÿ“‰’ •

‹   Ž‹

{ \^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_`e b d e` b Z^f]`\ `X ]^\_` c[]a\e ¡ded][[g uZf`d][ e`Xf\e Zb c[\b \_`\i ]e ]^\_` c[]a\e¢ `X _\^X`Z]`\ ]^f\\b \_`e X_ Y \l][s Xs `l\Zf Xk _\fe r 4 l\g b d e` `l\_ \v\ad`\ Z_ c XeeZY[g d_`fde`\i \_uZh fX_b \_`e r y_ Xfi\f `X \e`]Y[Zel ] e\adf\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ e\``Z_^ j `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_e a]_ Y \ de\i j ]e cf\e\_`\i Z_ 3\a`ZX_ € r 1 e `lZe a]_ [\]i `X c \fh sXfb ]_a\ ]_i aXe` c \_][`Z\e `l ]` kXd[i b ]z\ `lZe ]ccfX]al d_]aa\c`]Y[\ j Z` Ze _\a\ee]fg `X f\ida\ `l\ ]b Xd_` Xs `]b c \fhcfXXs aXb cd`]`ZX_ e de\i r 4X f\id a\ `l\ Xu\fl\]i Z_`fX ida\i Yg `]b c \fh cfXXs aXb cd`]`ZX_e j Z` Ze c XeeZY[\ `X \v\ad`\ X_[g `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ cl]e\ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]e ] `]b c \fh cfXXs aXb cd`]`ZX_ j [\]uZ_^ `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cl ]e\ Z_ e\adf\ r 1 e ed al j `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ b X i\[ i\eafZY \i Z_ 3\a`ZX_  r a]_ Y \ d e\i `X c]f`Z`ZX_ ]^\_`e Z_ `kX c ]f`e — X_\ Zb c[\b \_`Z_^ `l\ \v\ad`ZX_ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ e`]`\ ]_ i Z`e f\[]`\i `f]_eZ`ZX_e j ]_ i `l\ X`l\f Zb c[\b \_`Z_^ `l\ \v\ad`ZX_ Xs `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ e`]`\ ]_ i f\[]`\i `f]_eZ`ZX_e r 4 lZe b \]_ e `l]` `l\ xfe` c]f` Xs `l\ ]^\_` k Z[[ Y \ f\ec X_eZY[\ sXf `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ Xs `l\ ]^f\\b \_` ]_i `l\ e\aX_i c ]f` l]e `l\ f\ec X_eZYZ[Z`g Xs u][Zi]`Z_^ ]_i ]aa\c`Z_^ Xf _X` `l\ ]^f\\b \_` r 4X b ]z\ `lZe sf]b \kXfz \]eZ\f `X Zb c[\b \_` Z_ adff\_` ]^\_` ege`\b e j k\ aX_eZi\f `kX Z_i\c \_i\_`

 

 ™ ‹   ‹  “Ÿ’  ‹ ‘‹’“

1s`\f `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` l]e f\]al\i ]_ ]^f\\h b \_` j Z` b de` aXb b d_Za]`\ `l\ `\fb e Xs `lZe ]^f\\h b \_` `X `l\ ]aa\c`]_ a\ ]^\_` j k lZal k Z[[ \v\ad`\ `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ cl]e\ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ b X i\[ r 3Z_ a\ `l\ ]aa\c`]_ a\ cl ]e\ Xs `l\ b X i\[ b de` Y \ \v\ad`\i ]e ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ j `lZe ]^\_` Z`e\[s Ze f\dZf\i `X Y \ \v\ad`\i ]e ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ r 4 l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` b de` \v\ad`\ `l\ ]aa\ch `]_ a\ sd_ a`ZX_ i\x _\i Yg `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ b X i\[ ]_ i ]aa\c` Xf f\ \a` `l\ ]^f\\b \_` Y]e\i X_ Z`e f\ed[` r ys Z` ]aa\c`e `l\ ]^f\\b \_` j Z` Ze f\dZf\i `X Xd`cd` ] `\fb hXsh]aa\c`]_a\ j k lZal u]fZ\e ]aaXfiZ_^ `X `l\ _\\ie Xs `l\ c]f`Z\e Z_uX[u\i r y` b ]g Y \ ] u][Zi eZ^h _]`df\ sXf `l\ ]^f\\b \_` j ] af\iZ` a]fi _db Y \f Xf \u\_ ]_ \[\a`fX_Za c]gb \_` Xfi\f r

 

 ‰’ •Š‹ŽŸ“‰’•

fXb `l\ i\eafZc`ZX_ ]Y Xu\ j X_\ a]_ aX_a[di\ `l]` `l\ e\adfZ`g Xs `l\ ege`\b Ze Y]e\i X_ `l\ s]a` `l]` `l\ ]aa\c`]_ a\ ]^\_` Ze \v\ad`\i ]e ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ r fXb `lZe j `kX d\e`ZX_e ]fZe\ — nr ye `l\ ec[Z``Z_^ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`Xf de\sd[   r t l]` Ze `l\ e\adfZ`g Xs `lZe ]ccfX]al  4 l\ ]_ek\f `X `l\ xfe` d\e`ZX_ Ze g\e — `l\ ec[Z`h `Z_^ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`Xf Ze de\sd[ eZ_a\ Z` f\ida\e `l\ aXb cd`]`ZX_][ c Xk\f _\\i\i sXf `l\ e\adf\ aXb cdh `]`ZX_ j k lZal [Xk\fe `l\ aXe` Xs YdZ[iZ_^ `lZe eX[dh `ZX_ k l\_ aXb c]f\i `X `l\ ]ccfX]al i\eafZY \i Z_ 3\a`ZX_ € r 4 lZe aXe` f\ida`ZX_ k Z[[ _X` X_[g b ]z\ `lZe eX[d`ZX_ cf]a`Za][ Yd` k Z[[ ][eX ][[Xk sXf ] k Zi\f i\c[Xgb \_` Xs `lZe ]ccfX]al r

Negotiation Agent

Acceptance Agent Tamper-proof computation

Agent Place

Z^df\ € — 4 kX c]f`e Xs ] _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` ys `l\ cfXc Xe\i Zb c[\b \_`]`ZX_ Ze ]iXc`\i k Z`lh Xd` `l\ aX_adff\_` de\ Xs aXb c[\b \_`]fg e\adfZ`g b \]edf\e j Z` b ]g l]u\ ] e\adfZ`g [\u\[ `l]` Ze Z_s\h fZXf `X `l\ e\adfZ`g Xs `l\ cdf\ c \eeZb Ze`Za ]ccfX]al Xs 3\a`ZX_ € r  df cfXc Xe][ elXd[i Y \ e\\_ ]e ] lgh YfZi ]ccfX]al `l]` b Z_Zb Z \e `l\ [\u\[ Xs `fde` `l]` b de` Y \ c[]a\i X_ `l\ ]^\_ ag Yg `l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f r 4 lZe Ze eX Y \a]de\ `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` ˜e \v\ad`ZX_ ]e ] e\adf\ aXb cd`]`ZX_ ][[Xk e `l\ Xk _\f `X [Zb Z` `l\ i]b ]^\ ] al\]`Z_^ ]^\_ag a]_ b ]z\ r 3Z_a\ `lZe Ze ] lgYfZi ]ccfX]al j e\adfZ`g b \]edf\e ded][[g `]z\_ Z_    

 a]_ Y \ de\i l\f\ `X Zb cfXu\ `l\ e\adfZ`g Xs `l\ eal\b \ r 3Xb \ Xs `l\e\ b \]edf\e ]f\ aX i\ XYsdea]`ZX_ m Xl[ j noopq ]_i eX aZ][ aX_`fX[e mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q r 6X i\ XYh sdea]`ZX_ aX_ eZe`e Z_ l\dfZe`Zae `l ]` ][`\f `l\ aX i\ ]_i i]`] Xs ] cfX^f]b j b ]zZ_^ Z` iZw ad[` `X ]dh `Xb ]`Za][[g f\`fZ\u\ `l\ XfZ^Z_][ aX i\ ]_i i]`] Xf `X Z_s\f `l\ Y \l]uZXf Xs `l\ cfX^f]b r 3X aZ][ aX_h `fX[e aX_ eZe` cfZb ]fZ[g Xs [\^Ze[]`Zu\ Xf e\[sh\_sXfa\i f\^d[]`ZX_ j e\``Z_^ k l ]` aX_e`Z`d`\e `l\ aXff\a` Y \h l]uZXf sXf ]^\_aZ\e ]_ i ]^\_`e j ]_i \_sXfaZ_^ `lZe Y \l]uZXf Yg cd_Zelb \_` Xs `l\ c \fc \`f]`Xfe r 1 _h X`l\f eX aZ][ aX_`fX[ `l]` b ]g Y \ u\fg \š\a`Zu\ Ze Y[]az[Ze`Z_^ j k lZal kXd[i i\af\]e\ `l\ Z_ a\_`Zu\ sXf al\]`Z_^ Y \l]uZXf r y_ edb b ]fgj Xdf ]ccfX]al aXb YZ_\e `l\ ea][]h YZ[Z`g ]_i c \fsXfb ]_a\ Xs `l\     

    Z_ b XYZ[\ ]^\_` ege`\b e k Z`l eXb \ e`fX_^ ^d]f]_`\\e Xs Y \l ]uZXf j ][`lXd^l _X` eX e`fX_^ ]e Z_ `l\    

    Xs 3\a`ZX_ € r 4 lZe lgYfZi ]ccfX]al k Zi\_e `l\ ec \a`fdb Xs i\h c[Xgb \_` Xs ]^\_`hY]e\i _\^X`Z]`ZX_e j k lZ[\ [Zb Z`h Z_^ `l\ ]b Xd_` Xs i]b ]^\ ] al\]`Z_^ ]^\_ag a]_ Z_  Za` `X ]^\_` Xk _\fe r

 ‡†

 ŸŽŠ› ŸŽ‹   Ÿ•‹Š

–  Œ‹– ‹’“Ÿ“‰’

1 e i\eafZY \i Z_ 3\a`ZX_ € j e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe ]f\ `l\ ded][ b \]_ e sXf Zb c[\b \_`Z_^ `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_e k l\_ `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf b ]_ds]a`df\f Ze ] `fd e`\i \_`Z`gr  \` de ]eedb \ l\f\]s`\f `l]` ed al `fde`\i e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe ]f\ ]u]Z[]Y[\ ]` \]al ]^\_` c[]a\ j \]al c Xee\eeZ_^ ]_ ]eeX aZ]`\i afgc`X^f]clZa z\g c]Zf r 4 l\ cfX`X aX[ sXf `l\ \v\adh `ZX_ Xs ] _\^X`Z]`Xf Ze `l\_ i\x _\i Yg `l\ sX[[Xk Z_^

e`\ce — nr 4 l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f YdZ[ie _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]_i ]aa\ch `]_a\ ]^\_`e r 4 l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` b ]g aX_h `]Z_ aX_x i\_`Z][ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ r  r 4 l\ Xk _\f \_afgc`e `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` k Z`l `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf ˜e a\f`Zx\i cdY[Za z\gr € r 4 l\ Xk _\f e\_ie Y X`l ]^\_`e `X `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ sXf \v\ad`ZX_ r ƒ r 4 l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ e\_ie `l\ \_ afgc`\i ]aa\ch `]_a\ ]^\_` `X `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf ]_i Y \h ^Z_e \v\ad`ZX_ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` r ~ r 1s`\f `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` x_Zel\e Z`e \v\h ad`ZX_ j Z` e\_ie Z`e f\ed[`e `X `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` j k lZal Ze fd__Z_^ X_ `l\ e\adf\ aXh cfX a\eeXf r | r 4 l\ f\ed[`e Xs `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` ]f\ f\[]g\i Yg `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf `X `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ r 4 l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` b ]g de\ c \feZe`\_a\ Xf X`l\f e\fuZa\e cfXuZi\i Yg `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf `X cfXh `\a` Z`e\[s sfXb b ZeY \l ]uZ_^ ]^\_` c[]a\e j ]e iZeh adee\i Z_ 3\a`ZX_ € r

 ‡

‰“› ŸŽ‹  ‰’ Œ” –  Œ‹– ‹’“Ÿ“‰’

W XYZ[\ afgc`X^f]clgj ]e i\x _\i Z_ m3]_i\f ]_i 4 ealdiZ_ j noopq j Ze _X` g\` ] f\h ][Z`g Yd` Z`e aX_a\c`e aXd[i Y \ de\i `X YdZ[i 1 eedb Z_^ `l ]` ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_e r b \`lX i sXf                 Ze c XeeZY[\ j Xdf sf]b \kXfz aXd[i Y \ Zb c[\b \_`\i ]e sX[[Xk e — nr 4 l\ ]^\_` Xk _\f YdZ[ie `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]_i ]ah a\c`]_a\ ]^\_`e r  r 4 l\ Xk _\f \_afgc`e `l\ ]aa\c`]_ a\ ]^\_` deZ_^ b XYZ[\ afgc`X^f]clgj ]_i e\_ie Y X`l ]^\_`e `X `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ r € r 4 l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ \v\ad`\e `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` ]_i f\[]ge Z`e f\ed[`e `X `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` r

ƒ r 4 l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` Ze fd_ `X Xd`cd` ] eZ^_\i ]^f\\b \_` r

ƒ r 4 l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ f\[]ge `l\ \_afgc`\i ]^\_` `X Z`e aXhcfX a\eeXf ]_ i Y \^Z_ e \v\ad`Z_^ `l\ _\^Xh `Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` r

3Z_a\ Y X`l aX i\ ]_i i]`] sXf `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` ]f\ aX_ a\][\i j Z`e \v\ad`ZX_ a]_ Y \ aX_eZi\f\i ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ ]_i `l\ e\adfZ`g iZeadeh eZX_ sXf Xdf sf]b \kXfz Ze u][Zi Z_ `lZe aX_`\v` r

~ r t l\_ `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` x_Zel\e Z`e \v\adh `ZX_ j Z` e\_ie Z`e f\ed[`e `X `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` fd__Z_^ X_ `l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf r 4 l\ ]aa\ch `]_a\ ]^\_` u\fZx \e `lXe\ f\ed[`e ]_ i Zeed\e ] c]gb \_` Xfi\f Zs `l\ u\fZx a]`ZX_ Ze edaa\eesd[r

 ž

| r 4 l\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf u][Zi]`\e `l\ c ]gb \_` 1 ^X X i ]cc[Za]`ZX_ sXf ]^\_`hY]e\i _\^X`Z]`ZX_ Ze Xfi\f ]_i f\[]ge Z` `X `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ r \[\a`fX_Za aXb b \fa\ j k l\f\ edcc[Z\fe e\` dc \[\ah `fX_Za e`Xf\e `l]` a]_ Y \ uZeZ`\i Yg YdgZ_^ ]^\_`e r  r 4 l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ f\[]ge Y X`l ]^\_`e `X `l\Zf _\v` 4 lXe\ ]^\_`e _\^X`Z]`\ k Z`l `l\ e`Xf\ `X cdfal]e\ e`Xc r `l\ Z`\b e i\eZf\i Yg `l\Zf Xk _\fe ]` ]aa\c`]Y[\ aX_h iZ`ZX_e ¡cfZa\ j i\[Zu\fg `gc \ ]_i i]`\ ]_i eX X_ ¢r 4 lZe ]cc[Za]`ZX_ x`e k\[[ k Z`l Xdf cfXc Xe\i 1 [`lXd^l `l\ i\[Zu\fg Xs `l\ cdfal]e\ Ze _X` c]f` Xs `lZe cfX`X aX[ j Z` b ]g Y \ Z_ a[di\i Z_ Z` Zs `l\ XY \a` sf]b \kXfz eZ_a\ — Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]f\ Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ ^XX ie Xf Zs `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ Ze f\dZf\i `X Zeed\ ] f\a\Zc` r y_ `lZe `l\ ]^\_` a]_ \]eZ[g de\ Xdf _\^X`Z]`ZX_ b X i\[   a]e\ j `lXe\ Z`\b e b ]g Y \ i\[Zu\f\i \[\a`fX_Za][[g `X  `l\ \[\a`fX_Za e`Xf\ a]_ Y \ Zb c[\b \_`\i ]e ]_ `l\ ]^\_` Xf iZf\a`[g `X Z`e Xk _\f r ]^\_` c[]a\   `l\ ]^\_` c[]a\ a]_ cfXuZi\ ] e\adf\ aXh

cfX a\eeXf \_uZfX_b \_` sXf `l\ YdgZ_^ ]^\_`e r

4 lde j \]al edcc[Z\f YdZ[ie ]_ ]^\_` c[]a\ `l]` cfXuZi\e ] e`]_i]fi 1 y sXf uZf`d][ e`Xf\ Z_`\f]a`ZX_ k Z`l b XYZ[\ ]^\_`e r 4 l\e\ ]^\_` c[]a\e k Z[[ ][eX cfXuZi\ ] e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXf k l\f\ ]^\_`e a]_ Y \ \v\ad`\i r 4 lZe ^Zu\e ]^\_` Xk _\fe ¡`l\ ade`Xb \fe¢ `l\ al]_ a\ `X \v\ad`\ `l\ \_`Zf\ YdgZ_^ ]^\_` Z_ `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf \_uZfX_b \_` ¡`l\ ]ccfX]al sfXb mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q¢ Xf `X de\ Xdf sf]b \kXfz ]_i \v\ad`\ X_[g c]f` Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`Xf ]e ] `]b c \fh cfXXs aXb cd`]`ZX_ r y_ `lZe \v ]b c[\ j k\ ]eedb \ `l\ \vZe`\_a\ Xs ] aXb b \faZ][ \[\a`fX_Za c]gb \_` cfXuZi\f `l]` c[]ge `l\ fX[\ Xs aXhcfX a\eeXf b ]_ds]a`df\f r 1 e `l\ de\ Xs \[\a`fX_Za c]gb \_` ege`\b e ded][[g f\dZf\e `fde` X_ Z`e cfXuZi\f j k\ b ]g [\u\f]^\ `lZe _\\i ]_i f\h dZf\ ][[ c]gb \_` ege`\b de\fe `X `fde` `l\ cfXuZi\f Y X`l `X aXff\a`[g b ]_ ]^\ `l\ c]gb \_` ege`\b ]_i ][eX `X cfXuZi\ e\adf\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe sXf ]^\_` c[]a\e r y_ elXf` j ][[ d e\fe `fde` `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXfe `X aXfh f\a`[g l ]_i[\ c]gb \_` Z_sXfb ]`ZX_ r  Zu\_ `lXe\ e\``Z_^e j ]_g \_`Z`g k Z[[Z_^ `X b ]z\ ] cdfal]e\ kXd[i \v\ad`\ `l\ sX[[Xk Z_^ e`\c e —



       

1 ^\_`hY]e\i _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ege`\b e ]f\ u\fg d e\sd[ `X \[\a`fX_Za aXb b \fa\ e\``Z_^e j eZ_a\ `l\g ][[Xk `l\ ]d`Xb ]`ZX_ Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cfX a\ee `X f\ida\ aXe`e ]_i i\[]ge r 1 [`lXd^l b ]_g ]^\_` _\^X`Z]h `ZX_ ege`\b e ]f\ Y \Z_^ YdZ[` j `l\g ded][[g iX _X` ]iif\ee `l\ _\\i Xs `l\ ]^\_`e `X Y \ e\adf\i sfXb b ][ZaZXd e ]^\_` \v\ad`ZX_ \_uZfX_b \_`e Xf `l\ _\\i Xs ]^\_`e `X eZ^_ ]^f\\b \_`e Xf \v\ad`\ c]gb \_`e ]d`X_Xb Xde[g X_ Y \l][s Xs `l\Zf Xk _\fe r y_ `lZe c ]c \f j k\ ]i]c`\i `l\ c \eeZb Ze`Za ]ch cfX]al Xs mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q `X `l\ aX_`\v` Xs _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_`e ]_i Zb cfXu\i Z`e c \fsXfb ]_a\ Yg \v\ad`Z_^ X_[g c]f` Xs `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ cfX a\ee X_ `l\ aX_e`f]Z_\i \_uZfX_b \_` Xs ] `]b c \fhcfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ r t\ iZi `lZe Yg i\x_Z_^ ] _\^X`Z]h `ZX_ b X i\[ `l ]` c]f`Z`ZX_e ] _\^X`Z]`ZX_ Z_ `kX Z_h i\c \_i\_` cl]e\e j k Z`l `l\ b Xe` f\eXdfa\ Z_`\_eZu\ cl]e\ _X` f\dZfZ_^ `X Y \ \v\ad`\i ]e ] `]b c \fh cfX Xs aXb cd`]`ZX_ r 4 lZe ][[Xk e `l\ f\ida`ZX_ Xs `l\ c \fsXfb ]_a\ f\dZf\b \_`e Xs `l\ `]b c \fhcfX Xs \_uZfX_b \_` ]_i `l\ \v\ad`ZX_ Xs ] ^f\]`\f _db Y \f Xs ]^\_`e deZ_^ `l\ e]b \ \_uZfX_b \_` r

nr 5 \^Ze`\f k Z`l `l\ c ]gb \_` ege`\b cfXuZi\f `X Y \aXb \ ]_ ]d`lXfZ \i c]gb \_` Zeed\f r

  

 r 2 dZ[i ] _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]^\_` k Z`l `l\ _\a\ee]fg Z_h `\[[Z^\_ a\ `X _\^X`Z]`\ `l\ i\eZf\i Z`\b e ]_i ]_ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` ]Y[\ `X u\fZsg `l\ _\^X`Z]`ZX_ ]_ i Zeed\ `l\ aXff\ec X_iZ_^ c ]gb \_` ]aaXfiZ_^ `X `l\ c]gb \_` ege`\b Z_ de\ r

m6l\ee j noopq 6l\ee j r W r ¡ noop¢r 3\adfZ`g Zeed\e Z_ b XYZ[\ aX i\ ege`\b e r y_ Z^_ ] j  rj \iZ`Xf j          j _db Y \f nƒ no Z_  \a`df\ { X`\e Z_ 6Xb cd`\f 3aZ\_a\ j c]^\e n nƒ r 3cfZ_^\fh \f[]^ r

€r

m Xl[ j noopq  Xl[ j r ¡ noop¢ r 4 Zb \ [Zb Z`\i Y[]azh Y Xv e\adfZ`g — fX`\a`Z_^ b XYZ[\ ]^\_`e sfXb b ]h [ZaZXde lXe`e r y_ Z^_] j  rj \iZ`Xf j       j _db Y \f nƒ no Z_  \a`df\ { X`\e Z_ 6Xb h cd`\f 3aZ\_a\ r 3cfZ_^\fh \f[]^ r

 X a]`\

]_ ]ccfXcfZ]`\ \[\a`fX_Za e`Xf\ j ^\` Z`e aXhcfX a\eeXf a\f`Zx a]`\ j \_afgc` `l\ ]aa\c`]_a\ ]^\_` k Z`l `l\ aXhcfX a\eeXf cdY[Za z\g ]_i e\_i Y X`l ]^\_`e `X `l\ \[\a`fX_Za e`Xf\ ˜e ]^\_` c[]a\ r

mW ]b Y X \` ][rj noo|q W ]b Y X j W rj edi] j rj ]_i  z]b X`X j  r ¡ noo|¢ r fXvg eZ^_]`df\e — \[\^]h `ZX_ Xs `l\ c Xk\f `X eZ^_ b \ee]^\e r             j   oh1 ¡o¢—n€€p  n€~ƒ r

                  r

m W  j noooq  W  ¡ nooo¢ r

 Y \a` W ]_]^\b \_`  fXdc ¡k k k rXb ^ rXf^¢ r

4 r ]_i m3]_i\f ]_i 4 eald iZ_ j noopq 3]_ i\f j 4 ealdiZ_ j 6 r r ¡ noop¢ r fX`\a`Z_^ b XYZ[\ ]^\_`e ]^]Z_e` b ][ZaZXde lXe`e r y_ Z^_] j  rj \iZ`Xf j

      j _db Y \f nƒ no Z_  \a`df\ { X`\e Z_ 6Xb cd`\f 3aZ\_ a\ r 3cfZ_^\fh \f[]^ r m \g]b ] ]_i W ]i\Zf] j ‚‚ nq \g]b ] j  r ]_i W ]i\Zf] j  r 5 r W r ¡‚‚ n¢ r 1 _ ]d`Xb ]`\i _\^Xh `Z]`ZX_ b X i\[ sXf \[\a`fX_Za aXb b \fa\ r y_  

                

         j ][[]e j 4  j

31 r

m `X ]_ i ]l ]Y j ‚‚ nq `X j { r ]_i ]l]Y j 5 r ¡‚‚ n¢ r 3dfu\g eXYf\ e\^df]_ a] i\ eZe`\b ]e i\ ]^\_`\e b Xu\Ze  r 4\al_Za][ 5 \c Xf` y6h‚ nh‚p j y_e`Zh `d`X i\ 6Xb cd`] a]X h _Za]b c j 6]b cZ_]e j 3 j 2 f] Z[ r mt Z[l\[b \` ][ rj ‚‚‚q t Z[l\[b j r  rj 3`]]b ]__ j 3 r W rj ]_i 2 d``g]_ j  r ¡‚‚‚¢r 1 c \eeZb Ze`Za ]ch cfX]al `X `fde` Z_ b XYZ[\ ]^\_` c[]`sXfb e r         j c]^\e ƒ‚  ƒp r m}\\ ]_i 4g^]f j noo~q }\\ j 2 r ]_i 4g^]f j  r r ¡ noo~¢ r 3\adf\ aXcfX a\eeXfe Z_ \[\a`fX_Za aXb h b \fa\ ]cc[Za]`ZX_e r y_         

        j { \k }Xfz j {} j 31 r

3  { y r

SECURE NEGOTIATIONS FOR MOBILE AGENT ... - Sapao.net

rity challenges [Chess, 1998]. Among these are ... Agent Places: an agent place is a server appli- cation where ..... Internet Computing, pages 40-48. [Yee and ...

166KB Sizes 1 Downloads 183 Views

Recommend Documents

SECURE NEGOTIATIONS FOR MOBILE AGENT ... - Sapao.net
autonomous agents to roam around virtual stores and find desired products ... (owner) wants to send an agent to a virtual store ..... S. M., and Buttyan, L. (2000).

Negotiations
Jun 8, 2004 - 6/8/2004 fd. 3. Negotiation science(?). ▫ Symmetric prescriptive ⇒ game theory. ▫ Symmetric descriptive ⇒ sociology, psychology, etc. ▫ Asymmetric perspective ⇒ management, decision theory, etc. ▫ External perspective ⇒

Intelligent Mobile Agent for Intrusion Detection System - CiteSeerX
a finished intelligent tool prototype for intrusion detection. Intrusion ..... They receive alerts from correlator agents, analyse ... Monitoring and Surveillance.

Intelligent Mobile Agent for Intrusion Detection System - CiteSeerX
Therefore, JAVA language will be chosen for its .... the same time, a language and a knowledge base, also called .... php?action view=submenu&option=tree&id.

Secure Mobile Ad hoc Routing - IEEE Xplore
In mobile ad hoc networks (MANETs), multi-hop mes- sage relay is the common way for nodes to communicate and participate in network operations, making ...

A local mobility agent selection algorithm for mobile ...
Email: {yxu, hlee, vriz}@i2r.a-star.edu.sg. Abstract— The Mobile IP ... dent service. No matter where a host resides physically, the network should be able to identify it correctly with transpar- ent support for communications above network layer.

Mobile Information Agent using
using the internet as the network infrastructure to make available heterogeneous museum information .... Finally, .net framework deals with standards efficiently.

Secure Agent Mediated E-Commerce - School of Computing and ...
Application of agents in large-scale open distributed environment systems presents ..... Technologies for supporting development of semantic-agent system are ...

Secure Agent Mediated E-Commerce - School of Computing and ...
level of automation, a new paradigm of software is needed to handle ... problem in the agent paradigm further, we consider an example of a person who wishes .... e-commerce applications for Business-to-Consumer (B2C) transactions.

Secure Agent Mediated E-Commerce - School of Computing and ...
the Requirements for the Award of the Degree of Doctor of. Philosophy in Computer Science of Makerere University. Proposed ... Electronic commerce1 transactions can be distinguished depending on the nature of trans- ..... history that was published l

Speed and Secure Mobile Financial Services - F5 Networks
Use of mobile devices for financial services is exploding across the banking, trading, and insurance markets. ... What is the tag for this one? F5 Networks, Inc.

Secure Key Sharing towards Mobile Applications ...
provider may misuse sensitive data of client, thus securing data stored on cloud is of utmost importance. This paper ... The key design factors that a cloud-based secure key sharing system has includes : no additional server-side ... Various access c

On Secure Mobile Ad hoc Routing
Jun 14, 2007 - of network-based computation, attacks on insecured routing protocols can ..... of their frequent denial of service and/or failed service delivery such that they ... Routing [25] and Crowds [26], proposed for Internet-based ..... of the

Secure Key Sharing towards Mobile Applications ...
logic is required on the cloud provider end; easy data access; highly scalable key sharing among multiple authorized users; minimal ... credentials in its security definition for a CSP (Cloud Service Provider). Secret key sharing ... is developed whi

Authenticating Mobile Agent Platforms Using Signature ...
Of Computer Science and Computer Engineering. La Trobe ... agent can be authenticated, a level of trust can be established, which can then ..... cious hosts,” Lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol. 1419, pp. 44–60,. 1998. [Online]. Available: ..

Is it better for mobile apps to be easy-to-use, or secure? - GitHub
Page 1. A More Secure World for Apps. Page 2. Mercedes Wyss. @itrjwyss. Community Leader. Devs+502 & JDuchess Chapter Guatemala. Ex-JUG Member. Guatemala Java ..... Page 79. JSON Web Encryption. • The JWE Protected Header. • The JWE Encrypted Ke

Efficient Mobile agent based scheme for Out-of-band Wormhole attack ...
417. In the recent paper of (Ming-Yang Su & Kun-Lin Chiang, 2010), the authors have proposed a solution to detect and discard malicious nodes of the wormhole attack based on the deployment of Intrusion Detection. System (IDS) in MANETs using on deman

Efficient Mobile agent based scheme for Out-of-band ...
phones, laptops etc., connected by wireless network. MANET is an ... Figure 1 shows an example of typical wormhole attack in an ad hoc network. An attacker ..... Encryption).One of the major advantages of RSA is more secure and convenient.

Adv for Bid - Mobile - City of Mobile
Sep 2, 2015 - All bidders bidding in amounts exceeding that established by the State Licensing Board for. General Contractors must be properly licensed ...

Negotiations December 1 Agenda.pdf
ESSEX WESTFORD UNIFIED UNION SCHOOL DISTRICT. NEGOTIATIONS COUNCIL MEETING. Essex High School Library Conference Room. Thursday ...

Can negotiations prevent "sh wars? - Semantic Scholar
can burn money, i.e., destroy some of the surplus, whereas our model features ..... ine$cient exploitation of the renewable resource than the impatient player.

Negotiations British India and Palestine.pdf
Sign in. Page. 1. /. 7. Loading… ... He pointed out that there were many points of detail to be. examined and ... Negotiations British India and Palestine.pdf.

Business English- Negotiations- Saying Yes, No ... - UsingEnglish.com
That is absolutely my last word on this matter./ This is absolutely funda- mental/ crucial/ vital. I'm sure you don't (really/ honestly) expect us to accept…/ There's ...