O que são, afinal, redes de políticas públicas? Rafael Martins Ferrari

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

Revista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

77

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`6-,.#&%#45.#@.$,.&.#A.5.#&%#.+($%"#6(#'$(-%""(#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-." 1!"#$%&'!,"%)..2#-(5#-.'.-,&.&%#'.$.#,6:)4%6-,.$#"%4"#$%"4)+.&("#1!"#$%&'"3*%"4).27 L(6.:(6+#1TUUa2#.'(6+.#'.$.#+%($,."#'()*+,-."#')4$.),"+."#%#-($'($.+,@,"+." -(5(#$.*<%"#'.$.#(#$%-(6J%-,5%6+(#&.#,5'($+`6-,.#&%#5/)+,')("#.+($%"7 N,-O%$+#)*'0##%#!&.5#%#N$,%",#.'(6+.5#'.$.#."#5%"5."#$.*<%"9#.-$%"-%6C +.6&(# (4+$."# .&@,6&."# &.# +%($,.# &."# ($A.6,<.EH%"# 1NGXN8QY# )*' 0#9# TUUZ7 !b!cW# NQG8dG9# effZ9# '7# TeU27 c."9#.:,6.)#&%#-(6+."9#%5#;4%#-(6","+%5#."#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),C -."[#d%A46&(#N,-O%$+9#N),?6#%#N(''%6?.69#%)."#$%:%$%5C"%#.#\'.&$H%"#15.," (4# 5%6("2# %"+D@%,"# &%# $%).EH%"# "(-,.,"# %6+$%# .+($%"# ,6+%$&%'%6&%6+%"9# %5 $%).E3(# .# &%+%$5,6.&("# '$(0)%5."# (4# '$(A$.5."# &%# '()*+,-."# '/0),-."^ 1NGXN8QY#)*'0#9#TUUZ9#'7#g27#hD#c%6.J%5#&%:,6%#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-." -(5(#\$%).EH%"#,6+%A$.&."9#%"+D@%,"#%#&4$.&(4$."#%6+$%#.+($%"#A(@%$6.5%6C +.,"# %# 63(CA(@%$6.5%6+.,"9# i."# ;4.,"j# '$(@=%5# 45# .50,%6+%# %5# ;4%# (" ,6+%$%""%"#&(#%"+.&(#"3(#&%:,6,&("#%#45#'.$.&,A5.#&%#'()*+,-.#'$%@.)%-%^ 1c8k!l8c9#TUUV9#'7#eVm27#LM$<%)#&D#45.#&%:,6,E3(#45#'(4-(#5.,"#.5'). '.$.# (# +%$5(9# %6@()@%6&(# 5.,"# @.$,D@%,"7# d%A46&(# %).9# $%&%"# &%# '()*+,-." '/0),-."# -(6","+%5# %5# 45# -(6?46+(# $%).+,@.5%6+%# %"+D@%)# &%# $%).EH%"# &% 6.+4$%<.#,6+%$&%'%6&%6+%#%#63(CJ,%$D$;4,-.#%6+$%#&,@%$"("#.+($%"9#("#;4.," -(5'.$+,)J.5#,6+%$%""%"#-(546"#%5#$%).E3(#.#45.#'()*+,-.#%#;4%#+$(-.5 Revista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

78

$%-4$"("#%6+$%#",#'.$.#.+,6A,$#+.,"#,6+%$%""%"9#$%-(6J%-%6&(#;4%#.#-(('%$.C E3(#B#(#5%)J($#5%,(#&%#.)-.6EDC)("#1LPQR8S9#TUUV9#'7#ema27 >#(0?%+,@(#&(#.$+,A(#B#","+%5.+,<.$#.)A46"#&("#@D$,("#-(6-%,+("#&% $%&%"#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."9#04"-.6&(#%)4-,&.$#"4."#'("",0,),&.&%"#-(6-%,+4.,"9 +%F$,-."#%#'$D+,-."7#850($.#+.)#(0?%+,@(#63(#"%?.#,6B&,+(#n#(#:.5("(#.$+,A( -,+.&(#&%#LM$<%)#1TUUV2#+%5#%"".#5%"5.#,6+%6E3(#n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emmCegm27 86;4.6+(#.#'$('("+.#&%#LM$<%)#.'$%"%6+.#.'%6."#%""."#&4."#'("",C 0,),&.&%"#-(6-%,+4.,"9#.'$%"%6+.C"%#.;4,9#.)B5#&."#&4."#'("",0,),&.&%"#5%6C -,(6.&."9#+.50B5#.#&%#!&.5#%#N$,%",#1effZ2_#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-." -(5(#+%($,.7#8"+%#.$+,A(#&,@,&%C"%9#'($+.6+(9#%5#-,6-(#'.$+%"7#!)B5#&%"+. ,6+$(&4E3(#%#&.#-(6-)4"3(9#."#(4+$."#+$="#'.$+%"#-($$%"'(6&%5#o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b!cW NQG8dNG9# effZ9# '7# TeU27# >4# "%?.9# ."# $%&%"# &%# '()*+,-."# '/0),-."# "3(# 45. -(6"+.+.E3(# %5'*$,-.# "(0$%# .# %"+$4+4$.E3(# &.# $%).E3(# %6+$%# ("# &,@%$"(" .+($%"#%5#45.#&%+%$5,6.&.#D$%.#&."#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."7 Revista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

79

p5.#-(6-%,+4.E3(#5,6,5.),"+.#%#'.$-,5(6,(".#&%#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,C -."#'/0),-."#?D#B#"4:,-,%6+%#'.$.#.'$%"%6+.$#(#-(6-%,+(#-(5(#B#'$('("+( 6%"+.#'.$+%_#'.&$H%"#&%#%"+$4+4$.E3(#&."#,6+%$.EH%"#%6+$%#.+($%"#'()*+,-(" ,6+%$&%'%6&%6+%"#645.#&.&.#D$%.#&."#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."7 L(6.:(6+# 1effa29# 0."%.&.# %5# c.$"J# %# QJ(&%"9# .'$%"%6+.# .)A4C 5."#+,'()(A,."T#,&%.,"#'.$.#.6.),".$#.#,6+%$.E3(#%6+$%#("#.+($%"7#p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l8XS>9# effm27 850($.#'.$+%#&.#),+%$.+4$.#4+,),<%#+%$5("#-(5(#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-." '/0),-."#%#-(546,&.&%"#'()*+,-."#,6&,"+,6+.5%6+%9#.)A46"#.4+($%"#.'(6+.5 '.$.#&,:%$%6E."#%6+$%#%)%"9#6(#+,'(#&%#,6+%$.E3(#;4%#&%"-$%@%59#&%#:($5. ;4%#-.&.#45.#&%""."#+,'()(A,."#&%#,6+%$.E3(#,6:)4%6-,.#&,:%$%6+%5%6+%#(" $%"4)+.&("# &(# '$(-%""(# &%# '()*+,-."# '/0),-."# 1!"#$%&' !,"%)..2# 1l>qS8YYW Q!c8dl9# TUUm9# '7# TeV27 >4+$.#+.K(6(5,.#'.$.#."#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."#B#'$('("+.#'($ r.6# q..$&%69# ;4%# -(6",&%$.# (# 6/5%$(# &%# '.$+,-,'.6+%"# %# ."# $%).EH%" %6+$%# %"+.&(# %# "(-,%&.&%# 6.# &%"-$,E3(# %# -.$.-+%$,<.E3(# &."# $%&%"7# I($ %K%5')(9#;4.6&(#("#'$,6-,'.,"#.A%6+%"#"3(#F$A3("#&(#A(@%$6(#%#(#'$(-%"C "(#B#&,$,A,&(#'%)(#%"+.&(9#JD#\$%&%"#04$(-$D+,-."^W#?D#;4.6&(#(#'$(-%""(#B &(5,6.&(# '%).# "(-,%&.&%# %# JD# .'%6."# 45# A$4'(# $%)%@.6+%9# ("# .4+($%" &,<%5#;4%#JD#45.#\$%&%#-.'+4$.&.^W#"%#(#6/5%$(#&%#.+($%"#$%)%@.6+%"#B A$.6&%#%#(#'$(-%""(#+.50B5#B#&(5,6.&(#'%).#"(-,%&.&%9#JD9#"%A4,6&(#. '$('("+.#&%#l%-)(9#\$%&%"#+%5D+,-."^#1r!k#q!!Qb8k9#TUUe9#0!35#l>qS8YYW Q!c8dl9# TUUm9# '7# TsfCTsT27 Y.6+(#."#+,'()(A,."#.'$%"%6+.&."#'($#L(6.:(6+#;4.6+(#.#'$('("+. '($# r.6# q..$&%6# '(&%5# "%$# /+%,"# 6.# &%"-$,E3(# %# 6.# .6D),"%# &."# $%&%"9 .)B5#&%#"%$%5#-(5'.+*@%,"9#%5#5.,($#(4#5%6($#A$.49#-(5#."#&%:,6,EH%" Revista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

80

.'$%"%6+.&."#5.,"#6(#,6*-,(#&(#.$+,A(7#I($B59#.)B5#&."#-$*+,-."#.'$%"%6+.C &."#"(0$%#(#4"(#,6&,"+,6+(#&("#-(6-%,+("9#%)."#4)+$.'."".5#."#&,5%6"H%" ,6&,-.&."#'%).#&%:,6,E3(#&.&.#.-,5.7 !#&%:,6,E3(#.-,5.#.'(6+.#'.$.#&4."#&,5%6"H%"#(0"%$@D@%,"_#1,2#(" .+($%"#%#1,,2#.#,6+%$.E3(#%6+$%#%""%"#.+($%"7#X(6+4&(9#5.,"#&(#;4%#%K'),-,+.$ (#;4%#B#(0"%$@D@%)9#B#6%-%""D$,(#.,6&.#%K'$%"".$#-(5(#%""."#&,5%6"H%" "%# 5.6,:%"+.57 Y.)#+.$%:.#B#-45'$,&.#'($#!&.5#%#N$,%",#1effZ9#'7#Tss29#("#;4.," .'$%"%6+.5#45.#+,'()(A,.#&%#$%&%"#0."%.&.#6%""."#5%"5."#&4."#&,5%6C "H%"_#X(6?46+(#&%#.+($%"#%#$%).EH%"#%6+$%#.+($%"7#8""."#&,5%6"H%"#+$.&4C <%5#&(,"#+,'("#&%#@.$,D@%,"_#1,2#@.$,D@%,"#&%#-(5'(",E3(#1.+$,04+("#&(" .+($%"2#%#1,,2#@.$,D@%,"#%"+$4+4$.,"#1+,'("#&%#).E("9#$%).EH%"#%6+$%#("#.+(C $%"2# 1q !dd8Qc!kW# t !pdY 9# 0!35# ! b!c W# N QG8dG 9# effZ9# '7# Tss27# k%"". +,'()(A,.9#'.$.#&%"-$%@%$#."#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."9#-(50,6.5C"%#(" .+$,04+("#&("#.+($%"#1@.$,D@%)#T2#-(5#("#5(&("#&%#,6+%$.E3(#%6+$%#%)%" 1@.$,D@%)# e27 c%"5(#.""45,6&(#;4%#("#.+$,04+("#&("#.+($%"#'(&%5#"%#5.6,:%"C +.$# &%# &,@%$"."# 5.6%,$."9# !&.5# %# N$,%",# ('+.5# '($# -(6",&%$.$# %5# "4. +,'()(A,.#.'%6."#45.#-.+%A($,.#&%#.+$,04+(_#."#%0!06$#$*$).7#b%,K.59#."",59 &%#).&(#(4+$."#-.+%A($,."#&%#.+$,04+("9#-(5(#."#'$%:%$=6-,."#%#."#'%$-%'C EH%"# &("# .+($%"7# >'%$.-,(6.),<.5# .# %0!06$#$*&# '($# 5%,(# &.# %"+$4+4$.# &% '(&%$# 645.# &%+%$5,6.&.# D$%.# '()*+,-.7# b%"".# :($5.9# .# @.$,D@%)# T# &( 5(&%)(# &%# $%&%"# &%# '()*+,-."# '/0),-."# '$('("+(# '($# %""%"# .4+($%"# B# . &,"+$,04,E3(#&%#'(&%$9#%#"4."#-.+%A($,."#&%#@.$,.E3(#"3(#-(6-%6+$.E3(#&% '(&%$#%#:$.A5%6+.E3(#&%#'(&%$#%6+$%#("#.+($%"7 !#@.$,D@%)#e9#5(&(#&%#,6+%$.E3(#%6+$%#("#.+($%"9#.'$%"%6+.#+$="#-.+%C A($,."#&%#@.$,.E3(_#,6+%$.E3(#-(5''$%&(5,6`6-,.#&%#-(('%$.E3(9#,6+%$.E3( -(5#.4"=6-,.#&%#-(('%$.E3(#1-(6:),+(29'%#45.#:($5.#,6+%$5%&,D$,.9#;4%#(" .4+($%"#-J.5.5#&%#\0.$A.6J.^#1!b!cW#NQG8dG9#effZ9#'7#Tsa27 >#-$4<.5%6+(#%6+$%#%""."#&4."#&,5%6"H%"#.'(6+.#'.$.#"%,"#+,'(" &%# $%&%"# &%# '()*+,-."# '/0),-."9# -(6:($5%# G)4"+$.E3(# T7# d%A46&(# %"". +,'()(A,.9#%5#",+4.EH%"#&%#-(6-%6+$.E3(#&%#'(&%$9#5.6,:%"+.5C"%#,6+%$.EH%" -(5#-.$D+%$#J,%$D$;4,-(#1\"(50$.#&.#J,%$.$;4,.^2#1,&%59#'7#Tsm27

Revista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

81

Ilustração 1: Tipologia das estruturas de rede

!"*"#1*"1-&.2)'30#1-45.'30#1"(6$0()&1"#)!$)$!01*"1/&7"!(0(+0 >4+$.#'%$"'%-+,@.#"(0#.#;4.)#'(&%5#"%$#-(5'$%%6&,&."#."#$%&%" &%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."#0."%,.C"%#%5#.)A46"#'$%""4'("+("#&."#&,"-4""H%"#"(C 0$%#$%&%"#6.#"(-,()(A,.#%#6.#%-(6(5,.#n#%6:.+,<.6&(#(#"%5'$%#6%-%""D$,( &,D)(A(#%6+$%#."#@D$,."#&,"-,'),6."#&."#-,=6-,."#"(-,.,"7 k%"".#@,"3(9#."#$%&%"#"4$A%5#-(5(#%"+$4+4$.#&%#A(@%$6.6E.#.)+%$C 6.+,@.# o"# J,%$.$;4,."# %# .(# 5%$-.&(7# 85# "%4# :.5("(# ),@$(9# 70,-)*.' 0(5 /$),0,%/$).9#>),@,%$#q,)),.5"(6#1TUZm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d%A46&(#I(u%))#1TUUf29#."#+$(-."#%-(6]5,-."#1%#.;4,#"%#%K'.6&% %"".# '%$-%'E3(# '.$.# ;4.);4%$# +,'(# &%# ,6+%$.E3(# %6+$%# &,@%$"("# .+($%"9 -(5(#."#$%).EH%"#%5#;4.);4%$#"40","+%5.#'()*+,-(2#%"+3(#5%$A4)J.&."#%5 &%+%$5,6.&(# -(6+%K+(# "(-,(%"+$4+4$.)9# .'(6+.6&(# :.+($%"# ;4%# '%$5,+%5 $%-(6J%-%$#."#$%&%"#-(5(#45.#+%$-%,$.#:($5.#&%#-(($&%6.E3(#&.#.+,@,C &.&%#%-(6]5,-.#n#.)B5#&("#5%$-.&("#%#J,%$.$;4,."7 k%""%#"%6+,&(9#LM$<%)#1TUUV2#.$A45%6+.#;4%#."#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-." '/0),-."#-(6","+%5#%5#45#-(6?46+(#$%).+,@.5%6+%#%"+D@%)#&%#$%).EH%"#&% 6.+4$%<.#,6+%$&%'%6&%6+%#%#63(CJ,%$D$;4,-.#%6+$%#&,@%$"("#.+($%"9#("#;4.," -(5'.$+,)J.5#,6+%$%""%"#-(546"#%5#$%).E3(#.#45.#'()*+,-.#%#;4%#+$(-.5 $%-4$"("#%6+$%#",#'.$.#.+,6A,$#+.,"#,6+%$%""%"9#$%-(6J%-%6&(#;4%#.#-(('%$.C E3(#B#(#5%)J($#5%,(#'.$.#.)-.6EDC)("7 !#+%($,.#&%#$%&%"#5("+$.C"%#'$%"%6+%#6.#),+%$.+4$.#&%#.&5,6,"+$.E3( '/0),-.# 6.# &B-.&.# &%# TUUf# '($# 5%,(9# %6+$%# (4+$("9# &(# -(6-%,+(# &% Revista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

82

$(*),1"8),(4)(*'6"5&'1GvL27#d(0#%"".#.0($&.A%5#+%F$,-.9#&%:%6&,.C"%#;4%#. 5.,($#%:,-,=6-,.#%#%:,-D-,.#&."#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."#&%'%6&,.5#&.#'.$+,-,'.C E3(#&%#5/)+,')("#.+($%"9#'($#,""(#(#%"+.0%)%-,5%6+(#&.#.A%6&.#&%#'()*+,-."9 (# '$(-%""(# &%-,"F$,(9# ,&%6+,:,-.E3(# &%# '$(0)%5."# %# .# ,5')%5%6+.E3(# &% '$(A$.5."# +([email protected]"%# %5'$%%6&,5%6+("# 5.,"# -(5')%K("# 1t S8pQwW >pr8Qk8w9# effZ27 !#-(6"+.+.E3(#&%#;4%#("#.+($%"#'()*+,-("#($A.6,<.5C"%#'($#5%,(#&% $%&%"# 1LPQR8S9# TUUVW# Ql>b8d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emmCegm27#850($.#.#","+%5.+,<.E3( $%.),<.&.#'($#LM$<%)#%#.;4%).#'$('("+.#'($#%"+%#.$+,A(#"%?.5#&,"+,6+."9#%"". "%A46&.# %"-().# .'$(K,5.C"%# &(# -(6-%,+(# &%# $%&%"# +$.0.)J.&(# .;4,# -(5( \%"+$4+4$.#&%#,6+%$.E3(#%6+$%#.+($%"^9#;4%#-J.5.5("#&%#\+,'()(A,."^7 >"#%"+4&("#;4%#-(6-%,+4.5#$%&%"#-(5(#","+%5."#&%#,6+%$5%&,.E3( &%#,6+%$%""%"#-(6",&%$.5#(#,6+%$%""%#-(545#&("#.+($%"#(4#.#&%'%6&=6-,. &%# $%-4$"("# -(5(# ("# '$,6-,'.,"# :.+($%"# ;4%# )%@.5# o# -(%"3(7# hD# ("# ;4% -(5'$%%6&%5#."#$%&%"#%6;4.6+(#'$,6-*',(#&%#A(@%$6.6E.#%6:.+,<.5#;4% .# -(%"3(# '(&%# .&@,$# &%# :.+($%"# -(5(# .# -(6:,.6E.9# '$('F",+("# -(546"9 ),&%$.6E.#%#-.'.-,&.&%#&%#A%"+3(7#k%"+.#'%$"'%-+,@.9#.#-(%"3(#B#@,"+.#-(5( -.'.-,&.&%# &%# -(($&%6.E3(# ,6+%$($A.6,<.-,(6.)9# &%# :($5.# .# %"+.0%)%-%$ %"+$4+4$."#"(0$%#."#;4.,"#("#.+($%"#"%#$%).-,(6.5#%#+$(-.5#$%-4$"("#1tS8pQwW >pr8Qk8w9# effZ27 c.++J%u# h.-O"(6# +.50B5# %6:.+,<.# .# ,5'($+`6-,.# &."# $%&%"# 6(" $%"4)+.&("# &."# ,6+%$.EH%"# %6+$%# ("# ,6&,@*&4("# n# "%?.5# %""."# ,6+%$.EH%" %-(6]5,-."# (4# 63(7# 8)%# '.$+%# &.# '$%5,"".# &%# ;4%# ."# $%&%"# "(-,.,"# "3( %6&=5,-."#o"#,6+%$.EH%"#%-(6]5,-."9#.:,$5.6&(#;4%#'.$.#&,@%$"."#&%""." ,6+%$.EH%"9# (# -(6+%K+(# "(-,.)# 63(# B# .'%6."# '.6(C&%C:46&(9# 5."# @.$,D@%) %""%6-,.)# 6.# &%:,6,E3(# &(# -(5'($+.5%6+(# &("# .+($%"# %# $%"4)+.&("# &. ,6+%$.E3(# 1h!XNd>k9# effZ27 Revista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

83

p5# &("# %)%5%6+("# &.# &%:,6,E3(# &%# $%&%"# &.&.# '($# LM$<%)# B# ( $%-(6J%-,5%6+(# &.# -(('%$.E3(# -(5(# '(""*@%)# %"+$.+BA,.# .# "%$# .&(+.&. '%)("#.+($%"7#8"".#-(6"+.+.E3(#B#"4"+%6+.&.#'($#h.-O"(6#1effZ29#'.$.#;4%5 .#Y%($,.#&("#h(A("#,6-($'($.#.#;4%"+3(#&."#$%&%"#"(-,.,"#n#%@,&%6-,%C"% ;4%#.#Y%($,.#&("#h(A("#B#45#&("#@D$,("#5(&%)("#&%6+$(#&(#-(6?46+(#&% '$(0)%5."#;4%#"%#-(6@%6-,(6(4#-J.5.$#&%#b,)%5."#d(-,.,"7 !#&%"'%,+(#&.#.0"+$.E3(#&%""%#5(&%)(9#("#?(A("#-(('%$.+,@("#'%$C 5,+%5#.#,&%6+,:,-.E3(#&%#45.#@.$,%&.&%#&%#",+4.EH%"#%5#;4%#.#-(('%$.C E3(# %6+$%# ,6&,@*&4("# B# 0%6B:,-.7# 8"".# +%($,.# '.$+%# &(# '$%""4'("+(# &% ;4%9#&%"&%#;4%#%"+%?.5#-(6%-+.&("9#("#A$4'("#%6@()@,&("#6.#,6+%$.E3( -(('%$.5# %6+$%# ",7# k%""%# -."(9# (# -.+.),".&($# &.# -(('%$.E3(# %6+$%# (" A$4'("#B#.#-(546,-.E3(#n#(4#"%?.9#.#+$.6"5,""3(#&%#,6:($5.E3(#%6+$% ("#.+($%"7 k%""%#"%6+,&(9#.#-().0($.E3(#B#($,46&.#&.#,6+%$&%'%6&=6-,.#%6+$% ("#.+($%"9#%5#;4%#45#A$4'(#&%'%6&%#&("#$%-4$"("#-(6+$().&("#'($#(4C +$("9#63(#%K,"+,6&(#46,&.&%"#,6&,@,&4.,"#!),'.)9#5."#"(5%6+%#%5#$%).E3(#. (4+$."#46,&.&%"7#!"",59#("#.+($%"#-(5'.$+,)J.5#+.6+(#("#0%6%:*-,("#;4.6C +(#(#]64"#$%"4)+.6+%#&."#,6+%$.EH%"#%6+$%#",7#b.&.#.#,6+%$&%'%6&=6-,.9#. %"+$4+4$.#%5#$%&%"#'("",0,),+.#.#-(6"+$4E3(#&.#-(6:,.6E.9#&%#5(&(#;4%#. $%-,'$(-,&.&%#B#45.#@.$,D@%)#'$%"%6+%#%#."#'$%(-4'.EH%"#&("#.+($%"#63( "3(#,5%&,.+,"+."#n#(#;4%#6(#)(6A(#'$.<(#'%$5,+%#.""45,$#.#'$%@.)=6-,.#&% .+,+4&%"# -(('%$.+,@."# 1!x8SQ>b9# effg9# '7# TZa27 d%A46&(# v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vQ!k>r8YY8Q9# effm27 b.#5%"5.#:($5.9#.#&%6",&.&%#&."#$%&%"#B#,5'($+.6+%#@.$,D@%)#6. %"+$4+4$.#&%#A(@%$6.6E.7#b%).#&%'%6&%#.#,6+%$6.),<.E3(#&."#6($5."#"(-,C .,"9#."'%-+(#;4%#,6:)4%6-,.#.#;4%"+3(#&(#\-.$(6.^#19,)):,$5),29#45.#@%<#;4% A$4'("#5%6($%"#%#5.,"#-(%"("9#-(5#$%&%"#5.,"#&%6"."#%#5.,($#-(6:,.6E. %6+$%#("#.+($%"9#&%"%6-($.?.5#.#.E3(#&(#-.$(6.7#hD#A$4'("#5.,($%"#"%$3( Revista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

84

5%6("#&%6"("#%#5.,"#'$('%6"("#.#.EH%"#&%#-.$(6."9#'(,"#%""."#5%"5." 6($5."# 63(# "%$3(# :.-,)5%6+%# ,6-($'($.&."# n# %5# A$.6&%# 5%&,&.# %"". 5%6($# &%6",&.&%# &."# $%&%"# -(5# A$.6&%# 6/5%$(# &%# .+($%"# &%-($$%# &% ),5,+%"# %"'.-,.,"# %# +%5'($.,"# &."# ),A.EH%"# ;4%# ("# .+($%"# "4"+%6+.5 1vQ!k>r8YY8Q9# effm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b%"". :($5.9#.#,6"+,+4-,(6.),&.&%#&."#$%&%"#n#"(0$%#.#;4.)#"%#($A.6,<.#(#'$(-%"C "(#'()*+,-(#%#(#-(6+%/&(#&%#"4."#&%-,"H%"#n#"%$D#%"+$4+4$.&.#%5#:46E3( 1(4#"(0#A$.6&%#,6:)4=6-,.2#&.#.)(-.E3(#&%#$%-4$"("#%6+$%#("#.+($%"7#\k%"C "%#'.&$3(9#.#-(6-%'E3(#&(#-,-)(#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."#+($6.C"%#-(5')%+.C 5%6+%# &,:%$%6+%# &(# 5(&%)(# -)D"",-(9# (6&%# %)."# "3(# @,"+."# -(5(# %+.'." "%;y%6-,.,"#%5#;4%#("#'$(-%""("#&%#,5')%5%6+.E3(#%#%K%-4E3(#"%A4%5 ."# '$%"-$,EH%"# %"+.0%)%-,&."# &4$.6+%# .# :."%# &%# %).0($.E3(^' 1tS8pQw W >pr8Qk8w9# effZ9# '7# Va27 !# .0($&.A%5# &%# $%&%"# %6;4.6+(# %"+$4+4$.# &%# A(@%$6.6E.# @=# . -(%"3(#-(5(#'(+%6-,.)#&%#-(('%$.E3(#&.#-(546,&.&%#'()*+,-.#'.$.#"()4C E3(#&%#-(6:),+("#%5#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."7#X(6"%;y%6+%5%6+%9#.#-(6@%$A=6-,. &%#,6+%$%""%"#%#.#;4.),&.&%#&(#,6+%$-`50,(#&%#$%-4$"("#"3(#."'%-+("#$%)%C @.6+%"# '.$.# .# ;4.),&.&%# &%""."# '()*+,-."7# !"# $%&%"# &%# '()*+,-."# '/0),-." %6;4.6+(# %"+$4+4$.# &%# A(@%$6.6E.# $%;4%$%5# "4'($+%# '()*+,-(# ;4% ,6-$%5%6+%#.#-(($&%6.E3(9#&%#:($5.#;4%#.#,6+%$&%'%6&=6-,.#"%#&=#"%5#. '%$&.#&%#)%A,+,5,&.&%9#%@,+.6&(#,5'.-+("#6%A.+,@("#6.#%:,-,=6-,.#%#6.#%:,C -D-,.#&."#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."#1tS8pQwW#>pr8Qk8w9#effZ27 N,-O%$+#)*'0##1TUUZ9#'7#Tf2#",6+%+,<.59#6.#,)4"+$.E3(#.0.,K(9#."#'$,6C -,'.,"#&,5%6"H%"#&."#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."#@,"+."#-(5(#%"+$4+4$.#&% A(@%$6.6E.7 Revista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

85

Ilustração 2: Dimensões da perspectiva de governança de redes

!"*"#1 *"1 -&.2)'30#1 -45.'30#81 $%01 -"!#-"3)'701 )"9!'30 !"# $%&%"# &%# '()*+,-."# '/0),-."# +.50B5# "%# 5.6,:%"+.5# %6;4.6+( -(6J%-,5%6+(#-,%6+*:,-(#($A.6,<.&(#"(0#.#:($5.#&%#+%($,.7#d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email protected](#&("#:%6]5%6("9#.#-)."",:,-.E3(#&%#.-($&(#-(5#'$('$,C %&.&%"#-(546"#%9#'($#:,59#.#:($54).E3(#&%#)%,"9#;4%#-(6","+%5#%5#%646C -,.&("# ;4%# &%"-$%@%5# .# $%A4).$,&.&%# %6+$%# ("# :%6]5%6("# (0"%$@.&("7 X(5(#%K'),-,+.5#.#$%).E3(#%6+$%#%)%5%6+("9#."#)%,"#+.6+(#$%"45%5#45. A$.6&%#;4.6+,&.&%#&%#:.+("#-(5(#'%$5,+%5#"4.#'$%@,"3(#1Nk8SS8Q9#TUVf27 >#-%$6%#&."#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."#B#?4"+.5%6+%#%)4-,&.$#-(5(#"%#&D .#$%).E3(#%6+$%#&,@%$"("#.+($%"#-(5#(0?%+,@("#-(546"9#%5#45.#%"+$4+4$. '(4-(#J,%$.$;4,<.&.9#6.#;4.)#6%6J45#.+($#-(6-%6+$.#+(&("#("#$%-4$"("#% %"+3(#"4?%,+("#.#,6:)4=6-,."#5/+4."7 Q%"".)+.C"%#;4%9#%6;4.6+(#.#)%,#@%$,:,-.#(#'.&$3(#%"+D@%)#&%#%@%6C +("9# .# +%($,.# %)4-,&.# (# 5%-.6,"5(# $%"'(6"D@%)# '($# %""%# '.&$3(7# b%"". Revista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

86

:($5.9#%K'),-,+.#.#-.4".#/6,-.#;4%#46%#("#:.+("9#-."(#-(6+$D$,(#63(#%K,"+,C $,.#.#-%$+%<.#&%#;4%#(#'.&$3(#B#@%$&.&%,$(#%#63(#-(6"%;y=6-,.#:($+4,+.#&% -.4"."#&,"+,6+."7#>#'.'%)#&.#+%($,.#B#'$('($#(#5%-.6,"5(#;4%#$%"'(6&% '%).# $%A4).$,&.&%9# &%# :($5.# ;4%# .# )%,# .'$%"%6+.C"%# -(5(# -(6"%;y=6-,. )FA,-.#&("#'$%""4'("+("#+%F$,-("#1Nk8SS8Q9#TUVf27#I("+(#&%#(4+$.#:($5.9 ."# )%,"# -(6","+%5# %5# %646-,.&("# ,"().&("# -4?(# ",A6,:,-.&(# "%# '$%"%$@. 5%"5(# ;4.6&(# ,6-($'($.&(# .# 45# ","+%5.# +%F$,-(9# %6;4.6+(# ."# +%($,." "3(#-(6-.+%6.EH%"#&%#@D$,("#%646-,.&("#($&%6.&("#%6+$%#",9#(4#"%?.9#","+%C 5.+,<.&("#&%#:($5.#.5').9#-(5(#(0"%$@.&(#6."#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),C -."7# \!"# +%($,."9# %5# "45.9# "3(# ","+%5."# &%# %646-,.&("9# -(5# :($5.# &% A%6%$.),<.EH%"# 46,@%$".,"9# %5# ;4%# -(5'.$%-%5# +%$5("# +%F$,-("# 163(C (0"%[email protected],(6.,"2^# 1l8v8kL8Qv9# TUZs9# '7# Tmf27 b%# :($5.# 5.,"# %"'%-*:,-.9# d.0.+,%$# 1eff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p5# ()J.$ .+%6+(# '.$.# ."# $%&%"# &%# '()*+,-."# '/0),-."# 5("+$.# ;4%# %)."# .+%6&%5# .# n .)A46"#5.,"#".+,":.+($,.5%6+%W#(4+$("9#5%6("#n#+(&("#%""%"#%)%5%6+("7 X(5(#?D#@,"+(9#."#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."#$%'$%"%6+.5#.#(0"%$C @.E3(# &%# -%$+(# '.&$3(# &%# $%).-,(6.5%6+(# %6+$%# .+($%"9# -(5# ,6+%$.EH%" ;4%#"%#-.$.-+%$,<.5#'%).#54)+,'),-,&.&%#&%#.+($%"9#&,"+$,04,E3(#&%#'(&%$9 &%#$%-4$"("#%#$%).EH%"#5.,"#J($,<(6+.),<.&."7#k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evista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

87

&.&%#&%#($&%6.5%6+(#)FA,-(#&%#"%4"#'$%""4'("+("#+%F$,-("#%#.#-(5'.$.C E3(#-(5#.#$%.),&.&%#(0"%$@D@%)7#k%""%#"%6+,&(9#.:,$5.C"%9#-(5(#0."+.6+% %6:.+,<.&(# '($# I(''%$# 1TUZm29# ;4%# .# +%($,.# &%@%# "%$# :.)"%D@%)9# (4# "%?.9 &%@%# '%$5,+,$# "4.# @%$,:,-.E3(# -(5# ("# :%6]5%6("# ;4%# 04"-.# %K'),-.$7 z4.6+(#5.,($#.#'("",0,),&.&%#&%#+%"+%9#5%6($#.#'$(0.0,),&.&%#&%#%K,"+,C $%5#,6-(6","+=6-,."#,6+%$6."#1l8v8kL8Qv9#TUZs2#%9#6%""%#."'%-+(9#.#+%(C $,.# &."# $%&%"# &%# '()*+,-."# B# '.$+,-4).$5%6+%# "F),&.9# &.&.# .# :.-,),&.&%# &% $%.),<.E3(#&%#+%"+%#%5'*$,-(7#X(5(#%)4-,&.5#."#$%).EH%"#%6+$%#.+($%"#%5 &%+%$5,6.&.# '()*+,-.# '/0),-.9# (# %K.5%# &.# &,"'(",E3(# &%""%"# .+($%"9# &. :($5.#-(5(#%"+.0%)%-%5#"4."#$%).EH%"#%#&%#-(5(#A%$%6-,.5#("#$%-4$"(" &,"'(6*@%,"#5("+$.C"%#:.-+*@%)#.(#+%"+%#n#%#.#;4.6+."#$%'),-.EH%"#&(#5%"C 5(#"%#:.E.5#6%-%""D$,."7 !#-($$%).E3(#%',"+=5,-.9#%6+%6&,&.#-(5(#.#-(6%K3(#%K,"+%6+%#%6C +$%#(#%)%5%6+(#(0"%$@D@%)#&.#+%($,.#%#(#,6(0"%$@D@%)9#B#(4+$(#."'%-+(#&( -(6J%-,5%6+(#-,%6+*:,-(#&,A6(#&%#.+%6E3(7#Q%:%$%C"%#.(#%)(#%6+$%#.#'.$+% +%F$,-.#1("#'$%""4'("+("#)FA,-("#&.#+%($,.2#%#(#:.+(#(0"%$@D@%)#1.#$%.),&.&% %5'*$,-.29#("#;4.,"#&%@%5#"%$#J.$5(6,<.&("#6(#-(6"+$4+(#+%F$,-(7#!#-($C $%).E3(# %',"+=5,-.# 54,+."# @%<%"# B# :.-,),+.&.# '%)(# 4"(# &%# 5(&%)(" 1l8v8kL8Qv9# TUZs29# ("# ;4.,"# "3(# 0."+.6+%"# '$%"%6+%"# %# &%"%6@()@,&(" '($#&,@%$"("#'%";4,".&($%"#&."#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."7 !#-.'.-,&.&%#'$%&,+,@.#&.#'%$"'%-+,@.#&."#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),C -."#B#&%:%6&,&.#'($#!&.5#%#N$,%",#1effZ27#!(#.6.),".$%5#.#+,'()(A,.#&." $%&%"# &%# '()*+,-."# .:,$5.5# ;4%# %).# -(6"+,+4,# @.$,D@%)# ,6&%'%6&%6+%# 6. %K'),-.E3(# &.# 54&.6E.# 6.# '()*+,-.# '/0),-.# 1!"#$%&' %/0(1)27# !"# +,'()(A,." .'$%"%6+.&."#.-,5.#"%#5.6,:%"+.59#.;4,9#-(5(#.#(6+()(A,.#&(#5(&%)(9#.( &%:,6,$# "4."# @.$,D@%,"7 b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{#%K.+.5%6+%#6.#-(6%K3(#&.#+,'()(A,.#-(5#.#%K'),-.E3(#&%#$%).C Revista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

88

EH%"#-.4".,"#%#.#-.'.-,&.&%#&%#'$%-(6,<.$#:%6]5%6("#:4+4$("#;4%#$%",&% .#%""=6-,.#&.#+%($,.#1",6+%+,-.5%6+%9#6.#-(6%K3(#&%#1,,2#'.$.#1,,,227 !#G)4"+$.E3(#s#5("+$.#(#-(5'(6%6+%#%K'),-.+,@(#&.#+%($,.#&%#$%&%" &%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."#'$('("+."#'($#!&.5#%#N$,%",7 Ilustração 3: Potencial para mudança política e tipo de mudança

>0"%[email protected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d!L!YG8Q9#effZ27 k%""%#"%6+,&(9#."#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."#63(#"3(#.'%6."#.#$%C '$%"%6+.E3(#(4#.#&%"-$,E3(#&%#45.#",+4.E3(#%"'%-*:,-.#n#-(5(#45.#:($C 5.# &%# ,6+%$.E3(# %6+$%# .+($%"# (4# +,'()(A,."# &%# ,6+%$.EH%"7# d%4# %"-('( %K'),-.+,@(9#.#%)4-,&.E3(#&%#$%).EH%"#,6+%$6."#%#.#'("",0,),&.&%#&.#$%.),<.C E3(#&%#'$%&,EH%"#4)+$.'."".5#",+4.EH%"#'(6+4.,"9#&%#5(&(#;4%#."#$%&%" &%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."#"3(9#",59#45.#+%($,.7#8#-(5(#+(&.#+%($,.#-,%6+*:,-.9 .,6&.#JD#54,+(#.#"%$#&%"%6@()@,&(9#:($+.)%-,&(#%#&%),5,+.&(#n#:.+($%"#;4% "3(#'%$:%,+.5%6+%#-(%$%6+%"#-(5#(#-.$D+%$#'$(-%""4.)#&(#-(6J%-,5%6+( -,%6+*:,-(7

Revista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

89

3&(3.$#,& !-,5.#&%#;4.);4%$#-(6-%,+4.E3(9#."#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."#"4$C A%5# &.# (0"%[email protected](# &%# -%$+("# '.&$H%"# &%# $%).-,(6.5%6+(# %6+$%# .+($%"9 -(5#,6+%$.EH%"#;4%#"%#-.$.-+%$,<.5#'%).#54)+,'),-,&.&%#&%#.+($%"9#&,"+$,C 04,E3(# &%# '(&%$9# &%# $%-4$"("# %# $%).EH%"# 5.,"# J($,<(6+.),<.&."7# k(+.C"% ;4%# .# -(6-%,+4.E3(# &(# :%6]5%6(# B9# 6.# @%$&.&%9# 45.# -)."",:,-.E3(# &% $%).EH%"#%#46,3(#%5#+($6(#&%#.)A46"#%)%5%6+("#-(546"7 !"",5#-(5(#B#.#,6+%6E3(#&%#;4.,";4%$#5(&%)("9#+,'()(A,."#%#&%:,6,C EH%"9# (# ;4%# "%# 04"-(4# 6%"+%# .$+,A(# :(,# :.-,),+.$# .# -(5'$%%6"3(# &%# 45 :%6]5%6(#%5',$,-.5%6+%#(0"%$@D@%)#n#,6+%$.EH%"#%6+$%#.+($%"#n9#(#;4.) "%#-(6@%6-,(6(4#-J.5.$#&%#$%&%"#&%#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."7 k%""%#"%6+,&(9#."#&,"+,6EH%"#-(6-%,+4.,"#.'$%"%6+.&."#+=5#-.$D+%$ .'%6."# &,&D+,-(# n# (4# "%?.9# '%)(# %"-).$%-,5%6+(# &."# &%:,6,EH%"9# 04"-.C"% '%$5,+,$# ;4%# 45# ,6+%$)(-4+($# -(5'$%%6&.# (# ;4%# (# (4+$(# %"+D# &,<%6&(7 !&%5.,"9#(#$%-(6J%-,5%6+(#&."#$%&%"#-(5(#'.&$3(#&%#,6+%$.E3(#%6+$%#(" &,@%$"("#.+($%"#%5#45#"40","+%5.9#,6+%$.E3(#%"+.#-.$.-+%$,<.&.#'($#45. %"+$4+4$.#&%#A(@%$6.6E.#%5#;4%#JD#$%-(6J%-,&.5%6+%#,6+%$&%'%6&=6-,. %6+$%# %""%"# .+($%"9# '%$5,+%# .6D),"%# 5.,"# $,-.# &("# '$(-%""("# %# 54&.6E." %5#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."#n#(0?%+,@("#&%#45.#+%($,.9#n#0%5#-(5(#'$(@=#45 :%$$.5%6+.)#;4%#'%$5,+%#,6+%$@%6EH%"# 5.,"# '$%-,"."# &.;4%)%"# ;4%# +$.0.C )J.5#-(5#'()*+,-."#'/0),-."7

!":"!;(3'0#15'5.'&/!<:'30#

!b!c9#d,)O%W#NQG8dGW#l.6"'%+%$7#YJ%#k%+u($O#!''$(.-J7#G6_#d!L!YG8Q9#I.4)#!7 1($A727# ;/)",$).' "9 ' */)' !"#$%&' !,"%)..7# q%"+@,%u# I$%""9# effZ7 !hbpNG8qGXR9#N.<,5,%$<7#<,"6#)40.')'*)",$0.'50'9$#"."9$07#d3(#I.4)(_#S,@$.$,.#8&,C +($.#X,=6-,."#l45.6."9#TUZU7 L>k!t>kY9#S.4$.#X7#=)5).'5)'!"#>*$%0.'!?6#$%0.7#c.&$,&_#X%6+$(#&%#G6@%"+,A.-,(6%" d(-,()FA,-."9# effa7 Revista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

90

LPQR8S9# Y.6?.7# @,10($A$(1' B06&#"(_# (6# +J%# &,::%$%6+# -(6-%'+,(6"# (: # '(),-| 6%+u($O"7# I40),-# !&5,6,"+$.+,(69# @7Zg9# "455%$9# TUUV9# '7# emsCeZs7 tS8pQw9# d(6,.W# >pr8Qk8w9# !"","# c.:($+7# C).*D"' 5)' ,)5).# n# !# %"+$.+BA,.# &% $%A,(6.),<.E3(#&.#'()*+,-.#&%#"./&%7#Q,(#&%#h.6%,$(_#8&,+($.#tvr9#effZ7 t>pQ8R9#v%$.$&7#!#-(6"+$4E3(#&."#-,=6-,."7#d3(#I.4)(_#8&,+($.#p6%"'9#TUUm7 vQ!k>r8YY8Q9#c.$O7#YJ%#,5'.-+#(:#"(-,.)#"+$4-+4$%#(6#%-(6(5,-#(4+-(5%"7 E"3,(0#' "9 ' F%"("4$%' <),.!)%*$8).9# @7# TU9# 67T9# u,6+%$9# effm9# '7ssCmf7 l8XS>9#l4AJ7#G""4%#6%+u($O"#.6&#+J%#%K%-4+,@%#%"+.0),"J5%6+7#G6_#dYGSSc!k#GG9 Q,-J.$#h7#<36#$%'054$($.*,0*$"(_#-(6-%'+"#.6&#-."%"7#L("+(6_#l(4AJ+(6#c,::),6 X(5'.6|9# effm7 c8k!l8c9#v,).7#I(),-|#'.$.&,A5"9#'(),-|#6%+u($O"#.6&#u.+%$#'(),-|#,6#G"$.%)7 E"3,(0#'"9 '!36#$%'!"#$%&9#@7#TV9#67#s9#d%'Cb%-9#TUUV9#'7#eVsCsTf7 h!XNd>k9#c.++J%u#>7#YJ%#"+4&|#(: #"(-,.)#6%+u($O"#,6#%-(6(5,-"7#G6_#Q!pXl9 h.5%"#87#1($A27#;/)'4$..$(1'#$(-._#t($5.+,(6#.6&#&%-.|#(:#%-(6(5,-#6%+u($O"7 Q4""%))#d.A%#t(46&.+,(69#effZ7 NGXN8QY9#qW#NSGhk9#8W#%#N>II8kh!k9#h7#1($A27##70(01$(1'%"4!#)G'()*+",-._#"+$.+%A,%" :($#'40),-#"%-+($7#S(6&(6_#d!v8#I40),-.+,(6"9#TUUZ7 Nk8SS8Q9# v7# t7# H' %$I(%$0' %"4"' 0*$8$505)' /340(07# Q,(# &%# h.6%,$(_# 8&,+($.# &. p6,@%$",&.&%#&%#d3(#I.4)(9#R.J.$#8&,+($%"9#TUVf7 S!pc!kk9#87W#Nk>N89#b7#;/)'",10($A0*$"(0#'.*0*)_#"(-,.)#-J(,-%#,6#+J%#6.+,(6.) '(),-|#&(5.,6"7#c.&,"(6_#p6,@%$",+|#(:#q,"-(6",6#I$%""9#TUVZ7 I>q8SS9#q7#J)$*/),'40,-)*.'(",'/$),0,%/$).7#>$A.6,<.+,(6.)#L%J.@,($9#@7Te9#TUUf9 '7# eUmCssg7 Ql>b8d9# Q7!7q7# K(5),.*0(5$(1' 1"8),(0(%)_# I(),-|# 6%+u($O"9# A(@%$6.6-%9 $%:)%K,+,@|#%#.--(46+.0,),+|7#L4-O,6AJ.5_#>'%6#p6,@%$",+|#I$%""9#TUUZ7 QGXN8k9# t$%,&(# 1($A27# L$%$"(M,$"' 5)' *)",$0' 5"' %"(/)%$4)(*"' )' 4)*09>.$%07# X()%E3( ,&B,."#b,-,(6D$,("7#8&7#p6,@%$",&.&%#&(#r.)%#&(#Q,(#&("#d,6("9#effs7

Revista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

91

d!L!YG8Q9#I.4)#!7#;/)",$).'"9 '*/)'!"#$%&'!,"%)..7#q%"+@,%u#I$%""9#effZ7 qGSSG!cd>k9# >7# 70,-)*.' 0(5' /$),0,%/$)._# .6.)|","# .6&# .6+,+$4"+# ,5'),-.+,(6"7 k(@.#G($;4%_#t$%%#I$%""7#TUZm7 RGc!k9#h(J67#@#%"(/)%$4)(*"'%"(9$M8)#_#45.#%K')($.E3(#&("#:46&.5%6+("#'.$.#. -$%6E.#6.#-,=6-,.7#X.5',6."_#I.',$4"#8&,+($.9#TUUg7

(&)0# T #Y,'()(A,."#"3(#%6+%6&,&."#6%"+%#.$+,A(#-(5(#","+%5.+,<.EH%"9#(4#-.+%A($,<.EH%"9 &%#5.6,:%"+.EH%"#-(5#.+$,04+("#(4#-.$.-+%$*"+,-."#"%5%)J.6+%"7

e

# >0"%$@%C"%# ;4%# %"".# %"+$4+4$.# .'$(K,5.C"%# &.# &%:,6,E3(# &%# $%&%# &.&.# '($ LM$<%)#%#+$.6"-$,+.#6%"+%#.$+,A(7

!=>=?@1 %=ABCDE1 :?AA=AC# B# 8"'%-,.),"+.# %5# I()*+,-."# I/0),-."# %# v%"+3( v(@%$6.5%6+.)7# L.-J.$%)# %5# Q%).EH%"# G6+%$6.-,(6.,"# '%).# p6,@%$",&.&%# &% L$."*),.#n#GQ8S}p6L#%#c%"+$.6&(#%5#!&5,6,"+$.E3(#'%)(#IIv!}p6L7

Revista de Políticas Públicas e Gestão Governamental - Vol. 6, No 2 - Jul/Dez 2007

92