_--5yffi.-ts,
No.69 lzots - { RalEstt.
l/
2+1{ I
OF INDIA GOVERNMENT RAILWAYS OF MINISTRY (RAILWAYBOARD)
#-,;f
No.E(NG)l-201s/CRl3
New Delhidatedzq'06.2015
TheGeneralManagers(P) Units All ZonalRailways&,Production (Asperstandardlist). Sub:MaintenanceandpreparationojAnnua|-.Performance AppraisalReports.cbmmunicationofa||entriesfor fairnessandtransparencyinpub|icadministration regarding. od' l"lo'21,011t1n0a5Pursuantto the guidelinescontainedin'DOP&T'$. vide Board'sletterNo' i-ssued Estt(A)(pt.tt)dated t+.bs.zooe,in#;"iigni-*9t. & ravingdowlthe groc{1lg for,maintenance 2009/scc/3/6dated 18.08.200g communication and of AnnualPerform"nt"lpitaisal,Reports(APAR)pub.lic preparation administfation in trangqarency of all entriesrecordedin APARfor fairnessand instructions the_se that etc. The matterwas considered"no ii *"" decided'rater-on on ZonalRailways working t9-t!e non-O9z9t^t9U^1taff are applicanemutaiismutanOis dated30'04'201O'i videBoard'sletterNo.E(NG)I-2009/CR/2 . ,i,,,., 22'08'2014' Hon',blecAT/CalcuttaBench,Kolkata,in their order dated 2.
in o.A. no.ioazor zoii tireoby..shritlyp_ l-"y^J:,ihittaranjan detivered of an iollows:-"Non.communication LocomotiveWorks iCfWl, have diiecl"J 1" whentherei1 a nelc!.markbut in all casesthatan ;;ity l;;;[iti"iv. ltlr ,,entry,, ""ibnff good,of verygood)mus!!9 communicated fair,average, (whetherit is poor, tn"r""it I vioiationof principteof fairness'whichis to a public,"runil;h";il, since entryshouldbe.communicated' soul of naturaljustice.Evenan outstanding andmakehimworkharder'" thatboosttne moiaieof an employee containedin Boardtletterdated Boardwish to reiteratethat the instructions 3. in orderto complywith quoted-;b;;;';;y-U" uOrt"t"Jto scrupulously 30.04.2010 of Hon'bleCATiCalcutta' thedirectives
No. GMA/Law/oANo'104712A11 (Thisdisposesof cPo/cLW's Reference dated21.03.2015). Receiptof this tettermaybe acknowledged'
4*\u
flil-.tcwteenal
@
DeputyDirectorEstt'(N) RailwaYBoard
Norn"o 3, Chelntsfortt Road, New Dithi.
Cop'r'/itt'wanlel to lhe Genernl secret(,ries r{rffilioted ('/: Meliu Centre/NFtR
et;2_d1Q6.1.20!i lJnions of NFIRfor i,formation antl guidonce,
3{rrfigd.6 Slzots flRA g{frR
ta d'rrd{q (H df)
'd. ftqerdD sr$3m/3 r-201
5 a€ Rdt, fqaifr zq .06.201
zrdrsitrfrtwffi*l seft et{rqtS \Ri :rdrnd F+rgai31q, (alrdnqfr t 3ry$r) Rrqtt ar sqf{qnq 3f{ tS iqn a'rap srffito, Fqr- affio, ar4-A'qn- {aird eelrsr;ftwarar 3it{ cnffitdl Fnt * As stft ThFed f,r qm tatl *' m. ar. $. 210111112005-*€(q) *T*6 qii cRlqturfde{rrrt Adifi 14.0b.2009 q* *';66 affi ard' (crt-rr) * sgurr, *e t Aain 18.08.2009 t ti. zoosffi/3/6 Bqffi {ai*-d ft*E (qfr(B{rr)t rgaiw (,?ist tfi *,Tf f,I sf*.fi or frtftur mr$ gv qqtq'gTrr 6r qerarifr t riai?rfr srg*r EIrfrfr('eK' el mfr srffi+* f niq,rgsefi sBffi rRrFFt;r, 3rrE 614 fr 6qtdT gitr q{ERtil 3Trqt gtr rnrd qr ftqK fuqI rrql silT Erqf z16 *'q* Ti. ftqrsrlt-2009/S3{R/2*'rea artt frhlqs fr;qr rrqr lfi s}g h f{difi 30.04.2010 w efi drt1 dft}l t rrghr q:fiBd cffit sfia et{rq tat C' mrdrf, ffiqq'Ff, sffi' af rq+ {Trrq-qrurfudttrdr ta fqa sr€ndTrt+nrmseaQ* Rrq Er{r+201t *' rfl. ('. 2. *i. to+z * ?ffirdrqindrq yen€frm sTfufiTrrfiI strfirdr *E i sqi frlaiq, 22.08.2au * fr sneard'frtEr flcqr e{r:-'ffi cldR S'r qgar a &n Frffrs m{;n tr a *ra ffi Rffi fr'3TtrE €eff qr#rat * "ffift" (qrF q6 rs{rE,gfiHr;ur,3flTrir,Tftrrr 3prsr r+fr SctrtT d er qfir, 3iFrrerAs$ meffiT + fiil"d qn seritie Atar il *r q{dr 3TM-ar cldR fr q+ar m el ilfr qrfdq +dfu , t, qt ffiq. aqrq fr 3{rer tr zrrt an fr ry gsq q,,ffir * Fdt{tr fr ER drfi t 3i1rr$ 3i1rff,drfr t +T4stt fi qs6 ftffi f1" *' q f BFa E}g'* kdin 30.04.2010 3. dr* ga Etf,{arqrf,drF l*'5.s sffifr 3rghf mr qtt il{6 t tnra furrr sn' arfr' qlddl-q irdrq s?Trufrfi sfrqlurmla*rar * ff*fr 6"13Tgcrard dI sht (5r$ gw *rffim :+ffildwrwq 1047t2011 H'rfrceFT6 arar F)
*' v* d. fr('tr('/Ffi/3fE'+i + frFi*,, 21.A3.2015
?c'qr FF cr fir.Trd?fitt
I
wY
(qrr. f,. ffdT) htm FqITar (qa)
W dtt
